Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And of some have compassion, making a difference:
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And on some have mercy, who are in doubt;
and to some be kind, judging thoroughly,
And of some have compassion, making a difference,
And, on some, indeed, have mercy,—such as are in doubt, be saving, out of the fire, snatching them;
And indeed, have mercy on those who doubt;
And indeed, have mercy on some, making a distinction;
On some have compassion, making a distinction,
And have pity on those who are in doubt;
And haue compassion of some, in putting difference:
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And some indeed reprove, being judged:
Cross-references
- Galatians 6:1
Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted.
Both call for gently restoring someone caught in a fault.
- James 5:19-20
Brethren, if any of you do err from the truth, and one convert him;
Both call believers to restore someone who has wandered from the truth.
- Luke 6:36-37
Be ye therefore merciful, as your Father also is merciful.
Both call for mercy toward others and restraint in judging.
- Matthew 7:1-2
Judge not, that ye be not judged.
Both caution against harsh judgment toward others.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
40 sources
To show compassion with a difference means to distinguish between persons, classes and cases and to deal with each one according to their condition, needs and situation.Ms 37, 1902, par. 1Ms 22, 1903, par. 232T 220.1–3 Some are to be met with tender compassion, while others are to be saved with fear as if pulled out of the fire, with urgent warning to turn them from danger.Lt 330, 1908, par. 17–25Ms 94, 1903, par. 22–27RH Apr 14, 1903 This discerning work belongs with building up in most holy faith, praying in the Holy Ghost, keeping in the love of God, and looking for the mercy of the Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life.Lt 408, 1907, par. 15–16Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7Lt 147, 1902, par. 4–5 Saving souls in this way is most earnest work because not all are to be treated in the same way, requiring divine intuition learned in the school of Christ to know how to work for each soul.19MR 107.1Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 Strict duty toward the erring must therefore be joined with kindness, tender love, pity, patience and Christian meekness, and tender mercy with faithful reproof that clearly opposes sin without covering it up or turning disapproval into undue severity.3T 108.1–2TCBMP 135.1–22T 220.1–35T 255.2
Wording and Immediate Context
Making a difference means distinguishing between persons, classes, and cases and dealing with each according to condition, needs, and situation.Ms 37, 1902, par. 1Ms 22, 1903, par. 2316MR 272.1Ms 43, 1902, par. 21–263T 420.2 Those who care for souls must exercise compassion with wise, fitting care, using patience, gentleness, kindness, tenderness, and discretion to deal carefully with different minds, since harsh or indiscreet treatment can harm people and tear down more than it builds up.Ms 22, 1903, par. 232T 220.1–33T 420.2 Some who are ensnared are to be met with tender compassion, while others are to be saved with fear and pulled out of the fire, with urgent warning to turn them from danger and avoidance of the defilement associated with sin.Lt 330, 1908, par. 17–25Ms 94, 1903, par. 22–27RH Apr 14, 190319MR 107.1Lt 54, 1874, par. 28–30
This compassionate, discerning work belongs with building up in most holy faith, praying in the Holy Ghost, keeping in the love of God, and looking for the mercy of the Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life.Lt 408, 1907, par. 15–16Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7Lt 147, 1902, par. 4–5Lt 40, 1899, par. 39–42RH Jul 1, 1902 It is the charge to the beloved living when mockers walk after their own ungodly lusts in the last time and when those who separate themselves are sensual, having not the Spirit.Lt 408, 1907, par. 15–16Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7 In that setting believers are to be laborers together with God through thorough consecration in humility, with body, mind, and soul given to God and earnest asking for help, trusting that God knows human infirmities and will receive and strengthen them for this service.Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7Lt 147, 1902, par. 4–5 It is God's word to those who obey His commandments and honor Him, who are complete in Him and work with Him in saving souls.RH Jul 1, 1902
It is part of Jude's closing instruction that makes Christian work a complete, balanced whole and teaches how to conduct warfare in the service of Christ.19MR 106.2–419MR 105.2–106.1 That whole respects each person's individuality, with no one-sided extravagance, no indolence or shiftlessness, no cold-hearted criticism or selfish practice, with all human powers yielded to divine influence and brought into subjection to Christ.19MR 106.2–419MR 105.2–106.1 In all of it workers are to hate even the garment spotted by the flesh and keep their own garments undefiled, especially those claiming great light and spiritual knowledge.Lt 408, 1907, par. 15–1619MR 105.2–106.1RH Sep 9, 1902 This is done trusting Him who is able to keep them from falling and to present them before the presence of His glory with exceeding joy.Lt 408, 1907, par. 15–16
Prophetic and Historical Setting
The letter belongs to Jude the servant of Jesus Christ and brother of James, addressed to those sanctified by God the Father and preserved in Jesus Christ and called, to whom mercy and peace and love are multiplied.Lt 74, 1900, par. 25–26 It is a guard against the seductive influences of false teachers, men having a form of godliness who are not safe leaders.Ms 94, 1903, par. 28 In the last days such false teachers arise and become actively zealous, presenting all kinds of theories to divert minds from the very truth that defines the position that can be occupied with safety.Ms 94, 1903, par. 28 At the same time Satan works with power upon religionists who make a pretense of being righteous while failing to place themselves under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.Ms 94, 1903, par. 28
It exposes an apostasy in which ungodly men have crept in unawares, with murmurers and separatists walking after their own lusts.Lt 330, 1908, par. 17–25 It is a charge to the beloved living when mockers in the last time walk after their own ungodly lusts, and when those who separate themselves are sensual, having not the Spirit.Lt 408, 1907, par. 15–16 That portrayal of evildoers and mockers applies just as manifested in the present day and in this period of earth's history.Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7 It calls those who profess to believe in the soon coming of Christ to judge the earth to be thoroughly aroused to the situation and to examine heart and life to see if they stand in the position required.Lt 408, 1907, par. 17 That required position is keeping the commandments of God in order to be saved in His kingdom, with physicians and ministers needing assurance that they themselves are doing this.Lt 408, 1907, par. 17
In that setting believers are exhorted to earnestly contend for the faith once delivered to the saints while ungodly men have crept in unawares.Lt 330, 1908, par. 17–25 That contending is done by bringing men back from transgression of the commandments of God, proclaiming the gospel of Christ with earnestness and zeal as light to commandment-breakers, arousing men and women to prepare to meet God, and raising the standard of truth by magnifying the law and making it honorable.Lt 74, 1900, par. 25–26 The charge to have compassion, making a difference, is encouragement spoken to God's faithful people after the character of ungodly men is pointed out.Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7 In that evil setting believers must make the Lord their helper and trust in Him as their sufficiency for success.Lt 46, 1907, par. 5–7
Discerning Soul-Saving Work
Saving souls is the most earnest work, for it is work for souls ready to perish, and it is no light or easy work because not all are to be treated in the same way.19MR 107.1Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 Some souls are to be treated with the tenderest compassion while others are to be plucked out of the fire, so a difference must be made according to each case and need.19MR 107.1Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 To meet that need workers require divine intuition to know how to work for each soul.19MR 107.1 That intuition is learned in the school of Christ, by learning His given method of saving souls.19MR 107.1
Those who show such compassion are laborers together with God, building themselves up in most holy faith, praying in the Holy Ghost, keeping themselves in the love of God, and looking for the mercy of the Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life.Lt 147, 1902, par. 4–5 This labor requires thorough consecration in humility, with body, mind, and soul given to God, and earnest asking for help.Lt 147, 1902, par. 4–5 It rests on trust that God knows human infirmities and will receive and strengthen believers for this service.Lt 147, 1902, par. 4–5 The compassion itself is the sympathy of Christ shown by brother toward brother toward human wants and woes.Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 It is shown in watching over souls Christ purchased with His own blood and in watching for opportunities to do them good.Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16
It requires sitting at the feet of Jesus to learn of Him like Mary, and at the same time abounding in the work of the Lord like Martha.Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 It requires being much on the knees in sincere prayer and devoting hands and heart and whole being to the work.Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 It requires keeping the heart with all diligence under constant watchfulness against old habits, natural inclinations, and selfish and self-centered thoughts and plans.Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 Every fiber of the root of selfishness must be removed, lest it spring up and many be defiled.Lt 36, 1894, par. 14–16 Christian help must therefore be practical, varied labor for others’ salvation, joined with personal piety and love.2T 672.2–673.4 Christ’s servants must meet people where they are and suit help to the person’s condition, rather than impose exact rules in every case.2T 672.2–673.4
Spirit of Compassionate Labor
Strict duty toward those who have gone wrong must be joined with kindness, tender love, pity, patience, gentleness, discretion and Christian meekness, with compassion and discernment that distinguishes persons and gives fitting care to different minds.3T 108.1–2TCBMP 135.1–22T 220.1–3Lt 5, 1864, par. 9–11 Severity without tenderness provokes resistance, drives people away, causes harm, and tears down more than it builds up, while kindness and love win people and encourage them toward good.3T 108.1–2TCBMP 135.1–22T 220.1–3 Correction is therefore to comfort and entreat rather than to censure harshly or wield a figurative whip.Lt 5, 1864, par. 9–11
Tender mercy must be joined with faithful reproof, so that sin is still clearly opposed and sinners are urged to recognize sin through warning, urging, prayer, urgent intercession and every effort to win them.5T 255.23T 269.2GW 30.4 Compassion does not cover up sins and must not become such tolerance that the erring think reproof undeserved or unjust, nor may disapproval of sin become needless or undue severity toward the sinner.3T 269.2GW 30.4 Discernment distinguishes cases instead of treating everyone alike, overcoming reluctance to approach those in need, including unbelieving neighbors.5T 255.23T 269.2
Compassion calls for tender sympathy toward the perplexed, unfortunate, sick and suffering, caring for each according to needs and circumstances and treating them gently as a delicate plant.Lt 30, 1887, par. 28–30 It works through practical help, courtesy, conciliation and kindness that win trust and give hope and courage, and neither hardship nor rough manners is reason to withhold such care.Lt 30, 1887, par. 28–30 Toward one another it means healthful heart-beats instead of jealousy, suspicion, faultfinding, criticizing, envy, evil-surmising, evil-speaking and passing judgment upon one another.21MR 49.1–3 It requires loving as brethren, being pitiful and courteous, and living in complete unity in the love of God, so that the Spirit can work, prayers are offered in the spirit and power of God, and Christ's intercession to restore unity is answered.21MR 49.1–3
It requires bearing with one another's failings and weaknesses with patient, reasonable forbearance, helping and patiently bearing as Christ has borne, rather than seizing on words or rejecting without sufficient cause.15MR 125.2–3Lt 12, 1863, par. 3–59MR 196.2–4 This recognizes different temperaments, minds, understanding and experience, so all are not held to identical discipline or another person's measure of duty, since harsh judgment and faultfinding push people away while patient forbearance helps them move forward.15MR 125.2–3Lt 12, 1863, par. 3–5 Careful, wise action may keep erring people within the church's influence and win them to truth, while persistent disobedience or sin may require separation.9MR 196.2–4 Applied to teaching, it means first drawing near to God and then coming close to students with the love and gentleness of Christ rather than a harsh, domineering spirit, carrying them over the ground of knowledge with deep, earnest interest and imparting blessings received.RH Sep 9, 1902 It uses a close-meshed gospel net, making the application of Scripture easily discerned and coming right to the point, communicating knowledge with deep feeling and pathos of voice so that hearts are impressed, belonging with keeping in the love of God while looking for the mercy of the Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life and with saving others with fear, pulling them out of the fire while hating even the garment spotted by the flesh.RH Sep 9, 1902
People Needing Compassion
Those who have sinned and sincerely repented are to be met with compassion, especially when they are discouraged and afraid to hope.12MR 96.1 They are not to be treated as beyond forgiveness, but to be welcomed and encouraged and given opportunity to recover what they have lost.12MR 96.1 Genuine repentance is shown by earnest efforts to serve the Lord.12MR 96.1 Those who have wandered are to be worked for with discerning compassion to turn them back to the path of life and lead them to the Shepherd.17MR 214.3–5 Those in danger need kindly, thoughtful care suited to their particular condition, including those whose conduct or attitudes place others at risk, rather than special affection shown to a favored few.Lt 51d, 1887, par. 14–16 At times their eternal interests require zealous, decisive action.Lt 1, 1861, par. 8
Unbelieving neighbors are to be approached despite reluctance, with concern shown by warning, urging, praying, and making every effort to win them to Christ.5T 255.2 Those unfamiliar with new light, such as those unfamiliar with the visions, should not be pressured to affirm what they do not understand.1T 382.1 They are to be approached with care, patience, and mercy according to their understanding and experience, while those with greater light and experience may need different treatment, and such discretion can keep honest people from being driven into opposition.1T 382.1 Church members who err should be treated patiently and with forbearance, helped and borne with as Christ has borne with believers, rather than having their words seized upon or being rejected without sufficient cause.15MR 125.2–3 This is necessary because people have different temperaments, minds, understanding, and experience, and cannot all be held to identical discipline or another person's measure of duty.15MR 125.2–39MR 196.2–4 Careful, wise action may keep erring people within the church's influence and help win them to truth, while persistent disobedience or sin may require separation from the church.9MR 196.2–4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
18 sources
The verse commands compassion toward some, shown with discernment about how each person is to be helped.ST Dec 12, 1911ST Dec 12, 1911ST Dec 9, 1913 Different people need different approaches to be saved because people are not all alike, with sympathy for those who are misled through ignorance or weakness distinguished from the more urgent response required for those who act willfully.RH Apr 14, 1903RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 7, 1868RH Aug 4, 1863RH Oct 20, 1859 Those who have gone wrong or fallen into sin and despair are to be met with patient, gentle, loving personal care rather than scorn or harsh judgment, seeking to restore them and lead them back to God while loving the sinner and loathing the sin.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Jan 21, 1858ST Apr 11, 1911RH Aug 3, 1905 This compassion belongs to the work of saving souls by warning them about sin and urging them away from danger, with earnest efforts and urgent intercession to awaken them without covering up their sins.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Aug 24, 1905 It is given to those who obey God's commandments and honor Him, as part of keeping themselves in the love of God while looking for eternal life through the mercy of Jesus Christ.RH Jul 1, 1902
Compassion That Distinguishes
Jude 1:22 commands compassion toward some people, shown with careful discernment about how each person is helped.ST Dec 12, 1911ST Dec 12, 1911ST Dec 9, 1913 This command belongs to those who obey God's commandments and honor Him, who are complete in Him and work with Him in saving souls, as part of keeping themselves in the love of God while looking for eternal life through the mercy of Jesus Christ.RH Jul 1, 1902 Different people need different approaches in order to be saved, with some to be met with compassion and discernment and others to be rescued with fear, because people are not all alike.RH Apr 14, 1903RH Aug 4, 1863 For this reason no one should judge his own case by comparing himself with others, but should submit himself to God and to His people for judgment.RH Aug 4, 1863
Compassion is for those who are misled, distinguished from those who act willfully, so that some are to be treated with sympathy while others require a different, more urgent response.RH Apr 7, 1868RH Oct 20, 1859 A heart shaped by God's word grieves over sin and human misery without hating sinners, yet remains zealous against sin and its influence.RH Oct 20, 1859 Such compassion is to be shown to people who are ignorant and misled by false religion, distinguishing them from the leaders who promote spiritual wickedness and not classing them with wicked rulers whose spirit they have not adopted. Those who were not warned or taught about the danger they faced deserve compassion in a way that may differ from those who were faithfully warned, yet this distinction must not become partiality or sacrifice justice and fairness, and it is a lesson for dealing wisely with people who have erred in the church.RH Sep 21, 1869
The church should bear with those who have gone wrong through weakness or mistake, seeking to restore them rather than treating every case alike.RH Jan 9, 1855 The response depends in part on how much light they have received and therefore how much they are accountable for.RH Jan 9, 1855 Compassion is to be shown both to those known to be Christians and to those whose faith is doubtful, and concern for a person's soul should make harsh feelings impossible.
Saving Souls Through Compassion
The verse stands as part of the clear testimony that the world is not growing better but continues to the very end of the age in hatred and opposition to Christ and His true church.ST Aug 7, 1901 God's method is revolution by supernatural birth rather than evolution by natural growth, and the purpose of this dispensation is the out-gathering of the church as a people for His name rather than the conversion of the world.ST Aug 7, 1901 The witness of the church is by separation from the world rather than assimilation to it, so its great danger is accommodation and its final state as a whole is apostasy.ST Aug 7, 1901 Formalists and hypocrites and counterfeits of piety will remain in the church to the end too close to be always detected, the hope of both church and world is the coming of the Lord when the real world-wide triumphs of the gospel will begin, and the attitude of the believer is perpetual watching against worldliness and heresy and waiting for the return of the Son of man.ST Aug 7, 1901
The verse applies to saving people by warning them about sin and urging them away from danger, with discernment about how each one is met.RH Sep 30, 1852 It calls for compassionate, earnest efforts to awaken and rescue souls facing eternal loss.RH Aug 24, 1905 That rescuing work includes meeting the urgent needs of the afflicted colored race in the South.RH Aug 24, 1905 In rescuing perishing souls, compassion includes urgent intercession and efforts to bring sinners to recognize sin, and it does not mean covering up their sins.
Those who have gone wrong should be met with compassion and patient, gentle care rather than scorn, so they may be led back to God and goodness.RH Jan 21, 1858 People fallen into sin and despair need loving personal care that can rescue them and restore hope, with patient charity toward them rather than harsh judgment.ST Apr 11, 1911RH Aug 3, 1905 Hidden motives, struggles, and good within a person may be unseen, so the sinner is to be loved while the sin is loathed.RH Aug 3, 1905 Those who help the fallen are themselves weak and need mercy, which calls for humility.RH Jan 21, 1858
Applied to teachers urging students to surrender themselves to God, compassion that makes a difference means drawing near to God and then to students, coming close to them with the love and gentleness of Christ rather than a harsh, domineering spirit.RH Sep 9, 1902 It means carrying them over the ground of knowledge with deep, earnest interest to help, and imparting the blessings received.RH Sep 9, 1902 It belongs with keeping in the love of God while looking for the mercy of the Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life, and with saving others with fear, pulling them out of the fire while hating even the garment spotted by the flesh.RH Sep 9, 1902 It is done by using the gospel net with close meshes, making the application of Scripture easily discerned and coming right to the point, and by communicating knowledge with deep feeling and pathos of voice so that hearts are impressed.RH Sep 9, 1902 The verse calls believers to show compassion and work for others.RH Dec 7, 1916
Sources