AdventAI

Luke 17:23

And they shall say to you, See here; or, see there: go not after them, nor follow them.

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

12 sources

The warning was given to the disciples after the declaration to the Pharisees that the kingdom of God comes not with observation but is within, and before the declaration that His day will be as lightning shining across heaven, that He must first suffer many things and be rejected, and that as in the days of Noah and of Lot so it will be when the Son of man is revealed.Lt 293, 1904, par. 8–12 It belongs to the warning about the coming judgment in which people were warned for years, many did not turn to the Lord, a few heeded the warning, and others mocked those who heeded.Ms 123, 1909, par. 4–5 It commands God's people to give no allegiance to those who point to a localized appearing or presence of the Son of man in one place or another, and not to go after them nor follow them.Ms 185, 1897, par. 9Lt 293, 1904, par. 8–12Ms 156, 1907, par. 24Lt 112, 1890, par. 14–151MR 303.3–4

History will be repeated when many deceivers go forth declaring themselves to be the Christ, with such here-and-there reports and claims multiplying amid growing deceptions and impostures, so that by not going after them believers need not be deceived but must remain watchful.19MR 358.5–6Lt 112, 1890, par. 14–151MR 303.3–4 The warning applies when Satan personates Christ, professing to be Christ and assuming His person and apparently working His works with miracles and misrepresentations.Ms 185, 1897, par. 9 It covers every kind of voice claiming to identify Christ or the truth, whether in the wilderness or in the cities, which followers are neither to go after nor heed nor accept without careful watching lest they be misled.Lt 94, 1900, par. 1–3Lt 4, 1893, par. 25–29

It warns against following people who draw believers toward new claims about prophetic truth through a persuasive but mistaken theory that combines and misuses passages, departs from the truth already given for the time, and leads away from the right path.Ms 32, 1896, par. 27–30 It warns against following claims in the last days that the way of salvation is found in some alternative to the Bible's teaching, when people of varied beliefs point to one place or another, whereas repentance toward God for breaking His law and faith in Jesus Christ as Redeemer are the only way for sinners to enter, requiring a heart renewed through God's law and faith in Christ that produces enduring obedience rather than merely emotional or outward profession.4MR 182.3–184.2 It calls for constant readiness for the coming of Christ through inner preparation in harmony with all the principles and laws of the kingdom of God, with the message for this time earnestly lived and clearly proclaimed, because the coming day of the Lord comes unexpectedly as a thief in the night to all who are not ready.Lt 293, 1904, par. 8–12Ms 156, 1907, par. 2416MR 133.3

Those who have received light must therefore watch, pray and work, walk in the footsteps of Jesus, and work out their own salvation with fear and trembling.Ms 156, 1907, par. 2416MR 133.3 The warning is urgent for this time of peril when even people in positions of responsibility do not understand their own defects of character and are blinded by officiousness to the work to be done.16MR 133.3 Obeying it holds God's people unmoved amid rebellion and apostasy and requires hanging the helpless soul upon Christ by faith, for if they are so easily misled now they will otherwise fail to stand then.Ms 185, 1897, par. 9 For the gospel ministry this requires keeping its elevated, sacred character and staying with the work outlined in the prophetic Word without being diverted from God's way and methods into wrong lines by human methods and inventions when every call can be opened to.Lt 94, 1900, par. 1–3

Sources

  1. Lt 293, 1904, par. 8–12 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 19 (1904) — Lt 293, 1904 Ellen G. White, written October 17, 1904
  2. Ms 123, 1909, par. 4–5 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 24 (1909) — Ms 123, 1909 Ellen G. White, written July 17, 1909
  3. Ms 185, 1897, par. 9 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 185, 1897 Ellen G. White, written 1897
  4. Ms 156, 1907, par. 24 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 22 (1907) — Ms 156, 1907 Ellen G. White Estate, Ellen G. White, written July 22 – October 29, 1907
  5. Lt 112, 1890, par. 14–15 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Lt 112, 1890 Ellen G. White, written December 22, 1890
  6. 1MR 303.3–4 Manuscript Releases, vol. 1 [Nos. 19-96] — MR No. 65—Materials for General Use Ellen G. White, written June 11, 1893; published 1981
  7. 19MR 358.5–6 Manuscript Releases, vol. 19 [Nos. 1360-1419] — MR No. 1412—The Case of J. H. Kellogg; Christ, the Great Medical Missionary; Physicians to Labor as Christ Labored Ellen G. White, written November 1903; published 1990
  8. Lt 94, 1900, par. 1–3 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 15 (1900) — Lt 94, 1900 Ellen G. White, written July 3, 1900
  9. Lt 4, 1893, par. 25–29 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 8 (1893) — Lt 4, 1893 Ellen G. White, written December 23, 1893
  10. Ms 32, 1896, par. 27–30 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Ms 32, 1896 Ellen G. White, written December 6, 1896
  11. 4MR 182.3–184.2 Manuscript Releases, vol. 4 [Nos. 210-259] — MR No. 224—Ellen G. White Letters to Young Christians Ellen G. White, written June 24, 1875; published 1990
  12. 16MR 133.3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 16 [Nos. 1186-1235] — MR No. 1202—Diary Fragments—July to October, 1907 Ellen G. White, written 1907; published 1990

Pioneers and periodicals

40 sources

Jesus forbids his disciples to go away after those who point to a particular place and say Christ is there, and commands them not to follow such sayings.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Aug 20, 1894ST Aug 20, 1894 The reason is that the day of the Son of Man will be as open and unmistakable as lightning shining from one part under heaven to the other, so no one will need to be told where to find him.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Aug 20, 1894RH Feb 23, 1869 His coming is one personal, visible, glorious appearing in the clouds of heaven, when the living and resurrected righteous are gathered to be with him forever and the living wicked are destroyed.ST Jul 9, 1874RH Apr 9, 1857RH Oct 31, 1854 All localized appearances in desert or secret chamber, and all spiritualized accounts that make his coming death or conversion or an outpouring of the Spirit, are false and must not be pursued.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Feb 23, 1869ST Apr 19, 1877ST Apr 20, 1876ST Aug 27, 1885 As the end draws near false christs and false prophets will arise with great signs to deceive if possible even the elect, so readiness is not seeking a place but a holy character conformed to God's law, holding fast hope in the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.RH Feb 23, 1869RH Feb 23, 1869ST Jul 26, 1905RH Aug 9, 1864RH Jan 24, 1865

Meaning And Setting

The command forbids going away after people who announce that Christ is here or there in a particular place, and forbids following them or pursuing such localized claims about his presence.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Aug 20, 1894ST Aug 20, 1894RH Aug 6, 1857 It was spoken to the disciples concerning coming days when they would desire to see one of the days of the Son of Man and would not see it, at which time men would say to them that he is here or there.ST Aug 20, 1894ST Aug 20, 1894 It belongs to the teaching about the kingdom of God and the second advent, not merely to the destruction of Jerusalem, and warns of danger just before that advent.ST Aug 20, 1894RH Jul 15, 1873 It stands as part of the great prophecy giving light about events and conditions in the Christian age, especially the last days, so that God's people can be ready for what is coming.ST Oct 16, 1893

The verse stands in the prediction that the last days will be as the days of Noah and as the days of Lot.ST Oct 25, 1905 Then iniquity abounds and the love of many grows cold, with great perils measured by abounding sins among professed people and with great apostate Babylon controlling the whole world, proving there will be no conversion of the world before Christ comes.ST Oct 25, 1905 It belongs to the prediction of conditions in the social world that forerun the second advent.RH Nov 24, 1910 Those social signs are fulfilling now with a fullness and intensity that leaves no doubt they apply to this age.RH Nov 24, 1910

The warning is joined to the command to remember Lot's wife, for just before the advent worldly interests can absorb people and keep them from preparing for the final judgment.RH Jul 15, 1873 Like her, people must not cling to what they leave behind, but obey God and remain ready for deliverance.RH Jul 15, 1873 As God's children fled doomed Jerusalem without trying to preserve their earthly possessions, they will again flee doomed cities when the language about fleeing is applied to the final destructions and calamities.ST Jan 24, 1906 The warning applies to people living in the last time, who are fleeing spiritually from impending destruction and exposed to judgments, and must not follow claims that Christ has come in a hidden or localized place such as the desert or a secret chamber.RH Dec 10, 1857 The saying was also kept in mind and repeated to refuse the proclamation that the hour of God's judgment is come, while those refusing were taken up with the cares of the world and blinded by the god of this world.RH Aug 6, 1857

Manner Of Coming

The prohibition rests on the nature of the day of the Son of Man, which will be as open and unmistakable as lightning shining from one part under heaven to the other.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Aug 20, 1894RH Feb 23, 1869RH Jun 9, 1859RH Aug 9, 1864 No one will need to direct attention to its location, and those who expect him will not need to seek reports pointing here or there.ST Aug 20, 1894RH Jun 9, 1859RH Aug 9, 1864ST Jul 20, 1882 Localized claims that he has appeared in a particular place, hidden location, desert, or secret chamber are therefore false and must not be pursued, because his coming will not be secret or known only through such sayings.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Aug 20, 1894RH Feb 23, 1869RH Jun 9, 1859 The warning protects the hope of a personal, visible return by distinguishing every substitute from the true coming and commanding disciples not to go away after them nor follow them.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Aug 20, 1894RH Feb 23, 1869ST Jul 20, 1882

His coming is one personal, visible, glorious event in the clouds of heaven, visible across the earth like lightning flashing across the heavens.ST Jul 9, 1874RH Apr 9, 1857RH Oct 31, 1854ST Aug 27, 1885 At his coming the heavens blaze with glory and the earth trembles, even though the unbelieving world is unprepared for it.RH Apr 9, 1857RH Oct 31, 1854 The living wicked are destroyed and desolation comes on the earth, while the living righteous are gathered with the resurrected righteous dead to be taken to heaven.ST Jul 9, 1874 There they will be with him forever beyond sorrow, sighing, tears and pain, when he appears to take his children home.RH May 1, 1855

The coming of the kingdom is still future, not a hidden event already established at the first advent nor a kingdom already set up inwardly in the hearts of disciples.RH Jun 9, 1859ST Jul 20, 1882RH Oct 13, 1874 The kingdom will be revealed at the glorious second coming, when the Son of Man is revealed from heaven as visibly and unmistakably as lightning.RH Aug 9, 1864ST Jul 20, 1882RH Oct 13, 1874 While its nearness may be known, its time and hour have not been revealed.

The context shows a final separation affecting every class and relation in life, when even two sharing a bed are divided, one taken and the other left in the decisive hour before Christ appears.RH Dec 4, 1900 The fire from God then descends upon the wicked in the final destruction, with the destruction of Sodom as the pattern.RH Jan 19, 1869 The conflagration of the earth consumes the wicked before the saints inherit the new earth.RH Jan 19, 1869

False Claims Rejected

The verse forbids following claims that Christ has appeared or can be found in a particular place, hidden location, desert, or secret chamber, and such localized manifestations are false and must not be pursued.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Feb 23, 1869ST Aug 27, 1885RH Dec 10, 1857RH Feb 23, 1869 The protection is for the hope of a personal, visible return, for the coming of the Son of Man will be as open and unmistakable as lightning shining from one part under heaven to the other, not a hidden event known only to a few.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Feb 23, 1869ST Aug 27, 1885RH Dec 10, 1857ST Nov 16, 1876 His personal appearance will take place in the clouds of heaven and be visible across the earth, so no one will need to be directed here or there to find him.ST Aug 27, 1885RH Dec 10, 1857 The warning applies to people living in the last time while fleeing spiritually from impending destruction and exposed to God's judgments, calling them to reject substitutes and wait for His open revelation from heaven rather than follow secret settings.RH Dec 10, 1857RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876

Spiritualized accounts that locate the second coming at death, at conversion, or through an outpouring of the Spirit are deceptions and false signs, not the literal advent, and those who say Christ is here or there in that sense must not be followed.ST Apr 19, 1877ST Jul 9, 1874ST Apr 20, 1876RH Feb 10, 1874 His second coming is one visible, glorious, public event, like lightning flashing across the heavens, when He comes in glory to raise the righteous dead and gather the righteous living.ST Apr 19, 1877ST Jul 9, 1874ST Apr 20, 1876 The same warning exposes Spiritualism's proclamation of a spiritual coming and reign as a false sign of His coming rather than the literal advent.ST Jan 13, 1881

Movements that present a substitute for the promised return, whether in a person, an earthly kingdom, or secret spiritual manifestations, are ruled out, and believers are to hold to His personal appearing from heaven, openly visible like lightning, as their hope.RH Feb 23, 1869RH Feb 23, 1869 As the coming draws near false christs and false prophets will arise and perform great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect.ST Jul 26, 1905 A person's appearance, suffering, persecution, or large following does not prove a divine mission, since such things have also characterized false prophets.ST Jul 26, 1905

Reports of lo here or lo there are false and must not be followed, and the verse rules out a second probation in which Christ's personal presence converts the world. Repentance comes through faith in His sacrifice and the evidence already given, not through what is seen. The time and hour of His coming have not been revealed, though its nearness may be known, and when He comes the earth will be desolated, the living wicked destroyed, and the living righteous taken to heaven with the resurrected righteous dead.

Warning For Last Days

The command forbids following false teachers who point to particular places or schemes as where Christ or deliverance is to be found.RH Apr 1, 1909RH Oct 17, 1854RH Aug 9, 1864RH Jan 24, 1865 It therefore covers staged evangelistic meetings whose pressure tactics manufacture a misleading appearance of religious response.RH Apr 1, 1909 It guides the lonely believer not to seek fellowship by answering competing religious groups that call out with their rival invitations.RH Oct 17, 1854 It likewise bars joining religious movements that call to the disaffected, for those who heed it avoid being led astray.RH Jan 24, 1865 It exposes a lo here movement that seeks safety in a place or scheme, showing that those who so seek safety will be caught in their own devices.RH Aug 9, 1864

The same warning meets specific modern confusions, including preaching in other cities about Christ's soon return joined to claims about Louis Napoleon. It meets the claim that Christ and angels have already come to earth so that people need not go anywhere to find them.RH Apr 18, 1854 It meets the confusion evident in the rise of numerous sects and movements, including the Latter-day Saints movement and modern Spiritualism.ST Sep 21, 1915 It meets teaching that sets up another expected one against Christianity, for as the coming draws near false christs and false prophets will arise with great signs and wonders to deceive even the elect if possible, and neither a person's appearance nor persecution nor large following proves a divine mission, since such things have also marked false prophets.ST Jul 26, 1905

The present age is marked by such here and there claims amid many false religions, systems, and theories developed over time.ST Nov 28, 1900 These deceptions arise alongside an intense search for truth and expectation of world-changing events.ST Nov 28, 1900 Longing for his return amid trials can make disciples vulnerable to deceivers who claim his presence in a particular place, but his coming will be visible to all like lightning spanning the sky, so the verse guards against following supposed manifestations or locations of the expected one.ST Apr 27, 1882ST Nov 28, 1900

True preparation for his appearing is not seeking a place but a holy character conformed to God's law.RH Aug 9, 1864 Security in the day of wrath lies in the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.RH Aug 9, 1864 Amid confusion and fear believers are to hold fast their hope, trust the prophetic word, and look beyond earthly conflict to the coming King and approaching redemption.RH May 28, 1861 Those who heed the warning in this way avoid being led astray by movements calling them elsewhere.RH Jan 24, 1865

The saying has also been misused and turned against believers.RH Aug 6, 1857RH Dec 11, 1855 When the proclamation that the hour of God's judgment is come was sounded, the command not to go after lo here or lo there was repeated to refuse it, while those refusing were taken up with the cares of the world and blinded.RH Aug 6, 1857 Believers have likewise been accused of being led astray by reports of lo here and lo there, though the warning itself forbids pursuing claims that he has appeared in one place or another.RH Dec 11, 1855

Sources

  1. RH Nov 9, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 56 — The Bible Year Starr, November 9, 1916
  2. ST Aug 20, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 41 — LESSON IX.—SABBATH, SEPTEMBER 1, 1894 Monday, August 20, 1894
  3. ST Aug 20, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 41 — LESSON IX.—SABBATH, SEPTEMBER 1, 1894 Monday, August 20, 1894
  4. ST Nov 16, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 2, No. 46 — See Here, or See There John Nevins Andrews, Fifth-day, November 16, 1876
  5. RH Feb 23, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 9 — SEE HERE, OR SEE THERE John Nevins Andrews, February 23, 1869
  6. ST Jul 9, 1874 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 4 — GRACE AND GLORY July 9, 1874
  7. RH Apr 9, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 23 — EXPOSITION OF DANIEL II, 31-44 April 9, 1857
  8. RH Oct 31, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 12 — EXPOSITION OF DANIEL II, 31-44: October 31, 1854
  9. ST Apr 19, 1877 The Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 16 — The Kingdom at Hand James White, Fifth-day, April 19, 1877
  10. ST Apr 20, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 2, No. 19 — The Two Thrones, James White, April 20, 1876
  11. ST Aug 27, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 33 — Which Is Right? Stephen N. Haskell, August 27, 1885
  12. RH Feb 23, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 9 — SEE HERE, OR SEE THERE John Nevins Andrews, February 23, 1869
  13. ST Jul 26, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 30 — BAHAISM VERSUS CHRISTIANITY July 26, 1905
  14. RH Aug 9, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 11 — Another “Lo Here.” R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, August 9, 1864
  15. RH Jan 24, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 9 — Why We Prize the Review Stephen Nelson Haskell, January 24, 1865
  16. RH Aug 6, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 14 — An Interesting Letter A. S. H., August 6, 1857
  17. RH Jul 15, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 42, No. 5 — Remember Lot’s Wife E. O. Hammond, Third-day, July 15, 1873
  18. ST Oct 16, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 49 — THE LAST GREAT APOSTASY M. H. Brown, Monday, October 16, 1893
  19. ST Oct 25, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 43 — THE CONVERSION OF THE WORLD October 25, 1905
  20. RH Nov 24, 1910 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 87, No. 47 — No Apology F. M. W., November 24, 1910
  21. ST Jan 24, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 4 — A GREAT LITERAL PROPHECY January 24, 1906
  22. RH Dec 10, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 5 — REMEMBER LOT'S WIFE J. N. Loughborough, December 10, 1857
  23. RH Jun 9, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 3 — SAINTS' INHERITANCE J. N. Loughborough, June 9, 1859
  24. RH Aug 9, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 11 — Another “Lo Here.” R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, August 9, 1864
  25. ST Jul 20, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 27 — The Disciples of Christ Expected a Literal Kingdom John Norton Loughborough, July 20, 1882
  26. RH May 1, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 28 — A Few Sabbath Keepers J. G. Post, May 1, 1855
  27. RH Oct 13, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 16 — Mode of Refuting Error R. F. Cottrell, Third-day, October 13, 1874
  28. RH Dec 4, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 49 — ONE TAKEN, ANOTHER LEFT December 4, 1900
  29. RH Jan 19, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 4 — THE LAKE OF FIRE John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, January 19, 1869
  30. ST Nov 16, 1876 Signs of the Times, Vol. 2, No. 46 — See Here, or See There John Nevins Andrews, Fifth-day, November 16, 1876
  31. RH Feb 10, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 9 — GRACE AND GLORY; James White, February 10, 1874
  32. ST Jan 13, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 2 — THE GOAL AND CLIMAX OF ERROR R. F. Cottrell, January 13, 1881
  33. RH Apr 1, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 13 — False Revivals A. SMITH, Thursday, April 1, 1909
  34. RH Oct 17, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 10 — AN OLD SOLDIER An Old Soldier, October 17, 1854
  35. RH Apr 18, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 13 — SPIRITUALISM IN CANADA John Wesley, April 18, 1854
  36. ST Sep 21, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 37 — Some Prophetic Guideposts Daniel H. Kress, September 21, 1915
  37. ST Nov 28, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 48 — THE OUTPOURING OF THE SPIRIT, AND ITS COUNTERFEIT L. A. Phippeny, November 28, 1900
  38. ST Apr 27, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 17 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, April 27, 1882
  39. RH May 28, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 2 — WISDOM Geo. Wright, May 28, 1861
  40. RH Dec 11, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 11 — COMMUNICATIONS J. Ederton, December 11, 1855

Cross-references

  1. Matthew 24:23

    Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not.

    Warns against claims that Christ is here or there.

  2. Mark 13:21-22

    And then if any man shall say to you, Lo, here is Christ; or, lo, he is there; believe him not:

    Christ warns against claims that he is here or there and false signs.

  3. Matthew 24:40-41

    Then shall two be in the field; the one shall be taken, and the other left.

    The passage connects Matthew’s examples of one taken and one left with Luke’s.

  4. Luke 17:31

    In that day, he which shall be upon the housetop, and his stuff in the house, let him not come down to take it away: and he that is in the field, let him likewise not return back.

    The warning about leaving property belongs to the same account.

  5. Matthew 24:16-18

    Then let them which be in Judaea flee into the mountains:

    Both texts warn people to flee rather than follow or return.

  6. Acts 5:34-37

    Then stood there up one in the council, a Pharisee, named Gamaliel, a doctor of the law, had in reputation among all the people, and commanded to put the apostles forth a little space;

    Theudas and Judas are cited as earlier examples of claimants not to follow.

  7. Matthew 24:27

    For as the lightning cometh out of the east, and shineth even unto the west; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.

    Christ’s coming is compared to lightning across the sky.