AdventAI

Luke 20:28

Saying, Master, Moses wrote unto us, If any man’s brother die, having a wife, and he die without children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    Saying, Master, Moses wrote to us, If any man’s brother die, having a wife, and he die without children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed to his brother.

  • King James Version

    Saying, Master, Moses wrote unto us, If any man’s brother die, having a wife, and he die without children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    saying, Master, Moses wrote unto us, If any man’s brother die, having a wife, and he die without children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • Webster Bible

    Saying, Master, Moses wrote to us, If any man's brother should die, having a wife, and he should die without children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed to his brother.

  • Revised Version

    saying, Master, Moses wrote unto us, that if a man’ s brother die, having a wife, and he be childless, his brother should take the wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • American Standard Version

    and they asked him, saying, Teacher, Moses wrote unto us, that if a man’ s brother die, having a wife, and he be childless, his brother should take the wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • Young's Literal Translation

    saying, 'Teacher, Moses wrote to us, If any one's brother may die, having a wife, and he may die childless — that his brother may take the wife, and may raise up seed to his brother.

  • Darby Translation

    demanded of him saying, Teacher, Moses wrote to us, If any one's brother, who has a wife, die, and he die childless, his brother shall take the wife and raise up seed to his brother.

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    saying—Teacher! Moses, wrote for us, If one’s brother die, having a wife, and, he, be, childless, that his brother shall take the wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    “ Teacher,” they said, “ Moses wrote for us that if a man’ s brother dies and leaves a wife but no children, the man is to marry his brother’ s widow and raise up offspring for him.

  • World English Bible

    They asked him, “ Teacher, Moses wrote to us that if a man’ s brother dies having a wife, and he is childless, his brother should take the wife and raise up children for his brother.

  • Bible in Basic English

    Master, Moses said that if a man's brother comes to his end, having a wife, but no children, his brother is to take the wife, and get a family for his brother.

  • Geneva Bible

    Saying, Master, Moses wrote vnto vs, If any mans brother die hauing a wife, and hee die without children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise vp seede vnto his brother.

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    Saying: Master, Moses wrote unto us, If any man’s brother die, having a wife, and he leave no children, that his brother should take her to wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

2 sources

The law set out here required that when a man died without children, his surviving brother was to take the widow as wife in order to raise up offspring in the dead brother's name.3SP 48.2–3 The Sadducees brought forward this requirement as a test case against Christ, and with other opponents they framed such questions to entangle Him and to attack faith in the resurrection.3SP 48.2–3Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 Their argument rested on the supposition that those raised would come back with the same physical bodies and earthly appetites, so that marriage ties and other earthly relations would simply continue as before.3SP 48.2–3 Christ met these ensnaring inquiries with direct and discerning replies that shed valuable light upon the hearers and planted seeds of truth among them.Ms 71, 1897, par. 27

Sources

  1. 3SP 48.2–3 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — JESUS AND THE PHARISEES. Ellen G. White, 1878
  2. Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 71, 1897 Ellen G. White, written July 11, 1897

Pioneers and periodicals

20 sources

The verse repeats Moses' law that when a married man dies childless his brother should marry the widow to raise up children for him.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 28, 1930 The Sadducees use that law to set out a case in which seven brothers in turn marry the same childless widow, and ask whose wife she will be when the dead are raised.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Jan 18, 1883 They ask as those who deny the resurrection and any future life, in order to test Jesus and make His teaching that the dead will be raised seem incredible.RH Apr 2, 1914RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1899 His answer proves from Moses that the dead will be awakened to live again, and it does not teach conscious survival or that the dead are already alive, for to make them already alive would leave no need for a resurrection and undo the very proof He gives.RH Sep 15, 1874RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Sep 8, 1859

The Law and Its Challenge

The verse quotes Moses' law of levirate marriage, that if a married man dies without children his brother is to marry the widow and raise up offspring for his deceased brother.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 28, 1930ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854 The children so raised were counted as the deceased brother's heirs, and the rule concerns marriage and inheritance in this present life.RH Mar 18, 1902 The rule is that of Deuteronomy 25:5 and concerns a brother who has died; it does not forbid marrying a brother's widow after he is dead, for the widow is free from her deceased husband to marry another man, and if the brother did not die childless the widow and his brother could marry if they wished.ST Jan 2, 1893

The Sadducees use the law to frame a hypothetical in which seven brothers successively marry the same woman and each dies childless.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 From that case they ask whose wife she will be in the resurrection and how the marriage would work if the dead are raised, and their question concerns marriage in the future world and the resurrection state.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 28, 1930ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1910

Belief in the resurrection of the body was common among the Jews at the time of Christ and the apostles.ST May 15, 1879 The captious question comes after the foretelling of His death, the healing of the blind man, the call of Zacchaeus, the parable of the pounds, the riding into Jerusalem, the weeping over the city, and the parable of the husbandman, and before His discourse on the destruction of Jerusalem and His second coming.ST Apr 21, 1909

Resurrection Not Conscious Survival

The Sadducees denied the resurrection and therefore any future life, and they brought forward the law requiring a brother to marry his childless brother's widow and raise up offspring for him, with the case of seven brothers successively marrying the same woman, to test Jesus and challenge His teaching about the resurrection.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1899RH Jun 12, 1856RH Apr 5, 1860RH Dec 12, 1854 Treating the resurrection as incredible can weaken confidence in the gospel, which declares that the dead will be raised.RH Apr 2, 1914RH Dec 12, 1854 Christ used the exchange to answer their denial, proving from the writings of Moses, which the Sadducees themselves accepted, that the dead will be raised and live again.ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Apr 5, 1860 The patriarchs will be raised, and the resurrection is the awakening of the dead and the means by which people have future life.RH Sep 15, 1874ST Jan 18, 1883RH Apr 5, 1860

The verse and its context do not teach a conscious intermediate state, immortal souls, or that the patriarchs and the dead are already alive.RH Sep 15, 1874RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 The dispute concerns the resurrection of the dead, not how immortal souls would live between death and resurrection or the state of the dead.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 Their question about whose wife the woman would be concerns marriage after the resurrection and people who had died, not the condition of the dead.ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854 Reading Christ's reply as proof that people remain alive after death or that the dead are already consciously alive would make His argument undermine the resurrection it set out to establish.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 Interpreting His answer to mean the dead are already alive would make a resurrection unnecessary and would fail to answer the Sadducees.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Sep 8, 1859

In the argument He did not object to their views about the state of the dead.RH Apr 5, 1860 Christ's answer distinguishes the future resurrection state, where people do not marry, from present marital arrangements concerning marriage and inheritance in this life.RH Mar 18, 1902 Those worthy to receive the coming world and resurrection are distinguished before the resurrection takes place.RH Apr 2, 1914 The question concerns marriage in the future life, not a rule for Christians in this present life, and it does not teach that people must remain unmarried to obtain the resurrection or become like angels.RH Feb 25, 1915 Together with the surrounding answer about the resurrection, the verse belongs to the repeated assurance in God's Word that strengthens the faith of those facing death and supports hope in God's power over death.ST Sep 7, 1904

Sources

  1. ST Feb 6, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 6 — THE GOD OF THE LIVING Pittenger, February 6, 1901
  2. ST Oct 28, 1930 Signs of the Times, Vol. 57, No. 42 — BIBLE SILENT ON THIS QUESTION October 28, 1930
  3. ST Jan 18, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 3 — The Resurrection Ellet Joseph Waggoner, January 18, 1883
  4. RH Apr 2, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 14 — The Judgment M. G. Huffman, Thursday, April 2, 1914
  5. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  6. ST Oct 25, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 43 — LESSON VI.—SABBATH, NOVEMBER 11, 1899 October 25, 1899
  7. RH Sep 15, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 13 — Scriptures Perverted J. H. Waggoner, September 15, 1874
  8. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  9. RH Sep 8, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 16 — OR, AN INQUIRY INTO THE PRESENT CONSTITUTION AND FUTURE CONDITION OF MAN.^[^*] Editor, September 8, 1859
  10. RH Mar 18, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 11 — An Artful Question Well Answered March 18, 1902
  11. ST Jan 2, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 9 — 70. TAKING ONE'S BROTHER'S WIFE. LEV. 18:16; 20:21 Editor, Monday, January 2, 1893
  12. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  13. ST Oct 25, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 42 — Shiloh: the Man of Sorrows October 25, 1910
  14. ST May 15, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 20 — JOSEPHUS UNRELIABLE Eld. D. M. Canright, May 15, 1879
  15. ST Apr 21, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 16 — OUR BIBLE BAND April 21, 1909
  16. RH Jun 12, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 7 — THE FIRST AND NINETEENTH CENTURIES June 12, 1856
  17. RH Apr 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 20 — SADDUCEEISM Fifth-Day, April 5, 1860
  18. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  19. RH Feb 25, 1915 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 92, No. 10 — Celibacy C. M. S., Thursday, February 25, 1915
  20. ST Sep 7, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 36 — DEATH AND RESURRECTION W. A. Sweany, September 7, 1904

Cross-references

  1. Deuteronomy 25:5-6

    If brethren dwell together, and one of them die, and have no child, the wife of the dead shall not marry without unto a stranger: her husband’s brother shall go in unto her, and take her to him to wife, and perform the duty of an husband’s brother unto her.

    Mosaic law requires a brother to marry his deceased brother’s childless widow and preserve his name.

  2. Matthew 22:24

    Saying, Master, Moses said, If a man die, having no children, his brother shall marry his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

    Both recount the Sadducees’ question based on the same law of levirate marriage.

  3. Mark 12:18-23

    Then come unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked him, saying,

    The Sadducees challenge Jesus about resurrection using the brother’s marriage obligation.

  4. Mark 12:24-25

    And Jesus answering said unto them, Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God?

    Jesus answers that the risen neither marry nor are given in marriage.

  5. Luke 20:35-36

    But they which shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage:

    The resurrection brings an end to marriage and death.

  6. Luke 20:37-38

    Now that the dead are raised, even Moses shewed at the bush, when he calleth the Lord the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.

    Christ’s reply to the Sadducees proves resurrection from Moses.

  7. Acts 23:8

    For the Sadducees say that there is no resurrection, neither angel, nor spirit: but the Pharisees confess both.

    It identifies the Sadducees’ denial of resurrection.

  8. Leviticus 18:16

    Thou shalt not uncover the nakedness of thy brother’s wife: it is thy brother’s nakedness.

    Prohibits relations with a brother’s wife, distinct from marrying a deceased brother’s widow.

  9. Romans 7:2-3

    For the woman which hath an husband is bound by the law to her husband so long as he liveth; but if the husband be dead, she is loosed from the law of her husband.

    A husband’s death changes the woman’s obligations under marriage law.

  10. 1 Corinthians 7:39

    The wife is bound by the law as long as her husband liveth; but if her husband be dead, she is at liberty to be married to whom she will; only in the Lord.

    A widow is free to marry after her husband dies.

  11. 1 Corinthians 15:12-19

    Now if Christ be preached that he rose from the dead, how say some among you that there is no resurrection of the dead?

    Resurrection is essential to the truth of the gospel.