Bring all the tithes into the storehouse means bringing the full tenth of all increase into God's treasury so that there is food and supply in His house to sustain His work. All means the exact whole tenth, not a small part or portion chosen at will, and withholding tithes with offerings is the robbery the verse answers. The tenth is the Lord's own sacred portion reserved for Him, and returning it is honesty rather than generosity, to be honored first before personal wants are met. The storehouse supply is for the ministry alone, to sustain gospel laborers and send the message into new fields, and it must not be retained or turned to other uses even when they seem good. Prove me herewith is God's invitation to test Him by obedient giving, with the pledge that He will open heaven and pour out blessing too great to receive, above all in grace and the outpouring of His Spirit, while also rebuking the devourer and preserving the fruits of the ground.
Verse Wording and Setting
The command is to bring all the tithes into the storehouse, which is God's treasury, so that there may be meat, food and supply in His house to sustain His work. The tithe is to be brought in together with offerings to meet the needs of His house. Faithful return allows the means entrusted to men to advance the gospel, keeps supply abundant for His work, and brings God's promised blessing on those who obey, while withholding what is His is robbing Him. Bringing the full tithe is a plain duty and a test of obedience, stated so plainly as to leave no excuse for neglect, and it is the condition of prosperity temporal and spiritual. Neglect brings a curse, and God's failure to restrain destruction follows from refusal to be faithful, leaving men without His blessing and protection.
All means the exact full tenth, not a small portion, half, quarter, or two-thirds. Every steward must return an exact tenth of all increase because it is not his own, whether means are little or large, without measuring or calculating to see how it comes out. No part is to be withheld to satisfy a selfish heart taking what God claims as His own. There is to be no substituting of charity, gifts, or offerings given when and how human agents choose for God's exact plan. Those who honor His word and figure tithing truly and faithfully have His pledged word that He will open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing so large there is not room to receive it, and He will work in their behalf and entrust them with larger responsibilities and facilities for obtaining more means, while those who withhold in their own wisdom keep themselves under condemnation as unfaithful stewards, deprive themselves and His treasury of blessing, and will meet their robbery when the books are opened and every man is judged according to deeds done in the body. The tithes thus brought are to provide for God's work so funds are available when new fields open for messengers to carry the truth to those who do not know God and Jesus Christ, who may in turn become missionaries to others.
The verse is God's definite answer to His people's claim that they do not know wherein they have robbed Him, identifying withholding tithes and offerings as robbing God and bringing a curse on the whole nation. The system of tithing behind the command is treated as already understood. Malachi 3 stands as a clear and forceful statement of God's requirements. The verse holds out God's challenge to prove Him by obedience, with promise to open heaven and pour out blessing beyond capacity to receive.
The verse states the contract, covenant and agreement God has made with man. The earth is the Lord's storehouse, from which He supplies all necessities of fruits and grains and vegetables and sun and rain to good and evil alike, and from which the whole human family constantly draws. He has made men His stewards, almoners and distributors, to draw from His storehouse and then make a faithful return to Him in tithes and offerings so there may be meat in His house to supply the needs of His cause. On that faithful return He will act His part, bestowing His great gifts, opening the windows of heaven and pouring out blessing beyond capacity to receive, for He never fails to keep His agreements, while selfish withholding robs Him. Tithes and offerings are part of the covenant between God and His people, His plan is definitely stated and clearly understandable so no one can say the duty could not be understood, and those meeting His conditions may test Him and trust His abundant blessing, while failing to meet them forfeits what He promised. God gave His blessings, including giving His only begotten Son to die, and in return requires faithfulness to the contract, which is trifled with when the return is withheld.
The requirement to bring all the tithes into the storehouse so there may be meat in His house for sacred purposes spans the patriarchal age, the Jewish economy and the apostolic age. This arrangement was made by Jesus Christ and carries solemn, eternal consequences. The principle of systematic giving applies in every age, and the tithing system is a binding duty for God's people in the last days as for ancient Israel, with the needs of the last days calling for even deeper sacrifice. This duty belongs to believers in every age and is not to be enforced by men, but like Sabbath-keeping is to be obeyed willingly from the heart. Converts and newly raised churches must be taught these practical obligations plainly, since withholding the teaching leaves them unprepared for God's claims. Proving the Lord means returning tithes and offerings rather than withholding to save means, staying on the safe side in dealing with God, and joining faithful prayer with freewill giving, while disregarding His claim brings a curse and obedience carries His decided promise to be proved.
Joined to the promise are assurances that God will rebuke the devourer and destroyer, restrain destruction, and protect crops, fruits of the ground and vines from dropping fruit before the time. The blessing includes protection from crop loss and a fruitful land. He will make the land delightsome and cause all nations to call His people blessed. Faithfulness in giving is thus linked to prosperity in temporal and spiritual things, while withholding is disobedience.
The passage contrasts the apparent success of the proud and wicked with the faithful who honor God, who are remembered as His own and will ultimately be distinguished from the wicked. It belongs to the call for a refining, winnowing process and transformation of character in every church because the Lord is soon to come, so the church puts on the righteousness of Christ and vessels unto honor are made manifest by receiving the latter rain and being discerned between him that serves God and him that serves Him not, while every soul continuing in sin in the light now shining will be blinded and accept delusions from Satan as this earth's history closes.
The verse ordains organization and the ways, means and appointed agencies for forwarding God's work in days of peril. Denouncing the church as Babylon and standing against organization opposes this plain command to bring all the tithes into the treasury of God's house, neglects God-appointed work, and shows unscriptural views of the nature, office and power of His appointed agencies. Such work does not bring greater efficiency to the cause and kingdom of God.
Tithe Ownership and Measure
The tithe is one-tenth of all increase, income, substance and possessions, what is lent in trust, while the remaining nine-tenths are entrusted to people for their use, and withholding any of it is robbery that disregards divine law while faithful return recognizes divine ownership. Goods and means held by people remain entrusted by God who reserves the tenth and directs its use, and obeying that direction brings safety while following human plans instead is disobedience. The tithe is the Lord's own required portion, sacred and reserved for Him as the seventh day is set apart, to be set apart regularly for sacred use. That arrangement for support of His work is attributed to Jesus Christ.
Returning the tithe is not gratitude or generosity but honesty, because it already belongs to the Lord. Withholding that specified portion shows dishonesty before Him, and those who withhold cannot claim His favor while complaining He does not recognize them as they think He should. God's claim on income must be honored first before personal wants are met and not made as small as possible. Whether income is large or small the tenth belongs to God, even when income is small and giving requires sacrifice and hardship, and poverty does not excuse neglect since people are to give according to what they have and faithfulness with little is valuable.
The tenth is to be set aside and brought faithfully before the rest is used, and returning it leaves the remainder sanctified and blessed. It is part of the revenue supporting the gospel and is no longer available for personal or secular use, and it is not a fund for the poor to be used as one pleases but belongs in the treasury for provision for those carrying the message, so treating it as money to use at pleasure violates the requirement and forfeits blessing. Withholding part while appearing to follow the rules is like the deceit of Ananias and Sapphira. Their keeping back part of what was pledged illustrates covetousness, fraud and hypocrisy toward God who detects hidden sin and will not be mocked, and robbing God is choosing one's own way, will and pleasure and keeping back what is His through selfishness that lies at the foundation of all sin.
Neglect to return the tenth is recorded in heaven's books as unfaithful handling of entrusted means and as indebtedness to be met in judgment. Withheld offerings bring curse, poor harvests, loss and affliction, while free and unblemished offering of the best brings blessing on family and possessions. Simply beginning to tithe correctly later does not erase the record without repentance and restitution, so those who kept it back should reckon what they owe even over twenty years, make up the deficiency without delay, and bring all back tithe with promises to pay into the treasury so it is not left empty, with repentance shown by works bringing forgiveness and peace.
Christ is the absent householder who left His vineyard to men as husbandmen and stewards, the tithe is the rental owed to the Owner from all goods placed in man's care, and every church member must keep account of that portion and bring it with gifts and offerings into the treasury. Property in human hands is means provided for spreading the gospel, to be used in His service not for selfish or worldly purposes, and how it is used bears on reward in the judgment. As property and wealth accumulate and increase, stewards accountable for even small amounts are to honor God thankfully to do good and advance His cause rather than trust riches or turn means to harmful tempting uses, and wasting what is entrusted is forbidden. All money and property belongs to the Lord with men and women only stewards to bring into His storehouse under His counsel, and tying it up in houses or land or wasting it in pleasure-loving selfish gratification robs the treasury and hinders the cause.
Everyone including those connected with God's appointed institutions, who owe Him intellect and all capabilities, must bring tithes freely, willingly and gladly following Abraham who paid tithe of all he possessed and received, because there is no safety in withholding God's own portion. Those entrusted with large means and with goods as His agents for advancing His work including medical missionary work are tested to acknowledge all as His and use His capital to build His kingdom, bringing a faithful tithe besides gifts and offerings as the cause demands and walking honestly before Him.
Storehouse Purpose and Supply
The storehouse is God's treasury for sustaining gospel laborers, ministers, watchmen on the walls of Zion, and missionary work and for opening new fields. Faithful payment keeps an abundant supply in the treasury and encourages more laborers to take up ministerial work, while withholding through selfish hearts and hands, selfish handling, or using tithe to support other lines depletes the treasury, holds up the work, keeps men from entering the ministry, and leaves the treasury unable to provide for appointed ministers except in haphazard manner. Everything a person calls his own is held in trust from God, with a certain portion to be given back in tithes and offerings as the required return, and all receivers of His mercies show appreciation by complying as faithful stewards. The tithe is one-tenth of increase, sacred and reserved for God as the seventh day is set apart, with nine-tenths entrusted to people, and returning what He claims is obedient duty and privilege bringing happiness, abundant blessing, and protection of crops from destruction.
Meat in His house is the revenue thus brought in to supply the needs of His cause. That revenue sustains gospel laborers, supplies the treasury with means to carry forward the work, spreads the gospel, sends workers and publications, plants truth in new and foreign fields, and helps carry truth to every land, with a steady contribution from each member showing living interest in the success of truth and glory of God. Bringing all means the full honest amount with no part withheld to satisfy a selfish heart, not one-fourth or one-half but the whole tithe God requires, as men are His stewards asked to return from blessing received to bless others. Bringing all also means keeping a surplus in the treasury to amply advance the work in its various branches, so that those blessed let blessing continually flow out in deeds of mercy and benevolence, continually giving as they continually receive. Believers are to deny extravagant outlay, practice temperance and economy in home life, and support the ministry to the churches, for God made this provision so blessing may rest on the church and refusal leaves people without His approval.
The funds are to be used in an orderly way to sustain gospel laborers in sermonizing and all ministering. They sustain ministers and missionaries who teach Scripture and work from house to house, give adequate support to those devoting time to saving souls so just wages are not begrudged, necessities are not lacking, they can live comfortably and lead in donations, and provide facilities for carrying the message rapidly into new fields including the needy Southern field, sustaining established work, entering new territory, and providing many more laborers. Faithful payment relieves financial burdens and enables missionary work to advance, while withholding or postponing what is due is robbery bringing curse and rebuke and retarding the work. Bringing tithe to the Lord's house supplies resources that can support the work in other places, and one unfaithful should repent and bring a faithful tithe.
The tithe is sacred money for the ministry alone, His special revenue fund for that one purpose, to be carefully guarded and used strictly in appointed lines. It must not be retained, redirected, borrowed, or diverted to other lines even when those causes are good, and those other lines must receive separate support. It is not the minister's property to keep for personal purposes or redirect by human judgment, and goods and means held by people are entrusted by God who reserves this tenth and directs its use, so obeying brings safety and diverting to human plans is disobedience. Money dedicated to God must be handled faithfully for its appointed work, for diverting it is robbery of His treasury for which God will judge, whereas faithful stewardship would have advanced the work, and God will not work in favor of misusers.
What is set apart for the Lord is gospel revenue and is no longer ours. To take from His treasury to serve self or others in secular business is sacrilege, diverting from His altar what is dedicated to Him, and no one in strait place may take consecrated money for personal advantage even intending to repay later. It is far better to cut expenses to match income, restrict wants, and live within means than to use the Lord's money for secular purposes. The tithe must not be diverted under temptation or pressure to educating students, meeting temporal needs, or providing church conveniences, and the working force bearing truth must not be reduced to fit the treasury; departing from the plan lessens blessing and brings great lack of means. Money entrusted for a special purpose must promptly be placed where it belongs and every penny carefully recorded, never diverted to meet an emergency on assumption it can be replaced later, for such handling is unfaithful and forbidden. The tithe sustains ministers in new fields and other places generously with regard for greater cost of living and hard conditions, and borrowing it or meddling with it for other work including incidental expenses or business gaps creates evils and lifts from members a burden they should carry by gifts, offerings, self-denial, economy, plain dress without display or needless adornment, with faith and works corresponding.
The tithe is not to be used for ordinary, incidental, running, weekly, meetinghouse, or charity expenses or to care for the needy. Doing so diverts resources from sacred service, robs God, misapplies a consecrated fund, and loses His blessing. Those expenses belong to members to meet through gifts, offerings, self-denial, economy, and free sufficient giving, the tithe being distinct from local meeting expenses. A house built for divine service should be given for freely and sufficiently to finish comfortable, neat, and convenient for His presence and never left in debt, for debt dishonors Him, and withholding what belongs to God is answered by affliction in family and decrease of possessions according to the disposition to rob.
Bringing all the tithes means a constant stream and steady giving by each member keeping the treasury supplied and the work moving forward. Where tithe is abundant the extra is to be sent to poor places and foreign countries where tithe is limited and qualified men cannot be employed for lack of means, for the vineyard is large, and it is not to be drawn upon for weekly demands of well-furnished churches such as Oakland, Battle Creek, Healdsburg, and San Francisco. Those demands are to be met by members themselves through self-denial, economy, gifts and offerings, with officers binding about wants and setting example, and God will bless faithful messenger and members, but if tithe fills gaps in favored churches He will remove blessing. Funds must not be absorbed into work He has not appointed or spent selfishly while the needy lack help and the work is neglected, for such use is robbery, empties the treasury, deprives hungry people of temporal and spiritual bread, and leaves fields needing workers without support.
Each church is to bring its tithe so ministry is supported and more ministers can carry the gospel to new places. Money goes from the local church to the conference and to the General Conference for universal wants where the work must be built up, supporting the cause in different places and funding ministers sent elsewhere. The tenth with gifts and offerings belongs to God for advancing His work, including sending preachers to teach Scripture to those in spiritual darkness and preaching to the poor and needy, and must not be diverted to other lines. Ministers are also to practice self-denial, taking less so others called to serve can share support. Meat to provide for His servants includes giving a sick feeble worker the good Samaritan's care with best and most comfortable provision rather than penny-wise suffering. Such a worker must not be left to travel alone crowded with smokers and rough drinking men, but be given even a first-class carriage with expense freely charged rather than withheld for fear of taxing the conference, for to permit such suffering is grief, as what is done to His disciple is done to Jesus. Heaven's side opens when the bright beams of the Sun of Righteousness shine fully into the heart and spread to others, especially by careful tender regard making workers in hard deprived fields as comfortable and pleasantly situated as possible, and the Lord blesses such love toward workers in hard places. Directing tithe to urgently needy ministers and undone work does not withhold it from the Lord's treasury.
Proving God and Blessing
The verse invites men to prove and test God by obedient giving, bringing the full tithe into the storehouse for the needs of His work as a plain duty and test of obedience. Faithfulness is the condition of prosperity, and those who obey are promised abundant blessing in temporal and spiritual things, with protection of produce, crops and vines and a delightful, blessed land acknowledged by the nations. He means what He says and never fails His agreements, giving humility, wisdom and guidance in daily trust and obedience, and able to do more than can be asked even in difficulties brought to test faith.
The promised blessing is not money poured from heaven, for material means are entrusted to men to support the message and open new fields, and withholding them is robbery revealing selfishness. It is grace and power, rich floods of light, righteousness, peace and joy, and above all the outpouring of His Spirit in reviving fullness. That baptism of the Spirit alone can bring the church to its right position and prepare a people for the approaching conflict.
God is behind all His promises and distinctly pledges Himself to answer, His Word so positive and ample as to leave no room for mistake or limitation, Yea and Amen in Christ, with resources that cannot be exhausted. He challenges all to prove Him and see what He will do in their behalf if they do their part, opening heaven and pouring out blessing beyond measure, too large to receive, upon those who meet the conditions. Those who bring specified tithes and offerings as tokens of loyalty and submission have substance blessed and increased to abundance, and humble souls renewed to purity.
Obedience is duty and should be done for its own sake, yet in compassion for fallen humanity He joins His command with promises of richest blessing, with returns proportionate to what is given. Those who freely return what He requires are blessed in proportion to the value placed on sacred things, giving willingly and generously, while limiting offerings limits blessings. When His portion, claimed before every other claim, is returned the remainder is blessed, but when withheld the whole is sooner or later cursed and met with affliction and loss.
Those who honor His word and figure tithing truly and faithfully, bringing the exact tenth without measuring results or substituting charities and gifts of human choosing, have His pledged word to open heaven, work in their behalf, and entrust larger responsibilities and facilities for obtaining more means. When with grateful hearts they bring gifts and offerings not grudgingly or of necessity, His blessing attends them, gifts for sacred work are multiplied, the channel stays open, and faithful stewards are entrusted with greater trusts. Those who withhold, walk in their own wisdom and rob God keep themselves under condemnation as unfaithful stewards, deprive treasury and self of blessing, forfeit fitness for larger trust, and will meet the robbery when books are opened for judgment according to deeds done in the body.
Heaven's windows remain open and God is still waiting to be gracious with abundance of grace and power. Loss of blessing and the near-ceasing of godliness come not from His withholding but from separation from Him, unconverted barren souls, conformity to worldly customs, selfishness, and lack of faith that closes heaven against His people. The blessing is received by thorough conversion and deeper work of grace, giving the heart to God, fixing the eye of faith upon the cross, exalting Jesus and relying wholly on His merits as strength and salvation.
When He opens heaven He gives light and spiritual endowment for a purpose, the working of the Spirit quickening energies, lodging motive power in the heart, and arousing the missionary spirit. That light is to shine in practical works of righteousness, with deeper piety as those bought by blood and clothed in salvation, to carry the message, set forth Christ crucified, call to repentance, and warn that Christ is coming with power and great glory. The endowment must be used in cooperation with Him through human agencies, with patience and vigilance moving into unentered regions and cities, exercising every talent and leaving ease and pleasant homes; if bound in a napkin and hidden through selfish ease it is wasted, and lovers of pleasure fall back into deathlike slumber under curse.
He blesses the work of hands so men may return His portion, giving sunshine and rain, causing vegetation to flourish, granting fruitful seasons, health and ability to acquire means, with every blessing from His bountiful hand. Dependence on Him for life and health and for crops and fields, cattle, herds and vineyards calls for faithful duty in tithes and offerings, leaving no reason to rob Him. Gratitude is shown by returning tithes with thank offerings, freewill offerings and trespass offerings, devoting means to His service, and consecrating specified gifts as tokens of loyalty, dependence and submission to His sovereignty.
When all members pay a faithful tithe with gifts and offerings, a constant stream flows into the treasury and God richly blesses the faithful so the work of preparing a people for His coming may be quickly finished. The test reveals whether eternal riches are prized above earthly things and whether men will surrender self and the world to Christ. The promise of abundant blessing also belongs to His help in response to humble, contrite prayer from those who draw near to Him.
Robbery Curse and Judgment
Withholding tithes and offerings is robbing God, bringing a curse on the whole nation and on the delinquent, withdrawing blessing and protection and leaving guilt, while faithfulness is duty and honesty and the condition of prosperity temporal and spiritual. The tithe belongs to the Lord and must be brought in full to His storehouse to support His work and supply the gospel commission, showing dependence on Him and accountability for what He entrusts. Those who return it faithfully may test His promise, for He will open heaven and pour out blessing beyond capacity to receive, restrain the devourer and destroyer, protect crops and vines from dropping fruit early, make the land delightful, and cause other nations to call them blessed. Neglect of this duty withholds what is His, leaves people without His blessing and protection, and God's failure to restrain destruction follows from refusal to be faithful.
Withholding is no speculative theory but presumptuous robbery and wasting His goods upon self, a truth of deepest interest and most weighty importance to be carried distinctly worldwide so none has excuse in judgment. God is still testing whether people will be faithful servants, calling them to consider His goodness and respond with loyalty and gratitude in giving the full tithe for His house, with warning and instruction in righteousness for every soul whose promise still stands and would be fulfilled if obeyed. Keeping back the portion He reserved proves unfaithful stewardship, causing loss not only of what was withheld from God but also of what was entrusted as one's own, damaging spiritual life, while faithful stewardship studied and practiced through love and fear waters the garden of the soul and advances spiritual life. Neglect brings His sure visitation upon the neglectful, a loss that cannot be afforded, withdraws His special blessing, hinders His work, and the deficiency is to be made up without delay with repentance shown by works.
Insulting God by ignoring His love and requirements, treating entrusted gifts as human productions to be used as pleased, and leaving His worldwide work of sending light to those in darkness undone brings His judgments, for He can easily scatter possessions of all who dishonor Him. Tithing is a plain command with no exceptions requiring obedient dependent children to return the portion He marked as His own with gifts and offerings so His house is supplied, and everyone claiming belief must comply. Withholding breaks the covenant and agreement between God and humanity, turning blessing into curse, and can lead others to disregard His commandments. He knows every heart and rewards all who freely return what He requires, answering robbery with affliction in family and decrease in possessions according to the disposition to rob, permitting the destroyer to act and leaving people exposed to loss and calamity when they hinder His work.
Withholding to save wealth for children robs God and deprives children of earning and giving toward benevolent work and advancement of His cause. Using tithes to pay personal debts is robbery and debt does not justify withholding, for withholding what belongs to God is misusing entrusted goods, dishonest disobedience bringing curse and eternal loss, recorded in heaven's books. The tenth belongs to God as part of the steward's responsibility to put Christ's cause first, and those who use His gifts for self while doing little to advance His cause hinder His work, bring His curse upon themselves, and deprive themselves of heavenly treasure though their means remain entrusted for His use.
Many rich men are unfaithful stewards in God's sight in acquiring and using means, neglecting God as great Proprietor and failing to relieve the suffering and oppressed. Robbing God includes withholding from needy fellow workers while keeping profits and advantages under one's own management where one part has abundance and another struggles in poverty for lack of facilities, which is covetousness, selfishness and idolatry. The rich man failed to return tithe as acknowledgment that all came from God, while gifts and offerings should also help the needy like Lazarus, and after meeting God's claim first His people must care for the poor even by sacrifice, using entrusted money to relieve suffering, clothe the naked, feed the hungry, advance truth and build His kingdom lest the house lack provision.
Money held by worldly men is God's own money kept from Him all their lives. Returning what is His does not put the Creator in debt, and those who selfishly keep and use entrusted means for their own interests are unfaithful stewards whom God may end by scattering wealth or bringing affliction. Withholding to increase earthly treasure profits nothing, for God's claim underlies every other claim and all food, health, clothing and earthly blessing comes through Jesus Christ, so a portion must be returned to express gratitude, become laborers together with God, and secure happiness, safety and blessing reserved not to enrich Himself but for human good. Money spent on unnecessary selfish useless purposes limits giving to His work, diverts support from His cause, and deprives His house of meat for saving souls so the work is retarded and the treasury emptied through neglect.
Spending entrusted money on the destroying lust of tobacco, giving more to that indulgence than to the poor and to God while souls perish for the word of life, continues robbery of tithes and offerings that sustain the gospel, relieve the poor and supply His cause. Truly sanctified overcoming of every hurtful lust turns all those channels of needless expense to the treasury in self-denial, self-sacrifice and temperance. Faithfulness in giving would keep His treasury from being empty, and those who rob Him deprive themselves of rich blessings He is ready to bestow.
God's work depends on faithful stewardship, and hoarding lent means for personal or family wealth betrays trust, conflicts with bringing tithes to His treasury, and can harm children's spiritual interests. Giving only a small portion in a will does not make up for withholding during life, when means should be used faithfully to advance His cause through offerings and support for missions and spread of truth. Unfaithfulness in handling the cause's funds harms the work and damages discernment of right principles, and gives newcomers an excuse. Those who withheld should repent, humble themselves, make restitution as far as they can, meet His requirement so the gospel can be shared, and He will fill them with His Spirit and power.
Time, service, affection, prayer, worship, strength and property all belong to Him with money, and robbing Him is choosing own way, will and pleasure while professing to give all. Putting farms, business and earthly increase first robs Him of service time owed and brings curse rather than blessing, for all money and property is the Lord's, requiring giving in deed and truth to spread truth rather than withholding or putting it into children's hands to escape responsibility. The principle of bringing all tithes applies also to giving time and physical and mental strength, whose servants walk in light and triumph in Him, and God accepts only a spiritual priesthood bringing offering in righteousness, loving Him supremely and neighbor as self with no reservation, denying self and following Christ for present and eternal good.
Withholding comes from ceasing to deny self, as fruit of covetousness, decline of spirituality, doubt and unbelief, and strange principles spreading like evil leaven when grasping after higher wages is witnessed. Neglecting to render to God what is His is sin, and He will not bless His people while they disregard His plan of benevolence, for it is fearful to be guilty of robbing Him. The duty must be pressed by pointed practical teaching showing danger and sinfulness of selfishness and covetousness until conviction fastens on minds and the icy chill of selfishness is broken, so those who would do nothing are aroused to give.
Teaching Duty Faithfully
The command is God's own plain ordinance, laid down in clear lines with no exceptions or conditions, still binding now, and heaven's plan for teaching that men are subjects of Christ's kingdom. It requires obedient children dependent on God for all they have to bring the exact full honest tithe with gifts and offerings into the treasury so His house is supplied to sustain and carry on His work and send truth to all parts of the world. No desire to do duty, no ignorance, idea, or prejudice can excuse withholding, failure must be answered for at the judgment, and any teaching that tithes should not be paid is condemned as not from the Lord and exactly describes a present condition of robbery needing correction especially in the last days without setting the tithing system aside. Refusing to comply after warning brings the dealing described in the chapter, while meeting the requirement brings good to the obedient, helps others by example, and opens the promised special blessing and prosperity conditioned on doing His will.
Ministers and conference presidents bear solemn duty to teach and warn every member rich or poor on this point by personal labor, precept and example, impressing the crime of robbing God and educating, rebuking and warning against neglect. Neglecting this instruction leaves people secure in disobedience, leaves the treasury short, hinders the work and leaves the church lifeless and ineffective, while faithful teaching brings fruit in souls, honest payment of workers, funds to pay laborers and advance missionary work, and many more laborers. What is set apart for the Lord is the revenue of the gospel and no longer ours, so it must be sacredly devoted to His work from a portion of income belonging to God.
Converts and every newly raised church must be taught these practical obligations plainly as part of Christian instruction, the truth of the duty made clear so they can do what is essential for God's approval even when they say they cannot see it. Clouded spiritual perception keeps duties from being seen, withholding the teaching can leave converts unprepared for God's claims and cause some to reject truth later or turn away from the faith, and people should learn His requirements by searching the Old Testament Scriptures willing to bear inconvenience or hardship rather than withhold.
Dissatisfaction with leaders, lack of confidence in management at the heart of the work, disagreement with brethren, or belief that means are misused and unworthy ministers receive some of it gives no right to withhold for any reason. Duty is to keep paying gladly and freely and not withdraw from God's work because others are not doing right, to bring grievances and petitions openly in the right spirit to the proper ones to have things adjusted and set in order, to do what can be done to correct evil management, and to leave erring managers accountable to God for their own sin. Withholding from ignorance or dissatisfaction is unfaithfulness and robbery toward God that braves His curse, tends to poverty of soul and increases financial difficulty, while giving honors Him.
Gifts and offerings pledged to God are solemn commitments to the Creator witnessed and recorded in heaven, and nothing is sufficient excuse for breaking them. Honesty with God requires faithfulness in tithes and offerings including keeping pledges made under His Spirit and settling what is owed and one's account with God when means are available. Withholding is robbing God, and those who withheld must confess the wrong, stop withholding, make restitution as far as they can of what was not given, and prove the Lord by faithfully returning the full tithe along with gifts and offerings for the world, on which He promises abundant blessing.
God requires tithes according to the tithing plan He established to supply His house, and men are not free to replace His arrangement with one of their own. The system tests character week by week and month by month, develops character and reveals the true state of the heart, with each person responsible for deciding whether to give much or little. Giving is to be free, willing and glad without human compulsion or ministerial pressure, condemnation or sharpness over amount, to be obeyed willingly as sacred time is kept, following God's arrangement with each bearing a fair share and not requiring pledges beyond means or depriving families of necessities. One bringing tithes to sustain the ministry is trying to serve God with all his power and must not be met with sharpness, for God has a treasury to be sustained and largely sustained by the sacred liberal tithe, and those handling it must act so transparently that the confidence of the whole people is established and nothing is feared to be opened as light as day.
Reading Malachi with the Spirit brings a sense of personal responsibility for tithes and offerings, because what men possess belongs to God who entrusted it to them and calls everyone to bring a faithful tithe into His treasury so it will not be empty.
Prophecy for Last Days
The prophecy has special application to the last days, requiring God's people to bring a proportion of their substance as a freewill offering to the Lord. Its promise of opened heaven and blessing beyond capacity to receive concerns that duty of faithful giving, not speaking or praying in meetings. It is God's present call in the closing years of probation, as the great day of the Lord is at hand, to bring all the tithes into the storehouse so there may be provision in His house and to prove Him by doing so. This requires returning a certain portion to the treasury as His own, acknowledging dependence on God and accountability to Him, even though all men enjoy comes from Him and He is pleased for His people to enjoy His goods. Every soul converted to the truth and every newly raised church must be decidedly instructed in this requirement for tithes and offerings in the spirit of Christ, turning from sin to righteousness, and the means thus gathered is to be invested in missionary work to sustain foreign missions and fulfill the commission to teach all nations.
The promises will be fulfilled as God's people become channels through which His blessings flow to support the work, carrying out what He gives them zealously and unselfishly, including the work in Washington. The appeal applies now to do one's best to advance that work and to meet constant calls from foreign fields for men and means, so unbelievers may see the work begun is able to be finished, with the fitting response a willing collection. They will be fulfilled when those who have received great light humble themselves before God and confess their sins, for God will not uphold those who turn from truth and righteousness. Rendering to the Lord what is His own relieves His work of poverty, while hoarded wealth becomes a curse and God cannot preserve and bless possessions when owners feel no obligation to help proclaim the truth in new fields. Substance generously divided with brethren laboring with meager facilities in destitute fields brings rich blessings in return, and those truly converted who have more than sufficient for immediate necessities will freely impart of their abundance to help those poorer than they, while those who selfishly hold their means in this emergency will soon suffer loss of all they have.
The verse applies to advancing the third angel's message by giving cheerfully and liberally to provide laborers and facilities for entering new territory, since scarcity of means retards the work and God's rebuke rests on those who do not come up to His help against the mighty powers of darkness. Every church member is bound by covenant relation with God to bring all tithes and offerings as God's own into His treasury and prove faithful in paying them to make the record right, denying self of every extravagant outlay and practicing economy in home life. The means thus brought in are to give adequate support to those who devote their time to saving souls, so their just wages are not begrudged, they do not lack necessities, they can live comfortably, and they can lead in donations to the cause. Faithfulness supplies facilities for carrying the message rapidly into new fields, including the needy Southern field, sustains work already established, enters new territory, and provides many more laborers, while withholding retards the work; and faithfully bringing to the treasury the means He has lent carries the promise that His work will make rapid advancement, many souls will be won, and the day of Christ's coming will be hastened.
All the tithe belongs in God's storehouse to provide for His house, and honesty in tithes and offerings rather than robbery is joined to the invitation to test His promise that obedience brings abundant blessing. The verse also supports using entrusted means to spread the truth and advance missionary work, so believers who cannot go themselves can help reach people in distant lands by giving tithes and freewill offerings, avoiding unnecessary expenses, and using money saved to advance the message. Faithful giving supports meetinghouses, sanitariums, and schools, helps win people to the truth, and hastens Christ's coming. Now is the time to bring tithes and offerings into the storehouse as rendering to God for all His benefits and meeting obligation to the Creator, as working for the Master to save souls perishing in sin and representing Him by carrying truth into new territory and giving the warning to those in darkness, a solemn charge of representing Him as the light of the world laid upon His people for which the church will be held responsible if it fails.
What is required is a faithful tithe and a willing thank offering, with gifts of influence and property and capital entrusted rightly valued and used together with money, time, strength, and influence to relieve the needs of His cause and advance the interests dearest to God's heart, because He needs the cooperation of every soul for the large field to be worked. These gifts fill the treasury so workers can be sent to advance the work and reach people in spiritual darkness, and they are to be managed carefully and used to support those in need as well as the saving mission. Many will not be blessed till they make restitution of tithe withheld, by accurate reckoning and bringing to the Lord what was taken from His work with peace offerings, and upon free and full repentance and acknowledgment of misappropriating His goods He will forgive the transgression, for His holy law rests upon every soul enjoying His benefits and He waits for them to redeem the past. Bringing tithes into the storehouse provides means for God's work including missionary work, while withholding contributes to financial hardship and brings a curse as robbery of the Lord. Withholding robs God of resources intended to bring people to knowledge of the truth, and failure to bring the full tithe leaves His work without needed means, causing workers to hesitate, narrowing the work, and delaying efforts to reach the cities, while faithfulness helps provide for saving souls.
Offerings Beyond Tithe
The tithe is not the limit of liberality, for offerings beyond the tenth are also due as grateful response to continual blessings, proportionate to means for both the poor whose small gifts can do much and those with greater means who must give accordingly, and the command to bring all into the storehouse calls for both tithes and offerings together as faithful workers show by giving both. Offerings express gratitude for benefits received, and those able are not to come empty-handed but prepared according to means, including coming to religious meetings and camp-meetings ready to work, leaving home cares to find Jesus, and bringing gifts proportioned to blessings as gratitude to the Creator. Even the firstfruits of the new year are a privilege to bring though small, directed to God rather than spent on self-pleasing, and Christmas and Thanksgiving are best kept by turning gifts from presents and trifles to His treasury to support His work. Timely tithes belong with freewill offerings, and appeals awaken neglected duty so people recognize and give intelligently.
Offerings must be suitable, free, and from the best, unblemished from flocks and fields, with firstfruits of increase, for withholding a proper share brings curse on harvests, flocks, families and possessions while a right offering brings blessing on family and possessions. Giving follows the divine arrangement with each bearing a fair share, yet it does not require pledges beyond means or depriving families of necessities. Tithes, gifts and offerings belong to God as signs of loyalty, dependence and gratitude, and with faithful tithes the firstfruits provide ample means for His work and for helping the poor and suffering, while failure leaves the treasury short and the work in need. Gratitude must be shown in deeds not words alone, after first giving self to God with strictest integrity, for faith without works is worthless, and because He continually gives while men continually receive they remain obligated to return, with blessing withheld when they weary of doing so.
Value is measured not by amount but by willing loving motive, and giving is to be systematic in proportion to prosperity, including gifts from the poor, with even those unable to give much setting aside a small amount regularly. Every member rich or poor is to give as prospered, for withholding what belongs to God is robbery, and faithful giving provides funds to pay workers and advance missionary work. This duty never permits pressuring beyond means or taking food needed for a hungry family, and pledges to God are to be fulfilled while means are available. Faithful tithe joined with offerings and avoidance of extravagant spending supports the work and makes more facilities available.
The produce of field, orchard and soil is to be faithfully tithed for His house, while specified offerings and gifts also help the poor and sustain the growing work. Bringing what belongs to Him invites the test of the opened windows and blessing beyond capacity to receive, calling for means to be placed in His treasury and not withheld. Meat in His house means resources for ministers and missionaries bringing truth to seekers, so believers are urged to turn from selfish wants, give up possessions, dispose of idols and unnecessary things, and send means in many small contributions to support the work and advance the gospel. Entrusted money is to relieve suffering, feed the hungry, clothe the naked, advance truth and build the kingdom, and withholding deprives His house of what is needed. Princely offerings are called for to meet ever-increasing opportunities, as connected with the school in that locality.
Giving to support His work does not enrich God whose treasures are already His, but benefits the giver by laying up secure treasure in heaven and helping bring souls to salvation, while putting earthly wealth first robs the giver of eternal riches and brings curse rather than blessing. Bringing all tithes and offerings flows from a heart transformed by divine love and freed from selfishness and covetousness, with abundant blessing promised and faithfulness to the end leading toward the heavenly kingdom. To return His own is the whole duty and privilege of the steward, honoring Him with substance and firstfruits of increase rather than grudging or restricted return, for withholding brings spiritual loss. What is given is made secure and sent before the giver to the heavenly courts while what is retained is eternal loss, and spiritual prosperity is bound up with liberality, with blessing resting on unwearied diligence in small things and wise use of cents as well as dollars bringing wonderful increase. Gifts wisely placed where they do greatest good, especially now for cities and new fields, advance the work and produce a harvest of souls, including provision by will after family need so His cause receives its portion for present use.
God made provision for supporting His work including ministry to the churches so blessing may rest upon the church, and refusing is disobedience leaving people without approval and blessing. Giving what is not needed for personal comfort and indulgence shows love to God and neighbor and supports work for the needy, with means saved by economy, self-denial, plain dress and denial of indulgence bringing provision and rich blessing. Every member is bound by covenant to bring tithes and offerings and make the record right, denying extravagant outlay and practicing economy at home so workers devoting time to saving souls receive just wages without begrudging, have necessities, live comfortably, and can lead in donations. Faithfulness supplies facilities to carry the message rapidly into new fields including the needy Southern field, sustains established work, enters new territory and provides many more laborers, while withholding retards the work and brings rebuke on those who do not come up to help. When every family cuts indulgence His house is supplied and work opens where truth was never heard, with substance generously divided with brethren laboring with meager facilities in destitute fields returning rich blessings, while selfishly held means in emergency soon suffers loss of all.
The plan of systematic giving was devised by Jesus Christ Himself, who gave His life for the world, left the royal courts, laid aside honor as Commander of the heavenly hosts, clothed divinity with humanity to uplift the fallen race, and became poor so men through His poverty might be rich. A tenth of all possessions is reserved for Himself besides gifts and offerings to be brought into His storehouse, as provision for carrying forward the gospel and sustaining those who bear His message. This plan is best for men because it cultivates gratitude and liberality, frees from selfishness contrary to His character, and guards against worldliness, covetousness, avarice and greed, so that by grace men are registered as co-laborers with Christ in redemption. God gives gifts to those who love Him so they can share with others, and returning the tenth with offerings is His way of saving from worldliness, greed and selfishness.
Faithful Obedience and Fruit
Bringing all the tithes means giving back to God everything He claims, including a set portion of all income, and putting goods held in trust to use to relieve brethren in poverty and distress and to break every yoke of oppression. It is to be done in this life while entrusted means can still be used in His service, as an acknowledgment of dependence on Him and a return of what belongs to Him. Withholding is robbing Him, and there is no excuse for neglecting so plain a duty, for professing to serve Him while serving self and holding goods in selfish plans dishonors Him. The command speaks to every church, every family, and every individual, and will be met in the judgment in the revelation of the good that might have been done in acts of charity. Obedience proves Him, and He will open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing too large to receive.
Those who obey with unswerving fidelity in returning His own in tithes and offerings test His word and receive overflowing blessing from opened heaven. Strengthened faith, removal of doubts and perplexities, fears overcome by assurance, strength to fight spiritual battles, clear confidence of acceptance and favor, light, growth in grace and in the knowledge of Jesus Christ, and steadfastness in abounding work follow taking Him at His word and doing it. Giving the full tithe so His house is supplied is the condition for accepting professed Christians and answering their prayers, for holding it back for gain from worldliness and selfishness shuts the soul from Him, leaves curse hanging over it, and makes casual prayers for acceptance wholly vain without genuine conversion. Meeting the condition lets the obedient prove Him who promises blessing beyond capacity to receive, and returning it helps the gospel go forward with power as doing His will on earth as in heaven, while dishonest dealing brings judgment. This fidelity with undivided heart belongs to the present time of cooperation with God and heavenly agencies, and is urgent because the great day is near, great things are about to take place, time is especially precious, and night comes when no one can work, so light must be obeyed while it remains lest darkness come.
Tithes with gifts and offerings belong to God as His reserved portion and are to be faithfully returned as signs of loyalty, dependence, and gratitude, the tenth being due from all substance with liberal offerings keeping a constant stream so His house has provision. They are sacred, to be set apart regularly for His work and not handled by personal impulse, an arrangement for supporting the ministry that must not be diverted to other lines, which are to have separate support. Withholding is unfaithfulness and continual robbery of His portion, and withholders will answer for it, for because He continually gives and men continually receive they remain obligated to give back, and when they weary of it His blessing is withheld. Giving by His plan supports the church, provides honest wages for workers, lets the treasury meet its obligations, and advances missionary work, and if He were not robbed one hundred times more work could be done instead of cheap plans shaped by selfishness. When churches put finances in order without robbing Him, salvation is seen and the faithful are blessed and made channels of blessing, for faith without works is worthless and gratitude must be shown in deeds not words alone.
The verse lays down a working principle from henceforth requiring the naturally selfish and covetous to act in the opposite direction and give where they withheld, and this giving is the only way to victory and eternal life. Withholding His own in tithes and offerings is sin and robbery that withdraws His blessing and leaves great debt to Him, and it is not faithful to keep it for personal use when increased wealth enlarges the tithe or to delay it hoping to invest it for a larger future gift. Obedience requires curtailing expenses, turning money spent for self-gratification into His treasury, and for those with houses and lands even selling to give alms, making haste to be honest without delay and putting every talent of means and ability to use while day lasts because He is soon to come and is testing response to His benefits. Guilt for withholding must be confessed to God and to the church and put away by heeding the injunction to bring all the tithes so there may be means to sustain soul-saving work, as necessary preparation before asking for prayer and restoration of health.
Returning tithes and offerings tests allegiance and gratitude and puts means and compassionate labor to work helping needy perishing souls. It puts His claims first and brings walking in light, for His chosen people favored above all others and called from darkness into marvelous light to show His praises must return fruits essential to His kingdom in proportion to blessings received. Those given most advantages prove benefit by rendering His own in unselfish devoted service, with gratitude expressed in deeds of holiness and strictest integrity, dividing goods with fellow laborers, for blessings and privileges mean sacred responsibilities. Faithful tithes with peace, thank, and freewill offerings given for His great love leave no dearth in His treasury and make the gospel available to the world as He intends, and faithful giving is part of serving Him with spirit, soul, and body rather than robbing Him. So doing acknowledges that blessings and entrusted possessions come from Him and belong to Him, and gives the world evidence of remembrance.
Bringing tithes and offerings into His treasury has been followed by converted hearts, confession of wrong, and thousands given in love, the conversion of the heart being the greatest miracle and evidence of His work. Meat in His house means means to send warnings and entreaties to the world so suffering and want need not exist, and those who obey are promised blessing and peace while the disobedient are cursed. Holding back shuts out blessing, so robbers cannot expect to come to His house to be exalted like others but murmur and complain, and all who misplace entrusted means and fail to sustain His work must render account for souls lost and for retarding its advance. The money brought in is not enough for giving sacred truths, working barren fields, employing sowers, garnering harvest, and planting truth in new and foreign places, and learning self-denial and self-sacrifice in giving would make the church the light of the world. Cooperation by sincere service, self-denial, denying needless spending, and giving for Him as He gave His life plants His standard where truth was never heard and carries the work forward.
Wider Calls and Warnings
Faithful bringing of the whole tithe would supply what the gospel requires and keep the treasury full, so that there would be no need to resort to fairs, lotteries, or pleasure parties to raise funds. The command is to be carefully studied, obeyed, and taught to others so they may learn how to receive God's blessing, with those who receive it becoming educators of others in obedience. When all act together in harmony in obeying it, the salvation of God will be seen, for He blesses faithfully dealing both financially and spiritually. Failure to bring the full tithe leaves the work of saving souls without needed means, causing workers to hesitate, narrowing the work, and delaying efforts to reach the cities.
Wealth entrusted by God must not be misused on costly buildings when it is needed to carry the gospel to places that have not received it. Those who test His faithfulness are promised open windows of heaven with more blessing than can be received, together with restraint of the devourer, preservation of crops and vines from dropping fruit early, and being made delightsome and blessed among the nations. He will not fill His empty treasury by raining money from heaven, but maintains the gospel ministry through faithful return of the honest tithe with liberal gifts, since means, food, and clothing are entrusted to men as His helping hand. Parental dishonesty in robbing God and failure to train children by self-denial to return what is His, to give even from small gifts, and to use means by His directions hardens them against preaching when grown and robs God to the third and fourth generation through children and grandchildren with no inclination to fear and obey Him. When He sends workers to any field He has a work to be done there under His own direction requiring means to be used in that field, so to withhold what He requires is robbery, and failure to invest where distressing necessity calls leaves the work years behind.
His people are to stand in His strength with windows open heavenward and closed earthward so that salvation is revealed. The open windows bring blessing by binding medical missionary work and the gospel fast together as an inseparable united whole, by connecting talent in individuals, schools, and every institution with the management of His work and churches, by carrying the work through committees representing every part instead of leaving two or three minds to rule as kings, and by lifting foreign missionary work to a higher grade than before. The charge against withholding tithes applies to selfish, covetous withholding in Michigan rather than true liberal-heartedness. The churches in Australia and New Zealand were to do far more in 1893 than in any previous year in supplying means to the Lord's house, for a great revolution in giving had to take place in that country before the work could progress to any great extent.
Selfishness is the great sin of the world and has become the prevailing sin of the church, greatly dishonoring God when His people fail to impart means for the advancement of His work with power. Responsibility rests on believers everywhere to pay a faithful tithe, not allowing lax principles to lead to robbery, but keeping a faithful account with the Creator and being just with Him who has divine foreknowledge, each diligently searching the heart and looking up accounts to find how he stands in relation to God. Keeping back tithes and offerings is failing to hear and answer His claim to His portion, when the noise and distractions of the world prevent listening to Him and seeking Him earnestly. Practicing the truth ends this dishonest robbery for gain and disobedience, along with contention about who is greatest and strife for supremacy, and when all His commandments are obeyed with faithful tithes and offerings the love that brings peace and joy into the family circle is cherished and the Redeemer is honored before men. Families who test Him by self-denial and gifts to help teach the poor about the Saviour will be blessed.
Bring all the tithes into the storehouse means bringing the full tenth of all increase into God's treasury so that there is food and supply in His house to sustain His work. All means the exact whole tenth, not a small part or portion chosen at will, and withholding tithes with offerings is the robbery the verse answers. The tenth is the Lord's own sacred portion reserved for Him, and returning it is honesty rather than generosity, to be honored first before personal wants are met. The storehouse supply is for the ministry alone, to sustain gospel laborers and send the message into new fields, and it must not be retained or turned to other uses even when they seem good. Prove me herewith is God's invitation to test Him by obedient giving, with the pledge that He will open heaven and pour out blessing too great to receive, above all in grace and the outpouring of His Spirit, while also rebuking the devourer and preserving the fruits of the ground.
Verse Wording and Setting
The command is to bring all the tithes into the storehouse, which is God's treasury, so that there may be meat, food and supply in His house to sustain His work. The tithe is to be brought in together with offerings to meet the needs of His house. Faithful return allows the means entrusted to men to advance the gospel, keeps supply abundant for His work, and brings God's promised blessing on those who obey, while withholding what is His is robbing Him. Bringing the full tithe is a plain duty and a test of obedience, stated so plainly as to leave no excuse for neglect, and it is the condition of prosperity temporal and spiritual. Neglect brings a curse, and God's failure to restrain destruction follows from refusal to be faithful, leaving men without His blessing and protection.
All means the exact full tenth, not a small portion, half, quarter, or two-thirds. Every steward must return an exact tenth of all increase because it is not his own, whether means are little or large, without measuring or calculating to see how it comes out. No part is to be withheld to satisfy a selfish heart taking what God claims as His own. There is to be no substituting of charity, gifts, or offerings given when and how human agents choose for God's exact plan. Those who honor His word and figure tithing truly and faithfully have His pledged word that He will open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing so large there is not room to receive it, and He will work in their behalf and entrust them with larger responsibilities and facilities for obtaining more means, while those who withhold in their own wisdom keep themselves under condemnation as unfaithful stewards, deprive themselves and His treasury of blessing, and will meet their robbery when the books are opened and every man is judged according to deeds done in the body. The tithes thus brought are to provide for God's work so funds are available when new fields open for messengers to carry the truth to those who do not know God and Jesus Christ, who may in turn become missionaries to others.
The verse is God's definite answer to His people's claim that they do not know wherein they have robbed Him, identifying withholding tithes and offerings as robbing God and bringing a curse on the whole nation. The system of tithing behind the command is treated as already understood. Malachi 3 stands as a clear and forceful statement of God's requirements. The verse holds out God's challenge to prove Him by obedience, with promise to open heaven and pour out blessing beyond capacity to receive.
The verse states the contract, covenant and agreement God has made with man. The earth is the Lord's storehouse, from which He supplies all necessities of fruits and grains and vegetables and sun and rain to good and evil alike, and from which the whole human family constantly draws. He has made men His stewards, almoners and distributors, to draw from His storehouse and then make a faithful return to Him in tithes and offerings so there may be meat in His house to supply the needs of His cause. On that faithful return He will act His part, bestowing His great gifts, opening the windows of heaven and pouring out blessing beyond capacity to receive, for He never fails to keep His agreements, while selfish withholding robs Him. Tithes and offerings are part of the covenant between God and His people, His plan is definitely stated and clearly understandable so no one can say the duty could not be understood, and those meeting His conditions may test Him and trust His abundant blessing, while failing to meet them forfeits what He promised. God gave His blessings, including giving His only begotten Son to die, and in return requires faithfulness to the contract, which is trifled with when the return is withheld.
The requirement to bring all the tithes into the storehouse so there may be meat in His house for sacred purposes spans the patriarchal age, the Jewish economy and the apostolic age. This arrangement was made by Jesus Christ and carries solemn, eternal consequences. The principle of systematic giving applies in every age, and the tithing system is a binding duty for God's people in the last days as for ancient Israel, with the needs of the last days calling for even deeper sacrifice. This duty belongs to believers in every age and is not to be enforced by men, but like Sabbath-keeping is to be obeyed willingly from the heart. Converts and newly raised churches must be taught these practical obligations plainly, since withholding the teaching leaves them unprepared for God's claims. Proving the Lord means returning tithes and offerings rather than withholding to save means, staying on the safe side in dealing with God, and joining faithful prayer with freewill giving, while disregarding His claim brings a curse and obedience carries His decided promise to be proved.
Joined to the promise are assurances that God will rebuke the devourer and destroyer, restrain destruction, and protect crops, fruits of the ground and vines from dropping fruit before the time. The blessing includes protection from crop loss and a fruitful land. He will make the land delightsome and cause all nations to call His people blessed. Faithfulness in giving is thus linked to prosperity in temporal and spiritual things, while withholding is disobedience.
The passage contrasts the apparent success of the proud and wicked with the faithful who honor God, who are remembered as His own and will ultimately be distinguished from the wicked. It belongs to the call for a refining, winnowing process and transformation of character in every church because the Lord is soon to come, so the church puts on the righteousness of Christ and vessels unto honor are made manifest by receiving the latter rain and being discerned between him that serves God and him that serves Him not, while every soul continuing in sin in the light now shining will be blinded and accept delusions from Satan as this earth's history closes.
The verse ordains organization and the ways, means and appointed agencies for forwarding God's work in days of peril. Denouncing the church as Babylon and standing against organization opposes this plain command to bring all the tithes into the treasury of God's house, neglects God-appointed work, and shows unscriptural views of the nature, office and power of His appointed agencies. Such work does not bring greater efficiency to the cause and kingdom of God.
Tithe Ownership and Measure
The tithe is one-tenth of all increase, income, substance and possessions, what is lent in trust, while the remaining nine-tenths are entrusted to people for their use, and withholding any of it is robbery that disregards divine law while faithful return recognizes divine ownership. Goods and means held by people remain entrusted by God who reserves the tenth and directs its use, and obeying that direction brings safety while following human plans instead is disobedience. The tithe is the Lord's own required portion, sacred and reserved for Him as the seventh day is set apart, to be set apart regularly for sacred use. That arrangement for support of His work is attributed to Jesus Christ.
Returning the tithe is not gratitude or generosity but honesty, because it already belongs to the Lord. Withholding that specified portion shows dishonesty before Him, and those who withhold cannot claim His favor while complaining He does not recognize them as they think He should. God's claim on income must be honored first before personal wants are met and not made as small as possible. Whether income is large or small the tenth belongs to God, even when income is small and giving requires sacrifice and hardship, and poverty does not excuse neglect since people are to give according to what they have and faithfulness with little is valuable.
The tenth is to be set aside and brought faithfully before the rest is used, and returning it leaves the remainder sanctified and blessed. It is part of the revenue supporting the gospel and is no longer available for personal or secular use, and it is not a fund for the poor to be used as one pleases but belongs in the treasury for provision for those carrying the message, so treating it as money to use at pleasure violates the requirement and forfeits blessing. Withholding part while appearing to follow the rules is like the deceit of Ananias and Sapphira. Their keeping back part of what was pledged illustrates covetousness, fraud and hypocrisy toward God who detects hidden sin and will not be mocked, and robbing God is choosing one's own way, will and pleasure and keeping back what is His through selfishness that lies at the foundation of all sin.
Neglect to return the tenth is recorded in heaven's books as unfaithful handling of entrusted means and as indebtedness to be met in judgment. Withheld offerings bring curse, poor harvests, loss and affliction, while free and unblemished offering of the best brings blessing on family and possessions. Simply beginning to tithe correctly later does not erase the record without repentance and restitution, so those who kept it back should reckon what they owe even over twenty years, make up the deficiency without delay, and bring all back tithe with promises to pay into the treasury so it is not left empty, with repentance shown by works bringing forgiveness and peace.
Christ is the absent householder who left His vineyard to men as husbandmen and stewards, the tithe is the rental owed to the Owner from all goods placed in man's care, and every church member must keep account of that portion and bring it with gifts and offerings into the treasury. Property in human hands is means provided for spreading the gospel, to be used in His service not for selfish or worldly purposes, and how it is used bears on reward in the judgment. As property and wealth accumulate and increase, stewards accountable for even small amounts are to honor God thankfully to do good and advance His cause rather than trust riches or turn means to harmful tempting uses, and wasting what is entrusted is forbidden. All money and property belongs to the Lord with men and women only stewards to bring into His storehouse under His counsel, and tying it up in houses or land or wasting it in pleasure-loving selfish gratification robs the treasury and hinders the cause.
Everyone including those connected with God's appointed institutions, who owe Him intellect and all capabilities, must bring tithes freely, willingly and gladly following Abraham who paid tithe of all he possessed and received, because there is no safety in withholding God's own portion. Those entrusted with large means and with goods as His agents for advancing His work including medical missionary work are tested to acknowledge all as His and use His capital to build His kingdom, bringing a faithful tithe besides gifts and offerings as the cause demands and walking honestly before Him.
Storehouse Purpose and Supply
The storehouse is God's treasury for sustaining gospel laborers, ministers, watchmen on the walls of Zion, and missionary work and for opening new fields. Faithful payment keeps an abundant supply in the treasury and encourages more laborers to take up ministerial work, while withholding through selfish hearts and hands, selfish handling, or using tithe to support other lines depletes the treasury, holds up the work, keeps men from entering the ministry, and leaves the treasury unable to provide for appointed ministers except in haphazard manner. Everything a person calls his own is held in trust from God, with a certain portion to be given back in tithes and offerings as the required return, and all receivers of His mercies show appreciation by complying as faithful stewards. The tithe is one-tenth of increase, sacred and reserved for God as the seventh day is set apart, with nine-tenths entrusted to people, and returning what He claims is obedient duty and privilege bringing happiness, abundant blessing, and protection of crops from destruction.
Meat in His house is the revenue thus brought in to supply the needs of His cause. That revenue sustains gospel laborers, supplies the treasury with means to carry forward the work, spreads the gospel, sends workers and publications, plants truth in new and foreign fields, and helps carry truth to every land, with a steady contribution from each member showing living interest in the success of truth and glory of God. Bringing all means the full honest amount with no part withheld to satisfy a selfish heart, not one-fourth or one-half but the whole tithe God requires, as men are His stewards asked to return from blessing received to bless others. Bringing all also means keeping a surplus in the treasury to amply advance the work in its various branches, so that those blessed let blessing continually flow out in deeds of mercy and benevolence, continually giving as they continually receive. Believers are to deny extravagant outlay, practice temperance and economy in home life, and support the ministry to the churches, for God made this provision so blessing may rest on the church and refusal leaves people without His approval.
The funds are to be used in an orderly way to sustain gospel laborers in sermonizing and all ministering. They sustain ministers and missionaries who teach Scripture and work from house to house, give adequate support to those devoting time to saving souls so just wages are not begrudged, necessities are not lacking, they can live comfortably and lead in donations, and provide facilities for carrying the message rapidly into new fields including the needy Southern field, sustaining established work, entering new territory, and providing many more laborers. Faithful payment relieves financial burdens and enables missionary work to advance, while withholding or postponing what is due is robbery bringing curse and rebuke and retarding the work. Bringing tithe to the Lord's house supplies resources that can support the work in other places, and one unfaithful should repent and bring a faithful tithe.
The tithe is sacred money for the ministry alone, His special revenue fund for that one purpose, to be carefully guarded and used strictly in appointed lines. It must not be retained, redirected, borrowed, or diverted to other lines even when those causes are good, and those other lines must receive separate support. It is not the minister's property to keep for personal purposes or redirect by human judgment, and goods and means held by people are entrusted by God who reserves this tenth and directs its use, so obeying brings safety and diverting to human plans is disobedience. Money dedicated to God must be handled faithfully for its appointed work, for diverting it is robbery of His treasury for which God will judge, whereas faithful stewardship would have advanced the work, and God will not work in favor of misusers.
What is set apart for the Lord is gospel revenue and is no longer ours. To take from His treasury to serve self or others in secular business is sacrilege, diverting from His altar what is dedicated to Him, and no one in strait place may take consecrated money for personal advantage even intending to repay later. It is far better to cut expenses to match income, restrict wants, and live within means than to use the Lord's money for secular purposes. The tithe must not be diverted under temptation or pressure to educating students, meeting temporal needs, or providing church conveniences, and the working force bearing truth must not be reduced to fit the treasury; departing from the plan lessens blessing and brings great lack of means. Money entrusted for a special purpose must promptly be placed where it belongs and every penny carefully recorded, never diverted to meet an emergency on assumption it can be replaced later, for such handling is unfaithful and forbidden. The tithe sustains ministers in new fields and other places generously with regard for greater cost of living and hard conditions, and borrowing it or meddling with it for other work including incidental expenses or business gaps creates evils and lifts from members a burden they should carry by gifts, offerings, self-denial, economy, plain dress without display or needless adornment, with faith and works corresponding.
The tithe is not to be used for ordinary, incidental, running, weekly, meetinghouse, or charity expenses or to care for the needy. Doing so diverts resources from sacred service, robs God, misapplies a consecrated fund, and loses His blessing. Those expenses belong to members to meet through gifts, offerings, self-denial, economy, and free sufficient giving, the tithe being distinct from local meeting expenses. A house built for divine service should be given for freely and sufficiently to finish comfortable, neat, and convenient for His presence and never left in debt, for debt dishonors Him, and withholding what belongs to God is answered by affliction in family and decrease of possessions according to the disposition to rob.
Bringing all the tithes means a constant stream and steady giving by each member keeping the treasury supplied and the work moving forward. Where tithe is abundant the extra is to be sent to poor places and foreign countries where tithe is limited and qualified men cannot be employed for lack of means, for the vineyard is large, and it is not to be drawn upon for weekly demands of well-furnished churches such as Oakland, Battle Creek, Healdsburg, and San Francisco. Those demands are to be met by members themselves through self-denial, economy, gifts and offerings, with officers binding about wants and setting example, and God will bless faithful messenger and members, but if tithe fills gaps in favored churches He will remove blessing. Funds must not be absorbed into work He has not appointed or spent selfishly while the needy lack help and the work is neglected, for such use is robbery, empties the treasury, deprives hungry people of temporal and spiritual bread, and leaves fields needing workers without support.
Each church is to bring its tithe so ministry is supported and more ministers can carry the gospel to new places. Money goes from the local church to the conference and to the General Conference for universal wants where the work must be built up, supporting the cause in different places and funding ministers sent elsewhere. The tenth with gifts and offerings belongs to God for advancing His work, including sending preachers to teach Scripture to those in spiritual darkness and preaching to the poor and needy, and must not be diverted to other lines. Ministers are also to practice self-denial, taking less so others called to serve can share support.
Meat to provide for His servants includes giving a sick feeble worker the good Samaritan's care with best and most comfortable provision rather than penny-wise suffering. Such a worker must not be left to travel alone crowded with smokers and rough drinking men, but be given even a first-class carriage with expense freely charged rather than withheld for fear of taxing the conference, for to permit such suffering is grief, as what is done to His disciple is done to Jesus. Heaven's side opens when the bright beams of the Sun of Righteousness shine fully into the heart and spread to others, especially by careful tender regard making workers in hard deprived fields as comfortable and pleasantly situated as possible, and the Lord blesses such love toward workers in hard places. Directing tithe to urgently needy ministers and undone work does not withhold it from the Lord's treasury.
Proving God and Blessing
The verse invites men to prove and test God by obedient giving, bringing the full tithe into the storehouse for the needs of His work as a plain duty and test of obedience. Faithfulness is the condition of prosperity, and those who obey are promised abundant blessing in temporal and spiritual things, with protection of produce, crops and vines and a delightful, blessed land acknowledged by the nations. He means what He says and never fails His agreements, giving humility, wisdom and guidance in daily trust and obedience, and able to do more than can be asked even in difficulties brought to test faith.
The promised blessing is not money poured from heaven, for material means are entrusted to men to support the message and open new fields, and withholding them is robbery revealing selfishness. It is grace and power, rich floods of light, righteousness, peace and joy, and above all the outpouring of His Spirit in reviving fullness. That baptism of the Spirit alone can bring the church to its right position and prepare a people for the approaching conflict.
God is behind all His promises and distinctly pledges Himself to answer, His Word so positive and ample as to leave no room for mistake or limitation, Yea and Amen in Christ, with resources that cannot be exhausted. He challenges all to prove Him and see what He will do in their behalf if they do their part, opening heaven and pouring out blessing beyond measure, too large to receive, upon those who meet the conditions. Those who bring specified tithes and offerings as tokens of loyalty and submission have substance blessed and increased to abundance, and humble souls renewed to purity.
Obedience is duty and should be done for its own sake, yet in compassion for fallen humanity He joins His command with promises of richest blessing, with returns proportionate to what is given. Those who freely return what He requires are blessed in proportion to the value placed on sacred things, giving willingly and generously, while limiting offerings limits blessings. When His portion, claimed before every other claim, is returned the remainder is blessed, but when withheld the whole is sooner or later cursed and met with affliction and loss.
Those who honor His word and figure tithing truly and faithfully, bringing the exact tenth without measuring results or substituting charities and gifts of human choosing, have His pledged word to open heaven, work in their behalf, and entrust larger responsibilities and facilities for obtaining more means. When with grateful hearts they bring gifts and offerings not grudgingly or of necessity, His blessing attends them, gifts for sacred work are multiplied, the channel stays open, and faithful stewards are entrusted with greater trusts. Those who withhold, walk in their own wisdom and rob God keep themselves under condemnation as unfaithful stewards, deprive treasury and self of blessing, forfeit fitness for larger trust, and will meet the robbery when books are opened for judgment according to deeds done in the body.
Heaven's windows remain open and God is still waiting to be gracious with abundance of grace and power. Loss of blessing and the near-ceasing of godliness come not from His withholding but from separation from Him, unconverted barren souls, conformity to worldly customs, selfishness, and lack of faith that closes heaven against His people. The blessing is received by thorough conversion and deeper work of grace, giving the heart to God, fixing the eye of faith upon the cross, exalting Jesus and relying wholly on His merits as strength and salvation.
When He opens heaven He gives light and spiritual endowment for a purpose, the working of the Spirit quickening energies, lodging motive power in the heart, and arousing the missionary spirit. That light is to shine in practical works of righteousness, with deeper piety as those bought by blood and clothed in salvation, to carry the message, set forth Christ crucified, call to repentance, and warn that Christ is coming with power and great glory. The endowment must be used in cooperation with Him through human agencies, with patience and vigilance moving into unentered regions and cities, exercising every talent and leaving ease and pleasant homes; if bound in a napkin and hidden through selfish ease it is wasted, and lovers of pleasure fall back into deathlike slumber under curse.
He blesses the work of hands so men may return His portion, giving sunshine and rain, causing vegetation to flourish, granting fruitful seasons, health and ability to acquire means, with every blessing from His bountiful hand. Dependence on Him for life and health and for crops and fields, cattle, herds and vineyards calls for faithful duty in tithes and offerings, leaving no reason to rob Him. Gratitude is shown by returning tithes with thank offerings, freewill offerings and trespass offerings, devoting means to His service, and consecrating specified gifts as tokens of loyalty, dependence and submission to His sovereignty.
When all members pay a faithful tithe with gifts and offerings, a constant stream flows into the treasury and God richly blesses the faithful so the work of preparing a people for His coming may be quickly finished. The test reveals whether eternal riches are prized above earthly things and whether men will surrender self and the world to Christ. The promise of abundant blessing also belongs to His help in response to humble, contrite prayer from those who draw near to Him.
Robbery Curse and Judgment
Withholding tithes and offerings is robbing God, bringing a curse on the whole nation and on the delinquent, withdrawing blessing and protection and leaving guilt, while faithfulness is duty and honesty and the condition of prosperity temporal and spiritual. The tithe belongs to the Lord and must be brought in full to His storehouse to support His work and supply the gospel commission, showing dependence on Him and accountability for what He entrusts. Those who return it faithfully may test His promise, for He will open heaven and pour out blessing beyond capacity to receive, restrain the devourer and destroyer, protect crops and vines from dropping fruit early, make the land delightful, and cause other nations to call them blessed. Neglect of this duty withholds what is His, leaves people without His blessing and protection, and God's failure to restrain destruction follows from refusal to be faithful.
Withholding is no speculative theory but presumptuous robbery and wasting His goods upon self, a truth of deepest interest and most weighty importance to be carried distinctly worldwide so none has excuse in judgment. God is still testing whether people will be faithful servants, calling them to consider His goodness and respond with loyalty and gratitude in giving the full tithe for His house, with warning and instruction in righteousness for every soul whose promise still stands and would be fulfilled if obeyed. Keeping back the portion He reserved proves unfaithful stewardship, causing loss not only of what was withheld from God but also of what was entrusted as one's own, damaging spiritual life, while faithful stewardship studied and practiced through love and fear waters the garden of the soul and advances spiritual life. Neglect brings His sure visitation upon the neglectful, a loss that cannot be afforded, withdraws His special blessing, hinders His work, and the deficiency is to be made up without delay with repentance shown by works.
Insulting God by ignoring His love and requirements, treating entrusted gifts as human productions to be used as pleased, and leaving His worldwide work of sending light to those in darkness undone brings His judgments, for He can easily scatter possessions of all who dishonor Him. Tithing is a plain command with no exceptions requiring obedient dependent children to return the portion He marked as His own with gifts and offerings so His house is supplied, and everyone claiming belief must comply. Withholding breaks the covenant and agreement between God and humanity, turning blessing into curse, and can lead others to disregard His commandments. He knows every heart and rewards all who freely return what He requires, answering robbery with affliction in family and decrease in possessions according to the disposition to rob, permitting the destroyer to act and leaving people exposed to loss and calamity when they hinder His work.
Withholding to save wealth for children robs God and deprives children of earning and giving toward benevolent work and advancement of His cause. Using tithes to pay personal debts is robbery and debt does not justify withholding, for withholding what belongs to God is misusing entrusted goods, dishonest disobedience bringing curse and eternal loss, recorded in heaven's books. The tenth belongs to God as part of the steward's responsibility to put Christ's cause first, and those who use His gifts for self while doing little to advance His cause hinder His work, bring His curse upon themselves, and deprive themselves of heavenly treasure though their means remain entrusted for His use.
Many rich men are unfaithful stewards in God's sight in acquiring and using means, neglecting God as great Proprietor and failing to relieve the suffering and oppressed. Robbing God includes withholding from needy fellow workers while keeping profits and advantages under one's own management where one part has abundance and another struggles in poverty for lack of facilities, which is covetousness, selfishness and idolatry. The rich man failed to return tithe as acknowledgment that all came from God, while gifts and offerings should also help the needy like Lazarus, and after meeting God's claim first His people must care for the poor even by sacrifice, using entrusted money to relieve suffering, clothe the naked, feed the hungry, advance truth and build His kingdom lest the house lack provision.
Money held by worldly men is God's own money kept from Him all their lives. Returning what is His does not put the Creator in debt, and those who selfishly keep and use entrusted means for their own interests are unfaithful stewards whom God may end by scattering wealth or bringing affliction. Withholding to increase earthly treasure profits nothing, for God's claim underlies every other claim and all food, health, clothing and earthly blessing comes through Jesus Christ, so a portion must be returned to express gratitude, become laborers together with God, and secure happiness, safety and blessing reserved not to enrich Himself but for human good. Money spent on unnecessary selfish useless purposes limits giving to His work, diverts support from His cause, and deprives His house of meat for saving souls so the work is retarded and the treasury emptied through neglect.
Spending entrusted money on the destroying lust of tobacco, giving more to that indulgence than to the poor and to God while souls perish for the word of life, continues robbery of tithes and offerings that sustain the gospel, relieve the poor and supply His cause. Truly sanctified overcoming of every hurtful lust turns all those channels of needless expense to the treasury in self-denial, self-sacrifice and temperance. Faithfulness in giving would keep His treasury from being empty, and those who rob Him deprive themselves of rich blessings He is ready to bestow.
God's work depends on faithful stewardship, and hoarding lent means for personal or family wealth betrays trust, conflicts with bringing tithes to His treasury, and can harm children's spiritual interests. Giving only a small portion in a will does not make up for withholding during life, when means should be used faithfully to advance His cause through offerings and support for missions and spread of truth. Unfaithfulness in handling the cause's funds harms the work and damages discernment of right principles, and gives newcomers an excuse. Those who withheld should repent, humble themselves, make restitution as far as they can, meet His requirement so the gospel can be shared, and He will fill them with His Spirit and power.
Time, service, affection, prayer, worship, strength and property all belong to Him with money, and robbing Him is choosing own way, will and pleasure while professing to give all. Putting farms, business and earthly increase first robs Him of service time owed and brings curse rather than blessing, for all money and property is the Lord's, requiring giving in deed and truth to spread truth rather than withholding or putting it into children's hands to escape responsibility. The principle of bringing all tithes applies also to giving time and physical and mental strength, whose servants walk in light and triumph in Him, and God accepts only a spiritual priesthood bringing offering in righteousness, loving Him supremely and neighbor as self with no reservation, denying self and following Christ for present and eternal good.
Withholding comes from ceasing to deny self, as fruit of covetousness, decline of spirituality, doubt and unbelief, and strange principles spreading like evil leaven when grasping after higher wages is witnessed. Neglecting to render to God what is His is sin, and He will not bless His people while they disregard His plan of benevolence, for it is fearful to be guilty of robbing Him. The duty must be pressed by pointed practical teaching showing danger and sinfulness of selfishness and covetousness until conviction fastens on minds and the icy chill of selfishness is broken, so those who would do nothing are aroused to give.
Teaching Duty Faithfully
The command is God's own plain ordinance, laid down in clear lines with no exceptions or conditions, still binding now, and heaven's plan for teaching that men are subjects of Christ's kingdom. It requires obedient children dependent on God for all they have to bring the exact full honest tithe with gifts and offerings into the treasury so His house is supplied to sustain and carry on His work and send truth to all parts of the world. No desire to do duty, no ignorance, idea, or prejudice can excuse withholding, failure must be answered for at the judgment, and any teaching that tithes should not be paid is condemned as not from the Lord and exactly describes a present condition of robbery needing correction especially in the last days without setting the tithing system aside. Refusing to comply after warning brings the dealing described in the chapter, while meeting the requirement brings good to the obedient, helps others by example, and opens the promised special blessing and prosperity conditioned on doing His will.
Ministers and conference presidents bear solemn duty to teach and warn every member rich or poor on this point by personal labor, precept and example, impressing the crime of robbing God and educating, rebuking and warning against neglect. Neglecting this instruction leaves people secure in disobedience, leaves the treasury short, hinders the work and leaves the church lifeless and ineffective, while faithful teaching brings fruit in souls, honest payment of workers, funds to pay laborers and advance missionary work, and many more laborers. What is set apart for the Lord is the revenue of the gospel and no longer ours, so it must be sacredly devoted to His work from a portion of income belonging to God.
Converts and every newly raised church must be taught these practical obligations plainly as part of Christian instruction, the truth of the duty made clear so they can do what is essential for God's approval even when they say they cannot see it. Clouded spiritual perception keeps duties from being seen, withholding the teaching can leave converts unprepared for God's claims and cause some to reject truth later or turn away from the faith, and people should learn His requirements by searching the Old Testament Scriptures willing to bear inconvenience or hardship rather than withhold.
Dissatisfaction with leaders, lack of confidence in management at the heart of the work, disagreement with brethren, or belief that means are misused and unworthy ministers receive some of it gives no right to withhold for any reason. Duty is to keep paying gladly and freely and not withdraw from God's work because others are not doing right, to bring grievances and petitions openly in the right spirit to the proper ones to have things adjusted and set in order, to do what can be done to correct evil management, and to leave erring managers accountable to God for their own sin. Withholding from ignorance or dissatisfaction is unfaithfulness and robbery toward God that braves His curse, tends to poverty of soul and increases financial difficulty, while giving honors Him.
Gifts and offerings pledged to God are solemn commitments to the Creator witnessed and recorded in heaven, and nothing is sufficient excuse for breaking them. Honesty with God requires faithfulness in tithes and offerings including keeping pledges made under His Spirit and settling what is owed and one's account with God when means are available. Withholding is robbing God, and those who withheld must confess the wrong, stop withholding, make restitution as far as they can of what was not given, and prove the Lord by faithfully returning the full tithe along with gifts and offerings for the world, on which He promises abundant blessing.
God requires tithes according to the tithing plan He established to supply His house, and men are not free to replace His arrangement with one of their own. The system tests character week by week and month by month, develops character and reveals the true state of the heart, with each person responsible for deciding whether to give much or little. Giving is to be free, willing and glad without human compulsion or ministerial pressure, condemnation or sharpness over amount, to be obeyed willingly as sacred time is kept, following God's arrangement with each bearing a fair share and not requiring pledges beyond means or depriving families of necessities. One bringing tithes to sustain the ministry is trying to serve God with all his power and must not be met with sharpness, for God has a treasury to be sustained and largely sustained by the sacred liberal tithe, and those handling it must act so transparently that the confidence of the whole people is established and nothing is feared to be opened as light as day.
Reading Malachi with the Spirit brings a sense of personal responsibility for tithes and offerings, because what men possess belongs to God who entrusted it to them and calls everyone to bring a faithful tithe into His treasury so it will not be empty.
Prophecy for Last Days
The prophecy has special application to the last days, requiring God's people to bring a proportion of their substance as a freewill offering to the Lord. Its promise of opened heaven and blessing beyond capacity to receive concerns that duty of faithful giving, not speaking or praying in meetings. It is God's present call in the closing years of probation, as the great day of the Lord is at hand, to bring all the tithes into the storehouse so there may be provision in His house and to prove Him by doing so. This requires returning a certain portion to the treasury as His own, acknowledging dependence on God and accountability to Him, even though all men enjoy comes from Him and He is pleased for His people to enjoy His goods. Every soul converted to the truth and every newly raised church must be decidedly instructed in this requirement for tithes and offerings in the spirit of Christ, turning from sin to righteousness, and the means thus gathered is to be invested in missionary work to sustain foreign missions and fulfill the commission to teach all nations.
The promises will be fulfilled as God's people become channels through which His blessings flow to support the work, carrying out what He gives them zealously and unselfishly, including the work in Washington. The appeal applies now to do one's best to advance that work and to meet constant calls from foreign fields for men and means, so unbelievers may see the work begun is able to be finished, with the fitting response a willing collection. They will be fulfilled when those who have received great light humble themselves before God and confess their sins, for God will not uphold those who turn from truth and righteousness. Rendering to the Lord what is His own relieves His work of poverty, while hoarded wealth becomes a curse and God cannot preserve and bless possessions when owners feel no obligation to help proclaim the truth in new fields. Substance generously divided with brethren laboring with meager facilities in destitute fields brings rich blessings in return, and those truly converted who have more than sufficient for immediate necessities will freely impart of their abundance to help those poorer than they, while those who selfishly hold their means in this emergency will soon suffer loss of all they have.
The verse applies to advancing the third angel's message by giving cheerfully and liberally to provide laborers and facilities for entering new territory, since scarcity of means retards the work and God's rebuke rests on those who do not come up to His help against the mighty powers of darkness. Every church member is bound by covenant relation with God to bring all tithes and offerings as God's own into His treasury and prove faithful in paying them to make the record right, denying self of every extravagant outlay and practicing economy in home life. The means thus brought in are to give adequate support to those who devote their time to saving souls, so their just wages are not begrudged, they do not lack necessities, they can live comfortably, and they can lead in donations to the cause. Faithfulness supplies facilities for carrying the message rapidly into new fields, including the needy Southern field, sustains work already established, enters new territory, and provides many more laborers, while withholding retards the work; and faithfully bringing to the treasury the means He has lent carries the promise that His work will make rapid advancement, many souls will be won, and the day of Christ's coming will be hastened.
All the tithe belongs in God's storehouse to provide for His house, and honesty in tithes and offerings rather than robbery is joined to the invitation to test His promise that obedience brings abundant blessing. The verse also supports using entrusted means to spread the truth and advance missionary work, so believers who cannot go themselves can help reach people in distant lands by giving tithes and freewill offerings, avoiding unnecessary expenses, and using money saved to advance the message. Faithful giving supports meetinghouses, sanitariums, and schools, helps win people to the truth, and hastens Christ's coming. Now is the time to bring tithes and offerings into the storehouse as rendering to God for all His benefits and meeting obligation to the Creator, as working for the Master to save souls perishing in sin and representing Him by carrying truth into new territory and giving the warning to those in darkness, a solemn charge of representing Him as the light of the world laid upon His people for which the church will be held responsible if it fails.
What is required is a faithful tithe and a willing thank offering, with gifts of influence and property and capital entrusted rightly valued and used together with money, time, strength, and influence to relieve the needs of His cause and advance the interests dearest to God's heart, because He needs the cooperation of every soul for the large field to be worked. These gifts fill the treasury so workers can be sent to advance the work and reach people in spiritual darkness, and they are to be managed carefully and used to support those in need as well as the saving mission. Many will not be blessed till they make restitution of tithe withheld, by accurate reckoning and bringing to the Lord what was taken from His work with peace offerings, and upon free and full repentance and acknowledgment of misappropriating His goods He will forgive the transgression, for His holy law rests upon every soul enjoying His benefits and He waits for them to redeem the past. Bringing tithes into the storehouse provides means for God's work including missionary work, while withholding contributes to financial hardship and brings a curse as robbery of the Lord. Withholding robs God of resources intended to bring people to knowledge of the truth, and failure to bring the full tithe leaves His work without needed means, causing workers to hesitate, narrowing the work, and delaying efforts to reach the cities, while faithfulness helps provide for saving souls.
Offerings Beyond Tithe
The tithe is not the limit of liberality, for offerings beyond the tenth are also due as grateful response to continual blessings, proportionate to means for both the poor whose small gifts can do much and those with greater means who must give accordingly, and the command to bring all into the storehouse calls for both tithes and offerings together as faithful workers show by giving both. Offerings express gratitude for benefits received, and those able are not to come empty-handed but prepared according to means, including coming to religious meetings and camp-meetings ready to work, leaving home cares to find Jesus, and bringing gifts proportioned to blessings as gratitude to the Creator. Even the firstfruits of the new year are a privilege to bring though small, directed to God rather than spent on self-pleasing, and Christmas and Thanksgiving are best kept by turning gifts from presents and trifles to His treasury to support His work. Timely tithes belong with freewill offerings, and appeals awaken neglected duty so people recognize and give intelligently.
Offerings must be suitable, free, and from the best, unblemished from flocks and fields, with firstfruits of increase, for withholding a proper share brings curse on harvests, flocks, families and possessions while a right offering brings blessing on family and possessions. Giving follows the divine arrangement with each bearing a fair share, yet it does not require pledges beyond means or depriving families of necessities. Tithes, gifts and offerings belong to God as signs of loyalty, dependence and gratitude, and with faithful tithes the firstfruits provide ample means for His work and for helping the poor and suffering, while failure leaves the treasury short and the work in need. Gratitude must be shown in deeds not words alone, after first giving self to God with strictest integrity, for faith without works is worthless, and because He continually gives while men continually receive they remain obligated to return, with blessing withheld when they weary of doing so.
Value is measured not by amount but by willing loving motive, and giving is to be systematic in proportion to prosperity, including gifts from the poor, with even those unable to give much setting aside a small amount regularly. Every member rich or poor is to give as prospered, for withholding what belongs to God is robbery, and faithful giving provides funds to pay workers and advance missionary work. This duty never permits pressuring beyond means or taking food needed for a hungry family, and pledges to God are to be fulfilled while means are available. Faithful tithe joined with offerings and avoidance of extravagant spending supports the work and makes more facilities available.
The produce of field, orchard and soil is to be faithfully tithed for His house, while specified offerings and gifts also help the poor and sustain the growing work. Bringing what belongs to Him invites the test of the opened windows and blessing beyond capacity to receive, calling for means to be placed in His treasury and not withheld. Meat in His house means resources for ministers and missionaries bringing truth to seekers, so believers are urged to turn from selfish wants, give up possessions, dispose of idols and unnecessary things, and send means in many small contributions to support the work and advance the gospel. Entrusted money is to relieve suffering, feed the hungry, clothe the naked, advance truth and build the kingdom, and withholding deprives His house of what is needed. Princely offerings are called for to meet ever-increasing opportunities, as connected with the school in that locality.
Giving to support His work does not enrich God whose treasures are already His, but benefits the giver by laying up secure treasure in heaven and helping bring souls to salvation, while putting earthly wealth first robs the giver of eternal riches and brings curse rather than blessing. Bringing all tithes and offerings flows from a heart transformed by divine love and freed from selfishness and covetousness, with abundant blessing promised and faithfulness to the end leading toward the heavenly kingdom. To return His own is the whole duty and privilege of the steward, honoring Him with substance and firstfruits of increase rather than grudging or restricted return, for withholding brings spiritual loss. What is given is made secure and sent before the giver to the heavenly courts while what is retained is eternal loss, and spiritual prosperity is bound up with liberality, with blessing resting on unwearied diligence in small things and wise use of cents as well as dollars bringing wonderful increase. Gifts wisely placed where they do greatest good, especially now for cities and new fields, advance the work and produce a harvest of souls, including provision by will after family need so His cause receives its portion for present use.
God made provision for supporting His work including ministry to the churches so blessing may rest upon the church, and refusing is disobedience leaving people without approval and blessing. Giving what is not needed for personal comfort and indulgence shows love to God and neighbor and supports work for the needy, with means saved by economy, self-denial, plain dress and denial of indulgence bringing provision and rich blessing. Every member is bound by covenant to bring tithes and offerings and make the record right, denying extravagant outlay and practicing economy at home so workers devoting time to saving souls receive just wages without begrudging, have necessities, live comfortably, and can lead in donations. Faithfulness supplies facilities to carry the message rapidly into new fields including the needy Southern field, sustains established work, enters new territory and provides many more laborers, while withholding retards the work and brings rebuke on those who do not come up to help. When every family cuts indulgence His house is supplied and work opens where truth was never heard, with substance generously divided with brethren laboring with meager facilities in destitute fields returning rich blessings, while selfishly held means in emergency soon suffers loss of all.
The plan of systematic giving was devised by Jesus Christ Himself, who gave His life for the world, left the royal courts, laid aside honor as Commander of the heavenly hosts, clothed divinity with humanity to uplift the fallen race, and became poor so men through His poverty might be rich. A tenth of all possessions is reserved for Himself besides gifts and offerings to be brought into His storehouse, as provision for carrying forward the gospel and sustaining those who bear His message. This plan is best for men because it cultivates gratitude and liberality, frees from selfishness contrary to His character, and guards against worldliness, covetousness, avarice and greed, so that by grace men are registered as co-laborers with Christ in redemption. God gives gifts to those who love Him so they can share with others, and returning the tenth with offerings is His way of saving from worldliness, greed and selfishness.
Faithful Obedience and Fruit
Bringing all the tithes means giving back to God everything He claims, including a set portion of all income, and putting goods held in trust to use to relieve brethren in poverty and distress and to break every yoke of oppression. It is to be done in this life while entrusted means can still be used in His service, as an acknowledgment of dependence on Him and a return of what belongs to Him. Withholding is robbing Him, and there is no excuse for neglecting so plain a duty, for professing to serve Him while serving self and holding goods in selfish plans dishonors Him. The command speaks to every church, every family, and every individual, and will be met in the judgment in the revelation of the good that might have been done in acts of charity. Obedience proves Him, and He will open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing too large to receive.
Those who obey with unswerving fidelity in returning His own in tithes and offerings test His word and receive overflowing blessing from opened heaven. Strengthened faith, removal of doubts and perplexities, fears overcome by assurance, strength to fight spiritual battles, clear confidence of acceptance and favor, light, growth in grace and in the knowledge of Jesus Christ, and steadfastness in abounding work follow taking Him at His word and doing it. Giving the full tithe so His house is supplied is the condition for accepting professed Christians and answering their prayers, for holding it back for gain from worldliness and selfishness shuts the soul from Him, leaves curse hanging over it, and makes casual prayers for acceptance wholly vain without genuine conversion. Meeting the condition lets the obedient prove Him who promises blessing beyond capacity to receive, and returning it helps the gospel go forward with power as doing His will on earth as in heaven, while dishonest dealing brings judgment. This fidelity with undivided heart belongs to the present time of cooperation with God and heavenly agencies, and is urgent because the great day is near, great things are about to take place, time is especially precious, and night comes when no one can work, so light must be obeyed while it remains lest darkness come.
Tithes with gifts and offerings belong to God as His reserved portion and are to be faithfully returned as signs of loyalty, dependence, and gratitude, the tenth being due from all substance with liberal offerings keeping a constant stream so His house has provision. They are sacred, to be set apart regularly for His work and not handled by personal impulse, an arrangement for supporting the ministry that must not be diverted to other lines, which are to have separate support. Withholding is unfaithfulness and continual robbery of His portion, and withholders will answer for it, for because He continually gives and men continually receive they remain obligated to give back, and when they weary of it His blessing is withheld. Giving by His plan supports the church, provides honest wages for workers, lets the treasury meet its obligations, and advances missionary work, and if He were not robbed one hundred times more work could be done instead of cheap plans shaped by selfishness. When churches put finances in order without robbing Him, salvation is seen and the faithful are blessed and made channels of blessing, for faith without works is worthless and gratitude must be shown in deeds not words alone.
The verse lays down a working principle from henceforth requiring the naturally selfish and covetous to act in the opposite direction and give where they withheld, and this giving is the only way to victory and eternal life. Withholding His own in tithes and offerings is sin and robbery that withdraws His blessing and leaves great debt to Him, and it is not faithful to keep it for personal use when increased wealth enlarges the tithe or to delay it hoping to invest it for a larger future gift. Obedience requires curtailing expenses, turning money spent for self-gratification into His treasury, and for those with houses and lands even selling to give alms, making haste to be honest without delay and putting every talent of means and ability to use while day lasts because He is soon to come and is testing response to His benefits. Guilt for withholding must be confessed to God and to the church and put away by heeding the injunction to bring all the tithes so there may be means to sustain soul-saving work, as necessary preparation before asking for prayer and restoration of health.
Returning tithes and offerings tests allegiance and gratitude and puts means and compassionate labor to work helping needy perishing souls. It puts His claims first and brings walking in light, for His chosen people favored above all others and called from darkness into marvelous light to show His praises must return fruits essential to His kingdom in proportion to blessings received. Those given most advantages prove benefit by rendering His own in unselfish devoted service, with gratitude expressed in deeds of holiness and strictest integrity, dividing goods with fellow laborers, for blessings and privileges mean sacred responsibilities. Faithful tithes with peace, thank, and freewill offerings given for His great love leave no dearth in His treasury and make the gospel available to the world as He intends, and faithful giving is part of serving Him with spirit, soul, and body rather than robbing Him. So doing acknowledges that blessings and entrusted possessions come from Him and belong to Him, and gives the world evidence of remembrance.
Bringing tithes and offerings into His treasury has been followed by converted hearts, confession of wrong, and thousands given in love, the conversion of the heart being the greatest miracle and evidence of His work. Meat in His house means means to send warnings and entreaties to the world so suffering and want need not exist, and those who obey are promised blessing and peace while the disobedient are cursed. Holding back shuts out blessing, so robbers cannot expect to come to His house to be exalted like others but murmur and complain, and all who misplace entrusted means and fail to sustain His work must render account for souls lost and for retarding its advance. The money brought in is not enough for giving sacred truths, working barren fields, employing sowers, garnering harvest, and planting truth in new and foreign places, and learning self-denial and self-sacrifice in giving would make the church the light of the world. Cooperation by sincere service, self-denial, denying needless spending, and giving for Him as He gave His life plants His standard where truth was never heard and carries the work forward.
Wider Calls and Warnings
Faithful bringing of the whole tithe would supply what the gospel requires and keep the treasury full, so that there would be no need to resort to fairs, lotteries, or pleasure parties to raise funds. The command is to be carefully studied, obeyed, and taught to others so they may learn how to receive God's blessing, with those who receive it becoming educators of others in obedience. When all act together in harmony in obeying it, the salvation of God will be seen, for He blesses faithfully dealing both financially and spiritually. Failure to bring the full tithe leaves the work of saving souls without needed means, causing workers to hesitate, narrowing the work, and delaying efforts to reach the cities.
Wealth entrusted by God must not be misused on costly buildings when it is needed to carry the gospel to places that have not received it. Those who test His faithfulness are promised open windows of heaven with more blessing than can be received, together with restraint of the devourer, preservation of crops and vines from dropping fruit early, and being made delightsome and blessed among the nations. He will not fill His empty treasury by raining money from heaven, but maintains the gospel ministry through faithful return of the honest tithe with liberal gifts, since means, food, and clothing are entrusted to men as His helping hand. Parental dishonesty in robbing God and failure to train children by self-denial to return what is His, to give even from small gifts, and to use means by His directions hardens them against preaching when grown and robs God to the third and fourth generation through children and grandchildren with no inclination to fear and obey Him. When He sends workers to any field He has a work to be done there under His own direction requiring means to be used in that field, so to withhold what He requires is robbery, and failure to invest where distressing necessity calls leaves the work years behind.
His people are to stand in His strength with windows open heavenward and closed earthward so that salvation is revealed. The open windows bring blessing by binding medical missionary work and the gospel fast together as an inseparable united whole, by connecting talent in individuals, schools, and every institution with the management of His work and churches, by carrying the work through committees representing every part instead of leaving two or three minds to rule as kings, and by lifting foreign missionary work to a higher grade than before. The charge against withholding tithes applies to selfish, covetous withholding in Michigan rather than true liberal-heartedness. The churches in Australia and New Zealand were to do far more in 1893 than in any previous year in supplying means to the Lord's house, for a great revolution in giving had to take place in that country before the work could progress to any great extent.
Selfishness is the great sin of the world and has become the prevailing sin of the church, greatly dishonoring God when His people fail to impart means for the advancement of His work with power. Responsibility rests on believers everywhere to pay a faithful tithe, not allowing lax principles to lead to robbery, but keeping a faithful account with the Creator and being just with Him who has divine foreknowledge, each diligently searching the heart and looking up accounts to find how he stands in relation to God. Keeping back tithes and offerings is failing to hear and answer His claim to His portion, when the noise and distractions of the world prevent listening to Him and seeking Him earnestly. Practicing the truth ends this dishonest robbery for gain and disobedience, along with contention about who is greatest and strife for supremacy, and when all His commandments are obeyed with faithful tithes and offerings the love that brings peace and joy into the family circle is cherished and the Redeemer is honored before men. Families who test Him by self-denial and gifts to help teach the poor about the Saviour will be blessed.