AdventAI

Mark 2:8

And immediately when Jesus perceived in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, he said unto them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    And immediately when Jesus perceived in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, he said to them, Why reason you these things in your hearts?

  • King James Version

    And immediately when Jesus perceived in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, he said unto them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    And immediately, when Jesus perceived in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, he said unto them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

  • Webster Bible

    And immediately, when Jesus perceived in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, he said to them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

  • Revised Version, American Standard Version

    And straightway Jesus, perceiving in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, saith unto them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

  • Young's Literal Translation

    And immediately Jesus, having known in his spirit that they thus reason in themselves, said to them, 'Why these things reason ye in your hearts?

  • Darby Translation

    And straightway Jesus, knowing in his spirit that they are reasoning thus within themselves, said to them, Why reason ye these things in your hearts?

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    And Jesus, straightway, taking note in his spirit, that [thus] they are deliberating within themselves, saith [unto them]—Why, these things, are ye deliberating in your hearts?

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    At once Jesus knew in His spirit that they were thinking this way within themselves. “ Why are you thinking these things in your hearts?” He asked.

  • World English Bible

    Immediately Jesus, perceiving in his spirit that they so reasoned within themselves, said to them, “ Why do you reason these things in your hearts?

  • Bible in Basic English

    And Jesus, having knowledge in his spirit of their thoughts, said to them, Why are you reasoning about these things in your hearts?

  • Geneva Bible

    And immediatly when Iesus perceiued in his spirite, that thus they reasoned with themselues, he sayde vnto them, Why reason yee these things in your hearts?

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    Which Jesus presently knowing in his spirit, that they so thought within themselves, saith to them: Why think you these things in your hearts?

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

47 sources

Jesus at once perceived by divine insight, without any words spoken, the unspoken reasoning the scribes and Pharisees were holding within themselves in their hearts.ST3RED 69.2–3ST Mar 24, 1881 They were inwardly condemning Him as a blasphemer for telling the paralytic let down through the roof that his sins were forgiven, holding that He assumed a power belonging to God alone who only can forgive sins.Lt 391, 1907, par. 18–19Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14 He exposed their secret thoughts by fixing His reproving glance upon them and asking why they reasoned these things and entertained these thoughts in their hearts.ST Mar 24, 1881STMs 105, 1901, par. 19–20 To prove that He as Son of man has power on earth to forgive sins, He commanded the paralytic to arise, take up his bed and walk, and he immediately did so before them all.Lt 391, 1907, par. 18–19Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14 He forgave the man's soul before healing his body, because the burden of sin weighed more heavily than bodily suffering and peace of mind had to prepare the way for bodily restoration.ST3T 168.2–3RH May 21, 1914HRP 12.1–14.1MH 77.3

Setting and Background

Mark 2:8 belongs to the healing of the paralytic, the one sick of the palsy, at Capernaum.2SP 292.1MH 73.2–321MR 85.3–86.1 Jesus was teaching in a crowded house, Peter's house, when He had come again to Capernaum, with men, women, and children flocking from every direction to hear Him teach.2SP 292.1MH 73.2–3 This was part of His teaching beside the lake with the people gathered about Him, where the lame, the blind, the paralytic, and those dying of various maladies rose up in health praising God for deliverance.DA 262.4–264.2

Inside the house the disciples sat near Jesus to hear His words and understand the truths to proclaim by word and pen to all lands through all ages.ST Oct 16, 1879 Pharisees, doctors, scribes, and teachers of the law were also gathered near, waiting to see what Jesus would do.ST Oct 16, 1879MH 73.2–32SP 296.2 Outside pressed a promiscuous multitude of all grades of society and many nationalities, drawn by desire to hear, by curiosity and love of excitement, or by dim understanding in which seeds of life could lodge.ST Oct 16, 1879

Those hostile watchers concealed intense hatred and jealousy of His power and wisdom and watched His words with wicked purposes in their hearts.ST Jan 21, 18893RED 69.2–3ST Oct 16, 1879 They closely watched Him and sought to draw Him out and confuse Him, hoping to surprise Him into contradiction or forbidden heresy.3RED 69.2–3ST Oct 16, 1879 Their aim was to find grounds to accuse Him as an impostor and condemn Him to death.ST Jan 21, 18893RED 69.2–3ST Oct 16, 1879

The man brought to Him was a local paralytic reduced to utter helplessness by incurable palsy who had given up all hope of recovery.2SP 292.1 Dissipation had been the main cause of his palsy, for he had loved the pleasures of sin and his life had been a transgression of the law of God, so that his bodily affliction was the penalty of his crime.2SP 292.2 His friends and relatives had heard Jesus's gracious teaching and seen His wonderful miracles, that He turned no one away and even loathsome lepers found access to His presence and were healed.2SP 292.1 They had also heard that He could cure every malady, spoke mercy to the despairing, and set people free from Satan's power by a word of authority, so they began to hope the paralytic might be relieved if he could be brought under Jesus's notice, and his own hope revived to long to see Jesus and place himself in His hands.2SP 292.12SP 292.2

Yet he feared he would not be tolerated in the presence of the pure Physician, believing his sinful life and illness made him unwelcome.ST Mar 24, 18812SP 292.2 This reflected the teaching of the Pharisees and doctors, who judged his suffering to be God's punishment for his sins and held that sickness and distress were evidence of God's anger at a person's sin, a mistaken and hypocritical judgment since they themselves were corrupt.ST Mar 24, 18813RED 68.2–69.1 His illness followed a sinful life and his suffering was deepened by remorse, and he sought Jesus for healing and relief from sin and a troubled mind, longing for Jesus to see him and pardon his sins.ST Jun 30, 19142SP 293.23RED 68.2–69.1 He was content to live or die according to Jesus' will, believing forgiveness would be enough whether he lived or died.2SP 293.23RED 68.2–69.1

Jesus Perceives Hidden Thoughts

Immediately in His spirit Jesus perceived by divine insight the unspoken reasoning that the scribes, Pharisees, rabbis, doctors, teachers of the law and others were holding silently within themselves and in their hearts, with no words exchanged between them.ST3RED 69.2–3ST Mar 24, 1881DA 269.1–4MH 73.2–3 He knew this while teaching in the crowded house at Capernaum, Peter's house, with His disciples seated near Him to hear truths to proclaim to all lands through all ages, while haughty Pharisees, doctors and scribes were also gathered near with wicked purposes, concealing intense hatred and jealousy of His power and wisdom and closely watching His words in hope of confusing Him, surprising Him into contradiction or forbidden heresy, and finding grounds to accuse Him as an impostor and condemn Him to death, and while outside pressed a promiscuous multitude of all grades of society and many nationalities drawn by desire to hear, by curiosity and love of excitement, or by dim understanding where seeds of life could lodge.3RED 69.2–3ST Oct 16, 1879MH 73.2–3 What He discerned was their inward evil reasoning as they questioned His authority to forgive sins and inwardly condemned Him.STST Mar 24, 1881ST Oct 16, 1879

He exposed those secret thoughts by fixing His reproving glance upon them so that they cowered and drew back.DA 269.1–43RED 72.2–73.2 By that look and by direct address He confronted their hidden reasoning and asked why they reasoned these things and entertained these thoughts in their hearts.ST Mar 24, 1881STMs 105, 1901, par. 19–20DA 269.1–43RED 72.2–73.2 His question lays bare His power to perceive what people think in their hearts.ST

He also perfectly understood the paralytic's whole case.ST Jan 21, 1889RH May 21, 1914 He saw the man brought on his bed and let down through the torn-open roof in a case so urgent that dissolution was already working on the body.RH May 21, 1914 He knew the man carried a sickness of soul far worse than bodily suffering, and that the greatest and heaviest burden he had carried for months with no relief was sin.RH May 21, 1914HRP 12.1–14.1

He Himself had drawn that perplexed and doubting man to give hope to the guilty and wretched.ST Jan 21, 1889 His divine Spirit had stirred the sinner's heart while still at home and brought conviction to his conscience.ST Jan 21, 1889 He watched the first glimmer of faith that Jesus was his only helper deepen into belief and grow stronger with every effort to come into His presence.ST Jan 21, 1889 He acknowledged the simple faith proved by the sick man's persevering effort under perplexing difficulties to reach Him, and He answered the silent entreaty of pleading eyes with pardon, peace and healing.ST Jan 21, 1889

Opponents' Secret Accusation

The charge arose the moment the paralytic let down through the roof heard that his sins were forgiven, for those sitting by reasoned within themselves that such a declaration was blasphemy.Lt 391, 1907, par. 18–19Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877 In their hearts they held that forgiving sins assumed infinite power belonging to God alone, asking in effect who can forgive sins but God only.Lt 391, 1907, par. 18–19Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14ST Oct 16, 18796T 234.3 What they questioned was His authority to forgive sins at all.Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877

They spoke nothing aloud but looked into one another's faces sharing one thought.DA 269.1–43RED 72.2–73.2 Inwardly they condemned Him as a blasphemer for uttering words of divine pardon.ST Jan 21, 1889DA 269.1–42SP 297.23RED 72.2–73.2 They caught at those words to use them as grounds to accuse Him of a crime worthy of death.ST Jan 21, 1889DA 269.1–42SP 297.23RED 72.2–73.2

That inward reasoning was evil, exposing corrupt hearts and cold judgment.STDA 269.1–4 They had treated the man's sickness as proof of God's anger at sin.ST Oct 16, 18793RED 68.2–69.1 That judgment was mistaken and hypocritical, for while they pronounced him punished by God they themselves were corrupt.ST Oct 16, 18793RED 68.2–69.1

They had themselves refused the paralytic hope and declared him under God's curse.DA 269.1–4 They had tormented him with the suggestion that God had cast him off because of his sins.6T 234.3 Now they feared losing their influence over the people as the tide of feeling turned toward Jesus.DA 269.1–42SP 296.23RED 72.2–73.2 The sight of the healed man brought back to mind their earlier refusal to help him.2SP 296.2

Forgiveness Proved by Healing

To prove that the Son of man has power on earth to forgive sins, Jesus followed His question about their inward reasoning with a visible healing, commanding the paralytic to arise, take up his bed and walk, which he immediately did before them all.Lt 391, 1907, par. 18–19Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14ST Oct 16, 18792SP 297.2 The miracle gave compelling evidence that He had power both to forgive sins and to heal the sick.ST Mar 24, 18812SP 300.1 It displayed His power and compassion toward the guilty and afflicted and showed that His power to forgive was real.ST Oct 16, 1879ST Mar 24, 1881

The healed man carried with ease the couch on which he had been slowly borne away and stood before his family in the full vigor of manhood.ST Oct 16, 1879 Arms that had been lifeless were now quick to obey his will, flesh that had been shrunken and leaden-hued was now fresh and ruddy with health, and he walked with a firm, free step with hope written in every line of his face, all gloom gone and peace and purity in place of the marks of sin and suffering.ST Oct 16, 1879 His home was filled with rejoicing, tears of joy, glad thanksgivings, hope, joy and deep faith, and God was glorified through His Son.ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877

All except the faultfinders were amazed and glorified God.Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20 The opponents were left dumb with amazement, overwhelmed with defeat, disconcerted and abashed, with no opportunity to turn the multitude by prejudice and jealousy, and their influence for the time was forgotten.3RED 74.3 They recognized the presence of a superior being but would not confess it, and their hatred and unbelief hardened them against the evidence.2SP 300.13RED 74.3 He possessed and claimed as His own prerogative the power belonging to God alone, and He alone can pardon the sinner, which no human mediator or religious form can take His place in giving.3RED 74.3Ms 62, 1886, par. 9–12

Soul Healed Before Body

The paralytic came longing for forgiveness and peace with God, and his deepest need was relief from the burden of sin and assurance of pardon.ST3T 168.2–3HRP 12.1–14.1 That burden of sin weighed on him more heavily than his bodily suffering and was a deeper suffering than his bodily illness.ST3T 168.2–3HRP 12.1–14.1 His case was so urgent that dissolution was already working on the body when he was brought on his bed and let down through the torn-open roof.RH May 21, 1914 He had carried for months with no relief a sickness of soul far worse than bodily suffering, whose greatest burden was sin.RH May 21, 1914

Jesus saw and perfectly understood that condition in its whole urgency.3T 168.2–3RH May 21, 1914HRP 12.1–14.1 He lifted the heavy burden first by forgiving sins, bringing hope for despair and peace and joy for doubt and gloom, giving peace of mind, and only then healed the suffering body to life and strength.3T 168.2–3RH May 21, 1914HRP 12.1–14.1 He needed healing of the soul before he could appreciate healing of the body, for with the mind restored to peace the suffering body could then be reached.RH May 21, 1914MH 77.3 Christ brought relief to his mind and cleansed his soul from sin.RH May 21, 1914MH 77.3

Christ is a sin-pardoning Saviour whose forgiveness gives peace of mind, and that peace prepares the way for faith in what He promised to do, while unforgiven sin hinders recovery.Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20MH 77.3 The burden of sin, with its unrest and unsatisfied desires, is the foundation of many physical maladies, so the peace Christ gives restores vigor to the mind and health to the body.Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20MH 77.3 The healing displays wondrous love stooping to heal the guilty and the afflicted, with divinity sorrowing over suffering humanity and soothing its ills.3RED 74.2 It displayed marvelous power to the children of men that leaves the message of salvation beyond doubt and the mercies of a compassionate Redeemer not to be slighted.3RED 74.2

The healed man carried with ease the couch on which he had been slowly borne and stood before his family in the full vigor of manhood, with arms that had been lifeless now quick to obey his will and flesh that had been shrunken and leaden-hued now fresh and ruddy with health.ST Oct 16, 1879 He walked with a firm, free step with hope written in every line of his face, all gloom gone and peace and purity in place of the marks of sin and suffering.ST Oct 16, 1879 His home was filled with rejoicing, tears of joy, and glad thanksgivings, and God was glorified through His Son.ST Oct 16, 1879 The man and his family became fully faithful to Christ who had brought light into their darkened home, with no doubt dimming their faith and no unbelief marring their loyalty, ready even to lay down their lives for Him.ST Oct 16, 1879

Model for Ministry Today

Mark 2:8 belongs to the record of Christ's ministry to people's spiritual and physical needs, and that ministry makes Him the great Medical Missionary and the great Physician for soul and body.Lt 30, 1911, par. 11–13Ms 159, 1899, par. 24 He met people in their immediate trouble and pointed them toward the home above.Ms 230, 1902, par. 43–44 His work saved souls and bodies together, binding preaching the truth with healing the sick and joining forgiveness of sin with physical healing, first giving the paralytic peace of mind by pardon and freeing him from the tormenting suggestion that God had cast him off, then healing the body so all might know the Son of man has power to forgive sins.6T 234.3Lt 70, 1899, par. 8–9 That joined soul-and-body work is the work His followers are to do, including caring for the sick through hospitals and providing healthful exercise such as cultivating the soil.Lt 70, 1899, par. 8–9

Physicians who care for those sick in mind and body are to point their patients to Him, instructing in the principles of true temperance, warning the careless, cheering the disconsolate and hopeless, and wisely prescribing for the health of the suffering, and in this way medical missionary work does its work as the right arm of the body.Ms 159, 1899, par. 24 Successful treatment must minister to the diseased mind and relieve the sin-burdened conscience before the body can be fully reached, for He first lifted the heavy burden of sin carried for months with no relief, bringing hope for despair and peace and joy for doubt and gloom, and with the mind restored to peace the suffering body could then be reached and healed to life and strength.RH May 21, 1914 His forgiveness gives peace of mind, and that peace prepares the way for faith in what He promised to do, while unforgiven sin hinders recovery, so the sick and suffering today should trust Him, look to Him and live.Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20

Physical healing matters, but patients should also be shown the way of salvation, led to repentance, and offered forgiveness, as Jesus addressed the sick man with forgiveness and called him to leave in peace and sin no more.STB 99.1 The caviling of the Pharisees in this healing provides a warning against condemning others while regarding oneself as holy.DA 267.1–4 That same blindness appears when religious leaders accuse the Lord who made the Sabbath of breaking it, acting as if they had put out their own eyes.18MR 155.1–3

Sources

  1. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 1 — Christ the Teacher and Healer Ellen G. White
  2. 3RED 69.2–3 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — THE PARALYTIC. Ellen G. White, 1877
  3. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  4. Lt 391, 1907, par. 18–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 22 (1907) — Lt 391, 1907 Ellen G. White, written November 25, 1907
  5. Ms 105, 1901, par. 19–20 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 105, 1901 Ellen G. White, written September 28, 1901
  6. Ms 56, 1899, par. 12–14 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 56, 1899 Ellen G. White, written April 7, 1899
  7. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  8. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 1 — Christ the Teacher and Healer Ellen G. White
  9. 3T 168.2–3 Testimonies for the Church Volume Three — THE HEALTH INSTITUTE. Ellen G. White, 1875
  10. RH May 21, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 21 — Ministering to Soul and Body [^1] Ellen G. White, Thursday, May 21, 1914
  11. HRP 12.1–14.1 The Health Reform - Pamphlet — The Health Institute. Ellen G. White, 1871
  12. MH 77.3 The Ministry of Healing — *Healing of the Soul* Ellen G. White, 1905
  13. 2SP 292.1 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  14. MH 73.2–3 The Ministry of Healing — *Healing of the Soul* Ellen G. White, 1905
  15. 21MR 85.3–86.1 Manuscript Releases, vol. 21 [Nos. 1501-1598] — MR No. 1517—Dedication of Paradise Valley Sanitarium; Results of the San Francisco Earthquake; Defense of the True Sabbath Ellen G. White, written May 12–26, 1906; published 1993
  16. DA 262.4–264.2 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN. Ellen G. White, 1898
  17. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  18. 2SP 296.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  19. ST Jan 21, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 3 — Notes on the International Lesson Ellen G. White, January 21, 1889
  20. 2SP 292.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  21. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  22. 3RED 68.2–69.1 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — THE PARALYTIC. Ellen G. White, 1877
  23. ST Jun 30, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 25 — Thy Sins Be Forgiven Thee Ellen G. White, June 30, 1914
  24. 2SP 293.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  25. DA 269.1–4 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN. Ellen G. White, 1898
  26. 3RED 72.2–73.2 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — THE PARALYTIC. Ellen G. White, 1877
  27. ST Jan 21, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 3 — Notes on the International Lesson Ellen G. White, January 21, 1889
  28. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  29. ST Apr 5, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 15 — THE PARALYTIC Ellen G. White, April 5, 1877
  30. 6T 234.3 Testimonies for the Church Volume Six — THE PHYSICIAN’S WORK FOR SOULS. Ellen G. White, 1901
  31. ST Jan 21, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 3 — Notes on the International Lesson Ellen G. White, January 21, 1889
  32. 2SP 297.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  33. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  34. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  35. 2SP 300.1 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Two — CHAPTER XXIII. Ellen G. White, 1877
  36. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  37. ST Apr 5, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 15 — THE PARALYTIC Ellen G. White, April 5, 1877
  38. 3RED 74.3 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — THE PARALYTIC. Ellen G. White, 1877
  39. Ms 62, 1886, par. 9–12 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 4 (1883 - 1886) — Ms 62, 1886 Ellen G. White Estate, Ellen G. White, written April 15–29, 1886
  40. 3RED 74.2 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — THE PARALYTIC. Ellen G. White, 1877
  41. Lt 30, 1911, par. 11–13 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 25 (1910 - 1915) — Lt 30, 1911 Ellen G. White, written June 6, 1911
  42. Ms 159, 1899, par. 24 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 159, 1899 Ellen G. White, written December 13, 1899
  43. Ms 230, 1902, par. 43–44 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Ms 230, 1902 Ellen G. White, written September 14, 1902
  44. Lt 70, 1899, par. 8–9 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Lt 70, 1899 Ellen G. White, written April 14, 1899
  45. STB 99.1 Special Testimonies Series B — NOT FOR PLEASURE SEEKERS. Ellen G. White, 1913
  46. DA 267.1–4 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN. Ellen G. White, 1898
  47. 18MR 155.1–3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 18 [Nos. 1301-1359] — MR No. 1325—Perplexity Over Proposed Trip to Australia Ellen G. White Estate, Ellen G. White, written August 5, 1891; published 1990

Pioneers and periodicals

55 sources

Immediately Jesus perceived in His own spirit the silent reasoning they were holding unspoken within themselves in their hearts, and He answered their inward thoughts directly so that nothing concealed could remain hidden from Him.ST May 13, 1897ST Feb 3, 1904ST Apr 12, 1899 This perceiving was divine omniscience and insight by His Spirit, by which He knows the inward thoughts of every person and by His own creative power proves His authority to forgive sins and to heal.ST Jan 21, 1889ST Dec 2, 1889ST Feb 17, 1904 Those reasoning within themselves were inwardly condemning Him as a blasphemer for declaring sins forgiven, since only God can forgive sins, and they questioned His authority to forgive.ST Mar 24, 1881ST Apr 12, 1899ST Dec 2, 1889 His question why they reason these things in their hearts exposes that inward reasoning as evil and unbelieving, calls them to account for thinking as they do, and points to the test of which is easier to say, that sins are forgiven or that the sick should rise and walk.STST Jul 12, 1905ST Oct 15, 1894 The healing that immediately followed made the forgiveness received by faith visible and publicly confirmed that the Son of man has power on earth to forgive sins, for the same word and power that heals disease is equally powerful to forgive sins and restore soul and body.ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905ST Jun 21, 1905RH Sep 20, 1906

Setting And Historical Context

The scene is a crowded house in Capernaum where Jesus was teaching with the power of the Lord present to heal, when after seeing their faith He declared a paralytic let down through the roof forgiven of his sins.ST Apr 12, 1899ST Jan 16, 1896ST Jul 7, 1898ST May 22, 1901 The man had been brought on his bed and lowered through the torn-open roof in a case so urgent that dissolution was already working on the body.RH May 21, 1914 His word to the man first forgave sins and then commanded him to rise, take up his bed, and walk, a word applied to those whose spiritual condition weighs upon physical health, who on hearing forgiveness may rise and walk.RH May 21, 1914ST May 22, 1901

Seated near Him inside were scribes, Pharisees, and doctors of the law come from Galilee, Judea, and Jerusalem, watching with concealed hatred in hope of finding grounds to accuse Him.ST Jan 21, 1889ST Jan 16, 1896 His disciples were seated near Him to hear His words and understand truths to proclaim, while outside pressed a promiscuous multitude of all grades of society and many nationalities, drawn by desire to hear, by curiosity and love of excitement, or by dim understanding in which seeds of life could lodge.ST Oct 16, 1879 The haughty Pharisees, doctors, and scribes gathered near with wicked purposes in their hearts, concealing intense hatred and jealousy of His power and wisdom, closely watching His words and seeking to draw Him out and confuse Him in hope of surprising Him into contradiction or forbidden heresy so they might accuse Him as an impostor and condemn Him to death.ST Oct 16, 1879

This belongs to Mark's graphic account of the healing of the paralytic, one of the events he recounts in rapid succession.ST Oct 4, 1910 It is part of his portrayal of Jesus as a perfect model of character, combining power with love, justice with humility, and sympathy for those who suffer.RH Oct 30, 1860 The paralytic had lived a sinful life and his suffering was deepened by remorse, yet he came longing for forgiveness and peace with God.STST Jun 30, 1914 He feared his sinful life and illness made him unwelcome, while the Pharisees treated his sickness and distress as evidence of God's anger at his sin, in contrast to Jesus' mercy toward the helpless.ST Mar 24, 1881ST Oct 16, 1879ST Jun 30, 1914

Jesus Knows Hidden Thoughts

Immediately Jesus perceived in his own spirit the silent, unspoken reasoning the scribes were holding within themselves in their hearts in the crowded house in Capernaum where the palsied man had been let down through the roof and told his sins were forgiven.ST May 13, 1897ST Feb 3, 1904ST Apr 12, 1899 They were inwardly questioning his words, accusing him of blasphemy because only God can forgive sins, and nothing they reasoned inwardly could be concealed from him.ST Apr 12, 1899ST Feb 3, 1904ST Jun 21, 1905 He answered their thoughts directly and confronted them openly, challenging them to explain why they reasoned those things and exposing their doubts about his words.ST May 13, 1897ST Feb 3, 1904ST Feb 3, 1904ST Oct 15, 1894ST Jun 21, 1905

That perceiving of unspoken thoughts and inner reasoning is an act of divine omniscience and divine insight by his Spirit, joined to his authority to forgive sins and his power to heal the paralytic.ST Jan 21, 1889ST Dec 2, 1889 He knows the inward thoughts of every person, discerns the thoughts of his enemies, and used the occasion to demonstrate that power.ST Feb 17, 1904ST Feb 3, 1904 He forgave the paralytic and healed him by his own creative power, not through angels, and healing comes from God above in answer to faith that reaches for divine power rather than recognizing that power as already within a person.ST Feb 13, 1912

He likewise perfectly understood the paralytic's whole case and silent entreaty, because he himself had drawn the perplexed and doubting man to give hope to the guilty and wretched.ST Jan 21, 1889 His divine Spirit had stirred the sinner's heart while still at home, brought conviction to his conscience, watched the first glimmer of faith that Jesus was his only helper deepen into belief, and saw it grow stronger with every effort to come into his presence.ST Jan 21, 1889 He acknowledged the simple faith proved by persevering effort under perplexing difficulties and answered the silent pleading with pardon, peace, and healing, and he also knew the paralytic's inward thoughts when the command to rise was given as an example of acting in faith by doing what one can while trusting God to sustain and advance his cause.ST Jan 21, 1889RH Jun 8, 1869

Challenge To Unbelieving Reasoning

Those reasoning within themselves were inwardly condemning Him for declaring the palsied man forgiven, judging the declaration as blasphemy because only God can forgive sins, and questioning His authority to forgive.ST Mar 24, 1881ST Oct 16, 1879ST Jan 21, 1889ST Apr 5, 1877ST Apr 12, 1899 Sitting in the crowded house in Capernaum where the man had been let down through the roof, the scribes with the Pharisees, teachers and doctors of the law held this accusation unspoken in their hearts.ST Mar 24, 1881ST Oct 16, 1879ST Jan 21, 1889ST Apr 12, 1899ST Dec 2, 1889 He immediately perceived that inward accusation and confronted them openly, answering their silent thoughts directly.ST Mar 24, 1881ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877ST Apr 12, 1899ST Dec 2, 1889

His question why they reason such things in their hearts exposes that inward reasoning as evil and unbelieving and challenges them to explain why they think as they do.STST Jul 12, 1905ST Oct 15, 1894ST Oct 15, 1894ST Jul 12, 1905 It gives them opportunity to recognize their unbelief and who He is, and to recognize His authority to forgive.ST Jul 12, 1905ST Oct 15, 1894ST Oct 15, 1894ST Jul 12, 1905 The question leads to the test of which is easier to say, that sins are forgiven or that the sick should rise and walk, and the visible healing then demonstrates that the Son of man has authority on earth to forgive sins, an authority belonging to God.ST Jul 12, 1905ST Jul 12, 1905RH Jan 7, 1915

The dispute belongs to a wider pattern of religious offense, hostility and accusation by religious leaders toward Him and His mission, illustrated also by objections to His Sabbath actions.ST May 15, 1907ST Apr 9, 1894 Unbelief challenged His power even as He healed, so that men sought to kill both the Life-giver and those He raised in order to remove the evidence of His power from before the people.ST May 15, 1907ST Apr 9, 1894

Authority To Forgive Sins

The inward questioning is met by an outward proof, for the healing that immediately follows shows that the Son of man has power on earth to forgive sins.ST Oct 16, 1879ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905ST Jun 21, 1905ST May 13, 1897 What was received by faith in forgiveness is made visible in the restored body, and the cure publicly confirms the authority that had been challenged in silence.ST Oct 16, 1879ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905ST Jun 21, 1905ST Jul 12, 1905 The question about the reasoning of the heart therefore leads directly into a demonstration, exposing the objection to forgiving the paralyzed man's sins and calling for recognition of who has the right to forgive.ST Oct 16, 1879ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905

The same power accomplishes both the pardon and the cure, joining healing of the body with forgiveness of sins in one act.RH Sep 20, 1906RH Oct 30, 1913RH Nov 30, 1916 The word that heals disease is equally powerful to forgive sins, and the gospel is God's power to save from physical disease as well as from moral sin.RH Oct 30, 1913RH Nov 30, 1916ST Dec 17, 1894 It is creative power alone that can save from sin, and that divine power both assures the sinner of forgiveness and restores soul and body together.RH Sep 20, 1906RH Nov 30, 1916ST Dec 17, 1894

Blasphemy includes claiming the power to forgive sins which belongs to God, and the right to that power is proved by actually showing the ability to forgive.RH Dec 25, 1900 That same definition condemns the claim that priests have power to forgive sins.RH Dec 25, 1900 The authority once exercised on earth to forgive sins continues still, though He is now in heaven.RH Jan 7, 1915

Compassion And Character Of Christ

The moment discloses tender compassion and love at work in both physical and moral healing, for the Great Physician forgives sins even while teaching the multitudes in fields and woods and by the lakeside concerning the kingdom of heaven.ST Nov 14, 1906RH Feb 9, 1905 That same compassion appears in feeding the multitudes in the wilderness, healing their diseases, freeing them from evil spirits, and restoring their dead to life.ST Nov 14, 1906 It is compassion shown to a helpless, needy man whom others would pass by as hopeless, bringing him help and hope.RH Feb 9, 1905RH Nov 23, 1911

He feels sympathy for bodily suffering, yet a deeper sorrow for sin-sickness, so that His work draws people to Himself that they may have faith and be forgiven.STST Mar 16, 1904 His presence brings conviction of sin together with healing of spiritual as well as physical disease, because the deepest need of the paralyzed man was relief from the burden of sin and assurance of forgiveness and peace with God.STST Mar 16, 1904 Knowing the unspoken thoughts and challenging the inward reasoning, He then displays power and compassion toward the guilty and afflicted rather than cold judgment.STST Mar 24, 1881

The stricken one receives hope and strength, carrying with ease the couch on which he had been slowly borne away and standing in the full vigor of manhood.ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877 Arms that had been lifeless become quick to obey his will, flesh that had been shrunken and leaden-hued becomes fresh and ruddy with health, and he walks with a firm, free step with hope written in every line of his face.ST Oct 16, 1879 All gloom is gone, and peace and purity take the place of the marks of sin and suffering.ST Oct 16, 1879 His home is filled with rejoicing, tears of joy, and glad thanksgiving, and God is glorified through His Son.ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877 The man and his family become fully faithful to Christ who brought light into their darkened home, with no doubt dimming faith and no unbelief marring loyalty, ready even to lay down their lives for Jesus.ST Oct 16, 1879ST Apr 5, 1877

Scripture Connections And Doctrines

Christ's perceiving of inward thought shows that his knowing of people is not bare awareness, for to know can denote spiritual relationship as in Genesis 4:1.ST Feb 17, 1904 The word by which he heals disease is equally powerful to forgive sins, and leprosy stands as a picture of sin. His Spirit-filled life overcomes sin just as his word overcomes disease.

His healing of the sick man with forgiveness on the Sabbath pours out blessing through healing and forgiveness, teaching that the Sabbath is a day of special blessing.ST Jul 16, 1894 His Sabbath healings and his passing through the grainfields did not make him a transgressor of God's law or a sinner, for to make him a transgressor would make him an unfit sacrifice for sinners.RH Nov 1, 1853 Sin and bodily disease are real, and healing comes from God above in answer to faith. Faith reaches outward for divine power rather than recognizing that power as already within the person.

The healing of the paralytic belongs among the works he did on earth, and the promise that believers will do greater works does not necessarily mean they will heal more paralytics.RH Aug 7, 1913 It surely means they will see more miracles of grace upon the hearts of men, women, and children.RH Aug 7, 1913 There is no greater work than the transformation of the unregenerated heart.RH Aug 7, 1913

Application To Faith And Healing

The case shows a man in urgent dissolution already working on the body, brought on his bed and let down through the torn-open roof, whose condition was perfectly understood.RH May 21, 1914 He bore a sickness of soul far worse than bodily suffering, with sin as the greatest burden carried for months without relief.RH May 21, 1914 That heavy burden was lifted first by forgiveness, bringing hope for despair and peace and joy for doubt and gloom, and with the mind restored to peace the suffering body could then be reached and healed to life and strength.RH May 21, 1914 Successful treatment of disease must therefore minister to the diseased mind and relieve the sin-burdened conscience before the body can be fully reached, for before bodily strength was restored he needed mental relief and cleansing from sin.RH May 21, 1914 Disease results, directly or indirectly, from sin, and finding peace through forgiveness, faith, and trust can bring calmness of nerves and healing of physical ailments, showing the close relationship between relief of the soul and bodily health.RH Sep 26, 1912

Those whose spiritual condition weighs on physical health may, on hearing that sins are forgiven, rise and walk.ST May 22, 1901 The command to rise, take up the bed, and go home carried the power to make whole.ST Jan 18, 1899 The man's willingness to obey was met by that power.ST Jan 18, 1899

His response to the command is an example of acting in faith, known even in his inward reasoning, teaching that people should do what they can, trusting God to sustain them and advance His cause.RH Jun 8, 1869 The whole work was aimed to draw people to Himself so they could have faith and be forgiven.ST Mar 16, 1904 There was sympathy for bodily suffering, but a deeper sorrow for sin-sickness.ST Mar 16, 1904

Sources

  1. ST May 13, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 19 — Editorial Editor, MAY 13, 1897
  2. ST Feb 3, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 5 — LESSON 7.—FEBRUARY 14.—JESUS FORGIVES SIN February 3, 1904
  3. ST Apr 12, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 15 — LESSON V.—SABBATH, APRIL 29, 1899 April 12, 1899
  4. ST Dec 2, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 46 — THE PERSONALITY OF CHRIST Samuel T. Spear, D.D., December 2, 1889
  5. ST Feb 17, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 7 — LESSON 9.—FEBRUARY 28.—HEARERS AND DOERS OF THE WORD February 17, 1904
  6. ST Jan 21, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 3 — Notes on the International Lesson Ellen G. White, January 21, 1889
  7. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  8. ST Jul 12, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 28 — XI. THE POWER OF FORGIVENESS July 12, 1905
  9. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 1 — Christ the Teacher and Healer Ellen G. White
  10. ST Oct 15, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 49 — International S. S. Lessons Editor, Monday, October 15, 1894
  11. ST Jun 21, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 25 — COMFORT FOR THE SAD, SICK, AND WEARY Daniel Nettleton, June 21, 1905
  12. RH Sep 20, 1906 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 83, No. 38 — Two Important Features in Teaching Stephen Nelson Haskell, September 20, 1906
  13. ST Jan 16, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 3 — INTERNATIONAL SUNDAY SCHOOL LESSON January 16, 1896
  14. ST Jul 7, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 27 — On the Shores of Galilee H. P. H., July 7, 1898
  15. ST May 22, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 21 — PROSPECTS BEFORE THE CHRONIC INVALID David Paulson, May 22, 1901
  16. RH May 21, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 21 — Ministering to Soul and Body [^1] Ellen G. White, Thursday, May 21, 1914
  17. ST Jan 21, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 3 — Notes on the International Lesson Ellen G. White, January 21, 1889
  18. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  19. ST Oct 4, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 39 — Schedule for Week Ending October 15 Editor, October 4, 1910
  20. RH Oct 30, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 16, No. 24 — HISTORY J. Clarke, Third-Day, October 30, 1860
  21. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 1 — Christ the Teacher and Healer Ellen G. White
  22. ST Jun 30, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 25 — Thy Sins Be Forgiven Thee Ellen G. White, June 30, 1914
  23. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  24. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  25. ST Feb 3, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 5 — LESSON 7.—FEBRUARY 14.—JESUS FORGIVES SIN February 3, 1904
  26. ST Oct 15, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 49 — International S. S. Lessons Editor, Monday, October 15, 1894
  27. ST Feb 3, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 5 — LESSON 7.—FEBRUARY 14.—JESUS FORGIVES SIN February 3, 1904
  28. ST Feb 13, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 7 — 3663 — Has Christ Creative Power? A. K., February 13, 1912
  29. RH Jun 8, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 24 — REPORT FROM CALIFORNIA D. T. BOURDEAU, Third-day, June 8, 1869
  30. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  31. ST Jan 21, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 3 — Notes on the International Lesson Ellen G. White, January 21, 1889
  32. ST Apr 5, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 15 — THE PARALYTIC Ellen G. White, April 5, 1877
  33. ST Oct 15, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 49 — International S. S. Lessons Editor, Monday, October 15, 1894
  34. ST Jul 12, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 28 — XI. THE POWER OF FORGIVENESS July 12, 1905
  35. RH Jan 7, 1915 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 92, No. 1 — He Arose and Departed T. E. BOWEN, January 7, 1915
  36. ST May 15, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 20 — Read our list of tracts on page 13 Editor, May 15, 1907
  37. ST Apr 9, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 23 — The Case Against Sunday Laws Monday, April 9, 1894
  38. ST May 13, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 19 — Editorial Editor, MAY 13, 1897
  39. RH Oct 30, 1913 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 90, No. 44 — FREDERICK M. ROSSITER, M. D Frederick M. Rossiter, M. D., Thursday, October 30, 1913
  40. RH Nov 30, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 59 — The Divine Physician F. M. W., Thursday, November 30, 1916
  41. ST Dec 17, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 58 — International S. S. Lessons Editor, Monday, December 17, 1894
  42. RH Dec 25, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 52 — THE FIRST PLAGUE B. G. Wilkinson, December 25, 1900
  43. RH Jan 7, 1915 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 92, No. 1 — He Arose and Departed T. E. BOWEN, January 7, 1915
  44. ST Nov 14, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 44 — WE WOULD SEE JESUS Arthur Carlyle Logan, NOVEMBER 14, 1906
  45. RH Feb 9, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 6 — Publishers’ Page Editor, February 9, 1905
  46. RH Nov 23, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 47 — Thou Shalt Love Thy Neighbor as Thyself Daniel H. Kress, November 23, 1911
  47. ST Mar 16, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 11 — LESSON 13.—MARCH 27.—REVIEW OF THE QUARTER'S LESSONS March 16, 1904
  48. ST Mar 24, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 12 — THE PARALYTIC HEALED Ellen G. White, March 24, 1881
  49. ST Oct 16, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 39 — General Articles Ellen G. White, October 16, 1879
  50. ST Apr 5, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 15 — THE PARALYTIC Ellen G. White, April 5, 1877
  51. ST Jul 16, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 36 — THE TWO WORSHIPERS Monday, July 16, 1894
  52. RH Nov 1, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 17 — Importance of Obedience S. T. Belden, November 1, 1853
  53. RH Aug 7, 1913 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 90, No. 32 — Talks on Education W. E. H., August 7, 1913
  54. RH Sep 26, 1912 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 89, No. 39 — Medical Missionary Department F. M. Wilcox, September 26, 1912
  55. ST Jan 18, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 3 — THE SUPREME AND CERTAIN TEST Editor, January 18, 1899

Cross-references

  1. Matthew 9:4

    And Jesus knowing their thoughts said, Wherefore think ye evil in your hearts?

    Jesus perceives the scribes’ thoughts and challenges their doubts about his authority to forgive sins.

  2. Luke 5:22

    But when Jesus perceived their thoughts, he answering said unto them, What reason ye in your hearts?

    The parallel account says Jesus knew the scribes’ reasoning and questioned them about it.

  3. Luke 5:21

    And the scribes and the Pharisees began to reason, saying, Who is this which speaketh blasphemies? Who can forgive sins, but God alone?

    Records the inner reasoning Jesus perceived.

  4. Luke 5:23

    Whether is easier, to say, Thy sins be forgiven thee; or to say, Rise up and walk?

    Jesus continues his answer by showing his authority to forgive sins and heal.

  5. Matthew 9:5

    For whether is easier, to say, Thy sins be forgiven thee; or to say, Arise, and walk?

    Christ contrasts forgiving sins with healing the body.

  6. Luke 5:24

    But that ye may know that the Son of man hath power upon earth to forgive sins, (he said unto the sick of the palsy,) I say unto thee, Arise, and take up thy couch, and go into thine house.

    The healing miracle proves the Son of man’s power to forgive sins.

  7. Luke 7:48-50

    And he said unto her, Thy sins are forgiven.

    Jesus forgives the woman and sends her away in peace.

  8. Mark 2:12

    And immediately he arose, took up the bed, and went forth before them all; insomuch that they were all amazed, and glorified God, saying, We never saw it on this fashion.

    The healing miracle confirms Jesus’ power and leads the crowd to glorify God.