Translations
American King James Version, Bible in Basic English
Because they said, He has an unclean spirit.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Because they said, He hath an unclean spirit.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
because they said, He hath an unclean spirit.
because they said, 'He hath an unclean spirit.'
— because they said, He has an unclean spirit.
because they were saying—An impure spirit, he hath!
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Jesus made this statement because they were saying, “ He has an unclean spirit.”
— because they said, “ He has an unclean spirit.”
Because they saide, Hee had an vncleane spirit.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Because they said: He hath an unclean spirit.
Cross-references
- Matthew 12:31-32
Wherefore I say unto you, All manner of sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men: but the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men.
Jesus warns that calling the Spirit’s work demonic is blasphemy that will not be forgiven.
- Hebrews 10:29
Of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, where with he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace?
Treating the covenant blood as unholy and insulting the Spirit of grace rejects God’s saving work.
- Matthew 12:24
But when the Pharisees heard it, they said, This fellow doth not cast out devils, but by Beelzebub the prince of the devils.
The Pharisees attribute Jesus’ casting out demons to Beelzebub.
- Matthew 9:34
But the Pharisees said, He casteth out devils through the prince of the devils.
Both texts report the Pharisees accusing Jesus of casting out devils by Satan.
- Mark 3:22
And the scribes which came down from Jerusalem said, He hath Beelzebub, and by the prince of the devils casteth he out devils.
Records the accusation that Jesus casts out demons by Beelzebub.
- Luke 12:10
And whosoever shall speak a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but unto him that blasphemeth against the Holy Ghost it shall not be forgiven.
Both warn that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven.
- Luke 11:15
But some of them said, He casteth out devils through Beelzebub the chief of the devils.
Records the charge that Jesus cast out demons by Beelzebul.
- John 10:20
And many of them said, He hath a devil, and is mad; why hear ye him?
Both texts report that Jesus was accused of having an unclean spirit and being mad.
- Mark 3:21
And when his friends heard of it, they went out to lay hold on him: for they said, He is beside himself.
His family hears that people consider him beside himself.
- Matthew 12:31
Wherefore I say unto you, All manner of sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men: but the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men.
Identifies the sin described as blasphemy against the Holy Ghost.
- Matthew 12:22
Then was brought unto him one possessed with a devil, blind, and dumb: and he healed him, insomuch that the blind and dumb both spake and saw.
identifies the healing that led to the accusation
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
12 sources
This explanatory clause stands inside Mark 3:20-35, which together with Matthew 12:22-50 gives the account of who are Christ's brethren.DA 321 It gives the occasion for the warning about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, for after the healing of a possessed man who was blind and dumb the Pharisees said He had an unclean spirit.DA 321.3DA 321.1–24MR 360.116MR 93.1–4 They charged that He was controlled by an evil spirit and cast out devils through the prince of devils, by the power of Satan, thus calling God's holy power in His works satanic.DA 321.3DA 321.1–24MR 360.116MR 93.1–4
They could not deny the remarkable healings or explain them as natural, yet they recognized supernatural power at work.4MR 360.116MR 93.1–4 They stubbornly shut their eyes to the evidence and knowingly accused Him of serving the devil, resisting the truth so they would not be converted.4MR 360.116MR 93.1–4 News of that charge reached the sons of Joseph along with reports that entire nights were spent in prayer and days were so thronged that there was no time even to eat.DA 321.1–2 Friends thought incessant labor was wearing Him out and could not account for His attitude toward the Pharisees, and some feared His reason was unsettled.DA 321.1–2 The brothers felt keenly the reproach this brought upon them through relation to Him and knew the tumult His words and works created, and they were alarmed at His bold statements and indignant at His denunciation of the scribes and Pharisees.DA 321.1–2 They decided He must be persuaded or constrained to stop this manner of labor, and induced Mary to unite with them in hope that His love for her would prevail upon Him to be more prudent.DA 321.1–2
The sin against the Holy Spirit is wilfully attributing to Satan, to evil agencies, or to a human source a work known to be the work of God's Spirit.HSP 25.6Lt 20, 1889, par. 17–18Ms 159, 1903, par. 7–11Lt 212, 1897, par. 2–3 It rejects convincing evidence of its divine character and falsely condemns it as evil despite its good fruits, and such opposition is not done in ignorance.HSP 25.6Lt 20, 1889, par. 17–18Lt 212, 1897, par. 2–3 This deliberate rejection and perversion of the Holy Spirit's work is the unpardonable, unforgivable sin.4MR 360.116MR 93.1–4 The same serious guilt applies when Spirit-inspired messages are credited to a human giver, as when it was claimed after such messages were given that the human agent had given their inspiration, and when the power and heavenly light attending the first and second angels' messages is called satanic.Ms 159, 1903, par. 7–115MR 426.2Ms 3, 1853, par. 11
To declare the Spirit's work to be from Satan cuts the speaker off from the fountain of blessing and cuts off the channel by which God communicates and works upon the heart.DA 321.3HSP 25.6Lt 20, 1889, par. 17–18 It shuts the person out in spiritual darkness where repentance and faith cannot come, so that when the Spirit is finally rejected there is nothing more God can do for the soul.DA 321.3Lt 20, 1889, par. 17–185MR 426.2Ms 3, 1853, par. 11 By contrast, speaking against Jesus Himself without discerning His divine character can still be forgiven, because through the Holy Spirit the person can be brought to see the error and repent.DA 321.3 Whatever sin is repented of and believed is washed away in His blood.DA 321.3
Because ascribing the manifestation of the Holy Spirit to evil agencies brings such guilt, passing judgment on the work of others must be done with great care.SPBC 143.2–3 The church is to labor to separate evil from good and not knowingly tolerate wrongdoing but expel it from heart and life, rather than mingling evil with good and confusing good and evil.SPBC 143.2–3 Those who experienced the power and glory of the first and second angels' messages and then called that heavenly light satanic and hardened their hearts to refuse the third message are shut out, with more hope for sinners than for them.5MR 426.2Ms 3, 1853, par. 11 But those who have not hardened their hearts or received and resisted the earlier messages can still recognize their effects, understand how they join together, and joyfully accept and be brought to the truth.5MR 426.2Ms 3, 1853, par. 11
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
27 sources
Jesus gave his warning about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit because his opponents claimed he was possessed by an evil spirit.ST Nov 12, 1894RH Apr 28, 1853RH Nov 30, 1916 They made that charge against miracles plainly done by God's power before their eyes, especially his casting out of demons, saying he did them by Beelzebub the prince of devils.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Apr 14, 1887ST Oct 15, 1912ST Aug 6, 1912 To knowingly call the work of Christ and the Holy Spirit the work of the devil is itself that blasphemy and the unpardonable sin.ST Apr 14, 1887ST Oct 15, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907ST Jan 24, 1900 It cannot be pardoned not by an arbitrary limit on God's mercy but because the Spirit is God's only means to quicken, cleanse, sanctify, and lead sinners to repentance, so willful, persistent rejection of clear light cuts off the only remedy.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Oct 15, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907ST Oct 6, 1909ST Mar 25, 1880 That same sin is committed now when known truth is rejected, as in accusing commandment keepers of following an evil spirit, ascribing the Spirit's gifts such as prophecy to Satan, and counting Christ's blood in the sanctuary above as unholy (Hebrews 10:26-29). RH Apr 28, 1853RH Jan 9, 1855RH Aug 27, 1901
Setting and Meaning
Mark explains that Jesus gave his warning about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit because his opponents said he had an unclean spirit.ST Nov 12, 1894RH Apr 28, 1853RH Nov 30, 1916RH Jan 9, 1855 The scribes and Pharisees charged that he cast out demons by Beelzebub, the prince of devils, portraying him as empowered by an evil spirit.ST Nov 12, 1894RH Apr 28, 1853RH Nov 30, 1916ST May 17, 1899 In saying this they ascribed the work of the Spirit of God in Christ to Satanic agency, calling the Spirit's power an unclean power from Satan.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Apr 14, 1887ST Oct 15, 1912ST Oct 6, 1909
Their charge centered on his Spirit-empowered miracles, especially casting out demons, as done by Beelzebub, an unclean satanic power.ST Apr 14, 1887ST Sep 4, 1907ST Oct 6, 1909ST Dec 16, 1897 They called the Holy Spirit's power in Jesus' work of casting out devils the power of Beelzebub, attributing to Beelzebub the miracles he performed through the Spirit.ST Apr 14, 1887ST Oct 15, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907ST Dec 16, 1897 His miracles were a clear work of God, in harmony with his teaching, yet they rejected their divine source.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Oct 15, 1912ST Aug 6, 1912
They made this charge though the mighty power of God was manifest before their eyes in his teaching and miracles.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Aug 6, 1912ST Nov 12, 1894 That power was seen in curing multitudes of every disease and casting out unclean spirits, and in forgiving sins as only God can forgive and in healing as only God can create, by forgiving the sick of the palsy and bidding him rise and walk.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Nov 12, 1894 Their accusation came despite this clear evidence of God's loving power displayed before them.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Aug 6, 1912ST Nov 12, 1894
The charge was not a mere insult against Jesus as a man but a charge against the mighty power of God working through him.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Feb 5, 1902ST Nov 12, 1894 It was not merely an offensive form of words but revealed opposition to God's work, and hatred because his righteousness condemned their sinfulness.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Dec 17, 1894ST Feb 5, 1902ST Nov 12, 1894 By identifying him with Beelzebub, described as the filth god whom the Phoenicians associated with causing diseases, the accusers implied that an unclean spirit had made him mad and turned his brain.ST May 17, 1899ST May 17, 1899
Nature of Unpardonable Sin
In that instance the charge was the unpardonable sin, for to attribute what was known to be the work of Christ and of the Holy Spirit to the devil is blasphemy against the Holy Spirit.ST Apr 14, 1887ST Oct 15, 1912ST Apr 25, 1878 The scribes and Jews sinned against the Holy Spirit by calling the Spirit's work in Christ, especially His casting out of demons, an unclean power from Satan and Beelzebub the prince of devils.ST Apr 14, 1887ST Oct 15, 1912ST Apr 25, 1878 His miracles were a clear work of God in harmony with His teaching, yet by setting aside the only power that could save they could find no forgiveness because they could never discern its source.ST Oct 15, 1912 The same sin now is to attribute the work of the Holy Spirit manifested in the gifts of the church to the power of Satan, as when those who went out declare the gift of prophecy graciously manifested to God's people to be Satan's work in order to tear down and curse the remnant that keep the commandments of God under the third message.ST Apr 25, 1878
This sin is willful, knowing, and persistent rejection of clear light and experienced truth, not mere words, ignorance, or something mysterious and indefinable.ST Sep 4, 1907ST Jan 24, 1900ST Feb 5, 1902ST Jul 8, 1930 The claim that Jesus had an unclean spirit was not merely an offensive form of words but revealed opposition to God's work and willful rejection of the Holy Spirit's work made to avoid confessing the truth.ST Feb 5, 1902ST Jul 8, 1930ST Mar 25, 1880 It includes doing despite to the Spirit, rejecting the atonement and salvation and despising the mercy offered by the Father and the Son, treating Christ's death and blood as worthless, and attributing the Holy Spirit's work to natural or evil causes.ST Sep 4, 1907ST Jan 24, 1900ST Jun 20, 1906 Persisting in this rejection leaves no other means by which God can reach a person, so that person becomes unable to repent and beyond repentance and forgiveness, in danger of cherishing sin and resisting the Spirit's pleading until one no longer recognizes it.ST Sep 4, 1907ST Jul 8, 1930ST Jun 20, 1906
It is unpardonable because the Holy Spirit is God's only means to save men, the only power that can lead to repentance and salvation.ST Oct 15, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907ST Oct 6, 1909ST Dec 16, 1897ST Aug 8, 1900 Men are redeemed by the blood of Christ but quickened to new life and kept from sin, cleansed, sanctified, and regenerated by the Spirit of God through faith in Christ.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Dec 16, 1897ST Aug 8, 1900 To call the Spirit's power in Jesus' work of casting out devils the power of Beelzebub is to ascribe the work of the Spirit of God to satanic agency, not a mere charge against Jesus as a man but against the mighty power of God working through Him manifest in teaching and miracles, healing multitudes of every disease, forgiving sins as only God can forgive and creating as only God can create by forgiving the sick of the palsy and bidding him rise and walk.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Oct 6, 1909ST Dec 16, 1897 Whoever deliberately rejects that means makes himself guilty of an eternal sin and cuts himself off by his own deliberate rebellion, refusing the only remedy and the only way to be pardoned and cleansed, leaving no power by which God can save him from sin, not because God lacks mercy but because the soul refuses forgiveness.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Oct 6, 1909ST Aug 8, 1900
Persisting in this rejection hardens the heart until the person no longer discerns the Spirit's source, responds to its pleas, or turns to repentance.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Jul 8, 1930ST Jan 27, 1898ST Nov 21, 1900ST Jun 20, 1906 The accusation came despite clear evidence of God's loving power and good work through Jesus in the power of the Holy Spirit, showing resistance to the Spirit's final plea and evidence.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Nov 21, 1900 Such persistent resistance illustrates a heart hardened against God until it no longer receives divine influence, until the Spirit can no longer impress it.ST Jul 8, 1930ST Jan 27, 1898 Each step in slighting heaven's invitation to repent and in rejecting Christ is a step toward rejecting salvation and toward this unrepentable state.ST Jun 20, 1906
The loss is not by an arbitrary act of God, whose mercy has no limit.ST Oct 6, 1909ST Aug 11, 1914ST Apr 9, 1912 Those who do this in ignorance may still be accepted by God.ST Aug 11, 1914 A hardened conscience has no alarm about it, while grief over sin, sorrow for sin itself, desire to return, and striving to do the will of the Master show a person has not committed the unpardonable sin and need not be discouraged, cast down, or despair, for as long as a person is sorry and wants to return the Spirit can enable that person to find mercy.ST Oct 6, 1909ST Mar 25, 1880ST Apr 9, 1912
The same sin occurs now when true light is knowingly rejected.RH Apr 28, 1853RH Jan 9, 1855ST Apr 25, 1878 It is linked to accusing Sabbath keepers who teach obedience to God's commandments of being led by an unclean spirit, bringing a warning to beware.RH Apr 28, 1853 It is attributing the Holy Spirit's gifts in the church such as the gift of prophecy to Satan in order to tear down the remnant.ST Apr 25, 1878 It is also sinning willfully after receiving a knowledge of the truth by deliberately attributing the power of God to Satan as the Jews did, thereby trampling under foot the blood offered in the sanctuary above by the High Priest and counting the blood of the covenant wherewith he was sanctified an unholy thing no more valuable than other blood, and doing despite unto the Spirit of grace.RH Aug 27, 1901 For such there remains no more sacrifice for sins and no renewal to repentance because they reject Christ and put Him to open shame, but only a looking for of judgment and fiery indignation which shall devour the adversaries, counting themselves unworthy of eternal life and falling into the hands of the living God to whom vengeance belongs, far worse than despising Moses' law which brought death without mercy.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Aug 27, 1901 Those who held that leaders in their own day had said He hath an unclean spirit taught that by that ground they had committed that lost, unpardonable sin.RH Jul 30, 1901
Sources