Matthew 17:19
Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast it out?
Then the disciples having come to Jesus by himself, said, 'Wherefore were we not able to cast him out?'
Then the disciples, coming to Jesus apart, said [ to him], Why were not we able to cast him out?
Then, the disciples, coming near, to Jesus, privately, said—Wherefore could, we, not cast it out?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Afterward the disciples came to Jesus privately and asked, “ Why couldn’ t we drive it out?”
Then the disciples came to Jesus privately, and said, “ Why weren’ t we able to cast it out?”
Then the disciples came to Jesus privately, and said, Why were we not able to send it out?
Then came the disciples to Iesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Then came the disciples to Jesus secretly, and said: Why could not we cast him out?
Cross-references
- Mark 9:28-29
And when he was come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, Why could not we cast him out?
The disciples privately ask why they failed to cast out the demon, and Jesus explains.
- Matthew 10:1
And when he had called unto him his twelve disciples, he gave them power against unclean spirits, to cast them out, and to heal all manner of sickness and all manner of disease.
Jesus gave the disciples power to cast out unclean spirits.
- Luke 9:40
And I besought thy disciples to cast him out; and they could not.
The disciples could not cast out the spirit from the boy.
- Mark 11:23
For verily I say unto you, That whosoever shall say unto this mountain, Be thou removed, and be thou cast into the sea; and shall not doubt in his heart, but shall believe that those things which he saith shall come to pass; he shall have whatsoever he saith.
Faith without doubt empowers the disciples’ effective action.
- Mark 9:29
And he said unto them, This kind can come forth by nothing, but by prayer and fasting.
Jesus says this kind can be cast out only by prayer and fasting.
- Mark 9:23
Jesus said unto him, If thou canst believe, all things are possible to him that believeth.
Jesus assures that all things are possible to the one who believes.
- Luke 9:1
Then he called his twelve disciples together, and gave them power and authority over all devils, and to cure diseases.
Jesus had given the disciples authority over demons and diseases.
- Luke 10:17
And the seventy returned again with joy, saying, Lord, even the devils are subject unto us through thy name.
The disciples had earlier rejoiced that demons were subject to them.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
5 sources
The disciples came to Jesus privately and alone after they had failed to ask why they could not cast the demon out.DA 426.1–2DA 426.3–427.2DA 430.2–42SP 335.3ST Jun 7, 1877 Power and authority over unclean spirits to work miracles of healing had previously been conferred upon them.DA 426.3–427.22SP 335.3ST Jun 7, 1877 They had succeeded when they went out in faith, but on this occasion the spirit resisted them.DA 426.3–427.2 The failure they asked about was their attempt before many witnesses to deliver the boy with the dumb spirit.ST Jun 7, 1877 The public defeat left them humiliated, mortified and distressed before the people, unable to account for or explain it.DA 426.1–2DA 426.3–427.2ST Jun 7, 1877
The cause of the failure was unbelief and the carelessness with which they regarded the sacred work committed to them.DA 430.2–42SP 335.3ST Jun 7, 1877 Their faith had been weakened by lack of deeper sympathy with Christ, and by discouragement, jealousy, and attention to personal grievances.DA 430.2–4 They had not fitted and prepared themselves for their holy office by fasting and prayer.DA 430.2–42SP 335.3ST Jun 7, 1877
They could vanquish Satan and conquer the enemy of souls only by receiving power and strength from God, going to Him in humility of heart and self-sacrifice to plead for it in fervent prayer.DA 430.2–42SP 335.3ST Jun 7, 1877 Nothing but entire dependence upon God and full and perfect consecration to His work would insure success, so as to receive the Spirit's aid in conflict with the powers of darkness.DA 430.2–42SP 335.3ST Jun 7, 1877 Even faith as small as a grain of mustard seed makes nothing impossible.ST Jun 7, 1877
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
21 sources
The disciples came to Jesus privately and alone to ask why they had been unable to cast the demon out of the afflicted boy after failing before many witnesses though power to heal had been given them.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 6, 1906ST Jul 12, 1899ST Jan 20, 1909
Their failure came from unbelief, from little and insufficient faith, for inadequate faith brings failure as surely as no faith.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 6, 1906RH Apr 11, 1871
They had neglected prayer, fasting and watchfulness and regarded the sacred work carelessly, while this kind required prayer and fasting.ST Jun 7, 1877RH Dec 12, 1907ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 30, 1915RH Dec 9, 1852
They had also lost the power of their first mission through jealousy, selfishness, ambition and strife for the highest place, showing lack of the humility and unity needed for God to work through them.RH Feb 10, 1916RH Nov 30, 1911ST Mar 11, 1880RH May 7, 1914ST Apr 15, 1875
In answer they were taught that even faith as a grain of mustard seed makes nothing impossible, rendering humanly impossible things possible through God.ST Jun 7, 1877RH Nov 7, 1907ST Sep 30, 1886
Faith is the key to divine power and the secret of success in Christ's work, strengthened through prayer and fasting, so failure calls for seeking Jesus and examining the cause until faith and effective service are restored.RH Dec 30, 1915RH Dec 9, 1852ST Sep 30, 1886ST
Question and Setting
The verse records the disciples coming to Jesus privately, apart and alone, to ask why they had been unable to cast the demon out of the boy.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 6, 1906RH Dec 12, 1907ST Jul 12, 1899 Their question follows His answer that the failure came from little and insufficient faith, and it introduces His teaching on unbelief and on faith like a mustard seed, on effective prayer through trusting God's promise before the answer is seen and asking in Jesus' name according to His word and in faith, and on this kind of evil spirit requiring prayer and fasting by which faith is strengthened.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 6, 1906RH Dec 12, 1907RH Dec 30, 1915
They asked after failing before many witnesses to deliver the epileptic child, the boy with the dumb spirit, described as possessed by an unclean and evil spirit or devil.ST Jun 7, 1877ST Jul 12, 1899ST Jan 20, 1909 That public failure deeply mortified them even though power to work miracles of healing had been conferred upon them.ST Jun 7, 1877 Their private question, why they could not cast him out, arose from that insufficient faith and from the need for prayer and fasting, and it teaches about the power of faith.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 30, 1915ST Jan 20, 1909
The surrounding chapter contains the transfiguration on the mount, which represents the kingdom of glory with Christ as glorified King, Moses representing the righteous dead to be resurrected at Christ's second coming, and Elijah representing those to be translated without seeing death.ST Nov 7, 1900 That transfiguration happened during Christ's first advent about twelve months before His earthly mission closed and therefore is not His second coming.RH Jun 18, 1861 In this account, Jesus' use of generation has primary reference to His twelve disciples.
Cause of Failure
The failure to drive out the demon came from unbelief, described as little and insufficient faith.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 6, 1906RH Nov 7, 1907RH Dec 12, 1907 The private question about why the casting out had been impossible is answered by the lack of faith, and the kind of evil spirit involved required prayer and fasting.RH Dec 6, 1906RH Nov 7, 1907RH Dec 12, 1907ST Jul 12, 1899 Even though power had been given, insufficient faith explained the defeat and pointed to the need for prayer and fasting.RH Dec 12, 1907ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 30, 1915RH Dec 9, 1852
Inadequate faith, like no faith, leads to failure.RH Apr 11, 1871 A child of God enjoys all his faith lays hold of, and no more, so failure in work proves want of faith.RH Apr 11, 1871 The rebuke for lack of faith therefore carries a general rule that what is not grasped by faith is not possessed in experience.RH Apr 11, 1871
The defeat also came from neglecting prayer, fasting, and watchfulness.ST Jun 7, 1877RH Dec 12, 1907ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 30, 1915RH Nov 30, 1911 The sacred work had been regarded carelessly, and those sent had not fitted themselves for their holy office by fasting and prayer.ST Jun 7, 1877RH Dec 9, 1852 Power over unclean spirits was manifested only through prayer and faith, and prayer and fasting are connected with overcoming such obstacles and with strengthening faith.ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 30, 1915RH Dec 9, 1852 Lack of courage and confidence in Christ's power went with this neglect and left them spiritually unprepared.RH Nov 30, 1911
The power that had accompanied the first missionary tour had been lost through jealousy, selfishness, ambition, discord, and striving for the highest place.RH Feb 10, 1916RH Nov 30, 1911RH May 7, 1914 This showed lack of humility and lack of the unity and spiritual condition needed for God to give healing power.RH Feb 10, 1916RH Nov 30, 1911RH May 7, 1914 The power was not restored until those attitudes were put away and there was a new baptism with the Holy Spirit at Pentecost.RH Feb 10, 1916 Spiritual power was not theirs to use at will or to keep through carelessness, but its exercise depended on faith, humility, and seeking God's help and glory.ST Jun 7, 1877ST Mar 11, 1880ST Apr 15, 1875 It was impossible to vanquish Satan except as power was received from God, requiring continuing faith and dependence on Him.ST Jun 7, 1877ST Mar 11, 1880ST Apr 15, 1875
Faith Prayer and Service
The private question about failure to cast out the demon opens the teaching that faith like a mustard seed carries a deeper meaning than merely possessing a very small amount of faith. Even faith as a grain of mustard seed makes nothing impossible, so that what is impossible humanly becomes possible through God for those who believe.ST Jun 7, 1877RH Nov 7, 1907 Faith is the key to divine power and the secret of success in doing Christ's works.ST Faith in God enables effective action, while unbelief stands opposed to faith and cannot dwell in the heart alongside it.ST Sep 30, 1886 Effective faith rests on trust in God's power and willingness, and genuine faith produces works.
Believers are to trust God's promise before the answer is seen, for faith in God makes effective prayer possible.RH Dec 6, 1906 Asking in Jesus' name means asking according to His word and in faith.RH Dec 6, 1906 Requests made in faith receive an answer, though God may lovingly answer no.RH Nov 7, 1907 Workers who trust fully in the Master, His promises, resources, and Spirit can toil assured of success, even abundant and joyful success.RH Nov 7, 1907
Faith is strengthened through prayer and fasting, which are connected with overcoming such obstacles.RH Dec 30, 1915 Power over unclean spirits is manifested only through prayer and faith.RH Dec 9, 1852 Failure therefore calls for seeking Jesus and examining the cause so that faith and effective service may be restored.RH Nov 30, 1911 Jesus used the disciples' failures to teach and train them for leadership, as their later success shows.RH Sep 25, 1913 Their failure shows that even after years of instruction they still lacked faith and needed further conversion, having neglected prayer and watchfulness and lacked courage and confidence in Christ's power.RH Nov 30, 1911RH Jul 23, 1901
They must go to God in humility and self-sacrifice and plead for strength to conquer the enemy of souls.ST Jun 7, 1877 Nothing but entire dependence upon God and perfect consecration to the work will insure success.ST Jun 7, 1877 Supernatural power is not a possession to be used at will or kept through carelessness, but God works through those who humbly seek His glory in continuing faith and dependence on Him.ST Apr 15, 1875 When that dependence is neglected, courage and confidence in Christ's power are lacking and spiritual unpreparedness follows.RH Nov 30, 1911
Sources