Mark 9:28
And when he was come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, Why could not we cast him out?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And when he was come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, Why could not we cast him out?
And when he had come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, Why could not we cast him out?
And when he was come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, saying, We could not cast it out.
And when he was come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, How is it that we could not cast it out?
And he having come into the house, his disciples were questioning him by himself — 'Why were we not able to cast it forth?'
And when he was entered into the house, his disciples asked him privately, Wherefore could not we cast him out?
And, when he had gone into a house, his disciples, privately, were questioning him—Why, were, we, not able to cast it out?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
After Jesus had gone into the house, His disciples asked Him privately, “ Why couldn’ t we drive it out?”
When he had come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, “ Why couldn’ t we cast it out?”
And when he had gone into the house, his disciples said to him privately, Why were we unable to send it out?
And when hee was come into the house, his disciples asked him secretly, Why could not we cast him out?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And when he was come into the house, his disciples secretly asked him: Why could not we cast him out?
Cross-references
- Matthew 17:19-20
Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out?
Jesus explains the disciples’ failure as unbelief and teaches the power of faith.
- Luke 9:40
And I besought thy disciples to cast him out; and they could not.
The disciples could not cast out the spirit.
- Mark 6:7
And he called unto him the twelve, and began to send them forth by two and two; and gave them power over unclean spirits;
Jesus gave the disciples authority over unclean spirits.
- Mark 9:23-24
Jesus said unto him, If thou canst believe, all things are possible to him that believeth.
Jesus calls for belief, and the father asks for help with his unbelief.
- Mark 6:13
And they cast out many devils, and anointed with oil many that were sick, and healed them.
The disciples cast out demons during their earlier mission.
- Matthew 17:1-9
And after six days Jesus taketh Peter, James, and John his brother, and bringeth them up into an high mountain apart,
parallel lesson account
- Luke 10:17
And the seventy returned again with joy, saying, Lord, even the devils are subject unto us through thy name.
The disciples had previously rejoiced that demons were subject to them.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
After Jesus had cast out the spirit, the disciples came to Him privately to ask why they had been unable to cast it out.DA 426.3–427.22SP 335.33RED 124.2 Power and authority over unclean spirits to work miracles of healing had previously been conferred upon them, and they had succeeded when they went out in faith.DA 426.3–427.22SP 335.3 This time the spirit resisted their command, and their failure before many witnesses left them humiliated and perplexed, deeply mortified and without understanding of their defeat.DA 426.3–427.22SP 335.3
The reason for their failure was their unbelief and the carelessness with which they regarded the sacred work committed to them.2SP 335.33RED 124.2 They had not fitted themselves for their holy office by fasting and prayer, and it was impossible for them to vanquish Satan except as they received power from God.2SP 335.33RED 124.2
They needed to go to God in humiliation and self-sacrifice, pleading for strength to conquer the enemy of souls, since nothing but entire dependence upon God and perfect consecration to the work would ensure success.2SP 335.33RED 124.2 Jesus encouraged the disappointed disciples with the promise that faith as a grain of mustard seed can command a mountain to remove and that nothing shall be impossible.2SP 335.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
13 sources
When he had gone into the house, his disciples asked him privately why they had failed to cast the demon out of the afflicted boy.ST Jul 21, 1914ST Oct 6, 1881RH Dec 16, 1902 Their failure was because of unbelief and little faith.ST Jul 21, 1914ST Jul 12, 1899ST Oct 6, 1881 Faith as a grain of mustard seed can command a mountain to move from one place to another, and it will move, and nothing shall be impossible.ST Jul 12, 1899 Their lack of power also came from carelessness in sacred work, jealousy, love of supremacy and unholy ambition, and from neglecting watching and prayer and Scripture, yet this kind can be driven out only by prayer and fasting.ST Oct 6, 1881RH Dec 16, 1902RH Nov 30, 1911RH Apr 9, 1914 Power over Satan comes only as they receive it from God through humility, self-denial, complete dependence and consecration, with the heart cleansed to be a pure channel, so their question is a pattern after failure to seek Jesus, learn the reason, and examine neglected prayer and unchristlike traits.ST Oct 6, 1881RH Dec 16, 1902RH Nov 30, 1911RH Sep 25, 1913
Setting and Background
When he had come into the house, the disciples came to him privately to ask why they themselves had failed to cast the demon out and deliver the boy, after Jesus had driven out the evil spirit and the boy was healed.ST Jul 21, 1914ST Oct 6, 1881RH Dec 16, 1902RH Nov 30, 1911RH Sep 25, 1913 Their question came after their own unsuccessful attempt, and Jesus explained to them the reason for their failure so that they learned from him.RH Nov 30, 1911RH Sep 25, 1913RH Apr 9, 1914 The boy they had been unable to help was grievously afflicted and suffered as an epileptic possessed by a dumb spirit, falling often into fire and into water, and he is also spoken of as a young man.ST Jul 21, 1914ST Jul 12, 1899RH Apr 9, 1914ST Apr 1, 1897 Their asking followed Jesus rebuking the devil, with the boy cured from that hour.ST Jul 21, 1914ST Jul 12, 1899
The question belongs to the account of the transfiguration and what happened immediately afterward, when Jesus and the disciples came down from the mountain to the multitude and met suffering people needing help.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Mar 31, 1898RH Jan 4, 1912 They had come to the multitude on the way from Mount Hermon toward Capernaum.ST Jul 12, 1899 The larger passage parallels Luke 9:28-42 and comes six days after the promise that some standing there would not taste death till they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom, which the transfiguration fulfills.ST Mar 31, 1898
Those asking were the nine disciples left at the foot of the mount, whose inability reflected their state of mind and heart.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Apr 17, 1901 Although they had succeeded before and had received authority over demons and diseases, they now failed.RH Nov 30, 1911 Their private talk with Jesus in the house also exposed that they had been disputing which of them should be greatest.ST Jul 12, 1899 Those who have been with Christ on the mount are able to serve with power in casting out evil spirits at the foot of the mount.ST Jun 13, 1900 Yet the scene shows that the vision of God's kingdom did not remove earthly suffering or the need to minister to those afflicted by demons.RH Jan 4, 1912
They still held that his kingdom would be an earthly kingdom with its throne in Jerusalem, and they were discussing their relative fitness for places of trust in it.ST Jul 12, 1899 That material view of the kingdom barred the door of their hearts.ST Jul 12, 1899 The spiritual truth about his suffering, which he was trying for the second time to impress upon them, could not find entrance, and they were not deeply impressed by it.ST Jul 12, 1899
Cause and Cure of Failure
The failure to cast out the demon came from unbelief and little faith.ST Jul 21, 1914ST Jul 12, 1899ST Oct 6, 1881 It stood in contrast to the father's doubt about ability to heal, for when faith was called for the father prayed for help with his unbelief, and that prayer touched the heart so that the demon was driven out and the boy healed.ST Jul 21, 1914 The asking came after the cure of the grievously afflicted epileptic boy who fell often into fire and into water, when the devil had been rebuked and the boy cured from that hour.ST Jul 12, 1899 Carelessness in sacred work also lay behind the failure, for they had not prepared themselves.ST Oct 6, 1881
In connection with that failure it was taught that faith as a grain of mustard seed can say to a mountain, Remove hence to yonder place, and it shall remove, and nothing shall be impossible.ST Jul 12, 1899 The inability also reflected the state of mind and heart.ST Apr 17, 1901 Jealousy and love of supremacy had robbed them of healing power, along with unholy ambition.RH Dec 16, 1902RH Nov 30, 1911 Little faith was joined to lack of courage and trust in power, and to neglect of watching and prayer.RH Nov 30, 1911
This kind could be driven out only by prayer and fasting.RH Nov 30, 1911RH Apr 9, 1914 Their prayer and fasting were not genuine, and they had neglected prayer and Scripture.ST Oct 6, 1881RH Nov 30, 1911ST Apr 1, 1897 Satan could be overcome only by receiving power from God through humility, self-denial, prayer, complete dependence on God, and consecration to the work.ST Oct 6, 1881 God reveals His power through pure channels, so jealousy and other unchristlike traits had to be cleansed from the heart before He could work through them to free others, and the evil spirit of jealousy had to be cast out of them through prayer and fasting.RH Dec 16, 1902
The private question gives the pattern after failure to seek Jesus, have Him explain the reason, and learn from Him.RH Nov 30, 1911RH Sep 25, 1913 It calls for examination of the cause, including neglected prayer or Scripture and unholy ambition or jealousy, even by those who had succeeded before and had received authority over demons and diseases.RH Nov 30, 1911 The vision of God's kingdom did not remove earthly suffering or the need to minister to those afflicted by demons when coming down from the mountain to suffering people needing help.RH Jan 4, 1912 Those who have been with Christ on the mount are able to serve with power in casting out evil spirits at the foot of the mount.ST Jun 13, 1900 Prayer and fasting also guide plans and methods for helping young people escape the enemy's power in this kind of deliverance of the young man.RH Apr 9, 1914
Sources