If a private appeal fails to win an offender, one or two others are to be taken along so that every word may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses. This witnessed labor is the second step between going alone and telling it to the church, to be taken only after the first effort has failed and before any public action. Those brought are to be spiritually minded and impartial, and the work is to be done face to face with tenderness, humility, prayer and love that seeks confession and restoration rather than accusation. The steps must be faithfully followed with thorough, open investigation before any discipline, and they forbid settling the matter by gossip, hearsay, secret judgment or appeal to unbelievers. When so obeyed the process heals offenses, prevents many church trials and strife, preserves the unity and purity of the church, and heaven ratifies the decision of the church toward the unrepentant.
Verse Wording and Setting
If a private appeal to an offender fails to gain a hearing, one or two others are to be taken along so that every statement can be confirmed and settled by the testimony of two or three witnesses. This is the next step after private correction of a fault, sin, personal injury or misunderstanding, and it is not permission to hunt for faults or to spread reports about others. Its purpose is to replace suspicion, criticism and the spreading of reports with a direct and orderly way of remedying the wrong, and by keeping the matter among few it can heal wounds, stop false accusation, and prevent dissension, misunderstanding, alienation, strife and bitterness.
The procedure belongs to a personal trespass against the one giving the correction, a wrong between believers to be handled first privately and then with witnesses before any telling it to the church. It does not govern public wrongs that threaten the church, which are to be rebuked publicly, and a sin committed between a person and God alone need not be made public. If correction is ignored it is not to be hidden where members would be misled by continuing harmful influence, yet trials and disciplinary cases belong inside the church and must never be made known to the wicked. Believers must not intimate their troubles to unbelievers, circulate the trials of one church to other places, bring unbelievers in to give testimony to decide a case, or owe confession to unbelievers except where personal injury has been done to them, since doing so dishonors God, exposes weakness to those who hate believers, and brings darkness and loss of fitness for holy work.
The verse belongs to Christ's positive instruction in the whole of Matthew 18 for how followers are to act in every case and under all circumstances. That chapter is to be hung in the chambers of the mind, kept in memory, often read and pondered, obeyed, put into daily practice, and woven into Christian experience as the only terms for securing eternal life. It forbids striving for supremacy and teaches that greatness in the spiritual kingdom is not position, outward splendor or authority but inward excellence shown in true conversion and continual submission and obedience as meek and lowly in heart. It requires loving God with all heart, soul, mind and strength and neighbor as self, cultivating the garden of the soul, removing weeds and tares sown by Satan during neglect, ceasing to be occupied with weeds in the neighbor's garden, taking one's own garden under personal stewardship, bringing thoughts into captivity to Christ, purifying them, and not scattering words recklessly without careful consideration of their lodgment and result. It calls every individual to read and act, to be converted and obey the truth in real union with Christ in ministerial service, cooperating with Him and His angels and with true servants to help needy souls in the valley of decision, bring men to repentance, win souls, enlighten the ignorant and relieve the oppressed, rather than remaining unconverted and annoying and perplexing the weak in faith, and it disciplines the self by the Word, corrects withdrawing to labor alone and a selfish unholy spirit imagining things without foundation, and requires daily humbling before God, overcoming temptation, and receiving Christ's lessons before ministering the Word.
The verse also states a broader principle that no disputed matter is to be settled by one person's view, testimony or judgment alone. Two or more must be associated to share responsibility and confer together so that every word is established and what was said is confirmed, and in judgment one witness by himself cannot condemn or acquit. Judgment is not to rest on one mind alone because one mind is liable to deception, but on more minds than one centered on the same point, with mutual consideration and respect promoting unity and harmony. The same care applies to unkind or distrustful words, which should have what was said established by witness and answered with care while guarding against careless, harsh or disrespectful speech that grieves the Holy Spirit, and to church deliberations and the treatment of those who have erred, which should be carefully investigated with counsel and decision by the whole body rather than rushed or controlled by one person. This rule against one man setting up his judgment or opinions in opposition to the judgment of the church provides church discipline and government so the church holds together as a body and does not go to fragments, and when followed the highest heavenly authority ratifies its binding and loosing, a lesson with special bearing on the newly organized church and on the importance of union in effort and purpose.
The verse stands in a full ordered sequence: tell the fault alone, then take one or two more so testimony is firmly established, then tell it to the church, then if the church also is refused let the unyielding one be as a heathen and a publican outside fellowship. All possible effort is to be made to effect reconciliation between brethren, and those who stubbornly persist in remaining at variance are to be suspended until they can harmonize and live in harmony. The church of God with its appointed local and traveling elders and ministers to oversee, reprove, exhort, rebuke the unruly and comfort the feebleminded is the highest tribunal on earth, endowed by God with power, and its counsel, advice and decision must be submitted to. Members pledge mutual care and counsel under that oversight instead of each following private judgment and choosing his own course, for otherwise there will be confusion with no harmony or union, and those who will not submit cannot be helped, while resisting its authority and despising the judgment of its ministers is no light matter. Even if the church decides wrongly, the individual must still submit and leave correction to God in His own time to vindicate the right, without assuming responsibility for keeping the church in order.
Second Step Toward Restoration
The verse is the second step between laboring alone and telling it to the church, to be taken only when going to the trespassing brother alone and telling him his fault between him and the offended alone has failed, and before any public action or bringing the matter before the church. When the offender will not hear private reproof or private correction for his trespass, the one offended must take one or two more with him to speak to him and work with him gently and humbly with love for his soul, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. Wrongs between believers are to be righted and injuries healed privately when possible according to this process, without spreading the matter in the church or outside it and without making it a subject of conversation or seeking faults, while a sin between a person and God need not be made public. Ministers and men in positions of trust must ask anyone coming with a complaint about a brother or sister whether he has complied with the Saviour's rules in every particular, and if he has failed they must not listen to a word of his complaint and must refuse to take up a report against a brother or sister in the faith. Members who go entirely contrary to these rules make themselves subject to church discipline and should be put under the censure of the church, while neglecting the work entirely or doing it with harshness and severity wounds and bruises souls and leaves churches and institutions weak, inefficient, and almost Christless.
The prescribed steps with witnesses must be faithfully and exactly followed with thorough investigation and with tact, mercy, and the love of God, before complaints are heard, before officers or a committee recommend removal, and before the church votes discipline or removes a name from its books. A charge cannot rightly lead to condemning or removing a person unless these steps have been followed and the matter established by witnesses, and leaders must not cut someone off by their own judgment, self-assumed authority, harshness, haste, partiality or hypocrisy. Allegations of wrongdoing should be thoroughly and carefully investigated and handled according to Christ's instructions rather than by hasty judgments and unjust treatment, and correction must be carried out wisely and graciously. Doing so prevents gossip, helps preserve the church's health and purity, and church decisions made after the rule is fully obeyed may be ratified in heaven, whereas prejudice, selfish motives, and unjust judgments have no authority there.
The same rule applies to church members including physicians working among the churches and physicians employed in health institutions who fail to walk uprightly, to helpers in a religious institution who plainly understand the rules yet keep disregarding them, and to members who counterwork the minister, sow doubt and disaffection, or walk contrary to Bible rules. Such persons are subject to church oversight and the church must labor with those who sin, first going alone and then, if they do not heed personal correction, bringing others in so the matter is handled through an orderly, accountable process with patient, careful investigation by judicious persons. Patient labor must be given for a suitable time as directed, with admonition whether the physician is great or small, because a position of influence makes investigation more necessary, not less, and because one person who will not come to right terms affects the whole institution and community by the atmosphere surrounding the soul. If after faithful personal labor they will not hear, listen, change course, or submit to discipline, they are to be set aside, suspended, or separated from church fellowship and from the institution with reasons given, and grave sins must not be concealed or passed over without action, so that reproach is removed and blessing can rest, bringing a better condition instead of prevailing disorder.
The aim throughout is to seek recovery and restore someone who has gone astray through prayer and loving, caring correction rather than accusation or hastily separating the person from the church. Correction must not be neglected when wrongdoing and unchristian lives threaten to corrupt the church, but decided efforts are to be made to show the erring where they are wrong with a desire to save from ruin. The church must do everything possible for reformation before taking any step to sever from membership, and a faulty person may remain connected so that instruction and example can lead to recognition and correction. Willful uncorrected sin and unrepentant offenders require action and separation from the holy so that God's people remain clean and pure.
Spirit and Method Required
Those taken along should be spiritually minded, thoughtful people who are not parties to the trouble, so they can act more impartially. Their united appeal and agreement may carry greater weight, enlighten the mind of the one in error, and lead him to yield. The facts are to be heard calmly and kindly, seeking confession and a clear resolution.
The work is to be confined to as small a number as possible, with only one or two more joining to labor with the one in error. They are to be carefully and prayerfully taken, and to do more than talk, bowing in prayer and with humble hearts seeking the Lord. The labor is to be in tenderness, humility, meekness, pity, and with a heart throbbing in love for his soul. When brethren come together in harmony with this direction, Jesus Himself is present as a witness, the whole universe looks on with intense interest, and the Spirit of God moves upon the heart to convict of error. If pride and self-sufficiency keep him from confessing and healing the wrong, further steps must be taken to follow out the complete directions.
The fault is to be addressed directly, frankly, plainly, openly and face to face, in love, brotherly kindness, and Christ's spirit, giving opportunity to explain, answer, make plain what is not understood, and clear oneself. Every word is to be established by positive ground and faithful witnesses rather than by suspicion, appearance, secondhand reports, eager fault-finding, or the words of enemies. The matter must be sifted to the bottom by careful and thorough, open, frank and fair investigation, approaching as directed and praying with and for the person, with tact, mercy and the love of God, gently not roughly, removing evil suspicion. Talking over faults with others while keeping the person in ignorance violates the rule and causes gossip, coldness, shaken confidence, weakened love and breach of unity.
Those in charge and men in positions of responsibility must not rule as lords or kings, act on own judgment, impulse, or reports that investigation might prove groundless, or order dismissal at the hands of others without appearing as an actor. They must counsel with fellow responsible leaders, state reasons clearly, pray together and share responsibility, exercising wise counsel, prudence, wisdom and judgment that protects and strengthens God's people. The matter must be investigated carefully, patiently, humbly and prayerfully by the proper officers with sorrow for the erring, without self-assumed authority or a harsh, hard, unfeeling, overbearing spirit, and without dictating or meddling in matters that do not concern them. This open, Christian course reproves in love to save the person and may make retention possible, while failure risks serious blunder and offending one of Christ's little ones.
The instruction is the Saviour's clearly laid-down rule and standard for restoring a trespassing brother and resolving wrongs, to be strictly, carefully and practically obeyed rather than replaced by a contrary method. It is to be studied carefully, read, and put into daily practice in the home church, in the family and in the home, for it means much for living the Christian life and restoring agreement. Obeying it calls for greater spirituality and for converting power to come upon workers, and the Holy Spirit can enlighten understanding and make teacher and pupil sensitive and sympathetic by removing pride and selfishness.
Purposes and Blessed Results
Following the appointed course heals offenses and wounds and stops false accusations and criticism. It prevents dissension, misunderstanding, alienation, strife and bitterness in the church. Faithfully following it when one is thought to be in the wrong prevents church trials and upholds unity among believers, and it can prevent many church trials by keeping the matter among few and not spreading it in the church or outside it. Difficulties are healed promptly before small disagreements are magnified, and dissension and alienation that could have been healed are traced to refusal to receive reproof and turn from the wrong course. Carrying out the rules in the right way leaves a better condition with a better spirit in family, school and church, while neglecting them leaves disorder to prevail.
Going forward in faith and taking the case to the Lord in prayer, believing that He hears, brings relief and courage and hope. Confession of sins with repentance and a humble walk with God brings pardon. The correction described purifies and saves the one corrected. When brethren confine the difficulty to as small a number as possible and bow in prayer with humble hearts to seek the Lord, Jesus Himself is present as a witness, the universe looks on with intense interest, and the Spirit moves upon the erring heart to convict of error.
The process preserves the health and purity of the church and the sacred, holy character of Christ's church. Decided efforts are to be made to show those living unchristian lives where they are wrong, and if they will not correct their lives they are to be separated from the holy so that God's people remain clean and pure. Correction is not to be hidden if it is ignored, but when needed the church must be informed so its members are not misled by continuing harmful influence. Serious reproof is to be made known to experienced members, or to the whole church when needed, so others are not misled by unreformed influence, and charges against a member are never to be proved by questioning students about their teacher or discussing his errors with them for the world to hear, even if the suppositions were true, since that way of gathering testimony does greater injury to the cause. Faithful shepherds are to labor earnestly for those who walk contrary to Bible rules and give no evidence of seeking the life of Christ, and if they refuse to come out and be separate they are to be suspended from fellowship lest they be stumbling blocks, and if after earnest labor they still refuse to repent and humble themselves they are to be separated.
When the rule is fully obeyed, heaven ratifies the decision of the church in cutting off the unrepentant member. Church discipline is thus placed within a Bible-governed process, and heavenly authority ratifies the church's discipline when that rule is followed. Important decisions about an offender must not rest on one person's judgment alone but require prayerful collective discernment, with Christ as counselor, seeking the offender's restoration, and decisions made with prayer and faith according to God-given wisdom are ratified by Heaven and remain valid to the end of time. This lesson has special bearing on the newly organized church and on the importance of union in effort and purpose.
If private and witnessed labor fail to bring repentance, the offender is to be told to the church, and if still refusing to hear is to be separated and suspended until willing to heed and harmonize. Those who pursue transgression must be visited and labored with alone and then with one or two more, and if they still refuse to repent they must be separated from fellowship and their names not retained on the books, lest the saints be held accountable for evil deeds. The same steps apply to helpers in a religious institution who plainly understand the rules yet keep disregarding them, and to those who knowingly disregard an institution's rules, because one person who will not come to right terms affects the whole community by the surrounding atmosphere. The separated one is to be left alone rather than supported or given responsibility, and every member has duty to understand and do these rules of discipline and strive to preserve perfect harmony as in a well-regulated family. Keeping this discipline in the church below prepares for the great reunion in the church above, and those who here live in union with Christ may look forward to endless life in the heavenly courts.
Church Duty and Authority
The taking of one or two more belongs to remitting sins or restraining sins, which applies to the church in her organized capacity to preserve due order. Remission of sins itself is the prerogative of God alone, and no delegated servant has power to cast down or destroy or to remove guilt from any soul. The work belongs to wise representative men truly taught of God, possessing the inward working of the Holy Spirit with the Christ-life manifested in purity, faith and obedience, and having spiritual eyesight to discern spiritual things, whose actions in dealing with members can receive endorsement as from the head of the church. They are only to give God's message of what is written, to reprove, rebuke and exhort with longsuffering and doctrine, to give censure when needed, and to remove that censure when the one in error confesses and repents.
No liberty is given for any man to pass judgment upon others, but responsibility for individual members who fall into sin is placed upon the church in its organized capacity. The duty is to warn, to instruct, and if possible to restore, dealing faithfully with wrongdoing, warning every soul in danger, calling sin by its right name, and declaring what God has said about lying, Sabbath-breaking, stealing, idolatry, and every other evil. If sinners persist in sin, the judgment the church has declared from God's Word is pronounced upon them in heaven, for in choosing to sin they disown Christ. The church must show she does not sanction their deeds lest she dishonor her Lord, must say about sin what God says about it and deal with it as God directs, and her action is then ratified in heaven, so that he who despises the authority of the church in this work despises the authority of Christ Himself.
The instruction governs the church's duty toward members whose conduct dishonors the cause, and that duty must be carried out with justice and faithfulness. If the wrong is kept secret, those responsible cannot be shown their sin and the evil cannot be corrected. The matter should be stated plainly to someone trustworthy and handled in the light of God's Word so the wrong may be remedied and the evils set in order.
The plain words for how to treat those supposed to be in error are warning and counsel to be accepted and obeyed. A person sent a message of reproof must hear and receive it rather than refuse it, must not justify as obedience a course directly opposed to Christ's word, must not become an accuser of brethren while sympathizing with those not connected with God, and must not put the worst construction on a decided testimony calling to obedience. Accepting it recovers a person out of Satan's snares, while dismissing it as an idle tale and refusing to admit any possibility of error shows a heart steeled and captivated by Satan's bewitching power.
Rejecting Gossip and Injustice
Difficulties between believers are to be settled among themselves or by the church, not carried before unbelievers in a court of justice or by taking a fellow believer to law. The injured one seeks to save rather than avenge, and may entrust the case to God who judges righteously, proceeding in a humble Christlike spirit that guards against exposing sins before the world. Complaints and charges belong inside the church because outsiders cannot discern the principles governing believers, and the words of enemies must not dictate how God's people treat one another. Only after private appeal and then appeal with one or two others has failed is the matter to be told to the church as the last step, never publicized to the world where it damages the witness of saving grace.
Ministers and lay members displease God when they allow individuals to tell them the errors and faults of brethren without the Saviour's steps being strictly followed. They must inquire whether private labor and then labor with two or three witnesses was faithfully done, and if in any particular it has failed they must close the ears, listen to not a word, and refuse to take up a report or reproach against a brother or sister whose reputation Christ values. Without listeners evil tongues cease for lack of a field for biting and devouring one another, since listening to reports of evil is itself taking up the reproach. Failure to understand and follow this principle was illustrated in conduct toward W. C. White. Going entirely contrary to these rules makes one subject to church discipline and censure, while neglecting the work entirely or doing it with harshness and severity wounds and bruises souls and leaves churches weak and almost Christless.
Care is required to avoid bringing reproach on one who is not guilty, waiting patiently until both sides are heard and believing only what stern facts compel. Blame must not rest on the unproved and no one is to be removed on falsified reports, but every word established by thorough investigation according to Christ's instructions rather than leaders cutting off by their own judgment. Each person must watch his own actions instead of complaining of one another, ministers must not encourage such complaints or repeat church trials in preaching, and none should let prejudice and resentment be stirred by hearing the wrongs of others or artfully draw out from the unsuspecting matters they have no business with. The accused worker, as a child of God seeking to serve Him, must be given presence and full chance to explain and answer for himself before just men on positive ground and by faithful witnesses rather than by suspicion, appearance, secondhand reports or eager fault-finding, with facts presented openly, frankly and fairly instead of standing aloof in secret judgment without trial. To condemn and hurt and bruise souls on hearsay is un-Christlike and makes the actor a partaker with the accusers, charged in the books of heaven, tearing churches apart and driving the erring away instead of restoring him.
The second step forbids speaking evil in presence or absence, hearing evil, whispering, covert hints, and stabbing character in the dark, requiring checking the evil speaker, refusing to hear him, and going directly to the erring one instead. It forbids private watching, reporting, talebearing, and thinking and speaking evil against fellow members, listening to reports from unbelievers, taking arguments from those who deny the truth, and judging while the accused is left in ignorance. It forbids devising plans against a child of God, working secretly as a supposed friend, and seeking removal without ever telling the charges, for all such moves must be brought into the open and cannot be done secretly or underhanded because justice, righteousness and mercy require open dealing. Charges and accusers must be plainly set before the accused face to face, stating the faults charged and giving opportunity to know whereof accused, to answer, explain conduct, clear and vindicate if not true. Applied even to a grievance such as a matron failing to show sympathy or gentleness of tone to the sick, duty is to go to her herself in meekness and love seeking restoration rather than condemning without hearing, entertaining suspicions, carrying accusations, or complaining of deficiency to others in secret, which closes the door to division and draws hearts together.
Departing from this direction to spread reports through gossip brings condemnation, while accepting the plain warning and counsel recovers from Satan's snares and dismissing it as an idle tale shows a heart steeled and captivated. Those who listen to harmful reports share guilt with the spreader, and refusal to follow God's directions may become a matter of church discipline. Teaching and practicing a contrary way of dealing with the supposed erring gives the church a wrong mold, and endorsing and sustaining a worker who acts that way leaves guilt for unfaithfulness and neglect. Undoing the harm requires liberal, sustained labor to redeem the past, make restitution as far as possible, counteract wrong lessons and give an entirely different healthful influence, not feeble effort or short work and not personal ideas, impulses, harshness, haste, partiality or hypocrisy.
Wider Practice and Warnings
When one is believed to have done wrong, those concerned are to go to that person directly and respectfully to seek to cure the difficulty where it occurred, rather than spreading the charge or making it worse before hearing him. The approach is to be made with humility before God, gently and not roughly or inconsiderately, praying with and for the person and kindly pointing out the wrong with a heart softened by grace, seeking his good rather than accusing him. Evil suspicion is to be put away, and the matter is to be corrected where it arose, for departure from this plain instruction may itself become a matter for church discipline. The same rule is a principle for settling disagreements in a right and agreeable way, including damaging reports and misunderstandings, and for dealing with unsafe doctrines, where cooperation and striving for harmony among brethren prevent discord, alienation, and scattering from Christ.
The directions are to be followed carefully to the letter and not replaced by personal impulses, prejudice, or ideas. Acting hastily, spreading unfavorable reports, or condemning an erring member without following what Christ directed leads to mistakes, injustice, rumors, and wrong toward fellow members. Those in charge must not so act, but must carry out the required careful process with witnesses to establish the matter.
Labor for the erring is to be done with exactly the same diligence one would want exercised toward oneself, dealing with one another just as one would have the Lord deal with him, with a heart softened by the love of God and loving the soul in the spirit of Christ to reform and save. Time is to be given to the work, with patient labor for a suitable time whether the one in fault is great or small, and no one is to be cut off in zeal to expel under claim of too much business to do the work of saving. This applies with even greater necessity to physicians and others in positions of influence whose failure to walk uprightly dishonors the principles that should control Christ’s followers, requiring careful investigation by judicious persons; grave sins must not be concealed or passed over without action, the church must do everything possible for reformation before severing anyone from membership, and if after such labor there is refusal to submit to discipline, separation as unworthy of fellowship removes reproach so blessing can rest on God’s instrumentalities.
Neglecting this work entirely, or doing it with harshness and severity, wounds and bruises souls and leaves churches and institutions weak, inefficient, and almost Christless. The rule is to be followed at the outset when little matters arise, and anyone coming with a complaint about a brother or sister is to be asked whether he has complied with the Saviour’s rules in every particular, with not a word of complaint to be listened to and no report to be taken up if he has failed. Going entirely contrary to these rules makes one subject to church censure, while disregarding them manufactures church trials that distract and confuse minds, call ministers away from profitable soul-winning labor until that interest wavers and dies, divide hearts, harden each party until no concession will be made, arm souls with prejudice and distrust, set impressions almost indelibly, and lose souls, whereas following the rule at the start would have adjusted the difficulty and left the church in far better condition.
The instruction belongs to humbling oneself before God and showing sympathy and love for others, especially through personal effort to help those outside of Christ, and God does not desire anyone in conflict to draw apart from fellow believers. If wrong is kept secret, those responsible cannot be shown their sin and the evil cannot be corrected, so the matter should be stated plainly to someone trustworthy and handled in the light of God’s Word that the wrong may be remedied and evils set in order.
If a private appeal fails to win an offender, one or two others are to be taken along so that every word may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses. This witnessed labor is the second step between going alone and telling it to the church, to be taken only after the first effort has failed and before any public action. Those brought are to be spiritually minded and impartial, and the work is to be done face to face with tenderness, humility, prayer and love that seeks confession and restoration rather than accusation. The steps must be faithfully followed with thorough, open investigation before any discipline, and they forbid settling the matter by gossip, hearsay, secret judgment or appeal to unbelievers. When so obeyed the process heals offenses, prevents many church trials and strife, preserves the unity and purity of the church, and heaven ratifies the decision of the church toward the unrepentant.
Verse Wording and Setting
If a private appeal to an offender fails to gain a hearing, one or two others are to be taken along so that every statement can be confirmed and settled by the testimony of two or three witnesses. This is the next step after private correction of a fault, sin, personal injury or misunderstanding, and it is not permission to hunt for faults or to spread reports about others. Its purpose is to replace suspicion, criticism and the spreading of reports with a direct and orderly way of remedying the wrong, and by keeping the matter among few it can heal wounds, stop false accusation, and prevent dissension, misunderstanding, alienation, strife and bitterness.
The procedure belongs to a personal trespass against the one giving the correction, a wrong between believers to be handled first privately and then with witnesses before any telling it to the church. It does not govern public wrongs that threaten the church, which are to be rebuked publicly, and a sin committed between a person and God alone need not be made public. If correction is ignored it is not to be hidden where members would be misled by continuing harmful influence, yet trials and disciplinary cases belong inside the church and must never be made known to the wicked. Believers must not intimate their troubles to unbelievers, circulate the trials of one church to other places, bring unbelievers in to give testimony to decide a case, or owe confession to unbelievers except where personal injury has been done to them, since doing so dishonors God, exposes weakness to those who hate believers, and brings darkness and loss of fitness for holy work.
The verse belongs to Christ's positive instruction in the whole of Matthew 18 for how followers are to act in every case and under all circumstances. That chapter is to be hung in the chambers of the mind, kept in memory, often read and pondered, obeyed, put into daily practice, and woven into Christian experience as the only terms for securing eternal life. It forbids striving for supremacy and teaches that greatness in the spiritual kingdom is not position, outward splendor or authority but inward excellence shown in true conversion and continual submission and obedience as meek and lowly in heart. It requires loving God with all heart, soul, mind and strength and neighbor as self, cultivating the garden of the soul, removing weeds and tares sown by Satan during neglect, ceasing to be occupied with weeds in the neighbor's garden, taking one's own garden under personal stewardship, bringing thoughts into captivity to Christ, purifying them, and not scattering words recklessly without careful consideration of their lodgment and result. It calls every individual to read and act, to be converted and obey the truth in real union with Christ in ministerial service, cooperating with Him and His angels and with true servants to help needy souls in the valley of decision, bring men to repentance, win souls, enlighten the ignorant and relieve the oppressed, rather than remaining unconverted and annoying and perplexing the weak in faith, and it disciplines the self by the Word, corrects withdrawing to labor alone and a selfish unholy spirit imagining things without foundation, and requires daily humbling before God, overcoming temptation, and receiving Christ's lessons before ministering the Word.
The verse also states a broader principle that no disputed matter is to be settled by one person's view, testimony or judgment alone. Two or more must be associated to share responsibility and confer together so that every word is established and what was said is confirmed, and in judgment one witness by himself cannot condemn or acquit. Judgment is not to rest on one mind alone because one mind is liable to deception, but on more minds than one centered on the same point, with mutual consideration and respect promoting unity and harmony. The same care applies to unkind or distrustful words, which should have what was said established by witness and answered with care while guarding against careless, harsh or disrespectful speech that grieves the Holy Spirit, and to church deliberations and the treatment of those who have erred, which should be carefully investigated with counsel and decision by the whole body rather than rushed or controlled by one person. This rule against one man setting up his judgment or opinions in opposition to the judgment of the church provides church discipline and government so the church holds together as a body and does not go to fragments, and when followed the highest heavenly authority ratifies its binding and loosing, a lesson with special bearing on the newly organized church and on the importance of union in effort and purpose.
The verse stands in a full ordered sequence: tell the fault alone, then take one or two more so testimony is firmly established, then tell it to the church, then if the church also is refused let the unyielding one be as a heathen and a publican outside fellowship. All possible effort is to be made to effect reconciliation between brethren, and those who stubbornly persist in remaining at variance are to be suspended until they can harmonize and live in harmony. The church of God with its appointed local and traveling elders and ministers to oversee, reprove, exhort, rebuke the unruly and comfort the feebleminded is the highest tribunal on earth, endowed by God with power, and its counsel, advice and decision must be submitted to. Members pledge mutual care and counsel under that oversight instead of each following private judgment and choosing his own course, for otherwise there will be confusion with no harmony or union, and those who will not submit cannot be helped, while resisting its authority and despising the judgment of its ministers is no light matter. Even if the church decides wrongly, the individual must still submit and leave correction to God in His own time to vindicate the right, without assuming responsibility for keeping the church in order.
Second Step Toward Restoration
The verse is the second step between laboring alone and telling it to the church, to be taken only when going to the trespassing brother alone and telling him his fault between him and the offended alone has failed, and before any public action or bringing the matter before the church. When the offender will not hear private reproof or private correction for his trespass, the one offended must take one or two more with him to speak to him and work with him gently and humbly with love for his soul, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. Wrongs between believers are to be righted and injuries healed privately when possible according to this process, without spreading the matter in the church or outside it and without making it a subject of conversation or seeking faults, while a sin between a person and God need not be made public. Ministers and men in positions of trust must ask anyone coming with a complaint about a brother or sister whether he has complied with the Saviour's rules in every particular, and if he has failed they must not listen to a word of his complaint and must refuse to take up a report against a brother or sister in the faith. Members who go entirely contrary to these rules make themselves subject to church discipline and should be put under the censure of the church, while neglecting the work entirely or doing it with harshness and severity wounds and bruises souls and leaves churches and institutions weak, inefficient, and almost Christless.
The prescribed steps with witnesses must be faithfully and exactly followed with thorough investigation and with tact, mercy, and the love of God, before complaints are heard, before officers or a committee recommend removal, and before the church votes discipline or removes a name from its books. A charge cannot rightly lead to condemning or removing a person unless these steps have been followed and the matter established by witnesses, and leaders must not cut someone off by their own judgment, self-assumed authority, harshness, haste, partiality or hypocrisy. Allegations of wrongdoing should be thoroughly and carefully investigated and handled according to Christ's instructions rather than by hasty judgments and unjust treatment, and correction must be carried out wisely and graciously. Doing so prevents gossip, helps preserve the church's health and purity, and church decisions made after the rule is fully obeyed may be ratified in heaven, whereas prejudice, selfish motives, and unjust judgments have no authority there.
The same rule applies to church members including physicians working among the churches and physicians employed in health institutions who fail to walk uprightly, to helpers in a religious institution who plainly understand the rules yet keep disregarding them, and to members who counterwork the minister, sow doubt and disaffection, or walk contrary to Bible rules. Such persons are subject to church oversight and the church must labor with those who sin, first going alone and then, if they do not heed personal correction, bringing others in so the matter is handled through an orderly, accountable process with patient, careful investigation by judicious persons. Patient labor must be given for a suitable time as directed, with admonition whether the physician is great or small, because a position of influence makes investigation more necessary, not less, and because one person who will not come to right terms affects the whole institution and community by the atmosphere surrounding the soul. If after faithful personal labor they will not hear, listen, change course, or submit to discipline, they are to be set aside, suspended, or separated from church fellowship and from the institution with reasons given, and grave sins must not be concealed or passed over without action, so that reproach is removed and blessing can rest, bringing a better condition instead of prevailing disorder.
The aim throughout is to seek recovery and restore someone who has gone astray through prayer and loving, caring correction rather than accusation or hastily separating the person from the church. Correction must not be neglected when wrongdoing and unchristian lives threaten to corrupt the church, but decided efforts are to be made to show the erring where they are wrong with a desire to save from ruin. The church must do everything possible for reformation before taking any step to sever from membership, and a faulty person may remain connected so that instruction and example can lead to recognition and correction. Willful uncorrected sin and unrepentant offenders require action and separation from the holy so that God's people remain clean and pure.
Spirit and Method Required
Those taken along should be spiritually minded, thoughtful people who are not parties to the trouble, so they can act more impartially. Their united appeal and agreement may carry greater weight, enlighten the mind of the one in error, and lead him to yield. The facts are to be heard calmly and kindly, seeking confession and a clear resolution.
The work is to be confined to as small a number as possible, with only one or two more joining to labor with the one in error. They are to be carefully and prayerfully taken, and to do more than talk, bowing in prayer and with humble hearts seeking the Lord. The labor is to be in tenderness, humility, meekness, pity, and with a heart throbbing in love for his soul. When brethren come together in harmony with this direction, Jesus Himself is present as a witness, the whole universe looks on with intense interest, and the Spirit of God moves upon the heart to convict of error. If pride and self-sufficiency keep him from confessing and healing the wrong, further steps must be taken to follow out the complete directions.
The fault is to be addressed directly, frankly, plainly, openly and face to face, in love, brotherly kindness, and Christ's spirit, giving opportunity to explain, answer, make plain what is not understood, and clear oneself. Every word is to be established by positive ground and faithful witnesses rather than by suspicion, appearance, secondhand reports, eager fault-finding, or the words of enemies. The matter must be sifted to the bottom by careful and thorough, open, frank and fair investigation, approaching as directed and praying with and for the person, with tact, mercy and the love of God, gently not roughly, removing evil suspicion. Talking over faults with others while keeping the person in ignorance violates the rule and causes gossip, coldness, shaken confidence, weakened love and breach of unity.
Those in charge and men in positions of responsibility must not rule as lords or kings, act on own judgment, impulse, or reports that investigation might prove groundless, or order dismissal at the hands of others without appearing as an actor. They must counsel with fellow responsible leaders, state reasons clearly, pray together and share responsibility, exercising wise counsel, prudence, wisdom and judgment that protects and strengthens God's people. The matter must be investigated carefully, patiently, humbly and prayerfully by the proper officers with sorrow for the erring, without self-assumed authority or a harsh, hard, unfeeling, overbearing spirit, and without dictating or meddling in matters that do not concern them. This open, Christian course reproves in love to save the person and may make retention possible, while failure risks serious blunder and offending one of Christ's little ones.
The instruction is the Saviour's clearly laid-down rule and standard for restoring a trespassing brother and resolving wrongs, to be strictly, carefully and practically obeyed rather than replaced by a contrary method. It is to be studied carefully, read, and put into daily practice in the home church, in the family and in the home, for it means much for living the Christian life and restoring agreement. Obeying it calls for greater spirituality and for converting power to come upon workers, and the Holy Spirit can enlighten understanding and make teacher and pupil sensitive and sympathetic by removing pride and selfishness.
Purposes and Blessed Results
Following the appointed course heals offenses and wounds and stops false accusations and criticism. It prevents dissension, misunderstanding, alienation, strife and bitterness in the church. Faithfully following it when one is thought to be in the wrong prevents church trials and upholds unity among believers, and it can prevent many church trials by keeping the matter among few and not spreading it in the church or outside it. Difficulties are healed promptly before small disagreements are magnified, and dissension and alienation that could have been healed are traced to refusal to receive reproof and turn from the wrong course. Carrying out the rules in the right way leaves a better condition with a better spirit in family, school and church, while neglecting them leaves disorder to prevail.
Going forward in faith and taking the case to the Lord in prayer, believing that He hears, brings relief and courage and hope. Confession of sins with repentance and a humble walk with God brings pardon. The correction described purifies and saves the one corrected. When brethren confine the difficulty to as small a number as possible and bow in prayer with humble hearts to seek the Lord, Jesus Himself is present as a witness, the universe looks on with intense interest, and the Spirit moves upon the erring heart to convict of error.
The process preserves the health and purity of the church and the sacred, holy character of Christ's church. Decided efforts are to be made to show those living unchristian lives where they are wrong, and if they will not correct their lives they are to be separated from the holy so that God's people remain clean and pure. Correction is not to be hidden if it is ignored, but when needed the church must be informed so its members are not misled by continuing harmful influence. Serious reproof is to be made known to experienced members, or to the whole church when needed, so others are not misled by unreformed influence, and charges against a member are never to be proved by questioning students about their teacher or discussing his errors with them for the world to hear, even if the suppositions were true, since that way of gathering testimony does greater injury to the cause. Faithful shepherds are to labor earnestly for those who walk contrary to Bible rules and give no evidence of seeking the life of Christ, and if they refuse to come out and be separate they are to be suspended from fellowship lest they be stumbling blocks, and if after earnest labor they still refuse to repent and humble themselves they are to be separated.
When the rule is fully obeyed, heaven ratifies the decision of the church in cutting off the unrepentant member. Church discipline is thus placed within a Bible-governed process, and heavenly authority ratifies the church's discipline when that rule is followed. Important decisions about an offender must not rest on one person's judgment alone but require prayerful collective discernment, with Christ as counselor, seeking the offender's restoration, and decisions made with prayer and faith according to God-given wisdom are ratified by Heaven and remain valid to the end of time. This lesson has special bearing on the newly organized church and on the importance of union in effort and purpose.
If private and witnessed labor fail to bring repentance, the offender is to be told to the church, and if still refusing to hear is to be separated and suspended until willing to heed and harmonize. Those who pursue transgression must be visited and labored with alone and then with one or two more, and if they still refuse to repent they must be separated from fellowship and their names not retained on the books, lest the saints be held accountable for evil deeds. The same steps apply to helpers in a religious institution who plainly understand the rules yet keep disregarding them, and to those who knowingly disregard an institution's rules, because one person who will not come to right terms affects the whole community by the surrounding atmosphere. The separated one is to be left alone rather than supported or given responsibility, and every member has duty to understand and do these rules of discipline and strive to preserve perfect harmony as in a well-regulated family. Keeping this discipline in the church below prepares for the great reunion in the church above, and those who here live in union with Christ may look forward to endless life in the heavenly courts.
Church Duty and Authority
The taking of one or two more belongs to remitting sins or restraining sins, which applies to the church in her organized capacity to preserve due order. Remission of sins itself is the prerogative of God alone, and no delegated servant has power to cast down or destroy or to remove guilt from any soul. The work belongs to wise representative men truly taught of God, possessing the inward working of the Holy Spirit with the Christ-life manifested in purity, faith and obedience, and having spiritual eyesight to discern spiritual things, whose actions in dealing with members can receive endorsement as from the head of the church. They are only to give God's message of what is written, to reprove, rebuke and exhort with longsuffering and doctrine, to give censure when needed, and to remove that censure when the one in error confesses and repents.
No liberty is given for any man to pass judgment upon others, but responsibility for individual members who fall into sin is placed upon the church in its organized capacity. The duty is to warn, to instruct, and if possible to restore, dealing faithfully with wrongdoing, warning every soul in danger, calling sin by its right name, and declaring what God has said about lying, Sabbath-breaking, stealing, idolatry, and every other evil. If sinners persist in sin, the judgment the church has declared from God's Word is pronounced upon them in heaven, for in choosing to sin they disown Christ. The church must show she does not sanction their deeds lest she dishonor her Lord, must say about sin what God says about it and deal with it as God directs, and her action is then ratified in heaven, so that he who despises the authority of the church in this work despises the authority of Christ Himself.
The instruction governs the church's duty toward members whose conduct dishonors the cause, and that duty must be carried out with justice and faithfulness. If the wrong is kept secret, those responsible cannot be shown their sin and the evil cannot be corrected. The matter should be stated plainly to someone trustworthy and handled in the light of God's Word so the wrong may be remedied and the evils set in order.
The plain words for how to treat those supposed to be in error are warning and counsel to be accepted and obeyed. A person sent a message of reproof must hear and receive it rather than refuse it, must not justify as obedience a course directly opposed to Christ's word, must not become an accuser of brethren while sympathizing with those not connected with God, and must not put the worst construction on a decided testimony calling to obedience. Accepting it recovers a person out of Satan's snares, while dismissing it as an idle tale and refusing to admit any possibility of error shows a heart steeled and captivated by Satan's bewitching power.
Rejecting Gossip and Injustice
Difficulties between believers are to be settled among themselves or by the church, not carried before unbelievers in a court of justice or by taking a fellow believer to law. The injured one seeks to save rather than avenge, and may entrust the case to God who judges righteously, proceeding in a humble Christlike spirit that guards against exposing sins before the world. Complaints and charges belong inside the church because outsiders cannot discern the principles governing believers, and the words of enemies must not dictate how God's people treat one another. Only after private appeal and then appeal with one or two others has failed is the matter to be told to the church as the last step, never publicized to the world where it damages the witness of saving grace.
Ministers and lay members displease God when they allow individuals to tell them the errors and faults of brethren without the Saviour's steps being strictly followed. They must inquire whether private labor and then labor with two or three witnesses was faithfully done, and if in any particular it has failed they must close the ears, listen to not a word, and refuse to take up a report or reproach against a brother or sister whose reputation Christ values. Without listeners evil tongues cease for lack of a field for biting and devouring one another, since listening to reports of evil is itself taking up the reproach. Failure to understand and follow this principle was illustrated in conduct toward W. C. White. Going entirely contrary to these rules makes one subject to church discipline and censure, while neglecting the work entirely or doing it with harshness and severity wounds and bruises souls and leaves churches weak and almost Christless.
Care is required to avoid bringing reproach on one who is not guilty, waiting patiently until both sides are heard and believing only what stern facts compel. Blame must not rest on the unproved and no one is to be removed on falsified reports, but every word established by thorough investigation according to Christ's instructions rather than leaders cutting off by their own judgment. Each person must watch his own actions instead of complaining of one another, ministers must not encourage such complaints or repeat church trials in preaching, and none should let prejudice and resentment be stirred by hearing the wrongs of others or artfully draw out from the unsuspecting matters they have no business with. The accused worker, as a child of God seeking to serve Him, must be given presence and full chance to explain and answer for himself before just men on positive ground and by faithful witnesses rather than by suspicion, appearance, secondhand reports or eager fault-finding, with facts presented openly, frankly and fairly instead of standing aloof in secret judgment without trial. To condemn and hurt and bruise souls on hearsay is un-Christlike and makes the actor a partaker with the accusers, charged in the books of heaven, tearing churches apart and driving the erring away instead of restoring him.
The second step forbids speaking evil in presence or absence, hearing evil, whispering, covert hints, and stabbing character in the dark, requiring checking the evil speaker, refusing to hear him, and going directly to the erring one instead. It forbids private watching, reporting, talebearing, and thinking and speaking evil against fellow members, listening to reports from unbelievers, taking arguments from those who deny the truth, and judging while the accused is left in ignorance. It forbids devising plans against a child of God, working secretly as a supposed friend, and seeking removal without ever telling the charges, for all such moves must be brought into the open and cannot be done secretly or underhanded because justice, righteousness and mercy require open dealing. Charges and accusers must be plainly set before the accused face to face, stating the faults charged and giving opportunity to know whereof accused, to answer, explain conduct, clear and vindicate if not true. Applied even to a grievance such as a matron failing to show sympathy or gentleness of tone to the sick, duty is to go to her herself in meekness and love seeking restoration rather than condemning without hearing, entertaining suspicions, carrying accusations, or complaining of deficiency to others in secret, which closes the door to division and draws hearts together.
Departing from this direction to spread reports through gossip brings condemnation, while accepting the plain warning and counsel recovers from Satan's snares and dismissing it as an idle tale shows a heart steeled and captivated. Those who listen to harmful reports share guilt with the spreader, and refusal to follow God's directions may become a matter of church discipline. Teaching and practicing a contrary way of dealing with the supposed erring gives the church a wrong mold, and endorsing and sustaining a worker who acts that way leaves guilt for unfaithfulness and neglect. Undoing the harm requires liberal, sustained labor to redeem the past, make restitution as far as possible, counteract wrong lessons and give an entirely different healthful influence, not feeble effort or short work and not personal ideas, impulses, harshness, haste, partiality or hypocrisy.
Wider Practice and Warnings
When one is believed to have done wrong, those concerned are to go to that person directly and respectfully to seek to cure the difficulty where it occurred, rather than spreading the charge or making it worse before hearing him. The approach is to be made with humility before God, gently and not roughly or inconsiderately, praying with and for the person and kindly pointing out the wrong with a heart softened by grace, seeking his good rather than accusing him. Evil suspicion is to be put away, and the matter is to be corrected where it arose, for departure from this plain instruction may itself become a matter for church discipline. The same rule is a principle for settling disagreements in a right and agreeable way, including damaging reports and misunderstandings, and for dealing with unsafe doctrines, where cooperation and striving for harmony among brethren prevent discord, alienation, and scattering from Christ.
The directions are to be followed carefully to the letter and not replaced by personal impulses, prejudice, or ideas. Acting hastily, spreading unfavorable reports, or condemning an erring member without following what Christ directed leads to mistakes, injustice, rumors, and wrong toward fellow members. Those in charge must not so act, but must carry out the required careful process with witnesses to establish the matter.
Labor for the erring is to be done with exactly the same diligence one would want exercised toward oneself, dealing with one another just as one would have the Lord deal with him, with a heart softened by the love of God and loving the soul in the spirit of Christ to reform and save. Time is to be given to the work, with patient labor for a suitable time whether the one in fault is great or small, and no one is to be cut off in zeal to expel under claim of too much business to do the work of saving. This applies with even greater necessity to physicians and others in positions of influence whose failure to walk uprightly dishonors the principles that should control Christ’s followers, requiring careful investigation by judicious persons; grave sins must not be concealed or passed over without action, the church must do everything possible for reformation before severing anyone from membership, and if after such labor there is refusal to submit to discipline, separation as unworthy of fellowship removes reproach so blessing can rest on God’s instrumentalities.
Neglecting this work entirely, or doing it with harshness and severity, wounds and bruises souls and leaves churches and institutions weak, inefficient, and almost Christless. The rule is to be followed at the outset when little matters arise, and anyone coming with a complaint about a brother or sister is to be asked whether he has complied with the Saviour’s rules in every particular, with not a word of complaint to be listened to and no report to be taken up if he has failed. Going entirely contrary to these rules makes one subject to church censure, while disregarding them manufactures church trials that distract and confuse minds, call ministers away from profitable soul-winning labor until that interest wavers and dies, divide hearts, harden each party until no concession will be made, arm souls with prejudice and distrust, set impressions almost indelibly, and lose souls, whereas following the rule at the start would have adjusted the difficulty and left the church in far better condition.
The instruction belongs to humbling oneself before God and showing sympathy and love for others, especially through personal effort to help those outside of Christ, and God does not desire anyone in conflict to draw apart from fellow believers. If wrong is kept secret, those responsible cannot be shown their sin and the evil cannot be corrected, so the matter should be stated plainly to someone trustworthy and handled in the light of God’s Word that the wrong may be remedied and evils set in order.