AdventAI

Matthew 18:16

But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.

King James Version

Commentary, part 2 of 2

Commentary part 2 of 2

Pioneers and periodicals

108 sources

If a brother will not hear a private appeal for a personal trespass, the next step is to take one or two more with you, so that every word may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses before the matter is told to the church.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874 The whole object is to gain and restore the erring brother and win him back to Christ and to love, not to condemn him or merely punish him.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 20, 1859RH Dec 27, 1853 The work must be done in love, humility, meekness, kindness and patience, without anger, prejudice or gossip, and the fault must not be spread abroad at this stage but be told only through these appointed steps.ST Sep 19, 1900STRH Jun 25, 1914RH Jan 17, 1865ST Feb 4, 1886 The steps must be followed in order with no substitute, private appeal first, then one or two more, then the church, and no complaint is to be heard unless this order has been obeyed.RH Oct 31, 1871RH Nov 20, 1856RH Apr 1, 1909 Underlying it is God's law of evidence, that a matter is established by two or three witnesses and not by one witness alone.ST Dec 2, 1897ST Dec 9, 1897

Place in Christ's Instruction

When a brother will not hear a private appeal, the second step is to take one or two more with you so that every word may be established in the mouth of two or three witnesses, before telling it to the church.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874RH Jan 9, 1855RH Oct 31, 1871 This is Christ's plain and definite direction for addressing trespass, to be followed in order and with care so that brothers can settle difficulties with little trouble, restore confidence, warn the wrongdoer, and give opportunity to make things right before the matter goes further.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874RH Jan 9, 1855RH Oct 31, 1871 It is a safe and usually effective way to resolve private differences, and it spares the church, especially its young and weak members, the burden of hearing minor disputes, whereas taking grievances to the whole church before speaking directly to the person spreads hurt and trouble.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Oct 31, 1871 First go to him alone in love and reconciliation, recognizing personal weakness; if he will not hear, take two or three other brethren to join in united intercession and prayer to win him from the error of his ways.RH Jun 25, 1914 If that effort fails, bring the matter to the church, not for condemnation but for reclamation, for the whole object is to reclaim, not merely to discipline.RH Jun 25, 1914 Even if every effort fails and the church declares its disapproval and withdraws fellowship, that only declares the separation he has made by departing from Christ, and brethren must still pray for him and minister kindly to win him back without strengthening him in his error.RH Jun 25, 1914

The process belongs to a personal, private trespass against another and to serious faults needing correction, whether the trespass is real or only imagined.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Jul 3, 1856RH Dec 2, 1873RH Apr 1, 1862 Private wrongs and personal offenses or private misunderstandings are to be righted privately by first discussing them privately rather than publicly, while public sins are rebuked openly.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Apr 1, 1862 It does not require formal action for every instance of idle, silly, vapid, loose talk, for which dignified silence is sometimes the best reproof, nor for every trivial dispute.ST Whether talk, manner, and effect demand action must be sought from God, and reproof becomes duty when His Spirit bids and the salvation of a soul is at stake.ST The first visit deals with a brother's wrongs rather than with one's own wrongdoing, going to the brother alone to show him his fault in private, kindly asking what he meant in case he was misunderstood, in humility and meekness and kindness and love, with wisdom from God and consideration of self, almost invariably alone unless very rare circumstances demand otherwise.ST The words against thee in verse 15 are omitted in some of the most ancient manuscripts.ST

Going directly to the brother with the grievance leaves less to say and saves much trouble, keeps slandering and backbiting out of the church, and aims to restore the erring brother and spare both him and the church a wider trial.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Jan 17, 1865 His fault is not to be told to everybody in the church and to everybody in the world, and those who spread the matter to others instead err and need to be labored with themselves.RH Jan 17, 1865 Going to others is allowed for only one purpose, to get them to go along and humbly help effect a reconciliation in a humble, prayerful spirit to rescue him, and there is no right to go to a third party with the fault for any other reason or before first going to the offender.RH Dec 2, 1873 When one or two others are brought, their presence follows the principle that every word is established by two or three witnesses, to establish the offender's guilt and the facts on which the church may later act.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Jul 3, 1856ST Apr 23, 1885

One or two more means two or three witnesses in all.ST May 13, 1903RH Jun 20, 1854RH Oct 4, 1906 One who has been wronged may take one other witness to establish that he has done his part, while one who is the wrongdoer takes two as the safer course, and the aim is not self-vindication or merely proving conduct to the church but helping the wrongdoer recognize the sin and the blessing of doing right.ST May 13, 1903 The companions may be experienced church members, and the elders of the church may serve in place of the witnesses when their connection with the matter makes them able to do so, the matter being told to them only after the private appeal and not first except in a special circumstance.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Jun 20, 1854 A church may appoint a committee to visit and counsel the person, use its report as the basis for church action, and continue its work until the person is restored or shown to be incorrigible.ST Apr 23, 1885 In a school the teacher joins two or three pupils in this effort to show the wrongdoer the error before bringing the matter before the whole school.RH Oct 4, 1906

In carrying out the rule the elder first goes privately in the spirit of love and true principle to make the member guilty of immoral or dishonest act or given up to the world see his fault and warn him because he is on the road to ruin.RH Sep 8, 1874 If the member will not hear, the elder goes again, and when it is proven that the wrong is plain yet there is no confession and no willingness to make wrongs right, the elder calls a meeting of the church with ample notice to all parties and special invitation to be present.RH Sep 8, 1874 The matter is then laid before the church calmly and in love with a statement of what steps were taken and how they were met, the party is given full opportunity for reply or explanation, and any investigation to ascertain facts is conducted calmly, kindly, and thoroughly to bring out the simple truth while avoiding rancor and party feeling and keeping before the mind love, righteousness, and the certainty of the solemn Judgment when all wrongs meet their just desert.RH Sep 8, 1874 The elder as advisory officer gives advice and judgment with reasons, then calls for the judgment and decision of the church whether the wrong was committed, which decision amounts to a vote of censure.RH Sep 8, 1874 The censured member is then left a reasonable time for reflection, a month or two in ordinary cases unless the offense is so outrageous as to demand immediate expulsion, after which the elder brings the case up again and recommends expulsion or what the case demands.RH Sep 8, 1874

The instruction was spoken before Pentecost yet remains authoritative for the Christian age and for Christians after the kingdom was set up on the day of Pentecost, and its having been spoken before Pentecost does not make it obsolete.ST Aug 19, 1875ST Oct 1, 1885ST Jun 4, 1885 It belongs to Christ as the church's teacher, whose teachings are to be followed, and the directions for dealing with a brother who has sinned through the steps He gave are the word of God entrusted to the church, not a special authority given to Peter alone.ST Dec 5, 1916ST Aug 19, 1875 The rule for church discipline including taking one or two more with the offended brother must be followed now.ST Oct 1, 1885

Purpose of Taking Witnesses

The whole object of bringing one or two others is to gain the erring brother, to reclaim and restore him and to save him, not to condemn him or merely to punish him or to vindicate self.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 20, 1859RH Dec 27, 1853ST Jul 10, 1893 The effort is to win him from the error of his ways to Christ and to Christian love and to the church, and it is to be continued patiently for his recovery, repeated as needed rather than abandoned after one attempt.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 20, 1859ST Jul 12, 1899ST Aug 9, 1899 The matter is not to be made public at this stage, but only if he refuses to hear them is it to be brought to the church, and the course aims to spare both him and the church a wider trial.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Dec 27, 1853ST Jul 10, 1893 Even if every effort fails and fellowship is withdrawn, which only declares the separation he has made by departing from Christ, he is still to be approached kindly and earnestly for his conversion and prayed for and ministered to in order to win him back, without being strengthened in his error.RH Jun 25, 1914ST Jul 12, 1899

Those brought along both join in the work of persuasion and in united intercession and prayer to win him, and at the same time serve as witnesses by whom every word, the facts, and guilt may be established.RH Jun 25, 1914ST Apr 16, 1885RH Jul 3, 1856ST Jan 1, 1885ST May 13, 1913 What was said on both sides is thus confirmed by their testimony, the accused receives a fair and careful and impartial hearing with both reproof and defense heard, and the church is later furnished with established testimony on which it can act and decide.ST Apr 16, 1885ST Jan 1, 1885ST Sep 23, 1889ST May 13, 1913RH Mar 1, 1860 No accusation against character is therefore to be held on rumor, surmise or slander, and reliance on a single witness alone is rejected in favor of God's law of evidence requiring agreement of two or three.ST Sep 23, 1889ST May 13, 1913 This second step follows the private appeal between the two alone and comes before any telling it to the church, offering a way to seek reconciliation without unnecessary exposure.ST Apr 16, 1885RH Jul 3, 1856ST Jan 1, 1885

Following this private course with witnesses is a safe and usually effective way to settle private differences and restore confidence, sparing the church, especially its young and weak members, the burden of hearing minor disputes.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Dec 27, 1853RH Mar 1, 1860 Going directly to the brother with the grievance, rather than telling his fault to everybody in the church and to everybody in the world or taking grievances to the whole church first, leaves less to say, saves much trouble, avoids unnecessary exposure and publicity, and provides a way to address difficulties before they burden ministers and hinder the work.RH Feb 14, 1854ST Apr 16, 1885RH Mar 1, 1860RH Jan 17, 1865 Gospel order so followed keeps slandering and backbiting and speaking evil of one another out of the church, requiring swiftness to hear and slowness to speak and to wrath instead of spreading hurt and trouble.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Jan 17, 1865RH Feb 21, 1865 Lived out in this way the rule cures discord, keeps the enemy from sowing division, revives churches brought low by strife, brings them nearer together and restores the erring to full union, while guarding the church from confusion, corruption and division and preserving its purity, peace, love and unity.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Oct 20, 1859RH Feb 21, 1865

Spirit and Manner Required

The work of taking one or two more must be done in love, humility, meekness, kindness, patience, wisdom from God, brotherly love, confidence, and united intercession and prayer, with consideration of self and recognition of personal weakness.STRH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 16, 1900 It is to be done without striving for supremacy, anger, prejudice, malice, envy or hatred, and without gossip or self-righteousness, for greatness in Christ's kingdom rests on inward excellence, not position, splendor, or authority.ST Sep 19, 1900RH Apr 23, 1872 The first approach is to go to the brother alone and show him his fault in private, kindly asking what he meant in case he was misunderstood, almost invariably alone unless very rare circumstances demand otherwise, and in a humble, prayerful spirit to rescue him.STRH Dec 2, 1873 Formal action is not required for every instance of idle, silly, vapid, loose talk, for which dignified silence is sometimes the best reproof, but whether talk, manner, and effect demand action must be sought from God, and reproof becomes duty when His Spirit bids and the salvation of a soul is at stake.ST Learning and practicing this way of reproving one who errs by speaking directly to him gains a great victory, imitating Christ who pleased not Himself but lived trial and self-sacrifice, was kind to the unthankful and to the evil, and won confidence even from unbelievers by healing, kind acts, and friendly counsel, discarding mere theoretical expressions for charity that helps the erring and those less favorably situated.RH Apr 23, 1872

The fault must not be talked about to everyone met or spread in the church or outside it or to the world at this stage, for no Christian has any right to tell others about the faults of brethren and doing so is positively a sin forfeiting Christ's approval.RH Jan 17, 1865ST Feb 4, 1886 It may be told only through these steps — first alone, then with one or two more, then to the church — and this ordered process is not permission to spread the accusation, except when necessary to protect an innocent person.RH Jun 20, 1854RH Apr 5, 1860 Going to others is allowed for only one purpose, to get them to go along and humbly help effect a reconciliation after praying together and going at once directly to the offender, and there is no right to go to a third party for any other reason or before first going to the offender.RH Dec 2, 1873 Going directly to the brother with the grievance leaves less to say and saves much trouble, while spreading the matter to others instead is itself error needing to be labored with.RH Jan 17, 1865 First publishing a charge abroad without privately coming to the party involved, such as accusing of double dealing for stopping a paper before a subscription ran out, is forbidden, and the required order is to go alone first to inquire and ascertain the facts, then take the first and second steps with others, and only afterward make the matter public.RH Sep 25, 1856

Those brought along must be spiritually minded, spiritual and mature believers, experienced church members, loving toward God and neighbor, humble, meek, gentle, patient, and wise.ST Jul 10, 1893RH Oct 16, 1900RH Mar 9, 1916RH Jun 20, 1854 They must be free from bias and prejudice, not chosen merely because they share the first person's bias, and preferably known and acceptable to the person being corrected.RH Mar 9, 1916RH Jun 20, 1854 They are to act carefully and impartially so the matter can receive a fair hearing if it later comes before the church, hearing both the reproof and the defense before deciding how to proceed, with their testimony able to establish the facts for the church's later decision.RH Mar 1, 1860RH Mar 1, 1860 At this stage the church as a body has no role, and the step of returning with one or two others to make a united effort to bring the person back from error may need to be repeated before the matter is brought before the church.RH Mar 1, 1860RH Mar 9, 1916

Order Authority and Outcome

The steps stand in fixed order and must be kept to the letter with no substitute or change: private appeal first, then one or two more, then the church.RH Oct 31, 1871RH Nov 20, 1856RH Apr 1, 1909RH Jun 20, 1854RH Jun 20, 1854 The matter must not be taken to the church first even when that seems more effective or is felt as an impression, nor published abroad first, and neglect of the appointed course is itself sin.RH Oct 31, 1871RH Nov 20, 1856CO 21.1–2 No complaint is to be listened to or taken up unless the reporter has obeyed in every particular, and the church ought to refuse to investigate until the course with witnesses has been taken.RH Nov 20, 1856RH Apr 1, 1909 Any different course is to be rebuked, and going entirely contrary makes the reporter himself subject to discipline and censure.RH Nov 20, 1856RH Apr 1, 1909CO 21.1–2 Elders may serve in place of the witnesses when their connection with the matter fits them for it, after the private appeal has been made.RH Jun 20, 1854

Ministers, officers and men in trust must ask whether the Saviour's rules have been complied with and refuse to hear or investigate the report if not.RH Nov 20, 1856RH Apr 1, 1909 Those who accuse and disturb without taking the proper steps and calling for investigation in order are to be treated as railers and made subject to thorough church discipline.RH Nov 20, 1856 Raising a report without following the steps wrongs the brother, the church and those who appointed him, and is ground for censure.ST Aug 27, 1885 The instruction belongs to the organized, visible, responsible church in its duty to warn, instruct, deal faithfully with sin, call sin by its right name, and seek to restore.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916ST Nov 15, 1899RH Aug 4, 1874 The church must not sanction persistent sin or tolerate harmful influence, but must be aggressive against evil in its own bosom rather than silent, exercising careful, faithful discipline that keeps the standard high.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916RH Aug 4, 1874

No liberty is given to any man to pass judgment on others on his own, for responsibility for fallen members rests on the church in its organized capacity, which must warn every soul in danger and declare what God has said about lying, Sabbath-breaking, stealing, idolatry and every other evil.ST May 24, 1905ST Nov 15, 1899ST Jun 27, 1900 Denial of organization is an attempt to escape membership responsibility and this unpleasant duty of cleansing the church of sinning members who will not hear and repent.ST Nov 15, 1899ST Jun 27, 1900 The church must show she does not sanction their deeds lest she dishonor her Lord, must say about sin what God says and deal with it as God directs, and her action from God's Word is ratified in heaven.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909 He who despises the authority of the church in this work despises the authority of Christ Himself.ST May 24, 1905 Fellowship may be withdrawn and the person treated as a heathen and a publican only after faithful, patient, loving, prayerful effort with due notice and investigation.RH Jun 25, 1914ST Jan 1, 1885RH Apr 1, 1909RH May 22, 1866

Withdrawal is only by vote of the church as a body, never by a single leader or individuals acting alone, and no name is to be cut off hastily and no member placed under censure without full obedience to the Bible rule to the letter.RH Apr 1, 1909RH Sep 18, 1856RH Sep 8, 1874 The action only declares the separation he has made by departing from Christ, is meant to show him his position so he may repent, and looks to restoration as with the Corinthian offender.RH May 13, 1909RH Jun 25, 1914ST Jan 1, 1885 Even then brethren must still pray for him and minister kindly to win him back without strengthening him in error.RH Jun 25, 1914 Heaven ratifies a just decision, while an unjust decision counts for nothing before God, does not make an innocent person guilty, and does not change character before God.RH May 13, 1909RH Apr 1, 1909CO 21.1–2 Church officers must therefore be free from prejudice, partiality and selfish motives, wholly sanctified and refined, lest they misjudge and deal unkindly and unjustly with souls purchased by Christ's blood.RH Apr 1, 1909

In carrying out the rule the elder first goes privately in the spirit of love and true principle to make the guilty member see his fault and warn him because he is on the road to ruin, goes again if not heard, and when the wrong is proven plain yet there is no confession or willingness to make wrongs right, calls the church together with ample notice to all parties and special invitation to be present.RH Jul 21, 1863RH Sep 8, 1874 The matter is then laid before the church calmly and in love with a statement of what steps were taken and how they were met, the party is given full opportunity for reply or explanation, and any investigation to ascertain facts is conducted calmly, kindly and thoroughly to bring out the simple truth while avoiding rancor and party feeling.ST Apr 23, 1885RH Sep 8, 1874 The elder as advisory officer gives advice and judgment with reasons, then calls for the judgment and decision of the church whether the wrong was committed, which amounts to a vote of censure.RH Sep 18, 1856RH Sep 8, 1874 The censured member is left a reasonable time for reflection, a month or two in ordinary cases, unless the offense is so outrageous as to demand immediate expulsion, after which the case is brought up again for expulsion or what it demands.RH May 22, 1866RH Sep 8, 1874 Manifest outrageous crime is the stated exception where prior effort may be dispensed with, while absent members are to be sought, written to and kindly urged to report rather than threatened, and a committee may be appointed whose report is the basis for action until restoration or incorrigibility is shown.RH Jul 21, 1863RH May 22, 1866RH Oct 27, 1904ST Apr 23, 1885RH Sep 18, 1856

General Law of Witness

The verse continues the ancient requirement and states God's law of evidence that every word and every matter is established and confirmed by the testimony and agreement of two or three witnesses.ST Dec 2, 1897ST Dec 9, 1897ST Dec 11, 1893ST May 13, 1913 Reliance on a single witness alone is rejected, and at least two witnesses must testify to the same matter for it to be established.ST Dec 2, 1897ST Dec 9, 1897ST May 13, 1913 When one who will not listen to correction is approached with others brought along, their testimony confirms what was said and establishes guilt and the facts.RH Jan 10, 1854ST Sep 23, 1889ST May 13, 1913 Inward consciousness alone is an unreliable and fallible human witness, so assurance must rest on more than one witness and on a stronger basis for certainty.ST Oct 28, 1897 That same witness principle establishes the mission of Jesus, which was confirmed by the Father, by His works, and by the Scriptures.ST Oct 28, 1897

No accusation against character is to be held on rumor, surmise, or slander, and it must be established by evidence rather than accepted or spread without good evidence.RH Jan 10, 1854ST Sep 23, 1889 No serious charge is to endanger reputation or life without the agreement of multiple witnesses.ST Aug 8, 1900 A charge that one is afraid to bring through the open Bible-appointed process of going directly to the other person is likely false.ST May 6, 1897 When a charge is brought against a brother the matter must be carefully investigated rather than accepted on the word of dissatisfied or disconnected members, by going to the accused, seeking the truth, and speaking in a spirit of love, so that church discipline rests on a just and truthful process for a real trespass.RH Jan 10, 1854RH Mar 13, 1866 One clear fact can be decisive evidence, so a long list of arguments is unnecessary.RH Mar 4, 1862

The verse illustrates God's method of confirming His Word by giving a prediction or promise in Scripture and then a second witness in its fulfillment.ST May 17, 1899 The Bible's own often-repeated law of witness applies to the Bible itself, meaning it is tested by itself alone and by no other standard.ST May 9, 1906 It furnishes always agreeing witnesses between whom there can be no collusion to its divinity and authenticity, for God writes His testimony two or more times so there can be no question of its truth.ST May 9, 1906 His multiplied prophecies are reproduced in the rise and fall of empires and in the histories of men and cities, and His holy law given at Sinai is reproduced in the life and example of Jesus Christ and written again by creative power in the heart of the yielding believer, so that the law at Sinai witnesses to the law in Christ and to the law in those who accept Him.ST May 9, 1906 Jesus was witnessed to by the written prophecies and by His life, character, and works showing that the Father had sent Him, and the works He performed also confirmed the testimony John the Baptist had given about Him and answered John's doubts.ST May 17, 1899 The same legal requirement appears in Naboth's case, where two witnesses were needed for a death sentence and two false witnesses used this requirement corruptly to condemn him.ST Jul 14, 1898

Witnesses for Doctrine and Prophecy

The Old Testament stands as one witness to the mission and teaching of Christ and to the great plan of salvation which he preached and bade men search for eternal life, and the New Testament is not its substitute but its complement and second witness corroborating the first.ST Nov 14, 1906 The New Testament has no basis apart from the testimony of the Old, and no Scripture can be made the basis for anything that contradicts the doctrine of the Old.ST Nov 14, 1906 The same law of witness applies to the Bible itself, so that the Bible is tested by itself alone and by no other standard.ST May 9, 1906 It furnishes always agreeing witnesses between whom there can be no collusion to its divinity and authenticity, for God writes His testimony two or more times so there can be no question of its truth.ST May 9, 1906 His multiplied prophecies are produced again in the rise and fall of empires and in the histories of men and cities, His holy law is reproduced in the life and example of Jesus Christ and is written again by creative power in Christ in the heart of the yielding believer, so that the law of Sinai witnesses to the law in Christ and to the law in those who accept Him.ST May 9, 1906

God's method is to confirm His Word by giving a prediction or promise in Scripture and a second witness in its fulfillment.ST May 17, 1899 Jesus was witnessed to by the written prophecies and by His life, character and works, which showed that the Father had sent Him.ST May 17, 1899 His works also confirmed the testimony John the Baptist had given about Him and answered John's doubts.ST May 17, 1899

Different peoples who independently observe Friday, Saturday or Sunday serve as witnesses confirming that Saturday is the seventh day.RH May 17, 1870 The Muslim reckoning of the week is added as another witness, since its sixth day corresponds to the sixth day in Jewish and Christian reckoning.RH Aug 5, 1852 The agreement of these distinct peoples supports the claim that the weekly count has not been universally mistaken and that no change in the weekly reckoning occurred.RH Aug 5, 1852RH Jul 21, 1853

Two conflicting creation dates invoked as witnesses for Sunday being the seventh day cannot establish the claim when one starting point must be false and neither is proved correct.ST Jun 19, 1879 Counting forward and backward through weeks constructed from a Monday starting point only reproduces that starting assumption and does not prove Sunday is the Sabbath.ST Jun 19, 1879

Several Old Testament proofs that the Ten Commandments were separated from all other laws as God's holy law are sufficient proof by the two-or-three-witness rule, with no further proof from the New Testament needing to be offered.ST Mar 4, 1886 Multiple plain Bible testimonies likewise establish truth so that no further proof is needed, and here they establish the literal resurrection of the dead, that the bodies of the dead, those who sleep in the earth, will rise, against making the resurrection non-literal.ST Feb 18, 1886

The agreement of several historical and chronological authorities is ample proof of which ten kingdoms first arose in western Rome.RH Jun 20, 1854 The shared testimony of three ministers from different churches, whose experiences of the expected coming of Jesus agree, establishes the matter by two or three witnesses.RH Oct 25, 1853 The New Testament's testimony about Christ and His followers stands as faithful witnesses supporting the point under discussion.RH Feb 14, 1856

A church's testimony about its own apostolic claims is not sufficient by itself, but its claims must agree with the witness of God's Word.ST Dec 2, 1897 A single biblical passage alone is not to be relied on to justify lending at usury to strangers, since a matter should be confirmed by two or three witnesses.RH Nov 6, 1856 The same principle requires that a Bible teaching be proved by bringing together two or three texts that say the same thing, and more broadly that biblical teaching should be supported by abundant Scripture testimony.ST Jun 28, 1905RH Aug 19, 1852 It is also applied to support the evidence presented about Egyptian beliefs and embalming.RH Oct 5, 1869

When multiple independent historical accounts agree, their combined testimony strengthens the evidence for the event.ST Jul 30, 1885 The same confirming-witness principle applies to Christ's return, for God gives many confirming witnesses, including prophecies of signs and their fulfillment in the world, so people can know that the event is near.ST Aug 8, 1900 Serious accusations must not endanger a person's reputation or life without the agreement of multiple witnesses.ST Aug 8, 1900

The verse is a scriptural command to hear the church and is warrant for the church's authority, yet it does not specifically command Sunday observance or a change of the Sabbath.ST Sep 17, 1874

Life and Unity Applications

The instruction governs how all people are treated in matters of discipline, with students and teachers alike submitting to the same rule.RH Mar 31, 1904 When one addressed does not listen, one or two others are brought so the matter may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses, and this principle distinguishes harmful petty informing from reporting serious or repeated misconduct that threatens a school's welfare.RH Mar 12, 1908

Believers should draw together rather than withdraw, following the teaching on dealing with an offense by bringing one or two others when a private appeal is not heeded.RH Feb 23, 1905 Members are to cultivate brotherly kindness toward one another in treating an offender with one or two others when he will not listen.ST May 18, 1882 Each person is to know the plague of his own heart and confess his own sin while obeying God's plain directions for dealing with sin, and this puts all in condition to share the legitimate burden of soul-winning as laborers together with God instead of doing worse than the heathen and worse than misguided devotees of a false system.RH Apr 30, 1914 The Lord's specific directions for adjusting difficulties help members remain close and work together in love and unity rather than separate and scatter.RH Dec 23, 1909

The instruction belongs to humbling oneself before God and showing sympathy and love for others, especially through personal effort to help those outside of Christ.RH May 18, 1876 It belongs to the teaching on addressing a wrong that calls for stopping prayer to make things right rather than leaving a wrong uncorrected.ST Feb 3, 1904 It belongs to the closing lesson on how to treat brethren, joined to God's assurance that He hears the united prayers of His children.ST Jan 20, 1909

In matters requiring deliberation, including how to treat those who have erred, no one person's testimony or judgment should settle a disputed matter but two or more are to share responsibility so that every word is established, with God's servants conferring together rather than letting one person's opinion control, and this mutual consideration and respect promotes unity and harmony.ST Jan 20, 1881

Efforts should be made to bring about reconciliation between members, and members who stubbornly remain at variance should be suspended until they can live in harmony.ST Jan 18, 1883 The Saviour's process for dealing with a brother's wrong calls for going privately to those believed to be in error and discussing the matter in Christ's spirit with prayer rather than taking a fellow believer to law. Church discipline and settling of disputes are to be carried out under God's authority according to His law and the Bible's testimony by competent members, the church, or its ministers, with a matter confirmed by two or three witnesses, and not by taking fellow believers before secular courts.RH Jul 10, 1856 Members should work humbly and lovingly to settle difficulties among themselves rather than routinely seek help from outside, and when several quarrel and show a bad spirit all are to blame, while the church need not investigate every trivial dispute.RH Oct 24, 1885

The New Testament instruction for correcting faults was applied in seeking to correct Brother Ertzenberger's faults and restore the Swiss believers' confidence in him.ST Mar 11, 1875 Following Christ's rule for addressing disorder and withdrawing fellowship from some whose conduct was disorderly brought greater brotherly love and unity.RH Feb 3, 1859 The rule is followed in labor with holders of wrong teachings before fellowship is withdrawn until they repent and abandon them.RH Sep 16, 1852 Addressing wrongdoing is to deal openly and faithfully with sin rather than conceal it to protect the reputation of ministers or the gospel.RH Aug 26, 1875 Previous steps taken to address Whitney were said to have followed Christ's instruction to bring one or two others so the matter is established by multiple witnesses when one will not heed correction.RH Feb 25, 1862

Christ's better way of administering church discipline stands in contrast to a system that treats theological disagreement as a crime.RH Jan 9, 1900 The church in addressing a sinning or disorderly member should proceed with wisdom and seek a course that may win the person back.ST Oct 12, 1904 Gospel order and Bible principles give clear steps to follow when evil and division enter the church, requiring immediate effort to correct every wrong, bring back straying ones, and heal separation of heart and soul, with those who are spiritual doing the restoring before the enemy destroys the erring, so that sins are confessed, love returns, and unity is restored with the object to save and not to destroy those within the fold.RH Mar 5, 1901

Failing to follow the Lord's directions increases conflict, obstructs proper understanding of disputes, and wounds the church's cause.RH Apr 6, 1869 Neglecting the Bible's instruction for dealing faithfully with erring members allows sin to go unrebuked and contributes to division and apostasy.RH Jan 15, 1901

Sources

  1. RH Feb 14, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 4 — OSWEGO MEETING Editor, February 14, 1854
  2. RH Oct 8, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 41 — Has the Church any Protection From Inward Foes? G. I. BUTLER, Thursday, October 8, 1908
  3. RH Oct 13, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 16 — Church Government—No. 8 George Ide Butler, Third-day, October 13, 1874
  4. RH Jun 25, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 26 — Questions and Answers Editor, Thursday, June 25, 1914
  5. RH Oct 20, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 22 — THE GOLDEN RULE A. S. Hutchins, October 20, 1859
  6. RH Dec 27, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 25 — A Bible Course Third-day, December 27, 1853
  7. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 28 — Question Corner L. G. L.; Inquirer.
  8. RH Jan 17, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 8 — Sanctification: or Living Holiness D. T. Bourdeau, Third-Day, January 17, 1865
  9. ST Feb 4, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 5 — Our Words A. O. Tait, FEBRUARY 4, 1886
  10. ST Sep 19, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 38 — THE NEED OF UNITY Ellen G. White, September 19, 1900
  11. RH Oct 31, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 20 — “We Ought to Obey God.” Acts 5: 29 N. Orcutt, Third-day, October 31, 1871
  12. RH Nov 20, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 3 — Eating Unworthily H. S. Boyd, November 20, 1856
  13. RH Apr 1, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 13 — Church Discipline Thursday, April 1, 1909
  14. ST Dec 2, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 47 — IS THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH APOSTOLIC? Editor, December 2, 1897
  15. ST Dec 9, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 48 — Quickened by What? CONSTANT READER.; M. M. D.; W. H. S., December 9, 1897
  16. RH Jan 9, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 20 — CHURCH ORDER J. B. Frisbie, January 9, 1855
  17. RH Jul 3, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 10 — CHURCH ORDER J. B. Frisbie, July 3, 1856
  18. RH Dec 2, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 25 — Tattling and Gossip John Norton Loughborough, December 2, 1873
  19. RH Apr 1, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 18 — QUESTION Uriah Smith, THIRD-DAY, APRIL 1, 1862
  20. ST Apr 23, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 17 — The Church. No. 10. Editor, April 23, 1885
  21. ST May 13, 1903 Signs of the Times, Vol. 29, No. 19 — Question Corner D., May 13, 1903
  22. RH Jun 20, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 21 — THE CURE OF EVIL SPEAKING JUNE 20, 1854
  23. RH Oct 4, 1906 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 83, No. 40 — Discipline in Our Schools Allen Manry, October 4, 1906
  24. RH Sep 8, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 44, No. 12 — OFFICERS AND THEIR DUTIES George I. Butler, September 8, 1874
  25. ST Aug 19, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 41 — More Opposition to the Law of God J. H. W., August 19, 1875
  26. ST Oct 1, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 37 — Sensible at Last October 1, 1885
  27. ST Jun 4, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 22 — Information Wanted Editor, June 4, 1885
  28. ST Dec 5, 1916 Signs of the Times, December 5, 1916 — Sumatra, the Land with a Future F. A. Detamore, December 5, 1916
  29. ST Jul 10, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 35 — Church Discipline and Restoring a Brother Monday, July 10, 1893
  30. ST Jul 12, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 28 — LESSON V.—SABBATH, JULY 29, 1899 July 12, 1899
  31. ST Aug 9, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 32 — BINDING ON EARTH AND IN HEAVEN William N. Glenn, August 9, 1899
  32. ST Apr 16, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 16 — ADMINISTRATION OF DISCIPLINE Editor, April 16, 1885
  33. ST Jan 1, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 1 — The Church January 1, 1885
  34. ST May 13, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 19 — The Witnessing of God: The Basis of Our Confidence Editor, May 13, 1913
  35. ST Sep 23, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 37 — UNIMPEACHABLE TESTIMONY TO THE MISSION OF JESUS M. C. W., September 23, 1889
  36. RH Mar 1, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 15 — CHURCH TRIALS E. S. Lane, March 1, 1860
  37. RH Mar 1, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 15 — CHURCH TRIALS E. S. Lane, March 1, 1860
  38. RH Feb 21, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 13 — The Sabbath Among the Norwegians John Matteson, Third-Day, February 21, 1865
  39. RH Oct 16, 1900 Review and Herald, Vol. 77, No. 42 — STUDIES IN GALATIANS October 16, 1900
  40. RH Apr 23, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 39, No. 19 — “Be Kindly Affectioned One to Another with Brotherly Love.” Rom. 12: 10 A. W. Gould, April 23, 1872
  41. RH Jun 20, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 21 — THE CURE OF EVIL SPEAKING JUNE 20, 1854
  42. RH Apr 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 20 — SPEAK EVIL OF NO MAN F. Morrow, Fifth-Day, April 5, 1860
  43. RH Sep 25, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 21 — Note to J. K. Bellows. [^1] James White, September 25, 1856
  44. RH Mar 9, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 13 — Labor for the Erring F. M. W., March 9, 1916
  45. RH Jun 20, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 21 — THE CURE OF EVIL SPEAKING JUNE 20, 1854
  46. RH Mar 1, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 15 — CHURCH TRIALS E. S. Lane, March 1, 1860
  47. RH Jun 20, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 21 — THE CURE OF EVIL SPEAKING JUNE 20, 1854
  48. CO 21.1–2 Church Order — CHAPTER V. Halbert M. J. Richards, 1906
  49. ST Aug 27, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 33 — Important Question Editor, August 27, 1885
  50. RH May 13, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 19 — Divine Warnings Against Disorganization W. A. S., May 13, 1909
  51. RH Sep 14, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 46 — Divine Warnings Against Disorganization W. A. S., September 14, 1916
  52. ST Nov 15, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 46 — FIRST A HOLY CHURCH THEN THE HOLY GHOST Albion F. Ballenger, November 15, 1899
  53. RH Aug 4, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 8 — THE NATURE, POSITION, AND RESPONSIBILITY OF THE CHURCH George Ide Butler, August 4, 1874
  54. ST May 24, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 21 — REMITTING AND RETAINING SINS Ellen G. White, May 24, 1905
  55. ST Jun 27, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 26 — GIFTS OF THE SPIRIT A. F. Ballenger, JUNE 27, 1900
  56. RH May 22, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 25 — Fourth Annual Session of General Conference U. Smith, Third-day, May 22, 1866
  57. RH Sep 18, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 20 — Church Order A. S. Hutchins, September 18, 1856
  58. RH Jul 21, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 22, No. 8 — Report from Minnesota I. Sanborn; B. F. Snook, THIRD-DAY, JULY 21, 1863.
  59. RH Oct 27, 1904 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 81, No. 43 — Church Clerks Mrs. M. V. Newman, October 27, 1904
  60. ST Dec 11, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 6 — LESSON XII.—SABBATH, DECEMBER 23, 1893 Monday, December 11, 1893
  61. RH Jan 10, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 26 — Communication from Bro. Warren S. B. Warren, January 10, 1854
  62. ST Oct 28, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 42 — WHAT IS YOUR WITNESS? October 28, 1897
  63. ST Aug 8, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 32 — DISTRESS OF NATIONS, WITH PERPLEXITY August 8, 1900
  64. ST May 6, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 18 — INDIRECT LYING Julia H. Duffie, May 6, 1897
  65. RH Mar 13, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 15 — Report from Bro. Matteson John Matteson, Third-day, March 13, 1866
  66. RH Mar 4, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 14 — FIFTY UNANSWERABLE ARGUMENTS! E. GOODRICH., Third-Day, March 4, 1862
  67. ST May 17, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 20 — ROME'S PROOF OF INFALLIBILITY Editor, May 17, 1899
  68. ST May 9, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 19 — GOD'S WORD AND OTHER STANDARDS May 9, 1906
  69. ST Jul 14, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 28 — NABOTH’S VINEYARD July 14, 1898
  70. ST Nov 14, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 44 — THE BASIS OF TRUE DOCTRINE G., NOVEMBER 14, 1906
  71. RH May 17, 1870 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 35, No. 22 — Saturday Is the Seventh Day John Matteson, Third-day, May 17, 1870
  72. RH Aug 5, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 7 — IS SUNDAY THE TRUE SEVENTH DAY? John Nevins Andrews, THURSDAY, AUGUST 5, 1852
  73. RH Jul 21, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 5 — THE TRUE SEVENTH DAY John Nevins Andrews, July 21, 1853
  74. ST Jun 19, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 24 — Sunday Not the True Seventh Day John Nevins Andrews, June 19, 1879
  75. ST Mar 4, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 9 — The Law of Ten Commandments March 4, 1886
  76. ST Feb 18, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 7 — The Coming of a Literal Christ Editor, February 18, 1886
  77. RH Jun 20, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 21 — THE FOUR BEASTS. DAN. VII Josiah Litch, JUNE 20, 1854
  78. RH Oct 25, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 16 — Letter from J. B. Cook to F. G. Brown, written April, 1843 J. B. Cook, October 25, 1853
  79. RH Feb 14, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 20 — THE WORD M. H., Fifth-day, February 14, 1856
  80. RH Nov 6, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 1 — Usury Calvin W. Smith, November 6, 1856
  81. ST Jun 28, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 26 — EDUCATION IN THE HOME. NO. 7. June 28, 1905
  82. RH Aug 19, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 8 — The Sabbath and God’s Law Editor, Thursday, August 19, 1852
  83. RH Oct 5, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 15 — ORIGIN OF THE DOCTRINE OF THE IMMORTALITY OF THE SOUL Dudley Marvin Canright, Third-day, October 5, 1869
  84. ST Jul 30, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 29 — Can the Old Testament Be Trusted? July 30, 1885
  85. ST Sep 17, 1874 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 7 — WHO CHANGED THE SABBATH? SEPTEMBER 17, 1874
  86. RH Mar 31, 1904 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 81, No. 13 — Making Thinkers E. A. Sutherland, March 31, 1904
  87. RH Mar 12, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 11 — Informing of Misconduct C. C. L., March 12, 1908
  88. RH Feb 23, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 8 — The Weekly Prayer-Meeting H. J. Farman, February 23, 1905
  89. ST May 18, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 19 — Southern California Camp-Meeting May 18, 1882
  90. RH Apr 30, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 18 — Priest or Pastor? F. D. Starr, April 30, 1914
  91. RH Dec 23, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 51 — The Stay-Away Evil E. K. Slade, December 23, 1909
  92. RH May 18, 1876 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 47, No. 20 — THE SPARTA CAMP-MEETING Ellen G. White, May 18, 1876
  93. ST Feb 3, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 5 — A PAUSE IN PRAYER Editor; Donny, February 3, 1904
  94. ST Jan 20, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 3 — Our Bible Band Editor, January 20, 1909
  95. ST Jan 20, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 3 — General Articles Ellen G. White, January 20, 1881
  96. ST Jan 18, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 3 — Christian Unity Ellen G. White, January 18, 1883
  97. RH Jul 10, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 11 — CHURCH ORDER J. B. Frisbie, July 10, 1856
  98. RH Oct 24, 1885 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 26, No. 21 — Settling Church Difficulties J. Clarke., Third-Day, October 24, 1885
  99. ST Mar 11, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 18 — The Cause in Europe Onward John Nevins Andrews, March 11, 1875
  100. RH Feb 3, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 13, No. 11 — The Cause in Colon and Burlington James White, February 3, 1859
  101. RH Sep 16, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 10 — CLEVELAND, O., CONFERENCE Joseph Bates, Thursday, September 16, 1852
  102. RH Aug 26, 1875 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 46, No. 8 — Constantine—No. 5 Joseph Harvey Waggoner, August 26, 1875
  103. RH Feb 25, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 13 — BOTH SIDES Third-Day, February 25, 1862
  104. RH Jan 9, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 2 — A Better Way of Administering Discipline January 9, 1900
  105. ST Oct 12, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 40 — Question Corner October 12, 1904
  106. RH Mar 5, 1901 Review and Herald, Vol. 78, No. 10 — DISTRICT 5 R. M. Kilgore, Tuesday, March 5, 1901
  107. RH Apr 6, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 15 — THE CHURCH IN LAPEER H. S. Gurney; Hiram Perkes; W. W. Lockwood, Third-day, April 6, 1869
  108. RH Jan 15, 1901 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 78, No. 3 — DISTRICT 5 R. M. Kilgore, January 15, 1901