Matthew 18:17
And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.
And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
136 sources
When a fellow believer wrongs you personally, you are to go to him alone first, then with one or two others as witnesses if he will not listen, then to the congregation if he still refuses, and only then to regard him as outside its fellowship.STRH Oct 20, 1859RH Jul 3, 1856RH Jun 20, 1854RH Dec 27, 1853 Those steps must be taken in their given order without skipping, reversing, or substituting another course, and no one has any right to spread the matter to others meanwhile.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Oct 31, 1871RH Apr 1, 1909RH Jun 20, 1854 Telling it to the church is the last resort after private efforts fail, meaning the local assembly to which both belong, which must prayerfully hear the facts and seek a united decision for reclamation.ST Apr 16, 1885RH May 19, 1904RH Jun 25, 1914RH Jun 20, 1854ST Jan 1, 1885 If he also refuses to hear the church, his persistent course separates him from its fellowship and his name is removed, which is exclusion from believers and not final damnation or civil punishment.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874RH Aug 13, 1872CO 24.7 When the church judges justly from God's Word under the Holy Spirit's guidance, free from prejudice and selfish motives, its decision is ratified in heaven, and the whole course aims not to vindicate self but to gain and save the brother in love.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874RH Jun 25, 1914
Setting and Scope
Matthew 18:17 concerns a brother's personal trespass against another, not public sin in general or one's own wrongdoing.STRH Dec 27, 1853RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 1, 1862 It includes saying what is false or loose, idle talk that his actions show he did not mean at heart.ST When a fellow believer has wronged another, the course is to go and speak with that person directly rather than speaking about the matter to everyone else, to church officers, or to others met, and it is wrong to pursue a different course including speaking against a brother or sister.STRH Dec 27, 1853 The matter should first be discussed in a less public manner and brothers should settle difficulties privately whenever possible without a church trial.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 1, 1862 The first step is to go and show him his fault between him and the other alone, kindly asking in case he was not understood aright, and if he hears him the brother is gained, with further instruction to be followed only if he will not hear.STRH Dec 27, 1853
Reproof requires wisdom from God filled with love for the brother's soul, and is duty when God's Spirit bids and the salvation of a soul is at stake, with each person to seek God to know.ST It is to be done almost invariably alone and in private, in humility, meekness and kindness, unless very rare circumstances demand otherwise, while sometimes dignified silence is the best reproof to idle, silly talk.ST If he will not listen privately, one or two experienced, spiritually mature church members are then to be brought, and only then is the matter to be brought to the church, and if he rejects the church's appeal he is to be treated as an outsider.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Jan 9, 1855 This gradual effort aims to restore the erring person while sparing both him and the church an unnecessary public trial, so private wrongs should not be reported to the whole church before these steps are taken.RH Dec 27, 1853
Private wrongs are to be righted privately with the one injured, while sins committed openly in the light of day cannot be confessed secretly or obtain secret or private pardon but must be renounced and put away in a public manner and be openly rebuked and punished.RH Jan 6, 1874 Discipline under the verse addresses open conduct, not a person's hidden character or motives, and protects the church from being permeated by persistent sin.CO 25.1 It gives the church a defined process for addressing wrongs, rather than permitting members to air private grievances in social meetings.RH Aug 6, 1861 This rule contrasts with the instruction to Timothy to rebuke certain sins publicly, which concerns cases calling for public rebuke.RH Aug 6, 1861
The verse belongs to the closing section of Matthew 14 through Matthew 18:20 on how to treat brethren, joined to God's assurance that He hears the united prayers of His children, coming after the question of rank among the disciples, the warning about stumbling blocks, and the parable of the lost sheep.ST Jan 20, 1909 It is part of Jesus' teaching on humility and concern for others: following Him requires turning from self, showing sympathy and love, and making personal efforts to help those who are outside of Christ.RH May 18, 1876 It also calls for thorough conversion, singleness of purpose, and purity of motive.RH May 18, 1876 The comparison to a heathen man and a publican draws on their low standing in Jewish society, where publicans were classed with the heathen and excluded from Jewish worship, courts, and ordinary social privileges.ST Oct 11, 1899
The rule for church discipline in Matthew 18:15-20, including telling the matter to the church and treating the unrepentant offender as a heathen and a publican, remains instruction for the Christian church in this dispensation after the day of Pentecost and after the kingdom was set up, not only for the time when Christ spoke it.ST Aug 19, 1875ST Oct 1, 1885 Christ's teachings given before Pentecost are authoritative for the church and cannot be set aside on that ground.ST Aug 19, 1875ST Jun 4, 1885 It applies to church matters.ST Jun 4, 1885
Ordered Steps Toward Reconciliation
The verse gives the third and final steps of a graduated order for regaining an erring brother: first go to him privately, then take one or two others if he will not listen, and only if he neglects to hear them tell it to the church, and only if he neglects to hear the church treat him as a heathen man and a publican, a Gentile and tax collector outside fellowship.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Jul 3, 1856RH Jun 20, 1854RH Oct 13, 1874RH Mar 9, 1916 The church is not to take up the trial before those earlier steps, which are meant to reclaim him and work for his salvation, and the process begins with direct personal correction rather than reporting the fault to church officers or asking others to do the work.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Mar 9, 1916ST Jul 12, 1899RH Dec 27, 1853 When a brother is found guilty by two or three believing witnesses and still refuses correction, the bond of fellowship is severed on earth and that separation is recognized in heaven, following proper warning and full opportunity to make reparation, so that serious wrongdoing is not treated as unimportant.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 13, 1874 This course aims to restore the erring person while sparing both him and the church an unnecessary public trial, and private wrongs are not to be reported to the whole church before these steps are taken.RH Dec 27, 1853
The steps stand in a definite order that must not be reversed, bypassed, replaced, or added to by any precedent step, even when another course seems more effective or one feels impressed to take it.RH Oct 31, 1871RH Jun 20, 1854 The private appeal must come first and the later steps follow it in order, with telling the church as the third step after the private appeal and the approach with one or two witnesses, not before them.RH Jun 20, 1854RH Jun 20, 1854 Addressing small difficulties early in this order keeps them from growing into serious problems, rather than judging others from a self-appointed position of authority.RH Mar 15, 1860 Following the rule requires putting away malice, envy, and hatred and acting in love toward God and one another, with the church taking responsibility for resolving difficulties rather than relying on messengers, and only rarely should a matter need to be brought before the church.RH Oct 31, 1871RH Mar 15, 1860
The first step is to go and show him his fault between him and the offended one alone, directly and privately, in humility, meekness, kindness, and a prayerful spirit, and if he hears the brother is gained.STRH Jan 17, 1865RH Nov 20, 1856RH Dec 2, 1873 It is to be done almost invariably alone and in private unless very rare circumstances demand otherwise, kindly asking in case he was not understood aright, reproving and exhorting in a gentle tone to rescue him, with wisdom from God filled with love for the soul when His Spirit bids and salvation is at stake.STRH Dec 2, 1873 Going directly to the brother leaves less to say and saves much trouble, keeps slandering and backbiting out of the church, and is the pattern of self-sacrificing kindness that wins the erring.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Apr 23, 1872 This personal effort belongs to the aggrieved and cannot be done for him by another, whether by telling it to everybody in the church and everybody in the world or by reporting an absent brother's faults to a visiting messenger before doing the required duty.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Apr 5, 1860 It is especially the elder's watchcare toward the younger, and speaking directly to the erring person is required rather than seeking justice for self.RH Dec 2, 1873RH Apr 23, 1872
If he will not hear, one is to take one or two more along to humbly assist in effecting reconciliation, that every word may be established in the mouth of two or three witnesses.RH Nov 20, 1856RH Dec 2, 1873 The witnesses should be spiritually mature, experienced, impartial, believing church members who help ensure the brother receives a fair hearing before the case comes before the church for decision, and the church as a body is not involved in the first two steps.ST Jul 10, 1893RH Dec 27, 1853RH Mar 1, 1860 In approaching the church, one witness alongside the person making the appeal is enough to show that person has done his part, and the testimony of two or three establishes the matter with the aim of helping him recognize sin and choose what is right rather than vindicating self.ST May 13, 1903 The approach at every stage is to be meek and aimed at restoring the brother to favor, and worldly position or standing changes the duty of neither the individual nor the church.ST Jul 10, 1893
No one has any business going to a third party with the matter until first going to the offender, and no Christian has any right to talk about a brother's wrongs and faults to others, to everyone met, to everybody in the church and in the world, to church officers, or to a visiting messenger.ST Feb 4, 1886RH Jan 17, 1865RH Dec 2, 1873RH Apr 5, 1860 Spreading the grievance to others instead of going directly to the brother is error that itself needs to be labored with, and those who spread true accusations as gossip and evil-speaking err.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Feb 9, 1860 Ministers and members in trust must refuse to listen to any complaint or report against a brother or sister unless the reporter has complied with every particular of this instruction, and the church ought to refuse to investigate any complaint until this course has been taken, rebuking a different course.RH Apr 1, 1909RH Nov 20, 1856 Members who report contrary to these rules make themselves subjects of church discipline and may be censured and cut off under censure, and speaking about him instead of approaching him as directed violates brotherly love.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Apr 1, 1909 Speaking of the matter to no one else is the rule unless doing so is absolutely necessary to protect an innocent person.RH Jun 20, 1854
Discipline is meant to labor for the erring while giving their sins as little publicity as possible, and the process is not a license to expose or dwell on confessed sins.RH Jul 21, 1904 When a fault is serious enough to require mention to the church, it belongs within the church-directed process of correction aimed at restoration according to the prescribed steps, not in speaking about the fault to third parties.RH Feb 9, 1860
Telling It to Church
Telling the matter to the church is the last resort, taken only after private approach and approach with witnesses have both failed to gain the brother.ST Apr 16, 1885RH May 19, 1904RH Jun 25, 1914RH Mar 1, 1860ST Jul 2, 1885 Only at this stage is the matter properly before the church, for the church as a body takes no part in the first two steps.RH Mar 1, 1860RH Mar 1, 1860 The object in bringing it is reclamation rather than mere condemnation, with the body of brethren taking responsibility, prayerfully considering the facts, and reaching a united decision.RH May 19, 1904RH Jun 25, 1914RH Mar 1, 1860 When the offender will not hear the witnesses the duty to tell the church becomes binding, and if he then refuses to hear the church further responsibility for reclaiming him in that matter ends.ST Apr 16, 1885RH Jun 25, 1914ST Jul 2, 1885 Having faithfully followed the church's instruction before removing a name, the church has cleared itself before God and the evil is to be removed.ST Apr 16, 1885RH May 19, 1904
Here the church means the local assembly or congregation to which both persons belong, an organized local body within which members are accountable.RH Jun 20, 1854ST Jan 1, 1885ST Aug 13, 1885 It means the elder or elders who oversee that congregation, and officers chosen by the body whose judgments should be respected because of their position, though authority rests with the body.RH Jun 20, 1854ST Jan 1, 1885 The matter is to be brought through its elder for action, and where connection allows it may be brought to the elders to serve in place of witnesses after private steps fail.RH Jun 20, 1854RH Jul 2, 1914 If possible it should be brought in the offender's presence, with tenderness and love, the elders judging the conduct and rebuking with authority.RH Jun 20, 1854 The final decision belongs to the church body acting together in harmony with divine instruction, and an individual may not condemn the sinner.ST Jan 1, 1885RH Jul 2, 1914
Telling it to the church means the elder calls a meeting of the church with ample notice and special invitation to all parties to be present.RH Feb 25, 1862RH May 22, 1866RH Sep 8, 1874 He lays the matter before the church calmly and in love with a statement of what steps were taken and how they were met, gives the accused full opportunity for reply or explanation, and conducts any investigation needed calmly, kindly and thoroughly to bring out the simple truth, shutting out rancor and party feeling.RH Feb 25, 1862RH Sep 8, 1874 As advisory officer he may then give his advice and judgment with reasons and call for the judgment and decision of the church whether the wrong was committed, and a decision that it was amounts to a vote of censure.RH Sep 8, 1874 The church may by prior agreement of the parties appoint a committee of three whose decision will be final, preventing prolonged and confusing trials.RH Jul 21, 1863 Expulsion must be preceded by faithful labor and due notice of the trial with counsel of an experienced preacher, or if that cannot be secured of experienced and judicious lay brethren obtained through the State Conference Committee, and must be decided by at least a two-thirds vote of the entire membership.RH May 22, 1866RH May 27, 1875RH Oct 16, 1866 One who neglects to hear the church is ordinarily to be left for reflection a reasonable time, a month or two, before the case is brought up again to recommend expulsion or other action.RH Sep 8, 1874
The church should not take up the trial before the earlier steps, which are meant to reclaim the brother and work for his salvation.RH Oct 20, 1859ST Jul 10, 1893RH Dec 27, 1853 Private wrongs should not be reported to the whole church or to the world before private correction and the patient efforts of one or two others, and faults should not be exposed prematurely.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Dec 27, 1853RH Oct 2, 1855 The rule is first to go alone, then to take one or two more that every word may be established, and only if he neglects to hear them to tell it to the church, and not till then.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Dec 27, 1853RH Nov 20, 1856 The church ought to refuse to investigate any complaint until this course has been taken, and treating him as an outsider beforehand or speaking about him instead of approaching him violates brotherly love.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Nov 20, 1856 The witnesses should be spiritually mature and experienced, to assist humbly and ensure a fair hearing, and the matter may then be brought before the church officers.ST Jul 10, 1893RH Mar 1, 1860
The requirement for previous faithful labor may be dispensed with at the discretion of the church only in case of outrageous crime where guilt is manifest.RH May 22, 1866RH May 27, 1875RH Oct 16, 1866 Such an offense may demand immediate expulsion without the ordinary month or two left for reflection.RH May 22, 1866RH Sep 8, 1874 Apart from that exception expulsion should not be rushed, but should aim if possible to save the sinner rather than rashly cut him off.RH May 22, 1866RH May 27, 1875
Treated as an Outsider
When private appeal and appeal with witnesses have failed, bringing the matter before the congregation is the final step in seeking correction of a personal offense, and if the offender still refuses to hear the congregation he forfeits his standing and place in the body of Christ and is to be treated as outside its fellowship.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874ST Apr 16, 1885RH Feb 14, 1854 He is then to be regarded as outside the brotherhood, as an unbeliever, like one who has never joined it, his name removed and the bond of fellowship severed and withdrawn on earth.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874ST Apr 16, 1885CO 24.1–6 This follows patient efforts to restore him with proper warning and full opportunity to make reparation, and separation is called for only when those steps have failed, so that serious wrongdoing is not treated as unimportant.RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874CO 24.1–6 This course applies to a worldly person who abandons fellowship and cannot be reclaimed, to disorderly members, and to those who depart from the faith.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874ST Apr 16, 1885CO 24.1–6 When done in harmony with the instruction given, with the matter properly before the body and without hatred or unkindness, the decision is sanctioned and recognized in heaven and carries serious and eternal consequences for the unrepentant unless he changes, while helping settle differences, restore confidence, and spare the congregation, especially its young and weak, the burden of spread grievances.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874RH Feb 14, 1854
The congregation does not itself cast him out but declares the separation his persistent course has brought about.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 16, 1900 Holding to his own way against every effort of the brethren to restore him proves he does not have the spirit of Christian brotherhood and that he has separated himself from their company by his own choice.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 16, 1900 One who so chooses for himself against the word of God and against all brotherhood is to be rejected after first and second admonition, because he is subverted and sins, being condemned of himself.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 16, 1900 The bringing before the congregation is to seek his reclamation and not merely his condemnation, and thereafter the relation is limited to seeking his repentance and confession, with continued prayer and kindly ministry to win him back without supporting his sin, showing love and desire for his salvation, with fellowship restored when he repents.RH Oct 8, 1908RH Jun 25, 1914RH Oct 16, 1900
This exclusion from fellowship is distinct from the final separation of the righteous and the wicked at the end of the world.RH Aug 13, 1872CO 24.7RH Jun 11, 1908 It does not give the excluded person over to utter damnation and does not place him in the category of the unpardonable sin, nor does it end prayer and effort for him.RH Aug 13, 1872CO 24.7RH Jun 11, 1908 It is exclusion from the body of believers, not punishment by civil authority.RH Aug 13, 1872CO 24.7RH Jun 11, 1908 When exclusion is demanded it is to be prompt yet judicious, with unremitting effort and earnest prayer in the interval between exclusion and restoration that the wanderer may be reclaimed, and with ready and cordial restoration and welcome when restoration is deserved, after the pattern of the father's compassion, running, embrace, and kiss toward his prodigal son.RH Aug 13, 1872CO 24.7RH Jun 11, 1908
Another congregation must not disregard that action by receiving him or granting him privileges while he remains unrepentant, for doing so supports his rebellion and violates the rules given for discipline.ST Aug 13, 1885RH Sep 18, 1856 It is scriptural to exclude an offending member by vote after he has been labored with for his past wrongs, for the voice of the congregation has authority in settling existing trials.ST Aug 13, 1885RH Sep 18, 1856 A member under labor must therefore remain subject to the remaining members and to the advice and counsel of a disinterested committee until settlement takes place.ST Aug 13, 1885RH Sep 18, 1856 Leaving before settlement and refusing that voice, while still claiming fellowship elsewhere, is virtually withdrawing from the entire body, and withdrawing to avoid labor does not settle membership, raising the rule by which who is and who is not a member is determined, including whether receiving members by vote answers to excluding by vote.ST Aug 13, 1885RH Sep 18, 1856
Those who belong to the congregation are amenable to the discipline of that body.RH Sep 30, 1873 Membership carries subjection to discipline, and this accountability is a condition for partaking of the supper.RH Sep 30, 1873 Communion is therefore close communion, restricted to commandment-keeping Christians who have entered by scriptural baptism and who remain under the discipline of the body with which they partake.RH Sep 30, 1873
Heaven Ratifies Church Decisions
When the church warns, instructs and judges from God's Word under the Holy Spirit's guidance, its just decision is the decision of Christ its Head and is bound and ratified in heaven.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874RH May 13, 1909RH Aug 4, 1874 That ratification follows proper warning with full opportunity to make reparation, and it carries eternal consequences for the unrepentant unless he changes his course.RH Oct 8, 1908RH Oct 13, 1874ST Dec 5, 1916 The judgment declared must come from God's Word, with prayer, faith, God-given wisdom, and freedom from prejudice, partiality and selfish motives, dealing kindly with souls purchased by Christ's blood.RH May 13, 1909RH Apr 1, 1909ST Jan 13, 1888 The duty includes calling sin by its right name on lying, Sabbath-breaking, stealing, idolatry and every other evil, refusing to sanction wrongdoing while seeking to restore, and heaven ratifies the disfellowshipping of corrupt influences amid Satan's sowing of tares.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916 When properly carried out according to Christ's directions in Scripture, the severing of fellowship on earth is recognized in heaven, the relationship is then limited to seeking repentance and confession, and fellowship is restored when he repents, but one who remains unreconciled is excluded from heaven.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Oct 8, 1908ST Dec 5, 1916
Action contrary to Christ's Word and procedure is not confirmed in heaven.RH Apr 1, 1909CO 21.1–2ST Jan 13, 1888 The decision of an unjust judge is of no account in heaven and does not make an innocent man guilty before God.RH Apr 1, 1909 A church or member that violates the prescribed process is subject to the same discipline, and no hasty cutting off is allowed until the case has been investigated and the Bible rule fully obeyed to the letter.RH Apr 1, 1909CO 21.1–2
The power to bind and loose joined to this instruction was not given to Peter alone but in equal measure to the other apostles and in more limited measure to the entire church.ST Jan 13, 1888ST Dec 5, 1892 No individual in the church or out of it has power to bind or loose, and disfellowshipping is by the church as a body prayerfully considering the facts and seeking reform, not by an individual leader.ST Jan 13, 1888ST Jan 1, 1885RH Jul 25, 1907 The instruction is addressed to the church as a whole, not merely to its ministers, and while qualified officers chosen by the body are to have their judgments respected because of position, authority rests with the body.RH Aug 4, 1874ST Jan 1, 1885ST Jan 1, 1885 Even the church cannot bind or loose except when walking in the light with its members abiding in Christ, for when that ceases it ceases to be the church of Christ no matter what its name or pretensions.ST Jan 13, 1888
Despising the church's authority in this matter is despising Christ's authority and shows contempt for God.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916 The offender must make peace with the church, and rejecting its counsel and opposing its administration of discipline is a serious offense that can itself make a person subject to discipline.RH Aug 4, 1874ST Aug 27, 1885 Individual judgment must submit to the church's authority to preserve harmony, since insisting on individual independence leads to anarchy and confusion while unity witnesses powerfully to the world.ST May 24, 1883ST Aug 27, 1885
Church Exists as Organized
Jesus spoke of the church as an assembly to which a matter could be brought before Pentecost and before the gospel went to the Gentiles.ST Feb 15, 1910ST Jan 3, 1905ST Oct 29, 1894 The church was therefore already in actual existence when He spoke, and did not begin with Pentecost or with the period covered in Acts.ST Feb 15, 1910ST Jan 3, 1905ST Oct 29, 1894 This proves the church had existed from the time of Adam and in the days of Moses, continuing as God's congregation into the gospel dispensation.ST Jan 3, 1905RH Jun 12, 1879 It was already a recognized congregation before it acquired the later names used for it in the New Testament.RH Jun 12, 1879RH Jun 12, 1879
Christ's church is a visible, organized, responsible body that can hear about wrongdoing and speak with authority, not only an invisible body.ST Mar 6, 1884ST Nov 15, 1899ST Jun 27, 1900 It is real, tangible and organized, not an invisible, intangible, irresponsible nothing, with the responsibility of membership and the unpleasant duty of dealing with one who trespasses and, if he will not hear and repent, cleansing him out.ST Nov 15, 1899ST Jun 27, 1900 It therefore has a real, delegated role and responsibility in the work of salvation when a person will not listen, but that authority is not the exclusive, self-exalting power claimed by the papacy.ST Mar 6, 1884ST Apr 3, 1884 Nor may Christians act wholly independently of organization, and repudiation of organization is an attempt to escape this duty, while Christ's vesting of authority in the church includes authority to restrain ministers from acting independently of its counsel as part of God's order and not as arbitrary power.ST Mar 6, 1884ST Jun 27, 1900ST Apr 3, 1884
The church therefore has the duty to discipline its members and reject the unworthy.RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916ST Aug 28, 1884 When private correction and witnesses fail, the matter is brought before the church, and if the person will not heed the church he is regarded as an outsider, and following these plain directions keeps the community faithful and able to share in winning souls.RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916RH Apr 30, 1914 This discipline is part of God's plan for how and when people are cut off from fellowship, to keep the church pure in doctrine and practice and to exclude influences that lead to confusion and corruption.RH Apr 30, 1914RH Oct 8, 1908 It is meant for the church's good, peace and prosperity, and failure to follow it increases trials, obstructs understanding, wounds the cause, and calls for confession, humility and repentance.RH Oct 8, 1908RH Apr 6, 1869 The church must warn and instruct those who persist in sin, seek to restore them, and refuse to sanction their wrongdoing, with judgment grounded in God's Word that is ratified in heaven, and to despise the church's authority in this is to despise Christ.RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916
The object in following this gospel order when wrongs and divisions arise is to save and not to destroy those within the fold.RH Jun 16, 1903RH Mar 5, 1901ST Dec 20, 1899 The work is to bring back straying ones, redeem from sin, correct every evil before the enemy gains advantage, and restore the erring through the spiritual before the wicked one accomplishes their destruction, leading to confession, restored love and unity.RH Jun 16, 1903RH Mar 5, 1901ST Oct 12, 1904 Exclusion makes clear that the church does not sanction the conduct and shows the person standing outside its fellowship, in order to lead to repentance, reformation, recovery from Satan's influence, and restoration to Christ and the church, as with the Corinthian offender later forgiven after repenting and reforming.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898ST Apr 16, 1885 Even withdrawal of fellowship does not end labor for salvation, but continues as for those outside the faith, making every effort to correct the disorderly and save if possible, and withdrawing for his good and the good of the cause only when that cannot be done.RH Jun 16, 1903ST Apr 16, 1885ST Oct 12, 1904
Sabbath Authority Claim Answered
Christ's direction to hear the church is appealed to as establishing the church's authority, its apostolic tradition, and its power to require observances such as feast days and Sunday in place of the seventh-day Sabbath, with appeal made even to the Council of Nicea.ST Oct 10, 1878RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 27, 1873 The same direction is used to defend Sunday observance on the ground that Scripture commands people to hear the church and that church authority therefore warrants keeping Sunday.RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 27, 1873RH Oct 24, 1854
Hearing the church is granted, yet the direction itself does not specifically command Sunday observance nor state that the Sabbath was changed from Saturday to Sunday.ST Oct 10, 1878RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 27, 1873 It does not by itself specify that Sunday replaces the Sabbath, and Scripture nowhere in particular commands that change.ST Oct 10, 1878RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 27, 1873RH Oct 24, 1854
Applying the statement about the church to the Roman Catholic Church does not by itself establish that church's infallibility.ST May 17, 1899ST Aug 19, 1897 The church is not its own infallible teacher, but is to teach what Christ commands, being itself taught by Christ through the Scriptures and the Holy Spirit.ST May 17, 1899ST Aug 19, 1897
The direction is also applied to church discipline through excommunication, with the church's judgment treated as spiritually decisive and excommunication described as spiritual death and used against those who question the teachings of the Vatican Council.RH Jun 11, 1908ST Mar 25, 1875 Its consequence for one who will not hear is exclusion from the body of believers, not punishment by civil authority.RH Jun 11, 1908ST Mar 25, 1875
Faithful Discipline in Practice
Discipline must follow the stated process carefully and fairly, with due notice, opportunity to attend and answer for oneself, and full investigation to the letter before any name is cut off, without hasty action, free from prejudice, partiality and selfish motives, dealing kindly as with souls purchased by Christ's blood.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 1, 1909RH Jan 23, 1855 Ministers and those in trust must refuse to listen to any complaint or report against a brother or sister unless the reporter has complied with every particular of the private rule first alone, then with one or two more as witnesses, and only then telling it to the church, and one who reports otherwise makes himself subject to church discipline and censure.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 1, 1909 Members were excluded without notice of the business or chance to attend and answer in violation of these directions.RH Jan 23, 1855 Christ's better way of administering discipline is superior to treating theological disagreement as a criminal offense, calling instead for careful, judicious action with patient, earnest Christian labor rather than criticism or gossip, and not leaving one free to live carelessly while remaining in good standing.RH Jan 9, 1900RH Apr 1, 1915
It addresses offending members whose lives dishonor God or cause division and weakness, pursued not from personal spite or antipathy but for God's glory and the salvation of souls, never by physical force or persecution.RH Feb 3, 1859ST Sep 24, 1896 This includes disorderly conduct whose removal can take away reproach and foster brotherly love and unity, causing others to stumble while remaining spiritually diseased despite proper efforts to correct and heal, persistent wrong teaching and discord after earnest requests to meet and due course of labor until repentance and forsaking of error, and Sabbath-breaking and fault-finding where disbelief in visions was not the ground.RH Feb 3, 1859ST Aug 6, 1896RH Apr 25, 1854RH Jun 23, 1859RH Sep 16, 1852 The same rule reaches stubborn Sabbath-breaking, dances and questionable acts, unknown whereabouts despite efforts, slander, quarreling, disrespect to God's institutions, covetousness and fraud, and favoring oppression or rebellion or taking up arms beyond the Bible, for which the church may call to account and withdraw fellowship.RH Feb 3, 1859ST Sep 24, 1896
After patient, loving efforts, prayers and earnest appeals to reclaim them, those who refuse to respond to the Master's instruction are to be disfellowshipped by vote of the church, acting together in harmony with divine instruction through its elder, since no individual may condemn the sinner.RH Dec 28, 1916RH Jul 2, 1914RH Nov 9, 1916 The action is to be prompt yet judicious, like amputating a limb from the body which no one does until after doing all that can be done to restore or heal the affected part, and when done with a body's care few will have to be separated.RH Aug 13, 1872RH Apr 1, 1909 Even when influence corrupts others so that decided dealing and disfellowshipping are required, with heaven ratifying the action, the church must move cautiously because Christ and heavenly agencies are purifying a peculiar people zealous of good works while Satan sows tares and puts spurious Christians and false accusers in the church to weaken, confuse and divide it.RH Oct 19, 1916 Exclusion does not give the person over to utter damnation or place him in the unpardonable sin, nor end prayer and effort for him, but calls for unremitting effort and earnest prayer in the interval toward ready and cordial restoration and welcome when deserved, after the pattern of the father's compassion, running, embrace and kiss toward his prodigal son.RH Aug 13, 1872
The church is the final body to hear the matter, and once its instruction has been faithfully followed before removal, it has cleared itself before God, the evil is to be removed, and the matter rests on united decision.RH May 19, 1904RH Mar 9, 1916 It must make wrongdoing clear and remove it so evil does not spread and health and purity are preserved before God, cleansing out the impenitent as the apostolic church did Ananias and Sapphira, cutting off the incorrigible yet reclaiming the striving, protecting members from harmful influence like an offending member cut off to protect the body, and showing it does not sanction deeds lest it dishonor the Lord.ST Jun 27, 1900ST Aug 6, 1896RH Mar 9, 1916 Repudiation of organization as a real, tangible, organized, visible body is an attempt to escape this responsibility and unpleasant duty of dealing with trespass unto repentance.ST Jun 27, 1900 Treating the persistent wrongdoer as outside after proper steps, including excommunication unless there is repentance, does not mean holding hard feelings or counting him beyond salvation, but holding him as one still to be helped and labored for.ST May 3, 1910
Following this course settles differences, restores confidence and standing with united approval, spares especially the young and weak the burden and harm of spread private grievances, and serves the good, peace and prosperity of the church, while failure to follow it increases trials, obstructs understanding, wounds the cause and calls for confession, humility and repentance.RH Feb 14, 1854RH Apr 6, 1869ST Mar 11, 1875 Not every quarrel requires a formal church trial or inquiry into who is most to blame, for when members quarrel and show a bad spirit all are blameworthy and the church should not spend its effort on trifling disputes, which are often settled better within the church through humble, loving action than with help from outside.RH Oct 24, 1885 Addressing small difficulties early in the order God has given, with the church taking responsibility rather than relying on messengers, is easier than letting them grow, and introducing order does not create existing evils but brings them to light and separates from them according to gospel rules.RH Mar 15, 1860RH Jun 11, 1861
The instruction distinguishes persistent, damaging, serious misconduct to be brought to proper authority when private efforts do not resolve it from trivial informing motivated by revenge, self-protection or favor.RH Mar 12, 1908 It is the context for dealing with serious misconduct and for stopping prayer intended to undo a wrong, where one who will not listen even to the church is to be treated as an outsider.ST Feb 3, 1904RH Mar 12, 1908
Applied to schools, the same principles of discipline and governance bind students and teachers alike, with the school taking the place of the community.RH Mar 31, 1904RH Oct 4, 1906 If private correction and correction by two or three do not bring change, the matter is brought before the church, and if the offender still refuses to listen the community may separate from that person rather than let the whole body suffer, so a pupil who remains unresponsive may be asked to leave.RH Mar 31, 1904RH Oct 4, 1906
Spirit Toward the Erring
The whole course aims to gain the brother and save him, leading him to recognize sin and choose what is right rather than vindicating self or merely condemning him.RH Jun 25, 1914ST May 13, 1903RH Mar 5, 1901 Private correction comes first, then patient effort with one or two others, and only then is the matter brought to the church; only if he also refuses to hear the church is he to be regarded as a heathen and a publican.RH Oct 20, 1859RH Jun 25, 1914ST May 13, 1903 The testimony of two or three establishes the matter, and in approaching the church one witness alongside the one making the appeal is enough to show he has done his part.ST May 13, 1903 The church is not to take up the trial before those earlier steps, which are meant to reclaim the brother and work for his salvation, and to treat him as an outsider beforehand or to speak about him instead of approaching him as directed violates brotherly love.RH Oct 20, 1859 The object in following this gospel order when wrongs and divisions arise is to save and not destroy those within the fold, to bring back straying ones with immediate effort to correct every evil before the enemy gains advantage.RH Mar 5, 1901 Those who are spiritual restore the erring before the wicked one accomplishes their destruction, unto confession of sins and restored love and unity, the matter being brought before the church as part of a process intended, if possible, to win the person back.RH Mar 5, 1901ST Oct 12, 1904
Reproof calls for wisdom from God filled with love for the soul, undertaken when His Spirit bids and the salvation of a soul is at stake, each seeking God to know.ST It is to be done almost invariably alone and in private, in humility, meekness, kindness and a prayerful spirit, kindly asking in case he was not understood aright, unless very rare circumstances demand otherwise.ST The approach is to be meek and aimed at restoring the brother to favor, with witnesses who are spiritually mature, experienced and impartial, and the matter may then be brought before the officers; if the church fails to recognize what is right, wrongs are to be patiently borne in trust that God will set them right.ST Jul 10, 1893 It is to be carried out with brotherly kindness, gently and in love, without revenge, gossip, premature publicity, spite or harshness, protecting the erring and helping prevent needless trials.ST Jan 6, 1887ST May 18, 1882 Dignified silence is sometimes the best reproof to idle, silly talk, including saying what is false or loose talk shown by actions not to be meant at heart.ST A person's worldly position or standing does not change the duty of either the individual or the church, and loyalty to God and the good of the soul and the honor of the cause require the duty even when the person is a close friend or relative, without excusing or hiding sin.ST Jul 10, 1893ST Sep 10, 1912 These instructions rule out striving for supremacy, since greatness in the kingdom rests on inward excellence rather than position, splendor or authority.ST Sep 19, 1900
Even being regarded as outside ends only friendship and familiarity, not earnest goodwill, courtesy, practical kindness, prayer, and continued kindly ministry to win him back without supporting his sin.RH Jun 25, 1914ST Jul 12, 1899RH Jun 20, 1854 Fellowship is withdrawn and the separation his persistent course has brought about is declared, yet believers are still to pray, labor, show love and desire for his salvation, and hold no hard feelings as if he were beyond salvation.RH Jun 25, 1914ST May 3, 1910 Christ's spirit calls for earnest effort to win such a person through kindness rather than harshness, hateful words or neglect, without hatred or unkindness.RH Oct 8, 1908ST Jul 12, 1899 The church's relation to him is then limited to seeking his repentance and confession, with fellowship restored when he repents, and discipline carried through to excommunication unless there is repentance does not end labor directed toward his salvation as toward one outside the faith.RH Oct 8, 1908ST May 3, 1910RH Jun 16, 1903 In the interval between exclusion and restoration there is to be unremitting effort and earnest prayer that the wanderer may be reclaimed.RH Aug 13, 1872
Treating him as outside does not end efforts to seek him and urge repentance; if he confesses and forsakes sin he is to be forgiven, welcomed back and encouraged in the right way.RH Mar 9, 1916 Hearing correction gains the brother back to the church and to Christ, binding him to fellow Christians in love and, through obedience to the Word and the Spirit, to Christ, redeeming him from sin and restoring him to fellowship.ST Aug 9, 1899 Restoration when deserved is to be ready and cordial, after the pattern of the father's compassion, running, embrace and kiss toward the prodigal son.RH Aug 13, 1872 Forgiveness is required if he repents, even repeatedly, since forgiveness without repentance would defeat God's purpose to save people from sins and prepare them for the coming of the Son of man.RH Mar 1, 1860
When offended the better course is not to withdraw from the others but to come together and follow the teaching for addressing the matter, pressing together rather than separating and scattering in love and unity.RH Feb 23, 1905RH Dec 23, 1909 Individual judgment must submit to the church's authority to preserve harmony, since insisting on independence leads to anarchy and confusion, while unity is a powerful witness to the world and strengthens the cause.ST May 24, 1883 Every effort should be made to reconcile those at variance, but those who stubbornly remain at variance should be suspended until they can live in harmony.ST Jan 18, 1883 The instruction in Matthew 18 is to be read and obeyed in setting a self-denying example, praying for grace not to be a cause of stumbling to the young, under solemn accountability for the use of light on plain living.RH Jul 16, 1901
Sources