The speaker is a rich young ruler who professes to have kept the duties to others from his youth up and earnestly asks what he still lacks for eternal life. His claim is confident but self-deceived, for his outward blameless life is mistaken for true keeping while he does not grasp the depth of the law in mind and heart. What he lacks is exposed by his great possessions, for supreme love of riches rules his heart over love to God and to his neighbor, leaving him without the love that is the spirit and life of the commandments. Christ tests him by calling him to sell what he has, give to the poor, gain treasure in heaven and follow, but he goes away sorrowful, choosing seen earthly treasure over unseen heavenly treasure and fellowship with Christ. His case pictures many professed believers today who think themselves perfect and without lack yet cling to idols and turn sorrowful when self-denial, right use of wealth for the needy, and sacrifice for God's cause are required.
Speaker and Context
The one who speaks is a rich young ruler in Israel who comes to Christ as a teacher by whom he is willing to be taught. He has watched Christ's compassion for the poor and ignorant and has been touched and drawn by His meekness and lowliness of heart, attracted and charmed by His life and teaching. He is a man of pleasing appearance, outward piety, high capabilities and sincere desire, capable of great blessing and qualified for service, not ignorant of duty to God and convinced that obedience brings a place of happiness. He fully desires to be as Christ is and to work out a perfect character fit to live eternally with God, yet he still needs to give himself fully to Christ in heart devotion and love to God, with supreme love of self surrendered before his character can be sanctified for God's use.
The exchange concerns how to gain eternal life, and he is directed to keep God's commandments as obedience to principles expressing God's character and requiring harmony with Him. The commandments named to him are duties to other people, against murder, adultery, theft and false witness, with honor to father and mother and love to neighbor as self. The first four commandments containing duty to God are not named to him at first, and obedience is presented as necessary for eternal life. His profession of having kept all these things from his youth up draws Christ's call to be perfect by selling what he has, giving to the poor, gaining treasure in heaven, and coming to follow Him, a saying he hears and then goes away sorrowful because he has great possessions.
His reply claims to have kept all these things from his youth up and honestly asks what he still lacks in order to gain eternal life. The question is earnest and comes from high motives but imperfect understanding, moved by conviction at seeing Christ's love and self-denial. By human standards his outward life is blameless, yet he fears that all is not right between him and God, remaining dissatisfied with inward unease and sensing that something is still missing. His claim reflects a high estimate of his own righteousness rather than a sense of defectiveness, with an external and superficial understanding of the law, and he hopes Jesus can satisfy the need he still feels and complete a character that profession alone has not made complete.
Meaning of His Claim
The claim is made with full confidence in personal fidelity and righteousness, as one who thinks himself perfect, blameless, and lacking nothing. By human measurement his outward life is blameless, amiable, and willing to do good, and having been flattered for those traits he flatters himself that integrity in dealing with fellow men fulfills the law. That confidence conceals a fatal deficiency of character, for the sense of security is false while possessions are cherished as idols of greater value than eternal life. His attachment to earthly wealth when told to sell, give to the poor, and follow exposes the limits of his obedience and his unwillingness to obey fully.
The claim is false and self-deceived, for he supposes he has kept all the commandments from his youth but has not truly kept them and does not understand their depth and significance. His profession of obedience does not mean his character is complete, his heart is right, or he is ready to follow in self-denial. His supreme love of wealth keeps him from loving God with whole heart and neighbor as himself, so he fails to keep the commandments while thinking himself fit for eternal life. His question about what he still lacks itself reveals a real lack and weakness, showing he is not a true lover of God and needs to accept righteousness joined with divine power to human effort, which never permits breaking the law. The same deception is taught as holding where wealth is withheld from those in need and possessions are prized more than the Giver, leaving love to God and neighbor unfulfilled.
He mistakes outward integrity and amiable character for spiritual perfection, resting on outward propriety of conduct and profession of truth while the heart remains unregenerate. No human standard of propriety, profession, or letter of the law can save a soul from death, as seen in the same spiritual state as Paul when blameless touching the letter; God's standard must be seen, acknowledged, and followed. What is still lacking is the law written in mind and heart and brought home to the conscience to see the exceeding sinfulness of sin, unto death to self and crucifixion of self, without which spiritual holiness cannot be known and readiness for the kingdom is impossible. If he had understood through the commandment that he was sinful, as Paul did, and obeyed in spirit and truth, the law would have exposed and slain his sinful nature and he would have laid hold of eternal life. His refusal when tested to deny self, take up the cross, and follow proves disobedience, for keeping the whole law yet offending in one point is guilt of all.
Outward commandment-keeping can thus coexist with a cherished inward defect and a heart not made whole. Legal obedience had not fully entered his life and character, and he was unwilling to give all he had and all he was. Selfishness and covetousness are exposed as the plague-spot in his character, showing that outward obedience had not made his heart whole. The same self-righteous spirit appears in Judas, who appeared righteous yet neglected his own character and failed to live the words spoken to him.
Lack That Remained
What he still lacked was laid bare by his great possessions, for his supreme love of riches was his idol swallowing up his heart in earthly treasure. That idol stood in the way of loving God with whole heart and soul and mind, of following Christ in self-denial, of appreciating and receiving Christ, and of bearing the cross. Though he claimed to have kept the commandments from his youth and asked what was still wanting, outward obedience had not removed this governing attachment, and his sorrow showed he would not surrender riches to follow Jesus. He did not love his neighbor as himself because he kept his wealth rather than using entrusted wealth to help the poor and needy, and that same attachment kept him from loving God fully. Christ's invitation required giving up visible earthly treasure for unseen heavenly treasure, but he valued reputation and possessions more than fellowship with Christ and eternal life, so he turned away.
Because riches ruled him he failed both tables of the law. He failed the first four commandments containing duty to God by not loving God supremely, since supreme love of riches made it impossible to love God with all heart, soul and mind. He failed the last six by not loving his neighbor as himself, shutting his eyes to the wants of fellow men and withholding wealth from those in need instead of caring unselfishly for others, especially those in greatest danger and need. A profession of love for God without such love for one's brother is not genuine, and thinking he had kept the last six did not mean he had fulfilled their true demands. The call to sell and give to the poor proved how much God and truth were loved, testing whether he prized eternal life higher than riches.
What was missing was love, which is the spirit and life of the commandments. Self-love and worldly gain ruled his heart, making him a transgressor of the law and out of harmony with heaven's principles. He lacked the spirit of love and self-sacrifice that is the touchstone of character and the test applied at the final judgment. Keeping the commandments cannot be separated from love for others, so his refusal to give his possessions to the poor and follow Jesus disproved his claim and exposed a defect in character.
He loved his possessions more than eternal life, more than God, more than heavenly treasure, and more than fellowship with Christ. Though willing to keep the commandments and desiring eternal life and a perfect character, he wanted heavenly treasure and also the temporal advantages of riches. He desired eternal life but was unwilling to make the sacrifice, judging heaven to cost too much and counting giving up seen earthly treasure for unseen heavenly treasure too great a risk. His desire was chilled when required to give to the poor, he refused the offer of eternal life, renounced immortal life, and chose earthly treasure over eternal reward. He went away sorrowful because he had great possessions and gave his worship ever after to the world.
The inward plague-spot was supreme selfishness and covetousness. Self-love was supreme with him, concealing a fatal deficiency of character beneath confident claims to have kept all from his youth. He had a close and covetous heart that could tithe mint and rue and other small things while neglecting the weightier matters, proving lack of the true spirit of sacrifice acceptable to God. He loved God's gifts more than their Giver, loved his possessions above God and His service and more than the souls of his fellow men, so riches were his idol and the world held first place in his affections.
Christ's Test and Outcome
To his question what he still lacked, the answer is to be perfect by selling what he has, giving to the poor, gaining treasure in heaven, and coming to follow Christ. Entering life is conditional, and outward keeping of the commandments named to him does not meet his need. His profession of having kept them from his youth does not make him perfect or prove he has passed the test, for making these sacrifices is receiving the bread of life until Christ becomes the life-giving current within the soul.
The command exposes his idol and tests how much higher he prizes eternal life than riches and how much God and truth are loved. It points to undone duties plainly specified in the law, to love God supremely and to love his neighbor as himself by using entrusted wealth to help the poor and needy in their wants and greatest danger and need. His supreme love of riches has swallowed up his heart in earthly treasure, shut his eyes to fellow men, made it impossible to love God with all heart, soul, and mind, and therefore is both his failure in the first four commandments and his failure truly to keep the last six. Outward obedience without self-surrender and love in action is not enough, for truth set home by the Spirit crowds out love of riches, since love of Jesus and riches cannot dwell in the same heart.
He hears the saying and goes away sorrowful because he has great possessions. His desire is chilled and his sorrow shows he will not remove the obstacle, surrender his riches, or accept the condition of discipleship. He values his riches more than heavenly treasure, wants both the heavenly treasure and the temporal advantages of riches, counts giving up seen earthly treasure for unseen heavenly treasure too great a risk, refuses the offer of eternal life, and gives his worship ever after to the world.
Jesus invites him without compelling his choice. Yet obeying Christ's words is his only hope of salvation and of attaining a complete Christian character. Following Christ requires complete obedience and self-surrender, giving up whatever would corrupt the whole person and compete with God for the affections, whether much or little, even when the sacrifice seems great. His legal obedience has not fully entered his life and character, for he is unwilling to give Christ all he had and all he was, and keeping anything back diminishes moral strength and ability to do good until cherished worldly things take over the heart.
His refusal when tested proves disobedience, for keeping the whole law yet offending in one point is guilt of all. His claim is only outward propriety of conduct and profession while the heart remains unregenerate and the defect in the heart unseen, and his confidence comes from seeing only outward obedience. What he still lacks is the law written in mind and heart and brought home to the conscience to see the exceeding sinfulness of sin, unto death to self and crucifixion of self, without which spiritual holiness cannot be known and readiness for the kingdom and for the coming of the Lord is impossible. He needs a humble, contrite heart that recognizes the supreme love owed to God and its own lack, surrenders supreme love of self, finds its perfection in Christ, and is sanctified for God's use and service. He needs to accept Christ as Saviour and receive His righteousness, with divine power joined to human effort to obey God's law, for faith does not permit breaking the law.
Warning for Today
The young ruler pictures the condition of many Sabbath-keepers and professed believers who seek eternal life while confident they are perfect and lacking nothing when they are far from perfection. Like him they cherish idols that will shut them out of heaven, and if told to sell all and give to the poor they would go away sorrowful, choosing to keep riches rather than part with them to secure treasure in heaven. His claim to have kept from youth the duties toward neighbor exposes the same lack, for supreme love of riches as an idol makes it impossible to love God with all heart, soul and mind and shuts the eyes to the wants of fellow men.
He stands for a large class who, when duty is brought to bear upon them, see a cross to be lifted. Earthly treasures hold them back from obeying God, which is why few obey. His self-deception about having kept all the commandments is repeated by many who become sorrowful when the duty of keeping the Sabbath is pointed out to them because they are not willing to lift the cross and follow Christ in self-denial with wholehearted love to God.
His sorrowful turning away is repeated by those who, when God's work calls for their property, hold on to earthly goods rather than sacrifice to support its messengers, carry saving present truth to others, and feed hungry seekers in spiritual need. Holding wealth back leaves those needs unmet and fails to lay up treasure in heaven. Possessions thus withheld from God's work may soon be swept away by coming destruction, leaving it forever too late to sacrifice earthly goods and store treasure in heaven.
Riches must not be loved better than fellow men, better than God, or better than truth, for then eternal life cannot be had. They must be held as not one's own and faithfully discharged as God's stewardship, distributed to bless the needy and to advance God's cause, turned toward good works and used as lent for God's glory. When love to God so far surpasses love of riches, truth set home to the heart by the Spirit crowds out love of riches, affections are transferred to God, and the possessor finds highest pleasure in right disposition of the Lord's goods and ministering to the wants of His cause; then the first four commandments and the last six can be kept. Outward keeping alone does not reach the heart, for attachment to earthly riches can eclipse love for neighbor and the eternal inheritance, and discipleship is tested by willingness to give to the poor, take up the cross and follow.
The verse warns against self-deception when truth is not sought earnestly, for worldly cares, riches and other desires can choke the word, leave life without fruit, and let understanding of important truths fade until in darkness. Wanting everlasting life is not enough while unwilling to sacrifice, as shown also by the aged who would accept eternal life but not at cost to themselves. The choice weighs Christ against the world, and a person cannot hold riches as the heart's highest love and also possess treasure in heaven.
The speaker is a rich young ruler who professes to have kept the duties to others from his youth up and earnestly asks what he still lacks for eternal life. His claim is confident but self-deceived, for his outward blameless life is mistaken for true keeping while he does not grasp the depth of the law in mind and heart. What he lacks is exposed by his great possessions, for supreme love of riches rules his heart over love to God and to his neighbor, leaving him without the love that is the spirit and life of the commandments. Christ tests him by calling him to sell what he has, give to the poor, gain treasure in heaven and follow, but he goes away sorrowful, choosing seen earthly treasure over unseen heavenly treasure and fellowship with Christ. His case pictures many professed believers today who think themselves perfect and without lack yet cling to idols and turn sorrowful when self-denial, right use of wealth for the needy, and sacrifice for God's cause are required.
Speaker and Context
The one who speaks is a rich young ruler in Israel who comes to Christ as a teacher by whom he is willing to be taught. He has watched Christ's compassion for the poor and ignorant and has been touched and drawn by His meekness and lowliness of heart, attracted and charmed by His life and teaching. He is a man of pleasing appearance, outward piety, high capabilities and sincere desire, capable of great blessing and qualified for service, not ignorant of duty to God and convinced that obedience brings a place of happiness. He fully desires to be as Christ is and to work out a perfect character fit to live eternally with God, yet he still needs to give himself fully to Christ in heart devotion and love to God, with supreme love of self surrendered before his character can be sanctified for God's use.
The exchange concerns how to gain eternal life, and he is directed to keep God's commandments as obedience to principles expressing God's character and requiring harmony with Him. The commandments named to him are duties to other people, against murder, adultery, theft and false witness, with honor to father and mother and love to neighbor as self. The first four commandments containing duty to God are not named to him at first, and obedience is presented as necessary for eternal life. His profession of having kept all these things from his youth up draws Christ's call to be perfect by selling what he has, giving to the poor, gaining treasure in heaven, and coming to follow Him, a saying he hears and then goes away sorrowful because he has great possessions.
His reply claims to have kept all these things from his youth up and honestly asks what he still lacks in order to gain eternal life. The question is earnest and comes from high motives but imperfect understanding, moved by conviction at seeing Christ's love and self-denial. By human standards his outward life is blameless, yet he fears that all is not right between him and God, remaining dissatisfied with inward unease and sensing that something is still missing. His claim reflects a high estimate of his own righteousness rather than a sense of defectiveness, with an external and superficial understanding of the law, and he hopes Jesus can satisfy the need he still feels and complete a character that profession alone has not made complete.
Meaning of His Claim
The claim is made with full confidence in personal fidelity and righteousness, as one who thinks himself perfect, blameless, and lacking nothing. By human measurement his outward life is blameless, amiable, and willing to do good, and having been flattered for those traits he flatters himself that integrity in dealing with fellow men fulfills the law. That confidence conceals a fatal deficiency of character, for the sense of security is false while possessions are cherished as idols of greater value than eternal life. His attachment to earthly wealth when told to sell, give to the poor, and follow exposes the limits of his obedience and his unwillingness to obey fully.
The claim is false and self-deceived, for he supposes he has kept all the commandments from his youth but has not truly kept them and does not understand their depth and significance. His profession of obedience does not mean his character is complete, his heart is right, or he is ready to follow in self-denial. His supreme love of wealth keeps him from loving God with whole heart and neighbor as himself, so he fails to keep the commandments while thinking himself fit for eternal life. His question about what he still lacks itself reveals a real lack and weakness, showing he is not a true lover of God and needs to accept righteousness joined with divine power to human effort, which never permits breaking the law. The same deception is taught as holding where wealth is withheld from those in need and possessions are prized more than the Giver, leaving love to God and neighbor unfulfilled.
He mistakes outward integrity and amiable character for spiritual perfection, resting on outward propriety of conduct and profession of truth while the heart remains unregenerate. No human standard of propriety, profession, or letter of the law can save a soul from death, as seen in the same spiritual state as Paul when blameless touching the letter; God's standard must be seen, acknowledged, and followed. What is still lacking is the law written in mind and heart and brought home to the conscience to see the exceeding sinfulness of sin, unto death to self and crucifixion of self, without which spiritual holiness cannot be known and readiness for the kingdom is impossible. If he had understood through the commandment that he was sinful, as Paul did, and obeyed in spirit and truth, the law would have exposed and slain his sinful nature and he would have laid hold of eternal life. His refusal when tested to deny self, take up the cross, and follow proves disobedience, for keeping the whole law yet offending in one point is guilt of all.
Outward commandment-keeping can thus coexist with a cherished inward defect and a heart not made whole. Legal obedience had not fully entered his life and character, and he was unwilling to give all he had and all he was. Selfishness and covetousness are exposed as the plague-spot in his character, showing that outward obedience had not made his heart whole. The same self-righteous spirit appears in Judas, who appeared righteous yet neglected his own character and failed to live the words spoken to him.
Lack That Remained
What he still lacked was laid bare by his great possessions, for his supreme love of riches was his idol swallowing up his heart in earthly treasure. That idol stood in the way of loving God with whole heart and soul and mind, of following Christ in self-denial, of appreciating and receiving Christ, and of bearing the cross. Though he claimed to have kept the commandments from his youth and asked what was still wanting, outward obedience had not removed this governing attachment, and his sorrow showed he would not surrender riches to follow Jesus. He did not love his neighbor as himself because he kept his wealth rather than using entrusted wealth to help the poor and needy, and that same attachment kept him from loving God fully. Christ's invitation required giving up visible earthly treasure for unseen heavenly treasure, but he valued reputation and possessions more than fellowship with Christ and eternal life, so he turned away.
Because riches ruled him he failed both tables of the law. He failed the first four commandments containing duty to God by not loving God supremely, since supreme love of riches made it impossible to love God with all heart, soul and mind. He failed the last six by not loving his neighbor as himself, shutting his eyes to the wants of fellow men and withholding wealth from those in need instead of caring unselfishly for others, especially those in greatest danger and need. A profession of love for God without such love for one's brother is not genuine, and thinking he had kept the last six did not mean he had fulfilled their true demands. The call to sell and give to the poor proved how much God and truth were loved, testing whether he prized eternal life higher than riches.
What was missing was love, which is the spirit and life of the commandments. Self-love and worldly gain ruled his heart, making him a transgressor of the law and out of harmony with heaven's principles. He lacked the spirit of love and self-sacrifice that is the touchstone of character and the test applied at the final judgment. Keeping the commandments cannot be separated from love for others, so his refusal to give his possessions to the poor and follow Jesus disproved his claim and exposed a defect in character.
He loved his possessions more than eternal life, more than God, more than heavenly treasure, and more than fellowship with Christ. Though willing to keep the commandments and desiring eternal life and a perfect character, he wanted heavenly treasure and also the temporal advantages of riches. He desired eternal life but was unwilling to make the sacrifice, judging heaven to cost too much and counting giving up seen earthly treasure for unseen heavenly treasure too great a risk. His desire was chilled when required to give to the poor, he refused the offer of eternal life, renounced immortal life, and chose earthly treasure over eternal reward. He went away sorrowful because he had great possessions and gave his worship ever after to the world.
The inward plague-spot was supreme selfishness and covetousness. Self-love was supreme with him, concealing a fatal deficiency of character beneath confident claims to have kept all from his youth. He had a close and covetous heart that could tithe mint and rue and other small things while neglecting the weightier matters, proving lack of the true spirit of sacrifice acceptable to God. He loved God's gifts more than their Giver, loved his possessions above God and His service and more than the souls of his fellow men, so riches were his idol and the world held first place in his affections.
Christ's Test and Outcome
To his question what he still lacked, the answer is to be perfect by selling what he has, giving to the poor, gaining treasure in heaven, and coming to follow Christ. Entering life is conditional, and outward keeping of the commandments named to him does not meet his need. His profession of having kept them from his youth does not make him perfect or prove he has passed the test, for making these sacrifices is receiving the bread of life until Christ becomes the life-giving current within the soul.
The command exposes his idol and tests how much higher he prizes eternal life than riches and how much God and truth are loved. It points to undone duties plainly specified in the law, to love God supremely and to love his neighbor as himself by using entrusted wealth to help the poor and needy in their wants and greatest danger and need. His supreme love of riches has swallowed up his heart in earthly treasure, shut his eyes to fellow men, made it impossible to love God with all heart, soul, and mind, and therefore is both his failure in the first four commandments and his failure truly to keep the last six. Outward obedience without self-surrender and love in action is not enough, for truth set home by the Spirit crowds out love of riches, since love of Jesus and riches cannot dwell in the same heart.
He hears the saying and goes away sorrowful because he has great possessions. His desire is chilled and his sorrow shows he will not remove the obstacle, surrender his riches, or accept the condition of discipleship. He values his riches more than heavenly treasure, wants both the heavenly treasure and the temporal advantages of riches, counts giving up seen earthly treasure for unseen heavenly treasure too great a risk, refuses the offer of eternal life, and gives his worship ever after to the world.
Jesus invites him without compelling his choice. Yet obeying Christ's words is his only hope of salvation and of attaining a complete Christian character. Following Christ requires complete obedience and self-surrender, giving up whatever would corrupt the whole person and compete with God for the affections, whether much or little, even when the sacrifice seems great. His legal obedience has not fully entered his life and character, for he is unwilling to give Christ all he had and all he was, and keeping anything back diminishes moral strength and ability to do good until cherished worldly things take over the heart.
His refusal when tested proves disobedience, for keeping the whole law yet offending in one point is guilt of all. His claim is only outward propriety of conduct and profession while the heart remains unregenerate and the defect in the heart unseen, and his confidence comes from seeing only outward obedience. What he still lacks is the law written in mind and heart and brought home to the conscience to see the exceeding sinfulness of sin, unto death to self and crucifixion of self, without which spiritual holiness cannot be known and readiness for the kingdom and for the coming of the Lord is impossible. He needs a humble, contrite heart that recognizes the supreme love owed to God and its own lack, surrenders supreme love of self, finds its perfection in Christ, and is sanctified for God's use and service. He needs to accept Christ as Saviour and receive His righteousness, with divine power joined to human effort to obey God's law, for faith does not permit breaking the law.
Warning for Today
The young ruler pictures the condition of many Sabbath-keepers and professed believers who seek eternal life while confident they are perfect and lacking nothing when they are far from perfection. Like him they cherish idols that will shut them out of heaven, and if told to sell all and give to the poor they would go away sorrowful, choosing to keep riches rather than part with them to secure treasure in heaven. His claim to have kept from youth the duties toward neighbor exposes the same lack, for supreme love of riches as an idol makes it impossible to love God with all heart, soul and mind and shuts the eyes to the wants of fellow men.
He stands for a large class who, when duty is brought to bear upon them, see a cross to be lifted. Earthly treasures hold them back from obeying God, which is why few obey. His self-deception about having kept all the commandments is repeated by many who become sorrowful when the duty of keeping the Sabbath is pointed out to them because they are not willing to lift the cross and follow Christ in self-denial with wholehearted love to God.
His sorrowful turning away is repeated by those who, when God's work calls for their property, hold on to earthly goods rather than sacrifice to support its messengers, carry saving present truth to others, and feed hungry seekers in spiritual need. Holding wealth back leaves those needs unmet and fails to lay up treasure in heaven. Possessions thus withheld from God's work may soon be swept away by coming destruction, leaving it forever too late to sacrifice earthly goods and store treasure in heaven.
Riches must not be loved better than fellow men, better than God, or better than truth, for then eternal life cannot be had. They must be held as not one's own and faithfully discharged as God's stewardship, distributed to bless the needy and to advance God's cause, turned toward good works and used as lent for God's glory. When love to God so far surpasses love of riches, truth set home to the heart by the Spirit crowds out love of riches, affections are transferred to God, and the possessor finds highest pleasure in right disposition of the Lord's goods and ministering to the wants of His cause; then the first four commandments and the last six can be kept. Outward keeping alone does not reach the heart, for attachment to earthly riches can eclipse love for neighbor and the eternal inheritance, and discipleship is tested by willingness to give to the poor, take up the cross and follow.
The verse warns against self-deception when truth is not sought earnestly, for worldly cares, riches and other desires can choke the word, leave life without fruit, and let understanding of important truths fade until in darkness. Wanting everlasting life is not enough while unwilling to sacrifice, as shown also by the aged who would accept eternal life but not at cost to themselves. The choice weighs Christ against the world, and a person cannot hold riches as the heart's highest love and also possess treasure in heaven.