Matthew 23:18
And, Whosoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whosoever sweareth by the gift that is upon it, he is guilty.
Translations
And, Whoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whoever swears by the gift that is on it, he is guilty.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And, Whosoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whosoever sweareth by the gift that is upon it, he is guilty.
And whoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whoever sweareth by the gift that is upon it, he is guilty.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And, Whosoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whosoever shall swear by the gift that is upon it, he is a debtor.
'And, whoever may swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whoever may swear by the gift that is upon it — is debtor!
And, Whosoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whosoever shall swear by the gift that is upon it is a debtor.
And, whosoever shall swear by the altar, it is, nothing, but, whosoever shall swear by the gift that is upon it, is bound:
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And you say, ‘ If anyone swears by the altar, it means nothing; but if anyone swears by the gift on it, he is bound by his oath.’
And, ‘ Whoever swears by the altar, it is nothing; but whoever swears by the gift that is on it, he is obligated.’
And, Whoever takes an oath by the altar, it is nothing; but whoever takes an oath by the offering which is on it, he is responsible.
And whosoeuer sweareth by the altar, it is nothing: but whosoeuer sweareth by the offering that is vpon it, offendeth.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And whosoever shall swear by the altar, it is nothing; but whosoever shall swear by the gift that is upon it, is a debtor.
Cross-references
- Matthew 5:34-37
But I say unto you, Swear not at all; neither by heaven; for it is God’s throne:
Both forbid swearing by sacred or created things and call for truthful speech.
- James 5:12
But above all things, my brethren, swear not, neither by heaven, neither by the earth, neither by any other oath: but let your yea be yea; and your nay, nay; lest ye fall into condemnation.
Both forbid swearing oaths by things or under extra bonds.
- Exodus 29:37
Seven days thou shalt make an atonement for the altar, and sanctify it; and it shall be an altar most holy: whatsoever toucheth the altar shall be holy.
Cited for offerings described as most holy.
- Numbers 30:2
If a man vow a vow unto the LORD, or swear an oath to bind his soul with a bond; he shall not break his word, he shall do according to all that proceedeth out of his mouth.
Both texts describe oaths as binding obligations.
- Ecclesiastes 5:4
When thou vowest a vow unto God, defer not to pay it; for he hath no pleasure in fools: pay that which thou hast vowed.
Warns against rash vows and urges their fulfillment.
- Deuteronomy 23:23
That which is gone out of thy lips thou shalt keep and perform; even a freewill offering, according as thou hast vowed unto the LORD thy God, which thou hast promised with thy mouth.
Commands keeping what has been vowed.
- Matthew 5:17-28
Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.
shows law magnified pure and heart-searching
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
30 sources
Christ exposed a rule of the scribes and Pharisees that made swearing by the altar empty and unbinding, while swearing by the offering upon it was binding and left the swearer guilty.3SP 61.1ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2 That rule turned the truth upside down, for the altar is greater than the gift because the altar gives sacredness to the gift.ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2ST May 2, 1878 The saying lays bare their spiritual blindness in straining over fine distinctions while missing what matters most, being exact over trifles yet neglecting judgment, mercy, faith and the love of God.7MR 234.4–235.1Lt 165, 1901, par. 11–147MR 235.2–3Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14 Such hypocrisy that cloaks wrong under a show of godliness is more dangerous than open sin and brings the severer judgment.CH 671.25T 144.2 The rebuke stands as a warning beyond that generation against letting human authority rule the conscience, calling all in sacred trust to repent of unjust dealing and to let Scripture rather than priestly claims be the guide.4SP 414.3GC 596.2GC88 595.3–596.1Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 71a, 1894, par. 19–21
The Altar and the Gift
The rule condemned here held that taking an oath in the name of the altar carried no force and left a person free from obligation, while taking an oath in the name of the gift or offering laid upon it created a binding obligation that made the oath-breaker guilty.3SP 61.1ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2ST May 2, 1878Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14 The priests applied this as their own narrow, false standard of guilt, by which they excused vows and even serious offenses and serious crimes when money or large sums were paid, yet judged others harshly and with severe condemnation for trivial, lesser, and lesser-comparable faults.3SP 61.1ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2ST May 2, 1878Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14 In this way religious rules, forms, outward services, ceremonies, and human authority were made to evade the true weight of what is sacred, while pride and self-seeking displaced humble obedience and a life faithful to God.ST Mar 21, 1878Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 81, 1896, par. 6–8 The same blindness made leaders scrupulous about little matters and ready to make a man an offender for a word, while dealing unjustly, tampering with conscience, and lightly passing over very serious wrongs.Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 81, 1896, par. 6–8
That distinction reversed the true order, for the altar is greater than the gift because the altar is what sanctifies the gift.ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2ST May 2, 1878 Their rules therefore distorted the proper standard of guilt by treating as inconsequential what was greater and as binding what derived its sacredness from the greater.ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2ST May 2, 1878
These words belong to Jesus' final day of teaching in the temple and in the temple courts, when He exposed the character of the rulers and elders and the hypocrisy of the Pharisees and lawyers.3SP 57.1Ms 81, 1893, par. 43 That exposure was given to free the people from customs, traditions, and unquestioning trust in a corrupt priesthood, and His teaching was intended to reach people across ages and nations.3SP 57.1
The saying stands within His denunciation of the scribes and Pharisees as hypocrites and blind guides.Ms 5, 1882, par. 14–16Ms 5, 1882, par. 12–13 They pretended to godliness and professed piety while rejecting the light He brought and violating God's law, and their conduct brought unsparing divine rebuke and retribution upon false piety and hypocrisy.Ms 5, 1882, par. 14–16Ms 5, 1882, par. 12–13
Blindness and Hypocrisy Condemned
The chapter is a portrait of spiritual blindness, in which religious leaders strain over minor distinctions while failing to recognize what matters most and the relative weight of things they ought to understand.7MR 234.4–235.1Lt 165, 1901, par. 11–14 That blindness is the failure to see the relative importance of sacred things, giving undue importance to lesser religious concerns while neglecting judgment, mercy and faith.7MR 234.4–235.1Lt 165, 1901, par. 11–14
It made men very scrupulous about little matters, making a man an offender for a word through subtle, imaginary distinctions between degrees of guilt, as when swearing by the altar was counted as nothing and swearing by the gift upon it was counted as binding.7MR 234.4–235.17MR 235.2–3Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14 It was a distorted sense of right and wrong that condemned minor faults with great severity while lightly passing over very serious wrongs, neglecting justice, mercy and the love of God, failing to give practical evidence of love for brethren, dealing unjustly, tampering with conscience, and working false principles.7MR 235.2–3Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14 The priests set their own narrow standard of guilt by that rule, excusing vows and serious offenses for money and judging others harshly for trivial matters.3SP 61.1ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2 They judged different sins unequally, excused vows in exchange for money and sometimes overlooked serious crimes when offenders paid large sums, while imposing severe judgment for lesser and trivial offenses and rigorously enforcing ceremonies.3SP 61.1ST Mar 21, 1878DA 616.2ST May 2, 1878
Religious rules, outward services and ceremonies cannot replace obedience and a life faithful to God.ST Mar 21, 1878 Forms and human authority were used to evade the true weight of what is sacred, while pride and self-seeking displaced humble obedience.ST Mar 21, 1878Lt 81, 1896, par. 6–8 The words spoken against this were a fearless exposure of hypocrisy and dishonest religious practice and fraud, showing holy authority in defense of pure principles.ST Apr 5, 1905 They express hatred of all vain pretense and heavy denunciation of hypocrisy.4T 614.4
The rebuke falls on those who profess to have light far in advance of others while their works do not correspond with their profession and they do not feel its sanctifying influence, for neglect to improve granted light and opportunities leaves men and women in darkness.4T 614.4 Those who have spent life in sin but come to God in penitence with a sense of sinfulness are accepted with tenderness, even though they have been the chief of sinners, and are in a more favorable position for perfection of Christian character than those who have had great light and failed to improve upon it.4T 614.4 Religious hypocrisy is more dangerous than open sin because it cloaks wrongdoing in godliness, so practicing sin under the appearance of godliness brings especially severe judgment and there is more hope for an open sinner than for a hypocrite.CH 671.25T 144.2
The denunciation exposes hypocrisy and self-deception in those who stress God's mercy while overlooking His warnings against sin.ST Jan 6, 1881 It shows that impenitent religious leaders who oppose truth and righteousness face rebuke.Ms 175, 1897, par. 81 Those who reject reproof and continue in an exacting, intolerant spirit face judgment.Ms 18, 1896, par. 29–30 That condemnation shows that distorted judgments and gross sins deserved righteous indignation.ST May 2, 1878
Warning to Later Generations
Christ's denunciation of the scribes and Pharisees and his warning against following blind leaders expose the danger of human authority claiming power over conscience.4SP 414.3GC 596.2GC88 595.3–596.1 That warning was not limited to his own time but serves as an admonition to future generations beyond the dispersion of the Jews.4SP 414.3GC 596.2GC88 595.3–596.1 It shows how priests could turn lawful authority to unlawful ends, so that Scripture rather than priestly authority must be the guide for conscience.GC 596.2GC 102.1
Neglecting God's light and warnings leaves people in a worse position than those on whom these woes were pronounced.TBC1882 58.1 The condemnation that fell for self-righteous rejection of his counsel and despising of his mercies applies to those who claim to represent Christ while their lives deny him.3SP 9.2 It applies where selfishness and love of money and worldly honor are allowed to rule the heart.TBC1882 58.13SP 9.2
The denunciation and woes fell for misrepresenting righteousness, dealing unjustly, tampering with conscience, and cherishing and working false principles from an overbearing and imperious lack of principle.Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 71a, 1894, par. 19–21 They will verily fall on all in sacred positions of trust engaged in a like work unless they repent and their characters are reformed.Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 71a, 1894, par. 19–21 For righteousness exalts individuals as well as nations, while sin brings them to ruin.Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14 Professed representatives of Christ must therefore show his mercy, tenderness, forbearance, and love, since people judge Christ by their example.Lt 134, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 71a, 1894, par. 19–21
The same Pharisaism that treats religious rules with narrow precision while missing their deeper purpose is found in those who use their authority to restrict the spread of truth and hinder God's work.RCOC 35.3 Christ met such false claims to righteousness and sanctity with burning earnestness and words of terrible severity in denouncing the abominations he saw in the church and in the world, refusing to let the people be deceived.15MR 258.2–259.1 That example requires Christian missionaries and physicians to stand in God-given manhood, exercising freedom of speech and freedom of faith.15MR 258.2–259.1 They are to refuse to harmonize with the wrong plans of a fellow laborer, to refuse to be cowered into silence by a masterful spirit, to refuse to verify statements they know are not true, and to refuse to be held speechless by any binding influence when wrong sentiments are expressed.15MR 258.2–259.1 Instead they are to protest and correct false statements rather than do great harm and injury by listening without protest.15MR 258.2–259.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
47 sources
The rule condemned here allowed a person to swear by the altar without obligation, while swearing by the offering upon it bound him as guilty and indebted to perform his vow.ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859ST May 19, 1914 That distinction is false and blind, because the altar is greater than the gift, giving the offering all its sanctity, so an oath by the altar necessarily includes what is upon it.ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859RH May 29, 1855 It was a human tradition that trifled with God's commands and made His word of no effect, straining over outward punctilios while neglecting character and the weightier matters of the law.ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jan 9, 1893ST May 17, 1910 The saying belongs to the sevenfold woe pronounced upon the hypocritical scribes and Pharisees for misinterpreting Scripture and rejecting God's messenger.ST Jan 6, 1887RH Apr 15, 1909RH Apr 15, 1909 In it Christ fearlessly exposed a piety that concealed pride, covetousness and corruption of heart, controlling the faith of others while leading them to ruin.ST May 19, 1914RH Jun 2, 1859ST Nov 1, 1899
False Distinction About Oaths
The verse lays bare a rule of the teachers that an oath sworn by the altar is nothing and carries no obligation, while an oath sworn by the gift or offering placed upon it makes the swearer guilty, indebted and bound to perform it.ST Mar 21, 1878ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859ST May 19, 1914RH May 29, 1855 The altar is not empty when such an oath is taken, because the altar sanctifies the gift and the offering has no sanctity apart from it, so a man is just as much bound when he has sworn by the altar as when he has sworn by the gift.ST Mar 21, 1878ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859RH May 29, 1855ST Nov 1, 1899 Gift and altar, like temple and gold, are alike important, and an oath by the altar also involves what is upon it and must not be treated as void.ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859RH May 29, 1855ST Nov 1, 1899 The same vain reasoning appears when affirming under or by the pains and penalties of perjury is said to be nothing and not swearing because the term swear is not used in the ceremony, yet the word translated swear means being put under extra bonds to tell the truth, so any ceremony involving a penalty is swearing by that penalty.RH May 29, 1855
The distinction is blind and false, a trifling with the high commands of God by human tradition that made the word of God of none effect.ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jan 9, 1893 It pretended to teach God's law while failing to keep it, adding traditions until the law was stripped of its force, and it judged outward details without regard to character.ST Jan 9, 1893ST May 17, 1910 It strained over minor punctilios of tradition while neglecting the weightier matters of the law, showing a law exceeding broad and deep that searches even the thoughts and intents of the heart.ST Jan 9, 1893ST May 17, 1910
The verse belongs to common oaths made by sacred things, including the altar, the temple and the sacrifices.RH Oct 7, 1858 It illustrates the traditions about binding vows and the kind of oath that required a promise to be performed, rather than an oath taken in court.RH Apr 7, 1859
Altar Greater Than Gift
The altar is greater than the gift because the altar sanctifies the gift, and the gift has no sanctity apart from the altar that makes it holy.ST Mar 21, 1878ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jan 26, 1882 The rule that an oath by the altar is nothing and carries no obligation, while an oath by the gift upon it makes the swearer guilty, indebted and bound, is therefore blind and false.ST Mar 21, 1878ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859RH May 29, 1855ST Jan 26, 1882 A man is just as much bound when he has sworn by the altar as when he has sworn by the gift, for the gift is no greater than the altar that sanctifies it.ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859RH May 29, 1855ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jan 26, 1882 Gift and altar are alike important, as temple and gold are alike important, so an oath by the altar also involves what is upon it and must not be treated as empty.ST Nov 1, 1899RH Apr 7, 1859RH May 29, 1855ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jan 26, 1882 To value the gift on the altar above the altar itself puts outward wealth above sacred meaning, treating gold and silver as more important than what they adorn.ST May 14, 1902 Placing greater importance on the ritual gift than on the altar reflects blindness to the difference between temporary ceremonial forms and shadowy ritual and the enduring moral obligations and lasting demands of God's law.RH Jun 15, 1911
Setting in Final Rebuke
The verse stands within the seven woes pronounced against the hypocritical scribes and Pharisees, declaring their complete condemnation for misinterpreting Scripture and rejecting God's messenger.ST Jan 6, 1887RH Apr 15, 1909 It belongs to the sevenfold woe spoken upon the generation then living.RH Apr 15, 1909 The rebuke was spoken to the multitude in the presence of the disciples as a reproof of the scribes and Pharisees for their sins.ST Jan 14, 1875RH Dec 20, 1870 It came before declaring the doom of the Jews, Jerusalem with their city, and the temple, after which he departed from the temple, leading to the disciples pointing to the temple buildings.ST Jan 14, 1875RH Dec 20, 1870 Those woes concerned that generation and were to reach their climax in Jerusalem's destruction and the end of the Jewish nation, which stands as a crisis paralleling the end of the world.RH Apr 15, 1909RH Apr 15, 1909
The denunciation was uttered without sinful passion or revenge and expressed the judgment of the Eternal Judge.ST Nov 1, 1899 It was not spoken in anger, for even while condemning sin and opposing the evil principle upheld, there was pity for sinners and a seeking to draw them to himself. It was a denunciation against the teachers and responsible men of the nation that almost broke his heart.ST Sep 3, 1912
The rebuke was addressed to those who had made a public covenant with God but violated it in letter and spirit through intolerant self-righteousness. It fell upon religious leaders who knew God's revealed will yet degraded their spiritual privilege to serve personal ambition and greed.ST Jan 8, 1885
Hypocrisy and Empty Religion
Christ's words belong to his fearless exposure of hypocrisy, pride, covetousness and social arrogance among the religious leaders.ST Apr 5, 1905ST May 19, 1914RH Jun 2, 1859 Their piety concealed corruption of heart and dishonest practice while they presented themselves outwardly as God's servants, and concealed a desire to control the faith and worship of others.ST Apr 5, 1905ST May 19, 1914ST Nov 1, 1899 Such hypocrisy misleads others to ruin, and its exposure was spoken with holy authority in defense of pure principle against religious fraud.ST Apr 5, 1905ST Nov 1, 1899 It was a rebuke that those unwilling to hear his precepts would reject him for giving.RH May 7, 1901RH Jun 6, 1871
In condemning them he magnified the law in all its purity, showing it to be exceeding broad and deep and to search out the very thoughts and intents of the heart.ST Jan 9, 1893 He showed that he came to die because the law had been broken, stripping off the traditions and commands of men to leave God's law as it was given.ST Jan 9, 1893 The chapter shows that religious form, profession and extensive activity do not guarantee vital godliness, for truth could be preserved in form while personal piety was lacking and denominational activity did not prevent individual spiritual decline.RH Jul 13, 1916ST Sep 15, 1887 What people truly believe is shown by how they live, and outward religious service does not please God.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Oct 3, 1895
Religious rules and outward services cannot replace obedience and a life faithful to God.ST Mar 21, 1878 Righteousness that begins outwardly and is governed only by the letter of the law is hypocrisy, and laws compelling outward observance of religious institutions only make hypocrites instead of producing the holiness of heart, motive and life that God requires for true Sabbath-keeping.ST Oct 3, 1895 Their handling of vows belonged to excusing serious wrongdoing for money while rigorously enforcing ceremonies, judging sins unequally and excusing vows in exchange for money.ST Mar 21, 1878ST May 2, 1878 They could overlook serious crimes when offenders paid large sums while condemning others for trivial offenses.ST May 2, 1878
The same hypocrisy boasted of good works while laying heavy burdens grievous to be borne on others in ceremonial exactions, numerous fastings and ablutions and detailed rules.ST Nov 15, 1910ST May 19, 1881RH Oct 7, 1902 Those rules could preserve outward forms while separating religion from morality and its spirit, covering inward sins and selfishness with a cloak.ST Nov 15, 1910ST May 19, 1881RH Oct 7, 1902 Departure from God's plan to substitute the human became ever more manifest in centuries of apostasy, under which influence conscience soon becomes hard and speechless.ST Nov 15, 1910 Jesus uttered stronger denunciations against the formal Pharisees than against any other class for being punctilious about the conduct of others.ST Oct 3, 1895
The teachers are called blind leaders of the blind whose followers will fall into the ditch with them, hypocrites, fools, vipers, children of hell, full of hypocrisy and iniquity.ST Jan 9, 1893 They had a zeal for God but not according to knowledge, and that lack kept them ignorant of God's righteousness.ST Jul 15, 1908 Not having God's righteousness they sought to establish their own apparent righteousness, trying to make it appear that they were righteous when in reality they were not, and that effort to appear righteous is hypocrisy.ST Jul 15, 1908 They could be sincere in their religion yet be false professors who regarded themselves as righteous while remaining inwardly unclean, an example of self-deception about one's spiritual state.RH Sep 2, 1858 That denunciation of hypocrisy and self-deception is what those who stress God's mercy while overlooking his warnings against sin fail to heed.ST Jan 6, 1881
Their conduct as hypocrites and formalists stands contrasted with Christ's character.ST Jan 27, 1904 His words of woe are part of his testimony teaching what people should do and say and the way to eternal life.RH Apr 17, 1855
Oaths and Moral Application
Swearing by sacred things calls God to witness the truth of what is stated or promised, a vow so made must be carried out, and to swear falsely is perjury.ST Jan 26, 1882 The passage forbids swearing by heaven, by earth, or by any other oath, requiring instead that yes mean yes and no mean no.RH Jul 31, 1856 Applied to civil office, the oath demanded at inauguration makes the officer a breaker of God's law, so that even to elect a good bishop, deacon, or pious church member to office necessarily makes a bad man of him.RH Jul 31, 1856
The word rendered swear means to be placed under added bonds to tell the truth, so that affirming under or by the pains and penalties of perjury is no different from swearing, and any ceremony carrying a penalty is swearing by that penalty.RH May 29, 1855 All are already bound by moral principle to speak truth, there is no virtue in speaking truth merely because bound by an oath to do it, and the whole system of oath-taking rests on the implication that the precept against bearing false witness written upon human hearts is not enough to restrain falsehood.RH May 29, 1855 Fine, casuistical distinctions about oaths let people profess to bind themselves while believing they remained free.ST Jan 26, 1882 Such casuistry encouraged irreverence, practical perjury and impiety, weakened moral obligation and religious character, and endangered private virtue and public trust, especially through frequent, unauthorized oath-taking.ST Jan 26, 1882ST Jan 26, 1882
The warning reaches professed followers who keep the forms of religion but lack its living power, who deceive themselves and incur the judgment they pronounce upon hypocrites.ST Jan 29, 1908 His example in condemning hypocrites shows that preaching should include direct, searching words that can make hearers tremble, rather than hiding rebuke to protect influence or keep hearers comfortable, yet it does not warrant condemning others indiscriminately.RH Jul 29, 1875RH Oct 22, 1914 His censures display an unbroken course of controversy from the beginning of His public work in the synagogue at Nazareth until His death, falling not only on false doctrine and false principles but on the holders, supporters, and promoters of them.ST Apr 1, 1889ST May 27, 1913
The rebuke of the scribes and Pharisees concerns their religious conduct and relation to God as sinners marked by pride and hypocrisy, not their crimes, and their social respectability did not make them right before God.ST Oct 7, 1930 It is not a call for clergy to use pulpits to denounce or direct civic affairs.ST Oct 7, 1930 Sabbath observance enforced where the heart rebels offers the essence of hypocrisy, a contemptible sin, and laws compelling outward observance of religious institutions only make hypocrites instead of producing the holiness of heart, motive, and life required for true Sabbath-keeping.ST Dec 25, 1893ST Oct 3, 1895 Such enforcement brings two evils, that the world ceases to believe in the power of the Holy Spirit because the church fails to use it, and that world and church are plunged more deeply into sin by appealing for help against evil to its very source.ST Dec 25, 1893
Sources