Matthew 24:29
Immediately after the tribulation of those days shall the sun be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken:
Immediately after the tribulation of those days shall the sun be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken:
Commentary part 2 of 3
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Stars Falling Fulfilled
The falling of the stars means a literal shower of fiery meteors or shooting stars in great numbers, not the fall of fixed stars or planets whose descent would destroy the earth before it could be observed as a sign.ST Jan 8, 1880GSAM 96.1–2RH Mar 23, 1916RH Jun 23, 1863ST Mar 27, 1893 The modern distinction between stars and meteors does not alter the wording, because the smaller lights of heaven were called stars in ancient usage.ST Jan 8, 1880ST Dec 11, 1879 In common sense the term means meteors and shooting stars, not great suns a thousand times larger than the earth, which could not fall in numbers without destroying it.RH Dec 8, 1874RH Aug 1, 1865ST Mar 24, 1914ST Mar 24, 1881RH May 16, 1871 The ancients understood the word translated star to include a meteor, as with the star that went before the wise men to Bethlehem, and the Bible uses stars as a general term for heavenly bodies other than sun and moon.RH Dec 8, 1874RH Aug 1, 1865RH May 16, 1871 The Greek word aster includes the smaller lights of heaven, and the periodic November stream was observed to diminish by 1870, showing exhaustion.ST Mar 24, 1881RH May 16, 1871
They appeared to fall, though they did not literally fall from heaven, and even if the 1833 lights had originated within the atmosphere their small size would not prevent literal fulfillment, since the star guiding the wise men was small enough to indicate a particular house.ST Dec 11, 1879RH Oct 29, 1901ST Aug 8, 1916ST Jul 23, 1912ST Jun 7, 1905 The display matched the image of unripe figs cast from a tree shaken by a mighty wind, with meteors swiftly falling in every direction, each toward its own side of the sky.RH Jan 11, 1870RH Aug 11, 1853RH Oct 28, 1852ST Jul 31, 1884 They seemed to fall in different directions from a single point, some crossing one another's paths, and the event was a celestial phenomenon and display of divine power in which the atmosphere protected the earth, showing preserving care.RH Aug 11, 1853RH Jul 22, 1915ST Mar 24, 1881
The sign was fulfilled at least once by the great widespread shower of November 13, 1833, also dated November 12, across North America and over two thirds of the earth for hours, when the heavens were in motion and the air was filled with innumerable meteors like rain of fire emanating from Leo, as thick as snowflakes falling outward like unripe figs.ST Jan 8, 1880ST Oct 31, 1900ST May 4, 1915RH Jun 9, 1853 It drew world attention as a forerunner, making witnesses think the Judgment had come.ST Jan 8, 1880 The great shower lasted for hours before dawn, increasing from 11 to 4 and visible till daylight, with countless streaks and millions of fireballs like sky-rockets covering the vault throughout the United States and North America from the Atlantic to the Pacific and from South America to the British possessions, thick as snowflakes and seeming to come from Leo near Gamma Leonis, causing fear of judgment as an act of divine power and not an ordinary occurrence.ST Jan 31, 1906ST Oct 28, 1889ST Mar 27, 1893ST Mar 24, 1914RH Jul 22, 1915 It followed the darkening of the sun and moon on May 19, 1780.ST Jan 10, 1911
It began about three o'clock on a frosty cloudless morning and continued until daylight and even after sunrise, when meteors streamed as if all the stars were falling, millions upon millions, some leaving streaks like bright rainbows drawing up after a few seconds resembling large serpents, and after sunrise resembling large flakes of snow falling in sunlight.RH Jul 20, 1905RH Jul 20, 1905 The sight alarmed people, who thought the stars had left their spheres and nature or the world was ending, so that people ran from house to house confessing sins and imploring forgiveness, fell on their faces to implore mercy, and others hid in bed with covered faces to keep from seeing it.RH Jul 20, 1905RH May 20, 1862RH Jul 20, 1905 It was the greatest shower the world had witnessed, with more than 240,000 fireballs visible above the horizon at Boston at one time, the whole heavens in motion, appearing in every direction from a radiant in Leo and moving in different directions like untimely figs shaken by a violent wind, marking divine power and matching the details.ST Oct 19, 1915ST Jul 22, 1889ST Mar 27, 1893 The myriad bright fireballs made the whole heavens appear in motion.
The November 13 display covered much of the United States and was also seen in Europe including England, with showers in Europe in 1832 and a similar display over Europe and western Asia in 1860 which astronomers could not successfully predict as periodical, and a display in Europe on November 25, 1833 over parts of Silesia and Austria like rain or streams of fire with fireballs brightening the night and frightening people and animals.LDT 49.1–2GSAM 97.1–3RH Jul 24, 1913ST Feb 21, 1906ST Nov 25, 1913 People witnessing 1833 thought judgment had come, recalling it as spectacular like autumn leaves, commonly taking it as a sign that the day of God was near, some thinking it might directly usher in that day, witnessing it as strange and frightening and thinking the world was ending, given to point to the return and awaken desire.RH Nov 16, 1916RH Dec 3, 1903RH Oct 30, 1866RH Jun 7, 1906 Signs and judgments can bring people face to face with God and awaken minds, but the impression often fades when the experience is past.RH Jun 7, 1906
The 1833 meteors were true stars from a belt of small bodies orbiting the sun, which the earth encounters about every thirty-three years, and the fact that meteor showers occur at regular intervals by natural law does not prevent them from being the predicted sign.RH Jul 3, 1866 All the principal exhibitions took place within less than a hundred years, with none of any importance before 1799, including the shower of November 13 and 14 witnessed on the Eastern Continent, while the unusual number in November 1867 was not worthy of special note as that fulfillment, and a similar display happening when predicted and expected keeps it from impressing people as unusual and prophetic, though it still points to the coming of the Son of man and the end of the dispensation rehearsing the time when systems of suns and satellites are dissolved.RH Dec 10, 1867 The star sign was placed after the sun and moon darkening following May 19, 1780, and was also seen in 1799 in the Old World and the Americas on November 12, 1799, with great showers in 1799, 1832, 1833, and 1866 and another predicted in 1867, so it is not limited to a single display but repeated omens and heralds visible in both hemispheres, coming before the message of the coming which began in unified form around 1840-44.ST Nov 14, 1906RH Jul 24, 1913RH Nov 29, 1853RH Jan 8, 1867
A great meteoric shower was seen in Europe in November 1799, and the greatest recorded shower occurred on November 13, 1833 over America and much of the Atlantic, with one account dating the unparalleled fulfillment November 30, 1833, as appointed signs that the coming is near even at the door.ST Feb 27, 1901ST Apr 15, 1903 After centuries of waiting it was fulfilled on the morning of November 13, 1799, in the year following the end of papal rule, lasting four hours with thousands of meteors succeeding each other, fiery particles thick as hail crowding the sky so that no space as large as three diameters of the moon was left empty at any instant, visible over several thousand miles from Greenland to the equator and from South America to Weimar in Germany.AUST Jul 12, 1920 An earlier major shower occurred on November 12, 1779, and other showers were recorded often around those dates, so the signs in the stars have appeared, whether as meteors, since fixed stars falling would destroy the earth, or as reported by astronomers in the burning of fixed stars.RH Jun 23, 1863 The great showers seen in America in 1833 and Asia in 1866, described as rain of fire, were examples given to the whole world, and the much smaller 1866 shower in Europe recalled and renewed attention without equaling 1833, reflecting periodicity and confirming the end, with great numbers over Turkey and the eastern Mediterranean on November 13-14, 1866 illustrating the image presented as signs.RH Jan 17, 1856RH Oct 30, 1866RH Jan 15, 1867RH Aug 19, 1915
One account dates the meteor shower fulfilling the prophecy November 13, 1835, one dates the falling November 13, 1883, and one presents the 1833 Leonid as exceptionally numerous, with the sun and moon darkened May 19, 1780 and the stars falling November 13, 1883 together completing the threefold sign.ST Jul 8, 1897ST Jul 22, 1886RH Mar 1, 1860RH Mar 23, 1916 The falling refers to a literal meteoric display, not to ministers falling from their positions, and the 1833 display marked the opening of the generation in which the remaining events would take place.RH Jan 27, 1903 The description is not a prediction that stars will literally fall from their orbits or that the material universe will be destroyed, which would be contrary to Scripture and character, though sun and stars will lose light and be dimmed someday, even when the heavens change the fruitage of today abides.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Oct 7, 1897RH Sep 30, 1915
The falling meteors appeared like streams of fire or snowflakes in every direction from a single point, like unripe figs shaken by wind, impressing witnesses with judgment, the sky filled with bright falling fire like snowflakes and fireflies lasting hours and gradually abating, the greatest display of shooting stars recorded in history.ST Nov 28, 1895GSAM 95.3–4ST Mar 9, 1876RH Jul 12, 1864ST Oct 19, 1915 It is to be as literal as the preceding signs and to point to the event it signifies, described more fully as falling like unripe figs shaken from a tree by a mighty wind.ST Nov 28, 1895 The falling stars are a distinct sign, not an event accompanying the darkening of the moon, because shooting stars would have lit the sky, and the sign was fulfilled in the great star shower of November 13, 1833 when stars appeared to fall across the United States for hours with many fearing judgment near.ST Jan 10, 1911ST Jul 29, 1913 It is the last great sign in the series before the coming, after which the heavens depart like a scroll and the earth is shaken while the unprepared mourn and seek to hide from Christ coming with power and glory, and those ready will be changed from mortal to immortal and caught up to meet him.ST Jan 10, 1911ST Jan 10, 1911
The falling stars are the last sign of the coming and God's greatest marvel in the heavens, already fulfilled, which the world should know to stop the mad rush long enough to sow Bible truth, also proclaiming that the heavens will soon pass away as part of the warning to watch.RH Sep 3, 1901RH Sep 18, 1860ST Aug 12, 1880RH May 2, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884 Their fulfillment began eighteen years before the commencement of the time of the end, and the last of the signs following the 1260 years of papal supremacy took place in 1833.ST Aug 12, 1880ST Aug 7, 1884 They have occurred three times since 1780 as repeated witness, not merely a natural phenomenon every thirty-three years distinct from ordinary annual meteors, as proved when great preparations for the expected 1899 shower failed because it did not appear, and the purposeful 1833 sign came ten years before the cleansing of the sanctuary and beginning of judgment, marking the timetable.ST Apr 28, 1914ST Dec 18, 1901AUST Jul 12, 1920
The Turks interpreted the falling as the fall of the sultan's palace and the end of the Ottoman Empire, while Halley's comet awakened belief that the Creator was showing signs, though it is not said to fulfill the verse.ST Jun 4, 1894RH Jan 18, 1912 The 1833 starfall was witnessed by those then children ten or eleven years old and by particular individuals, including a woman of the fulfillment generation who died before the return and awaits the resurrection as a waymark, with eyewitnesses remembering the autumn of 1833 and thereafter watching the message, and an aged witness remembering the dark day and believing the Midnight Cry past.RH May 21, 1857RH Jan 9, 1913RH Jul 7, 1903RH Aug 15, 1907 Others who saw the fall could describe the sign, and one who witnessed it was noted in obituary record.RH Jan 9, 1913RH Oct 26, 1905
Powers of Heaven Shaken
The first three signs have been fulfilled while the shaking of the powers of heaven is still to come, and all but one of the signs were already past with the foretold conditions evident, already past in 1885 marking the last generation.ST Feb 7, 1906ST Jan 15, 1885
The sun, moon and stars are themselves the powers of heaven, and their shaking is a future literal disturbance brought by the voice of God the Father shaking heaven and earth before the resurrection by the voice of the Son and before the sign of the Son of man appears at the seventh vial when the voice from the throne declares It is done.ST Mar 9, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882RH May 7, 1867ST Sep 13, 1910ST Mar 14, 1911
It was still future when Paul wrote of it, distinct from commotion among earthly nations, with distress and perplexity among nations coming between the heavenly signs and the shaking, and in the chapter's sequence this shaking and the coming are the next great events awaiting the world, preceding the angels' trumpet call and the gathering of the elect.ST Mar 16, 1904RH Jun 28, 1864RH Jun 30, 1874
That future shaking immediately precedes the Son of man's coming in glory, completes the shaking of the nations, removes the power of earthly kingdoms and makes way for the eternal kingdom.ST Jan 31, 1906
It ushers in the great day of the Lord, a day of wrath, trouble, desolation and darkness, belonging to that wrath when heaven and earth shake at God's voice rather than serving as an earlier warning sign, with the falling stars as the last sign in nature before the coming.RH Jan 6, 1903ST Jun 23, 1881RH Sep 23, 1873
In sequence it corresponds to the heavens departing like a scroll in the sixth seal after the falling stars, and even when nature is convulsed God's people remain safe and unharmed while the earth is shaken.ST Apr 22, 1889ST Jul 22, 1889ST Jun 7, 1905ST Jun 7, 1905
The shaking begins the events connected with the immediate coming rather than being another sign that must occur before the coming can be expected as near, an attendant circumstance placed after the falling and before the sign of the Son of man immediately before coming in the clouds with glory, when the unprepared mourn and hide.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Jan 10, 1911RH Sep 23, 1873RH Dec 20, 1864RH Jan 24, 1856
It is caused by God's voice from on high and occurs with the seventh plague when the nations face judgment, ushering vast upheaval and desolation.RH Jan 24, 1856
The shaking is literal just as the darkening and falling are literal, linked to the promised final shaking of both earth and heaven in which what can be shaken is removed and what cannot be shaken remains.RH Aug 14, 1856
It refers to the heavens connected with the earth, not to God's dwelling place where what cannot be shaken remains.RH Aug 14, 1856
After the stars fall the atmosphere around the earth, the heaven in which birds fly, will literally be shaken and rolled together like a scroll, coinciding with the seventh vial and God's voice from the throne producing a great earthquake and other upheavals before the sign appears, and the stars' removal from their places is part of that shaking while the saints' kingdom cannot be removed.RH Aug 5, 1851ST Apr 27, 1904
Whether it precedes the coming as a sign, whether it is the same as the heavens passing away, whether it could mean storms in the sun and solar system, or whether it could be fulfilled both before and at the coming, was raised as a question.ST Sep 18, 1884
The shaking is still future after 1780 and 1833, closely connected with the appearing under the seventh and last plague after probation has closed and every destiny is fixed, occurring later at the seventh vial after the people are sealed and perfected and sinners fixed, followed by the sign of the Son of man.RH May 7, 1867ST Sep 13, 1910ST Mar 14, 1911ST Mar 16, 1904RH Jun 28, 1864
The word and leaves an indeterminate interval between the darkening and the falling, but and then links the shaking directly to the coming, and since the signs have been fulfilled the coming is shown to be near.ST Mar 14, 1911RH Jun 30, 1874
It is caused by God's voice heard as the final plague ends at the pouring of the seventh vial when God announces that the judgments have been poured out, near the close just before the advent during the wrath not before, before the manifestation yet in connection with it as a period after the signs, followed by mourning and coming in glory.ST Sep 28, 1882RH Jan 24, 1856ST Jul 22, 1889ST Jul 29, 1880RH Aug 14, 1856
The tribes mourn after the signs already occurred, and the shaking is the next event after those signs.
This shaking ushers the great day when the voice shakes heavens and earth, and the darkening and upheaval apply to the last plague with darkened skies and violent disturbances before Christ appears, in connection with Armageddon as the final event ushering the descent under the greatest earthquake ever known shaking heaven and earth.RH Sep 23, 1873RH Nov 24, 1868ST Oct 28, 1930RH Jan 9, 1900RH Feb 23, 1860
At the glorious appearing creation is convulsed and quakes, foundations shaken, sun and moon dim, earth vanishing to clear the way for new heavens and earth, while nature proclaims the coming too late for the unprepared.RH Jan 9, 1900RH Oct 9, 1856
It is probably not among the signs whose beginning marks nearness and the living generation, for those warn and give time to prepare leading to wailing and coming in glory; it is a separate later event not among the nearness signs, not to be preached to warn and prepare, occurring after the case is fixed, probation closed and salvation past, when faith is perfected and doom fixed.RH Dec 17, 1901RH Jan 10, 1871ST Mar 9, 1876GSAM 97.4RH Apr 17, 1855
Events after probation closes are not warning signs, for the coming with its attendant events is a period not only the instant of first appearance, and the falling as third sign is fulfilled before the fig-tree generation while the shaking belongs to the actual coming.GSAM 97.4ST Sep 18, 1884
The shaking placed immediately before the coming is the same event in which God speaks and shakes heaven and earth, caused by the voice only once so that descriptions of either heaven or earth shaken refer to the same immediate connection.RH Aug 14, 1856ST Jun 23, 1881
With the sign of the Son of man it occurs when the Father speaks at the seventh plague making the definite time known to His people, accompanied by fearful upheaval near the day causing vain flight and hiding where only the holy can stand, calling to prepare.RH Jun 28, 1864RH Feb 11, 1873
The commotion takes place when Christ appears, the heavens breaking and dashing together when the dead awake, among the closing events immediately before the sign, leading to the future shaking when heavens depart and mountains and islands are moved.RH Apr 25, 1865ST Jun 7, 1877RH Nov 21, 1871
The disturbances in sun, moon and stars are distinguished from the shaking that follows them: the celestial signs occur before the coming showing nearness while the shaking belongs to the immediate coming, so close as not to be an advance sign but an unprecedented commotion with the voice appearing after probation when the day begins.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Dec 18, 1879ST Nov 4, 1889RH Jun 26, 1866RH Aug 19, 1915
At the descent worlds move before Him accompanying judgment, the sun, moon and stars shaken, and the shaking may recur on a greater universal scale immediately before appearing, an unprecedented commotion among the solar bodies with God's voice.RH Oct 24, 1871
The powers are the sun, moon and sidereal heavens, the lights governing day and night and marking seasons and years, and their shaking is literal like the earth when God spoke at Sinai; at the coming under the seventh plague God speaks again and both shake, trembling before the literal appearance and sign.RH Dec 9, 1852ST Jul 12, 1905
The shaking remains before Christ the King of glory comes, placed before the sign and coming in glory and gathering of the elect as the hope of welcomers; it takes place after probation when the day begins while the sign and personal coming also remain.RH Feb 20, 1866ST Nov 7, 1900RH Oct 13, 1859RH Apr 2, 1857RH Jan 10, 1865
One application dated the shaking to 1848 after the darkening as first and the falling as second, placing the 1780 sign near the rise of the two-horned beast during the Revolutionary War.RH Oct 13, 1859
It is the departing of heaven as a scroll, still future in the same series, caused by the voice speaking in terrible majesty from the throne; as the earth shook when the law was spoken, then earth and heavens shake so earth reels like a drunkard, dissolved, mountains moved, islands changed, direst confusion reigning.ST Apr 24, 1879
The signs in sun, moon and stars show the waiting church nearness, distinct from the shaking in immediate connection which is not advance; the darkening and falling as heralds already fulfilled give evidence so there is no need to be in darkness, marking nearness and warning that a decisive event is soon, with signs among nations still portending.RH Nov 22, 1906ST Dec 18, 1879RH May 1, 1856RH Apr 26, 1864ST Mar 12, 1912
Those signs have been fulfilled in the present age so the coming is soon.RH May 15, 1856
The shaking had not yet occurred while the others were regarded as past, pointing to a still-future event in the sequence to the great day, described as heavens rolling back, with sun, moon and stars moved by God's voice to prepare for relocation of throne and dominion to the redeemed earth as seat of rule, when the delivered trust Him as refuge though earth changes.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 3, 1903RH Jun 11, 1901ST Sep 11, 1901ST Feb 21, 1911
The heaven shaken is the atmospheric heaven, announced by the voice at the close of probation.ST Feb 21, 1911
It is a literal future event never seen in any past age and not explicable as past spiritual fulfillment, standing immediately before the personal visible coming and gathering with the Son Himself as the sign appearing suddenly small then quickly increasing as lightning from east to west, all seen by this generation.ST Mar 31, 1881
After unprecedented tribulation near the end it belongs to the day of the Lord with descent to save and punish and power displayed in judgment.ST Jun 23, 1881RH Mar 7, 1865
It refers to sun, moon and stars shaken by the voice at the coming or in immediate connection.ST Mar 27, 1893
It comes after the close of probation and beginning of plagues and before Armageddon, associated with a partial resurrection; still future after the falling with distress and fear in the interval described in Luke 21, the falling behind and the gathering as a scroll ahead, the present standing between waymarks nearly all passed proving home very near.RH Mar 3, 1910ST Mar 4, 1903ST Aug 19, 1897ST Mar 4, 1903
The falling marks the beginning of the last generation.ST Mar 4, 1903
Shaken powers and earth removed mean cosmic upheaval when all is taken yet Jehovah remains and grace suffices, therefore the little flock need not fear but rejoice with lifted heads proclaiming nearness to bring home, the bodies pictured shaken in apprehension at Deity's approach as waymarks to the kingdom.ST Oct 5, 1904RH Jul 2, 1901
It is part of upheaval with judgment and protection, immediately before, referring to earthly heavens, next after what occurred, before manifestation yet in connection as a period with the voice at the final plague, not nearness but after probation.ST Oct 25, 1910RH Apr 17, 1855ST Sep 18, 1884RH Feb 23, 1860
When people trust their refuge while earth changes, the rolling back shaken with earth at the coming prepares heavens for relocation.RH Sep 3, 1903RH Jun 11, 1901ST Jan 2, 1893ST Sep 11, 1901
The shaking of the sky before the day is taking place in the northern lights, almost never seen earlier but frequent and brilliant in the last hundred years covering heavens with rolling red fire, blood-tinged sky and crimson clouds so bright cities mistook them for conflagrations, with myriads of falling stars as in 1837 and 1839; appearing above now startling, it means chariot wheels and near redemption calling to awake and rejoice.ST Jul 1, 1903RH Dec 17, 1872
It is one of the last signs of final dissolution still to be fulfilled when the atmospheric heavens dissolve by fire and elements melt, certain in order in the day of wrath among the unfulfilled.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 22, 1889RH Mar 8, 1870ST Mar 4, 1903RH Apr 14, 1874
It echoes cosmic upheaval connecting with coming in clouds seen by every eye in visible return; when powers are shaken overcomers stand toward the white cloud with solemn joy at deliverance hailing the King upon the cloud.ST Sep 17, 1874RH Oct 3, 1871
Order and Prophetic Parallels
The verse gives three specific signs in the sun, moon and stars, followed by a fourth, the shaking of the powers of heaven, all placed immediately after the tribulation and before the sign of the Son of man and his visible coming in the clouds with power and great glory, when the wicked mourn and angels with trumpet gather the elect.ST Jan 14, 1875ST Feb 25, 1875ST Mar 27, 1893ST Jan 31, 1906RH Nov 26, 1914 The darkening of the sun was fulfilled on May 19, 1780, after persecution ceased but before the 1260 years ended in 1798, and these heavenly signs have already appeared in history showing the coming King near.ST Feb 25, 1875RH Nov 26, 1914ST Oct 25, 1883
The sun darkened, the moon withholding light, and stars falling precede the sign of the Son of man, with the first three fulfilled and the shaking still future and soon to come, teaching preparation for coming in clouds with power and great glory before probation closes.RH Nov 20, 1860RH Dec 20, 1870RH May 28, 1867 The dark day of 1780 and falling stars of 1833 fulfilled the earlier signs, long ago pointing to the time of the end, while the shaking immediately precedes glorious coming, completes shaking of nations, removes earthly kingdoms and makes way for the eternal kingdom.RH Nov 20, 1860
They are signs of coming, not of tribulation itself nor of Jerusalem's destruction in A.D. 70, belonging to the sequence to coming and mourning of wicked, still future when John wrote Revelation, following persecution by the Roman power especially papal Rome which waned under the Reformation and ceased early in the eighteenth century.ST Dec 16, 1908RH Feb 13, 1866RH Apr 4, 1854ST Oct 21, 1889RH Aug 18, 1874 The tribulation is not Jerusalem but sufferings under heathen and papal persecutions, greatest since the flood and shortened for the elect, while elect churches outside Judea would have survived Jerusalem's fall, and the literal sun, moon and star signs follow in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries toward kingdom, judgment and gathering of nations.ST Oct 21, 1889RH Aug 18, 1874RH Apr 22, 1858
The signs were not fulfilled at the crucifixion, which lacked moon-darkening and falling stars, since the next verse places the Son of man's sign after, and mourning of all tribes shows more than the few present at the cross, belonging instead before the great day of the Lord and corresponding to sixth-seal signs after the Lisbon earthquake of 1755, preceding wrath on rulers and people not on Christ.RH Feb 27, 1872RH Feb 27, 1872RH Feb 27, 1872
Their fulfillment in 1780 and 1833 falls within the fixed period after tribulation, not still future, though the phenomena may recur in connection with the Son of man's coming apart from sign-giving, and literal past signs show literal can be given again as in Egypt's three days, the cross darkening prefiguring sorrow, and the literal star of the first advent making literal proper for the second.RH Dec 24, 1903ST Jan 31, 1906RH Aug 18, 1874 The sun-and-moon signs are also predicted in Joel 2:31 and Revelation 6:12-13, with prophetic days 538 to 1798, tribulation ceasing 1776, supernatural darkening May 19, 1780 four years after, and unusually dark following night though moon full.ST Jan 31, 1906RH Aug 18, 1874
They are to be taken in plain literal sense as events fulfilled in heavens and earth, not figures for later loss of Jewish civil and religious power, for Jews were already subject to Rome when spoken, distinct from earthly nations, standing between tribulation and personal second advent.ST Oct 21, 1889ST Jan 2, 1879ST Dec 11, 1879ST Oct 21, 1889 Luke's parallel distinguishes heavenly signs from distress among nations on earth, and to make material visible signs into symbols perverts their character, while Jerusalem fulfilled literally so these also literal physical.ST Oct 21, 1889ST May 25, 1904
They mean what they say in the physical heavens heralding literal coming, entirely distinct from movements among men and calamities of nations, expressly after tribulation not as tribulation or overthrow of Jews, before the Son of man, like the sixth-seal earthquake and signs literally fulfilled giving assurance coming near even at doors.RH Sep 3, 1872
They are not symbols for kings, queens, nobles, nor mystical, spiritual, political or temporal figures, but real literally fulfilled in darkened sun and moon and fallen stars including the 1833 meteors, proving coming real not mystical and very near even at doors, with the witnessing generation not passing before return in clouds with power and great glory.RH Jun 14, 1870RH Jan 8, 1875ST Mar 24, 1881ST Jan 4, 1883RH Aug 18, 1874 To explain them otherwise rejects Christ's words, and Mark's in those days allows occurrence within tribulation period rather than only after fully ended, with tribulation diminished by 1700 and last persecution just before 1779 sun-darkening and temporal power taken 1798.RH Jan 8, 1875ST Mar 24, 1881
They are not figures for Jewish loss already ended before prophecy nor for Roman invasion, but after long church persecution ends the prophecy starts over giving literal physical heralds leading to all tribes seeing him in power and glory and mourning, trumpet sounding, angels gathering elect from whole world from four winds from one end of heaven to other not Judea only, running forward even to passing of heaven and earth.RH May 10, 1864RH Sep 3, 1872 The Jewish calamities were commencement and first-fruits of greater unparalleled tribulation, and coming follows as personal return not Roman invasion.RH May 10, 1864
The darkening of 1780 minutely and magnificently and falling of 1833 proved by histories and living witnesses connect with Son of man in power and great glory leaving no room for many years to intervene, fulfilled without eclipse as stars like untimely fruit from shaken fig, showing great day near for the witnessing generation, caused by God at exact promised time as sign and pledge near at door, lasting till after midnight with stars thick as snow.RH Feb 19, 1861RH Jan 10, 1854ST Dec 5, 1878RH Aug 31, 1869ST Oct 25, 1905 Rejecting the 1780 application departs from original Advent faith.RH Jan 10, 1854
Unlike wars, famines, pestilences and earthquakes recurring through the age, these celestial signs near end of long apostasy and papal rule mark approach of end, hung in heavens and physical, political, social and religious world so people not be deceived, belonging to special last-day signs distinct from long prophetic histories.ST Sep 10, 1894RH Dec 27, 1870
They are omens before the event signified, the great day concluding history, closing probation, bringing retribution and reward, given and fulfilled and recorded in history before probation closed while escape possible, with predictions in Bibles everywhere and fulfillments in histories leaving all without excuse who do not compare and prepare.RH Dec 9, 1852RH Dec 13, 1870ST Jun 15, 1882ST Jan 23, 1879
The changes in sun, moon, stars and shaken powers point to nearness of return and are rapidly fulfilling and multiplying, listed among signs of coming and part of prophecy of second coming.RH Feb 26, 1914RH Nov 22, 1906ST Jan 13, 1914RH Nov 19, 1908ST Aug 26, 1913 They accompany earthly upheaval and perplexity before Judge appears showing chosen redemption near.RH Feb 26, 1914
They come after Jewish tribulations and great tribulation of which those were beginning, belonging to judgment period not Roman attack, therefore announcing another approaching event not siege itself, and to place them after Christ has come reverses order.RH May 10, 1864ST Oct 21, 1889
They stand between tribulation and coming as landmarks recognizing prophetic time and precursors of final judgment, like fig leaves showing summer near and kingdom at hand near doors with generation not passing till accomplished, marking history's point leading into Son of man's sign, mourning, glorious coming and gathering elect.RH Mar 17, 1853RH Apr 7, 1903RH Aug 1, 1865ST Oct 21, 1889ST Jan 3, 1911 The tribulation under pagan and papal Rome waned by Reformation and ceased early eighteenth century, heavenly signs fulfilled late eighteenth and early nineteenth, with shaking after probation and day of Lord begins while Son sign and personal coming remain.ST Oct 21, 1889RH Jan 10, 1865
They are definite specific signs after tribulation in sequence from First Advent and Jerusalem toward return, following wars beginning sorrows, Jerusalem destruction, great tribulation, false christs including Mormonism and Spiritualism, amid worldwide trouble and hearts failing, as culmination seen by this generation that will not pass till coming in cloud with power and glory.RH Oct 29, 1901ST Jul 30, 1902ST Jan 17, 1906RH Jul 3, 1860ST Jun 22, 1915 They follow rapidly, begin rapid succession preparing way, usher final gathering and fulfill promises, placed after 1260 days within sequence from First to Second Advent.RH Jul 3, 1860ST Jun 22, 1915RH Jan 10, 1854
All preceding the Son of man's sign have been fulfilled in history in consecutive order from Christ's time to end, explainable with illustration in few minutes, so nothing remains except coming as lightning east to west.RH Jun 23, 1904RH Dec 13, 1853
The prophecy spans his time to coming in clouds, fulfilled up to final specifications, with Son of man in power and great glory remaining in writer's time.RH Aug 4, 1904
They occurred in predicted order beginning May 19, 1780 with moon failing that night then stars, with other elemental signs following, nearly all fulfilled seen and passed though seem long past, sun darkened 1780 and moon that night and stars November 13, 1833 as confirming signs.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Apr 20, 1915RH Dec 13, 1853ST Apr 21, 1909ST Jun 23, 1887 The full moon gave no light till late then blood-red, not by eclipse, fulfilling prophecy without explaining other signs.ST Apr 20, 1915
Three great signs fulfilled to letter with historical accuracy prove kingdom nigh and coming next great event, beginning 1780 not twelfth showing judgment at hand and ending 1833, significant by place and timing in sequence not mere similarity, occurring after Dark Ages tribulation of 1260 years with sun-moon darkened shortly before end and stars few years later November 13, 1833 as part pointing to last generation proclaiming final mercy.RH Oct 29, 1901RH May 6, 1873RH Jan 29, 1861RH Sep 2, 1851 Observed darkening and falling testify to truth.RH Jun 9, 1868
They are waymarks tracing from first to second advent after Jerusalem destruction and Pagan-Papal tribulation, standing after earthquake with darkened sun-moon followed by Papacy's overthrow and falling stars then last generation and seven plagues then coming in glory with angels to gather children, showing near even at doors.RH May 7, 1867ST Dec 17, 1912
After Dark Ages persecution they bring to generation not passing, sun 1780 with moon, stars 1833, pointing to nearness of Judgment and coming before heavens depart and Lord comes, falling last with departing and coming next as budding leaves show summer, while shaking belongs to actual seen coming not earlier nearness signs, later in day of wrath.RH May 8, 1879GSAM 97.4STLDT 49.3–50.2ST Jul 22, 1889 The moon failure matched untimely figs shaken, not by eclipse.ST Jul 22, 1889
Seen historically they were understood as coming marks of last generation, special signs but part of larger set including other events preceding second coming given through apostles and prophets by Spirit.RH Nov 10, 1904ST Aug 4, 1914
Sun darkened and moon lightless 1780 and stars 1833 occurred just before 1798 deadly wound on persecuting power, to strengthen faith and show near, while shaking occurs later at seventh vial after sealed, perfected and fixed, followed by Son sign, not among fig-tree nearness signs while warnings still given, with sun-moon-stars fulfilled before coming and next event certain for words not pass.ST Mar 3, 1914ST Mar 24, 1881ST Feb 3, 1881 They were not all fulfilled before Jerusalem but belong to last generation, shaking at seventh vial.ST Feb 3, 1881RH Mar 18, 1873
The dark day May 19, 1780 with darkened moon that night and meteors November 13, 1833 as last special basis for nearness faith precede shaking and departure of atmospheric heaven after probation closes when condemned appeal to mountains to hide from God and Lamb.ST Jan 15, 1880
The sequence points after 1833 to coming war and earthly disturbances while God prepares people, nature linked with financial trouble, tidal waves and earthquakes, and since stars fell storms, floods, fires, earthquakes, eruptions increased signaling soon coming.ST Nov 21, 1895RH Jun 18, 1914
The related series begins with Lisbon earthquake 1755 as persecution closed, then 1780 sun-moon and 1833 stars with distress and roaring sea continuing though not all fulfilled, great earthquake preceding signs of approaching advent, included as sufficient warning for Europe where American signs foreign, beginning notable dark day and continuing, preceding Son sign, mourning and coming in clouds.ST Mar 20, 1893ST Mar 20, 1893RH Jan 17, 1856RH May 10, 1915RH Mar 9, 1916 The tribulation papal persecution ended 1776 while supremacy to 1798, leaving intervening years for fulfillment, fulfilling purpose of lights as signs, with three signs basis for knowing near even at doors while shaking, Son sign, mourning, glorious coming and gathering not nearness signs for sealing passed.ST Mar 20, 1893RH Jan 17, 1856ST Jun 13, 1906
They foretell same as sixth seal, earthquake, sun black as sackcloth, moon as blood withholding, stars as untimely figs, fulfilled by Lisbon 1755, 1780 darkening and reddened moon, 1833 meteors, linked with Mark 13:24-25, Joel 2:31, Revelation 6:12-13 within time of end after 1798 to warn near, with 1833 full opening sixth seal as last great before return, standing with Mark, Luke, Luke 21 as twelve lines converging to second coming showing earthly rule nearly over and reign at hand.ST May 2, 1906ST May 11, 1904ST Nov 28, 1895ST Sep 28, 1904ST Dec 14, 1904 Together with earthquakes, roaring seas and distress they token near approach before final scene.ST Sep 28, 1904ST Apr 22, 1913
The same associated sixth-seal and Joel correspondence describes how darkening occurred, connected also with judgment timing in Isaiah 29:6, same order with earth shaking, occurring during days of tribulation after papal power broken 1776 but before supremacy ended 1798.ST Mar 20, 1893ST Mar 17, 1914ST Sep 27, 1899ST Jan 24, 1900ST May 4, 1904 They occur after tribulation before Son appears, preceding judgment, same signs as sixth seal opening.RH Apr 5, 1860
In same order with earth shaking they join distress and perplexity on earth, referring to period deceived by miraculous signs, appearing, harvest, battle of great day and overthrow of enemies connected with Revelation 13, 14, 16, Matthew 13:38-39, Joel 3:9-15, fulfilling lights as signs and identifying Isaiah judgment.ST Mar 20, 1893ST Mar 17, 1914ST Sep 27, 1899ST Jan 24, 1900ST Jul 22, 1889 The chapter's events so connect.ST Dec 2, 1889
Luke adds distress and perplexity among nations and sea disturbances, belonging to signs and wonders extending to great day at close of gospel age ushering judgments and second advent.ST Apr 3, 1893ST Mar 11, 1875ST Jan 31, 1906RH Aug 18, 1874
They belong to warning about second coming guarding against deception about manner of return, for true coming conspicuous as lightning east to west in clouds with power, glory, angels and trumpet needing no report of here or there, so elect heeding not deceived while mass deceived by wonders wail unprepared, protecting against dream of world conversion before coming and exposing false christs with signs, with tribulation papal before present age of false prophets.ST Oct 11, 1905ST Jun 8, 1904ST Oct 13, 1909ST Sep 10, 1894ST Jan 18, 1877 Fulfilled heavenly with other last-day signs prove last generation and Revelation 14:6-12 message for this time, duty to know near even at doors.ST Sep 10, 1894RH Dec 14, 1869
They lead to tribes seeing coming in power and glory and mourning and angels gathering elect, placing return within plan ending history bringing kingdom rather than human political reform.RH Sep 3, 1872RH Jul 31, 1913
With following verses they associate return in power and glory when sleeping awake, living changed to immortality and caught up ending suffering, sickness, sorrow, death, gathering from every direction fulfilling resurrection hope and inheritance at last trumpet, gathering home on last great day.ST Dec 7, 1915RH Mar 17, 1853ST Oct 18, 1883ST Dec 2, 1897
The heavenly signs and gathering belong surrounding advent when Son comes to earth, not earlier heavenly judgment where Father gives kingdom but afterward as King with angels, coming in clouds with power and glory immediately after long tribulation marking kingdom, judgment, antichrist destruction and resurrection.ST Feb 21, 1878
They are striking heavenly warnings drawing attention that Saviour soon appears in clouds ending sin taking people home, with only short remaining to generation for millions in darkness to receive gospel, cited as Bible testimony of literal soon return unmistakable giving hope though individuals unexplained.RH Mar 12, 1914RH Dec 1, 1859RH Oct 22, 1903RH May 6, 1858RH Nov 22, 1906 Jesus prophesied coming in kingdom and glory descending with hosts gathering people.
Matthew places darkening after tribulation while Mark in those days after shows during broader days soon after persecutions cease not only after period ended, shortened with persecution largely ceased around 1776 while 1260 ended 1798 leaving about twenty-two years, belonging to day of Lord and personal judgment before millennium, minutely describing after 1260 papal supremacy with last sign stars 1833, beginning eighteen years before time of end, fulfilled seventy-four years before 1907 account.ST Jan 3, 1911RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 12, 1880RH May 2, 1907ST Aug 7, 1884
They mark closing days of papal domination ending 1798, immediately after 1260 years 538 to 1798 when civil lost, timing marking end of Gentile dominion trodden and Papacy downfall, now history, studied directing to Revelation 14 messages, heralding gathering with quick succession showing hope soon realized.RH Oct 8, 1857RH Sep 25, 1913ST Jun 20, 1916RH Jan 10, 1856 Their fulfillment heralds gathering.RH Dec 30, 1862
They answer sign of coming and end before great terrible day, meaning sun darkened, moon lightless, stars fallen immediately after tribulation ceased 1776 before close of 1260 ending 1798, part of clear New Testament prophecies and instructions about times and seasons, belonging to prophecy of Son's coming and world's close personally important calling to prepare.ST Nov 1, 1883RH Jun 9, 1868ST May 10, 1910RH Mar 27, 1856
They belong to more exact predictions of future connected with second advent including judgments and great changes removing hindrances to kingdom, sustaining prophet office teaching and warning.RH Feb 11, 1873RH Nov 18, 1862
They trace from disciples' time through Daniel tribulation to special last-day signs with heavenly, physical, political, social, religious wars, earthquakes, pestilences, part of consecutive history from Jerusalem A.D. 70 and Vesuvius Pompeii A.D. 79 to Pelee St Pierre and latest upheavals each fulfilled, judgments at advent not afterward, with shaking by God's voice at final plague end in immediate connection with coming, and chapter signs fulfilled or fulfilling with portents and upheavals pointing to soon return.ST Sep 28, 1882RH Jan 27, 1910RH Feb 28, 1854RH Dec 15, 1904
Cited among unmistakable signs without explaining individuals, they belong to converging prophecy to be proclaimed as warning beginning England 1827 and America through Miller 1833 spreading to nations, to awaken repentance not lull sin, to be preached as coming draws near, part of Mount Olives signs near and soon coming warning while time to save.RH Dec 1, 1859RH Aug 20, 1901ST Apr 6, 1888ST Jul 11, 1878 Read onward they speak last days.ST Oct 29, 1885
They mark timetable of Christian progress toward coming, standing with Mark and Luke as converging lines showing earthly rule over and reign at hand without fixing exact time, identifying position pointing to solemn near events, multiplying rapidly, already more than seventy years past calling to act without delay, fulfilled in present age.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Aug 26, 1862RH Feb 26, 1914ST Jan 13, 1914 So Matthew 24 with others converges to one focal second coming.ST Dec 14, 1904
They teach continued opposition to true church till end and duty to watch and wait for Son's return without separately explaining sun, moon, stars or shaking, speaking New Testament clarity of catastrophe and victory clarified by Revelation, connected with Peter's heavens and earth reserved for fire and day of Lord beyond Old prophets from Enoch.ST Aug 7, 1901RH Dec 8, 1874ST
Read onward they speak last days to be preached as draws near, presenting signs immediately after announcing end near and describing how he comes, identifying near and guarding against false claims and alarms, calling watchfulness for turning away leaves liable to deception or unprepared at unexpected coming.ST Apr 15, 1889STRH Jan 8, 1901
They were especially marked in America where God's cause and living religion moved westward, truly heralding when understood through prophetic Word and proclaimed in last message, Word and signs together twofold witness near, after tribulation 538-1798 ending 1776 with days to 1798, darkening May 19, 1780 with moon following night, meteors Europe November 1799 and greatest America and Atlantic November 13, 1833.ST Feb 27, 1901
They predict political nearness in unexampled complication among nations causing anger, distress and perplexity, now unprecedented with affairs hopelessly complicated so every adjustment increases perplexity, showing exactly fulfilled and Lord near at hand.RH Feb 19, 1861
Sources