Matthew 24:30
And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory.
And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory.
Commentary part 3 of 4
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Sequence After Tribulation Signs
The order is literal: after the tribulation come the darkening of sun and moon, the falling of stars and the shaking of the powers of heaven, then the sign of the Son of man appears in heaven, then all the tribes of the earth mourn and see him coming in the clouds with power and great glory, followed by the trumpet and the gathering of the elect from across earth and heaven.ST Aug 12, 1880ST Oct 25, 1905ST Jul 29, 1913ST Jan 2, 1879ST Sep 13, 1910 The signs are to be fulfilled literally in the heavens and on earth, not figuratively, and the generation witnessing the final signs will also witness the return.RH Apr 20, 1876ST Jul 29, 1913ST Jan 2, 1879 The shaking of the powers belongs in direct connection with the coming itself and the day of the Lord, not merely as an advance sign.ST Jan 31, 1906
His coming follows the great tribulation, specifically the 1260 years of papal supremacy and persecution from 538 to 1798, shortened for the elect's sake.RH Dec 11, 1860ST Jul 24, 1879ST Apr 24, 1879 Persecution was restrained by the Reformation and ended before papal power fell, ceasing about 1770-1779, and the signs followed the tribulation with the darkening of sun and moon May 19, 1780 and the falling of stars November 13, 1833, with Lisbon 1755 before them.RH Oct 8, 1857ST Jul 4, 1878ST Jul 24, 1879ST Apr 24, 1879RH Oct 30, 1866 The dark day occurred after persecution ceased but before 1798 ended, showing the coming near, and the meteor shower belongs to the prophetic period after 1799 so further showers in that period are also signs.RH Oct 8, 1857RH Oct 30, 1866
That shaking is the final act in the shaking of the nations when earthly kingdoms lose their power and Christ's eternal kingdom is established.ST Jan 31, 1906 It is fulfilled by the voice of God the Father shaking heaven and earth before the resurrection of the just and before the sign appears, probably at the pouring of the seventh vial into the air when the great voice from the throne in the temple says It is done.RH Jan 10, 1871ST Mar 4, 1875 That voice is not the voice of the Son descending to raise the dead but the Father's voice from heaven, amid darkness, lightning, thunder, hail, earthquakes and collapse of cities, islands and mountains, while God's people remain safe and unharmed because the Lord is their hope and strength.RH Jan 10, 1871ST Mar 4, 1875ST Sep 23, 1875 The glory of Christ and the angels then breaks through the darkness and terrifies the ungodly.ST Sep 23, 1875
The shaking, the sign and the mourning occur shortly before he comes, after every person's destiny is fixed and probation has passed.RH Aug 11, 1853RH Jan 17, 1856ST Aug 19, 1880 They are not then preached to the world to convert it because salvation time has passed, nor needed to perfect the saints' faith, and the shaking when the Lord comes is not a warning sign by which people learn the Advent is near.RH Aug 11, 1853ST Apr 5, 1883RH Jan 17, 1856 Wars, upheavals among nations, pestilences and other preceding events are warnings like the budding fig tree, but do not reveal day or hour.RH Mar 7, 1871
Wars and kingdom against kingdom, famines, pestilences, earthquakes, abounding iniquity, disputes over money and war preparations by all nations are only the beginning of sorrows; the end is not yet.RH Sep 6, 1864ST Nov 27, 1879RH Dec 15, 1904 Extraordinary signs in nature are portents of remarkable events in human history including the coming in power and glory, and present history fulfilling Matthew 24 points to that culminating coming bringing restoration as the final home of the faithful.RH Mar 16, 1869RH Dec 15, 1904 After the sun, moon and star signs come distress of nations with perplexity, sea and waves roaring, men's hearts failing for fear, and powers shaken, and then the Son is seen coming in a cloud.RH Oct 29, 1901
The coming follows so closely upon the told-time signs as to leave no room for many years to come between them, reckoned from the supernatural darkening in 1780 to the stars in 1833 with a fixed limit beyond which the generation cannot pass.RH Dec 1, 1874RH Feb 19, 1861RH Oct 29, 1901 If the generation is reckoned from 1780 it can last only a few more years, though exact year is not revealed, and the generation that saw the signs begun in 1780 and ended in 1833 shall not pass till all be fulfilled so the coming is right at the door.RH Dec 1, 1874RH Oct 29, 1901RH Sep 4, 1866 How long from signs to shaking to coming cannot be told from signs alone without definite prophetic time, but when those signs are fulfilled nearness can be known with certainty, and the world is then in the interval before the heavens part to reveal him.ST Jan 2, 1893ST Jan 10, 1911
The same signs appear in the same order in other prophecies, including Revelation 6 as history of the church in relation to civil governments bringing history to the end of probationary time, Joel 2 extending beyond Pentecost to the end of the dispensation, with Daniel 7, Matthew 13, Joel 3 and Revelation 13-16.ST Dec 2, 1889ST Jul 22, 1889RH Apr 5, 1860RH Dec 11, 1900 The order is that devilish miracle-working deceptions gather kings and people to the battle of the great day of God Almighty immediately after the day of salvation, the Son appears, the harvest is reaped, the battle is fought and enemies overthrown, with warning that he comes as a thief blessing the watcher.ST Dec 2, 1889 Then the prophecy that they shall look upon the pierced one is fulfilled.ST Nov 30, 1882
His coming follows the end-time events and is the time when he reaps the harvest of the earth, seated on a cloud of glory with sharp sickle doing the harvesting himself because salvation's work is finished and the race of sin is run.RH Sep 27, 1906RH Dec 23, 1873 When the foretold increase of evil, deceit, perilous last days with form of godliness, and truth fallen is manifest, the time is ripe, the sheaves gathered and work finished, so precious moments must be improved by consecration, united prayer, suffering with Christ and spreading truth.RH Jun 18, 1908RH Aug 22, 1871ST Nov 17, 1898 The three angels' messages precede this coming to warn and prepare, and their appearance is a sign the return is near.RH Dec 23, 1873
The coming is the climax of the prophetic line, of signs and tribulation, to be prepared for rather than itself one of the signs whose beginning shows redemption near.ST Dec 24, 1912RH Dec 17, 1901ST Mar 1, 1877 The church is to expect sorrow until he returns in person to end turmoil, and apparent triumph of Satan and troubling conditions do not mean delay but nearness.ST Mar 1, 1877RH Apr 21, 1904 The final events may occur at almost any time and may be fulfilled at any moment, startling the unprepared tribes to wail.ST Dec 24, 1912ST Sep 14, 1882RH Dec 17, 1901 Every event predicted before the sign has already been fulfilled in history, leaving nothing but the sign itself and the sudden universally visible coming like lightning from east to west.RH Dec 13, 1853
Every pre-coming sign in sun, moon and stars is now fulfilled, showing earth's last generation reached and the coming near even at the doors, with earth's long night of sin nearing its close.RH Mar 10, 1868RH May 11, 1916ST Jun 11, 1902ST Jun 23, 1887 That fulfillment refutes the delusion of a temporal millennium, brings Babylon's doom, destruction of kings gathered for battle by heaven's armies, and transfer of kingdoms to Christ to reign forever.RH Mar 10, 1868RH May 11, 1916 Telling the fulfilled falling stars as last heavenly sign sows Bible truth and stops the mad rush long enough to consider, despite time passed and warning work remaining.RH Sep 3, 1901ST Jun 23, 1887RH Mar 3, 1874
This coming connects with God speaking again and making the definite time known to his people at the seventh plague, immediately after the shaking.RH Feb 11, 1873 This gathering by Jesus descending with angels and sending them to gather the elect with his voice calling saints to meet him in the air is distinct from the earlier voice of God from Zion or Jerusalem that shakes heaven and earth before he commissions the angels.RH Aug 5, 1851 Nearly all signs are fulfilled with only the shaking of powers and the heavens rolling back as a scroll remaining, calling people everywhere to get ready to meet the Lord.RH Sep 3, 1903 The special sun, moon and star signs must occur and be proclaimed before the movement of the ten virgins going out to meet the bridegroom, the sign belonging to that connected sequence, and the bridegroom's tarrying represents disappointment among those expecting him.RH Jun 9, 1851GSAM 148.2
Historical Fulfillment of Signs
The darkening of the sun occurred on May 19, 1780, with the moon giving no light that night and then appearing as blood, and the falling of the stars occurred on November 13, 1833, also given as November 30, after the persecution of the saints had waned about 1770-1775 and before the 1260 years of papal supremacy from 538 to 1798 had ended.RH Jun 30, 1904ST May 4, 1915ST Mar 9, 1876ST Oct 28, 1889 These heavenly signs follow the tribulation and stand in the sequence leading to the appearing of the sign of the Son of man and his coming in the clouds with power and great glory, when all the tribes of the earth mourn and see him.RH Jun 30, 1904ST May 4, 1915ST Oct 19, 1915 The persecution under papal rule lasted twelve centuries and abated through the Reformation, ending in the first half of the eighteenth century during the resulting respite, so the signs belong to the prophecy of Christ's coming and not to the destruction of Jerusalem.ST May 4, 1915ST Oct 28, 1889 The generation that sees these signs as signs of Christ's coming is the generation that will not pass away before all is fulfilled, marking the start of the last generation and announcing that the day of the Lord is near, even at the doors.RH Jun 30, 1904ST May 4, 1915
Before this coming certain signs take place which have actually taken place in the exact manner foretold, so that when they are seen it is known as certainly as summer is near when leaves appear that Christ in glory is near.ST Aug 7, 1884 The same phenomena foretold in Revelation 6:12-13 were fulfilled by the great earthquake at Lisbon in 1755, the darkening of the sun and moon in 1780, and the falling meteors in 1833.ST May 2, 1906 The signs identified include Jerusalem's destruction, the Dark Ages, the darkening of the sun in 1780, and the falling stars in 1833, with the earthquake, darkening and falling stars as signs and forerunners of the great day when the Son of man comes in great power and glory amid earthly fear and turmoil.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 2, 1862 The falling stars of November 13, 1833 were an awe-inspiring worldwide sign and forerunner of that day, recalling a fig tree shedding its leaves in a mighty wind, and the faithful look beyond the trouble to his appearing when they will be delivered from mortality into eternal life.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Oct 28, 1852 Further showers in 1799, 1866 and afterward do not prevent the 1833 shower serving as the omen, and these meteors are distinct from ordinary annual showers or mere 33-year recurrence.ST Aug 7, 1884ST May 2, 1906
The stars that fall are meteors or shooting stars, not fixed planets or suns, whose impact would destroy the earth rather than serve as warning, since the word translated stars can also refer to meteors, as in the star that led the wise men.ST Mar 27, 1893RH Dec 8, 1874 The darkening of the sun and falling of stars are future signs before Christ's second coming, not the darkness at his crucifixion, which was a token of nature's horror when the moon was not darkened and no stars fell.RH Dec 8, 1874 The sign of the Son of man is the distant appearance of his cloud of glory, whose splendor far exceeds the brightness of the sun.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Dec 18, 1879 When the tribes see it they mourn because they heard and rejected the evidence that his coming was near, then realize their hopeless condition and seek shelter from the dazzling fearful sight, in immediate connection with the Lord's coming and not as an earlier sign proving nearness to the waiting church.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Dec 18, 1879
The verse has direct reference to the end of time and the final closing scenes of this world's history, not only to the destruction of Jerusalem, and describes Christ's personal return after the tribulation when the tribes will see him coming in heaven's clouds with power and great glory and will mourn.RH Jul 21, 1874RH May 10, 1864 It places that appearance and coming in glory after the tribulation of the days of papal persecution dated from 538 to 1798, followed by his angels gathering the elect from every direction.ST Apr 22, 1889 The claim that the Son of man came in heaven's clouds, was seen by the tribes, and caused them to mourn in connection with the Roman armies and Jerusalem's destruction is challenged because no biblical or other authentic record proves that the tribes saw him coming or mourned at the sight, whether literally, mentally, or spiritually.RH Sep 9, 1862RH Sep 9, 1862 The signs in sun, moon and stars come immediately after the tribulation and point forward to a still-future coming, for the tribulation is not the siege and destruction of Jerusalem and the coming is not that destruction, and the signs do not foretell the tribulation itself but denote the approach of another event, so the signs of Christ's coming are given before his coming, not after it.ST Oct 21, 1889
The signs in sun, moon and stars follow the fall of Jerusalem, the treading down of Jerusalem, and the fulfilling of the times of the Gentiles, and only after all these things has the kingdom of God to be known as near at hand and still future, not set up on the day of Pentecost.RH Apr 17, 1866 They begin during the final quarter-century of papal supremacy from 538 to 1798, with the darkening of the sun and moon in 1780 and the falling of the stars in 1833 marking the start of the last generation.RH Jun 30, 1904 Once these signs have occurred his coming is near and the heavens will open to reveal him, and the generation that witnessed the falling of the stars is the generation that would see these things fulfilled and Christ's coming at hand.RH Nov 7, 1871RH Aug 20, 1914 After signs in sun, moon and stars, distress and perplexity come upon the nations and men fear what is coming on the earth before Christ appears in glory, and recent tidal waves, earthquakes and other natural disturbances with roaring seas are part of that distress as signs of the approaching appearing.ST Nov 21, 1895 Its signs include the darkening of the sun and moon in 1780 and the falling of the stars in 1833, whereupon Christ's followers are to look up because redemption is near.RH Jun 9, 1853
Christ certifies his return by three great signs, the darkening of the sun and moon and showers of falling stars, which have been fulfilled to the letter and can be pointed out with historical accuracy, so that when they come to pass the kingdom of God is nigh at hand.RH May 6, 1873 The falling of stars is the last sign in the heavens of the second coming, already fulfilled, and the world should know of its fulfillment because telling it sows Bible truth about the second coming and stops people in the mad rush of the last days to consider it.RH Sep 3, 1901 The falling-star sign is identified with the great meteor shower of November 13, 1833 as fulfilled prophecy and notable indication that the day of the Lord is near, serving as a declaration meant to awaken people to prepare for his appearing.ST Mar 27, 1893RH May 20, 1862 With the wonderful shower of 1833 as the last of the signs, the generation that saw that shower will not pass away until the Lord himself descends, since the signs have been fulfilled and the coming in the clouds with power and great glory is the final part of all to be fulfilled within the generation that sees them.ST Nov 18, 1889RH Sep 4, 1866 When they come to pass the coming of Christ is the next great event after the proclamation of the three gospel messages, with the Son of man on the white cloud coming next, and after them the world is in the interval before the heavens depart as a scroll.RH May 6, 1873
The extraordinary darkness was explained as a sacred prediction connected with the last day in Matthew 24:29-30, and the fear and alarm it caused were regarded as a natural response to what people saw as a sign of approaching judgment.RH Jul 18, 1871 The darkening described in the surrounding prophecy was taken as a warning that the final day was near, leading people to fear, pray and seek refuge in Christ, connecting the signs in the heavens with the coming of the Son of man and the Last Day.RH Oct 7, 1873 The New England darkness of 1780 was treated by religion as fulfilled prophecy and stirred people to fear that Christ would appear through the torn clouds as a stern judge, bringing fear and mourning at his return in the clouds with power and glory.RH Oct 7, 1873 The signs preceding his coming unfold over time, and their full convergence, including the worldwide proclamation of the threefold message beginning in 1844, not the darkening of the sun and moon alone, shows that his coming is near, so that the generation seeing all these signs fulfilled will not pass before all is accomplished.ST Oct 20, 1909 Signs in the heavens such as Halley's comet could likewise awaken belief that the Creator was giving signs pointing to the soon coming of the Saviour.RH Jan 18, 1912
Signs in the heavens in Matthew 24:29-30 are portents of the Lord's second coming to earth, reserved to mark his return.ST Jun 7, 1910 Just as the miraculous signs associated with Christ's first coming pointed to his Messiahship, so signs in the sun, moon and stars are reserved to mark his return.ST Jun 7, 1910
Generation Nearness and Time
This generation is the people living on earth when the signs in sun, moon and stars appear, not the people alive when Jesus spoke, not the Jews as a race, and not a fixed number of years; this points to that particular future generation, which will not entirely pass away before all is fulfilled and some of them will see Christ return in the clouds with power and great glory.ST May 1, 1884RH Nov 18, 1858 The discourse covers the time from Jerusalem's destruction to the second advent, and with all but one of the heavenly signs past and the foretold conditions manifest, that sign-seeing generation bears the last message of mercy and proclaims his coming.ST The period begins with the darkening of sun and moon in 1780 and continues through the star shower of November 13, 1833 after the long persecution of the Dark Ages until Christ is seen coming, so that people still living who witnessed the first signs were evidence the generation remained.RH Nov 18, 1858
As leaves shooting forth show summer is near, so the fulfilled signs show the coming is near, even at the doors, and the generation witnessing the final signs will also witness the return.ST Jul 29, 1913ST The chapter's prophecies include events already fulfilled, showing the generation then living is the last before Christ returns to earth.ST May 11, 1904ST Jun 29, 1904ST May 25, 1904ST Aug 10, 1904 Yet day, hour, month and year remain secret; no date is set, all time-setting is false, and what is required is daily expectancy, fidelity, purity, understanding, watchfulness, prayer and action as prophecy reveals present duty.ST Jul 24, 1884RH Apr 15, 1909ST Feb 19, 1885ST Dec 9, 1889
The generation that sees all the signs fulfilled in the light of prophecy, including their full convergence and not the darkening alone, and including the worldwide proclamation of the threefold message beginning in 1844, will not pass before all is accomplished and Christ comes.ST Oct 20, 1909RH Jul 9, 1872ST Mar 17, 1914 That generation heard the worldwide message announcing his nearness and will behold him seated upon a cloud, and lines of prophecy converge upon it as the climax of Christian hope.ST Mar 17, 1914RH Sep 21, 1911 The expected coming at the end of Daniel's 2,300 days did not occur in the generation then living, but that failure did not mean God had not led his people.RH Feb 26, 1867 Conclusions in 1915 identified that living generation as the last, soon to see the heavens open, with prophetic evidence identifying the second coming in the clouds as imminent and to be witnessed by the present generation.ST May 12, 1914RH Sep 22, 1910RH Sep 21, 1911
More than fifty and then more than seventy years had passed since the last sign, with witnesses surviving, so the coming cannot be much longer and the remaining time to finish the message seemed very short.RH Jul 2, 1914 Only a short period still remains to this generation before he appears to make an end of sin and take his people home, during which the ignorant and careless millions in darkness must receive gospel light.RH Oct 22, 1903 Distress of nations with perplexity, extensive preparations for general war, and the state of the nations are as sure as summer when trees shoot forth leaves, bringing the kingdom of God nigh, Christ's immortal reign and a world without sorrow soon bursting upon vision, sealing destiny of all and calling for diligence while the majority pay no attention and scoff.RH Jun 11, 1857RH Sep 17, 1861 The prospect that some very elderly people may live to see him makes the end seem near and calls for urgent work among the nations.RH Oct 25, 1906
Humble students can know nearness by the signs as by the fig tree, though exact time was not expected in the disciples' lifetime; to prevent discouragement Jesus gave the transfiguration with Moses for the resurrected and Elijah for the translated, and as Noah completed his work before knowing the day so believers must work and watch.RH Jun 22, 1905ST Dec 9, 1889ST Feb 14, 1906 History gives evidence of accurate fulfillment of the prophecies of the chapter, which serve as heralds of the great event.RH Jun 22, 1905 Time prophecies must have been fulfilled before the second advent can be proclaimed with certainty, and prophetic periods do not themselves mark the coming since their expiration marks earlier events.RH Nov 18, 1909 Appearances and human reasoning may seem to make coming within the appointed generation impossible, and delay gives scoffers occasion to ridicule and tempts to wrongly set a definite time, but his words will not pass away though heaven and earth pass, and the passing years do not make the promise less certain.LS 184.3–185.1ST Nov 3, 1898ST Feb 14, 1906ST Dec 2, 1913RH Feb 9, 1864 This certainty sustains faith and readiness, calling for patient waiting, watchfulness and trust.LS 184.3–185.1ST Dec 2, 1913RH Feb 9, 1864RH Oct 11, 1864
After the falling of the stars on November 13, 1833, the last sign before the fig-tree parable is applied, teachers arose around the world to teach that parable with the spring of 1844 taken as the door opening to eternal bliss and glory.GSAM 97.4 The shaking of the heavens and Christ's visible coming are not among the signs announcing he is at the door; they occur when he is actually seen coming, so the parable places the advent proclamation after 1833 and teaches he will come before the hearing generation passes.GSAM 97.4 His glorious appearing in the heavens is God's approaching great day with sure forerunners, the present generation is the last the earth in its current condition will know, and rather than expecting lasting peace through human schemes or Socialism people should look for his coming and prepare to live in the earth made new.ST Sep 15, 1909 The generation addressed stands in the days of his coming and must be found living in the purity of the everlasting gospel when he comes, with the chapter's warnings and admonitions given to the last-days generation.ST Jan 9, 1893ST Oct 19, 1915
Sign of the Son
The sign is the cloud of glory itself, the cloudlike host of angels encircling Christ as he returns.ST Jul 18, 1911ST May 18, 1915ST Dec 3, 1896ST Feb 27, 1893 As a cloud received him from sight at the ascension, so clouds first appear dim in the distance and grow brighter as they draw near, until seen as the angelic host with the Son among them upon it with power and great glory.ST Jul 18, 1911ST Oct 19, 1888ST Dec 3, 1896ST Mar 27, 1893 The shaking of sun, moon and stars occurs at the same time or in immediate connection with his coming, caused by God's voice, as an incident of the coming rather than merely a preceding sign.ST Mar 27, 1893
It appears as a small dark cloud in the east, growing brighter and larger until Christ is seen seated upon it among ten thousand angels, with fire beneath and rainbow above.RH Jul 21, 1851RH Mar 20, 1866RH Nov 11, 1915 At first Jesus is not discerned upon the cloud, and the cloud appears before his outlines and the angels' are fully discerned; then as it draws nearer his lovely person is beheld.RH Jul 21, 1851RH Jul 21, 1851ST Oct 19, 1915 His descent brings searching judgment in which the rejected are overcome with fear while those with clean hands and pure heart stand by sufficient grace, followed by resurrection of sleeping saints and gathering of living and resurrected believers to meet him.RH Jul 21, 1851RH Nov 11, 1915
Those looking for him recognize the sign without long suspense and rejoice, for watching believers see it first as the signal that his coming is immediate.RH May 7, 1867ST Sep 28, 1904 It appears as a radiant cloud growing brighter and larger with Jesus and angels around him, and the waiting living look up and lift their heads because redemption is near.RH Feb 17, 1853RH Jul 8, 1862ST Oct 8, 1902 Others who dread his presence call for rocks and mountains to hide them, and he sends angels to gather his elect and take them to God's Mount Zion.RH May 7, 1867
The sign precedes the visible coming itself and causes the mourning, and it is distinct both from the earlier nearness signs already fulfilled and from the coming, showing that Christ is present.ST Apr 1, 1886ST Feb 6, 1896RH Nov 21, 1871 It marks the closing harvest at the end of the world when angels separate wicked from righteous, and the occasion of gathering the elect from the four winds with trumpet sound.ST Apr 1, 1886ST Feb 6, 1896 When it appears it is too late to warn or to learn the fig-tree lesson, for it belongs to the closing events after destiny is fixed.ST Jun 19, 1907RH Jul 27, 1905
It is the next great event after nearly all preceding signs have been fulfilled, still future and to appear soon in worldwide upheaval when earthly dominions collapse.RH Apr 3, 1866RH Jan 9, 1900RH Oct 28, 1852 All but one of the heavenly signs had already occurred, with only one sign remaining before Christ is seen coming visibly with angels and redeemed.ST Feb 7, 1906RH Nov 10, 1874RH Dec 9, 1852 After the Image Beast's rage has lasted a short time the white cloud will be seen, bringing sorrow to rejecters who wish for rocks to hide them.RH Dec 9, 1852
It is heralded by a brightness appearing in heaven, growing as it approaches until outshining the sun, amid lightning and thunder and opened heaven.RH Jan 6, 1853RH Jul 14, 1903RH Aug 20, 1857 The sight brings hope of deliverance to afflicted servants and fear to the wicked, signaling that coming and salvation have arrived with the King shining from the east.RH Jan 6, 1853RH Jul 14, 1903RH Aug 20, 1857 Angels accompany him to gather the faithful from across the earth to meet him and receive everlasting life, opening heaven to sight and making earth bright as the kingdom of the redeemed.RH Jan 6, 1853RH Aug 20, 1857ST Jul 2, 1902ST Jun 12, 1901RH Nov 21, 1871
Proposed explanations of the sign as a fiery radiant cloud, a brilliant star, or the shechinah are judged doubtful. Nor is it a gigantic luminous cross in the sky, for the material cross was a Roman instrument of punishment while the true glory of Christ's cross is the atonement, the sacrifice made there.
The sign will soon appear with the heavens opened and the opening heavens revealing his glory, first as a small cloud later becoming a great white cloud before which kings and great people fall in terror and call for rocks and mountains.RH May 12, 1910ST Aug 31, 1915RH Sep 21, 1869 Its appearance comes after tribulation and signs in sun, moon, stars and heavens, followed by angels gathering the elect, with special signs beginning eighteen years before the time of the end.ST Aug 12, 1880 Once it appears it is too late to make the sacrifices proving trust in God's promise, so full consecration risking everything is required now without keeping a fallback plan.GSAM 163.2–164.4
Its appearing fulfills what precedes it, the gospel preached as witness to all nations, the rise of deceptive false prophets, and lightning flashing from east to west, together assuring that his coming is near. The sign is the Son himself, or at least his sudden personal appearance in the cloud, following directly after the shaking of the powers of the heavens.ST Mar 31, 1881 The cloud at first appears small then increases as quickly as lightning from east to west, and the shaking, the personal visible coming, and the gathering are literal future events not fulfilled spiritually in any past age.ST Mar 31, 1881
Mourning of All Tribes
The mourning of all the tribes of the earth proves that Christ does not come after a universal reign of peace and righteousness, and leaves no room for a millennium beforehand or for a secret or merely spiritual return in another form.ST Nov 11, 1913RH Jun 7, 1915ST Sep 8, 1914ST Nov 11, 1913RH Dec 20, 1853 His kingdom is established in connection with his visible coming in the clouds with power and great glory, not before it, and together with the gathering of the elect by angels it belongs to the harvest at the end of the world when the righteous are gathered and the wicked destroyed.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Nov 11, 1913RH Dec 20, 1853RH May 9, 1854 The tribes mourn when they see the sign of the Son of man and then see him himself coming, because the great day of wrath and judgment has arrived.ST May 13, 1880ST May 13, 1880ST Nov 25, 1889 At that coming his intercession for sinners has ceased, probation is ended, the offer of mercy is past and doom is fixed, so the wicked recognize they cannot escape his presence while those who trust in God and look for him rejoice with exceeding joy at the revelation of his own glory, his Father's glory and the glory of the holy angels.ST Nov 25, 1889ST Feb 27, 1893RH Oct 14, 1902 All the tribes means those then living who see him, not every person who has ever lived, since the wicked dead do not live again until a thousand years after this event.RH Apr 1, 1858RH May 18, 1869ST Jul 29, 1880RH Feb 18, 1875ST Aug 19, 1886
The tribes mourn because most people are unprepared, deceived by false christs and false prophets appearing privately and needing announcement, whereas the true return is conspicuous with all holy angels and trumpet sound so that every eye sees him for itself.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Oct 11, 1905RH Nov 24, 1868RH Jul 23, 1857RH Jul 4, 1871 His coming in power and great glory brings the King of Glory's reckoning with no escape, ends earthly political and financial rule, and finds men weighed by heaven's faultless standards and found wanting, refuting any peaceful transformation of the world or conversion of the world before his return.ST Oct 11, 1905RH Jul 23, 1857RH Jul 4, 1871 Both the righteous and the wicked, including the living wicked and those not looking for him, will actually see him, which is distinct from seeing the Father whom only the pure in heart will see, and seeing does not itself bring salvation.ST Aug 29, 1911ST Nov 23, 1915ST Mar 24, 1914RH Jun 25, 1867RH Nov 26, 1872 Enemies recognize the pierced one too late for benefit, with terror, wailing, and hiding in dens and rocks from the Lamb's wrath.RH May 31, 1870RH Jul 23, 1857
The mourning happens while the sign is already visible and Christ as King draws near the earth with blazing glory attended by all holy angels, during the seven last plagues after the shaking of the powers of heaven, after many wicked have been destroyed amid thunder, earthquake, hail, upheaval, ruined cities and mountains, and broken creation.RH Nov 24, 1868RH Jan 10, 1871ST Jan 10, 1911RH Apr 25, 1865 The saints look on with hopeful trembling joy and lift their heads because redemption is near, but the remaining wicked of every rank join in one wail of consternation and seek in vain to hide, crying for mountains and rocks to fall because probation has ended forever and no sinner can live through that piercing brightness.RH Jan 10, 1871ST Nov 6, 1893RH Jul 22, 1873RH Feb 18, 1875 The wicked nations wail and lament and are not converted, but are destroyed like chaff after the wheat has been gathered and by the brightness of his coming, with no further probation.RH Jan 17, 1907ST May 1, 1907ST Sep 16, 1930ST Nov 11, 1913 That coming brings Babylon's doom, the destruction of the kings of the whole world gathered for battle by the armies of heaven, and the transfer of the kingdoms of this world to the Lord and his Christ to reign forever, while the righteous are caught up to live eternally.RH May 11, 1916ST May 1, 1907
By the time the powers are shaken, the tribes mourn and the Son comes, it is too late to gain benefit from knowing he is near, for sealing time has passed and the wicked face certain destruction while the saints are being gathered.ST Jan 10, 1878RH Jan 17, 1856RH Apr 3, 1866RH Sep 10, 1872RH Jan 5, 1911 The condemned wail knowing their doom, turn vainly to godly friends, stand trembling at the left among devils while saints and angels shout praises as the sentence is executed and the wicked nations are dashed in pieces.ST Jan 10, 1878RH Sep 10, 1872 Recognition of the one pierced comes too late to benefit, gives no reason to expect world conversion, and shows the church is given no period of earthly prosperity or triumph but temptation, tribulation and death until his personal return ends the troubled condition and establishes righteousness.RH Dec 20, 1853RH May 9, 1854RH Jul 31, 1913RH May 31, 1870RH Dec 27, 1853 Those who scorn the advent may yet live to witness its terrors without receiving its benefits.
Gathering Resurrection and Reward
At his coming he sends his angels with great trumpet sound and with archangel voice and shout to gather his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other and across the earth, and those angels are the reapers who separate the wicked from the righteous in the harvest at the end of the world.RH Jun 10, 1915ST Nov 11, 1913ST Oct 21, 1889ST Mar 16, 1904 The tribes of the earth mourn when they see him coming in the clouds with power and great glory, and the gathering that follows shows his coming does not follow a universal reign of peace and is not the Roman destruction of Jerusalem, since then all nations were not gathered for judgment and the persecuted saints did not possess the kingdom.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Oct 21, 1889ST Mar 16, 1904ST Aug 13, 1902
The gathering is the hope of the resurrection: the dead saints are raised in the first resurrection and the living are changed from mortal to immortal in a moment, caught up together to meet the Lord in the air to be forever with him, to possess the kingdom and enter his joy, and this does not happen one by one at death.ST Jan 11, 1883ST Aug 19, 1886ST Oct 1, 1894ST Dec 7, 1915 The present gospel age ends with this visible return in power and great glory accompanied by his angels, when all the tribes see him and mourn, and it belongs with the gathering of all nations before his throne and the separation of righteous from wicked at the end of the present world.ST Jan 11, 1883ST Aug 19, 1886ST Sep 16, 1930ST Dec 7, 1915 It is not his own resurrection, nor Pentecost, nor a spiritual presence, nor conversion, nor the outpouring of the Spirit, nor the day of a person's death, but the promised way his people will be with him and their comfort.ST Aug 19, 1886ST Oct 1, 1894ST Dec 7, 1915
The saints are taken from the earth to be with the Lord in heaven, not met on earth to rule there, for his coming is in the clouds and not down to the earth to meet them there.RH Sep 4, 1856RH Nov 15, 1853ST May 11, 1904 At the beginning of the thousand years only the holy angels accompany him, and the saints are caught up to live and reign with him in heaven for a thousand years while the earth lies desolate and the wicked are dead, and only after that period, at the beginning of eternity, do the Lord and the saints come down in the New Jerusalem.ST May 11, 1904ST Jun 6, 1916RH Mar 23, 1852ST Aug 12, 1889 The actual appearing ends heavenly ministry, and angels and redeemed are gathered to return to the city of God, the journey to the sea of glass taking about seven days.ST May 11, 1904ST Aug 12, 1889
At that coming the righteous dead from Abel to the last saint rise incorruptible in immortal youth pictured by his resurrection, the living are changed, and all are taken home to the mansions, the Holy City above, and the sea of glass to remain with him forever, while some are translated without death as Enoch was and the living wicked are destroyed.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Oct 31, 1878RH Jul 17, 1913RH May 22, 1866 Those who belong to Christ, including the disciples who died, will rise from their graves to see their Master appear, proving there is life for the just beyond the grave though righteous and wicked alike seem to go to dust together.ST Feb 20, 1879RH Feb 4, 1875RH May 22, 1866 He will receive the obedient and loyal to himself, crown the righteous with glory and honor, and separate the wicked from his presence to be consumed with fire when the world is in a corrupt, boastful, presumptuous, self-willed state of rebellion against God's law.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Oct 31, 1878
After the resurrection the sign of the Son of man appears in heaven, then comes the gathering of his saints, and afterward the wicked are gathered as the vine of the earth and cast into the winepress of God's wrath.RH Dec 16, 1858RH Sep 14, 1911ST Apr 21, 1909 His visible return in power and glory follows the fulfillment of the signs he gave and comes near the close of time after the gospel has been preached to every nation, when people must stand before him and the righteous who have kept God's law receive the crown of life and eternal life to dwell with the Lord.ST Mar 6, 1893RH Mar 5, 1867RH Sep 14, 1911ST Apr 21, 1909 Some living people may be caught up to meet him without first dying, and the prepared believer will then be changed to meet him in the air and share his immortality, while those who accept his offer of freedom and make him King and Lord in heart now will be able to see him and those remaining in sin will perish with it.ST Mar 6, 1893ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 21, 1909
The dead know nothing and wait until Christ is seen coming in the clouds with power and great glory, and they do not receive immortality or enter a spirit world or go to God and heaven to be with him before that return.ST Dec 10, 1885RH Nov 22, 1853ST Aug 13, 1874RH Dec 12, 1854 Being with Christ where he is happens only when he comes again, so his coming is the Christian hope, and the teaching that souls go to heaven at death puts people in heaven before the last trumpet sounds, before the dead are raised, and before Christ is seen returning and sends his angels to gather his chosen, in defiance of his word.ST Dec 10, 1885ST Aug 13, 1874ST Nov 9, 1882RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 1, 1860 The change of the living and the resurrection of the dead are the hope connected with his personal, public, literal return with trumpet sound, which is joined to the resurrection of the dead and the general judgment.ST Nov 9, 1882RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 1, 1860
The gathering brings together the raised dead and the living caught up to meet the Lord, and takes the righteous by the angels to their rest when Christ appears in glory at the last day.ST Feb 25, 1897ST Dec 4, 1884ST Aug 7, 1884 It places their entrance into the world of bliss and into his heavenly kingdom at his second coming, not in the intermediate state after death, and as he visibly departed so he will visibly return.ST Feb 25, 1897ST Dec 4, 1884RH Jan 7, 1873 He comes after receiving his kingdom and glory from the Father rather than coming to that tribunal to receive them, to take possession of the earth when probation closes after enough righteous have been saved to populate the new earth and fulfill God's original purpose, to receive his jewels into the everlasting kingdom and heavenly home with reunion of loved ones.RH Nov 30, 1869ST Aug 7, 1884ST Mar 4, 1875
His revelation in power and great glory follows the Father's judgment tribunal where the Son receives glory and kingdom, and the Father's majesty displayed there attends Christ when he is revealed, so the judgment scene and the ending of his intercession precede his descent and his sending angels to gather the elect, though the time between is not specified.ST Feb 21, 1878RHRH Nov 1, 1870RH Nov 30, 1869ST Feb 21, 1878 This coming to earth is distinct from the earlier scene in Daniel 7 where he comes to the Ancient of Days to receive the kingdom after his priesthood and wedding, and from the 1844 coming to judgment, and his vesture proves him already crowned King having received throne and dominion.ST Feb 21, 1878RH Nov 30, 1869ST Feb 21, 1878 It is his immediate coming after probation, not a secret coming, and the living wicked will see him.ST Aug 29, 1911RHRH Nov 1, 1870
He comes to raise the righteous dead and destroy the wicked, and his coming means exactly what it says, not the conversion of sinners, nor the death of saints, nor the coming of the Holy Spirit, nor a temporal millennium, nor another spiritualized application.ST Apr 22, 1875RH May 13, 1875 His coming is visible in the clouds with power and great glory, not a secret rapture nor a coming at individual deaths, and it brings an end to unrighteousness and to those who take pleasure in it.ST Apr 22, 1875RH May 13, 1875 Although the wicked will be destroyed by his coming, their destruction is not its express purpose, for he comes to deliver his faithful people.ST Aug 10, 1915
His coming with his mighty angels matches Enoch's prophecy that the Lord would come with ten thousands of his saints, since saints can refer to angels as well as good people, and the saints will be taken to heaven in the same manner as Enoch was translated.ST Sep 27, 1883ST Sep 27, 1883 Every eye will see him, including those who pierced him, he will come in glory with the heavenly host, all nations will be gathered before him, and the dead will be raised, including those whose bodies are in the sea.ST Sep 27, 1883ST Sep 27, 1883RH Nov 20, 1860 He will come at the close of Satan's first phase of rule to gather the good out of Satan's kingdom and deliver them forever from Satan's power, while the evil are left behind with Satan.RH Nov 20, 1860ST Feb 28, 1911
Those translated when he comes are people whose whole souls desire heaven and heavenly things and whose thoughts delight and dwell in honesty, moral integrity and uprightness.ST Mar 30, 1882 Until he is manifested and seen the Christian's life is hidden with Christ in God, and when Christ appears God's children will also be fully manifested in glory.ST He appears in clouds of glory to receive his own to himself, and those who accept the gospel message, including Moslems who see in it the same glorious saving power and are convinced Christ really died for them as well as for others, will in not a small number be waiting for him at that coming.ST
Sources