Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Or if he ask a fish, will he give him a serpent?
Or if he shall ask a fish, will he give him a serpent?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
or if he shall ask for a fish, will give him a serpent?
and if a fish he may ask — a serpent will he present to him?
and if he ask a fish, will give him a serpent?
Or, a fish also, shall ask,—a serpent, will give him?
Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a snake?
And if he asks for a fish, will give him a snake?
Or if he asks for a fish, who will give him a serpent?
Or if he makes a request for a fish, will give him a snake?
Or if he aske fish, wil he giue him a serpent?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Or if he shall ask him a fish, will he reach him a serpent?
Pictures

Cross-references
- Luke 11:11-13
If a son shall ask bread of any of you that is a father, will he give him a stone? or if he ask a fish, will he for a fish give him a serpent?
The fish-and-serpent example contrasts a father’s care with God’s good gifts to those who ask.
- John 16:24
Hitherto have ye asked nothing in my name: ask, and ye shall receive, that your joy may be full.
Both promise that asking leads to receiving.
- Luke 11:11
If a son shall ask bread of any of you that is a father, will he give him a stone? or if he ask a fish, will he for a fish give him a serpent?
Repeats the comparison of a father answering a child’s request.
- James 1:5
If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God, that giveth to all men liberally, and upbraideth not; and it shall be given him.
Both promise wisdom to those who ask God.
- Romans 8:32
He that spared not his own Son, but delivered him up for us all, how shall he not with him also freely give us all things?
God’s gift of his Son grounds confidence that he hears prayer.
- James 1:17
Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and cometh down from the Father of lights, with whom is no variableness, neither shadow of turning.
Good gifts come from the Father, who gives good things to those who ask.
- 1 John 5:14
And this is the confidence that we have in him, that, if we ask any thing according to his will, he heareth us:
God hears requests made according to his will.
- Luke 11:9
And I say unto you, Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you.
Both promise that asking, seeking, and knocking will receive an answer.
- Matthew 6:8
Be not ye therefore like unto them: for your Father knoweth what things ye have need of, before ye ask him.
Prayer rests on confidence that God knows and attends to human needs.
- John 15:7
If ye abide in me, and my words abide in you, ye shall ask what ye will, and it shall be done unto you.
Both promise that asking will be answered.
- John 16:23
And in that day ye shall ask me nothing. Verily, verily, I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall ask the Father in my name, he will give it you.
The Father gives what is asked in Jesus’ name.
- John 14:13
And whatsoever ye shall ask in my name, that will I do, that the Father may be glorified in the Son.
Both promise that asking will be answered.
- John 14:14
If ye shall ask any thing in my name, I will do it.
Jesus promises to act on requests made in his name.
- James 4:3
Ye ask, and receive not, because ye ask amiss, that ye may consume it upon your lusts.
Both connect asking with whether one receives.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
65 sources
A father whose child asks for a fish or for food does not mock or deceive him by giving a serpent or something harmful in its place.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5 As even imperfect and sinful parents know how to give good gifts to their children, much more surely will the Father in heaven give good things to those who ask Him.Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5 The good things He promises are above all the Holy Spirit, given abundantly to every needy soul who desires and seeks the things of God.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 28, 1900, par. 1Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 He withholds no good thing, but decides what is for the petitioner's good, and when what is asked would hurt He withholds it and gives instead what is good and healthful.MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 93, 1898, par. 3–5 Therefore those who need are to come as little children in simple, confiding trust, asking individually and directly for what He has promised, believing they receive it and persevering without doubt.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14Ms 115, 1905, par. 10–11Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10
Setting and Picture
The verse is part of the Sermon on the Mount, which was given especially to the disciples while the gathered multitude also heard it.DA 298.2–3 That sermon disappoints hope of worldly greatness and undoes false education by giving a right conception of Christ's kingdom and of His own character.DA 299.3 It sets forth the conditions of entrance into the kingdom of God without making a direct attack on error, leaving the hearers to draw their own conclusions as to its nature.DA 299.3 It lays down foundation principles of the kingdom of God that are no less important now than to the multitude on the hillside.DA 299.3 The verse belongs to the far-reaching principles taught in that sermon, principles that must be impressed on the heart because the state of the heart regulates the life and character.Lt 7, 1886, par. 34
The picture is a father answering his son or child who asks for a fish or for food.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15 A loving father does not answer that request with something harmful in its place, and a requested fish is not replaced with a serpent.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3 He does not give what would harm or deceive the child, nor does he mock, deceive, or disappoint him.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15 The contrast between the good thing asked and the harmful thing withheld illustrates that God gives good things to those who ask Him.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15 It supports confidence in coming to God in prayer and asking for good things, with His children to ask in living faith and depend on Him as little children.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3
Heavenly Father's Goodness
The picture is of a loving father answering a child who asks for food: he does not mock, deceive or disappoint him by putting something harmful in place of what was asked, and a fish requested is not replaced with a serpent.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5 As that earthly father does not answer with harm, so God does not answer those who ask Him with something harmful, but as a good Father gives good things and good gifts to those who ask Him.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10MYP 122.2–123.1 He does not answer a sincere request for what is good by giving evil instead, and this supports confidence in coming to Him in prayer and asking for good things.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3 His children are to ask in living faith and depend on Him as little children, trusting His promise rather than treating feelings as the measure of faith, for He knows their helplessness and lack of righteousness and will help and supply what they lack.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5
Though men are evil, imperfect and sinful, they know how to give good gifts to their children, and much more surely will the Father in heaven give good things and good gifts to those who ask Him.Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34 Even an imperfect human father gives good things to his child, so the heavenly Father is far more ready to answer those who ask.Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34ST Dec 12, 1892 His care is more merciful, tender, patient and loving than that of any earthly parent.Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15 He sustains the same tender relation to believers that a father sustains to his children, and regards all members of His earthly family, whatever their age, learning, rank, riches or honor, as no more than little children.Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43
Christ's teaching here contradicts human maxims and traditions taught as God's commandments, sweeps away Satan's misrepresentations of God, and reveals God not as a stern judge incapable of compassion, mercy and love but as a Father in true paternal relation to men.FE 309.1 It restores confidence in His love, reveals His character as paternal love, and leads men to know Him as Father and to address Him in sincerity as Our Father.FE 309.1 Christ Himself gave this lesson to people in sorrow and affliction to teach them to come for help with confidence that they would not seek in vain.Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29 His whole earthly life, filled with deeds of mercy and compassion toward the sufferers who thronged Him even when He was weary and needed rest, proves the willingness of the Father to give good things to those who ask.Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29
God stands behind His promises, withholds no good thing, does not restrict asking to certain things but blesses according to the riches of His grace.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 93, 1898, par. 3–5 As a good Father He decides what is for the petitioner's good.MYP 122.2–123.1 When a child asks for something that would hurt him, like a loving earthly parent He withholds what was asked and gives instead what is good and healthful for him.SG4 166.2–4GW92 114.1 Every honest prayer offered in faith from an honest heart is heard and answered with the blessing needed, often when most needed and beyond expectation.SG4 166.2–4GW92 114.1 In giving Jesus Christ He has already given all heaven, withholding nothing that He can give, so the promise is to be repeated in full confidence and taken as more sure and valuable than any human word, a barricade of infallible promise so that the wicked one cannot touch the trusting soul, to be received with wholehearted thanks.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34
Good Gifts Given
The good things promised to those who ask are the Holy Spirit, for whom people are to thirst as they seek godliness.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2 No spiritual condition bars anyone from asking, for the only condition is to desire and seek the things of God.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2 The promise therefore leaves no reason for doubt or hesitation.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2
God is more willing to give the Holy Spirit to those who ask Him than parents are to give good gifts to their children.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 He does not deny His children this gift, but as One who is good and righteous He gives blessings abundantly according to the riches of His grace.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 28, 1900, par. 1 He does not restrict asking to certain things, and His willingness rests on the definite Thus saith the Lord that belongs to every individual, not to conference presidents alone, so each one is to wait upon the Lord individually and seek Him for efficiency and help rather than depending on man.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11
The father who would not answer a child's request for a fish with a serpent assures sincere seekers that the heavenly Father gives good gifts, including the guidance of the Holy Spirit, to those who ask in faith.Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26ST Sep 5, 19002MR 26.120MR 192.4–193.1 Those who sincerely seek that guidance, including the teacher of true wisdom, will not be disappointed and will receive guidance rather than harm.ST Sep 5, 19002MR 26.120MR 192.4–193.1Ms 17, 1890, par. 19–21 Those who recognize their helplessness without Christ and ask for God's power will have their wants satisfied from His abundant fullness.ST Sep 9, 1889Ms 17, 1890, par. 19–21
God reveals Himself for His own name's sake and gives the assurance of the Holy Spirit to every needy soul, withholding nothing that He can give because in giving Jesus Christ He has already given all heaven.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34 The promise is to be repeated in full confidence as more sure and valuable than any human word, a barricade of infallible promise so that the wicked one cannot touch the trusting soul, to be received with wholehearted thanks.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34 He can be trusted to keep His promises and give divine help needed in trials and temptation, abundant grace when His children ask, His love to those who ask, and power to remain steadfast to those who ask in faith and persevere in seeking.Ms 198, 1898, par. 24Ms 39, 1893, par. 6–7Lt 20, 1876, par. 9–10Lt 148, 1899, par. 11–13 He hears those who come to Him, including the weak and hesitant, and gives strength and guidance rather than harm, drawing near to encourage them through His Word, His promises, and the Holy Spirit.19MR 10.1
The verse is a rich and full promise of spiritual nourishment, a heavenly banquet spread before those who feel their great soul need and hunger and thirst after righteousness.Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10 By asking and receiving the bread of heaven, good to the soul, the believer grows in grace, gains grace and strength day by day from the Source of all power, with strength for duty and fullness of peace.Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10ST Jan 29, 1902 Prayer is as necessary to the Christian life as food is to the physical life, and to every sincere, earnest prayer an answer will come, though not always just as desired or at the time expected, but always for good in the way and at the time that is for the best good, with prayers offered in loneliness, weariness, and trial answered by God.ST Jan 29, 1902
Prayer of Trust
The verse calls for coming to God as little children, in simple, childlike, confiding trust, with humility and dependence, trusting His promise and believing that He hears prayer.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–435T 201.1 Feelings are not to be taken as the measure of faith, for He knows human helplessness and lack of righteousness and will help and supply what is lacking.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43 Every member of the family is invited on this ground to come humbly in faith and present petitions, asking simply and faithfully for the blessings needed.Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–145T 201.1Ms 98a, 1905, par. 4 To doubt that He will hear is cruel, since He will not deceive or disappoint those who ask.Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43
Believers are to ask individually, simply and directly for what they need and for what He has promised, believing they receive it and persevering in seeking.Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10Ms 39, 1893, par. 6–7Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 Prayer is to be humble, trusting and persevering, without the doubt and unbelief that bar the open way.Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10 Weak, uncertain faith is thereby rebuked, and simple, unfaltering trust is called for toward One who has every good thing in store for those who walk uprightly.Ms 115, 1905, par. 10–11Ms 115, 1905, par. 7–9 Each person has the same privilege of waiting on the Lord individually and putting petitions before Him for efficiency and help, rather than depending on man.Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11
The promise leaves no reason for doubt or hesitation, for there is no spiritual condition barring any person from asking whose condition is to desire and seek the things of God.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2 It supports confidence in coming to God in prayer and asking for good things, bringing needs to Him earnestly and confidently without fearing that He will tire of being asked.Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3ST Mar 15, 1899 This is reason to ask Him more often and to praise Him, with expectation of receiving.Ms 75, 1909, par. 10–11ST Mar 15, 1899
Every sincere request sent up in faith from an honest heart is heard and answered, unlocking the treasury of heaven for which God holds Himself responsible.GW92 114.1Lt 49, 1903, par. 20 He gives His best and choicest gifts to supply great need because He loves to help.Lt 49, 1903, par. 20 No prayer of a true saint sent up in faith from an honest heart is lost.GW92 114.1
The answer may not come just as desired or at the time looked for, but it will come in the way and at the time that best meets need and brings good.MYP 250.2–3ST Jan 29, 1902 The blessing is often received when most needed and beyond what was expected, as a loving parent withholds what would hurt and gives instead what is good and healthful.SG4 166.2–4GW92 114.1 Prayer is as necessary to the Christian life as food is to the physical life, and by asking and receiving the bread of heaven the believer grows in grace, gains strength for duty, and is filled with peace, faith, comfort, hope, cheerfulness and courage.ST Jan 29, 1902Lt 323, 1904, par. 8
The verse means God invites people to come and commit their souls to Him, trusting His wisdom and power.Lt 49, 1903, par. 20 The heart is to be opened to His Spirit so that He works through the believer and blesses the labor, bringing faith, peace and comfort.Lt 49, 1903, par. 20 Those who pray are brought to the footstool of mercy and under the bow of promise, placed in right relation to Him where they can be sure of heaven's best gifts.Ms 85, 1909, par. 16Ms 53, 1898, par. 14 There they commune with God as the source of the strength and power Christ received in His humanity.Ms 53, 1898, par. 14
Confidence for Life
Those who plead with the heavenly Father for His promises and salvation do not receive a stone or a scorpion or a serpent in return, not something harmful or deceptive or a soul-damning influence.ExVEGW 6.3–41T 71.1–2ST May 30, 1878EW 16.3–17.1 Prayer and spiritual experience sought from God are therefore not mesmerism and not satanic deception, and there is no reason to fear that sincere seeking will be answered with an evil influence.ExVEGW 6.3–41T 71.1–2ST May 30, 1878EW 16.3–17.1 The assurance belongs to those who sincerely seek Him and claim His promises, that He will not give them deception instead of the spiritual good they ask for.1T 71.1–2ST May 30, 1878EW 16.3–17.1
The same fatherly care assures God's servants that He gives what they need to advance His work and to help His people in their work for Him.Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6RH Sep 7, 1905Ms 146, 1905, par. 4–9Ms 146a, 1905, par. 4–9 As an earthly parent would not answer a child's request for food with something harmful, believers can approach the heavenly Father with childlike trust, relying on His promises and believing that He hears prayer.Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6RH Sep 7, 1905Ms 146, 1905, par. 4–9Ms 146a, 1905, par. 4–9 This confidence was applied to asking God to move His people to provide the Nashville workers the means and help they need, to move them to send help for their work.RH Sep 7, 1905Ms 146, 1905, par. 4–9Ms 146a, 1905, par. 4–9
Prayer to God is answered with goodness and not with mockery or deception, for a father does not mock his son by giving a serpent when he asks for a fish.Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 Even men, being evil, know how to give good gifts to their children, so much more surely will the Father in heaven give good things to those who ask Him.Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 Those who lack wisdom are therefore to ask God directly and to look to Jesus instead of leaning on human wisdom and human guidance, which is a snare to souls and a broken reed.Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 The promise belongs to every individual and not only to conference presidents, so each one is to wait upon the Lord individually and put petitions before Him, seeking Him for efficiency and help rather than depending on man, on the definite Thus saith the Lord.Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11
Everyone may come to the Father for what is needed, regardless of color or nationality or weakness or wealth, for there is no caste with God.ST May 6, 1880Lt 49, 1875, par. 1410MR 308.310MR 115.2 When trials reveal helplessness, believers are to call on God for help as a hungry or thirsty child calls on an earthly father, for God is their helper and has abundant provision for them.ST May 6, 1880Lt 49, 1875, par. 1410MR 308.310MR 115.2 He hears earnest prayer and gives the help needed to resist temptation and to overcome sinful habits, and the weak and hesitant can pray with confidence that God will hear and save them.ST May 6, 1880Lt 49, 1875, par. 1410MR 115.2
Christ Himself gave this lesson to people in sorrow and affliction to teach them to come for help with confidence that they would not seek in vain.Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29Lt 80, 1894, par. 34–35Lt 323, 1904, par. 8 His whole earthly life, filled with deeds of mercy and compassion toward those who thronged Him even when He was weary and needed rest, proves the willingness of the Father in heaven to give good things to those who ask.Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29Lt 80, 1894, par. 34–35 God would have seekers hopeful and cheerful, with hearts filled with thanksgiving and praise and joy, looking on the bright side rather than the dark side, talking faith and hope and courage, and holding fast to the hand of divine power.Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29Lt 80, 1894, par. 34–35Lt 323, 1904, par. 8 His desire is that the hearts of the humble and contrite who are one with Him should be filled with His joy, and Christ's love received in the heart should likewise shape words and actions toward others in tender, generous care.Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29Lt 80, 1894, par. 34–35
Applied to God's servants, the child-and-father image warns them not to offer people harmful or empty teaching when they are hungry for spiritual food.Ms 101, 1901, par. 11–15Lt 106, 1902, par. 15–18 They must give the flock bread rather than a stone, pure spiritual food that leads to Christ and meets its need, what is spiritually nourishing and not what harms or fails to meet need.Ms 101, 1901, par. 11–15Lt 106, 1902, par. 15–18 This instruction on God's faithful giving, that He does not answer those who ask Him with something harmful but gives good things to those who ask, is part of the genuine science of higher education that physicians and ministers should study.Ms 25, 1906, par. 10–12Lt 148a, 1897, par. 1–2 It belongs to Jesus' teaching about a willing, gracious heavenly Father who responds to those who call upon Him, encouraging hope and courage in times of difficulty and trust that the Father will not withhold any good thing from those who love Him.Ms 25, 1906, par. 10–12Lt 148a, 1897, par. 1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
92 sources
A father asked for a fish does not answer with a serpent, a harmful and mocking opposite that cannot feed and would injure the child.RH Mar 22, 1870ST Feb 17, 1881 Even fathers who are sinful and imperfect know how to give good gifts to their children, so the Father in heaven will much more give good things to those who ask and trust Him.ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jul 8, 1858 He never answers a request for what is good with what is harmful or evil, and when what was asked is withheld it is because it would do harm, with something better given in its place.ST Feb 1, 1899ST Feb 1, 1899ST Jan 23, 1912ST Feb 23, 1915ST Dec 19, 1892 Even when sickness, poverty, tribulation or trial looks like a serpent instead of the fish requested, what He sends is for the believer's good and is to be received in faith rather than judged by appearances.ST Jan 23, 1912ST Jan 23, 1912 The promise belongs especially to the gift of the Holy Spirit, whom the heavenly Father is far more ready to give than earthly parents are to give good things, so those who ask need not fear being answered with deception or an evil influence.ST Dec 12, 1892ST Jul 4, 1911RH Jul 24, 1856ST Aug 11, 1914RH Jul 21, 1851 His readiness to bless is the reason to bless others and to give hungry souls true food rather than doubt and unbelief.RH Nov 16, 1911ST Dec 27, 1905RH Aug 1, 1912ST Jun 3, 1897
Words and Sermon Setting
The picture is of a father asked by his child for a fish who answers with a serpent, a harmful and opposite substitute that mocks the need, cannot sustain life, and would injure the child.RH Mar 22, 1870ST Feb 17, 1881ST Jan 23, 1912 The contrast is vivid and simple enough for even a very young child to grasp, and it parallels the stone given for bread.RH Jan 6, 1916ST Jun 3, 1897 The saying belongs to the discourse in Matthew 5-7, beautiful teaching that gives spiritual food and calls disciples to choose the spiritual above the earthly. Its blessed truths, as in Luke's sermon on the plain, were needed by the hearers.ST Nov 5, 1894
It is the second sermon on the mount, given nearly fifteen centuries after Sinai by the selfsame voice that spoke the law at Sinai amid thunder, lightning, thick cloud, trumpet, smoke, and fire with ten thousands of saints.ST Sep 22, 1909 It does not retract or nullify any portion of that law, but holds gracious words to be read, meditated upon, and fed upon.ST Sep 22, 1909 As part of the Sermon on the Mount it verbally declares the law's underlying principles and the blessings of righteousness, presenting the law not merely as a written standard but as a life of positive righteousness expressed in love and care for others.ST Aug 6, 1912 It vindicates rather than contrasts with or replaces the Ten Commandments.RH Jul 26, 1870 Its teaching stands against using an invented higher law to excuse acts contrary to God's law.RH Feb 28, 1907
The Sermon sets out the principles of Christ's spiritual kingdom while civil governments continue, not rules for governing a temporal state.ST Apr 9, 1896 Those principles could guide a government only if every person had Christ's Spirit, and in such a society there would be no adversaries, lawsuits, or prisons.ST Apr 9, 1896 With Romans 12 and 1 Corinthians 13 it gives a full-length picture of a Bible Christian.RH Jan 21, 1875 It sets a high standard that can make readers shrink back and ask how they can come up to it, yet the standard must stay high because human effort falls far below what is undertaken.RH Jan 21, 1875 Doing what it requires and living as a Bible Christian is necessary to stand acquitted when the heavens depart as a scroll and all, small and great, stand before God and are judged by the Bible.RH Jan 21, 1875 It teaches the Spirit of Christ and requires meekness as an essential element of true Christian experience, as truly a fruit of the Spirit as faith or love.ST Apr 6, 1882 Want of meekness blurs the whole character, blasts usefulness, and puts doubt about the power of grace and the reality of religion into the minds of sinners, while harshness, retaliation, and fits of anger are sin, the fruit of remaining carnality, the proof of an unsanctified nature, and a disgrace to the Christian name.ST Apr 6, 1882
Its teaching about God's fatherly love does not exclude His justice, for God is both Father and Judge without contradiction.RH Apr 4, 1871 Its teaching about mercy does not contradict divine justice or Christ's punishment of sin, for Christ's rule includes both love and judgment.RH Apr 4, 1871 It belongs to Jesus' teaching in Matthew 7 that God does not give harmful things to those who ask.
Father Proves God's Goodness
No father among men answers a son who asks for a fish by giving a serpent instead, deceiving him and mocking his need with what is harmful rather than food.ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jul 8, 1858ST May 3, 1899ST Aug 25, 1887 The appeal is to mere earthly parental affection and ordinary human fatherly goodness, set out in two illustrations of a child's request for food, to guarantee willingness to give what children ask.ST Jun 13, 1900 Even men who are evil, sinful, imperfect and selfish know how to give good gifts to their children and would not refuse to supply their wants, so the Father in heaven will much more give good things to those who ask Him and trust Him.ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jul 8, 1858ST May 3, 1899ST Aug 25, 1887 There is therefore no fear of refusal of spiritual help, since help from God is needed for spiritual welfare and success in work, and the way is to ask, seek and knock with confidence.ST Aug 25, 1887
A loving parent does not turn from a hungry son, trifle with him, tantalize him by raising expectation only to disappoint him, or promise good and nourishing food and then give what is useless or harmful.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Apr 28, 1909RH Dec 2, 1915 God welcomes His children's appeals and will not deceive them in this way.ST Apr 28, 1909 Much less will He dishonor Himself by refusing the call of His children, promising good life-giving help and then disappointing their confident hopes.ST Jul 4, 1911RH Dec 2, 1915RH Apr 20, 1916 Those who come as repenting sinners through Jesus to a merciful, forgiving Father, knocking and waiting at the throne of mercy with firm assurance, are assured He will do just as promised, and those who ask for definite things in faith may believe He hears and will give what is sought.ST Jul 4, 1911RH Apr 20, 1916
God is patient with those who ask and does not answer harshly or so quickly as to make them afraid to ask.ST Feb 13, 1907RH Mar 21, 1907 His care is pictured by a father who listens kindly to a child's questions and welcomes his children's requests.ST Feb 13, 1907RH Jul 8, 1909 He hears the humble prayer of those who call on Him, cares for them, is not too busy to attend to their needs, and grants their requests when He sees it is best.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Jul 8, 1909 Prayer is thus personal trust in a Father who welcomes requests rather than a fearful approach to one who repels them.RH Jul 8, 1909RH Mar 21, 1907
He is infinite in love and compassion with power to give, still more ready than imperfect human parents to hear prayer and answer with good gifts.ST Oct 21, 1897 As the perfect Father He has every good quality in its fullest measure, hears His children's troubles and needs, and is willing to supply what is good.ST Sep 17, 1902 Like a loving father He pities His children, understands their weakness, is mindful of His people, supplies what their needs require, and offers forgiveness and strength when they have sinned.RH Jun 19, 1856ST Sep 17, 1902RH May 2, 1871 As Father of His disciples they are to pray to Him, ask and receive, trusting with faith and confidence in His nearness, power, and willingness to supply their wants.RH May 2, 1871 As a father provides for his children, so God provides for His own, and this makes Him the model of fatherhood, showing that a human father should likewise protect and instruct his children.RH Nov 18, 1902
God Gives Only Good
God gives only good things and never answers a request for what is good with what is harmful or evil.ST Feb 1, 1899ST Feb 1, 1899ST Feb 23, 1915RH Oct 14, 1902 When a request is not granted it is because what was asked was not truly good, even if it appeared good to the asker.ST Feb 1, 1899ST Feb 1, 1899 He may withhold things in this life when they would do harm, but He gives what is best.RH Jul 15, 1862ST Feb 23, 1915
Prayer rightly offered in faith and humility is heard and granted.RH Sep 20, 1864ST Oct 6, 1898 Prayers for spiritual graces may be made without qualification, while requests for temporal blessings should be subject to God's pleasure.RH Sep 20, 1864 The answer may be what was asked or something better, for God grants requests in harmony with His will, and children can trust His promises without doubting.RH Sep 20, 1864ST Oct 6, 1898 When a child ignorantly asks for what would harm him, a loving father withholds it and gives something better instead, and so God answers prayer by refusing what is not best and giving what is better.ST Sep 15, 1887
Like a father who gives a thirsty child milk instead of water because it is better, God may replace what is mistakenly thought best with a richer blessing, including grace to guide and strength to bear burdens.ST Dec 19, 1892 His answer may be a refusal rather than the requested blessing, but such a refusal is still an answer and is not the opposite of loving care.ST Jan 23, 1912
Requests for pardon, holiness, and salvation according to His will are certain to be heard.RH Jul 15, 1862 To every sincere earnest prayer an answer will come, though not just as desired or at the time looked for, but in the way and at the time that is for the best good.ST Jan 29, 1902 He satisfies wants from His abundant fullness for those helpless without Christ, and those who recognize their helplessness and ask for God's power will not be disappointed.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Jan 29, 1902 Prayer is as necessary to the Christian life as food is to the physical life, and by asking and receiving the bread of heaven the believer grows in grace, gains strength for duty, and is filled with peace.ST Jan 29, 1902 Requests made at the throne of grace receive a favorable reply, so those who pray should expect an answer, wait for it, and be disappointed if it does not come rather than ask and go away as if no answer were expected.RH Oct 16, 1860 Christ has given strength to others who asked, and fellow travelers can by asking still receive strength to be whatever they will for God.
The verse gives assurance to bring needs earnestly and confidently without fearing He will tire, and to ask directly as a child asks for food.RH Apr 20, 1916ST Dec 19, 1892ST Nov 16, 1888 It supports asking God for definite things with faith, believing that He hears and will give what is sought.RH Apr 20, 1916 People in every kind of need, whether great or small, may ask and receive what they need.RH Oct 9, 1900 It encourages asking Him in times of trial, war, famine, drought, pestilence, and want.RH Feb 14, 1865 This assurance encourages prayer for oneself and for others, including family members and those who are lost.ST Dec 19, 1892 Asking is simple and proper and should not be treated as remarkable, and prayer as asking God to meet real needs does not require eloquent or lengthy words.ST Nov 16, 1888 What counts is the heart coming with sense of need and simple faith in God's wisdom, power, and goodness, and those who ask in faith will not be turned away empty, for He answers sincere humble prayer and does not disappoint the confident hopes of His trusting children.ST Feb 23, 1915RH Apr 20, 1916ST May 7, 1894
Prayer does not persuade God to become loving or merciful, since His love and mercy are already infinite.ST Dec 1, 1898 Prayer turns people toward that love and makes hearts willing to receive the best gifts an all-wise Father can give.ST Dec 1, 1898 Asking God for needed things is part of seeking the help that supplies wants and prepares for life with the redeemed.RH Jan 23, 1866
The verse applies to asking God for healing as well as forgiveness.ST May 12, 1898 Bodily disease is not to be accepted as necessary bondage, and the afflicted are urged to ask in faith, trusting God to heal when the obstacle in the heart is surrendered, with these gifts sought for God's honor and glory.ST May 12, 1898 It supports confidence in asking God for daily strength, which is not denied to those who ask.RH Aug 26, 1875 He hears earnest prayer and gives the help needed to resist temptation and overcome sinful habits.ST May 6, 1880
Christ gives help to every soul who asks in faith, including the weakest person who trusts in God.RH May 29, 1900 He will care for His people through affliction and provide what they need, even when comforts decline or the future is unknown.ST Oct 31, 1906
God's hearing is shown by concrete provisions for real needs.RH Jun 11, 1914ST Feb 27, 1893 When children prayed for shoes, shoes soon arrived through a neighbor, and help with clothing and money came through another person. When a person asked for a way to keep the Sabbath even while expecting to lose a day's pay or forfeit a position, God answered by moving those in authority to allow work on Sunday instead of the Sabbath without loss of salary.RH Jun 11, 1914 Help arriving after prayer is seen when a woman provided money for undertaker's and doctor's bills, and both the recipient and the undertaker thanked God for answering prayer.ST Feb 27, 1893 The Garhwal school buildings stand as evidence that God hears and answers prayer. A child who asked for things deeply wanted had prayers answered.RH Nov 11, 1915 A traveler's journey and the help found illustrate His care for those who depend on Him.
Seeming Refusals Are Good
Even when sickness, poverty, tribulation or trials look like a serpent given instead of the fish that was asked for, they are gifts sent for the believer's good and best when God sends them.ST Jan 23, 1912ST Jan 23, 1912 What seems to be a serpent may in fact be the fish requested, because its true nature can be mistaken.ST Jan 23, 1912ST Jan 23, 1912 Trust must therefore rest on sure word rather than appearances and limited sight, receiving His dealings in faith.ST Jan 23, 1912ST Jan 23, 1912
Like a kind and wise father He does not answer His children with what would harm them, nor does He chasten them while withholding the knowledge they need.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 Even His chastening comes with needed knowledge, for He teaches through every providence.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 When bread seems answered with a stone, the stone becomes a pillow for dreams of angels and a ladder to heaven, and morning brings manna so that the asker is fed. When strength is asked and fainting comes in the noontide heat, the Master lifts with sympathetic care and carries on His arm till the task is complete. When light is asked and night and tempest close around, lightning and a leading pillar of fire make the way straight and the path bright.
Prayer is answered though the answer may be delayed or different from expectation, as a loving parent withholds what was asked and provides something better.RH Sep 6, 1870ST Jun 28, 1883RH Jan 8, 1901 He will not answer prayer for good with something harmful, but gives the very gifts sought when hearts are weak, and often faith must learn a deeper rest and trust His silence when He does not speak.RH Sep 6, 1870RH Jan 8, 1901 The despairing one is to ask and believe, opening the heart and pleading each desire, hoping in God, resting in His love, yielding all, proving His fullness, casting self away and looking above.RH Sep 6, 1870 His boundless love gives rest to the care-burdened and sin-oppressed, and His silence and timing are for the best, so expectant faith need not marvel when He abundantly blesses.RH Sep 6, 1870ST Jun 28, 1883RH Jan 8, 1901
As high infinite Providence He acts like a mother toward little children, learning feelings and varied wills from actions, looks, complaints and pretenses, giving to one a look and to another a word, loving still whether stern or smiling.RH Sep 2, 1902 He makes human necessities His watchful task, listening to all prayers and helping all wants, and when He denies what looks right He denies to lead to asking, only appearing to deny while in denying granting.RH Sep 2, 1902 Prayer is the hand grasping His gift, with definite and unlimited promises and marvelous results, so that those who stand on them prevail.RH Nov 17, 1910 Appeal must therefore be transferred from men to God and trust shifted from organization to supplication, with eyes fixed on God when the crisis is too great for man, since human instrumentalities are only machinery awaiting inflowing power.RH Nov 17, 1910 Lack of believing prayer lies behind lack of enthusiasm, poverty of spiritual power, inactivity, dearth of missionary interest and lack of funds, which no plans can replace, because only the Spirit's guidance makes wise plans possible and only His power makes work effective.RH Nov 17, 1910
Holy Spirit and Spiritual Help
The promise applies especially to God's gift of the Holy Spirit.ST Dec 12, 1892ST Aug 1, 1911 As an imperfect human father still gives good things to his child and does not answer a request for food with something harmful or unsuitable, the heavenly Father is far more ready and more willing than earthly parents to answer those who ask.ST Dec 12, 1892ST Aug 11, 1914ST Aug 1, 1911 The argument runs from the natural love of a parent for a child to the willingness of God to help: a father does not turn from his hungry son, trifle with him, tantalize him by raising expectation only to disappoint him, or promise good and nourishing food and then give something useless or harmful, and much less will God dishonor Himself by refusing the call of His children.ST Jul 4, 1911 If human beings, though evil, know how to give good gifts to their children, the Father in heaven will much more give good things, including the grace of the Holy Spirit, to those who ask Him.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Aug 11, 1914
Those who come as repenting sinners through Jesus to a merciful, forgiving Father, knocking and waiting at the throne of mercy with firm assurance, are assured that He will do just as He promised and give them the Holy Spirit.ST Jul 4, 1911 The Spirit so given renews life so that believers may serve God and bless others. Those seeking the Spirit's guidance will not be disappointed, for even flawed human parents give their children good gifts rather than answering a sincere request with harm, and the heavenly Father gives good things to those who ask Him.ST Sep 5, 1900 This confidence belongs to daily strength and childlike guidance, to grace and strength received by those who ask, and it grows as they give themselves to God and seek His help trusting that He will give and not harm.RH Jul 16, 1914RH Dec 4, 1860RH Jul 11, 1912
They therefore need not reject the Spirit's help out of fear of deception.RH Jul 24, 1856 Asking the Father in heaven for His promises and salvation is no reason to fear that He will give deception or an evil influence in return.ST May 30, 1878RH Jul 21, 1851 The sincere appeal is not answered with the soul-damning influence of mesmerism, nor are genuine experiences of the Holy Spirit merely mesmerism or Satan's deception.RH Jul 21, 1851 Spiritual manifestations must still be tested, neither accepting every supernatural work as divine nor dismissing all spiritual phenomena as satanic.RH Jul 24, 1856
Living Out the Verse
God's goodness in answering prayer gives reason to treat others as one would wish to be treated, so those who receive His blessings are to bless others according to ability and circumstance and live out His love in return.RH Nov 16, 1911 His readiness to bless is the ground of the Golden Rule, for those who ask Him for blessings must themselves be ready to bless others, and He often bestows His blessings through other people.RH Nov 16, 1911
The contrast of fish and serpent pictures human kindness, requiring help, comfort, compassion and care for those in need instead of pain and harm.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Jun 8, 1882RH May 1, 1913ST Apr 21, 1898 On life's brief journey the burdened fellow traveler is to be treated kindly and helped rather than injured.ST Jul 1, 1889RH May 1, 1913ST Apr 21, 1898
Those entrusted with the gospel must give spiritually hungry souls the bread and water of life, which are the true message and Word of God represented by bread and fish, and not give a stone of doubt or a serpent of unbelief.ST Dec 27, 1905RH Aug 1, 1912RH Apr 7, 1910 To teach a seeker to distrust God's Word is to feed a serpent instead of a fish, and a professed servant who feeds even one soul doubt and unbelief assumes the most fearful responsibility possible for a human being.ST Dec 27, 1905RH Aug 1, 1912RH Apr 7, 1910 Such an unfaithful trustee who lives by the church while working against Christ will fare worse in judgment than the open infidel.RH Apr 7, 1910 Colleges that receive youth seeking what is pure and lofty but leave a considerable percentage of every class confirmed inebriates, develop a marked tendency that way in a much larger percentage, and produce nightly drink-frenzied screams that break mothers' hearts and destroy souls, give stones and worse for bread.ST Jun 3, 1897 In the same way, teachers who taught peasants distilling gave a serpent instead of bread.ST Aug 5, 1886
The fatherly care shown in answering a sincere request for help with good and not harm gives confidence that God supplies what His servants need to advance His work.RH Sep 7, 1905 The childlike believer's request for help and an honest livelihood is answered with what is good, not with harm.RH Sep 7, 1905ST Jun 13, 1900
Christ's words belong to His rebuke of the Pharisees for replacing God's commandments with human tradition, and so support testing religious teaching and practice by Scripture rather than accepting tradition as authority.
Living out the principles of the Sermon on the Mount means a person will not take weapons of deadly strife to go out deliberately to hunt and kill a fellow man in war.ST Jun 6, 1900
Sources