Matthew 7:9
Or what man is there of you, whom if his son ask bread, will he give him a stone?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Or what man is there of you, whom if his son ask bread, will he give him a stone?
Or what man is there of you, who, if his son shall ask bread, will give him a stone?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Or what man is there of you, who, if his son shall ask him for a loaf, will give him a stone;
'Or what man is of you, of whom, if his son may ask a loaf — a stone will he present to him?
Or what man is there of you who, if his son shall ask of him a loaf of bread, will give him a stone;
Or what man, from among yourselves, whom his son shall ask for a loaf,—a stone, will give him?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Which of you, if his son asks for bread, will give him a stone?
Or who is there among you who, if his son asks him for bread, will give him a stone?
Or which of you, if his son makes a request for bread, will give him a stone?
For what man is there among you, which if his sonne aske him bread, woulde giue him a stone?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Or what man is there among you, of whom if his son shall ask bread, will he reach him a stone?
Pictures

Cross-references
- Luke 11:11-13
If a son shall ask bread of any of you that is a father, will he give him a stone? or if he ask a fish, will he for a fish give him a serpent?
A father gives his child good gifts, illustrating God’s response to those who ask.
- Luke 11:13
If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children: how much more shall your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to them that ask him?
The Father gives the Holy Spirit to those who ask him.
- John 16:24
Hitherto have ye asked nothing in my name: ask, and ye shall receive, that your joy may be full.
Both promise that the one who asks will receive.
- Psalms 84:11
For the LORD God is a sun and shield: the LORD will give grace and glory: no good thing will he withhold from them that walk uprightly.
Both affirm that God will not withhold what is good.
- Luke 11:9-10
And I say unto you, Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you.
Asking, seeking, and knocking lead to the promise of receiving good things.
- James 1:5
If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God, that giveth to all men liberally, and upbraideth not; and it shall be given him.
Both promise God gives when asked without upbraiding.
- Romans 8:32
He that spared not his own Son, but delivered him up for us all, how shall he not with him also freely give us all things?
Having given his Son, God will not withhold good things from those who ask.
- 1 John 5:14
And this is the confidence that we have in him, that, if we ask any thing according to his will, he heareth us:
Both texts express confidence that God hears requests made according to his will.
- John 14:13-14
And whatsoever ye shall ask in my name, that will I do, that the Father may be glorified in the Son.
Christ promises to answer petitions made in faith.
- Hebrews 4:16
Let us therefore come bold ly unto the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy, and find grace to help in time of need.
The father’s care encourages confident prayer for help.
- Psalms 103:13-14
Like as a father pitieth his children, so the LORD pitieth them that fear him.
God pities his children and remembers their weakness.
- James 4:2-3
Ye lust, and have not: ye kill, and desire to have, and cannot obtain: ye fight and war, yet ye have not, because ye ask not.
Both connect asking with receiving.
- James 1:17
Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and cometh down from the Father of lights, with whom is no variableness, neither shadow of turning.
Says every good and perfect gift comes from God.
- Matthew 6:11
Give us this day our daily bread.
Both ask the Father for bread and daily provision.
- Jeremiah 29:12-13
Then shall ye call upon me, and ye shall go and pray unto me, and I will hearken unto you.
God hears those who pray and is found by those who seek him.
- Ephesians 3:20
Now unto him that is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think, according to the power that worketh in us,
Both describe God giving beyond what is asked.
- Matthew 6:9
After this manner therefore pray ye: Our Father which art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name.
Both teach calling God our Father.
- Psalms 22:24
For he hath not despised nor abhorred the affliction of the afflicted; neither hath he hid his face from him; but when he cried unto him, he heard.
God hears the afflicted when they cry to him.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
66 sources
The verse pictures a hungry child asking his father for bread, and denies that a father would answer with a stone that is useless, hard and harmful instead.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10 It assures that God as the kind Father in heaven hears those who ask Him and gives good things, not harm, deprivation or disappointment.EW 20.1Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10 The argument runs from the lesser to the greater, that if even evil and imperfect human parents know how to give good gifts to their children, much more will the heavenly Father give good things to those who ask Him.ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15Ms 75, 1909, par. 10–11 Believers may therefore come with the simplicity and confiding trust of a child to a parent, asking in earnest, humble faith for what they truly need, especially hunger for righteousness and the bread of life.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10 Those good things include the Holy Spirit with His guidance and power to resist temptation, endure trial and witness for Christ, which God is far more willing to give to those who ask in faith than sinful parents are to give good gifts to their children.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26Ms 39, 1893, par. 1–3Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34
Words and Setting
The saying pictures a hungry son asking his father for bread and denies that the father would answer with a stone instead, something useless, hard and harmful rather than good and nourishing.EW 20.1ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3Ms 14, 1905, par. 18 The familiar care of an earthly father who does not mock or disappoint such a request points to the far greater goodness of the Father in heaven, who gives good things and good gifts, including the Holy Spirit's guidance, to those who ask Him in prayer.EW 20.1Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10Ms 98a, 1905, par. 1–3Ms 14, 1905, par. 18Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26
The saying belongs to the Sermon on the Mount, given especially to the disciples while the multitude also listened.DA 298.2–3 That sermon teaches the far-reaching principles of God's law in its spirit, to be impressed on the heart, since the state of the heart shapes life and character.Lt 7, 1886, par. 34
There Christ states the conditions of entrance into the kingdom and lays its foundation principles, as important now as to the hearers on the hillside.DA 299.3 Its lessons are to be shown in daily life, and living them makes a deeper and more lasting impression than preaching them.6T 472.1
The sermon virtually contradicted the doctrines of the self-righteous scribes and Pharisees.FE 309.1 It corrects their misrepresentation of God as a stern judge incapable of compassion, mercy and love, and sweeps away misrepresentation so that confidence in God's love is restored.FE 309.1
It presents God in paternal love and His true relation to humanity as Father, teaching people to address the Supreme Ruler of the universe as Our Father, a name that when spoken in sincerity is music in the ears of God.FE 309.1 It leads to the throne of God by a new and living way, giving a right conception of Christ's kingdom and character to undo false education.DA 299.3FE 309.1 Without directly attacking error or vividly delineating human wretchedness from sin, it teaches something infinitely better than hearers had known, leaving them to conclude its nature for themselves.DA 299.3
Father's Willing Giving
The kind Father in heaven hears those who ask Him and answers with good things, not with harm, deprivation, or disappointment.EW 20.1Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 103, 1905, par. 8–10MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 39, 1893, par. 1–3 Those who come with living faith and complete dependence can trust His promise rather than making feelings the measure of faith, for He knows human helplessness and lack of righteousness and supplies what is needed.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 39, 1893, par. 1–3 Those who ask in earnest faith and humility can trust Him to give what they need in the time and way He knows is for their good, and are encouraged to ask Him often and praise Him.MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 75, 1909, par. 10–11 The argument runs from the lesser to the greater: even evil, imperfect, and sinful human parents know how to give good gifts to their children, so much more does the heavenly Father give good things to those who ask Him.ExVEGW 35.7–36.7Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15Ms 75, 1909, par. 10–11Ms 14, 1905, par. 18Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26
God holds the same tender relation to people that a father holds to his children, regarding all on earth, even the most learned, noble, and rich, as only little children and babes in knowledge and understanding.Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43 His paternal care is more merciful, tender, patient, loving, and generous than any earthly parent's, and He is far more willing to give than sinful parents are to give good gifts to their children.Ms 45, 1891, par. 14–15Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14 He does not trifle with His child, tantalize him by raising expectations only to disappoint him, or promise nourishing food and then give a stone.ST Dec 12, 1892ST Mar 15, 1899 He does not refuse appeals, reject need, upbraid those who ask, or weary of earnest coming, but stands behind His promises and answers the cry of the needy and longing heart.Ms 93, 1898, par. 3–5Ms 198, 1898, par. 24ST Dec 12, 1892ST Mar 15, 1899
The Lord withholds no good thing and nothing He can give, and does not restrict asking to certain things.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34 He blesses according to the riches of His grace which heaven is ready to bestow on every believer, loves to impart with generous liberality, and gives abundantly to those who make large calls for the bread of heaven.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 49, 1903, par. 20Lt 148, 1899, par. 11–13 He bestows His best and choicest gifts to supply great need because He loves to help, and nothing will be withheld because all heaven has already been given in Jesus Christ, who is to be received.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34Lt 49, 1903, par. 20 This is Christ's own lesson to needy and afflicted people that they can come for help and will not seek in vain.Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29 His life filled with deeds of mercy and compassion toward the children of sorrow who thronged His steps proves this willingness to give, taught in words so simple that all can understand, so that doubting His willingness to hear is cruel in view of the infinite sacrifice He made to bear human sin and redeem the fallen race for eternal life.Ms 155, 1902, par. 41–43Lt 111, 1904, par. 27–29
Asking in Faith
Jesus places the picture of a son asking bread and not receiving a stone among promises rich and full about asking, seeking and knocking, assuring that everyone who asks receives, so there is no reason for doubt.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34ST Mar 15, 1899 Weak, uncertain faith is rebuked in favor of simple, unwavering trust that takes God at His word.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 115, 1905, par. 10–11Ms 115, 1905, par. 7–9 The condition is asking and desiring the things of God, and the good things promised include the Holy Spirit.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34
Believers may approach with the simplicity and confiding trust with which a child comes to an earthly parent, expecting wants to be regarded and things really needed to be received.Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10 Asking is to be in earnest faith, humility, simplicity, dependence, and childlike confidence, plainly expressing needs and desiring the things of God.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10 Trust rests on His promise rather than making feelings, abilities, or fear of reproof the measure of faith, for He knows human helplessness and lack of righteousness and supplies what is needed.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6 He can be relied on to help in the work, to give what is needed in the time and way He knows is for good.MYP 122.2–123.1Ms 8, 1886, par. 3–6
This applies to great spiritual need and hunger and thirst after righteousness, asking for the bread of life, the bread of heaven, God's power, grace, love, wisdom, counsel, and strength.Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5Ms 198, 1898, par. 245T 201.1 One who lacks wisdom is to ask God directly in faith without wavering instead of looking to human wisdom and depending on human guidance, and God who gives liberally will give what is needed to know duty.Lt 324, 1907, par. 3–5 Prayer must be offered in faith with expectation of receiving, not holding back for fear of reproof and not going on as if nothing is expected.Ms 198, 1898, par. 24 There is no need to mourn lack of spiritual nourishment when the heavenly banquet is spread, but to continue praying with all perseverance, to cut away unbelief that bars the way and hides the open door to the Father, and to come in humble trusting faith to the Source of all power who will do good to the soul and feed it with the bread of heaven.Ms 21, 1889, par. 6–10 God is more willing to give power to remain steadfast than people are to ask, and gives every needed blessing when people ask in simplicity and faith.Ms 198, 1898, par. 245T 201.1
Prayer offered honestly and in faith is heard and answered, though the answer may not come immediately or take the form requested.SG4 166.2–4GW92 114.1MYP 250.2–3ST Jan 29, 1902 God gives the needed blessing, often when most needed and beyond expectation, in the way and at the time that best meet the need and are for good, and never fails.SG4 166.2–4GW92 114.1MYP 250.2–3ST Jan 29, 1902 Prayer is as necessary to the Christian life as food is to the physical life, unlocking the treasury of heaven.Lt 49, 1903, par. 20ST Jan 29, 1902 Asking and receiving brings the bread of heaven that makes grace grow, prepares for duty, and fills the heart with peace, and every sincere, earnest prayer, including prayers in loneliness, weariness, and trial, is answered.ST Jan 29, 1902 He holds Himself responsible to hear and answer supplications, bestowing His best and choicest gifts to supply great need because He loves to help, and trusting His wisdom and power gives faith, peace and comfort.Lt 49, 1903, par. 20
Those who ask are to ask often and praise Him.Ms 75, 1909, par. 10–11 Promises are fulfilled in experience when people place themselves in right relation to God.Ms 85, 1909, par. 16 The promise is to be repeated in full confidence and taken as more sure and valuable than any human word, with thanksgiving for being barricaded by infallible promises so the wicked one cannot touch, trusting the Lord to reveal Himself for His own name's sake.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34 Those who seek most earnestly should expect to receive the blessing, for He will help them, and He would have them hopeful and cheerful, with hearts filled with thanksgiving and praise, not looking on the dark side but on the bright side, talking faith and hope and courage, and holding fast to divine power.Lt 323, 1904, par. 8 Its promise calls for sober lives built with solid timbers, inquiring at every step what Jesus would have done, and opening the heart to the Spirit lets Him work through the believer and bless his labors.Ms 198, 1898, par. 24Lt 49, 1903, par. 20
God may permit disappointment and trial to reveal human helplessness and dependence on Him, and to make known the abundant help He provides regardless of circumstances.10MR 115.2 He brings those who seek Him to the footstool of mercy and under the bow of promise, where they can be sure of receiving heaven's best gifts.Ms 53, 1898, par. 14 Every soul who asks in faith receives help, and heavenly angels are sent to serve even the weakest person who trusts in God.RH May 29, 1900
The promise to ask and receive belongs to every person individually, not only to leaders or presidents of conferences, and each one who waits upon the Lord and puts petitions before Him will have requests heard and granted, with God as the help of all who call upon Him.Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 Anyone can approach Him, regardless of color, nationality, weakness, or wealth.10MR 308.3 This instruction is part of the genuine science of higher education and should be studied by physicians and ministers.Ms 25, 1906, par. 10–12
Requests for benefits are not meant to serve selfish aims or selfish pleasure, but to equip people to give to those in need, and the Lord gives grace to those who impart to others.Ms 93, 1898, par. 3–5Ms 198, 1898, par. 24 Workers who depend on God may ask Him for what they need to advance His work, trusting Him to provide means and move others to help, including the workers in Nashville.RH Sep 7, 1905Ms 146, 1905, par. 4–9Ms 146a, 1905, par. 4–9 All woes and griefs can be carried to God in prayer, with Jesus as Friend to bear them, because He has promised He will not withhold any good thing from those who love Him.Lt 15a, 1883, par. 6 Those who pray for counsel and strength, or ask for strength to resist temptation, will not ask in vain but receive help, encouragement, nearness, and strength for the weak and diffident, and habits that once attracted can become repulsive.19MR 10.1ST May 6, 1880
Seeking God for His promises and salvation does not result in receiving a harmful deception in answer.1T 71.1–2ST May 30, 1878EW 16.3–17.1 Asking the Father for bread does not result in receiving a stone, and the contrast between bread and a stone, alongside the related image of a scorpion, denies the charge that sincere prayer and religious experience are mesmerism or satanic deception, especially when people deny the Holy Spirit.ExVEGW 6.3–4ST May 30, 1878EW 16.3–17.1
Holy Spirit Good Gift
The good things the Father gives in answer to prayer include the Holy Spirit, with His guidance, power to remain steadfast, divine power to resist temptation and endure trials, and power to witness for Christ.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26Ms 39, 1893, par. 1–3Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Ms 198, 1898, par. 24 The picture is simple: as a father answers a son asking for bread with nourishing food rather than something useless, hard, or harmful, God answers those who ask Him with good gifts and not harm.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Lt 68, 1900, par. 25–26Ms 39, 1893, par. 1–3ST Sep 5, 1900 Those who ask may receive without reason for doubt, on the condition of asking and desiring the things of God, in prayer offered in faith with expectation of receiving and without holding back for fear of reproof.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 39, 1893, par. 1–3Ms 198, 1898, par. 24 This calls for simple faith that takes God at His word, for sober lives built with solid timbers, inquiring at every step what Jesus would have done, and not asking to use the answer for selfish pleasure.Ms 83, 1891, par. 1–2Ms 198, 1898, par. 24
God is far more willing to give the Holy Spirit to those who ask Him in faith than sinful and evil human parents are to give good gifts to their children.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11Ms 28, 1900, par. 1 As even an evil earthly father gives his hungry son bread rather than a stone, the good and righteous God will not deny His children the Holy Spirit but gives blessings abundantly and withholds nothing He can give.Ms 100, 1902, par. 13–14Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11Ms 28, 1900, par. 1 The promise to ask and receive belongs to every person individually, not only to leaders such as presidents of conferences, so each one who waits upon the Lord and puts petitions before Him will have requests heard and granted, with God as the help of all who call upon Him.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34Ms 100, 1894, par. 9–11 The promise is to be repeated in full confidence and taken as more sure and valuable than any human word, with thanksgiving for being barricaded by infallible promises so the wicked one cannot touch, trusting the Lord to reveal Himself for His own name's sake.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34 Its simplicity is not comprehended, and the assurance of the Holy Spirit to every needy soul feels too good to be true, yet nothing will be withheld because all heaven has already been given in Jesus Christ, who is to be received.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–34
Those who truly seek the Holy Spirit's guidance in faith will not be disappointed, but will have their requests heard and granted.Lt 98, 1893, par. 33–342MR 26.120MR 192.4–193.1Ms 74, 1897, par. 10 Earthly parents' care for their children represents the greater goodness of the heavenly Father, assuring true seekers of guidance and of power to witness for Christ.ST Sep 5, 19002MR 26.120MR 192.4–193.1 Those who pray are therefore encouraged to ask for the Holy Spirit's guidance and believe they will receive an answer.2MR 26.120MR 192.4–193.1Ms 74, 1897, par. 10
Feeding Others Bread
Souls hungering for the Bread of Life cry for bread and must not be given a stone in its place.Ms 95, 1894, par. 7–9 That bread is Bible truth as it is in Jesus, the love of God set forth in words easy to be understood, given line upon line, precept upon precept, here a little and there a little.Ms 95, 1894, par. 7–9 The stone is giving babes who do not know the first principles the strongest meat, pressing all the truth in its most striking character upon them at the outset before they are prepared to receive it.Ms 95, 1894, par. 7–9RH Oct 14, 1902
Those who teach and publish must feed God's flock with spiritually nourishing truth, pure spiritual food that leads people to Christ, and not with material that fails to feed them.RH Oct 14, 1902Lt 106, 1902, par. 15–18Ms 101, 1901, par. 11–15 They are to give people what they can bear, patiently teaching those new to Scripture in the measure they can receive rather than pressing the strongest teachings on them before they are ready.Ms 95, 1894, par. 7–9RH Oct 14, 1902 This feeding is to be done in the meekness and love of Jesus, ministering to perishing, starving souls so the truth will have a telling influence.Ms 95, 1894, par. 7–9 It must never lower God's standard of purity, temperance, and holiness.Lt 106, 1902, par. 15–18
One who asks for bread is given bread, not a stone, and so Christ in the heart moves believers to speak sincerely about what God has done for them.Lt 80, 1894, par. 34–35 They share the life-giving truth they have received, and their words nourish and uplift others rather than wearying them.Lt 80, 1894, par. 34–35
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
86 sources
No father asked by his son for bread answers a need for food with a stone that is useless and harmful instead of what is needed.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Feb 1, 1899 It shows that God as Father is willing and eager to give good things to those who ask Him, and even sinful human fathers know how to give fitting gifts to their children, much more the heavenly Father whose love is infinite and whose power is unlimited.RH Sep 7, 1905ST Jul 4, 1911ST Mar 15, 1899RH Jul 8, 1858 He never disappoints or mocks trusting children by promising life and then doing the harmful opposite, and His refusal of a request is still an answer and not a failure to answer.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Dec 12, 1892ST Aug 25, 1887 When what is asked is not received, limited human judgment may have asked for what was not truly good, for a loving father withholds what is asked in ignorance for something harmful and gives something good and better instead.ST Feb 1, 1899ST Jan 23, 1912ST Sep 15, 1887ST Dec 19, 1892RH Sep 20, 1864 Asking must be in faith resting on His promises, according to His will and in humble dependence, with full assurance in asking for pardon, holiness and the Holy Spirit, whom He is more willing to give than parents are to give good gifts.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Sep 5, 1900ST Mar 15, 1899RH Jul 8, 1858ST Jul 16, 1912
Words and Setting
The picture is of an ordinary father asked by his son for bread, and no father answers a request for needed food with a stone instead of what is needed.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Feb 1, 1899ST May 3, 1899ST May 3, 1899 A stone is something useless, hard, harmful and unsuitable, given in mockery rather than in care, and no father among those hearing would so answer his son.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Aug 25, 1887 The comparison shows human parents giving fitting gifts to their children and prepares the assurance of the Father in heaven giving good things to those who ask Him.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Feb 1, 1899ST May 3, 1899ST May 3, 1899ST Aug 25, 1887
The verse belongs to the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew 5, 6, and 7, Christ's inaugural address as He enters public ministry.ST Aug 6, 1912RH Jul 26, 1870ST Aug 30, 1877 It is Gospel teaching setting out the blessings of righteousness and God-like character, with righteousness as active obedience and love revealed through teaching and life.ST Aug 6, 1912 That doctrine is of an especially healing, encouraging, and comforting kind, suited to wounded minds.RH Nov 18, 1862 Christ's words there remain applicable to all time and give spiritual life, with their promises, commands, and blessings belonging to the Gospel.ST May 13, 1897
The sermon was given on a mount nearly fifteen centuries after Sinai by the selfsame voice that uttered the law at Sinai.ST Sep 22, 1909 It does not retract or nullify anything spoken there and does not contrast with or replace the Ten Commandments, but vindicates and fulfills the law, with not one jot or tittle to pass till all is fulfilled.RH Jul 26, 1870ST Sep 22, 1909 Its central truth and great subject are righteousness and law.ST Mar 9, 1888 Its summing up and closing require doing the will of the Father and doing Christ's sayings, not only saying Lord, Lord, believing, prophesying, casting out devils, or doing wonderful works.ST Aug 30, 1877 Hearing and doing is building a house upon a rock by work, digging deep and laying a solid foundation, which stands when rain, floods, and winds beat upon it, while hearing without doing, even with all faith, is building upon sand without labor for a foundation, and building hope of heaven on faith without works will fall with great fall in the storms of the coming day.ST Aug 30, 1877 Its words are gracious words to be read, meditated upon, and fed upon.ST Sep 22, 1909
The sermon sets out the principles of Christ's spiritual kingdom existing alongside earthly civil governments.ST Apr 9, 1896 It is presented as the influence of God and as the ideal the world hungers for and the law needed to apply to economic problems, standing opposite the law of the market.RH Jul 24, 1900ST Jan 16, 1901 Heeding it is incompatible with deliberately going into the field to hunt and kill fellow men with deadly weapons of war.ST Jun 6, 1900 Support for the drink trade is contrasted with that influence.ST Jan 16, 1901 Its picture of God as loving Father is compatible with God as judge who punishes sin in individuals and nations, since love and justice are both parts of God's character, so it is not contradicted by prayers for judgment against the guilty, and Christ's rule includes punishment of violent, implacable enemies.RH Apr 4, 1871RH Apr 4, 1871
The verse belongs to the precepts and promises of Matthew 7:1-14, which are summed up in the command to do to others whatever you would have them do to you.ST Jun 13, 1900
Father's Goodness in Prayer
The question presents two pictures that press home how willing God is to give what His children ask, and it calls for asking Him, trusting Him to supply help and needs, with full assurance for all true seekers.RH Sep 7, 1905ST Jul 4, 1911ST Dec 12, 1892ST Sep 5, 1900 Just as a father does not meet a son's request for bread with a stone, God gives good things to those who ask Him, and this was held out as ground for praying for workers in need with confidence that He will provide help for His work.RH Sep 7, 1905ST Jul 4, 1911ST Dec 12, 1892 He is ready to hear and answer those who come to Him in need, and will not disappoint them, appealing to the natural love and ordinary care of parents for their children to assure believers of the Father's willingness to help.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Dec 12, 1892ST Sep 5, 1900 An earthly father will not answer a request for bread with something useless or harmful, and so much more does God give good gifts, including the Holy Spirit and His guidance for true seekers.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Sep 5, 1900ST Mar 15, 1899 Even sinful parents know how to give good things to their children, so believers may come earnestly and confidently with their needs, trusting His promises and not fearing to weary Him.ST Mar 15, 1899
If even evil, sinful and selfish human fathers with limited means know how to give good and fitting gifts to their children, and would not answer a son asking for bread with something useless and hard, much more will the Father in heaven give good things to those who ask Him.RH Jul 8, 1858ST Oct 21, 1897ST Oct 18, 1899ST Apr 8, 1886 This is wonderful grace and mercy and a blessed promise that encourages coming to the throne of grace with holy boldness and confidence, freely and unreservedly and without fear.RH Jul 8, 1858 No real father gives a child a stone when the child asks for bread, and even selfish human parents give good gifts within their limited means, while God, whose love and compassion are infinite and whose power is unlimited, hears those who ask Him for good gifts.ST Oct 21, 1897ST Oct 18, 1899 A loving father does not deny his child's need by substituting what is useless for what was asked, and if earthly parents hear their children and supply their needs, God displays still greater love in answering His children's prayers.ST Oct 18, 1899ST Apr 8, 1886 He possesses in perfect fullness every good quality of earthly fathers, and in infinite love and goodness gives good things, including the grace of the Holy Spirit, so that because He has promised to care for His children, receiving an answer should not be treated as remarkable.ST Apr 8, 1886ST Aug 11, 1914
God will not disappoint His children, mock a son's request for food by giving something useless or harmful instead, tantalize by promising life-giving gifts and then doing the harmful opposite, deceive trusting children, or deliberately raise a hungry child's hopes only to disappoint him.ST Jul 4, 1911ST Dec 12, 1892ST Apr 28, 1909ST Aug 25, 1887ST Jan 23, 1912 The tender concern of a parent who would not answer hunger with a stone shows God's willingness to respond to the appeals of His children, and warns against imagining that He would refuse His spiritual children the help they need when they ask Him.ST Apr 28, 1909ST Aug 25, 1887 His refusal of a request is still an answer, not a failure to answer.ST Jan 23, 1912
When people do not receive what they ask for, their limited judgment may mean the request was not truly good for them, since a parent does not give a child something unsuitable in place of what is needed, and the heavenly Father gives good things.ST Feb 1, 1899 His gifts may look harmful, but trials, sickness and poverty can be good when He sends them, and though their nature may be mistaken they remain gifts intended for good.ST Jan 23, 1912
How God Answers
A loving father welcomes his children's requests yet does not always grant exactly what is asked, and when a child in ignorance asks for something harmful he withholds it and gives something good instead.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Jun 28, 1883 God answers in the same fatherly way, withholding what is not best to have and giving something better, even a richer blessing that includes grace to guide and strength to bear burdens.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Dec 19, 1892ST Dec 1, 1898 Prayer rightly offered is never unheard or left without a grant, for spiritual graces may be asked without qualification and temporal blessings subject to His will, both in faith and humility.RH Sep 20, 1864 His refusal of a harmful request is an exercise of wisdom, not unkindness, and His answer may be delayed or come in a different way than expected.ST Jun 28, 1883ST Dec 1, 1898
God hears prayer and may give what is desired or something more or better, granting each particular request as He sees best.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Sep 20, 1864RH Jan 8, 1901 He may answer in a better way than requested, delayed or in a different way than expected, according to His will and promises, and what looks like denial may itself be a granting that leads people to keep asking.ST Jul 16, 1912ST Jun 28, 1883RH Jan 8, 1901 Requests for what He has clearly revealed, such as forgiveness, cleansing and sanctification, may be made with assurance, while healing may be asked with confidence surrendered to His will, since He is willing to heal though He may answer in a better way.ST Jul 16, 1912 When believers mistakenly think a specific thing is best, He gives what is best instead.ST Dec 19, 1892
An answer may not look like the gift requested, for what first feels like a stone can lead to unexpected provision, help or guidance.RH Jul 22, 1902 Sometimes He gives the very bread asked for when hearts are weak, but often what He sends looks like a stone because He who is love sends what is best, and the stone does not leave the child unfed.RH Jul 22, 1902 It becomes a pillow for weary rest and a ladder of dreams leading upward to celestial mountains, bringing fresh manna by morning so that the one who asked is fed and goes on praising God. When He is silent faith must learn deeper rest and trust that He gives what is best, for every sincere earnest prayer is answered in loneliness, weariness and trial, not always just as desired or at the time expected, but in the way and at the time for the best good, always for good and never failing.ST Jan 29, 1902RH Jul 22, 1902RH Jan 8, 1901
Prayer does not persuade God to become loving or merciful, since His love and mercy are already infinite; it turns people toward that mercy and makes hearts willing to receive what He knows is best.ST Dec 1, 1898 Asking is like a hungry person asking food from a close friend, so those who pray should expect an answer, wait for it, and be disappointed when it does not come, rather than going away as if no favorable reply was expected.RH Oct 16, 1860 Expectant faith is met with blessing abundant, full, free, undisguised and more than asked or thought, with good success in the work brought to His feet.RH Oct 14, 1902ST Jan 2, 1893 Fear about whether He will answer is faithless, and amazement that He has answered is misplaced, since it would be more wonderful for Him to fail to bless than to bless.RH Oct 14, 1902 His promises to answer are definite and unlimited, the hand that grasps the gift and the abiding miracle to which marvelous results are promised, so that in crisis too great for man appeal is to be transferred from men to God, with eyes fixed on Him in supplication for the inflowing power of the Holy Spirit for which there is no human substitute.RH Nov 17, 1910
The promise is confirmed by concrete provisions for workers in need who ask trusting Him to provide help for His work.RH Sep 7, 1905 It sustained one who gave up livelihood to obey Him in trusting for daily provision, and a child who asked Jesus for what she needed and received answers.RH Nov 11, 1915 It gave shoes for children through a neighbor soon after prayer, with clothing material and money through others, and unexpected money meeting bills through another person.ST Feb 27, 1893 It gave freedom from Sabbath work by working Sunday instead without loss of pay or position, strength to resist temptation so that former habits became repulsive, and transformation within a year of a new believer who prayed with child-like faith even for a better-looking face to get honest work.ST May 6, 1880
Asking in Faith
Asking must rest on promises with holy boldness and confidence, coming freely and unreservedly and without fear to the throne of grace.ST Mar 15, 1899RH Jul 8, 1858RH Mar 11, 1915 It must be in faith, in Jesus' name, and according to God's will, where asking in His name means sharing His humility and submission and not merely speaking His name, with the submission shown in Gethsemane.ST Jul 16, 1912 Requests are to be earnest and confident, definite and believed to be granted, offered humbly in acknowledgment of weakness and dependence, with the heart raised to Him at all times, striving to live in that confidence and not fearing to weary Him.ST Mar 15, 1899RH Mar 11, 1915RH Sep 20, 1864RH Oct 16, 1860 Rightly made prayer is never unheard or left without a grant, and those who pray should expect an answer, wait for it, and be disappointed when it does not come, rather than going away as if no favorable reply was expected.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Oct 16, 1860
What God has clearly revealed can be asked without qualification and with assurance, including pardon, holiness, and salvation, forgiveness, cleansing, and sanctification.ST Jul 16, 1912RH Jul 15, 1862RH Sep 20, 1864 The same assurance belongs to power sought in helplessness without Christ, and to the despairing desire for love to inspire life and light to turn darkness into day, for rest and good and not harm, since conviction of sin shows God reaching to restore and not to disappoint.ST Sep 9, 1889RH Sep 6, 1870RH Feb 19, 1914 Requests for temporal blessings and for healing may be made with confidence while surrendered to God's will, for He is willing to heal though He may answer in a better way than requested.ST Jul 16, 1912RH Sep 20, 1864
God is more willing to give the Holy Spirit than human parents are to give good gifts, so asking brings assurance of receiving Him.ST Jul 4, 1911RH Jun 22, 1916ST Aug 11, 1914 With Him comes guidance for true seekers, dispelling of clouds, gloom, doubts and fears.ST Sep 5, 1900 Seeking the Spirit does not mean receiving deception or a satanic substitute in place of God's help, and those who go to God alone, plead His promises, and seek salvation are not asking to receive such deception.RH Jul 24, 1856RH Jul 21, 1851 Because of the danger of false manifestations, discernment must be trained to distinguish good from evil, avoiding both treating every supernatural manifestation as divine and treating every spiritual manifestation as satanic, and turning away from pure spiritual nourishment and calling it a stone is as unreasonable as refusing bread because stones exist.RH Jul 24, 1856
The verse warrants trusting God for bodily healing as well as forgiveness, seeking complete salvation for His honor rather than for selfish ends.ST May 12, 1898 It warrants asking for daily strength that is not denied to those who ask, for grace to all who seek and ask Jesus, for whatever spiritual help is needed great or small, and for strength so that fellow travelers can be whatever they will in the Christian life.RH Aug 26, 1875RH Jul 11, 1912RH Jan 23, 1866 It warrants asking the Heavenly Father as children ask parents, for help in times of trial, war, famine, drought, pestilence, or want, and for angelic help, so that every soul who asks in faith receives.RH Feb 14, 1865
Prayer is a plain, simple, direct request like a hungry child asking a parent for food in few words when need is felt, not a performance meant to impress listeners.ST Nov 16, 1888RH Apr 24, 1866 It is not to be left on paper for convenience, for God is not too busy to attend to needs but welcomes personal prayers.RH Jul 8, 1909 The heavenly Father is patient and does not answer so abruptly or harshly that questioners become afraid to ask, and He hears children as well as adults.ST Feb 13, 1907RH Mar 21, 1907RH Apr 24, 1866
Prayer is as necessary to the Christian life as food is to the physical life, bringing the bread of heaven that makes grace grow, gives preparation for duty, and fills the heart with peace.ST Jan 29, 1902 It brings blessings that give comfort and joy to the sad and lonely, since God does not answer a request for blessing by giving something harmful or useless instead. Every sincere, earnest prayer is answered, even in loneliness, weariness, and trial, though not just as desired or at the time expected, but in the way and at the time that is for the best good, always for good and never failing.ST Jan 29, 1902
Giving Bread to Others
Because God is good in answering prayer, that goodness is the reason to treat others as one wishes to be treated, helping and blessing them as far as ability and circumstances allow.RH Nov 16, 1911 Asking God for blessings and expecting to receive them calls for a like readiness to bless others, since God often gives His blessings through other people.RH Nov 16, 1911
A father does not answer his son's request for needed food with something useless or harmful instead, and people should treat one another in the same way by helping a fellow human being instead of adding to his burdens.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Jun 8, 1882RH May 1, 1913 Rather than harming, wounding, or hindering a fellow traveler in life, they should give help and show compassion, offering help, comfort, shelter, relief, and compassion to those less favored.ST Jun 8, 1882RH May 1, 1913 War-ravaged people who ask the rich for bread and are denied help receive a stone for bread, and that refusal of the privileged is a failure to provide for those in need. Colleges likewise owe students nourishing moral influence for all that is austerely pure and lofty as a father owes bread to a hungry son, while fostering drink gives a stone and worse, leaving a considerable percentage of every class confirmed inebriates and developing a marked tendency that way in a much larger percentage, producing nightly screams of boys frenzied with drink in college towns, breaking mothers' hearts and destroying souls, and failing even the interest of civilization.ST Jun 3, 1897
A soul hungry for spiritual life has a right to expect the bread and water of life, not doubt about God's word, and to give such a seeker doubt is like feeding a hungry person a stone.ST Dec 27, 1905RH Aug 1, 1912RH Apr 7, 1910 Those who seek God have a right to expect Christ's messengers to give them the bread and water of life, not stones of doubt or serpents of unbelief, and a minister who gives doubt and unbelief instead of the gospel gives a stone instead of bread and bears a grave responsibility.RH Aug 1, 1912RH Apr 7, 1910 People hungry for spiritual truth must be given the bread of life they need rather than something useless in its place, and those new to Scripture should be taught patiently with truth in measure they can receive, without pressing the strongest teachings on them before they are ready.RH Oct 14, 1902 Ministers who give people mere moral advice such as to be good and generous instead of calling them to repent give stones when people ask for bread.RH Jan 1, 1914 People need practical encouragement, sympathy, and inspiration for the burdens and duties of daily life, and a sermon that offers only praise of biblical figures fails to give them the help they seek.ST Jan 27, 1881
God is the model of fatherhood in providing for children rather than giving them what would harm them or fail to meet their need, and earthly fathers are to follow this model with provision that includes protection and instruction.RH Nov 18, 1902 A father does not mock his son's request for food with something useless or harmful instead, which rebukes parents who deny their children what they need, since children could not live if parents did so.RH Mar 22, 1870 The heavenly Father welcomes His children's requests and is patient with their questions, giving earthly parents the lesson to answer children gently rather than quickly saying no and making them afraid to ask.RH Mar 21, 1907 Even when a kind, wise father chastens his children, he does not withhold needed knowledge.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 This picture of parental care is simple enough for a young child to grasp and can help children learn the Bible's truths and the atmosphere of grace.RH Jan 6, 1916
Giving a stone for bread is cruel disappointment and hypocritical mockery of hunger. Selling mineraline, which is ground rock with no food value, to be mixed into flour is like giving a stone when bread is asked for. When people let ambition and the pursuit of fame and wealth displace patient love and gentleness, their selfish god feeds their hungry souls a stone instead of bread.ST Oct 6, 1887 Extremely religious people crying for spiritual bread may receive only a lifeless and cold foreign established church, leaving gentle-mannered, affectionate, teachable people as sad victims of religious ignorance and superstition.ST Nov 4, 1886 Nations hungry for relief from increased military burdens are given only empty wishes and resolutions to resume serious study of limitation instead of real reduction of armaments, which buries disarmament while arming for war goes on with greater madness.
Sources