Numbers 14:29
Your carcases shall fall in this wilderness; and all that were numbered of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, which have murmured against me,
Your carcases shall fall in this wilderness; and all that were numbered of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, which have murmured against me,
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
111 sources
God swore at Kadesh-barnea that the counted adults from twenty years old and upward who murmured at the spies' report would die in the wilderness and as a body would not enter the land promised to their fathers.ST Mar 2, 1882ST Oct 7, 1930RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1887RH Dec 27, 1906 He lifted up his hand in oath and took them at their own word, doing to them as they had spoken in his ears by granting their rebellious wish to die in the wilderness.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Nov 5, 1903RH Apr 28, 1874 The cause was unbelief after seeing His glory and miracles, trusting the fearful report of the ten about giants and walled cities and rejecting the faithful counsel of Caleb and Joshua.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 The forty days of spying became forty years of wandering until that generation was consumed, with only Caleb and Joshua of the first numbering remaining alive while their little ones were brought in to possess the despised land.RH Sep 14, 1916RH Dec 27, 1906ST Apr 10, 1893ST May 4, 1904ST Mar 3, 1881 That exclusion from the land sworn to them is the denial of God's rest in Psalm 95, standing as an example and warning lest later people come short through unbelief and murmuring over trials and fail to enter rest and kingdom.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 11, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907RH May 27, 1862
Words and Historical Setting
The sentence is God's oath and pronouncement spoken to Moses and Aaron at Kadesh-barnea after the congregation murmured at the report of the unfaithful spies.RH May 20, 1902ST Oct 7, 1930RH Nov 9, 1916RH Feb 6, 1900RH Jul 18, 1907 They had wished they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness, planned to make a captain and return to Egypt, cursed Moses and Aaron, reproached God for bringing them to fall by the sword, and threatened Caleb and Joshua who urged them to go up and possess the land.RH May 20, 1902RH Feb 6, 1900ST Jan 30, 1907RH Jul 18, 1907 Because the whole people joined this stubborn uprising on the verge of the promised land after seeing His glory and miracles in Egypt and in the wilderness, He decreed that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured against Him would have their carcasses fall in the wilderness and would not come into the land He swore to make them dwell in and give to their fathers, except Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun, while their little ones would be brought in to know the land they despised.RH May 20, 1902ST Oct 7, 1930RH Nov 9, 1916RH Feb 6, 1900RH Jul 18, 1907 Their unbelief barred them from Canaan and condemned them to die in the wilderness, and when the decision was made known their rage turned to mourning because they knew the punishment was just, yet their mourning was grief over wilderness prospects rather than sorrow for sin.RH Nov 5, 1903ST Jan 30, 1907RH Jul 18, 1907
The passage belongs to the account of Israel's murmuring and rebellion in the events described in Numbers 10-16.ST Feb 17, 1909RH Jul 25, 1907RH Nov 12, 1903 It is part of the record of the great rebellion on the borders of the promised land in the Twelve Spies history, which came immediately before and stands before the uprising of Korah, Dathan and Abiram described in Numbers 16.ST Feb 17, 1909RH Jul 25, 1907RH Nov 12, 1903
The phrase all that were numbered from twenty years old and upward means the counted census adults aged twenty or older, so those under twenty years old were not included in the sentence.ST Apr 15, 1903 Over 600,000 of the children who were under twenty when they started entered Canaan, though how many others were obedient or rebellious at the Exodus is unknown and reserved to God, and it does not mean the others were disobedient when they left Egypt. The judgment fell on the people as a body, including those who had been willing to enter by faith, who nevertheless shared the wilderness wandering and its hardships.ST Apr 15, 1903
The phrase your carcases shall fall means those adults would die in the wilderness instead of entering the Promised Land, with bodies strewn and buried there all along the way rather than entering Canaan.ST Nov 11, 1880RH Sep 14, 1916RH Apr 9, 1901RH Sep 8, 1874 The timid host who listened to the fearful spies turned backward with graves covering the desert as the mournful fate of those who dared not venture to possess their appointed heritage.ST Nov 11, 1880RH Sep 8, 1874 Their bodies strewn there punished unwillingness to submit to God's wise arrangements, and their deaths occurred gradually over the forty years of wandering until the unbelieving generation was consumed and the judgment fulfilled before Israel reached Canaan again.ST Nov 11, 1880RH Sep 14, 1916RH Apr 9, 1901
God lifted up His hand in the wilderness and solemnly swore the oath, taking Israel at their own word and doing to them as they had spoken in His ears by granting their rebellious prayer and desire to die in the wilderness.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Nov 5, 1903RH Apr 28, 1874RH Apr 15, 1873 Because they said they wished they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness, everyone numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured would fall and die there and not enter Canaan, while only Caleb and Joshua were spared and the little ones they said would be a prey would be brought in to know the despised land.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Nov 5, 1903RH Apr 15, 1873 The oath came after a second or prolonged probation that still ended in failure, for their unbelief showed itself in direct disobedience, in especial manner to the Sabbath, in despising judgments, walking not in statutes, polluting Sabbaths, and going after idols with heart after idols.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Apr 28, 1874
The sentence came after Israel left Sinai in the second month of the second year after Egypt and marched toward the wilderness of Paran eager for the promised land, reaching Kadesh-barnea close to the border after eleven marching days from Sinai.ST Jul 14, 1881 It followed shortly after keeping the second Passover, when the report of the spies tested Israel and almost as one man they broke out in rebellion from evil hearts of unbelief, proving unfit for the land.ST Oct 7, 1930ST Jul 14, 1881 That rebellion turned a journey of a few days or months, an eleven-day journey to the land of milk and honey, into decades of wandering, into thirty-eight long years of striving and into forty years fixed to answer the forty days spent examining the land, a year of wandering for each day of examination.ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jan 30, 1907RH Mar 13, 1866 Their murmuring prolonged the stay for many long years in the great and terrible wilderness to live, suffer and die, when a few months could have sufficed to pass the desert and enter Canaan.RH Mar 13, 1866
Moses pleaded for Israel on the ground of the honor of the Lord's name, referring to bringing the people out of Egypt with a mighty hand and the renown He had gained.ST Feb 9, 1882ST Oct 11, 1877 He urged that abandoning them to perish would lose that renown and cause His name to be reproached and blasphemed among the heathen, asking God to work for His own glory rather than for personal benefit.ST Feb 9, 1882ST Oct 11, 1877 Such jealousy for His name and love shown by asking Him to work for His own glory rather than personal benefit is acceptable with Him, for He is not moved by ambition and vainglory.ST Feb 9, 1882ST Oct 11, 1877
At Moses' prayer God in long-suffering and of great mercy pardoned them for the sake of His name among the nations, though displeased and threatening to smite and disinherit them.RH May 20, 1902RH Feb 6, 1900 Yet He still sentenced all that were numbered from twenty years old and upward who had murmured and tempted Him ten times without hearkening to His voice to have their carcasses fall in the wilderness and doubtless not come into the land sworn to their fathers, save Caleb and Joshua, a word fulfilled until that generation of men of war was wasted out in thirty-eight years of wandering.RH May 20, 1902RH Feb 6, 1900
Cause of the Judgment
The judgment fell because of unbelief and refusal to trust divine promise and power after witnessing glory, miracles in Egypt and in the wilderness, though deliverance had been wrought and the promise to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob established.RH May 20, 1902RH Jun 13, 1854RH Nov 11, 1858 That unbelief turned a journey of a few days into a delay of thirty-eight years and sentenced all murmurers from twenty years old and upward to die in the wilderness rather than enter the promised land.RH Jun 13, 1854 Even after repentant words offering to go up, it was too late to escape the consequence.RH Jun 13, 1854
The people trusted the fearful report of the ten spies and believed they could not take the land, rejecting the faithful counsel and good report of Caleb and Joshua and thereby bringing the judgment upon themselves.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jun 13, 1854ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jul 22, 1873 The ten brought proof of a land flowing with milk and honey, including a cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men, yet their telling of huge giants, high thick walls, and numerous inhabitants in whose sight Israel were as grasshoppers discouraged the multitude from going farther.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 The discouraging report was also of tall giants, the sons of Anak, inaccessible walls, numerous inhabitants, high walled cities and iron chariots, accurately describing difficulties ahead but breeding panic, selfish ease-loving retreat, and clamoring against faithful testimony even with stones in hand.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873ST Aug 13, 1902RH Oct 5, 1916RH Jul 22, 1873 The ten who discouraged the people died by plague before the congregation chiefly for that act, while the multitude that yielded to discouragement died more slowly during forty years of wandering.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 Two men spoke faith in vain because the human heart is naturally unbelieving, and looking only with physical sight upon obstacles too great for human strength and wisdom yields the conflict and buries a generation in desert graves.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873ST Aug 13, 1902
Strong feeling, fearful distrust, and looking only with physical sight produced discouragement, then distrust, then murmuring, rebellion, mutiny and insurrection against God and against Moses and Aaron.ST Oct 7, 1897ST Mar 1, 1910RH May 20, 1873 Discouragement is the first step to distrust, and murmurings follow bringing death, while fear led on to distrust and then to rebellion.RH May 20, 1873 Neither refusal to go forward from feeling nor afterward attempting the conquest after being told not to go was faith or obedience, and presumption ended in defeat, for failure came from unbelief not lack of zeal.ST Oct 7, 1897 Many who accepted the call out of Egypt acted from selfish motives, murmured and complained, and rose in insurrection against the purposes and plans of God.ST Mar 1, 1910
Their murmuring included cursing Moses and Aaron, wishing they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness, reproaching God for bringing them to fall by the sword, and planning to make a captain and return to Egypt.RH May 20, 1902ST May 31, 1899RH Jul 18, 1907 They murmured and found fault with God and with Moses, thereby profaning divine name and authority.RH Jun 23, 1868 They breathed suspicion against chosen leaders with strong bold accusations of partiality, blamed Moses for standing in the way of advancement when the wickedness of their own hearts kept God from using them, and grew wrathful and determined to get rid of Moses as one not put in place because he did not run things to their notion.RH Jul 30, 1914 They would have stoned Caleb and Joshua for urging them to go up and possess the land, cast stones at the faithful on their return, wept through the long night, and chose retreat, so their majority-backed refusal was rebellion not divine voice.ST May 31, 1899RH Jul 18, 1907RH Mar 26, 1901
The outbreak flowed almost as from one man from evil hearts of unbelief, proving them unfit for the land and showing what they were.ST Jul 14, 1881 Their destruction displayed displeasure with unbelief and indifference, while willingness to face conflict valiantly marked those spared.ST Mar 11, 1886 Bodies strewn in the wilderness punished unwillingness to submit to wise arrangements, and the long sojourn deaths display deep unwillingness to obey.RH Apr 9, 1901RH Jan 20, 1863 Many were no part of the real church despite accepting the call, acting from selfish motives in insurrection.ST Mar 1, 1910
The disobedience showed itself in direct positive disobedience, in especial manner to the Sabbath, and in general violation of law, despising judgments, walking not in statutes, polluting Sabbaths because the heart went after idols.RH Jan 7, 1862RH Jan 7, 1862RH Apr 28, 1874 Sabbath violation is given as one stated reason for exclusion from the promised land, connected with widespread idolatry during the sojourn and supported by Ezekiel 20:15-16.RH Jan 7, 1862RH Jan 7, 1862 Appetite dethroned reason and reigned in childish murmurings and rebellion, so that only two adults who left Egypt reached the good land and bodies lay all along the way.ST Apr 22, 1875ST Jun 10, 1875 Every murmuring can be traced to restrictions on food and drink or fears about eating and drinking, to lust for flesh meats eaten in Egypt, murmuring after manna was given, and loathing of divinely best provision.ST Apr 22, 1875ST Jun 10, 1875RH Mar 19, 1867 Manna was given because it was best, and flesh of quails, the simplest meat, only to prove manna better, yet meat made them sick while they still lusted and murmured.RH Mar 19, 1867
They had tempted God ten times and had not hearkened to His voice, and persistent murmuring and hardening turned them back to die instead of entering.RH May 20, 1902 Work for them was impossible while hearts were filled with bitter murmuring, for they were in no fit state to appreciate what would be done for them.ST Sep 2, 1880 A manifestation of power against enemies would only have filled them with pride and self-importance, since they would not sanctify God in their hearts and give Him glory.ST Sep 2, 1880
Scope and Fulfillment
The sentence fell upon the whole numbered adult generation from twenty years old and upward who murmured, so that as a body they would not come into the land sworn to their fathers but would die with their bodies fallen in the wilderness.ST Mar 2, 1882ST Jul 14, 1887RH Dec 27, 1906RH Jan 12, 1869RH Apr 17, 1879 Those who said they could not go up did not enter, for their rebellion after the evil report and their choice to return to Egypt brought withdrawal of protecting care until all so numbered perished.RH Jan 12, 1869RH Apr 17, 1879RH May 11, 1869 The judgment fell on the people as a body, so that even those who had been willing to enter by faith nevertheless shared the wilderness wandering and its hardships.ST Apr 15, 1903
Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun were excepted from the sentence and survived to enter Canaan.ST May 31, 1899RH Sep 14, 1916ST Oct 7, 1930RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1887 They were spared because they wholly followed the Lord, trusted God and urged the people to take the land, remained faithful when opposed, dared to be singular for a truthful report, and were willing to face conflict valiantly.RH Sep 14, 1916ST Mar 2, 1882RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1887ST May 4, 1904 Their little ones and those under twenty, whom the murmurers said would be a prey, would be brought in to know and possess the despised land.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Nov 5, 1903RH Sep 14, 1916RH Nov 9, 1916ST Apr 10, 1893 That younger generation was trained under Moses, nourished on bread from heaven, and witnessed God's presence in cloud and fire before entering after the complainers died.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Nov 5, 1903RH Nov 9, 1916ST Apr 10, 1893ST Feb 11, 1903
The spies' forty days examining Canaan corresponded to forty years of wandering, a year for each day, until the murmuring generation was gradually consumed and bore its iniquity.RH Sep 14, 1916RH Dec 27, 1906ST Apr 10, 1893ST Jul 14, 1881 What had been an eleven marching-day journey was thus turned into decades in the wilderness because rebellion proved them unfit for the land.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jul 14, 1881 The delay is also reckoned as thirty-eight years of wandering before that generation of men of war was wasted out and the children entered and conquered under Caleb and Joshua.RH Feb 6, 1900ST Nov 24, 1887ST Jan 30, 1907 Unbelief kept them from entering, brought defeat by Amalekites and Canaanites, and made a journey of a few days last thirty-eight years instead of eleven days.ST Nov 24, 1887ST Jan 30, 1907ST Jul 18, 1900
The threatened judgment was fulfilled, for by the second numbering none counted the first time remained alive except Caleb and Joshua.ST Nov 11, 1880ST Dec 30, 1880RH Dec 27, 1906ST Mar 3, 1881RH Mar 16, 1869 The later census confirmed the rebellious generation had died, their bodies lay buried all along the way in the wilderness before Israel reached Canaan again, and of the 600,000 who started from Egypt only two crossed the Jordan as inheritors.ST Nov 11, 1880RH Dec 27, 1906ST May 4, 1904ST Mar 3, 1881RH Mar 16, 1869 Moses and Aaron also forfeited entry because of their own sin and failure, though of high standing and though they bore the people's burdens and interceded for them, for God requires those entrusted with His work to depend on His strength and there is no excuse for sin.ST Oct 14, 1880 Even Moses died outside the promised land through a failure brought on by the stubbornness of the people, so that at the close of the forty years only descendants stood under Joshua on the bank of the Jordan ready to cross.ST Oct 14, 1880ST Feb 3, 1904
The sin of Kadesh-barnea clung to Israel, and for nearly forty years the people under rebuke were denied circumcision, the sign of devotion to God, while they remained in the wilderness until the wandering ended.RH Apr 27, 1911 Their failure to obey delayed entry into the promised land and taught the survivors obedience through suffering.RH Apr 27, 1911ST Feb 26, 1894
Rest and Future Hope
The land sworn to the fathers is the same thing Psalm 95 calls God's rest, and the sentence that the murmuring numbered adults from twenty years old and upward should fall in the wilderness and doubtless not come into that land shows that rest was denied that generation because of rebellion.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 11, 1869 That rest was not the seventh-day Sabbath, for all who fell in the wilderness received the Sabbath and Joshua did not give the Sabbath, and God never swore that rebels should not keep the Sabbath but had Sabbath-breakers put to death, whereas He did swear they should not enter Canaan.ST Jun 23, 1881 Nor was it the Canaan rest that Joshua gave, so a rest remains to the people of God which even those who entered under Joshua did not attain.RH Jul 20, 1869ST Jun 23, 1881
If Canaan was a type of Paradise, the oath may also reach to the future rest promised to believers, as Hebrews 4 connects the rest they failed to reach with the rest still open to God's people.RH Jul 20, 1869 On that understanding the oath may have excluded the rebels from that future rest as well, though whether they lost every opportunity to repent is left uncertain.RH Jul 20, 1869 Their failure illustrates how Israel came short of the promised rest through unbelief and disobedience, for persistent murmuring and hardening against God turned them back to die in the wilderness instead of entering the promised land.RH May 27, 1862RH Aug 4, 1868 Their unbelief in the face of the difficulties reported by the spies brought forty years of wandering and kept them out of the land, warning lest later people doubt, harden the heart, fall the same way, and fail to enter God's rest and kingdom.RH Feb 28, 1907RH Feb 9, 1911RH Aug 4, 1868
When Israel came near the borders of the land the report of the ten spies discouraged the people from going farther, and for that murmuring and unbelief God turned the multitude back over their weary course to wander forty years till all that were numbered from twenty years old and upward died there.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 The ten who brought the discouraging report, though they brought proof of a land flowing with milk and honey such as a cluster of grapes borne on a staff between two men, died by plague before the congregation because they had discouraged the people, while the multitude that yielded to discouragement died more slowly in the wilderness.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 In vain the two faithful spies tried to talk faith, because man's heart is naturally unbelieving and the devil is anxious to have people doubt, and God was greatly displeased that discouragement took the life out of His cause and forfeited His favor.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 This forty-year death stands as an example upon whom the ends of the world are come, recalled in Jude as the destruction after deliverance out of Egypt of those who did not believe and disobeyed God.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jan 7, 1904
Israel called out of Egypt represented the church of God, yet many who accepted the call acted from selfish motives, murmured and complained, and rose in insurrection against the purposes and plans of God, and were no part of the real church, the body of Christ.RH Jan 7, 1915ST Mar 1, 1910 They were rejected and destroyed in the wilderness by fire, by earthquake, by pestilence, by serpents, and in war, their carcasses falling in the wilderness, showing the vast chasm between professing and actually being.ST Mar 1, 1910 It is the same precedent for those shaken out in a later sifting, who like that generation do not share in the promised outcome.RH Jan 7, 1915 Fleshly descent from Abraham gives no title to the promises and no certainty of salvation, for the millions of literal descendants of Jacob who murmured fell and died in the wilderness under judgment.RH Jan 16, 1872 They stand with Korah, Dathan and Abiram, the hosts of idolaters who bowed to Baal and caused their children to pass through the fire, wicked Ahab and Jeroboam who caused Israel to sin, those who put God's prophets to death, Judas Iscariot, those who crucified the Lord of glory, and the thousands who perished at the destruction of Jerusalem, proving that even those with special light can perish.RH Jan 16, 1872
Doctrinal Warnings
The destruction of the numbered adults in the wilderness warns that divine mercy has a limit and forbearance toward repeated rebellion ends when iniquity is full.ST Dec 15, 1881RH Jan 12, 1869ST Mar 19, 1885 Privilege does not prevent judgment when it is rejected, and wasted warnings and opportunities make punishment more certain and severe while God in his own time vindicates his authority.ST Dec 15, 1881ST Mar 19, 1885 Their history stands as evidence that he punishes transgressors, warning Gentiles in their own day of favor not to presume.ST Mar 19, 1885
Even after repentant words it was too late to escape the consequence, for unbelief in trusting the fearful report of the spies instead of the promise had already brought the sentence of death without entering the land.RH Aug 7, 1866RH Jun 13, 1854 Their later confidence to go up was presumption, not faith, because God had forbidden them to go after their sin, and neither the first refusal to go forward from strong feeling nor the later attempt after he told them not to was faith or obedience.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Oct 7, 1897 That presumption ended in defeat by the Amalekites and Canaanites and in thirty-eight to forty years of wandering until almost every man and woman who started from Egypt perished.ST Nov 24, 1887RH Oct 9, 1866RH Sep 26, 1854 The failure to enter was due to unbelief, not lack of zeal or feeling, warning against refusing the first privilege to obey through fear and half-heartedness and waiting till it is withdrawn to weep and lament, but teaching to receive opportunity gladly not in personal worthiness but in the worthiness of Jesus through whom eternal life and all things may be had.ST Oct 7, 1897RH Oct 9, 1866
The majority-backed refusal to trust God after rejecting Caleb and Joshua was rebellion, not God's voice, and Caleb and Joshua were excepted from the sentence.ST May 31, 1899 Of the 600,000 who started from Egypt only two crossed the Jordan and entered as inheritors because they wholly followed the Lord and God stood with them, proving that the unbelief of the many does not make the truth of God of none effect.ST May 31, 1899ST May 4, 1904 The condemnation to die in the wilderness did not necessarily mean final loss, for many may have repented through Moses' instruction and the signs of God's presence, power and glory.RH Jul 21, 1868
The doom was God's own word through Moses, not merely human, for Christ himself as the Angel of the covenant veiled by the cloudy pillar went before them and gave Moses all his directions, and Israel was under divine guidance, not human leading.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Jun 7, 1906 Israel was unwilling to submit to the sentence, forgot God their Savior who had done great things in Egypt, treated it as only human, and blamed Moses for their doom, seizing every pretext to believe it was Moses who was leading them and had pronounced it.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Jun 7, 1906RH Aug 1, 1907 Marks of displeasure were already before them in broken ranks and missing numbers, yet they did not take the lesson to heart and were again overcome by temptation, at last recognizing punishment was certain and efforts to escape hopeless.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Aug 1, 1907 Korah, Dathan and Abiram contradicted that word, declaring it need not be so and was not from the Lord but that the people might if they would go right on to the land.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Nov 19, 1903 Korah denied that murmuring had brought wrath, taught the congregation was holy and at fault for nothing and desired only its rights, and charged all disasters and exclusion to the mismanagement and overbearing rule of Moses and Aaron.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Jul 25, 1907 He claimed that if he were leader and encouraged good deeds instead of reproving sins they would not wander but proceed directly in peace and prosperity, and with his followers saw in the sentence only Moses' arbitrary will to destroy them for not blindly following, to kill them in the wilderness and make himself altogether a prince, having brought them up without giving inheritance of fields and vineyards and refusing to go up when they were ready from wilful stubbornness.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Jul 25, 1907 Such smooth denial excusing where close scrutiny is not desirable and promising an easy time finds a ready audience in every unsanctified heart but leads to rough experience and ends in catastrophe.RH Nov 19, 1903
God never uses force, and the thousands who started for the land but died on the way died through unbelief because he would not bring them into Canaan against their own wills.ST Nov 17, 1909ST Jun 30, 1909 Doubting fearful thought produces its own fulfillment, as a man thinketh in his heart so is he: the spies feared walled cities, giant warriors and iron chariots and left God out, the multitude echoed that they were not able to go up, and their words proved true in that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured wore out their lives in the desert.ST Nov 17, 1909 By contrast Caleb and Joshua reasoned that promise was superior to giants, walled cities and chariots and that they were well able to overcome, and their word proved true in that though they shared the forty years they entered, with Caleb as courageous as when he left Egypt asking for and receiving the stronghold of the giants, driving out Canaanites in God's strength and possessing vineyards and olive groves where his feet had trodden, so that while cowards and rebels perished the men of faith ate of the grapes of Eschol.ST Nov 17, 1909
Most of the great host died prematurely in the camps during forty years in the great and terrible wilderness under testing trials and adverse circumstances, even though they had learned obedience to statutes and commandments covering the physical as well as the spiritual with promise that no sickness should come upon them.RH Sep 18, 1913 Their terrible mortality came because of sin, for sin affects physical life and cuts short usefulness even though sins are repented of.RH Sep 18, 1913 Their fall warns the last-day people being prepared for the promised land, from whom the Lord expects no less, making the gospel of health and practical right living vital for physical vigor to endure the tests of the closing message.RH Sep 18, 1913 They came out of Egypt physically but left their hearts there, carrying unsanctified overmastering desires and longing for Egypt and turning to its idolatry, with the slogan Back to Egypt instead of On to Canaan, and so their carcasses fell instead of entering.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Dec 13, 1905 Leaving Egypt physically did not mean leaving it spiritually, for when hardship came they forgot God and murmured, and like them people who carry Egypt in their hearts may fall on the journey.ST Dec 13, 1905 Their death is a fit symbol of those who stay in the darkness, unbelief and sin of the spiritual Egypt of this world, where Egypt stands for all that is bad and slavery and death and the Promised Land stands for all that is good and freedom and life, so that remaining in spiritual Egypt always means wilderness and death.ST Aug 6, 1912
The death of all the adults was God's lesson to teach reverence, for those bold men murmured and found fault with God and with Moses and by doing so profaned his name and authority, so they all fell and withered.RH Jun 23, 1868 The same God who divided the sea, overthrew their masters in it, brought water from the rock and fed them in a barren desert would not go with them to battle when they murmured against him.ST Mar 18, 1875 The promise of the Spirit is to all but its manifestations are various and will not be dictated to, serve no private purpose and gratify no curiosity; it asks faith and chooses its own method of trying faith, so murmuring and unbelief forfeit its accompanying power.ST Mar 18, 1875
Present Application
Present believers stand in the same condition as Israel on the way to the promised land and must not murmur as Israel did, but must take heed lest they fall even when they think they stand, staying wholly given up, consecrated and holy to be ready for Christ's coming.RH Sep 4, 1860RH Jul 24, 1860 A holy God regards a peevish, fretful, murmuring spirit under trial as shown when the carcasses of murmurers fell in the wilderness, and the same sin is committed when little trials in families and from other sources are met with peevishness and fretfulness.RH Jun 26, 1860 Murmuring is a dangerous and terrible sin by which only two of those who came out of Egypt reached the promised land, because the journey was made long through disobedience, unbelief and murmuring.RH Sep 4, 1860RH Sep 8, 1863RH Jul 24, 1860 Complaining against God over delay of deliverance and disappointment that He has not yet come to free His people from drudgery and hard work, over trouble, reproach, temptation and a world of work instead of expected blessing, over reproof for sin instead of deliverance, over a call to humility instead of exaltation beside the Saviour, over the watch-care of brethren, over liberality, self-denial and coming out for the Sabbath amid opposition, over hard constant painful work, withheld rain, friends turned to foes for obedience, and over present want and poverty, puts all former work at risk of being lost.RH Sep 8, 1863 Trials, afflictions and pains are the discipline of a heavenly Father answering prayer for sanctification, sent expressly for good as love tokens, and chastisement is a greater mark of love than caressing because it is painful to inflict and pleasant to impart, for God afflicts not willingly, so that if one trial were withheld a soul might be lost.RH Jun 26, 1860 Past murmurings need forgiveness, and every trial, affliction and pain should be welcomed as the choicest blessing leading to the Saviour, while the first murmuring thought must be cast out at once lest it spread like the leprosy of Egypt and darken the soul and spread to others, keeping instead a cheerful, thankful, courageous soul rejoicing in the goodness of the Lord.RH Jun 26, 1860RH Sep 8, 1863
Talking discouragement takes the life out of God's cause, displeases God and forfeits His favor, and the forty-year death in the wilderness stands as an example upon whom the ends of the world are come.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 When Israel came near the borders of the promised land the report of the ten spies discouraged the people from going farther, though they brought proof of a land flowing with milk and honey including a cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men, yet told of huge giants, high thick walls and numerous inhabitants in whose sight Israel were as grasshoppers.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 In vain the two faithful spies tried to talk faith, because man's heart is naturally unbelieving and the devil is anxious to have people doubt, so the people's unbelieving hearts sided with doubt and God was greatly displeased.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 The ten men who brought the discouraging report died by plague before the congregation chiefly because they had discouraged the people, while the great multitude that yielded to discouragement was turned back over its weary course to wander forty years in the desert till all that were numbered from twenty years old and upward died there for that act of murmuring and unbelief.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 Discouragement is the first step to distrust, and murmurings follow bringing death in the wilderness, as the multitude's carcasses falling shows the end of following the ten spies into discouragement, distrust and murmuring against God. Joshua and Caleb are the opposite pattern, speaking with courage that they are able to overcome, being strong and therefore entering Canaan, teaching saints under trial not to faint, weep, distrust and murmur but to be strong and courageous, meeting hardship with faith and courage and trusting God's mercy and power to move forward in faith instead of weakening themselves, blinding themselves to providence and delaying entry.RH Jun 27, 1907
The whole camp murmuring against Moses shows God is displeased when His chosen leader is spoken against, and that rebellion brought judgment.RH Mar 7, 1907 Rebels in the camp breathed out suspicion against God's chosen leaders, made strong and bold accusations of partiality, blamed Moses for standing in the way of their advancement when the wickedness of their own hearts kept God from using them in responsibility, and grew wrathful and determined to get rid of Moses as one God had not put in his place because he did not run things to their notion, and so destroyed themselves instead of destroying him and died in the wilderness instead of entering Canaan.RH Jul 30, 1914 Their fate warns against rebellion and against failing to support those chosen to lead God's work, for murmuring against those leading them weakened them, blinded them to God's providence and delayed entry into the promised land.RH Jun 27, 1907RH Jul 30, 1914 God's curse falls on those who fail to take a clear stand, and indifference in the present crisis is no more acceptable than it was then.ST Mar 11, 1886
The cowardly murmurers perished in the wilderness while faithful Caleb received a home in the promised Canaan, for the murmurers were selfish, ease-loving and panic-stricken, fearing tall giants, the sons of Anak and inaccessible walls and clamoring for retreat.RH Oct 5, 1916 Caleb honored God by faith that gave courage, kept him from fear of man, and made him stand boldly and unflinchingly in defense of the right, pressing to the front with courageous words for immediate action even when the cowardly ones stood with stones in their hands ready to beat him down for his faithful testimony.RH Oct 5, 1916 Them that honor God He will honor, and the same faithful and true Calebs, chieftains in Israel, are called for in these last days.RH Oct 5, 1916 As a man thinketh in his heart so is he, with doubting fearful thought producing its own fulfillment, for on the borders of Canaan the spies feared walled cities, giant warriors and iron chariots and left God out, and the multitude echoed their unbelief that they were not able to go up, and their words proved true in that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured wore out their lives in the desert and perished.ST Nov 17, 1909 By contrast Caleb and Joshua reasoned that God's promise was superior to giants, walled cities and chariots of iron and that they were well able to overcome, and their word proved true in that though they shared the forty years' wandering they entered the land of promise, with Caleb as courageous as when he left Egypt asking for and receiving the stronghold of the giants as his portion, driving out the Canaanites in God's strength and possessing the vineyards and olive groves where his feet had trodden, so that while cowards and rebels perished the men of faith ate of the grapes of Eschol.ST Nov 17, 1909 Those who murmured against God and lacked courage perished in the wilderness, while Caleb who followed the Lord wholeheartedly survived and received his inheritance.ST Sep 16, 1880
Though individuals were mightily shaken and lost faith, the nation God brought out still went into Canaan without His abandoning it to start another, so those who kept faith in the face of difficulties and stayed with the movement entered the Promised Land.RH Nov 9, 1916 The Lord's pronouncement to Moses and Aaron after Israel murmured when discouraged by the report of the unfaithful spies was that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured against Him would have their carcasses fall in the wilderness and would not come into the land He swore to make them dwell in, except Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun, while their little ones would be brought in to know the land they despised.RH Nov 9, 1916 The sin warned against is unbelief, rebellion against God, and rejection of those He chose to lead the movement He started from Egypt to the Land of Promise under the pillar of cloud and of fire.RH Nov 9, 1916
The murmurings that brought judgment can in every case be traced back to restrictions on what they should eat and drink or to fears about it.ST Apr 22, 1875ST Jun 10, 1875 Appetite dethroned reason and reigned in childish murmurings and rebellion against God, so that the adults who left Egypt died in forty years of wandering with their bodies left all along the way, and only two of those adults were permitted to reach the promised land.ST Apr 22, 1875ST Jun 10, 1875 God gave manna because it was best for them and gave the flesh of quails, the simplest meat, only to prove manna better for them, but the meat made them sick, yet they still lusted and murmured in lust for the flesh meats they ate in Egypt after God gave them manna.RH Mar 19, 1867 After encamping around Mount Sinai about two years for instruction and preparation when Canaan was only about eleven days' journey, they started out and within three days fell to lusting for the flesh-pots of Egypt and murmuring against God and Moses over manna, saying their soul loathed the light bread, and for that lusting and murmuring God kept them forty years in the wilderness until all numbered from twenty years old and upward died, while He was endeavoring through the simple manna diet to lead man back to the original diet.RH Jan 6, 1910 When God tried to lead Israel into the promised land He gave them a regimen, and many became weary of it and died in the wilderness, warning against doing likewise with health reform instruction, which must be taught again systematically. They died because they failed to receive God's provision by faith, treating the manna and water as if they came from human effort rather than from God the giver of life, illustrating the consequence of rejecting life from God.ST Jul 7, 1898
God drove Israel back into the wilderness because of murmurings, complainings and fault-finding until the grumblers from twenty years old and upward fell dead there.RH Oct 8, 1908 Israel came to the border of Canaan the first time with great power, was turned back, then came a second time in sight of the land with a remnant of complainers who were destroyed in sight of the land, after which God's people rose up as one man to do His work and neither the swelling Jordan, the Moabites nor the walls of Jericho could stop them because God led them with a strong arm.RH Oct 8, 1908 The same is true now, for God's people came in sight of the heavenly kingdom with power when ministers and people everywhere worked and sold books by the thousands, were turned back into the wilderness when murmuring and complaining spread, but now delay shall be no longer and they are in sight of the land again while murmurers and fault-finders are rapidly falling out, so if ministers and workers rise up and lead in scattering the printed page the earth will soon be lighted with the glory of God and they will be at home in the kingdom.RH Oct 8, 1908 The same sentence fell on God's people after the proclamation of the First Angel's Message over forty years ago, when the denomination reached its Kadesh-barnea and failed to reveal the fullness of Christ, so those who might have seen the immortal state in childhood remained in the world, and those who have taken the place of those who fell asleep now approach the promised land a second time where success depends on united forward movement.RH Jan 14, 1902 Those who murmur against God, heed the ill report of cities walled to heaven and giants and sons of Anak in the way, cast stones at the Calebs and Joshuas on their return, weep and wail through the long night that follows, and choose a captain to return to Egypt will not see the promised land but will be compelled to wander and die in the wilderness of sin.RH Mar 26, 1901 The church stands now on Canaan's border-land facing the same test, and escape comes only by refusing to reckon from a merely human standpoint, trusting that if God is for His people none can stand against them, standing by the faithful, giving a good report, and going up at once to possess the land, for the people must not turn back into the wilderness but have faith in God and go forward.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Mar 26, 1901RH Oct 29, 1903 Their children later did what their parents had judged impossible, after unbelief turned the people back from the land and delayed its possession.RH Jan 28, 1902
Israel eventually took the land, but taking it when God first called them to do so would have been easier, for delay brought greater hardship.RH Oct 19, 1905 The murmuring and unbelief of Israel when they stood before Kadesh-barnea brought judgment that their carcasses would fall in the wilderness through thirty-eight years of wandering; courage then would have brought eternal victory, but a faltering mind brought the wandering. A murmur now and a word of unbelief today brings the same result, and the generation that is to meet Christ at His coming cannot afford to spend much time wandering.
Hundreds and thousands of those who sang the song of Moses after crossing the Red Sea on dry ground fell in the wilderness because of their murmurings and unbelief, after Pharaoh and his army attempted the same crossing and perished in the sea.RH May 28, 1867 It is repeated when those who were in the great Advent movement of 1844 reject truth and sin against light through unbelief and draw back, thus falling by the way.RH May 28, 1867 The later attempt to go up to Canaan without God's presence ended in defeat, confirming the warning that those aged twenty and older who murmured would die in the wilderness, applied to the New-Time movement that those who disregard God's commandments cannot expect His presence or success.RH Sep 26, 1854
Those who were twenty years old and upward when they left Egypt, except two, perished in the wilderness through unbelief or disobedience, while those under twenty entered the promised land, encouraging young people to seek wisdom and exercise faith.RH Oct 13, 1868 The younger Israelites were more favorably shaped by what they witnessed and were morally fitted for that possession, making the wilderness generation an example for later believers who failed to attain the character needed to enter.RH Nov 24, 1874
Israel later regarded that long wilderness sojourn after the spies' report as unnecessary, wrongly claiming they could have taken Canaan sooner, and continued to murmur against God.ST Oct 21, 1880 As God did a special work in delivering Israel from Egyptian bondage, He is now doing a special work in developing the remnant church under the third angel's message, and just as Dathan and Abiram and all the secessionists fell in the wilderness, so all who oppose this work must fall and professed friends of truth found in rebellion must perish.RH Jan 24, 1865
Sources