Translations
And Moses said to them, Have you saved all the women alive?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
And Moses said unto them, Have ye saved all the women alive?
And Moses said to them, Have ye saved all the women alive?
And Moses saith unto them, 'Have ye kept alive every female?
and Moses said to them, Have ye saved all the women alive?
And Moses said unto them,—Have ye saved alive every female?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Have you spared all the women?” he asked them.
Moses said to them, “ Have you saved all the women alive?
And Moses said to them, Why have you kept all the women safe?
And Moses sayde vnto them, What? haue ye saued all the women?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Said: Why have you saved the women?
Cross-references
- Numbers 25:1-9
And Israel abode in Shittim, and the people began to commit whoredom with the daughters of Moab.
Israel’s sin at Peor and the resulting plague explain Moses’ rebuke.
- Numbers 31:2
Avenge the children of Israel of the Midianites: afterward shalt thou be gathered unto thy people.
God commands Moses to avenge Israel on the Midianites.
- Numbers 31:7
And they warred against the Midianites, as the LORD commanded Moses; and they slew all the males.
Both describe the Midianite attack, which leads to Moses’ rebuke.
- Numbers 25:16-18
And the LORD spake unto Moses, saying,
God identifies the Midianites’ role in leading Israel into sin at Peor.
- Revelation 2:14
But I have a few things against thee, because thou hast there them that hold the doctrine of Balaam, who taught Balac to cast a stumblingblock before the children of Israel, to eat things sacrificed unto idols, and to commit fornication.
both blame Midianite seduction for Israel's sin
- Numbers 31:8
And they slew the kings of Midian, beside the rest of them that were slain; namely, Evi, and Rekem, and Zur, and Hur, and Reba, five kings of Midian: Balaam also the son of Beor they slew with the sword.
Balaam, whose counsel led Israel into sin, is killed in battle.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
5 sources
Moses spoke these words to confront the officers returning from the war with Midian, demanding why they had saved the women, and the children, alive instead of carrying out God's command.SG4 50.1–21SP 327.2ST Jan 6, 1881 The Midianite women had enticed Israel into sin at Peor, seducing them into idolatry and sexual immorality and wrongdoing.SG4 50.1–21SP 327.2PP 456.2–3ST Jan 6, 1881ST Jan 6, 1881 They did this through Balaam's counsel, and their seduction brought a plague on the congregation of Israel.SG4 50.1–21SP 327.2
Because they led Israel into sin, the women were regarded as the most guilty and dangerous of Israel's enemies, and their idolatrous presence among the Israelites remained a continuing danger.PP 456.2–3ST Jan 6, 1881 Moses' question introduces his command that the captured women be put to death as punishment for their role in leading Israel into sin.SG4 50.1–2PP 456.2–3 That order of punishment also required the destruction of the male children.SG4 50.1–2 Sparing those who had led others into sin was a failure to carry out God's command, not an act of godly compassion.ST Jan 6, 1881 The war against Midian to which the verse belongs was God's judgment carried out by the Israelites as his instruments, an act of divine justice and mercy to uphold God's authority and glory, not to satisfy malice or revenge.ST Jan 6, 1881
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
11 sources
Moses spoke the question as a rebuke to Israel's officers and soldiers on their return from the war with Midian for sparing all the women and children alive after slaying the males and seizing women, children, flocks and herds, the first taking of captives by Israel, in disobedience to God's command to avenge Israel and destroy Midian.ST Jan 6, 1881RH Sep 4, 1860ST Apr 28, 1909RH Oct 1, 1861RH Jan 31, 1907 In Numbers 31 the word soul means a living person or animal, being used for both human captives and livestock taken in the war, with one out of every five hundred from each group set aside.ST Sep 7, 1904 The women were responsible for Israel's trespass against the Lord at Peor, where through Balaam's counsel and the deliberate use of women by Midian's leaders they enticed Israel into idolatry and sexual immorality and brought plague and divine judgment on the congregation.ST Jan 6, 1881ST Jan 6, 1881RH Sep 4, 1860ST Apr 28, 1909RH Jan 31, 1907
The war was an act of divine justice and mercy carried out by the Israelites as God's instruments to uphold God's authority and glory, not to satisfy malice or revenge, and the order that followed Moses' question was directed by the Lord and not chosen by Moses.ST Jan 6, 1881ST Apr 28, 1909 The women were to be destroyed not merely because they were corrupt but because they had the power and purpose to corrupt others, and sparing those who had led Israel into sin was not godly compassion, since preserving people wholly given over to evil could bring only further corruption and harm to many others.ST Jan 6, 1881ST The destruction combined justice with compassion as an act of mercy to protect Israel from destruction, from renewed sin and judgment through the women's continued dangerous presence, and to protect future generations from being raised in the same course, in a case where corruption had become so complete that children were born depraved with no hope of turning from evil.RH Sep 4, 1860ST Apr 28, 1909ST Jul 18, 1900
The order implied that the women should not be spared, the male children were killed to prevent future rebellion, and the female children and virgins were spared as servants and reserved for adoption into the families of the nation, a practice justified only for that age.RH Sep 4, 1860RH Oct 1, 1861 Sparing the women violated the local, temporary Sinaitic covenant that regulated Israel's social relations to keep them a separate and distinct race, for blending the blood of aliens with Israel by intermarriage and mingling freely with other nations was forbidden and visited with swift retribution by summary execution.RH Apr 8, 1915 That strict separation was necessary to hedge Israel against surrounding heathenism, to keep Israel from desiring to be like alien nations, and to guard the pedigree of Christ as the Seed of Abraham so that no doubt should follow His entrance upon His earthly work as the promised Seed with all predicted tokens of Messiahship centering in Him.RH Apr 8, 1915
The verse shows God prohibited rather than sanctioned the enslavement of prisoners of war, and therefore did not intend Israel to become a slaveholding nation.RH Oct 1, 1861 As part of Numbers 31 to 33, the verse teaches that no secret sin can be hidden from God.RH Feb 17, 1916
Sources