Romans 11:22
Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God: on them which fell, severity; but toward thee, goodness, if thou continue in his goodness: otherwise thou also shalt be cut off.
Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God: on them which fell, severity; but toward thee, goodness, if thou continue in his goodness: otherwise thou also shalt be cut off.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
107 sources
God holds out kindness to those joined to his people and stern judgment to those who fall away, with Israel as the living olive tree that is never destroyed and unbelieving Jews as natural branches broken off while believing Gentiles as wild branches grafted in to share its root and richness.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Apr 10, 1900RH Oct 22, 1861RH Mar 4, 1862 The stern side fell on Israel because of unbelief, distrust, disobedience and rejection of Christ, even after long patience and many chastisements.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872ST Mar 19, 1885RH Jun 11, 1901 The kind side lifts Gentiles who bring no merit of their own into equal privilege, heirship and promises with Abraham's seed, standing only by faith and drawing all life and strength from Christ the root.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Apr 10, 1900ST Nov 26, 1894ST Sep 26, 1906 That kindness lasts only while they continue in faith shown in obedience, for those who stand can fall and will likewise be cut off, wither and face burning if they become highminded and unfaithful.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872RH Mar 3, 1853RH Mar 13, 1879 Thus belonging to Israel depends wholly on faith in Christ, which makes a true Jew inwardly and Abraham's heir, and grafted citizens continue only by keeping the constitution of that commonwealth, the ten commandments including the Sabbath.RH May 13, 1915RH Aug 8, 1871ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 4, 1873RH Jan 23, 1872
Olive Tree Setting
The good or tame olive tree is Israel, the ancient Hebrew church and Abraham's family to which the covenants, the promises, the adoption, the glory and salvation belong, and that tree itself was not destroyed, plucked up and cast away, or replaced by a separate Gentile tree.RH Mar 4, 1862ST May 30, 1878RH Aug 8, 1871ST Oct 23, 1884 Believing Gentiles are grafted into that same tree to share its root and nourishment, which are the blessings of the new covenant and God's promises through Abraham and his seed, so that since Christ the Israelite tree is made up of believing Jews and believing Gentiles with equal privileges and heirship, and there is no other tree and no other Israel.RH Mar 4, 1862ST May 30, 1878RH Aug 8, 1871RH Jul 30, 1861ST Oct 23, 1884 The illustration is simple even though single expressions in the chapter are difficult, showing the relation of all men to God as the commonwealth of Israel, the household of God composed only of saints reconciled to God, and every scripture concerning Israel this side of Christ therefore applies to the spiritual seed and not to the literal seed alone.RH Aug 8, 1871RH Jul 30, 1861
The natural branches are Jews or Israelites according to the flesh, and the wild branches are Gentiles or unbelievers, so that being broken off means Jews who rejected Christ through unbelief ceased to be God's people, and being grafted in means Gentiles who believed were taken as God's people in their place without becoming a separate tree.RH Oct 22, 1861ST Sep 13, 1877ST Aug 11, 1909RH Sep 9, 1862RH Apr 12, 1864 The ancient tribes were broken off as unfruitful branches because of unbelief, while people of faith are grafted into the remaining stock through Christ by being born again, so that Israel's identity and restoration are spiritual and the twelve tribes continue in those who believe.ST Sep 13, 1877ST Jul 15, 1913ST Aug 11, 1909RH Sep 9, 1862 Those grafted in must not be highminded but must fear and continue in His goodness, for otherwise they also will be broken off and wither for burning, while the broken branches are not cast off beyond hope but can be grafted in again if they abide not still in unbelief but repent and turn to the Lord with the whole heart.RH Oct 22, 1861RH Apr 12, 1864
The grafting is contrary to nature because in natural grafting the ingrafted branch keeps bearing fruit like the tree the scion was taken from, whereas the wild scion grafted into the good stock partakes of its root and fatness and no longer bears wild olives but bears the same good fruit as Israel.RH May 13, 1862RH May 13, 1862RH Nov 10, 1904 The Gentile thus becomes an Israelite indeed, no longer sharing a bitter nature and bad fruit but bearing the fruit of the tame olive, even the fruits of the Spirit instead of the works of the flesh, with God's truth cutting off the former source of sinful life and cleansing the old nature to give a new nature.RH Nov 10, 1904ST Mar 11, 1897ST Jun 22, 1904ST Dec 11, 1893 Believers as branches joined to Christ draw life and quality from Him, and the root imparts its life to change their former nature so they bear good fruit according to Christ's nature rather than the old nature, righteous only as Christ works through them.ST Mar 11, 1897ST Jun 22, 1904ST Dec 11, 1893
That root which supports and nourishes the branches is Abraham and his Seed Christ with the promises God gave to Abraham and his seed, so that grafted branches share the root and richness of the olive tree and thus share Abraham's blessings.ST May 30, 1878ST Nov 26, 1894ST Sep 26, 1906 Christ is the root, the stock, the Root and Stock of true Israel and the all in all of the Israel of God, and as a branch draws nourishment from the tree so God's children draw nourishment from Christ, with those once far off made nigh by His blood to be no more strangers and foreigners from the commonwealth of Israel but fellow-citizens with the saints and of the household of God.ST Sep 26, 1906ST Mar 11, 1897RH Oct 12, 1869 The tree's root supports the grafted branches and not the reverse, and unbelievers are grafted into the old spiritual root by faith in Jesus Christ.RH Oct 12, 1869ST Oct 7, 1897
The present church continues the Old Testament church, for no covenant was ever made with Gentiles as Gentiles and they remain outside until engrafted into the Abrahamic stock, by which engrafting they become Israel and share in all the covenants then binding, including the new covenant made with Israel and not with the Gentiles as a nation.ST Jun 30, 1914RH May 6, 1862RH Jul 21, 1910 In this dispensation all Christians by faith are equally Israel with those of the former and are reckoned as belonging to the twelve tribes, since they are not all Israel which are of Israel and the true seed are not the literal Israel but only such as are Jews inwardly, gathered out of all nations into one united Israel in Christ.RH Jul 30, 1861RH Sep 8, 1853ST Jun 24, 1913RH Jan 12, 1864 In this sense Gentile believers became Israel whose remnant is the small number alive when Christ comes, the faithful branches chosen by grace, with their identity recorded in the heavenly sanctuary and to be complete at the close of probation and in the future state and new world where transplanted branches bear immortal fruit.RH Sep 8, 1853RH Jan 12, 1864
Branches and their treatment convey meaning through symbols rather than literal description.RH Dec 9, 1851 The olive-tree imagery also helps explain another symbol, showing that the meaning of one symbol can be conveyed through other symbols that are explained elsewhere.RH Aug 14, 1856
Severity Toward Fallen
The goodness and severity of God stand divided between two groups, with severity resting on those who fell, that is, the branches broken off because of unbelief, distrust shown in reliance on works, sin, disobedience, and rejection of Christ.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872RH Apr 10, 1900ST Jul 29, 1908 The natural branches were broken off because of unbelief while Gentiles grafted in stand by faith, and the goodness shown to those who trust in Christ is set against the severity shown to those who fell by trusting in their own works.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872ST Apr 17, 1893ST Jul 29, 1908 Those grafted in must not boast over the fallen branches or become high-minded and proud, but must fear and continue in humility and faith.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872RH Apr 10, 1900ST Jul 29, 1908
Israel's stumbling did not mean the whole people were cast away without exception, for there remained a faithful remnant chosen by grace while the nation at large was blinded.ST Sep 16, 1889 That stumbling brought salvation to the Gentiles, and the bringing in of the Gentiles was intended to provoke Israelites to seek that salvation.ST Sep 16, 1889 Even when God subverted and utterly overthrew the kingdom of the ten tribes He always left a remnant, with the honest-hearted staying true to the worship of the God of Judah and remaining connected with the kingdom of Judah throughout, so that the ten tribes were never wholly lost.ST Mar 28, 1906
The severity is expressed in Isaiah's image of withered boughs broken off and set on fire, meaning Israel cut off as a people of no understanding so that He who made them will have no mercy on them and He who formed them will show them no favor.ST Feb 22, 1883ST Feb 2, 1882RH Jan 19, 1860RH Jun 23, 1874 The withering and breaking off of the boughs parallels the breaking off of the branches, showing God's severity toward those who fall away.ST Feb 22, 1883ST Feb 2, 1882RH Jun 23, 1874 That judgment stands linked with a future gathering of God's people at the Lord's coming when the dead are raised and gathered to Him.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 19, 1860
God did not spare the natural branches but visited them with many privileges joined to much correction, severe chastisement, rich mercy and unsparing judgment.ST Mar 19, 1885 He spared them not in the wilderness where their carcasses fell through unbelief, nor when they were carried captive to Babylon, nor when Roman power destroyed their place and nation and scattered them to the ends of the earth.ST Mar 19, 1885RH Apr 11, 1871 After more than two thousand years of patience from the call of Abraham to the destruction of Jerusalem they were broken off by unbelief and lastingly expelled from their own land for spurning and killing the Saviour, as unbelief had once kept them out of Canaan forty years, with no promise of re-entering the land for greater earthly blessings while still rejecting Him, since to grant it would be inconsistent with His former actions.RH Jun 11, 1901
The rejection of the Jewish church was a moral fall through unfaithfulness and alienation, in which the Holy Spirit leaves, and not its immediate destruction, for destruction was deferred for a considerable period.RH Mar 6, 1855ST Jun 29, 1876 Because of wickedness and alienation from God she is given over to evil spirits, and this fall illustrates the later rejection of Babylon.RH Mar 6, 1855
Goodness Toward Grafted
God's goodness in the verse is toward the Gentiles grafted as wild olive branches into Israel's olive tree to share its root and fatness and its blessings and promises through faith in Christ, standing by faith with equal privileges and heirship with Abraham's seed.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Apr 10, 1900ST Jul 29, 1908RH Mar 4, 1862 The ancient Hebrew church is the good olive tree that was not destroyed, and unbelieving branches were broken off while believing Gentiles were grafted into it to share its root and blessings, with belonging to the tree conditional on continuing in God's goodness.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Jan 30, 1879 His treatment of the broken-off branches shows severity while his treatment of the grafted Gentiles shows goodness, contrasting severity toward branches broken off for unbelief with goodness toward those grafted in and standing by faith.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Apr 10, 1900 Gentiles stand by faith and must not boast over the branches that fell or become proud, but must continue in God's goodness or they too will be cut off.ST Feb 22, 1883ST Jul 29, 1908ST Jan 30, 1879
Those grafted bring no merit of their own and have no greater privilege or ground for boasting over the fallen branches, but must not be highminded and must fear, since all they have of life and power and fruit and grace and strength depends on God.RH Mar 3, 1853RH Jan 23, 1872ST Sep 13, 1877RH Jun 27, 1871RH Jun 27, 1871 The Jewish branches were broken off because of unbelief while Gentiles stand by faith, and if Gentiles persist in unbelief God will not spare them either.RH Jan 23, 1872ST Sep 13, 1877RH Jun 27, 1871 Both Jews and Gentiles come to God on the same basis of faith, so the truths and blessings received through Israel are not diminished even while Jewish unbelief and rejection of Christ are deplored.ST Sep 13, 1877RH Jun 27, 1871
The natural branches broken off are not cast off beyond hope but can be grafted in again if they abide not still in unbelief, for God is able to restore them.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872RH Apr 10, 1900ST Jul 29, 1908 This restoration is on conditions resting with them, if they repent and turn to the Lord with the whole heart, humble themselves, give up claims of descent, and believe in Christ, when God will graft them in again.RH Oct 22, 1861RH May 13, 1915 So by being turned away from sin all Israel, meaning all those who prevail with God, will be saved, and no people has a privileged standing apart from faith while opportunity remains.RH Oct 22, 1861RH May 13, 1915
The ingrafting into the good olive tree is the call of the Gentiles, prepared for by the gift of tongues on the day of Pentecost.RH Mar 4, 1862 This call stands opposite God's giving up the Gentiles to apostasy before the call of Abraham, when he confounded their language and scattered them abroad upon the face of the earth at Babel.RH Mar 4, 1862 Christ had prepared for the Gentile grafting during his life by seeking to lead the Jews out of exclusiveness through direct work outside acknowledged Israel, as in the conversion of the centurion and of the Syrophoenician woman, and the time then came for active and continued work among the Gentiles of whom whole communities gladly received intelligent faith and glorified God.ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879 When the synagogues were closed against the apostles at Antioch in Pisidia and elsewhere, private Gentile houses were thrown open for their use and public buildings of the Gentiles were also used to preach the word, while Jewish unbelief, bigotry, blindness, hardness, malice and rejection did not turn aside God's purpose to graft believing Gentiles as a new Israel into the old olive tree.ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879
The gathering of Israel taught by the verse is the restoration of the tree's lost branches through faith, not a return of carnal Jews to old Palestine as a nation.RH Jan 3, 1856RH Apr 17, 1900 To use Romans 11 to advocate that national return sets Paul against Paul and against his teaching that those in Christ are Abraham's seed and heirs of the promise, that the promises to the fathers are confirmed in Christ, and that not all who are of Israel are Israel.RH Jan 3, 1856 Jews and Gentiles share the same offer of salvation through faith in Christ with neither group holding exclusive nor pre-eminent standing, and Gentiles though unnatural branches are fellow heirs with Jews in one body brought near and made one by the gospel, so salvation is personal rather than restoration of Israel's national pre-eminence.RH Feb 7, 1856
Continue or Be Cut Off
God's goodness toward those grafted in lasts only while they continue in that goodness, and otherwise they also will be cut off.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872RH Apr 10, 1900RH Oct 22, 1861 That continuing means continuing faith, standing by faith rather than by works or merit, with living faith shown in works, perfect obedience to the commandments, and sharing Christ's life.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883ST Apr 17, 1893ST Jun 24, 1886ST Aug 7, 1884 Those joined to Israel by faith must not boast over the fallen branches or become high-minded and proud, but must be humble and fear, remembering that God did not spare the natural branches broken off for unbelief, distrust shown in works, sin, disobedience and rejection of Christ.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Feb 22, 1883RH Jan 23, 1872RH Apr 10, 1900ST Apr 17, 1893 If they do not continue they will be broken off in turn, to wither and face burning.RH Oct 22, 1861ST Apr 17, 1893ST Jan 17, 1906RH Apr 15, 1858RH Apr 11, 1871
Standing by faith does not place anyone beyond rejection or loss of salvation, for those who stand can fall away if they do not continue.RH Mar 3, 1853RH Mar 13, 1879ST Jun 24, 1886ST Aug 7, 1884RH Apr 15, 1858 Being in Christ does not guarantee salvation regardless of later choices, so the warning describes a real danger and calls for watchfulness, faithful perseverance, fear, and the speedy putting away of unbelief by earnest work and seeking God for strong faith unto complete victory over the world, the flesh, Satan and unbelief.RH Mar 3, 1853RH Mar 13, 1879ST Jun 24, 1886ST Aug 7, 1884RH Apr 11, 1871 The same severity that rejected the Jews for unfaithfulness and that let Israel fall in the wilderness for unbelief threatens Sabbath-keepers now if they hold doubts and unbelief about the last work under the third message of Revelation 14, which must prove fatal unless put away.ST Aug 7, 1884RH Apr 15, 1858RH Apr 11, 1871
Goodness and severity together govern continued existence itself, preserving those who submit to God's will and remain fit, and cutting off those who reject it as unfit.ST Jan 17, 1906ST Sep 16, 1875 This shows justice and holiness alongside goodness, so that God's character cannot be represented by mercy alone.ST Jan 17, 1906ST Sep 16, 1875 When His professed people apostatize they fall under severity and are cut off, but toward those who continue by heeding His regular call to come out from the world and from apostasy He continues goodness.ST Apr 29, 1908 In this sense the church is the regularly called-out ones in every age and not an unbroken succession, as in Elijah's day when the main body had apostatized yet God had His remnant called out, the same pattern as the remnant called out after Babylon and the remnant who followed Jesus at the first advent and composed the organized church.ST Apr 29, 1908
The special work among the Jews gave way to a special work among the Gentiles, made up of faithful natural branches like Abraham together with Gentiles sharing Abraham's faith, while those broken off through unbelief are not part of Israel.ST Sep 21, 1915RH Jan 23, 1872RH Jan 23, 1872 When the multitude of Gentile believers has been gathered in, this dispensation closes, with no later special probation for branches broken off through unbelief.RH Jan 23, 1872RH Jan 23, 1872 Nor does the cleansing of the sanctuary mean a future return of the Jews to favor and rejection of the Gentiles, for it concerns Christ's closing work of judgment.ST Sep 21, 1915
True Israel Defined
The chapter grants literal Israel no special standing before God, distinguishing Israel according to the flesh from the faithful children of promise, so that saved Israel is the faithful remnant and not every physical descendant of Jacob.RH Mar 13, 1856RH Sep 8, 1853RH Jan 12, 1864 The remnant is chosen by grace while the nation at large was blinded, and Israel's stumbling brought salvation to the Gentiles to provoke Israelites to seek it.RH Mar 13, 1856ST Sep 16, 1889 Jews who rejected Christ were broken off because of unbelief while Gentile believers were grafted into Israel and shared its root and blessings, and in this New Testament sense Gentile believers became Israel whose remnant is the small number alive when Christ comes.RH Sep 8, 1853RH Jan 12, 1864 The faithful branches are the remnant beloved for the fathers' sake, not the whole Jewish nation.ST Sep 16, 1889RH Jan 12, 1864
God has one plan of salvation in which Jews and Gentiles are saved through the same gospel by the same means.ST Jul 29, 1908ST Jul 31, 1884 Jews and Gentiles alike may come to Christ and receive mercy, and Jews who turn to the Lord have the veil removed and share the same opportunity for gospel blessings as Gentiles.RH May 23, 1854 Gentiles if they believe have an equal share with the Jews, while the Jews forfeit all the privileges of the people of God through unbelief, for all men are on a level and the promises are to all who believe irrespective of birth or nation.ST Jul 29, 1908 God is impartial, since birth, ancestry and inherited privileges do not make people acceptable, but he regards what they themselves are and do.ST Jul 29, 1908 Restoration is an individual work accomplished in precisely the same manner and by the same means that Gentiles are grafted in and made children of Abraham, so that in unbelief Israel are not Abraham's seed and are not heirs to the promises but have become aliens and foreigners, yet God has not cast them away beyond recovery, and to deny that Jews and Gentiles are saved in the same way by faith is to deny the gospel.RH May 23, 1854ST Jul 31, 1884 The grafting in of the Gentiles to take the place of rebellious Israel is no change in plan but was included in the original promise to Abraham, for those who are of faith are the sons of Abraham and God foresaw justifying the Gentiles by faith, preaching beforehand that in Abraham all nations would be blessed.ST Jul 29, 1908 All human beings are by right God's people, since Adam was the son of God and God did not cast off his descendants because they sinned, and his love embraced the world and did not contract in the days of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, Israel's only advantage being the privilege of carrying the glorious gospel to the Gentiles for whom it was always designed as much as for them.
Belonging to Israel depends wholly on faith in Christ, for unbelief brings severity in being broken off and faith brings goodness in being grafted in, and Jews may be joined again through faith.RH May 13, 1915RH Jan 23, 1872RH Jan 12, 1864 Jacob became Israel through faith, descendants were broken off through unbelief, Gentiles are grafted in through faith, and faith alone makes an Israelite, a Jew inwardly circumcised in heart, Abraham's seed and heir, while unbelief cuts off.RH Jan 23, 1872RH Jan 12, 1864ST Aug 4, 1909 The whole Israelite tree was not plucked up and cast away, but in severity the unbelieving branches were broken off and in goodness believing Gentiles were grafted in to supply their place, so that since Christ the tree is made up of believing Gentiles and believing Jews with no other tree and no other Israel.RH Aug 8, 1871RH Jan 12, 1864RH Jan 12, 1864 The broken-off branches remain cut off and entitled to no further promises unless they continue in his goodness by believing in Christ and are grafted in again, while those grafted in stand only by continuing in his goodness, otherwise they also shall be cut off, and therefore every scripture concerning Israel that applies this side of Christ applies to the spiritual seed and not to the literal seed.RH May 13, 1915RH Aug 8, 1871 Natural descent does not secure membership in true Israel while faith joins people to it, and those cut off may be grafted in again if they cease persisting in unbelief.RH May 13, 1915RH Jan 23, 1872 The complete olive tree is made up of the faithful of every nation who share the covenant promises in Christ, and those grafted in must continue in faith.RH Jan 12, 1864RH Jan 12, 1864 The branches were broken off in unbelief because Israel looked to its own righteousness and failed to reach the righteousness of God, while Gentile branches were grafted in to partake of the virtues of the stock of Israel and thus themselves become Israel, with all who look past their own righteousness to Christ finding his righteousness covering sin and meeting all need.RH Jan 12, 1864ST Aug 4, 1909
The olive-tree picture describes spiritual standing and not assurance that fleshly Israel or all humanity will receive salvation in a future probation.RH May 13, 1915RH Mar 25, 1873 Israel may be restored through repentance and faith while opportunity remains, but no people has a privileged standing apart from faith.RH May 13, 1915RH Mar 25, 1873 Israel has no special promise of national restoration apart from the gathering promised to all peoples, with Israel, Moab and Ammon sharing the same restoration in the same sense and at the same time.RH May 13, 1915RH Mar 25, 1873
God's keeping of his promise that Israel will never cease as a nation is seen in breaking off the old branches who refused to embrace the provisions of the new covenant and in grafting in branches contrary to nature to preserve and perpetuate the Israelite tree, becoming part of the main trunk.RH Mar 10, 1868 This breaking off and grafting keeps the promise inviolate with no need for a final restoration of the Jews as a whole in an age to come, and those with whom the new covenant is made are Israel in this sense.RH Mar 10, 1868
After more than two thousand years of patience from the call of Abraham to the destruction of Jerusalem, they were broken off by unbelief and lastingly expelled from their own land for spurning and killing the Saviour, as unbelief had once kept them out of Canaan for forty years.RH Jun 11, 1901 There is no promise of their re-entering the land to enjoy even greater earthly blessings in the last days while they still reject him, and to grant it would be inconsistent with his former actions.RH Jun 11, 1901 Toward them is severity in their fall, but goodness is open to them if they continue in it, and only by true faith can they return, otherwise they remain cut off in hardened unbelief.RH Jun 11, 1901
Covenant Duties Shared
No covenant was ever made with Gentiles as Gentiles, and they remain outside until engrafted into the Abrahamic stock, by which engrafting they become Israel and share in all the covenants then binding.ST Jun 30, 1914RH May 6, 1862 The new covenant was made with Israel and Judah, not with the Gentiles as a nation, and Gentiles enter it only through belief by being grafted in, with Christians who belong to the people of faith counted as Israelites.ST Jun 30, 1914ST Aug 11, 1909 Both Gentiles in the flesh as wild olive branches and Israelites according to the flesh as natural branches must be grafted into the good olive tree by being born again in Christ Jesus, and only in this way do Gentiles cease to be aliens from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers from the covenants of promise.ST Aug 11, 1909ST Jun 12, 1879ST Oct 23, 1884 In that grafting the kingdom of Israel is not abolished but only suspended for a season till He come whose right it is, because Israel is the Scriptural name for the seed and heirs of Abraham and cannot cease while the promises to Abraham stand sure.ST Jun 12, 1879 The covenants, promises, adoption, glory and salvation remain with Israel, and Gentiles receive no substitutes but have the middle wall broken down to be grafted in, to be fellow-heirs and of the same body and partakers of His promise in Christ by the gospel, no more strangers and foreigners but fellow-citizens with the saints and of the household of God, Abraham's seed and heirs according to the promise, sharers in the blessings of the new covenant, so that all Israel shall be saved.ST Aug 11, 1909ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 4, 1873ST Oct 23, 1884 The root is not dug up and destroyed, for in severity the unbelieving natural branches were broken off and in goodness believing Gentiles as unnatural branches were grafted in, and Gentiles are saved by embracing the covenant made with Judah and Israel and thereby becoming fellow-citizens with the saints and of the Israel of God.RH Mar 4, 1873
When Gentiles are thus grafted in and become citizens of the commonwealth of Israel they are in duty bound as good citizens to obey the constitution of that commonwealth, the ten commandments.ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 4, 1873 Toward them is goodness if they continue in His goodness, but that continuance is only in that obedience.ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 4, 1873 If they refuse obedience they disfranchise themselves and are cut off.ST Jun 12, 1879RH Mar 4, 1873
As grafted-in children of Abraham they do the works of Abraham, keeping God's commandments and laws and holding the faith of Jesus.ST Feb 11, 1875 This is seen in those brought to view by the third angel who keep the commandments of God, who are the 144,000 of the tribes of the children of Israel sealed in their foreheads with the seal or Sabbath of the living God, so Israel keeps the Sabbath.ST Feb 11, 1875 Through unbelief the natural branches were broken off, and by faith believing Gentiles are grafted into Israel as a green olive tree and become true Israel, Israelites indeed and Jews inwardly circumcised in heart and spirit.ST Feb 11, 1875
Joining this people means no longer being alienated from God's promises and brings a disposition to delight in His law and keep the Sabbath, with place among God's people depending on continuing in His goodness, otherwise they too can be cut off.ST Jun 26, 1884 After disobedient Jews were broken off, Gentiles were grafted in through Christ and became part of God's people, so the Sabbath sign applies to them as well as to the Jews.ST May 8, 1879 Those who keep the Sabbath acknowledge the true God, while God makes Himself known as Creator and the one who sanctifies His people.ST May 8, 1879
A wild-olive branch grafted into a tame olive tree bears the fruit of the tree into which it is grafted.RH Mar 12, 1872 Gentiles who are truly converted therefore have God's law written in their hearts and carry it out in their lives, bearing the fruit of Israel and no longer the bitter nature and bad fruit of the wild tree.RH Mar 12, 1872
Character and Present Application
God's goodness and severity belong together as the whole gospel, and to preach goodness alone is to preach only half the gospel, as if dividing the living child in two.ST Jul 1, 1875 His goodness pardons on condition of repentance, and this is not inconsistent with His severity toward those found at last in their sins, for faith that does not produce good works is dead.ST Jul 1, 1875 On them which fell, ancient Israel broken off because of unbelief and disobedience, falls severity, while toward those grafted in as a wild olive tree, sharing the root and fatness and the privileges once given to ancient Israel, extends goodness.
Both dealings are just and serve the highest good of His people, and even chastening is an expression of His love and care.RH Feb 18, 1915 He is never unjust but remains long-suffering and tenderly merciful, and sin brings judgment while mercy preserves those who are obedient.ST Jul 29, 1889ST Jun 25, 1885 He may grant a desire that is not for a person's best good, then use what was granted to humble that person and reveal faults, as when the people received Saul as the king they wanted so that the experience could teach them through its consequences.ST Jul 29, 1889 Solomon's sins brought evil upon his house, but for David's sake judgment was delayed and Rehoboam was left one tribe, for God visits the iniquity of those who hate Him through generations yet shows mercy to those who love Him and keep His commandments.ST Jun 25, 1885
At the cross mercy and forgiveness are joined with unwavering justice, for severity is felt when people are separated from Him while goodness is found when they repent and are reconciled to Him through Christ.ST Nov 30, 1882 The contrast between severity and goodness points to the sacrificial death of Jesus, where law and grace receive their clearest expression and both the terror of sin's consequences and the mercy that saves sinners are made plain.RH Mar 17, 1863 Sin brings punishment, while goodness is reason to take warning and avoid transgression. David's loss of four sons was a just fourfold payment for his sin, illustrating the severity of judgment, and the warning applies to anyone tempted to excuse a sin because it seems well-circumstanced.
The warning falls upon converts from the Gentile world, that they must continue in His goodness or they also will be cut off.ST Jan 2, 1879 It applies to the Protestant churches as Gentile converts, whose loss of influence upon the world and upon their own membership, with light becoming darkness and salt losing its savor, is the cutting off warned of, yet the warning falls unheeded on their ears.ST Jan 2, 1879 The Jews were tenacious of the commandments of God but rejected Christ and therefore fell and were broken off, while the churches profess faith in Christ but make the commandments of God of none effect by tradition, declaring the law changed, relaxed, or abolished.RH Sep 5, 1854 In boasting against the branches broken off and refusing to admit they also could be cut off, they are unmindful of the warning, and the severity that fell on them which fell will fall on them.RH Sep 5, 1854
The same severity threatens Sabbath-keepers now if they hold doubts and unbelief about the last work of God under the third message of Revelation 14 and the responsible position His people occupy.RH Apr 11, 1871 The children of Israel fell in the wilderness because of unbelief, and afterward the Jewish people were rejected and broken off because of unbelief that the Gentiles might be grafted in.RH Apr 11, 1871 Unbelief shuts out blessing and hinders mighty works, and such unbelief must prove fatal unless put away speedily by earnest work and seeking from God the help needed for strong faith, to obtain complete victory over the world, the flesh, Satan, and unbelief, and to stand entire at last.RH Apr 11, 1871
The grafting lesson teaches conversion as separation from the carnal nature and union with what is divine, not mere outward reform.ST Dec 11, 1893ST Jul 22, 1880 Like a wild branch grafted into a cultivated tree, the believer draws life from Christ and bears fruit according to Christ's nature rather than the old nature, and a person can be righteous only as Christ works through them.ST Dec 11, 1893 Outward reform cannot make bad fruit good, but regeneration changes the person at the root from the old Adam nature to a new nature given by Christ.ST Jul 22, 1880 Every person outside the Lord Jesus Christ is wild and untamed like the wild animals of the forest, and becoming tame is having the evil heart changed, forsaking evil propensities, and taking on the meekness and gentleness of the Lord Jesus through the grace that is in Him.RH May 29, 1913 Sinners lack what they need to bear good fruit and require radical change, and recognizing this need should lead to applying what is known of Christ with tenderness and concern, not judgment or criticism, and to seeking the sinner's restoration.RH Jul 31, 1900
God's goodness can bring a life weighed down by inherited evil to bear fruit for His glory when that life is surrendered to Him, like a fruitful graft set onto a wild tree.RH Dec 19, 1912ST Jun 1, 1904 Although inherited evil has deeply marked even a child's life, God can graft that life into the tree so that through surrender to Him it bears fruit for His glory forever.ST Jun 1, 1904 Those united to Christ by faith receive life from Him and must abide in Him to bear fruit, being pruned to become more fruitful.ST Sep 14, 1882 The fruitless Jewish nation was separated from Christ, while Gentiles were grafted in as living branches to share the life of the true Vine, showing that belonging and fruitfulness depend on connection to Christ.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Jan 24, 1878
Life and fruitfulness come from being joined to the living tree, not from branches binding themselves together.ST Apr 15, 1903 Branches nearly destitute of life receive life from the tree, grow, and bear fruit to His glory, while humanly fastening branches together cannot give them life or lasting fruitfulness.ST Apr 15, 1903 The image is reflected when some members are disfellowshiped as branches trimmed off while others are added as precious scions grafted in, with those turned away urged to return and the church called to labor so those gathered in will bear fruit.ST Feb 1, 1883 As part of the Gentile church grafted onto the good olive tree and distinguished from literal Israel, Gentile believers may claim the promise to Israel that weapons formed against Christ's church will not prosper, for God turns attacks aside, gives the church power to resist, or weakens those who strike it.RH May 24, 1864
God's goodness in grafting a new Israel into the old olive tree fell in severity on Jewish unbelief and malice, which could not turn aside His purpose, while goodness reached the Gentiles who were grafted in.ST Apr 23, 1885 Christ had prepared for this during His life by seeking to lead the Jews out of exclusiveness through direct work outside acknowledged Israel, as in the conversion of the centurion and of the Syrophoenician woman.ST Apr 23, 1885 The time then came for active and continued work among the Gentiles, of whom whole communities received the gospel gladly and glorified God for the light of an intelligent faith, so that when synagogues were closed against the apostles private houses were thrown open and public buildings of the Gentiles were also used to preach the word.ST Apr 23, 1885
Continued goodness by faith and perfect obedience to His commandments gives right to the privileges of the church in every age, secures election to salvation, and proves love to God. Boasting and high-mindedness are forbidden and fear is required, for he that covers his sins shall not prosper but whoso confesses and forsakes them shall have mercy, and happy is the man that fears always while he that hardens his heart shall fall into mischief. Otherwise those now standing by faith will also be cut off. In Christ the place of belonging is where people find a penitent heart and return to wholehearted love for God and equal love for neighbor, for the root supports the grafted branches and not the reverse.ST Oct 7, 1897
Israel's branches were broken off in unbelief because Israel looked to its own righteousness and failed to reach the righteousness of God, while Gentile branches were grafted in to partake of the virtues of the stock of Israel and thus themselves become Israel.ST Aug 4, 1909 All who look past their own righteousness to Christ find His righteousness covering sin and meeting all need.ST Aug 4, 1909 Mercy is joined to Jews and Gentiles in a way that did not bring the Jews the honor they would have had if they had received the gospel, as faithful people from many nations are joined to Him through the gospel.ST Apr 19, 1883 Gentiles share goodness by being grafted into the blessings entrusted to Israel, not because they bring any merit of their own, and must remain in goodness since they too can be cut off through unbelief, while Jewish unbelief and rejection of Christ are deplored without diminishing the truths and blessings received through them, and Jews may also share in the covenant's blessings.RH Jun 27, 1871
The image of withered boughs broken off and set on fire expresses severity toward those who fall away, and it is linked with the gathering of Israel at the Lord's coming, when the dead are raised and God's people are gathered to Him.ST Feb 22, 1883 Paul's illustration of grafting also shows that the word of God, like a seed grafted into the heart, changes the receiver: the heart takes on the nature of the word, and the person becomes new, a partaker of the divine nature.ST Sep 16, 1886 Israel's branches were broken off when they failed to continue bearing good fruit, making room for other branches to take their place.ST Sep 16, 1886
Further points
Goodness and severity are measured by continued bearing of good fruit.ST Jan 18, 1916 The branches of Israel were broken off because they failed to keep on bringing forth good fruit.ST Jan 18, 1916 By their removal room was made for other branches to take their place.ST Jan 18, 1916
Sources