The law exposes bondage in order to bring deliverance through Jesus Christ the Deliverer, by justification through faith, forgiveness by His blood, and freedom by the law of the Spirit of life from the law of sin and death.RH Nov 1, 1864ST Sep 23, 1908RH Mar 19, 1867 The new covenant writes the law in the heart so that obedience becomes nature and its righteousness is fulfilled in those who walk after the Spirit, as the Christian experience continues in Romans 8.ST Sep 23, 1908RH Mar 19, 1867RH Mar 12, 1872 The inward delight in God's law yet failure to perform good, with sin dwelling in the flesh warring against the mind and bringing into captivity, is not the final victory, for Christ who conquered Satan and overcame temptation in sinful flesh strengthens the believer to sure victory, to freedom from condemnation and fullness of joy.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867RH Sep 18, 1900ST Mar 23, 1904 The cry for deliverance from the body of death is answered only through Him, who breaks sin's power and makes possible self-government in God rather than settling for remaining in bondage.RH Sep 18, 1900ST Mar 23, 1904RH Mar 12, 1872
The carnal mind is enmity against God, not subject to the law and unable to be, in lasting opposition to its righteousness until renewed by divine grace.ST Sep 14, 1882RH Jul 21, 1868ST Mar 18, 1875 Keeping the spiritual law requires more than outward deeds, even more than partial keeping of its letter such as outward rest, since it reaches thoughts, intentions, emotions, secret purposes, exposing hatred as murder and unholy desire as adultery, and only obedience of the heart meets its requirements.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Mar 10, 1887ST Dec 30, 1889ST Mar 18, 1875 The Holy Spirit alone gives the willing heart, with love poured into the heart through faith in Jesus Christ, so the law is fulfilled not through fear or compulsion but through love.ST Mar 10, 1887ST Dec 24, 1885 Those born of the Spirit, with God's Spirit dwelling in them, become spiritual and in harmony with the Ten Commandments, and keeping them is possible only in Christ, while to be carnally minded is death.ST Dec 24, 1885ST Dec 30, 1889ST Mar 18, 1875
Those who transgress are held accountable and condemned, for the holy, just and good law is not made void, but a person dead to sin through faith is freed from its bondage, penalty and condemnation, not from the law itself or from obligation to obey it.RH Jul 21, 1868RH Jun 9, 1853 One in Christ, forgiven and walking by faith through the Spirit, is brought into harmony with the law and does not violate it, so the law does not condemn that person.ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868 If that person returns to carnal living or continues in transgression, the law condemns again, for those who have not died to sin have not undergone the change represented by death to sin, and to one remaining in sin the law is a yoke of bondage binding in sin and death.RH Jul 21, 1868ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jun 9, 1853ST
The first husband in the illustration is not the law but the old sinful self, which must die so the person can belong to Christ and be free from serving sin, not from obeying God's law.RH Mar 8, 1864RH Jan 31, 1854 Freedom comes not because the law dies but because the sinner becomes dead to sin by the body of Christ and is married to the risen Christ to bring forth fruit unto God under favor without transgressing the law.RH Jan 31, 1854RH Mar 5, 1857 The law remains in force as the instrument that exposes sin and brings the old carnal self to death, making way for new life in obedience in spirit to the same law of love.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 13, 1862
The letter still kills in the present tense by exposing transgressors and making sin appear exceeding sinful, since the commandment ordained to life is found unto death because sin takes occasion by it to deceive, slay and work all manner of lust.RH Oct 25, 1853RH Jun 14, 1870 The New Testament does not abolish the letter but ministers the same law by the Spirit, writing it in minds and hearts to enable perfect and acceptable obedience through Jesus Christ, in contrast to the former ministration when written on stone without that spiritual support it was continually transgressed.RH Oct 25, 1853ST Jan 14, 1897RH Oct 21, 1851 Those delivered from the law serve in newness of spirit and so keep it in reality, and if the law no longer condemned there would be no sin, no death, and no need for pardon and righteousness through the gospel.RH Jun 14, 1870ST Jan 14, 1897RH Oct 21, 1851
Human nature in itself is unable by its own power to obey the spiritual law or produce righteousness, having lost the power to keep the commandments, with requirements too vast for finite people to comprehend fully.ST Feb 11, 1903ST May 12, 1914ST Feb 3, 1909 Righteousness comes from Christ, whose obedience covers past failures while Christ dwelling in the believer does the good works of the present life, cleansing from sin and imputing His perfect past obedience while imparting His life.ST Feb 11, 1903ST May 12, 1914ST Jan 16, 1907 The gospel forgives past failures in duty and makes it possible to do that duty now, for when a person receives Christ, the living personification of the law, He works righteousness within and produces obedience.ST May 12, 1914ST Feb 3, 1909ST Jan 16, 1907
The new covenant answers the carnal condition by forgiving those who have broken the law and writing that spiritual, holy, perfect and just law, so good no better law can be made, in their hearts to insure future obedience and make obedience their nature.RH Mar 25, 1873ST Apr 12, 1899ST Feb 27, 1879 The new birth by the Spirit is necessary to leave the flesh, for a person remaining in the flesh cannot be subject to the law or please God, but by accepting Christ by faith becomes a partaker of the divine nature and a new creature in Christ serving in newness of spirit.ST Oct 7, 1886ST Oct 15, 1894RH Jul 21, 1868 Sin is natural to fallen humanity because people yielded to Satan and thereby perverted their nature, not part of the nature God originally made, and pardon through Christ's blood provides remission of sins that are past, conditioned on future obedience, not indulgence for future sins.RH Mar 25, 1873ST Apr 12, 1899ST Oct 15, 1894
Christ was made what carnal humanity sold under sin is in order to redeem it, taking on what people are so that they might become what He is, sharing the same human flesh and blood as near kinsman with right to redeem.RH Jan 8, 1901ST May 14, 1896RH Jan 15, 1901 Though joined to a human body containing sin and tendencies to evil, with enmity in the flesh brought by Adam's sin, He kept His mind spiritual and served God's law without sin, living a perfectly righteous life and abolishing the enmity in His flesh.RH Jan 29, 1901ST May 14, 1896 That obedience that saves is Christ's present obedience lived in the believer by union through being crucified with Him, for the self so identified with sin as its very life must die, the body of sin destroyed and left dead, and in resurrection the believer lives righteous to serve sin no more; conversion thus reverses the rule so the man empowered by God and under the Spirit rules over the flesh and keeps the body under while still fighting the good fight of faith.ST Apr 16, 1896RH Sep 18, 1900
Christ's death vindicates the law's righteous claim to the transgressor's life and its sentence of death, making pardon consistent with justice.ST Aug 26, 1875RH Nov 17, 1874 He changes the sinner by removing rebellion and enmity against God and His government and restoring obedience to the Father's holy law, rather than abolishing the spiritual law or releasing rebels from obligation, for to teach abolition degrades God's government and makes Christ a minister of sin instead of righteousness.ST Aug 26, 1875RH Nov 17, 1874 Possessing the Spirit in fullness He kept the law perfectly, magnifies it and makes it honorable, restoring it to its proper place as glorious law based on God's love and fulfilled through love, with Spirit and law inseparable as the throne of the Eternal.ST Nov 17, 1898RH Nov 17, 1874ST Jan 13, 1881
To be under sin is to serve sin as its slave and to be a breaker of the law, condemned and unable to rescue self, needing Christ to bear the guilt and redeem from sin and sinning.ST May 30, 1895ST Jan 13, 1887ST Jan 21, 1903 This bondage from which Christ sets people free is broken only through death to sin, which means repentance, abhorring evil, and crucifying the flesh with its passions and desires.ST Feb 3, 1914RH Jan 16, 1908ST Jan 4, 1916 When the gospel changes the heart the former slave is freed to become a servant of righteousness marked by obedience, for without that change people remain in bondage unable to free themselves by their own power.ST Jan 13, 1887ST Feb 3, 1914ST Jan 4, 1916
Experience the Verse Describes
The condition spoken of is that of a person awakened and convicted by the Spirit on the way to conversion, not the settled life of one made free in Christ.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908RH Jan 26, 1860ST Sep 17, 1896 The law is spiritual, reaching to hidden purposes, thoughts, dispositions, desires and intents of the heart, while the one convicted is carnal, fleshly, enslaved and helpless in himself to overcome sin or to carry out the good he wills.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908ST Sep 17, 1896RH Apr 14, 1863 Though the mind, conscience and will assent that the law is good and holy and desire to do right, sin dwelling within rules and brings into captivity, so he does the evil he hates, fails to perform the good he intends, remains subject to death, and repeatedly fails feeling doomed.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908RH Jan 26, 1860RH Apr 14, 1863 This is the first step toward conversion through which every adult passes to a greater or less extent, the experience of Romans 7:15-25 leading from bondage toward service, in contrast to the converted life of Romans 8.ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908ST Sep 17, 1896 The law thus exposes sin, shuts up the transgressor as justly condemned, and reveals utter helplessness in order to lead away from self to Christ the Deliverer, through whom justification by faith and freedom named in Romans 7:25 are found.ST Sep 23, 1908RH Jan 26, 1860ST Sep 17, 1896RH Apr 14, 1863
On another view, the verse opens the delineation of Christian experience as war in Romans 7 and 8, with lust together with the world, the flesh and the devil on one side and the soul aided by Christ, the Holy Spirit and good angels on the other.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867 The inward man delights in God's law and serves it with the mind, yet the flesh wars against the law of the mind and the Spirit, brings into captivity to the law of sin, and leaves the one in Romans 7 unable to meet the spiritual requirements and longing for deliverance from the body of death.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867 That stern and furious wrestling beats down the baser self, giving no quarter to lusts, strangling appetites and vanquishing inner foes, so that strength is gained to vanquish foes without.RH Mar 19, 1867RH Nov 5, 1861 Victory is sure to the true and faithful through Jesus Christ, who conquered Satan and overcame temptation in sinful flesh, and those who move into Romans 8 walk not after the flesh but after the Spirit, free from condemnation and from the law of sin and death, with the righteousness of the law fulfilled in them in freedom and fullness of joy.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867 Grace works upon the natural fleshly life to produce a new supernatural life distinct from the old, and this struggle with a partly forsaken carnal nature and partly crucified self is not to be settled for as final, since believers may press on into the liberty and assurance of Romans 8.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Apr 16, 1861ST Apr 10, 1907
Speaking as carnal while delighting in the law of God is true present reality, not a figure putting oneself back under a past abolished code, proving the moral law then present, holy, just and good.RH Feb 14, 1854 The law so called spiritual is the same moral law whose transgression introduced sin into the world, the Ten Commandments existing as law before Sinai, remaining exceeding broad and covering all moral duty, with penalties such as fourfold restitution arising from disobedience to it.RH Feb 14, 1854
On another differing view, the verse describes an actual experience laid in Judaism when the law was in full force, namely the first sin when the commandment came to the understanding at the years of responsibility, not conversion and not the constant habit of a Christian.RH Mar 25, 1873 Spiritual there means not sinful, standing opposite to carnal only when carnal means sold under sin, and is affirmable even of ceremonial precepts since no sinful ordinance was ever enjoined, while carnal in the sense of fleshly ordinance is also predicable of that same entire law given through Moses, the same as in Romans 6:14 and called flesh in verse 5, showing it was chiefly a political institution.RH Mar 25, 1873 The present tense is used as a vivid historical present for liveliness, so no comfort for continued sinning can be drawn from it.RH Mar 25, 1873
The verse belongs to one still struggling with a partly forsaken carnal nature and partly crucified self under sin, willing what is good but unable to perform it and doing what is hated while serving God's law with the mind yet pulled by the flesh into serving the law of sin.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Apr 16, 1861 That condition of walking in the flesh with the carnal mind, fleshly and enslaved and held in bondage to the law of sin in the members, is the struggle to overcome self and is not the final Christian experience.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Apr 16, 1861 The Christian need not remain continually doing what he disapproves but may gain victory, since deliverance comes through Jesus Christ who frees from the carnal mind so that with the whole being a person can serve the law of God and walk after the Spirit free from sin, and the law of the Spirit of life in Christ makes free from the law of sin and death.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Sep 10, 1872 To treat that condition as lasting until the resurrection would leave no room for the inner person to be renewed during this life, since regeneration is needed from it now.RH Feb 15, 1870
The carnal sold condition describes people by nature and also believers who rely on themselves rather than on Christ.ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jul 13, 1882 It is the daily experience of a person whose sins are forgiven but whose carnal nature remains, which cannot be purified or improved and continues to produce sin, so the cry for deliverance is a cry to be freed from the old self and sinful nature from which sinful acts spring.ST Apr 15, 1903ST Feb 11, 1889 To live there is to profess without love, taking the yoke of the law upon a stiff neck instead of Christ's yoke, so religion is bondage with broken resolutions, grievous commandments, a heavy unendurable yoke, and the cry of wretchedness instead of pleasantness and peace and righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Ghost.RH Mar 26, 1861 It is the failing experience of one whose faith has not advanced beyond defeat, for whom overcoming the world by faith remains a mystery, in contrast to the life hid with Christ that is radiant with the Spirit and claims victory by faith before the battle begins because the enemy is already conquered. Carnality was in the nature, for the flesh contained no good thing, yet calling oneself carnal can describe nature and not present opposition, since one may delight in God's law and no longer oppose His will, the carnal mind being destroyed when brought into harmony with and submission to His will.ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jul 13, 1882
Human flesh never becomes converted and never stops opposing the Spirit but remains the same perverse sinful flesh after conversion as before, in sinner and converted alike until bodies are changed at the Lord's coming.ST Apr 30, 1896ST May 14, 1896 The law is spiritual, so the things of the Spirit are the commandments of God, while the flesh stands opposed to that spiritual law and serves the law of sin.ST Apr 30, 1896ST May 14, 1896 The unconverted yield to the flesh and so are servants of sin and are not led by the Spirit even though the Spirit still strives with them, while the converted keep exactly the same flesh but yield to the Spirit so the flesh has no power and is controlled and its deeds are put to death, and for that reason are counted as not in the flesh but in the Spirit.ST May 14, 1896 Deliverance comes not by a change in the flesh but by the indwelling Spirit of Christ giving power over it, as proved by coming in the same sinful flesh yet remaining without sin by being always led by the Spirit.ST Apr 30, 1896ST May 14, 1896
The chapter records inward conflict between sin and holiness through which the fight is fought, the course finished and the faith kept unto the victor's crown.RH May 14, 1867 Sinfulness is recognized in the glory of Christ as on the Damascus road, where the light exposing unworthiness also brings cleansing, strength and help rather than discouragement. A terrible uprising of the old Adam may be felt within, and the tearful account written out of that conviction proves genuine Christians need conviction of sin as much as impenitent sinners, the keen north wind of the Spirit bringing professing Christians to repentance and tears and the cutting off of cherished sins so latent graces such as penitence flow out.RH Mar 21, 1871 The passage belongs with Matthew 5-7, Romans 6, 8, 12, Galatians 5-6, Ephesians 4-6, James 2-3, 1 Peter 1-2, 2 Peter 1, 3, and 1 John 1-3, 5, to be studied as a whole and in all its parts, since holiness is the design of all dispensations of grace and providence toward men.RH Nov 24, 1859
Sabbath and True Worship
The law that contains the Sabbath command in its bosom is spiritual, and because it is spiritual, holy, just and good the Sabbath is to be observed.ST May 10, 1905ST Oct 4, 1905ST Aug 13, 1885ST Mar 5, 1894ST Oct 19, 1915 Serving and keeping the whole law includes the seventh-day Sabbath, which with the other nine precepts is moral, universal and unlimited in obligation.ST May 10, 1905ST Oct 4, 1905ST Oct 19, 1915 That Sabbath command belongs to the holy, just and good law affirmed after the cross, and is entirely different from Jewish ordinances abolished by Christ's death, not a human tradition.ST Mar 5, 1894ST Oct 19, 1915 Keeping the Sabbath by faith means obeying God's Word and observing the seventh day it identifies, as proved by delight in that inward law and by teaching that keeping the commandments of God is what matters.ST Oct 4, 1905
The Sabbath as part of that spiritual law is a spiritual institution, and its rest, blessing and sanctification are spiritual and given as part of God's holy purpose.ST Nov 10, 1898ST Feb 20, 1896RH Jan 12, 1905 Only one who is spiritual and born of God by grace has power to keep holy what God has made holy, for keeping a holy day holy is a matter of power, not of right.ST Feb 20, 1901ST Feb 20, 1896 It memorializes God's spiritual rest, has the seventh day at its heart with all scriptural evidence for Sabbath sacredness applying to the seventh day alone and none for Sunday, and is a sign of Creator and Redeemer.ST Nov 10, 1898ST Feb 20, 1896RH Jan 12, 1905 That spiritual law is perfect, extends to all inward thoughts and outward actions, and can never be changed or annulled, so the command to keep the seventh-day Sabbath holy shares its spiritual, perfect, unchangeable character.ST Nov 10, 1898ST Aug 15, 1916 Its nature and demands belong to the religious realm, which the State has no proper jurisdiction to regulate.ST Mar 18, 1903
Sabbath rest is more than stopping physical work: it is spiritual rest in Christ's presence and rest from sin, received by faith.ST Feb 8, 1899STST Nov 15, 1899ST Feb 7, 1906 Faith sees the Sabbath as a sign of the living Creator and Redeemer and receives the blessing God has placed in it, making the Sabbath a delight.STST Feb 7, 1906 The fourth commandment reaches beyond outward actions and words to the thoughts and desires of the heart, calling people to delight in its holy service, and keeping the Sabbath according to the commandment therefore requires holiness and a spiritual condition.RH Jun 18, 1861ST Oct 3, 1900 A person cannot keep holy what God made holy unless first made holy by grace, for divine grace must free and sanctify the person before that person can keep it, and such observance cannot be made holy by human effort or enforced by human law.ST Feb 8, 1899ST Nov 15, 1899 Sin begins in the heart before outward acts, with hatred before murder, cherished lust before adultery, and inward disregard before Sabbath desecration, and the law exposes and governs these inward matters while civil law cannot control the heart or produce genuine observance.ST Feb 8, 1899
The carnal heart cannot understand spiritual things or enter God's rest, and because the heart has not been renewed people cannot see the Sabbath as a gift made for good or keep it in its spiritual sense.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Apr 29, 1903 The carnal condition puts man out of harmony with the law and makes true Sabbath-keeping impossible until conversion makes him spiritual again, at peace with God and partaker of the divine nature.ST Apr 29, 1903 God's law is spiritual because God is spirit and all His works and institutions share His character, and there was no secular time when He made creation and the week, since secular things came only because of sin and there was no sin when He founded the Sabbath. The Sabbath that makes the week and orders all its other days is therefore spiritual and not a movable secular segment of time, and the spiritual nature of the Christian dispensation and the Spirit's work does not cancel or change the seventh-day Sabbath.ST Dec 11, 1901 Because the law is spiritual no man and no civil government can administer, execute or enforce it, for human power cannot enforce faith, and the most any person can do, only by the help of the Spirit through faith in Christ, is to obey it himself.ST Apr 29, 1903
Obedience to the spiritual law is spiritual worship, not carnality or opposition to grace, and its spiritual character confirms its high moral standard and rules out the claim that keeping it dishonors Christ or the gospel.RH May 27, 1852ST Jul 8, 1880 Loving obedience prompted by love is spiritual service and the only true worship, not Pharisaical heartless outward observance in the letter.ST Mar 11, 1886ST Jun 12, 1884ST Apr 2, 1896 Keeping God's commandments together with faith in Jesus is the basis of spiritual worship and true Christian unity, while apostasy from that basis leads to confused, formal worship without spiritual power.ST To disobey willfully denies the Lord the honor and fear due to Him as Father and Master, and professed worship joined with willful disobedience is will-worship and mockery.ST Mar 11, 1886ST Jun 12, 1884ST Apr 2, 1896
Only obedience of the heart meets the law's entirely spiritual requirements, for outward conformity alone is not obedience since the law reaches thoughts and emotions, while true inward obedience also includes outward conformity.ST Dec 30, 1889ST Oct 17, 1906ST Jan 21, 1886 Its spirit does not contradict its letter and cannot be kept while its letter is broken, though keeping the letter without love fails to fulfill its righteousness.ST Jun 9, 1881ST Aug 26, 1875ST Jan 21, 1886 Formality without the spirit of love and obedience never did and never can fulfill the righteousness of the law, and respectable conduct or good citizenship is not obedience when the heart is impure.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Sep 18, 1893 The law reaches beyond outward acts to secret thoughts, purposes and motives and requires love to God and to others, so lust breaks the command against adultery and cherished envy, hatred and enmity break the command against murder even with no outward act, and civil laws can restrain outward acts but cannot enforce this spiritual obedience.ST Jun 9, 1881ST Dec 30, 1889ST Jan 21, 1886 Conscientious obedience to the Sabbath requires the Spirit of God working upon the heart, unlike outward compliance with a human ordinance which can satisfy legal demands without inward obedience.ST Oct 17, 1906
Because the law is spiritual, holy, just and good, obedience to it forms a character that is holy, true, just, good and pleasing to God.RH Jan 15, 1861RH Jun 24, 1852RH Dec 23, 1851 The law spoken of is the Ten Commandments, which remained holy, and calling that law a yoke of bondage comes from the carnal mind, never from the church, for the carnal sin-sold condition is in man while delight in the law of God belongs to the inward man.RH Jan 15, 1861RH Jun 24, 1852RH Dec 23, 1851 God's people consent it is holy, just, good and spiritual and honor it by loving, obeying, delighting in it from the inward heart and teaching it, proving faith does not void it.RH Jun 24, 1875RH Mar 1851 Seeing purity in the law and sinfulness in self rather than blaming the law leads to upholding it as the revelation of God's will, and those who love God find His commandments joyous, not grievous.RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jun 24, 1875
The law including its preface is spiritual, and its reference to Egypt and bondage also has a spiritual meaning.RH Jan 29, 1901 Egypt represents the realm of sin in its lowest depths and blackest darkness, and bondage represents enslavement to sin.RH Jan 29, 1901ST Jul 2, 1902 The opening words declare God as the Deliverer who brings people out of sin's realm by faith in Christ's blood so they may keep His commandments, and deliverance from sin must come before commandment-keeping.RH Jan 29, 1901ST Jul 2, 1902 Those redeemed from sin are brought out of spiritual Egypt, out of the house of bondage, just as literal Israel was brought out of literal Egypt, and are under added, special obligation to keep the spiritual law including His Sabbath blessed and sanctified in the beginning, which is a memorial of God's rest that was spiritual rest because God is a Spirit.ST Jul 2, 1902
State and Daily Life
Because the law is spiritual it can be fulfilled only through the Spirit God supplies, and it can be kept only by those who have the Spirit of Christ, so that without His Spirit no one can keep it and no one belongs to Him.ST Jan 7, 1897ST Aug 27, 1896ST Feb 20, 1907 Its meaning cannot be limited or altered by human judgment, since people cannot fathom the full depth of God's will or measure their own sin and righteousness, and the Spirit must work in each person because human authorities cannot impose the Spirit or define its mind.ST Jan 7, 1897 Therefore the cause and institutions of Christ cannot be promoted or preserved by carnal weapons, but only by God's spiritual armor of faith, truth, righteousness, salvation, peace and the word of God wielded by the Spirit.ST Aug 27, 1896 Its moral power cannot be taught mechanically or received by intellectual instruction alone, but must be received by faith in Christ Jesus, and anyone who would obey must be born again, receiving a new mind and life and becoming a new creature as Jesus born of the Spirit lived out the law in human life.ST Apr 5, 1905 Only spiritual people can keep it acceptably, for it has God's own life in it and remains alive even when people rebel against it, while civil laws cannot make anyone keep it or bind the conscience.ST Feb 20, 1907
Because the law is spiritual in every part, expressing God's character and love and reaching beyond outward acts to the mind, heart, motives, conscience and inner springs of action and character, civil government which can judge only outward conduct cannot enforce it in its spiritual sense.ST Apr 1, 1897ST Oct 16, 1893ST Jun 26, 1893 A person does not truly obey unless obedience comes from the heart, and civil government can regulate outward conduct but cannot produce the love or inward loyalty that obedience requires.ST Jun 26, 1893 Observing it requires the Spirit of Christ, and civil force can impose outward forms but cannot produce obedience to a spiritual law.ST Jan 30, 1907 Because the Sabbath precept is part of that law the Sabbath is spiritual too, so civil laws and coercion can enforce only outward observance, not true Sabbath keeping, and can compel hypocrisy.ST Feb 17, 1909 Carnal people and means cannot enforce God's law, since people who are carnal are under sin, and God seeks willing obedience by persuasion among converted people, while enforcing spiritual duties would put the state in God's place and produce only deluded hypocrites.ST Feb 6, 1896
No part of the spiritual law is within the power of human legislation, as Thou shalt not covet proves because no human power can enforce it or tell if it is violated, and that commandment is no more spiritual than the other nine.ST Aug 13, 1896 God's law pertains not to outward deed alone but to spirit, thought, motive and intent, so it can be broken in thought and motive alone, hatred is murder and cherished lust is adultery, and coveting violates God's law though civil law cannot reach or prohibit it.ST Aug 6, 1896 Sin as transgression of God's law is therefore distinct from crime as transgression of civil law regulating only the outward act.ST Aug 6, 1896 Civil laws protecting life and property may have the same wording as God's commands, but they are distinct from God's law and are necessary whether or not people know the Decalogue.ST Sep 24, 1894 Human law may restrain injury and fraud but cannot reform the heart or bring people nearer to Christ, and treating compliance with human law as obedience to God's law can produce self-righteousness and hypocrisy, while obedience offered in addition to faith in Christ as a way to become righteous comes from self-righteousness rather than Christ and cannot add to His righteousness.ST Feb 8, 1899ST Dec 5, 1892
True Christianity does not compel obedience from without but results in keeping of the commandments in the life of everyone who has it, because the spiritual law must be implanted in the heart by grace and wrought out by faith which works by love.ST Jun 16, 1898 Its consistent observance is spiritual and cannot be compelled by civil law, for a person obeys it from the heart where God's law is written.ST Oct 18, 1899 The commandments are holy, just, good and spiritual, and the righteous enshrine them in their heart's best love, and loving them leads to keeping them.RH Apr 26, 1870 They are not a yoke of bondage and are not grievous, and keeping them is the condition of entering into life and entering in through the gates into the city, a plain and easy way leading to glory, vindication, heavenly honor and unending glory despite worldly humiliation and reproach, while those who reject them for seeming present good will meet the fate of the disobedient.RH Apr 26, 1870 God's Word and law belong to the spiritual order, and the church is Christ's spiritual body filled, guided and controlled by His Spirit, and the Ten Commandments implanted in the heart guide His children to all eternity.ST May 31, 1899ST Sep 15, 1898 Because the law is wholly spiritual and alive, unlike human laws which have no life in themselves, keeping it requires spiritual service, and outward efforts made in a carnal state merely reproduce human nature rather than fulfill the law, since a carnal person is not subject to God's law and cannot be.ST Jan 14, 1897
Being under grace as distinct from being under law means being reborn, for a man is under grace because he is reborn and a man who condemns the law is not under grace.ST Jul 7, 1914 While a man under law antagonizes and hates the law and wants to break it, a man under grace loves the law and its Author, regards it as if he himself had made it, and finds his highest pleasure in honoring and obeying it and in leading others to do the same.ST Jul 7, 1914 Being under grace gives no license to break any part of the law but holds a man to stricter accounting and higher obligation, so that if a man under law ought to tithe much more a man under grace ought to tithe, and if a man under law must not commit adultery much more a man under grace must live a pure life.ST Jul 7, 1914 A person who knows the law spiritually will not question the Sabbath, for the Sabbath is not annulled by a person's natural opinion.
Only those who are carnally minded oppose God's law when they understand what it is, so enmity against the law proves the heart is carnal and not right before God, and any spirit that moves a person to defy, disobey or slight any part of God's law is not the Spirit of God.ST Aug 29, 1895 God's law is spiritual because God is a spiritual Being and His government and kingdom are spiritual, and it is a living law sharing the nature and life of God who gave it, with the Spirit of God permeating it so that law and Spirit are in perfect harmony, while spiritual is the opposite of carnal or fleshly and the carnal man is the opposite of the spiritual man.ST Aug 29, 1895 Conversion to Christ removes the carnal mind and its rebellion against God's law, and the renewed person delights in the law inwardly, which shows the verse does not make the law sinful or discredit it but contrasts the law's spiritual character with sinful human nature.ST Oct 18, 1883 Holiness means living in agreement with that law expressing God's character, and walking after the Spirit means inwardly loving God's law, and that inward love marks a condition acceptable to God, while self-asserted goodness is presumption not holiness.ST Feb 3, 1904 The natural person carnal and enslaved to sin is at odds with what comes from God and cannot submit to His rule or understand the Bible rightly, and natural selfish dispositions can lead people to resist the law's righteousness, so keeping the law rightly requires serving in newness of spirit where freedom from sin leads to willing obedience not freedom from the law.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Feb 17, 1904RH Jul 21, 1868
People become slaves under sin when they surrender self-control to perverted appetites or unholy ambition, and even good gifts and lawful pursuits can become masters when people let them rule instead of keeping themselves under God's control.ST Dec 8, 1887 Those bound to tobacco are examples of people ruled by sinful desires as carnal and enslaved to sin, slaves to their cravings not the pure joyful free people of the Lord.ST Sep 15, 1887 In the city this enslavement is seen in men whose minds are befogged by drink and who have lost virtue and love.ST Feb 7, 1906 A person whose heart remains corrupt is sold under sin, and learning and mental cultivation without moral correction can put knowledge and skill to harmful use.RH Aug 25, 1868 That description applies to those who mock efforts to reform and pursue holiness, in contrast with striving to live by Christ's example and obey His directions for bodily and spiritual purification.RH Mar 5, 1867 Humanity's surrender to Satan through appetite brought this enslavement, and a person cannot free himself by his own power, but only God's power can deliver people from that control and restore self-control.RH Feb 26, 1901
Pledging to keep the ideal Christian life for a time in human strength always fails, because the law is spiritual while unconverted human nature is carnal and sold under sin.ST Jan 27, 1909 This is seen when a business worker tries to be a consistent Christian yet is forced into deceit and lying for an employer and cannot hold both the job and the ideal.ST Jan 27, 1909 Excuses that divide business from religion, that an employee is only a machine writing what the employer dictates, and that the employer's conscience belongs to himself, do not change the carnal condition and do not make the life acceptable.ST Jan 27, 1909 At the judgment seat of Christ character alone will decide, measured not by fallen business standards or competition or for whom the work was done, but weighed in the balances of God's sanctuary.ST Jan 27, 1909 God's law reaches beyond outward actions to the inner life so that thoughts and intentions violating its spirit make a person guilty even when outward conduct appears correct, and therefore withholding tithes and offerings due to God is stealing from Him, while dishonoring parents is sin because it transgresses His law.ST Dec 12, 1895 The Sabbath law requires more than physical rest because God's law reaches the mind as well as the body, addressing thoughts, exposing desires and condemning affections, so keeping it in spirit and letter means not dwelling on secular subjects or planning worldly work.RH May 12, 1863 Human law can condemn an overt crime such as murder while lacking authority to judge hatred or murderous intent, but God's law condemns both because sin includes inward motives as well as deeds, and transgression of that holy just good law is sin whether or not human law treats the person as a criminal.ST Jan 20, 1898
Being sold under sin describes the lost condition accompanying the loss of mankind's dominion over the earth.ST Dec 23, 1889 The earth marred and cursed by sin will be reclaimed by Christ its Creator and Redeemer and restored to more than its original Eden beauty.ST Dec 23, 1889 In Eden man obeyed Satan instead of God and thereby placed himself under Satan's power, with all that man had going with him under Satan's dominion, and all humanity sold itself in sin and by choosing sin and death rather than righteousness and life forfeited even life itself.ST Jun 11, 1902ST Mar 31, 1898 Yet Christ has paid the redemption price to set free every son of Adam who desires that freedom, so man remains responsible for his sins and for his choice since the right and power of choice is his, and God made an eternal sacrifice through Jesus Christ to win man to eternal life.ST Jun 11, 1902ST Mar 31, 1898 Christ has redeemed people by His own blood, and Christ who is not in humanity's sinful condition gave His life as the price to redeem them, since they cannot pay the ransom for one another.RH Jul 22, 1915ST Jan 4, 1916 Those who persist in sin despite great light are left bound in sin without hope of escape.ST Feb 10, 1887
Those living in the flesh bound by sin are the living people to whom the Spirit preached in Noah's day, not conscious spirits preaching or receiving a message after death, so there is no probation after death. Their spirits are in prison because they are bound to the flesh, and Christ saves people from sin's bondage and the Spirit effects that deliverance.ST Feb 11, 1889 God's law is spiritual reflecting His holy character, and when that holiness and the law's spirituality are fully seen every self-deception is exposed and the heart stands uncovered.RH Sep 23, 1858 That exposure comes too late to correct one's mistake, for probation has closed, character is formed, and the life record is sealed for eternity.RH Sep 23, 1858
Recognizing both the law's spiritual nature and one's own carnality leaves hope for better days.ST Jan 30, 1912 Awakened as by Sinai's thunder to ingratitude, people like Israel of old try by impossible means of their own to obey that code and fail and lie disheartened and suppliant at His feet.ST Oct 12, 1904 God then shifts the view to Gethsemane and Calvary, where Christ the Creator bore shame and pain and death for rebels, and that love melts the cold sin-hardened heart until each command becomes a golden promise.ST Oct 12, 1904 Breaking that spiritual law grieves the Holy Spirit and puts the transgressor under condemnation and bondage, while repenting and living in obedience brings freedom from sin, the peace of God in the heart, and the witness of the Spirit that the person is no longer a servant but a son and an heir of God through Christ, which then overflows in praise and testimony.ST Apr 20, 1888 The gospel is entirely faith in just what God says, trusting the power of God manifested through His Word for salvation instead of trusting self, and received as the Word of God it effectually works holiness, justice, goodness and spirituality in those who accept it.ST Jun 16, 1898
Saul recognized that he was bound to sin and facing death, and saw his need for a power outside himself to save him, since sin holds a person in slavery and a person cannot deliver himself by his own power.ST Apr 20, 1915 In man, that is in his flesh, dwells no good thing, and they that are in the flesh cannot please God, which is the testimony of one who diligently sought for good within himself and came back broken and weary, proving that man since the fall has sought in himself the knowledge of good and finds it not.ST May 4, 1904 This condemns looking to self and listening to the voice within for light, and shows man must look to Christ instead.ST May 4, 1904 Fallen human beings are carnal and through Adam's disobedience sold under sin, and though people can understand the law's spiritual nature and recognize its power to expose sin, they cannot withstand Satan's power and deceptions without accepting Christ's atoning sacrifice. Perfect obedience to the law justifies, and such obedience is possible only through faith in Christ. Without knowledge of God people are hopeless with sin burned into bones, yet Christ who is not in that condition gave His life to set free every son of Adam who desires freedom.ST Jan 4, 1916ST Jun 11, 1902
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Deliverance in Christ
The law exposes bondage in order to bring deliverance through Jesus Christ the Deliverer, by justification through faith, forgiveness by His blood, and freedom by the law of the Spirit of life from the law of sin and death.RH Nov 1, 1864ST Sep 23, 1908RH Mar 19, 1867 The new covenant writes the law in the heart so that obedience becomes nature and its righteousness is fulfilled in those who walk after the Spirit, as the Christian experience continues in Romans 8.ST Sep 23, 1908RH Mar 19, 1867RH Mar 12, 1872 The inward delight in God's law yet failure to perform good, with sin dwelling in the flesh warring against the mind and bringing into captivity, is not the final victory, for Christ who conquered Satan and overcame temptation in sinful flesh strengthens the believer to sure victory, to freedom from condemnation and fullness of joy.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867RH Sep 18, 1900ST Mar 23, 1904 The cry for deliverance from the body of death is answered only through Him, who breaks sin's power and makes possible self-government in God rather than settling for remaining in bondage.RH Sep 18, 1900ST Mar 23, 1904RH Mar 12, 1872
The carnal mind is enmity against God, not subject to the law and unable to be, in lasting opposition to its righteousness until renewed by divine grace.ST Sep 14, 1882RH Jul 21, 1868ST Mar 18, 1875 Keeping the spiritual law requires more than outward deeds, even more than partial keeping of its letter such as outward rest, since it reaches thoughts, intentions, emotions, secret purposes, exposing hatred as murder and unholy desire as adultery, and only obedience of the heart meets its requirements.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Mar 10, 1887ST Dec 30, 1889ST Mar 18, 1875 The Holy Spirit alone gives the willing heart, with love poured into the heart through faith in Jesus Christ, so the law is fulfilled not through fear or compulsion but through love.ST Mar 10, 1887ST Dec 24, 1885 Those born of the Spirit, with God's Spirit dwelling in them, become spiritual and in harmony with the Ten Commandments, and keeping them is possible only in Christ, while to be carnally minded is death.ST Dec 24, 1885ST Dec 30, 1889ST Mar 18, 1875
Those who transgress are held accountable and condemned, for the holy, just and good law is not made void, but a person dead to sin through faith is freed from its bondage, penalty and condemnation, not from the law itself or from obligation to obey it.RH Jul 21, 1868RH Jun 9, 1853 One in Christ, forgiven and walking by faith through the Spirit, is brought into harmony with the law and does not violate it, so the law does not condemn that person.ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868 If that person returns to carnal living or continues in transgression, the law condemns again, for those who have not died to sin have not undergone the change represented by death to sin, and to one remaining in sin the law is a yoke of bondage binding in sin and death.RH Jul 21, 1868ST Jun 13, 1900RH Jun 9, 1853ST
The first husband in the illustration is not the law but the old sinful self, which must die so the person can belong to Christ and be free from serving sin, not from obeying God's law.RH Mar 8, 1864RH Jan 31, 1854 Freedom comes not because the law dies but because the sinner becomes dead to sin by the body of Christ and is married to the risen Christ to bring forth fruit unto God under favor without transgressing the law.RH Jan 31, 1854RH Mar 5, 1857 The law remains in force as the instrument that exposes sin and brings the old carnal self to death, making way for new life in obedience in spirit to the same law of love.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 13, 1862
The letter still kills in the present tense by exposing transgressors and making sin appear exceeding sinful, since the commandment ordained to life is found unto death because sin takes occasion by it to deceive, slay and work all manner of lust.RH Oct 25, 1853RH Jun 14, 1870 The New Testament does not abolish the letter but ministers the same law by the Spirit, writing it in minds and hearts to enable perfect and acceptable obedience through Jesus Christ, in contrast to the former ministration when written on stone without that spiritual support it was continually transgressed.RH Oct 25, 1853ST Jan 14, 1897RH Oct 21, 1851 Those delivered from the law serve in newness of spirit and so keep it in reality, and if the law no longer condemned there would be no sin, no death, and no need for pardon and righteousness through the gospel.RH Jun 14, 1870ST Jan 14, 1897RH Oct 21, 1851
Human nature in itself is unable by its own power to obey the spiritual law or produce righteousness, having lost the power to keep the commandments, with requirements too vast for finite people to comprehend fully.ST Feb 11, 1903ST May 12, 1914ST Feb 3, 1909 Righteousness comes from Christ, whose obedience covers past failures while Christ dwelling in the believer does the good works of the present life, cleansing from sin and imputing His perfect past obedience while imparting His life.ST Feb 11, 1903ST May 12, 1914ST Jan 16, 1907 The gospel forgives past failures in duty and makes it possible to do that duty now, for when a person receives Christ, the living personification of the law, He works righteousness within and produces obedience.ST May 12, 1914ST Feb 3, 1909ST Jan 16, 1907
The new covenant answers the carnal condition by forgiving those who have broken the law and writing that spiritual, holy, perfect and just law, so good no better law can be made, in their hearts to insure future obedience and make obedience their nature.RH Mar 25, 1873ST Apr 12, 1899ST Feb 27, 1879 The new birth by the Spirit is necessary to leave the flesh, for a person remaining in the flesh cannot be subject to the law or please God, but by accepting Christ by faith becomes a partaker of the divine nature and a new creature in Christ serving in newness of spirit.ST Oct 7, 1886ST Oct 15, 1894RH Jul 21, 1868 Sin is natural to fallen humanity because people yielded to Satan and thereby perverted their nature, not part of the nature God originally made, and pardon through Christ's blood provides remission of sins that are past, conditioned on future obedience, not indulgence for future sins.RH Mar 25, 1873ST Apr 12, 1899ST Oct 15, 1894
Christ was made what carnal humanity sold under sin is in order to redeem it, taking on what people are so that they might become what He is, sharing the same human flesh and blood as near kinsman with right to redeem.RH Jan 8, 1901ST May 14, 1896RH Jan 15, 1901 Though joined to a human body containing sin and tendencies to evil, with enmity in the flesh brought by Adam's sin, He kept His mind spiritual and served God's law without sin, living a perfectly righteous life and abolishing the enmity in His flesh.RH Jan 29, 1901ST May 14, 1896 That obedience that saves is Christ's present obedience lived in the believer by union through being crucified with Him, for the self so identified with sin as its very life must die, the body of sin destroyed and left dead, and in resurrection the believer lives righteous to serve sin no more; conversion thus reverses the rule so the man empowered by God and under the Spirit rules over the flesh and keeps the body under while still fighting the good fight of faith.ST Apr 16, 1896RH Sep 18, 1900
Christ's death vindicates the law's righteous claim to the transgressor's life and its sentence of death, making pardon consistent with justice.ST Aug 26, 1875RH Nov 17, 1874 He changes the sinner by removing rebellion and enmity against God and His government and restoring obedience to the Father's holy law, rather than abolishing the spiritual law or releasing rebels from obligation, for to teach abolition degrades God's government and makes Christ a minister of sin instead of righteousness.ST Aug 26, 1875RH Nov 17, 1874 Possessing the Spirit in fullness He kept the law perfectly, magnifies it and makes it honorable, restoring it to its proper place as glorious law based on God's love and fulfilled through love, with Spirit and law inseparable as the throne of the Eternal.ST Nov 17, 1898RH Nov 17, 1874ST Jan 13, 1881
To be under sin is to serve sin as its slave and to be a breaker of the law, condemned and unable to rescue self, needing Christ to bear the guilt and redeem from sin and sinning.ST May 30, 1895ST Jan 13, 1887ST Jan 21, 1903 This bondage from which Christ sets people free is broken only through death to sin, which means repentance, abhorring evil, and crucifying the flesh with its passions and desires.ST Feb 3, 1914RH Jan 16, 1908ST Jan 4, 1916 When the gospel changes the heart the former slave is freed to become a servant of righteousness marked by obedience, for without that change people remain in bondage unable to free themselves by their own power.ST Jan 13, 1887ST Feb 3, 1914ST Jan 4, 1916
Experience the Verse Describes
The condition spoken of is that of a person awakened and convicted by the Spirit on the way to conversion, not the settled life of one made free in Christ.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908RH Jan 26, 1860ST Sep 17, 1896 The law is spiritual, reaching to hidden purposes, thoughts, dispositions, desires and intents of the heart, while the one convicted is carnal, fleshly, enslaved and helpless in himself to overcome sin or to carry out the good he wills.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908ST Sep 17, 1896RH Apr 14, 1863 Though the mind, conscience and will assent that the law is good and holy and desire to do right, sin dwelling within rules and brings into captivity, so he does the evil he hates, fails to perform the good he intends, remains subject to death, and repeatedly fails feeling doomed.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908RH Jan 26, 1860RH Apr 14, 1863 This is the first step toward conversion through which every adult passes to a greater or less extent, the experience of Romans 7:15-25 leading from bondage toward service, in contrast to the converted life of Romans 8.ST Jun 24, 1886ST Sep 23, 1908ST Sep 17, 1896 The law thus exposes sin, shuts up the transgressor as justly condemned, and reveals utter helplessness in order to lead away from self to Christ the Deliverer, through whom justification by faith and freedom named in Romans 7:25 are found.ST Sep 23, 1908RH Jan 26, 1860ST Sep 17, 1896RH Apr 14, 1863
On another view, the verse opens the delineation of Christian experience as war in Romans 7 and 8, with lust together with the world, the flesh and the devil on one side and the soul aided by Christ, the Holy Spirit and good angels on the other.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867 The inward man delights in God's law and serves it with the mind, yet the flesh wars against the law of the mind and the Spirit, brings into captivity to the law of sin, and leaves the one in Romans 7 unable to meet the spiritual requirements and longing for deliverance from the body of death.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867 That stern and furious wrestling beats down the baser self, giving no quarter to lusts, strangling appetites and vanquishing inner foes, so that strength is gained to vanquish foes without.RH Mar 19, 1867RH Nov 5, 1861 Victory is sure to the true and faithful through Jesus Christ, who conquered Satan and overcame temptation in sinful flesh, and those who move into Romans 8 walk not after the flesh but after the Spirit, free from condemnation and from the law of sin and death, with the righteousness of the law fulfilled in them in freedom and fullness of joy.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Mar 19, 1867 Grace works upon the natural fleshly life to produce a new supernatural life distinct from the old, and this struggle with a partly forsaken carnal nature and partly crucified self is not to be settled for as final, since believers may press on into the liberty and assurance of Romans 8.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Apr 16, 1861ST Apr 10, 1907
Speaking as carnal while delighting in the law of God is true present reality, not a figure putting oneself back under a past abolished code, proving the moral law then present, holy, just and good.RH Feb 14, 1854 The law so called spiritual is the same moral law whose transgression introduced sin into the world, the Ten Commandments existing as law before Sinai, remaining exceeding broad and covering all moral duty, with penalties such as fourfold restitution arising from disobedience to it.RH Feb 14, 1854
On another differing view, the verse describes an actual experience laid in Judaism when the law was in full force, namely the first sin when the commandment came to the understanding at the years of responsibility, not conversion and not the constant habit of a Christian.RH Mar 25, 1873 Spiritual there means not sinful, standing opposite to carnal only when carnal means sold under sin, and is affirmable even of ceremonial precepts since no sinful ordinance was ever enjoined, while carnal in the sense of fleshly ordinance is also predicable of that same entire law given through Moses, the same as in Romans 6:14 and called flesh in verse 5, showing it was chiefly a political institution.RH Mar 25, 1873 The present tense is used as a vivid historical present for liveliness, so no comfort for continued sinning can be drawn from it.RH Mar 25, 1873
The verse belongs to one still struggling with a partly forsaken carnal nature and partly crucified self under sin, willing what is good but unable to perform it and doing what is hated while serving God's law with the mind yet pulled by the flesh into serving the law of sin.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Apr 16, 1861 That condition of walking in the flesh with the carnal mind, fleshly and enslaved and held in bondage to the law of sin in the members, is the struggle to overcome self and is not the final Christian experience.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Apr 16, 1861 The Christian need not remain continually doing what he disapproves but may gain victory, since deliverance comes through Jesus Christ who frees from the carnal mind so that with the whole being a person can serve the law of God and walk after the Spirit free from sin, and the law of the Spirit of life in Christ makes free from the law of sin and death.RH Nov 1, 1864RH Sep 10, 1872 To treat that condition as lasting until the resurrection would leave no room for the inner person to be renewed during this life, since regeneration is needed from it now.RH Feb 15, 1870
The carnal sold condition describes people by nature and also believers who rely on themselves rather than on Christ.ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jul 13, 1882 It is the daily experience of a person whose sins are forgiven but whose carnal nature remains, which cannot be purified or improved and continues to produce sin, so the cry for deliverance is a cry to be freed from the old self and sinful nature from which sinful acts spring.ST Apr 15, 1903ST Feb 11, 1889 To live there is to profess without love, taking the yoke of the law upon a stiff neck instead of Christ's yoke, so religion is bondage with broken resolutions, grievous commandments, a heavy unendurable yoke, and the cry of wretchedness instead of pleasantness and peace and righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Ghost.RH Mar 26, 1861 It is the failing experience of one whose faith has not advanced beyond defeat, for whom overcoming the world by faith remains a mystery, in contrast to the life hid with Christ that is radiant with the Spirit and claims victory by faith before the battle begins because the enemy is already conquered. Carnality was in the nature, for the flesh contained no good thing, yet calling oneself carnal can describe nature and not present opposition, since one may delight in God's law and no longer oppose His will, the carnal mind being destroyed when brought into harmony with and submission to His will.ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jul 13, 1882
Human flesh never becomes converted and never stops opposing the Spirit but remains the same perverse sinful flesh after conversion as before, in sinner and converted alike until bodies are changed at the Lord's coming.ST Apr 30, 1896ST May 14, 1896 The law is spiritual, so the things of the Spirit are the commandments of God, while the flesh stands opposed to that spiritual law and serves the law of sin.ST Apr 30, 1896ST May 14, 1896 The unconverted yield to the flesh and so are servants of sin and are not led by the Spirit even though the Spirit still strives with them, while the converted keep exactly the same flesh but yield to the Spirit so the flesh has no power and is controlled and its deeds are put to death, and for that reason are counted as not in the flesh but in the Spirit.ST May 14, 1896 Deliverance comes not by a change in the flesh but by the indwelling Spirit of Christ giving power over it, as proved by coming in the same sinful flesh yet remaining without sin by being always led by the Spirit.ST Apr 30, 1896ST May 14, 1896
The chapter records inward conflict between sin and holiness through which the fight is fought, the course finished and the faith kept unto the victor's crown.RH May 14, 1867 Sinfulness is recognized in the glory of Christ as on the Damascus road, where the light exposing unworthiness also brings cleansing, strength and help rather than discouragement. A terrible uprising of the old Adam may be felt within, and the tearful account written out of that conviction proves genuine Christians need conviction of sin as much as impenitent sinners, the keen north wind of the Spirit bringing professing Christians to repentance and tears and the cutting off of cherished sins so latent graces such as penitence flow out.RH Mar 21, 1871 The passage belongs with Matthew 5-7, Romans 6, 8, 12, Galatians 5-6, Ephesians 4-6, James 2-3, 1 Peter 1-2, 2 Peter 1, 3, and 1 John 1-3, 5, to be studied as a whole and in all its parts, since holiness is the design of all dispensations of grace and providence toward men.RH Nov 24, 1859
Sabbath and True Worship
The law that contains the Sabbath command in its bosom is spiritual, and because it is spiritual, holy, just and good the Sabbath is to be observed.ST May 10, 1905ST Oct 4, 1905ST Aug 13, 1885ST Mar 5, 1894ST Oct 19, 1915 Serving and keeping the whole law includes the seventh-day Sabbath, which with the other nine precepts is moral, universal and unlimited in obligation.ST May 10, 1905ST Oct 4, 1905ST Oct 19, 1915 That Sabbath command belongs to the holy, just and good law affirmed after the cross, and is entirely different from Jewish ordinances abolished by Christ's death, not a human tradition.ST Mar 5, 1894ST Oct 19, 1915 Keeping the Sabbath by faith means obeying God's Word and observing the seventh day it identifies, as proved by delight in that inward law and by teaching that keeping the commandments of God is what matters.ST Oct 4, 1905
The Sabbath as part of that spiritual law is a spiritual institution, and its rest, blessing and sanctification are spiritual and given as part of God's holy purpose.ST Nov 10, 1898ST Feb 20, 1896RH Jan 12, 1905 Only one who is spiritual and born of God by grace has power to keep holy what God has made holy, for keeping a holy day holy is a matter of power, not of right.ST Feb 20, 1901ST Feb 20, 1896 It memorializes God's spiritual rest, has the seventh day at its heart with all scriptural evidence for Sabbath sacredness applying to the seventh day alone and none for Sunday, and is a sign of Creator and Redeemer.ST Nov 10, 1898ST Feb 20, 1896RH Jan 12, 1905 That spiritual law is perfect, extends to all inward thoughts and outward actions, and can never be changed or annulled, so the command to keep the seventh-day Sabbath holy shares its spiritual, perfect, unchangeable character.ST Nov 10, 1898ST Aug 15, 1916 Its nature and demands belong to the religious realm, which the State has no proper jurisdiction to regulate.ST Mar 18, 1903
Sabbath rest is more than stopping physical work: it is spiritual rest in Christ's presence and rest from sin, received by faith.ST Feb 8, 1899STST Nov 15, 1899ST Feb 7, 1906 Faith sees the Sabbath as a sign of the living Creator and Redeemer and receives the blessing God has placed in it, making the Sabbath a delight.STST Feb 7, 1906 The fourth commandment reaches beyond outward actions and words to the thoughts and desires of the heart, calling people to delight in its holy service, and keeping the Sabbath according to the commandment therefore requires holiness and a spiritual condition.RH Jun 18, 1861ST Oct 3, 1900 A person cannot keep holy what God made holy unless first made holy by grace, for divine grace must free and sanctify the person before that person can keep it, and such observance cannot be made holy by human effort or enforced by human law.ST Feb 8, 1899ST Nov 15, 1899 Sin begins in the heart before outward acts, with hatred before murder, cherished lust before adultery, and inward disregard before Sabbath desecration, and the law exposes and governs these inward matters while civil law cannot control the heart or produce genuine observance.ST Feb 8, 1899
The carnal heart cannot understand spiritual things or enter God's rest, and because the heart has not been renewed people cannot see the Sabbath as a gift made for good or keep it in its spiritual sense.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Apr 29, 1903 The carnal condition puts man out of harmony with the law and makes true Sabbath-keeping impossible until conversion makes him spiritual again, at peace with God and partaker of the divine nature.ST Apr 29, 1903 God's law is spiritual because God is spirit and all His works and institutions share His character, and there was no secular time when He made creation and the week, since secular things came only because of sin and there was no sin when He founded the Sabbath. The Sabbath that makes the week and orders all its other days is therefore spiritual and not a movable secular segment of time, and the spiritual nature of the Christian dispensation and the Spirit's work does not cancel or change the seventh-day Sabbath.ST Dec 11, 1901 Because the law is spiritual no man and no civil government can administer, execute or enforce it, for human power cannot enforce faith, and the most any person can do, only by the help of the Spirit through faith in Christ, is to obey it himself.ST Apr 29, 1903
Obedience to the spiritual law is spiritual worship, not carnality or opposition to grace, and its spiritual character confirms its high moral standard and rules out the claim that keeping it dishonors Christ or the gospel.RH May 27, 1852ST Jul 8, 1880 Loving obedience prompted by love is spiritual service and the only true worship, not Pharisaical heartless outward observance in the letter.ST Mar 11, 1886ST Jun 12, 1884ST Apr 2, 1896 Keeping God's commandments together with faith in Jesus is the basis of spiritual worship and true Christian unity, while apostasy from that basis leads to confused, formal worship without spiritual power.ST To disobey willfully denies the Lord the honor and fear due to Him as Father and Master, and professed worship joined with willful disobedience is will-worship and mockery.ST Mar 11, 1886ST Jun 12, 1884ST Apr 2, 1896
Only obedience of the heart meets the law's entirely spiritual requirements, for outward conformity alone is not obedience since the law reaches thoughts and emotions, while true inward obedience also includes outward conformity.ST Dec 30, 1889ST Oct 17, 1906ST Jan 21, 1886 Its spirit does not contradict its letter and cannot be kept while its letter is broken, though keeping the letter without love fails to fulfill its righteousness.ST Jun 9, 1881ST Aug 26, 1875ST Jan 21, 1886 Formality without the spirit of love and obedience never did and never can fulfill the righteousness of the law, and respectable conduct or good citizenship is not obedience when the heart is impure.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Sep 18, 1893 The law reaches beyond outward acts to secret thoughts, purposes and motives and requires love to God and to others, so lust breaks the command against adultery and cherished envy, hatred and enmity break the command against murder even with no outward act, and civil laws can restrain outward acts but cannot enforce this spiritual obedience.ST Jun 9, 1881ST Dec 30, 1889ST Jan 21, 1886 Conscientious obedience to the Sabbath requires the Spirit of God working upon the heart, unlike outward compliance with a human ordinance which can satisfy legal demands without inward obedience.ST Oct 17, 1906
Because the law is spiritual, holy, just and good, obedience to it forms a character that is holy, true, just, good and pleasing to God.RH Jan 15, 1861RH Jun 24, 1852RH Dec 23, 1851 The law spoken of is the Ten Commandments, which remained holy, and calling that law a yoke of bondage comes from the carnal mind, never from the church, for the carnal sin-sold condition is in man while delight in the law of God belongs to the inward man.RH Jan 15, 1861RH Jun 24, 1852RH Dec 23, 1851 God's people consent it is holy, just, good and spiritual and honor it by loving, obeying, delighting in it from the inward heart and teaching it, proving faith does not void it.RH Jun 24, 1875RH Mar 1851 Seeing purity in the law and sinfulness in self rather than blaming the law leads to upholding it as the revelation of God's will, and those who love God find His commandments joyous, not grievous.RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jun 24, 1875
The law including its preface is spiritual, and its reference to Egypt and bondage also has a spiritual meaning.RH Jan 29, 1901 Egypt represents the realm of sin in its lowest depths and blackest darkness, and bondage represents enslavement to sin.RH Jan 29, 1901ST Jul 2, 1902 The opening words declare God as the Deliverer who brings people out of sin's realm by faith in Christ's blood so they may keep His commandments, and deliverance from sin must come before commandment-keeping.RH Jan 29, 1901ST Jul 2, 1902 Those redeemed from sin are brought out of spiritual Egypt, out of the house of bondage, just as literal Israel was brought out of literal Egypt, and are under added, special obligation to keep the spiritual law including His Sabbath blessed and sanctified in the beginning, which is a memorial of God's rest that was spiritual rest because God is a Spirit.ST Jul 2, 1902
State and Daily Life
Because the law is spiritual it can be fulfilled only through the Spirit God supplies, and it can be kept only by those who have the Spirit of Christ, so that without His Spirit no one can keep it and no one belongs to Him.ST Jan 7, 1897ST Aug 27, 1896ST Feb 20, 1907 Its meaning cannot be limited or altered by human judgment, since people cannot fathom the full depth of God's will or measure their own sin and righteousness, and the Spirit must work in each person because human authorities cannot impose the Spirit or define its mind.ST Jan 7, 1897 Therefore the cause and institutions of Christ cannot be promoted or preserved by carnal weapons, but only by God's spiritual armor of faith, truth, righteousness, salvation, peace and the word of God wielded by the Spirit.ST Aug 27, 1896 Its moral power cannot be taught mechanically or received by intellectual instruction alone, but must be received by faith in Christ Jesus, and anyone who would obey must be born again, receiving a new mind and life and becoming a new creature as Jesus born of the Spirit lived out the law in human life.ST Apr 5, 1905 Only spiritual people can keep it acceptably, for it has God's own life in it and remains alive even when people rebel against it, while civil laws cannot make anyone keep it or bind the conscience.ST Feb 20, 1907
Because the law is spiritual in every part, expressing God's character and love and reaching beyond outward acts to the mind, heart, motives, conscience and inner springs of action and character, civil government which can judge only outward conduct cannot enforce it in its spiritual sense.ST Apr 1, 1897ST Oct 16, 1893ST Jun 26, 1893 A person does not truly obey unless obedience comes from the heart, and civil government can regulate outward conduct but cannot produce the love or inward loyalty that obedience requires.ST Jun 26, 1893 Observing it requires the Spirit of Christ, and civil force can impose outward forms but cannot produce obedience to a spiritual law.ST Jan 30, 1907 Because the Sabbath precept is part of that law the Sabbath is spiritual too, so civil laws and coercion can enforce only outward observance, not true Sabbath keeping, and can compel hypocrisy.ST Feb 17, 1909 Carnal people and means cannot enforce God's law, since people who are carnal are under sin, and God seeks willing obedience by persuasion among converted people, while enforcing spiritual duties would put the state in God's place and produce only deluded hypocrites.ST Feb 6, 1896
No part of the spiritual law is within the power of human legislation, as Thou shalt not covet proves because no human power can enforce it or tell if it is violated, and that commandment is no more spiritual than the other nine.ST Aug 13, 1896 God's law pertains not to outward deed alone but to spirit, thought, motive and intent, so it can be broken in thought and motive alone, hatred is murder and cherished lust is adultery, and coveting violates God's law though civil law cannot reach or prohibit it.ST Aug 6, 1896 Sin as transgression of God's law is therefore distinct from crime as transgression of civil law regulating only the outward act.ST Aug 6, 1896 Civil laws protecting life and property may have the same wording as God's commands, but they are distinct from God's law and are necessary whether or not people know the Decalogue.ST Sep 24, 1894 Human law may restrain injury and fraud but cannot reform the heart or bring people nearer to Christ, and treating compliance with human law as obedience to God's law can produce self-righteousness and hypocrisy, while obedience offered in addition to faith in Christ as a way to become righteous comes from self-righteousness rather than Christ and cannot add to His righteousness.ST Feb 8, 1899ST Dec 5, 1892
True Christianity does not compel obedience from without but results in keeping of the commandments in the life of everyone who has it, because the spiritual law must be implanted in the heart by grace and wrought out by faith which works by love.ST Jun 16, 1898 Its consistent observance is spiritual and cannot be compelled by civil law, for a person obeys it from the heart where God's law is written.ST Oct 18, 1899 The commandments are holy, just, good and spiritual, and the righteous enshrine them in their heart's best love, and loving them leads to keeping them.RH Apr 26, 1870 They are not a yoke of bondage and are not grievous, and keeping them is the condition of entering into life and entering in through the gates into the city, a plain and easy way leading to glory, vindication, heavenly honor and unending glory despite worldly humiliation and reproach, while those who reject them for seeming present good will meet the fate of the disobedient.RH Apr 26, 1870 God's Word and law belong to the spiritual order, and the church is Christ's spiritual body filled, guided and controlled by His Spirit, and the Ten Commandments implanted in the heart guide His children to all eternity.ST May 31, 1899ST Sep 15, 1898 Because the law is wholly spiritual and alive, unlike human laws which have no life in themselves, keeping it requires spiritual service, and outward efforts made in a carnal state merely reproduce human nature rather than fulfill the law, since a carnal person is not subject to God's law and cannot be.ST Jan 14, 1897
Being under grace as distinct from being under law means being reborn, for a man is under grace because he is reborn and a man who condemns the law is not under grace.ST Jul 7, 1914 While a man under law antagonizes and hates the law and wants to break it, a man under grace loves the law and its Author, regards it as if he himself had made it, and finds his highest pleasure in honoring and obeying it and in leading others to do the same.ST Jul 7, 1914 Being under grace gives no license to break any part of the law but holds a man to stricter accounting and higher obligation, so that if a man under law ought to tithe much more a man under grace ought to tithe, and if a man under law must not commit adultery much more a man under grace must live a pure life.ST Jul 7, 1914 A person who knows the law spiritually will not question the Sabbath, for the Sabbath is not annulled by a person's natural opinion.
Only those who are carnally minded oppose God's law when they understand what it is, so enmity against the law proves the heart is carnal and not right before God, and any spirit that moves a person to defy, disobey or slight any part of God's law is not the Spirit of God.ST Aug 29, 1895 God's law is spiritual because God is a spiritual Being and His government and kingdom are spiritual, and it is a living law sharing the nature and life of God who gave it, with the Spirit of God permeating it so that law and Spirit are in perfect harmony, while spiritual is the opposite of carnal or fleshly and the carnal man is the opposite of the spiritual man.ST Aug 29, 1895 Conversion to Christ removes the carnal mind and its rebellion against God's law, and the renewed person delights in the law inwardly, which shows the verse does not make the law sinful or discredit it but contrasts the law's spiritual character with sinful human nature.ST Oct 18, 1883 Holiness means living in agreement with that law expressing God's character, and walking after the Spirit means inwardly loving God's law, and that inward love marks a condition acceptable to God, while self-asserted goodness is presumption not holiness.ST Feb 3, 1904 The natural person carnal and enslaved to sin is at odds with what comes from God and cannot submit to His rule or understand the Bible rightly, and natural selfish dispositions can lead people to resist the law's righteousness, so keeping the law rightly requires serving in newness of spirit where freedom from sin leads to willing obedience not freedom from the law.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Feb 17, 1904RH Jul 21, 1868
People become slaves under sin when they surrender self-control to perverted appetites or unholy ambition, and even good gifts and lawful pursuits can become masters when people let them rule instead of keeping themselves under God's control.ST Dec 8, 1887 Those bound to tobacco are examples of people ruled by sinful desires as carnal and enslaved to sin, slaves to their cravings not the pure joyful free people of the Lord.ST Sep 15, 1887 In the city this enslavement is seen in men whose minds are befogged by drink and who have lost virtue and love.ST Feb 7, 1906 A person whose heart remains corrupt is sold under sin, and learning and mental cultivation without moral correction can put knowledge and skill to harmful use.RH Aug 25, 1868 That description applies to those who mock efforts to reform and pursue holiness, in contrast with striving to live by Christ's example and obey His directions for bodily and spiritual purification.RH Mar 5, 1867 Humanity's surrender to Satan through appetite brought this enslavement, and a person cannot free himself by his own power, but only God's power can deliver people from that control and restore self-control.RH Feb 26, 1901
Pledging to keep the ideal Christian life for a time in human strength always fails, because the law is spiritual while unconverted human nature is carnal and sold under sin.ST Jan 27, 1909 This is seen when a business worker tries to be a consistent Christian yet is forced into deceit and lying for an employer and cannot hold both the job and the ideal.ST Jan 27, 1909 Excuses that divide business from religion, that an employee is only a machine writing what the employer dictates, and that the employer's conscience belongs to himself, do not change the carnal condition and do not make the life acceptable.ST Jan 27, 1909 At the judgment seat of Christ character alone will decide, measured not by fallen business standards or competition or for whom the work was done, but weighed in the balances of God's sanctuary.ST Jan 27, 1909 God's law reaches beyond outward actions to the inner life so that thoughts and intentions violating its spirit make a person guilty even when outward conduct appears correct, and therefore withholding tithes and offerings due to God is stealing from Him, while dishonoring parents is sin because it transgresses His law.ST Dec 12, 1895 The Sabbath law requires more than physical rest because God's law reaches the mind as well as the body, addressing thoughts, exposing desires and condemning affections, so keeping it in spirit and letter means not dwelling on secular subjects or planning worldly work.RH May 12, 1863 Human law can condemn an overt crime such as murder while lacking authority to judge hatred or murderous intent, but God's law condemns both because sin includes inward motives as well as deeds, and transgression of that holy just good law is sin whether or not human law treats the person as a criminal.ST Jan 20, 1898
Being sold under sin describes the lost condition accompanying the loss of mankind's dominion over the earth.ST Dec 23, 1889 The earth marred and cursed by sin will be reclaimed by Christ its Creator and Redeemer and restored to more than its original Eden beauty.ST Dec 23, 1889 In Eden man obeyed Satan instead of God and thereby placed himself under Satan's power, with all that man had going with him under Satan's dominion, and all humanity sold itself in sin and by choosing sin and death rather than righteousness and life forfeited even life itself.ST Jun 11, 1902ST Mar 31, 1898 Yet Christ has paid the redemption price to set free every son of Adam who desires that freedom, so man remains responsible for his sins and for his choice since the right and power of choice is his, and God made an eternal sacrifice through Jesus Christ to win man to eternal life.ST Jun 11, 1902ST Mar 31, 1898 Christ has redeemed people by His own blood, and Christ who is not in humanity's sinful condition gave His life as the price to redeem them, since they cannot pay the ransom for one another.RH Jul 22, 1915ST Jan 4, 1916 Those who persist in sin despite great light are left bound in sin without hope of escape.ST Feb 10, 1887
Those living in the flesh bound by sin are the living people to whom the Spirit preached in Noah's day, not conscious spirits preaching or receiving a message after death, so there is no probation after death. Their spirits are in prison because they are bound to the flesh, and Christ saves people from sin's bondage and the Spirit effects that deliverance.ST Feb 11, 1889 God's law is spiritual reflecting His holy character, and when that holiness and the law's spirituality are fully seen every self-deception is exposed and the heart stands uncovered.RH Sep 23, 1858 That exposure comes too late to correct one's mistake, for probation has closed, character is formed, and the life record is sealed for eternity.RH Sep 23, 1858
Recognizing both the law's spiritual nature and one's own carnality leaves hope for better days.ST Jan 30, 1912 Awakened as by Sinai's thunder to ingratitude, people like Israel of old try by impossible means of their own to obey that code and fail and lie disheartened and suppliant at His feet.ST Oct 12, 1904 God then shifts the view to Gethsemane and Calvary, where Christ the Creator bore shame and pain and death for rebels, and that love melts the cold sin-hardened heart until each command becomes a golden promise.ST Oct 12, 1904 Breaking that spiritual law grieves the Holy Spirit and puts the transgressor under condemnation and bondage, while repenting and living in obedience brings freedom from sin, the peace of God in the heart, and the witness of the Spirit that the person is no longer a servant but a son and an heir of God through Christ, which then overflows in praise and testimony.ST Apr 20, 1888 The gospel is entirely faith in just what God says, trusting the power of God manifested through His Word for salvation instead of trusting self, and received as the Word of God it effectually works holiness, justice, goodness and spirituality in those who accept it.ST Jun 16, 1898
Saul recognized that he was bound to sin and facing death, and saw his need for a power outside himself to save him, since sin holds a person in slavery and a person cannot deliver himself by his own power.ST Apr 20, 1915 In man, that is in his flesh, dwells no good thing, and they that are in the flesh cannot please God, which is the testimony of one who diligently sought for good within himself and came back broken and weary, proving that man since the fall has sought in himself the knowledge of good and finds it not.ST May 4, 1904 This condemns looking to self and listening to the voice within for light, and shows man must look to Christ instead.ST May 4, 1904 Fallen human beings are carnal and through Adam's disobedience sold under sin, and though people can understand the law's spiritual nature and recognize its power to expose sin, they cannot withstand Satan's power and deceptions without accepting Christ's atoning sacrifice. Perfect obedience to the law justifies, and such obedience is possible only through faith in Christ. Without knowledge of God people are hopeless with sin burned into bones, yet Christ who is not in that condition gave His life to set free every son of Adam who desires freedom.ST Jan 4, 1916ST Jun 11, 1902
Sources