The fall perverted nature, marred God's image and the inward copy of the law, subjected the mind to the flesh, and left humanity guilty in standing and corrupt in disposition, enslaved, ruled by sin and dead in sin.ST May 31, 1899RH Mar 10, 1904ST Nov 15, 1910ST Jun 8, 1915ST Feb 3, 1914 Before renewal the mind is carnal and hostile, with a downward pull away from God unless consciously resisted, and the spiritual mind that had ruled was lost leaving only the mind of the flesh expressed in carnal ordinances relying on human effort.ST May 31, 1899RH Mar 10, 1904ST Jun 8, 1915ST Feb 3, 1914ST Nov 7, 1900 After Adam transgressed, sin became incarnate and physical nature came under a perverted law of sin working against God's law of righteousness, so mind, soul and affections are by nature in harmony with sin, and this fallen life passed to all mankind who receive only what Adam had to give and are doomed to death.ST Nov 15, 1910ST Feb 3, 1914ST Nov 7, 1900
The carnal mind is self, the flesh, the old man, the body of sin and the first husband, a ruling power when yielded to, Satan's personal representative in every heart and a mind received from the serpent, opposed to Christ.ST Apr 12, 1883STST May 6, 1897RH Nov 22, 1906 A person is not carnally minded merely because temptation arises but when he yields and willingly follows the flesh, and its self-will disregards God's authority and would replace His will if given full sway, so acts from it are rebellion unacceptable to God.ST Apr 12, 1883ST May 6, 1897RH Mar 19, 1872 Being united to it is what makes a person a sinner, and because it cannot be reformed or made obedient it must be surrendered, denied, crucified, slain, put off and put to death, that the body of sin be done away and bondage end through daily death by being crucified with Christ.STST May 6, 1897RH Nov 22, 1906RH Mar 19, 1872
Its affections are fixed on created things and the passing world rather than on God who is spirit and unseen, on self, appetites, ambitions, passions, pleasure, mammon, pride, covetousness and self-glory rather than God's glory.ST Jul 19, 1883ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 10, 1874RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 27, 1901 Since the law requires supreme love for Him, a mind wholly set elsewhere cannot submit to it, and preferring the creature to the Creator carries the guilt of idolatry.ST Jul 19, 1883ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 10, 1874 This selfish spirit is the minding of the flesh and being in the flesh, in direct contrast to disinterested benevolence originating in the Father and Christ, and God's Spirit never bears witness with a heart controlled by selfish motives.ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 10, 1874RH Aug 7, 1866
It is the same in every age and place, explaining opposition to prophets, Christ, apostles and later persecutions, and it will continue until Christ destroys wickedness.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 27, 1901ST Jul 15, 1875ST Mar 29, 1905 Those ruled by pride, covetousness and pleasure oppose law-keepers, resist reproof as ancient opposers did, resent the law for condemning them, and cannot please God whether in one location or another.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 27, 1901ST Jul 15, 1875ST Mar 29, 1905 Confronted by Christ's pure, lofty piety and uncompromising holiness exposing rebellion, rebellious hearts desire their own inclinations as the antediluvians did and turn against the light because the path requires a cross.ST Jan 28, 1897ST Nov 27, 1901
Sin is natural to fallen flesh though not created by God, belonging to condition as well as deeds, perverting judgment, blinding to truth and making heavenly things repulsive.RH May 27, 1873ST Nov 25, 1908RH Apr 16, 1867 That sinful promptings feel natural gives no excuse for sin, for sin distorts judgment so wrong seems right and the law seems wrong, weakening mind, dulling feeling, hardening conscience, fostering unbelief and degrading physically, mentally and morally.RH May 27, 1873RH Apr 16, 1867ST Oct 15, 1894 Human nature was perverted by yielding to sin when humanity chose it, and this spiritual power works in every heart producing hatred and blindness overcome only by Jesus, through whom people may renounce their ways, receive a new nature and partake of the divine nature.ST Nov 25, 1908ST Oct 15, 1894
Outward restraint, knowledge, profession or morality without renewal does not change it, and the natural mind cannot receive spiritual things or understand Scripture without the Spirit.RH Jun 26, 1900RH Aug 25, 1868ST Aug 7, 1893ST Feb 17, 1904ST Jul 3, 1893 Left to itself the mind's strongest passions and thoughts remain human and sinful, and a corrupt heart remains dangerous even when richly developed in knowledge because learning without moral correction can be turned to evil.RH Jun 26, 1900RH Aug 25, 1868ST Aug 7, 1893ST Aug 25, 1909 The carnal person is as one dead to spiritual things, finds heaven's purity repulsive while following desires of flesh and mind, and needs the Spirit to enlighten the mind to understand the seriousness of what the deeply spiritual law forbids.ST Aug 7, 1893ST Feb 17, 1904ST Jul 3, 1893ST Aug 25, 1909
It cannot please God, do good, produce good fruit or attain charity by itself, and even seemingly good acts from selfish motive are sinful and unacceptable because source and motive are wrong.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Aug 29, 1895RH Jun 30, 1859ST Mar 2, 1904 The natural, unrenewed, unconverted person is itself enmity expressing complete opposition to Him, and since His law is in harmony with Him opposition to the law is opposition to God.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Aug 29, 1895ST Jun 12, 1884 Without Christ's aid people cannot obey acceptably, for only those in whom God's Spirit dwells are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, and the Spirit and the law are in perfect harmony so that the law's righteousness is fulfilled in Spirit-walkers whose love shown by keeping commandments proves enmity gone.ST Aug 29, 1895RH Jun 30, 1859ST Jun 12, 1884
The law governing sinful character is opposed to the law governing righteous character, for sinful nature is opposed to God's plans and purposes.RH Nov 17, 1874ST Aug 26, 1875 The carnal mind is the law of sin in the flesh, the other law in the members, entirely distinct from and contrary to God's law as flesh has been since Adam's fall, warring against the law the inward man loves and serves with the mind.RH Nov 17, 1874ST Aug 26, 1875 God's law is holy, just, good and spiritual while in the flesh dwells no good thing, and faith in Christ through the law of the Spirit of life frees from the carnal law so the heart delights in God's law and its righteousness is fulfilled.RH Nov 17, 1874ST Aug 26, 1875
When sin possesses a person the body belongs to God by right but God has departed because He will not share rule with the enemy, and yielding the body to God's foes identifies the person with that enemy in practice.ST Jan 22, 1902RH Jan 28, 1902 Sin takes the place belonging to God, enslaving the will and driving away His indwelling presence, leaving the mind carnal, hostile and unable to submit.ST Jan 22, 1902RH Jan 28, 1902 A wicked or unconverted priest has this carnal mind, which ordination and baptism do not change or confer grace to remove, so he remains under Satan's power and control.ST Jan 16, 1896RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 24, 1900 Because he cannot discern spiritual things or truth he cannot know who are sinners or rightly remit sin and bind in heaven and earth, and God rejects such assemblies, for outward profession without conversion is not true faith, God's righteousness by faith, or Christ's mind.ST Jan 16, 1896RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 24, 1900RH Jul 16, 1861
Human sin is real and not merely imputed, for people are not all personally guilty of Adam's specific act but their own sins also violate God's law.RH Feb 17, 1859 The nations belong to the world ruled by the flesh and are left out of the measuring of the temple because no earthly power can meet judgment righteousness, since the flesh-ruled mind is hostile and cannot submit and belongs to this world not the world to come.ST Jun 8, 1904 The holier the truth the more carnal minds oppose it, hating even its tenderly preached messenger, conceding its truth yet refusing practice and despising it.RH Apr 30, 1857ST Jul 22, 1889ST Oct 7, 1875ST Jun 17, 1889ST May 30, 1895 Conscience may witness to right and wrong but the carnal mind resists obedience, evades self-condemnation, mistakes absence of outward crime restrained by fear and love of approval for virtue, and holds truth in unrighteousness while destitute of love for moral principles it honors in others.ST Jul 22, 1889ST Oct 7, 1875ST May 30, 1895
Serving the carnal mind is service to sin, and giving strength and best years to sin is ingratitude.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Jun 10, 1880RH Jul 19, 1870 Counterfeit worldly pleasures appeal to the natural person who regards God's Spirit's things as foolish, though temporary and ending in pain, and turning to God only at life's end after spending life for flesh wastes God-given strength in selfishness and treats the Saviour's blood with contempt.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Jun 10, 1880RH Jul 19, 1870 The natural heart not subject to God's law explains why the majority have been arrayed against God and why the voice of the people is not the voice of God.ST Jul 15, 1889 Transgression made every mind carnal so it cannot submit, and since the law measures God's glory no carnal keeping can attain it, for even future perfect keeping would be only duty while past guilt remains, much less can it atone for past sins.ST Jul 15, 1889ST Sep 29, 1898
The fallen mind at war with God is shown in idolatry, superstition and pagan abominations, which are stages of apostasy and not innocent or uninstructed worship.ST Dec 22, 1887 Heathen rites are not childlike sincere attempts, crude rites of infancy of knowledge, or involuntary ignorance, but successive degradation, utterances of alienated hearts suppressing the light of nature from heavens, creation, providence and soul, becoming vain with darkened hearts, changing His glory into images and His truth into a lie to worship creature more than Creator.ST Dec 22, 1887 The impure selfish mind ruled by disobedience is unfit for holy companionship and heaven, finding no joy there and shrinking from God's presence, so exclusion is from unfitness not unwillingness to receive.ST Dec 22, 1887ST Nov 18, 1897
All are born aliens from God with the violated law barring kingdom citizenship, becoming citizens only by accepting Christ's mediation as propitiation for past alienation and vowing future obedience, made nigh by His blood.ST Jan 17, 1906 This carnal law-breaking state makes the unconverted aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and reconciliation comes only through His merits with allegiance to the law.ST Jan 17, 1906 Human dignity and God's fatherhood cannot be rightly affirmed while rejecting humanity's sinfulness and need for divine grace and renewal.ST Jan 17, 1906ST Feb 17, 1881 A religion of the flesh is earthly rather than heavenly, lacking the spirit and life of true religion and leaving people without God's light and truth.ST Feb 17, 1881ST Oct 10, 1878
The carnal mind holds a person bound so evil thoughts run riot despite efforts, with the will powerless to keep thoughts pure or hold concentration without evil thoughts intruding and carrying it to shameful things.ST Dec 1, 1898 Wealth and poverty do not make the heart right, for the carnal mind is hostile whether rich or poor, while giving the heart to God makes riches a stewardship and rich and poor rich toward God by the Spirit of Jesus.ST Dec 1, 1898ST Jul 24, 1901 The carnal mind by nature chooses hell so sinners placed in paradise would turn it into hell, meaning hell is not God's fault but giving the wicked their choice with death added to make it more tolerable.ST Jul 24, 1901RH Sep 10, 1901
The carnal mind is the state of those led captive by Satan who mock the firm in faith and make God's commandments of no effect by tradition, in contrast to those offering themselves as living sacrifices who stand on apostles and prophets with Christ as cornerstone and keep His commandments for right to the tree of life.RH Jun 23, 1859 Elements in every heart war against God and must be softened by God's Spirit, and where not subdued they appear openly as self-worship claiming divinity within and making the self into God.RH Jun 23, 1859ST Nov 19, 1902 That self-worship is not mere selfishness but worshiping supposed divinity, good and God within, claiming for finite man all attributes of the Infinite and making the I into God.ST Nov 19, 1902
Ground of Hostility
The hostility lies entirely on the human side, for God is not at war with people but every sinful person is at war with God through a selfish fleshly mind hostile to Him and unable to obey His law.ST Sep 29, 1898ST Feb 14, 1911ST Feb 27, 1896 God is love and loves even sinners, giving His only Son to die for them while they were still enemies and reconciling the world to Himself in Christ without holding their sins against them.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Feb 27, 1896 God cannot come into harmony with that mind, for to do so would deny His own nature as God and goodness and would be the greatest evil in the universe.ST Sep 29, 1898 Peace therefore cannot come by God changing or compromising, but only by the transgressor surrendering to God, giving up sin and self and receiving through Jesus Christ reconciliation, spotless righteousness, cleansing, fulness and rest.ST Sep 29, 1898ST Oct 15, 1902 Christ abolished this enmity in His flesh by taking away sin, not by abolishing or changing the Ten Commandments, and if the rebellious heart will not give up sin but retains enmity, fierce carnal strife follows as the sinner wars against God and His children and against his own flesh and blood.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Nov 11, 1897
Opposition to the moral law is opposition to God, and opposition to God is opposition to the law, for the law is in harmony with God and expresses His character.ST Sep 14, 1882 The natural unrenewed person is itself enmity against God, so rejection of the Ten Commandments is refusal of allegiance to the rightful universal Ruler whose law reaches motives as well as actions, placing people in rebellion with no neutral ground.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Nov 15, 1883ST Feb 4, 1886 Following the carnal mind is being out of harmony with God, which is sin as missing the mark God has set, going out of God's way, transgressing His holy law and coming short of His glory, and it is the primal cause of unrest and strife, the opposite of peace.ST Dec 29, 1909 Its actions cannot be accepted as service to God because their source and underlying motive are wrong.ST Sep 14, 1882
The inability is absolute while carnal, because God's law is spiritual while fallen flesh is carnal and the two cannot harmonize.ST Dec 4, 1893RH Aug 20, 1872ST Mar 7, 1906 The flesh never becomes converted and its hostility remains, but a person led by Christ's Spirit is no longer under its power and can be subject to God's law.ST Apr 30, 1896 Affections fixed on created things and the passing world rather than on the unseen God cannot submit to a law requiring supreme love for Him, and preferring the creature to the Creator carries the guilt of idolatry.ST Jul 19, 1883 Insubordination to God's law is the cause of man's alienation, for the law is the great rule of action that condemns man and by which he is to be tried.ST Mar 18, 1875 The carnal mind stands in the way of keeping the law until it is taken away, which happens only through Christ by humbly confessing sin to find pardon, having the carnal heart removed, and being converted.RH Aug 20, 1872
The rebellion is in the human mind and will, not in matter, for the body obeys the human mind.ST Sep 15, 1909ST Sep 22, 1909 God addresses the human mind and calls it to direct the body rightly, so when a person uses the body for evil the mind is responsible for that disobedience.ST Sep 15, 1909 The carnal mind resists God's will and the flesh can disobey the Spirit's direction, and this conflict continues while God does not override human free will.ST Sep 22, 1909 It is the source of human sin and responsibility.ST Sep 22, 1909
The fault lies not in God or the law but in the heart that resists it.RH Sep 11, 1856ST Oct 15, 1902 The law is holy, good, righteous, just and spiritual, ordained for life but made death by man, and it is not grievous, arbitrary, unjust, too demanding, or a yoke of bondage except to the resisting mind.RH Sep 11, 1856ST Oct 15, 1902RH Mar 22, 1864RH Jun 24, 1852 Those freed from the law of sin and death fulfill the righteousness of the law by being brought into obedience to it, while those who give up the Sabbath and oppose the commandments show the carnal mind's hostility.RH Jun 28, 1870 The contrast with spiritual-mindedness links submission to God's law with life and peace, and the law is not bondage to those who love and seek it.RH Mar 22, 1864
This hostility darkens understanding and biases conclusions against the law's righteousness, so that natural selfish dispositions favor conclusions that do not agree with what is holy, just and good and are unlikely to err in favor of God's law.ST May 27, 1908ST Oct 16, 1884 It makes truth seem false, leads to unbelief, doubt and inventions to evade duty, and underlies loss of faith in the Bible and the law even among professing Christians.ST May 27, 1908ST May 24, 1905 Because heavenly principles of unpopular truth conflict with every wrong habit and sinful desire, few have moral courage to stand for truth, since accepting and obeying it requires denying self, bearing the cross daily and following Jesus.ST Feb 24, 1887 Resistance can lead people to stifle conscience and become falsely at ease in sin at the cost of peace with God and eternal life, and turning away from God's Word leaves people open to deception as they act and speak against it.ST May 24, 1905
The enmity shows itself in hatred of what condemns loved sin, in seeking to break the divine mirror that shows defects and filth, and in opposing those who keep God's law from motives of pride, covetousness and pleasure.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Aug 7, 1866 In the old man it rules the life and appears in selfishness, pride, envy, jealousy, resistance to reproof, failure to govern appetites and passions, anger, strife, faultfinding, love of worldly pleasures, and calling good evil.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Apr 14, 1881 This explains why people who follow natural inclinations resisted the ancient prophets and rejected Christ's reproofs, for human nature remains the same across generations. Anyone living for the flesh's pleasures, desires and lusts and seeking self's good rather than God's glory cannot please God, but is God's enemy at war with Him.ST Nov 27, 1901 The person who longs for holiness yields to what condemns him and forsakes sin, washed in the blood, life and righteousness of Jesus Christ and walking in Christ's strength in the law as the perfect law of liberty.ST Jan 30, 1901
To remain carnally minded is death, corruption and rebellion ending in ruin and second death unless forsaken, and the carnal nature must die because freedom from sin requires release from its rule.ST Sep 16, 1880ST Oct 19, 1888RH Aug 15, 1907 Serving sin means obeying sin's law while serving God means keeping His law, and Christ brings this present salvation as freedom from sin's bondage in this life and harmony with God's law, not merely hope of eternal life.ST Oct 19, 1888 A person unwilling to obey any part of the law has a sinful heart, while a right heart welcomes God's requirements rather than finding them burdensome.ST Sep 16, 1880 The mind must be renewed and kept pure through God's Word and help and reconciled to God through His Son, for when people reject God's word and yield to the flesh they are cut off from spiritual life and remain subject to sin and death until Christ brings the Spirit's mind and restores access to God's life through His received word.RH Aug 15, 1907 The exchange for a spiritual mind of life and peace, with the human will completely subdued to God's will, is urgent amid thickening last-day perils, deceptions, signs and lying wonders, and it is a free glorious gift through Jesus Christ to everyone who humbly submits.RH Nov 6, 1856
Only the carnal mind is at enmity with God's law while the spiritual mind is in harmony with it, so rejecters stand with the overthrower of heaven's government and upholders relying on Christ's merits stand with heaven with no neutral ground.ST Jan 25, 1905RH Jun 21, 1870 When the carnal mind is taken away hostility and opposition cease, and those who walk after the Spirit are brought into submission and harmony with the spiritual law, for freedom from sin is harmony with the law restored through Christ.RH Jun 21, 1870 Transgression makes people sinners and separates them from God and His requirements, so reconciliation requires becoming once more in harmony with God's law.RH Sep 21, 1905 Denial that the carnal mind is not subject to the law and strenuous effort to set it aside marks the carnally minded class, in contrast to the converted condition delighting in the law with the law in the heart ensuring future obedience.RH Mar 25, 1873 Spiritual life and fleshly hostility remain in necessary antagonism and cannot combine, so wherever opposition to the law appears there is fleshly hostility with no genuine repentance or true conversion, and teaching the law abolished while its principles remain opens the door to the license that hostile mind enjoys.RH Mar 4, 1873 Only the carnal heart refuses the new covenant putting the Ten Commandment law in the heart so it becomes part of the person in Christ Jesus.ST May 21, 1896
While man remains at enmity God and man cannot work together to accomplish God's purpose, for working with God requires unity of desire and purpose.ST Dec 30, 1903 The one carrying the message must be submissive to the will of the One who has the message to give, and the one using power must use it in harmony with the will of the One who has power to bestow, or that power cannot be entrusted to him.ST Dec 30, 1903 Following Christ means setting up no standards of one's own but staying in the one way He established straight to the kingdom, because outside that way lies only a bewildering maze leading to darkness, ruin and destruction, whereas happiness and peace are found in obedience to His law.ST Aug 29, 1911ST Dec 30, 1903 The carnal heart is at enmity with the pure principles of the Word of truth, so the Bible cannot be submitted to the test of human judgment like ordinary current literature without failing.RH Jun 23, 1910
The natural heart's enmity may be concealed in indifference without conscious hatred, remaining dormant when God is not truly considered or is imagined without His real character and claims.ST Jul 19, 1883 When God is seen as He is, holy, just and requiring the affections and pursuits of godliness, the conflict between natural desires and His demands becomes plain and reveals resistance to surrendering earthly affections and receiving new ones.ST Jul 19, 1883 A person may love his own natural conceptions of God as beneficent and powerful, but he cannot love God as holy, as the God who hates, punishes and destroys sin.ST Apr 8, 1875RH Dec 23, 1873 The proof is that when that God intrudes into thoughts through the day and hour it breaks peace and makes the heart recoil with the wish that there were no God, revealing hidden hatred where there seemed approval and love.ST Apr 8, 1875 Having lost God, the faculty of love gropes for other objects, concentrates love and worship on them, and puts the creature in place of the Creator.RH Dec 23, 1873
Sin in the heart is enmity even when hiding its real nature and presenting itself as righteousness, and the cross reveals this hostility where sin opposed, persecuted and killed Jesus who gave Himself so sin's true character would be seen.RH Dec 10, 1903 Recognizing that same hostile spirit at work toward one another leads to repentance, separation from sin, and reconciliation with God and with one another.RH Dec 10, 1903 The law's prohibitions can provoke the proud, impatient, rebellious nature, making forbidden things seem especially attractive to one who clings to sin and values sinful pleasures above God's favor.RH Oct 14, 1902 Such a person hates the law because it condemns loved sins and sees its restraints as bondage, and is unwilling to retain the knowledge of God's ways and requirements.ST Aug 7, 1884
Its opposition lies in thoughts, will and way out of harmony with God, bringing conflict, condemnation and unrest that human penance cannot relieve while the mind remains unsubject to His law. Separated from the Source of truth and under passion and sin, judgment is blinded so truth may appear false and falsehood true, leaving the mind unfit for the holiness and joy of heaven until the sinner yields to God and is renewed by the Spirit.RH Jul 6, 1916 A work upholding God's law cannot be attributed to the devil because the carnal mind cannot favor God's law.RH Sep 23, 1858 Actions arising from the unchanged heart are acts of rebellion disregarding God's authority and springing from self-will, which would replace God's will with its own if left unchecked.ST Nov 15, 1883
Resistance to God's word causes divisions and prevents unity, while willingness to hear and obey makes unity possible with all speaking the same thing, no divisions, perfectly joined in the same mind and judgment.ST Aug 19, 1880RH Jan 16, 1872 Resistance to the commandments and preference for human traditions prevent accepting truth and produce divisions among professed Christians.RH Jan 16, 1872ST Aug 19, 1880 A confederacy of sects letting each keep its errors is a confederacy of carnality, leaving civil power in carnal hands to legislate for God, which brings religious persecution, so those who love God and His truth must keep His word and stand aloof from it.RH Jan 16, 1872
Believing God's word requires greater effort than doubting it because the natural heart is hostile, so choosing doubt strengthens the tendency to doubt while obeying understood light and duties leads to greater understanding.ST Jun 8, 1882 Doubting God's Word and goodness itself transgresses the law, showing supposed superior knowledge that lowers His character and lifts the doubter above Him as judge.ST Jan 27, 1898 It sets human judgment against the mind and will of God in revolt against His government, putting another in God's place in violation of His law, while faith is measured by simplicity in submitting judgment to the expressed mind and will of Him who is over all.ST Jan 27, 1898 Stressing inability as waiting for God to change the nature can leave hearers delaying obedience.RH Jul 29, 1875 Waiting until a doctrine becomes popular or accepted by the majority before obeying it to preserve influence is a carnal-minded device refusing to follow God's truth and leading many to perdition.RH Jul 8, 1873
The enmity can be cured by kindness prayerfully and faithfully exercised, which can awaken goodness even in an obstinate self-willed heart.RH Dec 5, 1865 Rebellion is wrong, all have been guilty of it, and all must give it up to become loyal and obedient.RH Oct 10, 1865 The contrast between the sinner unmoved by truth and the person humbled at the cross illustrates the enmity, with grace bringing changed emotions and hopes displaying the beauty of holiness.RH Dec 9, 1862 Rebellion as opposition to His law causes false prophets to draw people from God and obedience, lulling sinners with assurance and peace when repentance is needed, building their own power, prestige and wealth, healing wounds only slightly, exalting corrupted imagination above the Word, withholding unpopular eternal truth, substituting their teachings and pagan lies for truth, leading to trust in man and the multitude, and crying peace and safety on the eve of destruction.ST Nov 10, 1898
The carnal mind expects a way unlike God's leading, which crosses the flesh and humbles the creature.RH Apr 19, 1864 Opposition to keeping the law can come from fear of losing worldly standing rather than God's favor, and God's mercy exposes this depravity and can lead the rebellious heart to acknowledge it.RH Jan 31, 1865 To the evil-disposed unbeliever with a hating rebellious heart the command to be doers of the Word is impossible cold law and terror, while to the yielding believing heart loving the law it is blessed promise and gospel power because Christ's command carries enabling power to make people what He requires.ST Nov 21, 1900 The hostile carnal mind has no place for saying Our Father in faith, but true address is a gift from Heaven transplanted by Christ into trustful pilgrims who submit to the Holy Spirit and learn meekness and lowliness from Him, possessed only by those not of the world.ST Jun 6, 1878RH Oct 22, 1872
Remedy in Christ
Release comes not by setting the law aside but by taking away the hostile mind through repentance toward God and faith in Christ who died to redeem, who intercedes to release from bondage, and who condemned sin in the flesh so that the righteousness called for in the law may be worked within those who walk after the Spirit in complete submission to His teaching, power and life into freedom from condemnation and ever-increasing joy and peace.ST Jul 22, 1913ST Aug 19, 1889ST May 20, 1908 The law by itself offers no hope to those enslaved to flesh and sin, and its exposure of sinners under just penalty shows salvation must come through the life and death of Jesus to cleanse and overcome sin.ST Jun 27, 1906 The sinner is helpless with no strength in himself to obey, change the heart, escape guilt or death, or overcome fixed habit, and neither education, culture, willpower nor civil law can cure, for only divine power from within through the new birth can transform the nature that produces only evil.ST Jul 22, 1913RH Nov 25, 1915ST Aug 6, 1894ST Feb 13, 1912RH Sep 24, 1857 Of ourselves nothing can be done without Christ, but all things can be done through Christ who strengthens.ST Jan 31, 1906
Conversion destroys, crucifies and puts to death the carnal mind and gives a new spiritual mind, the mind of Christ, through birth from above by water and Spirit with the Spirit dwelling within, turning earthly fleshly nature from the first Adam into childhood of the spiritual second Adam so that a person can please God, love Him supremely, possess true piety and delight in His commandments.ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jul 16, 1912ST Oct 7, 1886RH Feb 21, 1871 Growing in grace requires bringing the will under God's will so the carnal mind is destroyed and, as the spirit of the world is renounced, the Spirit of Christ is received.RH Aug 14, 1856 Christ took the same fallen flesh with all its tendencies toward sin, and where man failed in the mind He by the Spirit of God dwelling in Him by faith overthrew and abolished that enmity, crucified it in taking human flesh, and took away sin without abolishing or changing the Ten Commandments, so that His complete submission to the Father's law removes enmity and brings God and humanity into harmony for believers to conquer in Him.RH Sep 25, 1913ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jun 24, 1913ST Nov 11, 1897 He did not Himself have the carnal mind, but delighted to do His Father's will with God's law in His heart.ST Oct 21, 1889
The new covenant does not merely forgive past sins but removes the sinful disposition that would otherwise fall again into sin and condemnation, writing the same law in heart and mind so that obedience becomes nature and delight, peace with God takes the place of hostility, and the law's righteousness is fulfilled in Spirit-walkers.RH Oct 6, 1863ST May 27, 1908ST Sep 23, 1886ST Jul 22, 1889ST Mar 29, 1883 One sent as Christ's ambassador must himself first be converted and reconciled, with the law written by the living Spirit on fleshy tables of the heart and not merely known as ink or on stone, joined with thorough knowledge of God's government in His Word.ST Feb 28, 1906 Justification by faith gives peace with God, clothes with saving power, establishes the law in the believer's heart, and brings harmony with letter and spirit agreeing, so that those truly saved are saved from sin through faith and enabled to obey.ST Jul 8, 1886RH Oct 29, 1903RH Mar 6, 1916ST Feb 15, 1899 Fulfilling the law by the Spirit does not destroy it.RH Sep 30, 1852
Forgiveness alone would leave the hostile disposition to sin again, and change alone would leave past guilt to condemn in judgment; Christ therefore both freely forgives past sins so sinners stand justified and slays the enmity to make peace, willing submission and delight in the law.RH Oct 6, 1863ST Nov 22, 1883ST Jun 19, 1879ST Jun 1, 1882RH May 5, 1874 No one can keep all ten commandments without being a Christian, for inability while carnal is absolute and the spiritual law cannot be obeyed except through the Holy Spirit taking away the carnal mind, making men spiritually minded to discern duty, obey truth and be sanctified unto obedience.RH Aug 20, 1872ST Jan 11, 1877ST May 12, 1914ST Nov 28, 1892ST Sep 2, 1886 Through faith in Jesus the mind receives God's Spirit, which leads into obedience, fulfills the law's righteousness, moves the heart to love the law and brings peace, and the gospel thus forgives past neglect and places the sinner where he may do his duty.ST Jul 3, 1893 Perfect obedience to the law through faith constitutes perfect Christianity.RH Aug 20, 1872
Peace comes only by laying down rebellion, surrendering one's own will, way and affections, accepting cleansing and Christ's rule with nothing between sinner and God, for a mind ruled by flesh cannot work in harmony with God or carry out His purpose.RH Jan 16, 1908RH Aug 12, 1915ST Nov 19, 1885ST Jul 8, 1886ST Aug 9, 1899 The enmity is on man's side only while God is not at enmity, and Jesus came to destroy that enmity in the flesh and bring peace, though if the rebellious heart retains enmity fierce strife follows against God, His children and its own flesh.ST Feb 14, 1911 The spiritual mind by contrast delights in God's law and walks in His commandments, bearing the Spirit's fruits which agree with the law instead of doing the works of the flesh which condemn and exclude from the kingdom.ST Jul 29, 1889RH May 27, 1852ST Jan 16, 1893ST Mar 25, 1880 Those born of the flesh do the works of the flesh, while those in whom God's Spirit dwells are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, and whoever lacks Christ's Spirit is none of His.ST Sep 2, 1886ST Feb 7, 1906
The exchange of the carnal for the spiritual mind, with the human will completely subdued to God's will, is urgent because the perils of the last days thicken with deceptive power that would deceive even the elect, yet it is a glorious bargain without price, a free gift through Jesus to everyone who humbly submits, bringing life and peace instead of death.RH Nov 6, 1856 Indulging sin hardens the heart and makes return more difficult and painful, for the carnal mind cannot readily turn from the world and put on Christ without struggle and a cross.ST May 15, 1884 All human ordinances, stated fasts and crucifixions of the flesh devised by human effort to live better, win favor or establish self-righteousness come from the carnal mind and passed away in Christ's work, and worship prompted by the flesh is abomination even when earnest.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jun 24, 1913ST Aug 27, 1894ST Mar 11, 1886RH Nov 19, 1914 Such self-directed service follows its own will and feelings, offers what God has not required while withholding what He commanded, treats pomp as essential, and is will-worship puffed up in vain, whereas giving up the carnal mind for the Spirit's mind enables acceptable worship anywhere since mind serves God.ST Mar 11, 1886RH Nov 19, 1914ST Apr 2, 1896
Christ's obedience avails nothing unless reproduced and wrought out in the believer, and His faithful, loving, tested, tried, unyielding, continual obedience dwelling in the heart by faith restores His image and secures eternal immortal life.ST Jan 31, 1906 While carnal the heart cannot produce repentance because sin is transgression of the law and repentance is spiritual sorrow for sin, so God must give it by the Holy Spirit planting faith where the natural heart has no desire to please God.ST May 7, 1894ST May 13, 1886 If Christ's tempter were merely His own carnal mind or lusts He would have been sinful, since the carnal mind is sinful enmity unable to submit to God's law, so the devil cannot be identified with Christ's nature.RH Jun 26, 1856 The flesh remains unconverted and hostile demanding service, but feeling its demands does not mean a Christian has lost God-given freedom. Therefore the flesh or carnal mind cannot be a sacred place where God continually ministers.RH Jul 21, 1904
If materialism were true, carnal enmity belonging to the whole race could not change by regeneration during life but only by bodily regeneration at the resurrection, denying day-by-day renewal of the inner person while the body decays and denying freedom and moral responsibility.RH Feb 15, 1870RH Sep 8, 1859 The opposite of the carnal mind is a right mind in harmony with God's law, serving God's law with the mind, staying on God in perfect peace, and receiving the law in mind and heart under the new covenant, as seen when Nebuchadnezzar turned to praise God, when the lost son returned, and when the delivered demoniac followed Christ.ST Jul 2, 1902 The natural worldly mind ruled by love of the world lives in disobedience from which it cannot free itself nor change itself into love, and the change comes only through believing the Word, accepting propitiation for the past, and surrendering the rebellious will to Christ's obedient will to pass from sin and death to love and eternal life.ST Nov 19, 1902 Waiting to become good enough by one's own efforts before praying, confessing Christ, being baptized or doing other duties is the carnal mind struggling to keep the old man alive in self-righteousness, dressing in own righteousness and expecting forgiveness for a few sins, which is self-deception without Christ, salvation or true repentance.RH Nov 2, 1869
No one can come to Christ unless the Father draws by the Spirit, so resisting a sense of duty or a faithful warning is resisting the Spirit's invitation and is dangerous.ST Aug 21, 1884 Only Christ's blood can subdue the carnal mind which nature's beauty and abundance cannot overcome, so a heart sanctified by grace can praise God and rejoice in any setting whether in abundance or hardship.ST Oct 22, 1885 The missionary spirit belongs to the spiritual mind in opposition to self-seeking, self-glory and selfishness, working through faith, love and the Holy Spirit against the fleshly mind.ST Apr 10, 1884 Knowing Christ only outwardly after the flesh while walking after the flesh is not the life-changing knowing of regeneration in which the old life passes and one walks after the Spirit.ST Jan 16, 1893 Those following the carnal mind remain opposed, alienated and enemies of Christ and resist Him, while those yielding to His holy requirements receive forgiveness, favor and union as friends, so Christ and His coming are alarm to the wicked and joy to the righteous.ST Feb 26, 1880RH Mar 4, 1875ST Feb 24, 1881
The heart at enmity is a small mean dwelling with room only for self, but Christ's Spirit entering overturns selfishness and makes a new creature expanding love first to family and then to all humanity, slowly as the deceitful heart is reconstructed as God's temple.RH Oct 21, 1873 The gospel conquers the enmity, replacing the war spirit with a spirit of peace toward others.RH Mar 16, 1911 The first deliverance is a mighty change freeing from the carnal mind, corrupt heart, evil conscience and vile raiment and giving Christ's Spirit, character and righteousness to begin faith's pilgrimage, distinct from the final deliverance changing bodies to immortality.ST Sep 17, 1894 The choice to resist the Spirit belongs to the person not the Spirit, for though unable to overcome sin alone and pulled downward by surroundings, one can choose good and ally with God's strength, the choice theirs and the power God's.ST Jun 12, 1901 Those hostile must be brought into harmony before receiving His spirit of love, for God does not dwell in anyone antagonistic to His law.ST Apr 2, 1902
Sabbath and Law Opposition
The hostility of the fleshly mind toward God accounts for contempt for the Sabbath He commands to be honored, calling it Jewish while attempting to make Sunday the Christian Sabbath, and such hostility cannot change which day God has made holy.ST Jun 24, 1886ST Jun 17, 1889ST Sep 12, 1878 The same opposition explains refusal to keep the seventh day as commanded, with excuses for rejecting it and establishing a rival institution, including laws to enforce that rival, all arising from resistance to divine law.ST Jun 17, 1889RH Nov 2, 1911 This carnality underlies attacks on the law, claims that the Decalogue is abolished, efforts to shift the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first, and reasonings that turn breaking bread on the first day into grounds for setting aside the fourth commandment.RH Nov 2, 1911ST Jul 1, 1886 Until the new covenant writes the law in the heart this opposition keeps breaking out in various forms, and it is the difficult objection behind much resistance to the true Lord's day, an objection only the holder can settle, although not everyone who opposes the Sabbath does so from this mind.ST Jun 26, 1893ST Jul 1, 1886
No one without experimental knowledge of divine power creating a new heart can truly keep the Sabbath or obey any other precept, for true observance requires sin banished from the heart and the soul born again and re-created, with the weekly Sabbath remaining as memorial of new creation as well as first creation.ST Oct 31, 1900RH Mar 4, 1909 A person must be converted and rid of the carnal mind before keeping the Sabbath holy, since no one ruled by that mind can keep it holy, and resistance to the commandments is evidence of hostility and denial of the faith of Jesus.RH Dec 4, 1860RH Mar 4, 1909 To be carnally minded is death, and claims that obedience to the fourth commandment is impossible wrongly portray God as requiring what cannot be done with help from above.RH Dec 4, 1860RH Mar 13, 1856 Disregard and nullification of the fourth commandment even by professed Christians preaching Jesus is evidence of this hostility, and worship prompted by the flesh is unacceptable to God even when earnest, with outward keeping apart from a sanctified mind becoming drudgery without benefit.RH Aug 7, 1860ST Aug 27, 1894
Refusal to obey the law including the Sabbath commandment reveals the hostile mind that neither submits nor can submit, in contrast to deliverance through the Spirit of life in Christ giving power to obey.RH Jan 1851RH Mar 13, 1856 Those who do not love God enough to keep His holy Sabbath, who turn away with contempt from Sabbath truth and close their eyes so as not to see it, display the mind hostile toward God and unable to obey His law.RH Dec 4, 1860RH May 23, 1854 That inability explains making void the law and fighting the truth by refusing to leave Sunday to keep the Lord's Sabbath.RH Feb 7, 1854 Holding back even when convinced, clinging to Sunday, and resisting light show the same condition.RH Oct 7, 1851RH Feb 7, 1854
Opposition to the law comes not from grace, forgiveness, or loyalty to Christ but from the carnal mind, and when that mind dies Christ gives a new heart and life that loves the law and delights in the commandments.ST Jul 16, 1912ST Jun 12, 1907 Railing against the law, teaching its abolition, declaring freedom from obligation, delighting in what it forbids, or claiming justification while opposing it is that mind showing enmity and inability to be subject, and such teaching verifies the verse.ST Oct 16, 1901ST Dec 27, 1905 Those who oppose the law in this way are already condemned by it and need converting rather than condemning, for resistance and efforts to release people from duty grow out of the natural bent of the heart.ST Oct 16, 1901ST Dec 27, 1905 The ten commandments having ceased of obligation so that the seventh-day Sabbath is abolished was taught by those who held that the only law ever requiring it had given place to another law.RH Jan 31, 1854
The New Testament church fulfills the righteousness of the law, that is, practices the right doing the law requires, and such a church obeys the fourth commandment including the Sabbath.RH May 5, 1874ST Jul 8, 1880 When Christ dwells and works through the Spirit, people can obey the divine law including its Sabbath precept, with the law's righteousness fulfilled in those who live by the Spirit.ST Jul 26, 1905ST Mar 28, 1906 No one can become subject to the law until the new heart replaces the old, renewed by the new spirit to become like Christ's mind in loving obedience, and through faith in Jesus the carnal mind gives way to a spiritual mind in harmony with the law, so that Gentiles who keep it are converted believers not persons exempt from it.ST Mar 28, 1906ST Sep 27, 1910 The passage stands among New Testament teachings that God's law remains permanent and unchanged.RH Feb 17, 1852
At creation the seventh-day Sabbath was built into human nature, but sinning against the law destroyed that inward harmony and left man carnal and hostile and unable to submit.STST Apr 29, 1903 True conversion turns man from carnal to spiritual, brings peace with God and harmony with His law, so the Sabbath is built into his nature again as he shares the divine nature, and redemption brings him back to where he stood before the fall.ST Apr 29, 1903ST Jun 26, 1884 When a person joins God's people through Christ the carnal mind gives way to a spiritual mind that delights in the law and makes the Sabbath a delight and a sign of new creation, and those whose hearts have become obedient honor it as holy to the Lord.ST Jun 26, 1884RH Jul 7, 1859 The Sabbath was given to Adam as head of the race and made for all mankind and intended for the righteous people of God, reconciled by God's purpose of righteousness for all, since no sinner as such could keep the day holy as required.ST
Only those experiencing conversion can keep God's law, so human laws cannot enforce it or make people truly observe the Sabbath, and the law being spiritual remains the standard of right yet cannot make a carnal person do right.RH Aug 17, 1905ST Jun 20, 1900 People in the flesh cannot become righteous merely through law enforcement or outward displays, but only those born of the Spirit can be righteous.RH Aug 17, 1905 Because the law of God is spiritual no human power can administer it over a sinful people, so no earthly government can rule by the commandments and the faith of Jesus nor construct a Christian nation by civil law; only God makes such a people by writing His law in hearts and ruling by a solely spiritual government.ST Aug 3, 1904 Any effort to compel sinners to observe the Sabbath attempts to force what God has declared impossible, with civil enforcement of Sunday observance absurdly impossible and enforcement of real observance on the real Sabbath also impossible, and a heart at enmity gains no benefit from outward observance.ST Oct 31, 1900RH Aug 17, 1905
This enmity explains why those ruled by pride, covetousness, and pleasure oppose keepers of God's law, resist light, and slander proclaimers of truth.RH Aug 7, 1866RH Oct 7, 1851 Rejecting the written Sabbath law in favor of human tradition exemplifies hostility, placing the Lord's Sabbath beneath human observance, which is not mere unwritten custom but refusal of God's law.ST Jan 22, 1902ST Jun 28, 1883 Failure to live by light received comes from the same resistance, though conscience still witnesses to right and wrong.ST Jul 22, 1889
The mind that treats carrying the mail on the Sabbath as acceptable follows opposition to God's law.RH Sep 11, 1856 Refusing to hire people to break the Sabbath is not the same as forcing them to observe it.RH Sep 11, 1856
Obedient Life and Warnings
Walking after the Spirit fulfills what the law calls for, bringing freedom from condemnation into rest, happiness, perfect peace and ever-increasing joy through complete submission to Christ's teaching, power and life.ST May 20, 1908ST Sep 9, 1913ST Nov 28, 1892ST Jul 3, 1893 The fleshly mind seeks happiness from appetites, ambitions and passions and finds only disappointment, while the Spirit-led life brings life and peace because the law, weak through the flesh and unable to give perfection or strength to overcome, is met when God sent His Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and condemned sin in the flesh.ST May 20, 1908ST Nov 28, 1892ST Jun 12, 1879 Change of heart and mind is necessary before obedience is possible, for through faith the mind receives the Spirit who leads into obedience, writes the law in the heart, moves the heart to love it, and puts to death the deeds of the body.ST Sep 9, 1913ST Nov 28, 1892ST Jul 3, 1893ST Jun 12, 1879
Deliverance is present freedom from transgression in this life, not freedom to break the law, for serving sin is obeying sin's law while serving God is keeping His law.ST Oct 19, 1888ST May 15, 1884ST Apr 12, 1899RH Mar 8, 1864 The carnal nature as the old man of sin and first husband must die and be crucified with Christ so the body of sin is destroyed, and being married to Christ frees from sin's bondage rather than from obedience.ST Oct 19, 1888ST May 15, 1884RH Mar 8, 1864 Christ does not free from the law's requirements but from sin's bondage and the carnal mind, rescuing from condemnation under the new covenant by making the law part of the being, and misusing liberty to transgress brings into bondage again.ST Apr 12, 1899ST Aug 19, 1886ST Mar 6, 1879
Conversion brings into harmony with God's character by learning to love His law, meditating on it and finding His commandments not grievous, as saints in all ages have delighted in it.ST May 20, 1908ST Jun 12, 1884ST Mar 25, 1889RH Sep 25, 1913 The unrenewed natural mind is itself enmity, so its opposition to the law is opposition to God whose character the law expresses, and its actions cannot be accepted as service because source and motive are wrong.ST Sep 14, 1882RH Sep 25, 1913 Those in whom the Spirit dwells are not in the flesh but belong to Christ, and the Spirit of the Son leads to love for the Father shown by keeping His commandments, with Christ's complete submission to the Father's law removing the enmity.ST Jun 12, 1884ST Mar 25, 1889RH Sep 25, 1913
Unwillingness to obey any part reveals a sinful heart, for a right heart welcomes requirements rather than finding them burdensome, and rejection of the Ten Commandments is refusal of allegiance.RH Mar 8, 1870ST Sep 16, 1880ST Feb 4, 1886 Outward keeping of most commands is not obedience if one command is rejected from prejudice, pride or fashion, for to such a mind requirements appear arbitrary and impossible.ST Feb 12, 1902RH Sep 2, 1852 Hatred in the heart shows the law of love absent, and following own will and feelings while offering what God has not required and withholding what He commanded is will-worship that leaves the mind vainly puffed up instead of worship in spirit.RH Sep 2, 1852ST Mar 11, 1886
A worldly mind is an enemy of God opposed to obedience, having the spirit of the world which is carnal-mindedness leading to death, while having Christ's Spirit leads to life and peace.ST Dec 3, 1874RH Sep 17, 1857 Seeking gratification of that mind through irreligious stories and novels harms spiritual life, and indulging tobacco by chewing or smoking shows the carnal mind unremoved.RH May 20, 1858 Worldly desires that make entertainments attractive cannot please God or bring to Christ, and bringing forth fruit unto self turns the heart to other gods through licentious pleasure and selfish gratification, proving none can serve both God and mammon.ST Feb 2, 1882ST Jan 30, 1901
Sinful deeds evidence inward disposition as fruit reveals a tree, for the depraved heart hostile to God and unable to submit produces selfish longings, passions and desires that must be put away.ST Feb 11, 1889RH Oct 9, 1856 Carnal appetite allowed to rule leads to death, so lust must be resisted by refusing sin rule over the body, making no provision for fleshly desires and crucifying the flesh with its affections to become new creatures growing in grace.RH Oct 9, 1856ST Apr 5, 1899 Knowingly keeping what is owed remains governed by the carnal mind, coveting the neighbor's goods and violating the law, with neglect not canceling the claim.RH Sep 25, 1856 Anger without cause is fruit of carnality and enmity already in the law, blinded by fleshly desires to minute moral precepts, and a heart in that condition cannot forgive, for mercy requires regeneration and childlike trustful obedience through new birth to enter the kingdom.ST Sep 11, 1893ST May 25, 1915ST Apr 5, 1899
Victory requires mortifying deeds of the body, receiving the Spirit of adoption, and waiting for redemption of the body.RH Mar 22, 1864 The old man ruling in selfishness, pride, envy, jealousy, resistance to reproof and ungoverned appetite and passion must be renewed by grace, surrendered and denied, crucified and put to death through the new birth by the Spirit.ST Apr 14, 1881RH Nov 22, 1906ST Apr 7, 1881 The carnal mind must be crucified through obedience after the pattern of Christ who kept the Father's commandments, since the perfect broad law converts the soul.RH Feb 10, 1859 Emancipation comes by casting down imaginations and bringing every thought captive to Christ's obedience, learning to hate evil imaginations, replacing the carnal mind with Christ's mind into glorious liberty from all that debases and freedom in all noble, pure and everlasting.ST Aug 27, 1902
Close friendship with those without converting grace conflicts with loving God and delighting in what pleases Him, because the law is to be written in the heart and only the Spirit can make that change.RH Jul 30, 1867ST Jul 8, 1889 One still having the hostile disobedient mind is an opposing influence, so a believer free to choose imperils salvation by close life-union with such a person, and in an unbelieving spouse unchanged desires let worldly interests outweigh faith beyond what promises to support worship can overcome.RH Jan 22, 1867RH Mar 2, 1911
The fleshly mind neither submits to God's law nor can do so, and this innate selfishness of greed, ambition, passion and lust for power is why laws and political changes cannot transform the heart and why the same injustices continue.ST Nov 21, 1911RH Jan 27, 1916 The root of anarchy is the rebellious turbulent carnal mind not subject to the Decalogue as the constitution of God's government, making every follower of his own way an anarchist toward God, lawless and self-enthroned, dethroning God and breaking down respect for law even when not openly active.ST Oct 9, 1901RH Feb 13, 1913 Roots of crime lie in this condition, curable only by the gospel bringing harmony with law through faith to overcome sin and live righteously, while fallen men unable to be governed by love require human law and government as temporary necessity to enforce doing no ill and secure measure of peace.ST May 5, 1909ST Jul 6, 1904ST Mar 29, 1905 Regeneration in which Christ's mind displaces the carnal mind into willing complete submission is true liberty and the cure, to be fully realized when ideals blocked by the perverse heart are reached at Christ's second coming with sin destroyed, though the gospel changes people now.RH Feb 13, 1913ST Jul 21, 1914
Each reader must face whether his own mind is carnal, for resistance to the law reveals natural carnality and need of conversion, since the unconverted heart loves neither the law nor its Author.ST May 28, 1894RH Apr 20, 1869ST Nov 11, 1875 Escape from hostility ending in death into life and peace requires a created clean heart and renewed right spirit, receiving Christ's mind, being led as sons and joint-heirs, putting on the new man in righteousness and holiness, with prayer heard only when the ear is open to the law.ST Jan 23, 1901 Sin-sick refusal of Christ's humiliating terms shows the hostility, for confession is bitter to the carnal mind as pleading guilty to breaking law and suing for pardon, yet confessing and forsaking is essential to mercy and life.ST Dec 1, 1898 Redemption saves from sin and hostility, not from obedience, raising to love and obey with cheerful obedience as evidence of His Spirit, while rejecting light despite professing devotion treads underfoot what Christ honored.ST Nov 11, 1875ST Oct 25, 1877
The verse tests possession of Christ's Spirit in public life, requiring obedient action rather than setting righteousness aside for expediency, compromising conviction or following worldly leaders, for the carnal mind controlling worldly times makes Christ's teachings seem incompatible with political life as with Pharisees, Sadducees and the Dark Ages, yet full surrender gives transforming life in which they fit.ST Sep 2, 1897ST Apr 26, 1905 Carnal-minded students cannot truly progress in Christian education and exert evil influence, so conversion is its foundation, requiring daily self-denial, cross-bearing and following Jesus against inclination that would silence conviction.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Feb 10, 1904 Resistance that refuses to deny appetite also refuses bodily laws of health even when self-denial is required, for the unrenewed mind is hostile to all good including good food and pure drink and must be made new creation with new tastes rather than merely reformed, lest like Israel it turn back to Egypt's fleshpots and loathe manna.RH Jul 4, 1865RH Sep 23, 1902RH Nov 3, 1868 When laws are put in mind and heart with God dwelling within, keeping them becomes delight, self-denial ceases as hardship, and reforms in eating, drinking and living are taken cheerfully, though beneath present crossing lies the crown.RH Sep 23, 1902RH Nov 3, 1868
Spiritual decline may come not by deliberate rush into sin but by neglecting worship and the sanctuary till devotion fades and the grieved Spirit leaves room for sin unto darkness and death.ST Sep 12, 1895 A carnal motive being enmity, singing to please it opposes devotion, while songs from loving hearts uplift.RH Aug 11, 1859 One professing faith while carnally minded chills a young convert's first love and damages God's begun work.RH Apr 12, 1864 Careful skillful work is needed to present truth to hostile minds, and religious retirement helps lift the heart above worldly drawing into carnal nature to keep hopes active.RH Sep 1, 1910RH Dec 12, 1854
Claimants to sanctification who turn from hearing the law prove carnal hearts and children of disobedience, repeating Satan's false claim of exalted sanctification while corrupting others, and God will not accept willfully imperfect service, with protection only by living by every word.RH Sep 3, 1901 A heart at enmity proves absence of true sanctification, so those claiming perfection while refusing perfect obedience and promise conditions are self-deceived and self-righteous expecting blessing promised only to the obedient, becoming false lights deceiving others into disregard and teaching unpunished transgression under Satan as when Adam and Eve were led to disregard God's word and fail the test.RH Sep 3, 1901 Church fundraising devised by carnal minds in feasts, games, lotteries and amusements appealing to appetite and worldly desire is not made acceptable by church name or use of proceeds.ST Nov 28, 1878 The carnal heart finds thorough confession difficult, so its resistance must be subdued and the mind renewed.RH Apr 21, 1859 Overcoming this opposed mind that drags character in dust and leaves inability to stand in battle must be abandoned with time past enough, the old man crucified and new man appearing to rise, advance at all risk to higher standard and readiness for the kingdom.RH Aug 7, 1855RH Feb 4, 1873
Further points
The carnal mind described is hostile to God and unable to submit to His law.RH Jan 8, 1901 The cross offends that mind, as does the need to be saved by another.RH Jan 8, 1901 Pride drives the desire for people to be their own saviors.RH Jan 8, 1901 Claimed independence from God does not bring freedom but leaves a person enslaved to evil principles and lawless passions.RH Jan 8, 1901
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
The fall perverted nature, marred God's image and the inward copy of the law, subjected the mind to the flesh, and left humanity guilty in standing and corrupt in disposition, enslaved, ruled by sin and dead in sin.ST May 31, 1899RH Mar 10, 1904ST Nov 15, 1910ST Jun 8, 1915ST Feb 3, 1914 Before renewal the mind is carnal and hostile, with a downward pull away from God unless consciously resisted, and the spiritual mind that had ruled was lost leaving only the mind of the flesh expressed in carnal ordinances relying on human effort.ST May 31, 1899RH Mar 10, 1904ST Jun 8, 1915ST Feb 3, 1914ST Nov 7, 1900 After Adam transgressed, sin became incarnate and physical nature came under a perverted law of sin working against God's law of righteousness, so mind, soul and affections are by nature in harmony with sin, and this fallen life passed to all mankind who receive only what Adam had to give and are doomed to death.ST Nov 15, 1910ST Feb 3, 1914ST Nov 7, 1900
The carnal mind is self, the flesh, the old man, the body of sin and the first husband, a ruling power when yielded to, Satan's personal representative in every heart and a mind received from the serpent, opposed to Christ.ST Apr 12, 1883STST May 6, 1897RH Nov 22, 1906 A person is not carnally minded merely because temptation arises but when he yields and willingly follows the flesh, and its self-will disregards God's authority and would replace His will if given full sway, so acts from it are rebellion unacceptable to God.ST Apr 12, 1883ST May 6, 1897RH Mar 19, 1872 Being united to it is what makes a person a sinner, and because it cannot be reformed or made obedient it must be surrendered, denied, crucified, slain, put off and put to death, that the body of sin be done away and bondage end through daily death by being crucified with Christ.STST May 6, 1897RH Nov 22, 1906RH Mar 19, 1872
Its affections are fixed on created things and the passing world rather than on God who is spirit and unseen, on self, appetites, ambitions, passions, pleasure, mammon, pride, covetousness and self-glory rather than God's glory.ST Jul 19, 1883ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 10, 1874RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 27, 1901 Since the law requires supreme love for Him, a mind wholly set elsewhere cannot submit to it, and preferring the creature to the Creator carries the guilt of idolatry.ST Jul 19, 1883ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 10, 1874 This selfish spirit is the minding of the flesh and being in the flesh, in direct contrast to disinterested benevolence originating in the Father and Christ, and God's Spirit never bears witness with a heart controlled by selfish motives.ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 10, 1874RH Aug 7, 1866
It is the same in every age and place, explaining opposition to prophets, Christ, apostles and later persecutions, and it will continue until Christ destroys wickedness.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 27, 1901ST Jul 15, 1875ST Mar 29, 1905 Those ruled by pride, covetousness and pleasure oppose law-keepers, resist reproof as ancient opposers did, resent the law for condemning them, and cannot please God whether in one location or another.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 27, 1901ST Jul 15, 1875ST Mar 29, 1905 Confronted by Christ's pure, lofty piety and uncompromising holiness exposing rebellion, rebellious hearts desire their own inclinations as the antediluvians did and turn against the light because the path requires a cross.ST Jan 28, 1897ST Nov 27, 1901
Sin is natural to fallen flesh though not created by God, belonging to condition as well as deeds, perverting judgment, blinding to truth and making heavenly things repulsive.RH May 27, 1873ST Nov 25, 1908RH Apr 16, 1867 That sinful promptings feel natural gives no excuse for sin, for sin distorts judgment so wrong seems right and the law seems wrong, weakening mind, dulling feeling, hardening conscience, fostering unbelief and degrading physically, mentally and morally.RH May 27, 1873RH Apr 16, 1867ST Oct 15, 1894 Human nature was perverted by yielding to sin when humanity chose it, and this spiritual power works in every heart producing hatred and blindness overcome only by Jesus, through whom people may renounce their ways, receive a new nature and partake of the divine nature.ST Nov 25, 1908ST Oct 15, 1894
Outward restraint, knowledge, profession or morality without renewal does not change it, and the natural mind cannot receive spiritual things or understand Scripture without the Spirit.RH Jun 26, 1900RH Aug 25, 1868ST Aug 7, 1893ST Feb 17, 1904ST Jul 3, 1893 Left to itself the mind's strongest passions and thoughts remain human and sinful, and a corrupt heart remains dangerous even when richly developed in knowledge because learning without moral correction can be turned to evil.RH Jun 26, 1900RH Aug 25, 1868ST Aug 7, 1893ST Aug 25, 1909 The carnal person is as one dead to spiritual things, finds heaven's purity repulsive while following desires of flesh and mind, and needs the Spirit to enlighten the mind to understand the seriousness of what the deeply spiritual law forbids.ST Aug 7, 1893ST Feb 17, 1904ST Jul 3, 1893ST Aug 25, 1909
It cannot please God, do good, produce good fruit or attain charity by itself, and even seemingly good acts from selfish motive are sinful and unacceptable because source and motive are wrong.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Aug 29, 1895RH Jun 30, 1859ST Mar 2, 1904 The natural, unrenewed, unconverted person is itself enmity expressing complete opposition to Him, and since His law is in harmony with Him opposition to the law is opposition to God.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Aug 29, 1895ST Jun 12, 1884 Without Christ's aid people cannot obey acceptably, for only those in whom God's Spirit dwells are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, and the Spirit and the law are in perfect harmony so that the law's righteousness is fulfilled in Spirit-walkers whose love shown by keeping commandments proves enmity gone.ST Aug 29, 1895RH Jun 30, 1859ST Jun 12, 1884
The law governing sinful character is opposed to the law governing righteous character, for sinful nature is opposed to God's plans and purposes.RH Nov 17, 1874ST Aug 26, 1875 The carnal mind is the law of sin in the flesh, the other law in the members, entirely distinct from and contrary to God's law as flesh has been since Adam's fall, warring against the law the inward man loves and serves with the mind.RH Nov 17, 1874ST Aug 26, 1875 God's law is holy, just, good and spiritual while in the flesh dwells no good thing, and faith in Christ through the law of the Spirit of life frees from the carnal law so the heart delights in God's law and its righteousness is fulfilled.RH Nov 17, 1874ST Aug 26, 1875
When sin possesses a person the body belongs to God by right but God has departed because He will not share rule with the enemy, and yielding the body to God's foes identifies the person with that enemy in practice.ST Jan 22, 1902RH Jan 28, 1902 Sin takes the place belonging to God, enslaving the will and driving away His indwelling presence, leaving the mind carnal, hostile and unable to submit.ST Jan 22, 1902RH Jan 28, 1902 A wicked or unconverted priest has this carnal mind, which ordination and baptism do not change or confer grace to remove, so he remains under Satan's power and control.ST Jan 16, 1896RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 24, 1900 Because he cannot discern spiritual things or truth he cannot know who are sinners or rightly remit sin and bind in heaven and earth, and God rejects such assemblies, for outward profession without conversion is not true faith, God's righteousness by faith, or Christ's mind.ST Jan 16, 1896RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 24, 1900RH Jul 16, 1861
Human sin is real and not merely imputed, for people are not all personally guilty of Adam's specific act but their own sins also violate God's law.RH Feb 17, 1859 The nations belong to the world ruled by the flesh and are left out of the measuring of the temple because no earthly power can meet judgment righteousness, since the flesh-ruled mind is hostile and cannot submit and belongs to this world not the world to come.ST Jun 8, 1904 The holier the truth the more carnal minds oppose it, hating even its tenderly preached messenger, conceding its truth yet refusing practice and despising it.RH Apr 30, 1857ST Jul 22, 1889ST Oct 7, 1875ST Jun 17, 1889ST May 30, 1895 Conscience may witness to right and wrong but the carnal mind resists obedience, evades self-condemnation, mistakes absence of outward crime restrained by fear and love of approval for virtue, and holds truth in unrighteousness while destitute of love for moral principles it honors in others.ST Jul 22, 1889ST Oct 7, 1875ST May 30, 1895
Serving the carnal mind is service to sin, and giving strength and best years to sin is ingratitude.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Jun 10, 1880RH Jul 19, 1870 Counterfeit worldly pleasures appeal to the natural person who regards God's Spirit's things as foolish, though temporary and ending in pain, and turning to God only at life's end after spending life for flesh wastes God-given strength in selfishness and treats the Saviour's blood with contempt.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Jun 10, 1880RH Jul 19, 1870 The natural heart not subject to God's law explains why the majority have been arrayed against God and why the voice of the people is not the voice of God.ST Jul 15, 1889 Transgression made every mind carnal so it cannot submit, and since the law measures God's glory no carnal keeping can attain it, for even future perfect keeping would be only duty while past guilt remains, much less can it atone for past sins.ST Jul 15, 1889ST Sep 29, 1898
The fallen mind at war with God is shown in idolatry, superstition and pagan abominations, which are stages of apostasy and not innocent or uninstructed worship.ST Dec 22, 1887 Heathen rites are not childlike sincere attempts, crude rites of infancy of knowledge, or involuntary ignorance, but successive degradation, utterances of alienated hearts suppressing the light of nature from heavens, creation, providence and soul, becoming vain with darkened hearts, changing His glory into images and His truth into a lie to worship creature more than Creator.ST Dec 22, 1887 The impure selfish mind ruled by disobedience is unfit for holy companionship and heaven, finding no joy there and shrinking from God's presence, so exclusion is from unfitness not unwillingness to receive.ST Dec 22, 1887ST Nov 18, 1897
All are born aliens from God with the violated law barring kingdom citizenship, becoming citizens only by accepting Christ's mediation as propitiation for past alienation and vowing future obedience, made nigh by His blood.ST Jan 17, 1906 This carnal law-breaking state makes the unconverted aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and reconciliation comes only through His merits with allegiance to the law.ST Jan 17, 1906 Human dignity and God's fatherhood cannot be rightly affirmed while rejecting humanity's sinfulness and need for divine grace and renewal.ST Jan 17, 1906ST Feb 17, 1881 A religion of the flesh is earthly rather than heavenly, lacking the spirit and life of true religion and leaving people without God's light and truth.ST Feb 17, 1881ST Oct 10, 1878
The carnal mind holds a person bound so evil thoughts run riot despite efforts, with the will powerless to keep thoughts pure or hold concentration without evil thoughts intruding and carrying it to shameful things.ST Dec 1, 1898 Wealth and poverty do not make the heart right, for the carnal mind is hostile whether rich or poor, while giving the heart to God makes riches a stewardship and rich and poor rich toward God by the Spirit of Jesus.ST Dec 1, 1898ST Jul 24, 1901 The carnal mind by nature chooses hell so sinners placed in paradise would turn it into hell, meaning hell is not God's fault but giving the wicked their choice with death added to make it more tolerable.ST Jul 24, 1901RH Sep 10, 1901
The carnal mind is the state of those led captive by Satan who mock the firm in faith and make God's commandments of no effect by tradition, in contrast to those offering themselves as living sacrifices who stand on apostles and prophets with Christ as cornerstone and keep His commandments for right to the tree of life.RH Jun 23, 1859 Elements in every heart war against God and must be softened by God's Spirit, and where not subdued they appear openly as self-worship claiming divinity within and making the self into God.RH Jun 23, 1859ST Nov 19, 1902 That self-worship is not mere selfishness but worshiping supposed divinity, good and God within, claiming for finite man all attributes of the Infinite and making the I into God.ST Nov 19, 1902
Ground of Hostility
The hostility lies entirely on the human side, for God is not at war with people but every sinful person is at war with God through a selfish fleshly mind hostile to Him and unable to obey His law.ST Sep 29, 1898ST Feb 14, 1911ST Feb 27, 1896 God is love and loves even sinners, giving His only Son to die for them while they were still enemies and reconciling the world to Himself in Christ without holding their sins against them.ST Oct 26, 1904ST Feb 27, 1896 God cannot come into harmony with that mind, for to do so would deny His own nature as God and goodness and would be the greatest evil in the universe.ST Sep 29, 1898 Peace therefore cannot come by God changing or compromising, but only by the transgressor surrendering to God, giving up sin and self and receiving through Jesus Christ reconciliation, spotless righteousness, cleansing, fulness and rest.ST Sep 29, 1898ST Oct 15, 1902 Christ abolished this enmity in His flesh by taking away sin, not by abolishing or changing the Ten Commandments, and if the rebellious heart will not give up sin but retains enmity, fierce carnal strife follows as the sinner wars against God and His children and against his own flesh and blood.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Nov 11, 1897
Opposition to the moral law is opposition to God, and opposition to God is opposition to the law, for the law is in harmony with God and expresses His character.ST Sep 14, 1882 The natural unrenewed person is itself enmity against God, so rejection of the Ten Commandments is refusal of allegiance to the rightful universal Ruler whose law reaches motives as well as actions, placing people in rebellion with no neutral ground.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Nov 15, 1883ST Feb 4, 1886 Following the carnal mind is being out of harmony with God, which is sin as missing the mark God has set, going out of God's way, transgressing His holy law and coming short of His glory, and it is the primal cause of unrest and strife, the opposite of peace.ST Dec 29, 1909 Its actions cannot be accepted as service to God because their source and underlying motive are wrong.ST Sep 14, 1882
The inability is absolute while carnal, because God's law is spiritual while fallen flesh is carnal and the two cannot harmonize.ST Dec 4, 1893RH Aug 20, 1872ST Mar 7, 1906 The flesh never becomes converted and its hostility remains, but a person led by Christ's Spirit is no longer under its power and can be subject to God's law.ST Apr 30, 1896 Affections fixed on created things and the passing world rather than on the unseen God cannot submit to a law requiring supreme love for Him, and preferring the creature to the Creator carries the guilt of idolatry.ST Jul 19, 1883 Insubordination to God's law is the cause of man's alienation, for the law is the great rule of action that condemns man and by which he is to be tried.ST Mar 18, 1875 The carnal mind stands in the way of keeping the law until it is taken away, which happens only through Christ by humbly confessing sin to find pardon, having the carnal heart removed, and being converted.RH Aug 20, 1872
The rebellion is in the human mind and will, not in matter, for the body obeys the human mind.ST Sep 15, 1909ST Sep 22, 1909 God addresses the human mind and calls it to direct the body rightly, so when a person uses the body for evil the mind is responsible for that disobedience.ST Sep 15, 1909 The carnal mind resists God's will and the flesh can disobey the Spirit's direction, and this conflict continues while God does not override human free will.ST Sep 22, 1909 It is the source of human sin and responsibility.ST Sep 22, 1909
The fault lies not in God or the law but in the heart that resists it.RH Sep 11, 1856ST Oct 15, 1902 The law is holy, good, righteous, just and spiritual, ordained for life but made death by man, and it is not grievous, arbitrary, unjust, too demanding, or a yoke of bondage except to the resisting mind.RH Sep 11, 1856ST Oct 15, 1902RH Mar 22, 1864RH Jun 24, 1852 Those freed from the law of sin and death fulfill the righteousness of the law by being brought into obedience to it, while those who give up the Sabbath and oppose the commandments show the carnal mind's hostility.RH Jun 28, 1870 The contrast with spiritual-mindedness links submission to God's law with life and peace, and the law is not bondage to those who love and seek it.RH Mar 22, 1864
This hostility darkens understanding and biases conclusions against the law's righteousness, so that natural selfish dispositions favor conclusions that do not agree with what is holy, just and good and are unlikely to err in favor of God's law.ST May 27, 1908ST Oct 16, 1884 It makes truth seem false, leads to unbelief, doubt and inventions to evade duty, and underlies loss of faith in the Bible and the law even among professing Christians.ST May 27, 1908ST May 24, 1905 Because heavenly principles of unpopular truth conflict with every wrong habit and sinful desire, few have moral courage to stand for truth, since accepting and obeying it requires denying self, bearing the cross daily and following Jesus.ST Feb 24, 1887 Resistance can lead people to stifle conscience and become falsely at ease in sin at the cost of peace with God and eternal life, and turning away from God's Word leaves people open to deception as they act and speak against it.ST May 24, 1905
The enmity shows itself in hatred of what condemns loved sin, in seeking to break the divine mirror that shows defects and filth, and in opposing those who keep God's law from motives of pride, covetousness and pleasure.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Aug 7, 1866 In the old man it rules the life and appears in selfishness, pride, envy, jealousy, resistance to reproof, failure to govern appetites and passions, anger, strife, faultfinding, love of worldly pleasures, and calling good evil.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Apr 14, 1881 This explains why people who follow natural inclinations resisted the ancient prophets and rejected Christ's reproofs, for human nature remains the same across generations. Anyone living for the flesh's pleasures, desires and lusts and seeking self's good rather than God's glory cannot please God, but is God's enemy at war with Him.ST Nov 27, 1901 The person who longs for holiness yields to what condemns him and forsakes sin, washed in the blood, life and righteousness of Jesus Christ and walking in Christ's strength in the law as the perfect law of liberty.ST Jan 30, 1901
To remain carnally minded is death, corruption and rebellion ending in ruin and second death unless forsaken, and the carnal nature must die because freedom from sin requires release from its rule.ST Sep 16, 1880ST Oct 19, 1888RH Aug 15, 1907 Serving sin means obeying sin's law while serving God means keeping His law, and Christ brings this present salvation as freedom from sin's bondage in this life and harmony with God's law, not merely hope of eternal life.ST Oct 19, 1888 A person unwilling to obey any part of the law has a sinful heart, while a right heart welcomes God's requirements rather than finding them burdensome.ST Sep 16, 1880 The mind must be renewed and kept pure through God's Word and help and reconciled to God through His Son, for when people reject God's word and yield to the flesh they are cut off from spiritual life and remain subject to sin and death until Christ brings the Spirit's mind and restores access to God's life through His received word.RH Aug 15, 1907 The exchange for a spiritual mind of life and peace, with the human will completely subdued to God's will, is urgent amid thickening last-day perils, deceptions, signs and lying wonders, and it is a free glorious gift through Jesus Christ to everyone who humbly submits.RH Nov 6, 1856
Only the carnal mind is at enmity with God's law while the spiritual mind is in harmony with it, so rejecters stand with the overthrower of heaven's government and upholders relying on Christ's merits stand with heaven with no neutral ground.ST Jan 25, 1905RH Jun 21, 1870 When the carnal mind is taken away hostility and opposition cease, and those who walk after the Spirit are brought into submission and harmony with the spiritual law, for freedom from sin is harmony with the law restored through Christ.RH Jun 21, 1870 Transgression makes people sinners and separates them from God and His requirements, so reconciliation requires becoming once more in harmony with God's law.RH Sep 21, 1905 Denial that the carnal mind is not subject to the law and strenuous effort to set it aside marks the carnally minded class, in contrast to the converted condition delighting in the law with the law in the heart ensuring future obedience.RH Mar 25, 1873 Spiritual life and fleshly hostility remain in necessary antagonism and cannot combine, so wherever opposition to the law appears there is fleshly hostility with no genuine repentance or true conversion, and teaching the law abolished while its principles remain opens the door to the license that hostile mind enjoys.RH Mar 4, 1873 Only the carnal heart refuses the new covenant putting the Ten Commandment law in the heart so it becomes part of the person in Christ Jesus.ST May 21, 1896
While man remains at enmity God and man cannot work together to accomplish God's purpose, for working with God requires unity of desire and purpose.ST Dec 30, 1903 The one carrying the message must be submissive to the will of the One who has the message to give, and the one using power must use it in harmony with the will of the One who has power to bestow, or that power cannot be entrusted to him.ST Dec 30, 1903 Following Christ means setting up no standards of one's own but staying in the one way He established straight to the kingdom, because outside that way lies only a bewildering maze leading to darkness, ruin and destruction, whereas happiness and peace are found in obedience to His law.ST Aug 29, 1911ST Dec 30, 1903 The carnal heart is at enmity with the pure principles of the Word of truth, so the Bible cannot be submitted to the test of human judgment like ordinary current literature without failing.RH Jun 23, 1910
The natural heart's enmity may be concealed in indifference without conscious hatred, remaining dormant when God is not truly considered or is imagined without His real character and claims.ST Jul 19, 1883 When God is seen as He is, holy, just and requiring the affections and pursuits of godliness, the conflict between natural desires and His demands becomes plain and reveals resistance to surrendering earthly affections and receiving new ones.ST Jul 19, 1883 A person may love his own natural conceptions of God as beneficent and powerful, but he cannot love God as holy, as the God who hates, punishes and destroys sin.ST Apr 8, 1875RH Dec 23, 1873 The proof is that when that God intrudes into thoughts through the day and hour it breaks peace and makes the heart recoil with the wish that there were no God, revealing hidden hatred where there seemed approval and love.ST Apr 8, 1875 Having lost God, the faculty of love gropes for other objects, concentrates love and worship on them, and puts the creature in place of the Creator.RH Dec 23, 1873
Sin in the heart is enmity even when hiding its real nature and presenting itself as righteousness, and the cross reveals this hostility where sin opposed, persecuted and killed Jesus who gave Himself so sin's true character would be seen.RH Dec 10, 1903 Recognizing that same hostile spirit at work toward one another leads to repentance, separation from sin, and reconciliation with God and with one another.RH Dec 10, 1903 The law's prohibitions can provoke the proud, impatient, rebellious nature, making forbidden things seem especially attractive to one who clings to sin and values sinful pleasures above God's favor.RH Oct 14, 1902 Such a person hates the law because it condemns loved sins and sees its restraints as bondage, and is unwilling to retain the knowledge of God's ways and requirements.ST Aug 7, 1884
Its opposition lies in thoughts, will and way out of harmony with God, bringing conflict, condemnation and unrest that human penance cannot relieve while the mind remains unsubject to His law. Separated from the Source of truth and under passion and sin, judgment is blinded so truth may appear false and falsehood true, leaving the mind unfit for the holiness and joy of heaven until the sinner yields to God and is renewed by the Spirit.RH Jul 6, 1916 A work upholding God's law cannot be attributed to the devil because the carnal mind cannot favor God's law.RH Sep 23, 1858 Actions arising from the unchanged heart are acts of rebellion disregarding God's authority and springing from self-will, which would replace God's will with its own if left unchecked.ST Nov 15, 1883
Resistance to God's word causes divisions and prevents unity, while willingness to hear and obey makes unity possible with all speaking the same thing, no divisions, perfectly joined in the same mind and judgment.ST Aug 19, 1880RH Jan 16, 1872 Resistance to the commandments and preference for human traditions prevent accepting truth and produce divisions among professed Christians.RH Jan 16, 1872ST Aug 19, 1880 A confederacy of sects letting each keep its errors is a confederacy of carnality, leaving civil power in carnal hands to legislate for God, which brings religious persecution, so those who love God and His truth must keep His word and stand aloof from it.RH Jan 16, 1872
Believing God's word requires greater effort than doubting it because the natural heart is hostile, so choosing doubt strengthens the tendency to doubt while obeying understood light and duties leads to greater understanding.ST Jun 8, 1882 Doubting God's Word and goodness itself transgresses the law, showing supposed superior knowledge that lowers His character and lifts the doubter above Him as judge.ST Jan 27, 1898 It sets human judgment against the mind and will of God in revolt against His government, putting another in God's place in violation of His law, while faith is measured by simplicity in submitting judgment to the expressed mind and will of Him who is over all.ST Jan 27, 1898 Stressing inability as waiting for God to change the nature can leave hearers delaying obedience.RH Jul 29, 1875 Waiting until a doctrine becomes popular or accepted by the majority before obeying it to preserve influence is a carnal-minded device refusing to follow God's truth and leading many to perdition.RH Jul 8, 1873
The enmity can be cured by kindness prayerfully and faithfully exercised, which can awaken goodness even in an obstinate self-willed heart.RH Dec 5, 1865 Rebellion is wrong, all have been guilty of it, and all must give it up to become loyal and obedient.RH Oct 10, 1865 The contrast between the sinner unmoved by truth and the person humbled at the cross illustrates the enmity, with grace bringing changed emotions and hopes displaying the beauty of holiness.RH Dec 9, 1862 Rebellion as opposition to His law causes false prophets to draw people from God and obedience, lulling sinners with assurance and peace when repentance is needed, building their own power, prestige and wealth, healing wounds only slightly, exalting corrupted imagination above the Word, withholding unpopular eternal truth, substituting their teachings and pagan lies for truth, leading to trust in man and the multitude, and crying peace and safety on the eve of destruction.ST Nov 10, 1898
The carnal mind expects a way unlike God's leading, which crosses the flesh and humbles the creature.RH Apr 19, 1864 Opposition to keeping the law can come from fear of losing worldly standing rather than God's favor, and God's mercy exposes this depravity and can lead the rebellious heart to acknowledge it.RH Jan 31, 1865 To the evil-disposed unbeliever with a hating rebellious heart the command to be doers of the Word is impossible cold law and terror, while to the yielding believing heart loving the law it is blessed promise and gospel power because Christ's command carries enabling power to make people what He requires.ST Nov 21, 1900 The hostile carnal mind has no place for saying Our Father in faith, but true address is a gift from Heaven transplanted by Christ into trustful pilgrims who submit to the Holy Spirit and learn meekness and lowliness from Him, possessed only by those not of the world.ST Jun 6, 1878RH Oct 22, 1872
Remedy in Christ
Release comes not by setting the law aside but by taking away the hostile mind through repentance toward God and faith in Christ who died to redeem, who intercedes to release from bondage, and who condemned sin in the flesh so that the righteousness called for in the law may be worked within those who walk after the Spirit in complete submission to His teaching, power and life into freedom from condemnation and ever-increasing joy and peace.ST Jul 22, 1913ST Aug 19, 1889ST May 20, 1908 The law by itself offers no hope to those enslaved to flesh and sin, and its exposure of sinners under just penalty shows salvation must come through the life and death of Jesus to cleanse and overcome sin.ST Jun 27, 1906 The sinner is helpless with no strength in himself to obey, change the heart, escape guilt or death, or overcome fixed habit, and neither education, culture, willpower nor civil law can cure, for only divine power from within through the new birth can transform the nature that produces only evil.ST Jul 22, 1913RH Nov 25, 1915ST Aug 6, 1894ST Feb 13, 1912RH Sep 24, 1857 Of ourselves nothing can be done without Christ, but all things can be done through Christ who strengthens.ST Jan 31, 1906
Conversion destroys, crucifies and puts to death the carnal mind and gives a new spiritual mind, the mind of Christ, through birth from above by water and Spirit with the Spirit dwelling within, turning earthly fleshly nature from the first Adam into childhood of the spiritual second Adam so that a person can please God, love Him supremely, possess true piety and delight in His commandments.ST Nov 1, 1899ST Jul 16, 1912ST Oct 7, 1886RH Feb 21, 1871 Growing in grace requires bringing the will under God's will so the carnal mind is destroyed and, as the spirit of the world is renounced, the Spirit of Christ is received.RH Aug 14, 1856 Christ took the same fallen flesh with all its tendencies toward sin, and where man failed in the mind He by the Spirit of God dwelling in Him by faith overthrew and abolished that enmity, crucified it in taking human flesh, and took away sin without abolishing or changing the Ten Commandments, so that His complete submission to the Father's law removes enmity and brings God and humanity into harmony for believers to conquer in Him.RH Sep 25, 1913ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jun 24, 1913ST Nov 11, 1897 He did not Himself have the carnal mind, but delighted to do His Father's will with God's law in His heart.ST Oct 21, 1889
The new covenant does not merely forgive past sins but removes the sinful disposition that would otherwise fall again into sin and condemnation, writing the same law in heart and mind so that obedience becomes nature and delight, peace with God takes the place of hostility, and the law's righteousness is fulfilled in Spirit-walkers.RH Oct 6, 1863ST May 27, 1908ST Sep 23, 1886ST Jul 22, 1889ST Mar 29, 1883 One sent as Christ's ambassador must himself first be converted and reconciled, with the law written by the living Spirit on fleshy tables of the heart and not merely known as ink or on stone, joined with thorough knowledge of God's government in His Word.ST Feb 28, 1906 Justification by faith gives peace with God, clothes with saving power, establishes the law in the believer's heart, and brings harmony with letter and spirit agreeing, so that those truly saved are saved from sin through faith and enabled to obey.ST Jul 8, 1886RH Oct 29, 1903RH Mar 6, 1916ST Feb 15, 1899 Fulfilling the law by the Spirit does not destroy it.RH Sep 30, 1852
Forgiveness alone would leave the hostile disposition to sin again, and change alone would leave past guilt to condemn in judgment; Christ therefore both freely forgives past sins so sinners stand justified and slays the enmity to make peace, willing submission and delight in the law.RH Oct 6, 1863ST Nov 22, 1883ST Jun 19, 1879ST Jun 1, 1882RH May 5, 1874 No one can keep all ten commandments without being a Christian, for inability while carnal is absolute and the spiritual law cannot be obeyed except through the Holy Spirit taking away the carnal mind, making men spiritually minded to discern duty, obey truth and be sanctified unto obedience.RH Aug 20, 1872ST Jan 11, 1877ST May 12, 1914ST Nov 28, 1892ST Sep 2, 1886 Through faith in Jesus the mind receives God's Spirit, which leads into obedience, fulfills the law's righteousness, moves the heart to love the law and brings peace, and the gospel thus forgives past neglect and places the sinner where he may do his duty.ST Jul 3, 1893 Perfect obedience to the law through faith constitutes perfect Christianity.RH Aug 20, 1872
Peace comes only by laying down rebellion, surrendering one's own will, way and affections, accepting cleansing and Christ's rule with nothing between sinner and God, for a mind ruled by flesh cannot work in harmony with God or carry out His purpose.RH Jan 16, 1908RH Aug 12, 1915ST Nov 19, 1885ST Jul 8, 1886ST Aug 9, 1899 The enmity is on man's side only while God is not at enmity, and Jesus came to destroy that enmity in the flesh and bring peace, though if the rebellious heart retains enmity fierce strife follows against God, His children and its own flesh.ST Feb 14, 1911 The spiritual mind by contrast delights in God's law and walks in His commandments, bearing the Spirit's fruits which agree with the law instead of doing the works of the flesh which condemn and exclude from the kingdom.ST Jul 29, 1889RH May 27, 1852ST Jan 16, 1893ST Mar 25, 1880 Those born of the flesh do the works of the flesh, while those in whom God's Spirit dwells are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, and whoever lacks Christ's Spirit is none of His.ST Sep 2, 1886ST Feb 7, 1906
The exchange of the carnal for the spiritual mind, with the human will completely subdued to God's will, is urgent because the perils of the last days thicken with deceptive power that would deceive even the elect, yet it is a glorious bargain without price, a free gift through Jesus to everyone who humbly submits, bringing life and peace instead of death.RH Nov 6, 1856 Indulging sin hardens the heart and makes return more difficult and painful, for the carnal mind cannot readily turn from the world and put on Christ without struggle and a cross.ST May 15, 1884 All human ordinances, stated fasts and crucifixions of the flesh devised by human effort to live better, win favor or establish self-righteousness come from the carnal mind and passed away in Christ's work, and worship prompted by the flesh is abomination even when earnest.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jun 24, 1913ST Aug 27, 1894ST Mar 11, 1886RH Nov 19, 1914 Such self-directed service follows its own will and feelings, offers what God has not required while withholding what He commanded, treats pomp as essential, and is will-worship puffed up in vain, whereas giving up the carnal mind for the Spirit's mind enables acceptable worship anywhere since mind serves God.ST Mar 11, 1886RH Nov 19, 1914ST Apr 2, 1896
Christ's obedience avails nothing unless reproduced and wrought out in the believer, and His faithful, loving, tested, tried, unyielding, continual obedience dwelling in the heart by faith restores His image and secures eternal immortal life.ST Jan 31, 1906 While carnal the heart cannot produce repentance because sin is transgression of the law and repentance is spiritual sorrow for sin, so God must give it by the Holy Spirit planting faith where the natural heart has no desire to please God.ST May 7, 1894ST May 13, 1886 If Christ's tempter were merely His own carnal mind or lusts He would have been sinful, since the carnal mind is sinful enmity unable to submit to God's law, so the devil cannot be identified with Christ's nature.RH Jun 26, 1856 The flesh remains unconverted and hostile demanding service, but feeling its demands does not mean a Christian has lost God-given freedom. Therefore the flesh or carnal mind cannot be a sacred place where God continually ministers.RH Jul 21, 1904
If materialism were true, carnal enmity belonging to the whole race could not change by regeneration during life but only by bodily regeneration at the resurrection, denying day-by-day renewal of the inner person while the body decays and denying freedom and moral responsibility.RH Feb 15, 1870RH Sep 8, 1859 The opposite of the carnal mind is a right mind in harmony with God's law, serving God's law with the mind, staying on God in perfect peace, and receiving the law in mind and heart under the new covenant, as seen when Nebuchadnezzar turned to praise God, when the lost son returned, and when the delivered demoniac followed Christ.ST Jul 2, 1902 The natural worldly mind ruled by love of the world lives in disobedience from which it cannot free itself nor change itself into love, and the change comes only through believing the Word, accepting propitiation for the past, and surrendering the rebellious will to Christ's obedient will to pass from sin and death to love and eternal life.ST Nov 19, 1902 Waiting to become good enough by one's own efforts before praying, confessing Christ, being baptized or doing other duties is the carnal mind struggling to keep the old man alive in self-righteousness, dressing in own righteousness and expecting forgiveness for a few sins, which is self-deception without Christ, salvation or true repentance.RH Nov 2, 1869
No one can come to Christ unless the Father draws by the Spirit, so resisting a sense of duty or a faithful warning is resisting the Spirit's invitation and is dangerous.ST Aug 21, 1884 Only Christ's blood can subdue the carnal mind which nature's beauty and abundance cannot overcome, so a heart sanctified by grace can praise God and rejoice in any setting whether in abundance or hardship.ST Oct 22, 1885 The missionary spirit belongs to the spiritual mind in opposition to self-seeking, self-glory and selfishness, working through faith, love and the Holy Spirit against the fleshly mind.ST Apr 10, 1884 Knowing Christ only outwardly after the flesh while walking after the flesh is not the life-changing knowing of regeneration in which the old life passes and one walks after the Spirit.ST Jan 16, 1893 Those following the carnal mind remain opposed, alienated and enemies of Christ and resist Him, while those yielding to His holy requirements receive forgiveness, favor and union as friends, so Christ and His coming are alarm to the wicked and joy to the righteous.ST Feb 26, 1880RH Mar 4, 1875ST Feb 24, 1881
The heart at enmity is a small mean dwelling with room only for self, but Christ's Spirit entering overturns selfishness and makes a new creature expanding love first to family and then to all humanity, slowly as the deceitful heart is reconstructed as God's temple.RH Oct 21, 1873 The gospel conquers the enmity, replacing the war spirit with a spirit of peace toward others.RH Mar 16, 1911 The first deliverance is a mighty change freeing from the carnal mind, corrupt heart, evil conscience and vile raiment and giving Christ's Spirit, character and righteousness to begin faith's pilgrimage, distinct from the final deliverance changing bodies to immortality.ST Sep 17, 1894 The choice to resist the Spirit belongs to the person not the Spirit, for though unable to overcome sin alone and pulled downward by surroundings, one can choose good and ally with God's strength, the choice theirs and the power God's.ST Jun 12, 1901 Those hostile must be brought into harmony before receiving His spirit of love, for God does not dwell in anyone antagonistic to His law.ST Apr 2, 1902
Sabbath and Law Opposition
The hostility of the fleshly mind toward God accounts for contempt for the Sabbath He commands to be honored, calling it Jewish while attempting to make Sunday the Christian Sabbath, and such hostility cannot change which day God has made holy.ST Jun 24, 1886ST Jun 17, 1889ST Sep 12, 1878 The same opposition explains refusal to keep the seventh day as commanded, with excuses for rejecting it and establishing a rival institution, including laws to enforce that rival, all arising from resistance to divine law.ST Jun 17, 1889RH Nov 2, 1911 This carnality underlies attacks on the law, claims that the Decalogue is abolished, efforts to shift the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first, and reasonings that turn breaking bread on the first day into grounds for setting aside the fourth commandment.RH Nov 2, 1911ST Jul 1, 1886 Until the new covenant writes the law in the heart this opposition keeps breaking out in various forms, and it is the difficult objection behind much resistance to the true Lord's day, an objection only the holder can settle, although not everyone who opposes the Sabbath does so from this mind.ST Jun 26, 1893ST Jul 1, 1886
No one without experimental knowledge of divine power creating a new heart can truly keep the Sabbath or obey any other precept, for true observance requires sin banished from the heart and the soul born again and re-created, with the weekly Sabbath remaining as memorial of new creation as well as first creation.ST Oct 31, 1900RH Mar 4, 1909 A person must be converted and rid of the carnal mind before keeping the Sabbath holy, since no one ruled by that mind can keep it holy, and resistance to the commandments is evidence of hostility and denial of the faith of Jesus.RH Dec 4, 1860RH Mar 4, 1909 To be carnally minded is death, and claims that obedience to the fourth commandment is impossible wrongly portray God as requiring what cannot be done with help from above.RH Dec 4, 1860RH Mar 13, 1856 Disregard and nullification of the fourth commandment even by professed Christians preaching Jesus is evidence of this hostility, and worship prompted by the flesh is unacceptable to God even when earnest, with outward keeping apart from a sanctified mind becoming drudgery without benefit.RH Aug 7, 1860ST Aug 27, 1894
Refusal to obey the law including the Sabbath commandment reveals the hostile mind that neither submits nor can submit, in contrast to deliverance through the Spirit of life in Christ giving power to obey.RH Jan 1851RH Mar 13, 1856 Those who do not love God enough to keep His holy Sabbath, who turn away with contempt from Sabbath truth and close their eyes so as not to see it, display the mind hostile toward God and unable to obey His law.RH Dec 4, 1860RH May 23, 1854 That inability explains making void the law and fighting the truth by refusing to leave Sunday to keep the Lord's Sabbath.RH Feb 7, 1854 Holding back even when convinced, clinging to Sunday, and resisting light show the same condition.RH Oct 7, 1851RH Feb 7, 1854
Opposition to the law comes not from grace, forgiveness, or loyalty to Christ but from the carnal mind, and when that mind dies Christ gives a new heart and life that loves the law and delights in the commandments.ST Jul 16, 1912ST Jun 12, 1907 Railing against the law, teaching its abolition, declaring freedom from obligation, delighting in what it forbids, or claiming justification while opposing it is that mind showing enmity and inability to be subject, and such teaching verifies the verse.ST Oct 16, 1901ST Dec 27, 1905 Those who oppose the law in this way are already condemned by it and need converting rather than condemning, for resistance and efforts to release people from duty grow out of the natural bent of the heart.ST Oct 16, 1901ST Dec 27, 1905 The ten commandments having ceased of obligation so that the seventh-day Sabbath is abolished was taught by those who held that the only law ever requiring it had given place to another law.RH Jan 31, 1854
The New Testament church fulfills the righteousness of the law, that is, practices the right doing the law requires, and such a church obeys the fourth commandment including the Sabbath.RH May 5, 1874ST Jul 8, 1880 When Christ dwells and works through the Spirit, people can obey the divine law including its Sabbath precept, with the law's righteousness fulfilled in those who live by the Spirit.ST Jul 26, 1905ST Mar 28, 1906 No one can become subject to the law until the new heart replaces the old, renewed by the new spirit to become like Christ's mind in loving obedience, and through faith in Jesus the carnal mind gives way to a spiritual mind in harmony with the law, so that Gentiles who keep it are converted believers not persons exempt from it.ST Mar 28, 1906ST Sep 27, 1910 The passage stands among New Testament teachings that God's law remains permanent and unchanged.RH Feb 17, 1852
At creation the seventh-day Sabbath was built into human nature, but sinning against the law destroyed that inward harmony and left man carnal and hostile and unable to submit.STST Apr 29, 1903 True conversion turns man from carnal to spiritual, brings peace with God and harmony with His law, so the Sabbath is built into his nature again as he shares the divine nature, and redemption brings him back to where he stood before the fall.ST Apr 29, 1903ST Jun 26, 1884 When a person joins God's people through Christ the carnal mind gives way to a spiritual mind that delights in the law and makes the Sabbath a delight and a sign of new creation, and those whose hearts have become obedient honor it as holy to the Lord.ST Jun 26, 1884RH Jul 7, 1859 The Sabbath was given to Adam as head of the race and made for all mankind and intended for the righteous people of God, reconciled by God's purpose of righteousness for all, since no sinner as such could keep the day holy as required.ST
Only those experiencing conversion can keep God's law, so human laws cannot enforce it or make people truly observe the Sabbath, and the law being spiritual remains the standard of right yet cannot make a carnal person do right.RH Aug 17, 1905ST Jun 20, 1900 People in the flesh cannot become righteous merely through law enforcement or outward displays, but only those born of the Spirit can be righteous.RH Aug 17, 1905 Because the law of God is spiritual no human power can administer it over a sinful people, so no earthly government can rule by the commandments and the faith of Jesus nor construct a Christian nation by civil law; only God makes such a people by writing His law in hearts and ruling by a solely spiritual government.ST Aug 3, 1904 Any effort to compel sinners to observe the Sabbath attempts to force what God has declared impossible, with civil enforcement of Sunday observance absurdly impossible and enforcement of real observance on the real Sabbath also impossible, and a heart at enmity gains no benefit from outward observance.ST Oct 31, 1900RH Aug 17, 1905
This enmity explains why those ruled by pride, covetousness, and pleasure oppose keepers of God's law, resist light, and slander proclaimers of truth.RH Aug 7, 1866RH Oct 7, 1851 Rejecting the written Sabbath law in favor of human tradition exemplifies hostility, placing the Lord's Sabbath beneath human observance, which is not mere unwritten custom but refusal of God's law.ST Jan 22, 1902ST Jun 28, 1883 Failure to live by light received comes from the same resistance, though conscience still witnesses to right and wrong.ST Jul 22, 1889
The mind that treats carrying the mail on the Sabbath as acceptable follows opposition to God's law.RH Sep 11, 1856 Refusing to hire people to break the Sabbath is not the same as forcing them to observe it.RH Sep 11, 1856
Obedient Life and Warnings
Walking after the Spirit fulfills what the law calls for, bringing freedom from condemnation into rest, happiness, perfect peace and ever-increasing joy through complete submission to Christ's teaching, power and life.ST May 20, 1908ST Sep 9, 1913ST Nov 28, 1892ST Jul 3, 1893 The fleshly mind seeks happiness from appetites, ambitions and passions and finds only disappointment, while the Spirit-led life brings life and peace because the law, weak through the flesh and unable to give perfection or strength to overcome, is met when God sent His Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and condemned sin in the flesh.ST May 20, 1908ST Nov 28, 1892ST Jun 12, 1879 Change of heart and mind is necessary before obedience is possible, for through faith the mind receives the Spirit who leads into obedience, writes the law in the heart, moves the heart to love it, and puts to death the deeds of the body.ST Sep 9, 1913ST Nov 28, 1892ST Jul 3, 1893ST Jun 12, 1879
Deliverance is present freedom from transgression in this life, not freedom to break the law, for serving sin is obeying sin's law while serving God is keeping His law.ST Oct 19, 1888ST May 15, 1884ST Apr 12, 1899RH Mar 8, 1864 The carnal nature as the old man of sin and first husband must die and be crucified with Christ so the body of sin is destroyed, and being married to Christ frees from sin's bondage rather than from obedience.ST Oct 19, 1888ST May 15, 1884RH Mar 8, 1864 Christ does not free from the law's requirements but from sin's bondage and the carnal mind, rescuing from condemnation under the new covenant by making the law part of the being, and misusing liberty to transgress brings into bondage again.ST Apr 12, 1899ST Aug 19, 1886ST Mar 6, 1879
Conversion brings into harmony with God's character by learning to love His law, meditating on it and finding His commandments not grievous, as saints in all ages have delighted in it.ST May 20, 1908ST Jun 12, 1884ST Mar 25, 1889RH Sep 25, 1913 The unrenewed natural mind is itself enmity, so its opposition to the law is opposition to God whose character the law expresses, and its actions cannot be accepted as service because source and motive are wrong.ST Sep 14, 1882RH Sep 25, 1913 Those in whom the Spirit dwells are not in the flesh but belong to Christ, and the Spirit of the Son leads to love for the Father shown by keeping His commandments, with Christ's complete submission to the Father's law removing the enmity.ST Jun 12, 1884ST Mar 25, 1889RH Sep 25, 1913
Unwillingness to obey any part reveals a sinful heart, for a right heart welcomes requirements rather than finding them burdensome, and rejection of the Ten Commandments is refusal of allegiance.RH Mar 8, 1870ST Sep 16, 1880ST Feb 4, 1886 Outward keeping of most commands is not obedience if one command is rejected from prejudice, pride or fashion, for to such a mind requirements appear arbitrary and impossible.ST Feb 12, 1902RH Sep 2, 1852 Hatred in the heart shows the law of love absent, and following own will and feelings while offering what God has not required and withholding what He commanded is will-worship that leaves the mind vainly puffed up instead of worship in spirit.RH Sep 2, 1852ST Mar 11, 1886
A worldly mind is an enemy of God opposed to obedience, having the spirit of the world which is carnal-mindedness leading to death, while having Christ's Spirit leads to life and peace.ST Dec 3, 1874RH Sep 17, 1857 Seeking gratification of that mind through irreligious stories and novels harms spiritual life, and indulging tobacco by chewing or smoking shows the carnal mind unremoved.RH May 20, 1858 Worldly desires that make entertainments attractive cannot please God or bring to Christ, and bringing forth fruit unto self turns the heart to other gods through licentious pleasure and selfish gratification, proving none can serve both God and mammon.ST Feb 2, 1882ST Jan 30, 1901
Sinful deeds evidence inward disposition as fruit reveals a tree, for the depraved heart hostile to God and unable to submit produces selfish longings, passions and desires that must be put away.ST Feb 11, 1889RH Oct 9, 1856 Carnal appetite allowed to rule leads to death, so lust must be resisted by refusing sin rule over the body, making no provision for fleshly desires and crucifying the flesh with its affections to become new creatures growing in grace.RH Oct 9, 1856ST Apr 5, 1899 Knowingly keeping what is owed remains governed by the carnal mind, coveting the neighbor's goods and violating the law, with neglect not canceling the claim.RH Sep 25, 1856 Anger without cause is fruit of carnality and enmity already in the law, blinded by fleshly desires to minute moral precepts, and a heart in that condition cannot forgive, for mercy requires regeneration and childlike trustful obedience through new birth to enter the kingdom.ST Sep 11, 1893ST May 25, 1915ST Apr 5, 1899
Victory requires mortifying deeds of the body, receiving the Spirit of adoption, and waiting for redemption of the body.RH Mar 22, 1864 The old man ruling in selfishness, pride, envy, jealousy, resistance to reproof and ungoverned appetite and passion must be renewed by grace, surrendered and denied, crucified and put to death through the new birth by the Spirit.ST Apr 14, 1881RH Nov 22, 1906ST Apr 7, 1881 The carnal mind must be crucified through obedience after the pattern of Christ who kept the Father's commandments, since the perfect broad law converts the soul.RH Feb 10, 1859 Emancipation comes by casting down imaginations and bringing every thought captive to Christ's obedience, learning to hate evil imaginations, replacing the carnal mind with Christ's mind into glorious liberty from all that debases and freedom in all noble, pure and everlasting.ST Aug 27, 1902
Close friendship with those without converting grace conflicts with loving God and delighting in what pleases Him, because the law is to be written in the heart and only the Spirit can make that change.RH Jul 30, 1867ST Jul 8, 1889 One still having the hostile disobedient mind is an opposing influence, so a believer free to choose imperils salvation by close life-union with such a person, and in an unbelieving spouse unchanged desires let worldly interests outweigh faith beyond what promises to support worship can overcome.RH Jan 22, 1867RH Mar 2, 1911
The fleshly mind neither submits to God's law nor can do so, and this innate selfishness of greed, ambition, passion and lust for power is why laws and political changes cannot transform the heart and why the same injustices continue.ST Nov 21, 1911RH Jan 27, 1916 The root of anarchy is the rebellious turbulent carnal mind not subject to the Decalogue as the constitution of God's government, making every follower of his own way an anarchist toward God, lawless and self-enthroned, dethroning God and breaking down respect for law even when not openly active.ST Oct 9, 1901RH Feb 13, 1913 Roots of crime lie in this condition, curable only by the gospel bringing harmony with law through faith to overcome sin and live righteously, while fallen men unable to be governed by love require human law and government as temporary necessity to enforce doing no ill and secure measure of peace.ST May 5, 1909ST Jul 6, 1904ST Mar 29, 1905 Regeneration in which Christ's mind displaces the carnal mind into willing complete submission is true liberty and the cure, to be fully realized when ideals blocked by the perverse heart are reached at Christ's second coming with sin destroyed, though the gospel changes people now.RH Feb 13, 1913ST Jul 21, 1914
Each reader must face whether his own mind is carnal, for resistance to the law reveals natural carnality and need of conversion, since the unconverted heart loves neither the law nor its Author.ST May 28, 1894RH Apr 20, 1869ST Nov 11, 1875 Escape from hostility ending in death into life and peace requires a created clean heart and renewed right spirit, receiving Christ's mind, being led as sons and joint-heirs, putting on the new man in righteousness and holiness, with prayer heard only when the ear is open to the law.ST Jan 23, 1901 Sin-sick refusal of Christ's humiliating terms shows the hostility, for confession is bitter to the carnal mind as pleading guilty to breaking law and suing for pardon, yet confessing and forsaking is essential to mercy and life.ST Dec 1, 1898 Redemption saves from sin and hostility, not from obedience, raising to love and obey with cheerful obedience as evidence of His Spirit, while rejecting light despite professing devotion treads underfoot what Christ honored.ST Nov 11, 1875ST Oct 25, 1877
The verse tests possession of Christ's Spirit in public life, requiring obedient action rather than setting righteousness aside for expediency, compromising conviction or following worldly leaders, for the carnal mind controlling worldly times makes Christ's teachings seem incompatible with political life as with Pharisees, Sadducees and the Dark Ages, yet full surrender gives transforming life in which they fit.ST Sep 2, 1897ST Apr 26, 1905 Carnal-minded students cannot truly progress in Christian education and exert evil influence, so conversion is its foundation, requiring daily self-denial, cross-bearing and following Jesus against inclination that would silence conviction.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Feb 10, 1904 Resistance that refuses to deny appetite also refuses bodily laws of health even when self-denial is required, for the unrenewed mind is hostile to all good including good food and pure drink and must be made new creation with new tastes rather than merely reformed, lest like Israel it turn back to Egypt's fleshpots and loathe manna.RH Jul 4, 1865RH Sep 23, 1902RH Nov 3, 1868 When laws are put in mind and heart with God dwelling within, keeping them becomes delight, self-denial ceases as hardship, and reforms in eating, drinking and living are taken cheerfully, though beneath present crossing lies the crown.RH Sep 23, 1902RH Nov 3, 1868
Spiritual decline may come not by deliberate rush into sin but by neglecting worship and the sanctuary till devotion fades and the grieved Spirit leaves room for sin unto darkness and death.ST Sep 12, 1895 A carnal motive being enmity, singing to please it opposes devotion, while songs from loving hearts uplift.RH Aug 11, 1859 One professing faith while carnally minded chills a young convert's first love and damages God's begun work.RH Apr 12, 1864 Careful skillful work is needed to present truth to hostile minds, and religious retirement helps lift the heart above worldly drawing into carnal nature to keep hopes active.RH Sep 1, 1910RH Dec 12, 1854
Claimants to sanctification who turn from hearing the law prove carnal hearts and children of disobedience, repeating Satan's false claim of exalted sanctification while corrupting others, and God will not accept willfully imperfect service, with protection only by living by every word.RH Sep 3, 1901 A heart at enmity proves absence of true sanctification, so those claiming perfection while refusing perfect obedience and promise conditions are self-deceived and self-righteous expecting blessing promised only to the obedient, becoming false lights deceiving others into disregard and teaching unpunished transgression under Satan as when Adam and Eve were led to disregard God's word and fail the test.RH Sep 3, 1901 Church fundraising devised by carnal minds in feasts, games, lotteries and amusements appealing to appetite and worldly desire is not made acceptable by church name or use of proceeds.ST Nov 28, 1878 The carnal heart finds thorough confession difficult, so its resistance must be subdued and the mind renewed.RH Apr 21, 1859 Overcoming this opposed mind that drags character in dust and leaves inability to stand in battle must be abandoned with time past enough, the old man crucified and new man appearing to rise, advance at all risk to higher standard and readiness for the kingdom.RH Aug 7, 1855RH Feb 4, 1873
Further points
The carnal mind described is hostile to God and unable to submit to His law.RH Jan 8, 1901 The cross offends that mind, as does the need to be saved by another.RH Jan 8, 1901 Pride drives the desire for people to be their own saviors.RH Jan 8, 1901 Claimed independence from God does not bring freedom but leaves a person enslaved to evil principles and lawless passions.RH Jan 8, 1901
Sources