Zechariah 1:5
Your fathers, where are they? and the prophets, do they live for ever?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, Webster Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version, Darby Translation
Your fathers, where are they? and the prophets, do they live for ever?
Your fathers, where are they?
And the prophets, do they live for ever?Your fathers — where [are] they? And the prophets — to the age do they live?
Your fathers, where are they? and, the prophets, to times age-abiding, do they live?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Where are your fathers now? And the prophets, do they live forever?
Your fathers, where are they? And the prophets, do they live forever?
Your fathers, where are they? and the prophets, do they go on living for ever?
your fathers, where are they? and doe the Prophets liue for euer?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Your fathers, where are they? and the prophets, shall they live always?
Cross-references
- 1 Peter 1:24-25
For all flesh is as grass, and all the glory of man as the flower of grass. The grass withereth, and the flower thereof falleth away:
Contrasts perishing people with the Word that endures forever.
- 2 Chronicles 36:16-17
But they mocked the messengers of God, and despised his words, and misused his prophets, until the wrath of the LORD arose against his people, till there was no remedy.
Recounts the fathers’ rejection of the prophets and the judgment that followed.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
2 sources
The question belongs to messages given when the Jewish people were anxious that the permission to rebuild might be withdrawn.RH Dec 26, 1907 Those messages were meant to sustain and encourage the people by revealing God's compassion and love.RH Dec 26, 1907
Its question reminds the people that their ancestors and the prophets who warned them do not live forever, pointing to the passing of generations.RH Dec 19, 1907 By contrast with those passing generations, the words that follow show that God's warnings and commands remained in force and were fulfilled in the fathers' experience.RH Dec 19, 1907 The verse therefore calls its hearers to learn from their fathers' disobedience and to heed God's sure word.RH Dec 19, 1907 God's word does not fail, and blessing is promised to those who listen to it.RH Dec 19, 1907
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
15 sources
Your fathers and the prophets did not live on forever, for human generations pass away and human life is frail and brief.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902 The verse was spoken to the Jews returned from Babylon to rebuild the temple, to call them to turn back to God with the promise that he would receive them.ST Apr 12, 1883ST Apr 12, 1883 Though the people and the prophets died, God's words, warnings and commands lived on and were fulfilled, overtaking the fathers so that they acknowledged he had dealt with them according to their ways.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902ST Apr 12, 1883 It warns its hearers not to repeat their fathers' refusal to listen, for rejecting his word brings perishing and oblivion while blessing belongs to those who heed it.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902 The question presses each generation to respond while opportunity lasts rather than delay, letting grief for the dead become fruitful in following their faithful example and filling their place in God's service.RH Feb 17, 1874ST Feb 5, 1880RH Feb 9, 1905RH Jun 18, 1914
Historical Setting and Purpose
The question was asked in Zechariah's first prophecy when he was only a young man, addressed to the Jews who had returned from Babylon under the proclamation of Cyrus king of Persia authorizing them to rebuild the temple at Jerusalem.ST Apr 12, 1883 The foundation of that temple had been laid by Zerubbabel, otherwise called Sheshbazzar, in the second year of their coming to Jerusalem.ST Apr 12, 1883 Zechariah 1:1-6 is the first vision of Zechariah 1, given by words without signs, concerning the sins that caused the Babylonian captivity.ST Apr 12, 1883 It places its question about the mortality of ancestors and prophets within the call to heed God's message in the reform under Zerubbabel.ST Apr 12, 1883ST Nov 25, 1908
It belongs to messages given when the Jewish people were anxious that permission to rebuild might be withdrawn.RH Dec 26, 1907 Those messages were meant to sustain and encourage them by revealing God's compassion and love.RH Dec 26, 1907 It belongs also to a prophetic message that called Israel to turn back to God after the people had abandoned His work in discouragement. Haggai and Zechariah rebuked their neglect and sin, and their message led the people to resume the work and receive God's blessing.
In that setting it urges the returned Jews to return to God with the promise that God will receive them.ST Apr 12, 1883
Mortal Messengers, Enduring Word
The fathers of earlier generations are gone, and the prophets who warned them did not live forever; human generations pass away, and human life is finite, frail and brief.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jul 5, 1910ST Jul 5, 1910 The messengers themselves died, but the word they spoke did not die with them.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 12, 1883
Though people and prophets passed away, God's words, statutes, warnings and commands remained in force and were fulfilled.RH Dec 19, 1907ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jul 26, 1910 The predicted consequences and calamity overtook the fathers who ignored the calls to turn from evil, and they could not escape the penalty of disobedience.ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jul 5, 1910ST Jul 26, 1910 Punishment overwhelmed those who refused to heed warning until utter ruin came, and only then they acknowledged that God had dealt with them according to their ways and deeds.ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jul 5, 1910ST Apr 12, 1883
The question therefore warns the hearers not to repeat their fathers' refusal to heed God.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902 If they rejected His word as their fathers had, they too would perish and pass into darkness and oblivion.ST Sep 24, 1902ST Sep 24, 1902 The passing of human generations does not make God's word any less enduring or its consequences any less certain, for His word does not fail.RH Dec 19, 1907ST Jul 5, 1910 Blessing is promised to those who listen and learn from their fathers' disobedience.RH Dec 19, 1907
Urgent Call to Respond
Human life is brief and not everlasting, for ancestors have passed away and even prophets do not remain alive forever.ST Feb 5, 1880RH Jun 18, 1914 The question therefore presses hearers to respond to God while opportunity remains rather than putting off turning to him until old age or a deathbed.ST Feb 5, 1880 The present generation must heed the message and remain faithful instead of presuming it can wait indefinitely.ST Feb 5, 1880RH Jun 18, 1914
Mourning fathers and prophets who have died and do not remain forever is fitting.RH Feb 9, 1905 Yet grief is vain if it leaves life fruitless; it should move the living to follow the saints' example, fill their fathers' place, and serve God.RH Feb 9, 1905 Though fathers and prophets do not live forever but die, their words and witness can continue to speak after them, as a dead man's written reasons for his hope and testimony of faith continue to speak.RH Feb 17, 1874
Sources