IN the REVIEW of June 21, under the heading “Peter and Rome,” we noticed the claims of the Catholic Church that Peter is the rock on which Christ founded his Church, and that the popes are the successors of Peter. In the same leaflet there referred to, is another claim which some desire to see noticed also. It is that the Church has been ordained as the infallible teacher of the truth; that the Catholic Church is the true Church, alone qualified to teach the truth, and hence that all interpretation of the Bible should be according to the teachings of that Church. In the leaflet aforesaid the claim is stated in these words:—
“It is denied that the Church of God is unerring in teaching the doctrine of Christ. Now in regard to the Church of God, WHAT DOES THE BIBLE SAY? ‘Go ye teach all nations . . . teaching them to observe whatsoever I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always even to the end of the world.’ St. Matt. 28:19, 20. ‘And he shall give you another Paraclete, the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name; he will teach all things, and bring all things to your mind, whatever I shall have said unto you.’ V. 26. ‘Upon this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against her.’ St. Matt. 16:18. ‘He that heareth you heareth me; and he that despiseth you despiseth me; and he that despiseth me, despiseth him that sent me.’ St. Luke 10:16. ‘The Church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.’ 1 Tim. 3:15.”
In all this there will be noticed the quiet assumption that the Roman Catholic Church is the Church of God. When Christ promised to be with his people to the end of the world, he did not promise to be with a church which should adopt pagan errors and superstitions and corruptions, and become an apostate church. All his promises were to those who should remain true to him, and be his people indeed. The Church of Rome, having become an unscriptural and antichristian Church, now arrogates to itself the promises which are made alone to the true Church, that Church which is alone entitled to the name, the Church of God. Christ’s charge was, “Teach all nations whatsoever I have commanded you.” But we do not know what he commanded them, except from the record they have given us; and the promise in John 14:26 was evidently the special gift of the Spirit, which brought all things to their remembrance, and enabled them to put on record what Christ had commanded them for the instruction of his people in coming ages.
What is recorded in Luke 10:16, was spoken personally to the seventy disciples whom Jesus sent out. It is true of subsequent teachers only as they teach in accordance with the instruction which Christ has caused to be put on record for our guidance.
As to 1 Tim. 3:15, it is “the Church of the living God” which is the pillar and ground of the truth, not a church which has unfortunately gone into darkness and error. And God has always had a church in the earth, and always will have, to maintain, defend, and propagate his truth—a church deriving the truth which it defends and upholds, not from tradition or human councils, but from the word of God alone.
IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.
[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]
Rom. 3:19 says that whatsoever things the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law; and yet in chapter 6:14, the same apostle says of Christians, “Ye are not under the law, but under grace.” How can the law say anything to us, if we are not under it? D. J. S.
Answer.—The expression, “under the law,” in these texts evidently means, under the condemnation of the law. To those who have not violated the law, it does not have anything to say by way of condemnation. Its only language, then, is that of instruction how to avoid coming under its condemning power. But the moment we violate the law, then it speaks to us to condemn us. Therefore the declaration that we are “not under the law,” in the sense of not being under its condemnation, in no wise releases us from obligation to obey the law. Paul to Timothy (1-1:9) expresses the relation of a righteous man to the law in these words: “The law is not made for a righteous man, but for the lawless and disobedient,” etc. The word here translated “made,” means to “lie against.” The law does not lie against (that is, condemn) a righteous man, but it does lie against the lawless, and disobedient, etc.
Does John 7:23, middle clause, refer to the law of ten commandments, or the law of circumcision? J. A. Y.
Ans.—To the law of circumcision. The ten commandments are never called “the law of Moses.” Christ’s argument with the Pharisees on this occasion, was, that it was more important to heal a man, than it was to keep the law of Moses. And yet in order to keep that law, they would circumcise a man on the Sabbath day, if the eighth day on which that law demanded that the child be circumcised, happened to fall on the Sabbath, although this rite involved more outward labor, and hence, to all appearance, a greater violation of the Sabbath, than the work he did in healing a man. And while they would scrupulously follow their law, and not put off circumcision on account of the Sabbath, they would at the same time condemn him for healing a man on the Sabbath, which was a more important work, and did not involve so much of an apparent violation of the Sabbath, as the other. Thus he put them to silence by exposing their inconsistency.
A lady who last fall purchased “Bible Readings,” and commenced to keep the Sabbath, desires an explanation of Rev. 4:7–9. Please give it through the Question Chair, and oblige, B. B. N.
Ans.—The use of the term, “beast,” in the text referred to, is a very unfortunate translation. It should be, “living beings.” And they are beings, too, of great power and glory, resembling the cherubim of Ezekiel, chapters 1 and 10. The qualities and capabilities inhering in these exalted beings, as indicated by the appearance of their different faces, would seem to be strength, perseverance, reason, and swiftness, in comprehending and carrying out the divine will. (See the subject more fully treated in “Thoughts on the Revelation.”)
212.—THE MARCH AROUND JERICHO.
Mrs. B. C. writes of a friend who is troubled over the march of the Israelites around Jericho for seven days, as described in Joshua 6, and asks how it can be harmonized with the Sabbath law.
Ans.—There is no difficulty. The Sabbath commandment forbids our own work, not any work which God may lay upon us to do. And the march around Jericho was not a work which the Israelites took up of themselves, and which pertained to the personal, temporal, and secular pursuits of the people; but it was a service which God especially enjoined upon them; and doing what he tells us to do, which is his work, no matter on what day, is no violation of a command which simply forbids our own work. The march around Jericho, was God’s work, not their work, and hence was no violation of the Sabbath law.
As our Saviour makes a darkening of the sun one prominent sign of his second coming, it seems certain it would occur in a land where many were believers—a land largely Christian. Signs taking place in heathen or Mohammedan countries would have no significance to such people. They would not know the signs were ever predicted by our Lord, though they might be greatly frightened by them. Neither would they be well understood in Catholic countries, where the people are not familiar with the Bible. It must be evident that they would have the greatest force and consideration in Protestant lands, where our Lord’s predictions were generally known. In such countries we should therefore reasonably expect their wonderful mysteries and solemn testimony would be given.
Of the mystery enshrouding the “Dark Day” of May 19, 1780, we give extracts from witnesses who beheld it.
Noah Webster, LL.D., in the New Haven Herald, 1843, said:—
“I stood and viewed the phenomenon. No satisfactory cause has been assigned.”
Rev. Edward Bass, D.D., First Episcopal Bishop of Vermont, in his “diary” (at Newburyport, Mass.), under date of May 19, 1780, wrote:—
“This day is most remarkable in the memory of man for darkness. To pretend fully and clearly to account for it, argues perhaps too great confidence.”
Judge Samuel Tenney, LL.D., wrote to the Historical Society in 1785:—
“Several gentlemen of literary ability have endeavored to solve the phenomenon, yet I believe you will agree with me that no satisfactory solution has yet appeared.”
Judge R. M. Devins, in Our First Century, says, “It was a wonderful dark day,” and one of “perpetual441interest.” It stands “almost, if not altogether, alone as the most mysterious and as yet unexplained phenomenon of its kind in nature’s diversified events during the last century.”
The astronomer Herschel is quoted in St. Nicholas as writing:—
“The Dark Day in northern America was one of those wonderful phenomena in nature which will always be read with interest, but which philosophy is at a loss to explain.”
Thus these learned witnesses testify of this mysterious, solemn, and unaccountable phenomenon which spread a pall of “sackcloth,” as the revelator declared, over the face of the sun, shutting out its light from 700,000 souls, and over an area of 320,000 square miles of the earth’s territory.
In the year 1783, just about three years later than the Dark Day of America, Europe was visited by similar phenomena, which though not as intense, were of longer continuance. A peculiar haze spread over the whole of Europe, far into Asia. We are indebted to Taylor’s “Great Consummation,” pp. 227–233, for the facts we quote.
This haze and strange darkness appeared in Denmark, May 29, reaching France June 14; Italy, June 16; Norway, June 22; Austria and Switzerland, June 23; Sweden, June 24; and Russia, June 25. Before the close of the month, it had overspread all Syria, and it reached to the Altai Mountains in the heart of Asia, about the middle of July.
“The obscurity prevailed a greater portion of the summer, imparting to the sun an unnatural color of a dull rusty red, and causing both the days and nights to wear a weird and gloomy aspect. The atmosphere was highly electric, and nature was greatly convulsed.”
Rev. W. R. Andrews, in the London Times, June 8, 1883, quotes as follows:—
“Gilbert White writes in the year 1783, in a letter published in his Natural History of Selborne, Eng., ‘The summer of 1783 was an alarming and portentous one, and full of horrible phenomena; for besides the alarming meteors and tremendous thunderstorms that affrighted and distressed England, the peculiar haze or smoky fog that prevailed for many weeks in this island and every part of Europe, and even beyond its limits, was a most extraordinary appearance, unlike anything known within the memory of man. The sun at noon looked black as a clouded moon, and shed a ferruginous [i. e., resembling iron rust, brownish or yellowish red] light on the ground and floors of rooms, but was particularly lurid and blood-colored at rising and setting. The country people began to look with a superstitious awe at the red lowering aspect of the sun, and indeed there was reason for the most enlightened persons to be apprehensive.’”
John Ruskin, who quotes the foregoing letter in his “Plague Storms,” p. 97, says, “The fog of 1783 made the sun dark with iron-colored rays.”
Milner, in his “Physical Phenomena,” p. 68, says, “The gloom extended out from Europe southward into Africa and westward into North America.” “The sun,” he says, “rose and set without its rays, even in a cloudless sky, and the moon high in heaven had the color of heated brick.”
Says the Penny Magazine, Dec. 17, 1836, “It was a remarkable and portentous kind of year.”
In his volume, “Ten Thousand Wonderful Things,” p. 414, Mr. E. King testifies, “It produced much fear that the end of all things was at hand.”
Dr. N. Webster, in his valuable “History of Pestilences,” Vol. II, p. 274, testifies to the general fear.
Says Taylor, “As it was in America on the occurrence of the Dark Day, so the churches in Europe were crowded with alarmed multitudes, supplicating mercy of heaven.”
Prof. Leland, the astronomer of France, attempted to quiet the popular fear by ascribing the darkened heavens to exhalations arising out of the earth; but both Webster and Humboldt (“Cosmos IV,” p. 75) reject this solution of the mysterious obscurity. Protestant England shared in the alarm it occasioned; and the poet Cowper sang that all the elements “preached the general doom.” It was to this unaccountable obscuration of light that he refers in his Task:—
“Nature seems with dim and sickly eye
To wait the close of all.”
Various efforts were made by learned men to account for these strange phenomena, but there has been no agreement among them. They are as Taylor declares, “but a jumble of adverse opinions.” They never have been explained, nor any reasonable cause given.
Yet it is not necessary to claim them as direct miracles, as we ordinarily understand that word, i. e., that there was a special exercise of miraculous or supernatural agency to cause them. God the Creator works as he chooses. At times his omnipotent power manifests itself by direct agency wholly outside of its ordinary exercise, as we are acquainted with it. We call that a miracle. Yet for all we know, it may be as consistent with the methods or laws through which he acts as other methods with which we are familiar. At other times his power exerts itself through natural law, as we have observed. Yet God is equally responsible for both methods, and his plans and providence are advanced by both.
In all the wonderful darknesses of the past; that at the exode, or in Palestine at the crucifixion, or in the “Dark Day,” or the strange darkness of Europe we have just considered, secondary causes may have been the agencies used by Providence to bring on the mysterious obscuration. But that fact does not militate against their being “signs,” and a fulfillment of predictions of prophecy, or being produced by Deity for a special purpose. How does it happen that such a wonderful darkness, of three days’ duration, “happened” to come over Egypt just at that particular juncture when Moses, the servant of God, was the agent for displaying signs and wonders before Pharaoh, at a great crisis in the affairs of his special people? What good reason can be given that after fifteen centuries had elapsed, with no such remarkable darkness appearing, on the middle of a particular day, when Jesus hung on the cross, all at once the blackness of night should cover the land, and all hearts be filled with terror, the people beating their breasts, and even the Roman centurion becoming convinced of the Saviour’s innocence?
And why did the same kind of strange phenomena again appear after the lapse of many centuries, all over Europe and in Christian America, in a period distinctly marked off—a little period of time bounded by plain prophetic declarations? Such events did happen precisely as, and in the time, our Lord predicted. Scientists have not been able to agree upon any explanation of them. They stand out as way-marks of history. They affect the people as something startling, strange, mysterious, unaccountable, and are regarded at the time they transpire as signs of the day of God. And truly they were such. In our next we present much more testimony concerning the “Dark Day.”
G. I. B.
(To be continued.)
SELF-EXAMINATION
THE duty of examining ourselves is one of the plain injunctions of the gospel. “Examine yourselves;” “prove your ownselves,” says the apostle, 2 Cor. 13:5. And the object of this exercise is not gained by merely looking at ourselves and stopping there. There is a point to be ascertained, a question to be decided; and that is expressed in these words: “Examine yourselves, whether ye be in the faith. . . . Know ye not your ownselves, how that Jesus Christ is in you, except ye be reprobates?”
The end to be gained is advancement in our spiritual condition, and growth in divine grace; for we never can be too thoroughly established in the truth, nor have too large a measure of the Spirit of Christ in us. Hence we are not to examine ourselves to see how much more progress we have made than we needed to make, and so how much we can rest and relax our efforts; but it is to see wherein, and how, greater attainments are to be made, and what hinders, or threatens, our Christian development and progress.
To do this work effectually, one must have the right standard to which to bring himself to be tested. Three standards at once suggest themselves as not the proper ones by which to be governed. First, a man should not examine himself by himself. He may be better than he has formerly been; but this is not the question to be decided; and this is not enough. The question is, Is he what he should be? Secondly, he should not examine himself by others (2 Cor. 10:12); for they may fall far below the true standard, so that he might be even better than they, and yet come short of standing the test. Thirdly, he should not take as a standard by which to judge of himself, what others may say of him; for others cannot read his heart, they cannot fathom his motives, nor know the whole truth in regard to his character or even his actions.
If we are to examine ourselves to see whether we be in the faith or not, the faith is that by which we are to test ourselves; if it is to see whether we are like Christ or not, then Christ’s life and teachings are to be our standard. In other words, true self-examination can be performed with nothing short of the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.
But how can we examine ourselves by these?—We must know them. Self-examination, then, implies a thorough study of God’s word, in all its teachings and admonitions for faith and practice, so that we may know them, and be able to test ourselves by them.
And finally, self-examination implies repentance for all the short-comings we discover in the past, and earnest and faithful amendment of life in days to come. So “let a man examine himself.”
The Present Indications
By Stephen N. Haskell
“WATCHMAN, WHAT OF THE NIGHT?”—NO. 1.
The Present Indications.
For more than two score of years Seventh-day Adventists have looked forward to three events that would stand in immediate connection with the coming of Christ. These events were:—
First, the spreading of the truth in all the nations of the earth as a witness. The Saviour gives this as a sign, and connects it with the end in response to the disciples’ question, “What shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world?” He said: “This gospel of the kingdom shall be preached in all the world for a witness unto all nations; and then shall the end come.”
Secondly, the loud cry of the third angel’s message. This is clothing the word of God with special power, signified by a mighty angel coming down from heaven, uniting with, and becoming a part of, the third angel’s message when his people would go forth to proclaim this truth unto the world. Thus would be fulfilled the prophecy recorded in Rev. 18:1: “I saw another angel come down from heaven, having great power; and the earth was lightened with his glory.” This would be proclaimed at the time when Babylon would have become the hold of every foul spirit, and the cage of every unclean and hateful bird, which is rapidly being accomplished at the present day.
Thirdly, a time would come when persecution would begin in this country by the imprisonment of those who conscientiously kept the commandments of God because they would not worship the beast or his image. This would result in the confiscation of their property, and the decree to put to death those who would not worship the image of the beast, at which time Christ would come and deliver his people. But the decree to put to death the people of God would not come until at the time of Christ’s coming, which is at least one year after the ending of probation.
In Daniel 2 we have the four kingdoms, which bring us down to the dividing up of the Roman empire into its ten parts; and these divisions were to continue till the fifth kingdom would be set up. There is nothing in this prophecy that marks the immediate nearness of the setting up of that kingdom, as already we have been in that state for about fourteen hundred years. The same might be said of the prophecy in the 7th and 8th chapters of Daniel, with this exception; that the Roman power is referred to as continuing for 1260 years, and as having a reviving in connection with the second coming of Christ. We find this to be the same with the 11th chapter.
The application of the prophecy in the latter part of the 11th chapter is understood to be the driving of the Turks from Europe, which would also be a sure indication of the second coming of Christ. But it will be noticed that when the king of the North shall plant the tabernacle of his palace between the seas, in the glorious holy mountain, “he comes to his end and none shall help him.” It is at that time that the time of trouble begins, such as never was since the beginning of the world. That is in the midst of the last movement of the nations of the earth, so we cannot tell with any degree of certainty how near we are, only every indication is that the next great move brings us to the second coming of Christ.
The international unrest, agitation, and suspicion of the Old World has been the same for many years, increasing at times, and at times lulled again into partial quietude by the professions of peace and safety. These are the war-waging elements that are held in check by the four angels standing on the four corners of the earth to hold the four winds for the sealing of God’s servants. How long the angels will restrain the elements is limited simply by the sealing of the servants of God, which brings us to the fulfillment of the prophecy of Matt. 24:14. Therefore there is nothing in these prophecies that marks the immediate coming of Christ; but in the spread of the gospel, in the loud cry of the third angel’s message, and in the persecution that comes upon those who keep the commandments of God, especially in this country, are evidences that are unmistakable and positively definite in their nature, and which connect the people of God with the ending of probation and the second coming of Christ.
Have we any indication that these events are now transpiring? Is it true that the third angel’s message is so rapidly spreading in this world that it will be impossible for us to tell how soon it will have accomplished its work as a witness? The growth and progress of the cause which shows the fulfillment of prophecy has been truly marvelous, from whatever standpoint we choose to look upon it. From a small beginning it has grown and developed until it has attracted national attention. Up to 1862 we had but one publishing house, and published one paper; yet the entire receipts were insufficient to pay the expenses of this one periodical. At the present time we have the Battle Creek Publishing House, the Pacific Press Publishing House, one in Australia, one in Basel, Switzerland, and one in Christiania, Norway. Our school interests also have grown as remarkably, with a college at Battle Creek, one at Healdsburgh, one at Lincoln, Nebr., and an academy at South Lancaster, Mass.
The health question has also grown, so that its influence is now felt all over the civilized world, to a greater or less extent. The health and temperance question has not been behind in its onward march. The Sanitarium at Battle Creek has become the largest and most thoroughly equipped institution of the kind known in the world. The one at St. Helena, Cal., is also assuming proportions that will enable it to send forth rays of light the coming year much in advance of any time in the history of the past.
How much property has been invested in these institutions, located in different portions of the world? Without speaking of other institutions that442are about to be established, it is safe to say that over a million dollars have been thus invested. This, with two dozen more or less of periodicals issued in different parts of the world in many of the principal languages spoken, shows a growth unparalleled by that of any religious denomination in the history of the gospel dispensation. We do not mean to say by this that the gospel never has spread more rapidly than now; but other things being equal, the growth has been marvelous and without a parallel. The last ten years have added new phases to the work, and a new impetus has been given to all its branches. A college will be built and equipped at Walla Walla, Wash., and be ready for operations by Jan. 1, 1893; and another at Cape Town, South Africa, a field that has only been opened a few years. Another educational institution will be located in Australia, and there will be a beginning in the southern part of the country in educational interests; so that we are gaining over twenty-fivefold the present year; or in other words, the cause will advance in 1893 as much as in twenty-five years in the past, in its general work.
S. N. H.
THE RELIABILITY OF CHURCH HISTORIANS.
By L. R. C.
(Concluded.)
But how little Dr. Bohmer dreamed of any apostolic appointment, yes, how positively he protested against any such idea, is seen from the following paragraphs. After considering 1 Cor. 16: 2 and Acts 20:7, also Justin Martyr, he draws the following conclusion:—
“The early Christians assembled surely in the original mother church (as Tertullian calls it), which was gathered at Jerusalem every day, and poured forth their united prayers, and preferred therefore by no means any certain day to any other, for it is well to be observed that we read nowhere that the apostles had ever held any consultations concerning the appointment of a certain day, nor given any command; if this had happened, Luke would surely not have omitted to mention it, as he does not pass institutions of minor importance. Yes, even the Acts of the Apostles show in the most decisive manner that the Jewish believers had never departed from their custom, but had been the most tenacious adherents to the custom of their fathers; therefore we must also conclude that they, according to their wonted custom, assembled on the Sabbath. The apostles desired no difference of days, and decidedly persisted upon liberty, and would not prescribe any laws or holy days. . . . How could one therefore believe that they should have prescribed to all the churches that they should keep the first day holy? How easy one can, therefore, from all this, guess that it cannot be ascribed to the law, nor to the apostolic command, but to the mere custom that the Christians had holy assemblies on this day.”
In a more emphatic manner neither Hartmann nor Dr. Bohmer could deny the assertion of Mosheim. But how did this man dare to rest his assertion on these writers? Surely he must have been hard up for proofs, to refer to positive statements against his theories as “unexceptionable testimonies” for them. In common life we know how such men would be considered. But we are not done as yet. We want to see whether we cannot learn something about Mosheim’s own opinions in this Sunday question. While he has been careful in his church history to avoid this subject, he has written in another work, called “Sittenlehre,” or “Christian Ethics,” quite a dissertation on Sunday, and there we find the following wonderful statement from his own pen:—
“The books of the New Testament do not state that the apostles have appointed a certain day for the assemblies of the Christians to the service of God.”
A plainer contradiction of his own words would be impossible. Thus we have not only the two witnesses to which Mosheim refers, against himself, but also Mosheim against Mosheim. Now whom or what shall we believe? This is the simple outcome: When men begin to deviate from the plain word of God and devise their own wisdom, it will always turn into folly, be they ever so eminent. This lack of Scripture texts Mosheim tries to make up by a lengthy argument, arguing from the nature of the case; but how little he succeeds, a German college president, Dr. Henke of Barmen, shows. We give his whole statement, so that the reader may get some idea of the position Mosheim takes on the Sunday question, and how he fails:—
“Mosheim tried to discover a middle course between the old and new doctrine. (Sittenlehre, Helmstädt 1752, Band V.) [Mosheim says:] ‘The obligation of the Christian to keep Sunday, cannot be proven from the Old Testament and from the Sabbath law given to the Jews. (p. 448.) Besides, Paul teaches that the Sabbath was done away; but that Sunday has taken the place of Sabbath, and Sabbath has thus been introduced anew, neither Paul nor any other apostle teaches.’ (p. 449.) If the opponents claim that God had given, right after creation, the Sabbath as an eternal law, then it should be demanded of them that they should also retain the seventh day to be kept. But in case they say that the apostles had power to change the Sabbath into Sunday, then they must first show the proof, and this cannot be furnished; for Mosheim truthfully and fittingly remarks, ‘Things occurred can only be proven by testimonies.’ (p. 454.) But in the Scriptures we read nothing of such an appointment from these men. Mosheim’s opinion is this: the apostles had authority to found churches and to organize them, therefore their appointments and institutions must be looked upon as coming from the Lord. (p. 461.) The laws of the apostles are either laws only for a definite time, or commandments forever binding. (p. 463.) Now the question comes, Have the apostles set apart a certain time to the service of God forever? The books of the New Testament contain no testimony concerning this. But Mosheim continues, ‘The nature of the thing’ stands for the lack of testimonies. But right here we appeal to Mosheim’s own words against Mosheim, ‘Things occurred can only be proven by testimonies.’ We might perhaps from the nature of a matter admit a supposition that something not testified to might have happened; but this we can only admit for periods, of which the historical testimonies are altogether too incomplete, but regarding a time with as rich a literature as the New Testament, never. And it is not at all allowable to set instead a supposition a certainty, on which we afterward build a doctrine, which binds our conscience. Also the question whether the apostles have appointed Sunday as the Christian day of worship, Mosheim answers in the affirmative. But we also know from history that the Sabbath had in Christendom the same right and the same honor, besides the Sunday, for nearly two hundred years after the apostolic age. Mosheim declares Sunday to be an ‘eternal’ institution, because the resurrection has eternal significance. (pp. 484, 485.) But in the life of Christ finally everything has an eternal signification. But can we without any special authority from the Scriptures, which according to Mosheim’s own statements are wanting with Sunday, tie to all the great events in the life of Christ, ceremonies, and declare them to be of the same eternal significance as those events?—By no means. Such would only be human ordinances, against which Christ himself has protested.” (Matthew 15.)
From the above statement of this German college president, though himself a Sunday-keeper, and writing in favor of Sunday, we can plainly see how Mosheim, by trying to invent a new theory to substantiate Sunday, simply contradicts himself. With what feelings Mosheim undertook to write on this subject, his words in the beginning of his treatise show:—
“I must openly confess that I have doubted for some time whether I should treat the doctrine concerning the Sabbath, as it is usually called, or Sunday, or not. As often as I presented to myself the intimate connection of this matter with the doctrine of public worship, as often I judged that I could not let it untouched. But as often as the multitude of treatises came to my mind and the different manners in which it was treated, as often I was ready to change this conclusion.”
This admission speaks for itself. When Mosheim was writing this church history, it was an easy matter to turn it off with a simple assertion by referring to two other authors; but when it came to prove the matter, he looked in vain for the divine command, or for the “express appointment of the apostles,” and instead of the “united testimonies of the most credible writers,” as Maclaine twists Mosheim’s words, he saw but a babel of theories, which scared him from the task for some time. But finally he became more courageous, and at the beginning of the eighteenth century he hoped to make Sunday-keepers happy by a new course of reasonings which would prove that they were right after all.
But lo, he simply added another to the multitudes of theories concerning Sunday, to be exploded by the next writer; and ever since, they have been busy writing essay after essay, inventing theory after theory. They can surely only be pitied in their unthankful task!
And on the assertion of such a man as Mosheim, ministers, theologians, and lay members dare to rest their assertions concerning Sunday, as though he was almost infallible. Yes, they will produce his simple assertion, which he rests on two other men, which say just the opposite from what he does, and even in spite of his own contradictions, hold it up against the plain word of God! If any one wishes to build on such a sandy foundation, he is to be pitied. One thing we have clearly proved, that church historians, at the best, have, when writing about the Sunday question in the first two centuries after the apostolic age, nothing more than the word of God, which we all have, and they not only disagree among themselves, but Mosheim with Mosheim. How grateful can we be for the plain, simple, and harmonious truths of this last message; and while others try to legalize a human ordinance held up by a network of contradictions, assertions, and untruths, the Lord in his boundless mercy has turned our eyes to the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. Great men err in their own wisdom, and worship in vain, observing the ordinances of men, but the simple may turn to the commandments of God; for it makes wise the simple, and enlightens his eyes. L. R. C.