Your ShelfYour Projects

Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 50.

THE NEW YEAR
Earlier text: The Future Kingdom

THE QUESTION CORNER.

THE THIRD JUDGE.

Who was the third judge of Israel?
A. N.
Answer : Shamgar. See Judges 3 : 31.

THE BREATH OF LIFE.

A Pennsylvania superintendent is in deep theological trouble, as the following letter plainly shows :—
“There were some texts of Scripture used in the lesson on the nature of man that I cannot understand as they are there explained. One is Eccl. 12 : 7. The Spirit spoken of cannot be the breath in the body; for, don’t you see, if the breath by simply going out into the surrounding atmosphere could be said to return to God, we could just as reasonably say the dust returns to God by mingling with the surrounding dust. When Nicodemus came to Jesus he told him that he must be born again; that is, born of the Spirit; and in Rom. 8 : 9, 10, 11, it is made very plain that we have a spirit that God takes to himself at death, and will restore it at the resurrection, which is our eternal life. I cannot explain this as I would if I could talk it to you; but I think these texts that are used in regard to the Spirit apply only to the sons of God, and not to the sinner or man in an unconverted state. I do not think this spirit that comes by the new birth has any consciousness after death; it is simply the earnest of our inheritance until the redemption of the purchased possession. Eph. 1 : 13, 14.”
The spirit spoken of in Eccl. 12 : 7 is ruach, the primary meaning of which is breath. See Gesenius. It must be the same as that breathed into man by God at his creation; for the way in which man dies, as described in the text before us, is just the reverse of the process by which he was created, as described in Gen. 2 : 7. Notice : In his creation, man was formed of the dust; in his dissolution, the dust returns to dust as it was. In his creation, the breath of life was given him by the Creator; in his dissolution that breath of life went back to God who gave it. In his creation, the breathing into his nostrils the breath of life caused him to live; in his dissolution, the taking away of that breath caused him to die. The conclusion, then, cannot be questioned, that the spirit which goes back to God at man’s death is the breath of life which God gave man at his creation.
But now the question arises, What is this breath of life? In answer, it may be positively said that, so far from its being something possessed by man alone, all the animals have it in common with him. Compare the following : “Breathed into his nostrils the nishmath chayyim, breath of lives.” Gen. 2 : 7. “Two by two of all flesh, wherein is the ruach chayyim, spirit of lives.” Gen. 7 : 15. “All in whose nostrils was the nishmath ruach chayyim, breath of spirit of lives.” Gen. 7 : 22.
I conclude, therefore, that the breath of life was the life principle,—that by which the complicated machinery of man’s organism was made to throb with life. It was something more than common air, for the perfectly formed, yet lifeless, man was surrounded with that before. Air, or breath, may be said to support life after it is given; but it is not life itself. The life principle was imparted to the lifeless organism by God. He chose to impart it through the breath. He might have imparted it in many other ways, or by a simple command, but he chose to breathe it into man’s nostrils; and because the breath was the means of conveying the life from God to man, it is called the breath of life. This life was not intelligent or conscious, much less immortal. The spirit’s going to God at death, is not the breathing out of the air which filled the lungs into the surrounding air,—but the taking away by Jehovah of the life principle, which having been imparted in and through the breath or spirit, is also taken away in the same manner.
Concerning the case of Nicodemus and the passage in Rom. 8 : 9-11, it need only be said that the spirit there referred to is the Holy Spirit, and not an inherent part of man’s nature. The Spirit of Christ which dwells in the true Christian, places him in such a relation to God that his life is said to be hid with Christ in God; and at the resurrection, he is raised to eternal life by the Spirit of Christ that he enjoyed in this life. This relation to God the unconverted man does not of course possess; the Spirit of Christ does not dwell in him. C. C. L.

THE ATONEMENT.

A NEW, ENLARGED, AND IMPROVED EDITION OF AN EXCELLENT WORK.
THOSE who have come to feel and confess that the blood of Christ alone can save us, are ready to acknowledge that the subject of the atonement, as an embodiment of this truth, is the great central doctrine of revelation. In it is involved also the great central “mystery” of the gospel—“God manifest in the flesh,” a divine being bearing the nature of the seed of Abraham, the innocent paying to inexorable law the debt of the guilty, the criminal pardoned, and at the same time the welfare of the universe not imperiled, the majesty of law sustained, justice satisfied, mercy magnified, and the love and wisdom of God manifesting themselves in a more brilliant aureole of light and glory.
It is a doctrine which is extremely sensitive in its relation to other doctrines; that is, more than any other doctrine it exacts of him who would understand it, correctness of belief in all other parts of his faith. It is a doctrine such that if erroneous views are held concerning it, those errors are more far-reaching and more demoralizing to a correct system of truth, than errors on almost any other article of faith.
Unfortunately the Christian world has suffered one of the great truths of revelation—a glowing feature of the plan of redemption—to pass into the background, and be lost sight of. We refer to the subject of the sanctuary. As a consequence, the doctrine of the atonement has become, in the minds of the great mass of Christians, involved in great obscurity and perplexity. And theologians have been led to take positions on the question which are immensely mischievous. Its nature is presented in such a light as to expose it to the charge of leading to license and immorality; and the time of its accomplishment is fixed at such a period that it makes inevitable the doctrine either of universal salvation, or of Calvinistic predestination.
Take the almost universally accepted view that Christ made the atonement on the cross, and one or the other of the errors above named is inevitable. For Christ bore upon the cross the sins of all the world; and if that was the making of the atonement, then the sins of the whole world are atoned for, and universal salvation is the result. Others who cannot accept this conclusion, still clinging to the error that the atonement was made upon the cross, are driven to the conclusion that the work of Christ upon the cross was not for all the world, but was partial, embracing only a special predestinated class, whose sins alone were atoned for, and who consequently, despite all contingencies, must be saved. Thus a distorted form of the doctrine of election is produced. The teaching of the sanctuary question shows that the atonement was not made upon the cross; and if men would accept this, the theology of Christendom would be revolutionized.
There are but few books issued upon this important subject; hence there is here a want to be supplied in the theological world. The book we here refer to, is the new edition of “The Atonement; an Examination of a Remedial System in the Light of Nature and Revelation,” by Eld. J. H. Waggoner. The author treats the subject from the vantage ground of present truth; and while the smaller book which he issued years ago, shed much light on this subject, and did a good work, we have here in the revised and enlarged edition, a complete and exhaustive treatise upon this great question. Yet the arguments are so concisely stated that the work is not bulky, consisting of only 368 pages, and not expensive, the price being only one dollar.
It is unnecessary to say to those so well acquainted with the author as are the readers of the REVIEW, that he builds his argument like an adamantine wall, of such smooth and compact face, that the sharpest darts of the opposition find no crevice through which they can enter, but fall blunted and broken at its base. The subject is presented in two parts: “I. An Atonement Consistent with Reason; II. The Atonement as Revealed in the Bible.” And the scope of the work will be seen from the headings of its chapters. Thus, “Part I. Chapter 1. Comparison of Nature and Morality; 2. The Moral System; 3. Requirements of the Moral System. Part II. Chapter 1. Principles of the Divine Government; 2. Sin and its Penalty; 3. Justification and Obedience; 4. The Death of Christ Vicarious; 5. The Son of God Died; 6. Doctrine of a Trinity Subversive of the Atonement; 7. What the Atonement is; 8. The Judgment; 9. The Scape-goat; 10. The Kingdom of Christ; 11 and 12. Redemption; 13. Conclusion,” followed by two Appendices, and a closing paper on “The Love of God in Creation.”
The book is needed. And now that the author has so well done his part, and the publishers have brought out the work neatly bound in muslin, at so reasonable a price, it should be sent forth on a lively mission. All our people should procure it, and not simply cursorily read it, but study it—study it till the idea is grasped, and the argument understood. Then place it in the hands of candid and thoughtful readers everywhere.
Too many oppose this doctrine because it is misrepresented. Too many think it a dry subject because they do not understand it. Too many are indifferent to it, because of the artificial and imaginary difficulties with which they clothe it. Now is a golden opportunity for all to assist in dispelling misunderstandings, and presenting in its true light and real beauty that marvelous work by which God has shown his love to man, and by which man becomes reconciled to God. See notice on last page.

THE IRREPRESSIBLE CONFLICT.

We have received from an officer of the “Liberal League” of America, a circular setting forth their “demands” and defining their present progress and position. No. 7, of their demands, which was underscored in the circular we received, reads as follows:—
“7. We demand that all laws directly or indirectly enforcing the observance of Sunday as the Sabbath shall be repealed.”
In an address to the liberals of America, on the reverse side of the circular, they call upon all to join their ranks “who are in favor of a total separation of Church and State;” they claim that they are “taking part in the mightiest movement in the history of the world,” and declare that “the prospects were never so bright before them as they are to-day.”
Such an attitude will arouse the church party—which is the “National Reform,” “Religious Amendment” or “Sunday” party—as nothing else could do. When liberalism becomes an active aggressive element, the church must supinely yield the ground, and give it the victory, or organize and push forward counter movements. This becomes absolutely necessary to their own existence; and neither party can adopt as their ultimatum any half-way measures. They must each seek ground so radical that it will leave no compromise with the other party; and neither can now recede from the stand it has taken. It is with each the final question of life or death.
This attitude on the part of the liberals will do more than anything else to unite Protestants and Catholics. And who for a moment doubts that these two bodies, once united and co-operating, can carry through any measure they may choose?

SIGNIFICANT MOVEMENTS.

A SHORT but very striking article, entitled “Catholics and Protestants,” appeared in the Springfield Weekly Union of Oct. 9, 1884. In this article the writer not only speaks of the growing indications that Protestants are inclined to abandon the specific grounds which have separated them from Rome, and seek an alliance with the papal hierarchy, but enthusiastically offers certain reasons why he thinks it ought to be so. Two of the more significant passages we quote. The first reads as follows:—
“The signs are many that Protestants, both ministers and laymen, are disposed to cut through the exclusiveness that has shut them off from any sort of communion with the Catholic church. The old Puritan spirit that could see no good whatever in the church of Rome has relaxed its rigidity. The distinctions of doctrine and authority remain, but there is a vast amount of Christianizing work to be done, in which there is essential unity of purpose.”
The time was when Protestants seemed to think that Christianizing work could best be done by Christians; that to be effectual it must be attended with the blessing of God; but that God could not bless any organization which sets itself up as a rival of the Most High, which is built upon a system that breeds all manner of corruption, and whose chief work is to bind the souls of men in degrading bonds of superstition and error. If ever a reason existed for a “protest” against these things, it exists in greater force to-day. Is it not then a startling fact that Protestants should now so far lose sight of their mission as to speak and act in a manner which is a virtual confession that the grand work of the past three centuries and a half is a mistake?
Again the writer says:—
“It is time that the coldness, or suspicion, or diffidence, or whatever it be, that has kept the clergymen of the two branches of the church apart, were thrown off, that differences of organization and doctrine were practically ignored, and that all Christians who can recite together the apostle’s creed, who can offer together the Lord’s Prayer and who can draw their faith and inspiration from the same Bible, should stand together in line of battle against Satan and all his works.”
Granted that it is time that there should be a discarding of differences and a cultivation of union, does the papal church propose to do any work of this kind? Not a particle. She claims infallibility and holds every Protestant to be a member of a damnable horde of heretics. Protestants must do all the retracting, make all the concessions. Then the Catholic church may perhaps take them back as erring and repentant children. Are Protestants willing to do this?
But what gives these movements special significance from our standpoint is the fact that we are drawing near to the time of the fulfillment of certain well defined prophecies, which involve this very condition of more or less outward union and co-operation between these very parties, Catholicism and Protestantism. And this position was taken by S. D. Adventists years ago, when not a whisper was heard in all the land in favor of such a union. And what does it now mean that such voices as quoted above are beginning everywhere to be raised? It means that anti-Christian forces are getting ready for their work, and the last act in the great prophetic drama is at our very doors. It means that Rev. 13:14-17 is soon to be fulfilled; and that brings to every loyal follower of Christ the fulfillment of Rev. 14:1,—the crowning victory on Mount Zion. Let the day of triumph come, though it must needs be through scenes of conflict which will try men’s souls.

MEN OF MICHIGAN, AROUSE!

Those who attended our late General Conference will well remember how on one occasion, when a question of importance was under consideration, and the discussion waxed warm and earnest, one speaker closed his remarks with the thrilling exclamation, “Rouse, ye men of Michigan!”
We felt like having this exclamation repeated in almost every church in Michigan, when in making out the General Conference statistics last week, the following facts appeared:—
California, with a membership of only 1339, pays $16,851.30 in tithes, or $12.58½ per member; while Michigan, with a membership of 3622, pays only $15,179.94 in tithes, or $4.19 per member. Only one church in Michigan approaches in the matter of tithes the churches in the California Conference: That is the church in Battle Creek, which pays an amount of tithes, averaging $10 per member, or about $5,000 in all, nearly one-third of the entire amount paid in the State; while outside of this church the average per member is about $3. Why should not others whose circumstances are generally better than those of the church here, do as well in the matter of tithes? Why should not Michigan do as well as California? What is the meaning of this? Where are your treasures? Where are your affections? “Men of Michigan, arouse!”

THE SEVEN WEEKS AND NEHEMIAH'S REFORMATION.

A CORRESPONDENT writes: “In ‘Thoughts,’ pp. 205, 206, you refer to Nehemiah 13:23-31 as recording events which mark the close of the seven weeks of Dan. 9:25, which began in the year 457 B. C. But in the margin of my Bible I find the year 434 given, instead of 408, as the date when the work of building and restoring was completed. ‘Smith’s History of the Bible’ also agrees with this marginal date. Is there an explanation of this matter?”
ANSWER. Nehemiah mentions, as one of the evils to be reformed, that even one of the sons of Joiada, the high priest, had contracted an unlawful marriage with a daughter of Sanballat, the Horonite, and thus set a most pernicious example of alliance with the heathen of the land. Nehemiah, stretching his authority to its utmost limit, was determined to break down that practice, and so made an example of even so eminent a person as the son of the high priest.
The question first to be determined is, Who was the high priest at that time according to the testimony of Nehemiah? His words in chapter 13:28, are: “One of the sons of Joiada, the son of Eliashib the high priest.” The only question here is whether the word “high priest” is in apposition with Joiada or Eliashib, or, in other words, which one of these persons is mentioned as the high priest at that time. On this point Prideaux (Connection I. 323) has the following remark:—
“If any one shall say that in the text of Nehemiah (ch. 13:28) the word high priest is put in apposition with Eliashib, and not with Joiada, and that therefore this last act of Nehemiah’s reformation was in the high-priesthood of Eliashib and not in that of Joiada his son; my answer hereto is, that the Hebrew original cannot bear this interpretation; for it having been the usage of the Jews, as well as of all other nations of the East, for the better distinguishing of persons, to add the name of the father to that of the son, in the same manner as was lately practiced by the Welsh, and still is among the Irish, these words in the text, ‘Joiada ben Eliashib,’ i. e., Joiada the son of Eliashib, all together make but one name of the same person, and therefore the word ‘high-priest,’ which followeth, can be put in apposition with nothing but the whole of it.”
This point being settled, on Nehemiah’s own testimony, that it was in the priesthood of Joiada, the next question to be considered is, When was Joiada made high-priest? This is settled by the “Chronicon Alexandrinum,” which, says Prideaux, “gives us the truest account of the succession of the high priests of the Jews from the captivity of Babylon to the reign of the Seleucian kings;” and according to this authority, Eliashib died and was succeeded by his son Joiada, in that year which corresponds to the eleventh year of Darius Nothus in the Canon of Ptolemy. This was the year 412 B. C., within four years of 408 B. C., where the 7 weeks, or 49 years of Dan. 9:25, would end dated from 457 B. C. And since this last act of reformation by Nehemiah, which finished the restoration of the Jewish state, was accomplished somewhere in or during the priesthood of Joiada, we may with all assurance place it in 408 B. C., four years from the time when he entered upon his office.
The reason the date is given as it is in the margin of Neh. 13:23, is doubtless because the translators supposed this event to have occurred in the priesthood of Eliashib, 434 B. C., instead of the priesthood of Joiada his son, B. C. 408, and did not see the connection between this record and the prophecy of Dan. 9:25.

THE WORLD’S EXPOSITION AT NEW ORLEANS.

It is well understood that the “World’s Exposition” is to be held at New Orleans, La., this winter. This will be the most favorable opportunity to scatter the seeds of truth throughout the South that has ever presented itself. The Southern States are specially interested in this Exposition, and will be largely represented. There will be an opportunity to send the truth, not only to all parts of the South, but to the most distant fields, and also to form an acquaintance with individuals from all parts of the world.
In the early history of the gospel, believers as well as persons who came from idle curiosity and for other causes, were present at Jerusalem during the annual feasts of the Jews. These annual gatherings were made special seasons of instruction, that a knowledge of the Scriptures might be carried to all parts of the earth. It was on one of these occasions that God signally poured out his Spirit, and three thousand were converted.
The Saviour chose public places in which to instruct his disciples, that the multitudes might hear the sound of the gospel. In order that it might be carried to all the world the great apostle to the Gentiles sought to preach the truth in centers of learning and travel, to which people flocked from all parts. “But I say, Have they not heard? Yes, verily, their sound went unto all the earth, and their words unto the end of the world.” It was the special providence of God that brought Luther to Worms that the leading men of the seventeenth century might hear the glad tidings of a Saviour’s love and a free salvation.
We have a world-wide message; it is to go to earth’s remotest bounds. The opportunity afforded by this World’s Fair to scatter the truth far and wide is one in which our brethren everywhere will feel an interest, and will want to show it in a practical manner. It was in view of these things that the following resolutions were passed at the time of the General Conference by the International Tract and Missionary Society:—
“Resolved, That we recommend that the various branches of the work connected with the cause of the third angel’s message be represented at this assembly of the nations.”
“Resolved, That immediate steps be taken by this Society to open a city mission in New Orleans, and to organize a sufficient corps of workers under the immediate direction of the President of this Society to labor in disseminating the light of present truth, by scattering our periodicals, obtaining addresses, and such other work as the occasion may demand.”
“Resolved, That we invite the different State societies and also our institutions to provide and support the laborers, and furnish the publications to carry on this important general enterprise.”
It can readily be seen that if the different State societies provide for the laborers during the Exposition, the expense would come very light upon any one fund or State, and yet each State would have the privilege of doing its part.
It was thought advisable for Eld. Kilgore to go directly from Battle Creek to New Orleans. Since his arrival we have had several encouraging letters from him. A space in the Exposition has been secured, and the prospect for carrying on the missionary work is good.
We have ordered from the REVIEW Office a large amount of books, and 2,000 Signs, to be sent directly from the Signs Office, besides a quantity of periodicals in the different languages, to be shipped to New Orleans. I expect within a few weeks to spend a short time in that city. My object in going will be to assist in organizing a missionary force. This will give an experience to those who wish to engage in city work in any part of the country. The missionary work carried forward in New Orleans will doubtless include all the features of that work, such as Bible-readings, ship-work, canvassing, and meeting with those who have come from other nations. This will be an important move, and steps should be taken immediately by our different societies to furnish laborers. It is expected that whoever goes to New Orleans to engage in the missionary work, according to the resolution, shall be recommended by the President of their own Conference or tract society; and we wish to learn from such individuals or from the Conference Committee, (1) the addresses of those who are going, and (2) when they will be prepared to start. By such a correspondence we shall be prepared to fix a definite time and place to meet in that city. Those coming should bring with them a bed and bed-clothing, and arrangements will be made so that all such can take care of themselves. The expense of living in New Orleans is as cheap as in any city in America, providing we make our own arrangements. All correspondence respecting the matter should be addressed to myself at South Lancaster, Mass.
S. N. HASKELL.

THE SONGS OF THE ANCIENT HEBREWS.

NEVER were truer words spoken in regard to music, than the following paragraphs from the pen of Sr. White, which appeared in the True Educator of September, of the present year:—
“The art of sacred melody was diligently cultivated in those schools of the prophets. No frivolous waltz was heard, nor flippant song that should extol man and divert the attention from God; but sacred, solemn psalms of praise to the Creator, exalting his name and recounting his wondrous works. Thus music was made to serve a holy purpose, to lift the thoughts to that which was pure and noble and elevating, and to awaken in the soul, devotion and gratitude to God.
“How different the object to which musical talent is often devoted! How many who possess this gift employ it to honor and exalt self, instead of glorifying God! A love for music leads the unwary to unite with world-lovers in pleasure gatherings where God has forbidden his children to go. Thus that which is a great blessing when rightly used, becomes one of Satan’s most successful agencies to allure the mind from God and eternal things.
“Music forms a part of God’s worship in the courts above. We should endeavor in our songs of praise to approach as nearly as possible to the harmony of the heavenly choirs. I have often been pained to hear untrained voices, pitched to the highest key, literally shrieking the sacred words of some hymn of praise. How inappropriate those sharp, rasping voices for the solemn, joyous worship of God. I long to stop my ears, or flee from the place, and I rejoice when the painful exercise is ended.
“Those who make singing a part of divine worship should select hymns with music appropriate to the occasion, not funereal notes, but cheerful yet solemn melodies. The voice can and should be modulated, softened, and subdued.
“The proper training of the voice should be regarded as an important part of education. The singer should train himself to utter every word distinctly. It should be remembered that singing as a part of religious service is as much an act of worship as is the prayer. The heart must feel the spirit of the words, to give them right expression. Parents should not employ a teacher of music, to instruct their children, who has no reverence for sacred things, nor should they allow them to learn and practice dance music and frivolous songs.”

Stubbornness Is Not Firmness

—Stubbornness is far from being firmness.

STOP BEFORE YOU BEGIN.

THE Bible repeatedly warns us that sin is a terrible thing, very dangerous to meddle with at all; because, when practiced, it blinds the mind, hardens the heart, and perverts the conscience. Sin caused the death of the Son of God 1 Cor. 15:3. Sin caused the banishment from heaven of those who were once holy angels, and its continued practice has degraded them into devils and demons. 2 Pet. 2:4. It was sin also that thrust Adam and Eve out of Eden (Gen. 3), and in consequence of sin the most of the race will finally be lost and destroyed. Matt. 7:13, 14.
Sin is very corrupting. It contaminates and defiles whatever it touches. To illustrate: Put a rotten potato in the midst of sound ones and it will soon rot those around it. But put a sound one among rotten ones, and will it make others sound? No, indeed. So it is with sin. It has a terrible influence for evil everywhere. Our only safety is in not meddling with it at all. It is like the leprosy, which, when once fastened upon a person, goes on spreading and poisoning the system till the whole body is devoured. Thus God says that a curse rests upon the house of the thief and of the false swearer, and that it shall abide there till that house is devoured. Zech. 5:1–4. A wrong once committed leaves a stain upon the conscience, a scar upon the soul which will remain long after the act is forgotten. A friend of mine tells me that once he was nearly drowned, but finally was resuscitated. In that brief moment of drowning all the deeds of his whole life came vividly flashing before him, just as clear and distinct as when first committed. So it will be in the Judgment.
Sin blinds a man's eyes. Matt. 15:14, 15. When a youth tells his first lie, he feels exceedingly guilty, ashamed, and unhappy. He thinks he will never do it again; but he is deceived. The next time he will yield to temptation easier than before, and so on till he is a confirmed liar. The only safe way is not to begin. The practice of wrong doing hardens the heart till the greatest crimes can be committed without feeling. Gibbs, the notorious pirate, the terror of the seas, who could butcher whole crews without flinching, began by little acts of wrong and meanness. Young man, don't venture the first step in wrong doing.
Sin perverts the judgment. Rom. 1:28. I have been in a Chinese temple, and seen intelligent men come in and worship a most hideous idol. Why can they not see the folly of this? Their judgment has been perverted.
I once ate of leaky butter, that is, butter tainted by leeks which the cows ate in early spring. It tasted strong, like onions, and was very repulsive. They told me to eat an onion first and then I would not taste the leeks. I did, and found it true. So, if we first taste of sin, afterward it does not seem very bad, and finally ceases to annoy us at all. Our only safety lies in heeding the solemn warning: “Touch not, taste not, handle not.” Col. 2:21.
If we disregard the first admonitions of conscience, its voice will become fainter and fainter till it ceases to be noticed at all. It is like an alarm clock, which, if you disregard a few times in order to take another short nap, will fail to awaken you at all, however loudly it may ring. I have tried this and know. Conscience disregarded ceases to warn. Hence we should be exceedingly careful of our habits, as these finally harden into permanent character. In view of this the prophet of God warns: “Can the Ethiopian change his skin, or the leopard his spots? Then may ye also do good that are accustomed to do evil?” Jer. 1:23.
That is it. When you have become accustomed to do evil, then stop if you can. Many, before they begin, think they can stop easily whenever they choose. Then why don't they do it? The fact that they don't is proof that they were deceived. The only safe course is to stop before you begin.
D. M. CANRIGHT.

DOES GOD'S PROVIDENCE CONTRADICT HIS EXPRESSED WILL?

The will of the Lord is expressed in his word. Jesus prayed that all who should believe on him might be one. And the completeness of this unity he expresses thus: “That they all may be one, even as we are one.” A unity equal to that which exists between the Father and the Son must be perfect. There can be no discord, no division of sentiment in such a union. This sort of unity among Christians was the desire of Jesus and the will of his Father.
The apostles taught the same. Says Paul, “Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.” Again he reproves the divisions of the church as follows: “Whereas there is among you envyings, and strife, and divisions, are ye not carnal? For while one saith, I am of Paul, and another, I am of Apollos, are ye not carnal?”
From these testimonies we learn that unity is of God, being in harmony with his will; but that division is the fruits of the carnal mind of men. Now when God can approve the carnal mind, which is enmity against God, then doubtless he can look with complacency on divisions among his people. But if divisions in the primitive church were wrong, by what means have they become right now? Is that which was contrary to the will of God then in harmony with his will now? Can it be that the present divisions are by his providence? Is God the author of them in any sense? Is it not rather the truth that as divisions originated with the carnal mind, they are perpetuated by the same?—a mind that cannot be made to yield to the claims of the law of God, as revealed in his word?
These reflections are suggested by an article in the Christian at Work, in which the writer alludes to the various sects of Christians as “armies of the Lord,” each sect constituting an army corps, all united in a spiritual unity; and claiming that these divisions are providential, that the emulations between them are healthy, and that “the church was never purer, more prosperous, or more efficient than it is to-day.”
Now was it not apostasy from the truth and the introduction of errors and lies which first brought divisions into the church? Could divisions be perpetuated, if none were in error? Are not differences in faith and practice a sure indication of error somewhere? Was it not by the perverse will of men that divisions came, and are they not perpetuated by the stubborn will, which refuses to abandon error for Bible truth? It is true, Providence suffers things to be as they are. God suffers men to do as they will, regardless of his word; but he never can approve of that which he once condemned. It is a query whether any of those sects in the Corinthian church thought of replying to Paul that their divisions were “providential,” that the “emulation between them” was “healthy.”
But a “spiritual unity” is supposed to exist between those who are in hopeless division in regard to revealed truth and duty. A liberality which favors a compromise of differing and discordant sects, is thought to be true charity, and an exhibition of spiritual unity. A unity in Bible truth and Christian duty is not proposed, as such a unity is hopeless. All are so tenacious of their contradictory creed that there is no hope that all can come to “speak the same thing” and be “perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.” Therefore a union is proposed which ignores the doctrines taught by the apostles, and puts truth and fables on an equal footing. The prediction of Paul is already fulfilled: “For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but after their own lusts shall they HEAP to themselves teachers, having itching ears; and they shall turn away their ears from the truth, and shall be turned unto fables.” In view of this he exhorts Timothy: “Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them: for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself and them that hear thee.”
The apostle had a jealous care to preserve the purity of the doctrine of Christ in the church. He desires Timothy to “charge some that they teach no other doctrine, neither give heed to fables.” But the fables have come in as he predicted they would, and have caused the divisions which we see at the present day. And now with a supposed “spiritual unity” which ignores the difference between truth and error, it is held that “the church was never purer, more prosperous, or more efficient than it is to-day.” And this charitable unity existing among Protestant churches called evangelical is capable of almost unlimited expansion. Present indications show that it is destined soon to embrace in its broad mantle that church which for centuries past has been held by them to be “the mother of harlots and abominations of the earth.” And why not? She has Bible truth mixed with fables and corruptions, as well as they. Indeed, they are indebted to her for the leading fables which they hold.
But God has prepared a message in prophecy which is sure to bring the remnant of his people into a real unity of faith and practice. Rev. 14:9–12. This message is now being proclaimed in fulfillment of the prophecy, and the people are being developed that eschew the corruptions of Romanism, and “keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.” All who obey this last call in truth, will be “perfectly joined together in one mind and one judgment;” they will “speak the same thing,” and there will be “no divisions among them.” The Lord hasten this blessed consummation.
R. F. COTTRELL.

ON THE WRONG SIDE OF THE CLOUD.

There is one very significant fact concerning the cloudy pillar that went with the Israelites through the wilderness. While it gave light to the people of God on the one side, it was darkness to the Egyptians on the other. Thus the record says:—“It was a cloud and darkness to them, but it gave light by night to these.” Ex. 14 : 20. To God’s people it was light; to his enemies, it was darkness. This seems to be an exact parallel to Paul’s statement : “The preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.” 1 Cor. 1 : 18.
That is the way it always has been with God’s truth. To those looking at it from the right side it is a most glorious light, but to those looking at it from the other side it is total darkness. Indeed, to the same persons in different moods the same work looks entirely different. So it makes a great difference which side of the cloud you are on. Get into the light, on the light side, and it will look light; but get into the dark, on the dark side, and it looks dark. Brethren, which side of the cloud are you on? D. M. CANRIGHT.
Continue reading: SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS