Washington, June 30.—Ex-Senator Ingalls addressed a large audience at the National Chautauqua, in Glen Echo, this afternoon, upon “The Problems of Our Second Century.” He began his lecture with a glowing tribute to Washington, eulogizing its many advantages as a resident city, referring to its lack of popular suffrage, and predicting that the time would never come when it would be removed from its present site.
“There is a growing sentiment,” said Senator Ingalls, as he entered upon the topic he had selected for his talk, “in favor of paternalism in this country; of the Government doing everything and the people doing nothing. This,” he continued, “was diametrically opposed to the idea of individualism upon which this Government had been built and the good Anglo-Saxon doctrine of root, hog, or die. It has always happened in every community that the weak were more numerous than the strong, that the number of those who failed, outnumbered those who succeeded, and that the wise, the intelligent, and the thoughtful were in the minority. We have now a new school of political philosophy that is repudiating the Declaration of Independence, and is endeavoring to overthrow maxims of democracy and to insist that the race shall not be for the swift nor the battle to the strong; that the distinction ordained by God among men shall be an obliterated statute, so that idleness shall bring the same reward as industry and thrift; that the ignorant shall be as wise as the learned; that debts shall be paid by acts of Congress; that money shall be made as plentiful as the autumn leaves of the forest; that taxation shall be abolished by acts of State legislatures, and that prosperity shall be forcibly distributed equally among all men.”
Dwelling for a few moments on the progress of the Anglo-Saxon race, Senator Ingalls then paid tribute to the people from whom the American nation sprung. “Among them,” he said, “were no Nihilists or Socialists.” The Anglo-Saxon characteristic of individualism, right of personal liberty, freedom of conscience, and the development of the faculties of every man, was forcibly emphasized. “It was a race,” he said, “that would not intermingle with other races. The Chinese have had some taste of this.”
“The negro has had some melancholy experiences, and the anarchists and socialists,” he added, amid applause, “will have a still more significant experience before the Anglo-Saxon race is through with them.”
“The doctrine of the devil take the hindmost,” continued Mr. Ingalls, amid laughter, “was a good one, but just now it seemed as if there were more hindmost than foremost. If the present condition of things were to continue without being retarded, this land, instead of being the home of the free and the land of the brave, would be the home of the rich and the land of the slave.”
In the course of his address, Mr. Ingalls said that he and Jay Gould were of about the same age, and had started in active life about the same time. “Mr. Gould,” said the Ex-Senator, “entered Wall Street with a patent mouse-trap as his only stock in trade, and setting it, has nearly succeeded in capturing everything in sight. I started West with my gripsack, and now I am a statesman out of a job.”
In conclusion, Mr. Ingalls said that he could not disguise the fact that the present was a momentous crisis, that the destructive forces of our civilization are marshaled for the final contest; upon this continent was to be fought the battle that meant despotism or victory. “This is the last experiment in republican institutions, but the attempt to cure the ills of society by statute would be as futile as the effort to make the mercury stand at zero in July and at boiling point in January.”
He apparently has great faith in the American people. “This Government,” he said finally, “is based upon the New Testament, upon the teachings of Jesus Christ, who declared that all men were equal before the law, and that the fatherhood of God resulted in the brotherhood of man. This contest will have but one result. I have no doubt that the progress of the nation will be constantly upward. In every crisis of history, in all the bitter struggles of humanity through the desolate tract of wretchedness and poverty, still the progress of the race has been onward and upward. Out of every struggle, out of every contest, have come broader liberty, greater opportunities for happiness and greater prophecies of the development of the race hereafter; and so out of this contest upon which we have entered, will come absolutely at last a triumph of liberty and social fraternity of the American people and the continued progress in wealth, industry, and intelligence of the entire American republic.”
—Kansas City Weekly Journal.
CONTRADICTORY DECISIONS OF THE CHURCH OF ROME.
By W. Penniman
The following question and answer from the St. Louis Globe Democrat of July 24, 1891, will show some of the contradictory decisions of the Church of Rome. Although the papal church boasts that its doctrine is a unit, that Rome never changes, it can be learned by reading its history, that there is much disagreement in doctrine. The boast that she never changes, is false, as it is a fact that she does change for the worse instead of the better; and the only reason why she does not persecute and run the Inquisition now as in the time of the papal supremacy, is that she lacks the power. If she would change for the better, she should hold another council, and repeal the doctrine of papal infallibility, which was proclaimed in the council of 1870.
Have the leading councils of the church always been harmonious in their decisions one with another?
The decisions of the councils have often been contradictory. For instance, the teaching of Athanasius was condemned by the councils of Arles, Tyre, and Milan, and approved by the councils of Nice and Sardica. The Council of Nice, which approved Athanasius, condemned Arius as a heretic, but three councils of Constantinople declared in favor of Arianism, and a council held at Sardica was so divided on the subject that each party excommunicated the other. The Council of Sardica, in 360, excluded the Apocrypha from the Canon, but in 397 the Council of Carthage declared it of equal authority with any other portion of Scripture. In 638 a council of Constantinople confirmed the doctrines of the Monothelites, but in 680 another council, also in Constantinople, declared it to be heresy, this decision being afterward condemned by four other councils. In 730 a council of Constantinople approved Iconoclasm, in 814 it was condemned, in 815 approved, and by four subsequent councils condemned. In 754 a Constantinople council condemned the worship of images; in 766 a Jerusalem council favored the practice; in 829 it was condemned; in 842 it was again approved. The above contradictory decisions are but samples of what may be ascertained by an examination of the acts of the councils.
W. PENNIMAN.
Cunard Line Orders Two Fast Ocean Racers
—The Cunard Line has contracted for two fast ocean racers of 12,000 tons each, capable of making the trip from Liverpool to New York in five days and eight hours. They will cost $2,000,000 each, and be ready in 1892.
Reform Judaism and the Sunday Services Question
For a number of years past, as our readers are aware, the question of establishing Sunday services for the Jews, and passing the Sabbath worship over to that day, has been extensively agitated among that people. Inasmuch as the Jews are so generally inclined to sacrifice their Sabbath convictions at the shrine of Mammon, and over-ride the Sabbatic institution for the sake of gain, it has been thought that by taking the day recognized in this country, by the Government and the churches, as a day of rest—a day when the Jew cannot follow his worldly pursuits—and making that a day of worship, it would tend to keep alive in his mind the Sabbatic idea, without interfering with his commercial passion. Dr. K. Kohler of the Sinai Congregation, Chicago, has been an earnest advocate of this plan, arguing that: “Reform Judaism would rather see the Sabbath observed on Sunday than not at all.”
But a change has come over the spirit of his dream; and in the Menorah Monthly (New York) of Sept. 1891, Dr. K. states his present position. He says:—
“Having for eighteen years been one of the chief advocates of a Sunday service for the Jews, often standing forth in its defense single-handed, I consider it not merely my privilege, but my duty, to state publicly that I have found sufficient reason to change my views on the subject.”
For this change of views Dr. K. assigns two reasons. The first is that where these Sunday services have been held by the Jews, it does not foster, as designed, but rather destroys, the Sabbatic idea. “Laxity,” he says, “appears to be the result. Skepticism and agnosticism are on the increase. The danger line, in fact, has been reached. The first dire consequence of the Chicago Sabbath success is that the ancient Sabbath has been ruled out. ‘Died from consumption’ is the official burial permit for the old Jewish Sabbath.”
The second reason he gives why the transfer from the Sabbath to Sunday should not be encouraged, is “the changed attitude of the world toward the Jew and the principles he represents.” In this he refers to the barbarous persecutions now carried on in Russia and some other European countries, against the Jews. It is unfortunate that most of the experience of the Jewish people has been with those miserable travesties of Christianity, represented by the Roman Catholic and Greek churches. But the Protestant Church is fast drinking in the same spirit, and in the following caustic exclamations, Dr. K. gives too true a forecast of the animus of the so-called Christian world in these last days, which will be manifested not only against the Jews, but against Christians also, if they are not in harmony with the coming politico-ecclesiastical machine. He says:—
“What a mockery has this so-called Christian civilization turned out to be! What a sham and a fraud has this era of tolerance and enlightenment become! The Middle Ages, with all their cruel bloodthirstiness, with their abominable hatred and fanaticism, have come back.”
In view of this state of things, he utters a rallying cry to his Jewish brethren to return to their duty. The following are his remarkable words, which we give with the italics as we find them:—
“Our duty to-day is to maintain our Jewish identity and preserve our Jewish institutions without faltering, without yielding. We must, with united forces, rally around our sacred Sabbath. The time has arrived for a universal effort to reconquer the lost Sabbath of the Jew.”
Is there not in this a hopeful indication? If such a Sabbath reform should be inaugurated among the Jews, and a genuine zeal and enthusiasm be aroused among them on this question, would it not tend to dispose them favorably to the truth, to learn that true Christianity does not antagonize the Sabbath, but that there is a class of Christians earnestly contending for the same Sabbath reform, setting forth in their true relations to each other the law and the gospel, the Mosaic economy and the work of Christ, discarding the superstitions, errors, and intolerance of the Dark Ages, and manifesting that interest and love for all men which was characteristic of the Master? And through this channel may it not be that many of that people may be brought to know and love the truth as it is in Jesus? Let us at least so hope and pray.
IN THE QUESTION-CHAIR.
THE TWO WITNESSES.
Please explain what is meant by the two witnesses of Revelation 11.
Answer.—See “Thoughts on the Revelation,” for an explanation of the chapter named.
DEPART AND BE WITH CHRIST.
What does Paul mean when he says, “Having a desire to depart and be with Christ.” Phil. 1:23? M. E. F.
Ans.—See explanation of this text and others of a similar nature, in the work “Here and Hereafter,” for sale at this Office. Price $1.
Please explain Isa. 4:1: “In that day seven women shall take hold of one man, saying, We will eat our own bread, and wear our own apparel; only let us be called by thy name, to take away our reproach.” You may infer why I ask the question, when I say that I am now living in Utah among polygamists. J. E. C.
Ans.—The attempted use of this text by the Mormons is only another illustration of how people will twist the Scriptures to try to make them sustain some pet theory. They have to reverse the conditions to make it fit their case. The text says that seven women take hold of one man; but in the Mormon practice, one man takes hold of seven women. The text has not the remotest allusion to such abominations as the Mormons practice, nor to polygamy in its ordinary sense. Chapter 4 is a continuation of the discourse of chapter 3, in the closing part of which great judgments are predicted against Judah on account of the oppression of the people and the pride and haughtiness of the daughters of Zion. And so great would be the slaughter, that most of the young men of the nation would perish in the war. Then to set forth the situation in the strongest light, the men are represented as being so scarce that the women could escape the reproach of celibacy only by some arrangement by which many of them could become connected with one man, so as to be called by his name, meanwhile foregoing all legal claims, and the usual relations of the marriage covenant. To try to apply this scripture in a time of peace, when men are as numerous as the women, and make it uphold polygamy, is a most manifest perversion.
IS SUNDAY THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK?
A correspondent inquires what answer should be given to one who says we cannot tell which is the first day and which the seventh, as the Bible does not say that Sunday is the first day of the week, or that Saturday is the seventh, adding, “It makes no difference, anyhow, just so we keep one day; and all the world keeps Sunday, and it is good enough for me.”
Ans.—No person of intelligence, questions for a moment that the week as brought to view in the New Testament, corresponds, day for day, to the week as now observed throughout Christendom. On the first day of this week the disciples went to the sepulcher to embalm the body of the Lord, and learned that he had just risen from the dead. Luke 24:1. When the ancient German nations embraced Christianity, they continued to call the days of the week by their old pagan names, and through this channel the present names have come into Christendom. With them the days of the week were named after their seven principal deities: Sun, Moon, Tuisco, Woden, Thor, Friga, and Saturn. The first day of the New Testament week was, in their calendar, Sun’s day (Sunday); the second, Moon’s day (Monday); the third, Tuisco’s day (Tuesday); the fourth, Woden’s day (Wednesday); and this is where we get the marvelous spelling of this day; the fifth, Thor’s day (Thursday); the sixth, Friga’s day (contracted to Friday); the seventh, Saturn’s day (Saturday). But there is no shadow of doubt that the first and last days of this week are the days which the Bible calls respectively, “the first day of the week,” and “the seventh day.” As to the statement that it makes no difference about the day, that is saying that what God says is of no account. By definite act and in definite language, God has set apart the seventh day, and no other, as a hallowed day; he has reserved that to himself, and commanded men to observe it accordingly; and how any one can presume, in the face of this, to say that that makes no difference, that the Lord did not know what he was talking about, and that any other day will do just as well as the seventh, is more than we can comprehend. Of the same piece is the last declaration: “All the world keeps Sunday, and it is good enough for me.” One may always know where to find a person who occupies such ground; it will be in the broad road, where the multitude travel. If majorities are to rule, then go with the majority; and as there are many more pagans than Sunday-keepers, this person should turn pagan at once on the ground that “all the world worship idols, and that is good enough for me!” Such a position is too frivolous to be worthy of serious notice.
CHRISTMAS
In the REVIEW of Sept. 1, in answering a question in regard to Easter, I notice that you speak as follows of Christmas: “An old pagan festival on the 25th of December was taken and made a festival of the birth of Christ, and called ‘Christmas.’” What is the authority for this statement?
E. B. T.
Ans.—Authority for the statement can be drawn from many sources; but an article on this subject in the Manifold Encyclopedia contains some statements perhaps as direct as any, which we copy as follows: “Christmas: the day on which the nativity of the Saviour is observed—assigned to Dec. 25. . . . It does not appear, however, that there was any uniformity in the period of observing the nativity among the early churches; some held the festival in May or April, others in January. There is no reason to suppose that Dec. 25 was the day of Christ’s nativity; indeed it is not evident that it could have been; for it is then the hight of the rainy season in Judea, when shepherds could hardly have been watching their flocks by night in the plains. . . . Not casually or arbitrarily was the festival of the nativity celebrated on Dec. 25. Among the causes that co-operated in fixing this period as the proper one, perhaps the most powerful was, that almost all the heathen nations regarded the winter-solstice which occurs at about this time, as a most important point of the year, as the beginning of the renewed life and activity of the powers of nature, and of the gods, who were originally merely the symbolical personifications of these powers. In more northerly countries this fact must have made itself peculiarly palpable—hence the Celts and Germans, from the oldest times, celebrated the season with the greatest festivities. At the winter-solstice the Germans held their great Yule feast, in commemoration of the return of the fiery sun-wheel, and believed that during the twelve nights from Dec. 25 to Jan. 6, they could trace the personal movements and interferences on earth of633their great deities, Odin, Berchta, etc. Many of the beliefs and usages of the old Germans, and of the Romans, relating to this matter, passed over from heathenism into Christianity, and have partly survived to the present day. . . . The Presbyterian churches in Scotland, and large portions of the English dissenters, reject it [Christmas], in its religious aspect, as a ‘human invention,’ and as ‘savoring of papistical will-worship,’ although, in England, dissenters as well as churchmen use it as a social holiday, on which there is a cessation from all business.”
McClintock and Strong say, “The observance of Christmas is not of divine appointment, nor is it of New Testament origin.” Then endeavoring to account for its origin by saying that it was the taste of the age to multiply festivals, they add: “At the same time the heathen winter holidays (Saturnalia, Juvenalia, Brumalia) were undoubtedly transformed, and, so to speak, sanctified by the establishment of the Christmas cycle of holidays; and the heathen customs, so far as they were harmless (e. g., the giving of presents, lighting tapers, etc.), were brought over into Christian use.”
FIRST-DAY OFFERINGS AND THE FOREIGN MISSIONARY WORK.
By Stephen Nelson Haskell
(Concluded.)
28. There were certain offerings recognized as belonging to God as really as the first tithe, and to withhold them is as truly robbing God as to withhold the first tithe, which was exclusively given to the priests. Mal. 3: 7-12.
“I saw that this Scripture has been misapplied to speaking and praying in meeting. This prophecy has a special application to the last days, and teaches God’s people their duty to bring a portion of their substance as a free-will offering to the Lord.”—Vol. 1, Testimony 6, p. 222.
“I saw that the cause of God is not to be carried forward by pressed offerings. God does not accept such offerings. This matter is to be left wholly with the people. They are not to bring a yearly gift merely, but should also freely present a weekly and monthly offering before the Lord. This work is to be left to the people; for it is to be to them a weekly, monthly, living test. This tithing system I saw would develop character, and manifest the true state of the heart.”
“I saw that God’s people must bring to him a free-will offering; and the responsibility should be left wholly upon the individual, whether he give much or little. It will be faithfully recorded. Give the people of God time to develop character.”—Id., p. 237.
29. As an individual can only be robbed of that which belongs to him, and we cannot loan to a person that which is already his, and he that giveth to the poor lendeth to the Lord, the poor in general should be sustained by some arrangement outside of the regular tithe, and certain offerings which God claims as his. Prov. 19: 17.
30. That some such arrangement existed in the gospel is evident. 1 Tim. 5: 1-6.
31. He that giveth of his first-fruits to the Lord has the promise of God’s blessing as really as the one who pays his first tithe. Prov. 3: 9, 10; Mal. 3: 10-12.
32. God prospers men to prove them, that they may see whether they are covetous or not; if they are not covetous, they will use their surplus means for him and trust his prosperous hand to continue them; if covetous, they will lay it up for ease and comfort. Luke 12: 13-21.
“The only means which God has ordained to advance his cause is to bless men with property. He gives them the sunshine and the rain; he causes vegetation to flourish; he gives health, and ability to acquire means. All our blessings come from his bountiful hand. In return, he would have men and women show their gratitude by returning to him a portion in tithes and offerings—in thank-offerings, free-will-offerings, in trespass offerings.”—Vol. 1, Testimony 31, p. 146.
33. The covetous heart will love to hear pleasant preaching, but will do nothing to sustain it. Eze. 33: 30-32.
34. Such men are not fit to hold any office in connection with the cause of God, and they cannot be saved. Ex. 18: 21; 1 Cor. 6: 9, 10.
The position taken respecting a second tithe and offering in the Old Testament, is not new or novel in any sense. Eminent men who have written on the subject, have taken the same position. Bishop Horne in Vol. 2, Part 2, Chap. 3, p. 8, says:—
“Another privilege enjoyed by the poor was that called a second tithe and second firstlings. Besides the tenth received by the Levites, the Israelites were obliged to set apart another tenth of their field and garden products, in like manner their cattle; a second set of offerings for the purpose of presenting a thank-offering at the high festivals. Of these offerings only certain fat pieces were consumed on the altar, the remainder, after deducting the priests’ portion, was appropriated to the sacrifice feasts, to which the Levites were bound to invite the stranger, the widow, and the orphan.”
Besides the first-fruits, the Jews also paid tithes, or tenths, of all they possessed. Num. 18: 21. They were in general collected of all the products of the earth (Lev. 27: 30; Deut. 14: 22, 23; Neh. 13: 5-10), but chiefly of corn, and wine, and oil, and were rendered every year, except the Sabbatical year. When these tithes were paid, the owner of the fruits gave another tenth part which was carried up to Jerusalem, and eaten in the temple at the feast offering, as a sign of gratitude, and rejoicing to God. These are called second tithes.
The same testimony may be found in Josephus Ant., Book 4, Chap. 8, Sections 8 and 22.
Dr. John Gill states:—
“Every year a tithe was paid to the Levites, and besides that, a second tithe, which was carried to Jerusalem, and eaten there. Every third year, it was eaten at home, in their towns and cities, and the country instead of it, with the Levite, poor, and stranger, and was called the Poors’ tithe.”
This is a comment on Deut. 26: 12. He gives other testimonies to the same effect, in his comment on the succeeding verses, and on Deut. 14: 23-28 and Lev. 27: 30.
In “Patriarchs and Prophets,” pages 530, 527, 528, 529, we read:—
“To promote the assembling of the people for religious service, as well as to provide for the poor, a second tithe of all the increase was required. Concerning the first tithe, the Lord had declared, ‘I have given the children of Levi all the tenth in Israel.’ But in regard to the second he commanded, ‘Thou shalt eat before the Lord thy God, in the place which he shall choose, to place his name there, the tithe of thy corn, of thy wine, and of thine oil, and the firstlings of thy herds and of thy flocks, that thou mayest learn to fear the Lord thy God always.’ This tithe, or its equivalent in money, they were for two years to bring to the place where the sanctuary was established. After presenting a thank-offering to God, and a specified portion to the priests, the offerers were to use the remainder for a religious feast, in which the Levite, the stranger, the fatherless, and the widow should participate. Thus, provision was made for the thank-offerings and feasts at the yearly festivals, and the people were drawn to the society of the priests and Levites, that they might receive instruction and encouragement in the service of God.”
“Every third year, however, this second tithe was to be used at home, in entertaining the Levite and the poor, as Moses said, ‘That they may eat within thy gates and be filled.’ This tithe would provide a fund for the uses of charity and hospitality.”
“The contributions required by the Hebrews for religious and charitable purposes amounted to fully one fourth of their income. So heavy a tax upon the resources of the people might be expected to reduce them to poverty, but, on the contrary, the faithful observance of these regulations was one of the conditions of their prosperity. On condition of their obedience, God made them this promise: ‘And I will rebuke the devourer for your sakes, and he shall not destroy the fruits of your ground; neither shall your vine cast her fruit before the time in the field.’ And all nations shall call you blessed; for ye shall be a delightsome land, saith the Lord of hosts.”
“In the days of Israel, the tithe and free-will offerings were needed to maintain the ordinances of divine service. Should the people of God give less in this age? The principle laid down by Christ is that our offerings to God should be in proportion to the light and privileges enjoyed. ‘Unto whomsoever much is given, of him shall be much required.’ Said the Saviour to his disciples as he sent them forth, ‘Freely ye have received, freely give.’ As our blessings and privileges are increased,—above all, as we have before us the unparalleled sacrifice of the glorious Son of God,—should not our gratitude find expression in more abundant gifts to extend to others the message of salvation? The work of the gospel as it widens, requires greater provision to sustain it than was called for anciently; and this makes the law of tithes and offerings of even more urgent necessity now than under the Hebrew economy.” S. N. H.
EDITORIAL NOTES.
By L. A. S.
The evil that is done in time, cannot be undone in eternity.
Men respect wealth, nationality, talent, beauty, influence; God respects only character.
When you have no reason to be dissatisfied with yourself, you will have no reason to complain of your circumstances.
God does not dispense his mercies to fallen men in proportion to their number. He will do just as much for one soul as for a thousand or a million.
Nothing is more essential to success in life, either temporally or spiritually, than the wisdom and ability to forego a present temporal profit for the sake of future gain.
At the end of all things is God. No movement can be inaugurated, no current set in motion, in the great world of human thought and action, which will not come to a final reckoning with him.
The dead are the greatest tyrants over the living. That which holds the world in its most grievous bondage to-day, in matters both civil and religious, is the evil inheritance which it has received from the past.
Self-denial does not consist, as many people imagine, in making a virtue of foregoing some pleasure or indulgence for which the heart naturally longs; but in putting all of self away, so that not its image, but the image of Christ, is reflected in the heart.
The Scripture says, “Resist the devil, and he will flee from you.” Many, however, find in their experience an apparent contradiction of this text. The trouble is that they have not strength enough to resist the devil successfully. They have not heeded the injunction, “Submit yourselves therefore unto God.” It is not the power of man making resistance, but the power of God, from which the devil flees.
The border line of faith runs very close to that of presumption, and the “foolish and unlearned” in divine things easily pass from the one domain to the other. The devil tempted Christ on the point of presumption by saying to him, when he had placed him on a pinnacle of the temple, “If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down: for it is written, He shall give his angels charge concerning thee: and in their hands they shall bear thee up, lest at any time thou dash thy foot against a stone.” Presumption said to him, Do this in order to show your faith in God’s protecting care. But the Saviour refused to do so, because such an action on his part was altogether unnecessary. Faith never requires us to do any thing merely for the purpose of showing that we have faith. Presumption, on the other hand, leads us to place ourselves in a position necessitating God’s special care, merely to show that we believe in his care. While God is ever ready to exercise his power in behalf of his children, let it be remembered that he does this when he has684brought them into a place needing the exercise of his power, or some uncontrollable circumstances have done it, and not when they have placed themselves there. God must be the one to determine when the fitting time is for him to manifest especial care over men.
L. A. S.
“RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE TO-DAY. PERSECUTED FOR CONSCIENCE’ SAKE.”
By A. O. T.
With the above for a subject, the editor of the Arena makes the following comments on the recent decision of Judge Hammond in the case of brother King. It seems to us that he strikes the matter about right. We give the whole article to our brethren, believing that they will enjoy reading it, and thinking that they might be able to use it to good advantage in their various localities; possibly, some of them may be able to secure its publication, as an editorial from the Arena, one of the leading magazines of the country, in some of their local papers.
“The decision recently handed down by Judge Hammond, of the United States District Court, in the celebrated case of R. M. King, is rich in lessons of vital importance to thoughtful minds at the present time of unrest, when conservatism is seeking on every hand, even under the cloak of radical movements, to secure statutes and legal constructions of laws which may at an early day be used to fetter thought, crush liberty, and throttle the vanguard of progress. Briefly stated, the important facts in the case in question are as follows: Mr. King is an honest, hard-working farmer. He is charged with no breach of morals; in fact, it appears that he is a remarkably upright man. But he is a Seventh-day Adventist; that is, he does not hold the same religious views as the majority in his State. He stands in the same relation to his countrymen as that occupied by the early disciples of Christ to Roman society when Nero undertook to punish Christians by kindling nightly human fires for the delectation of conservative or majority thought. He is of the minority, even as the Huguenots were in the minority when the church tortured, racked, and burned them for the glory of God and the good of humanity. He is of the minority, as was Roger Williams when, in 1635, the popular and conventional thought of Salem banished him. Mr. King is not an infidel or even a doubter. On the contrary, he is ardently religious, being a zealous and conscientious member of a sect of Christians noted for their piety and faith. The Adventists, of whom he is an honored member, it must be remembered, hold somewhat peculiar views about the second advent of Christ. They believe they find in the Bible, commands making it obligatory upon them to keep holy the seventh day of the week, or the Hebrew Sabbath, instead of Sunday, the holiday and rest-day observed by most Christian denominations.
Now it was shown in the trial that, conforming to his belief, Mr. King strictly observed the Sabbath, or Saturday; but being a poor farmer, he could not afford to rest two days each week, or over one hundred days in the year, and, therefore, after having kept the Sabbath, he plowed in his field on Sunday. This aroused the pious indignation of the narrow-minded and bigoted members of the community who profess to follow that great Leader who taught us to judge not, to resist not evil, and to do unto others as we would have others do unto us. These Christians (?) who, unfortunately for the cause of justice and religious liberty, are in the majority in Tennessee, had this conscientious, God-fearing man arrested as a common felon, and convicted of the heinous crime (?) of Sabbath-breaking by plowing on Sunday. He appealed to the Supreme Court, and the sentence was affirmed. Then the Adventists and the National Religious Liberty Association took up the case. Hon. Don M. Dickinson was engaged as counsel, and the case was taken to the Federal Court last November on a writ of habeas corpus, the contention being that the conviction was contrary to the bill of rights of Tennessee and the Constitution of the United States, and that the defendant was held prisoner by the sheriff without due process of law. The application was argued several months ago, and Judge Hammond has had it under advisement until recently, when his decision was given, in which the defendant was remanded back to the custody of the sheriff to pay the fine or serve the time according to the sentence. This decision holds that malice, religious or otherwise, may dictate a prosecution, but if the law has been violated, this fact does not shield the law-breaker. Neither do the courts require that there shall be some moral obloquy to support a given law before enforcing it, and it is not necessary to maintain that to violate the Sunday observance customs shall be of itself immoral, to make it criminal in the eyes of the law.
“Suggestive, indeed, are the lessons of this great judicial crime against liberty, justice, and God. In the first place it illustrates the fact which must long since have become apparent to thinking men, that the guarantee of the Constitution of the United States, which, more than aught else, has made this Republic the flower of all preceding nations, is yearly becoming less and less regarded by the small men and narrow minds who interpret law and who, instead of showing how unconstitutional any law is which violates the great charter of right, yield to the present craze for governmental paternalism, paying no more heed to our Constitution than if it was the ukase of a czar. In numerous instances during the past decade, has this solemn fact been emphasized, until it is evident that with the reaction toward paternalism and centralization, has come the old-time spirit of intolerance and moral obloquy on the part of the governing powers, which has been one of the chief curses of the ages, entailing indescribable misery on the noblest and best, and holding in subjection the vanguard of progress, which always has been and always will be the minority, regarded by the majority as dangerous innovators or disseminators of false theories and doctrines. In my article on Socialism, I noted the case of Mr. King, observing that—
“‘He in no way deserves the shameful imprisonment he is suffering; yet the prejudice of the majority sustains the infamous law that makes criminals of the innocent and does not take into consideration the rights of the minority. And what is more, the religious press is so dominated by bigotry and ancient prejudice, that it is blind alike to the Golden Rule and the inexorable demands of justice. If in any State the Adventists, the Hebrews, or any other people who believed in observing Saturday instead of Sunday, should happen to predominate, and they undertook to throw Christians into dungeons, and after branding them criminal, should send them to the penitentiary for working on Saturday, indignation would blaze forth throughout Christendom against the great injustice, the wrong against the liberty of the rights of the citizen. The only difference is that poor Mr. King is in the minority; he is the type of those who always have been and always will be made to suffer when the Government is strong enough to persecute all who do not accept what is considered truth and right by the majority.’”
“In replying to my paper, Mr. Bellamy thus flippantly dismissed this case: ‘Of this, it may be remarked that had it happened two centuries ago, it would have been symptomatic; to-day it is a curiosity.’ It will be observed that in order to minify the dangers of paternalism, Mr. Bellamy entirely ignored the point I had italicized; viz., the Christian sentiment of society was not outraged, and what was more, ‘The religious press was so dominated by bigotry and ancient prejudice that it was blind alike to the Golden Rule and the inexorable demands of justice.’ To-day we are told that this great judicial crime is a curiosity, although the religious bigotry of the majority has been upheld by the lower, the federal, and supreme courts, while the religious press has, with rare exceptions, sanctioned the persecution or ignored the case.
“In vain the long-cherished idea that this country was to pass down the cycle of time known as the land of freedom; that it was to be forever the asylum for religious liberty and the cradle of progress, unless the sober thought of our people be at once aroused to stem the rising tide of governmentalism and the steady encroachment of religious organizations and despotic foreign thought.
“Comparatively few of the leading secular journals have deemed this outrage sufficiently important to call for editorial comment, notwithstanding it marks the establishment of a precedent which must inevitably work great misery to innocent people at the hands of religious fanatics, unless there is a sufficient agitation to cause the repeal of many iniquitous laws which are a menace to the rightful freedom of citizens as long as they remain on the statute books.”