Earlier text: THE CROSS OF JESUSTHE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK.
The old attempt to impress the fourth commandment of the decalogue into the service of Sunday-keeping, by arguing a change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week, has been almost universally abandoned by those who have any acquaintance with the Sabbath controversy. Yet it may be well to briefly notice it for the sake of those who find it hard to surrender old ideas, and of those who still have the ground to go over. The argument may be presented under three heads: I. That the Sabbath changed itself; that is, that the events of that time were of such a nature that the Sabbath, as a natural consequence, without any legislation, changed from the seventh to the first day. II. That Christ changed the day. III. That the apostles changed it. I. What is meant by events being of such a nature as to change the Sabbath, is this: It is claimed that redemption is greater than creation; and that Christ finished, and rested from, the work of redemption when he arose from the dead on the first day of the week; therefore the seventh day disappears before the first day, as the moon disappears before the rising sun, and the first day is henceforth, from the very nature of the case, the great luminary of the Christian world. It is the easiest matter in the world to show that every proposition in this argument is either a plain contradiction of fact, or a naked assumption; that there is no coherence between the different divisions of the argument; and that not a single conclusion follows from the premises assumed. 1. Contradiction of fact. Redemption was not finished when Christ rose from the dead. Redemption includes the resurrection of the dead, the immortality of all the saints, and a world made new. It will not be finished till the end of probation and of sin. 2. An assumption. No man can tell which is the greater, creation or redemption, inasmuch as both are infinitely beyond his comprehension. It is therefore not merely an assumption, but the most reckless presumption, for him to attempt to decide between them. 3. A series of “non sequiturs.” First. “It does not follow,” even if redemption was finished on the first day of the week that that day should be observed as a rest day in consequence thereof. Secondly, “It does not follow,” even if it should be observed as a rest day, that it should be so observed every week. The proportion suggested would be that between the whole period of Christ’s ministry, which was three years and a half, and the day of his resurrection—one day in every three years and a half! Thirdly. “It does not follow,” even if we should observe that day as a Sabbath, and do it every week, that the observance of the seventh day should be discontinued. The seventh day rests upon its own independent foundation; and if an additional day is given us as a Sabbath, then we have two days to keep instead of the one day which the world had before. 4. Assumption, No. 2. It is assumed that we have redemption through the resurrection of Christ. But the Scriptures do not so declare. They do, however, twice assert (Eph. 1:7; Col. 1:14) that “we have redemption through his blood,” from which the inference naturally follows that if a day is to be observed to commemorate it it should be the day on which his blood was shed, not the first day of the week. 5. Unnecessary. Why do we need to observe a day to commemorate the resurrection of Christ, or the work of redemption, so far as it has been carried out? The Scriptures have plainly given us memorials of Christ’s death, burial, and resurrection, in the ordinances of the Lord’s supper and baptism. 1 Cor. 11:26; Rom. 6:4. And what need we more? Does God ever give two memorials for the same event? Anything more would be redundant, and an unheard-of thing in the whole list of religious institutions. As the first proposition thus vanishes from sight as soon as we look at it, we pass to the second. II. Christ, it is claimed, changed the day from the seventh to the first day of the week. An embarrassing fact meets the advocates of this proposition at the outset. Christ never uttered one syllable in reference to the first day of the week. How then could he have changed the Sabbath to that day, or have legislated in regard to it? The claim is absurd on the very face of it. Do you say the record shows that he did do it? Please show us the record. For thirty years we have searched for it, and cannot find it. The New Testament speaks of the first day of the week only eight times. Six of these instances are found in the four Gospels, and all refer to the day of Christ’s resurrection; and three of them, namely, Matt. 28:1; Mark 16:1; and Luke 23:56; 24:1, speak of it, not as the Sabbath, but as the day following the Sabbath. One such instance would be enough to show the distinction between the Sabbath and first day of the week; we have three. And in the other instances it is simply mentioned as the chronological part of the narrative, not as in any respect honored, elevated, or made Sabbatical in its character. But, it is asked, did not the disciples understand the change, and meet together on that first day of the week to celebrate the resurrection of Christ, and inaugurate the Christian Sabbath? and did not Christ meet with them, and sanction what they were doing by saying, Peace be unto you? It would be very nice for this theory if it were so, but unfortunately for it, there is no truth in it. At the close of that day, after the two disciples had returned from Emmaus (and it must have been very nearly if not quite into the beginning of the next day (Luke 24:29, 33) when they reached Jerusalem), they found the eleven gathered together, doubtless at their place of common abode (Acts 1:12, 13); for they were “at meat,” that is, partaking of their evening meal (Mark 16:12–14); and the eleven would not believe the report which these two disciples brought, that the Lord was risen and had appeared to them on their way to Emmaus. Then the Lord himself appeared in their midst, and they, so far from believing that he was risen, and waiting to see him, were terrified and affrighted at his presence (Luke 24:37); and then he upbraided them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they were so stubborn in their unbelief in regard to his resurrection that they would not believe even the members of their own company who declared that they had seen him. Mark 16:14. Is not this a promising mass of material out of which to erect a first-day Sabbath? A company of timid disciples, their hope crushed out by the recent crucifixion of their Master, and understanding so little about his resurrection, and being so faithless in regard to it, that they would not believe those who had seen him, had gathered to their common place of abode, and having made fast their doors against a possible intrusion of the Jews, who they feared might next seek their lives, were partaking in sadness of their evening meal. Christ appeared and upbraided them because they did not yet believe that he had risen. And now this first-day institution steps up, and with a brazen effrontery characteristic of all usurpers, claims that the disciples were met to celebrate the resurrection, and lay the foundation of the Christian Sabbath! Can any theory stand which is based on such preposterous absurdities! Inasmuch as this first interview proves no support to the first day Sabbath, not much importance could be attached to any subsequent one; yet great stress is laid by some on John 20:26: “And after eight days again his disciples were within,” etc. This, it is claimed, is a record that Jesus waited till the next Sunday came around, and then met with the disciples again, to confirm the Sabbatic nature of that day. But, 1. It cannot be shown that “after eight days,” means the next Sunday. If it be said that “after three days” (Mark 8:31) means “on the third day” (Matt. 16:21), and hence “after eight days” would mean “on the eighth day,” and so be Sunday, we reply that that was not a uniform manner of speaking. If it was, the expression, “after six days” (Matt. 17:1), would mean “on the sixth day;” but it did not mean so; for Luke, speaking of the same event, the transfiguration, says that it was about “eight days” after. Luke 9:28. 2. If it be granted that “the eighth day,” or just a week is meant, then it should be considered at what point the reckoning must begin. The meeting which began at the last evening of that first day (John 20:19), must have continued into the second day before the disciples arrived from Emmaus; for “the day was far spent” when Christ made himself known to them there, and after that they returned to Jerusalem, seven miles, on foot. Not till after they had arrived and reported, did Jesus appear. His appearance then must have been on the second day. But further, Thomas was absent on this occasion, and Christ had completed his interview with them, and disappeared before Thomas returned; yet it was not till after his return, and an interview by the disciples with him (verses 24, 25), that the period of the eight days is introduced. All this goes unmistakably to show that the reckoning should begin from the second day, and that the eighth day thereafter, would be the second day of the next week, not the first day. 3. If the intention was to honor the first day, why did not the record say, “On the next first day of the week”? or what would be better still, as the gospel of John was written after the Revelation, and if, as it is claimed, the first day had then come to be generally called “the Lord’s day,” why did he not say, “on the next Lord’s day”? Would he have omitted so appropriate and opportune a time to mention it? Impossible. But it was not the object of the meeting to honor the first day. The intention was simply to mark the time when Thomas was with them. But Christ met with his disciples on other occasions. Once, the third time, when they were out fishing. John 21:3, 14. Were they celebrating the resurrection then? Was this Sunday? and did the disciples, after Christ had met with them already twice, to honor the first day and establish the “Christian” Sabbath, so far forget themselves as to go off fishing upon that day? Again, a notable meeting with the disciples was on the day of his ascension, which is generally supposed to have been on Thursday. Certainly it was not on Sunday. Thus all the evidence vanishes which is produced to show that Christ changed the day. An apology is due to the reader from any one who would set up such a claim in face of Christ’s express declaration that he came not to change it. Matt. 5:17, 18. III. But it is still urged by some that the apostles changed the day of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week. As an insuperable barrier to this view lies the fact that Christ, having himself failed to change it, gave219 then no instructions to change it; and what he did not do nor instruct them to do, they had no right to do. Yet some seem to think that events in their experience prove the change. 1. The Pentecost. The outpouring of the Spirit on the day of Pentecost, was not to honor the first day of the week, as the Sunday advocate contends. Had that been the cause of the manifestation, it should, and unquestionably would, have said, When the first day of the week was come. But it simply reads, “When the day of Pentecost was fully come,” without telling us what day of the week it was. Pentecost, being the fiftieth day from the sixteenth of the first month, came in different years on different days of the week. If in A. D. 31, it chanced to fall on Sunday, that signified nothing for that day. But scholars are not agreed as to the day on which it fell. Prof. H. B. Hackett, D. D., in “Commentary on the Original Text of the Acts,” pp. 50, 51, says: “It is generally supposed that this Pentecost, signalized by the outpouring of the Spirit, fell on the Jewish Sabbath, our Saturday.” Christ’s crucifixion on the 14th day of the first month was the antitype of the slaying of the paschal lamb; his resurrection on the 16th of the month was the antitype of the waving of the sheaf of first fruits: fifty days from this latter point, the feast of Pentecost must meet its antitype; and this was fulfilled in the outpouring of the Spirit on that day; and hence this manifestation of the Spirit was delayed till that day was “fully come.” Ten days had elapsed since the ascension of Christ. One first day had been passed unnoticed and in silence. Why was not the Spirit poured out then? Because it was only the Pentecost which was to be thus marked, on whatever day of the week it might come. 2. Acts 20:7. In this scripture we have the only instance to be found in the New Testament of a religious meeting on the first day of the week. But there is no intimation of any custom, nor any command in reference to it. It was only an incidental meeting. It was an evening meeting; for there were “many lights” in the upper chamber where they were assembled. Verse 8. But according to the Bible method of reckoning time, the dark evening of the day was the first part of it, beginning with the setting of the sun. This meeting was held, therefore, at a time corresponding with our Saturday evening. Paul preached till midnight, healed Eutychus, broke bread, and continued his discourse till break of day, and then departed early Sunday morning on a twenty-mile foot journey, across the base of the peninsula from Troas to Assos. See Conybeare and Howson. We commend this apostolic example to our Sunday-keeping friends. With every step of that long journey through all the light part of that Syrian Sunday, Paul trampled such a thing as a Sunday Sabbath into the dust, where it belongs. 3. 1 Cor. 16:2. A careful reading of this instruction will show that the work enjoined was not to be done in the public congregation, but privately at home; it was not proper Sabbath employment, but the secular business of looking over worldly matters, and setting apart a portion for charity. The text shows that the apostle regarded it as a secular day. 4. Rev. 1:10. The “Lord’s day” of this text is not the first day of the week; for the Lord has never set apart that day as his. It is the Sabbath; for he claims that day as his. “The Son of man is Lord of the Sabbath day.” We have now noticed every instance in which the first day is mentioned, and every text supposed to refer to it; and there is not found in the record the first trace of any facts out of which a Sabbath could be constructed—no rest of any divine being upon the day, no law for its observance, and not the slightest regard paid to it by either Christ or the apostles. To find the change of the day, and the real institution of the Sunday Sabbath, our friends must go a step further. They must come down into that age when the “mystery of iniquity,” working even in Paul’s day, had developed full fledged the great apostasy; when men began to heap contempt upon the Sabbath to spite the Jews, and to elevate the Sunday to conciliate their heathen neighbors, and by so doing did despite to the word of God, and introduced those elements of apostasy and corruption which ruined the church, and sent a shout of triumph through all the realms of darkness. HOW WERE THE POETIC AND HISTORICAL BOOKS OF THE BIBLE WRITTEN?
By George I. Butler
HOW WERE THE POETIC AND HISTORICAL BOOKS OF THE BIBLE WRITTEN?
This is a question of some interest. Take, for instance, the Psalms. They contain most sublime and glorious descriptions of the works of God, his character, and attributes, and many prophetic passages in which the future is revealed, the work and character of Christ, and the future glories of his kingdom. They certainly could not have been written by mere human wisdom. David is called a prophet (Acts 2:29, 30; Matt. 27:35); and the Lord says, “If there be a prophet among you, I the Lord will make myself known unto him in a vision.” It is therefore most reasonable to conclude that David had visions of the Lord from time to time. This is directly indicated in the history of this remarkable man. In 1 Chronicles 28, David is represented as speaking to Solomon concerning the building of the temple, giving him the pattern of it, the offerings, etc. Verses 12 and 19 read as follows: “And the pattern of all that he had by the Spirit, of the courts of the house of the Lord, and of all the chambers round about, of the treasuries of the house of God,” etc.; “All this, said David, the Lord made me understand in writing by his hand upon me, even all the works of this pattern.” These texts plainly indicate that the whole form of the temple and its services were revealed to David by the Spirit of the Lord, evidently in a vision. The pattern of the sanctuary was also plainly shown to Moses. Ps. 89:19 contains a reference to visions which may refer to David. We conclude, therefore, that as he received important revelations from the Lord, it was by this means that he was enabled to write the Psalms, at least the prophetic portions. As the Spirit of God rested upon him, all the faculties of his soul were aroused to unwonted clearness and power, and he poured forth these psalms, which have been a source of light and comfort for all succeeding ages. Unaided human wisdom could never have written such words. There are questions of much interest relating to the manner of writing the historical books of the Bible, which have given rise to much discussion. Some claim they were written precisely the same as ordinary history in books not inspired: others that the same degree of inspiration is seen in them, which is contained in the prophetic books, and that the writers were inspired in the same manner. We seriously question both of these positions. That they were inspired by the Holy Spirit in a certain sense, so that they are true and reliable, we certainly believe; and this is all that we need of them. The statements they make concerning facts, are correct and in every way worthy of confidence. We hold that God never performs miracles when there is no necessity for them; nor does he reveal things in vision when they are already fully known and understood. God is a sensible and consistent being. He shows certainly as much wisdom as man, and vastly more. Man would never make a great effort and incur much expense when he knew that far less would accomplish the same object. What necessity can there be for special revelations when the facts are already plainly before the mind? Take, for instance, such a narrative as the gospel of Luke, which commences as follows:— “Forasmuch as many have taken in hand to set forth in order a declaration of those things which are most surely believed among us, even as they delivered them unto us, which from the beginning were eye-witnesses, and ministers of the word; it seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write unto thee in order, most excellent Theophilus, that thou mightest know the certainty of those things wherein thou hast been instructed.”
Here a friend, an eye-witness, who is well acquainted with all the important facts in the work of Christ, sets himself to the task of informing those he loves concerning them. What inspiration does he need more than that his memory of the facts shall be clear, and his power of delineating them excellent? If he stated things of which he was not a witness, he would need to have them revealed to him in some way. The book of Genesis, for example, which is a history of creation, and which covers many centuries, Moses could not have written except by revelation. Skeptics claim that he obtained it from tradition. But such conclusions we cannot for a moment accept. We believe Moses obtained light from which to write directly from God. This must be so, or it must be a book of no authority. We regard it as one of the most important books of the Bible. Moses did not live when he could be a witness to these facts. Some of the events, as those of the first week of creation, no human witness could behold. They must have been supernaturally revealed to some person in order to have been known. And most of those events related in Genesis transpired so long before Moses’ birth that traditions of them handed down from father to son would have been utterly untrustworthy. Moses must have received them from revelation, which is just as necessary in order250 to make known facts which have been lost as to reveal future events. But it is not so in such a case as that of Luke. In giving a brief preface to his history of Christ’s life, which he was writing for his friend Theophilus, he claims no special revelation, and says nothing about its having been revealed to him in a vision; but he does tell his friend that “he had perfect understanding of all things from the very first” concerning that which he was to relate; and because of this, his friend “might know the certainty” of the things he would write. He had been an eye-witness of these things; and being a man in whom Theophilus had confidence, he would of course accept as the truth what Luke said. Other eye-witnesses having written of these things, Luke wishes to add to the credibility of the records the facts which were familiar to him. Having, then, truthful eye-witnesses of these events to narrate them, where is the need that they should be revealed over again through a vision, or by some great manifestation of divine power? Evidently there is no such need if the witnesses were sure not to forget any of the facts. But human memory unaided is not sure to retain all that it has seen or heard. And after a term of years had passed by, as is evidently the case before most of the gospels were written, the discourses of Christ might be in a measure forgotten, and important facts might be omitted. Here, then, is a weakness of the human mind which needs the aid of the Holy Spirit to perfect it for the important work of giving to succeeding ages the needed light upon the life and acts of Christ. The memory must be strengthened so that we can be sure of the great fundamental facts of the gospel. Does the Bible tell us of any such form of inspiration? In our Saviour’s important discourse given just before his crucifixion, in which he several times repeats the promise of the Holy Spirit, he uses this language: “These things have I spoken unto you, being yet present with you. But the Comforter, which is the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance whatsoever I have said unto you.” John 14:25, 26. The province of the Holy Spirit, then, is not only to teach them new things, but to quicken their memory so that they could retain the great facts of the gospel which they had seen transpire in previous years, and recall the words of wisdom which he had spoken. The use of the memory is necessary in all kinds of inspiration. Moses needed memory to write what God spoke to him when he talked with him as a friend talks with a friend. Christ needed memory to retain what the Father had commissioned him to speak. The prophets needed memory to enable them to write and speak what God showed to them in visions and dreams. Sometimes such things were forgotten; as when Nebuchadnezzar could not recall what he had seen of the great image. But he quickly recognized it when Daniel brought the matter before him. Both of these men had seen the same thing in a night vision. One forgot it, the other did not. From this it would seem that at times God miraculously controls the memory. The king greatly desired to call the matter up, but could not. It had left a deep impression upon his mind, and because the wise men and astrologers could not help him out of his difficulty, he was about to destroy them all. God evidently controls the memory to carry out his own wise purposes. He did it in this case to make the king acquainted with Daniel and his God, that through him he might accomplish important objects. Thus we see that in all these various forms of inspiration memory is necessary, and that God’s Spirit controls it. Christ promises to do so in the case of those who were acquainted with the great facts of his ministry on earth. He “would bring all things to their remembrance, whatsoever he had said unto them.” This would be all the inspiration in this case which they needed; for the truths concerning which they had personal knowledge by seeing and hearing with their natural eyes and ears, were just as real as though they had been revealed in vision or any other way. The quickening of their memory by the Spirit of God to recall all the necessary facts was all the inspiration they needed. Then they could write out in their own language the facts which should be kept on record. The same principle applies to all the historical books which were written by those who were witnesses of the events contained in them. We judge from certain statements in the Old Testament that most of the historical books were written by prophets, or at least that they wrote the records of their kings. 2 Chron. 26:22; 1 Chron. 27:29. It is thought by commentators that the historical books of Samuel, Kings, and Chronicles were condensed by Ezra from the records which were written by the various prophets and kept in the nation’s archives. It is evident that we do not now have all those which are referred to in those histories. It is most likely that the prophets living under the reign of the kings wrote out from their own knowledge the facts which it was necessary should be preserved. The fact that prophets did this does not necessarily prove there was a special revelation through inspiration of the facts themselves; but that such were trustworthy persons whose testimony was worthy of confidence. We can see no necessity, for instance, for Nathan the prophet to have a revelation of the acts of King David, when he was perfectly well acquainted with them from his own observation. But we can see a good reason why such a man should keep a record of those acts. His high character would give the seal of credibility to what he said. Everybody could accept the record of a prophet of the Lord. We conclude, therefore, that the historical books of the Bible, when written by those well acquainted with the facts, were inspired in the sense that the Spirit of God brought clearly to remembrance of the writers the facts with which they were before familiar, even as Christ promised to do in the case of his disciples. This form of inspiration,—a spiritual invigoration of the memory,—is all the inspiration necessary to furnish us with the most reliable facts upon which to found our faith. We find the following remarkable paragraph in the Christian at Work of April 3, 1884:— “The objection is made to Lent that our Lord did not command any such observance by his disciples. Neither did he command the observance of Sunday nor the week-day prayer meeting. When can we get out of the adumbration of supposing that every jot and tittle of Christian worship must have been literally prescribed by Christ before being resorted to? And if this is the one unfailing test, why not apply it and take up with feet-washing? See the literal command in John 13:14.” We call this a “remarkable paragraph” and an “unwitting confession.” It virtually says, “We keep Lent without a command, because we keep Sunday without a command;” that is to say, because they keep one institution which Christ has not commanded, they can by that practice defend the doing of anything else which he has not commanded. And they keep Sunday without a command, because “Christian worship” need not be conformed to what Christ has “literally prescribed.” Such conformity the Christian at Work calls an “adumbration,” in reference to which it petulantly asks, “When can we get out of” it? Well, this is just what the devil has all along been trying to induce men to “get out of.” Very successfully has he led the papal church to get out of it; and the whole Protestant world has shamefully followed on in the same work of trying to get away from the literal teachings of Christ. And let this frank confession on the part of the C. at W. be noted; namely, that if we are to follow what has been “literally prescribed” by Christ, we shall drop Sunday-keeping, and practice feet-washing! Exactly. And this is just what they would do if Christ’s words were abiding in them. John 15:1-8. But let them remember that his words will judge them at the last day. Mark 8:38. THE CLEANSING OF THE SANCTUARY.—NO. 6.
By R. F. Cottrell
ALL the sacrifices of the ancients from the days of Abel to Christ, and all the services of the priesthood in the sanctuary of the first covenant, could not take away a single sin. Heb. 10:4. Their sacrifices could only point them forward to the sacrifice of Christ, and their sanctuary and services of priests therein could only point them to the services of our great High Priest in the heavenly sanctuary, and the atonement for sin to be made by him. The law of God existed; it was in the ark of the testimony in the sanctuary. They were sinners in fact; but there was no atonement but in figure. Their all depended upon the death and intercessions of Jesus Christ—his death as the Lamb of God that taketh away the sin of the world, and his priestly intercessions in the true tabernacle which the Lord pitched, and not man. Had not the Mediator of the new covenant died “for the redemption of the transgressions that were under the first testament” (Heb. 9:15), not one of them could be saved. But the typical system was of great service to the ancients as it pointed them forward to the real sacrifice for sins, and the real atonement to be made by Christ in heaven. And it is of no less value to us, since it is the means by which we learn the order of the ministration of our High Priest out of our sight, in heaven, especially of the closing part of his work, the cleansing of the sanctuary, the blotting out of all the sins of the saved, which is their acquittal in the Judgment. By the study of the type we learn concerning the antitype. 1. The sins of the sinner were laid on the victim for sacrifice. Then the sinner shed the blood of the sin offering outside of the sanctuary. So Christ was slain on the earth by us, sinners. Our sins being laid upon him, he was slain for us. He bore our sins in his own body on the cross. 1 Pet. 2:24. He died for all; but the atonement is not yet made. This is the work of a priest. It is a necessity that the blood should be offered in the sanctuary, in order to remission. Lev. 4:27–35. 2. In the typical service the priest must bear the sins in the blood of the sacrifice to the sanctuary, presenting them before God with intercession, and leave them there till the day of atonement or cleansing of the sanctuary, when they are to be borne out of the sanctuary. So Christ, having entered the heavenly sanctuary by his own blood which was shed for us, makes intercessions for all those to the uttermost that come unto God by him. Heb. 7:25. The victim was slain on Calvary; but the atonement must be made by the priest; and Christ was not a priest till he ascended to heaven. “For if he were on earth, he should not be a priest.” See Heb. 8:1–4. And in his priestly service he must follow the type. His ministration must be confined to the first apartment of the sanctuary till the time appointed for its cleansing. Lev. 16:2. 3. In the type the appointed time came once in a year. Ex. 30:10. Lev. 16:29; 23:27. The round of service was completed on the tenth day of the seventh month; and it was repeated “year by year continually;” but Christ was offered and performed the round of service but once. Heb. 10:1–18. As there was an appointed time for the atonement in the most holy of the earthly sanctuary, so the time was appointed for this work in the true tabernacle. “Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the sanctuary be cleansed.” Dan. 8:14. As we have seen, the time expired in A. D. 1844. Consequently the final work of the atonement is now being done. 4. Not only was the day appointed, so that all Israel could know when it came, but when the time arrived a special announcement was made by the blowing of trumpets. Num. 29:1; 10:10. Accordingly as we came to the end of the days in 1844, the trumpet was blown—a message sounded through earth, addressed to every nation, and kindred, and tongue, and people saying, with a loud voice, “Fear God, and give glory to him; for the hour of his Judgment is come.” This is a fact of history; and the history is the record of the fulfillment of prophecy. And this proclamation was based on the 2300 days, which ended at that time. It was the trumpet which announced the great and solemn day of atonement. Does the reader object that that message proved false; because the time of the Judgment did not then come? He may change his mind, if he will have patience to investigate till he has learned that the cleansing of the sanctuary, the final work of atonement, the blotting out of the sins of the saved, and that part of the Judgment in which they are accounted worthy of a place in the world to come and in the resurrection to eternal life, are one and the same thing, and that this must take place before the coming of Christ, when they who have been accounted worthy will be raised from the dead, putting on immortality in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye. Luke 20:35, 36; 1 Cor. 15:51, 52. And it is evident from Rev. 14:6–12, that the Judgment-hour message is not the last message of probation; for the warning of the third angel implies mercy to those who heed it, presenting a final choice between the worship of the beast and the commandments of God. Thus we are brought to the inevitable conclusion251 that Jesus, our great High Priest, has entered within the second vail to make the atonement for his people, blotting out their sins, and that he is about to come to those who look for him, without sin unto salvation. See Heb. 9:28; Acts 3:19–21. We learn from the types and other scriptures that when the sinner comes to God and finds pardon and acceptance, that this is not the final disposal of his sins. The final disposal of sin depends upon faithfulness up to the day of reckoning. When the sinner brought his offering and confessed his sins, they were, in a figure, laid on the sin offering, and in its blood conveyed to the sanctuary and left there till the day of atonement, which was a type of the investigative Judgment. Those who were then found faithful, had their sins borne out of the sanctuary and sent away to the land of separation; but those who were not faithful up to that time had no part in this final offering which was for all the true Israel, and consequently they were cut off. Lev. 16:29, 39; 23:29. Their sins were not atoned for, were not sent away: but reverted upon their own heads. This is in perfect accordance with other portions of Scripture. “But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, and doeth according to all the abominations that the wicked man doeth, shall he live? All his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: in his trespass that he hath trespassed, and in his sin that he hath sinned, in them shall he die.” Eze. 18:24. No credit is given for past obedience, if we turn again to sin. This is taught in the parable of the unmerciful servant. He owed his lord ten thousand talents; but earnestly pleading for patience on the part of his lord, the latter “was moved with compassion, and loosed him, and forgave him the debt.” But when he showed himself unworthy of such favors, by his abuse of his fellow-servant, “his lord was wroth, and delivered him to the tormentors till he should pay all that was due unto him.” The forgiveness granted was revoked, and the whole debt was required to be paid. And Jesus said, “So likewise shall my heavenly Father do also unto you, if ye from your hearts forgive not every one his brother their trespasses.” Matt. 18:23–35. The apostles did not teach the blotting out of sins immediately on conversion. Said Peter, “Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord; and he shall send Jesus Christ, which before was preached unto you; whom the heaven must receive until the times of restitution,” etc. Acts 3:19–21. From this testimony it seems clear that the sins of all his people are to be blotted out just before the second coming of Christ. This is the closing work of his priesthood, the cleansing of the sanctuary. “For on that day shall the priest make an atonement for you, to cleanse you, that ye may be clean from all your sins before the Lord.” Lev. 16:30. When all the sins of God’s people are blotted out, they are adjudged to eternal life. Professors who have failed to overcome, will have their names blotted from the book of life. Rev. 3:5. Continue reading: SARATOGA'S REMARKABLE TRIBUTE TO EXTEMPORE PREACHING