Your ShelfYour Projects

Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 28.

THOROUGHNESS IN THE CHRISTIAN MINISTER
Earlier text: THE SEVEN LAST PLAGUES

THE RESURRECTION OF THE WICKED.

Last week Bro. N. J. Bowers proved conclusively that special judgments by which God has often cut short the lives of wicked men have not constituted the full penalty for the sins of such individuals, releasing them from a resurrection and a second death.
In addition to the editorial note given therewith, we take occasion to say a word more upon the great principle which underlies this whole subject, as it is one of no small importance. A slight regard to the principle in question would effectually save any one from the heresy of the non-resurrection of the wicked. In its light, which seems to be strangely overlooked by some, it can be clearly seen that it is no more possible that the wicked, no matter who, nor when, nor where, should not have a resurrection and be judged for their personal acts and punished therefor, than it is possible for God to lie; and that the close of this present life, no matter under what circumstances, nor for what purpose it may occur, cannot by any possibility pay the penalty for the sins of this life, and release the individual from all further accountability to God.
These propositions once established, the doctrine of the non-resurrection of the wicked is remanded to the category of brainless delusions where it belongs; and these we will now prove.
It will be admitted by all that Adam was placed on probation, and that the penalty of death, absolute and irrevocable, was affixed to the violation of the command not to eat of the forbidden tree. There was no provision made for mitigation or removal of this penalty. While yet he had no posterity, he partook of the forbidden fruit, and the sentence passed upon him, “Unto dust shalt thou return;” till which time he was to eat his bread by the sweat of his brow.
How did that affect those who were to come after? Adam could bequeath to his posterity no higher nature than he possessed,—a nature, after his transgression, not only liable, but inevitably doomed, to death. The same plane of being was his children’s only heritage,—a heritage of wearing toil during the period of their life, and after that, death. And this, remember, was because their father Adam had sinned in the matter of the forbidden tree.
The apostle makes an explicit statement of this fact. He says (Rom. 5: 12): “Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin, and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned.” When did death pass upon all men?—When the natural father of all men subjected himself to death by sin. From that moment it became a fixed fact that every human being who should appear in this world, would be subject to death. Instead of the words “for that,” in the last clause, “for that all have sinned,” the Greek has ἐφ’ ᾧ (eph’ hō) “through,” or “on account of whom all have sinned.” The margin has, “in whom;” that is, in the “one man” Adam, by whom sin entered into the world. Again the apostle says (1 Cor. 15: 22), “In Adam all die.”
Adam’s sin, trial, and sentence, marked the end of probation with him, so far as it concerned that first offer of life which God had given him, which was suspended upon his obedience. And had nothing more been done, it would have been the end of probation for all. So long as God saw fit to let men propagate themselves upon the earth, their lot would have been simply a hopeless life, to be terminated by an inevitable and eternal death.
But immediately upon Adam’s failure under that first arrangement, supervened the plan of salvation through Jesus Christ. Before the first penalty was fully carried out, there was time for Adam to have another trial; and through the intervention of Christ, this opportunity was given him. There was promised a seed of the woman who should bruise the serpent’s head. Adam was placed upon a new probation. In the promised seed, the Redeemer, a new hope was set before him; and he was taught how to manifest faith in that Redeemer by typical services, sacrifices, and offerings.
This arrangement also looked forward into the future, and included all Adam’s posterity; else we had had no hope. A pertinent inquiry now arises; namely, How could the sentence of death already rendered, be inflicted upon the whole human family so that there should be no sacrifice of authority, principle, or prestige, on the part of God, and yet the new blessing of a hope of life through Christ be placed within their reach? It could be done in this way: Let men live, and, without any reference to their own personal actions, let them die in Adam, as the apostle assures us that they do. This fulfills the Adamic penalty for the Adamic sin, under the Adamic covenant. Then let all men, irrespective of character, be brought by Christ out from this condition of Adamic death, into which they fell through no fault of their own, once more to the plane of life; and being then alive beyond the extreme limits of the effects of the Adamic covenant and fall and death penalty, nothing remains but that they answer for their own course of conduct, and receive such destiny as shall be determined thereby—if guilty, through their own sins to suffer the same penalty for their sin that Adam suffered for his, which is death, and which to them is the second death, and will be eternal because no further plan of redemption relieves them from it, as Adam’s would have been had it not been for the intervention of Christ; and if righteous, through faith in Christ, to enter then upon a life which will be eternal.
This is the result to be reached, and the way here indicated being the only possible way to reach it, we may set it down as the actual arrangement in the case. And so Paul, when he declares that all men die in Adam, immediately adds, “Even so in Christ shall all be made alive.” 1 Cor. 15: 22.
We are now prepared to draw conclusions. When Adam, some 930 years after his experience in Eden, died, he died because he ate of the forbidden tree, not because of anything he did after that event. But if, after the Judgment, Adam shall be found worthy of the second death, and be consigned to that fate, it will not be because he ate of the forbidden tree, but because of what he did, and did not repent of, after that event. When Methuselah and Noah and Abraham died, it was not because of any sins they had personally committed, but because their father Adam had transmitted to them a mortal nature. And when Caligula, and Nero, and Cæsar Borgia, and Catharine de Medici, and Jeffreys, and Claverhouse died, it was not because they were themselves monsters of iniquity, but because they belonged to a death-doomed race. And when the antediluvians, and Sodomites, and Egyptians, and incorrigible Jews, died, it was not because of their personal sins, but because in the beginning death had passed upon all men.
Such is the inevitable conclusion from the established fact that we die the first death only in Adam, not on our own account. The second death is the only death in which is involved the result of our own personal actions; and this death is reached only after a person has passed through the first, and is the termination of a second state of being.
Does not God, then, ever visit judgments upon men in this life for their sins? He certainly does; but to what extent? Only so far as to anticipate by a brief period the death to which they are already doomed. And this is all that he could do; for the penalty of the second death can no more be reached till we have passed the first death, than the high-priest could enter the second apartment of the sanctuary without passing through the first.
Let us illustrate: Suppose that in some State where the death penalty is still in force, a man is convicted of murder, and sentenced to be hanged therefor in six weeks. Suppose, further, that, being remanded to prison under the sentence, his conduct becomes so intolerable that it cannot be endured, and therefore a change is made in the arrangement, which brings him to the gallows at the end of two weeks. Now what is done?—His sentence is, on account of his misdemeanors, anticipated by four weeks; but when he hangs, what is it for? Is it for his course of conduct in prison? No; but for the murder on account of which he had been tried and sentenced to death; and it could not be otherwise without ignoring and setting aside the first crime, guilt, trial, and sentence; to suppose which would be to insult the common sense of the officers of justice.
Just so with the antediluvians, whose cases will illustrate all others. Their conduct became so intolerable that God could not suffer them to live out their days. Therefore he anticipated by a time the death which, on entirely other ground, was their inevitable portion. Had he not brought the flood upon them as a manifestation of his displeasure against their sins, they would have died after a few years more of life; and had they been paragons of piety, they would have died just the same. But the death, whenever it came, would have been the death in Adam, which must first be inflicted, because it had passed on all men; and in this death our own personal righteousness or guilt is in nowise involved.
Therefore the personal account of the antediluvians, and of all others who have gone down under special judgments, still remains unsettled; and they must have a resurrection to answer therefor, and then receive the penalty for the same, which will be the second death.

Christian Graces Like Perfumes When Pressed

—Christian graces are like perfumes; the more they are pressed, the sweeter they smell.

THE TESTIMONY OF SILENCE.

We often hear this objection: “If the Sabbath commandment is binding on Christians, why did not the apostles command its observance?”
We reply: If it were not binding, why did they still call the seventh day the Sabbath without a word of explanation? Silence in regard to an established law and usage is not a proof of the abrogation of the law, or a change of the usage. The burden of proof rests with those who claim a change.
And we have a question: If the apostles taught or practiced a change in respect to the Sabbath—if they violated the commandment—why were they never accused by the Jews on this ground? The Jews accused Jesus of breaking the Sabbath, to which he pleaded, “Not guilty;” averring that what he did was “lawful,” that is, in accordance with the Sabbath law. But after the death and resurrection of Christ, the Jews, who were ever ready to persecute the Christians, never once accused them of violating the Sabbath. On which side of the controversy is the testimony of silence? A law need not be repeated to make it a law; but it cannot be abrogated, altered, or amended, by silence.
R. F. COTTRELL.

Important Questions for Church Members: Overcoming Discouragement

IMPORTANT QUESTIONS FOR CHURCH-MEMBERS.—NO. 7.

What effect do temptations have upon your efforts to overcome? Some are easily discouraged under trial. This is wrong. When a person becomes discouraged in a worldly enterprise in which he is engaged, it never succeeds, because he loses heart in the work, and therefore slackens his effort in its behalf. It is the same in religious matters. Satan knows this very well, and is therefore much pleased to have any one get discouraged in the Lord’s service. Then when we yield to discouragement, we place ourselves in the very position where Satan would have us, and just where the Lord does not want us to be. Thus we become a toy of Satan, a plaything of his will and pleasure.
Again, a discouraged person cannot claim a single promise of God. The blessings of the Bible are valueless to him while in that state, because they are receivable only through faith, and discouragement is the very opposite,—is distrust, a want of confidence, a destitution of faith. “Without faith,” says the apostle, “it is impossible to please God.” Heb. 11:6. Again, “Whatsoever is not of faith is sin.” Rom. 14:23. Without the possession of this rare commodity, none can excel in the Christian graces; none can gain a victory over the world and its temptations; none can be acceptable to God, and are therefore committing a great wrong in his sight, as well as against their own souls.
No one can overcome of himself. All are supposed to understand this when they start out in the race for life. If we gain any victories, it is only because God has wrought in our behalf. The promise of the gospel is, “Ask and ye shall receive.” Knowing, as we ought, our own weakness, it is our duty to ask for strength to overcome. According to the word of the Lord, the promise is not doubtful—Ye shall receive. But if upon measuring strength with the world, we fail of victory, and are overcome, upon whom rests the fault? But in self-justification one may say, I have asked daily for overcoming strength, but do not receive it. We reply, “This is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith.” 1 John 5:4.
In the case of our failure at any time to overcome, one of two things is evident. We have either neglected to ask for the needed strength, or in asking, we have lacked the great essential—faith. In either event we ourselves are at fault, and not the Lord. We knew when we started out that our own strength was not sufficient for the task. We might have had help from God. Then why lose confidence in him because of our failure; for that is what we do whenever we become discouraged. But in our applications to God, if we would have what we ask, we must believe that he will hear our petitions, and grant our earnest supplications. Heb. 11:6. It matters not how formidable may be the enemy, or how imminent our danger, our confidence in God should not falter in the least, if we expect help from him. The Scripture is explicit on this point. “He that wavereth is like a wave of the sea driven with the wind and tossed. For let not that man think that he shall receive anything of the Lord.” James 1:6, 7.
God is an unfailing source of strength when he is drawn upon properly. But some have seemed to think that because they were subject to temptations, it was evidence that the Lord had forsaken them; hence they feel very much discouraged. But such does not prove the Lord’s absence; it is rather evidence of his favor. Perhaps these very persons have been pleading with God to let them see themselves (how often we hear such prayers) that they might better put away their wrongs. Did they expect that prayer to be answered? If so, how? Could they think that the Lord would reveal himself to them in a special manner, as to his prophets of old? Very few are prepared for such visits now. Besides, there are just as practical methods by which to accomplish this end, that are already at hand.
The simplest and most natural means have ever been employed to reveal to men the sinfulness of their hearts. What more successful way could the Lord take to give us a view of ourselves than by suffering us to come in contact with those influences that will tempt our inclinations, and reveal our natural weaknesses? Just then we doubtless become the object of intense anxiety to holy watchers. Our judgments have heretofore been educated as to proper action under such circumstances, but now we are under a pressure. Our inclination pleads; our wisdom resists; and for a time the struggle seems doubtful even to ourselves. But help from God is at hand, by which, if employed by us at the proper time, we gain a victory for the right, and temptation flees away.
Under these circumstances we may be enabled to count it all joy when we fall into divers temptations. James 1:2. Now we have had a partial view of ourself, and have seen one of the weaknesses of our character. We may now set about the work in earnest of correcting this defect so plainly revealed. Now the weapon with which Satan purposed to destroy us, God has placed in our own hands to use in building up a character for heaven. Certainly there is no cause of discouragement in all this, but all such experience should be to us a source of joy.
While temptations, if not overcome, will surely destroy us, yet with the fallen condition of man, it is easy to see that without temptations, no one could develop a perfect character. Before man can ever be received into glory, he must pass tests so severe as to make him impregnable to the assaults of the enemy, though made in the most subtle manner. There is only one way this can be done, and that is by bravely meeting the temptations in the way and always gaining the victory. Each temptation resisted gives strength to successfully meet the next one, and thus from day to day we mold our characters, and establish our integrity. Looking at the results, it is not so strange that Paul should rejoice in tribulations. He well knew from actual experience that tribulations work patience, and patience experience, and experience hope, and that a well grounded hope will never cause shame. Rom. 5:3–5.
The same results may now be obtained by every child of God. One will need, however, to cultivate enduring faith in the promises of the Bible, and an unwavering perseverance in the principles of the truth. All who will thus engage in the warfare may rest assured that “God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it.” 1 Cor. 10:13. J. O. CORLISS.

THE PROMISED INHERITANCE.—NO. 3.

The hope of the gospel is based upon the promises made to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Christ is the promised seed, through whom all the promised blessings are to be given. And they that are Christ’s are Abraham’s seed, and heirs to the inheritance promised to him. Hence, while the apostles preached Jesus and the resurrection, they expected that through this means the promise to the fathers would be fulfilled. The fathers had died without receiving a foot-breadth of their promised inheritance. They must be raised from the dead. After they were dead, God declared to Moses that he was their God, and on this fact Jesus based an argument for the resurrection of the dead. The argument stands thus: 1. God is not the God of inanimate dust—the hopelessly dead. 2. But he declared himself the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob long after they were dead. 3. Therefore they are destined to live again—they live in the purpose of God; therefore he is still their God. The Saviour did not, as some suppose, set out to prove the resurrection of the dead, and bring out the conclusion that they have not really died, and consequently need no resurrection. Please pardon the digression.
The preaching of Christ by the apostles, and the resurrection of the dead through him, was the cause of offence to the Jews. But it was through this very means that the promise of an inheritance to Abraham and his true children (Gal. 3 : 29), was to be fulfilled. Accordingly Paul, in his defense before Agrippa, says, “And now I stand and am judged for the hope of the promise made of God unto our fathers: unto which promise our twelve tribes, instantly serving God day and night, hope to come. For which hope’s sake, King Agrippa, I am accused of the Jews. Why should it be thought a thing incredible with you that God should raise the dead?” Acts 26 : 6–8. By this testimony it is clear that the only hope of the fulfillment of the promise of an inheritance in the earth to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, depends upon the resurrection of the dead. Abraham was not ignorant of the doctrine of the resurrection. When he offered up Isaac, through whom God had promised him a numerous posterity, he did so, “accounting that God was able to raise him up, even from the dead; from whence also he received him in a figure.” Heb. 11 : 19. With this faith, he was not dismayed when God told him that he should go to his fathers in peace, that he should be buried in a good old age, and that several generations would pass before even the typical fulfillment of the promise. The ancient martyrs had faith in the resurrection. They endured the most cruel persecutions, not accepting deliverance on the terms of renouncing their faith, “that they might obtain a better resurrection.” Heb. 11 : 35. The better resurrection is the first. “Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection: on such the second death hath no power.” Rev. 20 : 6.
There is an age of glory in reserve for the earth; but it has been the mistake of many to look for it before the time. Sin and the curse must be removed ere that glorious day shall dawn. The Psalmist prayed, “Let the whole earth be filled with his glory. Amen, and Amen.” Though long since uttered, and not yet realized, this prayer will certainly be answered. When this petition is fulfilled, the Lord says, “They shall not hurt nor destroy in all my holy mountain: for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the glory of the Lord, as the waters cover the sea. Isa. 11 : 9.”
But the last days of the present dispensation, according to the predictions of Christ and the apostles, will be especially sinful and perilous. Matt. 24 : 11, 12, 24; 2 Tim. 3 : 1–5. It will be a time of great apostasy from the truth of God. 1 Tim. 4 : 1; 2 Tim. 4 : 3, 4. The “man of sin,” “the son of perdition,” will oppose and exalt himself above God, until he be destroyed by the brightness of Christ’s coming. 2 Thess. 2 : 1–8. So there is no possibility that the age of glory shall dawn, before the Son of man shall come in his glory, and all the holy angels with him. Then shall he sit upon the throne of his glory, and proceed to the execution of the Judgment. To his people he will say, “Come ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.” Matt. 25 : 34.
The kingdom which God “hath promised to them that love him” is prepared from the very foundation of the world. When the earth was created, it was designed to be the territory of an everlasting kingdom, possessed by sinless beings, as our first parents were before the fall; and though by disobedience man lost the dominion which God gave him over all the earth, Gen. 1 : 28, yet through the “last Adam,” the life-giving spirit, there shall be a “restitution of all things, which God hath spoken by the mouth of all his holy prophets since the world began” (Acts. 3 : 20, 21); and so the purpose of God respecting the earth will be accomplished: “He created it not in vain, he formed it to be inhabited.” Isa. 45 : 18.
This kingdom is not a myth, but a real kingdom. Like other kingdoms, it will be constituted with its king, its subjects, its laws, its capital city, and its territory. Jesus Christ the Son of God will be the king. Ps. 2 : 6–9; 89 : 18; 110 : 1; Isa. 9 : 6, 7; Luke 1 : 30–33; Heb. 1 : 8, 9; 10 : 12, 13; Rev. 19 : 11–16. The people who are redeemed from sin will be the subjects of the kingdom; but they cannot enter upon their inheritance until they shall be changed from mortality to immortality; and this change cannot take place till the trumpet shall sound which wakes the dead in Christ, when “the Lord himself shall descend from heaven.” It is written, “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God; neither doth corruption inherit incorruption. Behold, I show you a mystery; We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trump: for the trumpet shall sound, and the dead shall be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed. For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality.” 1 Cor. 15 : 50–53; 1 Thess. 4 : 16.
While in our present mortal state we may be “rich in faith, and heirs” to a promised kingdom (Jas. 2:5); but we must wait for the time of its possession, as described in Dan. 7:22: “Until the Ancient of days came, and judgment was given to the saints of the Most High; and the time came that the saints possessed the kingdom.” The Judgment must decide who “shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world and the resurrection from the dead” (Luke 20 : 35), and the Son of man must come in his glory, and be seated upon his glorious throne. Then will he say to those on his right hand, “Come, ye blessed of my Father, INHERIT the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.” Matt. 25 : 31–34.
The laws of the kingdom will be the laws of God. Of this there can be no doubt. The law of God consists of principles of truth and justice, which, from their very nature, must be as enduring and unchanging as God himself. The briefest epitome of these principles is, “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind,” and, “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.” These same principles are embodied more in detail in the ten commandments, which have been and are rightly regarded as the moral law. It is objected that the Sabbath precept is not a moral law. But the Creator has a moral right to claim of his creatures an act expressive of their acknowledgment of the fact that he is their Creator, and of their willing submission to his authority. The Sabbath precept is the only one of the ten which is a memorial of God, independent of all other considerations. Is it not a moral duty to observe it? Is it not robbery of God and rebellion to refuse submission to his claim? We believe that the principles of the other nine will not be violated in the future kingdom of God; but one thing is certain, and that is, that the Sabbath will exist, and be observed by all in the world to come; for it is expressly foretold in Isa. 66 : 22, 23: “For as the new heavens and the new earth which I will make, shall remain before me, saith the Lord, so shall your seed and your name remain. And it shall come to pass that from one new moon to another, and from one Sabbath to another, shall all flesh come to worship before me, saith the Lord.”
R. F. COTTRELL.
Continue reading: SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS