Your ShelfYour Projects

Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 41.

LABORS IN CHRISTIANA
Earlier text: THE OLD TESTAMENT

“THE ABOMINATION OF ALL AGES.”

Such is the term applied by W. H. Osborne, an Episcopal minister, to “a church controlled by, or controlling, the State by the carnal weapons of this world, not the weapons of Christ its founder.” And this is the very abomination which the National Reform Association is laboring to set up in our own country, by such a religious amendment to the Constitution as will “place all the Christian laws, institutions, and usages of the Government on an undeniable legal basis in the fundamental law of the land.” In a discourse on “Christian Methods in Promoting Temperance,” delivered in Music Hall, Springfield, Mo., Mr. O. said many good things concerning the relation of the church to the State, from which we quote the following thoughts. Our readers will find them well worth considering:—
“There is a fascination in many minds for any methods for bettering the condition of our race which are large and grand and magnificent in their scale. We are not content usually to deal with men’s souls one by one, but we propose larger ways of doing things, by which we hope to sweep into heaven whole nations and peoples in one day. So thought that king of the heathen nation to whom Christianity was taught by the missionaries, and who ordered his subjects to the river to be baptized at the point of the bayonets of his soldiers. So thought Philip of Spain when he tried to convert the Netherlands by the military power of the Duke of Alva. So thought Charles IX. when he would make all France Christian according to his ideas, by the massacre of St. Bartholomew. So thought also Elizabeth and Laud in England, when they would enforce uniformity of worship by the power of the civil law and its penalties; so thought also Cromwell and the Puritans when they tried to Christianize England by calling in the aid of the State to enforce Christian commands and compel the practice of what they deemed Christian virtue.
“The great problem of church and State, and the relation which they bear to each other, are brought to the front again in the discussion of Christian methods as distinct from State methods of treating intemperance.”
“Many people are unable to see that the nature of the church and State are different, and that this difference must be recognized in temperance matters. We must not confound the State and church on this question.
“The function of the church is to teach men the gospel of Christ. Its teachers are pre-eminently its ministers, who are stewards of its means of grace. With this stewardship they ought to be content. It is their privilege to preach the word and administer the sacraments; and in doing this, they appeal to the free will of men, and are forbidden to resort to coercion to carry out their purposes. They are not permitted to coerce men into the kingdom of God, even if that were possible. The whole influence which they may exert must be moral and spiritual. Their weapons are not carnal, but spiritual, to tear down the stronghold of sin.
“The constitutional nature of the church and its functions are defined by Christ: ‘My kingdom is not of this world; if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight.’ But forgetful of this saying of Christ against merging church and State, Christians and Christian ministers often have not only affirmed by precept and example that Christ’s kingdom ought to be of this world’s power, but that it is most proper and commendable to fight for this kingdom by invoking civil legislation in its favor. . . .”
“The church as a corporate moral power has no more to do with civil legislation than it has to meet together in this State through its ministers, and enact laws against stealing under penalty of imprisonment, or elect a senator to the United States Senate.
“Consult the pages of our great jurist, Cooley, in his work upon ‘Constitutional Limitations,’ where he says: Consult the pages of American jurists and all jurists and statesmen of this age when men believe in keeping separate the functions of the State and church, and they will all pronounce with one voice that the essential function of a State is to prescribe law as a rule of civil conduct with a penalty as its sanction. The State ever undertakes to coerce men to obedience if they will not obey without; but the church cannot coerce. It can persuade men by the glory and beauty of righteousness, and by the tenderness and pathos and love of Christ. Thus far can she go, and no further. But this boundary of her power makes her omnipotent. Here is the omnipotence of love, which, more than the edicts of monarchs, more potent than the strength of the warrior, and mightier than all magistracies, conquers and wins the human heart to purity and godliness by the ineffable vision and attraction of the majesty of eternal right. . . .”
“I do not oppose prohibition as a State measure. If the citizens of this country think it advisable, effectual, and expedient as a police regulation, Christians, as citizens, may vote for such a State measure. But let it be understood that the church of Christ is opposed to prohibition or civil legislation when they are offered as church measures for regenerating the world. Put prohibition where it belongs—upon the platform of a State measure; but don’t foist it upon the church of Christ as a moral, religious, and Christian measure. Thus the right relation between the function of the State and church will be preserved, and Christianity in its corporate life and action will not be liable to the rebuke of making itself that abomination of all ages, a church controlled by, or controlling the State by, the carnal weapons of this world, not the weapons of Christ, its founder. . . . Let those who have so great expectations of the civil law’s help in putting away this sin, listen to the wise words of John Milton concerning the quality of such legislation:—
“Though you may take from a covetous man all of his treasures, he has one jewel left—you cannot bereave him of his covetousness. Banish all objects of lust, shut up all youth into the severest discipline that can be exercised in any hermitage, you cannot make them chaste that came not hither so. Look how much we expel of sin, so much we expel of virtue. This justifies that high providence of God, who, though he commands us to temperance, justice, and continence, yet pours out before us ever in profusion all desirable things.”
“And if again you are impatient with the slowness of the Christian methods of dealing with this sin, remember, I entreat you, in the midst of your clamor for speedier methods, in your judgment, that he who believeth shall not make haste, and that God does not reap his harvest at every political election time.”

THE SEVENTH-DAY BAPTISTS.

HAVING just returned from the General Conference of the S. D. Baptists, perhaps a word or two in reference to that people may not be uninteresting to the readers of the REVIEW.
Their meeting was held in the public square of the beautiful village of Milton, Wis., beginning on the 22nd, and ending the 27th, of September. Over fifty ministers were present to participate in the deliberations, besides laymen as delegates. A large concourse of people attended, some 1,500, perhaps, being the maximum. The audience tent of the S. D. Adventists of Wisconsin was used on this occasion, while an eighty-foot tent spread its broad shadow for dining purposes, some eight hundred people partaking of the bounteous feast spread for all who wished to satisfy the demands of hunger.
Among the questions discussed was, Denominational Growth; Is it Desirable? How Can it be Brought About? From remarks made, it would appear that the denomination is scarcely holding its own. The Sabbath school society also complained of a decrease in numbers, though few seemed satisfied to receive this as a fixed fact.
Resolutions were passed expressing a belief in the coming of the Lord, but saying nothing of its nearness; and in the resurrection of the dead, but nothing was said in regard to time or manner. Collections were taken for the tract society and the missionary society, which are separate organizations. Among the things donated for this purpose was a beautiful silk quilt, valued at $125, upon which $106 were raised, the same to be sent to their missionary in China. Two gold rings were found among the contributions, which were auctioned off to the highest bidder, and resulted in no little merriment, and $72. The local elder showed himself to be possessed of peculiar qualifications for that calling, as well perhaps as for the ministry of the word.
One thing was particularly noticeable in the remarks of all when discussing their success as agitators of the demands of God's law; and that was, no recognition was made of any assistance from any sources outside of S. D. Baptists. This was the more remarkable in view of the fact that dolorous notes were heard of their own people's forsaking the Sabbath law of Jehovah, and turning for profit or pleasure to the world, which was even now convinced by their self-sacrificing efforts that no sanctity belonged to the Sunday; and they look forward to the time when the “Sabbath reform” shall have converted the world.
The choir consisted of some fifty members, and discoursed very excellent music, correct time and distinct utterance being particularly noticeable.
W. S.

The Word of God Yields New Wonders

—The word of God will stand a thousand readings; and he who has gone over it most frequently is the surest of finding new wonders there.— James Hamilton.

The Sun of Love and the Cold North

—A great sun of everlasting love shines upon the globe of our life with tropical force, but we get away to the North Pole of doubt and fear, and then complain that the sun has such little heat, or that he is so long below the horizon. He that will not go to the fire ought not to complain that the room is cold.—Bible Banner.

A Commonplace Life: Finding Beauty in Ordinary Days

—A commonplace life, we say, and we sigh; But why should we sigh as we say? The commonplace sun in the commonplace sky Makes up the commonplace day. The moon and the stars are commonplace things, The flower that blooms, and the bird that sings; But sad were the world, and dark were our lot, If the flowers failed to bloom and the sun shone not. And God, who seeth each separate soul, Out of commonplace lives makes his beautiful whole. —Susan Coolidge.

THE ARK AND THE COVENANT.

The 21st verse of 1 Kings 8, reads: “And I have set there a place for the ark wherein is the covenant of the Lord which he made with our fathers, when he brought them out of the land of Egypt.”
This text is quoted with great assurance by those who desire to prove that the covenant made with Israel, when they came out of Egypt,—the old or first covenant which has been done away,—was the ten commandments; for here, they say, Solomon affirms that this covenant was in the ark; and there was nothing in the ark but the ten commandments.
In reply to this it is only necessary to say that the word “wherein” does not refer to the “ark,” but to the “place” just before mentioned. Solomon had made in the temple a place for the ark; and in the same place was the covenant which was written in a book and placed in a coffer by the side of the ark. Deut. 31: 24-26 records in these words the instruction which was given to the Levites in this matter: “And it came to pass when Moses had made an end of writing the words of this law in a book, until they were finished, that Moses commanded the Levites which bear the ark of the covenant of the Lord, saying, Take this book of the law, and put it in the side of the ark of the covenant of the Lord your God, that it may be there for a witness against thee.”
Prideaux in his “Connection,” vol. i, p. 152, explains this to mean in a small chest or coffer by the side of the ark, not inside of it, and quotes the Chaldee Paraphrase of Jonathan Ben Uzziel in support of his position.
We have lately received a communication from a correspondent, in which he says:—
“In your tract on ‘The Two Covenants,’ in your comments on 1 Kings 8:21 you remark that ‘the key to the explanation of this passage lies in the antecedent of the word “wherein.”’ Further on, you state that ‘Hebraists tell us that the grammatical construction refers it unquestionably to the “place.”’ Will you be so kind as to furnish us with the names of a few authors who so construe it?”
In that expression we had reference to Hebrew scholars with whom we had personally conversed, and not to commentaries upon the passage. Expositors do not seem to have supposed that there was ground for any question to arise over the passage sufficient to demand a criticism, and so have paid no particular attention to the construction.
The word “wherein” is from the two Hebrew words אשר־שם (asher-shām). The first is the regular relative pronoun, “who” and “which.” The second is the adverb of place, “there.” Literally, it would be translated “which there;” and to these two words thus joined together, the lexicons give the simple definition “where.” Had reference been made to the “ark,” the relative would have been used with a demonstrative, preceded by a preposition, thus: אשר בו “in which;” literally, “which in him.”
Thus there seems to be no room for doubt as to the construction of 1 Kings 8:21, nor any ground to suppose otherwise than that the word “wherein” refers to the place where the ark was, and not to the ark itself.

THE NEW JERUSALEM

Rev. 21:1: “And I saw a new heaven and a new earth: for the first heaven and the first earth were passed away; and there was no more sea.”
The new heaven and earth. By the first heaven and first earth, John unquestionably means the ones which now are. Some have supposed that when the Bible speaks of the third heaven, in which are paradise and the tree of life (1 Cor. 12:2; Rev. 2:7), it refers to the heaven which is yet future, and does not prove that there is a paradise and tree of life literally in existence at the present time. They base their views on the fact that Peter speaks of three heavens and three earths: those before the flood, the ones which now are, and the ones which are to come. But all theories based upon this one fact are overturned by this first verse of Rev. 21; for John here reckons but two heavens and earths; the ones which now are, he calls the first; so that the future new heavens would be the second, and not the third, as Peter reckons. Hence it is certain that Peter did not design to lay down a numerical order, that we should speak of the one as the first, the other as the second, and the last as the third. The object of his reasoning was simply to show that as a literal heaven and earth succeeded to the destruction of the earth by the flood, so a literal heaven and earth would emerge from the renovation of the present system by fire. There is no proof therefore that the Bible, when it speaks of the third heaven, refers simply to the third state of the present heaven and earth; for then all the Bible writers would have been uniform in their reckoning on this point. Thus the arguments of those who would endeavor to disprove of the idea of a literal paradise and tree of life at the present time, fall to the ground.
We believe the Bible recognizes three heavens, all existing in the present constitution of things; namely, the first heaven, which the fowls of the air inhabit; the second, the region of the sun, moon, and stars; and the third, high above them all, where paradise and the tree of life are found, where God has his residence and his throne, to which Paul was caught up in heavenly vision, to which Christ ascended when he left the earth, where he now shares the throne of his Father as priest-king, and where the glorious city stands, awaiting the saints when they enter into life. Blessed be God that from that bright land intelligence has been brought to this far-off world of ours! and thanks to his holy name that a way has been opened from the dark places of earth, which leads like a straight and shining path of light up to those blest abodes!
Verses 2–4: “And I John saw the holy city, New Jerusalem, coming down from God out of heaven, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. And I heard a great voice out of heaven saying, Behold, the tabernacle of God is with men, and he will dwell with them, and they shall be his people, and God himself shall be with them, and be their God. And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain; for the former things are passed away.”
In connection with the view which John has of the holy city coming down from God out of heaven, a voice is heard, saying, “The tabernacle of God is with men, and he will dwell with them.” The conclusion naturally follows, that the tabernacle here mentioned is the city. This same city is called in John 14, the Father’s house in which there are many mansions. If an objection should arise in any mind that this is too permanent a place to be called a tabernacle, we reply that the word “tabernacle” sometimes means a permanent dwelling-place. And it seems that the great God takes up his abode on this earth. We do not suppose that God is confined to this, or any other one of the worlds of his creation; but he here has a throne, and earth enjoys so much of his presence that it may be said that he dwells among men. And why should this be thought a strange thing? God’s only begotten Son is here as a ruler of his special kingdom: the holy city which is called the Father’s house, and which, it is natural to suppose, will be the most beautiful and glorious place in the universe, will be here; the heavenly hosts take an interest in this world probably above what they feel in any other; yea, reasoning from one of the Saviour’s parables, there will be more joy in heaven over one world redeemed, than over ninety and nine which needed no redemption.
“And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes.” He does this not literally; for there will be no tears in that kingdom for him to literally wipe away; but he does it by removing all the causes of tears.
Verses 5, 6: “And he that sat upon the throne said, Behold, I make all things new. And he said unto me, Write; for these words are true and faithful. And he said unto me, It is done. I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end. I will give unto him that is athirst of the fountain of the water of life freely.”
He that sits upon the throne is the same that is mentioned in verses 11 and 12 of the preceding chapter. He says, “I make all things new,” not, I make all new things. The earth is not destroyed, annihilated, and a new one created, but all things are made over new. Let us rejoice that these words are true and faithful. And when this is accomplished, “it is done.” The dark shadow of sin has forever passed away from the universe. The wicked, root and branch, are wiped out of the land of the living, and the universal anthem of praise and thanksgiving (Rev. 5:13), from a redeemed world and a clean universe, goes up to God.

HOLINESS—PECULIAR

A correspondent sends us an account of a “Holiness Camp-meeting,” at Storm Lake, Iowa, which closed Aug. 30, after having continued ten days. In addition to what is stated in the following communication, we may mention that one of the leading spirits of the meeting, according to reports in the local papers, the pastor of the M. E. church of the place, in his prayer on Sunday evening, uttered the petition that the Lord would either convert or kill the Universalist minister of the place. The report attributes to him this exclamation: “O Lord, convert the Universalist minister of Storm Lake, or kill him—drive him out of town. If you cannot free us of him any other way, kill him with a blow from his fast horse.” He then went on to predict the death of said minister within thirty days, as his prayers, he said, are always answered. What kind of “holiness” a man could possess who would utter such a prayer, we leave our readers to judge. Of the meeting, our correspondent, E. M. Aldrich, says:—
“Inclosed I send an advertisement of a Holiness camp-meeting, which closed here Aug. 30. I have never seen nor heard anything to compare with it. It is stated that fully one thousand who were in attendance professed holiness, and the most attained to that state at the above meeting. I was on the grounds Sunday, the 29th, and tried to form some idea whence their power came. That there is a power among them no observing person can deny; but what that power is that controls the minds of the best men of our town and country, was what I wished to discover. Men and women of high standing in the business and social world were drawn under its influence, with apparently no power to resist. So manifest was this influence, I had no desire to enter the large tent where they held their meetings. I am satisfied that it is some influence that controls the mind like mesmerism. I noticed that persons of frail constitutions were the first to give way to this influence, and that as soon as they came under its control, every look of solemnity was gone. Their talk was trivial; and such exclamations as, ‘I’m holy! I’m saved! I’m fully sanctified!’ were heard on every hand. But when we come to measure them by the word of God, we find they cannot stand the most simple test.”
“But as to some of their professions of faith. They claim that this will go on until righteousness covers the whole earth; that soon this power will be so great that such miracles as were performed by Christ and the apostles will be a common occurrence; also that Christ is soon to come and set up his kingdom, and reign a thousand years. Could Satan ask for more? Could anything be better prepared for him to step in, representing the Lord, to carry on the great deception?”
“This movement is permeating all denominations in Northwestern Iowa, and I am satisfied no S. D. Adventist should have any connection with it. Those engaged in this work are sending out tents all over the country, staying from one to two weeks in a community. And wherever they go, they gain their adherents. Each tent company consists of ten or twelve persons, whom they call a praying band. This is enough to form a nucleus from which this power seems to arise. They push their work with great vigor, and cause great excitement wherever they go.”

ONLY THE COVERS LEFT.

The following anecdote illustrates most strikingly what many of the modern clergy are doing for the Bible. When a text does not suit them, they can often find what is, to their own minds at least, a very plausible way of discarding it; or if they cannot quite do that, they change it over to suit their own feelings or prejudices; just as it was lately declared in a religious paper that when Christ told his disciples that they should wash one another’s feet, he meant that they should black one another’s boots. Some throw away the entire Old Testament, on the ground that we have outgrown that. Others, for the same reason, throw away the Gospels, as all they record took place before the day of Pentecost, where they place the opening of the new dispensation. Some throw away the Revelation, on the ground that it is a sealed book, and boldly take the ground that the apostles were mistaken in this or that utterance which they cannot understand. Thus there is not much of anything left of the blessed Bible but the covers. The Canadian Baptist has the following telling anecdote on this point:—
“Mr. Moody tells a pithy story of a young man who held out a book to his pastor, saying, ‘Here’s your Bible,’ and turning the leaves, showed him the volume with many books cut out altogether, and hardly a whole page among those that were left. ‘Why, what do you mean?’ asked the doctor of divinity; ‘that is not my Bible.’ ‘Yes, it is,’ was the reply; ‘I have followed your preaching for ten years, and whenever you have discredited a book or verse or explained it away as uninspired or mythical, I have cut it out; and this is what is left of your Bible.’ ‘Let me have it,’ said the pastor. ‘Oh, no,’ said the young man instantly, ‘I am going to hang on to the covers anyhow.’”

THOUGHTS ON PRACTICAL SUBJECTS.

BE POSITIVE.

The man who impresses others, who converts others, who carries conviction with him, is the positive man, the one who is sure that he is right, and shows it in every expression. The uncertain man, who is always offering apologies for his opinions, who is always qualifying what he says, and splitting hairs, convicts nobody, even though he has the truth on his side. His very manner awakens doubt as to the truthfulness of his position. But the positive, enthusiastic man, who expresses his opinions without a doubt, who talks as though he knew he was right,—that man is always a power. The rule is, Be sure you are right, and then say so, with all the emphasis and assurance that you are capable of. If you are in doubt about your position, study it until you settle the matter, and be sure you settle it right. Too much argument is a bad thing. A few points well made, and driven home, are sufficient.

BE ENERGETIC AND ENTHUSIASTIC.

Energy and enthusiasm, what can they not accomplish? They are more than talent and learning, and, in fact, they often seem too strong for truth itself. Everything has to give way before them. Look at Peter the Hermit, a man of small capacity and narrow ideas; but with his unbounded energy and enthusiasm he swept all Europe like a hurricane. You will often see a man with a little bullet head and a handful of ideas accomplish more than a whole regiment of slow, logical, cautious men. Dr. Arnold says: “The difference between one boy and another consists not so much in talent as in energy.” Sir Thomas Buxton says: “The longer I live, the more I am certain that the great difference between men is energy. Invincible determination and honest purpose once fixed, and then it is death or victory.” Brethren, if you want to succeed, put enthusiasm into what you do.

READ OR STARVE.

A man who at length became one of the great lords of England, rose from a humble state to fill the highest office in the nation by his indomitable perseverance and hard study. For long years he met with no success, and almost starved. Many a man would have quailed and whined and made a failure; but no, this only spurred him on to greater exertions. When distaste, disinclination, or weariness crept over him, as they will over the most determined men, he would write and set before his aching eyes, “Read or starve!” three monosyllables which have achieved as many miracles as the magic word “Failure.” He did read, but he did not starve. Look at the lives of most great men, and you will find that here was the secret of their success. It was not luck or chance, but it was hard work long continued. Look at the enormous amount of work which some men undergo to obtain only trifling accomplishments. “You will see a man for years practice on his fiddle to draw sweet music from its strings. You will see another man practice for years to bring down a pigeon on the wing; another will devote half his life to acquiring the art of balancing himself on a rope, or standing on his head upon the top of a pole.” Then all the world wonder, and pay their money to see it. If ministers would make half the exertion, they would shake the world with their power.

KEEP A NOTE-BOOK.

One of the most valuable things a literary man can do is to keep in his pocket a little note-book. In it, put down any excellent thought which may occur to you at any moment, whether it come to you by reading, reflection, or observation. By doing this, you will treasure up, retain, and hold some of the most precious thoughts, which otherwise would escape you. This is what the great scholars of the world have done, and it is what every one should do. Whether riding, talking, or conversing, if a good, bright idea comes to you, write it down. The very act of doing this will impress it on your mind when otherwise you would soon forget it. And then you have the book to refer to, to refresh your mind. It takes but a moment, but it is an invaluable habit.

TAX YOUR MEMORY.

The mind which is never severely taxed, becomes lazy; hence, the person who wishes to have a strong, retentive memory, should often tax it to its utmost. It is said that the father of the great Sir Robert Peel used to try his memory in every way. Every Sunday, on returning from church, he would take him into a private room and make him repeat just as much as possible of the sermon. In this way he formed the habit of noticing and remembering what he heard. It was the secret of his great success. Another man tried the memory of his boy by requiring him to walk by a store, and then name just as many articles as possible which he had seen in passing. It is remarkable how a little practice increased his ability in this line. We do not know what we can do until we try.
D. M. CANRIGHT.

THE DEBATE AT DES MOINES GIVEN UP.

WORD from Iowa recently received brings the information that the proposed discussion between myself and Eld. Dungan, of the Disciple Church, will not come off as was appointed. The facts in brief are these: During our large camp-meeting at Des Moines last June, there was evidently a deep impression made upon the people. The Disciples have a church and a university there. Many people of that denomination were quite stirred over the preaching they heard at the meeting, and proposed a discussion. As we are opposed to debating unless really compelled to do so in defense of the truth, we gave them no encouragement; but this did not satisfy them. They were continually talking and urging it, and, to remove all objections, offered to furnish a house and also to board me. As we have a young mission there, our brethren feared that it would give an impression that we were afraid to defend the truth if we refused to debate. Therefore, finally we told them that, if they would do all they agreed to, they might choose their man, and if we could agree on the terms we would meet them.
The leaders in this were some young men from their university. We did not know what position they occupied or how responsible they were, nor did we stop to inquire. The next day these young men returned to our camp with Prof. Dungan, of their university, Eld. Lucas, the editor of their paper, Eld. Cornell, with whom I had formerly twice debated, and several other of their leading men. Elds. Haskell, Smith, Morrison, McCoy, and myself, and several others of our leading brethren met them. We had a very pleasant though brief interview, and readily agreed on the questions to be discussed, the rules, time, and everything concerning the debate. It was distinctly stated before all that they were to furnish a house free. When they suggested that a small admittance fee might be taken up, we said that we would not allow that, as it would keep away many of the people who might wish to attend. So they dropped the matter without urging it at all.
Under date of Sept. 10, Eld. Dungan wrote me, saying: “I find the party that was to furnish the house for the debate unable to do so. The best offer is the Standard Theater, at $20 a night. Now I will take the chances by raising at least a part of the amount by a door fee, or I will divide the risk and the income with you. But as I am not able to pay for the hall myself, I cannot provide a place for the debate without help.”
Of course we refused to make any such change in the conditions, and wrote Eld. Dungan to that effect. We are now told that the parties who urged on the debate are irresponsible. It seems to us that Eld. Dungan and the responsible men that were present ought to have been aware of that fact at the time, and not have waited till now to tell us so. And further, it seems to us, if their brethren who were to back them failed them, that their leading men who were present and assented to the agreement, should have felt themselves bound to make it good. We certainly would have done so if we had made such an agreement. It is remarkable also that the Oracle, their paper published at Des Moines, and edited by Eld. Lucas, who was their chosen moderator for the debate, came out a few days since with an offer to furnish a hall for a debate between the Adventists and the Spiritualists. It is a little singular that their people could furnish a hall so readily for such a debate, but could not furnish one for their own use, according to agreement.
At last, however, a hall was found that could be had for $7 an evening, or $70 for the entire debate. The students in their university raised $40 of the sum, but found their other brethren unwilling to help at all toward raising the balance needed. At least, so I am informed.
As far as I can see, Eld. Dungan seems to have been willing to do his part to carry out the discussion, and I judge that we would have had an interesting debate. But it seems that his brethren did not think they would gain anything by so doing, and failed to support him; so the matter was dropped.
Expecting the debate to come off, I have tried to post up thoroughly, as I thought it was my duty to do. I feel that the Lord has blessed me in this, and I have obtained many precious ideas and facts on the subjects of the Sabbath, law, and covenants. I shall endeavor to bring these out in some form, so as to preserve them for myself; and that others may have the benefit of them if they so desire.
D. M. CANRIGHT.
Being present at the interview above referred to, I can testify to the correctness of the statements Eld. Canright has made concerning it, and the conditions agreed upon for the debate.
U. SMITH, Editor REVIEW AND HERALD.

READ YOUR BIBLE THROUGH.

When a minister enters a new field, it is necessary for him to be acquainted with his weapons of warfare. The public largely estimate his knowledge by the amount of reading he has done. Suppose he should be asked, How often have you read the Bible through? and should have to reply that he had not once done so, what kind of an impression would he leave? His influence, in that neighborhood at least, would be greatly diminished. Preaching, and yet never read his Bible through! David refused to go out to meet the Philistines clothed with Saul’s armor, saying, “I cannot go with these; for I have not proved them.” How many of us are wont to be content with the armor of others? We store our minds with what other men have taught us, without proving for ourselves what is truth.
“Searching” the Scriptures may not imply a systematic course of reading them, yet the one should not prohibit the other. Points are gathered in reading the Bible through by course that in searching for texts bearing upon particular truths would be passed by, although contained perhaps in the next verse. A good systematic method for reading the Bible consists in enumerating the pages, and ascertaining how many should be read each day in order to read it through in a certain time. The ordinary minion 12mo. reference Bible contains something near twelve hundred pages; and to read it through in a year would require the reading of three and one half pages each day. To arise early in the morning, and spend one hour in reading and meditating upon this portion of my Bible each day, is, in my experience, a profitable manner of spiritual preparation for the day’s work. To read hastily, without due meditation, is to read without profit. For an ordinary reader, an hour is a sufficient length of time to peruse the above number of pages, and the benefit thus derived is inestimable.
“It is one thing now to read it with delight, And quite another thing to read it right.”
I heard of one man who read the Bible through twenty-one times, and finally came to the conclusion there was nothing in it. Such readings are unprofitable; and while we endeavor to let the world know that we have read the Bible through, we should also let them know that we have drank at its fountain and eaten of its substance.
Continue reading: SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS