Earlier text: TAKING FROM AND ADDING TO THE SCRIPTURESReply to Eld. Wardner’s Rejoinder.
By John Harvey Kellogg
The first paragraph of our reviewer’s article in rejoinder on this subject is devoted to establishing the fact that the righteous man receives a part of his reward in this life,—a position in which we fully agree with him. The contrary view is not necessitated by our view of the nature of man, nor have we ever assumed it. The remark which Eld. W. makes the basis of his opposition referred entirely to final rewards and punishments. We showed in our last article that if Eld. W.’s position is correct, the penalty of sin is simply “spiritual death”; that there is no need of a future punishment for sin, and if the reward of right doing is simply spiritual life, or “a state of favor with God,” there is no necessity for a future reward for the righteous. This argument he has not answered. Eld. W. says we have quoted the opinions of Mr. Hutton and Canon Barry against the testimony of Paul, Peter, and Christ, but does not show wherein the opposition lies. We have made no such use of the testimony of the learned authorities referred to. We quoted them in opposition to our reviewer, but showed a harmony between their views and those of Christ and the apostles, and, indeed, the whole Bible. We quoted these authors for the purpose of showing that the most advanced thinkers, even among those who still hold with our reviewer in the main with reference to the nature of man, are being compelled to modify their views upon this subject so greatly as to bring them practically upon our platform. This point we made very clear, and our reviewer has not attempted to answer our argument otherwise than by the equivocal assertion referred to above. In his next paragraph our reviewer repeats the attempt, made several times before, to show an absurdity in our position by a wrong representation of it. When he says that we claim that the soul, or organization, is “no part of the individual,” he makes an assertion which we have repeatedly corrected as a misrepresentation. We claim that the soul is the essential part of the individual; and this thought is prominent all through our little work which was the occasion of this discussion. Eld. W. says our view “makes death result in perfect annihilation of the whole man.” Let us see. According to Webster, “annihilation” means, “The act of reducing to nothing, or non-existence; or, the act of destroying the former combination of parts under which a thing exists, so that the name can no longer be applied to it.” If Eld. W. uses the word in the sense of the first part of the definition, then death does not, according to our view, result in annihilation, since the soul, an essential element of the individual, continues to exist after death so long as it has a representation, as we have explained at length in previous articles. Being abstract in nature, the soul can only exist by means of a representative; and so long as it340 has a representation, it may and does exist. If, however, the sense in which the word is used by Eld. W. is that given in the last part of the definition, the individual is annihilated at death; for death is certainly a destruction of the “former combination of parts” under which man exists during life. Nevertheless, our view stands on an equal footing with that of our reviewer on this point; for according to this meaning of the word, death is as much annihilation from his standpoint as from ours. An “intelligent, conscious entity” is only one of the combination of parts which make up man as we know him, according to Eld. W.; and if death is a separation of this conscious, intellectual part from the organic life and the material part of the individual, it is as much an act of annihilation as though it were the separation of an organization from the material parts composing the organism. We are not unwilling to accept his conclusion that death is annihilation, when the word is understood according to the above definition; but if this is a reflection upon our theory, it is an equally strong reflection upon that of Eld. W., as we have just shown. So much for our reviewer’s “second point.” Now let us consider briefly his “third point,” that, “if mind and character are products of a material organization, a radical change in said organization would, according to physical law, cause a corresponding change in the mind and character of the person.” This point we have fully considered before, and shown the absurdity of our reviewer’s conclusions; but as he does not seem to recognize the point made, we will again call attention to the fact that his own view involves the same philosophical difficulty, if there is any. We may with equal fairness reason, if mind and character are the products of “an immaterial entity,” and if a change in result necessarily implies a change in cause, a radical change in the character of an individual necessitates, according to the plainest rules of logical reasoning, an equally radical change in the “immaterial entity” which Eld. W. believes to be the soul. And if such a change implies loss of identity, then Eld. W.’s view is fully open to the same objection as ours. In other words, if a man who possessed a deformed, diseased, degenerated body in this world will lose his identity if he becomes the possessor of a superior organization and character in the next, the man who possesses a narrow, selfish, dwarfed, and vicious “immaterial entity” in this life, will lose his identity if he becomes the possessor of a pure, noble, elevated character in the next. “Great is the mystery of godliness.” We do not pretend to say how it is that a soul, an organization, perverted, depraved, dwarfed, and corrupted by the inherited effects of sin, and the results of sins committed,—can become elevated, pure, Christlike. This is a miracle of grace quite beyond our feeble comprehension; but it is evident that no greater miracle is required by our theory than by that of our reviewer. Our reviewer once more exhibits a remarkable agility in dodging the point when we invite his attention to our argument with reference to the nature of human identity. This is the strong-hold of our position, but he has persistently avoided attacking it, contenting himself with skirmishing in the distance, hardly approaching near enough to the real issue to make apparent even a moderate degree of relevancy in his arguments. He gives the reader to understand that he has met our arguments on this point by quotations from “some of the profoundest scientists of the world,” when in fact he has not once attempted to meet them and has adduced neither argument nor authority to show that we are in error on the subject of the nature of human identity. Referring to our quotation of the views of Canon Barry and Mr. Hutton, Eld. W. says, “Here is his fourth distinct definition of the soul, or the fourth soul in his theory.” If our reviewer had given the four definitions, and shown the difference between them, the reader would have had a fair chance to judge of the candor and fairness of the assertion. We have made but one explanation of the nature of the soul, claiming first and last that it is the organization, that which constitutes the basis of human identity. The sense of personal identity depends upon organization, and hence organization “lies at the bottom of it,” as claimed by Mr. Hutton and Canon Barry, both eminent theological lights in the orthodox religious world. Says Eld. W., again, “As the Doctor teaches, character is produced by the body; then a body radically different must produce a radically different character,” which he argues would imply a loss of identity. This argument we have already fully answered in this as well as in previous articles. We may say with equal force, with reference to Eld. W.’s view, if character is produced by an “immaterial entity,” then a radical change of character necessarily implies a radical change in the “entity,” and hence a loss of identity. Thus it appears that our reviewer’s theory is condemned by his own argument. Next Eld. W. builds an argument upon our remark that “the soul is not the individual,” by connecting with it the remark that “character is a product of the soul,” and then perverting our meaning thus: “Then neither the soul nor the character is any part of a man.” The gross disregard of logical fairness in the above is too evident to need pointing out. To say that the soul is not the individual is a very different thing from saying that the soul is no part of a man. If Eld. W. should say that laws and courts of justice do not constitute a good government, and we should represent him as saying that laws and courts are no part of a good government, we should feel that he was fully justified in arraigning us for committing a capital offense against truth and justice. All we ask is fair representation, and a moderate degree of “respectful attention” to the claims of logical propriety. May we not say, almost in the very words of our reviewer, in a previous article, “What does it indicate when a gentleman of our reviewer’s power and intelligence feels driven to make issues” by means of such logical unfairness! We have not attempted to “sugar over” any part of our theory, as intimated by Eld. W. On the contrary, we have been anxious to have its most vital features thoroughly tested by candid investigation. We have repeatedly urged that this might be done, but have almost wholly failed in every attempt, our reviewer having devoted almost his entire attention to side issues and minor points. But let us examine the three statements which Eld. W. says we have attempted to make appear:— 1. We have never tried to make it appear that conversion involves a loss of identity as much as annihilation, as represented by Eld. W. He wholly ignores the fact that we consider the organization not only a part of the individual but the essential part. Although we have corrected him upon this point at least twenty times in this discussion, he continues to misstate our position. He undoubtedly fully recognizes the fact that his only hope for making any appearance of an argument is by taking this course, although it does us the most gross injustice. In justice to our position, we are under the necessity of calling the reader’s attention to this fact, although it is very unpleasant for us to be obliged to do so. 2. We never attempted to maintain that a being no part of whom ever existed before, will be compelled to recognize himself as one who has so existed, whether for the purpose of reward or punishment. On the contrary, we have claimed that the resurrected individual is the same individual, for the reason that the organization, his essential part, is the very same that he possessed at death. 3. The fallacy of the third statement is fully exposed by our remarks on the foregoing. Says Eld. W., “My fourth point was that Christ, in asserting his Messiahship and divinity, said he had power to lay down his life and to take it again. The Doctor denies that he did this, or that he had any power to do it.” We have not attempted to deny or affirm anything respecting Christ. We offered an argument from the Scriptures, as follows:— “In Mark 10:45 we read that Christ came ‘to give his life [Greek ψυχή, psuche, soul] a ransom for many.’ ‘My soul [psuche] is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death.’ Matt. 26:38. ‘Thou wilt not leave my soul [psuche] in hell [the grave].’ Acts 2:27. Eld. Wardner says that the word here translated life and soul means simply animal life; but this rendering would make nonsense of the Sacred Word, as will appear by supplying this definition for the words life and soul in the text. Christ came to give his animal life a ransom for many. ‘My animal life is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death.’ ‘Thou wilt not leave my animal life in hell.’ Even Eld. W. will not claim that Christ’s animal life could be sorrowful. We can see no way for escape from the conclusion that it was Christ’s ‘rational or moral nature’ that was ‘sorrowful unto death.’ Hence, according to the testimony of Christ, it was possible that his soul, or ‘rational or moral nature,’ should die; and that the very same did die is evidenced by the testimony of Isaiah, ‘He hath poured out his soul [psuche] unto death,’ and that of John, ‘He laid down his life [psuche] for us.’ That the words soul and life here may mean something more than the mere animal or physical life, considered distinct from the ‘rational or moral nature,’ is evident not only from the sense of the language, but also from the fact that it is thus defined by Greek scholars. Robinson gives as one of the definitions of psuche, ‘the soul of man.’ This definition is fully justified by the use of the word in various texts of Scripture. The following texts are given by the lexicographer among others as illustrative of this use of the word psuche: Matt. 10:28: ‘And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul.’ Heb. 10:39: ‘But of them that believe to the saving of the soul.’ James 1:21: ‘Which is able to save your souls.’ Chap. 5:20: ‘He which converteth a sinner from the error of his way shall save a soul from death.’ 1 Pet. 2:11: ‘Abstain from fleshly lusts, which war against the soul.’ Will Eld. W. attempt to maintain that soul in all these instances means simply ‘animal life’? We think not. Have we not then shown by credible evidence that the language of Scripture does not forbid the view that Christ himself, even his divine nature, suffered the death of the cross? According to Heb. 13:20, it was ‘the God of peace that brought again from the dead our Lord Jesus,’ and not he that resurrected himself. So also in Acts 2:24 we read, ‘Whom God hath raised up,’ and in verse 32, ‘This same Jesus hath God raised up.’ These arguments Eld. W. does not attempt to answer. What conclusion shall we draw from his silence? He simply repeats the very same argument which we have conclusively answered above, and charges us with impeaching Christ simply because we quote several texts which show the incorrectness of his own views. As we explained in a former article, Christ was able to lay down his life and take it again, by reason of his faith in God. This is very clearly shown, not only by the scriptures quoted above, but by many others. The expressions upon which Eld. W. bases his argument, regardless of the evident and irreconcilable disagreement between his application of them and other texts, can be readily explained. According to Acts 6:8, Stephen “did great wonders and miracles among the people.” In Luke 9:6 we read, “And they departed, and went through the towns, preaching the gospel, and healing everywhere.” The literal reading of these texts indicates that the miracles were performed by Stephen and the disciples; but in Acts 19:11 we read again, “And God wrought special miracles by the hands of Paul.” Neither Stephen, Paul, nor the disciples of Christ, wrought the miracles which were attributed to them in common parlance, but God, who worked through them. That the very same is true respecting Christ is shown by Acts 10:38, 40: “How God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the Holy Ghost and with power; who went about doing good, and healing all that were oppressed of the devil; for God was with him.” “Him God raised up the third day.” Our reviewer then goes on at some length to show that according to our view the death of Christ was but a human sacrifice, and finally concludes, “Hence the Doctor’s theory claims that the essence of God, the Supreme Being, who created and upholds all things from the beginning, was made into corruptible flesh, was killed by men,” etc. The above statement is entirely correct, with a slight addition; the insertion of the words, “does not” just before the word “claim” will make the statement correct. As it stands, it is as wide a departure from the truth as it can be. The only grounds upon which our reviewer could be justified in making such a statement would be the supposition on his part that we believe in the doctrine of the trinity; but he very well knows, from positions taken and arguments used in previous articles, that we do not agree with him on this subject any better than on that of the nature of the soul. We believe in but one Deity, God, who is a unity, not a compound being. We think the Bible as well as common sense sustains this view. Says Eld. W., “His trinitarianism seems to shackle him much.” We repel the charge of “trinitarianism” without the slightest hesitation. We do not believe in a triune God, as before remarked. And we will not, as did our reviewer in a former article, leave the reader in doubt as to our position on this point. We are utterly at a loss to comprehend how our reviewer could have blundered so strangely as to suppose us to share in so gross an error as we believe the orthodox doctrine of the trinity to be. Thus are we able by a word to burst the “shackles” with which he seeks to bind us. The question, “Then who raised him to life?” is utterly irrelevant; and when Eld. W. adds, “But, according to the Doctor, God was, at that time, a mere mass of dead human flesh,” the unfairness and misrepresentation become so glaring that we need not offer a word, either by way of explanation or reply. If Eld. W. regards this manner of treating his argument as “ignoring” the point, we are willing to enter as deeply into the merits of the question as he may desire; but we think the evidence of perversion or most complete and incomprehensible misunderstanding is sufficiently plain to be evident to the most casual reader without further examination. To convince Eld. W. and the reader that we have no disposition to evade anything, if we have not already341 done so we will now notice the four questions in which he says our theory “culminates.” 1. “What was that pre-existing divinity that could be killed by men?” Ans. Let Christ himself speak: “I lay down my life.” “No man taketh it from me, but I lay it down of myself.” John 10:17, 18. That is, Christ possessed the power, through the aid of his Father, to defend himself against any assault which might be made upon him by men. Wicked men were only able to take his life as they were permitted to do so. We disclaim any ability to explain the nature of the union between divinity and humanity in Christ. In this respect we claim no advantage in our theory over any other. The Scriptures say, “He was made in all respects like unto his brethren.” We do not pretend to know anything more than what is given us by Inspiration. 2. “Was the universe without a Divine Being for three days and nights but a dead one, or is there a plurality of such beings?” Ans. We only need say in answer to this question that we have already expressed our views of the doctrine of the trinity, upon which the question is based. 3. “When did Christ possess immortality, before his advent or at his resurrection?” Ans. This question involves the nature of immortality. We have not space here to enter upon the question more fully than to say that we believe that there is only one being in the universe whose nature is intrinsically immortal. “The King of kings and Lord of lords; who only hath immortality.” 1 Tim. 6:15, 16. That is, we cannot conceive that any created being can ever become so far independent of its Creator as to be able to exist independent of the First Great Cause, or in opposition to the will of God. In other words, we believe that any being in the universe, God alone excepted, might die or cease to exist at any moment, provided such should be the will of God, or it should be necessary to the carrying out of any of his plans. 4. “Was his immortality an element of his divinity, which (the Doctor says) was made flesh, and was killed? or did he obtain it from some other source?” Ans. This question is fully answered in the answer to the preceding. Finally, Eld. W. repeats a question asked in a previous article, and answered in our reply, “If spirit and character are the products of material bodies, how can bodies so suddenly changed and radically different (after the resurrection), still produce the same spirits and characters, so as to preserve the same moral and intellectual identity? Can a sweet, pure fountain send forth the same quality of water that a bitter and corrupt fountain does? and vice versa. If not, then how can a pure, spiritual body produce the same character as a gross, diseased body?” Eld. W. will not claim that the characters of the redeemed are not changed, at least in some degree! Surely he will not insist that all who are saved shall carry to Heaven with them the narrow-mindedness, lack of love for higher culture, and numerous inconvenient and even repulsive, though not immoral, traits of character of which even the best of Christians are pretty sure to possess a few! Granting this, then we may rightfully answer his question almost in his own words, and substantially as before, by asking, if mind and character are the products of an immaterial entity, how can characters so suddenly changed and radically different (after the resurrection) still be produced by the same immaterial entity so as to preserve the same individuality? Can sweet, pure water and bitter, corrupt water, both come from the same fountain? If not, then how can a perfect, symmetrical, beautiful character be produced by the same immaterial entity as an imperfect, odd, warped, and unattractive one? We avoid the difficulty in which Eld. W. is evidently involved, and in which he seeks to involve us, by recognizing the fact that identity depends upon neither an immaterial entity nor a material body; but upon the organization, which includes all there is of an individual, and which is naturally subject to change without loss of identity. We have now noticed all the points made by Eld. W., in his review of our little work, “The Soul and the Resurrection.” If we have failed to reply to any argument which has been adduced, it has been through inadvertence, for our earnest desire has been to have the views in question tested by fair and thorough criticism, feeling that if we are wrong we ought to become aware of the fact as soon as possible. That we feel more strongly established in our position than at the outset may be considered as the natural result of controversy, but we attribute it, in part, at least, to the following facts:— 1. We have shown that the soul is the basis of human identity. Nothing has been proven to the contrary. Indeed, the position has not been denied. 2. We have shown by logical arguments that the basis of human identity is the organization. No attempt has been made to show that our reasoning is faulty. 3. We have drawn from the foregoing the conclusion that the soul and the organization are one, and have shown that both Scripture and science harmonize with this view. Our conclusion has been attacked, though the premises have not been touched, and no fault has been found with our reasoning. 4. We have shown that modern physiological researches very strongly contradict the popular view of the nature of the mind and the soul, and uphold the view that the mind is the function of the brain and dependent upon it. This view is indorsed by the leading scientists of the day. Eld. W. has made no attempt to answer the arguments upon which this view of the nature of mind is based. 5. In response to the argument that this theory of the mind does not explain the freedom of the will, we have shown that no greater difficulty exists in explaining “will” than in explaining any other force. We cannot explain gravitation, electricity, heat, light, nor other primary or secondary forces. A magnet manifests properties almost as wonderful and equally as inexplicable as the brain. 6. In answer to the argument that freedom of will necessarily implies the existence of an immaterial entity independent of the body, we have shown that lower animals possess free will as well as men, and that the theory held by our reviewer logically necessitates belief in beast souls, and the resurrection and future existence in a state of happiness or misery, of the whole animal creation, from the most highly developed mammal down to the lowest animalculum. Finding no other alternative, our reviewer tacitly admitted this conclusion. 7. In response to the argument that the body needs a governing entity to direct it, we showed that so far as logical necessity is concerned it applies as well to the entity supposed to control the body as to the body itself. That is, if the body needs an immaterial entity to regulate its movements, the entity needs a governor just as much, and the second entity a third, and the third, a fourth, and so on, ad infinitum. To this argument, no answer has been made. 8. To the argument that according to our view death is annihilation, we have shown that during death the individual may be represented by the record of his life in Heaven, and it has not been shown by either evidence or arguments that this may not be the case. 9. In response to our reviewer’s argument from the original words referring to soul and spirit, we showed that the same words are applied to beasts, so that, as Solomon says, they have all one Ruach, spirit. We thus proved that the distinctions made by Eld. W. cannot be maintained, and showed that our own view agrees fully with the Scripture teaching on the subject, since animals do really have souls,—organizations,—though they have no future existence, no reward nor punishment, because they have no moral organs, and hence no moral responsibility. 10. In reply to the argument that our view does not account for or explain the origin of God, we acknowledged our inability to solve this problem, and requested our reviewer to make the attempt with his theory. No such attempt has been made. We also showed that if our view makes matter superior to divinity, as he claims, his gives to force the same superiority. To this he has not replied. Thus it appears that the fundamental principles of our view remain untouched by any arguments which have been presented. In conclusion, we wish to express the hope that this controversy has not been the occasion for the production of any unfriendly feelings, and that it has not contributed in any degree to increase the differences which exist between the two denominations who have been most interested in it. If any word upon our part has seemed in any degree inconsistent with a friendly, Christian spirit, we heartily regret it, and hope that our reviewer and the reader will believe us when we say that we entertain no harsh or unkind feelings, and have only contended for what we believe to be the truth. We are also willing to entertain the same liberal feeling toward those of the opposite side. We have found but a few broken moments to devote to this matter, having been deeply engrossed in labor of a very different character, and do not feel that we have done either our subject or ourself proper justice. Much as we have regretted this, we regret still more having done any injustice to others, no matter how slight, if such has been the case. With many thanks to our esteemed reviewer for his scholarly and painstaking criticism, and to those of our readers who have patiently followed this investigation through the long interruptions and delays by which it has been attended, we now leave the subject, with the full confidence that those whose opinions are valuable will, in making up their minds upon the several questions considered, carefully eliminate every element of sophistry or uncandidness shown upon either side, and decide them upon their merits. J. H. Kellogg. ARE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS TEACHING NEW DOCTRINES?
By S. M. Swan
“Who first preached the advent doctrine?” asked a friend to whom I was speaking of the recent origin of the doctrine of a temporal millennium. “Wm. Miller,” was the reply; but I answered, “No.” The doctrine of the second coming of Christ was preached by Enoch, the seventh from Adam (Jude 14); and since that time, it has been taught by the prophets, by Christ and his apostles, by the reformers, and also by eminent Christians of the last century, who looked forward to about the present time for the coming of Him who has said, “If I go away, I will come again.” The glorious restitution of all things, which was the theme of the prophet Isaiah, was shown to the beloved disciple in vision, when upon the lonely Isle of Patmos he saw “a new heaven and a new earth,” heard a voice from Heaven saying, “Behold, the tabernacle of God is with men, and he will dwell with them,” and saw the New Jerusalem coming down from Heaven, as the capital of Christ’s everlasting kingdom, when he shall sit upon the throne of David, and inherit the promises made to Abraham. “But is not the Sabbath, as taught by this people, a new doctrine?” No; it was taught by the great Creator at the close of the first week of time, when he sanctified the seventh day, and gave it to man as a memorial of his work, that he might ever keep in memory the Maker of the heavens and the earth; and notwithstanding all the efforts of Satan since that time to blot it out of existence, it has never been without its observers. The prophet Joel foretold the revival of the gifts of the Spirit in the church as a special sign of the last days; and in prophetic vision, the apostle John saw the remnant people of God persecuted by the dragon; and they kept the commandments of God and had the testimony of Jesus, which “is the spirit of prophecy.” We have not embraced “new doctrines,” but are simply asking for the “old paths,” that we may walk therein (Jer. 6: 16); and while we are firmly planting our feet upon the doctrines taught by the prophets and by Christ and his apostles, oh, may we seek for the same zeal and devotion to the truth, the same death to the world and perfect consecration to the service of God, which they possessed Charity as a Duty of Christian Love
—That love which the Bible calls charity is not a mere matter of feeling. It is a spirit and a purpose of kindness toward others. Our surface feelings are not wholly within our control; but for our inner purposes we are directly responsible. Hence it is, that charity—or Christian love toward all—is a plain duty. We have no right not to love the unlovely. There is no being right and doing right without being loving, and showing love, in all our intercourse with all. As Sir Thomas Browne puts it: “Moses broke the tables without breaking the law, but where charity is broken, the law itself is shattered, which cannot be whole without love that is the fulfilling of it.” If, indeed, we are compelled to admit that we are not charitable—not loving where it is hard to love—let us recognize the fact that we are just as truly guilty in this spirit of uncharitableness as we should be in a spirit of envy, or hatred, or untruthfulness, or impurity, or irreverence; and let us turn in our guilt to crave pardon and to seek a new heart in place of the one which can harbor such guilt as this.—S. S. Times. On Public and Private Confession of Sin
—About confessions. If the sin has been a public one, the confession should be public; if a private one, the confession should be private. When you get down from this mount, you must expect to meet the devil at the foot.—Mr. Moody. Aunt Matilda was sitting in the twilight, rocking, with her knitting-work, and humming,— “There is a land of pure delight,” as she watched the sunset die on the mountains, when Elsie came down stairs, and drew a foot-stool to the old lady’s knee. It was an old, girlish habit,—the nestling at auntie’s knee when any trouble possessed her. She was understood without any words. The soft, withered hand left the knitting, and fell to stroking Elsie’s hair; the owner well knowing that the burden would be revealed before long. Presently Elsie broke forth:— “Auntie, I do wish you could tell me how to manage Eddie better. I presume you were shocked at the scene we had to-night; he determined not to go to bed, and went to sleep only when too tired to keep his eyes open. It’s some battle or other between his will and mine every day or two. I don’t think I’m fit to be a mother.” “Well, dear,” said her aunt, “what are you going to do about it? You are most emphatically a mother.” “Yes, I am. I can’t shift responsibility, and I don’t want to; but what shall I do? He must mind me, he must not be indulged in such fits of temper; and yet it takes all there is of me to control him while he is a baby. What will it be hereafter? He shall mind me though.” And with this very determined statement of the case, Elsie laid her head on the lap of peace beside her. “As thy day, so shall thy strength be,” said the old lady; “and don’t be discouraged, Elsie. It don’t seem very long since I saw you a little black-headed fury, screaming and stamping your foot because your mother would not let you play with the water-pail.” “Poor mother!” sighed Elsie. “I just begin to realize what she endured to raise us all.” “She brought you up very creditably, if I am any judge; but about Eddie, you pray for him, do you not?” “Pray for my child, auntie? Why of course I do.” “Well, for what do you pray?” “Why, I ask that I may be enabled to train him aright, that he may become a child of God.” “And when do you expect him to become a child of God?” “When he comes to years of discretion and is able to choose, I hope.” “Elsie, Elsie,” said the old lady with unwonted warmth, “where in the Bible do you find a passage that justifies a mother in praying for her child in that manner? Why don’t you ask the Lord to convert him now?” “Aunt Matilda, Eddie is not three until next month.” “He is old enough to love the Saviour, Elsie, if he is old enough to love you intelligently. Doesn’t the whole drift of Scripture go to show that God loves to call a child? We read, ‘Suffer little children,’ as if it were a tender, poetic sentiment to put over the grave of childhood instead of a command of Christ for the living; and we go away from the spirit of the Word, and give our children over to something else until they are old enough to choose him. Look at Hannah. Her child, dedicated to God before his birth, and given, in all the liberalness of her faith, to the temple while he was but a baby. He grew up a child of God. It seems to me that Hannah and Samuel are a glorious type of the Christian mother and child. If in those dim days of shadows her faith could take so much, what may not the parent of these days hope to receive? Now that every soul may enter into the holiest by the blood of Jesus, you may give your son in his infancy in as literal a dedication as hers.” “You upset all my ideas of things,” said her niece. “I have always thought of Eddie’s accepting Christ when a boy or a young man.” “‘According to your faith be it unto you.’ The promise is to you and to your children. Why may not you and your husband ask in full faith that Eddie’s early years may be sanctified by the rule of Christ? Thank God, your child has a Christian father.” “Yes, thank God,” murmured Elsie, her cheeks wet. “I have often thought of the subject in connection with my father’s family,” Aunt Matilda went on. “He was a godly man, full of faith and prayer. One day a young minister with his wife and baby was visiting at our house; and in conversation with him, father said, pointing to the baby on the floor, ‘Now you have given your child to God in a solemn covenant; train her up in the fear of God, and in after years she will give her heart to the Saviour.’” “I made no reflections upon it at the time, but I have since thought and prayed the thing out. All of father’s six children were converted between the ages of fifteen and nineteen. Does it not look as if, in his own mind, he unconsciously limited the time, and his faith, the thing that God answers, took hold on that period of youth in praying for his children? I do not think that either he or mother expected us to be converted in childhood, faithful and devout though they were.” “Auntie, you let in a new light upon me,” cried Elsie, lifting her head. “As you make it seem, there is certainly a great incongruity between the facts of the gospel, and the way we treat our children. Why, the great stumbling-block in the way of grown-up people’s accepting the truth is its simplicity; and yet we think our children must grow older before they are able to take it.” “Yes,” said Aunt Matilda, “this very fact that one is in his simple childhood is the best thing in his favor. A child should take in the knowledge and love of Jesus as it does sunshine or its bread and milk.” “The subject has a wonderful breadth to it,” said Elsie. “I suppose every mother of a strong-willed child feels sometimes that she works against fearful odds. But with God in the child’s heart, working through the child’s faith as well as through the parent’s, there must be victory. But oh, what kind of mothers must we be!”—Illustrated Christian Weekly. THE TRUEST HELP FOR YOUNG MEN.
A VETERAN worker sounds this trumpet-note: “Behind both the school and the church lies the mightiest agency of all in making or marring the spiritual destiny of young men, and that is the home. Parents are responsible for the atmosphere that either blasts their lives or quickens them into beauty. They must understand that their children will seek for some kind of amusement; and if innocent recreations are not provided for them at home, the devil will open doors for them to evil amusements. They must understand, also, that all the faithful efforts of the pulpit are of small avail in converting and saving their children, while the whole trend of the home-life is toward worldliness, money-getting, or godlessness of any kind. The chief helps and the chief hindrances to the salvation of young men are to be found in their own homes.” Speaking of young men in cities, without homes, he says: “We ought to open to them the doors of our young people’s meetings and church social gatherings. We ought to open our own doors to them. Employers could do a vast service to their clerks and employees, if they welcomed them to their houses, and interested themselves in securing evening enjoyments for them. Unless Christians find doorways for young men, they will soon discover for themselves plenty of others that lead down to death. My chief wonder is that more young men are not wholly ruined in all our large towns.” Here are two or three sentences referring to the prevalent tendency to skepticism among young men: “This is not to be counteracted by controversial books against various forms of infidelity. Warm, practical preaching of the positive gospel, and the positive living out of Christ, are the best correctives of skepticism. Cold churches, cold preaching, and offensive so-called ‘Christian’ living, make men skeptical. It looks now as though God meant to scourge us back to his one gospel, and to a purer, humbler, holier style of religion, by withholding his blessings from us”—S. S. Times. Continue reading: ON THE ART OF CONVERSATION