So much is said at the present time about the closing of the gates of the World’s Fair on Sunday, by the blind devotees of religious intolerance and opposers of American liberty, who are falsely asserting the wishes of the laboring men of this country to close the great Exposition on that day, that it must be a little humiliating, to say the least, when such resolutions as appear below, are passed, and appear before the intelligent people of this country, as they do from time to time. We copy from the Chicago News, June 20, 1892:—
Want the Fair open on Sunday. Working-men of New York Enter a Protest Against Closing.
NEW YORK, June 19.—At a meeting of the associated trades of New York, held this evening, the following resolutions were adopted:—
Whereas, The World’s Fair, to be held at Chicago in 1893, is and should be regarded as a national affair of the widest significance; and,—
Whereas, This Fair will be primarily an exhibition of the skill and products of the labor of the world; therefore, be it—
1. Resolved, That the working-men of New York, interested in all that concerns labor, demand that this great enterprise shall be worthy of the working people of the nation.
2. Resolved, That we demand the immediate passage of the bill now before Congress, appropriating $5,000,000 for this undertaking, to the end that the enterprise should be lifted from the narrow confines that limit its importance to a single city into the broad area of national dimensions, and we further demand it on the ground that the sum asked for from our national treasury has been expended for labor already performed.
3. Resolved, That we are unalterably opposed to the proposed project looking to the closing on Sundays of this great educator of the masses.
4. Resolved, That in the name of the toilers of the country, we protest against such a sacrifice and denial of their right to examine and study the work and skill of their brother toilers of the earth on the only day when their time is their own, and their mind is in its most receptive condition to perceive the larger lessons which the dignity, importance, and necessity of the labor world ever teach.
This testimony seems to cast quite a different light on the side of the working-men and their positions, and especially when we consider that this testimony expresses the wishes of one of the largest “associated trades” of America.
It would be well if all opposers of American liberty would make a note of this before presenting any more multiplied signatures of protest before the World’s Fair commissioners; and a little more caution would inspire a greater degree of confidence in those who are making such a gigantic effort to tell us what the laboring men’s wishes are. O. F. CAMPBELL.
THE NUMBER OF THE BEAST.
The following item which has been sent us, clipped from the Catholic News, will be of interest to our readers, as showing how the prophecy that points out a characteristic title of the papacy is viewed from a Catholic standpoint:—
“A correspondent in Massachusetts sends us the solution of the number of the beast, which is circulating among the unlearned and the unwise in that State of vaunted knowledge. It makes the name of the man whose number is that of the beast to be “Vicarius Filii Dei.” Unfortunately for the silly jackanapes who gets off this amusing absurdity, St. John wrote in Greek, and could not have referred to a Latin, French, English, or German name. He must have referred to a Greek name. In the next place Vicar of the Son of God is not a name but a title, and a modification of a Latin title of the pope, not that generally used. If President is the name of the gentleman at present occupying the White House, it is news to us. We were under the impression that a person whose name is Benjamin Harrison was elected, and that to say that his name is President, or in Latin, Praeses, is to show a mind diseased.”
If to make such an application of the prophecy, as herein noted, is to become a “silly jackanapes,” it is unfortunate for the writer of the foregoing paragraph that he has to go down one degree sillier in trying to answer it. John, to be sure, wrote in Greek, but John’s prophecy covers the whole gospel dispensation; and we wonder if it would not be just possible for him to give a prophecy of something outside of Greek territory, or the Greek tongue.
The power to which this prophecy has reference, arose, not in Greece, but in Italy, where the language spoken was not Greek but Latin; and the title to be assumed by that power would be in Latin, and not in Greek. John does not give the title, and has no occasion to, but only says that the power in question would have a name containing that number, and we find the number in this title, which is here admitted to be a modification of a Latin title of the papacy.
Our critic is also unfortunate in supposing that the name is the personal or family name of some individual man. Let him look at the prophecy, and he will find that it does not so read. The name is “the name of the beast,” and the beast is more than one man; and the number is “the number of his name,” that is, the name of the beast; and it is also the number of a man, not the number of the name of a man. The beast, like any other dynasty, is composed of a succession of men, to each one of which the name is of course applicable while upon the stage of action in that succession.
So the view of the prophecy presented is not half so absurd as our friend thought, and he has not come half so near answering it as he imagines.
RESPONSIBILITY FOR SECTARIANISM.
By L. A. S.
Seventh-day Adventists are often accused of doing much harm in Christian communities by “proselyting” from other churches, and thus weakening the membership of those churches and promoting sectarian divisions. The charge is usually made as if it applied to them alone,—as if it were one of the things peculiar to them as a denomination, and not found among the other and more popular religious bodies; and certainly if Adventists are no more guilty in this respect than are others of the religious world around them, this accusation ought not to be made against them by members of churches which are equally guilty in the same respect. It will be seen, however, that the sectarian spirit is just as prevalent among other religious bodies as among the denomination first mentioned. Consider, for example, the following from the Christian Union of June 25, written to that journal by one of its correspondents in the West. He says:—
“The city of ——, in which I live, has a population of 2,500, among whom are to be found every shade of religious belief, from the rankest atheist to the most enthusiastic Methodist. This is one of the oldest towns in the State, and ought to have churches of influence. Some twelve years ago the Presbyterians established a church here in response to a popular demand. Willingly they contributed to the enterprise. It was doing a great good for the whole community; its members were scattered over quite a district, and in each little district meetings were held, so that the influence of a Christian church was widely felt. Soon a roving Methodist minister came along, and, believing that the place would go to the Devil if there was not a Methodist church, organized one forthwith, by taking some members from an already weak church, and adding some others who had been floating about, and who considered that unless they had a Methodist church, they could not get along. This was, of course, a great set-back to the little Presbyterian church. Very soon the Methodists had a split among themselves, and a swarm from them constituted a Free Methodist church. Next some of the members of the Presbyterian church, with a few Congregational people who had come in, thought they ought to have a Congregational church. The Sunday-school Missionary was corresponded with. It was too good a chance to lose of adding one more new church to the list. My observation out here leads me to assert that the worship of statistics is one of the most popular forms of nineteenth-century idolatry. Here in the little city of ——, with three weak, uninfluential churches, there was actually imposed a fourth—a Congregational church. This, of course, was a sad set-back to the three, which had been established prior to its organization. But just about that time a devout churchman came along. ‘We must have a church here,’ quoth he. To work he goes, and actually secures an Episcopal minister to come here and organize a little church. In the meantime the Baptists are keeping an eye on things; it would not do at all if they were not ‘getting a work in,’ as they call it out here. A little time ago, Mr. Rockefeller gave a Pullman car to the Baptist denomination, fully equipped to hold religious meetings. From the religious press it was gathered that the car was to be used in little towns where they had no religious opportunities; of such towns there are scores. But that is not what is being done with the car; for, in the face of our five weak churches, a couple of Baptist preachers bring their car to the city of ——, and actually hold their meetings and organize another church. When asked how the enterprise was going to be supported, they reply, ‘Why, the home missionary societies, of course, will have to support it.’ In the meantime the German Lutherans and the Scandinavian Methodists each organize. Here, then, are eight little, uninfluential churches, each supported in part by the home missionary societies of their respective denominations.”
“This,” says the Christian Union, “is what sectarianism does,” and from the standpoint of the parties mentioned as engaged in this work, the complaint made by the correspondent is justified; for not one of them would claim that the formation of a new church made the salvation of those who joined it any more sure than it was when they were members of the original Presbyterian church. It was an exhibition of real “sectarianism,”—working for denominational interests independently of the interests of the soul.
With Seventh-day Adventists it is otherwise. Their only reason for propagating their faith throughout Christendom is their conviction that a correct religious faith is at the present time essential to the eternal welfare of men, the greater part of whom are to live through the perils of the last days down to the end of the world. They have, therefore, in their belief, the same reason for winning converts from other religious bodies that these denominations have for winning converts from heathenism to the Christian faith by missionary effort—that of its necessity to the salvation of the soul. Consequently their practice in this respect affords no ground for a discreditable charge against them.
The real sectarian spirit is to be found outside the ranks of the Adventists, among those who, denying that the denominational differences among them are in relation to matters of essential importance as concerns the welfare of the soul, still maintain and seek to perpetuate those differences as illustrated in the quotation given above, to the great injury of Christian interests in all lands.
Having already noticed the prominence of this sign, we now proceed to fix the time of its occurrence. “Immediately after the tribulation of those days shall the sun be darkened.” Matt. 24:29. The second evangelist is still more definite: “But in those days, after that tribulation, the sun shall be darkened.” Mark 13:24.
The attention of the reader is recalled to the argument upon the “great tribulation,” where it was shown that the period of “a time and times and the dividing of time” (Dan. 7:25), i. e., 1260 prophetic days, or years, was specified as the one in which the saints of God were “given into” the hands of the Roman papacy to “wear out,” or persecute to the death. Our Saviour said this “tribulation” was “shortened” for the “elect’s sake.” It was shown from history that about fifty years previous to the expiration of “those days,” in 1798, the persecutions ceased. Here is a little period in which the Saviour declares there shall be a wonderful darkening of the sun. “Immediately after the tribulation,” says Matthew. “In those days, after the tribulation,” says Mark. Both limit the period or periods of the sun’s obscuration within the space of a little less than fifty years. If the Saviour’s words are true, such a sign must occur in that marked-off space; for the language is very definite. Luke does not speak directly upon this point, but says there shall be “signs in the sun,” etc. Luke 21:25. But John, in the Revelation, gives the order of events in a way clearly to locate the point of time when the sun will be in the sack-cloth state.425
In the seven seals, which are a history of the true church during the gospel age, subdivided into seven periods, the great tribulation is brought to view under the fourth division as symbolized by a rider, “Death,” mounted on a pale horse, and “Hades” (the grave) following after, slaying his victims over a fourth part of the earth by the sword, hunger, and the beasts of the earth. The vast multitude thus slain under the fifth seal are symbolized as crying, “How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth?” They rest “a little season” under the symbolic altar—the earth—till others also are killed, as they were. Then the sixth seal opens, as follows: “And I beheld when he had opened the sixth seal, and, lo, there was a great earthquake; and the sun became black as sackcloth of hair, and the moon became as blood; and the stars of heaven fell unto the earth,” etc. Then comes the “great day of his wrath,” and the Son of God is seen. Rev. 6:8–17.
Just preceding the sun’s darkening is a “great earthquake.” It is located after the great persecutions under the fourth and fifth seals are past, since it is placed to mark the beginning of the sixth seal, in which nothing is said of persecutions, though they were the principal features of the fourth and fifth. It is remarkable that the greatest earthquake in extent, of which history gives any record, occurred Nov. 1, 1755, almost exactly at the point where persecution ceased. Its center was in the Atlantic, west of the coasts of Spain and Portugal. It came with great suddenness, and without warning, no earthquake having occurred in the Spanish peninsula for 150 years previous. Lisbon, the capital of Portugal, suffered most. It came on All Saints’ Day, when the churches were crowded with worshipers. The city had a population of 250,000. It is said by historians that 60,000 persons perished in six minutes. In fearful terror the people sought places of safety. Many rushed to the magnificent new quay, recently erected. It sank, with 6,000 people upon it, and the water where it stood is now 100 fathoms deep. The ships fastened to it were also engulfed. It is said that Lisbon has never recovered from this calamity.
But Lisbon, though the most prominent sufferer, was by no means the only one. Columbo, Oporto, and Braga were shattered. St. Ubes, having a population of 20,000, was swallowed in the sea. Terrible destruction was experienced in Malaga, Spain. Half of the island of Madeira was laid waste; 2,000 houses in Mitylene were demolished, thousands of miles away to the east. The city of Fez, in Morocco, 1,000 miles south, was more than half destroyed, and 10,000 Moors perished. Vast mountains were shaken to their foundations, and in some instances split in two. Avalanches of rocks were thrown into the valleys, and flames issued from some of them. The Alps felt the shock. The British Islands, Sweden and Norway, the Baltic coast and Germany, were shaken. A great tidal wave, in places sixty-five feet in height, deluged hundreds of miles of the coast of Portugal, and reached as far north as Ireland, rushing into harbors, whirling the ships about, and doing great damage. Ships forty leagues away from the coast experienced violent concussions, throwing men perpendicularly up from the deck. In the West Indies, 3,000 miles west, the tide rose three times as high as usual, the water being of inky blackness. Sewell says all the great lakes of North America were sensibly agitated. In England, the hot well of Bristol became red as blood, and the water so thick it could not be drank. In Scotland, water in some wells became as black as ink, and “in Bohemia, the warm springs of Teplitz all at once disappeared, and then furiously burst forth, and overflowed the region with water the color of ocher.”
Authors declare that portions of the earth four times as great as Europe were simultaneously shaken, and that it was the greatest earthquake recorded in history.
The earth continued to shake more or less for three years, and before it became quiet again, 200,000 persons perished. It is estimated that some twenty million square miles of our globe experienced the effects of this terrible convulsion. Its name has passed into history as “the great earthquake,” and all well-informed men understand that expression to mean the one that occurred Nov. 1, 1755. (These facts are taken from Taylor’s “Great Consummation,” pp. 203–208, where various authors are quoted.)
That this was the great earthquake foretold by the revelator, there can be no question. It came at the specified time. It was of the dimensions and extent foretold. As the prophet declared centuries beforehand, it was followed by the most remarkable darkening of the sun since Christ’s crucifixion. It fulfils every specification and condition of the prophecy, and no other earthquake fulfils them. Hence this must be the one foretold, if the Bible is accepted. Thus the great earthquake of Lisbon helps to fix unmistakably the point of time when the sun should be darkened.
Joining together these facts, we sum up the following points, fixing the time of the sun’s darkening: (1) It must occur “immediately after” the great persecution. (2) It must occur just “after a great earthquake.” (3) It must occur before the close of the 1260 years’ period in 1798. (4) It must be soon followed by a remarkable darkening of the moon. (5) It must be soon succeeded by a remarkable fall of stars.
Every one of these points must be met in point of time, to meet the Bible’s specifications. If one of them should fail, there would be reasonable grounds to question the application. When was there such a darkening of the sun?—“THE DARK DAY,” May 19, 1780;—so called on account of a remarkable darkness on that day, extending over all New England. In some places, persons could not see to read common print in the open air, for several hours together. Birds sang their evening song, disappeared, and became silent; fowls went to roost; cattle sought the barn-yard; and candles were lighted in the houses. The obscuration began about ten o’clock in the morning, and continued till the middle of the next night, but with differences of degree and duration in different places. . . . The true cause of this remarkable phenomenon is not known.”—Webster’s Dictionary.
Noted Names.
Noah Webster, in giving a list of phrases and names which have come by common usage to be well understood, gives this concerning the Dark Day. There is one day singled out, then, of all the days of the past, because of its remarkable darkness. When one sees this phrase in use, if fairly intelligent, he at once understands it to have been May 19, 1780. No other day in the Christian dispensation is called the dark day. It has thus become famous. On its centenary anniversary, a few years since, most all of the leading papers of our country noticed it, and many had long historical articles of marked interest, concerning it. It has by no means passed out of the mind, as its characteristics were so remarkable.
It is this famous day—so much more prominent than any other of its kind that it is specially designated in history—that we claim as a leading fulfilment of our Saviour’s prediction. It fulfils every one of the five points recently mentioned. It was after the close of the great persecution. It was but a brief space after “The Great Earthquake,” another phrase designating the greatest earthquake known to history. It was a little before the close of “those days” of persecution our Saviour mentions. It preceded the darkening of the moon and the falling of the stars. So far as time is concerned, it meets every requirement of the Bible predictions. This darkness was most mysterious. It has never yet been reasonably accounted for. Even could secondary causes be discovered for it, that fact would not destroy its significance as a sign. Our Saviour says nothing concerning the cause of the sun’s darkening. He only states the fact that at a certain period—clearly defined and marked in prophecy—such an event would occur. And such an event did occur at exactly the point foretold. In the very nature of things, no darkening of the sun occurring after “those days” had all expired—or since 1798—could possibly be the sign our Lord foretold. It would clearly violate the conditions he gave.
But the language used would not forbid other darkenings coming in the specified period. “In those days after the tribulation,” i. e., within the last fifty years of the 1260 to which our Saviour referred. For he did not specify that there would be only one darkening; but on the contrary, says there should be “signs [plural] in the sun.” Luke 21:25. G. I. B.
(To be continued.)
NO SENSIBLE MAN.
It seems utterly impossible for the National Reformers to comprehend the difference so clearly made in the Bible between those things which belong to God and those which belong to Cæsar. In those duties which lie between an individual and his God alone, man has no right to interfere. With reference to civil rights between man and man, the government may legislate. Yet the Christian Nation of June 22, contending for the right of the government to step in and close the World's Fair on the Lord's (?) day, says:—
“Government does propose to enforce the sixth and seventh and eighth commandments, and so far as it succeeds, it only does its duty. No sensible man will say that enforcing these commandments unites Church and State. No more are they united when the government enforces the law of the Sabbath.”
The government cannot of right take cognizance of any actions which merely distinguish a man as religious or non-religious. It can only take cognizance of those which mark him as civil or uncivil, as interfering or not interfering with the rights of his neighbors. Government can deal with people only as citizens of the State; and as such, it has no right to inquire whether a man is a Christian or not a Christian, whether he worships the true God or a false god, or no God at all; whether he keeps a Sabbath or does not keep any Sabbath. In short, whether he pays any attention, or not, to the first four commandments of the decalogue. The last six pertain to our relations to one another, and these, though the law of God of course covers them also, the State may regulate, so far as they come under the head of outward civil duties, and are such that if not observed, society could not exist.
But Sabbath-keeping does not come under the head of these latter duties. One's neighbors have no right to dictate whether one shall keep the Sabbath or not. The State has no right to dictate whether he shall keep it or not. It is a matter of conscience, solely between him and his Maker, and when the State undertakes to force a man's conscience in matters of worship, or religious observances of any kind, at the dictation of the church, then Church and State are united.
There is a difference, then, so far as the State is concerned, between stealing and killing and Sabbath-keeping. Our practice in the latter respect does not, and never can, interfere with the civil rights of our neighbors. But with these rights alone, the State has to do. Keep this distinction before the people. Religious zealots may try to ignore it; but candid people will see it.
THE RELIABILITY OF CHURCH HISTORIANS
By L. R. C.
When all the efforts to establish Sunday-observance from the Bible fail, men often produce certain church histories, such as Mosheim’s and others, and point with an air of triumph to certain statements of these men, in which they assert that Sunday was observed during the time of the apostles and the early church. But we ask, On what do these men rest their statements? Can they produce some surer testimony concerning the time of the apostles and the early church, than the word of God?—Surely not. Have they lived at that time, or seen it themselves?—No; for they lived either in the last or the present century, and therefore, as far as actual experience goes, are as far from it as other men. Have they any reliable documents outside of the holy Scriptures, concerning the doctrines held in the first two centuries?—No. Then how do they come to such statements?—Why, simply by taking the same Bible that we all have, and drawing inferences. This being the case, as further investigation will show, the act of making such a statement after failing to find any clue for any Sunday observance from the Bible, means simply to rest on somebody else’s assertion against our own actual experience. But are the church historians agreed among themselves, in their statements concerning early Sunday-observance?—By no means. It is the same with them as with the defenders of Sunday at the present day, there being as many theories as heads, simply because the proof is wanting, and each one draws his own inferences. To illustrate the above, we will take the statements of two eminent German church historians, and compare them, and see how each one arrives at his conclusions. I have before me the original editions of Neander and Mosheim. Neander says concerning Sunday:—
“The festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance, and it was far from the intentions of the apostles to establish a divine command in this respect,—far from them, and from the early apostolic church, to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday. Perhaps at the end of the second century, a false application of this kind had begun to take place; for men appear by that time to have considered laboring on Sunday as a sin.”—*Neander’s Kirchengeschichte, first edition, Vol. I, p. 339.
Mosheim makes the following statement:—
“The Christians of this century assembled for the worship of God, and for their advancement in piety, on the first day of the week, the day on which Christ re-assumed his life; for that this day was set apart for religious worship by the apostles themselves, and that after the example of the church at Jerusalem, it was generally observed, we have unexceptionable testimony.”—*Mosheim’s Kirchengeschichte, first edition, Vol. I, p. 152.
Now how is it that these two eminent men arrive at such different conclusions? We will first consider Neander, taking the original German edition as basis. The paragraph in which the above statement occurs, begins the Sunday argument as follows:—
“The opposition to Judaism introduced at an early period the special observance of Sunday, instead of Sabbath: the first trace we find in Acts 20:7, where we find the church assembled on the first day of the week; a later one in Rev. 1:10; for the Lord’s day mentioned here can barely be understood to mean the day of judgment.”
Neander finds in his days and from the church history, that Sunday has taken the place of Sabbath, and looks about for reasons. As a good Protestant, he takes his Bible and searches it, but he finds no command of Christ, nor any intention of the apostles to establish a divine command. But in some way the observance of Sunday must be accounted for, so he begins to look for traces or inferences, and hits upon Acts 20:7. But even while mentioning this, he feels under obligation to add the following in a foot-note:—
“An absolute proof is this passage by no means; for as the apostle Paul was about to depart, this might have caused the gathering of the small church for a brotherly farewell meal, during which occasion the apostle held his last speech, even if no special Sunday observance took place as yet. Still less in this respect can be proved from 1 Cor. 16:2. All this would be sufficiently explained, if one should consider this as the usual beginning of a week in civil life.”
Now we know how Neander arrives at his conclusions. He searches in the Bible, and finds no traces426of any command nor even a meeting, until he reaches Acts 20:7. Here he finds a Sunday-night meeting, but on a special occasion; namely, the departing of Paul. This he plainly sees furnishes no absolute proof or certain trace; still less he finds in 1 Cor. 16:2, and as to Rev. 1:10, he knows of but two interpretations,—either Sunday or the day of judgment. And as he hunts for a trace for Sunday, he rather decides that the passage must refer to this. After this, he quotes the very doubtful and, in fact, wrongly translated testimony found in the epistle of Ignatius to the Magnesians, and then expresses his conviction that as there is no divine command in the Bible and no positive proof of its observance, Sunday must be but a human ordinance, which somebody in some way introduced; otherwise it could not exist. He hunts also through the few and doubtful records of the so-called “Apostolic Fathers,” but fails to find any inference that people refrained from their business to hold any Sunday service, until he reaches the church father Tertullian, at the very end of the second century. And this very church father not only furnishes the first evidence for infant baptism, but mentions Sunday as originating from tradition.
One thing has been plainly proved by all this: that even the most eminent historians have nothing of any value except the Bible, and to this the humblest has access, and can see with his own eyes whether any proof is there or not. But we next consider Mosheim’s statement. The reader will remember that his history was written in the Latin, and thus the German, like the English, is but a translation. But the original, the German, and the English have the following important foot-note to the words “unexceptionable testimony,” marked “e” in the original German, and “a” in the English.
Phil. Jac. Hartmann, de rebus gestis Christianorum sub Apostolis, cap. 15, p. 387. Just. Hen. Böhmer, Dissert. 1. Juris Eccles. Antiqui de statu die Christianor. p. 20.
This proves, first of all, what unwarranted liberties Maclaine took in his translation of Mosheim, omitting the above foot-note, and calling the two writers, when he did not even know whether or not they really proved what Mosheim made them assert, “the united testimonies of the most credible writers.” But as both English translations omit this foot-note, the statement of Mosheim simply amounts to a mere assertion of a point, which demands the most positive proof. It may do for Catholics to produce the assertion of a certain pope as proof; for they believe him to be infallible; but for a Protestant to set aside the infallible rule of God by the simple assertion of an erring man, like Mosheim, is a painful sight indeed.
But we will investigate this “unexceptionable testimony” of these two writers, and see what wonderful proofs they produce. Both works are written in Latin. Phil. Jac. Hartmann’s work is entitled, “History of the Christian Antiquities,” and was published in Leipsic, in 1710. The above part treats of the deeds of the Christians at the time of the apostles. On page 387 he makes the following statement:—
“As the first church was composed of Jews, the established observance of the Sabbath remained for them at that time, and the apostles observed it once alone, as they visited the synagogues on the Sabbath day, to explain the gospel. To the Gentiles they spoke on every other day, concerning sacred things.
“But we deny by no means that the Sunday was introduced about the middle of the apostolic age; the Revelation mentions it plainly. The schools of the apostles and the elders of the apologists mention it as being introduced and kept already a long time, still thus, that its observance did not commence as long as Jerusalem stood.”
Concerning the introduction of Sunday after the destruction of Jerusalem, Hartmann makes the following statement in note 7:—
“Concerning the weekly observance of Sunday, no testimony can be produced except that of Rev. 1:10; for Acts 20:7 and 1 Cor. 16:2, on which Lightfoot bases his assertions, will not fit at all to Sunday. Lightfoot dares to assert to 1 Cor. 16:2 that the apostles and their disciples, converted to the faith in Judea, had not only observed Sunday, but had kept it holy also in consequence of a divine institution. Neither the Saviour nor the apostles have prescribed in any law new days to be observed.”
These statements of Hartmann clearly prove that Mosheim was not justified in referring to this writer as “unexceptionable testimony” in substantiating his own assertion. Hartmann in the plainest terms denies everything Mosheim asserts. Instead of furnishing proof for the “express appointment of the apostles,” mentioned by Mosheim, he positively states that there was no such thing; and instead of showing that the church in Jerusalem introduced the Sunday observance, Hartmann agrees with the opinion that it was not introduced until after the destruction of Jerusalem. If a man before the court would call upon a man to witness to his assertion, and this man would state just the opposite, what would the judge think of such a man? He would surely question his truthfulness. But then Mosheim produces two witnesses, and we want to see if he fares better with the second one. The title of the second work, which was published in 1711 at Leipsic, would be in English, “Dissertations on the Ancient Canon Law About the Stated Day Referred to in Pliny’s Letter.” And the bad luck of Mosheim is, that this noted writer on canon law proves in these very dissertations, that the stated day in Pliny’s letter must be the Sabbath, or the seventh day, and cannot be Sunday. We first quote the passage on p. 20 of this work, on which Mosheim must try to rest his assertion:—
“It therefore remains that we investigate whether the day of the sun was also to the Christians in Bithynia a definite day, on which they were accustomed to assemble, which as it appears is the more asserted, because this was already at the time of the apostles a Christian holy day.” L. R. C.