Your ShelfYour Projects

Review and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 16.

CHRIST'S INSTRUCTION TO HIS FOLLOWERS
Earlier text: DO YOU HAVE GOOD MEETINGS?

GERMANY HAS AERIAL WAR-SHIPS.

A DISPATCH from St. Petersburg, relating to the presence of German balloons in the Russian skies, is of the greatest interest as portending a new departure in war methods that may be practical in times of peace. It is known to be the traditional policy of the German war authorities to obtain accurate intelligence regarding the defenses and armies of its neighbors. They also have full information as to the topography of adjacent countries. This system was brought into great perfection under Von Moltke, and when the Franco-German war broke out, in 1870, the Germans had better war maps of France than the French possessed.
The reports from St. Petersburg are to the effect that balloons have been discovered in considerable numbers hovering over the Russian fortresses on the German frontier. They were so high in the air as to be out of gun shot, and evidently had motors and steering apparatus, as they hung in one spot when the wind was blowing, or even moved against the wind. It is evident from this fact that a German genius has solved the problem of aerial navigation, and that the German government has become sole proprietor of the invention.
These airy points of observation are used by night as well as by day, and are equipped with powerful electric search lights, by means of which, being invisible in the night sky, they send illumination to the darkest corners of the forts, and by magnifying glasses can make exact plans of all these defenses. In addition to this, in case of war, these air-ships could carry bombs through the atmosphere and drop them within the forts—a method of destruction far more thorough than the best artillery.
Science is forever on the forward move. Instruments of attack are first devised. Then come instruments to repel the attacks, or of defense. In this case, some rifled ordnance so mounted as to fire at long range perpendicularly, is the evident counterpart to the overhanging balloon. Perhaps these new horrors of warfare render war more improbable than it ever was before; for humanity is appalled at the awful destruction of life that would be caused, and prudence must count the expense of a war which would be so great as to bankrupt the richest nation in existence.—Chicago Journal, March 31, 1892.

THE USE OF PROPHECY.

An article by J. H. Edwards in the Christian Oracle (Disciple paper) of March 31, 1892, sets forth the following singular views concerning the use and value of the prophecies of the Bible:—
“Prophecy is of great value as an evidence of the presence of God in any revelation, but not until after it is fulfilled. To the present generation belongs all fulfilled prophecy, but what is not fulfilled belongs to the future generations.”
It would be difficult to conceive of a position which would more fully nullify the evident object God had in putting the prophecies into his word. Prophecy is foretelling things to come. For what purpose?—That his people may know what is before them, and make preparation therefor, accordingly.
Thus prophecy, as it appears in the Scriptures, sets our faces to the future, to prepare for things that are before us, and for experiences which we are to meet in days to come. But this man would have us turn our backs upon the future, and look only to the past. And when we see a prophecy that has been fulfilled, then we may know that that was all right, and God was in it. But the people to whom the prophecy was given received not a particle of benefit from it whatever.
Compare this with what the Scriptures say: Rev. 1:1: “The revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave unto him, to show unto his servants things which must shortly come to pass.” But this man would have it written in a very different manner, namely: “Which God gave unto him, to show unto his servants things which when they should have come to pass, they might know that the Lord was in it.”
Rev. 4:1: “I will show thee things [which have come to pass?—No, but things] which must be hereafter.” So Jesus told his disciples that when Jerusalem should be compassed by armies, the desolation thereof was nigh, and they should flee for their lives. Matt. 24:15, 16; Luke 21:20, 21. But, according to this man, the prophecy was not for their benefit at all, but for those who should live after it had been fulfilled. That is, those to whom it was spoken were to wait until Jerusalem was destroyed, and they were destroyed with it, and then they would know that the Lord was in it.
And the Lord further told them that when they should see certain signs, described in Matt. 24:29, as well as other events foretold in that chapter, they were to know that he, the Son of man, was near, even at the doors. Verse 33. And what was the object in giving them this prophecy?—Why, that they might prepare for his second coming. But, to suit the theory of this writer, they should wait until the Lord had come, and all who were not prepared for it had been destroyed, and then they would know that the Lord had given the prophecy. But what good would that do them if they had not known it beforehand and made preparation for it? It is no wonder that those who can thus distort their minds in reference to the prophecies, see no light nor profit in the study of them.

WORSE THAN POLYGAMY.

In Kate Foote’s Washington letter (New York Independent, April 7) she speaks of Utah and its condition, as follows:—
“Polygamy is popularly supposed to be the one thing that is to be eradicated. But that, bad as it may be, is not so bad as another thing, the pre-eminence of the church carried to the point where if there is a question between the Church and State, the former must always have the precedence.”
Such is her verdict concerning the union of Church and State in Utah; namely, that that union is a worse feature of Mormonism, than even its polygamous abominations. And doubtless many others would take the same view of it. Why then will they not take the same view of the evils, of a union of Church and State when applied to the whole country, and so take their stand against the movements of those misguided men who are seeking to unite Church and State through all the land, and are fast drawing the churches and other organizations into their iniquitous scheme?

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

[We aim to reply under this head, to questions which are of such a nature that the answers will be of general interest and profit to the readers of the REVIEW. Those sending in long lists of disconnected texts for explanation, evidently as a mere matter of curiosity, to see how certain puzzling passages will be disposed of, need not be surprised if no notice is taken of them. Many more inquiries are received than can be answered in this department; and the editor reserves the right to decide which to notice in this manner. All correspondents should therefore give their names and true post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

179.—THAT ROCK. MATT. 16:18.

Will you please explain Matt. 16:18, which reads: “And I say also unto thee, that thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.” What is that rock? The Catholics claim that it was Peter, and that their church is built upon him. E.-J. C.
Answer.—In verse 16 we read Peter’s sublime response to the question which Jesus had put to the disciples, “Whom say ye that I am?” To this Peter replied, “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.” Jesus immediately pronounced a blessing upon him for his discreet answer, and assured him that it was God alone, his heavenly Father, who had revealed it, that is, this great and sublime truth, unto him. Then Jesus further said, “And I say also unto thee, that thou art Peter [Petros, which also means a stone, implying a detached small, isolated stone], and upon this rock [not Petros, a small stone, but Petra, a massive solid ledge], I will build my church.” The subject under consideration was the great truth that Peter had uttered: “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.” This had called down upon him the blessing. This had been called a direct revelation from God. Peter’s name was Petros, stone, but he had uttered a truth which was a great Petra, ledge of rock, and upon this Petra, said Christ, I will build my church. So the rock was not Peter, but the confession which Peter had made that Christ was the Son of the living God. That truth is the grand foundation of the church. That is the rock upon which it is built. Then was given to him the keys of the kingdom of heaven, that is, a commission to open to the world the truths of the gospel, so guided in the work by the Holy Spirit that his decisions (the whole church being also included, as stated in other scriptures, see Matt. 18:17, 18), should be in accordance with the will of heaven.

180.—SINNING WITHOUT LAW. ROM. 2:12.

Please explain Rom. 2:12: “For as many as have sinned without law shall also perish without law.” A. V.
Ans.—The scriptural definition of sin is “the transgression of the law;” and it will be noticed that the text speaks of those who have sinned. “Without law” cannot therefore mean that there was no law in their cases; for, “where no law is there is no transgression.” The ones spoken of are contrasted with another class who have sinned “in the law.” We have then two classes of sinners or transgressors of the law: one “without law” and the other “in the law.” And in the world we also have two classes with respect to the law: one which has a written copy of the law in their hands, and a full knowledge of its requirements, and another, which is without such open revelation and full knowledge. And yet this latter class have knowledge enough of the law to be sinners, or knowing transgressors of its principles. And what is the knowledge of the law, which they have? Verses 14 and 15 show us: “For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these having not the law, are a law unto themselves; which show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the meanwhile accusing or else excusing one another.” From this it appears that all men have light enough to show them the difference between right and wrong, and to bring them under condemnation when they fail to follow the light which they have. And this light comes from Jesus Christ; for he is the one that “lighteth every man that cometh into the world.” John 1:19. But it is stated that not a heathen man can be found who will affirm that he is living up to the light he has, or is doing as well as he knows that he ought to do. A heathen man living fully up to all the light he has, will doubtless be saved, and that too through Christ, from whom comes whatever measure of light he has, though he may not be instructed or enlightened as to its source. But they need the gospel just the same, not only to give them more light, but to quicken their consciences to live up to what light they have, of whatever degree it may be. But in the judgment the heathen who have had only the light of nature, light derived from the principles of the law implanted in all hearts, if they have not lived up to that light, perish under the condemnation of having fallen short even of that, while those who have sinned with a full knowledge of the law, will be judged by it, having a more strict account to render.

181.—SINNERS WITHOUT SIN. 1 JOHN 1:8; 3:9.

Will you please harmonize 1 John 1:8 and 3:9: “If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.” “Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin; for his seed remaineth in him: and he cannot sin, because he is born of God.” MRS. L. C.
Ans.—If we do not try to make both texts apply to one and the same time, but let the second text apply to a time subsequent to that of the first, we think all difficulty will disappear. There is no man who can say that he has never been a sinner. If we say that we have always lived without sin, and have no need of Christ, we deceive ourselves. But when we confess our sins, and the work stated in verse 9 is wrought in us; namely, “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness,” what is our condition then? A person cleansed from all unrighteousness certainly is without sin, and so long as he remains in that condition, he has no sin. Then he is born of God, as the second text asserts. And if he maintains that condition, as he is able through Christ to do, he may live without condemnation, as stated in Rom. 8:1.

182.—THE 144,000. REV. 14:1.

In “Thoughts on Revelation,” page 644, it is said of the 144,000 that “they are the overcomers in the sixth, or Philadelphian, state of the church.” How can they be the overcomers in that church, when another church appears before the end? Would they not rather be overcomers in the last, or Laodicean, state of the church? J. F. L.
Answer.—They would be both, but the statement referred to is not designed to convey the idea that all the 144,000 will have been members of the church in its Philadelphian state. The work of God in the last days so rapidly assumes different phases that the last generation witnesses three states of the church; the Sardis, the Philadelphian, and the Laodicean. To the Sardis church it is said: If “thou shalt not watch, I will come on thee as a thief” (Rev. 3:3), showing that some from that division of the church would live to the coming of the Lord. To the Philadelphian church it is said: I “will keep thee from the hour of temptation, which shall come upon all the world,” etc. That hour of temptation is yet future, but some will be kept from it who were in the Philadelphian state of the church. But the greater number, of course, will be those who have had all their experience in the last, or Laodicean, church. But all these three states of the church will be represented in the company who are redeemed alive from the earth at the second coming of Christ.

DISGRACEFUL TRUCKLING.

As we read such statements as the following, the inquiry inevitably arises, Is it possible that men in high public positions will prostitute themselves to such utterances for the sake of a little political gain?
In the Converted Catholic, April, 1892, in an article headed “Ireland in America,” we find this statement:—
“At the dinner of the Friendly Sons of St. Patrick, one of the highest officials of the United States government, Mr. Foster, the Secretary of the Treasury, made a speech in which he said, ‘We are indebted to Irishmen for the building of our canals and railroads in the past. Now we are indebted to them for the government of our cities.’ By Irishmen he meant, of course, Roman Catholics, but he did not say so, though his audience would have been pleased if he had thus truthfully complimented them.”
But what truth is there in any of this? Did the Irishmen lay out these enterprises? Did they furnish the capital for them? Did they accomplish the great engineering feats necessary in their construction?—Nothing of the kind. What did they do?—Simply lifted the stone and shoveled the dirt, supplied some of the brute force necessary in the work, under the supervision of competent directors. And now, forsooth, they must be publicly lauded (that is, those of them who were Catholics), as the builders of the canals and railroads.
The statement about the government of the cities may be taken as nearer the truth, and the kind of government they are furnishing is described in the statements concerning the government of the city of New York, as set forth in the April number of the Review of Reviews, quoted in this paper last week.
It is such kind of foolish talking that is doing more than anything else to create discontent among the working men, and to lead them to claim, as many are now doing, that everything on which they have labored is theirs because they built it, and that they are entitled to it. But one kind of harvest can come from such sowing; and the men who think to make capital out of it for themselves now, will find that they will lose by it in the end.

SUNDAY SELFISHNESS.

It can be easily shown that the whole clamor for Sunday legislation is based in selfishness, pure and simple. For those who are clamoring most loudly for Sunday laws, profess to regard the day as holy to the Lord, and to be set apart by the divine law from all secular business. But they look out and see, those who do not so regard the day, taking some privileges which they do not profess to think belongs to the day. They see them riding on the cars, going on excursions, reading the Sunday newspapers, etc., etc., and they say, “That will never do, I will have just as much indulgence as any other man. They shall have no privileges that I don’t have. So let us have a law compelling them to forego these privileges.” Meanwhile, until the law is secured, they break over like the non-professor and do the same things, have their Sunday newspaper, Sunday rides, and various other Sunday indulgences, of which they are trying to deprive others, but from which they will not deprive themselves until all others are compelled to do without them likewise. This is what causes the leaders to cry out in chagrin, if not despair, that if the church-members will not themselves come up and carefully observe the day, they can hope for but little from those outside of the churches.

BOYCOTTING THE EXPOSITION.

One of the flimsiest reasons offered for the closing of the Columbian Exposition on Sunday is the statement that if it is opened on that day, multitudes will stay away for conscience' sake, and thus will be deprived of all its benefits. And one of the most impotent threats is that of the church people, that if it is opened on Sunday, they will boycott the whole enterprise.
In a published series of twenty-six reasons (circulated by the Woman's Christian Temperance Union) why the Fair should not be opened on Sunday, this is one, and is worded as follows:—
“If opened, some exhibitors and multitudes of people will stay away for conscience' sake, and will thus be deprived of all its benefits.”
In reply to this a writer in the Farmer's Reporter, Clyde, Ohio, March 31, 1892, says:—
“Those who desire to stay away for conscience' sake are at perfect liberty to do so. If they refuse to go in on week days because others have been in on Sunday, let them stay away altogether and give the world an exhibition of their intolerance and bigotry.”
It would be safe to say that three fourths of all the people of the United States, to say nothing of people of foreign countries, who will have an interest, on our invitation, in this Exposition, have no regard for Sunday as more sacred than any other day, and would have no scruples, whatever, about attending the Fair on that day. And now, for the one fourth, simply because they do not view the matter in the same light as the others, to presume to demand that the other three fourths shall not have the liberty of their own conscience in this matter, would be, as the writer just quoted says, an exhibition of intolerance and bigotry marvelous to behold. The sight would be as instructive as it would be humiliating:

THE SUPREME COURT.

“I BEHELD till the thrones were cast down, and the Ancient of days did sit, whose garment was white as snow, and the hair of his head like the pure wool; his throne was like the fiery flame, and his wheels as burning fire. A fiery stream issued and came forth from before him: thousand thousands ministered unto him, and ten thousand times ten thousand stood before him; the judgment was set, and the books were opened.” Dan. 7: 9, 10.
In these words of the inspired prophet we are enabled to get a glimpse of a scene the most awful, solemn, and sublime, of any which the incidents of our own or any other world have ever afforded. It is a picture of the session of the great court of all courts,—the supreme tribunal of the universe.
In this awful and indescribable scene, the central figure is the great Judge,—the “Ancient of days.” Invested with infinity in all the attributes of his being, there is none to question his right to the judgment-seat or dispute the validity of his decrees. No associate justices share with him this universal authority; for omniscience has no need of counsel, nor omnipotence of aid. Forth from his presence issues the all-devouring element by which his sentences are to be carried into execution. The judgment-seat is the throne of God; the court room, the temple which “was opened in heaven” (Rev. 11: 19) wherein was seen the “ark of his testament” containing the divine law which has been transgressed. This temple is, “the sanctuary,” the “true tabernacle, which the Lord pitched” (Heb. 8: 2) and a pattern of which was shown to Moses in Mt. Sinai.
The great court room is filled with an audience; and never such an audience were gathered within the precincts of any earthly event. Their very number lends sublimity to the scene. “Ten thousand times ten thousand, and thousands of thousands” (Rev. 5: 11),—no human eye could measure such a multitude. Not as a vast concourse of idle spectators, drawn thither by curiosity, are they assembled about the throne; not as a turbulent mob, whose sympathies are against the administration of justice. Throughout the entire scene there is perfect universal harmony of thought and actions. The great audience are animated by one feeling; they are of one mind with the great Chief Justice who presides.
An advocate is there, to plead the cause of those who have been cited to appear as transgressors of the holy law. Invested with the robes of his mediatorial office, he stands in the presence of the infinite Majesty upon the judgment-seat. Heb. 9: 24. For his responsible position he is perfectly qualified. He understands every claim of the law, and knows exactly what steps to take in behalf of those whose cause he represents. There is not the slightest danger that he will make any mistake in conducting the case. He is the one Advocate who never makes mistakes,—the one and only one who is qualified with the attributes of divinity.
This mighty advocate is the Son of God. He pleads before his Father in behalf of the sinner, but he is not there to clear the guilty. Ex. 34: 7. He does not seek to evade the claims of the law; he resorts to none of the subterfuges so common to earthly tribunals. There are no technicalities mentioned, but every case is tried upon its merits. Every one who is entitled to be cleared will be cleared, and not one who is not so entitled will escape his punishment; and of the justice of each decision there will be no doubt.
In the suits tried before this bar each transgressor appears alone as the party defendant, with God and all the hosts who are concerned in the extinction of sin, as parties plaintiff. The defendant appears in court by the entry of his name upon the heavenly record, and this record is the book of life. The witnesses for or against him are the writings which have been entered by the heavenly recorder in one of the great ledgers of heaven, and which give a faithful transcript of his life and character. This appears from the language of the inspired prophet, who says, “And I saw the dead, small and great, stand before God; and the books were opened: and another book was opened, which is the book of life: and the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works.” Rev. 20: 12. Each one is tried for a capital offense, that of treason against the royal government of heaven, and for each the decision is one for life or death.
From the fair pages of the book of life, an angel voice calls a name, and the individual is thus brought before the great assize. He is a descendant of Adam, and therefore by nature a transgressor of the law. Then the great ledger is opened in which are recorded the words and deeds of his life. There from the ark of the testament, from beneath the overpowering glory of the divine presence shines forth in awful characters the holy law which he has transgressed; and while the record of his life is examined, the law appears as his accuser, demanding his death. The most intense interest ever seen or felt in earthly courts is not to be compared with that felt by the vast angelic assembly during this investigation. If at the close it appears that he has confessed and forsaken his sins, professed faith in Christ and relied wholly upon his merits, the great Advocate at the bar raises his hands before the omnipotent Judge, pleads the merits of his own blood in satisfaction of the claims of the law, and asks that he be accepted and numbered among those to whom immortality will be brought at the appearing of the Lifegiver. He acknowledges the claims of the law, but offers a plea in bar, which cannot be denied. Then the sins of the individual are blotted out from the heavenly records, and a thrill of joy pervades the angelic host that another soul is added to the number that shall sing the song of the redeemed. But if the record shows that he had fallen from his justification,—that he had ceased to exercise living faith in Christ and to trust wholly in him,—the divine Advocate is silent, and a thrill of sadness runs through the great assembly, while an angel hand blots out his name from the book of life, and all his good deeds from the pages of his life history. The dark record of his sins is left, to be passed over to the second and final judgment, while the immutable unsatisfied law, shining out in letters of burning fire, declares his eternal doom. Matt. 10: 22; Luke 12: 8, 9; Rev. 3: 5.
Thus is the issue of life or death determined for all those who, by the entry of their names in the book of life, have announced that they have accepted the great sacrifice made for man and are candidates for immortality. In the case of all others, the fact that their names have not been entered upon its pages, signifies that the sentence of death for their transgressions has never been suspended, that they were never candidates for immortality, and that there is therefore no question as to what must be their end. They are passed over to the great final judgment, in which the saints will themselves take part, and in which angels as well as men will receive sentence for their sins. 1 Cor. 6: 2, 3; Rev. 20: 4.
In this tremendous scene all living souls have an interest and doubly so from the fact that it is a scene which Heaven presents to-day. The Supreme Court of the universe is now sitting, and it will sit but once. Ere its session is concluded, the case of every soul will have been decided. It did not begin its investigative work unannounced. The holy prophet, looking forward in vision to its great inaugural day, beheld an angel flying “in the midst of heaven, having the everlasting gospel to preach unto them that dwell on the earth, and to every nation, and kindred, and tongue, and people, saying with a loud voice, Fear God and give glory to him; for the hour of his judgment is come.” Rev. 14: 6, 7. He heard and saw, as it were, the angelic court crier, announcing to all the world that the great supreme tribunal had begun its session. This announcement was first sounded nearly fifty years ago, and from that time has been steadily going to every nation, kindred, tongue, and people, upon the earth. For nearly fifty years therefore this great investigation and decision of cases has been going on in the Supreme Court above, and who can say how near it now is to its completion?
It is court week in heaven, and every individual has a case pending. If he has professed Christ, his name has been entered in the book of life, and will be named before the great Judge and the innumerable company of angels. The moment must come when his name will be spoken there, while every thought is centered upon him among the infinite assembly, waiting with intensest interest the decision of his case. With many this moment must come while they are alive upon the earth; for the great work must be near to its completion; and who, when it comes, would wish it to find him in a trifling, careless mood? Who but would be awed into the most awful solemnity, did he know that his name was about to be spoken, his case investigated and forever determined, in the judgment scene above? Who but would then feel as he never felt before, the need of an all-powerful advocate and the worthlessness of any merits of his own?
From this hour of final reckoning there is no escape. There will be no pleading to the jurisdiction of this court; for it has both original and appellate jurisdiction in all cases and for all causes. There will be no postponement of the trial, no change of venue, no appeal from the decision of the court. If the individual has professed faith in Christ, his case will be individually examined and decided; and if he has made no such profession, his case will, when this court shall have closed its session, be just as conclusively determined. That closing will be announced by the solemn words, “He that is unjust, let him be unjust still: and he which is filthy, let him be filthy still: and he that is righteous, let him be righteous still: and he that is holy, let him be holy still,”—indicating that all cases, so far as any change of character is concerned, have been irrevocably settled. Rev. 22: 11.
The decisions of this great court are unerring and conclusive; there will be no minority decisions to be rendered; and when its solemn work is concluded, many a final judgment of the lower, earthly courts will have been forever overruled and reversed. L. A. S.

ARE THEY REASONS?

In the Christian Statesman of Feb. 27, Mrs. J. C. Bateham gives twenty-five reasons why the World’s Fair should be closed on Sunday. The arguments used are so illogical that we are constrained to notice some of them.
1. “It would be a flagrant national violation of God’s law, and expose us to his righteous wrath.”
As the nation has no jurisdiction over the sovereign State of Illinois, we cannot see how any action of the people of Illinois within the limits of the Constitution could be a national violation of anything. Further, we cannot see how opening an exhibition or doing any kind of work or business on Sunday by any individual or corporation is a violation of God’s law, for the very simple reason that God has nowhere said anything about Sunday’s being a holy day. To be sure the “church” has said something about it, but what right has the church to enforce church regulations upon those who do not belong to her communion? The church has as much right to compel people to be baptized or to partake of the Lord’s Supper as she has to say that they must keep the day she has chosen for religious services.
2. “Sabbath is the sacred day of America, and should be protected from desecration.”
This statement is chiefly remarkable for its indefiniteness. If the writer had said, “Sunday is the sacred day,” etc., then there would, at least, have been no ambiguity. To assume that “Sabbath” is the generally received appellation of Sunday is to fly in the face of all history. It was never so called until the Puritans gave it that title. The largest and most influential body of the so-called Christian church, the Catholic, never call it the Sabbath. The idea that Sunday had taken the place of the Sabbath was not thought of until modern times, and is now confined to people of puritanical tendencies.
3. “We are a Christian nation, and wish to honor our Lord and the Lord’s day, and the consciences and sentiments of the people would be outraged.”
We fail to see how the conscience of any one can be outraged by what some one else does. Conscience is supposed to be the monitor which approves or condemns our own conduct. It is our right and privilege to have “sentiments” and “conscience” for ourselves; but when we attempt to have “sentiments” and “conscience” for other people, we are making attempts to “stretch our conscience” far beyond its legitimate sphere of action. So if any one visits the Fair on Sunday and his own conscience is not outraged thereby, then no conscience will be affected. Others may think he is doing wrong, but they cannot be conscience for him. “To his own master he standeth or falleth.” The proposition rests on a false principle, and one that has caused a vast amount of trouble in the world. The attempt to be conscience for some one else resulted in the Inquisition. The Puritans in their attempts to be conscience for others drove Roger Williams from the colony of Massachusetts, nailed up the doors of a Baptist meeting-house, and whipped and put to death the Quakers.
4. “For six months it will deprive the thousands of exhibitors and an army of employees of any rest day, though specially needed.”
Does the writer believe that no one can be obtained in Chicago to take for one day the places of those who wish to rest? We have no hesitation in saying that we believe there are thousands of capable people who would be ready to take the places of those who wanted to rest, at any time. So no one will be deprived of “any rest day” after all.
5. “Visitors to the Fair greatly need a weekly day for absolute rest, and the Chicago people need it.”
If they need a day of rest, pray who is going to hinder their taking it? Is not each individual as good a judge of how much rest he needs as any other person is likely to be? And won’t the burden be just as heavy for the Chicago people to have these visitors taking their dinners in one place as in another? How are those whose houses are open to receive this large army of visitors going to obtain any absolute rest any day during the continuance of the Fair?
6. “The mass of working people do not desire its opening, preferring a day of rest.”
Upon this point we would prefer to hear from the working people themselves.
7. “We want to give the world an object lesson of the best of our American institutions,—the Sabbath,—and invite them to follow our example.”
So the Sabbath is an “American” institution like the “freeman’s meeting.” We would be glad to be told what Americans instituted it, and what American history contains a record of this action. If we had no better reason why men should keep a Sabbath than that it is “American,” we should have little hope to induce them “to follow our example.”
8. “If open, some exhibitors and multitudes of people will stay away for ‘conscience’ sake,’ and will thus be deprived of all its benefits.”
We feel very doubtful about the exact truthfulness of this statement. Ministers who have the most to say about Sunday street-cars, patronize them “just the same,” and we have no doubt that even if the Fair is open to the public Sundays, when it is once opened, those who have had the most to say against its being open Sunday, and have declared they would not be there, will be among the first to put in their appearance!
They will ease their “conscience” by going on some other day than Sunday, which of course is their privilege. If Seventh-day Adventists should say, “We won’t go to the Fair at all because it is opened Saturday,” these very people who threaten by their absence to jeopardize the success of the Fair (?) would look upon our conduct as the very essence of narrowness and self-imposed penance. We do not propose to do anything of the kind. If we visit the Fair, it will be some other day than the Sabbath, and our strict Sunday-keeping friends can enjoy the same privilege of selecting the day of their visit. What more can they ask for?
M. E. K.
Continue reading: The Blessed Hope