Earlier text: HIRELINGSTHE WORK OF THE DESTROYER.
By W. A. Spicer
In the “Great Controversy,” Vol. IV, after referring to the affliction of Job to show Satan’s power over the elements, the writer says of the exercise of that power in the last days:— While appearing to the children of men as a great physician who can heal all their maladies, he will bring disease and disaster, until populous cities are reduced to ruin and desolation. Even now he is at work. . . . He sweeps away the ripening harvest, and famine and distress follow. He imparts to the air a deadly taint, and thousands perish by the pestilence. These visitations are to become more and more frequent and disastrous. The worldly-minded may scoff at these predictions, and look for progress in sanitary science and bacteriology to ward off pestilential diseases. But the recent influenza scourge conveys to the world a broad hint as to how readily a more malignant disease might sweep from continent to continent. A recent cable dispatch from London reports a meeting of the share-holders of one of the oldest life insurance societies in Great Britain, at which the chief medical adviser, Dr. Smee, called attention to the increased severity of the epidemic this year over that of last year. He said it had cost their society two and a half times more than the great cholera visitation of about a generation ago. Whether he is right or wrong in the following statement as to the nature of the disease, the possibilities of which he speaks are evident to all in the very facts of the present epidemic, and his words as a man of the world, form an instructive comment on the quotation from the “Great Controversy”:— The influenza is a cerebro-spinal disease, communicable by man to man, and it is pure accident whether the lungs, the heart, the brain, or any other organ shall become involved. In every country in Europe local outbreaks of cerebro-spinal meningitis have followed in its wake, and have destroyed over ninety per cent of those attacked, and I see no reason why this disease might not at any time throw off its comparatively benign character, and appear in its true malignity to cast terror and consternation among the nations of the earth. In the attainment of our salvation God has not left us to do all the work ourselves, neither has he promised to do it all for us. He will make all the advances and provisions in our behalf that love and mercy can make; and then it remains for us to do something to show that we respond to the overtures of his grace, and will accept and act upon the conditions offered. For man is a free moral agent. His service and love to God must be voluntary and free. God does not, and will not, compel any one to obey and be saved. He has not made his intelligent creatures mere machines, compelled to move in just such channels as the designer had foreordained for them. To adjust in due proportion the divine and human agency in the actions of men, to decide how much is to be attributed to God’s absolute sovereignty, and how much to man’s free will, has caused a great amount of study, and in some minds no little perplexity. This is a question which should not be decided without due thought; for it is one on which there is liability of adopting wrong conclusions, and of running to dangerous extremes. That man, in some services at least, is taken into the high position of being a co-worker with God, is stated in such scriptures as these: 1 Cor. 3:8, 9: “And every man shall receive his own reward according to his own labor. For we are laborers together with God; ye are God’s husbandry, ye are God’s building.” Again, 2 Cor. 6:1: “We then, as workers together with him, beseech you also that ye receive not the grace of God in vain.” But lest it might be said that these scriptures refer more particularly to the work of those who are laboring in behalf of others, we will turn to another passage, which speaks expressly of our own experience, and of the relation in which we stand to God in this matter. Phil. 2:12, 13: “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling: for it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure.” The words, “Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling,” are very strong. They imply labor on a matter of infinite importance, and labor put forth with great earnestness and anxiety—work “with fear and trembling.” Having said this, it certainly cannot be that the apostle in the very next clause turns around and contradicts it all by asserting that the Lord is going to do all this work himself, and that we have nothing to do ourselves. So we think it will be found that in the closing statement of this quotation we are not released from “willing” and “doing” something in our own behalf. This is made clear by the construction of the passage itself. In the expression, “For it is God which worketh in you,” the verb is the participle with the article. Literally it would read, “For God is the working in you;” that is, “the one working in you.” Now if the idea is that God is the one who does all the work next mentioned, namely, “to will and to do of his good pleasure,” the sense would demand that the same construction be carried through the sentence, and these verbs be in the participial form also, so that literally it would read, “For God is the one working in you, the one both willing and doing of his good pleasure.” But such is not the construction. After the word “you,” there is a change from the participial form to the infinitive mode, so reading, not, “willing” and “doing,” but “to will” and “to do.” Who to will and to do?—“You to will and to do;” showing that to will and to do pertain to the “you,” and not to God. God is the one working in you, that you may both will and do his good pleasure. And this brings us back to the thought of man’s free moral agency, and the important part which man’s free will acts in this matter. For, as stated above, man is a free moral agent; and any theory that overlooks this fact, or fails to recognize its proper influence on this question, is sure to be misleading. In the presence of that awful prerogative of free will with which God has endowed the human family, he holds in abeyance his own omnipotence, that every man may be the arbiter of his own destiny. And this arena of man’s free will, is, in his case, the great battle-ground between truth and error, and right and wrong. God, Christ, and good angels bring all proper influences to bear upon men, and set before them all proper motives to lead them to the right way; while, on the other hand, the Devil and his evil angels bring to bear upon them all the influence they can exert, to lead them to the wrong. And that is all that either party can do in his case, till man sins away his day of grace. Man has the power to decide and choose in reference to all these influences; and for the exercise of that power he is responsible. How much then does Paul mean when he says that “it is God which worketh in you”?—He refers simply to those means which God uses (stopping short of any infringement upon our free will) to lead us to the right way. God makes known to us himself and his will; he sets before us promises to win us to the good, and threatenings to deter us from the evil; he gives us the marvelous manifestation of his love in the offering of his beloved Son; and he grants us the influence of the Holy Spirit to set home with due weight these great facts upon our minds. And what is the object of all this?—It is to lead us “both to will and to do of his good pleasure.” That is the first point to be gained—to induce us to yield to his desires and offers, to win over our wills to be in harmony with his own. And until this is done, he can neither use us nor do anything directly for us toward the attainment of our salvation. But when our will is yielded and turned in the direction of his invitations to us, then the doing of his good pleasure naturally follows; for then it is our pleasure to do his will, and our will to do his pleasure. And in this attitude toward God he can consistently give us, and has promised to give us, all the help we need, to enable us to do what we have to do. “I can do all things,” said Paul, “through Christ which strengtheneth me.” Phil. 4:13. So Joshua said: “As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.” And having thus “willed,” he went on and did the service. To illustrate: B is in possession of a certain book which A desires for some necessary purpose to consult; and he asks B for the loan of his book. If B is not inclined to accommodate him, he must first be made willing. And therefore A brings arguments to bear upon him, telling him how much he needs and desires it, and offering all the inducements in his power to lead him to comply with his request. A thus works in B. Finally, under this influence B yields, and producing the book, loans it to A for his use. Now B has done A’s will and good pleasure, has he not? But suppose B, in a state of insane passivity, had listened to A’s request, but made no move to comply with it, and A had stepped forward and taken the book himself, B simply letting him do it, could A then turn and thank and commend B for having complied with his request? Could it be said that B then had willed and done A’s good pleasure? No more can it be said of us that we will and do the Lord’s good pleasure, if we do nothing, but, as it is said, let him do it all. But remember that the apostle says, “You to will and to do of his good pleasure.” Some seem so desirous of having it appear not only that we have nothing to do, but that it is absolutely impossible for us to do anything, that they liken the Christian to a pen in the hand of a writer. We are to be instruments in the hands of God, we are told, as the pen is an instrument in the hands of the penman. And as the pen of itself can do nothing, so, it is said, we can do nothing. But a writer takes up the pen, and then a good and effectual work is wrought with it. So God takes us, and then we are instruments in his hands to accomplish his work. The trouble with both this idea and this illustration, is, that it ignores man’s free moral agency, which will never do. When the apostle teaches that we are to be instruments in the hands of God, what does he say?—“Yield yourselves unto God . . . and your members as instruments of righteousness unto God?” But suppose we will not yield? suppose we will not “will”?—Then we cannot become instruments of righteousness unto God, and we will not do of his good pleasure. If we were irresponsible sticks and stones, then God might use us as the penman uses his pen; but then our lot would be a hopeless and inexorable fatalism. We do not go to the pen or hoe and ask them if they will be instruments in our hands for the accomplishment of certain things, and leave them to decide the matter, as God comes to us and asks us if we will do his will or his good pleasure, and then leaves it with us to decide what we will do. A note on Phil. 2:13, in Dr. Clarke’s Commentary, so well expresses what must commend itself to every one as the true sense of this passage, that we copy it for the benefit of the reader:— “For it is God which worketh in you.—Every holy purpose, pious resolution, good word and good work, must come from him; ye must be workers together with him, that ye receive not his grace in vain; because he worketh in you, therefore work with him, and work out your own salvation. To will and to do—to thelein kai to energein. The power to ‘will’ and the power to ‘do’ must necessarily come from God; but the act of volition, and the act of working is of man. God gives power to will, man wills through that power; God gives power to act, and man acts through that power. Without the (divinely given) power to will, man can will nothing good; without the power to work, man can do nothing toward effectuating his own salvation. God neither wills for man, nor works in man’s stead, but he furnishes him with power to do both; he is therefore accountable to God for these powers. Because God works in them the power to will and the power to do, therefore the apostle exhorts them ‘to work out’ their ‘own salvation,’ most manifestly showing that the use of the powers of volition and action belongs to themselves. They cannot do God’s work, they cannot produce in themselves a power ‘to will and to do’; and God does not do their work, he does not work out their salvation ‘with fear and trembling’ (but enables them to do so). Though men have grievously puzzled themselves with questions relative to the will and power of the human being, yet no case can be plainer than that which the apostle lays down here: the power to ‘will’ and ‘do’ comes from God by the inworking of the Holy Ghost; the use of that power belongs to man. He that has not this power can neither will nor work; he that has this power can do both. But it does not necessarily follow that he to whom these powers are given will use them; the possession of the powers does not necessarily imply their use, because a man may have them and not use them; therefore the apostle exhorts: ‘Work out your own salvation.’” IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.
By Editor
[We aim to reply under this head, to questions which are of such a nature that the answers will be of general interest and profit to the readers of the REVIEW. Those sending in long lists of disconnected texts for explanation, evidently as a mere matter of curiosity to see how certain puzzling passages will be disposed of, need not be surprised if no notice is taken of them. Many more inquiries are received than can be answered in this department; and the editor reserves the right to decide which to notice in this manner. All correspondents should therefore give their names and true post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.] 153.—CHILDREN PUNISHED FOR PARENTS’ SINS.
How is Jer. 31 : 29, 30, which says that every one shall die for his own sins, harmonized with the second commandment, which says that God visits the iniquities of the parents on the children to the third and fourth generation of those that hate him? L. S.137 Answer.—The fact of individual responsibility for sin from a moral standpoint is more directly stated in Eze. 18 : 20, than in the passage quoted above from Jeremiah: “The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father.” Yet neither of these passages conflict with the second commandment; for this commandment speaks of iniquity from a different point of view, namely, as a consequence, not as a judicial punishment. The commandment does not say, “punishing the children for the iniquities of the parents,” but “visiting the iniquities of the fathers upon the children,” etc. The wrongs of parents in debauching their own moral natures, vitiating their blood, and corrupting their physical systems by evil practices, will by the law of heredity and the power of example, very likely be reproduced in their children, and they follow in the same wicked courses. Thus the iniquities of the fathers are visited upon the children. But in his moral accountability to God, every one shall answer for himself. 154.—ETERNAL LIFE—SECTION THREE.
Please give us Section 3 on the eternal life question by explaining 1 John 5:10-13, 20. Is it true that our Saviour did not have eternal life simply from the fact that he laid it down three days? Is it not implied in 1 John 3:15 that there are some that have eternal life? E. G. F. Ans.—See explanation of the scripture first referred to, in REVIEW of Dec. 8, 1891, also in REVIEWS of Jan. 12, 1892, Feb. 2, 1892, and Feb. 9, 1892. See also explanation in verse 11 of the reference itself: “And this is the record, that God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son.” Why was this last clause added?—Simply to show that this life is not ours absolutely or in fact, but only relatively as we are connected with the Son. But is it not added, “He that hath the Son hath life;” and do we not have the Son? and have we not therefore in us the eternal life which is in him, and all that is brought to view in the text?” To consider this, let us take in the next clause also: “He that hath not the Son of God hath not life.” Now here are two persons, one of whom has the Son of God, in the sense of the text, and the other has not; that is, one is a Christian, and the other is a sinner; what is the difference between them? They have the same bodily organization, the same physical life, are dependent on the same means for subsistence, are subject to the same vicissitudes, are exposed to the same accidents, and liable alike to disease and death. Wherein do they differ? In what respect is the one who has the Son unlike the one who has him not? The only difference there is, is a difference in spiritual condition. The one who has the Son, orders his life according to his example, he walks according to the Spirit, not after the flesh. He has new hopes, feelings, aspirations, and desires. He is a new creature in Christ Jesus; and in the strength given him by the inworking of the Spirit of God, he lives a new spiritual life. But is this peculiar spiritual condition all there is to eternal life? Is this what the Scriptures mean when they speak of eternal life—simply a spiritual condition?—Impossible. Eternal life, consistently with the greatness and glory of God who has promised it, must be the perfection of all life of every name and nature, spiritual and physical; and when a person is once endowed with this life, he can no more be destroyed by sword or flame or flood, than can the angels of God in heaven. Anything less than this is a smaller hope than the Scriptures lead us to cherish. The spiritual condition implied by the expressions, “having the Son of God,” or “being in him,” is of course essential to the realization of this hope; and so in an accommodated sense this condition may be said to be the beginning of eternal life; for so long as we maintain this, we have it in certain prospect. It can only be used in this sense in 1 John 3:15. The laying off of eternal life by the Son of God was not an event in the natural order of things, but was a special transaction for a special purpose, the mystery of which neither men nor angels can comprehend. Before he came to this earth, he had immortality, and life in himself, as God has life in himself. How he could lay that aside, man cannot tell; but the apostle says he “was made a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death.” Had his sacrifice for the world come about by any natural law, or the natural order of events, then he could not be said to have had immortality or eternal life before his advent to this earth. His incarnation cannot therefore be used as having any bearing on this question. OUR SAVIOUR'S GREAT PROPHECY.
By George I. Butler
WHEN, WHERE, AND WHY WAS THIS PROPHECY GIVEN?
Our Saviour had come up to Jerusalem to give his life a sacrifice for sinful man. The people he came to save were about to put him to death. He rode into the city amid triumphant hosannas from a vast crowd of the common people, who received him gladly. He wept over it with deepest grief, as before his mind in prophetic outline passed the fearful scenes soon to transpire in its terrible destruction. Some days were evidently spent in and about the city, previous to his crucifixion, during which he taught in the temple daytimes, and at night returned to the Mount of Olives, where he and his disciples rested. Luke 21 : 37, 38. The great crisis in the plan of salvation was almost reached, his earthly ministry almost closed. During this brief period, being fully conscious of all that awaited him, he was intensely active in closing his public instructions and ministry. The days and nights were full of earnest labor either for the people in general or for the preparation of his own disciples for the great change that awaited them. With divine power and authority he cast out the buyers and sellers from the temple, taught the people daily who heard him gladly, gave various parables concerning his coming and work, confounded the cunning hypocritical Pharisees and scribes who sought to entrap him in his talk, put the Sadducees to silence, denounced the wickedness, blindness, and great hypocrisy of the rulers, and announced the judgments which should come upon them and Jerusalem for their terrible sins. He instructed his disciples particularly about his coming death, celebrated with them the Passover Supper, washed their feet, and appointed the Lord’s Supper for their future celebration, encouraging, admonishing, and praying with and for them preparatory to the terrible scenes of his death, and their anguish when it should occur; he was then betrayed, abused, and crucified. During this period, the remarkable prophecy we are about to consider, was given, foretelling many of the great events of the Christian dispensation, his glorious coming, and the final reward of the righteous and wicked; but most clearly of all, the special signs of the close of the dispensation and his own glorious advent to save his people. This instruction seems not to have been altogether given in the form of one continued discourse in one place. Evidently neither of the evangelists have given all he said on the subject. Matthew presents far more than either of the others, and in a more connected, methodical manner. Mark gives mainly the same facts with some changes. Luke presents various points of interest on the same subject, but evidently from a somewhat different standpoint; while John says nothing about it. From the remarkable statement of John (John 21 : 25), we cannot suppose we have anything like a full and complete record of all our Saviour said and did while here on earth. For he supposes that “the world itself could not contain the books that should be written.” If all that he did was recorded, we would have an invaluable history. The Spirit of God inspired as much to be recorded as was necessary for us to know, to fully establish our faith as disciples of our blessed Lord. We may therefore reasonably conclude that we have in our Saviour’s remarkable prophecy only the substance of what he said on at least two different occasions. There is no contradiction or disagreement between the three gospel writers who have given us the record we have. They have simply written such portions as the Spirit indited, which we are to study and arrange according to the best light we can obtain in harmony with the written facts, doing violence to none of their statements, giving each its proper bearing, producing a harmony between them and other portions of the sacred Scriptures, upon the great subject these writers have treated, our Lord’s second coming. This discourse seems to have commenced as he was teaching in the temple (Luke 21 : 1–5), or perhaps at its gate, as he was about departing from it (Matt. 24 : 1; Mark 13 : 1), as some of his disciples called his attention to the great stones of which it was built. These were of white marble thirty-six feet long, eighteen feet broad, and twelve feet thick. (See Josephus’ Antiquities, book 15, chap. 11, sec. 3.) They were of wonderful workmanship. Christ told them the time would come when not one of these should be left upon another that should not be thrown down. How long he continued his discourse on these topics at the temple gate, we are not told, but we know it was completed on the Mount of Olives half a mile away (Matt. 24 : 3), and probably at night when he had returned there. From Luke’s record we should naturally draw the conclusion that what he records was spoken at the temple, though he does not say so directly, while Matthew and Mark both distinctly state that what they record was spoken at Olivet. The temple was a public place where crowds were gathered at the great feast. His remarks as recorded by Luke are spoken more especially of the destruction of the Jewish nation and the city of Jerusalem, though not wholly confined to these, while Matthew and Mark expressly state that they record what was spoken to his disciples alone, something, therefore, of peculiar interest to his own church and people. Yet the destruction of Jerusalem is also mentioned in it as a prominent event. It would seem reasonable, then, to suppose that when the Saviour’s attention was called to the beauty of the temple and its wonderful stones, he spoke quite fully before those present, of the fearful events awaiting it. And the disciples becoming anxious to learn more, made special inquiry of him when they had retired at the close of the day to the Mount of Olives. Two great events had been brought to their attention by him; for their inquiry relates to both: “Tell us, when shall these things be? [i. e., When shall these terrible calamities befall the Jewish capital and nation?] and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world?” Matt. 24 : 3. Whether they supposed these events would occur at the same time, we know not. We do know, however, that they had no clear conception of the nature of Christ’s kingdom. They were doubtless blinded by Jewish traditions, expecting it would resemble the glorious era in Israel’s history—the reign of David and Solomon. They evidently had little conception of the spirituality and divine glory of it. They hoped to share in its earthly splendor, and even after his resurrection, before their eyes were spiritually illuminated at Pentecost, they still expected him to restore Israel’s glory by subduing their enemies and reigning in person here on earth, in this mortal state. Matt. 20 : 20–28; Acts 1 : 6. But whatever may have been their conception concerning it or the relation between the destruction of Jerusalem and the coming of Christ, our Saviour’s reply shows the clearest distinction between those two events. So it becomes utter folly for138 any to seek to confound them. This will more fully appear as we proceed. This important prophecy, therefore, like many other of our Saviour’s discourses, seems to have been called out by the occurrence of circumstances. One of his disciples, partaking perhaps of the national satisfaction in the great beauty of the temple structure, calls his attention to its solid workmanship. To teach those about him the instability of these things in view of the sins of this people, Jesus prophesies its sure destruction. Not one of these great stones would in a little while be left upon another. At night Peter, James, John, and Andrew, desiring to learn more about this wonderful prediction, and especially as to how they may know when he will come to earth the second time, come to him privately on Olivet at night, and inquire, “Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world?” Matt. 24 : 1–3; Mark 13 : 1–3. The question concerned two great events only; Jerusalem’s ruin and the signs to precede His advent, the coming of Christ and the end of the world, or Christian age, occurring at the same time. His answer while answering their questions fully, gave still further information of deepest interest, of great moment to his waiting people. Let the reader carefully ponder the fact that the portion of his instruction given by Matthew and Mark was a private discourse to his own disciples, and not to the world in general. They desired special information concerning the signs that were to precede his coming, that they might know when it was near. He clearly and fully answered their queries. He thus recognized the propriety of their questions. He would not have answered them as he did, were it not a proper subject of inquiry. He therefore is pleased to have his disciples seek knowledge on this subject. It is not a forbidden theme, neither does the Lord desire us to be in ignorance upon this subject. It is a part of his revelation to his people. “The secret things belong unto the Lord our God: but those which are revealed belong unto us and to our children.” Deut. 29 : 29. We are therefore fully authorized, yea, under great obligation, to study this portion of revelation as well as our Saviour’s teachings on other subjects. It relates, as we shall see, to our salvation. The subject is most glorious,—the hope of the church of God in all ages, the theme of surpassing interest to all who truly love the Lord. Such will desire to know all they can of the time when he shall come after them to take them to the mansions he has gone to prepare for their eternal abode. John 14 : 1–3. How can any true disciple be indifferent to that which concerns his eternal welfare so greatly? THE CHRISTIAN TAI-PINGS.
By S. N. H.
During the time of the Tai-ping rebellion, missionaries that were in different parts of China often journeyed among them to learn of them. Their writings at that time appeared in the English magazines. It is evident that they sought to be friendly with their brethren across the waters. They could not believe that the English people, when they learned of them, would crush them out of existence. They could not in fact believe that it was the Christian portion of England that was making war with them. The following extracts are from the narrative of a journey among the Tai-pings, by the Revs. Edkins, John, Macgowan, and Hall, bearing the date Shang-Hai, July 16, 1860;— “From the information acquired, it is evident that the religious element enters very powerfully into this great revolutionary movement. Nothing can be more erroneous than the supposition that it is a purely political one, and that religion occupies but a subordinate place in it. So far is this from being the case, that on the contrary, it is the basis upon which the former rests, and is its life-perpetuating source. The downfall of idolatry and the establishment of the worship of the true God, are objects aimed at by them, with as much sincerity and devotion as the expulsion of the Manchus, and the conquest of the empire. In opposition to the pantheistic notions of the philosophers of the Sung dynasty, they hold the doctrine of the personality of the Deity; in opposition to the popular polytheistic notions, they have the clearest conceptions of the unity of God; and in opposition to the fatalism of the philosophical Buddhism, they believe in and teach the doctrine of an all-superintending Providence. This appears on the very surface, and no one can be among them for any length of time without being impressed with it. They feel that they have a work to accomplish, and the deep conviction that they are guided by an unerring finger, and supported by an omnipotent arm in its execution, is their inspiration. Success they ascribe to the goodness of the heavenly Father, and defeat, to his chastisements. The Deity is with them, not an abstract notion, not a stern implacable sovereign, but a loving Father, who watches tenderly over their affairs, and leads them by the hand. The scriptures of the Old and New Testaments are their proposed standard of faith now, as they were at the commencement of the movement.” “This feeling which they entertain toward foreigners is apparently of the most friendly nature; they are always addressed as ‘our foreign brethren.’ We worship the same heavenly Father, and believe in the same Elder Brother; why should we be at variance? They seem to be anxious for intercourse with foreigners, and desirous to promote the interests of trade. The opening up of the eighteen provinces to trade, they say, would be most pleasing to them. Some would say that policy would make them talk in this way. Suppose it did; how is it that policy, or something akin, does not make the imperialist speak in the same way? They say that foreigners will be respected whenever they pass through their territory; and the respectful attention that they paid to those who have visited them, is a sufficient proof of their sincerity.” “A great deal has been said about the cruelty of the long-haired rebels; but in this there has been much exaggeration and misrepresentation. In no instance have we witnessed any traces of willful destruction. It is true that they kill, but it is because they must do so or submit to be killed. They burn, but so far as our observation went, it is invariably in self-defense. Much of the burning is done by the imperialists before the arrival of the rebels, and the cases of suicide are far more numerous than those of murder. The fact that all the women have been allowed to leave Sang Kiang, and that they are known, in many cases, to have made attempts to save men and women who had plunged themselves into the canals and rivers, is a proof that they are not the cruel relentless marauders that they have been represented to be by many. They are revolutionists in the strictest sense of the term; both the work of slaughter and plunder are carried on so far as is necessary to secure the end. They are evils which necessarily accompany such a movement, and are justifiable or otherwise in so far as the movement itself is so.” These missionaries gave the above in a report to their secretary. Other reports from Rev. Griffiths John to Rev. Dr. Tidman and others might be quoted to show the sentiment of a large proportion of the missionaries who visited them and became acquainted with them. Before taking the various cities, they would send a message of peace, but it was upon condition that they would renounce idolatry and accept the true God and Christianity. They sought that China would be in the great congress of nations, instead of standing aloof in childish pomposity. They desired that free access be given to the arts, sciences, and manufactures of other nations. In fact, they publicly expressed themselves as wishing the introduction of the various arts and productions of other nations. They desired that all their relations with foreign nations should be kindly relations, and that the resources of the country be developed by a liberal exchange of its products for those of other lands. Certainly we can see that God in raising up this people of strict observers of the seventh-day Sabbath, went before his people, and he has cast great light upon China from time to time, which has not been appreciated by Christian nations or individuals that professed to be Christians. The rebellion lasted about fourteen years, and the number killed of these Christian Tai-pings is estimated at some over 2,800,000. The facts as above given are from the “History of the Tai-ping Revolution.” S. N. H. Continue reading: SHOULD SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN DENOMINATIONAL SCHOOLS?