In the Question Chair

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 22, 1896

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 73, No. 51.

Read the full edition

In the Question Chair.

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

718.—THE NEW TESTAMENT JAMESES — SELAH.

1. How could it be that Herod killed James (Acts 12:2) and afterward Peter sent word to him, as in verse 17? 2. What is the meaning of the word “selah,” as used so often in the Psalms? O. S.
Answer.—(1) There are three persons named James mentioned in the New Testament. First, James the son of Zebedee and the brother of John. Mark 1:19. This was the James whom Herod killed. Second, James the son of Alphæus. Matt. 10:3. Third, James the brother of the Lord. Matt. 13:55. (2) Gesenius, in his Hebrew Lexicon, makes “selah” the imperative form of the verb salah, and hence to signify a rest or pause. He says: “Its use seems to have been, in chanting the words of the Psalms, to direct the singers to rest, to pause a little, while the instruments played an interlude or symphony. It is a sign of pause.”

719.—READING OF 2 THESS. 1:10 — CHRIST’S IMMORTALITY.

1. An Age-to-come, “Millennial Dawn” preacher here reads 2 Thess. 1:10 in the future tense, to make it apply to the future age. Will it bear that rendering? 2. Does 1 Tim. 1:14-16 teach that God only by nature has immortality, and that Christ did not have it till it was bestowed upon him by the Father? J. F. A.
Ans.—(1) The testimony of which the apostle speaks is not a testimony that is to be given and believed in a future age, and thereby people be enabled to secure salvation who did not secure it here. The apostle simply speaks of a future coming of Christ, and how well it will be with believers in that day. When he comes, in the day of which Paul speaks, he will be glorified and admired by a certain class because they are prepared for that time. And who are these?—Believers. The words, “them that believe,” are in the Greek simply the definite article and a present participle—“the believing ones,” or believers. And how do they come to be believers?—Why, because the testimony of the apostles to the church was believed by them. When?—In this present time, when the gospel is preached and probation lingers. Those who now believe the testimony of the apostles and accept the gospel, will “in that day” be found “believers,” and share in the salvation which the Lord will bring to such. The verb “was believed” is in the past tense, and cannot be rendered by the future; and to bring out the idea more fully, the whole clause is enclosed in marks of parenthesis. (2) The expression that God “only hath immortality,” in the sense of being originally the supreme fountain and source of all life, must be true in the very nature of the case if he antedates all other beings. Christ had a beginning. John 1:1. But that was not like the beginning of other intelligences in the universe, which are all creations of Christ himself. Col. 1:16. He was not a created being, but “proceeded forth and came from God.” John 8:42. He is the only begotten Son of the Father. John 1:14, 18. By nature, then, he is co-equal with God. From the beginning of his existence he must have been as essentially immortal as God; and yet it all came from God; So Christ says that, “As the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself.” John 5:26. No others have immortality, except as God and Christ bestow it upon them.

720.—DISCREPANCIES IN THE BIBLE.

An elder of the “Church of Latter-day Saints” claims that there are contradictions in our Bible, and gave me the following references in proof. Ex. 33:11: “The Lord spake unto Moses face to face;” contradicted by verse 20, which says, “Thou canst not see my face,” and by John 1:18: “No man hath seen God at any time.” 1 Sam. 16:14, 15: “An evil spirit from the Lord.” Inconsistent. 2 Chron. 22:20; 22:1, 2, contradict 2 Kings 8:26, and make the son two years older than his father. Please explain. E. L. S.
Ans.—We wonder if that Mormon elder thinks Moses was such a fool as to contradict himself within the compass of ten verses. Moses does not say that he saw God’s face; and there is not the slightest ground for inference that he did. Could not one speak with another face to face in the dark, or through an intervening veil or screen? Verse 20 explains John 1:18: No man has seen God’s face; for no one could do so and live. As to the evil spirit that troubled Saul, the record first plainly states that the Spirit of the Lord had departed from him. Then God, who causes the wrath of man to praise him, could very properly make evil spirits subservient to his will to carry out his purposes. The passages in 2 Chronicles and 2 Kings are easily harmonized when we remember that the Hebrews anciently expressed numbers by single letters, and that the letter כ, caph, stood for 20, and the letter מ, mem, for 40. A slight imperfection in transcribing the former might easily cause it to be mistaken for the latter. And this was undoubtedly the case. The record in Kings is correct; for it is consistent with itself. The error in Chronicles is the fault of some scribe.

721.—GREATER WORKS THAN THOSE DONE BY CHRIST.

John 14:12 reads: “He that believeth on me, the works that I do shall he do also; and greater works than these shall he do; because I go unto my Father.” What works can be greater than those which Christ did? P. McC.
Ans.—Christ told his disciples that it was necessary for him to go away from them, that the Comforter, the Holy Spirit, might come unto them. Here he says that it is because he goes to the Father, that they will be enabled to do the greater works. These works must therefore be some manifestations connected with the outpouring of the Holy Spirit promised to them if he went to his Father. And what great manifestations of the Spirit did take place very soon after the Saviour ascended to heaven? Previous to the day of Pentecost, the gospel had made but one hundred and twenty converts, all told. Acts 1:15. But when the day of Pentecost closed, there were about three thousand one hundred and twenty believers. And the record continues that daily additions were made to the company, till it became about five thousand, and was called a “multitude.” Acts 4:4, 32; and chapter 6:1 says that the number of the disciples was still “multiplied.” These wonderful conversions were certainly sufficient to fulfil the promise of Christ; though some prefer to find the fulfilment in such circumstances as the sick being healed and devils cast out even by the shadow of the apostles passing by (Acts 5:15), or by handkerchiefs or aprons brought from them to persons at a distance. Acts 19:11, 12. U. S.