1 Samuel 15:23
For rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft, and stubbornness is as iniquity and idolatry. Because thou hast rejected the word of the LORD, he hath also rejected thee from being king.
For rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft, and stubbornness is as iniquity and idolatry. Because thou hast rejected the word of the LORD, he hath also rejected thee from being king.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Obedience Better Than Sacrifice
To obey and to hearken to the voice of the Lord is better than burnt offerings and sacrifice and the fat of rams.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jan 9, 1896RH Mar 23, 1916RH Nov 18, 1909ST Apr 6, 1888 The word of the Lord is the supreme authority in life, to be obeyed without question as the only guide even when another course seems pleasing or reasonable.ST Jan 9, 1896ST Dec 12, 1895ST Apr 6, 1888 Obedience is the purest and highest worship, the sacrifice that honors God and Christ, glorifying Him and giving Him pleasure and delight.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Dec 12, 1895ST Apr 6, 1888 Saul's keeping the best sheep and cattle of the Amalekites to offer as sacrifices did not excuse his disobedience, and his claim to have performed the commandment carried no weight while unmistakable tokens of disobedience remained.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jan 9, 1896RH Nov 18, 1909 Because he rejected God's command he was rejected from being king in a stern and solemn irrevocable sentence that sweeps away all self-justification, and another was raised up to take his place.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jan 9, 1896ST Dec 12, 1895RH Nov 18, 1909
No voluntary substitution or humanly devised honor can take the place of simple obedience.ST Jan 9, 1896RH Dec 1, 1868ST Dec 12, 1895RH Nov 18, 1909ST Oct 17, 1895 No religious feeling, worship, display, sincerity, profession of devotion, or claim of spiritual experience can replace it, and sacrifice cannot quiet, cover, or purchase pardon for disobedience.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Jan 9, 1896RH Dec 1, 1868ST Apr 6, 1888ST Oct 17, 1895 Even the most valuable lawful offering kept in detail becomes displeasing when substituted for willing service or regarded as having virtue in itself.ST Jan 9, 1896ST Sep 14, 1882 Sacrifices and other acts of worship cannot make up for disobedience, and presuming to decide which of God's commands matter is itself rebellion.ST Feb 14, 1911RH Dec 1, 1868ST Oct 17, 1895 Saul's partial obedience and attempt to excuse it by sacrifice amounted to rejecting God's word, and his effort to charge his sin upon Israel for sparing the best sheep and oxen to sacrifice in Gilgal did not free him from responsibility for failing to obey and enforce God's command with decision.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Aug 31, 1882RH Dec 1, 1868
Partial obedience is disobedience, and obedience must be whole-hearted.ST Sep 1, 1881ST May 11, 1876RH Dec 1, 1868ST Oct 17, 1895 It must be literal and exact, actually observing the letter and not merely one's own idea of the spirit, for neglecting a known requirement proves the heart is not right.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Sep 9, 1886ST Jul 29, 1889 Approximate obedience is not enough, for God's requirements are righteous while human departures from them are fallible.RH Oct 25, 1864ST Sep 9, 1886 Saul destroyed the inferior cattle but spared Agag and the best animals despite the explicit command, revealing a character unfit to rule, and his refusal to admit disobedience and his excuses did not make his actions acceptable even when he claimed the animals were kept for sacrifice.ST Sep 1, 1881ST May 11, 1876ST Oct 17, 1895 God accepts no partial obedience or compromise with self.ST Sep 1, 1881ST May 11, 1876
God is particular and exacting in His demands and allows no leeway or slight deviation from His commands, even when disobedience is excused by some imagined good to be accomplished.RH Sep 16, 1915RH Oct 25, 1864ST Sep 9, 1886 Even disobedience that seems small brings rejection when God has spoken plainly, for God spoke what He meant and meant what He spoke.RH Sep 16, 1915RH Oct 25, 1864ST Dec 30, 1903 Saul was commanded utterly to destroy the Amalekites with their flocks and herds and all they possessed, but he saved the best of the sheep and oxen to sacrifice as if to do better than required, and this disobedience brought displeasure and rejection from being king.RH Sep 16, 1915RH Oct 25, 1864ST Dec 30, 1903ST Aug 24, 1888ST Oct 18, 1883 Questioning or disregarding what God commands has serious consequences, and He is just as particular about obedience to His written word now as in former times.RH Oct 25, 1864ST Aug 24, 1888ST Oct 18, 1883 The claim that it makes no difference which day is kept as the Sabbath is thereby exposed, requiring implicit obedience in observing the seventh-day Sabbath rather than substituting another day, and trampling His holy law underfoot now that light is shining brings the same rejection.RH Sep 16, 1915RH Oct 25, 1864ST Dec 30, 1903
Saul diminished God's word by sparing what he was commanded to destroy and added to it by proposing the spoil as sacrifice.RH Oct 25, 1864RH Oct 18, 1853ST Jun 1, 1915 It is not safe to go beyond His revealed will or fall short of it by adding to His word or taking from it.RH Oct 25, 1864RH Oct 18, 1853 His sparing the best sheep and oxen and lambs was not trifling but an attempt to correct and improve God's commandment by man's wisdom, putting feeble man's wisdom above God and bringing a fall.RH Oct 25, 1864RH Oct 18, 1853ST Jun 1, 1915 His proposed offering did not excuse disobedience but added insult to rebellion, and disobedience is no less serious because it is offered in service to God.RH Oct 18, 1853ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jan 21, 1886 Those who serve God in their own way set aside His authority, and righteousness means doing exactly what God commands without substituting another way, as the spirit of obedience consists in actual observance of the letter.ST Jul 29, 1889ST Jan 21, 1886 The same rule applies to the Sabbath that the Creator instituted to commemorate creation by setting apart and hallowing the seventh day and resting upon it Himself: its spirit is kept only by actually observing the seventh day itself, not by setting up a rival institution and claiming to keep the spirit.ST Jul 29, 1889ST Jan 21, 1886
The sacrificial offerings of ancient times were of themselves of no value in God's sight.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Oct 31, 1895 Those who brought them had to understand their meaning, acknowledge their lost condition as sinners, repent of breaking God's law, and accept the death of Christ for them by faith in Jesus as the only one who could take away guilt.ST Sep 14, 1882 An offering becomes displeasing when substituted for true willing glad service, when the type is exalted above Christ whom it points to, or when brought in self-sufficiency without true penitence.ST Sep 14, 1882 God required offerings so His people would show loyalty by willingly sacrificing a portion of their own possessions, so animals preserved from destruction could not have been acceptable even if God had said nothing about the disposition of that property.ST Aug 12, 1889 Because God had commanded their destruction the act was doubly wrong, and Saul's offering of the spoil of Amalek which God had placed under curse was utterly abhorrent as open contempt for the authority of his Maker.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Aug 12, 1889 God does not command offerings and sacrifices because He needs anything; they are tests of loyal obedience, demanded first and all the time with nothing else able to take its place, and grace rejected by disobedience cannot be purchased by unholy sacrifice.ST Apr 17, 1879ST Oct 31, 1895 Saul quit the work of slaughtering commanded and entered religious exercises, thinking fat animals and delightful worship would please God more than obeying His voice, and his deposition was for leaving commanded duty for unauthorized worship, proving God today is still displeased when plain duty is shirked under plea of doing religious service.ST Apr 17, 1879 The highest example of the spirit of obedience is Jesus Christ, who became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross, delighting to do God's will with God's law within His heart.ST Oct 31, 1895
Rejection From Being King
Because Saul rejected the word of the Lord, the Lord rejected him from being king in a stern and solemn sentence that sweeps away all self-justification and is irrevocable.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jan 9, 1896ST Dec 11, 1884RH Dec 1, 1868 Saul’s partial obedience and attempt to excuse it by sacrifice amounted to rejecting God’s command, and his refusal to admit disobedience and his effort to charge his sin upon Israel did not free him, for God held him responsible for failing to obey and enforce the command with decision.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jan 9, 1896ST Dec 11, 1884RH Dec 1, 1868 Rebellion against God is as witchcraft and stubbornness as iniquity and idolatry, and Saul’s deliberate disobedience was rejection of the Lord himself, so the Lord’s rejection followed Saul’s own rejection of the Lord.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Jan 9, 1896ST Dec 11, 1884RH Dec 1, 1868ST Jun 25, 1885 No voluntary substitution or persuading oneself that God will accept sacrifice and overlook disobedience can quiet or cover disobedience, for to obey the voice of the Lord is better than burnt offerings and sacrifice and the fat of rams, and claiming to have performed the commandment while unmistakable tokens of disobedience remain carries no weight.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jan 9, 1896RH Dec 1, 1868ST Jun 25, 1885 When His people reject His word He withdraws His standing, leaving them weak in the Spirit, for obeying God as He directs honors Him more while substituting one’s own judgment sets self above God and is idolatry.ST Jun 25, 1885
The kingdom was taken from Saul and given to a better neighbor, David the son of Jesse, whom God raised up and anointed though not yet crowned.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Dec 12, 1895ST Sep 20, 1883ST Jul 2, 1885 Saul’s failure to follow the Lord’s command was rebellion manifesting selfishness and obstinacy, and no humanly devised substitute for obedience could excuse it, for obedience is the purest and highest worship and God’s word is the only guide even when another course seems pleasing or reasonable.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Dec 12, 1895ST Sep 20, 1883 His direct disobedience concerning the Amalekites, who were a curse to all the nations they came in contact with, in sparing the king and the best cattle and then excusing disobedience instead of confessing it, brought this last act of rejection and led to the anointing of David.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Dec 12, 1895ST Sep 20, 1883 This belongs to the account of the Lord’s rejection of Saul and his family followed by the anointing of David, in which David trusted God’s time and refused to seize the throne by killing Saul though hunted.ST Dec 12, 1895ST Mar 31, 1909ST Jul 2, 1885
Rejection meant the Spirit of the Lord was altogether withdrawn and Saul was left to himself with no answer by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets.ST Jun 13, 1906ST May 13, 1880ST Jan 15, 1902ST Saul’s sparing of the Amalekite king and the best sheep, oxen, fatlings and lambs when God commanded utter destruction of man and beast was rebellion and stubbornness even though claimed as spared to sacrifice unto God, and such presumption brings rejection from being king, departure of the Spirit, and dying apart from God as a lost man.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Feb 19, 1885 His rebellion included making light of God’s messages and resisting warnings meant to reform him, and this disobedient course grieved away the Spirit and made his career disgraceful and ruinous, though faithful preparation to rule and retaining the prophetic spirit could have led to an honorable and glorious career.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Feb 19, 1885 Continued resistance to counsel and reproof can lead to the Spirit’s final departure, after which rebellion is incurable, though it can be overcome in its first stages.ST Jun 13, 1906 The Lord finally refused to have anything to do with him, leaving him after years without intercourse through prophets in distress before the Philistines to seek the very witchcraft warned against.ST Jun 13, 1906ST May 13, 1880ST Jan 15, 1902
Saul lived on without the Spirit until he ended his life by his own hand, losing throne, Samuel’s friendship, crown and soul, defeated in battle and killing himself to avoid capture, dying comfortless and alone without anyone praying for him.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Aug 23, 1899ST Feb 25, 1897ST Sep 16, 1889ST No voluntary substitution can take the place of simple obedience, and Saul tried such substitution and it cost him his kingdom and his life, for turning away from what the Lord has spoken causes the Lord to turn away the offender from place as king.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Aug 23, 1899ST Feb 25, 1897 His royal dignity and power could not excuse him, and God put another man in his place, while the contrast stands with the New Testament Saul who obeyed God’s heavenly call and received a heavenly kingdom, so that one act of disobedience brought loss while obedience brought gain.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Aug 23, 1899ST Feb 25, 1897 His deposition was for leaving commanded slaughter for unauthorized worship, for he quit the work of slaughtering God commanded and entered religious exercises thinking fat animals and delightful worship would please God more than obeying His voice.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Jun 8, 1915ST Apr 17, 1879 Worshiping when he had no business to worship, when he had another work to do that he had no right to leave in hope of doing something better and more distinctively religious, proves that God today is still displeased when plain duty is shirked under plea of doing religious service, and that there is no promise of life except in the pathway of obedience.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Apr 17, 1879ST Sep 16, 1889
Rejection followed an earlier presumptuous act for which God had already said his rule would not continue, and Saul’s disobedience and rebellion culminated a pattern of departing from God’s will and made him unworthy to remain king.ST Aug 12, 1889ST Apr 28, 1914ST Oct 11, 1877 After twice displeasing the Lord through rebellion Saul was rejected from the kingship and soon died in battle, and his disobedience in the expedition against Amalek made his ruin sure.ST Aug 12, 1889ST Apr 28, 1914ST Oct 11, 1877 He had despised the prophets’ warnings and presumed on God’s mercy, and the consequences were later rehearsed to him in a way that drove him to despair, with repentance coming too late to reverse it.ST Jul 13, 1904ST Oct 11, 1877
Unlike David, Saul was not sorry for rejecting God in his refusal to follow God’s direction through Samuel, and being after God’s heart is seen in sorrow, confession and repentance when one fails, not in approval of sin.RH Oct 28, 1915 Instead of seeing his sin, humbling himself, confessing and crying for mercy, he offered miserable excuses and cast blame for his own misdeeds upon others, and because he would not acknowledge his need God could do no more for him but leave him to himself and remove him as king, so he lost kingdom, life, and all.RH Oct 28, 1915 David though king saw the depth of his sinfulness, humbled himself, confessed and obtained mercy because God delights in mercy, while Saul’s hardness of heart and refusal of reproof forfeits mercy and everlasting life.RH Oct 28, 1915
Saul’s failure to utterly destroy the Amalekites and all they had was his second great test of whether he would honor and obey the Lord and his final test, in which he turned back from following the Lord, proving his apostasy complete and settled and his heart incorrigible, so his probation was closed and he was rejected from being king.ST Jun 13, 1906ST Jan 15, 1902ST He sinned away his day of grace and could not return to God, and when he later sought guidance through a witch against God’s command the Lord did not answer him.ST Jun 13, 1906ST Jan 15, 1902ST His life proves that being once in grace does not mean always in grace, for only he that endures to the end shall be saved, and it is possible to pass the line of hope and of divine forbearance while in the full vigor of life, with the Lord withdrawing His Spirit when that line is passed.ST Jun 13, 1906ST Jan 15, 1902ST
Saul’s rise to kingship appeared good but ultimately became a curse, cited as an example of how outward honor and elevation are not necessarily blessings.ST Apr 11, 1911RH Jul 26, 1906RH Mar 30, 1916 He was a capable man called and given kingship when the people asked for a king, yet he proved unfaithful and unworthy and was deposed, with David taking his place in the establishment of the monarchy, and his disobedience thwarted God’s plan for him and harmed his own welfare.RH Jul 26, 1906RH Mar 30, 1916 His failure and rejection leads into the account of his downward course, showing he was false to the trust while the kingship itself remained important and divinely ordained and worthy of honor.ST Apr 11, 1911ST Jun 4, 1912 Holding that holy office did not make him holy, change his heart, or cleanse him, because position in God’s work without Christ is mockery and only Christ can save and cleanse.ST Jun 4, 1912RH Jul 26, 1906
Saul was made king when he was humble and submissive to God, but after he was exalted he turned away from the Lord, losing humility through self-exaltation, and his downfall began with that disobedience.ST Jul 13, 1904RH Jun 18, 1867RH Aug 12, 1875RH Nov 3, 1868RH Feb 25, 1873 Prosperity and great blessings can lead people to forget God and disobey Him, and his history warns of this, for pride led to his rejection from the kingdom and left him unable to rule justly through pride and uncontrolled passions.ST Jul 13, 1904RH Aug 12, 1875RH Feb 25, 1873 His claim to obey God could mask human policy and self-directed action, for blinded and acting with misguided zeal he did his own will rather than God’s, which the Spirit exposed as rebellion.ST Jul 13, 1904RH Jun 18, 1867RH Nov 3, 1868 His rejection did not necessarily mean God had withdrawn all favor, for had he humbled himself he might have been saved, but his pride kept him from doing his duty even when he recognized God’s hand in sparing his life, and repentance came too late to reverse it.ST Jul 13, 1904RH Jun 18, 1867RH Aug 12, 1875
Witchcraft Spiritualism and Endor
The verse stands as Old Testament testimony that dealing with familiar spirits, called witchcraft or sorcery, is a real sin, very heinous in the sight of God, Satanic, opposed to him and forbidden by him, in Israel punishable with death, and by placing rebellion on the same level with it shows how God regards disobedience.ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 6, 1880ST May 20, 1880 Samuel held this truth that witchcraft is a heinous sin.ST Jun 3, 1889RH Jul 30, 1872ST May 20, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877
A man with that conviction would not willingly consort with a medium during her forbidden incantations, hold friendly private converse with the wicked woman of Endor in the midst of them before beginning a message, put her on her guard by revealing that her guest was Saul, and then deliver a message to Saul on the devil's own ground.ST Jun 3, 1889RH Jul 30, 1872ST May 20, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877 Since the form at Endor did those things, it was not Samuel himself.ST Jun 3, 1889 Witchcraft is holding intercourse with Satan under the name of conversing with the dead, seeking contact with him under pretense of speaking with the dead, and those who do this put themselves completely under his power.ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 20, 1880 Satan uses wounded and grieving hearts, reproducing peculiarities, private tokens of friendship and fond memories of the dead so the inquirer is convinced he is conversing with a loved one who knows far more than himself, and is thus thrown off guard, captivated, and caused to believe doctrines of devils.ST May 20, 1880
Samuel's word that rebellion is like witchcraft was his last warning to Saul against disobeying the Lord.RH Nov 2, 1905ST May 13, 1880ST Oct 4, 1877 Saul despised that word and lived for many years in rebellion against God without intercourse with God through his prophets, with the Lord leaving him to himself and refusing to speak with him by dreams or by prophets or in any other way.ST May 13, 1880ST Oct 4, 1877 Then in distress before the Philistine army after years without contact and after Samuel's death, he determined to use the very witchcraft Samuel had warned him against, seeking one with a familiar spirit to obtain an interview with the dead Samuel himself.RH Nov 2, 1905ST May 13, 1880ST Oct 4, 1877 His presumptuous rejection of God's counsel led him toward seeking help from the witch of Endor, showing that determined disobedience can lead people into spiritualism, and that wholehearted obedience is the only safe path.RH Nov 2, 1905
Saul's persistent stubbornness kindled God's anger to rejection, caused the Lord to forsake him and refuse him help and prophetic counsel when alien armies invaded after Samuel's death, with no answer by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets, and with the Spirit altogether withdrawn.ST Oct 19, 1915ST Jan 15, 1902ST Dec 4, 1884STST Dec 11, 1884 His turning in distress to the witch of Endor for knowledge and counsel was not a new kind of sin but the same sin already condemned, proving that stubborn rebellion leads to open consulting of mediums.ST Oct 19, 1915RH Nov 2, 1905 Though called by God and favored by him and having condemned such practices, having rejected the Lord's word he was left to himself and later sought counsel from a woman allied with the devil, having sinned away his day of grace so he could not return and the Lord would have nothing more to do with him.ST Jan 15, 1902ST Dec 4, 1884STST Dec 11, 1884 Rejecting known truth can leave even enlightened people unable to judge rightly, until outrageous sin appears to them righteous.ST Dec 4, 1884 Rejecting messages of truth from God is rebellion, and such rebellion is like witchcraft; in this setting churches have rejected the truth while spiritualistic reasoning has obscured the Word of God and spiritualized away God's law and vital Christian truths.RH Jan 11, 1906
Sabbath and Law Obedience
Rebellion against God's command is witchcraft and stubborn refusal is iniquity and idolatry, and those who reject the light of God's law to follow human teaching worship the authority that established the false Sabbath rather than God the Creator, with the danger that as Saul rejected the Lord's word they may themselves be rejected by him.ST Jun 18, 1896 Keeping the first day of the week instead of the seventh-day Sabbath while claiming obedience repeats Saul's sin, for he failed to carry out God's command from fear of the people and confessed his transgression only after confrontation, and was rejected from being king.ST Mar 21, 1906 Strict observance of a different day cannot make up for disobedience, even when worshipers are sincere and God blesses them for faithfulness in what they understand, because people have no right to substitute their own practice for what God has declared and must obey without delay once his command is understood.ST Nov 15, 1905ST Jan 22, 1885 The spirit of the Sabbath is kept only by actually observing the seventh day God hallowed, and Christ is honored and loved only by doing what God commanded in his time and in the way Christ gave and by following in the Master's footsteps, not by keeping the first day as a memorial of the resurrection, since to reject the word of the Lord is rebellion and stubbornness that brings rejection.ST Feb 4, 1903ST Jan 22, 1885
God is particular and exacting and allows no leeway or slight deviation even when disobedience is excused by some imagined good to be accomplished, as when Saul spared the best sheep and oxen for sacrifice, yet obedience outweighs sacrifice and because he rejected the word of the Lord he was rejected from being king.RH Sep 16, 1915 The claim that it makes no difference which day is kept as Sabbath is therefore exposed, and implicit obedience is required in observing the seventh-day Sabbath rather than substituting another day.RH Sep 16, 1915 Even disobedience that seems small brings rejection when God has spoken plainly, for God spoke what he meant and meant what he spoke, and refusing to amend when shown to be wrong puts one on the downward path to destruction, which condemns changing the Sabbath.ST Dec 30, 1903 Religious feeling or worship cannot replace obedience to God's word.ST Nov 15, 1905
Because God is unchangeable the lesson binds today as in the past, with the Sabbath command and all the Ten Commandments demanding present obedience and forming the test of loyalty when seeking admission to his kingdom, since there is no promise of life except in the pathway of obedience.ST Jun 8, 1915 No voluntary substitution of any kind can take the place of simple obedience, and Saul's attempted substitution cost him his kingdom and his life, for turning away from what the Lord has spoken causes the Lord to turn the offender away from his place as king.ST Jun 8, 1915 Righteousness is expressed through obedience, which proves belief in God, and a seemingly small act of obedience may require greater faith than a conspicuous act.ST Aug 21, 1901 Rejecting God's word brings rejection from the responsibility entrusted to a person.ST Aug 21, 1901
Saul broke none of the Ten Commandments directly but rejected the word of the Lord spoken through Samuel, and such rebellion carries the guilt of witchcraft and such stubbornness carries the guilt of iniquity and idolatry, so that because he rejected the word of the Lord he was rejected from being king.RH Nov 12, 1901 In the same way rejecting the Testimonies God gives for the church brings danger of being rejected by God.RH Nov 12, 1901 Like Saul, people who knowingly set aside God's command may lose what they have been given.RH Oct 8, 1861 The modern Agags are persistent idols such as tobacco, coffee, tea and hoops, and delaying their removal or making exceptions is disobedience that risks losing the kingdom.RH Oct 8, 1861 Saul's sparing of Agag against God's command delivered through Samuel cost him his kingdom, and disobeying Samuel was as fatal as disobeying Moses, warning believers to recognize and remove their own Agag, whatever they are wrongly sparing.RH Dec 10, 1861 Every Agag withheld from God must be slain by full consecration that removes whatever is withheld and obeys without reservation.RH Oct 8, 1861RH Feb 17, 1859
Rebellion against God is as sinful as witchcraft and stubborn resistance to his will is as sinful as iniquity and idolatry, and rejecting God's word brings rejection by God.RH Dec 27, 1906 This underscores the importance of teaching children strict obedience to God's commands.RH Dec 27, 1906
Warnings for Believers Today
Saul's self-willed rejection of God's word presumed that God would accept terms of obedience Saul himself chose, and that disobedient course grieved away the Spirit of God and made his career disgraceful and ruinous, whereas faithful preparation to rule and retaining the prophetic spirit could have led to an honorable and glorious career.ST Feb 19, 1885ST Jun 13, 1906ST Nov 9, 1915 His failure to utterly destroy the Amalekites and all they had was his second great test of whether he would honor and obey the Lord and his final test, in which he turned back from following the Lord and proved his apostasy complete and settled and his heart incorrigible, so his probation was closed and he was rejected from being king.ST Jun 13, 1906ST Nov 9, 1915 He shows that it is possible to pass the line of hope and of divine forbearance while in the full vigor of life, and that the Lord withdraws His Spirit when that line is passed.ST Jun 13, 1906 He was partial in keeping God's commandment, performing part by destroying much yet sparing the best of the sheep and cattle and also Agag the king, and the part he refused to do robbed him of all the blessing, for willingness to do some of God's commandments but not all leaves one guilty of all.ST Nov 9, 1915 Going only part of the way and stopping short loses the blessing, and it is easier to keep all of God's law by His help and the blessing of heaven than to attempt to keep part in one's own strength.ST Nov 9, 1915
Saul illustrates self-righteousness by violating God's express command and then excusing disobedience by claiming fear of the people and virtual compulsion, defending wrongdoing by shifting blame to others or circumstances rather than accepting guilt.ST Feb 10, 1904RH Oct 28, 1915RH Jul 3, 1856 His sparing the best sheep and oxen and lambs when commanded to utterly destroy all belonging to Amalek was no trifling matter but an attempt to correct and improve God's commandment by saving the best to sacrifice, putting feeble man's wisdom above God and bringing a fall, and he had no right to alter that command or make exception to it.RH Oct 18, 1853RH Jul 3, 1856 Though he confessed his sin, it was only after he knew he was rejected, when Samuel could no more worship with him as before, showing God cannot look upon sin with the least allowance and showing His care for His word, which He has magnified above all His name.RH Oct 18, 1853 Instead of seeing his sin, humbling himself, confessing and crying for mercy, he offered miserable excuses and cast blame for his own misdeeds upon others, and because he would not acknowledge his need God could do no more for him but leave him to himself and remove him as king, so he lost kingdom, life, and all.RH Jun 18, 1867RH Jun 18, 1867RH Oct 28, 1915 Unlike David, who though king saw the depth of his sinfulness, humbled himself, confessed and obtained mercy because God delights in mercy, Saul's pride kept him from duty even when he recognized God's hand in sparing his life, and his rejection from kingship did not in itself mean God had withdrawn all possibility of salvation had he humbled himself.RH Jun 18, 1867RH Oct 28, 1915 The narrative therefore warns all with duties, including church members and ministers, not to conceal or excuse wrongdoing but to heed God's command and submit rather than justify wrong in self-will.RH Jun 18, 1867RH Jun 18, 1867
When God has made clear that an act is not obedience to His command, persistently insisting that it is obedience is presumption like Saul's claim that he had obeyed the Lord.ST Apr 6, 1888ST Feb 15, 1883ST Aug 27, 1902 Disobedience cannot be made obedience by offering a plausible religious excuse, for God rejects such reasoning about intentions or standing.ST Apr 6, 1888ST Feb 15, 1883 Saul disobeyed by sparing cattle and sheep and thought devoting them to the Lord for sacrifice would justify him, but sacrifice without obedience is an abomination to the Lord, whereas pagan religions treat sacrifice as better than good morals and let fat victims take the place of righteousness.ST Aug 27, 1902 Obedience is better than sacrifice and religion is obedience, the way of life with no exception, and no excuse for disobedience will be accepted and there is no justification for transgression, not the rank of the transgressor, not offerings made to the poor, not pressure of public opinion, for transgression leads to death.ST Aug 27, 1902
Rebellion against authority and a stubborn, unsubdued spirit are grievous sins, compared with witchcraft and idolatry, warning against resisting just and proper authority in the church and teaching humility and submission to God's will.RH Dec 23, 1862RH Sep 15, 1874 Stubborn rebellion against God's choice is as sinful as witchcraft and idolatry, and persisting in opposition to those God has chosen to minister before Him brings judgment like that which befell Dathan and Abiram.RH Dec 23, 1862 Rebellion against God and stubborn insistence on one's own way are as vile in His sight as witchcraft and idolatry, making professed Christians who knowingly resist duty, church discipline, or those placed in authority, and those who stubbornly carry out their own plans regardless of their brethren, guilty before God like idol worshipers even when outward conduct appears respectable. The rebellion condemned is high-handed opposition to God's cause, truth, and messengers after professed fellowship and satisfaction, turning again to opposition after confessing that opposition was the work of the Devil, bringing deeper condemnation and showing itself in reckless instability and self-deception.RH Jan 23, 1866 Division among God's people is Satan's work, and they must remain united so they do not bring reproach on God's heritage.RH Sep 23, 1862
Like workers who misuse building timbers by ignoring the marks that show where each belongs, departing from God's plan frustrates its purpose and brings serious consequences, and Saul's disobedience shows the failure that follows when people do not carry out God's instructions as given.RH Feb 6, 1879 In sparing the spoil of the Amalekites to offer in sacrifice, Saul and the people were guilty of covetousness, selfishness, and disobedience in the highest degree, attempting to gain credit by sacrificing what did not belong to them and what God had taken for destruction.ST Aug 12, 1889 God required offerings so His people would show loyalty by willingly sacrificing a portion of their own possessions, so animals preserved from destruction could not have been acceptable even if God had said nothing about their disposition, and because He had commanded their destruction the act was doubly wrong.ST Aug 12, 1889 His failure to obey God's command concerning the Amalekites led to his losing the throne and his life, teaching that kings who fail to punish those who outrage God provoke His wrath.ST Jun 23, 1887
Saul rejected God's counsel and was himself rejected as king, and his continued disobedience brought consequences that followed him to his death, for his rejection of Samuel's counsel, his pursuit of David, and his order to slaughter the priests at Nob left him to die comfortless and alone without anyone praying for him, teaching that those who want to die right must live right.ST Sep 16, 1889 He is an example of a soul going astray, drawn by an apparently small pleasure or gain, finding it easier to continue downward than to return, and becoming harder and more indifferent than expected. God is no more pleased by rebellion now than He was in Samuel's time when He reproved Saul, for rebellion against God is as sinful as witchcraft and stubbornness as sinful as iniquity and idolatry.RH Aug 19, 1873 Saul was rejected from being king because he rejected the word of the Lord, making him God's once-for-all example of an offender in disobedience, standing alongside Cain in murder, Lot's wife in loitering, Achan in coveting, Korah in presumption, and Uzziah in profanation as an awful warning of judgment on prominent forms of sin for the church for all time.RH Mar 6, 1913 He broke through the hedge God Himself puts about His people, the conscience and knowledge of right and wrong, and was bitten by the serpent of sin, and no one can break this hedge without danger of sin and biting, so the same result that came to Saul and others whose failure is recorded will surely follow young men and women today who break it.ST Dec 16, 1913
Sources