1 Samuel 28:15
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known unto me what I shall do.
Translations
And Samuel said to Saul, Why have you disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answers me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called you, that you may make known to me what I shall do.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known unto me what I shall do.
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am grievously distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God hath departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known to me what I shall do.
And Samuel saith unto Saul, 'Why hast thou troubled me, to bring me up?' And Saul saith, 'I have great distress, and the Philistines are fighting against me, God hath turned aside from me, and hath not answered me any more, either by the hand of the prophets, or by dreams; and I call for thee to let me know what I do.'
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul said, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answers me no more, neither by prophets nor by dreams; therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known to me what I shall do.
And Samuel said unto Saul, Wherefore hast thou disquieted me, by bringing me up? And Saul said—I am in sore distress, for, the Philistines, are making war against me, and, God, hath turned away from me, and answereth me no more—either by means of the prophets, or by dreams, therefore have I even called for thee, to let me know, what I am to do.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then Samuel said to Saul, “ Why have you disturbed me by bringing me up?”“ I am deeply distressed,” replied Saul. “ The Philistines are fighting against me, and God has turned away from me. He no longer answers me, either by prophets or by dreams. So I have called on you to tell me what to do.”
Samuel said to Saul, “ Why have you disturbed me, to bring me up?”Saul answered, “ I am very distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God has departed from me, and answers me no more, by prophets, or by dreams. Therefore I have called you, that you may make known to me what I shall do.”
And Samuel said to Saul, Why have you made me come up, troubling my rest? And Saul in answer said, I am in great danger; for the Philistines are making war on me, and God has gone away from me and will no longer give me any answer, by the prophets or by dreams: so I have sent for you to make clear to me what I am to do.
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me vp? Then Saul answered, I am in great distresse: for the Philistims make warre against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by Prophetes, neither by dreames: therefore I haue called thee, that thou mayest tell me, what I shall doe.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And Samuel said to Saul: Why hast thou disturbed my rest, that I should be brought up? And Saul said, I am in great distress: for the Philistines fight against me, and God is departed from me, and would not hear me, neither by the hand of prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest shew me what I shall do.
Pictures



Cross-references 20 of 22
- Deuteronomy 18:11
Or a charmer, or a consulter with familiar spirits, or a wizard, or a necromancer.
Forbids consulting familiar spirits and the dead.
- 1 Chronicles 10:13
So Saul died for his transgression which he committed against the LORD, even against the word of the LORD, which he kept not, and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to enquire of it;
Saul died for consulting a familiar spirit instead of seeking the Lord.
- 1 Samuel 28:6
And when Saul enquired of the LORD, the LORD answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets.
God had stopped answering Saul through His appointed means.
- Isaiah 8:19
And when they shall say unto you, Seek unto them that have familiar spirits, and unto wizards that peep, and that mutter: should not a people seek unto their God? for the living to the dead?
Warns against seeking the dead through familiar spirits instead of seeking God.
- 1 Samuel 28:19
Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines: and to morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me: the LORD also shall deliver the host of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.
The apparition predicts Saul’s defeat and says he will be with it the next day.
- Leviticus 19:31
Regard not them that have familiar spirits, neither seek after wizards, to be defiled by them: I am the LORD your God.
Forbids seeking counsel from familiar spirits.
- 1 Samuel 28:3
Now Samuel was dead, and all Israel had lamented him, and buried him in Ramah, even in his own city. And Saul had put away those that had familiar spirits, and the wizards, out of the land.
Samuel was dead and buried at Ramah, contrasting with the apparition’s claim to come up at Endor.
- 1 Samuel 31:4-6
Then said Saul unto his armourbearer, Draw thy sword, and thrust me through therewith; lest these uncircumcised come and thrust me through, and abuse me. But his armourbearer would not; for he was sore afraid. Therefore Saul took a sword, and fell upon it.
Saul’s defeat and death fulfill the apparition’s message after the encounter.
- Leviticus 20:27
A man also or woman that hath a familiar spirit, or that is a wizard, shall surely be put to death: they shall stone them with stones: their blood shall be upon them.
The law prescribes death for consulting familiar spirits.
- Ecclesiastes 9:5
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
The dead know nothing, rejecting the claim that Samuel returned as a spirit.
- 1 Samuel 28:7-8
Then said Saul unto his servants, Seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and enquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at Endor.
Saul seeks counsel from a medium after God does not answer him.
- Leviticus 20:6
And the soul that turneth after such as have familiar spirits, and after wizards, to go a whoring after them, I will even set my face against that soul, and will cut him off from among his people.
God condemns turning to familiar spirits.
- 1 Samuel 15:22-23
And Samuel said, Hath the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams.
Saul’s rebellion and disobedience led to the Lord’s rejection of him.
- 1 Samuel 28:20
Then Saul fell straightway all along on the earth, and was sore afraid, because of the words of Samuel: and there was no strength in him; for he had eaten no bread all the day, nor all the night.
Saul is terrified and weakened by the apparition’s words, believing it to be Samuel.
- 1 Samuel 28:8
And Saul disguised himself, and put on other raiment, and he went, and two men with him, and they came to the woman by night: and he said, I pray thee, divine unto me by the familiar spirit, and bring me him up, whom I shall name unto thee.
Saul seeks divination by a familiar spirit.
- 1 Samuel 16:14
But the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from the LORD troubled him.
The Lord’s Spirit had departed from Saul.
- 1 Samuel 25:1
And Samuel died; and all the Israelites were gathered together, and lamented him, and buried him in his house at Ramah. And David arose, and went down to the wilderness of Paran.
Samuel’s death is recalled before Saul’s interview with him at Endor.
- 1 Samuel 28:9
And the woman said unto him, Behold, thou knowest what Saul hath done, how he hath cut off those that have familiar spirits, and the wizards, out of the land: wherefore then layest thou a snare for my life, to cause me to die?
The medium belongs to the class Saul had proscribed.
- 1 Samuel 31:4
Then said Saul unto his armourbearer, Draw thy sword, and thrust me through therewith; lest these uncircumcised come and thrust me through, and abuse me. But his armourbearer would not; for he was sore afraid. Therefore Saul took a sword, and fell upon it.
Saul soon takes his own life.
- 1 Samuel 15:35
And Samuel came no more to see Saul until the day of his death: nevertheless Samuel mourned for Saul: and the LORD repented that he had made Saul king over Israel.
Samuel had ceased seeing Saul, who knew Samuel would not answer him.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
8 sources
Saul spoke out of sore distress because the Philistines were making war against him and God had departed from him and answered him no more, neither by prophets nor by dreams, and therefore he called for Samuel that he might make known what he should do.PP 680.1–2SG4 83.3–85.1PP 683.1–2 He felt alone and defenseless because God had forsaken him, and he was afraid and greatly troubled as the Philistine army threatened Israel.PP 680.1–2PP 675.1 His fear and sense of abandonment stood in contrast to Gideon's faith in God when facing the Midianites.PP 675.1
The one who answered was not the real Samuel brought up from the dead nor a messenger from heaven.PP 680.1–2SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.1 God did not bring Samuel from the grave, and Satan was not permitted to disturb his rest or resurrect him.SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.1 Saul inquired of a familiar spirit through the woman of Endor, and an evil angel impersonating the dead imitated Samuel's appearance and speech.SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.1PP 683.1–2 Thus Saul vainly turned to a messenger of hell for the guidance he had once rejected from Samuel.PP 680.1–2 The dead know nothing and hold no communion with the living, their thoughts and their love and hatred having perished, so no departed friend returns to speak.SLP 138.3–139.2
Although false, the apparition correctly stated Saul's fate and doom.1SP 376.11SP 376.2 Its message urging him toward ruin came from Satan, not from God.PP 683.1–2 Saul had let Satan lead him as a willing captive little by little until his perceptions were blunted and he could be led into crime, and Satan now exulted in Saul's confusion by spreading a correct description of his end before him.PP 680.1–21SP 376.2
By giving a correct prediction of Saul's end through the woman of Endor, Satan sought to get rebellious Israel to trust the sorceress, turn from God as counselor, be instructed by his cunning, place themselves under his guidance, and thereby sever the last link holding them to God.1SP 376.2PP 686.2 Satan still presents himself under the guise of departed friends to gain control of minds, true to his cunning when in the form of a serpent he deceived Eve.SLP 138.3–139.2 The ancient system of magic at Endor is the same as what is now called modern Spiritualism, with heathen oracles continued in spiritualistic mediums, clairvoyants and fortune-tellers whose lying words mislead those who refuse light from God's word.SLP 138.3–139.2 The account warns that claimed power to reveal the future can lure people away from God, for God has revealed in His word what is essential to know and given a safe guide, while seeking knowledge He has withheld leads people to despise what He has revealed.PP 686.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
83 sources
Saul was in sore distress because the Philistines were making war against him and God had departed from him and would answer him no more by prophets, dreams or Urim, so he went by night in disguise to the woman at Endor to learn through the dead Samuel what he should do.STRH Jul 30, 1872ST Oct 4, 1877ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jun 6, 1900 The voice that asked why it had been disquieted and brought up from below was not the dead prophet returned to life but a familiar spirit impersonating Samuel to deceive him, though a few held it was Samuel himself come up bodily and conscious from the grave.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909RH Jul 27, 1869ST Mar 11, 1880 It cannot have been the real Samuel in glory, for he is shown as a bent old man coming up out of the earth instead of down from heaven, raised at the summons of a forbidden medium after God Himself had refused to answer, and speaking what God had withheld.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Oct 2, 1855ST Feb 14, 1906RH Sep 8, 1859ST Oct 11, 1877 The dead know nothing and lie unconscious with perished thoughts until the resurrection at Christ's coming, and only a bodily raising could bring one back to converse, not a conscious disembodied soul.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Mar 26, 1902ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 17, 1914RH Oct 2, 1855 Saul's resort to necromancy was heinous witchcraft forbidden as an abomination, the ancient form of modern Spiritualism by which evil angels work real wonders and personate the dead, and his ruin warns that persistent rebellion drives away the Spirit and that seeking forbidden counsel gives no help but destroys hope.ST Dec 13, 1905ST May 6, 1880ST Mar 26, 1902ST Jun 6, 1900
Saul's Distress and Setting
Saul was in sore distress because the Philistines were making war against him, God had departed from him and answered him no more by prophets or by dreams, including by Urim, so he had called for Samuel to make known what he should do.STRH Jul 30, 1872ST Oct 4, 1877ST Jun 3, 1889 His disobedience had cut him off from further instruction from God, and the figure speaking as Samuel did not mean Samuel had returned from the dead.STST Sep 25, 1907 Samuel's reply led into the announcement that the kingdom would be taken from Saul for disobedience and that he and his sons would die in the coming battle.RH Jul 30, 1872
Saul had assembled Israel at Gilboa against the Philistines gathered at Shunem and was sore afraid.ST Jun 3, 1889 Disguised and by night he went to the woman at Endor to have her bring up Samuel, turning in his extremity to necromancy which claims power to communicate with the dead though forbidden by the Lord.ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jun 6, 1900 Instead of inquiring of God for direction in guiding the people committed to his care, he went to counsel with one who claimed power to receive messages from the dead for the living, and his own perverted heart drove him to seek refuge there.ST Jun 6, 1900ST Nov 27, 1879
Samuel had been Saul's counselor who anointed him king but was now dead.ST Jun 3, 1889 He was dead and buried at Ramah, many miles from Endor.RH Jan 3, 1865RH Oct 2, 1855 When an old man covered with a mantle appeared, Saul perceived from the woman's description that it was Samuel.ST Jun 3, 1889
God's departure and refusal to answer followed Saul's persistent preference for his own ways and rebellion against reproof.ST His slow separation from God came through pride, jealousy, disobedience and selfishness, growing pride and self-sufficiency, direct disobedience to God's command, lack of faith and self-will, until the Spirit of God withdrew.STST Oct 21, 1930ST Sep 20, 1883 Refusing known duty placed him where God regards prayer as an abomination and does not answer, and persistently doing evil and turning to a medium despite God's command severed what connection remained between him and the Lord.ST Nov 15, 1905ST Sep 16, 1889 It marked the end of his life after he had turned to wickedness and apostatized, and he soon died by suicide.RH Oct 19, 1869 He had lost his right to call on the Lord as helper, wanted information from God and not communion with God, and the evil spirits gave him no solace.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Sep 16, 1889
Saul's answer admits his extremity after Samuel in life would have nothing to do with him and no prophet would answer him.ST Apr 2, 1912 It shows him seeking from the dead through a medium the answer he could not obtain from God, consulting the dead through a familiar spirit as witchcraft.RH Apr 11, 1854RH Apr 7, 1874 He placed himself under the woman's forbidden influence, accepted her description of an old man covered with a mantle, and selfishness opened him to deception, for the dead have no knowledge to impart and the appearance was not something the Lord had brought about.ST Mar 26, 1902RH Apr 11, 1854RH Apr 7, 1874 The account does not prove the medium saw Samuel, and seeking God or His prophets contrary to His expressed will brings deception in the same way.ST Mar 26, 1902
Wording and Narrative Form
The wording speaks of being brought up out of the earth from below, not of coming down from heaven above.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859ST May 20, 1880RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jun 3, 1889 To be disquieted and brought up means to be raised from death, to come up from the grave by bodily resurrection, not to bring a disembodied immortal soul down from glory.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859RH Jul 27, 1869RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jun 3, 1889 The form so brought up is described as an old man covered with a mantle, and the language fits the ancient notion that the dead are in the lower regions of the earth and must be brought up from the ground.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Feb 14, 1906RH Sep 8, 1859RH Jul 27, 1869ST Jun 3, 1889
The narrative calls the speaker Samuel only by appearance and supposition, not because Samuel was actually present.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889RH Jul 30, 1872RH Jul 30, 1872 It follows what the woman and Saul thought and believed, describing the form that appeared as Samuel according to their supposition.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889RH Jul 30, 1872RH Jul 30, 1872 This is the common law of the language of appearance, recording what seemed to be seen without requiring that the appearance was literally Samuel.RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889RH Jul 30, 1872RH Jul 30, 1872ST May 20, 1908
Saul himself never saw Samuel, for only the woman is said to see an apparition.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Feb 4, 1909RH Jan 3, 1865ST Feb 14, 1906ST Mar 26, 1902 She describes it to Saul as an old man coming up covered with a mantle or robe, and Saul perceived or concluded it was Samuel from her description.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jan 3, 1865ST Sep 25, 1907ST Feb 14, 1906ST Mar 26, 1902 No visible form appeared to Saul, yet his belief that he was speaking with Samuel from that description made him ready to trust the words spoken through the medium.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 25, 1907ST Feb 14, 1906ST Mar 26, 1902
The question about being disquieted to be brought up is the speaker keeping up an assumed role.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Oct 11, 1877ST Nov 4, 1889ST Oct 11, 1877 It acknowledges coming in response to Saul's appeal through the medium, admitting it came up through Saul seeking help from below and not down from the courts of glory.ST May 20, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877ST Nov 4, 1889ST Oct 11, 1877 It portrays itself as disturbed from rest and compelled to answer a summons, as one who might complain of being disturbed and brought up if truly raised from the dead.ST May 20, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877ST Nov 4, 1889ST Oct 11, 1877
Speaker Is Not Samuel
The one who asks why Saul has disturbed him to bring him up is not the dead prophet come back from death but a fallen angel impersonating him through the woman at Endor to deceive Saul in his extremity.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 25, 1907ST Dec 13, 1905 Saul had forfeited by willful disobedience his right to call on the Lord as helper, had cut himself off from further instruction after God departed and would answer no more by prophets or by dreams, and though he had once decreed destruction of all with familiar spirits he now turned in fear to the abomination of witchcraft God condemns.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Apr 2, 1912ST Sep 25, 1907ST Dec 13, 1905ST Feb 14, 1906 Saul himself never saw the figure but only perceived it was Samuel from the medium's description of an old man coming up covered with a mantle or robe, and the narrative calls it Samuel only on that supposition because he believed it was he.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 25, 1907ST Feb 14, 1906 A glorified prophet in heaven would not remain a bent old man clad in a mantle, come up from the earth at Endor instead of down from heaven, be summoned by a dissolute woman living contrary to God's law, or be made to answer through a possessor of a familiar spirit condemned to death when God Himself had refused to answer through Urim and Thummim and His own appointed means.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Apr 2, 1912ST Feb 14, 1906 The answer therefore came not from the departed prophet but from a familiar spirit or demon under Satan the deceiver who appears as an angel of light, proving that Spiritualism has real wonder-working power and is not mere sleight-of-hand, and Saul in communing with that evil spirit paid for transgression and inquiry of familiar spirits with defeat, death for himself and his sons on the morrow, and loss of the kingdom.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Apr 2, 1912ST Sep 25, 1907ST Dec 13, 1905ST Feb 14, 1906
The affair was no miracle and gave Saul no visible form and no power in the woman to bring the dead to life.ST Nov 4, 1889RH Feb 4, 1909 The claim to bring up the dead and let them speak was false pretense, for the familiar spirit did all the speaking while dead Samuel had nothing to say and took no part in the interview.ST May 27, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877 Saul's belief that he was speaking with Samuel made him ready to trust the words spoken through the medium, but the appearance of communication was a deception joined to disobedience and a forbidden consultation.ST Nov 4, 1889RH Feb 4, 1909
The deception worked because Satan can assume different appearances and personate individuals, appearing fair and righteous rather than hideous, transforming himself as an angel of light.STST Nov 4, 1889ST May 7, 1902 Demons can exhibit forms of dead persons in the costume of their time, as of dead emperors and heroes like Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar, and here assumed the look of Samuel as an old man of God to keep up the assumed role.ST Feb 14, 1906STRH May 1, 1866 The voice could use what the devil had watched with wide-awake eyes in Saul's past life and impart it to the witch, and by shrewdness seeing what forces already in operation must bring to pass could speak of coming defeat, while controlling the mind and speech of the overcome medium as demons spoke through the possessed in Christ's ministry.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889ST May 7, 1902 In that guise it mixed unwelcome truth with falsehood to destroy courage and perseverance, even falsely predicting when Saul would die.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Nov 4, 1889
Those who held the immortal soul taught otherwise, taking the account as Samuel himself appearing, conversing, and coming up from the earth bodily.RH Jul 27, 1869ST Mar 11, 1880ST May 8, 1879 In that reading the appearance was cited as evidence that the dead remain conscious and can reappear, that man possesses an immortal soul or spirit capable of conscious existence between death and resurrection, and that the Endor episode gives assurance of survival and resurrection.ST Mar 11, 1880RH Jul 22, 1862AUST Jul 12, 1920 Even on that bodily reading it was said that the same Samuel who had died and entered the long sleep is represented as coming up and speaking from the earth, which does not show his soul lived consciously apart from his body while it lay in the grave, and his words about being disturbed and brought up were taken to picture the dead as resting in quietude rather than living actively in heaven.RH Jul 27, 1869ST May 8, 1879ST Mar 6, 1879
Reasons It Cannot Be Samuel
A glorified prophet in heaven would not still appear as a bent old man clad in a mantle or robe, nor come up from the earth at Endor instead of down from heaven, nor be summoned by a dissolute woman living contrary to God's law, nor be compelled to answer when God Himself had refused to answer Saul.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Feb 14, 1906ST Oct 11, 1877ST Oct 21, 1930 The complaint about being disquieted and brought up admits coming up from below through Saul's appeal, from regions below and not down from the courts of glory, reflecting the erroneous ancient idea that spirits are under the ground and must be brought up.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Oct 11, 1877ST Oct 21, 1930 Saul himself never saw the apparition but perceived or concluded it was Samuel only from the medium's description of an old man coming up covered with a mantle, while the account continues on that supposition.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Feb 14, 1906
On immortal-soul teaching the good are in heaven, yet this spirit is represented as brought up from below, and an immortal soul from glory would not come up out of the earth as this form did.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Jan 3, 1865RH Sep 8, 1859ST Jun 3, 1889 The words about bringing up speak of coming up from the grave by bodily resurrection language, not of bringing an immortal soul down from heaven.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859 A bodily resurrection at Endor is impossible because Samuel was buried at Ramah, many miles distant, and Samuel was not present either as an immortal spirit from heaven or as a man raised from the dead.RH Jan 3, 1865ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jun 3, 1889
God had refused to answer Saul by dreams, by Urim and Thummim, and by prophets, and He would not give a condemned witch with a familiar spirit power to raise Samuel, nor respect a petition presented through a forbidden channel condemned under pain of death, nor raise His servant to talk with Saul on the devil's own ground in answer to satanic or hellish incantations.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Mar 26, 1902ST Dec 8, 1909RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jun 3, 1889 The devil cannot raise the dead, and no woman by incantations has power to behold the holy Samuel, since the dead know nothing and can come back only by resurrection by God.ST Mar 26, 1902ST Jun 3, 1889 Since Samuel was God's prophet from childhood, the speaking through wonder-working demons could not have been Samuel but was a lying spirit personating him, and Saul's consultation of a medium was a transgression for which he died.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859ST Dec 8, 1909ST Dec 13, 1905RH Oct 2, 1855
The real Samuel, who held witchcraft a heinous sin, would not hold friendly private converse with the abandoned woman in the midst of her incantations, nor put her on guard by revealing her guest was Saul, nor allow himself to be seen by her while remaining invisible to Saul.ST Jun 3, 1889 No one through agency of the devil has power to summon at will any soul from glory or to raise anyone from the dead, and to be compelled to come at a witch's summons would make Samuel less free than in life and not at rest, even requiring him to undergo a second dissolution.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889ST Jun 3, 1889
The message itself betrays the impersonation, for like the accuser it piously regrets that Saul asks of it what God withheld and then gives the withheld information anyway, and it rebukes Saul for consulting it when the Lord had departed and become his enemy.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Oct 21, 1930 It mixes unwelcome truth with falsehood to destroy courage, perseverance and hope, using what was known about Saul's situation to predict defeat and death, inferring God's anger from Saul's actions and his attempt to consult the sorceress.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Aug 4, 1868ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889 It falsely predicts when Saul will die and assures him that though utterly forsaken by God he will be with Samuel the next day after battle, when good and bad cannot be together and when Scripture does not teach that righteous and wicked remain conscious together.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Sep 8, 1859ST Oct 21, 1930ST Oct 21, 1930
State of the Dead
The question about disturbing and bringing up says nothing about a soul and proves neither consciousness after death nor the immortality of the soul.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859RH Oct 2, 1855RH Jul 15, 1862 To take the voice at Endor as the real Samuel alive and speaking consciously after death supplies the very theory of modern Spiritualism, and the story belongs to those cited as proof of the conscious state of the dead, so that if it teaches consciousness it also supports Spiritualism.ST Dec 5, 1892RH Jul 15, 1862ST Oct 18, 1877 The words about bringing up mean brought up out of the earth, not come down from heaven, and the form brought up is an old man covered with a mantle, while Samuel lay dead and buried in Ramah.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859 Saul sought this through a woman with a familiar spirit at Endor after God would not answer him about the Philistine army at Shunem by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets, in necromancy which God had forbidden as a heinous sin, so God would not answer him in that way.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859 The being that spoke was not Samuel come down from heaven but a deception of the devil, a display of satanic power, an ancient spirit manifestation differing from modern manifestations only in that then the devil had to pretend to bring up the dead while now he rides belief in a conscious spirit entity to bring immortal souls back from heaven.RH Sep 8, 1859 It was not the real Samuel from heaven because a glorified soul would not return at the bidding of one with a familiar spirit, and because the speaker told Saul he would be with him the next day when Saul, utterly forsaken by God, could not go to heaven.RH Sep 8, 1859
The dead know nothing, their thoughts perish at death, and they lie unconscious until the resurrection.ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 17, 1914RH Apr 7, 1868ST Dec 27, 1905ST Sep 19, 1911 They are not living in any sense and cannot return to communicate with the living in any sense, and can come back only by resurrection by God, with only Christ able to release them from the grave and their hope resting in resurrection at Christ's second coming.ST Mar 26, 1902ST Dec 11, 1884ST Sep 19, 1911 No witch has power to bring the dead back to life, and God did not give power to the witch to bring Samuel up from his grave, since witchcraft is forbidden by God.ST Mar 26, 1902RH Apr 7, 1868 The figure Saul took for Samuel was therefore an impersonation, not the prophet himself, but Saul deceived by a lying familiar spirit under the forbidden influence of the woman at Endor.ST Mar 26, 1902ST Dec 11, 1884 Saul placed himself under that influence, accepted her description of an old man covered with a mantle, and perceived that it was Samuel, with selfishness opening him to the deception that then announced his doom for his last great rebellion in seeking her.ST Mar 26, 1902 What appeared was Satan and his angels transforming themselves into angels of light to personate Samuel, so that anyone claiming to consult with the dead really consults with evil angels and has fellowship with devils.ST Nov 17, 1914 Whatever spoke there came from evil angels through one that had a familiar spirit, the same source as modern Spiritualist communications, and asking counsel of the dead is foolish, while asking counsel of such a spirit is asking counsel of Satan, which the Lord forbids.ST Dec 27, 1905ST Sep 19, 1911 Saul inquired of that familiar spirit and inquired not of the Lord, using divination and necromancy that are an abomination unto the Lord, and therefore God slew him and turned the kingdom to David as a warning to leave Spiritualism alone.ST Sep 19, 1911 The deception at Endor shows how belief in the conscious state of the dead gives place to Satan's power to transform himself and deceive, from which almost every system of error springs.ST Dec 27, 1905
If the scene were real it could only happen by a resurrection of the buried man to converse, not by a disembodied spirit speaking.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Oct 2, 1855 The words disquieted and bring me up mean being raised from death, since Samuel was dead and buried, speaking of coming up from the grave by bodily resurrection, not bringing an immortal soul down from heaven.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Sep 8, 1859RH Oct 2, 1855 God had refused to answer Saul by dreams, Urim, and prophets, so He would not give a woman with a familiar spirit power to raise Samuel to speak with Saul after refusing His own appointed means of communication.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Oct 2, 1855
The account of Saul's visit to the witch of Endor and his supposed conversation with Samuel is considered in connection with whether the dead consciously exist, and belongs to passages that address man's nature and destiny and teach the state of the dead and the sin of witchcraft.ST Dec 11, 1884RH Jul 2, 1867RH Jun 2, 1868RH May 12, 1868RH May 5, 1868 It is often cited as an instance of a departed spirit reappearing, but Scripture is denied to give any such instances.ST Mar 6, 1884
Witchcraft and Modern Spiritualism
Saul's resort by night to the woman at Endor with a familiar spirit to bring up Samuel and obtain guidance is witchcraft, necromancy, sorcery and divination, the pretended raising of the dead and receiving messages from the dead for the living.ST May 6, 1880ST Jun 6, 1900 It was forbidden by the law of Moses which prohibited any questioning of the dead, and it stands condemned as a heinous sin and abomination by the testimony of both the Old Testament and the New Testament.ST May 6, 1880RH May 1, 1866 In his distress over the Philistine war, with God departed and answering no more by prophets or by dreams, Saul sought from the dead through the medium the answer he could not obtain from God.ST May 6, 1880ST Jun 6, 1900 The being that answered in Samuel's form must therefore have been a demon, for God would not answer through a forbidden channel, and demons can do such work by exhibiting forms of dead persons in the costume of their time, as of dead emperors and heroes like Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar.ST May 6, 1880RH May 1, 1866
The manifestation at Endor was ancient Spiritualism, belonging to the same category of necromancy and sorcery as modern Spiritualism.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 6, 1880 Sorcery then has its modern counterparts in spiritistic mediums, clairvoyants, fortune-tellers, visionaries, somnambulists, pretended prophets, trust in forebodings and dreams as oracles, mystic associations, amulets and charms, whose claims and disclosures lead away from the light of God's word and Spirit.ST Jun 4, 1885ST Dec 13, 1905ST May 6, 1880 The difference is only in accommodation to belief: then the devil pretended to bring Samuel up from the ground to fit the belief that the dead were in the lower regions of the earth, while now he pretends to bring immortal souls down from the upper spheres to fit the present belief that conscious spirits of the departed fill those regions.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jun 3, 1889 To use the words spoken as Samuel to prove the immortality of the soul makes the Bible a fiction, makes ancient necromancy a divine practice, and makes modern Spiritualism with its godless blasphemies and corruptions the reliable oracle of truth and purity.ST Jun 4, 1885ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 6, 1880
The deception proves that Spiritualism possesses real wonder-working power by evil angels and spirits of demons working signs, and is not mere sleight-of-hand or hypnotic spell.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Mar 26, 1902ST Sep 20, 1905RH Sep 20, 1906ST Feb 19, 1902 Its power lies in simulating Samuel's form and personating individuals, with the familiar spirit assuming the appearance of an old man covered with a mantle and claiming to materialize the dead.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Mar 26, 1902ST Sep 20, 1905 Its phenomena are real facts to be faced rather than dismissed with a sneer, and that counsel comes from the power of darkness itself, putting its seekers on a low intellectual and moral level as the blind led by the blind and by darkness for a purpose.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Sep 20, 1905RH Sep 20, 1906ST Feb 19, 1902 The same is repeated when kings today pay spiritualist mediums for seances and take counsel from them, and the going forth of that demon counsel to the kings of the whole world proves the coming of the Son of God is near.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Sep 20, 1905RH Sep 20, 1906
Consulting one having a familiar spirit was among the practices of the former heathen dwellers in Canaan that made them abhorrent to God and that He would have none of among His chosen people.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Feb 14, 1906ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 8, 1909ST Jun 6, 1900 Saul's consultation was disobedience and transgression against the Lord, seeking an interview with the deceiver through forbidden influence after God had refused to answer through His own appointed means.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Mar 26, 1902ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 8, 1909ST Jun 6, 1900 It was for this in part that God deserted him and left him to destruction, slew him, turned the kingdom to David, and permitted him to be slain by the enemies of Israel.ST Feb 14, 1906ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 8, 1909ST Jun 6, 1900 He soon fell in battle with Jonathan and his army beaten, dying by suicide at the end of a life turned to wickedness and apostasy after God had departed from him.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Feb 14, 1906RH Oct 19, 1869ST Jun 6, 1900
Warnings and Present Application
Refusing known duty puts a person where God regards prayer as an abomination and does not answer, as Saul distressed by war and forsaken by God illustrates when prophets and dreams brought him no answer.ST Nov 15, 1905RH Nov 2, 1905 Refusing the Lord's counsel led him toward Spiritualism, so that disobedience becomes a path to witchcraft and deception.RH Nov 2, 1905 Persistent sin and refusal to yield can drive away the Spirit and destroy communion with God, and Saul after turning from God and seeking guidance through a medium stands as a solemn warning of that loss.ST Oct 30, 1907 He had become so estranged that he mistook the satanic spirit working through the witch for the Holy Spirit speaking through Samuel, and his destruction followed shortly afterward.ST Oct 9, 1907 His course had sunk to a low intellectual and moral level, turning in superstition and vacillating distress to a Spiritualist medium for guidance, a case of the blind leading the blind.ST Oct 10, 1906 Partial obedience is disobedience, and his late resort to the devil's emissaries after disobeying God's commands shows rebellion linked with witchcraft.ST Oct 17, 1895
Slow separation from God through pride, jealousy, disobedience and selfishness ended with the Spirit withdrawn, leaving Saul wanting information from God rather than communion with God when war with the Philistines was at hand and God answered no more by dreams, by Urim and Thummim, or by prophets.ST Oct 21, 1930 His distress and the failure of his usual means of receiving answers did not make consulting a medium right, for God did not approve the method and his own perverted heart drove him to seek refuge there.ST Nov 27, 1879 Consulting the oracle at Endor to learn the future was consulting the devil in person and putting himself under the dominion of darkness and imposture to get disclosures he refused to accept from the hand of the living God.RH Dec 10, 1861 It came from refusing to submit the sense of the invisible world to the rule of Scripture and the divinely revealed record, and from disbelief in the sure word of prophecy, which only leads into new superstition.RH Dec 10, 1861 That oracle is the same in spirit as the oracle of Baal-zebub at Ekron, with present-day counterparts in visionaries and somnambulists, pretended prophets and fortune-tellers, trust in forebodings, presentiments and dreams as divine oracles, covert associations seeking disclosures in mystic obscurities, and amulets, charms and sympathetic remedies.RH Dec 10, 1861
All who seek God or His prophets contrary to His expressed will shall be deceived in the same way, for Saul placed himself under forbidden influence, accepted the woman's description of an old man covered with a mantle as Samuel, and through selfishness was opened to a lying familiar spirit that announced his doom for his last great rebellion in seeking her.ST Mar 26, 1902 God had departed and refused to answer by dreams, by Urim, or by prophets, and He gave no power to a condemned witch to bring up the dead, since the dead know nothing and return only by resurrection by God and since witchcraft is forbidden.ST Mar 26, 1902 Saul's resort to familiar spirits after persistently doing evil despite God's command severed what connection remained between him and the Lord, and the evil spirits gave him no solace.ST Sep 16, 1889 The apparition asking what disturbed and brought it up was a counterfeit Samuel summoned through appeal to Satan rather than Samuel sent by God, speaking of coming up from below and not down from heaven and using Saul's sins and despairing situation to extinguish his hope.ST May 20, 1880
Belief in the conscious state of the dead gives place to Satan's power to transform himself and deceive, from which almost every system of error springs, for asking counsel of the dead is foolish and asking counsel of such a spirit is asking counsel of Satan, which the Lord forbids.ST Dec 27, 1905 Belief in what the Bible teaches about the condition of the dead and heeding its warnings against all forms of Spiritism keeps people from being deceived by the seance, which was recorded for learning and not for deception, since Satan controlled the mind and speech of the medium he had overcome as demons spoke through the possessed and personated Samuel as an angel of light, and the Lord never gave a condemned witch power to bring up the dead.ST May 7, 1902 Seeking that counsel from the power of darkness itself, spirits of demons working signs, put Saul on a low intellectual and moral level, the blind being led by the blind and by darkness for a purpose.RH Sep 20, 1906 The same is repeated when kings today pay Spiritualist mediums for seances and take counsel from them, and the going forth of that demon counsel to the kings of the whole world proves the coming of the Son of God is near.RH Sep 20, 1906 That appearance of Samuel was a substitute or deception and not the real person, distinct from Jesus, who is the same real, bodily person who ascended and shall return literally.RH Aug 10, 1876
By the visit Saul gained nothing but lost everything, taking another downward step toward falling on his sword after leaving his royal standing to seek the witch's companionship in her low home, with the message taking away his last courage so that he fell full length on the dirt floor.ST Nov 4, 1889 He returned to battle broken-hearted, and his remaining courage was the courage of despair, ending in death by his own hand.ST Sep 16, 1889 The voice could tell things from his past life because the devil had watched him with wide-awake eyes and imparted what he had seen to the witch, and could tell of coming defeat because shrewdness sees what forces already in operation must bring to pass, but further than that in foretelling the future neither the witch at Endor nor any fortune-teller, Spiritualist, or necromancer can go.ST Nov 4, 1889 Turning into that gate as Saul did gains nothing and brings great danger of speedily committing spiritual and physical suicide.ST Nov 4, 1889
Sources