1 Samuel 28:7
Then said Saul unto his servants, Seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and enquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at Endor.
Translations
Then said Saul to his servants, Seek me a woman that has a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and inquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that has a familiar spirit at Endor.
Then said Saul unto his servants, Seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and enquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at Endor.
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
Then said Saul unto his servants, Seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and inquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at En-dor.
Then said Saul to his servants, seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and inquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at En-dor.
And Saul saith to his servants, 'Seek for me a woman possessing a familiar spirit, and I go unto her, and inquire of her;' and his servants say unto him, 'Lo, a woman possessing a familiar spirit in En-dor.'
Then said Saul to his servants, Seek me a woman that has a spirit of Python, that I may go to her and inquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman who has a spirit of Python at En-dor.
Then said Saul unto his servants—Seek me out a woman that owneth a familiar spirit, that I may even go unto her, and enquire of her. And his servants said unto him, Lo! there is a woman that owneth a familiar spirit in En-dor.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then Saul said to his servants, “ Find me a woman who is a medium, so I can go and consult her.”“ There is a medium at Endor,” his servants replied.
Then Saul said to his servants, “ Seek for me a woman who has a familiar spirit, that I may go to her and inquire of her.”His servants said to him, “ Behold, there is a woman who has a familiar spirit at Endor.”
Then Saul said to his servants, Get me a woman who has control of a spirit so that I may go to her and get directions. And his servants said to him, There is such a woman at En-dor.
Then saide Saul vnto his seruants, Seeke me a woman that hath a familiar spirite, that I may goe to her, and aske of her. And his seruants said to him, Beholde, there is a woman at En-dor that hath a familiar spirit.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And Saul said to his servants: Seek me a woman that hath a divining spirit, and I will go to her, and inquire by her. And his servants said to him: There is a woman that hath a divining spirit at Endor.
Pictures




Cross-references 20 of 26
- Deuteronomy 18:10-12
There shall not be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter to pass through the fire, or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch,
Forbids consulting familiar spirits.
- 1 Chronicles 10:13-14
So Saul died for his transgression which he committed against the LORD, even against the word of the LORD, which he kept not, and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to enquire of it;
Saul’s consultation of a familiar spirit is named as a transgression leading to his death.
- Leviticus 19:31
Regard not them that have familiar spirits, neither seek after wizards, to be defiled by them: I am the LORD your God.
Forbids seeking or consulting those with familiar spirits.
- Isaiah 8:19
And when they shall say unto you, Seek unto them that have familiar spirits, and unto wizards that peep, and that mutter: should not a people seek unto their God? for the living to the dead?
Condemns seeking guidance from familiar spirits instead of God.
- Leviticus 20:27
A man also or woman that hath a familiar spirit, or that is a wizard, shall surely be put to death: they shall stone them with stones: their blood shall be upon them.
The law forbids consulting familiar spirits and prescribes death for mediums.
- Leviticus 20:6
And the soul that turneth after such as have familiar spirits, and after wizards, to go a whoring after them, I will even set my face against that soul, and will cut him off from among his people.
Condemns turning to familiar spirits and warns of being cut off.
- 1 Samuel 28:15-19
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known unto me what I shall do.
Samuel’s apparition tells Saul that God has departed and announces his judgment.
- 1 Samuel 15:23
For rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft, and stubbornness is as iniquity and idolatry. Because thou hast rejected the word of the LORD, he hath also rejected thee from being king.
Saul’s rebellion is compared to witchcraft, which he later seeks through a medium.
- 1 Samuel 31:1-6
Now the Philistines fought against Israel: and the men of Israel fled from before the Philistines, and fell down slain in mount Gilboa.
Saul’s defeat and death follow his consultation with the medium at Endor.
- Exodus 22:18
Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.
The law forbids the spirit medium Saul sought.
- Ecclesiastes 9:5-6
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
The verses describe the dead as knowing nothing and having no part in earthly affairs.
- 1 Samuel 28:3
Now Samuel was dead, and all Israel had lamented him, and buried him in Ramah, even in his own city. And Saul had put away those that had familiar spirits, and the wizards, out of the land.
Saul had previously expelled people with familiar spirits.
- 1 Samuel 16:14
But the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from the LORD troubled him.
God’s Spirit had departed from Saul, and an evil spirit troubled him before his visit to Endor.
- 1 Samuel 28:19
Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines: and to morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me: the LORD also shall deliver the host of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.
Samuel’s apparition foretells Saul’s death and his being with Samuel.
- 1 Samuel 28:14
And he said unto her, What form is he of? And she said, An old man cometh up; and he is covered with a mantle. And Saul perceived that it was Samuel, and he stooped with his face to the ground, and bowed himself.
Saul identifies Samuel from the medium’s description.
- 1 Samuel 28:11
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring up unto thee? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
Saul asks the medium to bring Samuel up, and an impersonating spirit appears.
- Isaiah 29:4
And thou shalt be brought down, and shalt speak out of the ground, and thy speech shall be low out of the dust, and thy voice shall be, as of one that hath a familiar spirit, out of the ground, and thy speech shall whisper out of the dust.
Both describe familiar spirits speaking in low, whispering voices.
- 1 Samuel 28:20
Then Saul fell straightway all along on the earth, and was sore afraid, because of the words of Samuel: and there was no strength in him; for he had eaten no bread all the day, nor all the night.
Saul collapses in terror after hearing the message.
- 1 Samuel 28:13
And the king said unto her, Be not afraid: for what sawest thou? And the woman said unto Saul, I saw gods ascending out of the earth.
The woman claims to see an apparition ascending from the earth.
- 1 Samuel 28:12
And when the woman saw Samuel, she cried with a loud voice: and the woman spake to Saul, saying, Why hast thou deceived me? for thou art Saul.
The woman recognizes Saul when the apparition appears as Samuel.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
18 sources
Forsaken and afraid before the Philistine army at Gilboa with no answer from God, Saul asked his servants to find a woman with a familiar spirit for him to inquire of, and they told him of such a woman at Endor.PP 675.11SP 375.1PP 676.1–2 He knew such necromancy was forbidden and had himself ordered its practitioners put to death, yet in desperation he turned to the very practice he had condemned.PP 676.1–2 The woman was in league with Satan and yielded to his control, and no dead Samuel returned or spoke, for God did not permit Satan to disturb Samuel's rest, but Satan used his knowledge of Samuel to present a counterfeit in form and speech and to announce the fate of Saul and his sons.1SP 376.1SG4 83.3–85.11SP 375.1PP 676.1–2PP 683.1–2 That consulting was Saul's last act, cutting his last tie to his Maker and sealing his willful separation from God, making a covenant with death and hell, placing himself fully under demonic power and filling the cup of his iniquity.SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.31SP 376.2 To inquire at Endor was to seek counsel from Satan through evil spirits rather than from the Lord, not communion with the dead, for the dead know nothing and hold no communion with the living, and it is the same deception now appearing as modern Spiritualism in mediums, clairvoyants, fortune-tellers and seances.1SP 376.25T 193.1PP 683.1–2RH Sep 7, 1911SLP 138.3–139.2 It is cursed and forbidden ground that leads away from God toward ruin, to be shunned in favor of trust in the living God rather than anxiously seeking hidden knowledge that has not been revealed.1SP 376.2CH 490.2CTBH 115.15T 197.2PP 687.1
Saul Seeks Forbidden Counsel
Saul stands before the Philistine army near Mount Gilboa, afraid and feeling forsaken by God.PP 675.1 After God gave him no answer, he asked his servants to find a woman with a familiar spirit so that he could go to her and inquire of her, and they told him such a woman was at Endor.1SP 375.1PP 676.1–2 He knew necromancy was forbidden and had previously ordered its practitioners put to death, yet in desperation he turned to the very practice he had condemned.PP 676.1–2 The woman at Endor was in league with Satan, covenanted with him and yielded to his control, and he used her to perform wonders and reveal secret things.1SP 375.1PP 676.1–2
The dead Samuel did not appear or speak, for God did not permit Satan to disturb Samuel's rest in the grave or to resurrect him.1SP 376.1SG4 83.3–85.1 Satan's angels can imitate dead people in form, speech, and actions.1SP 376.1SG4 83.3–85.1 Satan used his knowledge of Samuel to present a counterfeit Samuel through the sorceress, so that Saul sought counsel from a familiar spirit rather than from the Lord, and to give an accurate announcement of the fate of Saul and his sons, using that deception to deepen ruin and draw Israel away from God.1SP 376.1SG4 83.3–85.1PP 683.1–2
This consulting of the woman was Saul's last act, cutting his last tie and last shred that held him to his Maker and sealing his willful separation from God as final.SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.31SP 376.2PP 676.3 By it he made an agreement with death and a covenant with hell, placed himself fully under the demonic power that had long influenced him, and filled the cup of his iniquity.1SP 376.3PP 676.3 He knew what he had done in thus severing his last link to God by willing submission to this course.1SP 376.31SP 376.2 It illustrates the terrible bondage that follows persistent resistance to God's Spirit and rejection of trust and obedience.PP 676.3
Necromancy Exposed and Shunned
To inquire at Endor was to seek counsel not from the Lord but from Satan through the sorceress, by a heathen oracle through communication with evil spirits.1SP 376.2PP 683.1–2SLP 138.3–139.2 Saul did not commune with Samuel the prophet of God, but through the woman with a counterfeit Samuel presented by Satan.1SP 376.2PP 683.1–2 Even the true announcement of his fate given through her was turned to deepen his ruin, and his willing submission to that course led him away from God and severed his last link to Him.1SP 376.2PP 683.1–2
The mystic voice that spoke at Endor spoke lying words to mislead men, the art of the prince of darkness working to gain control of minds.5T 193.1RH Sep 7, 1911SLP 138.3–139.2 Its disclosures were deceptive messages of evil spirits, not communion with the dead, for the dead know nothing, their thoughts and love and hatred have perished, and they hold no communion with the living.RH Sep 7, 1911SLP 138.3–139.2AA 289.2–290.2 Satan gains access to minds by presenting himself under the guise of departed friends, and seeking such counsel is a dangerous sorcery that draws men away from God.RH Sep 7, 1911SLP 138.3–139.2AA 289.2–290.2
Endor belongs to the same deceptive practice as the oracle at Ekron and the ancient system of magic, which is in reality the same as what is now called modern Spiritualism.5T 193.1SLP 138.3–139.2ST Mar 24, 1887 The heathen oracles have their counterpart today in spiritualistic mediums, clairvoyants, fortune-tellers, secret associations, seances, obscurities, wonders, and sorcerers, with seances replacing the mysteries of heathen worship.5T 193.1SLP 138.3–139.2ST Mar 24, 1887 It is the same power only appearing under a new guise, still misleading thousands who refuse light from God's word and His Spirit, who speak with scorn of the magicians of old while yielding to the same arts under a different form.5T 193.1SLP 138.3–139.2 The claim to cure disease by electricity, magnetism, or so-called sympathetic remedies is the magnetic power of Satan's sorcery, by which he casts his spell over the bodies and souls of men.SLP 138.3–139.2
The path to Endor is cursed and forbidden ground of witchcraft and reliance on spiritualist powers instead of trust in the living God.CH 490.2CTBH 115.15T 197.2 Feet that venture upon it will stumble and fall, for to go there is to put trust in witchcraft and to dishonor the God of Israel.CTBH 115.15T 197.2 It must be shunned in favor of faith in the living God, with whom is deliverance for all that are oppressed, and His professed followers must abide in the faith received from the beginning and shun profane and vain babblings, for righteousness is the habitation of His throne.CH 490.25T 197.2 Saul's choice stands as an example of turning to forbidden sources for hidden knowledge when anxious about what has not been revealed, instead of trusting God and waiting for His help, bringing only knowledge of evil and warning against seeking such knowledge rather than finding comfort through prayer and going to Jesus.PP 687.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
91 sources
Saul in extremity of war asks his servants to find a woman with a familiar spirit so he can go inquire of her, and they answer such a woman is at Endor.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Nov 4, 1889RH Jan 3, 1865 He does so after the Lord refuses to answer him by dreams, Urim or prophets because of willful disobedience, though he himself had cut off such practitioners from the land.ST Oct 4, 1877STST Apr 2, 1912 His request is witchcraft and necromancy, turning from seeking the Lord to seeking counsel from the dead through intercourse with Satan and evil angels forbidden by God on pain of death.ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 6, 1880ST Jun 3, 1889 What follows is not Samuel raised but Satan or a fallen angel impersonating him in form, voice and mantle so perfectly that Saul is deceived, for the dead know nothing and remain unconscious until the resurrection.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Sep 16, 1930RH Feb 4, 1909RH Apr 7, 1874ST Dec 11, 1884 The consultation is thus an ancient spiritualistic seance exposing modern spiritualism as the same deception rooted in the lie that the dead live and know, warning to seek God and His word and not mediums.ST May 17, 1905RH Feb 24, 1859ST Jan 9, 1893RH Jul 21, 1853
Words and Historical Setting
Saul asked his servants to seek out for him a woman who had a familiar spirit, so that he might go to her and inquire of her, and they answered him that there was such a woman at Endor.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Nov 4, 1889RH Jan 3, 1865ST Dec 11, 1884ST May 17, 1905 His request came after the Lord no longer answered him, and it marked his resort to forbidden consultation with a medium in fear of the Philistines rather than true communication with the dead.ST Dec 13, 1905RH Jan 3, 1865ST Dec 11, 1884ST May 17, 1905ST Feb 1, 1905 The incident belongs to the account of his visit to the woman and raises whether the dead take conscious part in earthly affairs, and it is presented as an Old Testament example of a spiritualistic séance.ST Dec 11, 1884ST May 17, 1905
He asked in the extremity of war, when the Philistines were pitched at Shunem against Israel at Gilboa, and he was afraid with his heart greatly trembling.RH Jul 30, 1872RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 28, 1852ST Feb 9, 1915 In that distress, when he inquired of the Lord and the Lord answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets, he turned to seek a woman who claimed to communicate with the dead.RH Jul 30, 1872RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 28, 1852ST Feb 9, 1915 Remembering Samuel, his former counselor who was now dead and whom all Israel had lamented and buried in Ramah, and desiring information about the approaching battle rather than communion with God, he sought counsel through this forbidden channel.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jun 3, 1889ST Oct 21, 1930 His prayer went unanswered because he called through fear of being overpowered, and his resort brought him to the spiritualist counselor without her at first knowing she was in the presence of the king.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Feb 9, 1915
He asked only after the Lord refused him by dreams, by Urim and Thummim, and by prophets, following willful disobedience, rebellion, pride, jealousy, and selfishness that separated him from the divine will until the Spirit withdrew and left him forsaken and cast off.ST Oct 4, 1877STST Apr 2, 1912ST Oct 21, 1930 Samuel before his death would have nothing more to do with him, and God would have nothing more to say to him.ST Apr 2, 1912ST May 7, 1902 His attempt to consult the dead through witchcraft was intercourse with forbidden power and a turn away from God, not a source of guidance from Him.ST Oct 4, 1877STST Dec 8, 1909ST Feb 1, 1905ST Mar 11, 1908
Though when in better standing before God he had cut off wizards and those with familiar spirits and ordered practitioners driven from the land in obedience to the command, in desperation he turned to the very practice he had suppressed.RH Jul 30, 1872ST Apr 2, 1912ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 7, 1902ST May 13, 1880 A few devil-controlled practitioners still worked in caution and secrecy, and the woman at Endor practiced her calling in the most secret manner because she knew his decree and feared punishment unto death.ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 7, 1902ST May 13, 1880 Therefore he disguised himself and went secretly by night with two men, traveling ten miles, so that she would not fear to work for him, a fitting way and time to seek agents of darkness.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Jun 3, 1889ST May 7, 1902ST Jul 17, 1884 Suspecting a trap to put her to death, she hesitated, and he swore by the Lord that no punishment would come to her for doing the work.RH Oct 2, 1855ST May 7, 1902
The woman claimed she could bring up anyone the inquirer named and stood ready to enable conversation with the dead.ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 7, 1902RH Apr 7, 1868ST May 13, 1880RH Jan 3, 1865 She assumed, as mediums do, that she could bring up whomever a patron desired, and when pressed she consented to bring up by the evil power she possessed the one he would name.ST May 7, 1902ST May 13, 1880RH Jan 3, 1865 Such a person with a genuine familiar spirit was under the control and influence of demons, able to appear pleasant while lacking moral principle, and her influence led those who heeded her away from God.ST May 15, 1907ST May 13, 1880
Forbidden Sin of Witchcraft
A familiar spirit is a demon, an evil or unclean spirit, a malign spirit called in Scripture an angel of the devil, supposed to attend at the call of the one who has it and to work through the medium. ST Sep 25, 1907ST Sep 15, 1898ST May 15, 1907ST Dec 10, 1912ST Jul 17, 1879 Saul turned to such a woman only after the Lord had rejected him for his rebellious ways and would answer him not by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets. ST Sep 25, 1907ST Sep 15, 1898ST Jul 17, 1879 His asking his servants to find her and going to her for consolation and guidance was a turn from seeking the Lord to seeking and inquiring of an evil spirit instead of the Lord. ST Sep 25, 1907ST Sep 15, 1898ST May 15, 1907ST Jul 17, 1879 A person with a genuine familiar spirit is under the control and influence of demons, and such people can appear pleasant while lacking moral principle, with an influence that leads those who heed them away from God. ST May 15, 1907 Those who seek to familiar or evil spirits in these days never ask counsel of the Lord and have no reverence for His word, just as Saul did. ST Jul 17, 1879
His request was witchcraft, necromancy, sorcery, and enchantment: a pretended power to communicate with the dead in order to reveal future events and obtain knowledge, which is actually intercourse with Satan and evil angels. ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 6, 1880ST Jun 3, 1889RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854 The woman at Endor claimed she could bring up anyone the inquirer named, and divined by means of the familiar spirit, reflecting the belief of ancient necromancers that the dead live consciously and can communicate with the living, though the spirit working through her could only counterfeit the dead and had no power to raise them. ST Oct 4, 1877ST Jun 3, 1889RH Apr 7, 1874 With legions of fallen angels under Satan standing ready to give such communications and to seek human ruin, Saul did not converse with the real Samuel but with the familiar spirit speaking in Samuel's name and personating him exactly. RH Apr 7, 1874 This practice was strictly forbidden by the Lord as an abomination of the Canaanites, punishable by death and by being cut off, because the dead have no knowledge to impart. ST Jun 3, 1889RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854
Saul came to it in extremity, with the Philistines gathered at Shunem and Israel pitched at Gilboa, sore afraid with greatly trembling heart, and with the Lord answering him not by dream, by Urim, or by prophet. ST Oct 4, 1877ST Jun 3, 1889RH Apr 11, 1854 Remembering Samuel, his former counselor and adviser who was now dead, his belief gave way to the pretensions that he could consult Samuel in this way. ST Jun 3, 1889 Though in obedience to the command he himself had cut off practitioners out of the land, a few devil-controlled workers still operated in caution and secrecy, so in distress he disguised himself and went secretly by night with that secrecy that the woman, knowing his decree against witchcraft, would not fear to work for him. ST Jun 3, 1889 His words afterward show that the Lord had departed from him and was not answering him. RH Apr 11, 1854 The Satanic origin is proved by what followed, for the pretended Samuel first told the woman that her guest was Saul and next drove Saul to despair so that in battle he slew himself, which is Satan's usual method of first tempting men to presumption by telling them there is time enough yet and then driving them to despair by telling them it is too late. RH Apr 7, 1874
The verse marks his turn away from God to seek counsel from the dead, from Satan's power, from the devil and the Lord's enemies, through a forbidden channel instead of humble repentance. ST Sep 25, 1907ST Feb 1, 1905ST Apr 7, 1909ST Jul 17, 1884RH Jan 20, 1863 He went against God's express statute in fear after God's Spirit had departed from him, in contrast with Gideon's visit to the enemy camp at God's direction. ST Jul 17, 1884 As a backslider and rebel who had forsaken God, his wicked, perverted heart drove him to the witch, and although he received a revelation, God did not approve his method and the episode presents the practice as a turn away from God, not a source of guidance from Him. ST Feb 1, 1905ST Nov 27, 1879RH Jan 20, 1863 Christians have no right to consult familiar spirits. ST Nov 27, 1879
For this transgression Saul was deserted by God and permitted to be slain by the enemies of Israel, falling soon afterward in battle, because he asked counsel of one that had a familiar spirit and inquired not of the Lord. ST Sep 16, 1930RH Oct 28, 1852ST Jun 6, 1900RH Jul 14, 1863ST Sep 15, 1898 By willful disobedience he had lost his right to the throne and his privilege of calling upon the Lord as his helper, and it is a tragedy for a man who once rejoiced in the truth of God and was called a friend of God, once converted with another heart and counted among the prophets, to fall into sin and deliberately follow the way God calls an abomination. ST Sep 16, 1930ST When he was in touch with God he decreed the destruction of all who had familiar spirits, but after his sin and rejection of God he turned by night to counsel with the woman who claimed power to receive messages from the dead for the living, one of the practices of the former heathen dwellers of Canaan that made them abhorrent to God and was forbidden to Israel. ST Sep 16, 1930ST Jun 6, 1900 He did not commune with Samuel, for from the medium's description of an old man coming up covered with a mantle he only perceived it was Samuel, yet Samuel in heaven would not still be a bent old man in a mantle, nor be called up from the earth, nor be called up by a dissolute woman living contrary to God's law, nor be made to answer when God had refused to answer Saul; it was a fallen angel with whom he communed. ST Sep 16, 1930 Seeking after familiar spirits to obtain knowledge is strictly forbidden by God on pain of death, and the Lord was true to His word to set His face against and cut off the soul that turns after them, so Saul's resort to it ended in his destruction and he died for his transgression against the word of the Lord. RH Oct 28, 1852STRH Jul 14, 1863ST Sep 15, 1898
Apparition Was Not Samuel
What came up at Endor was not Samuel himself, and the event was no miracle and no resurrection from the dead.ST Nov 4, 1889RH Feb 4, 1909RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Dec 8, 1909 It was Satan or a fallen angel impersonating Samuel, counterfeiting his form and voice and mantle and knowledge so exactly that Saul was deceived.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Sep 16, 1930RH Feb 4, 1909RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854 The woman divined by means of the familiar spirit according to the ancient necromantic belief that the dead live consciously and can speak with the living, but her claim to bring up whomever was named and enable conversation was only pretense.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Dec 8, 1909 The familiar spirit had no power to raise Samuel, yet with legions of fallen angels under Satan standing ready to ruin men it could personate him perfectly and speak in his name.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Dec 8, 1909 Spiritists appeal to this case as Bible proof for messages from the spirit world, but Saul communed not with Samuel but with a pretended spirit of the dead.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Feb 4, 1909ST Dec 8, 1909
God had refused to answer Saul, and He would not then raise Samuel at the devil's bidding through an outlawed witch and a forbidden channel.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jul 30, 1872RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889 Samuel in heaven would not remain a bent old man in a mantle, come up from the earth, answer at the call of a dissolute woman living contrary to God's law, or give what God had withheld.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Apr 7, 1868 Only God has power to raise the dead, and no witch or medium can tread on that power to raise a corpse to speak or bring a spirit from above.RH Apr 7, 1868RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889 Saul himself did not see the figure but perceived it was Samuel from the woman's description of gods ascending and an old man covered with a mantle.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Aug 4, 1868RH Oct 2, 1855 Only the medium saw in the dark seance, while the familiar spirit did all the speaking and dead Samuel had nothing to say, so the claim of familiar spirits to be dead friends deserves no weight.RH Oct 2, 1855ST May 27, 1880ST May 20, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877 In those who held it as a witched hoax, only the witch saw and acted as a ventriloquist to do the talking and deceive him.RH Apr 7, 1868
Such deceptive appearances work either by taking living matter and materializing it into solid visible forms that afterward disappear, or by hypnotizing the beholder into believing he sees what is really not there.ST Dec 10, 1912 The narrative therefore reports what the onlooker seemed to see in language of appearance rather than affirming that Samuel was truly present.ST Dec 10, 1912ST May 20, 1908 The pretended Samuel revealed the disguised Saul to the woman, complained of being disquieted to be brought up, and piously regretted giving information God had withheld before giving it.ST Oct 21, 1930RH Apr 7, 1874 Its message mixed truth about Saul's danger with falsehood, predicting defeat and that Saul and his sons would be with him on the morrow.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Nov 4, 1889RH Aug 4, 1868ST Dec 5, 1892 That lying prediction stripped away his courage and hope so that the terror-stricken king fell prostrate fainting full length upon the ground, and by driving him to despair it put him one step from falling on his sword and led him in battle to slay himself, which is Satan's way of first tempting to presumption and then driving to despair.ST Oct 21, 1930RH Apr 7, 1874ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889 The prediction was wrong about the day, for Saul was still alive when that day passed.RH Aug 4, 1868ST Dec 5, 1892
State of the Dead
The dead know nothing and have no knowledge to impart, lying in silence with memory and sense gone, unknowing and unknown, having no share in anything done under the sun and no part in earthly affairs, held by death and darkness in an unconscious condition until Christ raises them at the resurrection.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Dec 11, 1884RH Apr 7, 1868ST Dec 27, 1905 Saul sought knowledge from the dead through the woman at Endor, a practice God emphatically forbade His people, and the woman divined by means of the familiar spirit according to the belief of ancient necromancers that the dead live consciously and can communicate with the living.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Oct 2, 1855 He did not converse with the real Samuel, for Samuel was dead and all Israel had lamented him and buried him in Ramah, and Samuel had no part in what happened.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Dec 11, 1884 What came was not the spirit of Samuel at all but a wicked, lying spirit impersonating him, the familiar spirit speaking in Samuel's name and doing all the speaking while dead Samuel had nothing to say.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Dec 27, 1905 The familiar spirit had no power to raise Samuel from the dead, for only God has power to raise the dead and no witch or spirit medium can tread on that power, raise a corpse to speak, or bring a spirit from above.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 7, 1868
It was able to personate him exactly, with legions of fallen angels under Satan seeking human ruin standing ready to give such communications, and the apparent speech of dead friends is the work of fallen angels counterfeiting them, since Satan can transform himself into an angel of light and will try to deceive even the very elect.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Dec 27, 1905 Its Satanic origin is proved by what followed, for the pretended Samuel first told the woman that her guest was Saul and next drove Saul to despair so that in battle he slew himself, which is Satan's usual method of first tempting men to presumption by telling them there is time enough yet and then driving them to despair by telling them it is too late.RH Apr 7, 1874 In one account what happened was a witched hoax played on Saul, with only the witch seeing and acting as a ventriloquist to do the talking and deceive him, and Saul could not forestall his Maker or get ahead of Prince Emmanuel in this way, for if witches could restore one to life they could raise ten thousand more, even bringing them back from hell to dwell on earth.RH Apr 7, 1868 Like all who died and were resurrected, Samuel said nothing of being conscious in death, and belief in the conscious state of the dead is the spring of almost every system of error, for the Lord does not want people to be so foolish as to ask questions of a dead man, nor so wicked as to ask them of Satan.ST Dec 27, 1905
The Endor episode does not prove that the soul is immortal or conscious between death and resurrection.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Jul 27, 1869ST May 8, 1879RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889 Some cite Saul's seeking a woman with a familiar spirit so he could go to her and inquire of her, after the Philistines pitched in Shunem and Saul was afraid and his heart greatly trembled and when Saul inquired of the Lord the Lord answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets, to prove the existence of the soul after death.RH Oct 2, 1855 Saul swore the woman no harm for doing the work, she asked whom shall I bring up, he said bring me up Samuel, she cried out when she saw Samuel and knew Saul had deceived her, she said she saw gods ascending out of the earth, described an old man coming up covered with a mantle, Saul perceived that it was Samuel, and Samuel is represented as saying Why hast thou disquieted me to bring me up and declaring Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines and to-morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me.RH Oct 2, 1855 In that account Samuel is represented as coming up from the grave bodily, being disturbed, and speaking to Saul, yet this does not show that Samuel's soul lived consciously while his body remained in the grave and does not establish that his soul lived and knew things while his body remained in the grave.RH Jul 27, 1869ST May 8, 1879 The episode is a deception by the devil, not a genuine calling up of the dead, but an instance of ancient sorcery and witchcraft, a deception by the devil in disguise, not evidence that the dead are immortal or conscious.RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889 An argument from it to support conscious existence is the same argument used to support modern spiritualism, and therefore makes its proponent a spiritualist in theory.RH Jul 15, 1862
The ancient deception portrayed the dead as coming from beneath the earth, where people then believed they dwelt, with Samuel represented as coming up bodily from the grave.RH Jul 27, 1869RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 3, 1889 The ancient deception presented the dead as rising from the earth, in keeping with the belief that they dwelt below, while modern spiritualism presents them as descending from upper spheres, in keeping with the belief that departed spirits dwell there.ST Jun 3, 1889 In Saul's time the practice was presented as raising a dead person, while later mediums claimed to consult departed souls, but the dead are not a source of knowledge and necromancy falsely attributes knowledge to them.RH Jul 30, 1872RH Oct 2, 1855 Both falsely attribute knowledge to the dead.ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855
The law of Moses forbade consulting the dead or holding converse with them, so Saul's act in seeking to converse with dead Samuel through the woman at Endor was a great and forbidden sin.ST Sep 22, 1881 If Moses had still been numbered with the dead when he appeared on the mount, Christ, who was under the authority of that law, would have been guilty of the same sin in conversing with dead Moses that Saul was guilty of in seeking to converse with dead Samuel, which is absurd and proves Moses was resurrected and not present as a disembodied dead man.ST Sep 22, 1881 Familiar spirits cannot bring up the dead because the keys of death are not in their hands but in the hands of Jesus Christ; only God has power to raise, and the Lord never gave a witch power to raise the dead.RH Apr 7, 1868ST May 7, 1902 The account beginning here is the Bible's extended specimen case of the work of familiar spirits, in which the spirit professed to bring up any of the dead who are called for and to enable them to speak, but the claim is a false pretense and the testimony of familiar spirits that they are the spirits of the dead therefore carries no weight, for the Bible exposes them all as wicked and deceitful. The case proves that familiar spirits do not come from the dead themselves and do not and cannot bring up any of the dead, because the dead are unconscious, know nothing, and cannot hold converse with the living. No dead person was brought up at the seance with the condemned witch hiding at Endor, for Satan knew what was going on and controlled the mind and speech of the woman he had overcome, deceiving Saul through her, and personated Samuel as he can personate any individual, and believing the word of God concerning the condition of the dead and heeding His warnings against Spiritism keeps from being deceived by that seance, which was recorded for learning and not for deception.ST May 7, 1902
Ancient and Modern Spiritualism
Saul's night journey to Endor was an Old Testament spiritualistic séance, an instance of ancient sorcery and necromancy forbidden in both Testaments.ST May 17, 1905 Consulting a familiar spirit there was the same practice as consulting the dead through spirit mediums, the same art as modern spiritualism.RH Feb 24, 1859ST May 6, 1880 The familiar spirit he sought sustains the very character of the low rapping, whispering, peeping communicating spirits that are almost always ready to communicate, especially with those entirely devoted to them, now seen in turning tables, traveling tables, self-moving chairs, raps, writings, and communications from the dead.RH Feb 24, 1859RH May 30, 1854 It is rooted in Satan's lie that death is only separation while the soul lives, thinks, remembers, and loves.RH May 30, 1854
Spiritists cite Saul and the witch of Endor as Bible proof for messages from the spirit world and for survival assuring resurrection, but that claim is a deception of the dragon.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jun 23, 1859AUST Jul 12, 1920 The account does not prove that she saw Samuel or that the dead communicate with the living; she lied about it, for God having refused to speak to Saul would not then communicate through an outlawed witch. Samuel in heaven would not still be a bent old man in a mantle, nor be called up from the earth, nor be called up by a dissolute woman living contrary to God's law, nor be made to answer when God had refused to answer Saul; it was a fallen angel with whom Saul communed.ST Sep 16, 1930 This solitary apparent communication belongs to the story of a disobedient king who by willful disobedience had lost his right to the throne and his privilege of calling upon the Lord, who meets a wicked end and paid the penalty for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, and it serves as a warning against spiritualism.ST Sep 16, 1930 To use it to support conscious survival makes its proponent a spiritualist in theory.RH Jul 15, 1862
The voices associated with Endor are lying and misleading, like the voices of spiritualistic mediums, clairvoyants, and fortune-tellers in modern times; they are a renewed form of sorcery, not a trustworthy source of truth.ST Jun 4, 1885 They are deceptive voices of evil spirits, not communication with the dead, a dangerous sorcery that misleads people and draws them away from God.RH Sep 7, 1911 Endor's spirit voices belong with the oracle at Ekron as ancient forms of spiritism, with modern counterparts in mediums, clairvoyants, fortune-tellers, and séances.ST Mar 24, 1887 Its counterpart today is also visionaries and somnambulists, pretended prophets and fortune-tellers, forebodings, presentiments and dreams treated as divine oracles, covert associations seeking hidden disclosures, and recourse to amulets and charms and sympathetic remedies for disease, refusing to submit the presentiment of the invisible world to the rule of Scripture and to seek satisfaction in the divinely revealed record and the sure word of prophecy.RH Dec 10, 1861
The account of Samuel and the witch of Endor gives Bible evidence on the source and character of spiritualism, showing Bible teaching and predictions fulfilled by Spiritualists.ST Mar 11, 1908 It is an instance of Spiritualism, a supernatural working and a great deception that the Bible addresses and prophecy examines in its present-day fulfillment.RH Feb 18, 1909 That same Endor spiritualism continues in the study of occult and psychic phenomena, the human soul, and new thought, and in scientific investigation of psycho-physical forces to prove the existence of the soul, putting so-called scientific investigation above Bible instruction even when it contradicts Scripture, with its modern home even in universities and halls of culture and reform, and such wisdom is devilish.RH Dec 21, 1905
The account beginning with the request for a woman with a familiar spirit is the Bible's extended specimen case of familiar spirits, exposing witchcraft as sin and revealing the state of the dead.RH Mar 10, 1868RH May 12, 1868RH Jun 2, 1868 It concerns the state of the dead and the sin of witchcraft, teaching that the dead have no knowledge to impart.RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jul 2, 1867RH Jul 9, 1867 It bears on the state of the dead and condemns consulting the dead through forbidden spirit consultation.
Warnings and Applications
Saul had once been converted and given another heart by God and counted among the prophets, yet he fell from grace until God departed from him and the Spirit of the Lord was altogether withdrawn from him.STST Jan 15, 1902ST After Samuel's death he was confronted by a Philistine army and was afraid, and he inquired of the Lord, but the Lord rejected him and answered him not by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets.ST Jan 15, 1902ST In defiance of God's express command he then sought a witch and took counsel of her, showing how far he had departed from God.STST Jan 15, 1902ST That intercourse with familiar spirits proves he had sinned away his day of grace so that he could not return and the Lord would have nothing more to do with him, and he died because of this sin in defeat of his army and by suicide to avoid falling into Philistine hands.STST Jan 15, 1902ST His life therefore refutes the dogma of once in grace always in grace, for only he that endures to the end shall be saved.STST
Saul stands as a man whose prayer God would not hear because he refused to walk in known duty and obey the law.ST Nov 15, 1905 By turning away his ear from hearing the law he placed himself where his prayer was an abomination to God.ST Nov 15, 1905 Obedience is the condition on which God answers prayer, and unwillingness to comply with the conditions is why many prayers are not answered.ST Nov 15, 1905
Instead of seeking information from a medium who professed to call up Samuel who was dead, people were to seek God.ST Jan 9, 1893RH Jul 21, 1853ST Nov 27, 1879 Saul's wicked, perverted heart drove him to the woman at Endor who consulted familiar spirits after God would not answer him by dreams, the Urim, or prophets, and although he received a revelation God did not approve his method and Christians have no right to consult familiar spirits.ST Jan 9, 1893RH Jul 21, 1853ST Nov 27, 1879 The appearance brought before him was a pretended communication with the dead and a work of Satan, for the communication did not come from the dead but from evil angels.RH Jul 21, 1853ST Sep 19, 1911 Such resort to mediums and occult sciences rests on the belief that the dead live and can communicate with the living, yet it shuts out God and His word because God's word condemns it, and it is of Satan the deceiver, one with modern spiritualism, hypnotism, and saint worship.RH Jul 21, 1853ST Sep 19, 1911ST Dec 19, 1892 The episode therefore warns against seeking guidance from spirits instead of God's word, especially after rejecting His ways and truth, and serves as a warning against seeking messages from departed people.RH Jul 21, 1853ST Sep 19, 1911
Saul gained nothing and lost everything by going to the witch, for his resort to the spirits failed to give him the comfort he sought and marked his final separation from the Lord.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Sep 16, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889 He wrongly believed the apparition was Samuel, but it was Satan impersonating Samuel, and its message mixed truth with falsehood, since Satan knew Saul's danger and used the prediction of defeat and death to strip away his courage and hope.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Sep 16, 1889 He returned to battle broken-hearted, and his last courage was that of despair before his death by his own hand, having followed disobedience with the next downward step of seeking the companionship of the witch instead of humble repentance and a plea for pardon while an evil spirit troubled him.ST Sep 16, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889RH Apr 16, 1867 His choice to seek a message through a medium, specifying that the medium must be a woman and later asking her to bring Samuel up, was a secretive, discrediting rejection of proper counsel, not a way to compel God to answer after other means of communication with God seemed closed to him.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889 Leaving his royal robes behind as if conscious of his degradation, he found her home in the back alleys of Endor where his own officers who had scoured the country for witches had failed to go, living in a stable with her calf, and upon the dirt floor of that hut in that unkept alley the stately king of Israel fell full length upon the ground as the last atom of his courage was taken away by the message he received.ST Sep 16, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889 That visit put him one step from falling upon his sword and meeting his end, and his later death by his own sword made his fate a warning to others not to forsake God, a tragic end for one once strong and noble who followed the medium's instruction to death.ST Sep 16, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889RH Apr 16, 1867ST
His long career is a record of how a once-humble servant of God became persistently wicked after power led him away from God, showing that what looks like blessing or advantage at first can become a curse.ST Sep 20, 1883 In his downward course of failure he asked for a woman with a familiar spirit so he could seek an answer from her, and his rise to kingship that had seemed good ended in seeking a woman with a familiar spirit when he faced difficulty.ST Sep 20, 1883ST Apr 11, 1911 After putting away wizards he traveled ten miles to consult a witch despite his professed piety, and his resort to her was superstition and disobedience, not a faithful response to God's silence.ST Jul 17, 1884RH Nov 2, 1905 His rebellion against God led him to seek help from the witch of Endor, turning to a necromancer when he was in distress after rejecting the Lord's counsel and after his apostasy had led God to refuse to speak to him.RH Nov 2, 1905ST Jan 21, 1889 His earlier opposition to such practices did not protect him once he had set himself against God, for wholehearted obedience is the only safe path and determined refusal of God's way leaves people vulnerable to spiritualism.ST Jul 17, 1884RH Nov 2, 1905
Sources