Translations
But (which becomes women professing godliness) with good works.
But ( which becometh women professing godliness) with good works.
but (which becometh women professing godliness) with good works.
But (which becometh women professing godliness) with good works.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
but ( which becometh women professing godliness) through good works.
but — which becometh women professing godly piety — through good works.
but, what becomes women making profession of the fear of God, by good works.
But, which becometh women promising godliness, through means of good works.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
but with good deeds, as is proper for women who profess to worship God.
but with good works, which is appropriate for women professing godliness.
But clothed with good works, as is right for women who are living in the fear of God.
But (as becommeth women that professe the feare of God) with good workes.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
But as it becometh women professing godliness, with good works.
Cross-references
- 1 Peter 3:3-4
Whose adorning let it not be that outward adorning of plaiting the hair, and of wearing of gold, or of putting on of apparel;
Both contrast outward adornment with godly character.
- Matthew 25:35-36
For I was an hungred, and ye gave me meat: I was thirsty, and ye gave me drink: I was a stranger, and ye took me in:
Feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, and caring for those in need are good works.
- Matthew 5:16
Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.
Good works make godly profession visible and lead others to glorify God.
- Titus 2:12-14
Teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world;
Godly conduct rejects worldly desires and is zealous for good works.
- 1 Peter 3:4
But let it be the hidden man of the heart, in that which is not corruptible, even the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price.
Godly adornment is associated with the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit.
- Titus 2:3
The aged women likewise, that they be in behaviour as becometh holiness, not false accusers, not given to much wine, teachers of good things;
Aged women are to teach what is good.
- Titus 2:10
Not purloining, but shewing all good fidelity; that they may adorn the doctrine of God our Saviour in all things.
both speak of adorning profession by conduct
- Romans 2:13
( For not the hearers of the law are just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified.
Both distinguish doing what is right from mere profession.
- 1 Peter 2:12
Having your conversation honest among the Gentiles: that, whereas they speak against you as evildoers, they may by your good works, which they shall behold, glorify God in the day of visitation.
Good works among others can lead them to glorify God.
- James 2:18
Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
Faith is shown through works.
- James 1:27
Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this, To visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to keep himself unspotted from the world.
Sincere religion is shown through practical care for others.
- James 1:25
But whoso looketh into the perfect law of liberty, and continueth therein, he being not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, this man shall be blessed in his deed.
Both connect professed godliness with doing good works.
- Romans 2:6
Who will render to every man according to his deeds:
Both connect deeds with judgment.
- 1 Peter 3:16
Having a good conscience; that, whereas they speak evil of you, as of evildoers, they may be ashamed that falsely accuse your good conversation in Christ.
Both commend good conduct in Christ.
- Matthew 6:1
Take heed that ye do not your alms before men, to be seen of them: otherwise ye have no reward of your Father which is in heaven.
Both warn against doing good works for human approval.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
67 sources
What becomes women who profess godliness is to be adorned with good works, meaning godly character and deeds rather than outward display.4T 630.2RH Jun 25, 1861SG4 225.1–2 In its setting this means modest clothing worn with reverence and self-control, not with elaborate braided hair or gold or pearls or costly array.SG4 225.1–21T 20.2–4RH Dec 12, 1912 It forbids extravagant and showy dress and ornaments that draw attention, and requires dress that is plain, simple, neat, clean, becoming and healthful, judged by Scripture and Christ's example rather than fashion.1T 20.2–4RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–103T 366.1 The true and costly adorning is inward, the hidden heart with a meek and quiet spirit shown in modest, reserved and chaste conduct, speech and deportment, and in a life filled with practical kindness.Ms 56, 1900, par. 13–14Lt 72, 1894, par. 18–20Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–272T 459.22T 455.3 Such good works mean strict economy and self-denial in dress to help the poor, relieve the needy and advance God's cause, giving a holy visible example that distinguishes His people, while luxurious display in the last days brings reproach, imperils salvation and will meet condemnation in the Judgment.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Dec 12, 1912ST Nov 28, 1878Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10RH Dec 1, 1910
Fitting Adornment Defined
What becomes women professing godliness is adornment with good works, meaning godly character and deeds rather than outward display.4T 630.2RH Jun 25, 1861SG4 225.1–21T 278.1MYP 354.3–355.2 That profession is shown through modest dress joined to good works, not through costly or showy adornment, for good works are what befit a profession of faith.RH Jun 25, 1861SG4 225.1–21T 278.1MYP 354.3–355.2Ms 24, 1904, par. 11–12 In context this is modest apparel worn with shamefacedness and sobriety, understood as reverence and self-control, and not with braided or broidered or plaited or elaborate hair, or gold, or pearls, or costly or expensive array and clothing.SG4 225.1–2RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1Ms 24, 1904, par. 11–12Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10 Display of vanity is contrary to following the meek and lowly Jesus, and devoting God-given time and means to decoration of the person is contrary to the spirit of the gospel, while humility and self-denial befit those whose sins cost the infinite sacrifice of the Son of God.1T 20.2–4 The Bible standard binds conscience even when older and experienced Christians openly disregard it, and professed Christians dare not follow worldlings in demoralizing fashions or appear to sanction them by adopting them.1T 20.2–4RH Dec 12, 1912 Those who adopt such fashions show that Christ is not formed within, and where God's ancient women covered the face with a veil in public, small bonnets exposing face and head, hoops, glittering gold rings, large showy earrings, artificial flowers, costly ribbons in bows and puffs, extra ornaments, useless trimmings, and extravagance to gratify pride show lack of modesty and must be laid off and discarded.1T 20.2–4RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10
Outward decoration with jewels and luxury and expensive ornaments adds no worth to character and no value to influence, and the idea that dressing as worldlings dress gives weight to influence must be put away.Ms 56, 1900, par. 13–14 Adorning the person with jewels and luxurious things is idolatry, revealing love for things supposed to give value to the person, giving evidence of a heart destitute of inward adornment, bearing the sign of inward poverty and lack of spirituality, and giving an incorrect representation of truth that should always appear as of highest value.Ms 56, 1900, par. 13–14Lt 72, 1894, par. 18–20Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 The nicety and exactness often given to outward appearance belongs far more to inward adorning, the hidden man of the heart in the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is of great price in the sight of God.Lt 72, 1894, par. 18–20 Value in the Lord's sight comes not from dress but from inward adorning, the graces of the Spirit, the kind word and thoughtful consideration for others, with meekness, humility, modesty, prudence, chaste simplicity, modest behavior, refined taste and a cultivated mind surrounding a young woman with a protective reserve.RH Dec 1, 1910ED 248.5MYP 360.1 Devoting much labor, time, and money merely to make outward appearance attractive diverts the mind from eternal consequence, leaves beautiful traits of character uncultivated, forms stumbling blocks, obscures vision so inner faults are not discerned, and is self-indulgence and self-pleasing gratifying pride and love of appearance and praise.RH Dec 12, 1912Lt 72, 1894, par. 18–20Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 The outside appearance testifies of the inward working of the heart, and truth received transforms mind and character into doers of the Word, distinct and separate from the world in dress, speech, and deportment, turning from worship of self and spending for self-gratification to self-denial, economy, and relieving the needy.Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27RH Dec 1, 1910
The verse belongs to Paul's instruction in 1 Timothy 2 to be received and obeyed as written, and placing oneself on the Lord's side under divine guidance to heed it is for present spiritual good and of great consequence to all who desire enlightenment.Lt 19, 1897, par. 22–23Ms 190, 1901, par. 2Ms 46, 1898, par. 22–25 It is joined with men praying everywhere lifting up holy hands without wrath and doubting, and women learning in silence with all subjection.Lt 19, 1897, par. 22–231T 506.1–507.4 This plain teaching condemns vanity, worldly fashion, frivolity, and self-pleasing, and requires holiness of heart and life, sobriety, devotion, and prayer.1T 506.1–507.4 It directs an aggressive work conducted on Bible principles with Christlike simplicity, patience, forbearance, and love for God and for souls, to convince and not to condemn, without coming down to the enemy's level or using satanic weapons, while uplifting Christ, exalting the law of God, and demonstrating faith as a power of which Christ is the Author.Ms 46, 1898, par. 22–25
Modest Dress Standard
The verse forbids extravagant and showy dress that imitates worldlings, including elaborate braided or broidered hair, glittering gold rings and chains, large showy gold earrings, pearls, artificial flowers, bonnets adorned for display, costly ribbons arranged in bows and puffs, hoops, gaudy lace, fantastic dress, and extra ornaments with useless trimmings and needless adornings that draw attention to gratify pride.1T 20.2–4RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1SG2 13.2Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10 Such display is contrary to modest apparel worn with shamefacedness and sobriety, and what becomes women professing godliness is adornment with good works rather than vanity, humility and self-denial rather than devoting God-given time and means to decoration of the person.1T 20.2–4RH Dec 12, 1912Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10 In the last days fashions are shameful and immodest, first brought in by those past feeling and given over to lasciviousness, and luxurious living and extravagant dressing carried to excess is one of the signs of the last days that no Christian can follow without imperiling salvation.RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1 The Bible standard binds conscience even when older devoted Christians dress that way and are taken into the church without reproof, and parents must see that God's directions are carried out rather than children's wishes, since loving dress and dressing children fashionably sows vanity for which God will hold parents accountable.1T 20.2–4SG2 13.2TEPD 13.2
It requires clothing that is plain and simple rather than patterned after worldly dress, neat and tasteful and carefully made of good, durable material as true economy, clean, orderly, becoming, and appropriate for age, without rich trimmings and unnecessary expense for self-gratification and fashion.Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10RH Dec 1, 1910MYP 358.2 Christian women are to avoid vanity and display by dressing plainly and abstaining from jewelry and other ornaments, adorning themselves in modest apparel with shamefacedness and sobriety and not with braided hair or gold or pearls or costly array or gay or expensive clothing, but with good works.3T 366.1RH Dec 1, 19103T 366.2 Untidiness, laxity, overdressing, and deformed lack of form are also contrary to it, and where reform dress is adopted it calls for uniform order and right length; value in the Lord's sight comes not from dress but from inward adorning, the graces of the Spirit, the kind word and thoughtful consideration for others.RH Dec 1, 1910STSE 36.2–37.1MYP 358.2
Dress is to be judged by Scripture and God's directions and by virtue and practical propriety rather than by fashion, pride, display, or the customs of a fashionable world, following Christ's meek and lowly example instead of thinking much of appearance and decorating mortal bodies.1T 20.2–4SG2 13.2Lt 10, 1888, par. 14–18TEPD 13.2TDR 10.2–11.1 This applies especially in the house of God, where delight in display of dress, show and love of dress, and following the fashions of a degenerate age to gratify pride are forbidden, while those who dress modestly have the blessing of God.Ms 17, 1897, par. 8–9 No single pattern is required, and customs in dress may be followed so far as they conform to health principles and to modesty, with dress plain and simple in good durable material appropriate for the age.Ms 167, 1897, par. 5–6 At the same time the dress question must not fill the mind nor be made an all-absorbing present truth and test that creates division and controversy, but believers are to walk carefully and circumspectly before God as a living illustration of inward grace under the discipline of the living oracles.Ms 167, 1897, par. 5–6
The verse is given to instruct God's people to keep a peculiar, holy character distinct from the world, maintaining modesty and a clear separation in dress, deportment and good works rather than sanctioning demoralizing fashions by adopting them.RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1SG4 193.1–194.1 As inhabitants of earth grow more corrupt the line of distinction between them and the Israel of God must be more plain, for if God's professed people had not departed from Him there would be a marked difference between their dress and that of the world.1T 188.3–189.1 It upholds the distinction between male and female dress, setting modest apparel and good works against costly adornment and against clothing that erases that distinction.HTL6 62.3–63.1RH Feb 6, 1900 It condemns extremes in fashion and shameful immodesty and exposure of face and head, in contrast to ancient women who covered their faces with a veil when in public, counting small bonnets exposing the face and head and hoops a shame and lack of modesty.1T 188.3–189.1CH 650.2–3
Godly Conduct Beyond Dress
What becomes women professing godliness is modest, reserved, sober and circumspect conduct, with chastity and virtue that set them apart from the sexual corruption around them and hold up a better example.2T 459.22T 455.2CH 659.1SA 51.1 That profession is to be made visible in restraint and modesty, with less boldness and less joking and jesting in one another's company, since such levity is unbecoming and grieves the Spirit of God.2T 455.3CH 615.2–616.1 Deportment is to be careful and circumspect and words select and well chosen, avoiding even the appearance of evil and reflecting grace.2T 455.2CH 615.2–616.1SA 51.1 The fitting marks are modesty and reserve with sobriety, meekness, kindness, humility and purity, while forwardness, excessive familiarity and coarse joking are unbecoming to godliness.CH 659.1CH 615.2–616.1
Speech and deportment are therefore to be without boldness, excessive familiarity, coarse joking and jesting, and without even the appearance of evil, reflecting grace and benefiting the church rather than hindering it.2T 455.32T 455.2CH 615.2–616.1Ms 18, 1868, par. 2 A woman professing godliness displays it through good works and a character marked by grace, meekness and dignity, so that her influence helps the church.CH 615.2–616.1Ms 18, 1868, par. 2
Profession alone does not prove purity or faithfulness, for even those serving in sacred things may be deeply corrupt.2T 478.1 Outward appearance testifies of the inward working of the heart, and clothing is to accord with the faith professed — modest and plain, without worldly adornment — lest it contradict a godly character or mislead others.Lt 7, 1894, par. 11–17Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 Truth received in the heart transforms mind and character and makes doers of the Word, distinct and separate from the world in dress, speech and deportment.Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 Pride budding and blossoming in apparel reveals the thoughts and interests of the heart and is idolatry in small as well as large matters, separating from God as did the golden calf, and the call is to self-denial and economy, turning from worship of self and spending for self-gratification to relieving the needy and suffering.Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27
A true lady in God's sight is known not by meeting the world's idea of a lady, nor by being merely an ornament, nor by spending time and strength for self-gratification, but by a life filled with good works.Ms 18, 1868, par. 2Lt 4, 1903, par. 14–15Lt 4a, 1902, par. 13–15 Godly women keep mind and heart on thoughts that strengthen purity and draw them into communion with God, and this guards them against being led astray by deceptive and seductive temptations.2T 456.2 That higher life uses physical, mental and moral powers in the Master's service to be a blessing to those around, including being a useful wife and mother and helping practically such as by personal activity to help a husband reduce family expenses, which alone brings real happiness.Lt 4a, 1902, par. 13–15 Young women professing godliness are to follow Christ in conduct and not encourage romantic attachments in ways that harm others or undermine their usefulness.Ms 18, 1868, par. 2Lt 34, 1876, par. 5
Economy for Benevolence
The fitting adornment for women professing godliness is good works expressed in strict economy and self-denial in dress, choosing plain, simple, durable clothing of good quality without rich trimmings, useless expense, extra ornaments, or extravagance to gratify pride.ST Nov 28, 1878Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10RH Dec 1, 1910 Costly or useless ornaments are to be laid aside, laid off and discarded, even sold, and the savings economized to help remove heavy debts on churches, to advance the cause of truth, to support missionary work, and to lay up treasure beside God's throne in heaven, which is well pleasing to God.ST Nov 28, 1878Ms 132, 1897, par. 7–10RH Dec 1, 19104T 645.4–646.2MYP 320.4–321.1 Dress remains neat and tasteful, of good material carefully made as true economy, without display for self-gratification and fashion, leaving more money and time to help others, including teaching poorer women to dress simply and tastefully.RH Dec 1, 1910MH 207.2–3 In the last days of probation this separation from the world in dress is urgent, for value in the Lord's sight comes not from dress but from inward adorning, the graces of the Spirit, the kind word and thoughtful consideration for others.RH Dec 1, 1910MH 207.2–3
Spending God's money and time on needless finery while the naked lack clothing and the hungry lack food withholds help from the poor and robs God's cause and its work of mercy and benevolence.RH Jul 13, 19164T 645.4–646.2MYP 320.4–321.1CH 648.3 Such outward decoration with jewels, expensive ornaments and luxurious display adds no worth to character and no value to influence, and the notion that dressing as worldlings dress gives weight to influence must be put away.Ms 56, 1900, par. 13–14 Devotion to extravagant dress diverts the mind from matters of eternal consequence, leaves the beautiful traits of character uncultivated, obscures vision so inner faults are not discerned, encourages pride and vanity, can stir lust, can stifle the desire to do good, forms stumbling blocks for self and others, and puts salvation in danger.Ms 56, 1900, par. 13–14Lt 72, 1894, par. 18–20RH Jul 13, 1916CH 648.1 Adorning the person in this way is idolatry and self-pleasing, love for things supposed to give value to the person, gratifying pride and love of appearance and praise, revealing inward poverty and lack of spirituality, separating the soul from God like the golden calf, and giving an incorrect representation of truth.Ms 56, 1900, par. 13–14Lt 72, 1894, par. 18–20Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 The outside appearance testifies of the inward working of the heart, so truth received transforms mind and character into distinct, separate doers of the Word in dress, speech and deportment, turning from worship of self and spending for self-gratification to relieving the needy and suffering in harmony with faith.Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27
The practical good works that befit the profession are relieving the suffering, clothing the naked, feeding the hungry, visiting the poor, comforting the discouraged, reading God's word to those who cannot read, telling the truth for this time to those who know it not, and faithful service and work for Christ rather than living for display and pleasure.RH Dec 1, 1910MH 207.2–3CH 648.3STSE 44.1 They include using modest means and personal effort to help others receive the message, putting away pride and ornaments, practicing self-denial, and cherishing love, piety and faith so their fruits appear in the life.STSE 44.1LS 169.1–3HSFM 293.3 A profession of godliness is thus shown through doing good, with money and time used for the needy and for gospel work instead of vanity.4T 645.4–646.2MYP 320.4–321.1
Witness Influence and Accountability
Adorning with good works gives a holy and visible example of inward grace that marks those who profess godliness as distinct from the world and represents Christ to others, drawing them toward truth.RH Jun 25, 1861SG4 193.1–194.1SG2 227.1–228.15T 130.21T 131.1–2 Modest, reserved and sober conduct, with chastity and virtue set apart from surrounding corruption, is itself part of that witness, while immodest display and levity bring reproach upon truth and spread among believers like leaven.RH Jun 25, 18612T 459.2Ms 17, 1897, par. 8–9 Plain dress without worldly fashion and display puts influence on Christ's side, and professed Sabbath-keepers are to choose modest apparel and live to God's glory so that dress and conduct distinguish them from the world.5T 130.21T 131.1–2
Parents must carry out God's directions for dress rather than the wishes of their children or the customs of a fashionable world, teaching modesty and godly character instead of sowing seeds of vanity by loving dress and dressing children fashionably, for which they will be held accountable.Lt 10, 1888, par. 14–18TEPD 13.24T 72.2 Plain dress without useless ornamentation or display, with cultivation of Christian graces rather than fostering love of dress in self or children, is what befits the profession.Lt 10, 1888, par. 14–184T 72.2 New converts must be taught that vanity and pride in dress are to be left behind, even when following the gospel requires a decided change, and apparel then bears witness that they are being purified from vanity and selfishness and are not idolaters.6T 96.16MR 161.1 In worship extravagant dress and outward display are contrary to inspired instruction, and dress and spirit should suit the holy place, with the worshiper's unselfish life becoming a living message to others, though faith must be supported by corresponding works that have no merit of themselves, since credit belongs to God when His Spirit works in the obedient.Ms 23, 1886, par. 17
Neat, orderly and refined dress and deportment suit worship and shape the impressions made on unbelievers and youth.STBk 131.42MR 2.25T 498.2 Clothing should be neat, clean, plain and simple without unnecessary adornment, with even garments touching the skin kept clean and free from offensive odor, helping keep thoughts pure.STBk 131.4 Fantastic dress, gold chains, gaudy lace, excessive trimmings, ornaments and worldly fashions that attract attention profane the house of God and show poor judgment and pride, and delighting in display of dress there to gratify pride by following the fashions of a degenerate age is contrary to modest apparel.Ms 17, 1897, par. 8–92MR 2.2Ms 23, 1886, par. 17 Costly fashionable clothing spends God's money that should be invested in good works and missionary work to carry truth to the perishing and teach them to be clothed with the righteousness of Christ, and those with great light who continue in it rob God's cause of means needed for present and eternal good and separate their souls from God under the eye of the holy Watcher who traces what their means might have done to His glory.Ms 17, 1897, par. 8–9 Those who dress modestly have God's blessing, while immodest display surrounds the soul with an atmosphere that is spiritual malaria to others coming into the faith, and the leaven of pride and extravagance spreads until the whole lump is leavened, ceasing only when those whose names are on the church books are converted.Ms 17, 1897, par. 8–9
Luxurious living and extravagant dressing carried to excess are among the signs of the last days, and no Christian can conform to demoralizing fashions of the world without imperiling salvation, since adopting them shows Christ is not formed within and appears to sanction what professed Christians dare not follow.RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.1RH Dec 1, 1910 The plain teaching to adorn with modest apparel worn with shamefacedness and sobriety rather than braided hair or gold or pearls or costly array, with men praying everywhere lifting holy hands without wrath and doubting, requires holiness of heart and life, sobriety, devotion and prayer, condemns vanity, worldly fashion, frivolity and self-pleasing, and in the Judgment will condemn those who have not heeded it.RH Dec 12, 19121T 188.3–189.11T 506.1–507.4 Pride and vanity that look into the mirror to admire self leave little inclination to look into God's law, and this idolatry of dress destroys what is humble and meek and lovely in character, consumes precious hours that should be given to meditation, searching of heart and prayerful study of God's Word, and obscures vision of inner faults.RH Dec 12, 1912Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 Outward appearance testifies of the inward working of the heart, and truth received transforms mind and character into doers of the Word who are distinct and separate from the world in dress, speech and deportment, with zeal according to knowledge.1T 188.3–189.1Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27 Pride budding and blossoming in apparel reveals the thoughts and interests of the heart and is idolatry in small as well as large matters, like the golden calf, separating from God, while showy extravagant dress encourages pride and vanity, can stir lust and can stifle the desire to do good.Ms 52, 1898, par. 23–27CH 648.1 Where ancient godly women covered their faces with a veil in public, small bonnets exposing face and head and hoops now show lack of modesty and shame, and as the earth grows more corrupt the line of distinction between the world and God's Israel must grow more plain, lest the curse falling on worldlings fall on God's professed people who have departed from Him.1T 188.3–189.1 In the last days of probation those professing godliness must come out and be separate in dress, with neat tasteful clothing of good material carefully made as true economy but without rich trimmings and needless expense for self-gratification, valuing inward adorning, the graces of the Spirit, the kind word and thoughtful consideration for others, and practicing strict economy and self-denial in clothing for self and children in order to bring means to God, lay up treasure beside His throne, advance His cause, relieve suffering, clothe the naked, feed the hungry and tell the truth for this time to those who know it not.RH Dec 1, 1910
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
106 sources
What becomes women professing godliness is adornment with good works rather than costly, showy outward adornment, requiring plain, modest, simple dress and conduct fitting that profession.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Jun 26, 1860CO 93.4 Modest apparel means modest, sober, simple, plain, neat, clean, orderly, tasteful, economical, healthful and appropriate, without display, extravagance, or copying extreme fashions that suggest immodesty.RH Dec 12, 1912ST Aug 12, 1886 It forbids wearing gold, pearls, precious stones, jewelry and costly array to display or beautify the person from pride, including ornament worn for show.RH Apr 18, 1912 The true adornment is inward character and a life of service — a meek and quiet spirit, humility, purity, holiness and beneficence to others — which is more beautiful than gold or costly array.RH Feb 19, 1867RH Aug 5, 1909ST Jun 25, 1894RH May 8, 1866 Costly apparel is directly opposite to good works, for what is laid out on personal dress is taken from clothing the naked, feeding the hungry, relieving suffering and advancing God's cause, so economy and self-denial in dress save means and time for mission.ST Nov 28, 1878RH Dec 1, 1910RH May 21, 1872ST Oct 15, 1885
Words and Immediate Context
Which becometh means what is fitting and proper for the profession, so that conduct and attire must match a profession of godliness.RH Apr 1, 1862RH Apr 1, 1862RH Jul 31, 1856 Christianity cannot be joined with immodesty, and modesty takes priority over display.RH Apr 1, 1862RH Apr 1, 1862 Good works are the best ornaments and are precious in God's sight, reflecting bashfulness and sobriety rather than desire to attract attention.RH Apr 1, 1862RH Jul 31, 1856 Such conduct and dress should be modest rather than gaudy, vain or costly, and should deny self and live consistently with professed faith.RH Apr 1, 1862ST May 20, 1886RH Jul 31, 1856 Living by what is professed shows sincerity and principle, while following forbidden worldly fashions contradicts the profession, and the holy example of righteous actions distinguishes from worldly ways and can influence others and the world for good.RH Jan 6, 1863ST May 20, 1886
Though addressed to women, the duty to profess godliness applies to men as well, and the principle of adornment with good works applies to men by parity of reason.RH Jul 10, 1855RH Sep 1, 1863 Women professing godliness are to be distinguished and known by good works rather than by outward show.RH Sep 1, 1863ST May 20, 1886 Pearls names a kind of precious stone then commonly used and stands for precious stones generally.RH Jul 10, 1855 The created place of gold and precious stones does not make every use right, and they must not be used in a manner God has forbidden.RH Jul 10, 1855RH Jul 10, 1855
Wearing diamonds and precious stones for self-glory perverts God's purpose, serving only fancy, vanity and love of display and glorifying the creature instead of God.RH Dec 15, 1910 Precious stones were the covering of Lucifer when he came from his Maker's hands that he might reflect the glory of God, so to wear them for self-glory is unbecoming to believers in Jesus Christ.RH Dec 15, 1910 What becometh women professing godliness is good works, not such wearing.RH Dec 15, 1910
The verse continues the preceding verse's call to modest apparel with shamefacedness and sobriety instead of broided hair, gold, pearls and costly array.RH May 22, 1866 Together they enjoin modest apparel and condemn pride and vanity in dress, with principles to be lived out against present foolish fashions.RH May 22, 1866 The verse belongs to Paul's instruction on men and women laboring and praying for the salvation of all, in connection with Adam and Eve and the fall.ST Feb 15, 1899 Within those surrounding instructions Paul calls for subjection and forbids a woman to teach or usurp authority over a man, which does not exclude women from speaking truth, praying, prophesying or teaching good things in appropriate ways.RH Dec 2, 1862
The verse belongs with Ephesians 5:22-33, 1 Corinthians 7:1-17, Colossians 3:18-19 and 1 Peter 3:1-7 for learning a wife's reverence for her husband.ST May 26, 1898 Reverence means fear in the sense of being in subjection and regarding the husband as head as fit in the Lord, with duty to God first but without stirring strife at home.ST May 26, 1898 When cited for plainness in dress and worship it does not itself specify those practices.RH Mar 14, 1871
The prohibition concerns wearing gold or other things for ornament or self-adornment from motive of display, not practical use.ST Aug 21, 1907 Useful items such as watches may be used without being worn as ornament, for motive and use matter.ST Aug 21, 1907 The fitting adornment of the Christian is character shown in good works rather than tawdry display, jewelry worn for adornment, or making outward appearance the adornment.ST Aug 21, 1907
Modest Dress Standard
The verse requires modest apparel worn with shamefacedness and sobriety, meaning dress that is modest, sober, simple, plain, neat, clean, orderly, tasteful, economical, healthful, comfortable, durable and appropriate.RH Dec 12, 1912ST Aug 12, 1886RH Apr 17, 1879ST Nov 18, 1880 Modest apparel is dress without singularity or conspicuousness of style or color that would strain natural modesty to put on, especially at first wearing or among plain and modest people.ST Aug 12, 1886 It does not lead a stranger to suppose the wearer wealthier in station or attainment than is true, for it is not modest to pass for what one is not.ST Aug 12, 1886 It is not calculated to suggest licentious thoughts in the beholder or to raise doubts about the chastity of the wearer, but keeps clear the line of distinction between chastity and unchastity and does not copy the extreme fashions by which lewd women advertise their vocation.ST Aug 12, 1886 Christians are to be as peculiar for modest dress as worldlings are for ornamenting their persons, and such modest apparel adorns the meek and quiet in spirit.RH Dec 12, 1912ST Aug 12, 1886
The standard lies between two extremes, well but plainly dressed, rejecting both neglectful, unclean, untidy and slovenly carelessness and vain extravagance.ST Jan 17, 1906RH Dec 31, 1861 Christian modesty does not require carelessness or untidiness, but cleanliness, order, good manners and courtesy are consistent with godliness.RH Dec 31, 1861 Clothing should serve covering, warmth, comfort, neatness, health, convenience, usefulness, economy and good taste rather than display, and simplicity keeps dress from occupying the wearer's mind or attracting others' attention, leaving time and effort for higher purposes.RH Jun 23, 1903RH Aug 14, 1900RH Jul 10, 1855 Apparel fitting the Christian calling is clean and plain, not expensive, showy or dictated by fashion, and modest, simple, neat, durable and appropriate dress is worn without allowing concern over dress to fill the mind.RH Aug 14, 1900RH Jul 10, 1855
Godliness requires coming out from the world and being separate, with a visible difference from the world in dress in keeping with a high and holy profession, not following the fashion-plate for admiration or conforming to demoralizing fashions.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Nov 17, 1904RH Jun 22, 1916RH Oct 14, 1915 Dress is to be with dignity and propriety, neat and tasteful, of good material carefully made as true economy, but without rich trimmings and unnecessary expense for self-gratification and fashion.RH Dec 1, 1910 It is not a plain style adopted only among Sabbath-keepers and abandoned for gaudy fashions elsewhere, for changing dress by occasion avoids the self-denial of consistent plainness and can deceive the church, the world or the wearer.RH Oct 27, 1859 Freedom from bondage to the fashion-plate and from all extravagance requires courage to be neat and comfortable in spite of fashion, instead of protesting a little and then buying the latest bonnet or longing for a neat, comfortable, short walking-suit without independence to order it.RH May 8, 1879 Each believer must examine whether holding steady in modest dress or growing more careless, for daily life preaches more loudly than words and the test of religion is possession not profession.RH Jun 22, 1916RH Oct 14, 1915
Applied, the verse excludes immodest exposure and body-distorting fashion, such as short sleeves, low necks, transparent bodices and gowns swathed about the figure with no petticoats to blur the outline, narrow skirts, peek-a-boo waists, hoop skirts, confining pull-backs, corsets and artificial hair additions, towering bonnets, chignons, swelling hoops, wisps of straw and peacock-like trains sweeping streets, with evening-party finery invented for the wealthy yet copied by the poor for church.RH Sep 23, 1858RH May 8, 1879RH Jun 18, 1867ST Jul 30, 1912RH Mar 31, 1868 Worshiping fashion that distorts the body is inconsistent with a profession of godliness, and fashion adopted merely to keep up appearances is immodest and conflicts with holiness, while clothing may serve health, comfort, economy or convenience.RH Sep 23, 1858RH Mar 31, 1868 Clothing that prevents kneeling to pray, hinders growth in grace, or offends modesty and virtue does not honor God.RH Oct 14, 1858 The reform dress is commended as avoiding the immodest exposure associated with hoop skirts.RH Jun 18, 1867
Finery God Forbids
The fitting adornment is a life of good works rather than outward display, rejecting braided and elaborate ornamental hairstyles, gold, pearls, diamonds and precious stones, silver jewelry, and costly array worn to display or beautify the person from pride.RH Feb 6, 1900RH Apr 18, 1912RH Apr 17, 1879 The prohibition expressly forbids the wearing of gold, even a plain ring as unnecessary and a harmful example, and it applies to a wedding ring when worn for ornament.RH Apr 18, 1912ST Jan 31, 1911RH Apr 17, 1879 It likewise forbids ornaments on dress, earrings, finger rings, bracelets, gold chains, and any kind of jewelry about the person, set against modest apparel with shamefacedness and sobriety and against dress that disregards the distinction between male and female clothing.RH Feb 6, 1900RH Apr 18, 1912RH Apr 17, 1879 Plain dress that is always clean and neat is required instead.RH Apr 17, 1879
Jewelry and needless trimming for show are forbidden, including rings, bracelets, gold chains and massive chains with gold watches, ear ornaments, glittering rings, studded ornaments, clasps on arms, and even bogus imitations, since vain love of ostentatious show is excluded.RH Apr 18, 1912RH Mar 21, 1907 Feathers and plumes, artificial flowers, ribbons, velvet bands, braids, embroidery, buttons, cording, flounces, loops and useless trimming are forbidden as self-indulgence that wounds the soul, wastes time and money, and cannot have blessing, for artificial flowers do not adorn godliness.RH Mar 21, 1907RH Nov 19, 1857RH Feb 13, 1872 A fashion is to be rejected when it adds nothing to feminine beauty or depends on cruelty to creatures. The true Christian ornament is a meek, godly life rather than flowers, jewels, or fine clothing, with believers pictured in plain, simple, pure white robes and good works for adornment.RH Nov 19, 1857RH Feb 6, 1913 To put off simplicity for costlier outward appearance to please worldly taste is to leave godliness and join the world, exchanging humility and purity for pride and display.RH Feb 6, 1913RH Feb 13, 1872
Costly, showy, elegant fashionable attire does not become godliness, such as rich velvets and silks, shining satins, roses and gems, pearls to wear, diamonds decking the hair, elaborate curls, swelling hoops, towering feathers, gaudy jewelry, gold and diamonds, and tinsel show fit for the stage or ballroom rather than daily life.RH Mar 21, 1907RH Feb 6, 1913RH Feb 6, 1866 Also forbidden are tight lacing, round tires and mincing walk, towering bonnets, wisps of straw, chignons, confining pull-backs, peacock-like trains sweeping streets and country roads, and evening-party finery invented for the wealthy yet copied by the poor for church.RH Mar 21, 1907RH May 8, 1879RH Aug 12, 1873 Freedom from bondage to the fashion-plate and from all extravagance requires courage to be neat and comfortable in spite of fashion instead of protesting a little and then buying the latest bonnet.RH May 8, 1879RH Feb 6, 1866 Hoops and unnecessary ornaments and artificial extras are to be set aside as contrary to the command and as signs of worldly influence in seeking to please God and overcome sin.RH Apr 28, 1863RH Aug 12, 1873
Turning worship into a dress parade for showing off spring fashions is condemned, and jewels with luxurious embroidered clothing are rebuked in the house of prayer, where plain, modest dress without conspicuous personal adornment is fitting.ST Jun 4, 1885RH Oct 2, 1855RH Apr 30, 1872RH Jan 16, 1872 Extravagant display and conspicuous adornment in ordinary dress, especially at church, are inconsistent with unobtrusive piety, do not show repentance, and do not remove frailty.RH Oct 2, 1855RH Apr 30, 1872RH Jan 16, 1872 Such outward adornment does not arise from love or fear of God or desire to do His will and does not foster a holy temper, but springs from nature and conformity to human will rather than grace.RH Jul 10, 1855 It weakens humility, seriousness and simplicity and a meek and quiet spirit by feeding pride and vanity and passions that disturb the soul and by seeking human approval.RH Jul 10, 1855 Using clothing and adornment to attract people is not a fitting expression of godliness.RH Jun 30, 1863
Good Works God Requires
The fitting adornment for godliness is good works understood as inward character rather than outward dress or display.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Jun 26, 1860CO 93.4RH Apr 22, 1862RH Aug 5, 1909 That character is a meek and quiet spirit with humility and true modesty, goodness and purity, a right heart shown in a kind word and thoughtful consideration.ST Jun 25, 1894ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jul 27, 1915ST Nov 4, 1880 Such inward beauty is more beautiful than gold, gems, or costly array, and a right heart is what makes a woman truly refined rather than costly dress, jewels, cosmetics, or other outward charms.RH Aug 5, 1909ST Jun 25, 1894ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jul 27, 1915ST Nov 4, 1880 Pure religion is like gold needing no added ornament, and it appears to best advantage and most inviting to true followers when plain and simple, with clothing serving comfort and neatness rather than pride or show.RH Aug 5, 1909RH May 8, 1866ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jul 27, 1915
Good works mean not living only for self but seeking to benefit others in a life of service.RH Feb 19, 1867RH Apr 2, 1908RH Mar 11, 1915 They are righteous actions, holiness, Christian restraint, and consistent conduct that matches the profession and can influence the world for good.RH Feb 19, 1867RH Jul 10, 1856RH Apr 2, 1908RH Mar 11, 1915 That conduct is to be marked by seriousness and visible holiness as not of the world, with pride in appearance turning attention to self rather than God.RH Feb 19, 1867RH Jul 10, 1856 When the heart is right the clothing will be right, for modest, simple, appropriate clothing reflects a refined and sanctified heart in which needless adornment has no place.ST Nov 13, 1879ST Jul 27, 1915ST Nov 4, 1880
Dress reveals the mind and heart as lettering shows through thin tissue, so that mind measures gold but gold cannot measure mind.RH Sep 5, 1912RH Oct 3, 1912RH Feb 6, 1866 Female loveliness appears to best advantage in simplicity, and a modest woman dresses modestly.RH Sep 5, 1912RH Oct 3, 1912RH Feb 6, 1866RH Sep 11, 1913 True refinement shows in careful selection and faultless taste, in neatness, modesty, purity, dignity and propriety, with modesty and refinement manifested in apparel as much as in speech and deportment.RH Sep 5, 1912RH Oct 3, 1912RH Feb 6, 1866RH Sep 11, 1913 That modesty belongs to a retiring nature that avoids becoming the cynosure of curious eyes and the subject of slighting remark by extremes such as narrow skirts, peek-a-boo waists, short sleeves and low necks.RH Sep 5, 1912RH Oct 3, 1912RH Sep 11, 1913 Plain suitable clothing can still be pretty when beauty is joined to usefulness and appropriateness, with adornment fittingly expressed in a pure heart and clean hands rather than profuse ornament.RH Oct 3, 1912RH Feb 6, 1866ST Jul 2, 1885
What becomes the profession is therefore adornment with good works rather than elaborate clothing and costly, showy outward adornment.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Jun 26, 1860CO 93.4RH Apr 22, 1862RH Aug 25, 1859 This requires plain and modest dress instead of decoration meant merely to adorn the self or foster pride, keeping dress, furnishings and outward adornment secondary to godly character.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Jun 26, 1860CO 93.4RH Jan 23, 1908 It means modest apparel with simplicity, sobriety and economy, avoiding needless ornaments and superfluities as proof that godliness and the proper use of time and means matter more than display.RH Jan 23, 1908RH Feb 19, 1867RH Aug 25, 1859 Such plain, modest, simple dress and conduct fitting the profession stands in contrast to worldly conformity and the goods of Babylon.RH Jun 25, 1861RH Jun 26, 1860CO 93.4RH Jan 23, 1908RH Apr 22, 1862
Stewardship for Mission
Costly apparel is directly opposite to adornment with good works, for the more is laid out on personal dress the less is left to clothe the naked, feed the hungry, lodge strangers, relieve the sick and those in prison, and lessen affliction.ST Oct 15, 1885 Every shilling saved from needless dress can be spent clothing the naked and relieving the necessities of the poor, so every shilling needlessly spent on dress is in effect stolen from God and the poor.ST Oct 15, 1885 Costly apparel and ornaments are bought not to please God but to please fancy and to gain admiration and applause, and buying what is not needed defrauds opportunities of doing good and disables the buyer from doing good with irreparable loss, since each shall receive reward according to labor.ST Oct 15, 1885
What becomes godliness is good works rather than costly or useless ornaments, so such adornments are to be laid aside and sold with the money given to support the cause of God, and means spent on jewelry and finery can instead relieve suffering and share the gospel.ST Nov 28, 1878RH May 21, 1872 Strict economy and self-denial in clothing for self and children, with dress neat and tasteful and of good material carefully made as true economy but without rich trimmings and unnecessary expense for self-gratification and fashion, saves means to bring to God, to lay up treasure beside His throne, to advance His cause, to relieve the suffering, clothe the naked, feed the hungry, and tell the truth for this time to those who know it not.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Apr 17, 1879 Self-denial in hats and in all apparel gives a satisfied conscience about dress and means more than leaving off plume, flower, or buckle, since a plain hat with abundant rich trimmings still lacks self-denial, and what is saved makes a covenant with God by sacrifice and puts one more mite into His cause when much means is needed.RH Apr 17, 1879RH Dec 7, 1911 Valuable ornaments and pretty and choice adornments are to be put away and worn no longer but turned to good use by giving them to the mission as the Spirit moves hearts to sacrifice, which is better use than buying ornaments and may exceed large public gifts, for modest apparel rather than costly display is pleasing to the Lord and time and money should be used to help His work and save souls.RH Dec 7, 1911RH Nov 16, 1911
Devotion to extravagant dress diverts means from mercy, benevolence, and God's work, and conformity to demoralizing worldly fashion imperils soul salvation, while spending lavishly on adornment and giving only a little to need conflicts with the profession of godliness.RH Dec 12, 1912RH Jul 13, 1916ST Mar 4, 1875 Pride and vanity shown in looking into the mirror to admire self leaves little inclination to look into the law of God, and this idolatry of dress destroys all that is humble and meek and lovely in character.RH Dec 12, 1912 It consumes precious hours that should be given to meditation and searching of heart and prayerful study of God's Word, calls away from excessive concern with appearance to spend more time studying the prophecies than adorning the body, and wastes God-given time in making and caring for trimmed garments that should be returned to God.RH Dec 12, 1912ST Oct 18, 1877RH Sep 3, 1901
Wealth does not excuse display for ornament from pride, since those with wealth are responsible for stewardship and example because poorer people may deprive themselves of necessities to imitate them and they must answer to God.RH Aug 12, 1873RH Feb 6, 1908 Advantages increase obligation, so those professing godliness who boast of superior culture, advantages, and improvements, heady and high-minded and censuring past generations while oblivious that the world stands on the eve of a crisis greater than any in the past, will be accountable for unimproved advantages in the Judgment.ST Jun 3, 1889 Christians should therefore not dress in a way that encourages others to spend on outward adornment when those means could be used more wisely.RH Aug 12, 1873RH Feb 6, 1908
Influence Warning and Application
Dress exerts an unconscious influence for good or evil, and the obligation presses most heavily on older and leading members whose example decides younger converts whether to lay aside jewelry and immodest fashions.RH Apr 18, 1912RH Oct 14, 1915RH Feb 19, 1867 A contrary example becomes a stumbling block, for when influential believers wear gold or even imitations of gold they encourage approval of ornamentation and lead the young and weak to follow.RH Apr 18, 1912RH Feb 19, 1867 Teachers and instructors, workers for God and those closely linked to them must therefore teach simplicity, propriety and dignity by example and not by precept alone.RH Apr 18, 1912RH Oct 14, 1915RH Jun 1, 1916 The baptismal covenant commits to simple attire and laying aside jewelry worn for adornment, and giving up gold, silver and other jewelry, including rings, bracelets and gold chains, is putting away worldliness in accepting the message.RH Apr 18, 1912RH May 30, 1907RH Dec 4, 1913
Consistent plainness commends the truth and gives a telling influence at which heaven rejoices, while plain distinction testifies to neighbors of genuineness and leads many to embrace truth.RH Jul 31, 1856RH Aug 7, 1855 Changing dress by occasion — plain only among Sabbath-keepers and gaudy elsewhere — avoids the self-denial of steady plainness and deceives church, world or wearer, reversing that influence.RH Oct 27, 1859RH Aug 7, 1855 Outward distinction in plain dress without useless ornaments helps keep from worldly companionship and its snares.RH Apr 16, 1901RH Aug 7, 1855ST Mar 3, 1887 Modest means joined to personal effort helps others receive truth, and in benevolent work among the poor, the outcast and the fallen, as in visiting a home for the fallen, simple dress leaves minds free to receive help instead of drawing eyes and thoughts to fashion and feeding the love of adornment that causes downfall.RH Jul 31, 1856RH Apr 16, 1901ST Mar 3, 1887
To put off simplicity for costlier outward appearance to please worldly taste is to leave godliness and join the world, exchanging humility and purity for pride and display in pearls, rich velvets and silks, shining satins, diamonds decking the hair, roses and gems, and elaborate curls.RH Dec 12, 1912RH Jul 13, 1916RH Feb 6, 1913 Luxurious living and extravagant dressing carried to excess is one of the signs of the last days, and no Christian can conform to demoralizing fashions without imperiling soul salvation.RH Dec 12, 1912RH Jul 13, 1916RH Feb 6, 1913 When outward adornment reflects vanity it must be given up for love of Christ above it, for extravagant and immodest fashion is contrary to the profession because it can encourage vice, exert an immoral effect, blunt modesty, break down barriers between virtue and licentiousness, and bring moral degradation.RH Dec 12, 1912STRH Apr 24, 1913ST Sep 27, 1910 Pride and vanity in the mirror leave little inclination to look into God's law, and this idolatry of dress destroys all that is humble, meek and lovely in character while consuming hours that should be given to meditation, searching of heart and prayerful study of the Word.RH Dec 12, 1912RH Jul 13, 1916
The call reaches parents not to provide fashionable adornments to make children look pleasing to the world at the cost of their spiritual welfare.RH Aug 19, 1858RH Jun 1, 1916 Plain suitable clothing for schoolgirls can still be pretty when beauty is joined to usefulness and appropriateness, with adornment in pure heart and clean hands rather than profuse ornament.RH Aug 19, 1858ST Jul 2, 1885 A nurse's dress is to be modest, plain, practical and hygienic, suited to service rather than chosen for display or to attract admiration.RH Jun 1, 1916RH Jul 16, 1914ST Jul 2, 1885 Missionary workers are to avoid display so that example supports teaching, and the illustration of simpler dress joined to missionary and church work shows that religious activity must not lead to neglect of the husband.RH Jun 1, 1916RH Jul 16, 1914RH Oct 29, 1914 A mother's plain dress, freedom from display, humility, tireless unselfish care for family and life devoted to God illustrate godliness expressed in good works.RH Aug 19, 1858ST Feb 7, 1878RH Oct 29, 1914
Profession must become possession, for daily life preaches more loudly than words and the test is not profession but a life of good works declaring pilgrims and strangers looking for a better country, without joining profession of the near coming of the Lord to worldliness.ST Oct 16, 1884RH Oct 14, 1915RH Oct 27, 1910 The change from sinner to child of God is apparent to all, in avoiding all appearance of evil, keeping Bible precepts, dressing plainly, and hating pride and vanity as what God hates.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Dec 9, 1880RH Oct 14, 1915 Conduct must be especially careful because carelessness harms character and religion, and the fitting spirit is modest and retiring, shaped by Christ's simplicity, dignity and propriety rather than display to win praise or conformity to fashion for fashion's sake.RH Jun 3, 1858RH Oct 14, 1915RH Oct 27, 1910 Wearing gold and costly apparel is contrary to New Testament instruction and grieves and drives away the Spirit, while simplicity in dress is joined to purity and spiritual power.ST Oct 16, 1884RH Oct 14, 1915
The dress standard is God's best, to be accepted gladly, freely and hopefully and not by compulsion, with each left free to reject His plan yet facing consequences.ST Jan 30, 1901ST Jul 24, 1879 Pleasing God and seeking eternal life calls for dressing simply and putting away useless ornaments and trimmings.ST Jan 30, 1901ST Jul 24, 1879 Clothing that prevents kneeling to pray, hinders growth in grace, or offends modesty and virtue does not honor God.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Oct 14, 1858
Sources