2 Corinthians 12:8
For this thing I besought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me.
Translations
For this thing I sought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
For this thing I besought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Concerning this thing I besought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me.
Concerning this thing thrice the Lord did I call upon, that it might depart from me,
For this I thrice besought the Lord that it might depart from me.
In this behalf, thrice, besought I, the Lord, that it might depart from me;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Three times I pleaded with the Lord to take it away from me.
Concerning this thing, I begged the Lord three times that it might depart from me.
And about this thing I made request to the Lord three times that it might be taken away from me.
For this thing I besought the Lord thrise, that it might depart from me.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For which thing thrice I besought the Lord, that it might depart from me.
Pictures


Cross-references
- Matthew 26:39-44
And he went a little further, and fell on his face, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me: nevertheless not as I will, but as thou wilt.
Both prayed repeatedly for suffering to be removed, yet submitted to God’s will.
- Luke 22:42
Saying, Father, if thou be willing, remove this cup from me: nevertheless not my will, but thine, be done.
Jesus submits his request for relief to God’s will.
- 2 Corinthians 12:2
I knew a man in Christ above fourteen years ago, ( whether in the body, I cannot tell; or whether out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth;) such an one caught up to the third heaven.
Describes Paul’s vision of being caught up to the third heaven.
- Deuteronomy 3:23-27
And I besought the LORD at that time, saying,
Moses pleaded for his request, but the Lord refused it.
- 1 John 5:14
And this is the confidence that we have in him, that, if we ask any thing according to his will, he heareth us:
Prayer is heard when it accords with God’s will.
- John 16:23-24
And in that day ye shall ask me nothing. Verily, verily, I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall ask the Father in my name, he will give it you.
Jesus promises that the Father will give what is asked in his name.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
5 sources
Paul earnestly besought the Lord three times that the thorn in his flesh might depart from him.Ms 49, 1903, par. 15ST Nov 18, 1903ST Aug 29, 187814MR 56.2–57.1 The thorn was a bodily affliction, identified as poor eyesight.14MR 56.2–57.1 The Lord did not remove the affliction but answered with sufficient grace to give strength to bear the trial.Ms 49, 1903, par. 15ST Nov 18, 190314MR 56.2–57.1 Paul therefore rejoiced in his weakness and infirmities because Christ's power rested upon him.Ms 49, 1903, par. 15ST Nov 18, 1903
A continuing, troubling affliction like this can deepen a person's sense of dependence on God.LS 262.1–263.1ST Aug 29, 1878 Such an affliction is to be borne without murmuring and with trust in God.LS 262.1–263.1ST Aug 29, 1878 A prayer for relief may be answered not with the requested removal or healing but with grace to endure.Ms 49, 1903, par. 15
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
60 sources
Paul pleaded earnestly three times for a specific affliction to be taken away from him.ST Nov 15, 1905RH Jul 13, 1916RH Jul 17, 1860 The affliction was a painful bodily infirmity, a messenger of Satan permitted to buffet him to keep him humble after the abundance of revelations.ST Feb 17, 1881RH Oct 3, 1871 The removal he asked for was not granted, but he was assured that divine grace was sufficient for him and that strength is made perfect in weakness.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Aug 18, 1863ST Feb 17, 1881 Prayer is therefore answered not always by taking suffering away but by giving grace to bear it and to triumph through it.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Nov 23, 1911RH Mar 18, 1862 The thorn thus became cause for rejoicing and glorying in infirmity, learning dependence on God and finding strength in weakness.ST Aug 23, 1899RH Jan 7, 1873RH Oct 28, 1858
Prayer Wording and Context
The verse records Paul bringing one particular, urgent need to the Lord and pleading earnestly three times, repeatedly, that it might depart.ST Nov 15, 1905RH Jul 13, 1916RH Jul 17, 1860RH Apr 16, 1857 It is definite, prevailing prayer for one specific thing — the removal of the thorn in the flesh, described as a messenger of Satan to buffet him — rather than praying only in general terms, and earnest occasional prayer in times of distress.RH Jul 17, 1860RH Apr 16, 1857 One such definite prayer is more effective than a hundred general ones, and God answered it specifically, not by removal but by giving grace, so that Paul triumphed in spite of his infirmity, even because of it.RH Jul 13, 1916
The verse belongs to Paul's account of his own labors and of the conflicts and sufferings he endured for Christ's sake, spoken about himself under urgent necessity.RH Nov 24, 1868ST Apr 26, 1883RH Feb 20, 1872 Such speaking about himself he calls foolish glorying, yet the account shows triumph through suffering.RH Nov 24, 1868 His glorying in infirmities did not mean exalting himself for the revelation given him, for the thorn was given to keep him from being exalted because of that revelation.RH Feb 20, 1872 It is a hard-won religious experience of confronting sin and human weakness and seeking strength beyond oneself, helping believers recognize Christ as Redeemer and Savior and not merely as an unselfish friend or martyr.ST Dec 5, 1878
Paul felt the bodily infirmity hindered his usefulness in God's work and his efforts to win souls, believing he could do better work for God without it.ST Nov 15, 1905RH Sep 28, 1911 Burdened by a severe affliction meaning impalement, worse than ordinary sickness and hindering his wonderful evangelistic work, he specially asked three times not to be handicapped in this wretched way.RH Dec 7, 1916 His physical weakness in Galatia did not prevent his work but became the occasion for preaching the gospel, showing that Christ could accomplish great work through human weakness.ST Nov 21, 1900 God knew the thorn was needed for Paul to work effectively, so He permitted it to remain to prevent Paul being spoiled by self-exaltation, comforting him that divine grace is sufficient and strength is made perfect in infirmity.RH Sep 28, 1911RH Dec 7, 1916
At first Paul did not see the necessity of the thorn and asked three times for its departure before he learned its purpose.RH Oct 28, 1858RH Apr 5, 1860 The thorn was a messenger from Satan to buffet him, a thorn in the flesh to pierce his pride lest he should be exalted above measure by the revelations of God.RH Oct 28, 1858RH Apr 5, 1860 God did not answer by removing the trial but by promising grace sufficient to sustain him in it.RH Oct 28, 1858RH Apr 5, 1860 Afterward Paul rejoiced in sufferings, gloried in tribulation and even in infirmities, knowing what they accomplish under God and that all things work together for good.RH Oct 28, 1858 The trial had to be learned as the way of salvation, the way through crucifixion and death with Christ to resurrection in His likeness, from earthly to heavenly, from flesh to spirit, from self to God.RH Oct 28, 1858RH Apr 5, 1860
Thorn and Its Purpose
The thing pleaded against was the thorn in the flesh, a messenger of Satan to buffet and afflict.ST Feb 17, 1881RH Oct 28, 1858RH Dec 7, 1916RH Oct 7, 1915 It was a bodily infirmity and physical weakness that pierced and wounded like thorns, described as impalement and worse than ordinary sickness.RH Feb 24, 1916RH Oct 3, 1871ST Nov 6, 1893RH Dec 7, 1916RH Nov 25, 1873 Its burden lay in severe physical suffering that hindered work, yet even that weakness in Galatia became the occasion for preaching the gospel.ST Nov 21, 1900RH Dec 7, 1916
The weight of testimony identifies the thorn as defective eyesight, and states that it was not sin.ST Jan 24, 1906ST Jun 19, 1907 Beside this stands the reading of those who understood the messenger of Satan as wicked suggestions, making the pleading an example of mourning before God over troubling thoughts and seeking deliverance from them.RH Dec 4, 1856
The infirmity was permitted to keep Paul from being exalted above measure because of the abundance of revelations after being caught up to the third heaven.ST Feb 17, 1881RH Oct 3, 1871RH Oct 28, 1858RH Jun 8, 1911 Without it pride would have spoiled him, and granting removal would have left him to be exalted and to lose the favor of God, so continued suffering in the flesh with God's favor was better than relief without it.RH Oct 3, 1871RH Dec 7, 1916 It remained by God's wisdom to teach humility and trust, to show Paul that he still needed spiritual growth and was not perfect, to make him effective in work, and to guard those with great spiritual gifts from spiritual pride and their need for careful oversight.RH Oct 3, 1871RH Sep 13, 1864RH Sep 28, 1911RH Jun 8, 1911 In this way the surrounding passage presents suffering as what can keep a person humble while God works to save them.RH Apr 5, 1860RH Feb 5, 1867
Grace Sufficient in Weakness
The threefold plea for the thorn to depart was not granted as asked, but the affliction was left unremoved and permitted to remain.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Aug 18, 1863RH Jan 7, 1873ST Nov 6, 1893ST Nov 10, 1914 The Lord did not take away the bodily infirmity, even though it was sought repeatedly and earnestly.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Aug 18, 1863ST Nov 6, 1893ST Nov 10, 1914RH Sep 10, 1903 This withholding was because He knows what is best, and the plea lacked the full submission of Not my will but Thine be done, like those of Moses and Elijah, so that denial brought a greater triumph through special grace.ST Nov 10, 1914RH Sep 10, 1903
Instead of removal came the answer that divine grace is sufficient and divine strength is made perfect in weakness, with grace given according to need for comfort under the trial.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Aug 18, 1863ST Feb 17, 1881RH May 1, 1866ST Nov 6, 1893 Christ's power was promised to rest upon the sufferer, so that glad acceptance of infirmities and other hardships for Christ's sake was possible because weakness became strength.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Aug 18, 1863ST Feb 17, 1881RH May 1, 1866RH Sep 23, 1909 Bodily weakness therefore did not hinder the work but allowed the answer to be received with glorying in infirmity and pleasure in hardship for Christ's sake.ST Feb 17, 1881RH May 1, 1866RH Sep 23, 1909
That continued weakness more fully revealed the strength of the great Deliverer working through the afflicted one.ST Nov 6, 1893 Enduring the affliction without relief was also needed so it could serve as an example to others, that Christ's power and sufficient grace might be more fully revealed in steadfast endurance.ST Nov 6, 1893RH Mar 23, 1905
A thorn endured with enabling grace is better than freedom from the thorn without grace.ST Mar 19, 1885 To keep the piercing affliction while receiving strength to bear it is the greater good, since grace in trial outweighs ease without it.ST Mar 19, 1885
The comforting assurance of sufficient grace given to Paul in his trial remains for believers today.ST Feb 21, 1878 That living word of comfort is more valuable than possessing even a physical fragment of the thorn itself.ST Feb 21, 1878
Lessons on Prayer
Prayer may be answered not by removing the trouble prayed about but by giving grace to bear it and to triumph in spite of it, even because of it.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Nov 23, 1911RH Mar 18, 1862 The thorn was not taken away after three earnest pleadings, yet sufficient grace was supplied and strength was made perfect in weakness, so that pleasure could then be taken in infirmities.RH Jul 13, 1916RH Nov 23, 1911RH Mar 18, 1862 Sincere prayer does not bind God to grant the request literally, and prayers for health, prosperity, healing and other earthly blessings must be made only if it be the Father's will, with submission in the words Not my will but Thine be done.RH Nov 1, 1853RH Sep 10, 1903RH Dec 7, 1916RH May 30, 1912 Like the pleas of Moses and Elijah, Paul's threefold asking for the thorn to be removed was not granted as asked because that submission was lacking, and instead of removal God gave special grace that brought a greater triumph.RH Nov 1, 1853RH Sep 10, 1903
Even the apostle and other consecrated and faithful servants were not freed from personal suffering or disease when they asked, for prayer does not promise relief from every hardship because suffering may serve God's glory.ST Sep 5, 1900ST Feb 11, 1886RH May 30, 1912 Recovery may still be prayed for while accepting that God's will may be otherwise, and Paul therefore rejoiced in infirmities that Christ's power might rest upon him.ST Feb 11, 1886 Denial of removal comes because God knows what is best and sees what lies ahead, seeing in wisdom another outcome as better, and the believer must accept His wisdom.RH Sep 13, 1864ST Nov 10, 1914RH Sep 2, 1902 The affliction remained by God's wisdom, perhaps to teach humility and trust, and its removal was not His will, so Paul was left to seek greater grace instead.RH Sep 13, 1864
A request may be denied even when God hears it, yet prayer still lifts the asker and brings strength to bear what lies ahead.RH Jan 9, 1913RH Dec 2, 1909 Through asking three times for the affliction to be removed without receiving that grant, Paul was led to submit to God's will and received abundant grace to sustain him in continuing weakness.RH Jan 9, 1913RH Dec 2, 1909 His three requests make the appeal an example of definite, prevailing, earnest occasional prayer in distress, bringing one particular urgent need to the Lord and naming one specific thing rather than praying only in general terms.RH Jul 17, 1860RH Apr 16, 1857 One such definite prayer is more effective than a hundred general ones, and God answered specifically by giving grace.
Prayer for healing should be joined with intelligent cooperation with God, use of nature's remedies, and putting away what is wrong.RH Dec 7, 1916 If the Lord does not deliver after all is done, the sufferer should cheerfully glory in infirmity, trusting that God gives all the health infinite wisdom sees will be made good use of in this life.RH Dec 7, 1916ST Feb 11, 1886 Retained infirmity He blesses to the good of the sufferer and to His work, making it a greater blessing than health when Christ's power rests upon the weak.RH Dec 7, 1916 Paul's denied prayer for the thorn to depart stands with Christ's unanswered prayer in the garden.RH Sep 2, 1902
Enduring Trials Faithfully
The unanswered prayer became victory, for the wounding trial that brings weakness is where divine strength is found, and weakness itself becomes cause for rejoicing and glorying, with wrong gladly suffered so that power may rest upon the believer, for when he is weak then he is strong.ST Aug 23, 1899RH Sep 23, 1909RH Mar 18, 1862 The thorn was left unremoved and sufficient grace promised instead to sustain in it, and afterward there was rejoicing in sufferings and glorying in tribulation and even in infirmities, with resigned trust that all things work together for good.RH Jan 7, 1873RH Oct 28, 1858RH Apr 5, 1860 That inward victory brought resolve to forsake sin and be true, to walk in good conscience, to crucify the flesh with its affections and lusts, and to live unto God and Christ, taking pleasure in infirmities, reproaches, necessities, persecutions and distresses for Christ's sake, after which all other victories were easy.RH Jan 7, 1873 Suffering is one of the strange ways to obtain rest, because God is with those who suffer.RH Nov 5, 1901
Affliction was necessary for Paul and is necessary for others also, so disciples trying to serve the Lord should not think to be exempt from suffering and trials.RH Nov 10, 1910 Persecution in all its forms is the appointed result of faithful godliness, and trials are as necessary to the perfection of faith as fire is to purifying gold, to be met with patience and rejoicing rather than murmuring. A troubling affliction deepens dependence on God and is to be borne without murmuring and with trust.LS 262.1–263.1ST Aug 29, 1878RH Nov 10, 1910 Believers cannot of themselves maintain union with God against the devil as a roaring lion seeking to devour, but by sufficient grace they can continue in the union, with grace to overcome temptation and sin and to strengthen for service.ST Feb 21, 1906
God may permit ill health to remain and will bless it to the sufferer's good and to His work.ST Jan 26, 1915RH Dec 7, 1916RH Apr 30, 1914ST Jul 13, 1915 He gives all the health infinite wisdom sees will be made good use of, and retained infirmity becomes a greater blessing than health when Christ's power rests upon the weak.RH Dec 7, 1916 He steps into life and puts His finger on what thwarts His purpose, stripping all self-energy and leaving weakness like Jacob's limp.RH May 27, 1902 The remaining limp is good when power rests upon the weak, for He does not want human strength but weakness emptied to be filled, and only helpless clinging to God gives power with God that brings power with men.RH May 27, 1902
Believers must learn the same lesson to embrace all inward and outward trials and crosses as from the hand of the heavenly Father, as the way of salvation through crucifixion and death with Christ to resurrection in His likeness, from earthly to heavenly, from flesh to spirit, from self to God.RH Oct 28, 1858RH Apr 5, 1860 Bearing thorns is learned in three stages: first to be pierced without losing patience, then to make the sting positively advantageous, then to rejoice in being pierced and wounded, which is the senior lesson learned when near graduation into glory.RH Nov 25, 1873 The thorn represents disciplinary trials like shipwreck and the small persistent annoyances of life, which keep people humble, watchful and prayerful and form Christian character.RH Nov 25, 1873 Pain may remain as a remedy removing pride and bringing healing, so asking for relief does not rule out accepting a burden as chastening, asking for strength to bear burdens and patience in trouble and faith through dark times, trusting God to guide the way and lead His people to Himself.RH Sep 2, 1862ST Jul 14, 1887ST Apr 14, 1909
Continued wearing pain makes more tender, more thoughtful of the infirmities of others, and more gentle in ministry.RH Sep 2, 1902 Many thorns in the flesh, trials and hindrances can be borne while grace helps keep temper in check and remain patient and cheerful, through genuine humble prayer and steadfast trust.ST Jun 9, 1881 By analogy a troublesome church member with contrariness tests patience and forbearance like the thorn in the flesh and may keep the pastor from becoming proud, with sufficient grace to sustain him.ST Nov 28, 1878 Changing churches does not necessarily remove such a recurring trial.ST Nov 28, 1878
Sources