Acts 1:6
When they therefore were come together, they asked of him, saying, Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?
Translations
When they therefore were come together, they asked of him, saying, Lord, will you at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
When they therefore were come together, they asked of him, saying, Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
They therefore, when they were come together, asked him, saying, Lord, dost thou at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?
They, therefore, indeed, having come together, were questioning him, saying, 'Lord, dost thou at this time restore the reign to Israel?'
They therefore, being come together, asked him saying, Lord, is it at this time that thou restorest the kingdom to Israel?
They, therefore, having come together, began to question him, saying—Lord! art thou at this time duly establishing the kingdom unto Israel?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
So when they came together, they asked Him, “ Lord, will You at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?”
Therefore, when they had come together, they asked him, “ Lord, are you now restoring the kingdom to Israel?”
So, when they were together, they said to him, Lord, will you at this time give back the kingdom to Israel?
When they therefore were come together, they asked of him, saying, Lord, wilt thou at this time restore the kingdome to Israel?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
They therefore who were come together, asked him, saying: Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?
Cross-references 20 of 42
- Acts 2:1-4
And when the day of Pentecost was fully come, they were all with one accord in one place.
The gathered disciples receive the promised Holy Spirit at Pentecost.
- Luke 24:49
And, behold, I send the promise of my Father upon you: but tarry ye in the city of Jerusalem, until ye be endued with power from on high.
Jesus tells the disciples to wait in Jerusalem for the promised power from on high.
- Luke 24:21
But we trusted that it had been he which should have redeemed Israel: and beside all this, to day is the third day since these things were done.
Both express the disciples’ disappointed hope that Jesus would redeem Israel.
- John 18:36
Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence.
Jesus says his kingdom is not of this world.
- Acts 1:11
Which also said, Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye gazing up into heaven? this same Jesus, which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come in like manner as ye have seen him go into heaven.
The angels answer the disciples’ expectation by promising Christ’s return as they saw him ascend.
- Luke 24:50-51
And he led them out as far as to Bethany, and he lifted up his hands, and blessed them.
Jesus blesses his disciples and is taken up into heaven.
- Luke 19:11-12
And as they heard these things, he added and spake a parable, because he was nigh to Jerusalem, and because they thought that the kingdom of God should immediately appear.
The parable corrects their expectation that the kingdom would appear immediately.
- Luke 1:32-33
He shall be great, and shall be called the Son of the Highest: and the Lord God shall give unto him the throne of his father David:
Jesus is promised David’s throne and an endless reign over Israel.
- Luke 22:18
For I say unto you, I will not drink of the fruit of the vine, until the kingdom of God shall come.
Jesus says God’s kingdom will come in the future.
- Daniel 2:44
And in the days of these kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed: and the kingdom shall not be left to other people, but it shall break in pieces and consume all these kingdoms, and it shall stand for ever.
God establishes his everlasting kingdom after the earthly kingdoms.
- 2 Samuel 7:12-16
And when thy days be fulfilled, and thou shalt sleep with thy fathers, I will set up thy seed after thee, which shall proceed out of thy bowels, and I will establish his kingdom.
God promises David an enduring throne through his offspring, grounding hope for Israel’s restored kingdom.
- Daniel 7:13-14
I saw in the night visions, and, behold, one like the Son of man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of days, and they brought him near before him.
The Son of man receives an everlasting kingdom from the Father, whose timing is reserved.
- Acts 1:12-14
Then returned they unto Jerusalem from the mount called Olivet, which is from Jerusalem a sabbath day’ s journey.
The disciples return after the ascension and wait together in prayer.
- Daniel 7:27
And the kingdom and dominion, and the greatness of the kingdom under the whole heaven, shall be given to the people of the saints of the most High, whose kingdom is an everlasting kingdom, and all dominions shall serve and obey him.
The kingdom under heaven is given to the saints as an everlasting kingdom.
- Acts 2:30
Therefore being a prophet, and knowing that God had sworn with an oath to him, that of the fruit of his loins, according to the flesh, he would raise up Christ to sit on his throne;
God’s oath to David is fulfilled as Christ rises to sit on David’s throne.
- John 14:3
And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you unto myself; that where I am, there ye may be also.
Jesus promises to return and receive his followers.
- Matthew 19:28
And Jesus said unto them, Verily I say unto you, That ye which have followed me, in the regeneration when the Son of man shall sit in the throne of his glory, ye also shall sit upon twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel.
Jesus promises the disciples thrones in the coming kingdom.
- Amos 9:11-12
In that day will I raise up the tabernacle of David that is fallen, and close up the breaches thereof; and I will raise up his ruins, and I will build it as in the days of old:
The restored kingdom is connected to the raising up of David’s fallen house.
- Mark 11:10
Blessed be the kingdom of our father David, that cometh in the name of the Lord: Hosanna in the highest.
The crowd welcomes the coming kingdom of David.
- Matthew 6:10
Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done in earth, as it is in heaven.
The petition for the kingdom to come names the kingdom the disciples ask about.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
41 sources
In His final conversation with the disciples before His ascension, after showing Himself alive for forty days and speaking of the kingdom of God and the coming baptism with the Holy Spirit, they gathered together and asked Him whether He would then restore the kingdom to Israel.RH Nov 11, 1902Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6Lt 336, 1906, par. 11–15 Even after all His teaching they still hoped He would immediately take David's throne at Jerusalem, overthrow Roman rule, restore Israel's political power, and give them places of worldly honor.Ms 35, 1891, par. 1–4Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13ST Nov 7, 1878AC1 3.13SP 263.3–264.1 He did not tell them when restoration would come, but said the times and seasons the Father has kept in His own authority are not for them to know.Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6ST Nov 7, 1878 Instead of answering their curiosity about timing He directed them to wait in Jerusalem for power from above and, when the Holy Spirit came upon them, to become His witnesses from Jerusalem through Judea and Samaria to the uttermost part of the earth.RH Jul 28, 1903Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21Lt 244a, 1906, par. 16–20Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13Lt 115, 1904, par. 11–15 His kingdom was not to be a temporal kingdom in this world, but a kingdom of righteousness and peace established in the hearts of men.AA 30.12SP 71.1DA 138.1–3
Setting and Wording
The question belongs to Christ's final conversation with the disciples before His ascension.RH Nov 11, 1902Lt 88a, 1895, par. 1–3Ms 61a, 1895, par. 2–3 He had shown Himself alive after His suffering by many proofs for forty days and spoken to them about the kingdom of God.Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6 He had commanded them not to leave Jerusalem but to wait for the promise of the Father and baptism with the Holy Spirit not many days hence.RH Nov 11, 1902Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6 After promising they would receive power when the Holy Spirit came upon them to be His witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and in Samaria and to the farthest parts of the earth, He was taken up and a cloud received Him out of their sight, with the promise that He will return in the same manner.Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6Lt 336, 1906, par. 11–15
The coming together describes the disciples gathered in Jerusalem waiting for the promised gift.AA 30.2ST Aug 20, 1894 Those identified as His disciples and associated with the apostles assembled there, put away their differences, and prayed together for the promised power that would equip them to preach the gospel to all nations.ST Aug 20, 1894 That gathering was part of a series of communions with the Saviour: being called up into the mount with Him, a night of communion with Him, the meeting on the mountain in Galilee, the parting scene upon Olivet with the angel's promise, and the days of prayer and communion in the upper chamber before mission and before the power and glory of Pentecost. This remaining in Jerusalem was for a time, not a permanent settlement, for Jerusalem was not meant to become the permanent center and persecution afterward scattered them to preach in other parts of the world.Ms 148, 1905, par. 6–7 In that setting the Spirit is God's gift to enlighten, convert, and sanctify, given in fulfillment of Christ's promise to send the Holy Spirit after His ascension.5MR 336.1–2
The phrase at this time asks about immediate timing, whether He would then restore the kingdom to Israel.Lt 336, 1906, par. 11–15Lt 93, 1892, par. 17–18Lt 115, 1904, par. 16–17 They wondered whether this restoration would happen then, even at the time they were to receive the Holy Spirit.Ms 35, 1891, par. 1–47RED 3.1–2 They expected the coming of the Holy Spirit to lead the Jewish people to accept Jesus, reflecting their renewed hope after His resurrection.7RED 3.1–2
After remaining in Jerusalem to wait for power from above and praying together for ten days, they received the Holy Spirit in answer to prayer, and Peter explained to the people what had happened.Ms 121, 1909, par. 6–8
Expected Earthly Kingdom
Even after they had been taught about God's kingdom, the disciples still expected a political restoration of the kingdom to Israel.Ms 35, 1891, par. 1–4Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13 They asked whether this restoration would happen at the time they were to receive the Holy Spirit, even as they were being prepared to receive the Spirit and carry the gospel to the world.Ms 35, 1891, par. 1–4Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13 Their question about Israel's restoration thus stood in contrast with their immediate calling to gospel witness.Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13
Their hope, revived after the resurrection, was that Jesus would take David's throne at Jerusalem and restore the kingdom to Israel.ST Nov 7, 1878AC1 3.13SP 263.3–264.17RED 3.1–2 They expected Him to establish a temporal kingdom there, to take kingly authority immediately, to overthrow Roman rule and drive out the Romans, to restore Israel's political power and universal dominion, and to give them positions of worldly honor.2SP 71.1DA 30.18MR 241.2–242.3 They wondered whether this restoration would happen then, expecting the coming of the Holy Spirit to lead the Jewish people to accept Jesus.7RED 3.1–2
Some in the crowd at His entry into Jerusalem thought Israel's emancipation was at hand and wondered if He would now restore the kingdom.7RED 3.1–2Ms 128, 1899, par. 4–5 This expectation reflected the Jews' longing under Roman oppression for a Messiah who would defeat their enemies and bring national deliverance rather than redemption from sin.DA 30.2–3DA 30.1 They read prophecies according to their own hopes, overlooking prophecies of Christ's humiliation at His first coming and misapplying prophecies of His glory at His second coming.DA 30.2–3 This misunderstanding helped prepare them to reject Him, and they reproved Him because He did not fulfill it.DA 30.18MR 241.2–242.3
He was not appointed to reign as an earthly monarch on David's throne, and His kingdom was not to be established as a temporal kingdom in this world.AA 30.12SP 71.1 He came in poverty and humility, and His kingdom is one of righteousness and peace established in people's hearts.DA 138.1–3 That was the kingdom He came to establish rather than the one they expected.2SP 71.1DA 138.1–3
Timing and Witness Commission
He did not tell them when the restoration would happen, but said that the times and seasons the Father has put in His own power and kept in His own authority are not for them to know, leaving their question further unexplained.Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6ST Nov 7, 18783SP 263.3–264.1 The Holy Spirit would illuminate their minds, help them understand the work before them, and lead them to continue the work He had left them and to understand and undertake what He directed.ST Nov 7, 18787RED 3.1–2
He redirected them away from curiosity and speculation about timing and unrevealed things toward their immediate calling and work.Lt 244a, 1906, par. 16–20Lt 115, 1904, par. 11–15Lt 218, 1906, par. 15–18Lt 93, 1892, par. 17–18Lt 115, 1904, par. 16–17 Instead of seeking knowledge of the Father's appointed times, they were to wait in Jerusalem for power from above through baptism with the Holy Spirit, receive power when the Holy Spirit came upon them, and become His witnesses.Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6Lt 336, 1906, par. 11–15Lt 93, 1892, par. 17–18
That witness commission was His special direction for proclaiming the gospel, beginning in Jerusalem and extending through Judea and Samaria to the uttermost part of the earth and to the farthest parts of the earth.RH Jul 28, 1903Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21Ms 77, 1909, par. 1–6Lt 336, 1906, par. 11–15 Their question about Israel's restoration thus stands in contrast with gospel witness as their immediate calling.Lt 93, 1892, par. 11–13 Failing to do what He instructed brings great loss.RH Jul 28, 1903
Curiosity about such matters can distract from relying on living faith and the promises of Scripture.Ms 73, 1910, par. 3 Believers must walk by faith and take God at His word rather than dwelling on time.Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21Ms 73, 1910, par. 3 They are to give themselves to the individual work of warning and saving souls near and far, since salvation was purchased at infinite cost.Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21
Waiting and Witnessing Today
Christ gave strict orders to tarry in Jerusalem until imbued with power from on high, which meant they were not authorized to preach a single discourse except under the influence of the Holy Spirit.Ms 23, 1899, par. 43–44RH Jun 3, 1902 Success was promised them only as they placed themselves under the bright beams of the Sun of Righteousness, so their work and its success depended on that influence.Ms 23, 1899, par. 43–44RH Jun 3, 1902
The same tarrying for the Holy Spirit is essential for the success of the worker today.Ms 23, 1899, par. 43–44 Ministers should stay until equipped for their work, trust God's promises, and seek qualification and endowment from God rather than looking to any living man.Lt 15, 1883, par. 6Lt 39a, 1887, par. 1–5 A man who feels no burden to search the Scriptures and pray for himself and would preach discourses taken from another man's pen and brains should not preach but tarry as they did.Lt 39a, 1887, par. 1–5 Without it sermonizing and theorizing leave the churches ready to die, while with it the truth becomes a power sanctifying the soul of the receiver.Ms 23, 1899, par. 43–44
Their coming together is the pattern of communion with God that came before going forth on mission and before the power and glory of Pentecost, part of a series of communions with the Saviour: being called up into the mount, a night of communion, the meeting on the mountain in Galilee, the parting scene upon Olivet with the angel's promise, and the days of prayer and communion in the upper chamber. Those associated with the apostles assembled in Jerusalem waiting for the promised gift, put away their differences, and united in prayer for the promised power that would equip them to preach the gospel to all nations.ST Aug 20, 1894 They sought power not merely for themselves but to carry the gospel to the whole world and save souls, and the Spirit was then poured out and thousands were converted.RH Nov 19, 1908 Their example calls for earnest, sustained prayer and the Spirit's guidance before making decisions on solemn matters.6MR 87.1–5 They came together before Pentecost to seek God in simple faith, true humility, firm dependence, and full surrender, asking in simplicity for the things they need, and this way of coming is the condition for God to cooperate fully with His people and work as the case requires.Ms 85, 1909, par. 13–14
Those who believe in Christ as personal Saviour and apply His declaration to themselves are His witnesses, joined to Him by living faith to proclaim His love and everlasting life to the whole world.Ms 198, 1898, par. 7–8 This lays solemn responsibility to do the individual work of warning and saving souls near and far rather than dwelling on time, since salvation was purchased at infinite cost.Ms 91, 1909, par. 16–21 The Spirit is God's gift to enlighten, convert, and sanctify, and believers are to trust this promise and seek His work.5MR 336.1–2 A mighty power is at work in the world and heaven cooperates with those who do the Lord's work.Ms 77, 1909, par. 7 Failing to do what He instructed brings great loss, and calls for being educated to believe God's Word and to show faith by works in practical godliness.RH Jul 28, 1903Lt 177, 1899, par. 5
Remaining in Jerusalem was for a time, not a permanent settlement, and Jerusalem was not meant to become the permanent center.Ms 148, 1905, par. 6–7 Their work there was to help those who had hesitated to act on received light to decide, and afterward they were to carry the gospel to other parts of the world.Ms 148, 1905, par. 6–7 Persecution scattered them to preach elsewhere.Ms 148, 1905, par. 6–7
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
93 sources
At his final gathering with the disciples forty days after his resurrection, before his ascension from the Mount of Olives, they asked him whether he would at that time restore the kingdom to Israel.GSAM 71.1ST May 11, 1915RH Nov 26, 1872ST Mar 23, 1882 They expected a temporal, political kingdom with Christ on David's throne at Jerusalem overthrowing Roman rule and exalting them to honored rank.ST Jul 13, 1915 Their question showed misunderstanding and forgetfulness of his teaching that his kingdom is not of this world and that no one knows the day or hour, with error of timing in expecting at his first advent what belongs to his return.ST Jun 2, 1914ST Jun 22, 1915 Those who held it teach that their belief that he would restore Israel's kingdom on David's throne agreed with Scripture and was left uncorrected for time and the Spirit to clarify.ST Mar 20, 1884RH Aug 26, 1862 He answered that the times and seasons are kept in the Father's own power and are not for them to know, so the time of the kingdom and second advent remains with the Father alone.RH Jul 28, 1903GSAM 71.1 Instead of fixing the time he directed them to wait in Jerusalem to be baptized with the Holy Spirit and receive power to be his witnesses to the uttermost part of the earth, for the kingdom had not yet been set up and will be established only when he returns in glory.RH Jul 28, 1903GSAM 71.1ST May 11, 1915ST Mar 10, 1887
Setting at the Ascension
The question was asked at Jesus' final gathering with his disciples before his ascension, forty days after his resurrection, when he instructed them to wait in Jerusalem for the Father's promise and for power to witness.ST May 11, 1915ST Apr 13, 1882ST Apr 15, 1889 That gathering took place on Thursday on the Mount of Olives toward Bethany, in the open air, with teaching and blessing, worship, and the presence of angels.RH Nov 26, 1872ST Apr 13, 1882ST Jun 7, 1905 It was the fourth meeting of the risen Jesus with his disciples recorded in Acts 1:3-11, his public ascension from Olivet distinct from an earlier ascension after the resurrection and before his invitation to Thomas to touch him.ST Jun 7, 1905ST Apr 15, 1889 It was a solemn assembly of believers and the last recorded appearance in Jerusalem and Bethany.RH Nov 26, 1872ST Mar 23, 1882
Though so religious in character, that ascension-day gathering did not make the day itself holy.RH Nov 26, 1872ST Mar 23, 1882RH Jun 19, 1856 Meeting with the disciples on a day did not establish it as a Sabbath or rest day, and the events give no support for Sunday sacredness or a first-day Sabbath.ST Apr 13, 1882ST Apr 15, 1889RH Jun 19, 1856 The forty days spent with the disciples after the resurrection ended with the ascension on Thursday, leaving ten days of earnest prayer before the day of Pentecost fifty days after the resurrection, so that two first-days fell after the ascension with Pentecost falling on the second.ST Apr 13, 1882ST Apr 15, 1889RH Mar 31, 1874
The verse stands in Acts chapter 1 within two promises, the promise of the Holy Spirit and the direct promise of Christ's second coming, and belongs to the opening section Acts 1:1 to 8:4 covering the early chapters through the work after Pentecost.ST Mar 15, 1910 There Christ gave the great gospel commission concerning power for gospel work, telling the disciples to wait for the promise of the Father heard from him, that John baptized with water but they would be baptized with the Holy Ghost not many days hence.ST May 22, 1901 After the Holy Ghost came upon them they would receive power to be witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and in Samaria and unto the uttermost part of the earth.ST Mar 15, 1910 About 120 disciples identified with the apostles were assembled together in Jerusalem in communion and prayer, having put away differences, waiting for the promised gift and preparing for power to preach the gospel to all nations.ST Aug 20, 1894ST May 11, 1915ST May 22, 1901
Ten days after this ascension, watched by the disciples, Jesus began his ministry in the true tabernacle in heaven of which the earthly temple was an exact pattern. Sending down the Holy Spirit upon the disciples on that very day at Pentecost was the sign that the way into the holiest of all was now made manifest. That manifestation superseded all Jewish earthly sacrifices and all priestly services on earth.
Disciples Question and Expectation
Even after they had come to understand from Scripture that Jesus had to die and rise, and after forty days of instruction about the kingdom of God, the disciples still asked whether he would at that time restore the kingdom to Israel, showing both uncertainty about timing and eagerness for Israel's deliverance.GSAM 71.1ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874RH Feb 11, 1873 They believed Israel had once possessed a kingdom and lost it in the days of Zedekiah, and that Christ as its rightful king would begin his reign by restoring it then.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874 Their question supports that the kingdom for which Christians pray had not been established at Christ's first advent and was still future, with its time kept by the Father within his own authority and identified with the second advent of the Son.GSAM 71.1ST Mar 10, 1887RH Feb 11, 1873 Jesus did not deny that the kingdom would be restored, but said its times and seasons belonged to the Father's authority and directed them instead to receive the Holy Spirit and witness throughout the world.GSAM 71.1ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859 They had not yet understood that the Son of man must go away and return before the kingdom is established, or that Israel's promised heirs are the children of the promise counted as the seed and not Israel according to the flesh, truths into which the Holy Spirit would guide them.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874
Their question expected a temporal, political kingdom in which Christ would take David's throne at Jerusalem, overthrow Roman rule, free the Jews, and rule a universal dominion that dethroned all earthly kings.ST Jul 13, 1915ST Nov 3, 1909ST Jul 14, 1898 They thought the promised power of the Holy Spirit meant he would soon restore Judah's throne and rule Israel as king, his resurrection having convinced them that nothing was beyond his power.ST Nov 3, 1909 They also looked for high rank and honored positions for themselves, determined by prior precedence, with selfish hopes focused on conquering by force as an earthly king's followers.ST Jul 14, 1898 From first to last he had protested that his kingdom was not of this world, yet the hope of a mighty temporal monarch was so general that in the very last meeting they still held it and looked upon Christ as a temporal king in place of a Saviour from sin.ST Jun 2, 1914ST Jul 13, 1915ST Jul 30, 1885 That mistaken idea of his kingdom and mission kept them focused on selfish hopes, left them unbenefited by his mission, prevented understanding of the gospel and the atonement through his blood, and left them not fully prepared for their work.ST Jul 13, 1915
They asked only when the restoration would happen, not whether it would happen or whether their view of its nature was correct.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Dec 11, 1893 Jesus' answer addressed timing alone, confirming that the time was appointed by the Father though not revealed to them, and did not imply that the restoration would never take place.ST Mar 13, 1884RH Oct 27, 1863 Their hope was grounded in the prophets' promises of restoration and in conviction from Jesus' teaching and miracles that he was the promised heir of David, the seed of David who would sit on his throne.RH Mar 25, 1875RH Mar 25, 1875 They believed the time of his coming was near and expected a literal kingdom like the one David had ruled, a real promise concerning Israel and not merely a kingdom beyond time and space in name only, which God's word could be trusted to accomplish.RH Mar 25, 1875RH Mar 25, 1875 Their cherished hope was delayed while the Gentiles repented.ST Dec 11, 1893
The question reflected misunderstanding and forgetfulness of his teaching that his kingdom is not of this world, that no one knew the day or hour, and that he must suffer, be handed to the Gentiles, be crucified, rise, go away, and return.ST Jun 2, 1914ST Jul 13, 1915ST Jul 30, 1885 They asked it even while he was speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God, expressing the mistaken idea that the kingdom of glory would be restored at his first advent as an earthly kingdom.ST Jun 2, 1914ST Jul 30, 1885 The resurrection without understanding of Moses and the prophets confirmed them in error, and they were not fully led into the truth until the Holy Spirit came at Pentecost to bring his words to remembrance, guide into truth, and fit them for witness.RH Dec 16, 1858 That false conception was a deception to subvert the apostolic church, and he answered the question by his ascension to heaven, with two shining angels declaring that this same Jesus would come again in like manner.ST Jun 2, 1914
Their belief that Jesus would restore Israel's kingdom by ruling on David's throne agreed with Scripture rather than reflecting error.ST Mar 20, 1884RH Aug 26, 1862 The promised throne of David is distinct from the Father's throne on which Christ now serves as priest-king, and Christ will occupy David's throne in the future, rule over Israel, and reign without end in fulfillment of God's oath to David.ST Mar 20, 1884 Jesus did not then correct this expectation, leaving mistaken ideas about timing or manner for time and the Spirit's teaching to clarify.RH Aug 26, 1862
Their error was one of timing and order, expecting the fulfillment too soon at the first advent and not distinguishing the prophecies of Christ's suffering first coming from those of his glorious second coming and reign.ST Jun 22, 1915ST Sep 16, 1889 Even after forty days speaking of the kingdom they still did not understand the times and seasons, thought the kingdom of God should immediately appear, hailed him as Son of David entering Jerusalem without realizing he would be condemned and crucified, were sad after his death though they had trusted he would redeem Israel because his suffering and entering into glory was still a mystery, and were hardly persuaded he was risen.ST Sep 16, 1889ST Nov 27, 1879 They joined together the destruction of the city and temple with Christ's coming and the end, so their joining things together and their expectations do not prove the true chronological relation or when events will happen.ST Sep 16, 1889ST Nov 27, 1879RH Oct 27, 1863 Their disappointment when he did not then restore the kingdom was not a reason to reject his Messiahship, for the mistake concerned timing, not the truth of the promised literal, visible restoration that would replace earthly kingdoms and fill the whole earth.ST Jun 22, 1915RH Oct 27, 1863
Israel and Kingdom Defined
The question about restoring the kingdom to Israel shows the disciples believed Israel had once possessed a kingdom and had lost it in the days of Zedekiah.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874 They understood Christ to be its rightful king who would begin his reign by restoring it at that time.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874 They had not yet grasped that the Son of man must go away to receive a kingdom and return before it would be established.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874RH Dec 18, 1855 His answer about times and seasons being in the Father's authority did not deny that restoration.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874
The kingdom is to be restored not to Israel according to the flesh but to the children of the promise counted as the seed.ST Jul 20, 1882RH Jun 2, 1859ST Dec 3, 1874 Israel primarily names a character, not a birth line, as Jacob was called Israel though Esau was not, though they were twin sons of the same parents.ST Mar 13, 1884 Not all descended from Israel are true Israel, and descent from Abraham alone does not make one an heir of Abraham's blessings.ST Mar 13, 1884 Though unbelieving nominal Israel was rejected, God's promises stand, for the promise of kingly glory came before the nation existed and could not be cancelled by rejecting some or all of the nation as a nation.ST Mar 13, 1884 The kingdom taken from those without fruit is given to a people bearing its fruits, that is to true Israel, the faithful overcomers, or spiritual Israel.ST Mar 13, 1884RH Feb 18, 1902
Those who held the other teaching held that even the eleven after the resurrection still held the erroneous idea of re-establishing the temporal kingdom of Israel according to the flesh for the natural seed of the Jews only.ST Apr 17, 1901RH Feb 18, 1902 The fact of the resurrection without understanding of Moses and the prophets confirmed them in that error until Pentecost enlightened them.ST Apr 17, 1901 That error illustrates how promises forfeited by natural Israel are to be fulfilled to spiritual Israel, and it is corrected only by studying Moses and the prophets as applied by the Lord himself.ST Apr 17, 1901RH Feb 18, 1902
The restoration of the kingdom to Israel, or to the Israel of God, is accomplished through Christ's work in humanity.ST Dec 7, 1904ST Nov 28, 1900 By taking human flesh, defeating the devil and sin, delivering people from sin's dominion and fear of death, he restores God's image in the soul.ST Dec 7, 1904ST Nov 28, 1900 This restoration begins as present righteousness and the divine life and power of righteousness in believers.ST Dec 7, 1904ST Nov 28, 1900 It culminates in the kingdom shared by God's people.ST Dec 7, 1904
The kingdom in view is real and literal, not a kingdom beyond time and space in name only.ST Mar 10, 1887RH Mar 25, 1875 It is Christ reigning on David's throne over the house of Jacob forever, the restored dominion of the earth made perfect and free from sin, when dominion is restored to God's people and the saints possess the earth.RH Dec 18, 1855ST Mar 20, 1884ST Mar 10, 1887 That throne of David is distinct from the Father's throne on which Christ now serves as priest-king, fulfilling God's oath to David when he occupies it in the future to rule without end.ST Mar 20, 1884 The disciples' belief that Jesus would so rule agreed with Scripture rather than reflecting error.ST Mar 20, 1884 It is also the government of heaven established before the world was, whose ministers of the gospel are its ambassadors, sustained by all heaven.RH May 25, 1905
The Jewish hope that the kingdom will be restored to Israel on earth still lives in Jerusalem.RH May 13, 1902 There Jews weep over the ruins of the temple and pray for God to come and restore the temple and deliver them from misery and oppression, while prosperous Jews also expect Christ to come and establish a kingdom on earth.RH May 13, 1902 That merely earthly expectation of deliverance from oppression and restoration to former blessings and its own land will end in disappointment.RH Dec 31, 1857RH May 13, 1902
Timing Reserved to Father
Jesus answered that the times and seasons are kept in the Father's own power and authority and are not for the disciples to know, placing the time of establishing the kingdom and the second advent of the Son at the Father's disclosure alone.RH Jul 28, 1903GSAM 71.1ST Mar 10, 1887ST Mar 13, 1884RH Feb 11, 1873 After they understood from Scripture that he had to die and rise and after asking whether he would at that time restore the kingdom to Israel, he reserved its time within his own authority and directed them instead to receive the Holy Spirit and witness throughout the world.RH Jul 28, 1903GSAM 71.1ST Mar 10, 1887 They asked only when the restoration would happen, not whether it would happen or whether their view of its nature was correct, and his reply addressed timing without correcting their view, confirming the time was appointed by the Father though not revealed to them and not implying the restoration would never take place.ST Mar 10, 1887ST Mar 13, 1884RH Feb 11, 1873 His departure was thus joined to his promised return in the same manner, with their question about the kingdom set alongside their immediate mission, and failing to do what he instructed brings great loss.RH Jul 28, 1903GSAM 71.1
Here know means to make known, for he was not authorized to reveal the times and seasons the Father had reserved, the issue being not whether he knew the time but whether he was authorized to make it known.RH Mar 13, 1856 Though born to be King, he waits for his Father's time to enter on his reign, going to his Father in heaven to receive the earthly kingdom and rule of the whole earth, and shortly after that coronation coming visibly to earth as King in power and great glory to get his subjects.RH Aug 24, 1916 He was not to become only a king of the Jews but to receive later a greater kingdom in heaven before returning to earth for its subjects, and the disciples did not know that his entering on his reign as King means the end of all earthly kingdoms.RH Aug 24, 1916 When he goes to receive his kingdom he ceases his ministry as Priest, which ends the gospel on earth and closes the door of mercy forever as suddenly as the closing of the ark's door in Noah's day, coming as a thief in the night.
The cleansing of the heavenly sanctuary and work of judgment began at the close of the 2,300 years in 1844, with his death on the cross at his first advent laying the foundation for the establishment of his kingdom and making salvation possible to all men.RH Nov 12, 1914 But when that judgment work ceases in heaven, when he closes his work as priest and begins his glorious reign as king, is not revealed and the exact time when he is to receive the kingdom is kept by the Father in his own power and is not made known.RH Nov 12, 1914 Of that day and hour no man knows, nor Jesus himself, nor the angels, nor God's people, until the Father announces it and its events begin to come to pass, some time before his personal advent to get his people. The verse therefore gives no basis for fixing the time of his standing up or the close of probation by the removal of Turkey's government to the Holy Land, since the time when he receives his kingdom from the Father is known only to the Father who has kept that time within his own authority.RH Oct 22, 1914RH Aug 31, 1916 Even when the foretold political sign occurs, it does not reveal the exact time of this event, so people must be ready and act without delay.RH Oct 22, 1914
The question and answer rebuke attempts to fix a time for his return and kingdom, since that date had not been revealed to them and setting dates was not for them to know.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Feb 4, 1889ST Dec 17, 1896 They could know when he was near, but they were not given those times, and their question came from a natural desire and human curiosity about matters that would do them no good, for knowing the time would not have helped them do their work.ST Sep 14, 1882ST Dec 27, 1905ST Dec 17, 1896 Their chief concern was knowing when his kingdom would be established and the kingdoms of the world would end, yet he redirected them from questions about timing to the work that had to be done before the kingdom was established.RH Sep 3, 1914RH Jan 23, 1913 Their longing could instead be met by the Spirit promised by the Father, exposing the mistake of continually putting time before work and consuming time and energy in theorizing over precise details instead of doing the work committed to them.RH Sep 3, 1914RH Jan 23, 1913ST Dec 17, 1896
Spirit Power and Worldwide Witness
Instead of answering about timing, Jesus told the gathered disciples to wait in Jerusalem for the promise of the Father which they had heard from him, that John baptized with water but they would be baptized with the Holy Ghost not many days hence, and that they would receive power after the Holy Ghost came upon them.RH Nov 11, 1902GSAM 71.1ST May 11, 1915ST Mar 15, 1910 The question whether the kingdom would at that time be restored to Israel was met with the statement that the times and seasons the Father had put in his own power were not for them to know, and with direction instead to receive the Spirit and witness for him throughout the world.RH Jul 28, 1903RH Nov 11, 1902GSAM 71.1 This exchange was his special direction for proclaiming the gospel, and failure to do what he instructed brings great loss.RH Jul 28, 1903
That power is a gift produced in believers by the Holy Ghost, whose attributes include love, and the promise is extended to all whom God calls.GSAM 71.1ST Mar 20, 1893 It would equip them to be his witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea, in Samaria, and to the uttermost part of the earth, from Jerusalem to the ends of the earth.RH Jul 28, 1903RH Nov 11, 1902ST Mar 15, 1910 The commission implied a work far beyond Jerusalem and Israel, redirecting a national expectation to a worldwide mission that must be accomplished before the kingdom is established.RH Jul 28, 1903GSAM 71.1ST Mar 15, 1910 A great work had to be accomplished first, beginning where the seeds of truth had already been sown among multitudes who had heard and believed but lacked courage to confess, which after the outpouring would blossom and ripen into fruit with courage and hope to proclaim a risen Saviour to the ends of the earth.ST Oct 14, 1889
He left their question further unexplained because the Holy Spirit would illuminate their minds, help them understand the work before them, bring his words back to their minds at the right time, and lead them to continue the work he had left them.ST Nov 7, 1878RH Jun 2, 1859 They had not yet understood that the Son of man must go away and return before the kingdom is established, and they would be guided into the truth about this by the Spirit, who would help them understand Scripture and proclaim the gospel intelligently.RH Jun 2, 1859ST Feb 13, 1896 They were not fully led into the truth until the Spirit came at Pentecost, which fitted them to understand and to proclaim with boldness, healing, tongues, and many conversions, after prayer and confession of sin had prepared them for power to speak with boldness and success.RH Dec 16, 1858RH Jan 19, 1911ST Feb 13, 1896 Even on ascension day they still expected a political kingdom despite teaching that his kingdom was not of this world, and they still hoped he would take David's throne at Jerusalem, showing they were not fully prepared for their work and had forgotten that no one knew the day or hour.ST Nov 7, 1878ST Feb 13, 1896
The power from on high comes from Christ, includes the presence of the Father and the Son, overcomes the world, and equips for witness to gather people for the kingdom rather than immediately becoming rulers.ST May 15, 1901ST May 15, 1901 Christ will establish a tangible kingdom on earth, not limited to the Jewish people, but citizenship requires the new birth, and promised positions and salvation depend on enduring to the end.ST May 15, 1901ST May 15, 1901 The role given was not to become rulers immediately but to share in the kingdom by receiving the Spirit of Christ who gave his life for sinners, and by seeking and saving the lost as subjects of the kingdom through witnessing to the truth throughout the world, with the qualifications and safeguards that important trust required.ST May 15, 1901ST May 15, 1901ST May 15, 1901
The question illustrates the mistake of expecting Christ to finish the work without the labor of his followers, since he answered that they, empowered by the Holy Spirit, were to do the work of witnessing.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Aug 22, 1912 It shows the early disciples continually putting time before work, with their chief thought even after the resurrection being just when he would change the existing order of things.RH Jan 23, 1913ST Jan 16, 1893 That directing of attention to timing to the exclusion of the work given to do consumes time and energy in theorizing over precise details instead of doing the work committed, representing a passive concern with timing contrasted with the active work of receiving power and bearing witness to the ends of the earth while being more concerned with knowing when the kingdom would be restored than with receiving the promised blessing.RH Jan 23, 1913RH Aug 22, 1912ST Jan 16, 1893
Future Kingdom and Present Duty
The question itself proves the kingdom had not yet been set up before the ascension, not at the crucifixion, during earthly ministry, or at the first advent, but remained future to be established when Christ returns.ST Mar 10, 1887RH Dec 10, 1857RH Mar 11, 1858RH Oct 31, 1854RH Dec 10, 1857 Just before being taken from them the disciples still expected restoration and asked whether it would happen at that time, confirming that the kingdom for which Christians pray was still future and its time kept by the Father within His own authority.ST Mar 10, 1887RH Mar 11, 1858RH Oct 31, 1854RH Dec 10, 1857RH Dec 23, 1852 That future setting up is when the saints enter the immortal state, when Daniel's prophecy is fulfilled, and when David's throne is restored at Jesus' return.RH Dec 10, 1857RH Mar 11, 1858RH Oct 31, 1854RH Dec 10, 1857RH Dec 23, 1852
Christ did not restore the kingdom at His first advent because His kingdom was not worldly, but He will receive it and sit on His throne in glory when He returns.ST Jul 30, 1885RH Dec 18, 1855ST Dec 7, 1904RH Oct 27, 1863ST Jun 2, 1914 He went away to receive a kingdom and return, and then dominion will be restored to God's people when the saints possess the earth.ST Jul 30, 1885RH Dec 18, 1855RH Oct 27, 1863 That kingdom will not be merely the gospel dispensation but a literal, visible rule that replaces the kingdoms of the earth and fills the whole earth, beginning as present righteousness in believers through defeating the devil and sin, delivering from sin's dominion, and restoring God's image, and culminating in the kingdom shared by God's people.RH Dec 18, 1855ST Dec 7, 1904RH Oct 27, 1863 Those who held the earthly expectation wrongly looked for Him to take earthly rule at the triumphal entry and at the first advent, and the crucifixion rebuked that view, leaving His earthly rule until He returns as He was seen ascending to heaven.ST Jul 30, 1885ST Jun 2, 1914
Jesus answered the question by His ascension itself, with two shining angels from His kingdom of glory declaring that this same Jesus would come again in like manner as He was seen going into heaven.GSAM 71.1ST Jun 2, 1914RH Sep 2, 1862 The departure was thus joined to the promised return in the same manner, exemplifying and teaching the fact and manner of His personal, literal second coming.GSAM 71.1ST Jun 2, 1914RH Sep 2, 1862 The question had been asked while He was speaking of things pertaining to the kingdom of God, expressing the mistaken idea that the kingdom of glory would come as an earthly kingdom at the first advent contrary to His declaration that His kingdom is not of this world, a false conception serving as Satan's deception to subvert the apostolic church.GSAM 71.1ST Jun 2, 1914
The disciples' intense hope that Jesus would redeem Israel, their great grief when His death shattered that expectation and laid Him in Joseph's tomb, and their disappointment on learning He was going to His Father with a long period of tribulation and anguish before them, parallel the Advent believers who expected Christ to come and establish His kingdom in 1844 and were disappointed when the time passed without His coming or the kingdom being restored.RH Jul 24, 1856RH Feb 6, 1855RH Jul 24, 1856GSAM 196.1RH Nov 19, 1872 Their mistaken expectation and misapplication of a divine message does not prove the message was not from God and God had ceased to guide His people.RH Feb 6, 1855RH Oct 11, 1915GSAM 196.1 Disappointment should lead to correcting errors, not to abandoning confidence in God.RH Feb 6, 1855RH Oct 11, 1915GSAM 196.1
Their preparation in coming together, putting away differences, confessing and forsaking sin, praying earnestly, waiting in consecration, and asking for the promised blessing is the model for those called to warn of the near advent and to receive the latter rain.RH Jan 19, 1911RH Oct 28, 1858ST Jan 28, 1903RH Jan 22, 1914RH Jul 6, 1911 Their prayer and confession preceded the promised descent of the Holy Spirit, and their delay in Jerusalem was not neglect of urgent need but preparation for effective service, since consecration joined with prayer brought the power of Pentecost.RH Jan 19, 1911ST Jul 12, 1905ST Jan 28, 1903 Earlier showers of blessing had revealed the risen Christ and filled them with joy and the message that He had risen, and then the refreshing at Pentecost enabled and fitted them to carry out the great commission, drawing hearers who sought salvation so that many were converted with boldness and success.RH Jan 19, 1911ST Jul 12, 1905RH Jul 6, 1911 Christians must first be made right with God so divine power can work through them, and ministers must represent present light with heaven's sustaining power.ST Jul 12, 1905ST Jan 28, 1903RH Jan 22, 1914
The verse exposes the delusion of seeking the kingdom through worldly power, civil law, political rule, voting, carnal warfare, or enforced worship.ST Sep 28, 1882ST Aug 20, 1894 The disciples still expected the Messiah to overthrow Roman rule, establish a temporal kingdom, rule the nations, and give them high rank, despite plain instruction, and this kept them from understanding Christ's mission and the true nature of His kingdom.ST Sep 28, 1882ST Aug 20, 1894ST May 15, 1901 The same desire for worldly power appears in religious leaders who seek civil laws to regulate religious duties and improve spiritual life, relying on earthly rulers for what only Heaven can give, and in the expectation of a Jewish racial kingdom restored in Palestine.ST Sep 28, 1882ST May 15, 1901 Wrong ideas about the kingdom contributed to the Jewish nation's downfall, and the idea that Christ's kingdom is to be established through political or national power has fostered persecution and tyranny and will have a final deceptive expression in a union of Catholicism and federated Protestantism.ST Aug 20, 1894
Even between the casting off of Israel as a nation when it was said Your house is left unto you desolate and the proclaiming of the new law on the day of Pentecost, the disciples asking earnestly about restoration were praying children of God and not children of the Devil, proving God still had a people on earth when the kingdom had not yet been established.RH Feb 28, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852 Their mistaken expectation about timing is an example of how the church's actions and disappointments can occur within the fulfillment of prophecy.RH Feb 28, 1854 Their misunderstanding of the event did not mean they had no part in fulfilling prophecy such as Zechariah 9:9.RH Feb 28, 1854RH Jun 10, 1852
The apostles had taken in the spirit of Jesus' teaching about the kingdom of God, and their question about its restoration to Israel reflects the kingdom as a central subject of His teaching.ST Dec 20, 1899RH Jan 9, 1913 Yet their dullness of apprehension after three years of discipline showed they could not take in the great scenes presented to them, so when about to leave them He bade them tarry in Jerusalem until imbued with power from on high before going forth to preach the truth of the kingdom of God.ST Dec 20, 1899RH Jan 9, 1913 Arguments however logical would not melt the hard heart or break through selfishness and worldliness; truth could only be effectual when coming from hearts made warm and lips made eloquent by a living knowledge of the Way, the Truth, and the Life.ST Dec 20, 1899RH Jan 9, 1913
Sources