Acts 15:2
When therefore Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them, should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.
Translations
When therefore Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them, should go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
When therefore Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them, should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.
When therefore Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain others of them, should go to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And when Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and questioning with them, the brethren appointed that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them, should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.
there having been, therefore, not a little dissension and disputation to Paul and Barnabas with them, they arranged for Paul and Barnabas, and certain others of them, to go up unto the apostles and elders to Jerusalem about this question,
A commotion therefore having taken place, and no small discussion on the part of Paul and Barnabas against them, they arranged that Paul and Barnabas, and certain others from amongst them, should go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question.
And, when Paul and Barnabas had had no little dissension and discussion with them, it was arranged that Paul and Barnabas and certain others from among them should go up unto the Apostles and Elders in Jerusalem concerning this question,
And after engaging these men in sharp debate, Paul and Barnabas were appointed, along with some other believers, to go up to Jerusalem to see the apostles and elders about this question.
Therefore after engaging these men in sharp debate, Paul and Barnabas were appointed, along with some other believers, to go up to Jerusalem to see the apostles and elders about this question.
Therefore when Paul and Barnabas had no small discord and discussion with them, they appointed Paul, Barnabas, and some others of them to go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question.
And after Paul and Barnabas had had no little argument and discussion with them, the brothers made a decision to send Paul and Barnabas and certain others of them to the Apostles and the rulers of the church at Jerusalem about this question.
And when there was great dissension, and disputation by Paul and Barnabas against them, they ordeyned that Paul and Barnabas, and certaine other of them, should goe vp to Hierusalem vnto the Apostles and Elders about this question.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And when Paul and Barnabas had no small contest with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain others of the other side, should go up to the apostles and priests to Jerusalem about this question.
Cross-references 20 of 42
- Acts 15:28-29
For it seemed good to the Holy Ghost, and to us, to lay upon you no greater burden than these necessary things;
The council gives its Spirit-guided decision and the requirements for Gentile believers.
- Galatians 2:1-5
Then fourteen years after I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, and took Titus with me also.
Paul recounts the Jerusalem discussion over requiring circumcision of Gentile believers.
- Acts 15:6
And the apostles and elders came together for to consider of this matter.
The apostles and elders gather to consider the disputed question.
- Galatians 1:7
Which is not another; but there be some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ.
The disputed teaching perverted the gospel of Christ.
- Acts 15:10
Now therefore why tempt ye God, to put a yoke upon the neck of the disciples, which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear?
Peter calls the disputed Mosaic requirements an unbearable yoke.
- Acts 15:24
Forasmuch as we have heard, that certain which went out from us have troubled you with words, subverting your souls, saying, Ye must be circumcised, and keep the law: to whom we gave no such commandment:
Jerusalem’s leaders deny authorizing the soul-subverting teaching that sparked the dispute.
- Acts 15:19-20
Wherefore my sentence is, that we trouble not them, which from among the Gentiles are turned to God:
The council answers the dispute by setting requirements for Gentile believers.
- Galatians 2:11-14
But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
Paul rebukes Peter for withdrawing from Gentile believers and pressuring them to live as Jews.
- Galatians 2:5
To whom we gave place by subjection, no, not for an hour; that the truth of the gospel might continue with you.
Paul refused to yield to the demand, to preserve the gospel’s truth.
- Acts 16:4
And as they went through the cities, they delivered them the decrees for to keep, that were ordained of the apostles and elders which were at Jerusalem.
Paul and his companions deliver the Jerusalem council’s decrees to the churches.
- Galatians 2:4
And that because of false brethren unawares brought in, who came in privily to spy out our liberty which we have in Christ Jesus, that they might bring us into bondage:
Describes the false brethren pressing circumcision on Gentile believers.
- Galatians 5:6
For in Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but faith which worketh by love.
Circumcision has no saving value; faith works through love.
- Acts 15:22
Then pleased it the apostles and elders, with the whole church, to send chosen men of their own company to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas; namely, Judas surnamed Barsabas, and Silas, chief men among the brethren:
The apostles, elders, and church jointly choose delegates to carry the council’s decision.
- Galatians 2:1
Then fourteen years after I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, and took Titus with me also.
Places Paul and Barnabas at the Jerusalem meeting fourteen years later.
- Acts 15:29
That ye abstain from meats offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication: from which if ye keep yourselves, ye shall do well. Fare ye well.
The council gives Gentile believers its requirements, including abstaining from blood.
- Galatians 2:6
But of these who seemed to be somewhat, ( whatsoever they were, it maketh no matter to me: God accepteth no man’s person:) for they who seemed to be somewhat in conference added nothing to me:
The Jerusalem leaders added nothing to Paul’s gospel.
- 1 Corinthians 7:19
Circumcision is nothing, and uncircumcision is nothing, but the keeping of the commandments of God.
Circumcision is nothing; keeping God’s commandments matters.
- Galatians 2:9
And when James, Cephas, and John, who seemed to be pillars, perceived the grace that was given unto me, they gave to me and Barnabas the right hands of fellowship; that we should go unto the heathen, and they unto the circumcision.
Jerusalem’s leaders recognize Paul and Barnabas and affirm their distinct fields of ministry.
- Acts 15:12
Then all the multitude kept silence, and gave audience to Barnabas and Paul, declaring what miracles and wonders God had wrought among the Gentiles by them.
The gathered multitude hears Paul and Barnabas report God’s work among the Gentiles.
- Galatians 5:2-4
Behold, I Paul say unto you, that if ye be circumcised, Christ shall profit you nothing.
Requiring circumcision for salvation makes Christ of no benefit and obligates one to the whole law.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
27 sources
At Antioch certain Jewish believers from Judea insisted that Gentile converts must be circumcised and keep the law of Moses in order to be saved, and this claim produced widespread contention and threatened division.AA 188.2–189.18RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4 Paul and Barnabas met the demand promptly and stood firmly against binding those Jewish rites upon Gentile Christians.AA 188.2–189.18RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4 To prevent continued debate from dividing the church, Antioch decided that Paul and Barnabas with other responsible men should go up to Jerusalem to lay the question before the apostles and elders in general council for a decision to be universally accepted.8RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 1879 That council rejected the requirement of circumcision and the ceremonial law for Gentiles by a decision sanctioned by the Holy Spirit, while Jewish converts who chose to observe those ordinances were left free to do so.ST May 1, 1884SLP 192.3–194.1AA 400.2–401.1 The sending of the question to Jerusalem shows the order that when a local church cannot agree, the matter is referred to a council of appointed delegates with the apostles and elders acting as counselors rather than rulers, so that scattered believers remain one united body.LS 406.3–407.1Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16AA 95.3–96.1
Dispute at Antioch
The dissension arose at Antioch in Syria, the field from which Paul and Barnabas had been sent forth and to which they returned from their missionary journey.AA 188.1 Upon their return they gathered the believers together and rehearsed all that God had wrought with them and how He had opened the door of faith unto the Gentiles.AA 188.1 That church was large and growing, a center of missionary activity and one of the most important companies of believers, composed of many classes of people from both Jews and Gentiles.AA 188.1
Into that church came certain Jewish believers from Judea, of the sect of the Pharisees, who asserted with great assurance that except Gentile believers were circumcised and kept the entire ceremonial law, the law of Moses, they could not be saved nor belong to the church of Christ.AA 188.2–189.18RED 26.1–2ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1SLP 63.1–2 Their claim produced widespread controversy at Antioch that grew into much discussion and contention and no small dissension.AA 188.2–189.18RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1 It brought consternation to the believing Gentiles, caused serious division, and threatened the unity of the church.AA 188.2–189.18RED 26.1–2ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1SLP 63.1–2 Many of the believing Jews at Antioch favored the position of the brethren newly come from Judea.AA 188.2–189.1
Paul and Barnabas met this false doctrine with promptness and stood firmly against the introduction of Jewish rites and ceremonies as conditions for Gentile Christians.AA 188.2–189.18RED 26.1–2ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1SLP 63.1–2 God had taught Paul that these unnecessary burdens were not to be bound upon the Gentiles, and his stand brought freedom to the churches from those rites.8RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1SLP 63.1–2 Human traditions and preferences must not take the place of revealed truth nor hinder the progress of the gospel.AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1
The demand sprang from the difficulty of Jewish believers in accepting that God was opening the gospel to the Gentiles without requiring them to adopt Jewish ceremonies.SLP 63.3–65.18RED 34.1 In Jerusalem Jewish exclusiveness was strong, with attachment to national privileges and traditions, jealousy toward Paul as one who weakened the obligation of the Jewish law, prejudice against him, and resistance to Christianity moving beyond the ceremonies and traditions of Judaism.SLP 209.2–210.28RED 34.1SLP 304.1–2 The dispute was part of Paul's defense of Christianity against the narrow restrictions of Judaism, carried on both at Antioch and at Jerusalem.SLP 209.2–210.2SLP 304.1–2 The Jewish Christians urged circumcision and the ceremonial law because they feared Gentile practices connected with idol offerings, blood and things strangled, and sexual immorality would bring dishonor upon Christianity and disrupt fellowship between Jewish and Gentile believers.SLP 65.2–66.23SP 372.1 They regarded circumcision and the keeping of the ceremonial law as tests of sincere conversion and as a barrier to keep persons continuing in immoral practices from entering the church.SLP 65.2–66.23SP 372.1
Council at Jerusalem
To prevent division from continued debate, the church at Antioch decided that Paul and Barnabas, with some other responsible men from the church, should go up to Jerusalem to lay the matter before the apostles and elders.8RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1SLP 63.1–2 There they were to meet delegates from the different churches and those who had gathered for the approaching festivals, and all controversy was to cease until a final decision was given in general council.AA 190.2–4 That decision was then to be universally accepted by the different churches.8RED 26.1–2AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18793SP 368.2–369.1SLP 63.1–2
The delegation presented the controversy and its effects before the gathered churches, reporting both the success of the Gentile mission and the confusion caused by converted Pharisees who said circumcision and observance of the law of Moses were necessary for salvation.ST Jun 26, 18793SP 369.2 Paul first met privately with Peter, James, and John, who supported the position that Gentiles were free from the ceremonial law.SLP 192.3–194.1 At the apostolic council in Jerusalem where Paul's work among the Gentiles was considered, Paul related his conversion and the work God had done through him among the Gentiles.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884 The Spirit bore witness to his words, the council set aside its prejudices, accepted his position, and sent an address to the churches expressing their agreement.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884
The council rejected requiring Gentile converts to observe the ceremonial law, including circumcision.SLP 192.3–194.1AA 400.2–401.1AA 383.1–2SLP 121.1–122.1AA 387.2–388.1 It made recommendations about rites and customs and commended Barnabas and Paul as trustworthy workers, so that those who had criticized their methods came to share in decisions that helped unite believers.AA 400.2–401.1 The decision was sanctioned by the Holy Spirit and remained in force.ST May 1, 1884 Jewish converts could observe Mosaic ordinances if they chose, but those ordinances were not obligatory for Gentile converts, though some continued to press for a distinction between the two groups.SLP 121.1–122.1 It recognized Paul's divine calling and equal standing as an apostle, and he followed the council's decisions in his work among the Gentiles.SLP 192.3–194.1AA 387.2–388.1
Paul understood that the sacrificial rites had foreshadowed Christ's death and that their purpose had ended when the reality they prefigured came, while he nevertheless continued to keep the Ten Commandments.SLP 63.3–65.1 The false teachers in Galatia ignored the council's decision and urged converts to keep the law.AA 383.1–2 The later advice to Paul to conform was not prompted by the Spirit.ST May 1, 1884
Church Order and Unity
The serious dispute over circumcision and the law of Moses led Paul, Barnabas, and others to go up to Jerusalem to consult the apostles and elders for counsel on the disputed question.LS 406.3–407.1Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16 In that meeting the apostles and elders acted as counselors, not as rulers commanding the church, leaving room for the Holy Spirit to judge.LS 406.3–407.1Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16 Church order and organization are to serve the unity and perfection of the church, not to give leaders power to command or control fellow laborers.Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16 The course taken shows the model of bringing a serious church matter to responsible counsel rather than letting individuals impose authority beyond what was given them.LS 406.3–407.1Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16
When dissension arose in a local church like Antioch and the believers were unable to come to agreement among themselves, such matters were not permitted to create division in the church.AA 95.3–96.1 They were referred to a general council of the entire body of believers, made up of appointed delegates from the various local churches with the apostles and elders in positions of leading responsibility.AA 95.3–96.1 This order made it possible for companies of believers scattered over a large territory to remain members of one body and to move forward solidly in concert and harmony with one another as a well-disciplined army.AA 95.3–96.1 In this way Satan's efforts to attack the church in isolated places were met by concerted action on the part of all, and his plans to disrupt and destroy were thwarted.AA 95.3–96.1
The difference of understanding over circumcision, whether admission to the church should be granted to uncircumcised Gentiles, was a short-lived exception to the union that prevailed among believers after the resurrection and ascension, when they were all of one heart and one mind.LS 406.3–407.114MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 The matter was soon settled, the meeting settled the difficulty, and the brethren rejoiced at the consolation it brought.LS 406.3–407.114MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 Through the divine illumination and sanctification of the Spirit the believers were perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 This harmony in understanding what is truth and unity in judgment exists only in proportion to illumination and sanctification, as believers receive the enlightenment of the living Spirit, and it is and always will be the fruit borne under the influence of the Holy Spirit.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
105 sources
At Antioch men from Judea taught that Gentile believers could not be saved unless circumcised, and Paul and Barnabas strongly opposed them in serious dissension that left the church hardly knowing what to believe and fearing division.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900CO 82.4–83.1 It was settled that Paul and Barnabas with certain other responsible men should go up as delegates to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 28, 1856RH Aug 31, 1916 The question was whether Gentiles must be circumcised after the custom of Moses and keep the ceremonial law in order to be saved, a counterfeit gospel opposed to salvation through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ by faith alone.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900ST Aug 30, 1877ST Dec 15, 1898 The meeting at Jerusalem was the first council of the church to settle the matter once for all, where the apostles and elders counseled together under the Holy Ghost, James giving the final sentence while Peter sat only as an equal, and their united judgment brought rejoicing and established the churches.RH May 5, 1863RH Apr 29, 1909ST Apr 26, 1883RH Jun 13, 1871ST Jul 5, 1910 The dispute concerned circumcision and shadowy ordinances whose season had passed at the cross, not the Sabbath or the Ten Commandments, for the moral law remains firm as the throne of Heaven and the absence of the Sabbath from the letter no more abolishes it than silence about murder or theft abolishes those commands.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Sep 9, 1880RH Jun 10, 1875RH Apr 16, 1861ST Jun 8, 1882
Setting and Wording
The dissension at Antioch in Syria was serious and sharp, arising when men from Judea, including believing Pharisees, taught the Gentile brethren that except they were circumcised after the manner or custom of Moses and commanded to keep the law of Moses they could not be saved.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900CO 82.4–83.1RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 7, 1901 Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, firmly opposing the requirement in order to protect the truth of the gospel, and the controversy was so grave that the church hardly knew what to believe and feared division.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900RH Mar 28, 1854ST Nov 28, 1892ST May 6, 1897 To secure union and settle the question of salvation, it was decided that the matter should be carried to Jerusalem.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900CO 82.4–83.1RH Mar 28, 1854RH May 7, 1901
The word rendered determined means settled or decided.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 28, 1856RH Aug 31, 1916ST Jun 9, 1898 The decision was that Paul and Barnabas, with certain others as responsible men and delegates or representatives from the churches, should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Aug 31, 1916RH Mar 28, 1854ST Jun 9, 1898 Elders renders presbuteros.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Feb 28, 1856RH Aug 31, 1916 Investigation and much discussion had come before this referral, and the question that could not be settled locally was thus brought before the gathered leaders for full consideration.RH Feb 28, 1856
The meeting at Jerusalem was Paul's second visit there after his conversion, held about A.D. 50 to 52, about seventeen years after his conversion in about A.D. 34 and fourteen years after his first visit.ST Mar 4, 1886RH Nov 28, 1871 Three years had first been spent in Arabia and Damascus, followed by a fifteen-day stay with Peter.ST Mar 4, 1886 This dating is used to place the end of the 490 years allotted especially to the Jewish people.ST Mar 4, 1886
Paul went up both by the appointment or decision of the church at Antioch, where he was laboring, and by revelation.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Nov 28, 1892ST Dec 16, 1897 He went not on an errand for men but for the Lord, as the Lord's servant and not man's, not to learn whether he had been teaching the truth or to seek confirmation of the gospel he had preached for seventeen years, but to impart to others the light God had given him and to uphold it.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Nov 28, 1892 Because of false brethren who would pervert every word spoken in public, he set forth the gospel he preached among the Gentiles privately to some, and those who were chief added nothing to him.ST Nov 28, 1892 Titus, a Greek by birth converted by Paul and the first Christian convert left uncircumcised, accompanied him as proof that circumcision was not required, and on the way through Phenicia and Samaria they told the brethren of God's work in the conversion of the heathen.ST Nov 29, 1910ST May 28, 1902ST Dec 16, 1897
The meeting at Jerusalem was the first council or general conference of the church, convened by the apostles to decide the question once for all and to seek God and reach a better understanding where the disciples differed.ST Apr 26, 1883ST Jul 5, 1910ST Sep 30, 1908ST Mar 18, 1903ST Sep 30, 1908 Delegates walked 300 miles from Antioch to Jerusalem and back, and the labor was more than repaid in restored harmony.ST Apr 26, 1883ST Sep 30, 1908ST Feb 7, 1906 Peter was present only as an equal, for he did not convoke the council, preside over it, or promulgate its canons, but James presided and gave the final sentence.ST Jul 5, 1910ST Sep 30, 1908ST Sep 30, 1908
Dispute over Circumcision
The question at Antioch was whether Gentile believers must be circumcised after the manner or custom of Moses and be commanded to keep the law of Moses, even the whole ceremonial law, in order to be saved and to be received into the church.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900CO 82.4–83.1RH Mar 28, 1854 It was pressed by men coming from Judea, Judaizing teachers and zealous Pharisees, unauthorized independent teachers who judged others by Jewish tradition.ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900RH Mar 28, 1854 The disagreement became sharp dissension over salvation itself, so to secure the union of the faithful Paul and Barnabas with certain others were sent up to Jerusalem to consult the apostles and elders.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 13, 1884ST Aug 8, 1900CO 82.4–83.1RH Mar 28, 1854 The question before that assembly concerned circumcision and the law of Moses, not Sabbath observance or the Ten Commandments, and its decision rejected the continuing necessity of an ordinance whose significance had passed away.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Mar 4, 1862
Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with those teachers, entering into strong dispute with the advocates of making circumcision a condition of salvation.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Nov 28, 1892ST May 6, 1897ST Dec 16, 1897ST Dec 5, 1892 They firmly refused to give place to the requirement, opposing the teaching to protect the truth of the gospel.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Dec 15, 1898ST Dec 16, 1897 Their strong opposition proves the controversy was not small or unimportant, but a conflict between the true gospel and a counterfeit in which resistance was necessary to preserve the truth.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Nov 28, 1892ST Dec 15, 1898 The dispute concerned making circumcision a requirement for salvation, not circumcision as a practice in itself, and even while traveling they kept exhorting, teaching, and strengthening believers as their foremost concern.ST May 6, 1897ST Dec 5, 1892
Investigation and much discussion came before the testimony of the Holy Ghost and the judgment, with contention against the Judaizing teachers followed by scriptural and experimental remarks by Peter, Paul, Barnabas and James.RH Feb 28, 1856RH May 5, 1863 The matter was considered in full discussion by the gathered church and its leaders rather than decided by one man alone, and the decision was reached collectively rather than by Peter alone.RH May 5, 1863ST Apr 13, 1915ST Dec 12, 1892 Paul and his brethren acted in the counsel and strength of Christ as shepherds of the flock and guardians of truth rather than leaving false teachers alone.RH May 5, 1863 The judgment by the apostles and elders with the whole church, testified to by the Holy Spirit, was sent by chosen men with letters to the Gentile churches in Antioch, Syria and Cilicia, opening with union among the brethren and bringing consolation, rejoicing, and a happy settlement as authoritative decrees for the churches.RH May 5, 1863
Ceremonial Law Distinguished
The dispute taken to Jerusalem concerned circumcision after the manner of Moses and the command to keep the law of Moses, that is circumcision and the ceremonial law of which it is a part, including carnal ordinances, shadowy sabbaths and the law of ordinances.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Apr 16, 1861ST Jun 8, 1882RH Jul 2, 1861RH Jun 15, 1911 That law was the yoke debated at Jerusalem which neither the Jews nor the fathers could bear, and it stands distinct from the moral law of ten commandments.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Apr 16, 1861RH Jul 2, 1861 The moral law is the royal law and law of liberty, perfect and a delight and kept by Christ, firm as the throne of Heaven and subjecting even the apostles themselves, and it includes the command against coveting and the fourth commandment of grateful rest on the seventh day in acknowledgment of the Creator's power, benevolence and goodness, unlike Sunday observance as a man-made yoke.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Apr 16, 1861RH Jul 2, 1861 The council therefore decided that circumcision and the ceremonial law were not binding on Gentiles, and its decision showed Gentile believers including Titus were not required to be circumcised, for the law at issue was ceremonial and not a precept of the moral law.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Jun 10, 1875ST Jun 8, 1882 No dispute about Sabbath observance or about the moral law in general or the fourth commandment in particular was brought before them, and if Gentile Christians had been breaking the Sabbath it would have caused even greater complaint than neglect of circumcision, so the absence of such complaint proves no occasion existed and they were keeping the Sabbath.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jun 8, 1882ST Nov 5, 1912
By letter the apostles required only abstinence from meats offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Oct 26, 1911RH Apr 22, 1862 These four were a Christian rule of action and cautions where Gentiles were in danger, not the whole of Christian duty and not the Mosaic law imposed as a condition of justification, and Gentiles like Jews are saved through the grace of Jesus Christ.ST Aug 12, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH Apr 22, 1862 Silence about the other commandments does not release Gentiles from them, for the Ten Commandments were not the question the council met to decide and silence about a command is no evidence it no longer applies.RH May 27, 1875ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 27, 1875 To treat the four as the only Christian rules would permit idolatry in part, blasphemy, dishonoring parents, murder, theft, false witness and lawlessness, turning gospel liberty into licentiousness and making Christ the minister of sin.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 27, 1875 Only one precept of the Decalogue is mentioned while idolatry, taking God's name in vain, dishonoring parents, stealing, murder and false witness are also left out yet remain binding, so to limit the Ten Commandments to what was named would set aside eight of the ten and even the most important part of the other two, the first and last named falling under the second and seventh without covering all those commandments require.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Aug 12, 1875RH Oct 26, 1911 That inference from silence is negative rather than direct evidence and is contradicted by Romans 2 and 3 and Galatians 3, which prove Gentiles sustain the same relation to the law as Jews and are condemned as violators, for where no law is there is no transgression.RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 27, 1875
Circumcision had been right in its season, but that season had passed and its significance had passed away.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Dec 20, 1883ST Oct 29, 1912 It had fulfilled its purpose and ended at the cross, and circumcision of the heart had replaced it as the distinctive badge of God's people.ST Dec 20, 1883ST Oct 29, 1912 Continuing to teach the outdated requirement was false teaching that brought discouragement, dissension and disorder to the church, substituting shadows of the old dispensation for the moral precepts of God's law and true faith in Christ.ST Dec 20, 1883RH Jun 15, 1911 The first general conference therefore met to decide which rites of the Old Testament dispensation had served their purpose and were not to be brought over into the new, with circumcision prominent among them, rejecting the continuing necessity of such an ordinance for reception into the church.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Oct 29, 1912ST Nov 5, 1912 The dispute concerned the ceremonial law, not the Sabbath of the Decalogue, which was given in Eden before the age of shadows as a memorial of Jehovah's rest and not a shadow.RH Jun 15, 1911ST Oct 29, 1912
The concession at Jerusalem that healed the threatened schism has been taught by those who held it as liberty rather than uniformity that annulled the sacred code given at Sinai.ST Feb 14, 1906 It has likewise been reported as the argument of others in the Sabbath debate that because the council said nothing about keeping the Ten Commandments they were abolished there.RH Feb 26, 1857
Salvation by Grace
The sharp dissension at Antioch arose because certain men from Judea taught the brethren that except they were circumcised after the custom of Moses they could not be saved, and Paul and Barnabas strongly opposed that teaching so that they with others were appointed to go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Aug 8, 1900RH Jan 2, 1900 The dispute that sent them was nothing less than the question of salvation itself and therefore of supreme importance, concerning what proclaims salvation and what the gospel truly teaches.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Aug 8, 1900 Faith in the name of Christ is the only way of salvation, and Gentiles like Jews are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, justified by faith rather than by law.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868RH Jan 2, 1900 The council's decision that Gentiles were saved through Christ's grace did not abolish the Ten Commandments or excuse breaking them, for circumcision and the law of Moses as a condition of justification were not binding while God's commandments remained binding.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868
The false brethren who came to Antioch denied Christ by teaching that something else besides faith was necessary, adding circumcision to faith in Christ as necessary for salvation.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Aug 8, 1900 Their teaching was another gospel, opposed to the gospel of the power of God unto salvation, a gospel of damnation that is no good news at all.ST Aug 8, 1900 The controversy was between the true gospel of Christ and a counterfeit presented as the gospel, and Paul and Barnabas firmly refused to give place to the requirement because their strong dissension proves it was not small or unimportant.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Dec 15, 1898 Resisting the false teaching was necessary to preserve the truth of the gospel and to hold to it, a vital question to the new believers then that remains important now, fought in order that the truth of the gospel might continue with believers then and now.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Dec 15, 1898ST Sep 12, 1900ST Aug 8, 1900
The council settled the question of circumcision and the law that troubled Gentile believers, showing that Gentile believers were not required to be circumcised or to observe the ceremonial law.RH Jun 10, 1875ST May 27, 1875ST Nov 22, 1883 Titus, a Greek by birth converted by Paul and left uncircumcised, was taken up to Jerusalem, and he was not compelled to be circumcised, proving Gentile converts need not be circumcised.RH Jun 10, 1875ST May 27, 1875ST Nov 29, 1910 The decision, sanctioned by the Holy Spirit, remained in force, requiring of the ceremonial law only abstinence from things offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 22, 1885 Later advice urging conformity to the ceremonial law to avoid Jewish hatred and persecution was the fruit of cowardice, not consistent with that decision and not prompted by the Spirit of God.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 22, 1885
Links to Other Scriptures
The whole chapter must be read together with Galatians, especially its second chapter, which treats the conference and the things that led to it and grew out of it, without which the force of the apostle's words cannot be appreciated.ST Aug 8, 1900 The visit to Jerusalem about this question is the same as Paul refers to in Galatians 2:1-4, his second visit there, about A.D. 51, seventeen years after his conversion and fourteen years after his earlier visit.RH Apr 15, 1873 The issue troubling Antioch was also troubling the Galatian believers, and Acts 15 is the only recorded parallel to those disputes over requirements of the former dispensation.RH Oct 8, 1857 Those disputes included spoiling the disciples through philosophy, bewitching them, persuading them to observe days and months and years, and bringing them under the yoke of circumcision, under the rudiments of the world, which is the handwriting of ordinances.
The inference that Gentiles need keep only the four duties named in the letter is false and exceedingly immoral in tendency, contradicted by Romans 2 and 3 and Galatians 3, which prove directly that Gentiles sustain the same relation to the law that the Jews did and are condemned by the law as violators of it, for where no law is there is no transgression.RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 27, 1875 To make Christ release men from obligation to the ten commandments in this way disgraces the gospel by making Christ the minister of sin and turning gospel liberty into licentiousness.RH May 27, 1875 The omission of the Sabbath and of idolatry, taking God's name in vain, dishonoring parents, and stealing does not prove they are not binding, since only one precept of the Decalogue is mentioned there.RH Oct 26, 1911 The prohibition of abstaining from blood remains binding as a rule first given when God permitted animal food and later stated as a perpetual statute, while the distinction between clean and unclean animals remains relevant as a principle beyond the ceremonial requirements not imposed on Gentile converts.RH Dec 31, 1861RH Dec 31, 1861
The chapter belongs to the restoration of David's kingdom in the gospel age, presenting Christ, David's heir, gathering God's true people from all nations and completing His kingdom.RH Mar 25, 1873 The gospel takes from the nations a people for God's name, and its success does not require the whole world to be converted.ST Oct 9, 1879 The meeting at Jerusalem addressed teaching converts to keep the law of Moses, and its decision exposed teachers claiming to be apostles as false.RH Mar 26, 1857RH Jun 10, 1862 Testing those who claimed to be apostles was the work of the whole apostolic church, not just one local congregation, yet if it belonged to any one congregation, that at Jerusalem was the very one, and the church that received the decision was not Ephesus but those at Antioch, Syria, and Cilicia to whom letters were sent.RH Mar 26, 1857ST Jan 15, 1880 At that council Paul had been urged to remember the poor, fulfilled in his later delivery of gifts from Gentile churches to Jerusalem.ST Jan 15, 1885
At the council Paul related his conversion and the work God had done through him among the Gentiles, and the Spirit bore witness to his words so that the council set aside prejudice and expressed agreement with his position.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 15, 1885 On the way Paul and Barnabas had told the brethren in Phenicia and Samaria of God's work in the conversion of the heathen, and at Jerusalem believing Pharisees declared circumcision and observance of the law of Moses binding on such converts.ST May 28, 1902 After much disputation Peter declared that God chose the Gentiles to hear the gospel by his mouth and believe, bore them witness by giving them the Holy Ghost as to Jewish believers, and put no difference between them, purifying their hearts by faith.ST May 28, 1902 To lay circumcision upon them was therefore tempting God with a yoke neither the fathers nor the apostles could bear, since both Jew and Gentile are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ.ST May 28, 1902 This turned discussion against circumcision and the law of ceremonies, showing that by accepting uncircumcised Gentiles God revealed such rites were no longer necessary for them and no longer binding on Jews, so that when Paul and Barnabas spoke every voice was hushed to hear how God had wrought through them, a decision that came through the Holy Spirit's work in the apostles' experiences.ST May 28, 1902ST Nov 22, 1883
Council and Church Order
The church at Antioch appointed Paul and Barnabas with certain others as its delegates, men from the Gentile churches, to carry to Jerusalem a dispute over teaching that affected churches in different regions and could not be settled locally.RH Aug 31, 1916RH May 2, 1907ST Jan 15, 1885RH May 9, 1907 They were sent to consult the apostles and elders about the shared question, bringing the interests of the wider body before a representative assembly whose decision was understood as guided by the Holy Spirit and vital to the continued prosperity and existence of the church.RH Aug 31, 1916RH Apr 29, 1909RH May 9, 1907 In this the churches were represented by elders and delegates from Antioch and Jerusalem and by representatives of influential Jewish and Gentile churches, illustrating cooperation among churches and their leaders to preserve fellowship through delegated brethren addressing common concerns.RH Jul 9, 1901RH Apr 29, 1909RH May 2, 1907 Its deliberations were not infallible but followed enlightened judgment.RH Apr 29, 1909
The apostles and elders acted as counselors and not as rulers lording over God's heritage, leaving room for the Holy Ghost to act as Judge.LS 406.3–407.1RH May 5, 1863ST Jun 11, 1874RH Dec 1, 1874 Christ by His Spirit led the assembly because apostles, elders, and all the brotherhood were in a teachable frame of mind, and He led them out of their difficulties, proving His leadership and the equality of the ministerial brotherhood.RH May 5, 1863RH Dec 1, 1874 The whole body of Christians did not vote on the question, but after full discussion by leaders and brethren the apostles and elders framed and issued the decree, showing the Spirit proceeds in harmony with counsel.RH Jul 9, 1901ST Apr 13, 1915RH Feb 26, 1901 The decision therefore carried both their authority and the sanction of the Holy Ghost, and organization must work with a pure, peaceable, gentle spirit rather than strife for supremacy.RH May 5, 1863 Differences settled in this teachable way remain settled, while those disposed of by mere church authority are seldom really settled at all.RH Dec 1, 1874
James presided over the council and gave its final decision and sentence that Gentile believers should not be burdened, not Peter.RH Apr 29, 1909ST Jul 5, 1910ST Sep 30, 1908RH Oct 19, 1916 Peter was present only as an equal with his fellow apostles in a general council assembled to decide questions on which believers were divided.ST Apr 13, 1915RH Jun 13, 1871ST Dec 3, 1894 He did not convoke the council, preside over it, or formulate and promulgate its canons as a pope would do through himself or his legates, and its decrees were promulgated in the name of the apostles, the elders and the brethren.RH Jun 13, 1871 The early church therefore never thought of a pope, and the matter was considered and decided collectively rather than by one man alone.ST Apr 13, 1915RH Jun 13, 1871
The judgment, reached with the whole church, was sent by chosen men with letters to Antioch, Syria, and Cilicia, opening with union among the brethren and the testimony of the Holy Ghost.RH May 5, 1863RH Mar 26, 1857 Paul with Silas carried the authoritative decrees through the cities to be kept, and they brought consolation, rejoicing, and encouragement, establishing the churches in the faith and thwarting division.LS 406.3–407.1RH May 5, 1863 It was a real and happy settlement of the trouble caused by teachers requiring circumcision for salvation, reached after contention against Judaizing teachers followed by scriptural and experimental remarks by Peter, Paul, Barnabas, and James.RH May 5, 1863 Though some later murmured and tried to undermine experienced teachers, testing those who claimed to be apostles and exposing the false was the work of the whole apostolic church, not merely one local congregation.RH Mar 26, 1857
The gathering answers the same purpose as a General Conference, with leading men coming together to counsel concerning things of general interest as part of God's assignment of offices, divisions, gifts, powers, and agencies to make the church effective in saving its own members and reaching those outside.CO 28.2–29.2RH Aug 18, 1874 It stands as a model of Christian piety for conference sessions in the way leaders and delegates meet together to worship and conduct business, showing the need for gatherings for consultation and prayer.RH Nov 11, 1902 Its discussion and decision recognized remarkable liberty, in contrast with later church domination, exclusion, and persecution.ST Dec 13, 1905 It serves as an example of a church court for questions of church order rather than an ordinary public religious service, where apostles and elders were together and many elders served by vote of the church or appointment while remaining with their own church rather than giving all their time to travel as those wholly set apart do.RH Jul 30, 1861RH Jul 3, 1856
Sabbath Unaffected by Council
The dissension that sent Paul and Barnabas with others up to Jerusalem was over whether Gentile believers must be circumcised and keep the law of Moses in order to be saved, not over Sabbath observance or the Ten Commandments.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Sep 9, 1880RH May 27, 1875ST Jun 8, 1882 No dispute about the Sabbath was laid before the apostles and elders, no proposal to keep a different day was made, and the sacredness of the Sabbath was never challenged.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 8, 1880ST Nov 5, 1912RH May 5, 1874 The assembly met as the first general conference to decide which rites of the old dispensation had served their purpose and were not to be carried into the new, with circumcision prominent among them, and if any hint of changing or abolishing the Sabbath had been offered there would have been plenty of controversy.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jul 8, 1880ST Nov 5, 1912
If those Gentile Christians had been breaking the Sabbath it would have caused even greater complaint than their neglect of circumcision.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jul 8, 1880RH May 5, 1874 Those who found them uncircumcised and accused Paul for it would have raised the Sabbath still more earnestly had he taught them to neglect it.ST Sep 9, 1880RH May 26, 1863RH Mar 4, 1862 The absence of any such complaint proves no occasion for it existed and that they were keeping the Sabbath.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jul 8, 1880RH May 26, 1863 This silence several years after Paul had preached to the Gentiles on the Sabbath shows he had not taught them to neglect it and did not release them from its obligation.RH May 26, 1863RH Mar 4, 1862
The council's letter forbade only sacrifices to idols, eating blood, eating things strangled, and fornication, the first and last falling under the second and seventh commandments without covering all those commandments require.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Oct 26, 1911 Only one precept of the Decalogue is mentioned there, while idolatry in part, blasphemy and taking God's name in vain, dishonoring parents, stealing, murder, and false witness are also left out yet remain binding, for where no law is there is no transgression.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Aug 12, 1875RH Oct 26, 1911 To limit the Ten Commandments to what was named would set aside eight of the ten and even the most important part of the other two, making gospel liberty lawlessness and abolishing nearly the whole law of God.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Aug 12, 1875 None of the Ten Commandments was mentioned or repealed, and failure to mention the Sabbath does not release Gentiles from that duty.RH May 27, 1875ST Oct 29, 1912
The law considered was circumcision and the ceremonial law of which it is a part, a yoke neither the Jews nor the fathers could bear, distinct from the moral law which is the royal law and law of liberty, perfect, a delight, and kept by Christ.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Apr 16, 1861 The apostles had no need to establish the authority of the moral law, for it is as firm as the throne of Heaven and they themselves were subject to it.ST Sep 9, 1880 The dispute concerned carnal ordinances and shadowy sabbaths, not the Sabbath of the Decalogue given in Eden before the age of shadows as a memorial of Jehovah's rest.RH Apr 16, 1861RH Jun 15, 1911 Jewish converts and Christian converts still kept the seventh day under the fourth commandment in grateful rest acknowledging the Creator's power, benevolence and goodness, while Sunday observance is a man-made yoke, and the chapter, last mentioning the apostles as a body, gives no hint of a change to the first day.RH Apr 16, 1861ST Jan 27, 1881
The journey to Jerusalem settled only the points dividing the flock, such as eating with Gentiles and meats that were abomination to the Jews, not the whole of Christian duty, so it cannot do away with God's holy Sabbath.RH May 23, 1854 Its decision to lay no greater burden than the four abstinences brought rejoicing and should settle the question forever, and to add a prohibition of swine's flesh is to lay a greater burden than seemed good to the Holy Ghost and the apostles.RH May 23, 1854 Certain restrictions were placed on Gentile converts without imposing the old Levitical laws, yet the distinction between clean and unclean animals remains relevant beyond those ceremonial requirements not imposed. The requirement to abstain from blood confirms a prohibition still binding as a perpetual statute from when animal food was first permitted.RH Dec 31, 1861RH Dec 31, 1861
Lessons for Church Today
Fearing that continued debate would divide the church, discussion of the serious disagreement at Antioch was to pause until responsible leaders reached a decision that the churches would accept.ST Jun 26, 1879CO 83.2RH May 9, 1907RH Aug 27, 1901CO 83.3 Paul and Barnabas with other responsible men were sent as delegates from different churches to Jerusalem to present the question of circumcision and keeping the law of Moses as necessary for salvation to the apostles and elders for counsel.ST Jun 26, 1879RH May 9, 1907RH May 9, 1907RH Aug 27, 1901 There the delegates were to meet, seek God, and let the Word have undisputed sway, with controversy ceasing while the matter was considered and the resulting united decision under the Word meant to guide the churches and preserve harmony.CO 83.3 That council decision was understood as guided by the Holy Spirit and as important to the church's continued prosperity and existence, yet some resisted it in independence and spread division.RH May 9, 1907
The assembly acted as counselors rather than as commanders lording over God's heritage, giving room for the Holy Ghost to act as Judge, and Christ by His Spirit led apostles, elders, and all the brotherhood out of their difficulties because they were in a teachable frame of mind.RH Dec 1, 1874 The episode therefore shows the principle of standing by truth even when it proves one wrong and abandoning error once it is recognized, allowing the Holy Spirit to reconcile differing opinions in discussion of both practice and teaching.RH Dec 1, 1874RH Jan 13, 1874ST May 6, 1897ST May 28, 1902 Differences settled in this teachable way remain settled, while those disposed of by mere church authority are seldom really settled at all.RH Dec 1, 1874 The labor illustrates that where no counsel is the people fall but in the multitude of counselors there is safety, for delegates walked 300 miles from Antioch to Jerusalem and back and messengers had to return afterward to confirm the decision, yet all the time and labor were more than repaid in restored harmony, establishment of a basis of peace, encouragement of the brethren, thwarting of the enemy's purpose to divide the young church, and an example to the church for all time.RH Mar 3, 1904ST May 28, 1902
Paul and his brethren acted in the counsel and strength of Christ as shepherds of the flock and guardians of truth rather than leaving false teachers alone, engaging in united, systematic action to settle doctrine through contention against Judaizing teachers followed by scriptural and experimental remarks by Peter, Paul, Barnabas, and James.RH May 5, 1863 When a new condition or emergency arises in the church it must be faced and settled at that time, and every such question must be decided by Bible principles rather than by unauthorized independent teachers.RH Dec 28, 1905RH Nov 12, 1903 Although Paul and Barnabas were themselves Jews, they made a magnanimous concession in agreeing to lay before Jerusalem a matter their opponents claimed to represent, and the referral resulted in complete victory for the Gentile contention when the apostles utterly repudiated those teachers.ST May 28, 1902 The judgment framed by the apostles and elders with the whole church, testified to by the Holy Spirit, was then sent by chosen men with letters to the Gentile churches in Antioch, Syria, and Cilicia, opening with union among the brethren and bringing consolation, rejoicing, and authoritative decrees that preserved the church's spiritual effectiveness.RH May 5, 1863RH Dec 28, 1905
Sources