Acts 15:1
And certain men which came down from Judæa taught the brethren, and said, Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
Translations
And certain men which came down from Judaea taught the brothers, and said, Except you be circumcised after the manner of Moses, you cannot be saved.
And certain men which came down from Judæa taught the brethren, and said, Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
And certain men which came down from Judea taught the brethren, and said, Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
And certain men who came down from Judea, taught the brethren, and said, Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
And certain men came down from Judaea and taught the brethren, saying, Except ye be circumcised after the custom of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
And certain men came down from Judæa and taught the brethren, saying, Except ye be circumcised after the custom of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
And certain having come down from Judea, were teaching the brethren — 'If ye be not circumcised after the custom of Moses, ye are not able to be saved;'
And certain persons, having come down from Judaea, taught the brethren, If ye shall not have been circumcised according to the custom of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
And, certain persons, coming down from Judea, began to teach the brethren—Except ye be circumcised according to the custom of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then some men came down from Judea and were teaching the brothers, “ Unless you are circumcised according to the custom of Moses, you cannot be saved.”
Some men came down from Judea and taught the brothers, “ Unless you are circumcised after the custom of Moses, you can’ t be saved.”
Now certain men came down from Judaea, teaching the brothers and saying that without circumcision, after the rule of Moses, there is no salvation.
Then came downe certaine from Iudea, and taught the brethren, saying, Except ye be circumcised after the maner of Moses, ye cannot be saued.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And some coming down from Judea, taught the brethren: That except you be circumcised after the manner of Moses, you cannot be saved.
Cross-references 20 of 64
- Acts 15:10-11
Now therefore why tempt ye God, to put a yoke upon the neck of the disciples, which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear?
Peter calls the law an unbearable yoke and affirms salvation through Jesus’ grace.
- Acts 15:28-29
For it seemed good to the Holy Ghost, and to us, to lay upon you no greater burden than these necessary things;
The council’s decree rejects imposing circumcision on Gentile believers.
- Acts 15:5
But there rose up certain of the sect of the Pharisees which believed, saying, That it was needful to circumcise them, and to command them to keep the law of Moses.
Believing Pharisees demand circumcision and observance of Moses’ law.
- Galatians 2:3-5
But neither Titus, who was with me, being a Greek, was compelled to be circumcised:
Paul refuses to require circumcision of Gentile believers despite false brethren’s pressure.
- Acts 15:24
Forasmuch as we have heard, that certain which went out from us have troubled you with words, subverting your souls, saying, Ye must be circumcised, and keep the law: to whom we gave no such commandment:
The council disavows unauthorized teachers who troubled believers by demanding circumcision and law-keeping.
- Galatians 1:6-7
I marvel that ye are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ unto another gospel:
The circumcision requirement is a perversion of Christ’s gospel.
- Galatians 5:2-4
Behold, I Paul say unto you, that if ye be circumcised, Christ shall profit you nothing.
Circumcision required for justification obligates one to keep the whole law and makes Christ of no benefit.
- Acts 15:19-20
Wherefore my sentence is, that we trouble not them, which from among the Gentiles are turned to God:
James rules that Gentile converts should not be troubled, but gives them four requirements for conduct.
- Galatians 2:11-14
But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
Paul rebukes Peter for pressuring Gentile believers to live by Jewish customs.
- Galatians 5:6
For in Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but faith which worketh by love.
Circumcision does not avail in Christ; faith works through love.
- Colossians 2:14
Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross;
The ordinances imposed by the ritual law are described as blotted out and nailed to the cross.
- 1 Corinthians 7:19
Circumcision is nothing, and uncircumcision is nothing, but the keeping of the commandments of God.
Circumcision itself is nothing; keeping God’s commandments matters.
- Galatians 2:5
To whom we gave place by subjection, no, not for an hour; that the truth of the gospel might continue with you.
Paul and Barnabas resist the circumcision demand to preserve the truth of the gospel.
- Acts 16:4-5
And as they went through the cities, they delivered them the decrees for to keep, that were ordained of the apostles and elders which were at Jerusalem.
The churches receive and keep the Jerusalem council’s decrees, strengthening them in the faith.
- Romans 4:9-11
Cometh this blessedness then upon the circumcision only, or upon the uncircumcision also? for we say that faith was reckoned to Abraham for righteousness.
Abraham was counted righteous by faith before receiving circumcision as a sign.
- Acts 15:29
That ye abstain from meats offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication: from which if ye keep yourselves, ye shall do well. Fare ye well.
The council’s letter sets out its requirements for Gentile believers.
- Ephesians 2:15
Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances; for to make in himself of twain one new man, so making peace;
Christ abolished the ordinances that were made a condition of salvation.
- Galatians 2:3
But neither Titus, who was with me, being a Greek, was compelled to be circumcised:
Titus, a Greek, was not compelled to be circumcised.
- Romans 2:28-29
For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh:
Contrasts outward circumcision with circumcision of the heart.
- Galatians 3:10-14
For as many as are of the works of the law are under the curse: for it is written, Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them.
Christ redeems from the law’s curse so Abraham’s blessing reaches Gentiles.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
30 sources
Certain men from Judea came down to Antioch and taught with great assurance that Gentile believers could not be saved unless they were circumcised after the manner of Moses and kept the entire ceremonial law.AA 188.2–189.1Ms 165, 1899, par. 18–19AA 190.2–4 This happened after Paul and Barnabas had returned to the large and growing church at Antioch from the mission that church had sent them on and had told how God had opened the door of faith to the Gentiles.AA 188.2–189.1AA 188.1 Their teaching brought consternation and contention among the believing Gentiles, which Paul and Barnabas promptly opposed as false doctrine rather than allow it to be imposed on the Gentiles.AA 188.2–189.1AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 1879 The Jerusalem council considered the question, yielded its prejudices, witnessed the Spirit's work among the Gentiles, and rejected the requirement, leaving Gentile converts free from the obligations of the ceremonial law.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884AA 400.2–401.1 Christ's saving work embraces the whole world, so circumcision cannot be made a condition of salvation or church membership alongside faith in Christ, and to insist on it mingles Jewish traditions with the gospel, perverts the gospel, and lays an unnecessary burden on believers.Ms 165, 1899, par. 18–19AA 383.1–2AA 199.3–200.1SLP 121.1–122.1
Setting of the Dispute
The setting was Antioch in Syria after Paul and Barnabas returned from the mission that church had sent them on, assembled the believers, and told all that God had done with them and how God had opened the door of faith to the Gentiles.AA 188.1AA 190.2–4 The church at Antioch was large and growing, one of the most important groups of Christian believers and a center of missionary activity, with members of many classes from both Jews and Gentiles.AA 188.1 At that time the apostles with ministers and lay members were united in earnest effort to win many souls to Christ.AA 188.2–189.1
Certain Jewish believers from Judea, of the sect of the Pharisees, came down to Antioch and taught with great assurance that except Gentile believers were circumcised after the manner or custom or law of Moses they could not be saved.AA 188.2–189.1Ms 165, 1899, par. 18–19AA 190.2–4SLP 63.1–23SP 368.2–369.1 They also insisted that the entire ceremonial law must be kept.AA 188.2–189.1ST Jun 26, 18798RED 26.1–2SLP 63.1–23SP 368.2–369.1 By joining Jewish tradition to the gospel in this way they perverted the gospel and turned some people away from the truth.Ms 165, 1899, par. 18–19
This teaching brought consternation, alarm, confusion, discussion, contention and discord among the believing Gentiles.AA 188.2–189.1AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18798RED 26.1–2SLP 63.1–2 There was fear that continued discussion would produce division.AA 190.2–4 Paul and Barnabas met the teaching with promptness as false doctrine and opposed introducing the subject to the Gentiles and imposing it on Gentile converts.AA 188.2–189.1AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18798RED 26.1–2SLP 63.1–2 Many of the believing Jews at Antioch favored the position of the brethren newly come from Judea.AA 188.2–189.1
Because the local believers could not agree and settle the matter among themselves, the church decided to send Paul and Barnabas with responsible men to Jerusalem to lay the matter before the apostles and elders.AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 18798RED 26.1–2SLP 63.1–23SP 368.2–369.1 They were to meet delegates from the different churches gathered there, for a final decision in general council to be universally accepted by the churches, with all controversy to cease until the decision was given.AA 190.2–4 On the way to Jerusalem Paul and Barnabas visited believers in the cities through which they passed and encouraged them by relating their experience in God's work and the conversion of the Gentiles.AA 190.2–4 At Jerusalem they reported the success of their ministry among the Gentiles and the confusion caused by the circumcision demand, which the delegates from Antioch also reported to the assembly there.AA 190.2–4ST Jun 26, 1879
Behind the demand was Jewish exclusiveness, for some teachers treated Israel as uniquely entitled to Abraham's promises and Christ as Saviour of the Hebrews alone, and so made circumcision a condition of church membership and admission.SLP 121.1–122.1 Behind it was also attachment to Judaism, for Jewish Christians, especially those at Jerusalem, prized the privileges of their nation and the sacred status of Jewish customs.SLP 63.3–65.18RED 34.1 They believed Christianity had to retain Jewish ceremonies and customs and resisted the change from Jewish ceremonies and traditions to the Christian faith.SLP 63.3–65.18RED 34.1 Some therefore viewed Paul with anger and jealousy, believing his teaching made him lax about the Jewish law.8RED 34.1 It was the narrow restrictions of Judaism that Paul defended Christianity against at Jerusalem and at Antioch.SLP 304.1–2
Behind the demand was also fear about Gentile morals, for Jewish Christians feared that Gentile converts would retain practices tied to idol worship, eating blood or meat from strangled animals, and sexual immorality, and would bring immorality and reproach on the church and bring Christianity into disrepute.SLP 65.2–66.2ST Jun 26, 18793SP 372.18RED 28.2–29.3AA 191.1–192.2 They therefore regarded circumcision and observance of the ceremonial law as a test of sincere conversion and devotion to guard the church.SLP 65.2–66.2ST Jun 26, 18793SP 372.18RED 28.2–29.3AA 191.1–192.2 By that test they intended to keep out those without true conversion who had not truly turned from pagan practices.3SP 372.18RED 28.2–29.3AA 191.1–192.2
Truth Decided at Jerusalem
The question carried to Jerusalem was whether Gentile believers had to accept circumcision and keep the requirements of the Mosaic law, observing circumcision and other rites in order to be saved and accepted as saved.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884AA 400.2–401.1SLP 192.3–194.1AA 199.3–200.1 In council prejudice was yielded, the Spirit's witness to the gospel work among the Gentiles was recognized, agreement was given to Paul's position, and the requirement was rejected.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884AA 400.2–401.1SLP 192.3–194.1 By that rejection Gentiles were left free from the obligations of the ceremonial law, and the churches were freed from Jewish rites and ceremonies.SLP 192.3–194.1AA 199.3–200.1 Mosaic ordinances could still be observed by Jewish converts, but they were not to be imposed on Gentile converts.SLP 121.1–122.1 Christ's saving work embraces the whole world, so circumcision cannot be added alongside faith in Christ nor made a condition of church membership and admission to the church.SLP 121.1–122.1
To insist on circumcision according to Jewish custom and the law of Moses as necessary for salvation imposed an unnecessary burden on Gentile believers.Ms 165, 1899, par. 18–19AA 383.1–2AA 199.3–200.1 That insistence joined Jewish tradition to the gospel, mingled Jewish traditions with the gospel, perverted the gospel, and turned some away from the truth, and the same false urging to observe the ceremonial law continued despite the decision of the Jerusalem council.Ms 165, 1899, par. 18–19AA 383.1–2AA 199.3–200.1 The demand confused the temporary ceremonial system with the gospel, for the sacrifices and rites had pointed forward to Christ and His death brought their purpose to its end.SLP 63.3–65.1 Those ceremonies would therefore cease, while the Ten Commandments continue to be kept in letter and spirit.SLP 63.3–65.1
In deciding, the council made recommendations about certain customs to help unite the believers.AA 400.2–401.1 It also commended Barnabas and Paul as trustworthy workers.AA 400.2–401.1 It recognized Paul's divine commission to preach to the Gentiles and accepted him as a fellow worker of equal standing, and Paul complied with its decisions in his work among the Gentiles.AA 400.2–401.1SLP 192.3–194.1AA 387.2–388.1 That decision that Gentile converts were not required to keep the ceremonial law remained in force.ST May 1, 1884 Later advice for Paul to conform to the ceremonial law was inconsistent with it and was not prompted by the Holy Spirit but arose from fear of persecution, since nonconformity exposed Christians to hatred from unbelieving Jews and to accusation before the Sanhedrin that could lead to swift punishment as apostates.ST May 1, 1884
Pattern for Church Unity
The dissension that arose in the local church at Antioch was over a matter the believers there were unable to agree upon and settle among themselves.AA 95.3–96.1 It was not permitted to create a division in the church but was referred to a general council of the entire body of believers, made up of appointed delegates from the various local churches with the apostles and elders in positions of leading responsibility.AA 95.3–96.1 This moving in concert and in harmony kept the scattered companies of believers as members of one body, moving forward solidly as a well-disciplined army.AA 95.3–96.1 Satan's effort to attack the church in an isolated place was thus met by concerted action on the part of all, and his plans to disrupt and destroy were thwarted.AA 95.3–96.1
In that process the apostles and elders in Jerusalem served as counselors, allowing the Holy Spirit to guide the decision rather than settling the matter through mere church authority.LS 406.3–407.1 Their report expressed agreement with the Holy Spirit, and the decision brought consolation and joy to Gentile believers in Antioch, Syria, and Cilicia.LS 406.3–407.1 The account shows a way to address church disagreements that can bring lasting unity without leaders lording authority over the church.LS 406.3–407.1
The difference about circumcision was over whether admission to the church should be granted to uncircumcised Gentiles, and it was short-lived and soon settled.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 Apart from this brief exception and brief dispute, union prevailed after the resurrection and ascension of Christ, with believers all of one heart and one mind, unlike the differences now existing among Christians.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 Through the divine illumination and sanctification of the Spirit the believers were perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 Such unity exists in proportion to illumination and sanctification, and is and always will be the fruit borne under the influence of the Holy Spirit.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
84 sources
Certain men came down from Judea to the brethren at Antioch and taught that unless they were circumcised after the manner of Moses they could not be saved, making circumcision and keeping the Mosaic law a condition of salvation and church acceptance.ST Aug 8, 1900RH Nov 16, 1916ST May 6, 1897 They were unauthorized false brethren, including believing Pharisees and Judaizing teachers who claimed to speak for the apostles and elders though they had received no commandment from them, and their teaching alarmed Gentile believers and threatened the church with division and schism.CO 82.4–83.1RH Mar 28, 1854 Their demand made an outward sign and human work the means of salvation, putting circumcision in Christ's place and teaching that faith in Jesus was not enough without circumcision and law-keeping.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Dec 15, 1898ST Dec 15, 1898 Adding circumcision in this way denies Christ and makes Him of no effect, for it is another gospel that perverts the message and brings bondage rather than good news.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Aug 8, 1900ST Dec 15, 1898 Salvation is through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ for Jew and Gentile alike, by faith alone purifying the heart, with the Holy Spirit given to uncircumcised Gentiles as to Jews, while the circumcision that saves is inward, of the heart through faith working by love.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868RH Feb 1851 The council decided under the Holy Spirit that Gentile disciples were not required to be circumcised or keep the ceremonial law, which had fulfilled its purpose and ended at the cross, yet that decision did not abolish the Ten Commandments or the seventh-day Sabbath, whose continued obligation is untouched by its silence.RH Oct 26, 1911ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jun 17, 1897ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868
Historical Setting Detailed
Certain men came down from Judea to the brethren at Antioch in Syria and Cilicia, teaching that except they were circumcised after the manner and custom and law of Moses they could not be saved.ST Aug 8, 1900RH Nov 16, 1916ST May 6, 1897ST Nov 28, 1892RH Feb 28, 1856 They made circumcision and keeping the law of Moses the condition of salvation and of acceptance into the church, raising whether Gentile believers stood on equal footing with Jewish believers under the gospel.ST Aug 8, 1900RH Nov 16, 1916RH Feb 28, 1856ST Mar 13, 1884 Their teaching opposed the truth of the gospel, troubled the disciples and would bring them into bondage, and Paul and Barnabas resisted it so that the gospel would continue.ST May 6, 1897ST Nov 28, 1892ST Mar 13, 1884
The teachers were false brethren, believing and converted Pharisees and Judaizing teachers from Judea and Jerusalem, who claimed to represent the apostles and elders but had no commandment from them.ST Jun 26, 1879RH Mar 28, 1854ST May 28, 1902RH May 9, 1907 They alarmed the believing Gentiles and raised general consternation and confusion and dispute, subverting souls by attempting to compel all to be circumcised.ST Jun 26, 1879CO 82.4–83.1RH May 9, 1907 They insisted the whole ceremonial law be kept as a test of sincere conversion, because they feared continued idolatry and blood-eating and eating of strangled meat and fornication, and hoped to lessen Jewish opposition and attract Jews.ST Jun 26, 1879CO 82.4–83.1RH Mar 28, 1854 They argued that God had recognized the Jewish religion and that Christ had observed its customs, and when Paul and Barnabas reported the conversion of the Gentiles they rose up saying circumcision and keeping the law of Moses was needful.RH Mar 28, 1854ST May 28, 1902RH May 9, 1907
Their teaching was met by Paul and Barnabas with no small dissension and disputation and questioning, discouraged the Gentiles, divided the church, threatened schism and its work, and left the church uncertain.ST Aug 8, 1900ST May 6, 1897ST Mar 13, 1884RH May 5, 1863RH Mar 28, 1854 The brethren determined that Paul and Barnabas and certain others with responsible representatives and elders and delegates from Antioch and other churches should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Mar 13, 1884RH Mar 28, 1854RH Apr 29, 1909 That referral involved a 300-mile walk each way and took considerable time and labor, but the Jerusalem conference addressed and settled the dispute through counsel of the apostles, elders, and whole church, restoring harmony and thwarting permanent division.RH May 5, 1863RH Mar 28, 1854RH Apr 29, 1909
The Jerusalem meeting occurred about A.D. 51, also dated A.D. 52, seventeen years after Paul's conversion about A.D. 34.ST Mar 4, 1886RH Nov 28, 1871 Paul spent his first three years as a Christian in Arabia and Damascus, then went up to Jerusalem and stayed fifteen days with Peter, and fourteen years afterward went up again to Jerusalem, and this later visit is the meeting described in Acts 15.ST Mar 4, 1886 Paul went up by revelation as the Lord's servant, not on an errand for men, not to find out if he had been teaching the truth but to impart to others the light God had given him. Because of false brethren who would pervert his public words he presented the gospel privately to some, and the council marked the end of the 490 years allotted especially to the Jewish people.ST Mar 4, 1886
False Teaching Unmasked
The demand made an outward rite the means and condition of being saved, putting circumcision in the place of Christ and exalting the sign without faith above faith without the sign.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Dec 15, 1898RH Aug 14, 1900 It taught that faith in Jesus was not enough, that Christ plus circumcision and law-keeping was required, even for those already saved through faith who had trusted Jesus, received the witness of the Spirit, and grown in faith.RH Aug 14, 1900ST Dec 5, 1892 It professed to tell men what they must do to be saved and therefore professed to preach the gospel, while palming off a perversion as the true gospel though there is only one gospel.ST Dec 15, 1898 Paul and Barnabas refused it any place but met it with strong dissension and disputation, because the contest was vital and resistance was necessary that the truth of the gospel might continue with believers.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Dec 15, 1898
To add circumcision denies Christ and denies His power and sufficiency to save believers without the sign, rejecting Him as complete Saviour.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Dec 15, 1898RH Aug 14, 1900 Trusted as a condition, it makes Him of no effect so that He profits nothing to the one circumcised for that purpose.RH Aug 14, 1900 It is a counterfeit gospel, another gospel different from the gospel of the power of God unto salvation, a gospel of damnation and bondage that perverts the message and subverts souls.ST Nov 28, 1892ST Aug 8, 1900ST Dec 15, 1898ST Dec 15, 1898 It is no gospel at all because there is no good news in it.ST Aug 8, 1900
Salvation is through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ for Jew and Gentile alike, by faith alone and not by works of flesh or law-keeping, through His merits and God's free grace.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868ST May 28, 1902ST Dec 12, 1892 God put no difference between them, purifying hearts by faith and giving the Holy Spirit to uncircumcised Gentiles as to Jews.ST May 28, 1902ST Dec 12, 1892 The circumcision necessary for salvation is inward, of the heart and spirit through faith working by love, which Abraham possessed before the outward mark that served only as sign and reminder, and which the believers at Antioch already possessed in receiving Christ.ST Dec 15, 1898
Circumcision in itself is nothing either way and may be practiced, but trusted as a means of justification it makes the death of Christ vain.ST Jun 3, 1886 Since only Christ saves from sin, choosing something else apart from Him turns a person from Christ back to all his sins and leaves him under the yoke of sin.ST Jun 3, 1886 With the coming of gospel faith believers are redeemed from the law, freed from cumbersome ceremonies, and receive the promise of the Spirit by faith and the adoption of sons, so circumcision is no longer a sign of sonship but a yoke of bondage. Obedience added from self-righteousness is sin and bondage, and outward observances including Sabbathkeeping and the ordinances cannot save when Christ is left out, for Christ living in the believer produces obedience and makes righteous, and good works are the fruit and evidence of faith, not its ground.ST Dec 5, 1892RH Jan 15, 1901
Ceremonial Requirement Rejected
The question laid before the council was whether Gentile believers must be circumcised after Moses and keep the law of Moses in order to be saved, and that law meant the ceremonial, ritual law governing sacrifices and temple service, not the moral law of the Ten Commandments that forbids coveting.RH Oct 26, 1911ST Sep 9, 1880RH May 27, 1875ST Jun 3, 1875 The dispute concerned Jewish ceremonial requirements, holy days, and sabbaths, and the same conflict continued afterward among Nazaraean Jewish Christians who kept Mosaic rites.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Mar 4, 1862ST Jun 3, 1875 Its silence about a commandment released no one from it, and its decision did not release Gentiles from the Sabbath or the Ten Commandments.RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 27, 1875RH Mar 4, 1862ST Aug 12, 1875
Circumcision belonged among the ceremonial ordinances of the law of Moses, though first given to Abraham and incorporated into that law.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Feb 1851 It was a yoke that neither the fathers nor the apostles could bear, and unlike the Sabbath which continued to be kept after the cross it was a yoke of bondage.RH Feb 1851ST May 28, 1902 Those who accepted it became bound to keep the whole law of Moses with its offerings and atonements, so relying on those rites rejected Christ's one offering as the ground of justification.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Feb 1851 With the coming of gospel faith believers are redeemed from the law, freed from cumbersome ceremonies, and receive the promise of the Spirit by faith and the adoption of sons, so circumcision is no longer a sign of sonship.ST May 28, 1902
The council decided, with the Holy Spirit's leading, that Gentile disciples were not required to be circumcised or keep the ceremonial law, including circumcision.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868RH Jun 10, 1875ST May 27, 1875 This was shown by Titus the Greek convert whom Paul took to Jerusalem and who was not compelled to be circumcised, the first Christian convert who was not circumcised.RH Jun 10, 1875ST Nov 29, 1910 The ceremonial ordinances had fulfilled their purpose and ended at the cross, abolished, blotted out and nailed to the cross, and the ordinance's significance had passed away.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868 Carnal ordinances and shadowy sabbaths are distinct from the lasting Decalogue Sabbath, and the decision contrasted circumcision with keeping God's commandments, which remain a rule of life received through repentance, faith in the atonement, and obedience.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868RH Jun 10, 1875
The four requirements to abstain from things offered to idols, from blood, from strangled things, and from fornication were a Christian rule of action for the emergency dividing the flock, not an exhaustive list of duty or a replacement for the commandments of God.ST Aug 12, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH May 27, 1875RH Jul 21, 1868 Silence about other commandments does not release anyone from them, including the Sabbath commandment and most of the Ten Commandments also omitted from the letter.RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 27, 1875ST Aug 12, 1875 Treating the letter as permission to disregard everything unmentioned turns gospel liberty into lawlessness and license for immorality, and the claim that Christ released people from the Ten Commandments leaving only those four duties would make the gospel a license for immoral conduct.ST Aug 12, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH May 27, 1875 Just as its silence about baptism, murder, theft, blasphemy, false witness, or swine's flesh does not abolish those duties, so its silence about the Sabbath, murder, theft, blasphemy, and false witness does not release believers from keeping the Sabbath or refraining from those sins.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868
That decision concerning Gentile converts and the ceremonial law, sanctioned by the Holy Spirit that they observe no such thing save only those four abstentions, still held good afterward.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 22, 1885 Later counseling Paul to conform to the ceremonial law to remove misapprehension was inconsistent with it and was not prompted by the Holy Spirit.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 22, 1885 The advice arose from fear of persecution, since nonconformity exposed Christians to hatred from unbelieving Jews and to accusations before the Sanhedrin leading to swift punishment as apostates.ST May 1, 1884
Sabbath Remains Binding
The question raised was whether uncircumcised Gentile believers must be circumcised after the manner or custom of Moses and keep his law in order to be saved, and the assembly at Jerusalem took up circumcision and the ceremonial or ritual law, not whether the moral law of the Ten Commandments or the seventh-day Sabbath remains binding.RH Oct 26, 1911ST Sep 9, 1880RH May 27, 1875RH Mar 4, 1862ST Aug 12, 1875 The omission of the Sabbath from the list of necessary requirements no more abolishes the Sabbath than the omission of most other commandments abolishes them, since only one commandment is mentioned and silence about a commandment does not release anyone from it.RH Oct 26, 1911RH May 27, 1875RH Mar 4, 1862ST Aug 12, 1875ST Aug 30, 1883 The four prohibitions to abstain from idolatry, blood, strangled things, and fornication were not an exhaustive Christian rule of conduct, and to treat the letter as permission to disregard every duty it does not mention, such as baptism, murder, theft, blasphemy, false witness, or swine's flesh, turns gospel liberty into lawlessness and license for immorality.ST Aug 12, 1875
No complaint that the Gentile converts were breaking the Sabbath was raised by the visitors from Judea and Jerusalem, and no Sabbath dispute is recorded, though circumcision provoked long and heated debate with much disputing.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 8, 1880RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 15, 1904 Their charge concerned circumcision and the ceremonial law, not Sabbath observance.ST Jun 8, 1882ST Jul 8, 1880RH May 5, 1874 If the Gentiles had neglected the Sabbath too, or if Christians had taught that it was changed or abolished, it would have caused an even greater disturbance and strong resistance, so the absence of controversy attests that the Gentile believers had not been taught to neglect it and that the apostolic church faithfully kept the day of rest in the way Christ taught while the apostles continued to observe it.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Jul 8, 1880ST Nov 5, 1912RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 15, 1904
The Sabbath is referred to only in the statement that Moses is read in the synagogues every Sabbath day, which proves that Sabbath keeping continued and marked the apostolic churches.RH May 26, 1863 The nature of the dispute over circumcision strongly attests that the ancient Sabbath had not been abolished or changed before the meeting, and when the meeting ended the Sabbath remained sacred as part of the fourth commandment.RH May 26, 1863RH Mar 4, 1862 The sacredness of the Sabbath was not questioned at the council and the first day of the week was never mentioned, so the controversy did not concern replacing the Sabbath with Sunday observance, and claims that this assembly released the Gentiles from the Sabbath misrepresent it.RH May 26, 1863ST Oct 18, 1899
Appeal to this chapter as chief proof against obligation to keep the seventh-day Sabbath, together with 2 Corinthians 3, fails and is easily answered.RH Nov 30, 1869 The council gives no weapon against commandment-keepers, and those who use it to attack the law turn its argument against themselves.RH Nov 17, 1859 The claim that the commandments were not transferred or given to the Gentiles conflicts with the opponents' own position on the Jerusalem council, and the meeting's silence about keeping the Ten Commandments was wrongly used to argue that they had been abolished.RH Jul 28, 1868ST Sep 13, 1877RH Feb 26, 1857 Keeping the seventh-day Sabbath does not require circumcision or keeping the Mosaic ordinances in order to be saved, and since the demand reported does not say its teachers required keeping the seventh-day Sabbath, it is not evidence that circumcision and Sabbath keeping together were taught as necessary for salvation.RH May 10, 1860
Church Council Pattern
The verse opens the account of the first general council or conference of the Christian church held at Jerusalem to settle the dispute over whether circumcision was required for salvation.RH May 5, 1863RH Apr 29, 1909ST Oct 29, 1912RH Aug 24, 1916 Unauthorized independent teachers from Judea had carried questions of teaching and practice into the Gentile churches, and the resulting dispute over circumcision and the ceremonial law generally could not be settled by a single local church alone.RH May 5, 1863RH Aug 18, 1874RH May 9, 1907RH Aug 24, 1916 That gathering, in which leading men came together to counsel concerning things of general interest with representatives of all concerned, answers the same purpose as a General Conference and provides the pattern for General Conferences, for council meetings in Fiji, and for all time.RH Apr 29, 1909RH Mar 3, 1904RH Aug 18, 1874RH Aug 24, 1916 When a new emergency arises it is to be met when it arises, with questions requiring the believers' attention considered by Bible principles under the Holy Spirit's guidance so that the work proceeds rightly and in unity.RH Nov 12, 1903RH Mar 3, 1904RH Aug 18, 1874
Delegates from Antioch and other churches, including Paul and Barnabas with responsible representatives, met with the apostles and elders and the whole church at Jerusalem, and discussion was to wait for their decision which the churches were expected to accept.RH May 5, 1863RH Apr 29, 1909RH May 9, 1907RH May 9, 1907CO 83.3 James presided over the apostolic council and framed its conclusions, while Peter was present only as one among his fellow apostles.RH Apr 29, 1909RH Jun 13, 1871RH Oct 19, 1916 He did not convoke the council, he did not preside over it, and he did not formulate or promulgate its canons, for its decrees went forth in the name of the apostles and elders and brethren.RH May 5, 1863RH Jun 13, 1871 This proves Peter held no lordship or papal primacy or infallible headship over the apostles and the church, and it shows the council did not claim infallibility but decided through enlightened judgment, with apostles correct when led by the Spirit.RH May 5, 1863RH Apr 29, 1909RH Jun 13, 1871
The council proceeded by orderly counsel with much disputing and discussion and amazing liberty rather than enforced uniformity, preserving freedom of conscience.LS 406.3–407.1ST Jun 11, 1874ST Feb 14, 1906RH Dec 1, 1874RH Dec 28, 1905 The apostles and elders did not order or command nor lord it over God's heritage but acted as wise counselors who gave room for the Holy Ghost to act as Judge.LS 406.3–407.1ST Jun 11, 1874RH Dec 1, 1874 Christ by His Spirit came into that teachable assembly and witnessed to Paul's account of his conversion and of the work God had done among the Gentiles, leading prejudices to be yielded and differing opinions to be reconciled.LS 406.3–407.1ST May 1, 1884RH Dec 1, 1874 The united decision was expressed as seeming good to the Holy Ghost and to them, settling to the satisfaction of all the question of circumcision as necessary for salvation so that it would not impair spiritual efficiency.LS 406.3–407.1ST Jun 11, 1874RH Dec 1, 1874RH Dec 28, 1905 That settlement brought consolation and joy to the Gentile brethren in Antioch and Syria and Cilicia, with harmony, peace, and encouragement, and differences settled by Christ's leading in this way remain settled.LS 406.3–407.1ST Jun 11, 1874ST Feb 14, 1906RH Dec 1, 1874
Churches connected to Christ recognized such united, Spirit-guided decisions as authoritative under the Word of God, kept the decrees ordained at Jerusalem, and were established in the faith so that harmony and unity could prevail.RH May 9, 1907CO 83.3RH Apr 29, 1909 Testing those who claimed apostolic authority while teaching that believers must keep the law of Moses was the work of the whole apostolic congregation at Jerusalem, not of one church alone.RH Mar 26, 1857RH Jun 10, 1862ST Jan 15, 1880 Yet some in the church promoted separation and error through independence and anarchy, murmuring and finding fault and undermining experienced leaders, and were unwilling to accept the council's decision.RH Apr 29, 1909
The teaching from Judea that Gentile believers could not be saved unless circumcised after the manner of Moses raised the momentous question whether Gentile believers stood on equal footing with Jewish believers under the gospel.ST Mar 13, 1884RH May 9, 1907RH Feb 26, 1901 The dispute concerned righteousness by faith, regeneration, and the organization of Christ's body, and it concerned the prosperity and even the existence of the Christian church.RH May 9, 1907RH Feb 26, 1901 The same question of whether a Hebrew in becoming a Christian is obliged to abrogate the ritual of Mosaic Judaism and Levitical customs and ceremonies is not new, and it is met properly only by letting the Word of God have undisputed sway, letting God say what shall be done and then doing it without quibble or hesitation.RH May 9, 1907ST May 8, 1901
Scripture Connections Clarified
The demand at Antioch that Gentile believers could not be saved unless circumcised according to Moses prompted the Jerusalem council and was the same issue that threatened the Galatians by imposing circumcision and the law of Moses on Paul's converts and thereby undermining his work.RH Jun 10, 1875 The Jerusalem council addressed and settled this question by deciding that Gentile disciples were not required to be circumcised, as shown by Titus the Greek convert who was not compelled to undergo it, proving the ceremonial law was no longer binding on Christians.RH Jun 10, 1875 Acts 15:1-35 is the only biblical parallel to the controversy in Galatians over circumcision and obligations belonging to the former dispensation, and Galatians 2 deals with this conference and what led to it and grew out of it, so Acts 15 must be borne in mind when reading Galatians 2.RH Oct 8, 1857 The circumcision requirement was a yoke imposed on the disciples and part of the ceremonial ordinances, treated as an end and not a means and trusted as able to impart righteousness and procure salvation while superseding the need of Christ.RH Sep 17, 1901 It revealed faith that did not grasp the spiritual conditions and eternal realities of the promise but rested in the literal and temporal, which Paul battled in Galatians to set the Jewish people right, for when the Seed came in Christ's appearing, circumcision and the whole ceremonial law disappeared as stars fade before the sun.RH Sep 17, 1901
The dispute at Antioch arose when believers were judged by interpreting the law through Jewish traditions and drawn back into ceremonial requirements.RH Jan 2, 1900 That early trouble over teachers saying keeping the law of Moses, including circumcision, was necessary for salvation shows that the teaching about food, festivals, new moons, and sabbaths in Colossians 2 applied to the church in the apostles' day, not to observers of the seventh-day Sabbath.RH Jan 2, 1900RH Oct 21, 1851
The restoration of David's kingdom in the chapter is a gospel work fulfilled through Christ, beginning with the presentation of David's heir to the Jews, gathering the true seed from all nations to take a people for God's name, and completed when Christ receives David's throne, the nations are destroyed under the seventh trumpet, and his kingdom is established under the whole heavens.RH Mar 25, 1873ST Oct 9, 1879 It does not teach a restoration of the Jews as a people or the conversion of the whole world, since the gospel's purpose is not to convert everyone but to make salvation possible for all and gather those who accept its invitation.RH Mar 25, 1873ST Oct 9, 1879
Certain restrictions were placed on Gentile converts, but the old Levitical laws were not imposed on them because those ceremonial laws had been given to the Jewish nation. The distinction between clean and unclean animals remained a matter of principle and not merely a rule created by Levitical law, while the apostles turned to the Gentiles who remained bound by the prohibition against eating blood.RH Dec 31, 1861
The chapter belongs to the last account in Acts of the apostles acting as a body, dated to A.D. 52, and it gives no hint that they changed the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first.RH Nov 28, 1871
Sources