Acts 5:36
For before these days rose up Theudas, boasting himself to be somebody; to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered, and brought to nought.
Translations
For before these days rose up Theudas, boasting himself to be somebody; to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered, and brought to nothing.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
For before these days rose up Theudas, boasting himself to be somebody; to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered, and brought to nought.
For before these days rose Theudas, boasting himself to be somebody; to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered, and brought to naught.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For before these days rose up Theudas, giving himself out to be somebody; to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were dispersed, and came to nought.
for before these days rose up Theudas, saying, that himself was some one, to whom a number of men did join themselves, as it were four hundred, who was slain, and all, as many as were obeying him, were scattered, and came to nought.
for before these days Theudas rose up, alleging himself to be somebody, to whom a number of men, about four hundred, were joined; who was slain, and all, as many as obeyed him, were dispersed and came to nothing.
For, before these days, there rose up one Theudas, affirming, himself, to be somebody,—unto whom was inclined a number of men, about four hundred; who was slain, and, all as many as had been trusting in him, were disbanded, and came to nothing.
Some time ago Theudas rose up, claiming to be somebody, and about four hundred men joined him. He was killed, all his followers were dispersed, and it all came to nothing.
Some time ago Theudas rose up, claiming to be somebody, and about four hundred men rallied to him. He was killed, all his followers were dispersed, and it all came to nothing.
For before these days Theudas rose up, making himself out to be somebody; to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves. He was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were dispersed and came to nothing.
For before this there was Theudas, who said he was someone important, to whom about four hundred men gave their support: he was put to death, and his band was broken up and came to nothing.
For before these times, rose vp Theudas boasting himselfe, to whom resorted a number of men, about a foure hundreth, who was slaine: and they all which obeyed him, were scattered, and brought to nought.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For before these days rose up Theodas, affirming himself to be somebody, to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all that believed him were scattered, and brought to nothing.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
11 sources
The verse belongs to the account of the apostles' witness before the Sanhedrin, amid opposition to their preaching about Christ's cross and resurrection.SPBC 139.2AA 77.1 It describes a former claimant whose movement came to nothing after he was killed.SPBC 139.2 The fifth chapter in which the verse stands shows that God will just as surely punish deceptive, unstraightforward, oppressive and unjust dealings in His work in order that the truth shall triumph.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28 That includes fraud and connivance, exacting exorbitant prices, diverting His means into a wrong channel, and using lawyers to take advantage of circumstances.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28
The speaker is Gamaliel, whom God raised up for the moment, a learned Pharisee and doctor of great reputation, learning, high position, extreme caution and clear intellect.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1RH Feb 9, 1911 He recognized the voice of God in the disciples' words.AA 82.3–83.1 He intervened when the priests and rulers, enraged by Peter charging them with murdering Christ, decided without further trial and without authority from the Roman officers to take the law into their own hands and put the prisoners to death.7RED 27.1RH Feb 9, 1911 Knowing the elements he dealt with, that the murderers of Christ would hesitate at nothing to carry out their purpose, and seeing with clear intellect that such violence would lead to terrible consequences, he had the prisoners removed and then spoke with great deliberation and calmness to the men of Israel to take heed what they intended to do.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1RH Feb 9, 1911 His warning was against using violence to suppress the apostles before the character of their movement was clear.AA 82.3–83.1SLP 13.1–2
Theudas rose up before that time, boasting himself to be somebody and claiming importance for himself, to whom about four hundred men joined themselves.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2AA 82.3–83.1AC1 26.2–27.2 He was slain and killed, and all who obeyed and followed him were scattered and dispersed, and his cause and movement were brought to nothing and ended in failure.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1AC1 26.2–27.2RH Feb 9, 1911 The example is the first proof that counsel and work begun by human beings comes to nothing and that human movements fail.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1SPBC 140.2–3 It shows that a human-led movement can collapse when its leader is gone.AC1 26.2–27.2 It warns against hastily attacking a movement that may fail on its own.3SP 290.1–2AC1 26.2–27.2
Applied to the apostles, the council should refrain from them and let them alone and take care before knowing whether their work is from God.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1AC1 26.2–27.2SLP 13.1–2 For if their counsel and work is of men it will fail in the same way, but if it is of God it cannot be overthrown.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2AA 82.3–83.1 Opposing a work begun by God cannot overthrow it and may amount to fighting against God.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1SPBC 140.2–3 His plea for the apostles prevailed and the priests saw the counsel as reasonable and agreed to it, though they still beat the disciples and repeatedly forbade them to preach in the name of Jesus before releasing them.RH Feb 9, 1911STMW6 5.1–6.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
26 sources
Gamaliel, a Pharisee of high reputation and caution, had the apostles removed when the enraged council would have put them to death without trial, and cautioned the council to refrain from them lest they be found fighting against God, and by that moderate counsel spared the apostles from immediate violence and gave them opportunity to keep preaching.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902ST May 7, 1885 Theudas gave himself out to be somebody great and drew about four hundred men to himself, but he was slain and all who obeyed him were scattered and brought to nothing.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906 He stands as the first precedent that if the apostles were criminal disturbers like him, Rome itself would attend to them without the council risking trouble by overreaching its powers.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902 What is begun by human effort will fail and be overthrown, while what is of God and done in the name of Jesus will bear the test and cannot be overthrown.RH Jul 8, 1875ST May 24, 1899RH Jul 8, 1875 Theudas arose before Jesus as a false claimant to be the coming one, and his counterfeit lacked the divine credential of fulfilled prophecy.ST Feb 4, 1897RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 A movement built around a self-exalting leader collapses when its leader is gone, and that same love of self and power will draw disciples after domineering men and culminate in self-exaltation set as God in the temple, which is the church.RH May 17, 1906ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 14, 1901
Setting and Historical Sense
The words belong to Gamaliel's intervention when the council, enraged by the charge that they had murdered Christ, had decided without further trial and without Roman authority to put the apostles to death.RH Feb 9, 1911ST May 7, 1885RH Jan 18, 1912 Gamaliel was a Pharisee of high reputation, learning, position, caution and clear intellect, who saw that violence would bring terrible consequences.RH Feb 9, 1911 He had the prisoners removed and spoke with deliberation and calmness, cautioning the council to take heed what to do with these men.RH Feb 9, 1911ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902 He advised refraining from them and leaving the matter alone, lest they be found fighting against God.RH Feb 9, 1911RH Jan 18, 1912 His moderate counsel spared the apostles from immediate violence, protected the early gospel movement, and for a time gave the disciples opportunity to continue preaching, though the priests still beat the disciples and repeatedly forbade them to preach in the name of Jesus before releasing them.RH Feb 9, 1911ST May 7, 1885RH Feb 16, 1911
Theudas is described as boasting himself and giving himself out to be somebody important and great.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 About four hundred men joined themselves to him.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 He was slain and killed.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 All, as many as obeyed him, were scattered and dispersed and brought to nought.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902 So his movement ended in failure.RH Feb 9, 1911RH May 17, 1906RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876
He is cited as the first precedent to guide the council's course.ST Feb 12, 1902 He is presented as a criminal disturber of the kind dealt with by the Roman government.ST Feb 12, 1902 The point is that the Jewish council did not need to put the apostles to death and risk trouble with the government by rashly overreaching its recognized powers, for if the apostles were really criminal disturbers like Theudas, Rome would attend to them.ST Feb 12, 1902 The phrase before these days shows the sense of the Greek word for day as a full day of twenty-four hours embracing night and day.RH Dec 12, 1871 It belongs with texts where periods of days are specified or a succession of days is mentioned, in which day stands for the entire twenty-four hours.RH Dec 12, 1871
The chapter around the verse records a great revival with multitudes of men and women added to the Lord.RH Sep 28, 1916 It was kept from becoming a great defeat like Israel at Ai because the hidden sin of Ananias and his wife, what Achan was to Israel, was detected and put away before a great work for God through the manifest presence of the Holy Spirit and spiritual discernment.RH Sep 28, 1916 The verse is included among the post-resurrection condemnations and persecutions of the apostles and Christ's people which, together with the rejection and crucifixion of Christ, filled up Jerusalem's measure of iniquity before its destruction.RH May 10, 1915 The court in which the words were spoken united civil and ecclesiastical power, being composed of the council and senate with the high priest as judge dictating procedure, so that the civil power was subject to the decrees of the church.ST Feb 12, 1902
Teaching and Present Application
The example gives the test that a work originating with men and begun by human effort will fail and be overthrown and come to nothing, while a work that is of God and done in the name of Jesus and standing on the plain Word of God will bear the test and cannot be overthrown, and to oppose it is to fight against God.RH Jul 8, 1875ST May 24, 1899RH Jul 8, 1875ST Jun 13, 1900ST Feb 12, 1902 Theudas claimed importance and gathered about four hundred followers, but after he was killed his followers scattered and were dispersed and his movement ended in failure.RH Feb 9, 1911RH Jul 8, 1875 The steady progress of a work is evidence of God's providence and grounds for confidence that it will endure.ST May 24, 1899
Gamaliel's counsel is sound sense, sound doctrine, wise, concise and reasonable, and wise caution when people are quick to call unfamiliar teaching heresy.RH Jul 8, 1875ST Dec 25, 1893RH Sep 22, 1868ST Feb 12, 1902 Whether it was divinely inspired is left uncertain.RH Jul 8, 1875 It was not an expression of support for Christianity but a means of letting time test the Christian movement, and his moderate advice helped spare the apostles from immediate violence and protected the early gospel movement.ST May 7, 1885
Theudas is a false messiah and false claimant who arose before Jesus in the days of Christ's first advent, claiming to be the one who should come and presenting himself as someone important and great.ST Feb 4, 1897RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 His claim was counterfeit because it lacked the divine credentials of harmonious fulfillment of prophecy.ST Sep 16, 1875 His failure, with his followers scattered and his movement brought to nothing after he was killed, warns against later religious claimants who offer substitute kingdoms or experiences instead of the hope of Christ's promised return.RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876ST Sep 16, 1875
Theudas illustrates the failure of a movement built around a self-exalting human leader and human ambition, which collapses and comes to nothing when its leader is gone.RH May 17, 1906ST Feb 12, 1902 He claimed personal importance and greatness and gathered about four hundred followers, but after he was killed his followers scattered.RH May 17, 1906ST Feb 12, 1902 The root sin of love of self and love of power that produced such boasting in Jewish times will just as surely develop from human hearts in Gentile times among overseers of the church, with men seeking power and drawing disciples after themselves, seen in domineering leaders who love pre-eminence and culminating in the great apostasy where tolerated self-exaltation places a self-declared head as God in the temple of God, which is the church.RH May 14, 1901
Applied to the apostles' preaching, the issue was whether it fulfilled God's promises of redemption and salvation or was a counterfeit opposed to God.RH Jul 8, 1875 The verse also serves as an example of a failed revolt presented as a call to liberty from secular Roman rule that ended in defeat with followers scattered, leaving open whether its cause was just.RH May 18, 1916 More broadly it shows how Satan hinders God's power by the established church uniting with civil power to restrain every movement advocating religious reform in order to maintain its own ascendency and keep out rivalry, since letting truth have free course would draw adherents under the Spirit's influence and disintegrate its own source of authority.ST Feb 12, 1902
Sources