Acts 5:37
After this man rose up Judas of Galilee in the days of the taxing, and drew away much people after him: he also perished; and all, even as many as obeyed him, were dispersed.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
After this man rose up Judas of Galilee in the days of the taxing, and drew away much people after him: he also perished; and all, even as many as obeyed him, were dispersed.
After this man rose Judas of Galilee, in the days of the taxing, and drew away many people after him: he also perished; and all, even as many as obeyed him, were dispersed.
After this man rose up Judas of Galilee in the days of the enrollment, and drew away some of the people after him: he also perished; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered abroad.
After this man rose up Judas of Galilee in the days of the enrolment, and drew away some of the people after him: he also perished; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered abroad.
'After this one rose up, Judas the Galilean, in the days of the enrolment, and drew away much people after him, and that one perished, and all, as many as were obeying him, were scattered;
After him rose Judas the Galilean in the days of the census, and drew away [ a number of] people after him; and he perished, and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered abroad.
After him, rose up Judas the Galilaean, in the days of the enrolling, and drew a people into revolt after him; and, he, perished, and, all, as many as had trusted in him, were scattered.
After him, Judas the Galilean appeared in the days of the census and drew away people after him. He too perished, and all his followers were scattered.
After him, Judas the Galilean appeared in the days of the census and drew away many people after him. He too perished, and all his followers were scattered.
After this man, Judas of Galilee rose up in the days of the enrollment, and drew away some people after him. He also perished, and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered abroad.
After this man, there was Judas of Galilee, at the time of the numbering, and some of the people went after him: he was put to death, and all his supporters were put to flight.
After this man, arose vp Iudas of Galile, in the dayes of the tribute, and drewe away much people after him: hee also perished, and all that obeyed him, were scattered abroad.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
After this man, rose up Judas of Galilee, in the days of the enrolling, and drew away the people after him: he also perished; and all, even as many as consented to him, were dispersed.
Cross-references
- Matthew 22:15-22
Then went the Pharisees, and took counsel how they might entangle him in his talk.
shows significance of Judas's cry against tribute
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
10 sources
The words are those of Gamaliel, a learned Pharisee and doctor of the law, a man of great reputation, learning, high position, and extreme caution.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1 He spoke them in pleading for the apostles after the rulers were cut to the heart by their witness that they must obey God rather than men and took counsel to kill them.AA 82.3–83.1STMW6 5.1–6.1 Knowing he was dealing with murderers of Christ who would stop at nothing to carry out their purpose, he recognized the divine voice in the disciples' words and saw clearly that the violent course contemplated by the priests would lead to terrible consequences.AA 82.3–83.1 He therefore had the imprisoned apostles removed and then spoke with great deliberation and calmness, telling the men of Israel to take heed what they intended to do.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1 His counsel was to let the movement opposing them reveal its character before using violence, and his words prevailed to save the apostles at that time.AA 82.3–83.1SLP 13.1–2STMW6 5.1–6.1
His second example of a merely human movement, after Theudas, was that Judas of Galilee rose in the days of the taxing at the time of the census enrollment.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2AA 82.3–83.1 He drew away much people after him and gathered many followers.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1AC1 26.2–27.2 Yet he perished and died, and all who obeyed and followed him were dispersed and scattered.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2Ms 22, 1900, par. 26–28AA 82.3–83.1AC1 26.2–27.2 His failed movement stands as the record given in the verse.3SP 290.1–2Ms 22, 1900, par. 26–28RH Feb 9, 1911
Judas and the scattering of his followers serve as proof and warning that a movement, cause, counsel, undertaking, or work originating with men and led by men will fail and come to nothing.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2Ms 22, 1900, par. 26–28AA 82.3–83.1AC1 26.2–27.2 Gamaliel therefore urges refraining from the apostles and leaving them alone.7RED 27.1AA 82.3–83.1 For if their counsel or work is of men it will come to naught like that of Judas, but if it is of God it cannot be overthrown.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2AA 82.3–83.1SPBC 140.2–3RH Feb 9, 1911 To oppose it in that case is to oppose God and to fight against God.7RED 27.13SP 290.1–2Ms 22, 1900, par. 26–28AA 82.3–83.1
Together with the rest of Acts 5, the verse shows that God will just as surely punish deceptive, unstraightforward, oppressive, and unjust dealings in His work as He punished Ananias and Sapphira.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28 This includes using lawyers to take advantage of circumstances, exacting exorbitant prices, practicing fraud and connivance, hindering His cause, and diverting His means into a wrong channel.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28 For He has a work to accomplish on earth in order that the truth shall triumph, and He will pass judgment against every wrongdoer.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
29 sources
This is Gamaliel's second precedent in his plea for caution to the council, like that of Theudas before it.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Dec 25, 1893RH Sep 22, 1868 It tells that Judas of Galilee rose up in the days of the taxing, drew away much people after him, perished, and all who obeyed him were dispersed.ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893 The taxing was the census and Roman tax under Quirinus governor of Syria, laid by Emperor Augustus.RH May 18, 1916ST Feb 12, 1902 It belongs to his counsel to refrain from the apostles and let them alone, because counsel or work of men will come to nothing, but what is of God cannot be overthrown, and to oppose it may be to fight against God.ST Feb 12, 1902RH Jul 8, 1875 His failed movement is the example of a human leader drawing people to himself rather than exalting Christ, whose work collapsed when he died, and the protection given by the speech shielded the young gospel movement for a time to continue preaching.RH Feb 9, 1911RH May 17, 1906ST May 24, 1899ST May 7, 1885RH Feb 16, 1911
Gamaliel's Counsel and Setting
Acts 5 stands in a time of great revival in which multitudes of both men and women were added to the Lord.RH Sep 28, 1916 The manifest presence of the Holy Ghost was seen in spiritual discernment that detected and put away the sin of Ananias and his wife, as Achan's sin was put away from Israel.RH Sep 28, 1916 By that purging the church escaped the kind of defeat Israel suffered at Ai and could go forward in a great work for God.RH Sep 28, 1916
The verse belongs to the trial of the apostles before the council and senate of the Jews, a court joining religious and civil power with the high priest sitting as judge and dictating procedure.ST Feb 12, 1902 The members were cut to the heart and were minded to slay the apostles, then commanded to put the apostles forth a little while.ST Feb 12, 1902 Then Gamaliel, a Pharisee and doctor of the law honored by all the people, stood up and warned the men of Israel to take heed what they were about to do.ST Feb 12, 1902
What is recorded here is Gamaliel's second precedent in his plea for caution, the other similar case like that of Theudas.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 12, 1902 It was offered as wise counsel.ST Dec 25, 1893 It stands as a reasonable appeal for those resisting religious truth to consider.RH Sep 22, 1868
Judas of Galilee rose up in the days of the taxing or enrolment or census.ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893RH Sep 22, 1868ST Nov 16, 1876 He drew away much or many people after him.ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893RH Sep 22, 1868ST Nov 16, 1876 He also perished, and all, even as many as obeyed him, were dispersed or scattered abroad.ST Feb 12, 1902RH May 17, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893RH Sep 22, 1868ST Nov 16, 1876 The same is recalled as a human work coming to nothing, unlike a work that is of God and cannot be overthrown.RH Feb 9, 1911
The uprising was an insurrection in Galilee during Roman rule, when heavy taxes and Roman authority reminded the Jews of their subjection.ST Jul 16, 1894 It occurred when Jesus was ten years old.ST Jul 16, 1894 The taxing was the census and Roman tax under Quirinus governor of Syria.RH May 18, 1916
The revolt was in opposition to the land tax imposed by Emperor Augustus, raising the cry that it is not lawful to pay tribute to Caesar.ST Feb 12, 1902 Those who held that Judas opposed paying the temple tax placed his resistance while Jerusalem was under Roman rule.ST Oct 27, 1881 His enemies may have tried to associate Jesus with that resistance.ST Oct 27, 1881
Human Work Versus God's Work
The verse belongs to counsel over whether the work of the apostles was from human beings or from God.RH Jul 8, 1875RH Jul 8, 1875 They were proclaiming Jesus as the promised Messiah, that God had fulfilled His promise by giving a Redeemer and Saviour, and that redemption and salvation were offered through faith and obedience.RH Jul 8, 1875RH Jul 8, 1875 That proclamation was either a true fulfillment of God's promises or a false work opposed to God.RH Jul 8, 1875RH Jul 8, 1875
The counsel was to refrain from the apostles and let them alone and leave their cause to the test of time.ST Feb 12, 1902RH Jul 8, 1875RH Jan 18, 1912ST Jun 13, 1900 Counsel or work of men will come to nothing and be overthrown, but what is of God cannot be overthrown.ST Feb 12, 1902RH Jul 8, 1875RH Jan 18, 1912ST Jun 13, 1900 To oppose it might mean fighting against God.RH Jul 8, 1875RH Jan 18, 1912ST Jun 13, 1900 The restraint urged in the speech kept the council from using immediate violence against the apostles.ST May 7, 1885RH Feb 16, 1911 That protection was one of the means used to shield the young gospel movement and gave them, for a time, an opportunity to continue preaching the gospel.ST May 7, 1885RH Feb 16, 1911
Judas of Galilee is one of the false messiahs who arose before the true Messiah in the days of the first advent, together with Theudas, claiming to be the one who should come.ST Feb 4, 1897RH Feb 23, 1869ST Sep 16, 1875 He was not like John the Baptist or the prophets, who were sent by God and did not claim to be the Messiah.ST Feb 4, 1897 His failed movement is the example of a human leader drawing people to himself rather than exalting Christ, proclaiming his own greatness and gathering many followers.RH Feb 9, 1911RH May 17, 1906ST May 24, 1899RH Jan 18, 1912ST Feb 12, 1902 Such a work not sustained by God comes to nothing, collapsing when its leader dies and his followers are dispersed and scattered abroad.RH Feb 9, 1911RH May 17, 1906ST May 24, 1899RH Jan 18, 1912ST Feb 12, 1902
Counterfeit religious leaders and false time messages may appear before or after a genuine prophetic fulfillment but lack its divine credentials and harmonious fulfillment.ST Sep 16, 1875 Movements claiming to offer the kingdom of God in place of Christ's promised return are like those earlier movements that gathered followers and came to nothing.RH Feb 23, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 Substitutes such as the claims about Ann Lee, the New-Jerusalem state, Christ coming at the destruction of Jerusalem, manifestations of familiar spirits in secret chambers, and a kingdom of God in the desert are not to be followed.RH Feb 23, 1869 These are found among the Shakers, Swedenborgians, Oneida Community, Spiritualists, and Mormons, all such Lo heres and Lo theres offering substitutes for the kingdom of God.RH Feb 23, 1869 Those who long to see that same Jesus wait till the opening heavens reveal Him.RH Feb 23, 1869
Authority, Persecution, and Warning
The verse belongs to the trial of the apostles before the council and senate of the Jews, a court joining religious and civil power with the high priest sitting as judge and dictating procedure.ST Feb 12, 1902 It is included among the biblical illustrations of the limit of human rule, that civil authority must not take the place of conscience or God.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Feb 12, 1902 Civil laws bind all alike without regard to individual conscience or preference, while religion is a matter of personal preference for each person singly and must be left to the power of the Holy Ghost.ST Feb 12, 1902 Bringing the working of the Holy Ghost into conflict with human laws brings persecution on the religious side, and bigotry framed into law quickly ripens into persecution.ST Feb 12, 1902 The verse thus shows persecution made possible by union of church and civil power, where the civil is made subject to the decrees of the church and its force is used to enforce religion.ST Feb 12, 1902
The account shows how Satan hinders God's power among men, for the established church unites with civil power to restrain every movement for religious reform in order to maintain its own ascendency.ST Feb 12, 1902 Letting God's truth have free course would bring its own adherents under the influence of the Spirit and disintegrate its source of authority.ST Feb 12, 1902 Though it has no right forcibly to interfere since it draws recruits from all ranks, once established it treats the field as exclusively its own and appeals to civil power for laws that will not tolerate prescribed differences in order to keep out all rivalry.ST Feb 12, 1902 The verse gives an example of a leader whose followers were scattered after he perished, and it is cited among instances of persecution against Christ's apostles for preaching Christ.RH Jun 8, 1916 It is grouped with Daniel 3 as an example of persecutors, whose actions differ from a government draft intended to defend the people rather than oppress them, so that difference in motive matters when judging an action.RH Sep 23, 1862
Judas rose in the days of the taxing to incite insurrection and draw much people after him with the watchword of Liberty, kindled by the old theocratic spirit.RH May 18, 1916 He stood forth as the great apostle of liberty calling the people from bondage and slavery to mortal men as lords to freedom from the imposed yoke.RH May 18, 1916 He taught that after God they should submit to no mortal lord, that it was cowardice to endure paying tax to the Romans, and promised deliverance from enthroned tyranny to all who would follow him.RH May 18, 1916 His mission of liberty failed, for he perished and all who obeyed him were dispersed and brought to nothing.RH May 18, 1916 It illustrates an effort to secure freedom from supposed domination by the secular power under the shibboleth of Liberty, which is the shibboleth of rebellion and apostasy, whether the cause in which it is used is righteous and just or not.RH May 18, 1916
Judas opposed Roman taxation and led many people away after him, and his revolt ended with his death and the dispersal of his followers. The Eleazar who defended Masada is connected with Judas as his ancestor, sharing Judas's resistance to Roman rule and belief that submitting to any authority but God was impious. The taxing was the census and Roman tax under Quirinus governor of Syria, and in the weight of teaching the revolt was in opposition to the land tax imposed by Emperor Augustus, raising the cry that it is not lawful to pay tribute to Caesar, while those who held the other teaching identified it as opposition to paying the temple tax while Jerusalem was under Roman rule.RH May 18, 1916ST Feb 12, 1902ST Oct 27, 1881 His example and its result show the significance of the attempt of the Pharisees and Herodians to get Christ to commit Himself on the question of tribute to Caesar.ST Feb 12, 1902 Jesus' enemies may have tried to associate Him with Judas's resistance.ST Oct 27, 1881 His rising is presented as a precedent for a popular revolt, and the prospect of a national rising around Jesus was feared as potentially even fiercer than Judas's.ST Apr 20, 1882
Sources