Deuteronomy 28:41
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters, but thou shalt not enjoy them; for they shall go into captivity.
Translations
You shall beget sons and daughters, but you shall not enjoy them; for they shall go into captivity.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters, but thou shalt not enjoy them; for they shall go into captivity.
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters, but thou shalt not enjoy them: for they shall go into captivity.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters, but they shall not be thine; for they shall go into captivity.
'Sons and daughters thou dost beget, and they are not with thee, for they go into captivity;
Sons and daughters shalt thou beget, but thou shalt not have them [ to be with thee]; for they shall go into captivity.
Sons and daughters, shalt thou beget, and they shall not be thine, for they shall go into captivity.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
You will father sons and daughters, but they will not remain yours, because they will go into captivity.
You will father sons and daughters, but they will not be yours, for they will go into captivity.
You will have sons and daughters, but they will not be yours; for they will go away prisoners into a strange land.
Thou shalt beget sonnes, and daughters, but shalt not haue them: for they shall goe into captiuitie.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters, and shalt not enjoy them: because they shall be led into captivity.
Cross-references
- Leviticus 26:14-39
But if ye will not hearken unto me, and will not do all these commandments;
Disobedience brings covenant judgment, including scattering and exile.
- Deuteronomy 28:3-4
Blessed shalt thou be in the city, and blessed shalt thou be in the field.
The blessing on offspring contrasts with the curse of children carried into captivity.
- Daniel 9:11-14
Yea, all Israel have transgressed thy law, even by departing, that they might not obey thy voice; therefore the curse is poured upon us, and the oath that is written in the law of Moses the servant of God, because we have sinned against him.
The curse in Moses’ law came upon Israel because they sinned.
- Luke 21:24
And they shall fall by the edge of the sword, and shall be led away captive into all nations: and Jerusalem shall be trodden down of the Gentiles, until the times of the Gentiles be fulfilled.
Jesus foretells death and captivity among the nations.
- Ezra 1:1-4
Now in the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, that the word of the LORD by the mouth of Jeremiah might be fulfilled, the LORD stirred up the spirit of Cyrus king of Persia, that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and put it also in writing, saying,
It records the return to the land after the exile.
- Isaiah 10:6
I will send him against an hypocritical nation, and against the people of my wrath will I give him a charge, to take the spoil, and to take the prey, and to tread them down like the mire of the streets.
Both describe the Lord’s judgment through a hostile power.
- Jeremiah 25:11
And this whole land shall be a desolation, and an astonishment; and these nations shall serve the king of Babylon seventy years.
Foretells the seventy-year duration of captivity.
- 2 Chronicles 36:15-16
And the LORD God of their fathers sent to them by his messengers, rising up betimes, and sending; because he had compassion on his people, and on his dwelling place:
Mocking God’s messengers brought remediless wrath and captivity.
- Psalms 14:7
Oh that the salvation of Israel were come out of Zion! when the LORD bringeth back the captivity of his people, Jacob shall rejoice, and Israel shall be glad.
Celebrates the turning of Jacob’s captivity.
- Daniel 1:1-2
In the third year of the reign of Jehoiakim king of Judah came Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon unto Jerusalem, and besieged it.
Judah’s captivity unfolds as part of prophecy tracing the rise and fall of nations.
- Deuteronomy 28:53-57
And thou shalt eat the fruit of thine own body, the flesh of thy sons and of thy daughters, which the LORD thy God hath given thee, in the siege, and in the straitness, wherewith thine enemies shall distress thee:
The siege of Jerusalem fulfills the famine and distress described in the covenant curse.
- Deuteronomy 28:64
And the LORD shall scatter thee among all people, from the one end of the earth even unto the other; and there thou shalt serve other gods, which neither thou nor thy fathers have known, even wood and stone.
Israel is scattered among the nations as a judgment.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
9 sources
Moses read the warning as one of the covenant curses for disobeying God's law: parents would beget sons and daughters but would not keep or enjoy them, for they would be taken into captivity.PP 466.1–315MR 292.3Ms 68, 1900, par. 3–5SG4 53.2PK 676.2 It was a fearful result of transgressing God's commands, set in contrast with the blessings that follow obedience.15MR 292.3Ms 68, 1900, par. 3–5PK 676.2 Israel's experience in the promised land was made to depend on obedience, with disobedience bringing the loss of their children to captivity.15MR 292.3Ms 68, 1900, par. 3–5 The same warning illustrates the broader principle that God sends prosperity or adversity according to obedience to or transgression of His law, without developing the specific detail about children going into captivity.1SP 403.2
The Lord's promises rest upon the condition of obedience.Lt 106, 1897, par. 21–24 Keeping His judgments, ordinances, and statutes and walking in them brings life, while disobedience causes His purpose to be altered.Lt 106, 1897, par. 21–24 This explains why the adult army that left Egypt was refused entry into the promised land, a reason seen by reading Deuteronomy 28.Lt 106, 1897, par. 21–24 The chapter plainly states the blessings of obedience and expresses the principles of the law of God's kingdom made specific, so that minds are not left in ignorance and uncertainty.RH Dec 25, 1900 Those directions present the never-ceasing obligation of all who have been blessed with life and health and with advantages in temporal and spiritual things.RH Dec 25, 1900
Its message has not grown weak because of age, and God's claims are just as binding now and just as fresh in importance as His gifts are fresh and continual.RH Dec 25, 1900 The voice speaking there is not the voice of man but the voice of Christ from the enfolding pillar of cloud.RH Dec 25, 1900 Christ has repeated the same directions with His own voice, calling His followers to a life of consecration and self-denial.RH Dec 25, 1900 The instruction belongs with Exodus 15:26, where God promised to put none of the Egyptian diseases upon Israel if they diligently hearkened to His voice and kept His commandments and statutes.15MR 29.3–30.2 Breaking down the barriers God erected to preserve health brings disease upon human beings through transgression of the law of God.15MR 29.3–30.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
48 sources
Parents will have sons and daughters but will not keep and enjoy them with them, for the children will be taken away into captivity.RH Nov 4, 1862ST Jul 22, 1913RH Aug 11, 1910 It stands in the blessings and curses of Deuteronomy 27-30, solemnly set forth from Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal before Israel entered the land, promising earthly prosperity for obedience and earthly loss for disobedience.RH Aug 11, 1910ST May 23, 1911ST Mar 11, 1908RH Feb 18, 1873ST Mar 13, 1884 The loss is threatened if Israel refuses to hearken and do all His commandments, turns from Him to serve other gods and breaks His covenant, and it is the reverse of being blessed in city and field, in fruit of body and ground and cattle, in lending and not borrowing and being the head and not the tail.ST Feb 12, 1894RH Nov 10, 1904RH Aug 11, 1910ST Sep 20, 1899ST Mar 8, 1910 It was fulfilled literally and in detail in Israel's history, through the Babylonian captivity and the seventy years foretold, and through the Roman siege and destruction of Jerusalem with killing, famine, enslavement and dispersion among all kingdoms to the present hour.RH May 9, 1854ST Mar 30, 1915ST Jul 22, 1913ST Jan 17, 1906ST Mar 10, 1909 So plainly and exactly foretold beyond human foresight, it witnesses to the truth of the Bible and its divine inspiration, and it remains as a lasting warning that God's moral claims are still binding, that obedience brings well-being and disobedience brings chastening and loss.ST Feb 12, 1894ST May 8, 1907ST Sep 26, 1895ST Oct 13, 1909RH Dec 27, 1870
Words and Covenant Setting
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters but shalt not enjoy keeping them with thee, for they shall be taken into captivity.RH Nov 4, 1862ST Jul 22, 1913RH Aug 11, 1910ST Jun 10, 1913ST Aug 31, 1915 This loss of children through captivity belongs to the chapter's judgments and curses for Israel's disobedience.RH Nov 4, 1862ST Jul 22, 1913RH Aug 11, 1910ST Jun 10, 1913 It was fulfilled in the captivities under the Chaldeans and Romans and in the later dispersal of the Jews among the nations, including the deaths and enslavement that followed the fall of Jerusalem in A.D. 70, when many were killed and 97,000 were sold as slaves.RH Nov 4, 1862ST Jul 22, 1913ST Aug 31, 1915 Disobedience in turning away from God and breaking His covenant brings this national calamity upon parents and children, and Israel's history in fulfilling the warning serves as an admonition to later generations.RH Aug 11, 1910ST Jun 10, 1913
The verse belongs to the solemn blessings and curses from Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal recorded in Deuteronomy 27 and 28, within the covenant-renewal section running from chapters 27 to 30.RH Aug 11, 1910ST May 23, 1911ST Mar 11, 1908RH Feb 24, 1916 It was spoken as warning before Israel crossed the Jordan to enter Canaan and the land they were entering.RH Aug 11, 1910ST Feb 3, 1904 Deuteronomy 28:1-68 sets out promises for obedience and severe curses for turning aside from God's commands, with threatened afflictions and removal from the land later carried out against Israel's descendants.ST May 23, 1911ST Mar 11, 1908 Refusal to keep and do the commandments would bring destruction like the heathen nations dispossessed before them, so that they would not continue to inhabit the land, with the Lord forsaking them and hiding His face from them till as a nation they would be devoured, while doing His commandments would set them on high above all nations of the earth and make them the head and not the tail.ST Feb 3, 1904 Israel came to the end the chapter foretold, and its history stands as a warning to the generation that will enter the spiritual land of rest, for the revealed will of God in this warning belongs to His people and to their children forever, that they may do all the words of His law, because God reveals His will in order that it may be obeyed.RH Aug 11, 1910ST Mar 11, 1908
The stated rewards and penalties are earthly and temporal, dealing with this life.RH Feb 18, 1873ST Mar 13, 1884 Children born but not enjoyed because taken into captivity illustrate that the law's stated rewards and penalties concerned this life.RH Feb 18, 1873 Losing children to captivity as punishment for disobedience presents children as an earthly blessing that can be taken away, fitting the contrast between the temporal rewards of obedience and the hardships that follow sin.ST Mar 13, 1884
The denunciation against breaking God's commandments was paired with the blessing pronounced on keeping them.RH Jul 2, 1867 It was promulgated with shaking of the mountain, flashing of lightning, thunder, and God's voice to impress the people that the law emanated from the Deity.RH Jul 2, 1867 The denunciation thus shows the commandments proceed from unquestionable divine authority and contain no time limit in their own terms, so they remain in full force until God expresses in the most direct and unequivocal manner a desire that they be abolished, amended, or relaxed.RH Jul 2, 1867
Curse for Disobedience
The loss of children to captivity is threatened if Israel serves other gods, turns from God, breaks His covenant, and refuses to hearken to do all His commandments and statutes, belonging to the fearful curses that follow transgression and to the threatened covenant judgments whose exile shows the warnings carried out.ST Feb 12, 1894RH Aug 11, 1910ST Mar 8, 1910ST Feb 9, 1882
It is the opposite of the promised temporal prosperity for obedience on the city and field, on the fruit of body, ground, cattle, kine and sheep, on being the head and not the tail, on lending and not borrowing, and on being made plenteous in goods, with everything desirable as relates to this life promised if the commandments are kept, spoken by a God who cannot lie and not confined to one race or age but for all people in all ages, with fulfilments recorded in the Bible.ST Feb 12, 1894RH Nov 10, 1904ST Sep 20, 1899
It stands with pestilence cleaving until consumed, consumption, fever, inflammation, extreme burning, sword, blasting, mildew, wonderful plagues on them and their seed, great plagues and sore sicknesses of long continuance, all the diseases of Egypt, and every sickness and every plague not written in the book of the law until destroyed.ST Feb 12, 1894
Disobedience and covetousness and withholding from God bring loss, chastening, affliction, and multiplied affliction because sins separate from God and hastening after a strange god multiplies affliction, while liberality and cheerful faithful obedience and acceptable service bring plenty and well-being and make it better with His people; being so chastened proves sonship rather than abandonment, with similar blessings of plenty in this dispensation.RH Aug 15, 1871
The threatened consequence is national calamity, loss of inheritance, removal from the land entered across the Jordan, destruction like the heathen nations dispossessed before them, forsaking and hiding of God's face, scattering among the nations, and being devoured as a nation, while doing His commandments would set them on high above all nations of the earth and make them the head and not the tail.ST Feb 3, 1904ST Feb 3, 1904
The judgments came for neglected opportunities, unperformed duties, transgression of God's law, previous shortcomings and disobedience to the sacred moral law given from Sinai, refusal to heed His prophets, and the final rejection of Christ.ST May 14, 1896RH Aug 16, 1870ST May 5, 1881
God watches over the threatened judgment and brings it to pass in His own time, including captivity and the calamities that befell Jerusalem.RH Aug 16, 1870
Obedience alone preserves harmony between man and man and between man and Maker, gives safety to individuals and the nation in the land, secures divine favor, happiness and prosperity, and makes Israel appear a wise and understanding people with superior laws, for the rich promises were given on condition of obedience.ST Jan 31, 1911
If they do not keep His commandments God will not and cannot fulfill the promises.ST Jan 31, 1911
Fulfillment in Jewish History
The verse belongs to the prophecies of Israel's future history in Leviticus 26 and Deuteronomy 28 and 29, spoken by Moses nearly two thousand years before fulfillment, foretelling times, places, and persons centuries beforehand beyond human sagacity to calculate and beyond possibility of fraud, to be read and marked with astonishment.ST May 1, 1907RH Nov 4, 1862ST Mar 30, 1915RH Dec 27, 1870 Together with the prophecies respecting Nineveh, Babylon, Tyre, Egypt, the destruction of Jerusalem, the Man of Sin, Daniel and Revelation, and the life, character, work, claims of the Lord Jesus and the progress of Christianity, it forms an increasing mass of evidence exactly corresponding to events, applying to no other history, incapable of prior artifice or later application.RH Dec 27, 1870 The predictions were fulfilled literally, in every detail to the letter, giving prophecy of what would come upon the Jews in consequence of disobedience and what did come upon them, and continue to be fulfilled to the present hour.ST Mar 30, 1915ST Jan 17, 1906ST Mar 10, 1909RH Dec 27, 1870
From the days of Solomon onward Israel utterly refused the explicit conditions God required to keep the promised land, and though He had compassion and sent messengers rising up early to turn them, they mocked the messengers, despised His words, and scoffed at His prophets until wrath arose with no remedy.ST Jul 22, 1913 Then came the Babylonian captivity with sons and daughters going into captivity for the seventy-year period also foretold in Jeremiah and Ezekiel down to the very time the Jews should remain captive to Babylon.ST Jul 22, 1913 Because they were continually rebellious God brought upon them the evils predicted, with fulfillment seen in terrible wars by Shishak, Shalmaneser, Nebuchadnezzar, Antiochus Epiphanes, Sosius and Herod, and finally by Titus in the complete subjugation and overthrow of Jerusalem, and in the captivities under the Chaldeans and Romans and the later dispersal among the nations.RH Nov 4, 1862RH Sep 1, 1874 The verse means rebellious Israel would beget sons and daughters but would not enjoy keeping them with them, because they would be taken into captivity.RH Nov 4, 1862RH Sep 1, 1874
The warning was fulfilled in the Roman siege and destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70, together with the Saviour's words about that siege, when the people suffered battle destruction with added famine and disease, many dying of starvation and sickness, some driven to cannibalism, and sons and daughters lost to captivity.ST Jul 22, 1913ST Mar 30, 1915ST Aug 31, 1915 Many Jews were killed and 97,000 were sold as slaves, bringing Judea's destruction and subjection under Rome and final dispersion with no promised restoration to civil or religious privilege.RH May 9, 1854ST Jul 22, 1913ST Aug 31, 1915 It was fulfilled in the closing work of the Jewish age when the people suffered siege inside Jerusalem behind its massive walls and endured awful suffering before the siege ended in the greatest time of affliction ever endured.ST Jul 19, 1905 Unbelief that such trouble could come did not stop its fulfillment, but God lost none of His own because those who obeyed the admonition escaped to the mountains.ST Jul 19, 1905
The threatened afflictions and removal from the land were later carried out against Israel's descendants in captivity and dispersion among the nations, showing God had carried out the warnings given through Moses and that Israel experienced the fulfillment for forsaking God.ST May 23, 1911ST Jun 10, 1913ST Feb 9, 1882 If the Jews rebelled and went the way of the heathen they would be scattered to every kingdom and people in the world, separated from the nations, in fear and dread wherever they went, with persecution following them wherever Jews are found.ST May 8, 1907 That scattering and ill-treatment fulfills the prophecy in their own lives and explains Palestine's desolation.ST May 8, 1907RH Jun 24, 1902 In this application the loss of children through captivity belongs to the Lord's 2520-year indignation, which ends when the curse ceases and Jacob is redeemed from bondage.RH Jan 17, 1856 The land's condition cannot be materially changed by money or change of ownership; it will be glorious under the coming reign of the King of the Jews.RH Jun 24, 1902
Proof of Divine Inspiration
Thou shalt beget sons and daughters but not enjoy them for they shall go into captivity gives part of the outline of the whole history of the Jews set forth in the oldest books of the Bible.ST May 8, 1907 It means that if they rebelled against God and went the way of the heathen they would be scattered to every kingdom and people in the world, separated from the nations, in fear and dread wherever they went, with persecution following them.ST May 8, 1907 That scattering and ill-treatment wherever Jews are found fulfills the prophecy in their own lives, so that even human wrath and disobedience praises God and shows Him to be the God of truth, and the Jews stand as a witness and evidence that the Bible is true.ST May 8, 1907 It is part of the prophecy of Israel's future history whose fulfillment is presented as evidence of the divine authority of Scripture, one of the predictions given through Moses whose fulfillment in disobedience and calamities witnesses to the truth of the Bible.ST Sep 26, 1895ST Oct 13, 1909
It belongs to literal prophecy stated in simple plain language so clear that only those who refuse can fail to understand.ST Apr 9, 1896 In it Moses clearly foresaw the promised land, the coming and death of Christ, the tribulation of the Jews, and the glorious consummation in Christ's eternal triumph.ST Apr 9, 1896
It is part of the prophecies of Moses respecting the Jews that foretold times, places, and persons centuries beforehand beyond human sagacity to calculate and beyond possibility of fraud.RH Dec 27, 1870 It has been fulfilled to the letter and is being fulfilled to this hour.RH Dec 27, 1870 Together with the prophecies respecting Nineveh, Babylon, Tyre, Egypt, the destruction of Jerusalem, the Man of Sin, Daniel and Revelation, and the life, character, work, claims of the Lord Jesus and the progress of Christianity, it forms an increasing mass of evidence as ages roll on that exactly corresponds to the events, applies to no other history, cannot be preceding artifice or posterior application, and proves the supernatural inspiration and divine authority of the Bible.RH Dec 27, 1870
Lasting Obligation and Warning
The blessings and curses belong to God's commandments as His moral law, and the ending of Israel's civil government does not end them, for God keeps the power to give or send them apart from penalties laid on by human authorities.RH Mar 7, 1871 Moral principles were put into concrete positive legal shape with enforcement in this life, treating Israel as children who needed a tangible command and fear of punishment rather than abstract moral reason.RH Oct 29, 1872 That schooling was to train them for the gospel, which rules by general principles and brings moral duty back to its simple moral ground.RH May 6, 1873RH Oct 29, 1872 The directions lay out plainly the principles of the law of God's kingdom so that minds are left in no ignorance or uncertainty.RH Dec 25, 1900 The voice speaking them is not man's voice but Christ's from the enfolding pillar of cloud, and Christ has repeated the same directions with His own voice, calling His followers to consecration and self-denial.RH Dec 25, 1900
The solemn blessings and curses from Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal in Deuteronomy 27 and 28 form a fearful foretelling of what would come on Israel if it departed from God.ST Mar 11, 1908 The denunciation was set against the blessing on keeping the commandments, and was proclaimed with shaking of the mountain, lightning, thunder, and God's voice to impress that the law came from the Deity.RH Jul 2, 1867 God's revealed will in this warning belongs to His people and their children forever, that they may do all the words of His law, since He reveals His will in order that it be obeyed.ST Mar 11, 1908 The commandments carry no time limit in their own terms, and remain in full force until God in the most direct and unequivocal way expresses a desire to abolish, amend, or relax them.RH Jul 2, 1867
Family well-being and bodily health rest on keeping God's moral requirements, and the continued presence of these diseases proves those requirements have not ceased.ST Feb 12, 1894 Begetting sons and daughters without enjoying them because they go into captivity is one of the bodily curses for not hearkening to do all His commandments and statutes, standing opposite the promised good for obedience in city and field, in fruit of body and ground, in cattle, increase of kine, and flocks of sheep, in which everything desirable for this life is pledged on keeping His commandments.ST Feb 12, 1894 It stands with pestilence cleaving until consumed, consumption, fever, inflammation, extreme burning, sword, blasting, mildew, wonderful and great plagues on them and their seed, sore sicknesses of long continuance, all the diseases of Egypt, and every sickness and plague not written in the book of the law, until destroyed.ST Feb 12, 1894 Distrust and disobedience to all of God's requirements bring terrible loss upon temporal prosperity, including children taken captive and not enjoyed, the opposite of His working for temporal prosperity on condition of obedience, spoken by a God who cannot lie, not confined to one race or age but for all people in all ages, with fulfillments recorded in the Bible.RH Nov 10, 1904 His claims are just as binding now and just as fresh in importance as His gifts are fresh and continual, laying a never-ceasing obligation on all blessed with life, health, and advantages in temporal and spiritual things, and the message has not grown weak with age.RH Dec 25, 1900
The warning was given to Israel before entering Canaan that if they turned from God and His law and broke His covenant, calamities would overtake them and their children would be taken into captivity so parents would not enjoy them.RH Aug 11, 1910RH Aug 11, 1910 Israel came to the end the chapter foretold, and its history fulfilled the warning and stands as warning and admonition to later generations and to the generation that will enter the spiritual land of rest.RH Aug 11, 1910RH Aug 11, 1910 Israel knows those words came true in losing sons and daughters to enemies, showing the warning had reason and purpose in it, and heeding such warning brings escape from calamity and shelter in the refuge provided.RH Feb 21, 1907 The setting joins a nation's choices about holiness and sin to blessings or curses upon its course, applying to a country's decision about its way.ST Jul 4, 1899 A nation putting itself forward as the true Israel to claim Israel's hopes and promises must also expect its judgments and desolations, and God takes such a nation at its word and deals with it accordingly, with years of strifes, storms, and corruptions reducing its political and social condition giving foreboding of that dealing in action.RH Feb 16, 1864
Sources