AdventAI

Exodus 16:27

And it came to pass, that there went out some of the people on the seventh day for to gather, and they found none.

King James Version

Commentary, part 2 of 2

Commentary part 2 of 2

Pioneers and periodicals (continued)

Test Obedience and Rebuke

God gave the bread from heaven to prove whether they would walk in His law, leaving them without express direction to provide for the seventh day so that regard for His law would appear by free voluntary action and each heart would be revealed.RH May 7, 1857RH Mar 3, 1863RH Dec 4, 1856ST Aug 18, 1909 Moses withheld what God had said until action showed regard, giving no new precept respecting the Sabbath but only saying To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord, and the people of their own accord gathered a double portion on the sixth day.RH May 7, 1857RH Mar 3, 1863RH Dec 4, 1856 Their correct gathering proved the reckoning of the weeks had been correctly kept, while going out on the seventh and finding none drew the rebuke for refusing an existing law of which the holy Sabbath is a part.RH May 7, 1857ST Feb 11, 1913RH Mar 3, 1863RH Dec 4, 1856

Sabbath observance was singled out as the test of obedience, loyalty, and keeping God's law and the fourth commandment before Sinai.RH Sep 24, 1872ST Feb 11, 1913RH Jul 14, 1874ST Aug 18, 1909 The daily provision with double supply and preservation on the sixth day tested whether they would obey the Sabbath instruction, and failure to gather exposed disobedience to God's commands.RH Sep 24, 1872ST Feb 11, 1913 The weekly events identified the seventh day as the same sanctified rest day established in Genesis, proving the Sabbath was not first made known at Sinai.RH Jul 14, 1874ST Aug 18, 1909 This proving applies also to God's people in later time and the last reformation.RH Jul 14, 1874

Going out was disobedience, needless disregard of divine instruction and especially of the Sabbath commandment, refusal to keep commandments and laws and to trust and obey.ST Jun 25, 1902ST Aug 11, 1914RH Sep 24, 1872ST Mar 7, 1906 It violated the Sabbath when no manna was provided and the people were to rest, showing refusal that exposed whole-law disobedience.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 24, 1872ST Feb 11, 1913 The attempt confirmed manna was not provided that day and that the seventh day was the Sabbath, for God had provided twice as much on the sixth so they could rest on the seventh.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Aug 18, 1909

Going out drew the rebuke How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws, though Moses had only said To-morrow is the rest and though it was only a single violation.ST Jun 25, 1902RH Dec 17, 1861RH May 7, 1857ST Aug 11, 1914RH Apr 11, 1854 The question shows long refusal of laws already in force, long-standing knowing repeated neglect and transgression rather than a first violation of a newly established institution.RH May 7, 1857RH Apr 11, 1854ST Mar 7, 1906ST Jun 16, 1887 God and Moses thus spoke of the Sabbath as an old institution, to which Israel was called back only thirty days after leaving bondage where they could not observe it.RH Apr 11, 1854RH Dec 4, 1856

Their action violated an already instructed Sabbath obligation despite prohibition and despite being told none would be available.ST Apr 26, 1883ST Jun 25, 1902RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 2, 1862RH Sep 24, 1872 They had failed to prepare enough and had not gathered a double portion through slow belief and disobedient hearts, expecting to gather because they had not anticipated the Sabbath.ST Jun 25, 1902RH Sep 24, 1872RH Sep 24, 1872 The incident does not by itself establish that the Sabbath was first instituted then, but shows the seventh day had been identified as Sabbath and manna was not available that day.ST Apr 26, 1883RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 2, 1862 The Lord's rebuke and instruction to remain in place then made the Sabbath definite and known.RH Sep 24, 1872

The going out was principally instigated by the large mixed multitude in the camp who led in murmuring and rebellion.ST Jun 25, 1902 Recent separation from Egypt makes it reasonable that they had become habitual Sabbath breakers, with recent Egypt making habitual breaking understandable.ST Jun 25, 1902RH Jun 10, 1862 Yet earlier inability to keep the Sabbath in Egypt did not explain wilderness failure, and the wilderness disobedience showed knowing repeated neglect.ST Mar 7, 1906ST Jun 16, 1887 Their disregard had been long-standing, even though they were then constrained to comply.ST Mar 7, 1906

God declared He had given them the Sabbath and therefore gave the bread of two days on the sixth day, with six days appointed for gathering and a double portion on the sixth.ST Jun 25, 1902ST Aug 11, 1914 He required every man to abide in his place and let no man go out of his place on the seventh day, after which the people rested on the seventh day.ST Jun 25, 1902RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 24, 1872ST Aug 11, 1914RH Sep 24, 1872 Their disobedience was thus restrained, and the Sabbath obligation already known before the manna fell was enforced.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 2, 1862

Continued Sabbath violations were a chief cause of exclusion from the promised land and death in the wilderness.ST Mar 18, 1875RH Apr 8, 1875ST Mar 18, 1875ST Jul 30, 1912 The Sabbath test revealed whether they would obey God's law, and repeated rebellion in this particular brought that judgment.ST Mar 18, 1875RH Apr 8, 1875ST Mar 18, 1875 God's first care in making known His law was to make known and require reverence for His Sabbath, making obedience in this particular the test of keeping the whole law and the token that Israel knew the Lord and His sanctifying power.ST Oct 4, 1905 By this Israel was started in the way that will terminate in restoration of Eden, of which the Sabbath is part and earnest, and all who did not by faith obtain the spiritual rest God placed in the Sabbath never entered Canaan as type of Eden restored.ST Oct 4, 1905

Men are prone to seek gain on the Sabbath by doing the work of the week in a disobedient and covetous spirit that greatly displeases the Lord.RH Jul 4, 1854 Holy resting one day in seven will not impoverish, because six days suffice to procure the bread of seven by providence of the Lord of the Sabbath, who withheld manna on that day while giving a double portion on the sixth and preserving what was laid up.RH Jul 4, 1854 Their search taught that God's provision and Sabbath instructions do not change to suit doubts or convenience, and that His word must be heeded carefully.ST Feb 22, 1905 The weekly provision also made the seventh-day rest a lesson in creation and dependence on God as Provider.ST Feb 22, 1905

Opposing Institution Views

On the contrary view, the verse belongs to the first command to observe the Sabbath given in the wilderness of Sin and described as given to the Jews as Saturday, when some went out to gather food on the seventh day and found none because they had not anticipated the rest sacred to the Lord and had not gathered a double portion on the sixth day, and the rebuke and instruction to remain in place then made the Sabbath definite and known.RH Sep 24, 1872ST Mar 13, 1879ST Feb 5, 1880
Oppositely, the manna commands were tentative arbitrary tests to prove whether they would walk in His law and to prepare them for the giving of the law, and the Sabbath was first instituted in the wilderness at the succouring of the Jews not long before its solemn establishment in the fourth commandment, with no mention or allusion for about twenty-five hundred years from creation to Egypt in the general history before Abraham and in the circumstantial lives of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob proving it was not instituted at creation nor observed all along.RH Sep 24, 1872RH Oct 29, 1872RH Dec 20, 1864ST Apr 24, 1879
There is no intimation that the Sabbath then appointed was only revival of an ancient neglected forgotten or suspended institution, no imputation of such neglect to the old world or Noah's family, and no record of permission to dispense with it during the Egyptian captivity or other emergency; just seven days before that first keeping the whole host of 600,000 adults besides children with mixed multitude and flocks and herds left Elim for Sin after leaving Egypt seventy-five days before and marched on the seventh day by direction of angel and cloud doing weary traveling with burdened backs, which shows the Sabbath was not made obligatory from creation onward.RH Dec 20, 1864
The origin shown at the fall of the manna one month after the exodus is distinct from the Sabbath ordained at the close of creation in Paradise, with the patriarchal Sabbath falling the day after the Sabbath Israel then began to observe; the disobedience on the seventh day was no better kept than other long-disobeyed commandments, and the rebuke How long refuse ye to keep my commandments refers to those many commandments of which the Sabbath was only one, not an old law long known and desecrated, since the rulers were ignorant a Sabbath was to follow until Moses told them and orders for the day were given when the day begins at evening.RH Oct 29, 1872ST Apr 24, 1879

On that view, when introduced it was given simply as a rest sacred to God without any reference to creation or to deliverance from bondage, while permanent legislation with proper reasons was reserved for Sinai when Israel became a holy nation, God having required a double portion on the sixth day without telling beforehand of a Sabbath to follow or that no manna would fall that day even though keeping manna over had failed before.RH Sep 24, 1872
The seventh day after six manna days when none fell was Saturday ever afterward observed, while the day one week before that first Sabbath was spent marching and therefore could not have been a Sabbath until God set it apart at the fall of the manna, proving a new distinct Sabbath at that time, though both the marching date and the change at the manna are denied in favor of placing the change one month earlier at the exodus.ST Apr 24, 1879
The wilderness revival is said to have substituted a new seventh day for a lost old day, setting the Sabbath back one day at the Exodus for the particular use of the Jews and forward again one day for Christians so that the Christian Sabbath is the original seventh day the Sabbath of the Lord; yet the verse belongs to an account that does not establish a newly introduced day, for the Sabbath was definite and known even where the Hebrew article is absent, the seventh day withheld because it was already the Sabbath, the same seventh sanctified from creation and generally observed, not a new Jewish Sabbath for a single purpose nor proof the patriarchal day was changed, and the weekday of arrival in Sin or number of manna days before the Sabbath is not established.ST May 17, 1883ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 8, 1856ST May 20, 1875
It is claimed the Sabbath was changed from the seventh back to the sixth on the fifteenth of Abib just before the Red Sea passage and changed again just after, so that if the manna Sabbath had been in succession from Paradise the fifteenth must have been so too and would have been kept as Sabbath with no part spent marching from Elim to Sin; but the sacred record contradicts such a change, and the question remains whether the manna day coincided with the seventh in regular succession from the Paradisiacal week.ST Nov 15, 1883RH Dec 9, 1873

The Hebrew lacks the definite article because when an institution is instituted or first mentioned the article is always wanting, and the English supplying the is mistranslated so arguments built on it have false basis, with other article-less Sabbaths having adequate separate reasons not affecting Exodus 16.RH Nov 12, 1872
Rules for the article cannot set aside that God blessed and sanctified the seventh day, since insertion or omission often depends on euphony and rhythm and fine distinctions felt readily but transferred with difficulty, generally promoting perspicuity by insertion and vivacity by omission, used more in philosophical than rhetorical composition and far more in prose than poetry, varying widely among manuscripts especially with proper names in Old and New Testaments, and instances of holy convocation and attending sabbaths and memorials first mentioned without the article prove nothing about first mention for they were never mentioned otherwise; long afterward the weekly Sabbath is still spoken of without the article, so weekly and yearly sabbaths stand in the same category and first-mention versus re-mention for additional legislation does not explain use or omission.RH Sep 24, 1872RH Oct 29, 1872
Nothing proves the travel from Elim to Sin was on the Sabbath, the sixth day of double gathering means the sixth day of the week without reference to counting from the first fall, and Exodus 16 gives no institution with founding facts, expressed meaning and intent, or assigned reason why it should be observed.RH May 7, 1857RH Nov 15, 1864RH Dec 20, 1864
Even if Israel marched on the Sabbath at God's command that would not break the Sabbath law, because obeying God is not doing own work which the Sabbath forbids, just as marching around Jericho seven successive days including a Sabbath forty years later did not break it, and the camp did not afterward move on the Sabbath; the count beginning with one travel day followed by six manna days with the seventh named Sabbath made known the Rest-day by cessation, since God would not direct travel and soon after forbid such work on pain of death.RH May 7, 1857RH Dec 20, 1864RH Jun 19, 1856

The restriction to abide every man in his place and let no man go out of his place applied specifically to going out to gather manna in those circumstances after being told none would be found in the field, not the universal Sabbath law on stone; it was a temporary by-law for that manna situation, not forbidding leaving the dwelling to assemble for religious meetings or sacred duties, nor what is necessary for human life and comfort or work helping the sick and suffering, for God required Sabbath offerings and holy convocation taking Israel out of houses and Israel marched around Jericho with the ark on the Sabbath without violating the law in the ark, the prohibition being against work for selfish purposes profit or pleasure while gathering belonged to the six days.RH Nov 25, 1852ST Jul 1, 1908RH May 27, 1873RH May 2, 1854
The wilderness manna regulations were a class of precepts adapted to Israel's circumstances rather than part of original institution, temporary and associated with that period.RH May 2, 1854RH Mar 21, 1865
Exodus 16 gives no institution with founding facts, meaning, reason or general requirements, and conclusions about mutual understanding or general notoriety require positive knowledge of actual condition and circumstances not imagination unwarranted by record; it recognizes the seventh day already as the Lord's Sabbath and enforces abstaining from ordinary work without instituting it or explaining why made holy, since instituted at creation and enforced before Sinai, and the disobedience of going out to gather despite being told to rest identifies the Sabbath and its unavailability without by itself establishing first institution.RH Dec 2, 1862RH Aug 6, 1872RH Sep 24, 1872RH Nov 15, 1864RH Mar 31, 1859
The same day of the week as Genesis 2 existed before Sinai proclamation with obligation to keep holy, which does not prove obligation from creation.RH Aug 6, 1872

No command for Sabbath observance is given until after this violation, though the Sabbath was known and observed at least a month before Sinai as part of God's existing law without giving a command to keep it; Moses gives no new precept, the people of their own accord gather double on the sixth showing already knowing the Sabbath with correct week reckoning, left free without express prohibition so choice revealed hearts whether they would walk in law, the command not to go out implied in manna instructions but stated expressly after rebuke, and the rebuke about long refusal proves not origination with manna but already existing sacred institution long transgressed, making this not the first violation.RH Sep 19, 1854RH Mar 3, 1863RH Jul 27, 1869RH Feb 3, 1852RH Feb 3, 1852
The interval from triumph at the Red Sea to cessation marking the wilderness Sabbath was proposed as a period completing a Sabbath change, but the observed day cannot be shown to differ from the seventh counted from creation, and the chronology is unreliable since Israel departed Rameses on the fifteenth not fourteenth and time at each station is not established.RH Oct 31, 1871
Exodus 16 contains nothing fixing a change from paradisaical rest-day to Jewish Sabbath at the manna and may not be used to prove Moses changed it, though cited for that argument; the whole chapter must be considered and keeping must follow the original commandment on the day God rested rather than treating rest day as indefinite.RH Feb 14, 1865ST Jul 24, 1879
The chapter is presented as possible revival yet does not mention suspension in Egypt.RH May 6, 1852
The wilderness cycle is counted from start of manna falling without apparent reference to creation week, requiring every seventh day holy whatever point began the cycle.RH Jan 31, 1856
Withholding on the seventh while giving on the first is connected with sacred observance of the Lord's day instead of seventh-day Sabbath, for on the Lord's day the Lord always rains manna from heaven, though this difference does not prove superiority over the Jewish Sabbath.RH May 20, 1873
Marked disagreement holds over the fall including the seventh when some went out and found none, between teaching origination at creation still to be hallowed and teaching beginning with manna ending with Christ's death.RH May 27, 1873
The claim of a six-day week in Egypt moving the Sabbath from seventh to sixth depends on unsupported counting rather than biblical testimony and is rejected as relevant to change or shift at exodus.ST Jul 17, 1879
The seventh in Exodus 16:22-30 is truly the seventh, not the sixth or first improperly called seventh, with no change of Eden creation Sabbath to another day at the Red Sea or before leaving Egypt or at the manna, and no change back to the first day at the resurrection, conflicting change claims misusing the manna account contradicting each other and leaving Sunday without evidence.RH Jul 8, 1873

Moral Law and Covenant

The going out to gather on the seventh day and finding nothing violated an already known Sabbath obligation to rest when no manna was provided, showing the Sabbath was understood before the manna fell and that the divine rebuke restrained the transgression.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Feb 11, 1913ST Mar 7, 1906RH Mar 1851 The chapter places this at least a month before Israel reached Sinai and treats the Sabbath as part of God's commandments and laws, though it gives no fresh command to keep it.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Feb 11, 1913RH Mar 3, 1863RH Mar 1851 The double provision on the sixth day made rest possible on the seventh, and the attempt to gather tested whether they would obey God's law and keep the Sabbath.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Feb 11, 1913ST Mar 7, 1906RH Mar 1851 The disregard was needless disobedience especially against the Sabbath commandment, and the question How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws shows the refusal was long-standing even while they were then constrained to comply.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Feb 11, 1913ST Mar 7, 1906RH Mar 1851 The account belongs to the second mention of the Sabbath in Moses' narrative, the circumstantial narrative of Exodus 16:4-30, where bread from heaven proves whether they will keep His existing law of which the holy Sabbath is a part, Moses giving no new precept respecting the Sabbath.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Feb 11, 1913ST Mar 7, 1906RH Mar 3, 1863 Their gathering a double portion on the sixth day of their own accord proves previous knowledge and correct keeping of the weekly reckoning, and the rebuke See, for that the Lord hath given you the Sabbath identifies it as a gift already given before it was spoken at Sinai, an established institution connected to sanctifying the seventh day at creation.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Mar 7, 1906RH Mar 3, 1863RH Mar 1851 Breaking it before Sinai was sin, proving law already existed, with every Decalogue precept transgressed before Sinai.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Sep 19, 1854ST Feb 11, 1913ST Mar 7, 1906RH Mar 3, 1863

The account treats the Sabbath as already known before the giving of the Mosaic law, since the people were expected to understand why they gathered twice as much on the sixth day, and those who went out on the seventh were reproved for failing to keep it properly.RH Apr 4, 1854ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 27, 1852ST Jun 2, 1881RH Jul 24, 1866 Thus its obligation is independent of the Mosaic law, requiring no new keeping command because it was already a familiar institution generally observed.RH Apr 4, 1854ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 2, 1881RH Jul 24, 1866RH Feb 3, 1852 It was the same seventh day sanctified from creation, not a new Jewish Sabbath then instituted for a single purpose, and not proof that the patriarchal Sabbath day was changed.RH Apr 4, 1854ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 27, 1852ST Jun 2, 1881RH Jul 24, 1866 The surrounding account points to an institution already known but not properly remembered or observed rather than a new law first given on that occasion.RH Apr 4, 1854ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 27, 1852ST Jun 2, 1881RH Jul 24, 1866 The Sabbath was already in existence before the covenant made at Horeb with Israel thirty-two days later, so that covenant did not create or institute it but only embodied moral duties already binding.RH Apr 4, 1854ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 27, 1852RH Jul 24, 1866RH Feb 3, 1852 Therefore it did not depend for existence on the old covenant and that covenant's passing did not abolish it, and to make it merely local or national would make the fourth commandment obsolete and leave no Sabbath law for the present dispensation.RH Apr 4, 1854RH May 27, 1852ST Jun 2, 1881RH Jul 24, 1866RH Feb 3, 1852 The idea that it was made at Sinai for Hebrews only is false, since it was instituted at creation and in force before Sinai.RH Apr 4, 1854ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 27, 1852ST Jun 2, 1881RH Feb 3, 1852

Moses telling Israel that the morrow was the Sabbath was not a new commandment but a reminder of an old commandment long neglected, given some weeks before arrival at Sinai where the whole law was repeated with solemnity and manifestation of divine majesty.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jan 17, 1906RH Mar 26, 1867RH Mar 1851RH Nov 15, 1853 In the giving of manna God instituted three weekly miracles to guard against further desecration during the wilderness journey, to which the going out and finding none belongs.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jan 17, 1906RH Mar 26, 1867RH Mar 1851RH Nov 15, 1853 Since the original Sabbath made for man was never repealed and Abraham kept the commandments and laws of God, the Sabbath law continued unbroken from Eden to Sinai.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jan 17, 1906RH Mar 26, 1867RH Mar 1851RH Nov 15, 1853 The seventh day was the Lord's Sabbath, not belonging only to the Jewish people, made for man in the broadest sense meaning all mankind and the whole race of Adam including Adam, Noah, Enoch and Abraham, not Jews only.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jan 17, 1906RH Mar 26, 1867RH Mar 1851RH Nov 15, 1853 It was established before any Jew-Gentile distinction, declared sacred with enforced observance, and its obligation did not begin in the wilderness but came from God's setting apart the seventh day at creation to which the fourth commandment reaches back.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jan 17, 1906RH Mar 1851RH Nov 15, 1853ST Sep 16, 1880 The seventh day's name is linked to a Hebrew root meaning to be full or complete, the number's frequent use in Scripture is connected with creation, and the day was separated for worship, remembering the Creator, contemplating His works, giving thanks, and benefit even in Eden.ST Apr 25, 1906ST Jan 17, 1906RH Mar 26, 1867RH Mar 1851RH Nov 15, 1853

The threefold weekly miracle of the manna fixed the Sabbath so there could be no mistake about the definite day of the Lord's rest during forty years, spanning the centuries from creation to the Exodus and establishing by miraculous power the identity of the week and order of its days, proving the day was not lost.ST Aug 30, 1905ST Aug 7, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 23, 1896 The day thus fixed was then guarded by a holy commandment placed in the heart of God's unchangeable law.ST Aug 30, 1905ST Aug 7, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 23, 1896 The manna confirmed that it fell during the six preceding days and not on the Sabbath, identifying the commanded seventh as the same seventh on which He had rested, with gathering and preparing on the sixth and resting on the seventh.ST Aug 30, 1905ST Aug 7, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 23, 1896 God joined the Sabbath institution to the day so they cannot be separated, proving only one day was and could be His Sabbath, the seventh of the seven, since He rested on one day only, blessed one day only, and sanctified one day only.ST Aug 30, 1905ST Aug 7, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 23, 1896 That Sabbath is the seventh day of the week immediately following the sixth-day preparation, the very day of God's rest in making heaven and earth, the day enjoined in the commandment, the day kept at Christ's death between preparation and the first day, the only weekly Sabbath ever given, rooted in creation rest, blessing and hallowing just before the first day and kept by Jesus as perfect Example.ST Aug 30, 1905ST Aug 7, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 23, 1896

The account recognizes the seventh day as already the Lord's Sabbath and enforces abstaining from ordinary work, without instituting the Sabbath or explaining why it was made holy, since it had been instituted at creation and the manna enforces an existing obligation before Sinai.RH Aug 6, 1872ST Apr 1, 1875ST Nov 3, 1881 Sanctifying consists in abstaining from the ordinary work of the other six days and resting because God commanded it, and desecrating consists in working on that day contrary to the commandment.RH Aug 6, 1872ST Apr 1, 1875ST Nov 3, 1881 The Sabbath is a definite seventh day to be kept by rigid observance, and Israel's keeping that definite day for forty years with no manna to gather proves keeping the same time is physically possible.RH Aug 6, 1872ST Apr 1, 1875ST Nov 3, 1881 Because God commanded it its performance is possible, and what was possible for forty years can always be done despite differences in days when traveling east, west, north or south.RH Aug 6, 1872ST Apr 1, 1875ST Nov 3, 1881

The falling of manna on the first day with a double portion on the sixth and none on the seventh marks the first, sixth and seventh of a weekly cycle before Sinai, and the going out was the first profanation of the seventh day.ST May 20, 1897ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 14, 1882ST Apr 11, 1900 Since holiness was never given to the first six days and only what is already holy can be profaned, this proves the seventh was already holy and the identical seventh in direct order from creation.ST May 20, 1897ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 14, 1882ST The divine answer shows condemnation for long refusal to keep commandments and laws already in force, and recognizes that day as the seventh from creation as the commandment places it, proving the order of days was preserved to Sinai.ST May 20, 1897ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 14, 1882ST Apr 11, 1900 Proper observance means resting and worshiping on the seventh day commonly called Saturday, for worship on another day does not make that day the Sabbath.ST May 20, 1897ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 14, 1882ST The passage speaks of the original Sabbath of Eden and Sinai which is the seventh day Saturday kept by the Jews, not Sunday the first day, applying to the seventh alone and not to Sunday.ST May 20, 1897ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 14, 1882ST Apr 11, 1900ST Exodus 16 distinguishes the seventh from all others in a marked manner, leaving it without rival after Sunday and the other five working days fail to show God's rest, blessing and hallowing, furnishing strong presumptive proof that the seventh alone is entitled to be the Lord's Sabbath, coming from the same hand as Genesis creation and the tablets from Jehovah.ST May 20, 1897ST Nov 19, 1885ST Sep 14, 1882ST Apr 11, 1900

The manna and seventh-day Sabbath account is discussed as the basis for the claim that the Sabbath began as a memorial of the giving of manna and that the Christian Sabbath replaced it when Christ the true bread from heaven came.ST Jun 5, 1879RH Jun 5, 1900 The Sabbath established among Israel after deliverance from Egypt, where some went out on the seventh to gather and found none, was treated by fourth-century bishops as a model for Sunday, claiming Sabbath duties had been transferred to Sunday.ST Jun 5, 1879RH Jun 5, 1900 That claim belongs to a false scheme identifying church and state with God's kingdom.ST Jun 5, 1879RH Jun 5, 1900

Observance of the seventh-day Sabbath enforced before the law at Sinai proves it was God's rest from the foundation of the world, and therefore it could not be the rest given by Joshua consisting in peaceable possession of Canaan.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Nov 4, 1886RH Mar 10, 1868 Israel already had the seventh-day Sabbath before reaching Canaan, so the Sabbath-rest argument in Hebrews 4:4,9 cannot be about entering a weekly Sabbath, and failure to enter the promised rest was through unbelief not failure to keep a Sabbath.RH Mar 3, 1853ST Nov 4, 1886RH Mar 10, 1868

God brought Israel out of Egypt that they might observe His Sabbaths and keep His laws and proved them by the Sabbath, showing the great importance He attaches to Sabbath observance.RH May 12, 1863 The Sabbath is inseparably connected with the rest of the law, the key to God's law and the golden link uniting man to the Creator and joining duties to God with duties to fellow man.RH May 12, 1863

The Sabbath as a particular part of God's law entrusted to Israel made their loyalty to it a converting influence among all peoples.ST Aug 11, 1909

Keeping that seventh day after six days of work in gathering manna answered all the two-fold purposes for which the Sabbath was instituted.RH Jun 19, 1856 Whether that designated day coincided with the seventh in regular succession from the creation week cannot be determined by human means, yet because the Sabbath is one institution binding from its giving and God knew the true seventh, the day God designated was the true seventh in succession from the first week and is not to be questioned.RH Jun 19, 1856

The Sabbath of the Lord was already binding in the wilderness when some went out and found none, and was in force all through the wilderness sojourn before entering the land.RH Mar 31, 1863 This marks the contrast with the annual Jewish sabbaths, which were prospective ordinances to be kept after entering the land, differing in origin and obligation.RH Mar 31, 1863

Preparation Rest and Application

The sixth day, a portion of which is now called Friday, was designed for closing up work and making preparation for the Sabbath, with food to be gathered, baked and boiled on the sixth so that no boiling, baking, gathering, or finishing of secular work would remain to be done on the holy day.RH Apr 11, 1854RH Sep 19, 1854ST Aug 7, 1879 God gave the bread of two days on the sixth day, with six days appointed for gathering and a double portion on the sixth, and required every man to abide in his place and let no man go out of his place on the seventh day, after which the people rested on the seventh day.ST Aug 11, 1914RH Apr 11, 1854RH Sep 19, 1854 Their going out to gather on the seventh day and finding none belonged to God's proving whether they would walk in His law by gathering a set amount each day and preparing twice as much on the sixth, since the seventh is the rest of the holy Sabbath with nothing to be found in the field.ST Aug 11, 1914RH Apr 11, 1854RH Sep 19, 1854 The manna confirmed that it fell during the six preceding days and not on the Sabbath, identifying the seventh day God commanded as the same seventh day on which He had rested.RH Aug 14, 1868ST Jul 22, 1880ST Aug 7, 1879

The principle remains applicable, though circumstances may call for warming food on the Sabbath, and any such work should be kept as light as possible so that more time is available for honoring and worshiping God.ST May 24, 1910 The sixth day's portion was to be prepared and kept for the Sabbath, teaching provision beforehand rather than gathering food on the Sabbath, and in the warm wilderness of Sinai no fire was needed day or night for warmth, only for cooking.ST May 24, 1910ST Apr 19, 1877 Holy resting one day in seven will not impoverish, because six days are sufficient to procure the bread of seven by the providence of the Lord of the Sabbath.RH Jul 4, 1854 No one could plead necessity for violating the sacred rest, for God had already provided for all wants beforehand in harmony with the requirement to keep the holy day, manna kept over any other day corrupting while manna kept over the Sabbath was preserved good for food.RH Jul 4, 1854ST Jun 24, 1875 This weekly double provision means two miracles each week, 4,160 miracles during the forty years of sojourning, having for their direct object the proper observance of and regard for the seventh day, the holy Sabbath.ST Jun 24, 1875

The Sabbath did not require going without food, because God had provided twice as much on the sixth day for needs beforehand, and their attempt to gather showed refusal to trust and obey.RH Nov 27, 1913RH Jul 4, 1854 Eating on the Sabbath is lawful but gathering is not, and the people were not to gather before or after that day but to keep it when it came and remain in place.RH Jul 4, 1854 The daily gathering order did not include the Sabbath and did not authorize gathering on it, for the command to gather every day was limited to days when ordinary work was lawful, to every common working day, the six days in man's keeping, while the seventh is God's reserved day where gathering is forbidden.ST Aug 11, 1914ST Aug 18, 1909RH Aug 5, 1852RH Sep 24, 1872ST Dec 8, 1881 The instruction not to gather on the Sabbath was given as the Sabbath drew near, and the people had voluntarily gathered twice as much on the sixth day rather than being told beforehand to do so.RH Aug 5, 1852 The Lord rained bread from heaven to prove Israel whether they would walk in His law, giving flesh at evening in quails and bread to the full in the morning in manna, corn of heaven, angels' food, gathered every morning for six days with twice as much on the sixth, and Moses declared To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto Jehovah and that on the seventh day which is the Sabbath in it there shall be none.RH Jun 19, 1856

Their attempt showed failure to prepare enough food on the sixth day through slow belief, and the empty search exposes disobedience, defeats the claim that any day will do, and confirms manna fell the six preceding days and not on the Sabbath.RH Aug 14, 1868ST Jul 22, 1880ST Oct 23, 1893ST Aug 7, 1879 The day was plainly identified by the six-day pattern of gathering, the doubled provision on the sixth, and the absence on the seventh, making the Sabbath distinguishable even if observance had been lost in Egypt and marking the definite seventh day as the Sabbath.RH Aug 14, 1868ST Jul 22, 1880ST Jan 17, 1911 The empty field was part of miracles kept up for forty years, with manna breeding worms and stinking if kept overnight from the first five days but twice the usual amount gathered on the sixth keeping sweet when laid up for the Sabbath, showing the Lord's regard for the Sabbath day.ST Oct 23, 1893 Finding none proves the Sabbath is the definite seventh day fixed by the Lord Himself and not left to men, guarding against the idea that the day is settled by human caprice or custom, which Israel knew even when rebelling against and disregarding it.ST Oct 23, 1893RH Dec 5, 1871

God's first care in making known His law was to make known and require reverence for His Sabbath, making obedience in this particular the test of keeping the whole law and the token or evidence that Israel knew the Lord and that His sanctifying power was manifested among them.ST Oct 4, 1905 By this Israel was started in the way that will terminate in the restoration of Eden, for the Sabbath was a part of Eden, and God at this time more fully revealed the Sabbath truth as an earnest of their inheritance, to remind them every week in a tangible way of the blessedness of that goodly land.ST Oct 4, 1905 All who did not by faith obtain the spiritual rest that God had placed in the Sabbath never entered Canaan, which was to be the type of Eden restored, and continued Sabbath violation was one chief cause of exclusion from the promised land and death in the wilderness.ST Oct 4, 1905RH Apr 8, 1875 The Sabbath was not a day chosen merely for convenience, but the particular day God had blessed and hallowed, and loyalty was tested by recognizing and keeping the seventh day and no other.ST Oct 24, 1900RH Dec 5, 1871RH Apr 8, 1875 In that setting it was supremely fitting for Him to make known His Sabbath as memorial of creation and sign of redemption and sanctification, because the Sabbath is first a memorial of creative power and goodness and secondly the sign of power to recreate, save, sanctify and regenerate, and was His weekly constant pledge of His everlasting covenant to redeem, an unchangeable part of God's law.ST Sep 10, 1902ST Jul 27, 1904

After bondage where the mass in abject toil under a Jehovah-denying monarch could not observe it and memory was nearly erased by idolatry, God called Israel back only thirty days after leaving the house of bondage where they could not observe it, placing them where all was adjusted for the Sabbath, reminding them of creation rest, reinforcing it by manna, and turning them from sun-worship.RH Apr 11, 1854ST Oct 24, 1900RH Oct 29, 1914 The going out to gather on the seventh day and finding none took place in the wilderness of Sin thirty days after Israel left Egypt on the fifteenth day of the first month and thirty days before coming to Mount Sinai on the fifteenth day of the third month, about a month before the law was spoken, proving the Sabbath did not originate at Sinai for the Jews alone.RH Apr 11, 1854RH Dec 9, 1851ST The Israelites received food from heaven and did not need a day away from hard labor, so the Sabbath's presence in the wilderness cannot be explained merely as provision for rest from toil.RH Dec 9, 1851 The weekly manna lesson taught Sabbath observance before the law was spoken at Sinai, though neglected during long servitude in Egypt, and forgetting the Sabbath was associated with return to sun-worship.ST Oct 24, 1900RH Oct 29, 1914ST The speaking of the law at Sinai was only a repetition of the law that Abraham and all God's prophets had been keeping down to Moses, and as part of God's eternal law of love the Sabbath is as eternal as God Himself and will be kept in the new earth.ST

The wilderness proving is repeated after the first and second messages proclaimed to the fall of 1844, when by the third angel's message based on the closing sanctuary work begun at the end of the twenty-three hundred days God calls attention to the ark containing His law in heaven and first proves His people by the Sabbath whether they will walk in His law or no.RH May 28, 1867 He thus gathers a people who keep the ten commandments and the faith of Jesus, bear the Sabbath of the fourth commandment as the sign and seal of the living God and the Father's name opposite the mark of the beast, and are prepared for translation at Christ's appearing.RH May 28, 1867 The Sabbath test included children with their parents, and it types the second and last recovery of the true Israel who keep and restore the same seventh-day Sabbath with all the commandments, whose likewise obedient children will go with them into the heavenly Canaan.RH Jan 1851 From Israel's wilderness experience the end-time remnant learns not to fall away from the cleansing truths given to them concerning cleansing and obedience.RH Nov 3, 1868

Breaking right after correction for keeping manna overnight shows disobedience is natural, grieves the Lord, and brings His rebuke How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws, remembering former transgressions.RH Aug 17, 1869 Going out to gather was open violation of God's holy law and commandments, trampling His Sabbath underfoot and doing one's own pleasure on His holy day, a guilt made greater when a minister of the gospel lives in it and by example and work teaches others to reject God's law.ST Aug 31, 1882 It warns present believers to take warning from Israel, walk in the light, and not think they can with impunity abrogate, change, or break one of the least of the commandments or claim exception from obedience to the fourth, for the Lord will not hold them guiltless after all the warnings and chastisements of Israel and the light of present truth.RH Aug 17, 1869 God brings His people out of bondage to sectarian creeds and churches to prove and try them to know what is in their hearts whether they will keep His commandments, since the Sabbath cannot be kept in such bondage, as He brought Israel out of the house of bondage to prove them by reminding them of His Sabbath.RH Jan 2, 1908 Going out was rebellion and unbelief, refusal to be content with God's gift of food and drink and with raiment that did not wear out on the mere journey to the land of milk and honey, the same rebellion repeated by those professing to journey to the heavenly Canaan yet longing for the flesh-pots of Egypt or the feasts of Baal instead of trusting Christ the supplier of food and fountain of living water to go with them as Leader, Helper, Saviour, and comfort and hope.ST Mar 18, 1889

The episode belongs to God's preparation of Israel after the call out of Egypt for the land flowing with milk and honey, beginning with health reform, diet, and the law of God, feeding them manna from heaven instead of the flesh-pots they were loath to leave.RH Jan 6, 1910 The simple manna diet was what the divine Leader knew was best, because bodies are made of what is eaten and the purest food makes the purest blood, and by it God sought to purify their blood and make them a holy, happy people, showing how little faith they had in these heaven-born principles which came not from the science of that day but from the mind of God.RH Jan 6, 1910 When the manna fell there was no animal food in connection with it, revealing that in the beginning God gave man no animal food and that vegetables and grains and fruits and nuts are better than all flesh food, so man ought to live according to the highest law of eating and drinking to the glory of God.ST Aug 13, 1912RH Dec 21, 1905 The manna was part of an education embracing all habits of life, where everything concerning well-being was the subject of divine solicitude and came within divine law, and its nature promoted physical, mental and moral strength, so that notwithstanding hardships there was not a feeble one in all their tribes.ST Nov 2, 1915 Israel's dependence on this provision made the wilderness delay a test of trust, and those living in harmony with God's providence were grateful for the manna and used their time well, showing the Sabbath is easy and joyful, not a heavy yoke, with plain diet best.RH Jul 20, 1869

The seventh day identified there by three miracles every week for forty years is the same Lord's Sabbath known by Ezra and Nehemiah after the Babylonian captivity, observed by Christ in the same way as the Jews, and rested on by the disciples according to the commandment while Christ rested in the tomb, proving identity continued without break to the present.ST Jun 28, 1905 It stands in the unbroken line from Paradise lost to Paradise restored where the Sabbath will be kept, made for man and not abolished, proving it must now be brought out and vindicated after long being trodden down.RH Jan 1851 It is not a temporary or makeshift arrangement for the exodus life, nor a separate Israelite Sabbath different from Adam's, but the same original seventh day given at creation and afterward enjoined from Sinai, the only weekly Sabbath in every age, coming just before the first day of the week.ST Jun 26, 1893ST Jun 2, 1881 The manna's six-day provision and absence on the seventh identified the Sabbath and helped preserve knowledge of which day was the seventh, confirming the continuing order of days during the forty years.STST Jun 4, 1912 The Sabbath conflict connected with the verse is evidence that Sabbath observance had been restored among the Israelites in Egypt before deliverance, and the Sabbath as sign of loyalty so restored before the Exodus is compared with its restoration in the last days before deliverance from sin.RH Mar 25, 1909

Sources

  1. RH May 7, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 1 — Reply R. F. C., May 7, 1857
  2. RH Mar 3, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 14 — Lessons for Bible Students Third-Day, March 3, 1863
  3. RH Dec 4, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 5 — THE SCRIPTURE AUTHORITY AND OBLIGATION OF THE SABBATH EXAMINED Rev. W. M. O'Hanlon, December 4, 1856
  4. ST Aug 18, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 32 — The Sabbath Through the Ages Charles L. Taylor, August 18, 1909
  5. ST Feb 11, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 6 — The Law of God—What It Is A. C. T., February 11, 1913
  6. RH Sep 24, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 15 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Peter Vogel, September 24, 1872
  7. RH Jul 14, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 5 — Why Not Be Honest? Uriah Smith, July 14, 1874.
  8. ST Jun 25, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 26 — Sabbath Reform in the Wilderness G., JUNE 25, 1902
  9. ST Aug 11, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 31 — The Sabbath Previous to Sinai George I. Butler, August 11, 1914
  10. ST Mar 7, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 10 — THE WILL OF GOD W. A. Sweany, March 7, 1906
  11. RH Dec 17, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 3 — History of the Sabbath John Nevins Andrews, Third-Day, December 17, 1861
  12. RH Apr 11, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 12 — THE SABBATH April 11, 1854
  13. ST Jun 16, 1887 Signs of the Times, Vol. 13, No. 23 — THE LAW AND THE SABBATH BEFORE THE EXODE June 16, 1887
  14. ST Apr 26, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 17 — The Law and the Gospel April 26, 1883
  15. RH Dec 2, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 1 — Perpetual Observance of the Sabbath Uriah Smith, Third-Day, December 2, 1862
  16. RH Sep 24, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 15 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Peter Vogel, September 24, 1872
  17. RH Jun 10, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 2 — REVIEW OF A. N. SEYMOUR J. M. Aldrich, Third-Day, June 10, 1862
  18. ST Mar 18, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 19 — Morality of the Sabbath. AND Its Importance Dudley Marvin Canright, March 18, 1875
  19. RH Apr 8, 1875 Review and Herald, Vol. 45, No. 15 — MORALITY OF THE SABBATH AND ITS IMPORTANCE Dudley Marvin Canright, Fifth-day, April 8, 1875
  20. ST Mar 18, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 19 — Morality of the Sabbath. AND Its Importance Dudley Marvin Canright, March 18, 1875
  21. ST Jul 30, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 29 — The Rival Sabbaths July 30, 1912
  22. ST Oct 4, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 40 — A MATTER OF FAITH Walter E. Gillis, October 4, 1905
  23. RH Jul 4, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 22 — DISCOURSE ON THE SABBATH Seth Williston, July 4, 1854
  24. ST Feb 22, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 8 — THE SABBATH L. A. Phippeny, February 22, 1905
  25. ST Mar 13, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 11 — Baptist Banner on the Sabbath Editor, March 13, 1879
  26. ST Feb 5, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 5 — EDWARDS (BELLVILLE), NEW YORK Charles C. Lewis, February 5, 1880
  27. RH Sep 24, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 15 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Peter Vogel, September 24, 1872
  28. RH Oct 29, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 20 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Peter Vogel, THIRD-DAY, OCTOBER 29, 1872
  29. RH Dec 20, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 4 — Still in the Dark Editor, December 20, 1864
  30. ST Apr 24, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 17 — Sunday Not the True Seventh day John Nevins Andrews, April 24, 1879
  31. ST Apr 24, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 17 — Sunday Not the True Seventh day John Nevins Andrews, April 24, 1879
  32. ST May 17, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 19 — Armstrong's Deceptive Argument Editor, May 17, 1883
  33. ST Jun 10, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 22 — DOCTOR BENSON'S SUNDAY BOOK Fifth-day, June 10, 1880
  34. ST Jun 10, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 22 — DOCTOR BENSON'S SUNDAY BOOK Editor, Fifth-day, June 10, 1880
  35. RH May 8, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 4 — Learned Men on the Sabbath Rev. John S. Stone, D. D., May 8, 1856
  36. ST May 20, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 28 — More Confusion May 20, 1875
  37. ST Nov 15, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 43 — A Check on Adventism November 15, 1883
  38. RH Dec 9, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 26 — The First-Day Sabbath vs. the History of the Sabbath John Nevins Andrews, December 9, 1873
  39. RH Nov 12, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 22 — Discussion on the Sabbath Question Peter Vogel, November 12, 1872
  40. RH Sep 24, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 15 — ELD. J. H. WAGGONER'S FIRST NEGATIVE Joseph Harvey Waggoner, September 24, 1872
  41. RH Oct 29, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 20 — ELD. J. H. WAGGONER'S THIRD NEGATIVE Joseph Harvey Waggoner, THIRD-DAY, OCTOBER 29, 1872
  42. RH May 7, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 1 — FIGHTING AGAINST GOD D. Bosworth, May 7, 1857
  43. RH Nov 15, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 25 — No Sabbath Third-Day, November 15, 1864
  44. RH Dec 20, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 4 — Still in the Dark Editor, December 20, 1864
  45. RH Jun 19, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 8 — THE INSTITUTION OF THE SABBATH Editor, June 19, 1856
  46. RH Nov 25, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 14 — CONVERSATION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION Unbeliever, Thursday, November 25, 1852
  47. ST Jul 1, 1908 Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 27 — With Our Inquirers July 1, 1908
  48. RH May 27, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 41, No. 24 — Objections to the Sabbath Answered Dudley Marvin Canright, May 27, 1873
  49. RH May 2, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 15 — THE SABBATH May 2, 1854
  50. RH Mar 21, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 16 — The Sabbath J. M. Aldrich, Third-Day, March 21, 1865
  51. RH Aug 6, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 8 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION John Harvey Waggoner, August 6, 1872
  52. RH Mar 31, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 13, No. 19 — THOUGHTS FOR THE THOUGHTLESS March 31, 1859
  53. RH Aug 6, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 8 — ELD. VOGEL'S FIRST REPLY Eld. Vogel, August 6, 1872
  54. RH Sep 19, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 6 — SIXTEENTH OF EXODUS R. F. Cottrell, September 19, 1854
  55. RH Jul 27, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 5 — TO CORRESPONDENTS Third-day, July 27, 1869
  56. RH Feb 3, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 11 — Remarks of O. R. L. Crozier on the Institution, Design and Abolition of the Sabbath February 3, 1852
  57. RH Feb 3, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 11 — Remarks of O. R. L. Crozier on the Institution, Design and Abolition of the Sabbath February 3, 1852
  58. RH Oct 31, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 20 — EXAMINATION OF T. M. PREBLE'S FIRST-DAY SABBATH John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, October 31, 1871
  59. RH Feb 14, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 12 — Meetings in Ills R. F. Andrews, Third-Day, February 14, 1865
  60. ST Jul 24, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 28 — Sunday Not the True Seventh Day July 24, 1879
  61. RH May 6, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 1 — THE SABBATH John Nevins Andrews, May 6, 1852
  62. RH Jan 31, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 18 — THE TRUTH FOUND. A Short Argument for the Sabbath January 31, 1856
  63. RH May 20, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 23 — ARTICLE EIGHT Origen, May 20, 1873
  64. RH May 27, 1873 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 41, No. 24 — Testimony of the Fathers John Nevins Andrews, May 27, 1873
  65. ST Jul 17, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 27 — Sunday Not the True Seventh Day John Nevins Andrews, July 17, 1879
  66. RH Jul 8, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 4 — DISCUSSION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION J. H. Waggoner, Third-day, July 8, 1873
  67. RH Mar 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 7 — THE WEEKLY SABBATH INSTITUTED AT CREATION AND NOT AT SINAI March, 1851
  68. RH Apr 4, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 11 — INSTITUTION OF THE SABBATH April 4, 1854
  69. RH May 27, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 2 — THE SABBATH Thursday, May 27, 1852
  70. ST Jun 2, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 21 — NOT A SABBATH, BUT THE SABBATH June 2, 1881
  71. RH Jul 24, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 28, No. 8 — The Memphis Discussion Third-Day, July 24, 1866
  72. RH Feb 3, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 11 — Remarks of O. R. L. Crozier on the Institution, Design and Abolition of the Sabbath February 3, 1852
  73. ST Apr 25, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 17 — A BAPTIST AGAINST THE LAW OF GOD G., April 25, 1906
  74. ST Jan 17, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 3 — THE SABBATH UNIVERSAL AND PERPETUAL G., January 17, 1906
  75. RH Mar 26, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 16 — Notes on Genesis Scott; Bush; T. H. Horne, Third-day, March 26, 1867.
  76. RH Mar 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 7 — THE WEEKLY SABBATH INSTITUTED AT CREATION AND NOT AT SINAI March, 1851
  77. RH Nov 15, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 19 — THE LAW OF GOD J. H. Waggoner, November 15, 1853
  78. ST Sep 16, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 35 — THE FOURTH COMMANDMENT September 16, 1880
  79. ST Aug 30, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 35 — WHICH IS THE TRUE SEVENTH DAY? August 30, 1905
  80. ST Aug 7, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 30 — Sunday Not the True Seventh Day John Nevins Andrews, August 7, 1879
  81. ST Aug 20, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 34 — The Sabbath August 20, 1902
  82. ST May 1, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 17 — The Lost-Time Objection to the Sabbath Editor, May 1, 1884
  83. ST Jan 23, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 4 — Question Corner C. E., January 23, 1896
  84. ST Apr 1, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 21 — Sabbath in Scotland April 1, 1875
  85. ST Nov 3, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 41 — CAN'T UNDERSTAND IT Editor, November 3, 1881
  86. ST May 20, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 20 — Christ Was the Lord or Creator of the Sabbath and the Week C. A. Wyman, May 20, 1897
  87. ST Nov 19, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 44 — "Numerical Designation" in the Sabbath Commandment Ellet Joseph Waggoner, November 19, 1885
  88. ST Sep 14, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 35 — Is Sunday a Sacred Day? September 14, 1882
  89. ST Apr 11, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 15 — A STRANGE APPEAL FOR SUNDAY! April 11, 1900
  90. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 2 — Why Not Restore the Borrowed Clothing?
  91. ST Jun 5, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 22 — Denison, Texas Robert M. Kilgore, June 5, 1879
  92. RH Jun 5, 1900 Review and Herald, Vol. 77, No. 23 — THE THIRD ANGEL'S MESSAGE Eusebius, June 5, 1900
  93. RH Mar 3, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 21 — The Seventh-day Sabbath not a type of the Christian's Rest. Heb. iv, 4, 9 J. H. Waggoner, Thursday, March 3, 1853
  94. ST Nov 4, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 42 — The Seventh-Day Sabbath Not a Type of the Christian’s Rest. Heb. 4: 4, 9 John Harvey Kellogg, November 4, 1886
  95. RH Mar 10, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 13 — THE SABBATISM OF HEB. IV March 10, 1868
  96. RH May 12, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 24 — Proper Observance of the Sabbath D. T. Bourdeau, May 12, 1863
  97. ST Aug 11, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 31 — The Sabbath Through the Ages Charles L. Taylor, August 11, 1909
  98. RH Jun 19, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 8 — THE INSTITUTION OF THE SABBATH Editor, June 19, 1856
  99. RH Mar 31, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 18 — Lessons for Bible Students Third-Day, March 31, 1863
  100. RH Apr 11, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 12 — THE SABBATH April 11, 1854
  101. RH Sep 19, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 6 — THE SABBATH OF THE LORD Alvares Pierce, September 19, 1854
  102. RH Aug 14, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 32, No. 8 — TEN POPULAR OBJECTIONS TO THE SABBATH ANSWERED Dudley Marvin Canright, Third-day, August 14, 1868
  103. ST Jul 22, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 28 — THE SEVENTH DAY OR A SEVENTH DAY J. W., July 22, 1880
  104. ST May 24, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 20 — 3136.— Building a Fire on the Sabbath Day Editor, May 24, 1910
  105. ST Apr 19, 1877 The Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 16 — The Sabbath—Its Observance J. O. Corliss, Fifth-day, April 19, 1877
  106. ST Jun 24, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 33 — The Sermon Ellet Joseph Waggoner, June 24, 1875
  107. RH Nov 27, 1913 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 90, No. 48 — The Pot of Manna F. W. Stray, Thursday, November 27, 1913
  108. RH Aug 5, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 3, No. 7 — THE SABBATH THURSDAY, AUGUST 5, 1852
  109. RH Sep 24, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 15 — ELD. J. H. WAGGONER'S FIRST NEGATIVE Joseph Harvey Waggoner, September 24, 1872
  110. ST Dec 8, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 46 — BRIEF COMMENTS Dr. Edwards; Prof. Moses Stuart, December 8, 1881
  111. RH Jun 19, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 8 — THE INSTITUTION OF THE SABBATH June 19, 1856
  112. ST Oct 23, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 50 — AUTHORITY FOR THE SABBATH Ellet Joseph Waggoner, Monday, October 23, 1893
  113. ST Jan 17, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 3 — Studies on the Sabbath R. A. Underwood, January 17, 1911
  114. RH Dec 5, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 25 — Instructive Comparisons H. A. St. John, Third-day, December 5, 1871
  115. ST Oct 24, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 43 — THE CYCLE OF THE SABBATH George A. Snyder, October 24, 1900
  116. ST Sep 10, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 37 — WHY NOT ALL OF IT? September 10, 1902
  117. ST Jul 27, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 30 — Question Corner K., July 27, 1904
  118. ST Oct 24, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 43 — THE CYCLE OF THE SABBATH George A. Snyder, October 24, 1900
  119. RH Oct 29, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 45 — The Sabbath of the Lord F. M. W., October 29, 1914
  120. RH Dec 9, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 8 — THE SABBATH DECEMBER 9, 1851
  121. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 1 — The Sabbath W. H. Armstrong
  122. RH May 28, 1867 Review and Herald, Vol. 29, No. 24 — OUR PRESENT POSITION, In the Waiting, Tarrying Time A. C. Bourdeau, May 28, 1867
  123. RH Jan 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 5 — DUTY TO OUR CHILDREN Joseph Bates, January, 1851
  124. RH Nov 3, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 32, No. 19 — CONDITIONS OF BECOMING HEAVENLY HEIRS H. G. Buxton, Third-day, November 3, 1868
  125. RH Aug 17, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 8 — ONE DAY IN SEVEN F. A. BUZZELL, August 17, 1869
  126. ST Aug 31, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 33 — Experience, and Investigation of the Sabbath Question E. W. Barnes, August 31, 1882
  127. RH Jan 2, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 1 — THE PRESENT TRUTH January 2, 1908
  128. ST Mar 18, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 11 — ADMONITION, COMFORT, HOPE M. C. W., March 18, 1889
  129. RH Jan 6, 1910 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 87, No. 1 — Diet From the Bible Standpoint A. W. Semmens, January 6, 1910
  130. ST Aug 13, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 31 — 3824 — Clean and Unclean Meats M. B. R., August 13, 1912
  131. RH Dec 21, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 51 — A Fleshless Diet From a Biblical and Christian Standpoint D. H. KRESS, M. D., December 21, 1905
  132. ST Nov 2, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 43 — The Education of Ancient Israel Ellen G. White, November 2, 1915
  133. RH Jul 20, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 4 — How Long Will It Be? Jos. Clarke, Third-day, July 20, 1869
  134. ST Jun 28, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 26 — REPLY TO SOME ANTI-SABBATH ARGUMENTS Editor, June 28, 1905
  135. RH Jan 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 1, No. 5 — THE PERPETUITY OF THE LAW OF GOD John Nevins Andrews, January, 1851
  136. ST Jun 26, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 33 — AN OLD OBJECTION TO THE SABBATH Monday, June 26, 1893
  137. ST Jun 2, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 21 — NOT A SABBATH, BUT THE SABBATH June 2, 1881
  138. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 47 — With Our Inquirers J. H. B.; E. E. P.
  139. ST Jun 4, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 22 — IF YE WILL INQUIRE, INQUIRE YE Editor, June 4, 1912
  140. RH Mar 25, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 12 — The Controversy Over the Sabbath Question in Egypt W. A. C., March 25, 1909