Exodus 16:28
And the LORD said unto Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws?
Translations
And the LORD said to Moses, How long refuse you to keep my commandments and my laws?
King James Version, Revised Version
And the LORD said unto Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws?
And the Lord said unto Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws?
And the LORD said to Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws?
And Jehovah said unto Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws?
And Jehovah saith unto Moses, 'How long have ye refused to keep My commands, and My laws?
And Jehovah said to Moses, How long do ye refuse to keep my commandments and my laws?
Then said Yahweh unto Moses,—How long have ye refused to keep my commandments and my laws?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then the LORD said to Moses, “ How long will you refuse to keep My commandments and instructions?
The LORD said to Moses, “ How long do you refuse to keep my commandments and my laws?
And the Lord said to Moses, How long will you go against my orders and my laws?
And the Lord sayde vnto Moses, Howe long refuse yee to keepe my commandements, and my lawes?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the Lord said to Moses: How long will you refuse to keep my commandments, and my law?
Cross-references 20 of 73
- Exodus 20:8-11
Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.
The Sabbath command grounds observance in God’s creation and seventh-day rest.
- Exodus 16:4
Then said the LORD unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.
The manna tested whether Israel would walk in God’s law.
- Genesis 2:2-3
And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made.
God’s creation rest established the seventh day, which the manna account confirms as the Sabbath.
- Exodus 16:23
And he said unto them, This is that which the LORD hath said, To morrow is the rest of the holy sabbath unto the LORD: bake that which ye will bake to day, and seethe that ye will seethe; and that which remaineth over lay up for you to be kept until the morning.
Moses identifies the next day as the holy Sabbath and instructs the people to prepare manna.
- Genesis 26:5
Because that Abraham obeyed my voice, and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my laws.
Abraham kept God’s commandments and laws before the exodus.
- Deuteronomy 5:14-15
But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, nor thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thine ox, nor thine ass, nor any of thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates; that thy manservant and thy maidservant may rest as well as thou.
The Sabbath command recalls Israel’s deliverance from Egypt as a reason to keep the Sabbath.
- Ezekiel 20:12
Moreover also I gave them my sabbaths, to be a sign between me and them, that they might know that I am the LORD that sanctify them.
The Sabbath is described as a sign between God and his people.
- Nehemiah 9:14
And madest known unto them thy holy sabbath, and commandedst them precepts, statutes, and laws, by the hand of Moses thy servant:
God made his holy Sabbath known to Israel at Sinai.
- Matthew 5:18
For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.
Jesus declares that no part of the law will pass away while heaven and earth endure.
- 1 John 3:4
Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.
Sin is defined as transgression of the law.
- Luke 23:56
And they returned, and prepared spices and ointments; and rested the sabbath day according to the commandment.
The women rested on the Sabbath according to the commandment.
- Isaiah 58:13-14
If thou turn away thy foot from the sabbath, from doing thy pleasure on my holy day; and call the sabbath a delight, the holy of the LORD, honourable; and shalt honour him, not doing thine own ways, nor finding thine own pleasure, nor speaking thine own words:
Honoring the Sabbath brings delight in the Lord and his promised blessing.
- Ezekiel 20:20
And hallow my sabbaths; and they shall be a sign between me and you, that ye may know that I am the LORD your God.
The Sabbath is a sign by which Israel knows the LORD their God.
- Deuteronomy 4:13
And he declared unto you his covenant, which he commanded you to perform, even ten commandments; and he wrote them upon two tables of stone.
The Lord identifies the commandments he spoke with his covenant.
- James 2:10
For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.
Breaking even one commandment makes a person guilty of the law as a whole.
- Exodus 31:13-17
Speak thou also unto the children of Israel, saying, Verily my sabbaths ye shall keep: for it is a sign between me and you throughout your generations; that ye may know that I am the LORD that doth sanctify you.
The Sabbath is a perpetual sign between God and Israel, with its observance commanded.
- Exodus 16:5
And it shall come to pass, that on the sixth day they shall prepare that which they bring in; and it shall be twice as much as they gather daily.
God commanded a double gathering of manna on the sixth day in preparation for the Sabbath.
- Numbers 15:32-36
And while the children of Israel were in the wilderness, they found a man that gathered sticks upon the sabbath day.
A man was put to death for gathering sticks on the Sabbath.
- Exodus 16:20
Notwithstanding they hearkened not unto Moses; but some of them left of it until the morning, and it bred worms, and stank: and Moses was wroth with them.
Manna kept overnight spoiled, showing Israel’s disobedience.
- Romans 3:31
Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.
Faith does not make void God’s law; it establishes the commandments.
Commentary part 1 of 2
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
23 sources
The Lord's question is a rebuke for refusing to keep His commandments and laws, spoken to those who went out to gather manna on the seventh day against His special direction and found none, whose Sabbath-breaking was disobedience and disloyalty to God.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13ST May 13, 1886PP 296.2–3 It belongs to the miraculous provision of manna before Sinai, when God commanded a double gathering on the sixth day and rest on the seventh to impress the sacredness of the Sabbath, withholding manna every seventh day and miraculously preserving the preparation-day portion fresh through the Sabbath for nearly forty years.RH Oct 28, 1902Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15SG3 255.1PK 180.2RH Nov 6, 1913 The Sabbath was already known, expected and kept as one of God's commandments and laws on the way to Sinai, not first given there nor for Israel alone, for the seventh day had been hallowed at creation and made known in Eden and the weekly manna continually repeated that law before it was proclaimed at Sinai in the bosom of the Ten Commandments.DA 283.1–2Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13RH Aug 18, 1910Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12Ms 63, 1897, par. 1–3 As part of the Decalogue it carries imperishable obligation not for Israel merely but for the world, continuing as the Creator's sign so long as heaven and earth endure and honored by all in the restored Eden.DA 283.1–2 The instructions and rebuke were recorded for all who live to the close of time, so the Sabbath command remains a test of obedience, and as God brought Israel out of Egypt that they might keep His Sabbath unmolested, He calls His people out of Babylon that they may not worship the beast by accepting the spurious first-day rival sabbath set up by the man of sin.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12Lt 1f, 1890, par. 16–17Ms 143, 1901, par. 48–522MR 228.2–3
Manna and Sabbath Setting
The question belongs to the miraculous provision of manna before the law was spoken at Sinai, when instruction was given for a double gathering on the sixth day and rest on the seventh to impress the sacredness of the Sabbath.RH Oct 28, 1902Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15SG3 255.1 The extra portion on the sixth day, the absence of manna on the seventh, and its staying fresh through the Sabbath were designed to impress the people with the Sabbath's sacredness, and failure to follow these instructions was disobedience to God.RH Oct 28, 1902SG3 255.1 Every seventh day the manna was withheld, while the double portion that fell on the preparation day was miraculously preserved and kept fresh through the Sabbath.SG3 255.1PK 180.2RH Nov 6, 1913 Through nearly forty years of wandering this weekly miracle constantly reminded Israel of God's appointed rest day.PK 180.2RH Nov 6, 1913 This weekly withholding and preservation also repeated the Sabbath law given in Eden, teaching that the seventh day is the Lord's Sabbath, with Friday's provision made enough for two days.Ms 38, 1898, par. 9
The Lord's question is a rebuke for refusing to keep His commandments and laws, directed at those who went out to gather manna on the seventh day contrary to that special direction and found none.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13ST May 13, 1886PP 296.2–3 Their Sabbath-breaking was disobedience to God and showed failure of loyalty to Him.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13ST May 13, 1886 The weekly manna miracle had already taught them that the Sabbath was sacred and binding before they reached Sinai, yet they remained lax in keeping its sacred obligation.PP 296.2–3PP 408.4–409.3 That disregard for the Sabbath was among the reasons the first generation was excluded from Canaan.PP 408.4–409.3 That disobedience is connected especially with profaning the Sabbath.Ms 14, 1901, par. 6–12
God brought Israel out of Egyptian bondage that they might keep His Sabbath, and tested them upon His law by commanding a daily gathering with a double portion on the sixth day and rest on the seventh.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13ST Feb 27, 1896 In bondage their taskmasters had attempted to force them to labor on the Sabbath by increasing the amount of work required each week and making the conditions of labor harder and more exacting.PK 180.2 Israel was delivered from bondage and brought to a place where they might observe unmolested all the precepts of Jehovah.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13PK 180.2 The manna with its doubled provision on the sixth day affirmed the sacredness of the Sabbath, which the Son of God later proclaimed at Sinai as the Ten Commandments.ST Feb 27, 1896
Though everything needed for religious service could have been supplied without human contribution, cooperation was required, giving each person a part in the work as moral discipline.4T 469.1 His commandments and laws cover all the habits of life and everything that concerns well-being as a matter of divine care.ST Nov 2, 1915 Even in providing food He sought Israel's highest good, and the manna fed to them in the wilderness was fitted to promote physical, mental, and moral strength.ST Nov 2, 1915 So notwithstanding the hardships of wilderness life there was not one feeble person in all their tribes.ST Nov 2, 1915 Strangers who observed the Sabbath were allowed to share the manna, the food from heaven.Ms 14, 1901, par. 6–12
Sabbath Law Before Sinai
Exodus 16:28 proves the Sabbath was already known, expected and kept as one of God's commandments and laws on the way to Sinai before it was embodied in the law.DA 283.1–2RH Aug 18, 1910Ms 63, 1897, par. 1–3 When some profaned it, the rebuke for refusing to obey showed Israel already had knowledge of it there and was under obligation to keep it.DA 283.1–2RH Aug 18, 1910 The manna experience taught Israel to keep those commandments and laws, including the Sabbath, and continually testified to it.Ms 63, 1897, par. 1–3 The Sabbath was therefore not first made known or given at Sinai, and it was not an obligation for Israel alone.DA 283.1–2RH Aug 18, 1910
The seventh day had been hallowed and sanctified at creation and made known to mankind in Eden.DA 283.1–2Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12 The weekly manna upheld it, continually testified to it, and repeated the Sabbath law given in Eden, with no manna falling on the seventh day and Friday's provision sufficing for two days.DA 283.1–2Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12Ms 38, 1898, par. 9ST Mar 31, 1898 God sustained the validity of the seventh-day Sabbath by that miracle and by commanding a daily gathering with a double portion on the sixth day and rest on the seventh.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12 It was afterward proclaimed at Sinai in the very bosom of the Ten Commandments, when the Father and the Son descended and spoke the precepts of the law in the hearing of all Israel so there could be no mistake.DA 283.1–2Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12ST Feb 27, 1896
As part of the Decalogue the Sabbath carries imperishable obligation, not for Israel merely but for the world.DA 283.1–2 It continues as a sign of the Creator's power so long as heaven and earth endure.DA 283.1–2 It will be honored by all in the restored Eden when all worship from one Sabbath to another.DA 283.1–2
Yet this holy institution is discarded for a spurious first-day rival sabbath set up by the man of sin and accepted by the professed Christian world in disloyalty to God.Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12 The Sabbath command remains a test of obedience, and replacing God's sanctified day with a rival Sabbath defies Him and warns against disobeying His law.Ms 143, 1901, par. 48–52 By that rival sabbath the man of sin exalts himself above God, removes God's memorial, and defies God.Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12Lt 1f, 1890, par. 16–172MR 228.2–3
Warning and Present Obedience
The directions given through Moses about gathering each day and gathering twice as much on the sixth day and resting on the seventh were written down for the good of everyone living on earth until the close of time, so the question how long refusal to keep the commandments and laws would continue summons all to hear God's words and obey them.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13 That rebuke was spoken because some went out to gather on the seventh day against the special direction and found nothing, and their Sabbath-breaking was disobedience that was reproved.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13 God had brought Israel out of Egypt so they might keep His Sabbath and proved them upon His law by this daily test, and the law thus tested was afterward spoken without possibility of mistake when the Father and the Son came down upon Mount Sinai and uttered its precepts in the hearing of all Israel.Ms 3, 1885, par. 12–13 The Sabbath command still stands as a test of obedience, and to set aside God's sanctified day for a rival Sabbath defies Him and stands as a warning against disobeying His law.Ms 143, 1901, par. 48–52
Israel's lax keeping of the weekly reminder of the Sabbath's sacred obligation showed refusal to obey, and that disregard was among the causes for which the first generation was shut out of Canaan.PP 408.4–409.3 God warned that after they settled in the land their children would be scattered among the nations.PP 408.4–409.3 As God called the children of Israel out of Egypt that they might keep His Sabbath, so He calls His people out of Babylon that they may not worship the beast nor his image.Lt 1f, 1890, par. 16–172MR 228.2–3 That final call means refusing the spurious rival Sabbath by which the man of sin lifts himself above God, takes away God's memorial, and defies God.Lt 1f, 1890, par. 16–172MR 228.2–3
The verse requires the Sabbath to be kept by resting from work and forbids carrying on common labor on that day.Ms 231, 1902, par. 46–57 A restaurant therefore is never to be opened on the Sabbath but is to be closed, with all food for customers and for helpers made ready on Friday.Ms 231, 1902, par. 46–57 On Friday simple foods such as good bread and crackers and other simple food already provided are to be wrapped up and placed in baskets or in packages with compartments, with a little note stating the price, so that people can take them to their rooms and live on them until the restaurant is opened again, and only what is already prepared is to be handed out, which keeps the Sabbath unbroken.Ms 231, 1902, par. 46–57 Sickness or fear of being harmed by weekday food is no excuse for breaking it.Ms 231, 1902, par. 46–57
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
248 sources
The Lord rebuked Moses because some of Israel went out to gather manna on the seventh day and found none, and their going out is charged as refusing to keep His commandments and His laws.RH Mar 1851RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851RH Sep 24, 1872RH Apr 30, 1872 The rebuke was spoken in the wilderness of Sin about a month before Sinai, after Israel left Egypt on the fifteenth of the first month and reached Sin on the fifteenth of the second month, when God already spoke of sixth day and seventh day and enforced the Sabbath before the Ten Commandments were spoken.ST Apr 26, 1883ST Oct 31, 1906RH Jul 14, 1874RH Feb 3, 1852 His words How long and refuse show willful, long-continued neglect of law already known and binding, not a first offense in ignorance, for Israel already knew the Sabbath reckoning and gathered a double portion on the sixth without a new order.RH Sep 24, 1872ST Mar 7, 1906RH Dec 23, 1851RH Dec 4, 1856ST Jun 16, 1887 That Sabbath was the definite known seventh day, the last day of the week kept from sunset to sunset, originating when God rested the seventh day at creation and blessed and sanctified it, not instituted in the wilderness, though others taught that it was first enjoined and instituted in the wilderness of Sin.RH Sep 24, 1872ST May 17, 1883ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880 God marked that day by a threefold weekly miracle for forty years, with manna six days, double on the sixth, preservation over the Sabbath and none on the seventh, choosing the Sabbath to test loyalty so that keeping it proved obedience to the whole moral law and breaking it exposed refusal of the whole, the same test now repeated to prepare His people for the heavenly inheritance.STRH Mar 3, 1863RH Jan 2, 1908ST Jul 22, 1880
Words and Setting of Rebuke
The Lord's rebuke was spoken to Moses because some of the people went out to gather manna on the seventh day and found none, and their going out was charged as refusing to keep His commandments and His laws.RH Mar 1851RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851STST Aug 11, 1914 The disobedience over the Sabbath proved the Sabbath already given and already binding, with the people reminded of it and proved by it, and the rebuke restrained their transgression for a time.RH Mar 1851RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jan 2, 1908 God had therefore given the bread of two days on the sixth day, requiring every man to abide in his place and not go out on the seventh day, and the people then rested on the seventh day.ST Aug 11, 1914RH Jan 2, 1908 The Sabbath was thus shown to be the command violated, with its obligation already known rather than newly instituted in the wilderness, and with observance already required and understood so that the people rested.RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851ST
The rebuke was addressed to Moses with the people and belongs to the Sabbath instructions in the manna account, with disobedience connected to those instructions.RH Sep 24, 1872RH Apr 30, 1872RH Dec 24, 1861ST Jun 27, 1900 The next verse identifies the Sabbath as a command He had given them and states explicitly the command not to go out to gather manna on the seventh day, after the rebuke, showing the Sabbath already in existence and enforced by law before Israel came to Mount Sinai and before the Ten Commandments were spoken there.RH Apr 30, 1872RH Feb 3, 1852 The chapter is the one in which God gave the Sabbath to Israel, distinct from Exodus 19 in which God gave Himself to Israel by espousing them as a holy nation and from Exodus 20 in which God gave Israel His law, and it is assigned for reading alongside the teaching about the bread of life.RH Dec 24, 1861ST Jun 27, 1900 The Sabbath command is the first precept recognized in Scripture as the law of God.RH Mar 25, 1862
The rebuke occurred in the wilderness of Sin about a month before Sinai, about thirty days before seeing Mount Sinai and thirty-two days before the Ten Commandments were spoken.ST Apr 26, 1883RH Jul 14, 1874RH Jan 2, 1908RH Apr 11, 1854RH Dec 29, 1868 This was after leaving Egypt on the fifteenth day of the first month and coming to Sin on the fifteenth day of the second month, thirty days before coming to Sinai by way of Rephidim on the fifteenth day of the third month.RH Jan 2, 1908RH Apr 11, 1854 About a month before Israel came to Sinai they kept the seventh-day Sabbath in their camp between Elim and Sinai, and from that time on the seventh day was specially marked by the withholding of manna on that day.ST Apr 26, 1883ST Oct 31, 1906 God spoke familiarly of sixth day and seventh day a month before Sinai, the people already well understood the Sabbath one month and three days before Israel came to Sinai, and He enforced the Sabbath at least fifteen days before Sinai, taking the Sabbath commandment as the one by which to test obedience to His law.RH Jul 14, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854 The saying that the Lord hath given you the Sabbath proves the Sabbath already given and spoken of as an old institution, not instituted at Sinai for the Jews alone at the giving of the law, so the Sabbath of the fourth commandment did not begin at Sinai and is not a Jewish institution beginning there.ST Apr 26, 1883RH Apr 11, 1854
The words How long and refuse show long-continued knowing neglect and willful refusal, not a first offense or ignorance from difficulty.ST Mar 7, 1906RH Dec 4, 1856ST Jun 16, 1887RH Jun 20, 1912ST Jun 11, 1894 How long points to longstanding refusal to obey and to prior knowing neglect of commandments and laws, indicating the law was already known and had been neglected over time, with the manna incident bringing an ancient established Sabbath observance back into view rather than instituting a new one.ST Mar 7, 1906RH Dec 4, 1856ST Jun 16, 1887 The disobedience was not new, for they had repeatedly violated the holy rest day, directly charged with having long refused to keep His commandments and laws in keeping the Sabbath, and God would not first introduce His law to an ignorant people with such a rebuke.RH Jun 20, 1912RH Dec 9, 1851 Some went out after failing to gather enough on the sixth day despite provision of twice as much manna on the sixth and instruction to remain in place on the seventh, and after earlier disobedience about keeping manna overnight.ST Jun 11, 1894RH Dec 9, 1851 Those who held a different position taught that the rebuke does not prove continued desecration of the Sabbath alone, since it says commandments and laws and not the Sabbath alone, the manna instruction being a new test commandment kept no better than other commandments long refused, with How long pointing to that long disobedience in general.RH Oct 29, 1872
The setting is the journey to Sinai after the crossing of the Red Sea and the song of Moses, as part of provision for guidance and sustenance in the wilderness.RH Jan 20, 1916 It belongs to the history portion of Exodus, chapters 1 to 18, within the going out of Israel from Egypt that gives the book its Greek name, telling the detailed story of great deliverance from bitter bondage and oppression after growing more and mightier than the Egyptians, and of becoming a nation with thorough organization, efficient leadership under Moses as chosen leader, a complete code of laws, and an established form of worship.RH Jan 20, 1916 Quail came in the evening and manna fell the next morning, this first giving of quail in the wilderness of Sin preceding the later giving after the people grew weary of manna.ST Apr 22, 1889 The manna fed the people miraculously six days a week for forty years, was God's miraculous provision and not a natural tamarisk secretion, could be boiled or baked yet melted in the sun, and is presented as a biblical example of a diet without flesh meat showing God's original plan for human food remained in force after animal food was permitted.ST May 4, 1904ST Dec 17, 1912RH Jun 25, 1914 Murmuring over hunger and longing for the flesh-pots showed unbelief and forgetfulness of benefits.ST Dec 17, 1912
The general order to gather every day and every morning meant only the six working days and did not include the set-apart seventh day, since the specific Sabbath law with no manna excepted it.RH Aug 5, 1852ST Dec 8, 1881RH Aug 4, 1868RH Jun 18, 1901ST Sep 16, 1875 Every day does not necessarily include the day God set apart as the Sabbath, but applies only to days when secular work was lawful, excluding that day on which manna does not fall and which is set apart for the Lord.RH Aug 5, 1852ST Dec 8, 1881RH Jun 18, 1901 Some went out on the seventh day to gather and found none, and the Lord rebuked them for refusing to keep His commandments and laws, proving gathering on the seventh day disobedience and proving the Sabbath holy, set apart from working days, and already binding.RH Aug 4, 1868ST Sep 16, 1875 They voluntarily gathered twice as much on the sixth day though not told in advance to gather a double portion, with specific instruction about the Sabbath given as it drew near.RH Aug 5, 1852 The question presents failure to observe God's commands as disobedience but does not establish that the stone tablets already existed when the events began, and Deuteronomy 5 recalls the Sinai command, not an Exodus 16 command.RH Dec 23, 1851
The march from Elim to Sin could not be used to fix a Sabbath violation, for God would not command travel and then forbid it.RH May 7, 1857RH Jun 19, 1856ST Apr 24, 1879 One day was used by divine direction to travel from Elim to the wilderness of Sin, then manna fell on the six following days and the seventh day is named the Sabbath, and that travel day could not have been the Sabbath because God would not without assigned reason command travel and soon afterward forbid such work on pain of death, while the camp is not moved again on the Sabbath during the wilderness sojourn.RH May 7, 1857 A journey performed under the direction of the Lord on the seventh day is no violation of the Sabbath law, just as marching around Jericho seven successive days including the Sabbath was no violation, since such a journey is not doing their own work.RH Jun 19, 1856 Reckoning back from the Sabbath cannot fix the marching day, for when God spoke of the sixth day He meant the sixth day of the week regardless of when He began to rain manna and not merely the sixth day counted from the first fall of manna.RH Jun 19, 1856ST Apr 24, 1879 The first fall of manna did not have to be on the first day of the week, one or more days could have passed after Israel arrived in the wilderness of Sin before the manna fell, and the first gathering could not have occurred on the true Sabbath, since gathering manna on the Lord's Sabbath violated the Sabbath.ST May 1, 1879ST Apr 24, 1879 The time from the triumph at the Red Sea to the first cessation of the manna might have been occupied in a proposed change of the Sabbath, but the day observed could still have coincided with the seventh day kept in succession from creation, and the chronology used to support a change is unreliable since Israel departed from Rameses on the fifteenth not the fourteenth and the text does not establish that only one day elapsed at each named station.RH Oct 31, 1871
Law Already Binding Before Sinai
God's commandments and laws, including the fourth commandment for the seventh-day Sabbath, were already known, binding, and expected to be kept before proclamation at Sinai, so Sinai created no new moral obligation.RH Mar 1851ST Apr 26, 1883RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851 The rebuke over going out to gather manna on the seventh day treats that going out as refusal to keep His commandments and laws, and shows the Sabbath had already been given and its observance already required.RH Mar 1851RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851ST The reproof came about thirty days before Israel saw Mount Sinai, proving the Sabbath of the fourth commandment did not begin at Sinai and is not a Jewish institution beginning there.ST Apr 26, 1883RH Jul 14, 1874RH Dec 9, 1851ST Aug 13, 1885RH Jun 30, 1859 The lack of mention of Sabbath-keeping in Genesis does not prove the Sabbath did not exist during that period, and the seventh day and the Sabbath both designated the last day of the week.ST Apr 26, 1883 Disobedience over the Sabbath showed it was the test of loyalty and obedience, and keeping it proved obedience to the whole law while breaking it exposed refusal of the commandments and laws as a whole.STST Feb 11, 1913ST Jun 10, 1875ST Aug 18, 1909ST Oct 18, 1905
Israel already knew the Sabbath reckoning before Sinai, voluntarily gathering a double portion on the sixth day and resting the seventh without a new order, speaking of it as an existing holy day with the week already reckoned.RH Sep 24, 1872RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jul 14, 1874RH Mar 3, 1863RH May 7, 1857 The reference to the Sabbath treats it as definite and known at this point, with twice as much manna provided on the sixth day and command to remain in place on the seventh, and the people then rested on the seventh day.RH Sep 24, 1872RH Dec 23, 1851ST Oct 31, 1906RH Jul 14, 1874RH Mar 3, 1863 About a month before Israel came to Sinai they kept the seventh-day Sabbath in camp between Elim and Sinai, and from that time on the seventh day was specially marked by withholding of manna on that day.ST Oct 31, 1906RH Jul 14, 1874RH Mar 3, 1863 Moses gave no new precept respecting the Sabbath there, and their gathering a double portion on the sixth day of their own accord proves the reckoning of the weeks had been correctly kept up to that time.RH Mar 3, 1863RH May 7, 1857 God took the Sabbath commandment as the one by which to test obedience to His law, so Israel knew and kept that institution more than a month before God spoke it on Sinai.RH Jul 14, 1874RH May 7, 1857
Moses withheld the test until the double gathering showed regard for the Sabbath, and no Sabbath precept is given until after its violation, proving the Sabbath did not originate with the manna but was already transgressed law.RH May 7, 1857RH Dec 9, 1851RH Jul 27, 1869RH Apr 14, 1874ST Mar 18, 1913 The manna was designed to prove the people whether they would walk in God's law, leaving them free to manifest regard for His law or what was in their heart, and the rebuke therefore honors law they already knew and shows its sacredness by miracles rather than giving a special day for the first time.RH May 7, 1857RH Jul 27, 1869RH Apr 14, 1874 The wording How long refuse ye shows the people were not wholly ignorant, for God would not first introduce His law to an ignorant people with such a rebuke, and How long proves the going out was not the first violation but long transgression of an existing sacred institution.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Jul 27, 1869RH Jan 24, 1871 The rebuke for gathering shows they had been commanded before the Red Sea, whether by tradition or written code, although no earlier record gives the Sabbath command to Israel.RH Apr 14, 1874RH Dec 10, 1857ST Mar 18, 1913 Spoken in the wilderness of Sin thirty days before the covenant made in Horeb on the fifteenth day of the third month, it rebukes breaking the Sabbath as refusing God's commandments and laws miraculously guarded in the giving of manna, not first made at Sinai or in Horeb.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Dec 9, 1851
God gave the manna to prove whether Israel would walk in His law, choosing the Sabbath to test loyalty, with manna falling six days and withheld on the seventh and double gathered on the sixth.STRH Mar 3, 1863ST Feb 11, 1913ST Jun 10, 1875ST Aug 18, 1909 The only reason given here for resting on the seventh day is that God had a law requiring it, declaring He had given them the Sabbath and therefore gave on the sixth day the bread of two days.ST Jun 10, 1875RH Oct 21, 1851ST Aug 16, 1910 The wilderness deliverance also represents God's people being tested before entering their inheritance, with refusal over the Sabbath stirred chiefly by the mixed multitude revealing disloyalty to God and to all His commandments.ST Oct 18, 1905 The command was renewed because unsettled wilderness life might seem an excuse, with Israel supposing in their unsettled state they were exempt, though the Sabbath enforced is the same day instituted when God finished creation and afterward commanded in the Decalogue.RH Dec 9, 1851ST May 17, 1883 Being made known at Sinai means declared from heaven and unfolded more fully and impressively, not first brought to knowledge, spoken in awful grandeur to impress importance and cause belief and obedience amidst thunderings, lightnings, quaking and trumpet.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Jul 14, 1874RH Jun 30, 1859RH Apr 21, 1868RH Aug 3, 1869 That later making known was public proclamation and writing designed not so much to give new information about duty as to fill Israel with awe and reverence for the Lawgiver and cause them to remember and do them.RH Jun 30, 1859RH Apr 21, 1868RH Aug 3, 1869
Israel had been unable to keep the Sabbath under rigorous Egyptian bondage and idolatry and had neglected it, and deliverance brought them where they could observe it and be tested.ST Aug 16, 1910RH Mar 1851ST Oct 24, 1900RH Oct 21, 1851ST Oct 21, 1897 Freedom meant opportunity and power to obey, with God specially enforcing observance after freeing them when they were able to keep it, bringing them out where they could serve Him into the wilderness where they could keep the test of service.ST Aug 16, 1910RH Mar 1851RH Oct 21, 1851ST Oct 21, 1897 Observance had been neglected during long servitude, and the manna's weekly pattern taught Sabbath observance before the law was spoken at Sinai and continued through the wilderness years.ST Aug 16, 1910ST Oct 24, 1900 Keeping the Sabbath as memorial of creation turned the people from Egypt's sun-worship toward the Creator, and Moses and Aaron pointed out duty and they attempted to keep it while Pharaoh hindered them and charged them with making the people rest from burdens.ST Oct 24, 1900ST Oct 21, 1897 The Sabbath is presented as an established familiar institution restored soon after release from slavery, not a new one.RH Mar 1851
The commandments and laws accountable before the Horeb covenant include the Sabbath later linked with the laws Abraham kept, observed before covenant-making began in Exodus 19 so it did not originate with that covenant and could continue after it was dissolved.RH Oct 21, 1851ST Aug 13, 1885 Abraham obeying God's voice, commandments and laws means he rested the seventh day, and patriarchs from earliest ages regarded what the Decalogue enjoins.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Jan 24, 1871RH Jun 3, 1862ST Oct 7, 1880RH Apr 21, 1874 The words How long prove these Sabbath laws had long been known in the most ancient church during patriarchal ages and were not new at Sinai, with the way of the Lord Abraham would command his children to keep including seventh-day rest as shown in the beginning.RH Jan 24, 1871RH Jun 3, 1862 Knowledge of the first Sabbath and the Creator's example could pass from Adam through only two lives, Methuselah and Shem, down to generations living in Abraham's days.RH Jan 24, 1871 Keeping His commandments and laws means resting on the seventh day, and the rebuke brought the people to rest on the seventh day which is the way to keep the Sabbath, so Abraham's keeping means he kept the Sabbath.RH Jun 3, 1862ST Oct 7, 1880RH Apr 21, 1874
Creation Origin and Wilderness Institution
The rebuked Sabbath originated at creation when God rested the seventh day and blessed, sanctified and hallowed it, and its origin and reason are found only in Genesis 1-2 and Exodus 20:8-11.ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jul 27, 1882RH Aug 6, 1872 It was not instituted in the wilderness, for the seventh-day Sabbath was already known when the rebuke was spoken, and the manna was withheld on that day because it was the Sabbath, not to make the day a Sabbath.ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880RH Apr 11, 1854RH Aug 6, 1872 The chapter gives no account of institution and does not explain why that day is the Sabbath, but recognizes and enforces an already existing Sabbath tied to God's rest after creation as Genesis 2 and the fourth commandment state.RH Apr 11, 1854ST Jul 27, 1882RH Aug 6, 1872 The Sabbath thus regulated the manna rather than the manna regulating the Sabbath, and the command is not a temporary institution limited to Israel or to Jews alone.ST Jun 10, 1880ST Jul 27, 1882
The absence of Sabbath mention in Genesis after Genesis 2 for more than twenty-five centuries does not prove it was not in force.ST Apr 26, 1883RH Apr 11, 1854RH Sep 19, 1854RH Jul 14, 1874ST Jun 28, 1883 The brief fifty-chapter record of 2500 years touches only great events and the important historical points, yet still includes the institution of the Sabbath at the beginning, the reckoning of time by weeks which could come from nothing but the institution of the Sabbath, the understanding of the principles of the moral law, and Abraham keeping God's statutes, commandments and laws.ST Apr 26, 1883RH Apr 11, 1854RH Jul 14, 1874 Silence in such a record can reflect how well known a practice was, and the long silence does not mean the Sabbath was unknown or unobserved but is evidence that it continued to be kept until Exodus.ST Jun 28, 1883RH Dec 11, 1856 The reproof coming thirty days before Israel saw Mount Sinai proves Israelites already understood the obligations of the Sabbath before Sinai, so the Sabbath of the fourth commandment did not begin at Sinai and is not a Jewish institution beginning there.ST Apr 26, 1883
Exodus 16 contains no institution of the Sabbath and no recorded act instituting it.RH Sep 19, 1854RH Nov 15, 1864RH Feb 3, 1852RH Sep 24, 1872RH Jan 21, 1875 The sixth day on which twice as much manna was gathered is the sixth day of the week, not a sixth day counted from the first fall of manna.RH Nov 15, 1864 The chapter contains no facts on which such an institution is based, no statement of its meaning and intent, and no reason assigned why it should be observed except that God had a law requiring it, without explaining why such a law was made or why it fixed on the seventh day.RH Nov 15, 1864RH Jan 21, 1875 Moses calls the coming day the Lord's holy Sabbath, treating it as already established, and the reproof for breaking it implies prior knowledge and continued refusal to keep existing commandments of which the Sabbath was the part chosen to test loyalty.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Sep 24, 1872 If a command is needed to complete the institution, it is given at Sinai, where permanent Sabbath legislation with its proper reasons was reserved for solemn proclamation when Israel became a holy nation, while the origin, blessing and sanctification rest on the different basis that God rested from creation on the seventh day and blessed and sanctified it, making the Sabbath a memorial of creation while the Passover was the memorial of deliverance from Egypt.RH Sep 19, 1854RH Sep 24, 1872RH Sep 24, 1872
Others taught the opposite, that the Sabbath was first mentioned, enjoined and instituted in the wilderness of Sin between Elim and Sinai as a Jewish ordinance later established with solemnity in the fourth commandment.ST Mar 13, 1879RH Apr 21, 1868RH Nov 12, 1872RH Jan 30, 1866 On this reckoning before this point there was neither command, precept, nor example for any man to set apart or have respect for any set day as sacred, after 2500 years with no Sabbath command to the patriarchs.RH Jan 30, 1866RH Dec 20, 1864 Exodus 16 was said to give no intimation that the Sabbath then appointed was only the revival of an ancient institution that had been neglected, forgotten or suspended, to impute no such neglect to the inhabitants of the old world or to any part of the family of Noah, and to record no permission to dispense with the institution during the captivity in Egypt or on any other public emergency. The first account of the Sabbath ever being kept was placed about twenty-five hundred years after creation and just seven days after Israel marched from Elim to Sin, seventy-five days after leaving Egypt with 600,000 adults besides children plus a mixed multitude and flocks and herds and very much cattle, and that march from Elim made on the seventh day by direction of the angel and cloud was taken to prove no obligation from creation had been laid on man, for God would not lead His only chosen ones to tramp with weary limb and burdened back on that day if He had bidden all men keep it holy.RH Dec 20, 1864 The Hebrew word for Sabbath in Exodus 16 having no definite article was urged as marking first mention under the rule that the article is wanting when an institution is instituted or mentioned for the first time, with the the in English called a mistranslation with no Hebrew basis.RH Nov 12, 1872
A related reckoning held that the first Sabbath there was calculated from the first day the manna fell without apparent reference to creation, counted from deliverance with the fifteenth spent marching.RH Jun 19, 1856RH Oct 31, 1871RH Jan 31, 1856RH Jun 19, 1856ST Jul 17, 1879 God rained bread from heaven on the fifteenth day of the second month after leaving Egypt to prove Israel whether they would walk in His law, giving flesh at evening and bread to the full in the morning, with gathering every morning for six days and twice as much on the sixth, and with the declaration that tomorrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord, that on the seventh day which is the Sabbath there shall be none, that the Lord had given them the Sabbath and therefore gave bread of two days on the sixth, commanding every man to abide in his place with no going out on the seventh, so the people rested on the seventh day.RH Jun 19, 1856 This was called the first recorded instance of formal observance of a day of rest by the descendants of Abraham, with the long journey from Elim to the wilderness of Sin on the day before the manna fell and on the fifteenth day of the second month showing they were not then keeping an established Sabbath.RH Jun 19, 1856RH Oct 31, 1871 Whether the day designated by the manna coincided in regular succession with the seventh day from the paradisaical week cannot be determined, but as the seventh after six days work in gathering the manna its observance was said to answer all the purposes for which the Sabbath was instituted, fully establishing the authority of the day selected at the Red Sea after about five weeks, the seventh after six days of manna and the first of its cessation being the fifth Sabbath in regular order after leaving the Red Sea, twenty-eight days or four even weeks from the seventeenth day of the first month.RH Oct 31, 1871RH Jun 19, 1856RH Dec 9, 1873
Another opposing claim held that the old seventh day from creation had been lost and a new substituted day set apart at the manna, with obligation beginning there and ending at the crucifixion.RH Sep 24, 1872ST Mar 21, 1878ST Apr 24, 1879ST Jun 5, 1879RH May 8, 1856 On this claim Israel counted its rests and holy days from the departure from Egypt, not from creation, and the Sabbath afterward observed was set apart one month after the exodus as a different day from the Sabbath of the Lord ordained in Paradise at the close of creation, with the patriarchal Sabbath falling the day after the Hebrew Sabbath.ST Mar 21, 1878ST Apr 24, 1879 The manna account was used to claim the Sabbath began as a memorial of the giving of manna, and that Christ the true bread from heaven fulfilled this type, with the Christian Sabbath taking the place of the Sabbath given to the Jews.ST Jun 5, 1879 Exodus 16 was thus set forward with Deuteronomy 5 and Nehemiah 9 as grounds for denying that the Sabbath was enjoined on man at creation and for setting aside the obvious meaning of Genesis 2:3 according to the order of events in Genesis 1-2.RH Sep 24, 1872
Against new-day claims it is held that the Jews recorded no change of day and had not noted any change of Sabbath day nor believed the command allowed a proportionate period of observance on a different day.RH Oct 29, 1872RH May 26, 1868ST May 20, 1875RH Jul 8, 1873 Conflicting claims about the same wilderness Sabbath leave the change theory self-condemned, some saying the first day of Eden wrongly called seventh in Genesis was changed to the seventh at the falling of the manna, others saying the day called seventh in Exodus was really the sixth changed at the passage of the Red Sea or before leaving Egypt, so that if there were evidence all would unite in presenting it.RH Jul 8, 1873 Counting two settings back leaves the day off the original seventh, and it must be set forward one day more to place it upon the original Sabbath, the Sabbath of the Lord, so God is not shown to have set the Sabbath back one day for the Jews and then set it forward again for Christians so that Sunday is the original seventh.ST May 20, 1875 The claim that the Exodus 16 mention made the weekly Sabbath definite by emphatic distinction over the yearly sabbaths fails, because the weekly Sabbath still wants the article long afterward, with no vestige of difference to put them in different categories.RH Oct 29, 1872
The prevailing teaching holds that the Sabbath was revived, restored, re-enacted and reintroduced about thirty days before Sinai after being largely forgotten, lost and trampled down under the hoof of slavery in Egypt, renewing the Eden Sabbath in expanded solemn form for mankind rather than revoking it.RH May 6, 1852ST Jun 26, 1879ST Feb 25, 1889RH Jun 11, 1857 Even if the order of the days of the week had been lost from Adam to Moses, God restored and made known the true seventh day in the days of Moses, commanding the people to keep the seventh day because He rested on it from the work of creation, pointing out the day by the weekly miracles of withholding manna on the seventh and preserving the portion gathered the day before, and rebuking refusal to keep His commandments and laws.ST Jun 26, 1879 This resurrection when Israel was free from Egypt to serve and worship God proves the Sabbath no merely ceremonial or transitory law, but born in Paradise at creation, recognized by the patriarchs from Noah onward as indicated by division of time into weeks, already having moral claims over the race as made for man before the covenant of Sinai gave it awful sanction and permanent establishment in the bosom of the Decalogue alongside the other unchangeable and eternal moral commandments, marking a reform on the seventh-day Sabbath at the close of the patriarchal dispensation and proving it binding all through that dispensation.ST Feb 25, 1889RH Jun 11, 1857
The first fall with double on the sixth and none on the seventh synchronized with the original creation week, proving the weekly period preserved from the beginning with no change at the exodus from first to seventh.RH Jun 2, 1851ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 25, 1889RH Aug 6, 1872ST May 1, 1879 God Himself pointed out the true seventh day by manna, each day a daily portion, on the sixth a double portion, on the seventh none, with what was gathered on the sixth kept good over the Sabbath, and by this threefold weekly miracle for forty years marked the true seventh, so whether knowledge had been preserved or not it was made certain and preserved thereafter through inspired men who blessed its observers and cursed its desecrators.RH Jun 2, 1851 Since holiness was never given to the first six days of creation they could not be profaned, and since nothing can be profaned that is not already holy, going out to gather on the seventh was the first profanation of the seventh and proves it already holy, already incorporated into law before Sinai, and the identical seventh in direct order from creation, with the commandment placing it as the seventh from creation and showing the order preserved to Sinai.ST May 20, 1897 This second definite fixing just after deliverance, with the sixth and seventh synchronizing with the same days of the original week and with Christ's recognition of the Jewish seventh, guarded the identity of the Sabbath blessed and sanctified at creation beyond reasonable doubt, confirming it remained the seventh of the original week and showing God's weeks ordained in the beginning remain unchanged, with no week beginning with God's seventh and ending with His sixth ever existing by His permission.ST Mar 25, 1889ST May 1, 1879
Sources