Galatians 3:2
This only would I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?
Translations
This only would I learn of you, Received you the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
This only would I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?
Webster Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
This only would I learn from you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?
this only do I wish to learn from you — by works of law the Spirit did ye receive, or by the hearing of faith?
This only I wish to learn of you, Have ye received the Spirit on the principle of works of law, or of [ the] report of faith?
This only, am I wishing to learn from you:—by works of law, received ye, the Spirit? or by a believed report?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
I would like to learn just one thing from you: Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law, or by hearing with faith?
I just want to learn this from you: Did you receive the Spirit by the works of the law, or by hearing of faith?
Give me an answer to this one question, Did the Spirit come to you through the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?
This only would I learne of you, Receiued ye the Spirit by the workes of the Lawe, or by the hearing of faith preached?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
This only would I learn of you: Did you receive the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?
Cross-references 20 of 50
- Galatians 2:16
Knowing that a man is not justified by the works of the law, but by the faith of Jesus Christ, even we have believed in Jesus Christ, that we might be justified by the faith of Christ, and not by the works of the law: for by the works of the law shall no flesh be justified.
Contrasts justification by faith in Christ with works of the law.
- Galatians 3:11
But that no man is justified by the law in the sight of God, it is evident: for, The just shall live by faith.
The righteous live by faith, not by justification through the law.
- Romans 4:13
For the promise, that he should be the heir of the world, was not to Abraham, or to his seed, through the law, but through the righteousness of faith.
Abraham’s inheritance promise came through faith, not the law.
- Galatians 3:24
Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.
The law is a schoolmaster bringing people to Christ and justification by faith.
- Acts 15:5
But there rose up certain of the sect of the Pharisees which believed, saying, That it was needful to circumcise them, and to command them to keep the law of Moses.
Believing Pharisees urged circumcision and observance of the law.
- Galatians 3:10
For as many as are of the works of the law are under the curse: for it is written, Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them.
Reliance on works of the law leaves people under the curse.
- Romans 3:20
Therefore by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight: for by the law is the knowledge of sin.
The law gives knowledge of sin, not justification.
- Galatians 3:6
Even as Abraham believed God, and it was accounted to him for righteousness.
Abraham was counted righteous through faith, just as the Spirit is received through faith.
- Romans 3:31
Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.
Faith establishes rather than makes void God’s law.
- Galatians 3:14
That the blessing of Abraham might come on the Gentiles through Jesus Christ; that we might receive the promise of the Spirit through faith.
The promised Spirit is received through faith.
- Genesis 15:6
And he believed in the LORD; and he counted it to him for righteousness.
Abraham’s belief was counted as righteousness, illustrating righteousness by faith.
- Ephesians 2:8-9
For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
Contrasts salvation by grace through faith with works.
- Romans 1:17
For therein is the righteousness of God revealed from faith to faith: as it is written, The just shall live by faith.
God’s righteousness is revealed in the gospel through faith.
- Galatians 3:22
But the scripture hath concluded all under sin, that the promise by faith of Jesus Christ might be given to them that believe.
All are under sin, so the promise is received by faith.
- Romans 10:4
For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth.
Christ is the law’s end for righteousness to everyone who believes.
- Romans 6:14-15
For sin shall not have dominion over you: for ye are not under the law, but under grace.
Grace frees from the law’s condemnation, not from obedience.
- Galatians 3:21
Is the law then against the promises of God? God forbid: for if there had been a law given which could have given life, verily righteousness should have been by the law.
God’s law is not contrary to his promise.
- Galatians 3:18
For if the inheritance be of the law, it is no more of promise: but God gave it to Abraham by promise.
The inheritance comes by promise, not by the law.
- Galatians 3:26
For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.
Faith in Christ makes believers children of God.
- Romans 4:11
And he received the sign of circumcision, a seal of the righteousness of the faith which he had yet being uncircumcised: that he might be the father of all them that believe, though they be not circumcised; that righteousness might be imputed unto them also:
Circumcision is a sign of righteousness received by faith.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
9 sources
Paul's single question presses the Galatians on how they received the Spirit, whether by works of law or by hearing with faith.CE 93.2AA 384.27MR 355.1–356.1FE 196.19MR 331.3 The answer is that the Spirit comes by hearing with faith, not by works of law.CE 93.2AA 384.27MR 355.1–356.1FE 196.1AA 207.2–208.1 Their own first Christian experience proves it, for they received the Spirit by hearing and believing the message of faith.AA 384.2AA 207.2–208.1AA 208.2–3 That experience confirms that the gospel brings the Spirit through faith in Christ.AA 384.2AA 207.2–208.1AA 208.2–3
What had been taught them was righteousness by faith in Christ's atoning sacrifice, not reliance on works of law, and through faith in Christ they became children of God.AA 207.2–208.1 After being converted through the doctrine of righteousness by faith, they were led into error by false teachers whose boasting and wonder-working powers blinded their spiritual eyesight.7MR 355.1–356.1Ms 43, 1907, par. 7–9 That turning was a removal from the grace of Christ unto another gospel.Ms 43, 1907, par. 7–9
The verse belongs to the controversy over the law in Galatians, a matter some addressed without fully understanding the issue and so took wrong positions, and those positions together with failure to cherish Christ's Spirit brought loss to the church.9MR 331.3 As a rebuke it calls them foolish and bewitched for not obeying the truth even though Jesus Christ crucified had been plainly set forth before their eyes.CE 93.27MR 355.1–356.1FE 196.1Ms 43, 1907, par. 7–9CE 94.1–2 It teaches that having begun in the Spirit they cannot be made perfect by the flesh.CE 93.27MR 355.1–356.1FE 196.1Ms 43, 1907, par. 7–9CE 94.1–2 God ministers the Spirit and works miracles among them by the hearing of faith.Ms 43, 1907, par. 7–9
It warns them lest they have suffered so many things in vain.CE 93.2FE 196.1 The same rebuke applies to believers today to whom the truth has been opened.CE 93.2FE 196.1CE 94.1–2 The glory of God's infinite truth grows the more it is contemplated, yet they allow themselves to be bewitched away from obeying it.FE 196.1 Those deceived are called to see their error, refuse the interpretations of apostate teachers, defeat evil, and come back to an intelligent, genuine experience of righteousness by faith in Jesus Christ.Ms 43, 1907, par. 7–9
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
45 sources
Paul rebukes the Galatians by appealing to their own experience after believing the gospel, having received the Spirit and seen the supply of the Spirit and miracles among them by believing what they heard and not by doing works of the law.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900RH May 22, 1900 The hearing of faith is hearing the testimony about God's Son and trusting in Him, when the Spirit enters the heart and bears witness there by experience.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 2, 1886RH Sep 23, 1858 Works of the law are all that unregenerate man can do in attempting to keep a spiritual law, an outward form with the heart unchanged that condemns the doer and leaves him under its curse.ST Dec 2, 1897 No one is justified by those works but only by faith, since fallen people cannot be justified by a holy law they have transgressed, yet the law still convicts of sin and drives sinners to Christ without being made void or abolished.RH Jan 1851RH Apr 24, 1900RH Jul 18, 1854RH Jul 18, 1854 The life begun in the Spirit by receiving the Spirit through faith must likewise be continued by faith and cannot be completed by the flesh or by human law-keeping.ST Sep 19, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868ST Sep 19, 1900ST Apr 18, 1911 True obedience does not earn the Spirit but follows because He has first come, as God works through the believer to bring forth the fruit of the Spirit in union with Christ.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Dec 2, 1897RH Mar 5, 1901
Historical Setting and Occasion
Paul's question is a rebuke for not obeying the truth, appealing to the Galatians' own experience after they had accepted the gospel, believed in Christ, and received the Spirit.ST Jan 25, 1899ST Nov 21, 1900RH May 22, 1900 Departure from the gospel is departure from God, and since God is the God of truth, departure from Him is disobedience to the truth.ST Jan 25, 1899 Their experience had come through faith in Christ and not through their own power, with Christ crucified vividly set before them in preaching, and with the supply of the Spirit, miracles, and rejoicing among them.ST Nov 21, 1900RH May 22, 1900 They had been redeemed from the curse of the law, received justification by faith which is the blessing of Abraham, and received the promise of the Spirit through faith, but had been bewitched by a false gospel of justification by works and driven back from the purity of faith to works, losing the blessedness they once had.RH May 22, 1900RH Aug 14, 1900
They were Gentiles who had not known God and had been in bondage to those which by nature are no gods, but heard the gospel and believed and were delivered from bondage.RH May 15, 1900 In this they received the adoption as sons of God, so that they were no more bondmen but sons and heirs of God through Christ.RH May 15, 1900 They first received the pure gospel by the Holy Spirit, but were later confused by professed believers in Jesus who knew nothing of true faith and the freedom Christ gives, who remained formalists and came with a perverted, counterfeit gospel which was not the gospel at all.RH May 15, 1900RH Aug 14, 1900 These turned them from faith to works and from the Spirit to the flesh as the means of justification and the hope of salvation, toward another way of salvation through formal or ceremonial observance.RH May 15, 1900RH Aug 14, 1900 To describe this as bringing them back to Jewish ritual is inaccurate in one respect, because as Gentile believers they had never observed that ritual.RH Aug 27, 1857
The false teaching was that except a man be circumcised after the manner of Moses he cannot be saved, presenting another, counterfeit gospel to those who had accepted the Gospel.ST Jan 25, 1899 Outward circumcision was given as a sign of righteousness already possessed by faith, a sign that the law was written in the heart by the Spirit, and is only mockery and sham when the law is transgressed.ST Jan 25, 1899 To be circumcised in order to be saved is to put trust in works of one's own and not in Christ.ST Jan 25, 1899 Their attachment to circumcision, whether in practice or belief, belonged to the former law-dispensation and was not common to the present gospel age, and their fault was not keeping the moral commandments but reliance on the law of circumcision rather than the hearing of faith.RH Oct 8, 1857 Although the specific rite of circumcision is no longer urged as necessary to salvation, the question whether the Spirit is received by works of the law or by the hearing of faith remains the vital question of salvation itself, whether by human works or by Christ alone.ST Jan 25, 1899
The verse begins Paul's examination and contrast of the covenants God made with His people, showing that justification by faith is the only hope of salvation for a church that had lost sight of it.RH Jan 1851 On one side stands the covenant with Abraham based on the righteousness of faith, securing the inheritance of the earth to him and his seed; on the other stands the law added 430 years afterward, whose principles existed from creation, made the condition of the covenant with literal Israel and making works of the law instead of the righteousness of faith the ground of heirship.RH Jan 1851RH Mar 4, 1873 In this argument the question whether the Spirit was received by doing the works of the law or by hearing with faith supports the distinction between the law and the promise received by faith, presenting the gospel and pardon as coming through faith in Christ for those who wanted to be under the law.RH May 23, 1854RH Mar 4, 1873 The law so added continued only until Christ came.RH Mar 4, 1873
The chapter develops the promise to Abraham as a promise received through faith, so that those who belong to Christ are Abraham's seed and heirs according to that promise.ST Apr 23, 1912 The faithful of earlier ages were likewise reconciled to God through faith in Christ as believers are now, sharing Abraham's faith, with salvation resting on Christ and not on the sacrifices of the first covenant.ST Jul 2, 1885 The gospel is one and unchanging, the same gospel of salvation, grace and peace preached beforehand to Abraham and afterward to the children of Israel.ST Jul 9, 1896 It reveals the righteousness of God as God's power unto salvation to everyone who believes, and the chapter agrees with Paul's teaching in Romans and is to be read alongside Galatians 5:14 as consistent with the continuing place of God's law.RH Dec 1850ST Jul 9, 1896
Meaning of Key Terms
Works of the law are all that unregenerate man can do by law in attempting to keep a spiritual law. ST Dec 2, 1897 They may preserve an outward form of truth and obedience while the heart remains unchanged, as with the Jews, but since being comes before doing and a man must be righteous before he can do righteousness, they cannot make a person righteous. ST Dec 2, 1897 They condemn the doer by the law itself and leave him under its curse, whereas Christ makes the believer righteous and gives him His Spirit so that resulting obedience is not works of the law but fruit of the Spirit and of union with Christ. ST Dec 2, 1897
On one understanding the law in question is the whole law-system or dispensation, not the Ten Commandments alone or any single part of that system. RH Oct 8, 1857 On another understanding the law that exposes and condemns sin and whose curse Christ redeems people from is the Ten Commandments, the moral law, not the Levitical law, because law cannot justify a sinner and people are justified by faith in Christ and not by doing what any law requires. ST Jul 25, 1911RH Jul 25, 1854 On still another understanding the law done away in view is the ceremonial law of circumcision, animal sacrifices and similar rites that pointed forward to Christ. ST Jan 3, 1878RH Jun 26, 1900 Attachment to circumcision in practice or belief belonged to the former law-dispensation and not to the present gospel age, and the fault rebuked was not keeping the moral commandments but reliance on the law of circumcision rather than the hearing of faith. RH Oct 8, 1857
Outward circumcision was given as a sign of righteousness already possessed by faith, a sign that the law was written in the heart by the Spirit, and becomes only mockery and sham when the law is transgressed. ST Jan 25, 1899 To be circumcised in order to be saved is to put trust in works of one's own and not in Christ, yet although that specific rite is no longer urged as necessary to salvation the question whether the Spirit is received by works of the law or by the hearing of faith remains the vital question of salvation itself, whether by human works or by Christ alone. ST Jan 25, 1899 Those ceremonies are now a dead letter of no binding force which no one declares necessary, so ceremonialism of that particular form no longer threatens anyone. RH Jun 26, 1900
The message means more than circumcision and sacrifices, for if it referred only to that past form of ceremonialism it would be dead and of value only as a record of old mistakes. RH Jun 26, 1900RH Jun 26, 1900 As God's word directed to every person in every age it warns against any ceremonialism by which righteousness is thought to be earned by works, whether by the ceremonial law, by the outward expression of love to God and man lived out by one's own efforts, or even by copying the acts of Christ in the law of the Spirit of life to make oneself like Christ. RH Jun 26, 1900RH Jun 26, 1900 All such attempts miss the true import of the law and become a dry round of outward forms and dead works, leaving the life Christless because Christ alone is salvation, and bringing falling from grace and under the curse. RH Jun 26, 1900
The hearing of faith means hearing and believing the gospel testimony about God's Son. ST Oct 3, 1906RH Sep 23, 1858 As a person trusts in the Son the Spirit enters the heart with that truth and begins to bear witness there, a witness known by experience. RH Sep 23, 1858 The Spirit and spiritual life come through faith, not through doing the law's works, relying on one's own deeds, or earning the Spirit by works, for works follow because the Spirit has first come into the heart and God then works through the believer, and the worker of miracles acts through the hearing of faith. ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 2, 1886 The law nevertheless convicts sinners of guilt and lack of spiritual life, driving them to Christ, and keeps believers close to Christ to prepare them for fuller life from God, while Abraham's obedience was likewise the obedience of faith and not a way to earn faith, since sinners can be made righteous only by believing God. ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 2, 1886
Spirit Received by Faith
The question puts two ways side by side, whether the Spirit was received by works of law or by hearing with faith, and the answer drawn from experience is that the Holy Spirit is received through faith in God and in Christ.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868RH May 22, 1900ST Nov 18, 1913 That reception does not come by doing works of law, by reliance on one's own deeds, by human effort, or through legal or moral precepts or theological beliefs.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868ST Nov 18, 1913RH Mar 5, 1901 The contrast sets faith in Christ against reliance on law-keeping and upholds the distinction between law and promise received by faith.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900ST Nov 18, 1913RH May 23, 1854
The same question points to the supply of the Spirit and to the working of miracles among believers.ST Sep 19, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900RH Jul 18, 1854 The worker of miracles acts through the hearing of faith, and miracles are done through faith rather than by law.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900RH Jul 18, 1854ST The Spirit's presence was evident in preaching that set Christ crucified vividly before hearers, and in miracles and rejoicing among them, showing that their experience came through faith in Christ and not through their own power.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900 This does not make the moral law invalid, for a holy and just law cannot justify one who has transgressed it but rightly holds the transgressor under condemnation, and its inability to justify the guilty is no argument against its justice or perpetuity.RH Jul 18, 1854ST Human works are imperfect and cannot make a person righteous.ST Oct 3, 1906ST
Received by faith, the Spirit descends silently and invisibly upon the praying sinner.ST Apr 18, 1911RH Mar 5, 1901 He takes away the old sinful nature and leaves the divine nature in its place, shedding abroad in the heart the love of God which alone can fulfill the law.ST Apr 18, 1911 So received, the Spirit gives power, indwells and energizes the whole person, and turns profession into practice.ST Apr 18, 1911RH Mar 5, 1901
The early experience of believing and receiving the Spirit was identical with Abraham's experience.ST Oct 3, 1906RH May 22, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900 Abraham's obedience was the obedience of faith and not a way to earn faith, and only those who so believe are blessed.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Dec 19, 1900 Those who believe have received the true gospel, believed in Christ, been redeemed from the curse of the law, received justification by faith which is the blessing of Abraham, and received the promise of the Spirit through faith.ST Oct 3, 1906RH May 22, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900 The question therefore exposes being bewitched by a false gospel of justification by works and being driven back from the purity of faith to works, losing the blessedness once had.RH May 22, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900
The verse is relevant to the claim that the Holy Spirit is received through faith.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Sep 19, 1900RH Aug 12, 1858 Yet that reception does not by itself settle whether baptism must precede pardon.RH Aug 12, 1858 Nor does the verse establish that the Spirit can be received only after justification.RH Aug 12, 1858
Justification and Law's Role
The question declares the single principle that no person is justified by works of law but only by faith, which is the only hope of salvation because all have sinned.RH Jan 1851RH Apr 24, 1900RH Jul 18, 1854RH Jun 26, 1900ST Jul 25, 1911 To make deeds of law the ground of justification would empty justification by faith, since fallen and guilty people cannot be justified by a law that condemns them.RH Jan 1851RH Apr 24, 1900 A holy and just law cannot justify one who has transgressed it, but rightly holds the transgressor under condemnation, and its inability to justify the guilty is no argument against its justice or perpetuity.RH Jul 18, 1854ST Jul 25, 1911 Receiving the Spirit belongs to this same contrast between faith and works, for the Spirit and the working of miracles come through faith and not through works of law, and keeping law cannot provide a separate way to salvation or replace reliance on Christ.RH Jul 18, 1854RH Jun 26, 1900RH Jul 18, 1854 The warning reaches beyond circumcision and sacrifices to every age and every form of ceremonialism that supposes righteousness can be earned by works, whether by outward expressions of love to God and man performed by one's own efforts or even by copying the acts of Christ in order to make oneself like Christ, all of which miss the true import of law, become a dry round of outward forms and dead works, leave life Christless because Christ alone is salvation, and bring falling from grace and under the curse.RH Jun 26, 1900
The law nevertheless has its appointed work, convicting sinners of guilt and of lack of spiritual life and driving them to Christ.ST Sep 2, 1886RH Jul 18, 1854 Under the Spirit's influence sinners see through the law that sin is exceedingly sinful, for the law is a perfect mirror and the Spirit is its great reflector, revealing a person's condition and need to obey and put away sin.RH Jul 23, 1857 That same law continues to keep believers close to Christ and to prepare them for fuller life from God, revealing the need for justification though it cannot free from guilt, so that where sin abounds grace abounds more.ST Sep 2, 1886
Deliverance from the curse or condemnation of law does not release people from obligation to law, for faith does not make law void.ST Sep 29, 1881RH Aug 5, 1852 The chapter concerns justification by faith and is no argument that law is abolished or that Christians should not keep it, since Christ took its curse upon himself and opened the way to mercy and salvation for those who believe.RH Jul 18, 1854RH Aug 5, 1852 To be under law means to be under its condemnation and not merely to be subject to it, and God's pardoning grace removes that condemnation without permitting sin, working instead to write God's law in the heart so that people live in harmony with it.ST Feb 20, 1912 Gentiles stand in the same relation to God's law as Jews and, like them, are condemned as its violators, which is direct evidence against the claim that law is not binding on Gentiles.ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 27, 1875 Freedom is received by faith, and when faith comes the believer is no longer in prison; faith does not make a thing true by believing it but lays hold of facts already accomplished, proving that freedom in Christ is already given to all and that anyone can have it by grasping it and walking at liberty.ST Apr 5, 1899
Continuing by Faith
The life that begins by receiving the Spirit through hearing with faith cannot be brought to completion by human effort, the flesh, or reliance on law-keeping, but must likewise be continued by faith.ST Sep 19, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868ST Sep 19, 1900 The Spirit is received through hearing and believing the gospel, not through deeds of the law, and the same hearing of faith brings the supply of the Spirit and the working of miracles among believers.ST Sep 19, 1900RH Jul 28, 1868 To begin in the Spirit by faith and then seek to be made complete or to carry the life forward by works and the flesh is a sudden change turning away from faith to law.ST Sep 19, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900 That early experience of believing and receiving the Spirit is identical with Abraham's experience, and only those who so believe are blessed.ST Dec 19, 1900
Works do not earn the Spirit but follow because the Spirit has first come into the heart, and God then works through the believer.ST Oct 3, 1906 Christ makes the believer righteous and gives His Spirit, and the resulting obedience is not works of the law but the fruit of the Spirit and of union with Christ.ST Oct 3, 1906ST Dec 2, 1897 Works of the law are unregenerate attempts to keep a spiritual law, preserving an outward form of obedience while the heart remains unchanged, and they cannot make a person righteous but leave him under the curse.ST Dec 2, 1897 Abraham's obedience was likewise the obedience of faith and not a way to earn faith, since people have sinned and can be made righteous only by believing God.ST Oct 3, 1906
The verse declares the one principle that a man is not justified by works of the law but by faith, and warns against ceremonialism in every age as thinking righteousness can be earned by works.RH Jun 26, 1900 That ceremonialism includes trusting in the ceremonial law of circumcision and sacrifices, trusting in the outward expression of love to God and man lived out by one's own efforts, and even copying the acts of Christ in the law of the Spirit of life to make oneself like Christ.RH Jun 26, 1900 All such attempts miss the true import of the law and become a dry round of outward forms and dead works, leaving the life Christless because Christ alone is salvation, and bringing falling from grace and under the curse.RH Jun 26, 1900 The gospel's way is faith and not human works, whereas in the apostasy that developed into the papacy works of the law were substituted for the law of faith and forgiveness was made chiefly dependent on priestly absolution rather than the individual's faith.RH Sep 4, 1900
The Spirit of God is received by faith and not by works of the law, descending silently and invisibly upon the praying sinner to take away the old sinful nature and leave the divine nature in its place.ST Apr 18, 1911 In that coming He sheds abroad in the heart the love of God which alone can fulfill the law.ST Apr 18, 1911 Having received the Spirit by faith, the believer is to go on by faith walking in the Spirit, and in that walk will not fulfill the lust of the flesh.ST Apr 18, 1911
Sources