The free grant to eat from every tree joined to the ban on the tree of knowledge of good and evil under certain death was the first half of the original law given to Adam, and that command, not the Ten Commandments, was the law whose transgression made humanity sinful and brought sin and death and made necessary another law for forgiveness, distinct from and two thousand years earlier than the Ten Commandments since every one of the ten could have been obeyed and this law still transgressed.RH Jan 31, 1854 The prohibition with death as penalty was a test of obedience under divine law, and the death imposed on Adam and the race shows the command belonged to the whole universal moral law, not a mere request or private regulation.RH Aug 3, 1876 God gave His heavenly moral law to Adam by commanding him in the garden, Adam knew its claims as part of the law governing humanity, and transgression brought loss of Paradise, curse on earth and reign of death, so that to transgress even its least part brings terrible loss though the sentence was only in proportion to the deed.ST Jan 17, 1911RH Aug 20, 1872ST Sep 22, 1909
That command was God's moral law existing before the ceremonial law was added, giving free access to every tree except one with death in the day of eating and continued life while obedient, whose transgression made men condemned sinners necessitating Christ's death and the added second law of sacrifices, priests, altar, temple and support shadowing Him till He should come.RH Apr 15, 1873 The moral law was already present in Eden before the ceremonial system arose after the fall, beginning with few precepts and later growing through further instruction while remaining distinct from the ceremonial law.ST May 20, 1875 Righteousness is active conformity to moral law established by the Creator in harmony with the nature and relations of Creator and moral subjects, character being developed by activities, trials and tests, obedience as His expressed will being the condition for continuance forever of the life given to the race, and the Eden commands were not less than nor essentially different from the ten holy, perfect and good precepts later formally given as the perpetual rule.RH Aug 3, 1876
God gave Adam a law as part of a covenant of works binding Adam and all descendants to complete, exact, lifelong obedience, promising life for obedience and threatening death for disobedience while giving ability to obey.RH Jan 1, 1861 That covenant of works bound Adam and all posterity to personal, exact, entire and perpetual obedience including remembering the seventh day of every week and no other, with free permission to eat of every tree joined to prohibition of one tree paralleling free permission to labor six days joined to required rest of the seventh, so that substituting another day is as impossible as substituting another tree, labor on the six days being as innocent in itself as prayer and as eating of the permitted trees as a natural and inalienable right accepted by Adam as a free moral agent, while eating the forbidden fruit and violating the seventh-day rest bring guilt and the curse on all men at birth unless redeemed by Christ, that law continuing after the fall as a perfect rule of righteousness delivered on Mount Sinai in the Ten Commandments so that the fourth commandment and the Sabbath law of the covenant of works are one and the same law binding believers now as a rule of life, finished in Adam nearly six thousand years ago and written on the heart as requiring no other holy day.ST Aug 1, 1878 The positive provision of perpetual life was clearly set before Adam under the everlasting covenant previously perfected between Father and Son, free permission being part of the one moral test of obedience by which sin could be known and condemnation follow, which Adam accepted with full understanding of stipulations for continuing Edenic life or subjection to death, his standing resting on the covenant already ratified and sealed by the promise of Christ's offered blood to be given in due time for redemption.RH Apr 1, 1915
God made a covenant with Adam in Eden lying at the foundation of the whole plan of redemption which Adam transgressed, this command belonging to the original covenant whose condition was obedience for life.ST Jan 25, 1905ST Jul 7, 1914 Adam's life in Eden was subject to God's law with life conditional on obedience, perfect obedience being the condition of eternal life rather than a bargain excluding grace or Christ, and after the fall life is offered through Christ whose obedience makes righteous, with accepting Him meaning choosing God's way of obedience. Adam was placed in Paradise under a test where obedience to God's law was the condition of remaining righteous and being justified by obedience, so that had he obeyed through probation he would have been justified and Christ would not have needed to die, while after sin obedience can no longer justify because future keeping cannot atone for past transgression.RH Mar 24, 1859RH Apr 14, 1859
Before the fall eternal life could be secured by simple obedience without faith in Christ as Saviour and without needing a Saviour, free permission including the tree of life joined to the prohibition making death depend only on eating the forbidden fruit, proving a kept law gives life in itself and one who always keeps divine law is justified by works and not by faith, since as long as he kept eating of the permitted trees he would not die, so delaying disobedience for a thousand years would delay death for a thousand years and never disobeying would mean never dying.RH Mar 17, 1874 Adam was placed under perfect obedience and the same perfect obedience is required today, unblemished righteousness now obtainable only through Christ's imputed righteousness and God's provision for forgiveness and restoration by which Eden's requirement can still be fulfilled, for the law is unchangeable and stands as firm as the throne of Jehovah and conforming to His standard is the only way to gain admittance into heaven, contrary to Satan's claim that God has abrogated His law and that belief alone is enough.RH Sep 3, 1901RH Sep 24, 1901 Adam was given a command with ability to obey before the fall, distinct from gospel provisions to Christians, Adam and the patriarchs having the gospel only in embryo while Christians have it in demonstration and fact.RH May 12, 1859
The command concerning the tree was held by some to be primary law but positive rather than moral, resting exclusively on God's will with no moral reason, demonstrating that a primary law can be positive rather than moral so that even if all the Ten Commandments are primary it does not follow that the Sabbath is moral, and that a moral law can be abolished while its principle remains.RH Mar 4, 1873RH Feb 4, 1873 Against this, the weight holds that it tested obedience through a positive command about what was otherwise available, obeying God's authority being itself a moral duty, so once God commands an otherwise indifferent act it is no longer indifferent and neglect is disobedience.RH Apr 4, 1865 The specific test about the trees was not the whole moral law nor the present test of character, and describing the law as merely a rule about eating apples misses the point.RH Jun 30, 1859
The prohibition was not the moral law itself but a test of obedience to it, requiring placing no other authority above God, not coveting and not stealing, violating the first, tenth and eighth commandments, while obedience to it did not replace broader moral duties to God and others taught for perfect character.RH May 12, 1859 The transgression was not merely violation of a positive rule but involved moral principles with no prior transgression, violating the first and eighth commandments, while the duty to work in the garden was also moral duty, and the inherited dying condition shows the consequence, the nature of the tree being explained no further than the brief statements in Genesis.RH Aug 6, 1857 Eating the forbidden fruit violated the principles of nine of the Ten Commandments including coveting, false witness, stealing, adultery, murder, dishonoring God as Father, disregarding His name, idolatry and putting another master before God, while the Sabbath was not involved in the act itself but had been given as a separate command, showing God's law known and binding before Sinai.ST Dec 11, 1884 The express grant of food within obedience with the next verse's restriction tested loyalty and disobedience violated principles of nine of the Ten Commandments with the Sabbath separately given, so disobedience was not merely test failure separate from moral law but also violated Decalogue commands, and together with the prohibition the verse shows eating from the tree of knowledge would transgress at least the eighth and tenth commandments, while apart from that command Adam needed no further written law because principles of moral law were inherent in his originally perfect nature.ST Dec 11, 1884RH Jun 30, 1859ST Jan 11, 1916RH Apr 9, 1857
Read with the following command and Eve's account in Genesis 3:3, Adam recognized God's supreme authority and obligation to obey, expressing the first and great commandment comprising the principle of the first four of the Ten Commandments.ST Apr 13, 1915 God gave newly created man and woman in His image in harmony with His spiritual law only one prohibition to test love because untested love is weak, love not envying or seeking its own so cannot take what belongs to another, and partaking was the first ungodlike act transgressing love's law which was as broad then as ever because His infinite character was the same.ST Nov 20, 1901 The tree of knowledge was placed as a pledge and test of obedience, love, loyalty, trust and faith to prove sincere filial love and whether humanity would respect what God withheld as well as gave, freely given with bounty wisely adapted to wants with only one prohibition, retaining inexpressibly happy estate upon condition of obedience just as with holy angels, with Satan limited to only that tree and unable to harm while they obeyed but gaining power to annoy, perplex and trouble if they disobeyed.ST Jan 16, 1879ST Feb 18, 1913ST Mar 10, 1898
The law God gave in Eden commanding obedience with definite penalty warns that the wages of sin is death, God's retributive justice never fails, He exacts strict regard for His commandments, and the penalty is as definite and sure as when law was proclaimed at Sinai, as seen in the temptation, fall and punishment afterward.ST May 31, 1910 The command was a loyalty test whose disregard was transgression and sin, showing the law defining sin already existed when Adam fell, namely the moral law of the Ten Commandments.ST Feb 8, 1905 The breach was infinite because of the majesty, holiness, perfection and absolute unchangeableness of the law broken, so only the life of the Son of God was sufficient to heal the breach and restore man to his Maker.ST Sep 22, 1909 The death of Christ testifies in trumpet-tones that the law of Jehovah is immutable, divine and unalterable and could not be abolished or even altered or modified, which is why His death became necessary.ST Sep 22, 1909 Since the Sabbath is an inseparable part of that same holy, infinite, moral and immutable law, His cross proclaims the Sabbath fixed and man under perpetual obligation to keep it in letter and in spirit, and the shedding of His blood ratifies the everlasting new covenant that puts the Sabbath law along with the whole law into the heart.ST Sep 22, 1909
The reliability of the creation record in which the verse stands supports the fourth commandment, for if the first two chapters are untrue the commandments lose their claim to come from God and the whole system of morality and religion depends on the creation record being correct, the verse being part of the creation history comprehended by the fourth commandment belonging to the record conveying knowledge of God as Creator.ST Jul 28, 1881RH Sep 30, 1852 The specific command about the garden's fruit was given to Adam and Eve alone, consisting in eating permitted fruit and refraining from forbidden fruit, and was not a command to keep the Sabbath, so the verse does not establish this garden command as the present condition of God's promises.RH May 12, 1859 It was argued by opponents that the verse commands Adam not to know good or evil by not eating, and since the Sabbath is a moral institution involving good or evil Adam's observance of it before sin would have violated God's law and itself caused all sin and misery, precluding dating the Sabbath from creation.ST Mar 10, 1887
Faithfulness to the specific command stood for obedience in everything with obedience leading to eternal life and disobedience to death, and when they accepted the serpent's contradiction they chose falsehood over truth and woe came upon the world, while Satan has ever since persuaded men God's requirements are faulty with no dire results following rejection, seen where Christian nations observe Sunday instead of the Sabbath and alter the law from the form in which God gave it.ST Oct 8, 1894ST Sep 24, 1912 Disregard of the Eden command brought terrible consequences as a warning against rejecting God's commandments, with the Sabbath as the present-day test of obedience, the same test now placed on humanity by bringing the Sabbath as memorial of creative power testifying He made the world in six days and rested the seventh, so that disregarding the Sabbath repeats Eden's disregard, barring men from using it for their own pleasure as the fruit was barred.ST Jun 18, 1894ST Sep 3, 1912ST Aug 29, 1895 The verse is a specific exact command requiring implicit obedience with no leeway for substitution of another resembling or more convenient tree, and likewise those who substitute Sunday for the seventh-day Sabbath blessed, sanctified and hallowed to memorialize completed creation cannot be justified.RH Sep 16, 1915 The prohibition was not enforced by visible barrier but left to free choice, and a specific divine requirement tests loyalty and worship, just as keeping the seventh day tests loyalty today against man's first day and Satan's false sabbath and Sunday laws, and as in Eden possession of the heavenly Canaan depends wholly on implicit obedience.ST Jul 21, 1914
God placed a prohibition on use of a garden tree to test and train people and teach reverence for His law, compared with a claimed restriction on Sunday use while distinguishing Sunday from God's Sabbath, in contrast to the Sunday prohibition imposed as a test by human authority rather than God's Sabbath command.STST Feb 15, 1910 The forbidden tree was the Lord's reserved portion and mark of ownership and the original test of obedience, so taking it brought death just as taking the tithe now brings eternal ruin and death, and salvation requires returning to unfallen obedience and acknowledging God's ownership.RH Oct 28, 1915 The reservation was an act of care rather than arbitrary, testing respect for God's right and wisdom with passing necessary before entrustment with immortality and eternal riches, while reaching for the reserved thing revealed covetousness, selfishness, greed and unfitness for perpetual life, dominion and God's kingdom, exposing greed opposed to the unselfish character required for life in God's kingdom.ST Aug 8, 1916
God reserved the tree of knowledge as a lasting reminder that all things belong to Him, an arrangement made by Jesus Christ, and faithfully setting aside one tenth likewise acknowledges His ownership, the reserved tree before sin being contrasted with the tenth of produce claimed after sin and removal from Eden.RH Mar 31, 1903 God freely bestowed every tree while reserving one as holy to Himself, establishing His sovereign right to bestow and withhold, with the same test continuing in the seventh day and the tithe which man has no more right to use as he pleases than Adam had to eat the forbidden tree, and failure there is the line of apostasy in all ages on which Satan leads the world away from God.RH Mar 23, 1905 God freely gave enjoyment of His Eden bounties, every tree pleasant and good for food, with one exception reserved by Him as constant reminder of His ownership giving opportunity to demonstrate faithfulness, trust and perfect obedience, corresponding to the tithe people may not use, devoted to a specific purpose to support those carrying salvation, the nine tenths freely used corresponding to free permission while the reserved tree corresponds to the tithe, taking it being appropriating what did not belong to them and transgressing Thou shalt not steal, the same standard of loyalty still deciding whether God's people can regain the kingdom.RH Nov 5, 1901RH Apr 8, 1902RH Aug 10, 1905
The Lord as owner of the earth freely gave every tree while reserving one to Himself, the same act as still reserving a tenth of increase as holy, taking what He reserved being robbing God, and withholding the tenth denying His possessions and even His existence.ST Jan 22, 1902 God gave the abundance of Eden while reserving the tree of knowledge as His own, the restriction testing loyalty and appreciation of His goodness, and together with the Sabbath the reserved tree reminded them that time and possessions belonged to God as gifts from Him. As God gave use of all trees save one reserved tree, so He has given six days for common labor but put His sanctity on the seventh day to be sacredly observed as holy memorial of creation, God giving Adam free use of every tree as part of absolute dominion over earth and all in it, reserving only the tree of knowledge and the use of the Sabbath day to Himself.ST Mar 31, 1898RH Feb 9, 1905
God's law is as sacred as Himself requiring implicit obedience in heaven and earth, with the happy estate of Adam and holy angels retained only on condition of obedience, the divine word to be treated as sacred and commands obeyed implicitly, the single restriction leaving Adam without provision or excuse.ST Jan 16, 1879 God gave Adam a command and Adam understood God's prohibitions so acting contrary to God's will was sin and living in harmony with it was righteousness, God teaching what was needed and the command expressing God's eternal law though the commandments were not given on stone tablets until Moses' time.ST God gave Adam a moral command in Eden while allowing freedom of choice, the law given for humanity's good requiring obedience, and the garden command placed human life under God's authority as life entrusted by God rather than man's to use as he pleased, to remain in keeping while used to reveal and glorify God and forfeited by wrongdoing.RH Dec 15, 1868
Adam's needs were fully supplied and obeying the limit taught respect for God's authority and others' rights, while eating the forbidden tree would express selfishness and begin transgression.ST Apr 13, 1904 God placed humanity on probation testing loyalty, people not made beyond power of disobedience, and enduring would lead to eternal security, God's favor, fellowship with angels and equality with angels.ST Jan 9, 1879RH Feb 8, 1915 The reserved tree marked the Creator's sovereignty and the test of obedience, life depending on harmony with God's law, God freely giving every tree reserving only one thing leaving no unmet need requiring forbidden eating, the command asking only to refrain from one act amid abundance with death clear in the adjoining warning.ST Sep 24, 1912ST Oct 19, 1915 God placed humanity on probation testing loyalty with free permission to eat from every garden tree, this provision contrasting with later foods and substances introduced to gratify appetite rather than glorify God and supporting setting those things aside.RH Jan 22, 1867 God gave permission to eat while commanding not to disobey with a clear understood command setting the one forbidden tree against the eatable trees, disobedience bringing threatened death and rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality, God's command not a matter of indifference but to be obeyed even when disobedience is made appealing.ST Dec 13, 1883RH Sep 20, 1864
Diet Health and Provision
The free permission to eat from every tree, together with the trees being described as good for food, shows fruit was part of the original diet, and combined with the provision of seeds and herbs it identifies fruits, grains, and nuts as that diet, in contrast with the green herbs assigned to other creatures.ST Aug 31, 1915ST May 25, 1915 Together with the following verse it shows the first human diet was the garden's plant foods of grains, vegetables, and fruits and did not include flesh-meat.RH Mar 12, 1867 The command reflects the original design for food as free access to health- and strength-giving garden fruit, with humanity to subsist largely on fruit and plant food rather than flesh, with no death in Eden and no permission for animal food until after the flood.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Apr 2, 1914RH Jul 18, 1907RH Mar 21, 1912
It freely gave every tree except one for food, so Eden's diet was what grows from the ground with no animal flesh, for it was never the design that any creature's life be taken for human sustenance.RH Aug 15, 1871 Death in man or beast came in consequence of sin, making flesh-eating the fruit of transgression, and for 1656 years diet remained the green herb with no permission in the Sacred Record to use flesh for food until after the flood.RH Aug 15, 1871 Then Noah, shut in the ark one year and ten days with provisions running low and the desolated earth able to afford nothing until seed preserved in the ark could grow, was permitted flesh as a matter of necessity until the earth should bring forth again the proper food for man.RH Aug 15, 1871 The free permission to eat is the heaven-appointed bill of fare of fruits, cereals, legumes, vegetables, and other simple products lacking no needed food element and supplying the body directly and safely rather than second-hand through animals with impurities and disease.ST Mar 17, 1909
Freedom to eat the garden's fruit establishes fruit as food created for people and the original best-adapted choice, with grains and nuts also suited to human needs, set apart by God's word and prayer to be received with thanksgiving.RH Apr 21, 1904 The verse gives the first great hygienic rule for health and well-being defining the human diet, granting free permission for every garden tree except one, making food the wonderful variety growing out of the ground and excluding animal flesh such as beef, pork, mutton, chicken, turkey, goose, and duck.RH Aug 15, 1871 The meat appointed here means food in general, not animal food.RH Aug 15, 1871 Together with the provisions of seeds and herbs and the prohibition it shows diet instructions for what is good and fit to eat and what is not fit and must not be eaten.RH Jun 19, 1900
Had Adam, Eve, and posterity conformed to those instructions disease and death would never have entered, but instructions were disregarded by substituting and adding unfit things, for nearly six thousand years the family has paid little attention, so death is now in food all over the world.RH Jun 19, 1900 The permission applies to fruits, grains, and vegetables provided as suitable foods, especially when simply and healthfully prepared.ST Aug 13, 1894 The fruits of the garden trees were provided to meet human needs, and Eden's trees served both usefulness and beauty, while tending creation was intended to bring happiness.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Jul 25, 1871
Simple natural food was provided in harmony with nature's laws with few wants and abundant supply, while selfishness and unnatural perverted appetite bring excess, want, sin, and misery.ST May 7, 1912ST Aug 12, 1897 Departing from the provided food marred the home and would have prevented much misery, showing indulgence of appetite can demoralize and violation of health laws brings disease, degeneracy, and removal of the prospering hand.RH Apr 2, 1914ST May 5, 1914 Abstinence was taught in Eden where life depended on abstaining from one tree and eating meant dying, with appetite as the means of temptation through fruit appearing pleasant and desirable.RH Feb 24, 1874RH Mar 19, 1867
The definite command about the tree teaches strict temperance as later taught in abstinence from wine and strong drink for tabernacle service, to preserve clear judgment and faithful obedience, since success through appetite came by tempting and intemperance weakens physical, mental, and moral powers until right and wrong are confused.ST Jul 1, 1880 The first prohibition teaches appetite was to remain subordinate to moral and intellectual powers, a blessing when controlled but a degrading master when uncontrolled.ST Apr 15, 1875 The Eden command made appetite a test of obedience that is repeated after the Fall, with unrestricted appetite becoming a grave source of sin and suffering.ST Apr 15, 1875
Abstaining from the desirable forbidden fruit because it was prohibited would have let moral judgment and higher faculties rule appetite, strengthening character, happiness, and habit of virtue with each victory.RH Sep 18, 1860 When eating occurred, appetite, a lower faculty, overturned the proper order in which moral powers were to govern the other faculties, and pursuit of other wisdom showed true wisdom was to fear God and fully obey Him.RH Feb 26, 1867RH Jan 1, 1861 The test in Eden concerned appetite and desire for unlawful knowledge, and yielding to appetite was a way they were overcome.RH Oct 11, 1906
Abundant food and variety was given, permitting eating from every garden tree except the forbidden one, and Eve did not need that fruit, but desire for one more variety made her susceptible to the claim of a higher happier life, so her reason gave way to appetite, with uncontrolled appetite leading to the fall.ST Apr 15, 1875 Free access to every garden tree for food made the one forbidden tree a superfluity not needed for true comfort or life, and eating from it was intemperate indulgence in an unnecessary thing, with the sorrow following indulgence warning for all time against superfluous eating and drinking and all reaching after unnecessary and injurious enjoyment.ST Jan 13, 1881 Every tree was freely given for food but one thing was wisely withheld for good, and the first wrong eating set the pattern for leading men to partake of alcohol, tea, coffee, tobacco, pepper, mustard, and other inferior unsuitable materials by which human temples are defiled and made to decay, explaining racial degeneracy.RH Aug 3, 1911
Human senses and experience cannot be trusted as a guide in choosing food and drink, since conclusions from experience opposing God's word are unreliable and God's word is the infallible guide.ST Jan 18, 1916 Food from Eden trees given before sin shows eating daily food to sustain physical life belongs to sinless perfect existence and is not a weakness to be outgrown, since even sinless Adam needed food, so no spiritual progress can bring people to live without food.RH Mar 26, 1914 Humanity began in Eden under conditions intended to favor righteousness, with a suitable diet, yet those favorable conditions did not prevent sin, so knowledge and healthful living alone cannot free a sinner from sin.RH Nov 2, 1905
Provision of simple rest and simple food far from habitations teaches return to natural provisions and rebukes food for perverted appetite, while men are still led to partake of the prohibited tree of knowledge.ST Aug 12, 1897 Trust in God's Word was given as the way to meet temptation and overcome, the same means used in weakened humanity in the wilderness with It is written, and the same instruction given to each soul since.ST Jun 16, 1898 The command at creation provided for human life, connecting obedience to God's laws with freedom from sickness and preservation of life.RH Feb 20, 1872
In the Eden home lavish provision gave free permission for every tree including every food-bearing tree and the tree of life by which the race could live forever, with dominion over every living creature, the grant covering all trees with only one forbidden exception not even to be touched if exaltation would be kept. With continued faithfulness blessing, direct companionship, and privilege of bringing forth children to share blessings would remain. Adam and Eve were put in the garden and freely given all privileges needed for comfort and happiness including the best food from every tree, while obedience was tested centering on the tree of knowledge.RH Apr 27, 1905
Eden was their home with what they needed for happiness and fellowship with God, and disobedience led to being driven from that home.ST Mar 30, 1904 Love in provision for comfort and happiness freely gave of every tree of the garden, together with the family relation and the Sabbath as means to that end.ST Nov 23, 1904 Life, home, companion, and the garden were gifts calling for gratitude and love toward God.ST Nov 14, 1892 Placing in Eden permitted eating from the garden's trees including the tree of life, with human life in the garden including real physical food.RH Apr 4, 1871 Life was given to continue on condition of loyalty to government, and the promise failed when man listened to the deceiver.ST Feb 23, 1915 A command governing what could be eaten was given, and the following prohibition made disobedience a rejection of that command.RH Feb 26, 1867
Redemption Restoration and Application
Man created in the divine image as a free moral agent with dominion over all the earth was placed on probation to test fidelity to that enormous responsibility, and the free permission to eat of every tree with the single prohibition was the test of obedience to holy law, but overcome by wiles he disobeyed and ate, and that transgression being sin whose wages is death left humanity with all its endowments completely lost, sold into Satan's hands and needing the Son of man who made him to come to seek and save and restore all to original Edenic purity.ST Mar 11, 1897 The verse belongs to the Eden account before the fall showing the first plan, where Adam was created in the divine image upright in body, mind, and soul, and this original life reveals the gospel and helps understand power in Christ, so its truths are to be lived in restoring the divine image in humanity. God's free gift of every garden tree for food was a command testing whether Adam would be obedient or disobedient, for man was created for divine glory with purpose to repopulate heaven with the human race if after test and trial they proved loyal, with thoughts as God's thoughts and character moulded after the divine similitude had he stood, but he did not endure, forgot the warnings, believed Satan the enemy, and with Eve fell into sin.ST May 29, 1901
God did everything to prevent sin by giving all that heart could really wish, leaving no desire unsatisfied and therefore no excuse for illegal satisfaction, surrounding man with every inducement to remain true and loyal and obedient, giving His law as a safeguard around him, creating him pure and noble with no tendency or bias to evil, since it was never His purpose that man should be sinful.RH Jun 4, 1901RH Sep 24, 1901ST Aug 11, 1909 Together with the next verse it was the very first command, a prohibition against sinning, proving that character is the purpose of creation and redemption, without which the Word, the Gospel, and the infinite gift of the Son would have no meaning or significance.ST Mar 5, 1902 The express command left Adam and Eve, come from God's hand without sin or taint of evil, free to choose good or evil, and they could have kept innocence by living by every word from God's mouth and refusing the strange voice telling a different story, but they abused high and holy privileges and chose evil by believing Satan's lie and disobeying, so what was pure and godlike became perverted and defiled, and Christ came as propitiation living a perfect human life to elevate humanity and restore what was lost.ST Aug 26, 1897
The divine Son gave blessed and precious precepts in the beginning, and transgression brought woe and ruin upon a lost world, and the verse means what Christ clothed in human flesh came to live among men to show by action and what He explained in His first teachings to show what observing and obeying the law means.ST Adam stood in innocence in Eden with unfallen human nature, and for the Son to take even that innocent nature would have been almost infinite humiliation, yet He did not take it but accepted humanity as weakened and defiled by four thousand years of sin, accepting like every child of Adam the results of the great law of heredity as shown in His earthly ancestors, to share sorrows and temptations and give example of a sinless life, coming as a helpless babe subject to weakness into a world where Satan claimed dominion to meet life's peril in common with every soul and fight as every child of humanity must at risk of failure and eternal loss.ST Dec 9, 1913 In Eden before the fall humanity lived in harmony with God receiving life from Him, meant to pass on life to other creatures through love and unselfish giving.ST Dec 23, 1903
The earth was made as humanity's home according to the original purpose that it be inhabited, and sin's curse did not cancel that purpose, for God will fulfill it with a people who are all righteous.ST Sep 4, 1893 The verse is part of the eternal unchangeable purpose that this earth with all its contents in beautiful original perfection, including free provision from every tree, should be the eternal possession and everlasting inheritance of a holy, happy, immortal race, and though accomplishment was long delayed by sin it will finally be carried out in fullness because God does not change or suffer His plans to be thwarted, but will make all things new so that all lost in Adam is regained in Christ.ST Mar 18, 1903 In the beginning man possessed the right to eat of the tree of life belonging to his perfect condition before sin, together with a body made in God's image, direct communion with God, dominion over the whole earth in its perfect condition, and vigor and intellectual power but little less than angels, and this is the possession in the first phase of redemption owned at first, then lost through sin, then to be regained by being repurchased by Christ.ST Sep 12, 1900 It is a precautionary warning not to commit sin in order to preserve man in the upright and very good state in which he was first created, showing God's purpose in creating the earth to be inhabited was that it be the home of righteous human beings, not disembodied spirits.ST Mar 26, 1902
The verse belongs to the description of earth's original perfection in Eden, and the earth made new will be like that paradise God planted in the beginning.RH Jun 15, 1916 Eden was Adam and Eve's home where they had what they needed for happiness and fellowship with God, and their disobedience drove them from that home, while Christ left His heavenly home and accepted poverty to make it possible for people to have a home with Him.ST Mar 30, 1904 The garden command presents a test of character, for had Adam and Eve stood the trial they would have received the earth as an eternal possession free from sin and curse, but their failure brought consequences upon all descendants.RH Jun 27, 1907 It placed them under obedient submission, the same condition of salvation placed upon every human being to obey God's law and wear Christ's yoke with submission, and disobedience when tempted caused the fall.ST Jul 22, 1897
Adam at first possessed eternal life by creation as God's life operating in harmony with law, held by faith while believing and yielding to its righteous claims with God's life working normally in him, but turning from the law he lost it and became dying, and the same life is offered again by regeneration through faith accepting Jesus alone, held only by faith until character is perfected under test and possessed absolutely.ST Aug 27, 1896 The permission to eat freely from every tree is contrasted with later foods and substances introduced to gratify appetite rather than glorify God, supporting setting those things aside and living to honor God.RH Jan 22, 1867 Adam had to trust God's word about good and evil and believe eating from the tree of knowledge was wrong, and even sinless man had to develop perfect character by implicit faith, for such trust brings acquaintance with God, knowledge that He can be depended upon, genuine love and delight in His will, while refusing to believe makes pleasing Him impossible and brings sad disaster.ST Sep 23, 1889ST Feb 4, 1913
When God made man upright, innocent, and virtuous with His law in the heart, He gave in the paradise home free use of the tree of life and every tree except one as part of every blessing making life desirable while man ruled over all the earth in subjection to God and kept the Sabbath commemorating creation.RH May 12, 1874 The free permission including the tree of life was a good gift by which obedience would have allowed living forever, yet man was made to believe superior good lay in disobeying by eating the tree of knowledge though warned disobedience would bring certain death, and the choice proved a fatal mistake.RH May 12, 1874 God placed man in Eden with free permission joined to warning that disobedient eating would bring death as penalty for transgression of holy, just, and good law to be finally inflicted even in the second death, for death is an enemy, curse, and fruit of sin, not birth into higher life, and He gave a command in a place of purity, communion, and glorious earthly future where man could have remained had he obeyed, reserving the tree as test of fitness to remain, so that continued stay depended on obedience and love, lost through disobedience and driven from the garden, but restorable through Christ with obedience conditioning return to Eden and access to the tree of life in the everlasting kingdom.ST Aug 21, 1879ST Feb 24, 1887RH Mar 30, 1911ST Aug 10, 1915
God gave a command concerning the garden's trees whose disobedience opened the floodgates of woe, teaching His requirements are to be obeyed whatever the cost, and life depended on faithful obedience to His wholesome laws from which Satan's denial departed, for permission joined to command not to disobey led upon disobedience to rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jun 20, 1907RH Sep 20, 1864 God gave a clear understood command setting the one forbidden tree against the eatable trees, and disobedience brought the threatened death, teaching His command is not a matter of indifference but must be obeyed even when disobedience is made appealing.ST Dec 13, 1883 God gave a test concerning appetite and desire for unlawful knowledge by which yielding to appetite they were overcome, and the command presented obedience as the way to happiness and life grounded in well-being depending on living by love for God and one another, and disobedience as bringing misery and death, being not only a test of loyalty but a warning.RH Oct 11, 1906ST Jul 23, 1894
God gave religious liberty as gift and natural, fundamental, inalienable right that majorities cannot settle and government cannot take away, for He granted liberty of choice as essential to true worship and moral responsibility, creating the mind free and though Lord of body and mind with power to coerce choosing not to propagate religion by coercion, so that sin itself proves this liberty as original choice not to serve Him, and all attempts to influence mind by temporal punishments, burdens, or civil incapacitations only beget hypocrisy and meanness and depart from His plan.ST Jul 3, 1907 From the beginning He gave the right of choice in religion, permitting going astray though all were made good, so He does not favor compulsory religious laws and never authorized compelling Sabbath observance.ST Feb 22, 1910 It tested whether Adam and Eve would be obedient with loyalty or disloyalty deciding destiny as the pattern for testing all, and since the fall men excuse sin by charging God and saying His commandments cannot be kept, repeating Satan's heavenly insinuation, but inability need never be pleaded, for the Saviour stands with crucifixion marks as living witness the law can be kept, and men fail not because they cannot but because they will not.RH May 28, 1901
God gave a command in Eden and Adam knew the law's claims as part of the law governing humanity, and transgression brought loss of Paradise, curse on earth, and reign of death.ST Jan 17, 1911 God gave a command about eating from the garden trees where obeying was right and required, and Eve's disobedience was transgression and sin, not a benefit greater than obedience, for obedience would not have kept mankind as blind naked idiotic babies in shameful ignorance, nor did disobedience give a wisdom to be preferred, and justifying transgression as good points the wrong way, so doing exactly opposite is sure to do right.ST May 3, 1877 God gave permission while commanding not to disobey, and the forbidden fruit was later eaten in disobedience, since when humanity has sought to improve on God's ways, with disobedience leading to rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality.RH Sep 20, 1864 God gave a command in Eden on which life depended through faithful obedience to wholesome laws as the point of departure for Satan's denial and disobedience, giving permission while commanding not to disobey.RH Jun 20, 1907RH Sep 20, 1864
Trustworthiness Against False Theories
The creation and fall account in Genesis 1-3 stands or falls together, so that to reject it is to reject other biblical teachings with it.ST Jan 3, 1911 Christ and the apostles appealed to the ancient Scriptures as truthful and important, and to count Moses' account of creation false requires counting Moses either credulous or deliberately deceptive and counting the other Bible writers and Christ either mistaken followers or participants in deception.ST Mar 9, 1888ST Jul 28, 1881
That account presents God as Creator rather than life arising through gradual development from an original cell. Its fundamental facts are directly opposed to the major premise of evolutionary theory. Disobedience to the garden command caused the downward fall of man, which is the very foundation of Christian theology, bringing sin and its effects upon the race and requiring a Saviour to suffer and die to rescue fallen man in the atonement; the Mosaic account containing the command is fact upheld through the whole Bible, referred to by Christ and His apostles as accepted truth and interwoven into the very warp and woof of Bible doctrine and history, so to set it aside as fable undermines the whole structure of Bible doctrine and authority and destroys its credibility.RH Apr 1, 1909 The claim that man's fall was upward, advancing by evolution from ape and animal creation to present eminence, denies that fall and is utterly subversive of the whole Biblical doctrine of the atonement.RH Apr 1, 1909
The historic account of creation must be trusted rather than recast to fit evolutionary hypotheses.RH Aug 23, 1906 The first and second chapters mean what they say and lie within theology's own proper field, yet modern scientific theology no longer believes the Bible means what it says there, having retired from explaining them under pressure from science as matters too deep for it.RH Aug 23, 1906ST Jan 6, 1887 The garden and the command to Adam are literal, not a hidden spiritual meaning to be explained away by allegorical interpretation as Origen did.ST Apr 1, 1875
God through Christ was speaking with and directing man in Eden before sin entered.ST Together with the prohibition in the following verse, the permission shows God used the tree of the knowledge of good and evil as a test of obedience, whose violation transgressed at least the eighth and tenth commandments.RH Apr 9, 1857 God thereby gave a command in Eden before the fall, so divine law existed before humanity sinned and placed Adam and Eve on probation under law and accountable to it, with command and restriction making obedience possible, since without law they could not have fallen.ST Mar 11, 1875ST Apr 26, 1883
That Eden command made life depend on faithful obedience to wholesome laws, and it was the point of departure for Satan's denial of the warning and humanity's disobedience.RH Jun 20, 1907 Permission to eat from the garden trees stood joined to the command not to disobey, and disobedience led to rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality.RH Sep 20, 1864 The command was clear and understood, setting the one forbidden tree against the eatable trees with death as the threatened consequence, proving God's command is not a matter of indifference but must be obeyed even when disobedience is made appealing.ST Dec 13, 1883
The test concerned appetite and desire for unlawful knowledge, and yielding to appetite was a way they were overcome.RH Oct 11, 1906 It presented obedience as the way to happiness and life and disobedience as bringing misery and death, grounded in the fact that creature well-being depends on living by love for God and one another, and not only as a test of loyalty.ST Jul 23, 1894 Adam knew the law's claims, for the command was part of the law governing humanity, and transgression brought loss of Paradise, the curse on the earth, and the reign of death.ST Jan 17, 1911 Obeying that eating command was right and required, while Eve's disobedience was transgression and sin and no greater benefit than obedience; obedience would not have kept mankind as pitiable blind, naked, idiotic babies in shameful ignorance, disobedience gave no wisdom to be preferred over ignorance, justifying the transgression as good points the wrong way, and doing exactly opposite is sure to do right.ST May 3, 1877
Commentary part 3 of 3
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Law Covenant Sabbath Tithe
The free grant to eat from every tree joined to the ban on the tree of knowledge of good and evil under certain death was the first half of the original law given to Adam, and that command, not the Ten Commandments, was the law whose transgression made humanity sinful and brought sin and death and made necessary another law for forgiveness, distinct from and two thousand years earlier than the Ten Commandments since every one of the ten could have been obeyed and this law still transgressed.RH Jan 31, 1854 The prohibition with death as penalty was a test of obedience under divine law, and the death imposed on Adam and the race shows the command belonged to the whole universal moral law, not a mere request or private regulation.RH Aug 3, 1876 God gave His heavenly moral law to Adam by commanding him in the garden, Adam knew its claims as part of the law governing humanity, and transgression brought loss of Paradise, curse on earth and reign of death, so that to transgress even its least part brings terrible loss though the sentence was only in proportion to the deed.ST Jan 17, 1911RH Aug 20, 1872ST Sep 22, 1909
That command was God's moral law existing before the ceremonial law was added, giving free access to every tree except one with death in the day of eating and continued life while obedient, whose transgression made men condemned sinners necessitating Christ's death and the added second law of sacrifices, priests, altar, temple and support shadowing Him till He should come.RH Apr 15, 1873 The moral law was already present in Eden before the ceremonial system arose after the fall, beginning with few precepts and later growing through further instruction while remaining distinct from the ceremonial law.ST May 20, 1875 Righteousness is active conformity to moral law established by the Creator in harmony with the nature and relations of Creator and moral subjects, character being developed by activities, trials and tests, obedience as His expressed will being the condition for continuance forever of the life given to the race, and the Eden commands were not less than nor essentially different from the ten holy, perfect and good precepts later formally given as the perpetual rule.RH Aug 3, 1876
God gave Adam a law as part of a covenant of works binding Adam and all descendants to complete, exact, lifelong obedience, promising life for obedience and threatening death for disobedience while giving ability to obey.RH Jan 1, 1861 That covenant of works bound Adam and all posterity to personal, exact, entire and perpetual obedience including remembering the seventh day of every week and no other, with free permission to eat of every tree joined to prohibition of one tree paralleling free permission to labor six days joined to required rest of the seventh, so that substituting another day is as impossible as substituting another tree, labor on the six days being as innocent in itself as prayer and as eating of the permitted trees as a natural and inalienable right accepted by Adam as a free moral agent, while eating the forbidden fruit and violating the seventh-day rest bring guilt and the curse on all men at birth unless redeemed by Christ, that law continuing after the fall as a perfect rule of righteousness delivered on Mount Sinai in the Ten Commandments so that the fourth commandment and the Sabbath law of the covenant of works are one and the same law binding believers now as a rule of life, finished in Adam nearly six thousand years ago and written on the heart as requiring no other holy day.ST Aug 1, 1878 The positive provision of perpetual life was clearly set before Adam under the everlasting covenant previously perfected between Father and Son, free permission being part of the one moral test of obedience by which sin could be known and condemnation follow, which Adam accepted with full understanding of stipulations for continuing Edenic life or subjection to death, his standing resting on the covenant already ratified and sealed by the promise of Christ's offered blood to be given in due time for redemption.RH Apr 1, 1915
God made a covenant with Adam in Eden lying at the foundation of the whole plan of redemption which Adam transgressed, this command belonging to the original covenant whose condition was obedience for life.ST Jan 25, 1905ST Jul 7, 1914 Adam's life in Eden was subject to God's law with life conditional on obedience, perfect obedience being the condition of eternal life rather than a bargain excluding grace or Christ, and after the fall life is offered through Christ whose obedience makes righteous, with accepting Him meaning choosing God's way of obedience. Adam was placed in Paradise under a test where obedience to God's law was the condition of remaining righteous and being justified by obedience, so that had he obeyed through probation he would have been justified and Christ would not have needed to die, while after sin obedience can no longer justify because future keeping cannot atone for past transgression.RH Mar 24, 1859RH Apr 14, 1859
Before the fall eternal life could be secured by simple obedience without faith in Christ as Saviour and without needing a Saviour, free permission including the tree of life joined to the prohibition making death depend only on eating the forbidden fruit, proving a kept law gives life in itself and one who always keeps divine law is justified by works and not by faith, since as long as he kept eating of the permitted trees he would not die, so delaying disobedience for a thousand years would delay death for a thousand years and never disobeying would mean never dying.RH Mar 17, 1874 Adam was placed under perfect obedience and the same perfect obedience is required today, unblemished righteousness now obtainable only through Christ's imputed righteousness and God's provision for forgiveness and restoration by which Eden's requirement can still be fulfilled, for the law is unchangeable and stands as firm as the throne of Jehovah and conforming to His standard is the only way to gain admittance into heaven, contrary to Satan's claim that God has abrogated His law and that belief alone is enough.RH Sep 3, 1901RH Sep 24, 1901 Adam was given a command with ability to obey before the fall, distinct from gospel provisions to Christians, Adam and the patriarchs having the gospel only in embryo while Christians have it in demonstration and fact.RH May 12, 1859
The command concerning the tree was held by some to be primary law but positive rather than moral, resting exclusively on God's will with no moral reason, demonstrating that a primary law can be positive rather than moral so that even if all the Ten Commandments are primary it does not follow that the Sabbath is moral, and that a moral law can be abolished while its principle remains.RH Mar 4, 1873RH Feb 4, 1873 Against this, the weight holds that it tested obedience through a positive command about what was otherwise available, obeying God's authority being itself a moral duty, so once God commands an otherwise indifferent act it is no longer indifferent and neglect is disobedience.RH Apr 4, 1865 The specific test about the trees was not the whole moral law nor the present test of character, and describing the law as merely a rule about eating apples misses the point.RH Jun 30, 1859
The prohibition was not the moral law itself but a test of obedience to it, requiring placing no other authority above God, not coveting and not stealing, violating the first, tenth and eighth commandments, while obedience to it did not replace broader moral duties to God and others taught for perfect character.RH May 12, 1859 The transgression was not merely violation of a positive rule but involved moral principles with no prior transgression, violating the first and eighth commandments, while the duty to work in the garden was also moral duty, and the inherited dying condition shows the consequence, the nature of the tree being explained no further than the brief statements in Genesis.RH Aug 6, 1857 Eating the forbidden fruit violated the principles of nine of the Ten Commandments including coveting, false witness, stealing, adultery, murder, dishonoring God as Father, disregarding His name, idolatry and putting another master before God, while the Sabbath was not involved in the act itself but had been given as a separate command, showing God's law known and binding before Sinai.ST Dec 11, 1884 The express grant of food within obedience with the next verse's restriction tested loyalty and disobedience violated principles of nine of the Ten Commandments with the Sabbath separately given, so disobedience was not merely test failure separate from moral law but also violated Decalogue commands, and together with the prohibition the verse shows eating from the tree of knowledge would transgress at least the eighth and tenth commandments, while apart from that command Adam needed no further written law because principles of moral law were inherent in his originally perfect nature.ST Dec 11, 1884RH Jun 30, 1859ST Jan 11, 1916RH Apr 9, 1857
Read with the following command and Eve's account in Genesis 3:3, Adam recognized God's supreme authority and obligation to obey, expressing the first and great commandment comprising the principle of the first four of the Ten Commandments.ST Apr 13, 1915 God gave newly created man and woman in His image in harmony with His spiritual law only one prohibition to test love because untested love is weak, love not envying or seeking its own so cannot take what belongs to another, and partaking was the first ungodlike act transgressing love's law which was as broad then as ever because His infinite character was the same.ST Nov 20, 1901 The tree of knowledge was placed as a pledge and test of obedience, love, loyalty, trust and faith to prove sincere filial love and whether humanity would respect what God withheld as well as gave, freely given with bounty wisely adapted to wants with only one prohibition, retaining inexpressibly happy estate upon condition of obedience just as with holy angels, with Satan limited to only that tree and unable to harm while they obeyed but gaining power to annoy, perplex and trouble if they disobeyed.ST Jan 16, 1879ST Feb 18, 1913ST Mar 10, 1898
The law God gave in Eden commanding obedience with definite penalty warns that the wages of sin is death, God's retributive justice never fails, He exacts strict regard for His commandments, and the penalty is as definite and sure as when law was proclaimed at Sinai, as seen in the temptation, fall and punishment afterward.ST May 31, 1910 The command was a loyalty test whose disregard was transgression and sin, showing the law defining sin already existed when Adam fell, namely the moral law of the Ten Commandments.ST Feb 8, 1905 The breach was infinite because of the majesty, holiness, perfection and absolute unchangeableness of the law broken, so only the life of the Son of God was sufficient to heal the breach and restore man to his Maker.ST Sep 22, 1909 The death of Christ testifies in trumpet-tones that the law of Jehovah is immutable, divine and unalterable and could not be abolished or even altered or modified, which is why His death became necessary.ST Sep 22, 1909 Since the Sabbath is an inseparable part of that same holy, infinite, moral and immutable law, His cross proclaims the Sabbath fixed and man under perpetual obligation to keep it in letter and in spirit, and the shedding of His blood ratifies the everlasting new covenant that puts the Sabbath law along with the whole law into the heart.ST Sep 22, 1909
The reliability of the creation record in which the verse stands supports the fourth commandment, for if the first two chapters are untrue the commandments lose their claim to come from God and the whole system of morality and religion depends on the creation record being correct, the verse being part of the creation history comprehended by the fourth commandment belonging to the record conveying knowledge of God as Creator.ST Jul 28, 1881RH Sep 30, 1852 The specific command about the garden's fruit was given to Adam and Eve alone, consisting in eating permitted fruit and refraining from forbidden fruit, and was not a command to keep the Sabbath, so the verse does not establish this garden command as the present condition of God's promises.RH May 12, 1859 It was argued by opponents that the verse commands Adam not to know good or evil by not eating, and since the Sabbath is a moral institution involving good or evil Adam's observance of it before sin would have violated God's law and itself caused all sin and misery, precluding dating the Sabbath from creation.ST Mar 10, 1887
Faithfulness to the specific command stood for obedience in everything with obedience leading to eternal life and disobedience to death, and when they accepted the serpent's contradiction they chose falsehood over truth and woe came upon the world, while Satan has ever since persuaded men God's requirements are faulty with no dire results following rejection, seen where Christian nations observe Sunday instead of the Sabbath and alter the law from the form in which God gave it.ST Oct 8, 1894ST Sep 24, 1912 Disregard of the Eden command brought terrible consequences as a warning against rejecting God's commandments, with the Sabbath as the present-day test of obedience, the same test now placed on humanity by bringing the Sabbath as memorial of creative power testifying He made the world in six days and rested the seventh, so that disregarding the Sabbath repeats Eden's disregard, barring men from using it for their own pleasure as the fruit was barred.ST Jun 18, 1894ST Sep 3, 1912ST Aug 29, 1895 The verse is a specific exact command requiring implicit obedience with no leeway for substitution of another resembling or more convenient tree, and likewise those who substitute Sunday for the seventh-day Sabbath blessed, sanctified and hallowed to memorialize completed creation cannot be justified.RH Sep 16, 1915 The prohibition was not enforced by visible barrier but left to free choice, and a specific divine requirement tests loyalty and worship, just as keeping the seventh day tests loyalty today against man's first day and Satan's false sabbath and Sunday laws, and as in Eden possession of the heavenly Canaan depends wholly on implicit obedience.ST Jul 21, 1914
God placed a prohibition on use of a garden tree to test and train people and teach reverence for His law, compared with a claimed restriction on Sunday use while distinguishing Sunday from God's Sabbath, in contrast to the Sunday prohibition imposed as a test by human authority rather than God's Sabbath command.STST Feb 15, 1910 The forbidden tree was the Lord's reserved portion and mark of ownership and the original test of obedience, so taking it brought death just as taking the tithe now brings eternal ruin and death, and salvation requires returning to unfallen obedience and acknowledging God's ownership.RH Oct 28, 1915 The reservation was an act of care rather than arbitrary, testing respect for God's right and wisdom with passing necessary before entrustment with immortality and eternal riches, while reaching for the reserved thing revealed covetousness, selfishness, greed and unfitness for perpetual life, dominion and God's kingdom, exposing greed opposed to the unselfish character required for life in God's kingdom.ST Aug 8, 1916
God reserved the tree of knowledge as a lasting reminder that all things belong to Him, an arrangement made by Jesus Christ, and faithfully setting aside one tenth likewise acknowledges His ownership, the reserved tree before sin being contrasted with the tenth of produce claimed after sin and removal from Eden.RH Mar 31, 1903 God freely bestowed every tree while reserving one as holy to Himself, establishing His sovereign right to bestow and withhold, with the same test continuing in the seventh day and the tithe which man has no more right to use as he pleases than Adam had to eat the forbidden tree, and failure there is the line of apostasy in all ages on which Satan leads the world away from God.RH Mar 23, 1905 God freely gave enjoyment of His Eden bounties, every tree pleasant and good for food, with one exception reserved by Him as constant reminder of His ownership giving opportunity to demonstrate faithfulness, trust and perfect obedience, corresponding to the tithe people may not use, devoted to a specific purpose to support those carrying salvation, the nine tenths freely used corresponding to free permission while the reserved tree corresponds to the tithe, taking it being appropriating what did not belong to them and transgressing Thou shalt not steal, the same standard of loyalty still deciding whether God's people can regain the kingdom.RH Nov 5, 1901RH Apr 8, 1902RH Aug 10, 1905
The Lord as owner of the earth freely gave every tree while reserving one to Himself, the same act as still reserving a tenth of increase as holy, taking what He reserved being robbing God, and withholding the tenth denying His possessions and even His existence.ST Jan 22, 1902 God gave the abundance of Eden while reserving the tree of knowledge as His own, the restriction testing loyalty and appreciation of His goodness, and together with the Sabbath the reserved tree reminded them that time and possessions belonged to God as gifts from Him. As God gave use of all trees save one reserved tree, so He has given six days for common labor but put His sanctity on the seventh day to be sacredly observed as holy memorial of creation, God giving Adam free use of every tree as part of absolute dominion over earth and all in it, reserving only the tree of knowledge and the use of the Sabbath day to Himself.ST Mar 31, 1898RH Feb 9, 1905
God's law is as sacred as Himself requiring implicit obedience in heaven and earth, with the happy estate of Adam and holy angels retained only on condition of obedience, the divine word to be treated as sacred and commands obeyed implicitly, the single restriction leaving Adam without provision or excuse.ST Jan 16, 1879 God gave Adam a command and Adam understood God's prohibitions so acting contrary to God's will was sin and living in harmony with it was righteousness, God teaching what was needed and the command expressing God's eternal law though the commandments were not given on stone tablets until Moses' time.ST God gave Adam a moral command in Eden while allowing freedom of choice, the law given for humanity's good requiring obedience, and the garden command placed human life under God's authority as life entrusted by God rather than man's to use as he pleased, to remain in keeping while used to reveal and glorify God and forfeited by wrongdoing.RH Dec 15, 1868
Adam's needs were fully supplied and obeying the limit taught respect for God's authority and others' rights, while eating the forbidden tree would express selfishness and begin transgression.ST Apr 13, 1904 God placed humanity on probation testing loyalty, people not made beyond power of disobedience, and enduring would lead to eternal security, God's favor, fellowship with angels and equality with angels.ST Jan 9, 1879RH Feb 8, 1915 The reserved tree marked the Creator's sovereignty and the test of obedience, life depending on harmony with God's law, God freely giving every tree reserving only one thing leaving no unmet need requiring forbidden eating, the command asking only to refrain from one act amid abundance with death clear in the adjoining warning.ST Sep 24, 1912ST Oct 19, 1915 God placed humanity on probation testing loyalty with free permission to eat from every garden tree, this provision contrasting with later foods and substances introduced to gratify appetite rather than glorify God and supporting setting those things aside.RH Jan 22, 1867 God gave permission to eat while commanding not to disobey with a clear understood command setting the one forbidden tree against the eatable trees, disobedience bringing threatened death and rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality, God's command not a matter of indifference but to be obeyed even when disobedience is made appealing.ST Dec 13, 1883RH Sep 20, 1864
Diet Health and Provision
The free permission to eat from every tree, together with the trees being described as good for food, shows fruit was part of the original diet, and combined with the provision of seeds and herbs it identifies fruits, grains, and nuts as that diet, in contrast with the green herbs assigned to other creatures.ST Aug 31, 1915ST May 25, 1915 Together with the following verse it shows the first human diet was the garden's plant foods of grains, vegetables, and fruits and did not include flesh-meat.RH Mar 12, 1867 The command reflects the original design for food as free access to health- and strength-giving garden fruit, with humanity to subsist largely on fruit and plant food rather than flesh, with no death in Eden and no permission for animal food until after the flood.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Apr 2, 1914RH Jul 18, 1907RH Mar 21, 1912
It freely gave every tree except one for food, so Eden's diet was what grows from the ground with no animal flesh, for it was never the design that any creature's life be taken for human sustenance.RH Aug 15, 1871 Death in man or beast came in consequence of sin, making flesh-eating the fruit of transgression, and for 1656 years diet remained the green herb with no permission in the Sacred Record to use flesh for food until after the flood.RH Aug 15, 1871 Then Noah, shut in the ark one year and ten days with provisions running low and the desolated earth able to afford nothing until seed preserved in the ark could grow, was permitted flesh as a matter of necessity until the earth should bring forth again the proper food for man.RH Aug 15, 1871 The free permission to eat is the heaven-appointed bill of fare of fruits, cereals, legumes, vegetables, and other simple products lacking no needed food element and supplying the body directly and safely rather than second-hand through animals with impurities and disease.ST Mar 17, 1909
Freedom to eat the garden's fruit establishes fruit as food created for people and the original best-adapted choice, with grains and nuts also suited to human needs, set apart by God's word and prayer to be received with thanksgiving.RH Apr 21, 1904 The verse gives the first great hygienic rule for health and well-being defining the human diet, granting free permission for every garden tree except one, making food the wonderful variety growing out of the ground and excluding animal flesh such as beef, pork, mutton, chicken, turkey, goose, and duck.RH Aug 15, 1871 The meat appointed here means food in general, not animal food.RH Aug 15, 1871 Together with the provisions of seeds and herbs and the prohibition it shows diet instructions for what is good and fit to eat and what is not fit and must not be eaten.RH Jun 19, 1900
Had Adam, Eve, and posterity conformed to those instructions disease and death would never have entered, but instructions were disregarded by substituting and adding unfit things, for nearly six thousand years the family has paid little attention, so death is now in food all over the world.RH Jun 19, 1900 The permission applies to fruits, grains, and vegetables provided as suitable foods, especially when simply and healthfully prepared.ST Aug 13, 1894 The fruits of the garden trees were provided to meet human needs, and Eden's trees served both usefulness and beauty, while tending creation was intended to bring happiness.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Jul 25, 1871
Simple natural food was provided in harmony with nature's laws with few wants and abundant supply, while selfishness and unnatural perverted appetite bring excess, want, sin, and misery.ST May 7, 1912ST Aug 12, 1897 Departing from the provided food marred the home and would have prevented much misery, showing indulgence of appetite can demoralize and violation of health laws brings disease, degeneracy, and removal of the prospering hand.RH Apr 2, 1914ST May 5, 1914 Abstinence was taught in Eden where life depended on abstaining from one tree and eating meant dying, with appetite as the means of temptation through fruit appearing pleasant and desirable.RH Feb 24, 1874RH Mar 19, 1867
The definite command about the tree teaches strict temperance as later taught in abstinence from wine and strong drink for tabernacle service, to preserve clear judgment and faithful obedience, since success through appetite came by tempting and intemperance weakens physical, mental, and moral powers until right and wrong are confused.ST Jul 1, 1880 The first prohibition teaches appetite was to remain subordinate to moral and intellectual powers, a blessing when controlled but a degrading master when uncontrolled.ST Apr 15, 1875 The Eden command made appetite a test of obedience that is repeated after the Fall, with unrestricted appetite becoming a grave source of sin and suffering.ST Apr 15, 1875
Abstaining from the desirable forbidden fruit because it was prohibited would have let moral judgment and higher faculties rule appetite, strengthening character, happiness, and habit of virtue with each victory.RH Sep 18, 1860 When eating occurred, appetite, a lower faculty, overturned the proper order in which moral powers were to govern the other faculties, and pursuit of other wisdom showed true wisdom was to fear God and fully obey Him.RH Feb 26, 1867RH Jan 1, 1861 The test in Eden concerned appetite and desire for unlawful knowledge, and yielding to appetite was a way they were overcome.RH Oct 11, 1906
Abundant food and variety was given, permitting eating from every garden tree except the forbidden one, and Eve did not need that fruit, but desire for one more variety made her susceptible to the claim of a higher happier life, so her reason gave way to appetite, with uncontrolled appetite leading to the fall.ST Apr 15, 1875 Free access to every garden tree for food made the one forbidden tree a superfluity not needed for true comfort or life, and eating from it was intemperate indulgence in an unnecessary thing, with the sorrow following indulgence warning for all time against superfluous eating and drinking and all reaching after unnecessary and injurious enjoyment.ST Jan 13, 1881 Every tree was freely given for food but one thing was wisely withheld for good, and the first wrong eating set the pattern for leading men to partake of alcohol, tea, coffee, tobacco, pepper, mustard, and other inferior unsuitable materials by which human temples are defiled and made to decay, explaining racial degeneracy.RH Aug 3, 1911
Human senses and experience cannot be trusted as a guide in choosing food and drink, since conclusions from experience opposing God's word are unreliable and God's word is the infallible guide.ST Jan 18, 1916 Food from Eden trees given before sin shows eating daily food to sustain physical life belongs to sinless perfect existence and is not a weakness to be outgrown, since even sinless Adam needed food, so no spiritual progress can bring people to live without food.RH Mar 26, 1914 Humanity began in Eden under conditions intended to favor righteousness, with a suitable diet, yet those favorable conditions did not prevent sin, so knowledge and healthful living alone cannot free a sinner from sin.RH Nov 2, 1905
Provision of simple rest and simple food far from habitations teaches return to natural provisions and rebukes food for perverted appetite, while men are still led to partake of the prohibited tree of knowledge.ST Aug 12, 1897 Trust in God's Word was given as the way to meet temptation and overcome, the same means used in weakened humanity in the wilderness with It is written, and the same instruction given to each soul since.ST Jun 16, 1898 The command at creation provided for human life, connecting obedience to God's laws with freedom from sickness and preservation of life.RH Feb 20, 1872
In the Eden home lavish provision gave free permission for every tree including every food-bearing tree and the tree of life by which the race could live forever, with dominion over every living creature, the grant covering all trees with only one forbidden exception not even to be touched if exaltation would be kept. With continued faithfulness blessing, direct companionship, and privilege of bringing forth children to share blessings would remain. Adam and Eve were put in the garden and freely given all privileges needed for comfort and happiness including the best food from every tree, while obedience was tested centering on the tree of knowledge.RH Apr 27, 1905
Eden was their home with what they needed for happiness and fellowship with God, and disobedience led to being driven from that home.ST Mar 30, 1904 Love in provision for comfort and happiness freely gave of every tree of the garden, together with the family relation and the Sabbath as means to that end.ST Nov 23, 1904 Life, home, companion, and the garden were gifts calling for gratitude and love toward God.ST Nov 14, 1892 Placing in Eden permitted eating from the garden's trees including the tree of life, with human life in the garden including real physical food.RH Apr 4, 1871 Life was given to continue on condition of loyalty to government, and the promise failed when man listened to the deceiver.ST Feb 23, 1915 A command governing what could be eaten was given, and the following prohibition made disobedience a rejection of that command.RH Feb 26, 1867
Redemption Restoration and Application
Man created in the divine image as a free moral agent with dominion over all the earth was placed on probation to test fidelity to that enormous responsibility, and the free permission to eat of every tree with the single prohibition was the test of obedience to holy law, but overcome by wiles he disobeyed and ate, and that transgression being sin whose wages is death left humanity with all its endowments completely lost, sold into Satan's hands and needing the Son of man who made him to come to seek and save and restore all to original Edenic purity.ST Mar 11, 1897 The verse belongs to the Eden account before the fall showing the first plan, where Adam was created in the divine image upright in body, mind, and soul, and this original life reveals the gospel and helps understand power in Christ, so its truths are to be lived in restoring the divine image in humanity. God's free gift of every garden tree for food was a command testing whether Adam would be obedient or disobedient, for man was created for divine glory with purpose to repopulate heaven with the human race if after test and trial they proved loyal, with thoughts as God's thoughts and character moulded after the divine similitude had he stood, but he did not endure, forgot the warnings, believed Satan the enemy, and with Eve fell into sin.ST May 29, 1901
God did everything to prevent sin by giving all that heart could really wish, leaving no desire unsatisfied and therefore no excuse for illegal satisfaction, surrounding man with every inducement to remain true and loyal and obedient, giving His law as a safeguard around him, creating him pure and noble with no tendency or bias to evil, since it was never His purpose that man should be sinful.RH Jun 4, 1901RH Sep 24, 1901ST Aug 11, 1909 Together with the next verse it was the very first command, a prohibition against sinning, proving that character is the purpose of creation and redemption, without which the Word, the Gospel, and the infinite gift of the Son would have no meaning or significance.ST Mar 5, 1902 The express command left Adam and Eve, come from God's hand without sin or taint of evil, free to choose good or evil, and they could have kept innocence by living by every word from God's mouth and refusing the strange voice telling a different story, but they abused high and holy privileges and chose evil by believing Satan's lie and disobeying, so what was pure and godlike became perverted and defiled, and Christ came as propitiation living a perfect human life to elevate humanity and restore what was lost.ST Aug 26, 1897
The divine Son gave blessed and precious precepts in the beginning, and transgression brought woe and ruin upon a lost world, and the verse means what Christ clothed in human flesh came to live among men to show by action and what He explained in His first teachings to show what observing and obeying the law means.ST Adam stood in innocence in Eden with unfallen human nature, and for the Son to take even that innocent nature would have been almost infinite humiliation, yet He did not take it but accepted humanity as weakened and defiled by four thousand years of sin, accepting like every child of Adam the results of the great law of heredity as shown in His earthly ancestors, to share sorrows and temptations and give example of a sinless life, coming as a helpless babe subject to weakness into a world where Satan claimed dominion to meet life's peril in common with every soul and fight as every child of humanity must at risk of failure and eternal loss.ST Dec 9, 1913 In Eden before the fall humanity lived in harmony with God receiving life from Him, meant to pass on life to other creatures through love and unselfish giving.ST Dec 23, 1903
The earth was made as humanity's home according to the original purpose that it be inhabited, and sin's curse did not cancel that purpose, for God will fulfill it with a people who are all righteous.ST Sep 4, 1893 The verse is part of the eternal unchangeable purpose that this earth with all its contents in beautiful original perfection, including free provision from every tree, should be the eternal possession and everlasting inheritance of a holy, happy, immortal race, and though accomplishment was long delayed by sin it will finally be carried out in fullness because God does not change or suffer His plans to be thwarted, but will make all things new so that all lost in Adam is regained in Christ.ST Mar 18, 1903 In the beginning man possessed the right to eat of the tree of life belonging to his perfect condition before sin, together with a body made in God's image, direct communion with God, dominion over the whole earth in its perfect condition, and vigor and intellectual power but little less than angels, and this is the possession in the first phase of redemption owned at first, then lost through sin, then to be regained by being repurchased by Christ.ST Sep 12, 1900 It is a precautionary warning not to commit sin in order to preserve man in the upright and very good state in which he was first created, showing God's purpose in creating the earth to be inhabited was that it be the home of righteous human beings, not disembodied spirits.ST Mar 26, 1902
The verse belongs to the description of earth's original perfection in Eden, and the earth made new will be like that paradise God planted in the beginning.RH Jun 15, 1916 Eden was Adam and Eve's home where they had what they needed for happiness and fellowship with God, and their disobedience drove them from that home, while Christ left His heavenly home and accepted poverty to make it possible for people to have a home with Him.ST Mar 30, 1904 The garden command presents a test of character, for had Adam and Eve stood the trial they would have received the earth as an eternal possession free from sin and curse, but their failure brought consequences upon all descendants.RH Jun 27, 1907 It placed them under obedient submission, the same condition of salvation placed upon every human being to obey God's law and wear Christ's yoke with submission, and disobedience when tempted caused the fall.ST Jul 22, 1897
Adam at first possessed eternal life by creation as God's life operating in harmony with law, held by faith while believing and yielding to its righteous claims with God's life working normally in him, but turning from the law he lost it and became dying, and the same life is offered again by regeneration through faith accepting Jesus alone, held only by faith until character is perfected under test and possessed absolutely.ST Aug 27, 1896 The permission to eat freely from every tree is contrasted with later foods and substances introduced to gratify appetite rather than glorify God, supporting setting those things aside and living to honor God.RH Jan 22, 1867 Adam had to trust God's word about good and evil and believe eating from the tree of knowledge was wrong, and even sinless man had to develop perfect character by implicit faith, for such trust brings acquaintance with God, knowledge that He can be depended upon, genuine love and delight in His will, while refusing to believe makes pleasing Him impossible and brings sad disaster.ST Sep 23, 1889ST Feb 4, 1913
When God made man upright, innocent, and virtuous with His law in the heart, He gave in the paradise home free use of the tree of life and every tree except one as part of every blessing making life desirable while man ruled over all the earth in subjection to God and kept the Sabbath commemorating creation.RH May 12, 1874 The free permission including the tree of life was a good gift by which obedience would have allowed living forever, yet man was made to believe superior good lay in disobeying by eating the tree of knowledge though warned disobedience would bring certain death, and the choice proved a fatal mistake.RH May 12, 1874 God placed man in Eden with free permission joined to warning that disobedient eating would bring death as penalty for transgression of holy, just, and good law to be finally inflicted even in the second death, for death is an enemy, curse, and fruit of sin, not birth into higher life, and He gave a command in a place of purity, communion, and glorious earthly future where man could have remained had he obeyed, reserving the tree as test of fitness to remain, so that continued stay depended on obedience and love, lost through disobedience and driven from the garden, but restorable through Christ with obedience conditioning return to Eden and access to the tree of life in the everlasting kingdom.ST Aug 21, 1879ST Feb 24, 1887RH Mar 30, 1911ST Aug 10, 1915
God gave a command concerning the garden's trees whose disobedience opened the floodgates of woe, teaching His requirements are to be obeyed whatever the cost, and life depended on faithful obedience to His wholesome laws from which Satan's denial departed, for permission joined to command not to disobey led upon disobedience to rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality.RH Mar 16, 1916RH Jun 20, 1907RH Sep 20, 1864 God gave a clear understood command setting the one forbidden tree against the eatable trees, and disobedience brought the threatened death, teaching His command is not a matter of indifference but must be obeyed even when disobedience is made appealing.ST Dec 13, 1883 God gave a test concerning appetite and desire for unlawful knowledge by which yielding to appetite they were overcome, and the command presented obedience as the way to happiness and life grounded in well-being depending on living by love for God and one another, and disobedience as bringing misery and death, being not only a test of loyalty but a warning.RH Oct 11, 1906ST Jul 23, 1894
God gave religious liberty as gift and natural, fundamental, inalienable right that majorities cannot settle and government cannot take away, for He granted liberty of choice as essential to true worship and moral responsibility, creating the mind free and though Lord of body and mind with power to coerce choosing not to propagate religion by coercion, so that sin itself proves this liberty as original choice not to serve Him, and all attempts to influence mind by temporal punishments, burdens, or civil incapacitations only beget hypocrisy and meanness and depart from His plan.ST Jul 3, 1907 From the beginning He gave the right of choice in religion, permitting going astray though all were made good, so He does not favor compulsory religious laws and never authorized compelling Sabbath observance.ST Feb 22, 1910 It tested whether Adam and Eve would be obedient with loyalty or disloyalty deciding destiny as the pattern for testing all, and since the fall men excuse sin by charging God and saying His commandments cannot be kept, repeating Satan's heavenly insinuation, but inability need never be pleaded, for the Saviour stands with crucifixion marks as living witness the law can be kept, and men fail not because they cannot but because they will not.RH May 28, 1901
God gave a command in Eden and Adam knew the law's claims as part of the law governing humanity, and transgression brought loss of Paradise, curse on earth, and reign of death.ST Jan 17, 1911 God gave a command about eating from the garden trees where obeying was right and required, and Eve's disobedience was transgression and sin, not a benefit greater than obedience, for obedience would not have kept mankind as blind naked idiotic babies in shameful ignorance, nor did disobedience give a wisdom to be preferred, and justifying transgression as good points the wrong way, so doing exactly opposite is sure to do right.ST May 3, 1877 God gave permission while commanding not to disobey, and the forbidden fruit was later eaten in disobedience, since when humanity has sought to improve on God's ways, with disobedience leading to rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality.RH Sep 20, 1864 God gave a command in Eden on which life depended through faithful obedience to wholesome laws as the point of departure for Satan's denial and disobedience, giving permission while commanding not to disobey.RH Jun 20, 1907RH Sep 20, 1864
Trustworthiness Against False Theories
The creation and fall account in Genesis 1-3 stands or falls together, so that to reject it is to reject other biblical teachings with it.ST Jan 3, 1911 Christ and the apostles appealed to the ancient Scriptures as truthful and important, and to count Moses' account of creation false requires counting Moses either credulous or deliberately deceptive and counting the other Bible writers and Christ either mistaken followers or participants in deception.ST Mar 9, 1888ST Jul 28, 1881
That account presents God as Creator rather than life arising through gradual development from an original cell. Its fundamental facts are directly opposed to the major premise of evolutionary theory. Disobedience to the garden command caused the downward fall of man, which is the very foundation of Christian theology, bringing sin and its effects upon the race and requiring a Saviour to suffer and die to rescue fallen man in the atonement; the Mosaic account containing the command is fact upheld through the whole Bible, referred to by Christ and His apostles as accepted truth and interwoven into the very warp and woof of Bible doctrine and history, so to set it aside as fable undermines the whole structure of Bible doctrine and authority and destroys its credibility.RH Apr 1, 1909 The claim that man's fall was upward, advancing by evolution from ape and animal creation to present eminence, denies that fall and is utterly subversive of the whole Biblical doctrine of the atonement.RH Apr 1, 1909
The historic account of creation must be trusted rather than recast to fit evolutionary hypotheses.RH Aug 23, 1906 The first and second chapters mean what they say and lie within theology's own proper field, yet modern scientific theology no longer believes the Bible means what it says there, having retired from explaining them under pressure from science as matters too deep for it.RH Aug 23, 1906ST Jan 6, 1887 The garden and the command to Adam are literal, not a hidden spiritual meaning to be explained away by allegorical interpretation as Origen did.ST Apr 1, 1875
God through Christ was speaking with and directing man in Eden before sin entered.ST Together with the prohibition in the following verse, the permission shows God used the tree of the knowledge of good and evil as a test of obedience, whose violation transgressed at least the eighth and tenth commandments.RH Apr 9, 1857 God thereby gave a command in Eden before the fall, so divine law existed before humanity sinned and placed Adam and Eve on probation under law and accountable to it, with command and restriction making obedience possible, since without law they could not have fallen.ST Mar 11, 1875ST Apr 26, 1883
That Eden command made life depend on faithful obedience to wholesome laws, and it was the point of departure for Satan's denial of the warning and humanity's disobedience.RH Jun 20, 1907 Permission to eat from the garden trees stood joined to the command not to disobey, and disobedience led to rejection from the tree of life and loss of immortality.RH Sep 20, 1864 The command was clear and understood, setting the one forbidden tree against the eatable trees with death as the threatened consequence, proving God's command is not a matter of indifference but must be obeyed even when disobedience is made appealing.ST Dec 13, 1883
The test concerned appetite and desire for unlawful knowledge, and yielding to appetite was a way they were overcome.RH Oct 11, 1906 It presented obedience as the way to happiness and life and disobedience as bringing misery and death, grounded in the fact that creature well-being depends on living by love for God and one another, and not only as a test of loyalty.ST Jul 23, 1894 Adam knew the law's claims, for the command was part of the law governing humanity, and transgression brought loss of Paradise, the curse on the earth, and the reign of death.ST Jan 17, 1911 Obeying that eating command was right and required, while Eve's disobedience was transgression and sin and no greater benefit than obedience; obedience would not have kept mankind as pitiable blind, naked, idiotic babies in shameful ignorance, disobedience gave no wisdom to be preferred over ignorance, justifying the transgression as good points the wrong way, and doing exactly opposite is sure to do right.ST May 3, 1877
Sources