Adam answered God after eating by admitting that he ate, saying the woman gave him of the tree, the woman whom God gave to be with him.ST Apr 7, 1914RH May 1, 1879RH Mar 17, 1910 Instead of confessing he blamed two persons, the woman who gave him the fruit and God who gave him the woman, throwing the responsibility back upon the Lord.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Jul 7, 1898ST Jul 7, 1898 His admission did not remove responsibility and was not repentance, but an evasive self-justifying excuse that hid sin and increased guilt.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Nov 18, 1913ST May 27, 1897 Eve was deceived but Adam was not deceived, for he deliberately chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord, putting her before God.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882ST Dec 11, 1884 This was humanity's first disobedience and rebellion, when sin entered by one man and death by sin, bringing guilt, condemnation, separation from God, and the need for redemption.RH Dec 14, 1905ST Sep 9, 1930RH Dec 25, 1913 His excuse began the universal pattern of softening wrongdoing and confessing the faults of others instead of frankly owning sin, so covering sin is fatal and wrongs must be owned, confessed and forsaken.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jan 1, 1894
Words and Eden Setting
The man in the verse is Adam, the same Adam named as man in Genesis 1:26-27, made in the image and likeness of God and given inheritance and dominion over the earth as part of the creation pronounced very good.ST Jan 28, 1903 It is his answer to God after eating, admitting that he ate of the forbidden tree while saying the woman gave him of it, the woman whom God gave to be with him as a companion.ST Apr 7, 1914RH May 1, 1879RH Mar 17, 1910ST Jan 1, 1894RH Jan 17, 1865 His acknowledgment did not remove responsibility but placed it in his own choice, even as he offered an excuse when questioned instead of confessing his own act and shifted blame to the woman and indirectly to God who had given her to him.RH May 1, 1879RH Mar 17, 1910ST Jan 1, 1894RH Jan 17, 1865
The exchange belongs to God's audible address to Adam after sin entered, for before sin man had communion with God face to face, and after man sinned God still instructed His people by an audible voice, of which Genesis 3:8-18 is the address to Adam in that manner.PGGC 5.1–2 It is Christ's first pitying conversation with the fallen pair as straying, torn, bruised, sad and despairing sheep, when the plan of redemption laid in the counsels of eternity was first made known to this world to break the first news of pardon through Christ and the possibility of return.ST Aug 6, 1894 That news culminated in the promise that the Seed of the woman would bruise the serpent's head, giving them still the privilege to choose the right, to escape the eternal death to which they were doomed, and to share in the final restoration of paradise with Satan and sin and unrepentant sinners nowhere found.ST Aug 6, 1894 The chapter thus presents in order the temptation, the fall, and the promise, and the successive steps of that account can be traced, joining the rebellion in heaven and the testing of man with why sin was permitted, why Satan was not destroyed, why man was tested, and the plan of redemption devised for man's salvation beginning with Adam.ST Mar 17, 1914ST Dec 15, 1898ST May 19, 1898 The same portion that holds the promise of the Seed also holds the difference between the characters of Cain and Abel and the account of Cain's descendants with their early skill in metal-working and music in the story of the fall told in Genesis 3 and 4.ST Dec 29, 1909
Eve was deceived but Adam was not deceived; he deliberately chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord, putting her before God in open violation of the first commandment.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 In that yielding he idolized her by esteeming a creature more than the Creator, which those who distinguished the act from the later excuse identified as breaking the second commandment.ST Dec 11, 1884 He had been placed in the garden with right to everything for comfort and enjoyment, including the tree of life, except the tree of the knowledge of good and evil which the Lord reserved by command to prove his fidelity to his Maker, with obedience keeping his right to live continually and disobedience bringing the displeasure of God and the sentence of death.RH Jan 19, 1869 His guilt came from disobeying God's command, with eating from the forbidden tree as the particular forbidden act, not an act inherently wrong apart from God's command.
The setting is the literal garden of Eden, Paradise with the tree of life, where the garden, serpent, Adam and Eve are real, and eating what was forbidden leads to being driven out of paradise.ST Sep 4, 1901 That Eden Paradise of Genesis 2 and 3 is the city above, the bride, the Jerusalem above, the mother of all because man was created from it, and Adam's fall and exclusion left Paradise desolate until Adam its original possessor returns through the Mediator to claim its glories.ST Sep 23, 1875 The fall occurred after the Sabbath was fully made by resting, blessing and sanctifying, when Adam still enjoyed sight of God's perfect works, converse with angels and God, and dominion, with plain directions of duty, promised reward and punishment, and strong conviction of duty that he would not immediately violate.RH Jan 7, 1862 God on the seventh day rested and was refreshed, delighting in His works and in laying the foundation of the Sabbath, which could not be true if man made in His image for dominion had already violated His plain command and placed himself under the government of the enemy, proving the Sabbath is not a type to end in Christ but a memorial pointing back to creation when man needed no types to show him a sinner and no way of salvation through Christ's death.RH Jan 7, 1862 Before sin laid its hand upon Eden, Adam and Eve were innocent with lives unstained by disobedience, when the Sabbath was given to keep them in perfect accord in character with God, bringing them into His very presence to enter deeper into His creative love, but with sin Eden was lost, innocence was gone, and the door was opened through which a flood of misery and woe would rush into the world. Yet amid the ruins ever about him Adam never forgot the holy calm and quiet of the first Sabbath and continued devout contemplation and purest worship on that day, offering sacrifices from flock and herd with holy fire descending to signify acceptance in heaven, as the patriarchs did through all their generations.RH Feb 16, 1860 The concise Mosaic sketch of man's primeval rectitude and federal character and fall remains familiar Biblical history and the only authentic history of those remote events, contained in the Pentateuch and the prophets, for there were no historical records in Assyria, Egypt, Phoenicia, Chaldea, or Greece before Moses, and no other history is so ancient or so safe to rely on.RH Feb 5, 1867
By the time Adam was placed in Eden Lucifer the Day Star or Light-bringer, one of the morning stars, had already fallen from the company that sang together and shouted for joy when the foundations of the earth were laid, and he appears as the tempter in the Garden immediately after the six days' work.ST Jul 7, 1898 As the serpent-tempter he is a real personal being who by lying to Eve brought death upon the whole human race, thus making Satan the murderer of the whole human family from the beginning, which locates the fall of Satan about the beginning of this world.ST Dec 17, 1874 He deceived the first pair so that they did not act with full understanding of the deception, and his deception and fraud exemplify how he and the fallen angels have sought to ruin humanity.ST Jan 14, 1875ST May 27, 1880 In Eden Eve ate after Satan told her she would not surely die though God had said she would die if she ate, and that first false claim is the origin of the doctrine of the immortality of the soul held by the heathen world and nearly all Protestant churches from which a multitude of errors have sprung.RH Jun 8, 1916 The lie in Genesis 3:4-5 that people would not die and would become like gods is the source of belief in natural immortality, linked to witchcraft and other false religions.
God knew Adam's thoughts before and after the fall, and the verse records a thought Adam had after he fell.ST Nov 22, 1910 Eve was not contented with the knowledge of good alone but had to know good and evil both, and Solomon followed her in the same discontent when he gave his heart to know wisdom and to know madness and folly, testing forbidden things to taste what sweet was in them, which he found to be vanity and vexation of spirit, grief and anguish and sorrow.RH Jan 12, 1869
The excuse took the form of presenting himself as compelled to eat by the union of man and woman, as if obedience to God did not require him to sin and as if the command that man and woman remain together imposed a necessity God never imposed.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914RH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911 It also took the form of excusing the act as an effort to preserve peace with Eve, which did not remove his responsibility.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914RH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911 It was the beginning of blame-shifting in marriage, speaking reproach against his wife and accusing her to save himself because he was afraid God would blame him, even though he loved her very much.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914STRH Nov 5, 1901 He did not answer openly, honestly and frankly with I have, but answered indirectly and evasively, involving both the Lord and the woman in guilt before himself to shelter himself behind them and clear himself by involving them.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914STRH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911 In this he argued that he would never have done it had it not been for somebody else, reasoning with if that Eve had done differently he would not have sinned, taking the least possible blame upon self and holding that self is the last one that can be wrong, which reveals unbelief.RH Dec 10, 1908STRH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911
This accusing, criticizing spirit is of Satanic origin, begun when Satan accused God of injustice and falsehood with the intimation in tempting Eve that God was deceiving her and her husband.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 It is the first example of the favorite pretext of sinners to blame God for the existence and continuation of sin, trying to throw responsibility back upon the Lord by pointing to the woman God had given to be with him as the cause.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 After the first pair sinned the man accused the woman rather than owning his wrong, for accusing another can conceal or excuse the evil in one's own heart, which belongs to human nature when not controlled by grace.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 His answer was a double accusation against Creator and wife, showing the evil mind received from Satan and no longer reflecting the image and glory of God but the image and shame of his seducer, displaying the very disposition Lucifer had developed in heaven.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 That disposition, which God never put into mankind yet now lives in every human soul, exalts self above all and through all and in all by dodging behind anything or anybody and excusing self because somebody else does the same or worse, which is the very essence of the claim of infallibility and the creature exalting himself to sit in judgment upon the Creator and call in question His righteousness, truth and infallibility.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901
Fall Death and Loss
Genesis 3:12 belongs to the account of humanity's first disobedience and rebellion in eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, when sin entered by one man and death by sin.RH Dec 14, 1905ST Sep 9, 1930ST Nov 23, 1904RH Jul 1, 1909ST Jun 6, 1878 That fall brought guilt and condemnation, separation from God, misery, sorrow and ruin to Adam's descendants, who were created perfect and then fell under the power of the enemy.ST Sep 9, 1930RH Dec 25, 1913ST Nov 23, 1904RH Jul 1, 1909ST Jun 6, 1878 The need for redemption began at that fall and expulsion from Eden, from Paradise lost to Paradise restored, when Jesus took human sin upon Himself and died to save the whole race and to recover humanity to innocence.RH Dec 14, 1905RH Dec 25, 1913RH Jul 1, 1909
Adam and Eve both knowingly broke God's clear command, and their confessions are enough to establish their guilt and proceed to the sentence of death.RH Nov 6, 1860RH Aug 22, 1854RH Aug 3, 1876 By that disobedience, treated as sin, Adam incurred the threatened death penalty and brought the penalty of death upon the human race.RH Nov 6, 1860RH Aug 22, 1854RH Aug 3, 1876 He forfeited the right to live and to the tree of life, and God told him he must return to the ground out of which he was taken.ST Dec 9, 1880RH Dec 29, 1868ST Jan 28, 1875ST Jun 12, 1879 What God takes back at death is simply the breath of life breathed into Adam's nostrils to make him a living soul, held in God's own keeping until He gives life a second time; what was given was life, not a conscious being from glory living within the body, so when it is taken there is no life, thought or knowledge left, just as before it was given, proving man has no inherent immortality.ST Dec 9, 1880RH Dec 29, 1868ST Jun 12, 1879 Death is the fruit of sin and does not open a door back into the paradise from which sin caused man to be expelled.ST Jun 12, 1879
Through that fall sin caused the human family to lose Paradise, the garden where the first parents had been placed and where the tree of life stood, with its life without end.ST Jan 28, 1875ST Sep 26, 1878 Adam's fair inheritance passed to Satan until Christ redeems it, for Adam surrendered dominion to the tempter and Satan became its usurping ruler.ST Jan 17, 1878 God drove Adam out to prevent him from eating from the tree of life and living forever, and the garden remained on earth for a time guarded from human approach by the cherubim's flaming sword, probably removed to heaven at the time of the Flood.ST Jan 28, 1875 That same Paradise, prepared for mankind in innocence when the earth was founded and now in the third heaven within the heavenly Jerusalem made infinitely more glorious, will be given to the saved as the overcomer's reward, when the second Adam first introduces the saved family into it as the beginning of giving them the kingdom.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Mar 1, 1870 In that apostasy Paradise was lost, man was excluded from the tree of life, cut off from heaven's family and intercourse with God and angels and sold into bondage, the earth came under God's curse and was marred from very good beauty, and death entered through sin.
Eating only one piece about six thousand years ago forfeited Eden glory, ended Edenic brightness and began a long dark night of woe.ST Sep 17, 1902RH Jul 9, 1872 That one sin, by the mother of the race and apparently small and insignificant, opened the way for an innumerable host of sins spreading destruction to earth's remotest bounds, becoming the fatal origin of centuries of pain and misery.ST Sep 17, 1902 Its results are terrible and far-reaching, disfiguring nature so that the earth in its present sin-cursed state bears only faint traces of primitive fertility and beauty, wrecking this beautiful earth and changing an Eden into a charnel-house, with every tear and sorrow and pain and grief and wail of agony and gray hair and bent form and bed of death caused by disobedience.ST Sep 17, 1902ST Oct 12, 1904 Although sinless nature was created in six literal days, its restoration requires 7,000 years, with that original sin living on in its innumerable posterity for six thousand years past and another thousand years to come, until destroyed with its original progenitor, that old serpent, which is the devil, and Satan.ST Sep 17, 1902 That first transgression, believing and acting a lie to obtain greater exaltation and bringing instead humiliation, degradation and death, laid the foundation for every other disappointment to the present day, for disappointments from false hopes are the common experience of mortals largely on account of sin.ST Aug 13, 1902 God is no respecter of persons and will not deal more leniently with others than with Adam and Eve, so if Eden was lost for only one sin it cannot be regained while even one comparatively small sin remains buried in the heart.RH Jul 9, 1872 After the fall enmity also arose among different kinds of animals and they gradually became carnivorous, marking the change from the peace of creation to the effects of sin.RH Mar 12, 1861
That sin is a fixed fact that gained a foothold in God's universe after the tempter gained the confidence of the first mother and drew Adam with Eve into rebellion, and God's banishing of Adam and Eve from paradise shows how He viewed it, yet it is an intruder and usurper that came in by fraud, gained no rights by possession, was not willed by God, displeases Him now as at its origin, exists in defiance of Him, and is not a natural or necessary part of human life or heritage.RH Mar 3, 1874RH Aug 25, 1910 By yielding to Satan's suggestions in Eden our first parents were overcome and perverted in their natures, so that since then the human race has been readily led into sinful indulgence.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898 Temptation itself does not make a person evil or a devil; yielding to it brings sin and places the person under Satan's control so long as the sinful practice continues.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898 That yielding broke the charm of obedience and marked the rise of self-will, for Adam and Eve attempted to exalt themselves by eating the forbidden fruit and substituting their own ways for God's ways, which is selfishness as rebellion against God and His government, any effort of the creature to exalt self at the expense or neglect of divine order, bringing misery and death upon themselves and their race as a solemn warning that God's law admits no substitution.ST Jan 25, 1899RH Jan 2, 1866 Since the fall people's sinful desires readily align with the law of self and resist God's will, so obedience to God is an absolute necessity, not a choice to set aside at will.ST Jan 25, 1899
True History Upheld
Genesis 1-3, including Adam's answer about the woman given to be with him, is factual, literal, inspired history, received by Moses by revelation since he had no personal knowledge of those events, not tradition, allegory, myth, poem, legend, spiritualized legend, literature for ethical instruction only, or childish fable, but plain and clear enough for a child, truly written by Moses and held as truth by Christ and the apostles as part of the inspired Scriptures and the true account of the first parents of the human race.ST Jul 28, 1881ST Nov 25, 1889ST Mar 20, 1907ST Mar 9, 1888ST Nov 1, 1905 Its credibility as history is foundational to confidence in the Bible, for the truthfulness of the fall account underlies the whole Book.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Aug 25, 1881
The fall recorded there is foundational to the gospel, for without that real disobedience in Eden when the first parents ate of the tree there would be no need for redemption, atonement, incarnation, Saviour, or plan of salvation, and to treat it as fable makes the gospel itself rest on a fable.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Nov 13, 1893ST Apr 2, 1896ST Nov 15, 1883ST Jul 26, 1910 Denying that the fall occurred requires reconsidering all doctrines founded on that plan, and rejection of creation and the fall is linked to rejection of inspiration of Scripture, the atonement, Christ's divinity and resurrection, and His second coming.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Jul 26, 1910 That disobedience made man a fallen race in sin, and Christ came to suffer and die to rescue man from its effects, so the whole Biblical doctrine of the atonement and what Christ declared He came to accomplish depends on its reality.ST Apr 2, 1896RH Apr 1, 1909 To deny it undermines the need for a Redeemer and Christ's atonement, subverts the atonement, destroys the credibility of the Bible revelation, and removes the Saviour's necessity, the flood's reason, and the authority of Scripture from Moses to Revelation.ST Apr 2, 1896ST Nov 15, 1883RH Apr 1, 1909
The Bible teaches a downward fall from a higher, perfect state, not upward evolution from apes through savagery and barbarism to civilization, and the Fall and evolution cannot both be held but one must be abandoned.RH Apr 1, 1909AUST Jun 14, 1920ST Jun 3, 1913 Man was formed a perfect being by the infinite Creator and since that sin has been degenerating through the ages rather than evolving upward from lower life, so that no men today correspond in strength and physical prowess to the giants of the times before Christ, and disobedience brought moral ruin instead of improvement.ST Aug 22, 1916ST Jun 3, 1913 The most fundamental facts of the first chapters are directly antagonistic to the evolutionist major premise of successive geological ages, which is the weakest point in the whole evolution theory, and denial of the fall comes from allowing uncertain geology built on human hypothesis to set aside the Word of God, so that evolution supersedes creation and Darwin's Origin of the Species is preferred to the Books of Moses on which the faith of Jesus Christ rested.ST Feb 13, 1901 To replace the fall with constant advancement from ape and animal creations through evolutionary processes subverts the atonement, and discarding the fall keeps the form of godliness while denying its power.RH Apr 1, 1909
The Mosaic account is familiar Biblical history and the only authentic history of those remote events, contained in the Pentateuch and the prophets when there were no historical records in Assyria, Egypt, Phoenicia, Chaldea, or Greece before Moses, who is the father of history, an inspired record explaining the widespread traditions of an original good age and its loss, of man's primal purity, fall, and promise of redemption.ST Feb 10, 1887RH Feb 5, 1867 It is not myth, poem, or allegory but truth, the word of the living God to be heeded, given by inspiration of God and profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, so to reject the writings of Moses is to reject the teaching of Christ and His apostles.ST Nov 1, 1905 It gives detailed facts showing who Adam was and what he did, how by one man sin entered into the world and death by sin and how in Adam all die, and makes plain who that old serpent is, what he did in bringing sin, and why he is to be bound a thousand years, thereby revealing the origin, nature and true character of the archdeceiver and the necessity and plan of redemption, without which these statements impart no tangible instruction and the rest of Scripture is scarcely intelligible. Even the Karen people of Burma hold traditions closely like that account, together with creation and the flood, showing that at some remote time they knew Jehovah, and though wandering far from God in the dark night of demon worship they still retain in their hearts a knowledge of and belief in the Supreme Being, whom God regards with great compassion as a despised and mistreated people.RH Aug 10, 1905
The cause of the first transgression was disputed, some holding that God permitted Adam to fall, while others held that God decreed the sin and arranged events so that Adam and Eve could not avoid the fall, which God foresaw and according to the predestinarian position ordained and appointed.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Apr 10, 1879 Misuse of the account takes Genesis 3:1-24 to mean God laid a trap for man and then condemned and punished him for falling into it, making God unfair and unjust, and uses it as a reason for rejecting all divine revelation, presuming human reason can balance the right or wrong of God's dealings and pass judgment on Him who reads all hearts, knows all motives, and sees the end from the beginning.RH Feb 18, 1902 The temptation and fall also raises why man was tested and why sin was permitted and why Satan was not destroyed, belonging to the great controversy between good and evil as illustrated in the life of Adam, from whom a lesson is drawn and which is connected with the plan of salvation extending to the establishment of the kingdom at Pentecost, contrary in almost every respect to what unaided human reason could devise.STST Feb 19, 1880
Modern scientific theology rejects the doctrine of Adam's fall into sin and of an original state of innocence to which Adam's answer belongs.RH Mar 28, 1907
Law Atonement and Restoration
The fall came by violation of the moral law already planted in Eden before the fall, under which Adam and Eve stood on probation, and disregarding the divine prohibition was transgression of that law bringing the curse and misery that followed.ST Apr 15, 1875ST Sep 21, 1876ST Mar 11, 1875 Eve ate from the motive to become as gods, while Adam, who was not deceived, deliberately chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord, putting her before God in open violation of the first commandment, and his own words that the woman gave him of the tree expose that deliberate choice.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 The consequences prove that changeless law could not be changed or abolished to free them, for the sentence of death and resulting suffering followed, the earth was blighted because of human sin, and the curse, the blighting, and the testimony to guilt show its sacred and unalterable character.ST Apr 15, 1875ST Mar 11, 1875ST May 10, 1883 That account of curse after disobedience is not itself a rule of obedience, and does not show that the Sabbath was not commanded or could not be kept after the fall, for God means what He says in His commands.ST Apr 15, 1875RH Feb 24, 1859
The fall brought loss of the estate, rights and dominion given to the first pair, leaving humanity in debt, helpless, corrupt, and under judgment, and therefore in need of a divine Saviour and dependence on divine grace.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Mar 26, 1885ST Apr 11, 1911 The Creator foresaw that fall, and the purpose of redeeming humanity was already included in His purpose in creating the world, so that the gospel's provisions reach back to Eden and the history beginning with the first sin leads to redemption through Christ.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Dec 24, 1885 Adam's disobedience was rash ingratitude that plunged him from his blessed state into deep woe, shifting blame to the woman and indirectly to God who gave her, yet Christ in love gave Himself to buy humanity back and acted to save the fallen.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Apr 11, 1911ST Apr 11, 1878 He suffered Adam's penalty sinless in sinful flesh to show man can overcome, and thus redeems Adam's disgrace.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Mar 26, 1885
What was lost in Adam is to be regained in Christ, for humanity created perfect fell and brought ruin on its descendants, from which Christ came to recover humanity and restore it to innocence.ST Aug 6, 1894RH Jul 1, 1909 The pitying Shepherd's first conversation with the straying, torn, bruised, sad and despairing pair after sin first made known to this world the plan of redemption laid in the counsels of eternity, breaking the first news of pardon through Christ, the promise that the Seed of the woman would bruise the serpent's head, the still-open privilege to choose the right, escape the eternal death to which they were doomed, and share in final restoration where paradise is regained with Satan and sin and unrepentant sinners nowhere found.ST Aug 6, 1894 Sin caused the human family to lose Paradise, the garden where the first parents were placed and where the tree of life stood, which remained on earth for a time guarded by the cherubim's flaming sword and was probably removed to heaven at the Flood, leaving Paradise desolate until Adam its original possessor returns through the Mediator to claim its glories.ST Sep 23, 1875 That Paradise prepared for mankind in innocence, now in the third heaven in the heavenly Jerusalem, the city above, the bride, the mother of all from which man was created, will be given to the saved as the overcomer's reward, when the eternal purpose shown from Genesis 1 and 3 to the last two chapters of the Bible is completed with all Satan's agencies gone down in eternal ruin, God's dwelling with men, all tears wiped away, death the last enemy destroyed, the earth made new and clothed again in Edenic purity, and all things in heaven and earth gathered together in one in Christ in the fullness of times.ST Sep 23, 1875ST Sep 26, 1878ST Aug 17, 1915
The Eden history hides the whole gospel and God's first plan in Adam created in the image of God and upright in body, in mind, in soul, vividly portraying a life to be desired and lived. Uprightness of body comes only by obeying the laws of health in eating, dressing and breathing according to divine principles, uprightness of mind by Christian education, and uprightness of soul by feeding upon God's word, and leading pupils to live these truths restores the image of God in humanity, which is the gospel; the Christ-life must be seen in Adam, seeing God in Eden gives understanding of the same power in the Christ-child, and living what is studied is the only proof of successful teaching. God in love created the first pair and richly endowed them with physical and mental power for His glory and their happiness, being the author of life, health, strength and true happiness and not the author of sickness, sorrow and death, but the first great transgression by those representatives of the dying race brought moral and physical evils, disease, suffering and death upon the race.ST Sep 2, 1875ST Apr 1, 1875ST Apr 15, 1875 Death, sickness, sorrow and physical and moral wretchedness are the legitimate offspring of transgression of moral and natural law, sickness is no more a necessity than sin, death even in ripe old age exists because of that first transgression, and premature death in childhood, youth or middle life comes from continued transgression which aggravates Eden's evils.ST Apr 1, 1875 Adam's eating at Eve's giving was a reckless departure from God's requirements through moral powers weakened by indulgence of perverted appetite, bringing guilt and sorrow upon the world and the penalty of the crime upon man, and the example and result with the history of his family was traced for the benefit of all who should live upon the earth to deter them from the same steps, so his failure is no reason to complain of him while repeatedly sinning despite having that history, its consequences, the plan of redemption through Christ, and the instruction of Scripture.ST Jul 8, 1880ST Sep 1, 1881ST Apr 15, 1875 That disobedience cost infinite expense, leading the Son of God to leave the royal courts of heaven to take a humble place on earth where He was subjected to insult, rejection and crucifixion by the very ones He came to bless, the Majesty of heaven sacrificed to save man, for God pronounced judgment against Adam for that transgression and did not pass over it lightly, and He will not pass over any transgression of His law now more lightly.ST Sep 1, 1881
Warning for Daily Life
Adam's answer began the universal pattern of excuse that every transgressor has followed since, softening wrongdoing, palliating faults, and confessing the faults of others instead of frankly saying I have sinned.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jan 1, 1894ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jul 3, 1856 His admission that he ate did not remove responsibility, for he gave no valid reason but shifted blame to the woman and to God who gave her to be with him, revealing the evasive, self-justifying spirit of sinners.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jan 1, 1894ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jul 3, 1856 To blame others for neglect or wrongdoing is a sign of inward backsliding, making barefaced sin appear almost a matter of necessity rather than lamenting one's own corrupt depravity.ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jun 7, 1870 Covering sin in this way is fatal, so wrongs must be owned without extenuation, confessed and forsaken with earnest work and seeking of pardon and improvement before it is too late.ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jul 3, 1856RH Jun 7, 1870
Each person exercised free power of choice in the test and was not obliged to go together into sin, and condemnation rested on Adam because he had the power and right to choose.ST Jan 17, 1911 Eve's giving did not compel him or remove his responsibility before God, for God holds each person individually to account for his own action toward Him with equality in personal responsibility.ST Jan 17, 1911ST Apr 12, 1883 Temptation is not all outward happening but also inner readiness, and saying he tempted me explains only one side, for no outsider is as responsible for a person's sins as the person himself.ST Apr 12, 1883ST Jan 6, 1904 It takes two to make a successful temptation, and one of the two is always one's own responsible self, which must be answered for, and no excuse will save him.ST Jan 6, 1904
The answer shows the beginning of blame-shifting in marriage, when the first man spoke reproach against his wife and accused her to save himself because he was afraid God would blame him, even though he loved her very much.STRH Apr 9, 1901 That same ungallant blaming of wives by husbands to avoid blame still continues, as men since Adam blame women rather than take responsibility for their own faults.ST Sin and selfishness replaced God's rule and destroyed the first home, damaging the natural and domestic relations of human life and bringing sorrow, strife, suffering and death.RH Apr 9, 1901ST Mar 29, 1905 The purity of the Eden home as a heaven of peace and joy was lost, and since then in a sin-cursed earth homes are darkened by sin with few husbands and wives measuring up to the standard of the Word, and married life is subject to trials and discord that lasting peace cannot escape apart from religion.RH Apr 9, 1901ST Jan 16, 1901
Adam's disobedience and blame-shifting warn against repeating the fall while lamenting his transgression, for his example stands to deter all who live on earth.ST Feb 11, 1875ST Jun 3, 1886RH Mar 4, 1875 His sin in eating what had been forbidden, after listening to the deceptive temptations of the enemy, brought guilt and sorrow and opened the floodgates of woe, growing worse until the flood and steadily increasing since, which would have plunged the race into hopeless despair apart from God's goodness and mercy.ST Jun 3, 1886ST May 26, 1898ST Jun 3, 1875 That disobedience is repeated when God's plain command is discarded, as in rejecting the Sabbath of the Lord for a spurious sabbath, and man is required to reverence and obey the divine law without questioning its feasibility or convenience.ST Jun 3, 1886ST May 26, 1898ST May 11, 1876 Obedience protects from intemperance, sexual immorality and disease, while further falls bring increasing sin and harm, whether by disbelieving God like Babel or by neglecting watchfulness in pleasant life.ST Feb 11, 1875ST May 11, 1876ST Jun 3, 1875
The answer proves the great change that took place in character and nature at the fall, with righteousness gone and sin in its place, and innocence, happiness, holiness, love, faithfulness and obedience fled while depravity showed itself in every movement.ST Apr 9, 1912 Self-defense and accusing another to conceal or excuse the evil in one's own heart are effects of sin and part of human nature when not controlled by God's grace.RH Jan 20, 1916ST Jul 26, 1910 After the fall humanity developed a disposition to reject God's word and became willing to accept systems of religious error.RH Nov 11, 1858RH Sep 15, 1874 Adam's story begins the Bible's treatise on temptation and its conquest, warning that all sin promises joy but proves false and brings death and worse, separation from God, and showing that even a perfect human being could fall when left to himself, so that holiness and safety depend on divine preservation.RH Jul 29, 1858RH Sep 15, 1874
The same excuse appears when willful, disobedient, headstrong young people blame an earthly parent, when children hide wrong and throw blame on another, and when husbands blame wives.STRH Apr 9, 1901RH Apr 3, 1866 Children must not form the habit of making excuses, but be willing to own it when they have done wrong, for one quick at making excuses is not likely to be good for anything else or to be loved and honored.RH Apr 3, 1866 The plea that when a thoughtless girl or evil-minded woman puts temptation before a man he must fall has become universal from Adam down, and reasoning with if that Eve had done differently he would not have sinned reveals unbelief that has lost many battles.RH Feb 17, 1916ST Aug 21, 1901 Instead of pleading temptation the right course is to refuse to do wickedness and sin against God and to flee like Joseph, for there is power in Christ to keep from sin if He is let to keep, no matter what the temptation of wine, women, or any sin Satan can invent, and then there is safety.ST Aug 21, 1901 Satan's conquest in Eden contains the germ of all later war of man with man as the acorn contains the oak, and the trail of the serpent lies over nearly every great disaster involving terrible loss of life through greed joined with governmental corruption or inefficiency, as in the Iroquois Theater at Chicago where the house was opened to make money before it was ready and inspection failed to remedy gross neglects, growing through corruption and war until the Lord subdues the usurper, for degeneracy is measured by injury done to the world.RH Jun 24, 1915ST Jul 27, 1904
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
136 sources
Adam answered God after eating by admitting that he ate, saying the woman gave him of the tree, the woman whom God gave to be with him.ST Apr 7, 1914RH May 1, 1879RH Mar 17, 1910 Instead of confessing he blamed two persons, the woman who gave him the fruit and God who gave him the woman, throwing the responsibility back upon the Lord.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Jul 7, 1898ST Jul 7, 1898 His admission did not remove responsibility and was not repentance, but an evasive self-justifying excuse that hid sin and increased guilt.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Nov 18, 1913ST May 27, 1897 Eve was deceived but Adam was not deceived, for he deliberately chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord, putting her before God.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882ST Dec 11, 1884 This was humanity's first disobedience and rebellion, when sin entered by one man and death by sin, bringing guilt, condemnation, separation from God, and the need for redemption.RH Dec 14, 1905ST Sep 9, 1930RH Dec 25, 1913 His excuse began the universal pattern of softening wrongdoing and confessing the faults of others instead of frankly owning sin, so covering sin is fatal and wrongs must be owned, confessed and forsaken.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jan 1, 1894
Words and Eden Setting
The man in the verse is Adam, the same Adam named as man in Genesis 1:26-27, made in the image and likeness of God and given inheritance and dominion over the earth as part of the creation pronounced very good.ST Jan 28, 1903 It is his answer to God after eating, admitting that he ate of the forbidden tree while saying the woman gave him of it, the woman whom God gave to be with him as a companion.ST Apr 7, 1914RH May 1, 1879RH Mar 17, 1910ST Jan 1, 1894RH Jan 17, 1865 His acknowledgment did not remove responsibility but placed it in his own choice, even as he offered an excuse when questioned instead of confessing his own act and shifted blame to the woman and indirectly to God who had given her to him.RH May 1, 1879RH Mar 17, 1910ST Jan 1, 1894RH Jan 17, 1865
The exchange belongs to God's audible address to Adam after sin entered, for before sin man had communion with God face to face, and after man sinned God still instructed His people by an audible voice, of which Genesis 3:8-18 is the address to Adam in that manner.PGGC 5.1–2 It is Christ's first pitying conversation with the fallen pair as straying, torn, bruised, sad and despairing sheep, when the plan of redemption laid in the counsels of eternity was first made known to this world to break the first news of pardon through Christ and the possibility of return.ST Aug 6, 1894 That news culminated in the promise that the Seed of the woman would bruise the serpent's head, giving them still the privilege to choose the right, to escape the eternal death to which they were doomed, and to share in the final restoration of paradise with Satan and sin and unrepentant sinners nowhere found.ST Aug 6, 1894 The chapter thus presents in order the temptation, the fall, and the promise, and the successive steps of that account can be traced, joining the rebellion in heaven and the testing of man with why sin was permitted, why Satan was not destroyed, why man was tested, and the plan of redemption devised for man's salvation beginning with Adam.ST Mar 17, 1914ST Dec 15, 1898ST May 19, 1898 The same portion that holds the promise of the Seed also holds the difference between the characters of Cain and Abel and the account of Cain's descendants with their early skill in metal-working and music in the story of the fall told in Genesis 3 and 4.ST Dec 29, 1909
Eve was deceived but Adam was not deceived; he deliberately chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord, putting her before God in open violation of the first commandment.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 In that yielding he idolized her by esteeming a creature more than the Creator, which those who distinguished the act from the later excuse identified as breaking the second commandment.ST Dec 11, 1884 He had been placed in the garden with right to everything for comfort and enjoyment, including the tree of life, except the tree of the knowledge of good and evil which the Lord reserved by command to prove his fidelity to his Maker, with obedience keeping his right to live continually and disobedience bringing the displeasure of God and the sentence of death.RH Jan 19, 1869 His guilt came from disobeying God's command, with eating from the forbidden tree as the particular forbidden act, not an act inherently wrong apart from God's command.
The setting is the literal garden of Eden, Paradise with the tree of life, where the garden, serpent, Adam and Eve are real, and eating what was forbidden leads to being driven out of paradise.ST Sep 4, 1901 That Eden Paradise of Genesis 2 and 3 is the city above, the bride, the Jerusalem above, the mother of all because man was created from it, and Adam's fall and exclusion left Paradise desolate until Adam its original possessor returns through the Mediator to claim its glories.ST Sep 23, 1875 The fall occurred after the Sabbath was fully made by resting, blessing and sanctifying, when Adam still enjoyed sight of God's perfect works, converse with angels and God, and dominion, with plain directions of duty, promised reward and punishment, and strong conviction of duty that he would not immediately violate.RH Jan 7, 1862 God on the seventh day rested and was refreshed, delighting in His works and in laying the foundation of the Sabbath, which could not be true if man made in His image for dominion had already violated His plain command and placed himself under the government of the enemy, proving the Sabbath is not a type to end in Christ but a memorial pointing back to creation when man needed no types to show him a sinner and no way of salvation through Christ's death.RH Jan 7, 1862 Before sin laid its hand upon Eden, Adam and Eve were innocent with lives unstained by disobedience, when the Sabbath was given to keep them in perfect accord in character with God, bringing them into His very presence to enter deeper into His creative love, but with sin Eden was lost, innocence was gone, and the door was opened through which a flood of misery and woe would rush into the world. Yet amid the ruins ever about him Adam never forgot the holy calm and quiet of the first Sabbath and continued devout contemplation and purest worship on that day, offering sacrifices from flock and herd with holy fire descending to signify acceptance in heaven, as the patriarchs did through all their generations.RH Feb 16, 1860 The concise Mosaic sketch of man's primeval rectitude and federal character and fall remains familiar Biblical history and the only authentic history of those remote events, contained in the Pentateuch and the prophets, for there were no historical records in Assyria, Egypt, Phoenicia, Chaldea, or Greece before Moses, and no other history is so ancient or so safe to rely on.RH Feb 5, 1867
By the time Adam was placed in Eden Lucifer the Day Star or Light-bringer, one of the morning stars, had already fallen from the company that sang together and shouted for joy when the foundations of the earth were laid, and he appears as the tempter in the Garden immediately after the six days' work.ST Jul 7, 1898 As the serpent-tempter he is a real personal being who by lying to Eve brought death upon the whole human race, thus making Satan the murderer of the whole human family from the beginning, which locates the fall of Satan about the beginning of this world.ST Dec 17, 1874 He deceived the first pair so that they did not act with full understanding of the deception, and his deception and fraud exemplify how he and the fallen angels have sought to ruin humanity.ST Jan 14, 1875ST May 27, 1880 In Eden Eve ate after Satan told her she would not surely die though God had said she would die if she ate, and that first false claim is the origin of the doctrine of the immortality of the soul held by the heathen world and nearly all Protestant churches from which a multitude of errors have sprung.RH Jun 8, 1916 The lie in Genesis 3:4-5 that people would not die and would become like gods is the source of belief in natural immortality, linked to witchcraft and other false religions.
God knew Adam's thoughts before and after the fall, and the verse records a thought Adam had after he fell.ST Nov 22, 1910 Eve was not contented with the knowledge of good alone but had to know good and evil both, and Solomon followed her in the same discontent when he gave his heart to know wisdom and to know madness and folly, testing forbidden things to taste what sweet was in them, which he found to be vanity and vexation of spirit, grief and anguish and sorrow.RH Jan 12, 1869
Blame Without Repentance
Adam did not confess his sin but blamed two persons for it, the woman who gave him of the tree and God who gave the woman to be with him.ST Jul 7, 1898ST Jul 7, 1898ST Feb 26, 1885ST Feb 14, 1906RH Aug 3, 1876 His answer about eating from the forbidden tree shifted responsibility instead of owning disobedience, placing the fault for his act upon the woman for giving him the fruit and upon God for giving her to him.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Jul 7, 1898ST Jul 7, 1898ST Feb 26, 1885ST Feb 14, 1906 Though he acknowledged that he ate, his admission was not repentance but an attempt to cast reflection upon God and throw the responsibility back upon the Lord.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Nov 18, 1913ST Feb 26, 1885ST Feb 14, 1906RH Aug 3, 1876
That acknowledgment did not remove responsibility, for transgressors give excuses and not valid reasons that take away guilt.ST Nov 18, 1913ST May 27, 1897ST Feb 14, 1906RH Aug 3, 1876ST Apr 7, 1914 Rather than claim innocence he admitted eating while trying to excuse himself by blaming the woman God had given him, which showed he knew he had disobeyed.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Nov 18, 1913ST May 27, 1897ST Apr 7, 1914 He could neither deny nor excuse his sin, yet he showed no repentance and only shifted responsibility away from himself.ST Jan 23, 1879ST Nov 18, 1913ST May 27, 1897ST Apr 7, 1914 His response illustrates the human tendency to soften or evade responsibility, to refuse frank confession and palliate wrongs by transferring blame to others rather than lamenting corrupt depravity.ST Nov 18, 1913ST Jun 10, 1889RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916 That excuse set the pattern the whole race has followed ever since, turning confession of self into confession of others' faults so that barefaced sin appears almost a matter of necessity, hiding sin and increasing guilt.ST Nov 18, 1913ST Jun 10, 1889ST Apr 7, 1914RH Nov 5, 1901
The excuse took the form of presenting himself as compelled to eat by the union of man and woman, as if obedience to God did not require him to sin and as if the command that man and woman remain together imposed a necessity God never imposed.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914RH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911 It also took the form of excusing the act as an effort to preserve peace with Eve, which did not remove his responsibility.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914RH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911 It was the beginning of blame-shifting in marriage, speaking reproach against his wife and accusing her to save himself because he was afraid God would blame him, even though he loved her very much.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914STRH Nov 5, 1901 He did not answer openly, honestly and frankly with I have, but answered indirectly and evasively, involving both the Lord and the woman in guilt before himself to shelter himself behind them and clear himself by involving them.RH Dec 10, 1908ST Apr 7, 1914STRH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911 In this he argued that he would never have done it had it not been for somebody else, reasoning with if that Eve had done differently he would not have sinned, taking the least possible blame upon self and holding that self is the last one that can be wrong, which reveals unbelief.RH Dec 10, 1908STRH Nov 5, 1901ST Jan 17, 1911
This accusing, criticizing spirit is of Satanic origin, begun when Satan accused God of injustice and falsehood with the intimation in tempting Eve that God was deceiving her and her husband.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 It is the first example of the favorite pretext of sinners to blame God for the existence and continuation of sin, trying to throw responsibility back upon the Lord by pointing to the woman God had given to be with him as the cause.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 After the first pair sinned the man accused the woman rather than owning his wrong, for accusing another can conceal or excuse the evil in one's own heart, which belongs to human nature when not controlled by grace.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 His answer was a double accusation against Creator and wife, showing the evil mind received from Satan and no longer reflecting the image and glory of God but the image and shame of his seducer, displaying the very disposition Lucifer had developed in heaven.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901 That disposition, which God never put into mankind yet now lives in every human soul, exalts self above all and through all and in all by dodging behind anything or anybody and excusing self because somebody else does the same or worse, which is the very essence of the claim of infallibility and the creature exalting himself to sit in judgment upon the Creator and call in question His righteousness, truth and infallibility.ST Mar 10, 1898RH Nov 5, 1901RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jan 30, 1901
Fall Death and Loss
Genesis 3:12 belongs to the account of humanity's first disobedience and rebellion in eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, when sin entered by one man and death by sin.RH Dec 14, 1905ST Sep 9, 1930ST Nov 23, 1904RH Jul 1, 1909ST Jun 6, 1878 That fall brought guilt and condemnation, separation from God, misery, sorrow and ruin to Adam's descendants, who were created perfect and then fell under the power of the enemy.ST Sep 9, 1930RH Dec 25, 1913ST Nov 23, 1904RH Jul 1, 1909ST Jun 6, 1878 The need for redemption began at that fall and expulsion from Eden, from Paradise lost to Paradise restored, when Jesus took human sin upon Himself and died to save the whole race and to recover humanity to innocence.RH Dec 14, 1905RH Dec 25, 1913RH Jul 1, 1909
Adam and Eve both knowingly broke God's clear command, and their confessions are enough to establish their guilt and proceed to the sentence of death.RH Nov 6, 1860RH Aug 22, 1854RH Aug 3, 1876 By that disobedience, treated as sin, Adam incurred the threatened death penalty and brought the penalty of death upon the human race.RH Nov 6, 1860RH Aug 22, 1854RH Aug 3, 1876 He forfeited the right to live and to the tree of life, and God told him he must return to the ground out of which he was taken.ST Dec 9, 1880RH Dec 29, 1868ST Jan 28, 1875ST Jun 12, 1879 What God takes back at death is simply the breath of life breathed into Adam's nostrils to make him a living soul, held in God's own keeping until He gives life a second time; what was given was life, not a conscious being from glory living within the body, so when it is taken there is no life, thought or knowledge left, just as before it was given, proving man has no inherent immortality.ST Dec 9, 1880RH Dec 29, 1868ST Jun 12, 1879 Death is the fruit of sin and does not open a door back into the paradise from which sin caused man to be expelled.ST Jun 12, 1879
Through that fall sin caused the human family to lose Paradise, the garden where the first parents had been placed and where the tree of life stood, with its life without end.ST Jan 28, 1875ST Sep 26, 1878 Adam's fair inheritance passed to Satan until Christ redeems it, for Adam surrendered dominion to the tempter and Satan became its usurping ruler.ST Jan 17, 1878 God drove Adam out to prevent him from eating from the tree of life and living forever, and the garden remained on earth for a time guarded from human approach by the cherubim's flaming sword, probably removed to heaven at the time of the Flood.ST Jan 28, 1875 That same Paradise, prepared for mankind in innocence when the earth was founded and now in the third heaven within the heavenly Jerusalem made infinitely more glorious, will be given to the saved as the overcomer's reward, when the second Adam first introduces the saved family into it as the beginning of giving them the kingdom.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Mar 1, 1870 In that apostasy Paradise was lost, man was excluded from the tree of life, cut off from heaven's family and intercourse with God and angels and sold into bondage, the earth came under God's curse and was marred from very good beauty, and death entered through sin.
Eating only one piece about six thousand years ago forfeited Eden glory, ended Edenic brightness and began a long dark night of woe.ST Sep 17, 1902RH Jul 9, 1872 That one sin, by the mother of the race and apparently small and insignificant, opened the way for an innumerable host of sins spreading destruction to earth's remotest bounds, becoming the fatal origin of centuries of pain and misery.ST Sep 17, 1902 Its results are terrible and far-reaching, disfiguring nature so that the earth in its present sin-cursed state bears only faint traces of primitive fertility and beauty, wrecking this beautiful earth and changing an Eden into a charnel-house, with every tear and sorrow and pain and grief and wail of agony and gray hair and bent form and bed of death caused by disobedience.ST Sep 17, 1902ST Oct 12, 1904 Although sinless nature was created in six literal days, its restoration requires 7,000 years, with that original sin living on in its innumerable posterity for six thousand years past and another thousand years to come, until destroyed with its original progenitor, that old serpent, which is the devil, and Satan.ST Sep 17, 1902 That first transgression, believing and acting a lie to obtain greater exaltation and bringing instead humiliation, degradation and death, laid the foundation for every other disappointment to the present day, for disappointments from false hopes are the common experience of mortals largely on account of sin.ST Aug 13, 1902 God is no respecter of persons and will not deal more leniently with others than with Adam and Eve, so if Eden was lost for only one sin it cannot be regained while even one comparatively small sin remains buried in the heart.RH Jul 9, 1872 After the fall enmity also arose among different kinds of animals and they gradually became carnivorous, marking the change from the peace of creation to the effects of sin.RH Mar 12, 1861
That sin is a fixed fact that gained a foothold in God's universe after the tempter gained the confidence of the first mother and drew Adam with Eve into rebellion, and God's banishing of Adam and Eve from paradise shows how He viewed it, yet it is an intruder and usurper that came in by fraud, gained no rights by possession, was not willed by God, displeases Him now as at its origin, exists in defiance of Him, and is not a natural or necessary part of human life or heritage.RH Mar 3, 1874RH Aug 25, 1910 By yielding to Satan's suggestions in Eden our first parents were overcome and perverted in their natures, so that since then the human race has been readily led into sinful indulgence.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898 Temptation itself does not make a person evil or a devil; yielding to it brings sin and places the person under Satan's control so long as the sinful practice continues.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898 That yielding broke the charm of obedience and marked the rise of self-will, for Adam and Eve attempted to exalt themselves by eating the forbidden fruit and substituting their own ways for God's ways, which is selfishness as rebellion against God and His government, any effort of the creature to exalt self at the expense or neglect of divine order, bringing misery and death upon themselves and their race as a solemn warning that God's law admits no substitution.ST Jan 25, 1899RH Jan 2, 1866 Since the fall people's sinful desires readily align with the law of self and resist God's will, so obedience to God is an absolute necessity, not a choice to set aside at will.ST Jan 25, 1899
True History Upheld
Genesis 1-3, including Adam's answer about the woman given to be with him, is factual, literal, inspired history, received by Moses by revelation since he had no personal knowledge of those events, not tradition, allegory, myth, poem, legend, spiritualized legend, literature for ethical instruction only, or childish fable, but plain and clear enough for a child, truly written by Moses and held as truth by Christ and the apostles as part of the inspired Scriptures and the true account of the first parents of the human race.ST Jul 28, 1881ST Nov 25, 1889ST Mar 20, 1907ST Mar 9, 1888ST Nov 1, 1905 Its credibility as history is foundational to confidence in the Bible, for the truthfulness of the fall account underlies the whole Book.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Aug 25, 1881
The fall recorded there is foundational to the gospel, for without that real disobedience in Eden when the first parents ate of the tree there would be no need for redemption, atonement, incarnation, Saviour, or plan of salvation, and to treat it as fable makes the gospel itself rest on a fable.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Nov 13, 1893ST Apr 2, 1896ST Nov 15, 1883ST Jul 26, 1910 Denying that the fall occurred requires reconsidering all doctrines founded on that plan, and rejection of creation and the fall is linked to rejection of inspiration of Scripture, the atonement, Christ's divinity and resurrection, and His second coming.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Jul 26, 1910 That disobedience made man a fallen race in sin, and Christ came to suffer and die to rescue man from its effects, so the whole Biblical doctrine of the atonement and what Christ declared He came to accomplish depends on its reality.ST Apr 2, 1896RH Apr 1, 1909 To deny it undermines the need for a Redeemer and Christ's atonement, subverts the atonement, destroys the credibility of the Bible revelation, and removes the Saviour's necessity, the flood's reason, and the authority of Scripture from Moses to Revelation.ST Apr 2, 1896ST Nov 15, 1883RH Apr 1, 1909
The Bible teaches a downward fall from a higher, perfect state, not upward evolution from apes through savagery and barbarism to civilization, and the Fall and evolution cannot both be held but one must be abandoned.RH Apr 1, 1909AUST Jun 14, 1920ST Jun 3, 1913 Man was formed a perfect being by the infinite Creator and since that sin has been degenerating through the ages rather than evolving upward from lower life, so that no men today correspond in strength and physical prowess to the giants of the times before Christ, and disobedience brought moral ruin instead of improvement.ST Aug 22, 1916ST Jun 3, 1913 The most fundamental facts of the first chapters are directly antagonistic to the evolutionist major premise of successive geological ages, which is the weakest point in the whole evolution theory, and denial of the fall comes from allowing uncertain geology built on human hypothesis to set aside the Word of God, so that evolution supersedes creation and Darwin's Origin of the Species is preferred to the Books of Moses on which the faith of Jesus Christ rested.ST Feb 13, 1901 To replace the fall with constant advancement from ape and animal creations through evolutionary processes subverts the atonement, and discarding the fall keeps the form of godliness while denying its power.RH Apr 1, 1909
The Mosaic account is familiar Biblical history and the only authentic history of those remote events, contained in the Pentateuch and the prophets when there were no historical records in Assyria, Egypt, Phoenicia, Chaldea, or Greece before Moses, who is the father of history, an inspired record explaining the widespread traditions of an original good age and its loss, of man's primal purity, fall, and promise of redemption.ST Feb 10, 1887RH Feb 5, 1867 It is not myth, poem, or allegory but truth, the word of the living God to be heeded, given by inspiration of God and profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, so to reject the writings of Moses is to reject the teaching of Christ and His apostles.ST Nov 1, 1905 It gives detailed facts showing who Adam was and what he did, how by one man sin entered into the world and death by sin and how in Adam all die, and makes plain who that old serpent is, what he did in bringing sin, and why he is to be bound a thousand years, thereby revealing the origin, nature and true character of the archdeceiver and the necessity and plan of redemption, without which these statements impart no tangible instruction and the rest of Scripture is scarcely intelligible. Even the Karen people of Burma hold traditions closely like that account, together with creation and the flood, showing that at some remote time they knew Jehovah, and though wandering far from God in the dark night of demon worship they still retain in their hearts a knowledge of and belief in the Supreme Being, whom God regards with great compassion as a despised and mistreated people.RH Aug 10, 1905
The cause of the first transgression was disputed, some holding that God permitted Adam to fall, while others held that God decreed the sin and arranged events so that Adam and Eve could not avoid the fall, which God foresaw and according to the predestinarian position ordained and appointed.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Apr 10, 1879 Misuse of the account takes Genesis 3:1-24 to mean God laid a trap for man and then condemned and punished him for falling into it, making God unfair and unjust, and uses it as a reason for rejecting all divine revelation, presuming human reason can balance the right or wrong of God's dealings and pass judgment on Him who reads all hearts, knows all motives, and sees the end from the beginning.RH Feb 18, 1902 The temptation and fall also raises why man was tested and why sin was permitted and why Satan was not destroyed, belonging to the great controversy between good and evil as illustrated in the life of Adam, from whom a lesson is drawn and which is connected with the plan of salvation extending to the establishment of the kingdom at Pentecost, contrary in almost every respect to what unaided human reason could devise.STST Feb 19, 1880
Modern scientific theology rejects the doctrine of Adam's fall into sin and of an original state of innocence to which Adam's answer belongs.RH Mar 28, 1907
Law Atonement and Restoration
The fall came by violation of the moral law already planted in Eden before the fall, under which Adam and Eve stood on probation, and disregarding the divine prohibition was transgression of that law bringing the curse and misery that followed.ST Apr 15, 1875ST Sep 21, 1876ST Mar 11, 1875 Eve ate from the motive to become as gods, while Adam, who was not deceived, deliberately chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord, putting her before God in open violation of the first commandment, and his own words that the woman gave him of the tree expose that deliberate choice.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 The consequences prove that changeless law could not be changed or abolished to free them, for the sentence of death and resulting suffering followed, the earth was blighted because of human sin, and the curse, the blighting, and the testimony to guilt show its sacred and unalterable character.ST Apr 15, 1875ST Mar 11, 1875ST May 10, 1883 That account of curse after disobedience is not itself a rule of obedience, and does not show that the Sabbath was not commanded or could not be kept after the fall, for God means what He says in His commands.ST Apr 15, 1875RH Feb 24, 1859
The fall brought loss of the estate, rights and dominion given to the first pair, leaving humanity in debt, helpless, corrupt, and under judgment, and therefore in need of a divine Saviour and dependence on divine grace.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Mar 26, 1885ST Apr 11, 1911 The Creator foresaw that fall, and the purpose of redeeming humanity was already included in His purpose in creating the world, so that the gospel's provisions reach back to Eden and the history beginning with the first sin leads to redemption through Christ.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Dec 24, 1885 Adam's disobedience was rash ingratitude that plunged him from his blessed state into deep woe, shifting blame to the woman and indirectly to God who gave her, yet Christ in love gave Himself to buy humanity back and acted to save the fallen.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Apr 11, 1911ST Apr 11, 1878 He suffered Adam's penalty sinless in sinful flesh to show man can overcome, and thus redeems Adam's disgrace.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Mar 26, 1885
What was lost in Adam is to be regained in Christ, for humanity created perfect fell and brought ruin on its descendants, from which Christ came to recover humanity and restore it to innocence.ST Aug 6, 1894RH Jul 1, 1909 The pitying Shepherd's first conversation with the straying, torn, bruised, sad and despairing pair after sin first made known to this world the plan of redemption laid in the counsels of eternity, breaking the first news of pardon through Christ, the promise that the Seed of the woman would bruise the serpent's head, the still-open privilege to choose the right, escape the eternal death to which they were doomed, and share in final restoration where paradise is regained with Satan and sin and unrepentant sinners nowhere found.ST Aug 6, 1894 Sin caused the human family to lose Paradise, the garden where the first parents were placed and where the tree of life stood, which remained on earth for a time guarded by the cherubim's flaming sword and was probably removed to heaven at the Flood, leaving Paradise desolate until Adam its original possessor returns through the Mediator to claim its glories.ST Sep 23, 1875 That Paradise prepared for mankind in innocence, now in the third heaven in the heavenly Jerusalem, the city above, the bride, the mother of all from which man was created, will be given to the saved as the overcomer's reward, when the eternal purpose shown from Genesis 1 and 3 to the last two chapters of the Bible is completed with all Satan's agencies gone down in eternal ruin, God's dwelling with men, all tears wiped away, death the last enemy destroyed, the earth made new and clothed again in Edenic purity, and all things in heaven and earth gathered together in one in Christ in the fullness of times.ST Sep 23, 1875ST Sep 26, 1878ST Aug 17, 1915
The Eden history hides the whole gospel and God's first plan in Adam created in the image of God and upright in body, in mind, in soul, vividly portraying a life to be desired and lived. Uprightness of body comes only by obeying the laws of health in eating, dressing and breathing according to divine principles, uprightness of mind by Christian education, and uprightness of soul by feeding upon God's word, and leading pupils to live these truths restores the image of God in humanity, which is the gospel; the Christ-life must be seen in Adam, seeing God in Eden gives understanding of the same power in the Christ-child, and living what is studied is the only proof of successful teaching. God in love created the first pair and richly endowed them with physical and mental power for His glory and their happiness, being the author of life, health, strength and true happiness and not the author of sickness, sorrow and death, but the first great transgression by those representatives of the dying race brought moral and physical evils, disease, suffering and death upon the race.ST Sep 2, 1875ST Apr 1, 1875ST Apr 15, 1875 Death, sickness, sorrow and physical and moral wretchedness are the legitimate offspring of transgression of moral and natural law, sickness is no more a necessity than sin, death even in ripe old age exists because of that first transgression, and premature death in childhood, youth or middle life comes from continued transgression which aggravates Eden's evils.ST Apr 1, 1875 Adam's eating at Eve's giving was a reckless departure from God's requirements through moral powers weakened by indulgence of perverted appetite, bringing guilt and sorrow upon the world and the penalty of the crime upon man, and the example and result with the history of his family was traced for the benefit of all who should live upon the earth to deter them from the same steps, so his failure is no reason to complain of him while repeatedly sinning despite having that history, its consequences, the plan of redemption through Christ, and the instruction of Scripture.ST Jul 8, 1880ST Sep 1, 1881ST Apr 15, 1875 That disobedience cost infinite expense, leading the Son of God to leave the royal courts of heaven to take a humble place on earth where He was subjected to insult, rejection and crucifixion by the very ones He came to bless, the Majesty of heaven sacrificed to save man, for God pronounced judgment against Adam for that transgression and did not pass over it lightly, and He will not pass over any transgression of His law now more lightly.ST Sep 1, 1881
Warning for Daily Life
Adam's answer began the universal pattern of excuse that every transgressor has followed since, softening wrongdoing, palliating faults, and confessing the faults of others instead of frankly saying I have sinned.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jan 1, 1894ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jul 3, 1856 His admission that he ate did not remove responsibility, for he gave no valid reason but shifted blame to the woman and to God who gave her to be with him, revealing the evasive, self-justifying spirit of sinners.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jan 1, 1894ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jul 3, 1856 To blame others for neglect or wrongdoing is a sign of inward backsliding, making barefaced sin appear almost a matter of necessity rather than lamenting one's own corrupt depravity.ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jun 7, 1870 Covering sin in this way is fatal, so wrongs must be owned without extenuation, confessed and forsaken with earnest work and seeking of pardon and improvement before it is too late.ST Jun 10, 1889RH Jul 3, 1856RH Jun 7, 1870
Each person exercised free power of choice in the test and was not obliged to go together into sin, and condemnation rested on Adam because he had the power and right to choose.ST Jan 17, 1911 Eve's giving did not compel him or remove his responsibility before God, for God holds each person individually to account for his own action toward Him with equality in personal responsibility.ST Jan 17, 1911ST Apr 12, 1883 Temptation is not all outward happening but also inner readiness, and saying he tempted me explains only one side, for no outsider is as responsible for a person's sins as the person himself.ST Apr 12, 1883ST Jan 6, 1904 It takes two to make a successful temptation, and one of the two is always one's own responsible self, which must be answered for, and no excuse will save him.ST Jan 6, 1904
The answer shows the beginning of blame-shifting in marriage, when the first man spoke reproach against his wife and accused her to save himself because he was afraid God would blame him, even though he loved her very much.STRH Apr 9, 1901 That same ungallant blaming of wives by husbands to avoid blame still continues, as men since Adam blame women rather than take responsibility for their own faults.ST Sin and selfishness replaced God's rule and destroyed the first home, damaging the natural and domestic relations of human life and bringing sorrow, strife, suffering and death.RH Apr 9, 1901ST Mar 29, 1905 The purity of the Eden home as a heaven of peace and joy was lost, and since then in a sin-cursed earth homes are darkened by sin with few husbands and wives measuring up to the standard of the Word, and married life is subject to trials and discord that lasting peace cannot escape apart from religion.RH Apr 9, 1901ST Jan 16, 1901
Adam's disobedience and blame-shifting warn against repeating the fall while lamenting his transgression, for his example stands to deter all who live on earth.ST Feb 11, 1875ST Jun 3, 1886RH Mar 4, 1875 His sin in eating what had been forbidden, after listening to the deceptive temptations of the enemy, brought guilt and sorrow and opened the floodgates of woe, growing worse until the flood and steadily increasing since, which would have plunged the race into hopeless despair apart from God's goodness and mercy.ST Jun 3, 1886ST May 26, 1898ST Jun 3, 1875 That disobedience is repeated when God's plain command is discarded, as in rejecting the Sabbath of the Lord for a spurious sabbath, and man is required to reverence and obey the divine law without questioning its feasibility or convenience.ST Jun 3, 1886ST May 26, 1898ST May 11, 1876 Obedience protects from intemperance, sexual immorality and disease, while further falls bring increasing sin and harm, whether by disbelieving God like Babel or by neglecting watchfulness in pleasant life.ST Feb 11, 1875ST May 11, 1876ST Jun 3, 1875
The answer proves the great change that took place in character and nature at the fall, with righteousness gone and sin in its place, and innocence, happiness, holiness, love, faithfulness and obedience fled while depravity showed itself in every movement.ST Apr 9, 1912 Self-defense and accusing another to conceal or excuse the evil in one's own heart are effects of sin and part of human nature when not controlled by God's grace.RH Jan 20, 1916ST Jul 26, 1910 After the fall humanity developed a disposition to reject God's word and became willing to accept systems of religious error.RH Nov 11, 1858RH Sep 15, 1874 Adam's story begins the Bible's treatise on temptation and its conquest, warning that all sin promises joy but proves false and brings death and worse, separation from God, and showing that even a perfect human being could fall when left to himself, so that holiness and safety depend on divine preservation.RH Jul 29, 1858RH Sep 15, 1874
The same excuse appears when willful, disobedient, headstrong young people blame an earthly parent, when children hide wrong and throw blame on another, and when husbands blame wives.STRH Apr 9, 1901RH Apr 3, 1866 Children must not form the habit of making excuses, but be willing to own it when they have done wrong, for one quick at making excuses is not likely to be good for anything else or to be loved and honored.RH Apr 3, 1866 The plea that when a thoughtless girl or evil-minded woman puts temptation before a man he must fall has become universal from Adam down, and reasoning with if that Eve had done differently he would not have sinned reveals unbelief that has lost many battles.RH Feb 17, 1916ST Aug 21, 1901 Instead of pleading temptation the right course is to refuse to do wickedness and sin against God and to flee like Joseph, for there is power in Christ to keep from sin if He is let to keep, no matter what the temptation of wine, women, or any sin Satan can invent, and then there is safety.ST Aug 21, 1901 Satan's conquest in Eden contains the germ of all later war of man with man as the acorn contains the oak, and the trail of the serpent lies over nearly every great disaster involving terrible loss of life through greed joined with governmental corruption or inefficiency, as in the Iroquois Theater at Chicago where the house was opened to make money before it was ready and inspection failed to remedy gross neglects, growing through corruption and war until the Lord subdues the usurper, for degeneracy is measured by injury done to the world.RH Jun 24, 1915ST Jul 27, 1904
Sources